Chromatograph data processing device and chromatograph

The chromatographic data processing device facilitates accurate and reproducible peak area calculations by allowing users to choose between methods prioritizing accuracy or reproducibility, enhancing the reliability of peak area determination.

JP7581158B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-12HITACHI HIGH TECH ANALYSIS CORP
View PDF 5 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021139365
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-08-27
Publication Date
2024-11-12
Estimated Expiration
2041-08-27

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing chromatography techniques face challenges in achieving accurate and reproducible peak area calculations, particularly in resolving overlapping peaks and ensuring stability in waveform processing.

Method used

A chromatographic data processing device that allows users to select a waveform processing method based on priorities for accuracy or reproducibility, using a waveform processing method selection unit and peak area calculation unit to determine peak areas, incorporating methods like vertical division, tangential division, and Gaussian curve fitting.

Benefits of technology

Enables easy selection of methods with high accuracy or reproducibility for peak area calculations, improving the reliability and precision of peak area determination.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007581158000001
    Figure 0007581158000001
  • Figure 0007581158000002
    Figure 0007581158000002
  • Figure 0007581158000003
    Figure 0007581158000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a data processor capable of selecting an appropriate waveform processing method.SOLUTION: A data processor 120 of a chromatograph for finding a peak area by performing data processing of the chromatogram, includes: a waveform processing method selection unit (waveform processing method learning-selection unit 121) that receives instruction on which to prioritize, the accuracy or the reproducibility of peak areas obtained; and a peak area calculation unit 122 that finds the peak area by performing data processing of the given chromatogram by the selected waveform processing method.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a chromatography technique such as a liquid chromatograph, and more particularly to a data processing device for a chromatograph, and a chromatograph. [Background technology]

[0002] In the field of high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC), a method for analyzing chromatograms is one of the development themes. This is because the Chromatography Data System (CDS) calculates the peak area by time integration, but there are problems with the accuracy and stability of the results. In the conventional method, the characteristic points of the peak are found based on the time derivative of the chromatogram. These are, for example, the apex, the start point, the end point, the valley point, and the shoulder-like inflection point. The area is calculated by cutting the peak waveform from the chromatogram in a straight line with scissors from one of these differential characteristic points to the other characteristic point (see, for example, Patent Document 1). Alternatively, a method is adopted in which a peak-like waveform similar to a normal distribution function (Gaussian) is fitted to the measured chromatogram by the kerf fitting method (see, for example, Patent Document 2). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2020-153864 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2006-177980 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] Simply put, we aim to achieve more accurate waveform processing or devise more stable waveform processing, but the aim of the present invention is slightly different. The inventor of the present application realized that there may be waveform processing methods that excel at calculating peak areas accurately and waveform processing methods that calculate peak areas with good reproducibility. From this perspective, it should be possible to consider the optimization of each method.

[0005] That is, the focus shifts to selecting a waveform processing method suited to the purpose. The purposes referred to here are (1) improving the accuracy of peak areas, and (2) improving the reproducibility of peak areas. There is also (3) correct resolution of overlapping peaks, which can be considered as part of (1). The object of the invention is to provide users with a method for accurately calculating peak areas, or to provide users with a waveform processing method with good reproducibility. It is possible to provide users with each of these two options. For this reason, the present invention can also be called meta-waveform processing, as it is a waveform processing method based on a higher (super) perspective. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention provides A data processing device for a chromatography, which separates a measurement sample in a column, detects the separated components, processes data of a chromatogram obtained, and determines a peak area corresponding to the amount of the separated components, a peak processing method selection unit that receives an instruction according to the accuracy of the obtained peak area and the priority level of reproducibility, and selects a peak processing method corresponding to the instruction; a peak area calculation unit that processes data of a given chromatogram by a selected waveform processing method and calculates a peak area for the separated components; The present invention is characterized by having the following.

[0007] This allows the user to specify the priority level, such as whether to place importance on determining the peak area accurately or on calculating the peak area with good reproducibility, or on the balance between accuracy and reproducibility, and thereby an appropriate waveform processing method is selected and the peak area is determined without the user having to directly select a waveform processing method.

[0008] The peak area corresponds to the amount of a component, and includes the use of peak height as the peak area. Effect of the Invention

[0009] According to the present invention, it is possible to easily select a waveform processing method having excellent accuracy or good reproducibility. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of a chromatograph. [Diagram 2] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a waveform processing method. [Diagram 3] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a waveform processing method. [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing an example of a waveform processing method. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is an explanatory diagram showing a display example of a chromatogram. [Figure 6] 11 is a table showing an example of display of a processing result. [Figure 7] FIG. 13 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of another chromatograph. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0011] (Schematic configuration of chromatograph 100) As shown in FIG. 1, the chromatograph 100 includes a chromatograph unit 110 that separates components in a sample using a column to generate chromatogram data, and a data processing device 120 that performs waveform processing on the generated chromatogram data to determine peak areas corresponding to the amounts of the separated components.

[0012] The data processing device 120, as described later, is provided with a waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 that obtains and stores evaluation indices of accuracy and reproducibility of peak areas obtained by a plurality of types of waveform processing methods for chromatogram data obtained by the chromatograph unit 110 for a predetermined sample specimen, and chromatogram data input from the outside or generated by a predetermined data processing by the chromatogram data input and generation unit 130, and selects a waveform processing method in response to an instruction from a user of the chromatograph 100. Examples of the plurality of types of waveform processing methods include a vertical division method from a peak valley (FIG. 2), a tangent division method from an inflection point or the like (FIG. 3), and a processing method using a method of decomposing overlapping peaks by curve fitting such as Gaussian (FIG. 4).

[0013] The data processing device 120 is also provided with a peak area calculation unit 122 that performs waveform processing using the waveform processing method selected by the waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 on chromatogram data, such as that shown in FIG. 5, obtained by the chromatograph unit 110 for an actual sample, and calculates a peak area corresponding to the amount of separated components. The calculated peak area is displayed on the display unit 123 in a table format, such as that shown in FIG. 6, together with the waveform of the chromatogram, such as that shown in FIG. 5. Here, although not limited thereto, when the chromatogram is displayed, the applied waveform processing method and the reliability score may be displayed together, as shown in FIG. 5. The reliability score differs depending on the selected waveform processing method Xi and the components, but all the actual measurement data of the unknown sample show a common score. For example, the reliability score in FIG. 5 and FIG. 6 is an index that expresses the larger difference from the calculated peak area to both ends of the 95% confidence interval as a percentage. In addition, mathematical statistical indexes such as risk ratio and z score can also be displayed.

[0014] According to the above-described chromatograph 100, as described in detail below, the user can indicate whether they place importance on determining the peak area accurately or on calculating the peak area with good reproducibility, and an appropriate waveform processing method can be selected to determine the peak area without the user having to directly select a waveform processing method.

[0015] (Key Points of the Present Embodiment) The main points of this embodiment will be described below in detail.

[0016] (1) The user can specify the accuracy or reproducibility of the peak area as the criterion for selecting the peak processing method as described above. More specifically, the user interface allows selection such as (a) improvement of peak area reproducibility or (b) improvement of peak area accuracy.

[0017] (2) Multiple peak processing methods are scored based on the evaluation criteria of peak area accuracy or reproducibility, and an appropriate peak processing method is selected.

[0018] (3) When only either the accuracy or reproducibility of peak areas is specified by the user, the optimal peak processing method is selected based on the above score.

[0019] (4) When both peak area accuracy and reproducibility are specified by the user, the optimal peak processing method is selected based on the overall score.

[0020] (5) When scoring is performed for the accuracy of the peak area, various chromatograms are input to the waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121. Both real data and simulated data can be applied, but the accuracy must be known. The same applies to the calculation of peak areas by evaluating the peak area ratio of overlapping peaks, such as by using a curve fitting method that uses a Gaussian-like peak shape.

[0021] (6) When scoring is performed for peak area reproducibility, multiple nearly identical chromatograms are input. Both real data and simulated data can be used.

[0022] (7) Note that the specific form of the data processing device 120 may be a function installed in a stand-alone chromatograph 100 (CDS), or a network service that requests processing from a server PC.

[0023] (8) The above processing is suitable for using AI and big data, but can also be performed manually.

[0024] (Learning of waveform processing method, evaluation (learning) of chromatogram data input to the selection unit 121 and waveform processing method) The multiple chromatograms input to the waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 include general examples and individual special examples.

[0025] (1) For reproducibility evaluation, measured repeated injection data (multiple) (2) Data obtained by combining multiple peak sizes measured (target: one component) (3) Data in which peaks of known sizes of multiple analytes are overlaid (target: multiple components) (4) The above three types of simulation data generated using random numbers (Monte Carlo method) Since these are all intentionally synthesized, their true values ​​are known and their accuracy can be evaluated (they become training data).

[0026] For the above chromatogram data, peak areas are calculated using various waveform processing methods, such as the valley integration method, the truncation method that takes into account up to the second derivative, and calculation of peak areas using curve fitting that uses a Gaussian-like peak shape, and scores are assigned by calculating the variance and error from the true value for each waveform processing method.

[0027] As an example of an optimal solution obtained as a result of the above search, for example, the following waveform processing method is selected.

[0028] (1) Highly accurate peak processing methods include, for example, the cutting method (scissors and balance integration) that takes into account the second derivative of the peak processing method (Figure 2), and the calculation of peak areas using curve fitting that uses Gaussian-like peak shapes (Figure 3). (2) An example of a waveform processing method with high reproducibility is the valley-crossing integration method in waveform processing (Figure 4). In this manner, a waveform processing method is sought that corresponds to an instruction as to whether to prioritize the accuracy or reproducibility of the obtained peak area, and processing is performed using an appropriate waveform processing method by the user indicating the goal they wish to prioritize.

[0029] (About each waveform processing method and processing parameters) The processing steps and processing parameters of the waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 that evaluates (learns) the accuracy and reproducibility of the waveform processing method will be described.

[0030] (1) Waveform processing method learning: The selection unit 121 takes in multiple sheets of chromatogram data from the chromatograph unit 110 and the chromatogram data input / generation unit 130.

[0031] (2) Waveform processing method learning: The selection unit 121 obtains the score of each waveform processing method and selects the one that obtains the best score. For example, provisional automatic parameters or default parameters are used as processing parameters at this time. Parameters related to the differential coefficient of each component include a noise threshold, a slope threshold, a shoulder threshold based on the second derivative, an S / N ratio, and a peak-valley ratio. Parameters for each component peak based on the curve fitting method include an initial value of retention time, a standard deviation related to the peak width, and a time constant related to the asymmetry of the tailing peak.

[0032] (3) For the waveform processing method of the best score, the parameters are successively changed to obtain the score in the same manner, and the optimal parameters for obtaining the best score are successively set in accordance with the evaluation criteria.

[0033] (4) The waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 determines and stores the optimization parameters.

[0034] (5) Here, the score is calculated using multiple chromatogram data and their respective known true values.

[0035] Once the optimized parameters have been determined in the above manner, the user can thereafter specify the waveform processing method for which the optimized parameters have been set for an unknown sample.

[0036] In addition, instead of optimizing the processing parameters after determining the optimal waveform processing method using provisional automatic parameters, etc., as described above, it is also possible to obtain a score for each combination of each waveform processing method and multiple types of parameters and directly determine the optimal combination of waveform processing method and parameters.

[0037] (More detailed explanation of "Criteria for high peak area reproducibility" and "Criteria for accurate peak area measurement") To select the most suitable peak processing method from among multiple methods, the following criteria can be used for score evaluation. Examples include "criterion for improving the reproducibility of peak areas" and "criterion for measuring peak areas accurately."

[0038] 1. Criteria for improving peak area reproducibility 1.1. To validate an analytical method, repeatability is calculated using the relative standard deviation (RSD) (%) of quantitative values ​​or peak areas. In other words, a peak processing method with high reproducibility is selected according to the variability of peak areas obtained by each peak processing method based on multiple chromatograms obtained from the same sample. Although a smaller RSD is desirable, it is often the case that results differ depending on the peak processing method and the parameters set, even when the same chromatogram is statistically processed. Users may adjust parameters to improve reproducibility.

[0039] In the case of multiple components, an RSD is calculated for each component a, b, c, etc., and the sum of squares of each RSD becomes the overall score for all components. Alternatively, the maximum RSD, function max(each RSD), can be selected from the RSDs to make it the overall RSD. Depending on the purpose, the inverse function min(RSDa,RSDb,RSDc, etc.) can also be used.

[0040] 1.2. The present invention aims to use the RSD of this evaluation index as a criterion for selecting a waveform processing method. As mentioned above, since the RSD also depends on the parameters, waveform processing methods A, B, and C with different parameters are called A1, A2, ..., B1, B2, etc., respectively. The RSD of each waveform processing method X and set Xi of parameters i can be calculated, and the set that gives the smallest RSD can be selected.

[0041] 1.3. For example, if B2 is chosen, it is also possible to further tune parameters in the vicinity of that parameter.

[0042] 1.4. If we estimate the factors that cause the variation in this RSD, it is thought that each peak processing method depends on the SN ratio. In this case, the SN ratio means the ratio of peak height to baseline noise. For example, in the case of a 1 mg peak, the SN ratio is large enough and the difference between the peak processing methods is not large, but in the case of 1 μg, it is expected that the SN ratio will affect the response performance of the peak processing methods, and differences will occur. As an example, when the SN ratio is large and when it is small, multiple sheets of chromatogram data for two groups are prepared and the RSD is calculated for each. A peak processing method that is not affected by the level of the SN ratio is selected. In other words, if there is almost no superiority or inferiority in the former, a peak processing method that outputs a good RSD even for the latter difficult subject is selected. This preparation can be done by injecting an actual sample to prepare a chromatogram, but it is generally easier to use it by creating multiple chromatograms with various noises in a simulation.

[0043] 1.5. Another factor in the variation of RSD is the case where the peak is not isolated. If it is isolated, it is thought that the superiority or inferiority of the peak processing method is not so clear. If it is not an isolated peak, it is difficult to find the start and end points of the peak, and the influence on the RSD depends on the peak processing method. Another difficult phenomenon is when the baseline is not a horizontal straight line. The method of inputting multiple sheets of such difficult chromatograms and evaluating the durability of the peak processing method by RSD is an effective means for the present invention.

[0044] 2. Criteria for accurate measurement of peak areas 2.1. As mentioned above, if the S / N ratio is large enough, there is an isolated peak, and the baseline is horizontal and straight, there is no significant difference in the peak processing methods in terms of accurately calculating the peak area. The issue is which peak processing method can obtain the peak area more accurately when any of these are not the case, i.e., when the S / N ratio is small, there are adjacent peaks, or the baseline is inclined or curved.

[0045] 2.2. In this case, evaluation is performed using chromatogram data with known true values. In other words, each peak processing method processes a chromatogram with known peak areas to calculate the peak area. The method with the closest calculated result to the true value is selected as the superior peak processing method. As mentioned above, each peak processing method is called a parameter and a set Xi.

[0046] 2.3. For example, the true peak area is At, the calculated peak area is Ac, and the absolute value (%) of │Ac-At│ / At is used as a score, with the smaller being considered as good. This is a comparison of ratios, but comparing the absolute value of the peak area │Ac-At│ (V·s) is not affected by the magnitude of At, and may be preferable for evaluating accuracy. In other words, the latter absolute value comparison is an evaluation method in which even if there is a certain degree of deviation in │Ac-At│ for relatively small peaks, if there is a large deviation for even one large peak, it is considered to be poor.

[0047] Also, for example, if there is a certain waveform processing method X and multiple chromatograms i=1, 2, ... are input, the peak area errors a1, a2, a3 ... for a certain component a are accumulated. Generally, the sum of squares is used.

[0048] If you simply evaluate component a, but also b, c, etc., the sum of squares of the errors for group a and group b are added together, the larger peaks will be emphasized in comparison. In such a case, if you want to evaluate the accuracy more fairly from small peaks to large peaks, it is preferable to evaluate using an index such as the error rate obtained by dividing each error by the true value. In that case, the evaluation will be done using the sum of squares of the error rates of a1, a2, a3...b1, b2, b3...c1, c2, c3...

[0049] 2.4. Input chromatograms of overlapping peaks with known true peak areas can be obtained in several ways:

[0050] 2.4.1. Chromatogram obtained by mixing multiple components with known concentrations in a given amount 2.4.2. Chromatograms of single components with known concentrations are measured and converted into numerical data. Next, each component is converted to an arbitrary amount by stretching or shrinking the vertical axis, and each chromatogram is synthesized to generate a single chromatogram. The same operation is repeated to obtain multiple synthesized chromatograms. The true value of the peak area is known from the synthesis process. This method can be called a semi-measured synthesized chromatogram.

[0051] 2.4.3. There is also the Monte Carlo method, which uses random numbers to generate chromatograms by simulation. First, a single peak chromatogram of components a, b, ... is generated using Gaussian. EMG (Exponentially Modified Gaussian) equivalent to a unit amount such as 1.0 μg may also be used. Next, the blend amounts determined by random numbers are converted to the vertical axis direction, and finally, they are synthesized into one chromatogram. Noise and drift components can also be added randomly. Since the synthesis process of this Monte Carlo chromatogram is also known, the true value of the peak area is known. Only the Monte Carlo chromatogram has the characteristic that random numbers can be applied to the time axis on the horizontal axis. In other words, the retention time is also changed randomly, and the true value of the peak area is still known. However, it is generally preferable to set rules for generation, such as not placing two components close to each other for a certain period of time, or setting the peak area ratio to 100:1 or more.

[0052] 2.5. When inputting a large amount of chromatogram data, such as 100 or 1,000 sheets, it may be difficult to actually measure each one, so in that respect, semi-measured synthetic chromatograms or Monte Carlo type chromatograms are advantageous.

[0053] 2.6. Waveform Processing Method The learning and selection unit 121 operates as follows.

[0054] 2.6.1. Each waveform processing method uses provisionally automatically set parameters, which are denoted as automatic parameters 0. The waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 takes in multiple pieces of input chromatogram data and selects the one with the smallest deviation score from A0, B0, .... The search method using these multiple chromatograms and the true values ​​of their peak areas is the first screening of the waveform processing method.

[0055] 2.6.2. Next, the parameters of the selected waveform processing method, for example, method B, are changed sequentially to B0, B1, B2, .... The waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 further searches for the waveform processing method Bn that minimizes the deviation score using the experimental design method. This is the second screening.

[0056] 2.6.3. Using the optimized parameter method Bn, the waveform processing method learning and selection unit 121 thereafter instructs the peak area calculation unit 122 to process the analysis of unknown samples using the Bn method when the user instructs that priority be given to peak area accuracy.

[0057] (Other matters) In addition, the waveform processing method corresponding to the instruction according to the accuracy of the obtained peak area and the priority level of reproducibility is not limited to the waveform processing method with the highest score, but may be determined within a range in which the accuracy score and / or reproducibility score satisfy a predetermined relationship. Specifically, for example, the waveform processing method with the highest reproducibility may be determined among the waveform processing methods with an accuracy equal to or higher than a predetermined threshold, or conversely, the waveform processing method with the highest accuracy may be determined among the waveform processing methods with a reproducibility equal to or higher than a predetermined threshold. In addition, when there are multiple waveform processing methods with accuracy or reproducibility equal to or higher than a predetermined threshold, they may be presented to the user as candidates so that the user can select from them.

[0058] Also, instead of obtaining the peak area by using the waveform processing method as described above, the peak area or peak area ratio may be obtained directly from the chromatogram data by machine learning. That is, for example, as shown in Fig. 7, if the chromatogram data and the known peak areas are input to a peak area calculation model 140 using a neural network or the like and the corresponding relationship is machine-learned as so-called supervised learning, the peak area can be obtained based on the machine learning result and the actually measured chromatogram data.

[0059] As a simple example of supervised learning, we will show the problem of finding the peak area ratio of two overlapping peaks. Multiple chromatograms are input to the input layer, and the correct area ratio of the front peak is shown as teacher data to the output layer. This input data is not two-dimensional image data, but one-stroke time series data (numerical data showing the signal strength at each time). It is defined in advance that the area ratio of the rear peak added to the front peak is 1. The various chromatograms presented to the input layer can be formed by simulation as mentioned above, and 10,000 or more are preferable. Since they are formed by simulation, the correct area ratio is naturally known. In so-called deep learning, a significantly multi-layered intermediate layer is set in the neural network. The weight coefficients in the neural network are tuned by assigning multiple chromatograms and corresponding teacher data. Backpropagation technology is used for this tuning. In addition, convolutional neural network technology can also be used for preprocessing if necessary. Once these weighting coefficients are obtained, the chromatogram of the unknown overlapping peaks can be input and the peak area ratio can be output. This process is exactly the resolution of the overlapping peaks. Strictly speaking, this function of obtaining the area ratio does not obtain the peak area itself. It is merely a ratio. For this reason, the total peak area is required to convert to the peak area. In other words, the idea of ​​this example is to draw a baseline for the two peaks together and calculate the total peak area as the sum of these separately. Another feature of this method using a neural network is that it may not be able to answer at all how the two peaks overlap. In this respect, it differs greatly from the curve fitting method.

[0060] It is conceivable to apply the present invention to increase the number of peaks from two to three or four, but applicability becomes gradually more difficult. In the first place, the number of hidden peaks may be unknown, and humans will have to estimate the number by trial and error. It is also possible to train deep learning to estimate the number, but this is a new challenge. In addition to calculating the peak area ratio, supervised learning is also possible, in which the peak area is directly calculated using a simulation chromatogram. It is expected that high accuracy can be obtained by supervised learning.

[0061] On the other hand, the use of machine learning including reinforcement learning is expected to achieve high reproducibility. For example, in a task of searching for optimal parameters for a certain scissors-and-balance integration method, the relative standard deviation (RSD) of peak areas is used as an evaluation index, and optimal parameters are searched for to minimize the RSD. In this case, the input can be multiple unknown chromatograms actually measured. Normally, scissors-and-balance integration is performed with predetermined parameters, but in this example, the idea is to search for parameters to minimize the RSD, which is the evaluation index. The peak areas are calculated using the optimized parameters obtained in this way. [Explanation of symbols]

[0062] 100 Chromatography 110 Chromatography Unit 120 Data Processing Device 121 Waveform processing method learning, selection section 122 Peak area calculation section 123 Display section 130 Chromatogram data input and generation section 140 Peak area calculation model

Claims

1. A data processing device for a chromatography, which performs data processing of a chromatogram obtained by separating a measurement target sample in a column and detecting separated components, and determines a peak area corresponding to the amount of the separated components, a peak processing method selection unit that receives an instruction according to the accuracy of the obtained peak area and the priority level of reproducibility, and selects a peak processing method corresponding to the instruction; a peak area calculation unit that processes data of a given chromatogram by a selected waveform processing method and calculates a peak area for the separated components; A chromatographic data processing device comprising:

2. 2. The data processing device of claim 1, 4. A data processing device for a chromatography, wherein the waveform processing method includes at least one of a valley integration method, a clipping method, and a curve fitting method.

3. A data processing device for a chromatograph according to claim 1; a chromatographic unit that separates and measures components contained in a sample; A chromatograph comprising: The data processing device is a chromatograph characterized in that it selects the waveform processing method in accordance with the error from the true value of the peak area obtained by each of a plurality of waveform processing methods based on a plurality of chromatograms in which the true values ​​of the peak areas are known.

4. A data processing device for a chromatograph according to claim 1; a chromatographic unit that separates and measures components contained in a sample; A chromatograph comprising: The data processing device is a chromatograph characterized in that it selects the waveform processing method in accordance with the variation in peak areas obtained by a plurality of waveform processing methods based on a plurality of chromatograms obtained by the chromatographic unit for the same sample.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Data processor for chromatography

    JP1992268451A

  • Chromatographic data processing device, chromatographic data processing method, and chromatographic analyzer

    JP2006177980A

  • Data processor for chromatograph mass spectrometer

    JP2014134385A

  • Chromatograph data processing device, data processing method and chromatography

    JP2020153864A

  • Chromatogram data processing device and program

    WO2016185552A1