Disaster assessment device, disaster assessment method, and program
The disaster evaluation device and method address the limitations of existing systems by simulating multiple disaster types and converting damage data into common social values, enabling comprehensive and timely recovery planning.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023079320
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-12
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
AI Technical Summary
Existing disaster evaluation systems primarily focus on earthquake damage and do not account for various disaster types, cultural damage, and lack real-time comprehensive assessment methods, especially for disasters like tsunamis and flooding, which hinder effective recovery planning.
A disaster evaluation device and method that includes multiple simulation units to assess various disaster types, converts damage data into common social values, and evaluates changes in social value using a data conversion and evaluation unit to support real-time recovery planning.
Enables comprehensive evaluation of disaster damage, including cultural and economic impacts, facilitating timely and effective recovery measures by integrating simulation results into common social value assessments.
Smart Images

Figure 2024163577000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a disaster assessment device, a disaster assessment method, and a program for comprehensively assessing a damage state caused by the occurrence of a disaster. [Background technology]
[0002] A system for appropriately assessing the amount of damage caused by the occurrence of a disaster is known (see, for example, Patent Document 1). The damage assessment system of Patent Document 1 effectively assesses damages expected to occur due to an earthquake. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 11-175623 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] In the technology described in Patent Document 1, only earthquakes are listed as an example of the type of disaster to be evaluated, and the damage rate is calculated based on the assumed earthquake, and damage is evaluated based on this damage rate. Furthermore, the damage rate due to earthquakes, earthquake fires, ground liquefaction, etc. is calculated only for buildings located in each district divided into meshes, and cultural damage due to disasters is not taken into consideration at all.
[0005] The present disclosure has been made to solve such problems, and its purpose is to provide a disaster assessment device, a disaster assessment method, and a program that can comprehensively assess the damage state caused by the occurrence of a disaster. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] The disaster assessment device of the present disclosure is a plurality of simulation units each performing a simulation of a damage state for a plurality of types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of the disaster; a data conversion unit that converts data indicating the damage state as a simulation result of each of the plurality of simulation units into data indicating a common social value; a social value assessment unit that assesses a change in social value due to the disaster based on the plurality of data converted by the data conversion unit; It is equipped with the following.
[0007] The disaster assessment method of the present disclosure includes: In response to the occurrence of a disaster, a simulation of damage conditions for a plurality of types of events caused by the disaster is carried out, converting the data indicating the damage state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; Based on the plurality of converted data, a change in social value due to the disaster is evaluated.
[0008] The program of the present disclosure is On the computer, A process of simulating a damage state caused by a disaster for each of a plurality of types of events in response to the occurrence of the disaster; A process of converting the data indicating the restoration state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; A process of evaluating a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted values of the damage states of the multiple simulation results; This is what causes the following to be executed. Effect of the Invention
[0009] According to the present disclosure, it is possible to provide a disaster assessment device, a disaster assessment method, and a program capable of comprehensively assessing the damage state caused by the occurrence of a disaster. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0010] [Figure 1]FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a process from the occurrence of a disaster to the evaluation of the damage caused by the disaster. [Diagram 2] 1 is a conceptual diagram showing an overall configuration including a disaster assessment device according to an embodiment. [Diagram 3] 3 is a block diagram showing a configuration of the disaster assessment device shown in FIG. 2. [Figure 4] 1 is a flowchart showing an outline of a disaster damage assessment process according to an embodiment. [Diagram 5] FIG. 4 is a conceptual diagram showing inputs to each simulation unit. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a conceptual diagram showing an example of the relationship between various simulation units for multiple types of events executed when an earthquake occurs. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0011] (Embodiment) Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. However, the invention according to the claims is not limited to the following embodiment. Furthermore, not all of the configurations described in the present embodiment are necessarily essential as means for solving the problem. For clarity of explanation, the following description and drawings are omitted and simplified as appropriate. In each drawing, the same elements are given the same reference numerals, and repeated explanations are omitted as necessary.
[0012] <Issues in disaster assessment> First, the issues in assessing disaster damage and disaster recovery in the present disclosure will be described. As described in the background art above, simulations of damage at the time of disaster occurrence have often been used to estimate the content of monetary damage, i.e., the amount of damage, for individual events (e.g., damage caused by tsunamis or flooding after earthquakes, damage caused by landslides after heavy rain or typhoons, fires caused by forest fires, etc.). Therefore, such damage simulations have not been able to estimate disaster damage comprehensively. In the following, the issues in disaster assessment in the present disclosure will be described based on these.
[0013] First, there is the issue of the lack of a unified method for evaluating disasters. In other words, damage caused by disasters includes not only economic damage that can be converted into a monetary amount (for example, the amount of damage caused by the collapse of a building), but also human damage (for example, how many people died and how many were injured in the disaster) and cultural damage (for example, the loss of cultural property). There is a strong need for a method for converting the integrated value of such damage, which cannot be converted into a single indicator (for example, monetary amount).
[0014] Secondly, when simulating the damage state for multiple types of events (e.g., tsunami and flooding) that occur due to a disaster, initial values are required to be input for the simulation of each event. The problem is what initial values should be prepared for simulating the damage state for one or multiple events. In addition, the national and local governments also want to obtain the results of each simulation early in order to present recovery and reconstruction measures early. For example, if experts conduct on-site surveys to verify and investigate the damage caused by the disaster and evaluate the disaster that has occurred, there is no problem with taking a reasonable amount of time to carefully evaluate it. However, in recent years, digital twins (disaster digital twins) have been used to plan responses early, but with these digital twins, a method that can meet real-time demands for prediction results is required when planning disaster countermeasures.
[0015] <Outline of the Disaster Assessment Device of the Present Disclosure> The disaster assessment device of the present disclosure has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems. Below, an overview of the disaster assessment device according to this embodiment in the simulation of damage from the occurrence of a disaster will be described. In principle, the targets of evaluation of the disaster assessment device, disaster assessment method, and program of the present disclosure are all phenomena that occur when a disaster occurs. The present disclosure targets the idea of disaster resilience (the ability to recover from a disaster).
[0016] First, the evaluation of the damage state at the time of occurrence of a disaster by the disaster evaluation device of the present disclosure will be described. Here, a case where an earthquake occurs as a disaster will be exemplified. FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a flow from the occurrence of a disaster to the evaluation of the damage state caused by the disaster. As shown in FIG. 1, first, when a disaster (disaster phenomenon) occurs, the disaster evaluation device receives information indicating the scale of the disaster and the location of occurrence (epicenter and depth of the epicenter) as disaster occurrence information from, for example, the country (government) or a corresponding organization (Japan Meteorological Agency). In the virtual world of the disaster digital twin, the disaster evaluation device performs various simulations of the damage state and estimates the state of various damages (damage state) such as damage to buildings and facilities in flooded areas, damage to historical and social assets, damage to logistics and economic activities, and human damage.
[0017] Meanwhile, in the physical world of the disaster digital twin, the disaster assessment device obtains information on the actual damage state of the current disaster by sensing the movements of people and objects and collecting information from the national and local governments.
[0018] Next, in the virtual world of the disaster digital twin, the disaster assessment device comprehensively assesses the damage caused by the disaster based on the estimated information on various damage conditions, and evaluates the change in social value caused by the disaster. In other words, the disaster assessment device comprehensively judges the results of various simulations, and evaluates and determines the extent to which social value has decreased due to the disaster.
[0019] Next, in the virtual world of the disaster digital twin, the disaster assessment device may quantify resilience (durability and resilience) against the decline in social value from the estimated result of the damage state due to the disaster, formulate countermeasures (measure proposals) to increase this resilience, and perform a simulation of the damage state again. In this way, by creating countermeasures and looping the simulation, and by feeding back information on the damage state of the physical world, the disaster assessment device may propose countermeasures to prevent the decline in social value as much as possible. In other words, the disaster digital twin of the present disclosure estimates the damage state for multiple types of events by performing a simulation to evaluate the results (damage state) of the disaster phenomenon caused by the occurrence of a disaster, and evaluates the disaster damage by comprehensively evaluating these multiple damage states.
[0020] <Configuration of the disaster assessment device> Next, the configuration of the disaster assessment device according to this embodiment will be described. In this embodiment, the disaster assessment device will be described using an earthquake and a tsunami that occurs thereafter as a specific example of a disaster, but the type of disaster is not limited to this. In addition to earthquakes and tsunamis, other anticipated disasters include disasters caused by typhoons and landslides after the typhoon passes, fires caused by forest fires, and disasters caused by heavy rain. First, the overall configuration including the disaster assessment device will be described. FIG. 2 is a conceptual diagram showing the overall configuration including the disaster assessment device according to this embodiment.
[0021] As shown in Fig. 2, the disaster assessment device 100 is connected to a national government agency server 210, national ministry and agency servers 220-22N, a people flow server 230, and a traffic-related server 240 via a network 300 such as the Internet. Here, the people flow server 230 is a server that provides people flow information within a specified area, and may be, for example, a server owned by a mobile terminal communication company (carrier). The traffic-related server 240 may be a server of various transportation facilities, and may include, for example, a server of each railway company, a server of each bus company, a server of each airline company, a server of each shipping company, and the like.
[0022] When a disaster occurs, the disaster assessment device 100 acquires disaster occurrence information from the government agency server 210 and each ministry / agency server 220-22N, as described below. For example, if the disaster is an earthquake, the disaster occurrence information includes the scale of the earthquake, the location of the epicenter, the depth of the epicenter, and the like.
[0023] Upon acquiring information on the occurrence of an earthquake, the disaster assessment device 100 is configured to receive seismic intensity information of each area affected by the earthquake from the Meteorological Agency server in each ministry / agency server 220-22N, and to acquire people flow information of the relevant area from the people flow server 230, for sensing the physical world. The disaster assessment device 100 is also configured to acquire information on the transportation network related to the relevant area (traffic-related information) from the traffic-related server 240, in particular, information on damage and delays of railways, information on the takeoff and landing of passenger aircraft, and operation information of ships. The disaster assessment device 100 may be configured to constantly acquire people flow information and traffic-related information.
[0024] Thereafter, the disaster assessment device 100 is configured to simulate the damage state for multiple types of events caused by this earthquake, as described below, and convert data indicating the damage state as a result of each simulation into data indicating a common social value. The disaster assessment device 100 is then configured to evaluate a change in social value caused by the earthquake based on these multiple converted data. The specific operation of the disaster assessment device 100 will be described in detail later with reference to the block diagram of FIG. 3 and the flow chart of FIG. 4.
[0025] Usually, when an earthquake occurs, social value decreases. The disaster assessment device 100 may be configured to recommend a plurality of countermeasures for a plurality of types of events based on the assessed degree of social value decrease due to the earthquake. The disaster assessment device 100 may also be configured to transmit the recommended information to the government agency server 210 and each ministry and agency server 220 to 22N. The country (government) may decide whether or not to set up a disaster countermeasure headquarters based on the recommended countermeasures as necessary. The country (government) and local governments in disaster-stricken areas may use the recommended information as necessary to decide disaster relief activities to be carried out for residents (victims) in areas affected by the earthquake disaster.
[0026] Next, a configuration of the disaster assessment device 100 according to the present embodiment will be described. Fig. 3 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the disaster assessment device 100 shown in Fig. 2. The configuration of the disaster assessment device 100 according to the present embodiment will be described with reference to Figs. 2 and 3.
[0027] 3, the disaster assessment device 100 includes a control unit 110, a transmission / reception unit 120, a storage unit 130, a plurality of simulation units 140 to 14N, a data conversion unit 150, and a social value assessment unit 160. The control unit 110 is configured to control each unit in the disaster assessment device 100.
[0028] The transmitting / receiving unit 120 is configured to transmit and receive data between the government agency server 210, the ministries and agencies servers 220-22N, the people flow server 230, and the traffic-related server 240 via the network 300. Specifically, as described above, the transmitting / receiving unit 120 is configured to receive disaster occurrence information indicating the scale of the earthquake, the location of the epicenter, and the depth of the epicenter after a disaster, here an earthquake, occurs from the government agency server 210 and the ministries and agencies servers 220-22N. The transmitting / receiving unit 120 outputs the received disaster occurrence information to the simulation units 140-14N for simulating the damage state.
[0029] The transmitting / receiving unit 120 is also configured to receive damage status data indicating actual values of damage conditions that have occurred due to an earthquake and whose actual conditions have become clear from the government agency server 210 and each ministry / agency server 220-22N. The transmitting / receiving unit 120 outputs the received damage status data to the simulation units 140-14N for re-simulating the damage status.
[0030] The transmitting / receiving unit 120 may transmit data indicating a change in social value assessed by the social value assessment unit 160 in response to the occurrence of an earthquake to the government agency server 210 or the like.
[0031] The storage unit 130 is configured to temporarily store data indicating a damage state as a result of simulation by the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N as necessary. The storage unit 130 is also configured to temporarily store various data converted by the data conversion unit 150.
[0032] Furthermore, the storage unit 130 is configured to temporarily store disaster occurrence information and damage status data received by the transmitting / receiving unit 120 , and data relating to changes in social value assessed by the social value assessment unit 160 .
[0033] The storage unit 130 may be configured to store data on buildings and social infrastructures having a specific added value. The storage unit 130 may also be configured to include a database (not shown) that stores data on buildings and social infrastructures having a specific added value. Examples of buildings and social infrastructures having a specific added value include historical buildings such as shrines and temples, tourist spots such as Tokyo Tower and Skytree, buildings designed by famous architects, and suspension bridges such as Rainbow Bridge and Seto Ohashi Bridge. Each of such buildings and infrastructures having a specific added value is set with a coefficient of damage amount according to the specific added value and a value recognized by the country, etc., and when the buildings and infrastructures are damaged as historical and social asset damage shown in FIG. 1, a higher damage amount is calculated than that of normal buildings. The transmission and reception unit 120 may be configured to receive such data from, for example, each ministry and agency server 220 to 22N.
[0034] The multiple simulation units 140-14N are configured to perform simulations of damage states for multiple types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of the disaster. Specifically, the multiple simulation units 140-14N are configured to perform simulations of damage states for multiple types of events based on disaster occurrence information received by the transmission / reception unit 120. Each simulation unit 140-14N is configured to output data indicating the damage state as a corresponding simulation result to the other simulation units 140-14N related to itself. In this way, in the disaster assessment device 100 according to this embodiment, the multiple simulation units 140-14N are linked together to estimate the assessment of social value by the social value assessment unit 160 at the subsequent stage.
[0035] For example, multiple types of events caused by disasters include road and building damage, building structure damage, human casualties, infrastructure damage, rescue operations and evacuation shelters, economic damage, basic administrative services, medical supply transportation, and relief supply transportation, as shown in Fig. 6 for earthquakes and tsunamis. Fig. 6 is a conceptual diagram showing an example of the relationship between various simulation units for multiple types of events that are executed when an earthquake occurs.
[0036] In this embodiment, each of the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N performs a corresponding simulation for these events when a disaster occurs. Here, the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N include simulation units that are related and cooperate with each other as shown in Fig. 6, and in such a related simulation unit, the simulation results of the previous simulation unit are used as inputs of the subsequent simulation unit in a time series.
[0037] For example, the simulation results of the road and building damage simulation unit are used as input for the infrastructure damage simulation unit, the human casualty simulation unit, the rescue operation and evacuation shelter simulation unit, the medical supply transportation simulation unit, and the relief supply transportation simulation unit.
[0038] Regardless of the various simulation units illustrated in FIG. 6, as a specific example, when an earthquake occurs as a disaster, first, the scale of the earthquake indicated by the magnitude, the epicenter of the earthquake, the depth of the epicenter, etc. are obtained by a seismometer or the like. However, since the fault plane of the earthquake is unknown, a simulation is performed to calculate the fault plane based on this information and the seismic intensity of each area. Then, when the fault plane is identified by this simulation, a simulation is performed to calculate how much the sea level has risen at that location. When the sea level rise is determined by this simulation, a simulation is performed to calculate how the risen sea level will propagate. When the propagation of the wave (tsunami) is determined, a simulation is performed to calculate when the wave will reach the coast and how much of the ground will be flooded. When the flooded area is determined, a simulation is performed to calculate the extent to which roads, buildings, and infrastructure will be damaged.
[0039] Here, to each of the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N, as shown in Fig. 5, a disaster variable value that varies depending on the type of disaster, a non-disaster variable value that varies with the passage of time from the occurrence of the disaster regardless of the type of disaster, and a fixed value that hardly varies depending on the type of disaster are input as input values. Fig. 5 is a conceptual diagram showing the inputs of each simulation unit 140 to 14N.
[0040] Disaster variable values are values that are essentially clarified by investigation (e.g., the scale and location of an earthquake, its mechanism, etc.), and are acquired from the various servers 210, 220-22N, etc., via the network 300 and the transmitting / receiving unit 120. Non-disaster variable values are values that are constantly collected and can be sensed regardless of disasters (e.g., temperature and humidity, the number of people in a certain place during a certain time period, bed occupancy rate, etc.), and are acquired from the various servers 220-22N, 230, 240, etc., via the network 300 and the transmitting / receiving unit 120. Fixed values are values that fluctuate relatively infrequently (e.g., topography, facility buildings, physical coefficients, etc.), and are stored in advance in the storage unit 130, for example. The fixed values may also include the maximum number of patients that each medical facility can accept, the location of each piece of equipment, the location of each piece of infrastructure, etc.
[0041] In addition, the data indicating the damage state as a result of multiple simulations by multiple simulation units 140 to 14N includes data that can be converted into the amount of damage, data indicating the damage state caused by the occurrence of a disaster as a relative evaluation against a reference state, data obtained by weighting and adding multiple evaluation values, data based on rankings, and data based on the number of similar evaluation values.
[0042] Data that can be converted into the amount of damage means standard conversion data, and the obtained numerical value can be converted into a common value (here, monetary amount such as damages). Data that shows the damage state caused by the occurrence of a disaster as a relative evaluation against a standard state means standard state relative conversion data, and specifically, a standard state is set, and the value state from each viewpoint is evaluated relatively to the standard state to obtain the standard state ratio value. For example, if the state has improved compared to the standard state, it is a positive value, and conversely, if the state has deteriorated, it is a negative value. This data then shows whether the value is positive or negative in terms of a ratio by calculating the degree of positivity or negativity.
[0043] Data obtained by weighting and adding multiple evaluation values means weighted conversion data, and specifically, it is obtained by multiplying different evaluation values by weighting coefficients and adding them. For example, it includes satisfaction in a questionnaire described later. Data based on ranking means rank conversion data, and it is obtained by ranking multiple objects having the same structure for data that is difficult to evaluate absolutely, ratio, or relatively. This data is obtained, for example, by the difference or rank when a similar type of but different phenomenon occurs. Specifically, it corresponds to the case where it is obtained by the population difference within a region, the number per population, the number of administrative facilities within a region (the number of nursery schools and schools, the number of children's parks, etc.). Data based on the number of similar evaluation values means so-called O / X number conversion data, and it is obtained by counting the number of objects of similar value.
[0044] Each of the simulation units 140 to 14N may be configured to perform a simulation of a damage state for a target event according to a time series from the occurrence of a disaster. Each of the simulation units 140 to 14N may receive, as an input value, data indicating a damage state as a simulation result of the other simulation units 140 to 14N that performed a simulation of a damage state for one or more events that occurred before the target event as a time series of the event.
[0045] Furthermore, when the transmission / reception unit 120 receives actual damage data indicating the actual value of the damage state that occurred due to a disaster and the actual situation has become clear, the actual damage data received by the transmission / reception unit 120 can be input to each of the other simulation units 140-14N that are chronologically subsequent to the corresponding simulation unit 140-14N, instead of data indicating the damage state as a simulation result of the corresponding simulation unit 140-14N.
[0046] In addition, when the storage unit 130 stores data on buildings and social infrastructure having a specific added value, the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N include at least a road and building damage simulation unit that simulates the damage state of roads and buildings, and an infrastructure damage simulation unit that simulates the damage state of social infrastructure. Then, the road and building damage simulation unit and the infrastructure damage simulation unit may respectively simulate the damage state of buildings and social infrastructure having a specific added value stored in the storage unit 130, taking into account the specific added value.
[0047] The data conversion unit 150 is configured to convert data indicating the damage state as the simulation result of each of the plurality of simulation units 140 to 14N into data indicating a common social value. The plurality of data converted by the data conversion unit 150 are output to the social value assessment unit 160.
[0048] Furthermore, as described above, when data indicating the damage state is evaluated using multiple different evaluation methods (damage amount conversion, reference state relative conversion, etc.), the data conversion unit 150 is configured to convert multiple pieces of data evaluated using different evaluation methods into multiple pieces of data indicating a common social value.
[0049] Furthermore, when the transmission / reception unit 120 receives damage status data indicating actual values of the damage status that have become clear, the data conversion unit 150 converts the damage status data into data indicating a common social value, and reconverts the data indicating the damage status as new simulation results of the simulation unit 140-14N to which the damage status data has been input and other simulation units 140-14N related to the simulation unit 140-14N into data indicating a common social value. As a result, the damage status becomes clearer over time, and the simulation results of the simulation units 140-14N become more accurate.
[0050] The social value assessment unit 160 is configured to assess a change in social value due to a disaster, based on the multiple data converted by the data conversion unit 150. The transmission / reception unit 120 may transmit the change in social value assessed by the social value assessment unit 160 (a change in a negative value in the event of a disaster) to the government agency server 210 or each of the ministry and agency servers 220 to 22N.
[0051] When the transmission / reception unit 120 receives damage status data indicating actual values of the damage status in which the actual situation has been clarified, the simulation units 140 to 14N output new simulation results, and the data conversion unit 150 performs conversion again, the social value assessment unit 160 may re-evaluate the change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted value of the damage status data received by the transmission / reception unit 120 and the data indicating the common social value re-converted by the data conversion unit 150. By the social value assessment unit 160 re-evaluating the change in social value using the converted value based on the damage status data, it is possible to re-evaluate social value in accordance with the actual damage situation, and, if necessary, to re-recommend countermeasures suited to the actual situation of the disaster.
[0052] Here, there will be explained an outline of a series of operations of the disaster assessment device 100. Depending on the disaster state after the occurrence of a disaster, the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N perform various simulations and output data indicating the damage state and restoration state as the simulation results.
[0053] The data conversion unit 150 converts each data into data indicating a common social value, and the social value assessment unit 160 assesses a change in social value due to a disaster based on the multiple converted data. Here, the control unit 110 may cause the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N to perform an error calculation optimization process so that the assessment result of the social value assessment unit 160 becomes as high as possible.
[0054] The error calculation optimization process is a process in which the data input to each of the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N is shifted little by little to obtain the evaluation result of the social value assessment unit 160 each time. By optimizing the evaluation result, it is possible to suppress the decline in social value in a damaged state. Obtaining such a simulation result is only possible by performing a comprehensive evaluation by the social value assessment unit 160.
[0055] Specifically, in this error calculation optimization process, the control unit 110 changes the contents of rescue, relief, and recovery in the multiple simulation units 140 to 14N, while the social value evaluation unit 160 evaluates the change in social value, and obtains the difference in the obtained social value. Then, the control unit 110 calculates the relative difference with the social value expected at the time of the disaster occurrence, and searches for an optimal solution while performing coefficient correction so that this social value is optimized. As a method for searching for an optimal solution, conventional methods such as error random number optimization method and exhaustive calculation method may be adopted.
[0056] The disaster assessment device 100 may then recommend corrections to policies and countermeasures to be taken by the national or local governments, based on the content of rescue, relief, and recovery that is the optimal solution determined by the error calculation optimization process by the control unit 110.
[0057] By configuring the social value assessment unit 160 as described above, it is possible to obtain a relatively comprehensive judgment result (assessment result) early and to propose multiple countermeasures with an order of priority based on the change in the assessed social value. Therefore, the disaster assessment device 100 can support the political judgment of the overall judge, who is the head of the country or each local government in the disaster area.
[0058] Digital twins that have been used up until now for use in disasters have only been used to simulate the state of damage caused by a disaster and evaluate the state and circumstances of the damage caused by the disaster as a result of the simulation. According to the disaster assessment device 100 of this embodiment, as described above, the state of damage caused by a disaster can be comprehensively assessed. In order to evaluate the resilience of society as a whole against this damage, numerical values and the like as simulation results obtained from simulations of multiple types of events can be efficiently combined to comprehensively evaluate social value.
[0059] Furthermore, according to the disaster assessment device 100 of this embodiment, data indicating actual values of the damage state when the actual situation becomes clear is fed back, taking into consideration the execution of multiple simulations according to time series. Then, by performing simulations again using the relevant simulation units 140-14N after the relevant simulation unit 140-14N, errors in the simulation results by the multiple simulation units 140-14N can be corrected, and this makes it possible to effectively prevent the assessment by the social value assessment unit 160 from being overestimated.
[0060] If the initial simulation results by each of the multiple simulation units 140-14N deviate from the actual values of the damage state or restoration state when the actual situation becomes clear beyond an allowable range, the control unit 110 may be configured to review the simulation coefficients, etc., in the corresponding simulation unit 140-14N. This allows for a more accurate evaluation of the change in social value due to the disaster in the early stages.
[0061] <Operation of the disaster evaluation device> Next, the operation of disaster assessment device 100 of this embodiment will be described with reference to FIG. First, the evaluation of the damage state when a disaster occurs will be described. Fig. 4 is a flowchart showing an outline of the disaster damage assessment process according to this embodiment. This disaster damage assessment process is started, for example, when a disaster occurs and disaster occurrence information is provided from the government agency server 210 and each ministry and agency server 220-22N. Here, as with the above, the operation of the disaster assessment device 100 when an earthquake occurs as a disaster will be described.
[0062] When disaster occurrence information is received, the disaster assessment device 100 requests the government agency server 210 and each ministry / agency server 220-22N to transmit information related to the disaster via the transmission / reception unit 120. Then, the transmission / reception unit 120 receives information on the scale and epicenter of the earthquake (disaster occurrence information) (step S1), and outputs the received information to the multiple simulation units 140-14N. Each of the multiple simulation units 140-14N executes a simulation of the damage state for the corresponding event in chronological order based on the information on the scale and epicenter of the earthquake (step S2). Each simulation unit 140-14N outputs data indicating the damage state as a simulation result to the other simulation units 140-14N in the subsequent stage as is, and also outputs the same data to the data conversion unit 150 as necessary. When data indicating the damage state is received from the simulation units 140 to 14N, the data conversion unit 150 converts each of the multiple data indicating the damage state as the simulation results of the corresponding simulation units 140 to 14N into data indicating a common social value (step S3).
[0063] The data conversion unit 150 outputs data (converted value) indicating the converted social value to other simulation units 140 to 14N in the subsequent stage as necessary, and also outputs the data to the social value assessment unit 160. When the data indicating the social value converted by the data conversion unit 150 for the simulation results of all the simulation units 140 to 14N is received, the social value assessment unit 160 assesses the change in social value due to the disaster based on these multiple pieces of data (step S4).
[0064] Although not shown in the flowchart of Figure 4, at the stage when the change in social value due to a disaster has been evaluated, the disaster assessment device 100 may transmit the evaluation results to a government agency server 210, etc. via the transmission / reception unit 120 and the network 300.
[0065] Next, the control unit 110 judges whether or not the transmission / reception unit 120 has received damage status data indicating an actual value of the damage state corresponding to any of the multiple simulation results of the multiple simulation units 140-14N from the relevant government agency servers 220-22N (step S5). The disaster assessment device 100 waits in this step S5 until the transmission / reception unit 120 receives such damage status data.
[0066] When the control unit 110 determines that any of the damage status data has been received by the transmission / reception unit 120, the transmission / reception unit 120 outputs the received damage status data to the subsequent simulation unit 140-14N in a time series related to the corresponding simulation unit 140-14N. Then, the simulation unit 140-14N that has received the damage status data executes its own simulation again, and outputs data indicating the damage status as a new simulation result to the other related simulation units 140-14N in the subsequent stage. The other related simulation units 140-14N in the subsequent stage similarly execute their own simulation again, and as a result, the simulation of the corresponding simulation unit 140-14N is executed (step S6).
[0067] Next, similarly to the process of step S3, the data conversion unit 150 converts again the data indicating the damage situation as the simulation result of the simulation units 140 to 14N that executed the simulation again into data indicating a common social value (step S7). Then, the social value assessment unit 160 reassess the change in social value due to the disaster based on a plurality of data including the reconverted data (converted value) (step S8).
[0068] Then, the control unit 110 ends this disaster damage assessment process. Although not shown in the flowchart of Fig. 4, the disaster assessment device 100 may transmit the reassessment result to the government agency server 210 or the like via the transmission / reception unit 120 and the network 300 every time a change in social value due to a disaster is reassessed.
[0069] The type of damage actual data obtained varies depending on the type of disaster being simulated, but after starting the disaster damage assessment process, the disaster assessment device 100 simply repeats steps S5 to S8 of the disaster damage assessment process until all damage actual data has been received by the transmitter / receiver 120.
[0070] As described above, the disaster assessment device 100 according to this embodiment includes a plurality of simulation units 140-14N that respectively perform simulations of damage states for a plurality of types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of a disaster, a data conversion unit 150 that converts data indicating the damage states as the simulation results of each of the plurality of simulation units 140-14N into data indicating a common social value, and a social value assessment unit 160 that assesses changes in social value due to a disaster based on the plurality of data converted by the data conversion unit 150. By configuring the disaster assessment device 100 in this way, data indicating the damage states as the simulation results of a plurality of simulations is converted into data indicating a common social value, and social value is assessed based on the converted data, so that the damage state due to the occurrence of a disaster can be comprehensively assessed.
[0071] The disaster assessment method according to the present embodiment is configured to perform simulations of damage conditions for multiple types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of a disaster, convert data showing the damage conditions as the results of the multiple simulations into data showing a common social value, and evaluate changes in social value caused by the disaster based on the multiple converted data. This provides the same effects as the disaster assessment device 100.
[0072] A part or all of the processing in the disaster assessment device 100 described above can be realized as a computer program. Such a program can be stored and supplied to a computer using various types of non-transitory computer-readable media. The non-transitory computer-readable medium includes various types of tangible recording media. Examples of the non-transitory computer-readable medium include magnetic recording media (e.g., flexible disks, magnetic tapes, hard disk drives), magneto-optical recording media (e.g., magneto-optical disks), CD-ROMs (Read Only Memory), CD-Rs, CD-R / Ws, and semiconductor memories (e.g., mask ROMs, PROMs (Programmable ROMs), EPROMs (Erasable PROMs), flash ROMs, and RAMs (Random Access Memory)). The program may also be supplied to a computer by various types of temporary computer-readable media. Examples of the temporary computer-readable medium include electrical signals, optical signals, and electromagnetic waves. The temporary computer-readable medium can supply the program to a computer via a wired communication path such as an electric wire and an optical fiber, or via a wireless communication path.
[0073] Although the present invention has been described with reference to the embodiment, the present invention is not limited to the above embodiment and can be modified as appropriate without departing from the spirit of the present invention.
[0074] A part or all of the above-described embodiments may be described as, but is not limited to, the following supplementary notes. (Appendix 1) a plurality of simulation units each performing a simulation of a damage state for a plurality of types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of the disaster; a data conversion unit that converts data indicating the damage state as a simulation result of each of the plurality of simulation units into data indicating a common social value; a social value assessment unit that assesses a change in social value due to the disaster based on the plurality of data converted by the data conversion unit; A disaster assessment device comprising: (Appendix 2) The data indicating the damage state as a result of a plurality of simulations by the plurality of simulation units includes data that can be converted into an amount of damage, data indicating a relative evaluation of the damage state caused by the occurrence of the disaster with respect to a reference state, data obtained by weighting and adding a plurality of evaluation values, data based on ranking, and data based on the number of evaluation values of the same order, The data conversion unit converts the plurality of data evaluated by different evaluation methods into a plurality of data indicating the common social value. 2. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 1. (Appendix 3) Each of the plurality of simulation units receives as input values a disaster variable value that varies depending on the type of the disaster, a non-disaster variable value that varies depending on the time elapsed since the occurrence of the disaster regardless of the type of the disaster, and a fixed value that does not vary depending on the type of the disaster. 2. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 1. (Appendix 4) Each of the plurality of simulation units performs a simulation of a damage state for the event in accordance with a time series from the occurrence of the disaster, Each of the plurality of simulation units receives, as an input value, data indicating a damage state as a simulation result of the other simulation units that have performed a simulation of the damage state for one or more events that occurred before the event as the time series of the target event. 2. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 1. (Appendix 5) A transmission / reception unit for receiving damage status data indicating an actual value of the damage status that has occurred due to the disaster and the actual situation has become clear, The damage status data received by the transmission / reception unit is input to each of the plurality of simulation units instead of data indicating the damage status as a simulation result of the other simulation units. 5. A disaster assessment device as described in appendix 4. (Appendix 6) the data conversion unit converts the damage status data into data indicating a common social value, and converts again data indicating the damage status as a new simulation result of the simulation unit to which the damage status data has been input and the other simulation units related to the simulation unit into data indicating the common social value; The social value assessment unit reassess a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted value of the damage actual situation data received by the transmission / reception unit and the data indicating the common social value reconverted by the data conversion unit. 6. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 5. (Appendix 7) The transmitting / receiving unit receives disaster occurrence information indicating a scale and a location of the disaster after the disaster occurs, the plurality of simulation units respectively perform simulations of damage states for the plurality of types of events based on the disaster occurrence information received by the transmission / reception unit. 6. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 5. (Appendix 8) If the disaster is caused by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami, the damage caused by the disaster includes damage to buildings and facilities in flooded areas, damage to historical and social assets, damage to logistics and economic activities, and human damage. 2. A disaster assessment device as described in appended claim 1. (Appendix 9) Further comprising a storage unit for storing data of buildings and social infrastructure having specific added value; The plurality of simulation units include at least a road and building damage simulation unit that simulates a damage state of a road and a building, and an infrastructure damage simulation unit that simulates a damage state of a social infrastructure, the road / building damage simulation unit and the infrastructure damage simulation unit respectively perform a simulation of the damage state of the buildings and social infrastructure having the specific added value stored in the storage unit, the simulation taking into account the specific added value; 9. A disaster assessment apparatus as described in appended claim 8. (Appendix 10) In response to the occurrence of a disaster, a simulation of damage conditions for a plurality of types of events caused by the disaster is carried out, converting the data indicating the damage state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; Evaluating a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted data. Disaster assessment methods. (Appendix 11) On the computer, A process of simulating a damage state caused by a disaster for each of a plurality of types of events in response to the occurrence of the disaster; A process of converting the data indicating the restoration state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; A process of evaluating a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted values of the damage states of the multiple simulation results; A program to execute. [Industrial Applicability]
[0075] The disaster assessment device etc. disclosed herein can be applied to applications such as comprehensively assessing the damage caused by the occurrence of a disaster, comprehensively assessing the recovery state during recovery from a disaster, and predicting the happiness level of disaster victims during recovery from a disaster. [Explanation of symbols]
[0076] 100 Disaster Assessment Device 110 Control section 120 Transmitter / receiver 130 Storage section 140-14N Simulation Department 150 Data conversion section 160 Social Value Assessment Department 210 Government Server 220-22N Servers for various ministries and agencies 230 People Flow Server 240 Traffic related servers 300 Network
Claims
1. a plurality of simulation units each performing a simulation of a damage state for a plurality of types of events caused by a disaster in response to the occurrence of the disaster; a data conversion unit that converts data indicating the damage state as a simulation result of each of the plurality of simulation units into data indicating a common social value; a social value assessment unit that assesses a change in social value due to the disaster based on the plurality of data converted by the data conversion unit; A disaster assessment device comprising:
2. The data indicating the damage state as a result of a plurality of simulations by the plurality of simulation units includes data that can be converted into an amount of damage, data indicating a relative evaluation of the damage state caused by the occurrence of the disaster with respect to a reference state, data obtained by weighting and adding a plurality of evaluation values, data based on ranking, and data based on the number of evaluation values of the same order, The data conversion unit converts the plurality of data evaluated by different evaluation methods into a plurality of data indicating the common social value. The disaster assessment device according to claim 1 .
3. Each of the plurality of simulation units performs a simulation of a damage state for the event in accordance with a time series from the occurrence of the disaster, Each of the plurality of simulation units receives, as an input value, data indicating a damage state as a simulation result of the other simulation units that have performed a simulation of the damage state for one or more events that occurred before the event as the time series of the target event. The disaster assessment device according to claim 1 .
4. A transmission / reception unit for receiving damage status data indicating an actual value of the damage status that has occurred due to the disaster and the actual situation has become clear, The damage status data received by the transmission / reception unit is input to each of the plurality of simulation units instead of data indicating the damage status as a simulation result of the other simulation units. The disaster assessment device according to claim 3 .
5. the data conversion unit converts the damage status data into data indicating a common social value, and converts again data indicating the damage status as a new simulation result of the simulation unit to which the damage status data has been input and the other simulation units related to the simulation unit into data indicating the common social value; The social value assessment unit reassess a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted value of the damage actual situation data received by the transmission / reception unit and the data indicating the common social value reconverted by the data conversion unit. The disaster assessment device according to claim 4 .
6. The transmitting / receiving unit receives disaster occurrence information indicating a scale and a location of the disaster after the disaster occurs, the plurality of simulation units respectively perform simulations of damage states for the plurality of types of events based on the disaster occurrence information received by the transmission / reception unit. The disaster assessment device according to claim 4 or 5.
7. If the disaster is an earthquake and subsequent tsunami, the damage caused by the disaster includes damage to buildings and facilities in flooded areas, damage to historical and social assets, damage to logistics and economic activities, and human damage. The disaster assessment device according to any one of claims 1 to 5.
8. Further comprising a storage unit for storing data of buildings and social infrastructure having specific added value; The plurality of simulation units include at least a road and building damage simulation unit that simulates a damage state of a road and a building, and an infrastructure damage simulation unit that simulates a damage state of a social infrastructure, the road / building damage simulation unit and the infrastructure damage simulation unit respectively perform a simulation of the damage state of the buildings and social infrastructure having the specific added value stored in the storage unit, the simulation taking into account the specific added value; The disaster assessment device according to claim 7.
9. In response to the occurrence of a disaster, a simulation of damage conditions for a plurality of types of events caused by the disaster is carried out, converting the data indicating the damage state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; Evaluating a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted data. Disaster assessment methods.
10. On the computer, A process of simulating a damage state caused by a disaster for each of a plurality of types of events in response to the occurrence of the disaster; A process of converting the data indicating the restoration state as a result of a plurality of simulations into data indicating a common social value; A process of evaluating a change in social value due to the disaster based on the converted values of the damage states of the multiple simulation results; A program to execute.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Earthquake damage evaluation system and recording medium
JP1999175623A
Cited By
Disaster evaluation device, disaster evaluation method, and program
WO2025197484A1
