Electromagnetic Imaging Calibration Method
The in-line calibration module with multiple states addresses RF hardware variations and patient movement in electromagnetic imaging, ensuring accurate calibration and reliable imaging results by monitoring cable motion and adjusting for phase and amplitude errors.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024538245
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-12-22
- Filing Date
- 2022-12-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Electromagnetic medical imaging systems face challenges in achieving accurate calibration due to variations in RF hardware characteristics, which cause phase and amplitude differences between sensor channels, and these differences are exacerbated by movement of the system or patient during measurement, leading to errors that mask weak target responses.
A method and device using an in-line calibration module with multiple states (short, open, and load) to calibrate an electromagnetic imaging system by measuring scattering parameters and calculating a transmission matrix, accounting for phase and amplitude variations, and monitoring cable motion to ensure stability during patient measurements.
The solution provides precise calibration by minimizing phase and amplitude errors, ensuring accurate imaging results even with patient movement, and automatically adjusting for cable migration, thereby enhancing the reliability of electromagnetic medical imaging.
Smart Images

Figure 2024545336000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to medical imaging techniques, in particular to electromagnetic imaging, and more particularly to electromagnetic medical imaging calibration modules and methods. [Background technology]
[0002] Electromagnetic medical imaging typically requires a multi-channel sensor array with transmitting and receiving antennas positioned around the imaging subject. To enable accurate and unbiased measurements of the radio frequency ("RF") signals received by each antenna, it is essential to set the amplitude and phase of each sensor channel equally and precisely. In practice, however, due to differences in the RF hardware of each sensor channel, significant amplitude and phase differences may occur between channels. Such undesirable phase shifts and amplitude attenuation are primarily caused by unintended variations in the RF characteristics of antennas, matching media, adapters, connectors, transmission lines, coaxial cables, etc. Furthermore, the phase and amplitude characteristics of most RF devices are frequency and temperature dependent and typically drift with time.
[0003] For the sensor array to perform as desired in an accurate and reliable manner, the system hardware is calibrated by measuring and equalizing the phase and amplitude characteristics of all sensor channels. Because the relative phase / amplitude shifts of RF devices are often temperature and mechanical disturbance dependent and typically change over time (e.g., due to aging and temperature changes), calibration of such hardware must be repeated periodically (or when necessary) to correct for these variations. In fact, such calibration is essential to obtain valid imaging results, since the changes in the scattering signal due to these undesirable effects can be larger than the target response, such as the stroke response in head imaging.
[0004] Portable EM imaging systems have been developed. While this has obvious advantages, it poses significant challenges in system calibration. In particular, system movement and the act of placing the antenna array on the patient's head cause unavoidable movements of the connecting cables, which introduce errors into the acquired data. These errors can mask weak target responses from deep and / or small targets. [Prior art documents] [Non-patent literature]
[0005] [Non-Patent Document 1] A. Ferrero and U. Pisani, “Two-port network analyzer calibration using an unknown ‘thru’,” in IEEE Microwave and Guided Wave Letters, vol. 2, no. 12, pp. 505-507, Dec. 1992 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] It would therefore be desirable to overcome or alleviate one or more of the disadvantages of the prior art, or at least provide a useful alternative. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In accordance with the present invention, there is provided a method of calibrating an electromagnetic medical imaging device having a vector network analyzer (VNA) coupled via a transmission line to an array of antennas disposed about an imaging region, the method comprising: Using the device, a scattering parameter S for a known calibration object at a known position within the imaging region is measured. calwherein each of the antennas of the array of antennas is connected to the VNA via a corresponding transmission line and a corresponding in-line calibration module disposed between the transmission line and the antenna, the measurements being performed for each of at least four configurations of the in-line calibration module, the at least four configurations including a measurement configuration in which the in-line calibration module is configured to electrically connect the transmission line to a corresponding antenna, and at least three calibration configurations in which the in-line calibration module is configured to implement the transmission line with a respective corresponding calibration standard; The measured scattering parameter S cal to calculate the calibration terms e00, e01, e10, e11 for ports A and B; repositioning at least a portion of the transmission line in preparation for imaging an object located within the imaging region; With the repositioned transmission line, the scattering parameters for the one-port calibration standard are measured and the matrix Y for each corresponding port A and B is calculated according to the following equation: A and Y B determining
number
number
number
[0008] In some embodiments, the at least three calibration arrangements include a calibration arrangement in which the in-line calibration module is configured to (i) short-circuit the transmission line, (ii) open the transmission line, and (iii) electrically connect the transmission line to a predetermined load.
[0009] In some embodiments, the method comprises: measuring scattering parameters with the apparatus while the object remains within the imaging region and the in-line calibration module is configured to connect a first end of the transmission line to the predetermined load; calculating the difference between the obtained measurement result and a corresponding past measurement result; comparing the difference to a noise level to estimate motion of the transmission line; It further has:
[0010] In some embodiments, the method further comprises monitoring motion of the transmission line over time by repeating (i)-(iii) at timed intervals, hi some embodiments, the method further comprises pausing further scattering parameter measurements if the calculated difference is not substantially greater than the noise level.
[0011] In some embodiments, the method further comprises pausing further measurements of the scattering parameter if the calculated difference is not substantially greater than the noise level.
[0012] The present invention also provides an electromagnetic medical imaging apparatus configured to implement any of the methods described above.
[0013] The invention also provides a computer readable medium storing executable instructions which, when executed by at least one processor of an electromagnetic medical imaging apparatus, cause the at least one processor to perform any of the methods described above.
[0014] The present invention also provides an electromagnetic medical imaging apparatus comprising: an array of antennas disposed about an imaging region; a vector network analyzer (VNA) connected to the antennas via respective transmission lines, and an in-line calibration module provided between the antennas and the transmission lines; at least one processor, the at least one processor comprising: Scattering parameters S for a known calibration object at a known position within the imaging region cal receiving from the VNA measurement results of (a) (i) above, the measurements being performed for each of at least four configurations of the in-line calibration module with the transmission line in a first configuration, the at least four configurations including a measurement configuration in which the in-line calibration module is configured to electrically connect the transmission line to a corresponding antenna, and at least three calibration configurations in which the in-line calibration module is configured to implement the transmission line with a respective corresponding calibration standard; The measured scattering parameter S cal to calculate the calibration terms e00, e01, e10, e11 for ports A and B; receiving from the VNA measurements of scattering parameters of a one-port calibration standard, the measurements being performed with at least a portion of the transmission line in a second configuration different from the first configuration in preparation for imaging an object located within the imaging region; The scattering parameters for the one-port calibration standard are processed to obtain a matrix Y for each corresponding port A and B according to the following equation: A and Y B determining
number
number
number
[0015] In some embodiments, the at least three calibration arrangements include a calibration arrangement in which the in-line calibration module is configured to (i) short-circuit the transmission line, (ii) open the transmission line, and (iii) electrically connect the transmission line to a predetermined load.
[0016] In some embodiments, the at least one processor: measuring scattering parameters with the apparatus while the object remains within the imaging region and the in-line calibration module is configured to connect a first end of the transmission line to the predetermined load; calculating the difference between the obtained measurement result and a corresponding past measurement result; comparing the difference to a noise level to estimate motion of the transmission line; The device is further configured to execute:
[0017] In some embodiments, the at least one processor is further configured to monitor motion of the transmission line over time by repeating (i)-(iii) at time intervals.
[0018] In some embodiments, the at least one processor is further configured to suspend further scattering parameter measurements if the calculated difference does not become substantially greater than the noise level.
[0019] According to the present invention, a method of calibrating an electromagnetic medical imaging device having a vector network analyzer (VNA) coupled via a transmission line to an array of antennas disposed about an imaging region is also described, the method comprising: Using the device, a scattering parameter S for a known calibration object at a known position within the imaging region is measured. cal wherein each of the transmission lines has a corresponding in-line calibration module having a first port and a second port, the first port connected to a first end of the corresponding transmission line, the other end of the corresponding transmission line connected to the VNA, and the second port connected to a corresponding antenna of the array of antennas, the measurements being performed for each of at least four configurations of the in-line calibration module, the at least four configurations including a measurement configuration in which the in-line calibration module is configured to electrically connect the transmission line to a corresponding antenna, and at least three calibration configurations in which the in-line calibration module is configured to implement the transmission line with a respective corresponding calibration standard; The measured scattering parameter S cal to calculate the calibration terms e00, e01, e10, e11 for ports A and B; repositioning at least a portion of the transmission line in preparation for imaging an object located within the imaging region; With the repositioned transmission line, the scattering parameters for the one-port calibration standard are measured and the matrix Y for each corresponding port A and B is calculated according to the following equation: A and Y B determining
number
number
number
[0020] The at least three calibration arrangements include a calibration arrangement in which the in-line calibration module is configured to (i) short-circuit the transmission line, (ii) open the transmission line, and (iii) electrically connect the transmission line to a predetermined load. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0021] Some embodiments of the present invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which: [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram of a prior art electromagnetic imaging device; [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating VNA multiport calibration of a prior art electromagnetic imaging device. [Diagram 3] 1 is a block diagram of an electromagnetic imaging device including an in-line calibration portion in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 4] 1 is a flow diagram of an electromagnetic imaging calibration method according to an embodiment of the present invention; [Diagram 5] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing the unknowns and error matrix of a prior art UT calibration method; and [Figure 6]Included are graphs of the difference in power levels as a function of frequency for (left graph) a fixed calibration object, and (right graph) a patient that moved during the scan. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0022] Electromagnetic ("EM") imaging is typically performed by introducing the object to be imaged (e.g., a patient's head) into an imaging region surrounded by an inward-facing array of antennas. The antennas are sequentially energized, generating electromagnetic (e.g., microwave) signals that are scattered by, transmitted through, and reflected from the object, and received by other antennas in the array to gather significant spatial information representative of the spatial distribution of features within the object. The information thus gathered includes measurements of the reflected signal for each antenna, as well as measurements of the transmitted signal between each pair of antennas. These measurements, in addition to reflection measurements (by the transmitting antenna), are performed over a range of frequencies by sequentially transmitting a sweep of frequencies at each antenna and receiving the resulting signal at the other antenna. A device known in the art as a "vector network analyzer" (or "VNA") generates measurement data from the array by storing the ratio of the transmit antenna voltage to the receive antenna voltage at each of its ports as a function of frequency. The resulting data are referred to in the art as "scattering parameters" (or "S-parameters").
[0023] FIG. 1 is a high-level schematic block diagram showing a typical data acquisition section of a prior art EM imaging system, but including an in-line calibration device according to an embodiment of the present invention. In general, there may be multiple sets of flexible and / or fixed RF transmission lines (typically, but not necessarily, in the form of coaxial cables) and connectors utilized to attach the antennas to the respective ports (port 1...port N) of the VNA. In some systems, the antennas are separated by a thin layer of air, while in other systems, one or more materials are used as coupling media to improve signal penetration to the imaging target. These two regions beyond the antennas (i.e., including the coupling medium / medium and the object under test, respectively) are assumed to be part of the imaging region. The VNA is typically connected to the antennas via coaxial cables. In the described embodiment, the antennas are encased in a rigid volume, which prevents them from moving relative to each other and absorbs stray signals that may otherwise escape. To best fit the antennas to the object under test, the volume between the antennas and the object under test is filled with liquid to avoid large gaps.
[0024] EM imaging systems suffer from calibration uncertainties and unknowns such as: (i) Inside the VNA: uncertainties along the EM signal path, such as switching elements, inter-channel leakage, impedance mismatch, etc. (ii) Transmission lines / coaxial cables: Impedance mismatch and phase length variations due to manufacturing tolerances / imperfections (iii) Connectors: Impedance mismatch due to torque variations and manufacturing tolerances / imperfections (iv) Antennas: variations in sensitivity across frequency bands due to manufacturing tolerances and / or imperfections in individual antennas (v) Antenna array placement: Initial variations in structure and antenna position due to manufacturing tolerances
[0025] These problems fall into two classes: (i) Initial inconsistencies: These are evident when comparing a particular prototype of a system with other prototypes. These inconsistencies may be caused by manufacturing tolerances / imperfections and can be corrected after manufacturing. (ii) Time stability: evident when comparing the same system at different times and can be caused by operational and / or temperature variations. These need to be corrected regularly, especially before measuring a patient.
[0026] [Standard VNA Calibration] VNA manufacturers recommend standard multiport calibration to determine the correction coefficients corresponding to each pair of network ports, including the VNA body and the corresponding connecting cables. As shown in Figure 2, at a minimum, each pair of ports must be connected to a reference port to determine the error terms for each port combination. Calibration by VNA manufacturers is often performed using detailed error models that account for signal leakage as well as internal switching between receivers and paths within the VNA body. As a result of this calibration, the reference plane is effectively moved to the end of the cable farthest from the VNA, and the calibration results can be stored and applied later. With regard to the uncertainties / unknowns mentioned above, this prior art calibration process fully addresses the VNA internal uncertainties / unknowns (i) and partially addresses the cable and connector uncertainties / unknowns (ii) and (iii).
[0027] [Inline Calibration] The present inventors have identified that a persistent shortcoming of prior art VNA calibration and factory calibration is that cables can (and typically do) move between the time of VNA calibration and the time the measurement is performed, introducing unwanted phase changes.
[0028] To address this shortcoming, in an embodiment of the present invention, as shown in FIG. 4, the calibration process utilizes an in-line calibration module that is attached to the antenna feed point as shown in FIG. 3. For an N-port antenna array, a total of N in-line calibration modules are required. Each calibration module has four states, including a "measuring" state, an open circuit state, a short circuit state, and a predetermined or known load state. Before using the modules in an electromagnetic imaging system, a (calibrated) VNA is used to measure the electromagnetic characteristics of each module in the four states. The resulting S-parameter measurements are stored in a database and retrieved during the calibration process. This calibration process can be considered as an extension of the "unknown through" (or "UT") calibration method described in Non-Patent Document 1 ("Ferrero"), also known as the "Reciprocal Short Open Load" (or "RSOL") calibration method.
[0029] [Unknown Through Method] The UT calibration method is particularly applicable to network calibrations where the electromagnetic transmission characteristics of the signal carrying components at each port of the VNA can be easily measured under open circuit, short circuit, and known load conditions, but are difficult to measure for a known "thru" (i.e., the object being imaged) without changing the measurement geometry. Application of the method to the object being imaged (in the general sense traditionally referred to in the art as a "device under test", hence abbreviated as "DUT") relies on the following: (i) The object is in opposite phase. (ii) have approximate knowledge of the phase change of the object Sij; (iii) There is a detectable signal at the receiving end.
[0030] The UT method uses the measured unknown through matrix S as shown in Figure 5. m and two error matrices E for ports A and B, respectively. A and E BAs described by Ferrero, in the context of a two-port network (which can be easily extended to multiple ports by computing the error terms described below for all port pairs in the network), the two error boxes shown in Figure 5 can be expressed as scattering matrices:
number
[0031] matrix Y A and Y B is defined depending only on terms from these error matrices and can be solved for each port individually using the reflection coefficients measured at the ports by three one-port standards (in the case of the in-line calibration module described herein, these standards are provided by short circuit, open circuit, and known load conditions).
number
[0032] Transmission matrix T m and T DUT is S m and S DUT where S DUT is the scattering matrix of the calibrated object (denoted as "DUT") (this is the desired output of these calculations).
number
[0033] [Unknown Skip - How to Skip the Past] The main difficulty in directly applying UT techniques to EM medical imaging systems is that the patient may move within the array, and furthermore, physical processes within the patient's body may cause subtle changes in its electromagnetic properties. The most significant impact of this is that the assumption of reciprocity is not met. Not only this, but the unknown through paths when attached to the patient's body may lead to several S ij There is a high probability of experiencing high losses along the signal path, and such uncertainty increases as the measurement signal-to-noise ratio decreases, so it is desirable to use a low-loss path for the unknown through.
[0034] For this purpose, a calibration object of known dimensions is inserted into the imaging region at a known position to collect initial UT calibration parameters. The electromagnetic properties of the calibration object are preferably reciprocal (i.e. non-magnetic) and can be optimized for best matching to the antenna. The calibration object should be positioned in a reproducible manner to provide a consistent and known phase path for each signal measurement. Furthermore, knowledge of the object's properties and size can be used to make a more accurate initial estimate of the phase using the UT method.
[0035] For a fixed imaging system without any changes between the calibration object and the patient measurements, this calibration object and UT method provide sufficient calibration. However, when using a portable system, it is not practical to attach the calibration object to the EM system with the exact same cable arrangement that was used when measuring the patient. To address this challenge, the inventors have developed a new calibration method, referred to herein as the "Unknown-Through-Past-Through" (or "UT-PT") calibration method, as follows. 1. Using the in-line calibration module described above, an initial measurement is performed on a known calibration target at a known (fixed) location in the image domain. The UT calibration terms described above are fully calculated for this location, and the resulting S m,cal is saved for later use. 2. The EM system is then moved to the patient, the one-port calibration standard is measured, and the Y A,pat and Y B,pat get. 3. The through error term for calibrating the patient data is calculated according to the following formula:
number
number
number
[0036] Here, t 11 and 22 are the reflection tracking error coefficients for each port. These terms compensate for the difference in frequency response between the two receivers inside the VNA, which collect and compare the source reference signal and the reflected signal for each port. These and the measured value S m21 , S m12 The transmission tracking error is calculated by combining
[0037] In practice, the reflective tracking error coefficient dominates the equation, and the ratio S m12 / S m21has a larger effect than . If reciprocity is lost during calibration as a result of patient movement during the sweep time, this ratio term can become more dominant and introduce significant inaccuracies into the calibration. Since the ratio term only depends on the response port test signal and the stimulus port reference signal if reciprocity is maintained, this term from the calibration object must be valid for use in the context of patient measurements.
[0038] An example of this is shown in Figure 6. In this example, the VNA sweep time was approximately 1.5 seconds. Antenna pairs 1,3 and 1,15 were compared. Antennas 1 and 3 were both measured as transmitters early in the measurement window, while antenna 15 was measured towards the end of the window. In the raw measurements of the calibration object (left graph), there was little difference in the reciprocity as the calibration object was stable in the domain. In the raw measurements of the patient (right graph), it can be seen that the reciprocity is affected a little bit depending on the time when the 3rd antenna is transmitting, and much more when the 15th antenna is transmitting.
[0039] [Monitoring of measurement stability] Another use of the in-line calibration module is its ability to monitor the amount of cable movement while the headset is in position for patient measurement. Periodically, the in-line module can be switched to a standard 50 ohm terminal load, known in the art as a "matched load," and measurements taken while the array is positioned on the patient and compared to the most recent matched mode measurement. If the difference power reaches a level higher than the signal-to-noise ratio required to produce an accurate image, it can be concluded that there has been cable movement, and that these effects are greater than the disease response. The system then automatically repeats the measurement and comparison, waiting until the movement subsides before proceeding to collect calibration data and continuing with the patient measurement.
[0040] [Calibration form] In addition to using the UT-PT method, EM imaging systems can use calibration objects with specific dielectric properties to solve many other calibration problems. Having known dielectric properties at known locations in a rigid array can address uncertainties in individual antennas and antenna array placement.
[0041] Many variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the scope of the invention.
Claims
1. 1. A method of calibrating an electromagnetic medical imaging device having a vector network analyzer (VNA) coupled via a transmission line to an array of antennas disposed about an imaging region, comprising: Using the device, a scattering parameter S for a known calibration object at a known position within the imaging region is measured. cal wherein each of the antennas of the array of antennas is connected to a corresponding in-line calibration module disposed between the transmission line and the antenna, the measurements being performed for each of at least four configurations of the in-line calibration module, the at least four configurations including a measurement configuration in which the in-line calibration module is configured to electrically connect the transmission line to a corresponding antenna, and at least three calibration configurations in which the in-line calibration module is configured to implement the transmission line with a respective corresponding calibration standard; The measured scattering parameter S cal to calculate the calibration terms e00, e01, e10, e11 for ports A and B; repositioning at least a portion of the transmission line in preparation for imaging an object located within the imaging region; With the repositioned transmission lines, the scattering parameters for the one-port calibration standard are measured and the matrix Y for each corresponding port A and B is calculated according to the following equation: A and Y B determining [0010] A through error term α M Calculating T cal is the transfer matrix of the known calibration object; [0025] measuring scattering parameters of the object located within the imaging region with the rearranged transmission lines; calibrating the measured scattering parameters of the object according to the following equation: T subject_cal is the calibrated transfer matrix of the object, and T subject is the uncalibrated transfer matrix of the object; [0030] The method according to claim 1,
2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the at least three calibration arrangements include a calibration arrangement in which the in-line calibration module is configured to (i) short the transmission line, (ii) open the transmission line, and (iii) electrically connect the transmission line to a predetermined load.
3. 3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, (i) measuring scattering parameters with the apparatus while the object remains within the imaging region and the in-line calibration module is configured to connect a first end of the transmission line to the predetermined load; (ii) calculating the difference between the obtained measurement result and the corresponding previous measurement result; (iii) comparing the difference with a noise level to estimate motion of the transmission line; The method further comprises:
4. 4. The method of claim 3, further comprising the step of monitoring motion of the transmission line over time by repeating (i)-(iii) at time intervals.
5. 5. The method of claim 4, further comprising the step of suspending further scattering parameter measurements if the calculated difference does not become substantially greater than the noise level.
6. An electromagnetic medical imaging device configured to implement the method according to any one of claims 1 to 5.
7. A computer readable medium storing executable instructions which, when executed by at least one processor of an electromagnetic medical imaging device, cause the at least one processor to perform the method of any one of claims 1 to 5.
8. an array of antennas disposed about an imaging region; a vector network analyzer (VNA) connected to the antennas via respective transmission lines, and an in-line calibration module provided between the antennas and the transmission lines; at least one processor; 1. An electromagnetic medical imaging apparatus comprising: The at least one processor Scattering parameters S for a known calibration object at a known position within the imaging region cal receiving from the VNA measurement results of a first configuration of the transmission line, the measurement being performed for each of at least four configurations of the in-line calibration module with the transmission line in a first configuration, the at least four configurations including a measurement configuration in which the in-line calibration module is configured to electrically connect the transmission line to a corresponding antenna, and at least three calibration configurations in which the in-line calibration module is configured to implement the transmission line with a respective corresponding calibration standard; The measured scattering parameter S cal to calculate the calibration terms e00, e01, e10, e11 for ports A and B; receiving from the VNA measurements of scattering parameters of a one-port calibration standard, the measurements being performed with at least a portion of the transmission line in a second configuration different from the first configuration in preparation for imaging an object located within the imaging region; The scattering parameters for the one-port calibration standard are processed to obtain a matrix Y for each corresponding port A and B according to the following equation: A and Y B determining [0045] A through error term α M Calculating T cal is the transfer matrix of the known calibration object; [0050] measuring scattering parameters of the object located within the imaging region with the rearranged transmission lines; calibrating the measured scattering parameters of the object according to the following equation: T subject_cal is the calibrated transfer matrix of the object, and T subject is the uncalibrated transfer matrix of the object; [006] 4. An electromagnetic medical imaging device configured to perform the steps of:
9. 9. The apparatus of claim 8, wherein the at least three calibration arrangements include a calibration arrangement in which the in-line calibration module is configured to (i) short the transmission line, (ii) open the transmission line, and (iii) electrically connect the transmission line to a predetermined load.
10. 10. The apparatus of claim 8 or 9, wherein the at least one processor comprises: (i) measuring scattering parameters using the apparatus while the object remains within the imaging region and the in-line calibration module is configured to connect a first end of the transmission line to the predetermined load; (ii) calculating the difference between the obtained measurement result and the corresponding previous measurement result; (iii) comparing the difference with a noise level to estimate motion of the transmission line; 4. The method of claim 3, further comprising: Device.
11. 11. The apparatus of claim 10, wherein the at least one processor is further configured to monitor motion of the transmission line over time by repeating (i)-(iii) at time intervals.
12. 12. The apparatus of claim 11, wherein the at least one processor is further configured to suspend further scattering parameter measurements if the calculated difference does not become substantially greater than the noise level.
