Method for estimating nugget diameter in resistance spot welding
The method enhances nugget diameter estimation accuracy in resistance spot welding by using a correction formula to adjust for disturbances, achieving estimation errors below 10% through measured resistance value differences.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2022109704
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-07-07
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-07-07
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for estimating nugget diameter in resistance spot welding are inaccurate due to disturbances such as gaps between steel plates, plate inclination, electrode wear, and other factors, leading to poor accuracy in determining the weld nugget diameter.
A method using a predetermined estimation formula that incorporates the electrical resistance value of the current-carrying circuit and current-carrying period, with a correction formula to account for disturbances, allowing for accurate calculation of the nugget diameter by correcting welding parameters based on measured resistance value differences.
The method significantly improves the accuracy of nugget diameter estimation by accounting for disturbances, reducing estimation errors to within 10% or less, ensuring reliable weld quality.
Smart Images

Figure 0007582267000001 
Figure 0007582267000002 
Figure 0007582267000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a method for estimating a nugget diameter in resistance spot welding. [Background technology]
[0002] Conventionally, resistance spot welding has been used as a means for joining multiple metal plates together when manufacturing vehicle body frames and the like. In this resistance spot welding, a current is passed between a pair of electrodes while the workpieces (multiple metal plates) are sandwiched between them, and the metal plates are melted and joined together using Joule heat generated by the electrical resistance of the workpieces themselves. In order to increase the joint strength of the welded portion between the metal plates, it is necessary to ensure a sufficient weld nugget diameter obtained by this resistance spot welding. For this reason, a method for estimating whether a sufficient weld nugget diameter has been ensured is required.
[0003] The resistance welding method described in Patent Document 1 describes how a database is prepared in advance that associates the amount of power, which is the integrated value of the power input to the workpiece, with the nugget diameter, and how the nugget diameter can be estimated from the actual integrated amount of power. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2011-104628 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] However, as described in Patent Document 1, the method of estimating the nugget diameter simply from the correlation with the amount of power has a problem in that the accuracy of estimating the nugget diameter is poor when there are various disturbances at the welding site, such as gaps between the steel sheets, inclination of the steel sheet, wear of the tip of the electrode that is pressed against the steel sheet, etc. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] The present disclosure can be realized in the following forms.
[0007] (1) According to one embodiment of the present disclosure, there is provided a method for estimating a nugget diameter, which estimates a nugget diameter by using a predetermined estimation equation having a welding parameter that contributes to the size of a nugget diameter formed in resistance spot welding as a first explanatory variable and an estimated value of the nugget diameter as a first objective variable, and includes the steps of: acquiring an actual initial resistance value, which is an electrical resistance value of an entire current-carrying circuit including an object to be welded and which is an electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current-carrying period in a target welding that is a welding that corresponds to the nugget diameter to be estimated; acquiring a master initial resistance value, which is the electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current-carrying period in a master welding that is a welding that is performed in a state free of disturbance that may affect the size of the nugget diameter and is a reference for creating the estimation equation; and acquiring the actual initial resistance value acquired in the actual initial resistance value acquisition step. and a correction value calculation step of calculating a correction value of the welding parameter by substituting the measured resistance difference calculated in the measured resistance difference calculation step into a predetermined correction formula indicating a correlation between the measured resistance difference and a correction value of the welding parameter, the correction value being a second explanatory variable and the correction value of the welding parameter being a second objective variable; a parameter correction step of correcting a value of the welding parameter by applying the correction value calculated in the correction value calculation step to a value of the welding parameter measured during the target welding; and a nugget diameter calculation step of calculating the nugget diameter by substituting the corrected value of the welding parameter into the estimation formula. According to this embodiment, the correction value of the welding parameter is calculated by substituting the actual resistance value difference into a predetermined correction formula that indicates the correlation between the actual resistance value difference and the correction value of the welding parameter, and the nugget diameter is calculated by substituting the corrected welding parameter value into a predetermined estimation formula. In the case of a master welding, which is a welding in a state where there is no disturbance that can affect the size of the nugget diameter, and which is a reference for creating the estimation formula, a disturbance may occur in the target welding, which is an actual welding to be estimated for the nugget diameter. In addition, when a disturbance actually occurs, if the value of the welding parameter without correction is used for the predetermined estimation formula, the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter may decrease. The inventors of the present application have found that there is a correlation between the presence or absence of a disturbance in welding and the measured resistance value difference, which is the difference between the master initial resistance value and the measured initial resistance value. In the above embodiment, the welding parameters are corrected using the measured resistance value difference and the correction formula, so that the nugget diameter calculated by substituting the value of the welding parameter after the correction into the estimation formula can be obtained as a highly accurate nugget diameter, and the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter can be improved. (2) In the above embodiment, the correction formula may be created including: (I) a parameter difference calculation step of calculating a parameter difference between a value of the welding parameter in a master pattern indicating a correlation between the value of the welding parameter and the nugget diameter, obtained by performing the master welding a plurality of times, and a value of the welding parameter in disturbance correlation data indicating a correlation between the value of the welding parameter and the nugget diameter, obtained by performing welding with disturbance, which is welding in a state where the disturbance is present; (II) a disturbance resistance value difference calculation step of calculating a disturbance resistance value difference between the master initial resistance value and a disturbance initial resistance value, which is the electrical resistance value, and is the electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current application period in the welding with disturbance; and (III) a derivation step of deriving the correction formula using the correlation between the parameter difference and the disturbance resistance value difference. According to this aspect, the correction equation can be easily derived by using the correlation between the parameter difference and the disturbance resistance value difference. (3) In the above embodiment, the correction formula may be a linear equation calculated by linearly regressing plot points in which the disturbance resistance value difference and the parameter difference are associated. According to this embodiment, the correlation between the disturbance resistance value difference and the parameter difference can be uniquely expressed. In addition, the estimation formula can be easily created using plot points in which the disturbance resistance value difference and the parameter difference are associated. (4) In the above embodiment, the estimation method may further include a disturbance discrimination step of discriminating a type of the disturbance from characteristics of the electrical resistance value during the current application period when the target is welded, and the correction value calculation step may obtain the correction value of the welding parameter by using a correction equation corresponding to the disturbance discriminated in the disturbance discrimination step, from among the correction equations created corresponding to each type of disturbance. According to this aspect, the type of disturbance is identified in the disturbance identification process, and the welding parameters are corrected using a correction formula according to the type of disturbance. Therefore, an appropriate correction value according to the type of disturbance can be calculated, thereby further improving the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter. (5) In the above-described embodiment, the disturbance determination step may determine the type of the disturbance by comparing the electrical resistance value during the target welding with the electrical resistance value during the master welding. According to this embodiment, the type of the disturbance can be easily determined by comparing the electrical resistance value with the electrical resistance value during the master welding. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0008] [Figure 1] 1 is a schematic configuration diagram showing a nugget diameter estimation system according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of a control device in the first embodiment. [Diagram 3] 4 is a flowchart showing the steps of a method for estimating a nugget diameter. [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the change in resistance value over time. [Diagram 5] 10 is a flowchart showing the steps of a method for creating a correction equation. [Figure 6] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between welding parameters before correction and nugget diameter. [Figure 7] FIG. 13 is a diagram illustrating an example of a correction formula. [Figure 8] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing the correlation between corrected welding parameters and nugget diameter. [Figure 9] FIG. 11 is a diagram for comparing the estimation error of the nugget diameter before and after correction using the correction formula. [Figure 10] FIG. 11 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of a control device according to a second embodiment. [Figure 11] 10 is a flowchart showing the procedure of a method for estimating a nugget diameter in a second embodiment. [Figure 12] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the change in resistance value over time. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the change in resistance value over time. [Figure 14] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the change in resistance value over time. [Figure 15] 13 is a table showing characteristics of the waveform of the resistance value when each disturbance occurs. [Figure 16] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the correlation between welding parameters and nugget diameter. [Figure 17] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the correlation between welding parameters and nugget diameter. [Figure 18] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing the correlation between welding parameters and nugget diameter. [Figure 19] FIG. 11 is a diagram for comparing the estimation error of the nugget diameter before and after correction. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0009] A. First embodiment: A1. Overall configuration of nugget diameter estimation system 1: A first embodiment of the present disclosure will be described with reference to Figs. 1 to 9. In describing a method for estimating a nugget diameter in the first embodiment of the present disclosure, first, a configuration of a nugget diameter estimation system 1 (hereinafter, also simply referred to as "estimation system 1") will be described. Fig. 1 is a schematic configuration diagram showing a nugget diameter estimation system 1 according to the first embodiment of the present disclosure. The estimation system 1 is a system that estimates a nugget diameter of a weld formed on a welded member W by resistance spot welding performed by a resistance spot welding apparatus 10. The estimation system 1 includes the resistance spot welding apparatus 10, a control device 100, and a measurement mechanism 9.
[0010] The resistance spot welding apparatus 10 is an apparatus that melts and joins a plurality of overlapping metal plates W1, W2 to be welded together W. The resistance spot welding apparatus 10 includes a welding gun G and a robot arm RA.
[0011] The welding gun G includes a gun body 11, a pair of electrodes, an upper electrode 2 and a lower electrode 3, an electrode lifting device 4, a pressure device 5, and a current adjusting device 6. The gun body 11 is held by a robot arm RA. The lower electrode 3 is a fixed electrode arranged in a fixed state on the lower part 11b of the gun body 11. The upper electrode 2 is a movable electrode that is movable in a direction along the opposing direction of the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3. The upper electrode 2 is attached to the upper part 11a of the gun body 11 via the electrode lifting device 4. The upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 each have a flow path (not shown) formed therein for circulating cooling water.
[0012] The electrode lifting device 4 is an electric device that holds and lifts the upper electrode 2. The electrode lifting device 4 is attached to the tip of the upper part 11a of the gun body 11. The electrode lifting device 4 includes a servo motor 41 and a lifting member 42 that is coupled to the drive shaft of the servo motor 41. The electrode lifting device 4 lifts and lowers the lifting member 42 by operating the servo motor 41 in accordance with a lifting command from the control device 100.
[0013] The pressure device 5 presses the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 in a direction in which the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 approach each other. Specifically, the pressure device 5 is a device that applies a force to each of the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 in order to press the welded member W with a predetermined pressure force in a state in which the welded member W is sandwiched between the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3. The pressure device 5 applies a predetermined force to each of the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 in response to a pressure command from the control device 100.
[0014] The current adjusting device 6 adjusts the value of the welding current (hereinafter, referred to as the current value) flowing between the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 in response to a current command transmitted from the control device 100. The current adjusting device 6 is, for example, a device equipped with a variable resistor or a device equipped with a converter.
[0015] 2 is a block diagram showing a schematic configuration of the control device 100. In this embodiment, the control device 100 has a function of controlling the operation of the resistance spot welding device 10, as well as a function as an estimation device for estimating a nugget diameter in resistance spot welding. Note that the estimation device may be configured separately from the control device 100 and may be configured to communicate data via wire or wirelessly.
[0016] The control device 100 includes a communication unit 30, a display 40, an input operation unit 50, a storage unit 60, and a CPU 20. The control device 100 is, for example, a computer including each of the components 20 to 60. The communication unit 30 connects the resistance spot welding device 10 and the measurement mechanism 9 to the control device 100 so that they can communicate with each other. The display 40 is, for example, a liquid crystal display, and displays information in response to commands from the CPU 20. The input operation unit 50 includes, for example, a keyboard and a mouse, and receives instructions from a user.
[0017] The storage unit 60 stores various programs for controlling the operation of the resistance spot welding apparatus 10, and various data including a correction equation 650 and an estimation equation 670. The storage unit 60 includes a RAM, a ROM, a rewritable non-volatile memory, and the like. The estimation equation 670 is a relational equation prepared in advance for calculating an estimated value of the nugget diameter. Specifically, the estimation equation 670 is a relational equation in which a welding parameter that contributes to the size of the nugget diameter is a first explanatory variable, and the estimated value of the nugget diameter is a first objective variable.
[0018] Correction equation 650 is a relational equation created to calculate a correction value of a welding parameter to be substituted into estimation equation 670. Correction equation 650 is an equation showing the correlation between an actual resistance value difference, which will be described later, and a correction value of a welding parameter, and is a predetermined equation in which the actual resistance value difference is a second explanatory variable and the correction value of the welding parameter is a second objective variable. Here, in estimation equation 670 and correction equation 650, "first" and "second" are added for convenience in order to distinguish the explanatory variables and objective variables, respectively.
[0019] The correction formula 650 is expressed by the following linear equation (1). Note that a and b are constants determined by a combination of a resistance value difference and a parameter difference, which will be described later. y is a correction value, and x is an actual resistance value difference. The derivation of the correction formula 650 will be described in detail later. y=ax+b Equation (1)
[0020] The CPU 20 functions as an operation control unit 200, an acquisition unit 210, a difference calculation unit 220, a correction formula creation unit 230, a correction value calculation unit 240, and an estimation unit 290 by deploying various programs stored in the memory unit 60.
[0021] The operation control unit 200 controls the operation of the resistance spot welding apparatus 10. The operation of the resistance spot welding apparatus 10 is controlled in accordance with parameters (hereinafter, welding parameters) that are preset for welding. That is, the welding parameters are welding conditions that are preset when welding is performed. The welding parameters are, for example, a current value, a voltage value, a resistance value, an amount of displacement between electrodes, an amount of expansion, and a welding force of the electrodes 2, 3. The operation control unit 200 controls these operations in an integrated manner. The operation control unit 200 controls the operation of the resistance spot welding apparatus 10 in accordance with the set values of the welding parameters that are preset by the user via the input operation unit 50, for example.
[0022] Acquisition unit 210 acquires various data used for creating correction equation 650 and substituting into estimation equation 670. For example, acquisition unit 210 acquires an actual measured initial resistance value, described later, used when calculating an actual measured resistance value difference. Difference calculation unit 220 calculates the actual measured resistance value difference. Correction equation creation unit 230 creates correction equation 650. Correction value calculation unit 240 uses correction equation 650 to calculate a correction value of a welding parameter to be substituted into estimation equation 670. Specifically, correction value calculation unit 240 calculates the correction value by substituting the actual measured resistance value difference into correction equation 650 (the above equation (1)).
[0023] The estimation unit 290 includes a parameter correction unit 291 and an estimate value calculation unit 292. The parameter correction unit 291 calculates corrected parameters by reflecting the correction values in the welding parameters. The estimate value calculation unit 292 calculates an estimate value of the nugget diameter in the target welding using the corrected welding parameters. Details of each function will be described later together with a method of estimating the nugget diameter. At least a part of the functions of the CPU 20 may be realized by a hardware circuit.
[0024] Measurement mechanism 9 is a mechanism that measures actual values of welding parameters as physical quantities required for welding using resistance spot welding apparatus 10. The "actual values of welding parameters" referred to here are the values of the welding parameters that are actually observed when welding is performed according to commands related to the welding conditions transmitted from operation control unit 200, i.e., preset set values of the welding parameters. The actual values of the welding parameters measured by measurement mechanism 9 are transmitted to CPU 20 via communication unit 30.
[0025] In this embodiment, the measurement mechanism 9 includes a current value measuring unit 91, a voltage value measuring unit 92, a resistance value calculating unit 93, a pressure measuring unit 95, an inter-electrode displacement measuring unit 96, and an inter-electrode displacement calculating unit 97. Note that the configuration and functions of the measurement mechanism 9 are not limited to this. For example, the measurement mechanism 9 may further include a mechanism for measuring other welding parameters. Also, at least a part of the functions of the measurement mechanism 9 may be realized as one function of the CPU 20.
[0026] Each of the components 91-97 included in the measurement mechanism 9 measures the actual values of the welding parameters at predetermined measurement times during welding. The current value measurement unit 91 measures the value of a current flowing between the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3. The current value measurement unit 91 is, for example, a current sensor. The voltage value measurement unit 92 measures the voltage value (potential difference) between the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3. The voltage value measurement unit 92 is, for example, a voltage sensor.
[0027] The resistance value calculation unit 93 calculates the electrical resistance value (hereinafter, resistance value) using the actual current value and voltage value measured when electricity is applied. Specifically, the resistance value calculation unit 93 calculates the resistance value by dividing the voltage value by the current value. At this time, the current value and voltage value at the same measurement point are used to calculate the resistance value.
[0028] The pressing force measuring unit 95 measures the pressing force of each of the electrodes 2, 3 against the welded members W. The pressing force measuring unit 95 is, for example, a load cell housed inside the electrode lifting device 4. The inter-electrode displacement amount measuring unit 96 includes a first displacement amount measuring unit 961 that measures the displacement amount of the upper electrode 2 (hereinafter, referred to as the first displacement amount), and a second displacement amount measuring unit 962 that measures the displacement amount of the lower electrode 3 (hereinafter, referred to as the second displacement amount).
[0029] The first displacement amount measuring unit 961 measures, for example, the elevation position of the upper electrode 2 at a first measurement time point and the elevation position of the upper electrode 2 at a second measurement time point a predetermined measurement time after the first measurement time point, and calculates the first displacement amount from the difference between the measurement values. The first displacement amount measuring unit 961 is, for example, an encoder housed inside the electrode lifting device 4 and detecting the rotation angle position of the output shaft of the servo motor 41 to measure the elevation position of the upper electrode 2.
[0030] The second displacement amount measuring unit 962 measures the second displacement amount. Specifically, it is fixed to the lower part 11b of the gun body 11. Therefore, when a force is applied due to thermal expansion, the lower electrode 3 distorts without moving. Therefore, the second displacement amount measuring unit 962 measures the force (strain value) applied to the lower electrode 3 as the second displacement amount. The second displacement amount measuring unit 962 is, for example, a strain sensor that measures the strain value of the lower electrode 3.
[0031] The inter-electrode displacement amount calculation unit 97 calculates the amount of displacement between the upper electrode 2 and the lower electrode 3 (hereinafter, inter-electrode displacement amount) using the first displacement amount measured and calculated by the first displacement amount measurement unit 961 and the second displacement amount measured by the second displacement amount measurement unit 962. At this time, the inter-electrode displacement amount is calculated using values at the same measurement time point. The inter-electrode displacement amount calculation unit 97 calculates the inter-electrode displacement amount during current application, for example, by adding up the first displacement amount and the second displacement amount during the current application period. Note that the method of calculating the inter-electrode displacement amount is not limited to this.
[0032] A2. Method for estimating nugget diameter: Next, a method for estimating a nugget diameter in the first embodiment of the present disclosure using the estimation system 1 described above in detail will be described. Fig. 3 is a flowchart showing the steps of the method for estimating a nugget diameter. As shown in Fig. 3, the method for estimating a nugget diameter includes an actual initial resistance value acquisition step (S110), an actual resistance value difference calculation step (S120), a correction value calculation step (S130), a parameter correction step (S140), and a nugget diameter calculation step (S150), and each step is performed in this order.
[0033] In the measured resistance difference calculation step (S120), the acquisition unit 210 acquires a measured initial resistance value at the beginning of a current-carrying period in the target welding, which is a welding corresponding to the nugget diameter to be estimated. Here, in this embodiment, the "beginning of the current-carrying period" refers to a time from the start of current-carrying to a quarter of the entire current-carrying period. It is not limited to the quarter, and may be any period in the first half of the current-carrying period. Hereinafter, the "resistance value" refers to the electric resistance value of the entire current-carrying circuit including the welding object. FIG. 4 is a graph showing the change in resistance value over time. In FIG. 4, the resistance value Rm in the master welding (hereinafter also referred to as the master resistance value Rm) is shown by a thin solid line, and the resistance value Ra in the welding with disturbance (hereinafter also referred to as the measured resistance value Ra) is shown by a dashed line as an example of the target welding.
[0034] Here, the master welding is welding in a state where there is no disturbance that may affect the size of the nugget diameter, and is welding that is a reference for creating the estimation formula 670. It means welding for acquiring master data that is a reference for taking a difference from an actual measured resistance value when estimating the nugget diameter. The disturbance is, for example, a gap between steel sheets (hereinafter, also simply referred to as "sheet gap"), the inclination of the steel sheet, wear of the tip of the electrode 2, 3 pressed against the steel sheet, etc. In addition, "no disturbance" is not limited to the case where the above-mentioned sheet gap, inclination of the steel sheet, and wear of the tip are completely absent (zero), but has a broad meaning including the case where there is a small amount that can be considered to be completely absent. For example, if the sheet gap is 0.1 mm or less, the inclination angle is 0.1° or less, and the wear is 0.1% or less, it can be said to be in a state of "no disturbance". In FIG. 4, the change in the current value is shown by a solid line. In FIG. 4, the start of energization is 100 ms, and the end of energization is 470 ms.
[0035] In this embodiment, the "initial period Ti" is set to between 170 ms and 200 ms. This is to avoid the period immediately after the start of current flow when the waveform is not stable, and to take into consideration the period when the effect of disturbance is easy to read. The inventors of the present application have found that the resistance value at the initial period Ti during the first half of the current flow period is easy to capture the characteristics of disturbance, and when disturbance occurs, the resistance value is lower than the resistance value during master welding. The average value at the initial period Ti is used as the measured initial resistance value.
[0036] In the measured resistance difference calculation step (S120), the difference calculation unit 220 calculates the measured resistance difference. The measured resistance difference is the difference obtained by subtracting the measured initial resistance from the master initial resistance. The master initial resistance is the initial electrical resistance in master welding, and here, like the measured initial resistance, an average value at the beginning of current flow Ti is used. Note that the master initial resistance is obtained from data in master welding previously performed before the target welding is performed, and is stored in the storage unit 60, for example.
[0037] In the correction value calculation step (S130), correction value calculation unit 240 calculates the correction value of the welding parameter by substituting the actual resistance value difference into correction equation 650. In the parameter correction step (S140), the value of the welding parameter is corrected by parameter correction unit 291. Specifically, the correction is performed by adding the correction value calculated in the correction value calculation step (S130) to the value of the welding parameter measured during target welding. In other words, the corrected welding parameter is defined by the relational expression shown in the following equation (2). Corrected welding parameters = Uncorrected welding parameters + Correction values Equation (2)
[0038] In the nugget diameter estimation step (S150), the nugget diameter is calculated by the estimated value calculation unit 292. Specifically, the corrected welding parameter values are substituted into an estimation equation to calculate the nugget diameter.
[0039] A3.How to create correction formula 650: Next, a method for creating the correction equation 650 will be described. Fig. 5 is a flowchart showing the procedure of the method for creating the correction equation 650 executed by the correction equation creation unit 230. Note that the flowchart shown in Fig. 5 is executed before the flowchart shown in Fig. 3. As shown in Fig. 5, the method for creating the correction equation 650 has a parameter difference calculation step (S201), a disturbance resistance value difference calculation step (S202), and a derivation step (S203), and each step is executed in this order.
[0040] In the parameter difference calculation step (S201), a parameter difference is calculated, which is a difference between a welding parameter value in a master pattern and a welding parameter value in correlation data with disturbance. The master pattern indicates a correlation between a welding parameter value and a nugget diameter obtained by performing master welding multiple times. The correlation data with disturbance indicates a correlation between a welding parameter value and a nugget diameter obtained by performing welding with disturbance multiple times in a state where a disturbance is present.
[0041] FIG. 6 is a diagram showing the correlation between the welding parameters before correction and the nugget diameter. The vertical axis in FIG. 6 represents the value of the welding parameters, and the horizontal axis represents the nugget diameter. In FIG. 6, the master pattern is plotted as a black circle, and the correlation data with disturbance is plotted as a black square. In this embodiment, the disturbance is the occurrence of a plate gap, and the average resistance value in the latter half of the welding period is used as the welding parameter. The straight line in FIG. 6 is a linear equation calculated by linear regression of plot points corresponding to the values of the welding parameters and the nugget diameter in the master welding, and corresponds to the estimation formula 670. As shown in FIG. 6, when there is a disturbance, the plot points are shifted downward from the estimation formula. This "shift" is the difference Pd between the value of the welding parameter in the master pattern and the value of the welding parameter in the correlation data with disturbance, that is, the "parameter difference".
[0042] In the disturbance resistance value difference calculation step (S202), a disturbance resistance value difference is calculated, which is the difference between the master initial resistance value and the disturbance initial resistance value at the beginning of the current application period in welding with disturbance. FIG. 7 is a diagram showing an example of the correction formula 650. In FIG. 7, the horizontal axis represents the actual resistance value difference, and the vertical axis represents the correction value. Also, in FIG. 7, the horizontal axis corresponds to the disturbance resistance value difference described above, and the vertical axis corresponds to the parameter difference described above. In FIG. 7, data without disturbance is plotted as a black filled circle, and data with disturbance is plotted as a black filled square. The straight line in FIG. 7 is a linear equation as an approximation line calculated by linear regression of each of these plot points, and corresponds to the correction formula 650.
[0043] That is, in this embodiment, the correction formula 650 is created using the correlation between the parameter difference and the disturbance resistance value difference. The correction value is calculated as y by substituting the measured resistance value difference for x in the created correction formula 650 (the above formula (1)). FIG. 8 is a diagram showing the correlation between the welding parameters and the nugget diameter after correction. The vertical axis in FIG. 8 represents the value of the welding parameter after correction, and the horizontal axis represents the nugget diameter. In FIG. 8, the master pattern is plotted as a black circle, and the correlation data with disturbance is plotted as a black square. As shown in FIG. 8, the correlation data with disturbance is corrected to a position closer to the approximation line compared to FIG. 6. That is, the correction was possible as data that can be treated equivalently to the master pattern.
[0044] FIG. 9 is a diagram for comparing the estimation error of the nugget diameter before and after the correction using the correction formula 650. The "estimation error" here refers to the degree of deviation between the actual measurement value of the nugget diameter and the estimated value of the nugget diameter calculated by the estimation formula 670. The left diagram of FIG. 9 shows the estimation error of the nugget diameter when the nugget diameter is estimated without correcting the welding parameters substituted into the estimation formula 670. The right diagram of FIG. 9 shows the estimation error of the nugget diameter when the nugget diameter is estimated by substituting the welding parameters after the correction using the correction formula 650 into the estimation formula 670. The horizontal axis in the left diagram and the right diagram of FIG. 9 is the estimation error of the nugget diameter. The vertical axis in the left diagram and the right diagram of FIG. 9 is the actual measurement diameter of the nugget diameter.
[0045] In addition, in FIG. 9, data obtained by performing welding without disturbance multiple times is plotted as black filled circles, and data obtained by performing welding with disturbance multiple times is plotted as black filled squares. As shown in the left diagram of FIG. 9, when the nugget diameter is estimated without correcting the welding parameters substituted into the estimation formula 670, the estimation error of the nugget diameter in the case of the presence of disturbance is often 10% or more. On the other hand, as shown in the right diagram of FIG. 9, when the nugget diameter is estimated by substituting the values of the welding parameters corrected by the correction formula 650 into the estimation formula 670, the estimation error of the nugget diameter is within a range of 10% even in the case of the presence of disturbance. That is, according to the first embodiment, the nugget diameter can be accurately estimated by correcting the welding parameters substituted into the estimation formula 670 of the nugget diameter by the correction formula 650.
[0046] Furthermore, in the above estimation method, the master initial resistance value and the correction formula 650 are stored in advance in the storage unit 60. Therefore, when estimating the nugget diameter, the correction value can be calculated by a simple process of acquiring the measured initial resistance value at the beginning of current application, calculating the measured resistance value difference, which is the difference from the registered master initial resistance value, and substituting the calculated measured resistance value difference into the correction formula 650. In addition, the correction formula 650 is created taking into account the influence of disturbances, and correlates the disturbance resistance value difference, which is the deviation from the master welding, with the parameter difference. Therefore, the influence of disturbances can be corrected by correcting the value of the welding parameters using the correction value obtained using the correction formula 650.
[0047] B. Second embodiment: Next, a second embodiment of the present disclosure will be described with reference to Figs. 10 to 19. In the second embodiment, the overall configuration of the nugget diameter estimation system 1 (Fig. 1) and the schematic configuration of the control device 100 (Fig. 2) are substantially similar to those of the first embodiment, so the same reference numerals are used for substantially the same parts and the description thereof will be omitted. Fig. 10 is a block diagram showing the schematic configuration of the control device 100. As shown in Fig. 10, the second embodiment is different from the first embodiment in that the CPU 20 further includes a disturbance determination unit 250. The other configurations are the same.
[0048] The disturbance determination unit 250 determines the type of disturbance from the characteristics of the electric resistance value during the current application period during welding of the target. In the second embodiment, the disturbance determination unit 250 determines three types of disturbance. The first of the three types of disturbance is "plate gap", the second is "push-up / push-down", and the third is "failure to maintain perpendicularity". "Push-up / push-down" is a phenomenon in which the electrode pushes up or pushes down the surface to be welded due to disturbances or errors in the position control by the robot of the lower electrode 3, or wear of the tips of the electrodes 2 and 3. In "push-up", the upper electrode 2 is in weak contact and the lower electrode 3 is in strong contact. In "push-down", the upper electrode 2 is in strong contact and the lower electrode 3 is in weak contact. "Failure to maintain perpendicularity" is a phenomenon in which the perpendicular relationship between the electrode and the surface to be contacted is lost due to disturbances in the position control by the robot of the lower electrode 3, etc.
[0049] In the second embodiment, a correction equation 650 is created for each disturbance, and in this embodiment, three correction equations 650 are stored in the storage unit 60. The correction equation 650 is created in the same manner as in the first embodiment, and is created by taking data for different types of disturbance.
[0050] Fig. 11 is a flowchart showing the procedure of the nugget diameter estimation method in the second embodiment. As shown in Fig. 11, the second embodiment is different from the first embodiment in that a disturbance determination step (S121) is provided between the actual resistance value difference calculation step (S120) and the correction value calculation step (S130). In the disturbance determination step (S121), the disturbance determination unit 250 determines which of the three types of disturbance is assumed to have occurred in the target welding. This determination is performed by comparing the waveform of the electric resistance value during the target welding with the waveform of the electric resistance value during the master welding.
[0051] 12 to 14 are graphs showing the change in resistance value over time. In each figure, the resistance value Rm in master welding (hereinafter simply referred to as master resistance value Rm) is shown by a thick solid line, and the resistance values Rg1 and Rg2 in welding with disturbance are shown by a dashed line and a two-dot chain line. In addition, in Fig. 12, the change in current value is shown by a thin solid line. In each figure, current flow starts at 100 ms and ends at 300 ms.
[0052] FIG. 12 shows data when a plate gap occurs as a disturbance. In FIG. 12, resistance value Rg1 is the resistance value when a plate gap of 1 mm is used, and resistance value Rg2 is the resistance value when a plate gap of 2 mm is used. FIG. 13 shows data when push-up and push-down occur as disturbances. In FIG. 13, resistance value Rg1 is the resistance value when pushed up by 2 mm, and resistance value Rg2 is the resistance value when pushed down by 2 mm. FIG. 14 shows data when a failure to be in perpendicular to the surface occurs as a disturbance. In FIG. 14, resistance values Rg1 and Rg2 show data when a failure to be in perpendicular to the surface of 3° occurs twice.
[0053] As shown in each of Figs. 12 to 14, the characteristics of the waveform of the resistance value during the welding period differ depending on the type of disturbance. Fig. 15 is a table showing the characteristics of the waveform of the resistance value when each disturbance occurs. Here, the "initial period of main current T1" is 140ms to 160ms in Figs. 12 to 14, the "first half of main current T2" is 140ms to 178ms, and the "second half of main current T3" is 270ms to 300ms. For convenience, the above divisions are made in acquiring the characteristic amounts, but the "first half of current" indicates the range from the start of the current period to the middle position of the current period. In addition, the "initial period of main current" here can be set differently from the "initial period of current" when acquiring the actual initial resistance value.
[0054] As shown in Figures 12 to 14 and 15, the resistance waveform when the disturbance is a plate gap is smaller than the master resistance value Rm at the beginning of main current application, the slope is greater than 0 in the first half of main current application, and is smaller than the master resistance value Rm in the second half of main current application. The resistance waveform when the disturbance is pushing up or pushing down is smaller than the master resistance value Rm at the beginning of main current application, the slope is nearly 0 in the first half of main current application, and is nearly the same as the master resistance value Rm in the second half of main current application. The resistance waveform when the disturbance is failure to be perpendicular to the surface is smaller than the master resistance value Rm at the beginning of main current application, the slope is greater than 0 in the first half of main current application, and is larger than the master resistance value Rm in the second half of main current application.
[0055] In the above example, the resistance value is smaller than the master resistance value Rm in the early stage of the main current flow, but it is possible to distinguish between the different disturbances by comparing the slope of the first half of the main current flow and the master resistance value Rm in the second half of the main current flow. Specifically, in order to distinguish the type of disturbance by these characteristics, a specific threshold value for the target welding is determined in advance, and the type can be distinguished by whether or not it exceeds the threshold value.
[0056] In the second embodiment, after the type of disturbance is identified, the correction value of the welding parameter is calculated using the correction formula 650 corresponding to the disturbance identified in the disturbance identification step (S121) among the correction formulas 650 created corresponding to each type of disturbance. Figs. 16 to 18 are diagrams showing the correlation between the welding parameter and the nugget diameter. In each diagram, the vertical axis represents the value of the welding parameter, and the horizontal axis represents the nugget diameter. In each diagram, the master pattern is plotted as an open square, data with disturbance before correction is plotted as a triangle, and data with disturbance after correction is plotted as a cross.
[0057] FIG. 16 shows data when a plate gap occurs as a disturbance. FIG. 17 shows data when push-up and push-down occur as disturbances. FIG. 18 shows data when a surface perpendicularity failure occurs as a disturbance. The straight lines in each figure are linear equations calculated by linear regression of plot points corresponding to the welding parameter values and nugget diameters, and correspond to the estimation formula 670. As shown in each figure, when there is a disturbance, the plot points in the data before correction are shifted downward from the estimation formula. However, by performing correction using each correction formula 650, the plot points in the corrected data are corrected to positions almost close to the estimation formula.
[0058] FIG. 19 is a diagram for comparing the estimation error of the nugget diameter before and after the correction using the correction formula 650. The left diagram of FIG. 19 shows the estimation error of the nugget diameter when the nugget diameter is estimated without correcting the welding parameters substituted into the estimation formula 670. The right diagram of FIG. 19 shows the estimation error of the nugget diameter when the nugget diameter is estimated by substituting the welding parameters after the correction using the correction formula 650 into the estimation formula 670. The horizontal axis in the left diagram and the right diagram of FIG. 19 is the estimation error of the nugget diameter. The vertical axis in the left diagram and the right diagram of FIG. 19 is the actual measured nugget diameter.
[0059] As shown in Fig. 19, data whose estimation accuracy was significantly off by ±20% or more without correction could be estimated to within ±20% with correction. That is, according to the second embodiment, the same effects as those of the first embodiment can be achieved. Furthermore, since the type of disturbance is identified and the welding parameters are corrected using the correction formula 650 according to the type of disturbance, an appropriate correction value according to the type of disturbance is calculated, and the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter can be further improved.
[0060] C. Other embodiments: (C1) In the above embodiments, the measured initial resistance value and the master initial resistance value are average values at the beginning of current flow Ti. However, values at any time at the beginning of current flow Ti may be used.
[0061] (C2) In each of the above embodiments, estimation equation 670 is a relational equation in which the welding parameter is the first explanatory variable and the estimated value of the nugget diameter is the first objective variable. Here, when a plurality of welding parameters are included as the first explanatory variable, correction equation 650 may be created for each of all the welding parameters, and the nugget diameter may be estimated after calculating the corrected value. Alternatively, any welding parameter may be selected, and correction equation 650 may be created only for the selected welding parameter.
[0062] The present disclosure is not limited to the above-mentioned embodiments, and can be realized in various configurations without departing from the spirit of the present disclosure. For example, the technical features in each embodiment corresponding to the technical features in each form described in the Summary of the Invention column can be appropriately replaced or combined in order to solve some or all of the above-mentioned problems or to achieve some or all of the above-mentioned effects. Furthermore, if a technical feature is not described as essential in this specification, it can be appropriately deleted. [Explanation of symbols]
[0063] 1...nugget diameter estimation system, 2...upper electrode, 3...lower electrode, 4...electrode lifting device, 5...pressure device, 6...current adjustment device, 9...measurement mechanism, 10...resistance spot welding device, 11...gun body, 11a...upper, 11b...lower, 20...CPU, 20...disturbance determination unit, 30...communication unit, 40...display, 41...servo motor, 42...lifting member, 50...input operation unit, 60...memory unit, 91...current value measurement unit, 92...voltage value measurement unit, 93...resistance value calculation unit, 9 5...pressure measuring section, 96...inter-electrode displacement measuring section, 97...inter-electrode displacement calculating section, 100...control device, 200...operation control section, 210...acquisition section, 220...difference calculating section, 230...correction formula creating section, 240...correction value calculating section, 250...disturbance determining section, 290...estimating section, 291...parameter correcting section, 292...estimated value calculating section, 961...first displacement measuring section, 962...second displacement measuring section, G...welding gun, RA...robot arm, W...welded member, W1...metal plate
Claims
1. 1. A method for estimating a nugget diameter by using a predetermined estimation equation having a welding parameter that contributes to a size of a nugget diameter formed in resistance spot welding as a first explanatory variable and an estimated value of the nugget diameter as a first objective variable, comprising: an actual initial resistance value acquisition process for acquiring an actual initial resistance value, which is an electrical resistance value of an entire current-carrying circuit including a welding object, and is the electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current-carrying period in a target welding that is a welding corresponding to the nugget diameter to be estimated; an actual resistance difference calculation process for calculating an actual resistance difference, which is a difference between a master initial resistance value, which is the electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current application period in master welding, which is welding performed in a state free of disturbances that may affect the size of the nugget diameter and which is a reference for creating the estimation formula, and the actual initial resistance value acquired in the actual initial resistance value acquisition process; a correction value calculation step of calculating the correction value of the welding parameter by substituting the actual resistance value difference calculated in the actual resistance value difference calculation step into a predetermined correction formula indicating a correlation between the actual resistance value difference and a correction value of the welding parameter, the correction value being a second explanatory variable and the correction value of the welding parameter being a second objective variable; a parameter correction step of correcting a value of the welding parameter by applying the correction value calculated in the correction value calculation step to a value of the welding parameter measured during welding of the target object; a nugget diameter calculation step of calculating the nugget diameter by substituting the corrected welding parameter values into the estimation formula; The method for estimating a nugget diameter comprises:
2. The correction formula is (I) values of the welding parameters in a master pattern obtained by performing the master welding a plurality of times, the master pattern indicating a correlation between the values of the welding parameters and the nugget diameter; and A value of the welding parameter in disturbance-present correlation data indicating a correlation between the value of the welding parameter and the nugget diameter, the data being obtained by performing disturbance-present welding, which is welding in a state where the disturbance is present; and A parameter difference calculation step of calculating a parameter difference, which is the difference between (II) the master initial resistance value; and The electrical resistance value is an initial disturbance resistance value that is the electrical resistance value at the beginning of a current application period in the welding with disturbance; a disturbance resistance value difference calculation step of calculating a disturbance resistance value difference, which is the difference between (III) a derivation step of deriving the correction equation using a correlation between the parameter difference and the disturbance resistance value difference; The method for estimating a nugget diameter according to claim 1,
3. The correction formula is The method for estimating a nugget diameter according to claim 2 , wherein the disturbance resistance value difference and the parameter difference are a linear equation calculated by performing linear regression on plot points in which the disturbance resistance value difference and the parameter difference correspond to each other.
4. The estimation method includes: a disturbance determination step of determining a type of the disturbance based on a characteristic of the electrical resistance value during the current application period when the target is welded; Further equipped with The method for estimating a nugget diameter according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein in the correction value calculation process, the correction value of the welding parameter is obtained using a correction formula corresponding to the disturbance identified in the disturbance identification process, from among the correction formulas created corresponding to each type of disturbance.
5. In the disturbance determination step, The method for estimating a nugget diameter according to claim 4 , further comprising the step of determining a type of the disturbance by comparing the electrical resistance value during the target welding with the electrical resistance value during the master welding.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Resistance welding method, resistance welding material, resistance welding device and control device for the same, control method and program for resistance welding device, and evaluation method and program for resistance welding
JP2011104628A
Resistance spot welding device
JP2020171942A
