Information processing device, information processing method, recording medium, and program
The information processing device addresses the need for evaluating and improving sales negotiation skills by comparing negotiation data with reference standards, presenting improvement points, and monitoring action adherence, thereby enhancing negotiation abilities.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023086314
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies lack effective methods to evaluate and improve the negotiation skills of sales personnel in remote business negotiations, particularly for those with little experience, by providing appropriate evaluation data and efficient learning environments.
An information processing device that compares analysis data from business negotiations with reference data to generate evaluation data, monitors and presents improvement points, and notifies the salesperson and their superiors about their actions during the negotiation process.
The system provides clear improvement points for sales personnel, enhances their negotiation skills by monitoring and notifying actions, and allows superiors to assess the effectiveness of the evaluation data usage.
Smart Images

Figure 2024169111000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to an information processing device, an information processing method, a recording medium, and a program, and to a technique relating to evaluation and education regarding interviews. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, synchronous shared communication has become widespread as communication between users via a network such as the Internet. The synchronous shared communication here refers to communication between users that is carried out by synchronously displaying display content including, for example, a common image on a guest terminal and a host terminal. For example, by sharing display content including captured images of each user as the display content, each user can realize communication while checking the appearance of the other user and themselves.
[0003] Such synchronous shared communication is also effectively used in sales meetings (business negotiations). Patent Document 1 listed below discloses a technology for confirming and examining business negotiations, assuming that such a technology is used in such situations. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2022-71874 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] By using synchronous shared communication, for example, in business negotiations, a customer and a sales representative in remote locations can proceed with the discussion while seeing each other or sharing explanatory materials.
[0006] When considering business negotiations through synchronous shared communication from the company's perspective, it is important to improve the sales representatives' sales negotiation skills. For example, it is desirable to provide an appropriate evaluation to sales representatives with little experience in sales negotiations and provide them with an efficient learning environment.
[0007] Therefore, the present invention provides a technique for presenting appropriate evaluation data to sales personnel regarding interviews such as business negotiations, and for contributing to training in interview techniques. [Means for solving the problem]
[0008] The information processing device of the present invention is equipped with a control unit that executes a presentation control process that presents evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data that serves as a comparison standard for multiple evaluation items related to the interview, and a notification control process that monitors a specified action of the person being evaluated in response to the presentation and executes a notification regarding the specified action.
[0009] The interviews to which the technology of the present invention can be applied include various opportunities for communication between people, such as business negotiations, medical treatment, counseling, lectures, presentations, education, entertainment, and other interviews, as well as online interviews and face-to-face interviews. The interview information is, for example, image and audio information during the interview.
[0010] In the present invention, the above configuration allows the person being evaluated to be, for example, a sales representative, and by comparing the interview with the standard data, evaluation data is generated and presented that indicates areas where the person being evaluated should improve. Also, it is monitored whether the person being evaluated actually takes action in response to the presentation, such as watching an ideal video, and the person being evaluated and their superiors are notified of the result. Effect of the Invention
[0011] According to the present invention, improvement points for a salesperson can be presented as evaluation data, which can be used to improve sales capabilities. In addition, by actually monitoring and notifying the actions of a salesperson, the salesperson and his / her superior can recognize whether the evaluation data is being used effectively. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0012] [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram of a schematic configuration example of a communication support system according to an embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram of display contents synchronously displayed in the communication support system according to the embodiment. [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of an information processing device serving as a negotiation analysis server according to an embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram of a functional configuration of an information processing device serving as a negotiation analysis server according to an embodiment. [Diagram 5] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram of the contents stored in a database according to an embodiment. [Figure 6] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram of the entire process according to the embodiment; [Figure 7] 13 is a flowchart of analysis data processing of high performers and low performers according to an embodiment. [Figure 8] FIG. 4 is an explanatory diagram of the contents of an analysis data group according to the embodiment. [Figure 9] 10 is a flowchart of generation of model data according to an embodiment. [Figure 10] FIG. 4 is an explanatory diagram of the contents of an analysis data group using model data according to the embodiment. [Figure 11] 11 is a flowchart of a reference data setting process according to an embodiment. [Figure 12] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram of negotiation attributes according to an embodiment. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram of an analysis according to an embodiment. [Figure 14] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram of identifying a focused evaluation item according to an embodiment. [Figure 15]13 is a flowchart of an evaluation data generation process according to the embodiment. [Figure 16] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram of presentation contents based on evaluation data according to the embodiment. [Figure 17] 13 is a flowchart of an attention data generation process according to an embodiment. [Figure 18] 11 is a flowchart of a presentation control process according to an embodiment. [Figure 19] 11 is a flowchart of a notification control process according to an embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0013] The embodiments will be described below in the following order. <1. System configuration> <2. Configuration of the information processing device as the negotiation analysis server device> <3. Overall process flow> <4. Storage and processing of analytical data> <5. Reference data setting process> <6. Evaluation data generation process> <7. Attention data generation processing> <8. Presentation and notification of evaluation data> <9. Effects and Modifications of the Embodiments>
[0014] In the embodiment, an example of an "interview" is a "business negotiation" between a sales representative and a customer. An "interview image" is, for example, an image (including video, still images, slide images, etc.) that records the state of the interview, and mainly includes video video and audio. In the embodiment, this interview image is an image that records screen video and audio during a business negotiation conducted through synchronous shared communication. This will be referred to as a "business negotiation image."
[0015] <1. System configuration> FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing an example of a schematic configuration of a communication support system 100 according to an embodiment of the present invention. As shown in the figure, the communication support system 100 includes a communication support device 1 (hereinafter referred to as “support device 1”), a web server device 2, a guest terminal 5, a host terminal 6, and a negotiation analysis server device 7.
[0016] The support device 1, web server device 2, guest terminal 5, host terminal 6, and negotiation analysis server device 7 are configured as information processing devices equipped with a microcomputer having a CPU (Central Processing Unit), ROM (Read Only Memory), and RAM (Random Access Memory).
[0017] In this example, a support device 1, a web server device 2, a guest terminal 5, a host terminal 6, and a negotiation analysis server device 7 are capable of mutual data communication via a network 4 such as the Internet.
[0018] The guest terminal 5 is an information processing device used by a guest user U1, and the host terminal 6 is an information processing device used by a host user U2. In the embodiment, an example will be described in which the communication support system 100 is used in business negotiations for a transaction, so the guest user U1 is a customer and the host user U2 is a sales representative. Therefore, in the following, the guest user U1 will be referred to as "customer U1" and the host user U2 will be referred to as "sales representative U2."
[0019] However, this does not mean that the communication support system 100 of the embodiment is applicable only to business negotiations between a person in charge and a customer. The communication support system 100 of the embodiment is applicable to communication support in interviews between users with various relationships, not limited to the relationship between a customer and a person in charge. For example, the communication support system 100 is suitable as a system for supporting communication within an organization such as a company or a school, communication within a community, communication between friends, communication within a family, etc.
[0020] The support device 1 is an information processing device that performs various processes for performing synchronous shared communication between a customer U1 and a person in charge U2, and is used by a service manager who operates a service that provides synchronous shared communication.
[0021] The synchronous shared communication referred to here means communication between users by synchronously displaying display content including a common image on the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6 .
[0022] 2A and 2B show examples of display contents that are synchronously displayed to a customer U1 and a person in charge U2 in synchronous shared communication. Here, an example is shown of the display content when the images provided from the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6 are captured images of each user, with Figure 2A showing an example of the display content on the guest terminal 5 and Figure 2B showing an example of the display content on the host terminal 6.
[0023] In this case, on the guest terminal 5, as shown in Fig. 2A, the captured image vU2 (image provided by the host terminal 6) of the person in charge U2 as the communication partner is displayed large, and the captured image vU1 of the customer U1 as the user is displayed small. Similarly, on the host terminal 6, as shown in Fig. 2B, the captured image vU1 (image provided by the guest terminal 5) of the customer U1 as the communication partner is displayed large, and the captured image vU2 of the person in charge U2 as the user is displayed small. For example, a business negotiation can be carried out while viewing each other's images in this way.
[0024] In addition, in Fig. 2, an example of synchronous display of display contents in synchronous shared communication is shown in which captured images are displayed synchronously on each other's terminals, but the images to be displayed synchronously are not limited to captured images. For example, it is also conceivable that the customer U1 and the person in charge U2 may share some kind of document instead of captured images, in which case the image to be displayed synchronously would be an image showing the document. In this case, the synchronous display may be such that, for example, when one of the users who provides the document, either the customer U1 or the person in charge U2, performs a page forward operation on the document, the other user also forwards the page of the document.
[0025] Furthermore, when sharing materials as described above, the materials to be shared may be materials that the user has previously uploaded to the support device 1. In this case, the support device 1 may convert the uploaded materials into a format suitable for a slide show and store them, and during synchronous shared communication, it may be possible to synchronously display slide images of the materials thus stored on the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6. In this disclosure, "business negotiation images" is a general term for images displayed during business negotiations, such as images captured by each other's cameras, materials shared and displayed on the screen for explanation purposes, and controls such as icons.
[0026] The guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6 are configured as information processing devices having an imaging function and a calling function. The calling function here is not limited to a function for calling via a telephone line, but broadly means a function for calling via a communication line other than a telephone line, such as an Internet line. Specifically, the host terminal 6 and the guest terminal 5 may each be configured as, for example, a personal computer, a tablet terminal, or a smartphone.
[0027] In Figure 1, the support device 1 receives images provided from a guest terminal 5 and a host terminal 6, and performs various processes to enable synchronous shared communication between a customer U1 and a person in charge U2, such as processing to synchronously display display content between the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6.
[0028] 1 shows only one pair of guest terminal 5 and host terminal 6 as the target terminals of the synchronous shared communication, but the support device 1 can perform processing for synchronous shared communication not only for one pair of guest terminal 5 and host terminal 6, but also for multiple pairs of guest terminals 5 and host terminals 6. That is, although not shown in the figure, in the communication support system 100 in this example, there are actually multiple guest terminals 5 and multiple host terminals 6. In this example, the synchronous shared communication is one-to-one communication between users, and the support device 1 performs necessary processing such as connection between terminals for multiple pairs of such one-to-one synchronous shared communication.
[0029] However, since the processing for synchronous shared communication performed by the support device 1 is similar for each pair of a guest terminal 5 and a host terminal 6, in the following explanation, only one representative pair of a guest terminal 5 and a host terminal 6 will be cited to explain the processing related to synchronous shared communication. Although the description will be given taking a one-to-one user pair as an example, one-to-many synchronous shared communication is also possible with, for example, one host terminal 6 and multiple guest terminals 5. For example, a case where one person in charge U2 gives a presentation to multiple customers U1.
[0030] The web server device 2 is an information processing device that provides web page data 2a and the like that should be acquired by the guest terminal 5 and the like in order to realize synchronous shared communication. For example, the web server device 2 provides web pages that are accessed from the guest terminal 5 to start online business negotiations, provides web pages that constitute a UI screen shared between the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6, and provides web pages to be used as business negotiation materials.
[0031] In this example, the web server device 2 is an information processing device managed by a service operator of synchronous shared communication, and constitutes a service operation system 3 together with the support device 1 . In the service operation system 3, data communication may be performed between the support device 1 and the web server device 2 via a network 4. The support device 1 and the web server device 2 may be configured to enable data communication via a communication line other than the network 4. Furthermore, the support device 1 and the web server device 2 may be configured as an integrated device.
[0032] However, the web server device 2 may be a device unrelated to the service operation system 3. For example, when a person in charge U2 shares a website of his / her company with a customer U1 to proceed with business negotiations, the web server device 2 may function as a server for the website.
[0033] The business negotiation analysis server device 7 is an information processing device that performs processing to provide information for evaluation and training of the person in charge U2 with the aim of improving the business negotiation technique of the person in charge U2. For example, the business negotiation analysis server device 7 performs processing to analyze business negotiation images of the business negotiation conducted between the guest terminal 5 and the host terminal 6, generate evaluation data for the person in charge U2, and display the evaluation data on the terminal device of the person in charge U2, or display reference videos that the person in charge U2 should watch. The database 7a is a database in which the negotiation analysis server device 7 stores information for evaluation and presentation. Hereinafter, the database will be abbreviated as "DB."
[0034] The following will provide a detailed explanation of the configuration and processing of the negotiation analysis server device 7 in the communication support system 100 according to the embodiment shown in FIG.
[0035] <2. Configuration of the information processing device as the negotiation analysis server device> FIG. 3 is a block diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of an information processing device 10 that can function as the negotiation analysis server device 7. As shown in FIG.
[0036] 3, the information processing device 10 includes a CPU 11, a ROM 12, and a RAM 13. The CPU 11 functions as an arithmetic processing unit that performs various processes, and executes the various processes according to a program stored in the ROM 12 or a program loaded from the storage unit 19 to the RAM 13. The RAM 13 also stores data and the like required for the CPU 11 to execute the various processes, as appropriate.
[0037] The analysis unit 25 is configured as, for example, a signal processor or an AI (Artificial Intelligence) processor, and is capable of various analytical processes, such as image analysis, voice analysis, etc. In particular, in the case of this embodiment, it is possible to generate analytical data by analyzing business negotiation images and accompanying voice data. The function of the analysis unit 25 may be provided in the CPU 11 .
[0038] The CPU 11, the ROM 12, the RAM 13, and the analysis unit 25 are connected to one another via a bus 14. To this bus 14, an input / output interface (I / F) 15 is also connected.
[0039] An input unit 16 consisting of operators and operation devices is connected to the input / output interface 15. For example, the input unit 16 may be various operators and operation devices such as a keyboard, a mouse, a key, a touch panel, a touch pad, a dial, a remote controller, or the like. An operation is detected by the input unit 16, and a signal corresponding to the detected operation is interpreted by the CPU 11.
[0040] Further, the input / output interface 15 is connected, either integrally or separately, to a display unit 17 formed of an LCD (Liquid Crystal Display) or an organic EL (Electro-Luminescence) panel, or the like, and an audio output unit 18 formed of a speaker, or the like. The display unit 17 is used to display various types of information, and is configured by, for example, a display device provided in the housing of the information processing device 10, a separate display device connected to the information processing device 10, or the like.
[0041] The display unit 17 executes display of images for various image processing, moving images to be processed, etc. on the display screen based on instructions from the CPU 11. Furthermore, the display unit 17 performs display of various operation menus, icons, messages, etc., that is, as a GUI (Graphical User Interface), based on instructions from the CPU 11.
[0042] A storage unit 19 and a communication unit 20 may be connected to the input / output interface 15 . The storage unit 19 is configured with a hard disk drive (HDD) or a solid state drive (SSD), and stores various types of information. A DB may be constructed in the storage unit 19. For example, in the case of an information processing device 10 functioning as the negotiation analysis server device 7, it is also possible to consider that a DB 7a is constructed in the storage unit 19.
[0043] The communication unit 20 performs communication processing via a transmission path such as the Internet, and communication with various devices via wired / wireless communication, bus communication, and the like.
[0044] A drive 22 is also connected to the input / output interface 15 as required, and a removable recording medium 21 such as a memory card or an optical disk is appropriately attached thereto.
[0045] The drive 22 allows data files such as programs used in each process to be read from the removable recording medium 21. The read data files are stored in the storage unit 19, and images and sounds contained in the data files are output on the display unit 17 and the sound output unit 18. In addition, the computer programs and the like read from the removable recording medium 21 are installed in the storage unit 19 as necessary.
[0046] In the information processing device 10 having the above hardware configuration, for example, software for the processing of this embodiment can be installed via network communication by the communication unit 20 or the removable recording medium 21. Alternatively, the software may be stored in advance in the ROM 12, the storage unit 19, etc.
[0047] The CPU 11 performs processing operations based on various programs, thereby executing the necessary information processing and communication processing as the negotiation analysis server device 7.
[0048] Although the above describes the information processing device 10 as the negotiation analysis server device 7, the support device 1, the web server device 2, the guest terminal 5, and the host terminal 6 can also be realized by information processing devices having roughly the same configuration.
[0049] The support device 1, web server device 2, and negotiation analysis server device 7 are not limited to being configured as a single information processing device as shown in Fig. 3, but may be configured as a system of multiple information processing devices. The multiple information processing devices may be configured as a system using a LAN (Local Area Network) or the like, or may be located in a remote location using a VPN (Virtual Private Network) using the Internet or the like. The multiple information processing devices may include information processing devices serving as a server group (cloud) available through a cloud computing service. Furthermore, the support device 1, the web server device 2, and the negotiation analysis server device 7 may be integrated into one information processing device.
[0050] The CPU 11, which is the control unit of the information processing device 10 serving as the negotiation analysis server device 7, has the functions shown in Fig. 4. That is, the CPU 11 has a reference data setting processing unit 11a, an evaluation data generation processing unit 11b, a presentation control processing unit 11c, a notification control processing unit 11d, and a consideration data generation processing unit 11e.
[0051] The reference data setting processing unit 11a has a function of performing a reference data setting process that compares analysis data generated based on highly rated interview information with analysis data generated based on poorly rated interview information for each of a number of evaluation items related to business negotiations, identifies noteworthy evaluation items among the multiple evaluation items based on the differences between the analysis data, and sets reference data for the noteworthy evaluation items. Highly rated interview information is, for example, information on business negotiations of sales representatives with a high record of closing deals in business negotiations, and is information such as video and audio during business negotiations. Lowly rated interview information is, for example, information on business negotiations of sales representatives with a low record of closing deals in business negotiations, and is information such as video and audio during business negotiations. In the case of business negotiations, these high and low ratings are expected to be based on the evaluation of sales performance, but even when this technology is applied to interviews other than business negotiations, for example, interviews in various fields such as medicine, counseling, lectures, presentations, education, and entertainment, highly rated interview information and low rated interview information may be selected based on an evaluation according to the purpose of the interview.
[0052] In the embodiment, a business negotiation image is given as an example of highly evaluated interview information and low evaluated interview information. For example, highly evaluated interview information is a business negotiation image of a person in charge of high business negotiation performance (hereinafter referred to as a "high performer"). For example, it is a business negotiation image of a person in charge of high business negotiation success rate, a person in charge of many successful deals, etc. The low-evaluation interview information is sales negotiation images of representatives with low sales negotiation performance (hereinafter referred to as "low performers"). For example, sales negotiation images of representatives with low sales negotiation success rates or inexperienced representatives. Sales negotiation images are images (videos, still images, pseudo-video slide images, etc.) that record screen video and audio during sales negotiations.
[0053] The analysis data is data obtained by analyzing various evaluation items in business negotiations from business negotiation images (e.g., videos and accompanying audio). The evaluation item of interest is an evaluation item that deserves attention among a plurality of evaluation items, particularly an evaluation item for which there is a large difference in analytical data between high performers and low performers. The baseline data is data that serves as a standard for evaluating each individual person in charge U2. By generating baseline data based on the focus evaluation items, it is possible to generate baseline data that reflects the negotiation techniques and negotiation tips of high performers.
[0054] The evaluation data generation processing unit 11b is a function that performs evaluation data generation processing to generate evaluation data for the person being evaluated (a certain person in charge U2) by comparing analysis data regarding the evaluation items of interest generated based on the business negotiation image of the person being evaluated with reference data. The evaluation data is evaluation data about the individual person U2 who is the person being evaluated, and is generated by comparing it with standard data that reflects the sales techniques of high performers, and therefore reflects the differences between the high performers and the person being evaluated, U2.
[0055] The presentation control processing unit 11c is a function that performs a presentation control process to present the evaluation data generated by the evaluation data generation processing unit 11b and to store a predetermined action of the person to be evaluated (a certain person in charge U2) in response to the presented content. The predetermined action is, for example, an action of watching a reference video.
[0056] The notification control processing unit 11d is a function that performs notification control processing for executing a notification regarding a predetermined action. In this case, the notification is a notification to the evaluated person in charge U2 himself or a notification to his superior (the manager of the person in charge U2).
[0057] The attention data generation processing unit 11e is a function that performs processing to generate and store attention data to be presented by the person in charge U2 during business negotiations, based on the target evaluation items. The attention data is information that serves as advice to the person in charge U2 during a business negotiation, such as points to note during a business negotiation, desirable behavior and topics, etc. Specifically, for example, information such as matters to be asked of the customer U1 during a business negotiation, ice-breaking time, desirable topics, and how to explain materials is assumed. In particular, it is conceivable that such attention data is displayed on the screen of the host terminal 6 in FIG. 2B during a business negotiation so that the person in charge U2 can see it during the business negotiation.
[0058] Although the CPU 11 has the above-mentioned functions, the CPU 11 of the information processing device 10 serving as the negotiation analysis server device 7 in this embodiment does not need to have all of these functions. For example, the CPU 11 may be configured to include only the reference data setting processing unit 11a and the evaluation data generation processing unit 11b among the functions shown in FIG. Also, a configuration in which the CPU 11 has only the presentation control processing unit 11c and the notification control processing unit 11d among the functions shown in FIG. 4 is conceivable. Furthermore, when the negotiation analysis server device 7 is made up of multiple information processing devices 10, the CPU 11 of each information processing device 10 may have the functions of FIG. 4 in a distributed manner. Furthermore, the CPU 11 may have a processing function not shown in FIG.
[0059] FIG. 5 shows data stored in the DB 7a during the processing of the function of FIG. The business negotiation image data group 71 indicates video data (including audio data) as actual business negotiation images. Every time a business negotiation is held, a business negotiation image is added.
[0060] In the DB 7a, analytical data obtained by analyzing the negotiation images is stored as the analytical data group 72. For example, each time an analytical process is performed on the negotiation images of each person in charge U2, analytical data corresponding to the negotiation images is added. This includes analytical data obtained by analyzing the negotiation images of high performers and analytical data obtained by analyzing the negotiation images of low performers.
[0061] In the DB 7a, reference data generated by the reference data setting processing unit 11a is stored as the reference data group 73. Although one piece of reference data may be used, it is preferable to generate a plurality of pieces of reference data according to, for example, business negotiation attributes (industry, product, customer type, etc.).
[0062] The DB 7a stores the attention data generated by the attention data generation processing unit 11e as the attention data group 74. For example, attention data is generated for each negotiation attribute and is additionally stored.
[0063] The DB 7a stores the evaluation data generated by the evaluation data generation processing unit 11b as the evaluation data group 75. Every time an evaluation process is performed on the person in charge U2, the generated evaluation data is additionally stored.
[0064] <3. Overall process flow> The overall flow of processing by the negotiation analysis server device 7 will be described with reference to FIG.
[0065] The sales negotiation analysis server device 7 performs sales negotiation analysis of the high performer in step ST1. This is a process of analyzing various evaluation items from the sales negotiation images of the person in charge U2 selected as a high performer (referred to as "high performer U2H" for distinction), converting them into numerical values and text, and saving them.
[0066] In step ST2, the sales negotiation analysis server device 7 performs sales negotiation analysis of the low performer. This is a process of analyzing various evaluation items from the sales negotiation image of the person in charge U2 selected as a low performer (referred to as "low performer U2L" for distinction), converting the results into numerical values and text, and saving them.
[0067] The processing order of steps ST1 and ST2 is not fixed. The processing of steps ST1 and ST2 is performed sequentially, and the analysis data of the high performers U2H and the low performers U2L are additionally stored as the analysis data group 72 in the DB7a.
[0068] In step ST3, the negotiation analysis server device 7 determines the evaluation items of interest and generates the reference data. This includes a process of comparing the analysis data of high performers with the analysis data of low performers to determine the evaluation items with the largest difference and setting them as the evaluation items of interest, and a process of generating the reference data based on the evaluation items of interest. In this case, it is desirable to use analysis data of common deal attributes as the analysis data for high performers and the analysis data for low performers.
[0069] In step ST4, the negotiation analysis server device 7 generates evaluation data for a specific person in charge U2 who is to be evaluated (hereinafter, referred to as "evaluatee U2d" for the sake of distinction). This is a process of comparing the analysis data of the negotiation image of the evaluatee U2d with the reference data to generate evaluation data for the evaluatee U2d.
[0070] In step ST5, the negotiation analysis server device 7 displays an image based on the evaluation data on the screen of the host terminal 6 used by the appraisee U2d, and presents the contents of the evaluation data. In this case, the server device 7 also monitors the actions of the appraisee U2d in response to the presentation (e.g., watching a reference video), and notifies the appraisee U2d himself or his superior.
[0071] The negotiation analysis server device 7 can generate attention data in step ST6 in response to the determination of the notable evaluation items in step ST3. Since the notable evaluation items are evaluation items with a large difference between the high performers U2H and the low performers U2L, attention data including contents to be noted during negotiations can be generated based on the notable evaluation items.
[0072] <4. Storage and processing of analytical data> A specific example of the process at each step in Fig. 6 will now be described. First, the process of generating and saving the analysis data at steps ST1 and ST2 will be described.
[0073] FIG. 7A shows a specific example of processing in step ST1 of FIG. The CPU 11, which is the control unit of the negotiation analysis server device 7, selects a high performer U2H in step S101 of Fig. 7A. For example, in response to an operation by a manager or the like to select a person in charge U2 with good sales performance, the CPU 11 selects the person in charge U2 as a high performer U2H. Alternatively, the CPU 11 may automatically select a high performer U2H by referring to a database that stores sales performance and the like.
[0074] In step S102, the CPU 11 performs a process of analyzing the sales negotiation of the high performer U2H. For example, the CPU 11 reads out the sales negotiation image of the selected high performer U2H from the DB 7a, analyzes it for various evaluation items in the analysis unit 25, and receives the analysis results.
[0075] There are many possible evaluation items, such as "ice-breaking time," "keywords used in ice-breaking," "time to explain slides," "speaking speed," "time to listen to requests," "question keywords," "number of nods," "proportion of speaking," "number of smiles," etc. Of course, evaluation items may also change depending on negotiation attributes such as industry, product, type of customer, and negotiation process.
[0076] In step S103, the CPU 11 generates data on the evaluation items for the high performers U2H. For example, the CPU 11 generates data including numerical values and text for each evaluation item as described above from the analysis results of the business negotiation image. For example, "Ice break time: 5 minutes", "Keywords used in ice break: weather, newspaper articles", etc.
[0077] In step S104, the CPU 11 collects the data generated for these evaluation items and stores it in the DB 7a as analysis data for the high performer U2H.
[0078] FIG. 7B shows a specific example of processing in step ST2 in FIG. The CPU 11, which is the control unit of the negotiation analysis server device 7, selects a low performer U2L in step S111 of Fig. 7B. For example, in response to an operation by a manager or the like to select a person U2 with poor sales performance or little experience, the CPU 11 selects that person U2 as a low performer U2L. The CPU 11 may automatically select a low performer U2L by referring to a database that stores sales performance and the like.
[0079] In step S112, the CPU 11 performs a process of analyzing the sales negotiation of the low performer U2L. For example, the CPU 11 reads out the sales negotiation image of the selected low performer U2L from the DB 7a, analyzes it for various evaluation items in the analysis unit 25, and receives the analysis results.
[0080] In step S113, the CPU 11 generates data on the evaluation items for the low performer U2L in the same manner as in step S103 described above. Then, in step S114, the CPU 11 collects the data generated for each evaluation item that is the same as that for the high performers, and stores the collected data in the DB 7a as analysis data for the low performers U2L.
[0081] By the above process, for example, analytical data of one high performer U2H and analytical data of one low performer U2L are obtained. By performing such processes multiple times, the DB 7a is in a state where analytical data of multiple high performers U2H and analytical data of multiple low performers U2L are stored as an analytical data group 72, for example, as shown in FIG. For example, as shown in the figure, the analysis data is stored in a state in which management information, negotiation attributes, file links, etc. are associated with the analysis data.
[0082] The management information includes identification information of the person in charge U2 who has been selected as a high performer U2H or a low performer U2L, information on the business negotiation to be analyzed, the date and time of the business negotiation, and the like.
[0083] The business negotiation attributes include information indicating the industry, merchandise, customer type, business negotiation process, etc., of the business negotiation being analyzed. The industry is information about the industry of the customer you are doing business with, such as IT, construction, manufacturing, retail, service, etc. The merchandise is information on the type and category of goods or services that are the subject of a transaction. The customer type includes information such as the size of the customer (large company, small or medium-sized company, consumer), the age group, sex, job title, etc. of customer U1. The negotiation process is, for example, a stage in the progress of a negotiation, such as information indicating a stage such as "needs analysis," "proposal and explanation," or "negotiation," or information on the number of negotiations.
[0084] The file link is, for example, link information such as video data of the business negotiation image that is the source of the analysis data, or related text data files. The video data to be associated includes a link to the entire video file of the business negotiation that was the subject of the analysis, and may further include information indicating the scene corresponding to each evaluation item in the video (for example, the time codes of the start and end points of the scene). For example, in response to an evaluation item related to ice breaking, the time codes of the start and end points indicating the section of the business negotiation video that was analyzed as an ice breaker may be included.
[0085] In this way, the analysis data of high performers U2H and low performers U2L are stored in association with management information, sales negotiation attributes, file links, etc., making it possible to later select appropriate analysis data and set standard data.
[0086] In the above, an individual as the person in charge U2 is selected as a high performer U2H or a low performer U2L, and analytical data is generated for each individual. However, analytical data may also be generated for models (virtual people) of the high performer U2H or the low performer U2L.
[0087] For example, the CPU 11 performs the process of FIG. 9 to generate model data. In step S121, the CPU 11 selects analytical data to be reflected in the model. For example, when generating model data of a high performer U2H in a certain negotiation attribute, the analytical data of the high performer U2H in the corresponding negotiation attribute is selected. Then, in step S122, the selected analysis data is used as an input for machine learning, and in step S123, the model data is updated according to the learning results. This process is repeated for the analysis data of multiple high performers U2H with common negotiation attributes until the process is terminated in step S124.
[0088] The same applies to the model for low performers U2L, where machine learning processing is performed using the analytical data of multiple low performers U2L as input.
[0089] As a result, model data for one or more high performers U2H and model data for one or more low performers U2L, for example, as shown in FIG. 10, are generated. The model data for one high performer U2H is, for example, analytical data for each evaluation item generated as a model by inputting analytical data for multiple high performers U2H for specific sales negotiation attributes through machine learning. The associated management information includes information showing the analysis data used to generate the model, update information, etc. As the business negotiation attributes and file links, business negotiation attributes corresponding to the model data and links to video data, etc. are set.
[0090] Similarly, the model data for one low performer U2L is analytical data for each evaluation item as a model generated by machine learning by inputting analytical data for multiple low performers U2L in specific deal attributes, for example.
[0091] <5. Reference data setting process> The reference data setting in step ST3 in Fig. 6 will be described with reference to Fig. 11. The CPU 11 sets the reference data using the analysis data of the high performers U2H and the low performers U2L.
[0092] In step S151 of FIG. 11, the CPU 11 determines analysis data for high performers U2H and low performers U2L according to negotiation attributes for which reference data is to be generated. For example, when it is desired to generate reference data for a specific negotiation process in a specific industry, the CPU 11 reads out from the DB 7a the analysis data of the high performers U2H and the low performers U2L in the negotiation attribute of the specific negotiation process in the specific industry. In this case, model data for the high performer U2H, model data for the low performer U2L, or both may be used instead of analysis data for a specific high performer U2H or low performer U2L.
[0093] FIG. 12 shows a schematic diagram of the industry and negotiation process as negotiation attributes. The negotiation processes P1, P2, P3, and P4 are different for each industry A, B, and C, and the contents of each negotiation process are different. Therefore, the desired form (conversation, topics, time allocation, etc.) of the person in charge U2 may be different between negotiations in one industry or negotiation process and negotiations in another industry or negotiation process. Therefore, if one wishes to generate standard data for evaluating a sales negotiation process in a certain industry, one would compare the analytical data of high performers U2H and low performers U2L in that sales negotiation process in that industry.
[0094] For example, FIG. 13 shows the analysis data of the high performer U2H and the analysis data of the low performer U2L (here, the analysis data of time allocation) for the sales negotiation process P2 in the industry A in FIG. In this way, we compare the analytical data of high performers U2H and low performers U2L, who have common sales deal attributes.
[0095] Here, the industry and negotiation process are used as examples, but negotiation attributes such as products and customer attributes may also be targeted. Depending on the purpose of the evaluation, one or more deal attributes are determined, and reference data for the deal attributes is generated.
[0096] In step S152 in FIG. 11, the CPU 11 performs a comparison process for each evaluation item between the analysis data of the high performer U2H and the analysis data of the low performer U2L selected as processing targets. Then, in step S153, the CPU 11 identifies a focus evaluation item according to the negotiation attribute.
[0097] The above process is shown diagrammatically in Figure 14. Figure 14 shows the evaluation items such as "ice-breaking time" and "keywords used in ice-breaking," as well as the analysis results of the high performers U2H and low performers U2L for these evaluation items. In this example, the difference in "ice-breaking time" is large, such as "5 minutes" and "1 minute," while the difference in "speaking speed" is small, such as "1.8 words / second" and "2.0 words / second."
[0098] In addition, whether the difference is large or small can be determined by setting a threshold value for each evaluation item. The threshold value can also be set as the median value by comparing the average value of multiple high performers U2H and the average value of multiple low performers U2L for the same negotiation attribute.
[0099] The difference between the high performers U2H and the low performers U2L in the analysis results of such evaluation items is determined, and the evaluation item with the largest difference is selected as the evaluation item of interest. In the example shown in the figure, the evaluation items of interest are "ice-breaking time," "keywords used in ice-breaking sessions," "time to explain slides," "time to listen to requests," "keyword questions," and "number of nods."
[0100] In step S154 of Fig. 11, the CPU 11 determines the ideal form. Specifically, the analysis result of the high performer U2H for the evaluation item of interest is set as the ideal form. Furthermore, in step S155, the CPU 11 identifies a business negotiation image according to the ideal content. For example, a video of the ice-breaking scene in the business negotiation image of the high performer U2H is identified according to the "ice-breaking time" and "keywords used in ice-breaking" in Fig. 14. For example, the scene can be identified by using the information on the file link described in Fig. 8 and Fig. 10. Alternatively, ice-breaking scenes of other high performers U2H with the same business negotiation attributes may also be identified as corresponding video data at the same time. Also, for the evaluation item of interest, "slide explanation time," video data of slide explanation scenes of the high performer U2H using the analysis data in step S151 and other high performers U2H with the same sales negotiation attributes are associated.
[0101] Then, the reference data is set including numerical values and text data as the ideal form for the evaluation item of interest, and information indicating the corresponding moving image, and this is stored in the DB 7a. In this way, one piece of reference data corresponding to a certain negotiation attribute is set. By performing this process for each sales negotiation attribute, reference data is created according to one or a combination of industry, product, customer type, and sales negotiation process.
[0102] <6. Evaluation data generation process> Next, the generation of evaluation data in step ST4 in Fig. 6 will be described with reference to Fig. 15 and Fig. 16. This is a process of generating evaluation data for an assessee U2d, the assessee being a certain person in charge U2.
[0103] 15, the CPU 11 designates the person in charge U2 who will become the appraiser U2d. For example, in response to input from the person in charge or his / her superior, the CPU 11 designates a specific person in charge U2 as the appraiser U2d.
[0104] In step S172, the CPU 11 analyzes the negotiation image of the assessee U2d and compares it with the reference data as an ideal form. The reference data in this case is the reference data of the same negotiation attribute as the negotiation image of the assessee U2d to be evaluated. In the process of step S172, the CPU 11 first reads out the negotiation image of the assessee U2d from the DB 7a, and has the analysis unit 25 analyze the image to obtain the analysis result for the evaluation item of interest. Then, the analysis result for each evaluation item of interest is compared with the analysis result for the reference data with the common negotiation attribute.
[0105] FIG. 16 shows the analysis results for the benchmark data (i.e., the analysis results for the high performer U2H) and the analysis results for the assessee U2d for the evaluation items of interest in the example of FIG.
[0106] 15, the CPU 11 identifies an evaluation item that should be improved by the assessee U2d (person in charge U2) based on the comparison result. For example, among the evaluation items of interest, an evaluation item with a large difference in numerical value or content as an analysis result is determined to be an evaluation item that should be improved. For example, the analysis results for each item of the assessee U2d are compared with the standard data and scored. In Figure 16, the score of the person in charge is shown as a numerical value. Items with low scores are the evaluation items that need improvement.
[0107] In step S174, the CPU 11 generates evaluation data to be presented for the improvement items. For example, a process of associating a reference negotiation video with an evaluation item for which the assessee U2d has a low score is performed. The reference negotiation video is a video of a scene associated with the evaluation item of interest in the reference data as described above. In addition, if there is data on comments from superiors, colleagues, etc., the data is associated.
[0108] Then, the CPU 11 compiles these notable evaluation items, evaluation items to be improved, scores for each evaluation item, reference video links, comments, and video playback counts, and sets them as evaluation data for the evaluatee U2d.
[0109] The CPU 11 stores the evaluation data thus generated in the DB 7a in step S175. This allows the appraisee U2d and his / her superiors to view the evaluation data for the appraisee U2d thereafter.
[0110] <7. Attention data generation processing> The generation of attention data in step ST6 in FIG. 6 will be described with reference to FIG. With respect to a certain negotiation attribute, the focused evaluation item is determined in step ST3 of FIG. 6, and the CPU 11 generates the attention data based on the focused evaluation item at any timing.
[0111] In step S191 of FIG. 17, the CPU 11 acquires the evaluation item of interest. In step S192, the CPU 11 generates attention data based on the evaluation items of interest. For example, in a certain negotiation attribute, the evaluation items of interest themselves become attention data. Topics and keywords used by the high performer U2H in ice-breaking and product explanations are also included in the attention data. Contents of interviews with the customer U1 are also included in the attention data. Time allocation for ice-breaking, interviews, slide explanations, etc. by the high performer U2H is also included in the attention data.
[0112] After generating these pieces of attention data, the CPU 11 stores the attention data in the DB 7a in association with the negotiation attributes in step S193. By carrying out such processing, data is generated that summarizes the points that person in charge U2 should pay attention to during the negotiation for each negotiation attribute. Therefore, by displaying the contents of the attention data on the screen of the host terminal 6 during an actual business negotiation, it is possible to inform the person in charge U2 of the things to be mindful of during the business negotiation. This leads to real-time improvements in the contents of the business negotiation, especially for the next business negotiation onwards.
[0113] <8. Presentation and notification of evaluation data> A specific example of the presentation and notification process in step ST5 of FIG. 6 will be described. FIG. 18 shows an example of the presentation process of the evaluation data.
[0114] The CPU 11 acquires the evaluation data to be presented in step S201 from the DB 7a in response to a request from the terminal of the person in charge U2, etc. For example, the CPU 11 searches for the evaluation data for the person in charge U2 in response to the identification information of the person in charge U2.
[0115] Then, the CPU 11 performs a presentation control process for the evaluation data in step S202. That is, the CPU 11 transmits the evaluation data read from the DB 7a to the terminal device or the like of the person in charge and displays the contents. Specifically, the content shown in FIG. 16 is displayed on the screen.
[0116] For example, the display shows the analysis results of the evaluation items for the high performer U2H (i.e., the standard data), as well as the analysis results for the person in charge U2, and also displays the score. This allows the person in charge U2 to know the evaluation items that he or she needs to improve. In addition, for the evaluation items that need to be improved, one or more links to reference videos are presented as reference negotiation videos. Additionally, if there are any comments from superiors or colleagues about those evaluation items, these will also be displayed.
[0117] By viewing this content, the person in charge U2 can understand where his or her sales negotiation skills are lacking. Also, the person in charge U2 can watch the reference video by clicking on the video link in the reference sales negotiation video. The reference video is a sales negotiation scene of the high performer U2H that corresponds to the evaluation item, and is not the entire sales negotiation. Therefore, the person in charge U2 can easily and quickly watch the scene that is necessary for him / her, without having to watch the entire sales negotiation video or search for the necessary scene.
[0118] When the person in charge U2 who has seen such a presentation performs an operation to watch the video, the CPU 11 proceeds from step S203 to step S205 in Fig. 18 to perform a process of playing the linked video. Then, when playback of the video ends, the CPU 11 proceeds from step S206 to step S207 to perform a process of counting the number of times the video has been played. The count value of the number of times the video has been played is included in the evaluation data of the person in charge U2, and in step S207, the count value stored in the evaluation data is also updated.
[0119] The number of times the reference video has been played is also displayed on the presentation screen. This number of times the reference video has been played is a numerical value based on the counting process in step S207. The display of the number of times the video has been played indicates whether or not the person in charge U2 has actually watched the reference video and is studying to improve his / her sales negotiation skills.
[0120] When the person in charge U2 performs an operation to end viewing of the evaluation data, the CPU 11 ends the presentation process from step S204.
[0121] An example of the notification process is shown in Fig. 19. This notification process may be executed periodically by the CPU 11 for each person in charge U2, for example.
[0122] In step S221, the CPU 11 identifies the person in charge U2 who is the processing target. In step S222, the CPU 11 acquires the evaluation data of the identified person in charge U2 from the DB 7a.
[0123] In step S223, the CPU 11 checks the count value of the number of times the reference video has been played, which is included in the evaluation data, and determines whether or not the video has been viewed a prescribed number of times or more. If the specified number of times is not reached, the CPU 11 proceeds to step S225 and performs a viewing reminder notification process. For example, a process is performed to send a notification to the terminal of the person in charge U2 himself or his superior recommending viewing of the reference video. As a notification method, the fact that the specified number of times has not been reached may be notified by email, or a pop-up display indicating that the specified number of times has not been reached may be executed on the screen of the terminal of the person in charge U2. Furthermore, when the screen for viewing the evaluation data is opened, a display indicating that the specified number of times has not been reached may be displayed on the screen. Note that this viewing reminder notification may be executed periodically until the number of times of playback reaches the specified number.
[0124] If it is determined that the viewing has been performed a prescribed number of times or more, the CPU 11 proceeds from step S223 to step S224, and performs a process of notifying the terminal of the person in charge U2 himself or his superior that the viewing record has been satisfied. In this case, the CPU 11 may notify the personnel evaluation system that the person in charge U2 has satisfied the viewing record.
[0125] For example, by performing the process shown in FIG. 19, a supervisor or other person in charge can check whether each person in charge is effectively using the evaluation data viewing screen.
[0126] <9. Effects and Modifications of the Embodiments> The above embodiment provides the following advantages.
[0127] In the information processing device 10 as the negotiation analysis server device 7 of the embodiment, the CPU 11, which is the control unit, performs a reference data setting process in which, for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to negotiation, first analysis data generated based on the negotiation image of the high performer U2H is compared with second analysis data generated based on the negotiation image of the low performer U2L, and a notable evaluation item is identified based on the difference between the analysis data among the plurality of evaluation items, and reference data is set for the notable evaluation item. The CPU 11 also performs an evaluation data generation process in which the analysis data related to the notable evaluation item generated based on the interview image of the evaluatee U2d is compared with the reference data, and evaluation data for the evaluatee U2d is generated (see Figs. 11 and 15).
[0128] In this sales negotiation analysis server device 7, evaluation items with large differences between sales negotiations of high performers U2H and low performers U2L are identified, and these are used as focus evaluation items to compare each sales representative with the ideal form. This clearly shows the difference between high performers U2H and low performers U2L. In other words, it can be said that the sales negotiation techniques and conversation tips that high performers U2H consciously or unconsciously demonstrate are visualized as focus evaluation items. Then, for each evaluation item of interest, the ideal benchmark data is compared with the analysis data of sales negotiations for each salesperson U2, so the evaluation data clearly identifies the areas where salesperson U2 is lacking, providing information that is useful for improving sales capabilities.
[0129] In the embodiment, in the reference data setting process, the negotiation analysis server device 7 identifies key evaluation items by comparing analysis data generated based on negotiation images of a high performer U2H and a low performer U2L with the same negotiation attributes (see steps S201 to S153 in FIG. 11). Depending on the attributes of sales negotiations, the evaluation items that cause differences between high performers U2H and low performers U2L may differ. Therefore, the evaluation items of interest are determined based on the analysis data of high performers U2H and low performers U2L based on sales negotiation images with the same sales negotiation attributes. This makes it possible to set standard data for evaluations that are appropriate for sales negotiation attributes. It is also possible to set the reference data from the viewpoint of general negotiations, without making distinctions based on negotiation attributes.
[0130] In the embodiment, the negotiation attribute is an attribute of the negotiation, and includes any one of information on the industry in which the negotiation is conducted, information on the product, information on the negotiation process, and information on the customer type. It is considered that the preferred method and technique of negotiations differ depending on the industry, product, negotiation process, customer type, etc. Therefore, it is appropriate to compare the analysis data of high performers U2H and low performers U2L based on negotiation images with the same negotiation attributes.
[0131] In the embodiment, sales negotiation images of a sales representative U2 (high performer U2H) selected for high sales performance and sales negotiation images of a sales representative U2 (low performer U2L) selected for low sales performance are used to determine the evaluation items of interest and generate reference data. This makes it possible to extract the negotiation techniques specific to high performers. Using this as standard data for evaluation, it will be ideal for training to appropriately convey the negotiation techniques of high performers.
[0132] In the embodiment, the evaluation data includes the score of the evaluatee U2d calculated based on the difference from the reference data for each evaluation item of interest (see FIGS. 15 and 16). By calculating the score for the evaluation items of interest for the evaluatee U2d based on the difference between the standard data based on the business negotiation images of the high performer U2H and the evaluatee U2d, the differences between the evaluatee U2d and the high performer U2H can be clearly shown for each evaluation item of interest.
[0133] In the embodiment, the evaluation data includes information associating reference videos with all or some of the evaluation items of interest (see FIGS. 15 and 16). For example, link information for reference videos can be set so that reference videos for notable evaluation items with low scores can be presented for the assessee U2d. This makes it possible to clearly present images of business negotiations by high performers U2H that should be used as reference by the assessee U2d. In particular, presenting reference videos for evaluation items that are of interest to the person in question means presenting videos that the person in question should watch, which is advantageous in that it allows the person in question to watch the videos efficiently in a short amount of time.
[0134] In the embodiment, the reference video is a video of a scene related to the corresponding evaluation item of interest. For example, the video indicated by the reference video link is not the entire sales negotiation of the high performer that serves as a reference, but a scene related to the associated evaluation item of interest. For example, for an evaluation item related to ice-breaking, the video is a video of the ice-breaking scene of the high performer U2H. By extracting only the necessary scenes in this way, rather than the entire sales negotiation, the person in charge can efficiently learn sales negotiation techniques.
[0135] In the embodiment, the CPU 11 performs processing to generate and store attention data to be presented during an interview based on the focused evaluation items (see FIG. 17). The noteworthy evaluation items based on the comparison of the analysis results between high performers U2H and low performers U2L are themselves information on matters that affect the success or failure of sales negotiations. Therefore, by generating and storing attention data based on the noteworthy evaluation items, it becomes possible to provide useful information to the person in charge during sales negotiations.
[0136] In the information processing device 10 as the negotiation analysis server device 7 of the embodiment, the CPU 11, which is the control unit, performs a presentation control process in which evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the negotiation image of the evaluatee U2d with reference data serving as a comparison standard for a plurality of evaluation items related to the negotiation is presented, and a predetermined action of the evaluatee U2d in response to the presented content is stored. The CPU 11 also performs a notification control process in which a notification regarding the predetermined action is executed (see Figs. 18 and 19). By presenting the evaluation data, such a sales negotiation analysis server device 7 can clearly indicate areas for improvement and shortcomings for the person in charge U2, which can be useful in improving sales capabilities. Also, by monitoring and notifying whether the person in charge actually takes action such as watching the reference video, the person in charge himself or his superior can recognize whether the evaluation data is being used effectively. The notification of the execution of the action may be reflected in the personnel evaluation of the person in charge. For example, the viewing history of the reference video may be included as personnel evaluation data.
[0137] In an embodiment, the evaluation data includes information associating reference videos with all or some of the evaluation items, and the CPU 11 presents the information associated with the reference videos through a presentation control process, and monitors the viewing action of the reference videos through a notification control process. This will make it possible to manage whether or not personnel actually watch the reference videos provided. The actions to be monitored are not limited to watching videos. For example, the person in charge may be able to send a report to his / her superior, create attention data, etc. from the presentation screen, and the execution of these actions may be monitored and counted.
[0138] In the embodiment, in the notification control process, the CPU 11 performs processing for sending a notification regarding a predetermined action to a terminal device of the assessee U2d or the manager (supervisor, etc.) of the assessee U2d. This allows the person in charge U2 to be encouraged to take action such as watching a reference video, or to communicate this to their supervisor, who is the manager, and can be used to improve actual sales negotiation skills.
[0139] The program according to the embodiment is a program that causes the CPU 11 to execute all or part of the processing shown in FIGS. The program causes an information processing device to execute a standard data setting process that compares first analysis data generated based on high-evaluation interview information with second analysis data generated based on low-evaluation interview information for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to the interview, identifies evaluation items of interest among the plurality of evaluation items based on the difference between the analysis data, and sets standard data for the evaluation items of interest, and an evaluation data generation process that compares the analysis data for the evaluation items of interest generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with the standard data, and generates evaluation data for the person being evaluated. The program also causes an information processing device to execute a presentation control process that presents evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data that serves as a comparison standard for multiple evaluation items related to the interview, and a notification control process that monitors a specified action of the person being evaluated in response to the presentation and executes a notification regarding the specified action.
[0140] Such a program can realize an information processing device 10 that executes all or part of the functions of the negotiation analysis server device 7 described in the embodiment. For example, by downloading the program to a personal computer, a portable information processing device, or the like, the personal computer can be made to function as the negotiation analysis server device 7.
[0141] Such a program can be pre-recorded in a HDD as a recording medium built into a device such as a computer device, or in a ROM in a microcomputer having a CPU, etc. Also, the program can be provided by being temporarily or permanently recorded on a removable recording medium such as a memory card or an optical disk. Such programs can also be downloaded from a download site via a network such as a LAN (Local Area Network) or the Internet.
[0142] The business negotiation analysis server device 7 in the embodiment is configured to analyze business negotiations between a person in charge U2 and a customer U1 conducted in the communication support system 100, but it can also be used to analyze communication in fields such as medicine, education, and distribution, in addition to business negotiations. For example, the technology in the embodiment can be applied to processes such as generating, presenting, and notifying evaluation data for a teacher on the host side in a remote lecture.
[0143] In the embodiment, the present technology has been explained using the example of a business negotiation in a support system 100 that performs synchronous shared communication, but the technology disclosed herein can also be applied to face-to-face interviews, such as a business negotiation conducted face-to-face between a person in charge U2 and a customer U1. For example, by recording a face-to-face interview, the interview information can be saved. For example, if a multi-directional microphone is placed between the person in charge U2 and the customer U1 to record the voice, the recorded data can be used as interview information, and various evaluation items such as speaking speed and number of times that statements overlap can be derived. Of course, face-to-face interviews can also be recorded with a video camera, and this recorded data can also be used as interview information.
[0144] In addition, in the embodiment, the "interview information" as high evaluation interview information, low evaluation interview information, and interview information of the person being evaluated is an interview image (business negotiation image) including audio, but it may be image data only, or audio data only. [Explanation of symbols]
[0145] 5. Guest terminal 6 Host terminal 7. Business negotiation analysis server device 10. Information processing device 11 CPU 11a Reference data setting processing section 11b Evaluation data generation processing unit 11c Presentation control processing unit 11d Notification control processing section 71 Business negotiation image data set 72 Analysis Data Set 73 Standard Data Set 74 Noteworthy Data Group 75 Evaluation data set 100 Communication Support System U1 Customer (guest user) U2 Person in charge (host user) U2H High Performer U2L Low Performer U2d Evaluatee
Claims
1. a presentation control process for presenting evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data serving as a comparison standard for a plurality of evaluation items related to the interview, and storing a predetermined action of the person being evaluated in response to the presented content; a notification control process for executing a notification regarding the predetermined action; A control unit that executes Information processing device.
2. The evaluation data includes information associating reference videos with all or some of the evaluation items, The control unit is In the presentation control process, information associated with the reference video is presented; The notification control process monitors the viewing action of the reference video. The information processing device according to claim 1 .
3. The reference video is a video of a scene related to the corresponding evaluation item. The information processing device according to claim 2 .
4. The evaluation data includes a score of the assessee calculated based on a difference between the evaluation items and the reference data. The information processing device according to claim 1 .
5. The control unit is In the notification control process, a process for transmitting a notification regarding the predetermined action to a terminal device of the assessee or the assessee's manager is performed.
5. The information processing device according to claim 1.
6. The control unit is a reference data setting process for comparing first analysis data generated based on the high-evaluation interview information with second analysis data generated based on the low-evaluation interview information for each of a plurality of evaluation items related to the interview, identifying a notable evaluation item among the plurality of evaluation items based on the difference between the analysis data, and setting reference data for the notable evaluation item; an evaluation data generation process for generating evaluation data for the evaluatee by comparing analysis data on the evaluation items of interest, which is generated based on interview information of the evaluatee, with the reference data; Run The presentation control process causes the evaluation data generated in the evaluation data generation process to be presented.
5. The information processing device according to claim 1.
7. a presentation control process for presenting evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data serving as a comparison standard for the multiple evaluation items related to the interview; A notification control process that monitors a predetermined action of the assessee in response to the presentation and executes a notification regarding the predetermined action; The information processing method is executed by an information processing device.
8. a presentation control process for presenting evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data serving as a comparison standard for the multiple evaluation items related to the interview; A notification control process that monitors a predetermined action of the assessee in response to the presentation and executes a notification regarding the predetermined action; A recording medium on which a program for causing an information processing device to execute the above is temporarily or permanently recorded.
9. a presentation control process for presenting evaluation data generated by comparing analysis data generated based on the interview information of the person being evaluated with reference data serving as a comparison standard for the multiple evaluation items related to the interview; A notification control process that monitors a predetermined action of the assessee in response to the presentation and executes a notification regarding the predetermined action; A program for causing an information processing device to execute the above.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Information processing system, information processing method and program
JP2022071874A
Cited By
Interview support device, interview support method, program, recording medium
JP2026124696A
Information processing systems, information processing methods, and programs
JP7908708B1
Information processing device, information processing method, and program
WO2026211926A1
