Qualification evaluation device and qualification evaluation method

The qualification device automates the operational qualification of multiple analytical systems by integrating a reception, acquisition, and execution control system, facilitating efficient and continuous testing through automated preparatory work and parallel/serial execution.

JP7585833B2Active Publication Date: 2024-11-19SHIMADZU SEISAKUSHO LTD
View PDF 9 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2021015562
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-02-03
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2041-02-03

Smart Images

  • Figure 0007585833000001
    Figure 0007585833000001
  • Figure 0007585833000002
    Figure 0007585833000002
  • Figure 0007585833000003
    Figure 0007585833000003
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide an eligibility evaluation device and an eligibility evaluation method that can efficiently perform eligibility evaluation during operation of a plurality of analysis systems.SOLUTION: An eligibility evaluation device 100 comprises: a receiving unit 102 that can receive selection of a plurality of system tests for performing eligibility evaluation during operation of a plurality of analysis systems constituted by an analyzer 20; an acquisition unit 103 that acquires the details of evaluation obtained through the plurality of system tests received by the receiving unit 102 as a plurality of pieces of evaluation information; a presentation unit 16 that, based on the plurality of pieces of acquired evaluation information, presents the details of advance preparation to be performed before execution of the plurality of system tests; an execution control unit 106 that, after the completion of the advance preparation for the plurality of system tests, controls the analyzer 20 so that the plurality of system tests are executed; and output units 108, 109 that output results of the plurality of system tests controlled by the execution control unit 106.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 7
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present invention relates to a qualification evaluation device and a qualification evaluation method. [Background technology]

[0002] Generally, after an analytical device is installed, a field engineer (hereinafter referred to as an inspection worker) performs a qualification test to check whether the analytical device operates normally. The qualification test is called validation. Various devices have been proposed that automate part of the qualification test. For example, Patent Document 1 describes an analytical device validation device that automatically performs validation of an analytical device. Patent Document 2 describes an automatic qualification determination system that automates the operational qualification determination of components that make up an analytical system. Furthermore, Patent Document 3 describes a validation device that verifies analytical control software. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2014-29282 A [Patent Document 2] International Publication No. 2020 / 065804 [Patent Document 3] International Publication No. 2020 / 044517 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] In recent years, software has been developed that automatically performs operational qualification and then creates a report. When using such software, advance preparation work is required, such as preparing various solutions and standard samples to be used in the evaluation, and selecting an executable file. Inspection workers must perform advance preparation work before running the operational qualification software.

[0005] In some cases, multiple detectors are attached to one analytical device to configure multiple analytical systems. When the above-mentioned software or the like is used to perform Operational Qualification of such multiple analytical systems, an inspection worker must perform preparatory work before the Operational Qualification of each analytical system, making it difficult to automatically perform Operational Qualification of multiple analytical systems, for example, at night. This reduces the overall efficiency of the Operational Qualification of multiple analytical systems.

[0006] An object of the present invention is to provide a qualification evaluation apparatus and a qualification evaluation method that are capable of efficiently performing operational qualification evaluation of a plurality of analytical systems. [Means for solving the problem]

[0007] A qualification evaluation device according to one embodiment is a qualification evaluation device that performs operational qualification of an analytical device, and includes a reception unit configured to accept a selection of multiple system tests for performing operational qualification of multiple analytical systems constituted by the analytical device, an acquisition unit that acquires the evaluation contents from the multiple system tests accepted by the reception unit as multiple evaluation information, a presentation unit that presents the contents of pre-preparation to be performed before executing the multiple system tests based on the multiple evaluation information acquired, an execution control unit that controls the analytical device so that the multiple system tests are executed after completion of pre-preparation for the multiple system tests, and an output unit that outputs results of the multiple system tests by the execution control unit.

[0008] A qualification method according to another aspect is a qualification method for performing operational qualification of an analytical apparatus, and includes the steps of accepting a selection of multiple system tests for performing operational qualification of multiple analytical systems constituted by the analytical apparatus, acquiring evaluation contents from the accepted multiple system tests as multiple evaluation information, presenting contents of pre-preparation to be performed before executing the multiple system tests based on the acquired multiple evaluation information, controlling the analytical apparatus so that the multiple system tests are executed after completion of pre-preparation for the multiple system tests, and outputting results of the executed multiple system tests. Effect of the Invention

[0009] The present invention allows for operational qualification of multiple analytical systems. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating a configuration of an analysis device according to an embodiment. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a diagram showing the configuration of the analysis control device shown in FIG. [Diagram 3] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a plurality of operation screens displayed on a display unit by the qualification evaluation device. FIG. [Figure 4] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a plurality of operation screens displayed on a display unit by the qualification evaluation device. FIG. [Diagram 5] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a plurality of operation screens displayed on a display unit by the qualification evaluation device. FIG. [Figure 6] 13 is a diagram showing an example of a plurality of operation screens displayed on a display unit by the qualification evaluation device. FIG. [Figure 7] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing a functional configuration of the qualification evaluation device. [Figure 8] 3 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation of the qualification evaluation device of FIG. 2. [Figure 9] 3 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation of the qualification evaluation device of FIG. 2. [Figure 10] 3 is a flowchart showing an example of the operation of the qualification evaluation device of FIG. 2. [Figure 11] 11 is a flowchart illustrating parallel execution of first and second system tests. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0011] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS A qualification evaluation device according to an embodiment of the present invention will be described in detail below with reference to the drawings.

[0012] (1) Configuration of the analysis device and analysis control device 1 is a diagram showing the configuration of an analytical device according to one embodiment. In this embodiment, the analytical device 20 is a liquid chromatograph. The analytical device 20 includes pumps PM1 and PM2, a sample introduction section SI, a switching valve SW1, a separation column CL, a first resistance tube R1, a second resistance tube R2, a column oven CO, a switching valve SW2, a detector DA, and a detector DB.

[0013] The pumps PM1 and PM2 introduce the mobile phase contained in the mobile phase containers VE1 and VE2 to the sample introduction unit SI. The sample introduction unit SI introduces a sample into the introduced mobile phase. The sample introduction unit SI is, for example, an autosampler. In this embodiment, the switching valve SW1 has one liquid inlet and three liquid outlets. The sample introduction unit SI supplies the mobile phase and the sample to the liquid inlet of the switching valve SW1.

[0014] The separation column CL separates the sample in the mobile phase into components. The first and second resistance tubes R1, R2 are used during operational qualification of the detector DA. In this example, the first and second resistance tubes R1, R2 are configured to be mountable between the switching valves SW1 and SW2 in parallel with the separation column CL. An inspection worker mounts the first and second resistance tubes R1, R2 to the switching valves SW1 and SW2 during operational qualification of the detector DA. The separation column CL, the first resistance tube R1, and the second resistance tube R2 are housed in the column oven CO.

[0015] The three liquid outlets of the switching valve SW1 are connected to three pipes that respectively guide liquid to the separation column CL, the first resistance tube R1, and the second resistance tube R2. The switching valve SW1 is configured to be switchable so as to selectively introduce the mobile phase and sample supplied from the sample introduction section SI into any one of the three pipes.

[0016] In this embodiment, the switching valve SW 2 has three liquid inlets and two liquid outlets. The three liquid inlets of the switching valve SW2 are connected to three pipes that guide liquids derived from the separation column CL, the first resistance tube R1, and the second resistance tube R2, respectively. The two liquid outlets of the switching valve SW2 are connected to two pipes that guide liquids to the detectors DA and DB, respectively. The switching valve SW2 is configured to be switchable so as to selectively introduce the mobile phase and sample guided by the separation column CL, the first resistance tube R1, or the second resistance tube R2 into the detector DA or the detector DB.

[0017] The detectors DA and DB detect components of the sample introduced through the switching valve SW2. In the analysis device 20 of Fig. 1, a first analysis system using the detector DA and a second analysis system using the detector DB are configured. The detectors DA and DB are, for example, an ultraviolet-visible light detector, a photodiode array detector, a fluorescence detector, an electrical conductivity detector, a differential refractive index detector, an evaporative light scattering detector, or the like. In this embodiment, the detector DA is a photodiode array detector, and the detector DB is a fluorescence detector.

[0018] Here, the tests for performing operational qualification evaluation of the first and second analytical systems are called system tests. In this embodiment, the system tests include one or more tests such as an absorbance linearity test, a gradient concentration test, an injection linearity test, a carry-over test, and a reproducibility test. The absorbance linearity test is a test for confirming that the concentration of the sample introduced into the detectors DA and DB is proportional to the signal intensity. The gradient concentration test is a test for confirming the optimum composition of the eluent. The injection linearity test is a test for confirming that the amount of the sample introduced from the sample introduction section SI is proportional to the signal intensity at the detectors DA and DB. The carry-over test is a test for detecting the carry-over value. The reproducibility test is a test for confirming the reproducibility of the analysis result of the sample.

[0019] In this embodiment, one of the system tests that performs operational qualification of a first analytical system including a detector DA is called a first system test, and one of the system tests that performs operational qualification of a second analytical system including a detector DB is called a second system test.

[0020] The analysis control device 10 controls the operations of the pumps PM1 and PM2, the sample introduction unit SI, the switching valve SW1, the column oven CO, the switching valve SW2, the detector DA, and the detector DB. The analysis control device 10 includes a qualification evaluation device 100 (described later) for automatically performing operational qualification evaluation.

[0021] Fig. 2 is a diagram showing the configuration of the analysis control device 10 in Fig. 1. The analysis control device 10 is composed of a CPU (Central Processing Unit) 11, a RAM (Random Access Memory) 12, a ROM (Read Only Memory) 13, a storage unit 14, an operation unit 15, a display unit 16, and an input / output I / F (interface) 17. The CPU 11, RAM 12, ROM 13, storage unit 14, operation unit 15, display unit 16, and input / output I / F 17 are connected to a bus 18. The CPU 11, RAM 12, and ROM 13 constitute a qualification evaluation device 100.

[0022] The RAM 12 is used as a working area for the CPU 11. The ROM 13 stores a system program. The storage unit 14 includes a storage medium such as a hard disk or a semiconductor memory. The storage unit 14 stores an analysis control program. The CPU 11 executes the analysis control program stored in the storage unit 14 or the like on the RAM 12, thereby controlling the analysis device 20. The storage unit 14 also stores a qualification evaluation program. The qualification evaluation program may be stored in a storage medium different from the storage unit 14. The CPU 11 executes the qualification evaluation program stored in the storage unit 14 or the like on the RAM 12. As a result, the analysis control device 10 performs operational qualification of the analysis device 20 in FIG. 1 through the input / output I / F 17.

[0023] The operation unit 15 is an input device such as a keyboard, a mouse, or a touch panel. The display unit 16 is a display device such as a liquid crystal display device. An inspection operator can use the operation unit 15 to give various instructions to the qualification evaluation device 100. The display unit 16 displays various screens and the like for operational qualification by the qualification evaluation device 100. The input / output I / F 17 outputs various commands from the CPU 11 or the operation unit 15 to the analytical device 20, and inputs various data from the analytical device 20 to the CPU 11.

[0024] (2) Preparation for system testing 3 to 6 are diagrams showing examples of a plurality of operation screens displayed on the display unit 16 by the qualification evaluation device 100. Fig. 3 shows a successive execution selection screen 120. As shown in Fig. 3, the successive execution selection screen 120 includes selection buttons 121 and 122, a plurality of selection fields 123, selection buttons 124 and 125, parallel execution availability display sections 127 and 128, and a completion button 129.

[0025] Selection buttons 121 and 122 are operated to select whether or not to execute multiple system tests consecutively. When the inspection operator designates selection button 121, multiple system tests are executed consecutively. When the inspection operator designates selection button 122, a single system test is executed. In this example, selection button 121 is selected.

[0026] The inspection operator can select a system test to be executed using one or more selection fields 123. In this example, a first system test and a second system test are selected using two selection fields 123. When selecting a test to be executed, for example, each selection field 123 displays selectable system tests using a pull-down menu.

[0027] The selection buttons 124, 125 are selectable only when the selection button 121 is selected. The selection buttons 124, 125 are operated to select parallel execution or serial execution of multiple system tests. Parallel execution means that multiple system tests are executed in parallel in time. Serial execution means that multiple system tests are executed in serial in time. The parallel execution possible / not possible display units 127, 128 display whether parallel execution is possible or not. When the parallel execution possible / not possible display unit 127 is lit, parallel execution is possible. When the parallel execution possible / not possible display unit 128 is lit, parallel execution is not possible. In this example, it is displayed that the first system test and the second system test cannot be executed in parallel. In this case, the inspection operator can select only the selection button 125.

[0028] When the parallel execution possibility display unit 127 is lit, Inspection The operator can select either of the selection buttons 124 and 125. Based on a plurality of system tests selected in the selection field 123, one of the selection buttons 124 and 125 may be automatically selected.

[0029] When the selection button 125 is selected, the switching valve SW2 is switched in sequence so that the mobile phase and the sample are guided to either the detector DA or the detector DB in the analysis device 20 of Fig. 1. This causes the first and second system tests to be performed in sequence. On the other hand, when the selection button 124 is selected, the switching valve SW2 is switched so that the mobile phase and the sample are simultaneously guided to the detector DA and the detector DB in the analysis device 20 of Fig. 1. In this state, the first and second system tests are performed simultaneously.

[0030] When the inspection operator operates the completion button 129, an evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 shown in Fig. 4 is displayed on the display unit 16. As shown in Fig. 4, the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 includes a first confirmation window 131, a second confirmation window 132, a previous button 133, and a next button 134. The first and second confirmation windows 131, 132 display the evaluation conditions for the first and second system tests, respectively.

[0031] In the evaluation conditions for the first system test in this example, "detector DA" is displayed as the detector. "High pressure gradient" is displayed as the liquid delivery mode for pumps PM1 and PM2. "Standard cell" is displayed as the flow cell in the detector. In this example, since a mixer is not used in the analyzer 20, the mixer capacity of the sample introduction section SI is displayed as "none." "Caffeine" is displayed as the standard solution (standard sample) for the absorbance linearity test, gradient concentration test, and injection linearity test.

[0032] In the evaluation conditions for the second system test in this example, "Detector DB" is displayed as the detector. "High Pressure Gradient" is displayed as the liquid delivery mode for pumps PM1 and PM2. "Standard Cell" is displayed as the flow cell in the detector. The mixer capacity of the sample introduction section SI is displayed as "None." "Caffeine" is displayed as the standard solution for the absorbance linearity test and injection linearity test.

[0033] The inspection operator checks the evaluation conditions of the analysis device 20 in Fig. 1 according to the display of the first and second confirmation windows 131, 132. After checking the evaluation conditions, the inspection operator operates the next button 134. When the operator wishes to change the item selected on the successive execution selection screen 120 in Fig. 3, he or she operates the previous button 133. When the previous button 133 is operated, the successive execution selection screen 120 in Fig. 3 is displayed again on the display unit 16.

[0034] When the inspection operator operates the next button 134, an execution file selection screen 140 shown in Fig. 5 is displayed on the display unit 16. As shown in Fig. 5, the execution file selection screen 140 includes a first file selection window 141, a second file selection window 142, a previous button 143, and a next button 144.

[0035] Here, the executable file will be described. In this example, the executable file is a batch file. The batch file is a text file including a plurality of instructions. In this embodiment, each executable file is used to execute a system test. For example, executable files B1 to B3 are prepared to execute an absorbance linearity test. Also, executable file B4 is prepared to execute a reproducibility test. Furthermore, executable file B5 is prepared to execute an injection linearity test.

[0036] The first and second file selection windows 141 and 142 display a plurality of selection fields 141a and 142a for selecting one or a plurality of executable files. When the first and second system tests are selected as the tests to be executed in FIG. 3, executable files to be used in executing the first and second system tests are automatically selected. The inspection operator can change the executable files to be used in the first and second system tests by operating the selection fields 142a and 142b corresponding to the desired executable files in the first and second file selection windows 141 and 142.

[0037] In the first system test of this example, the executables B1 and B2 for the absorbance linearity test, the executable B4 for the repeatability test, and the executable B5 for the injection linearity test are selected. In the second system test of this example, the executable B3 for the absorbance linearity test and the executable B5 for the injection linearity test are selected.

[0038] When confirmation or modification of the executable files in the first and second file selection windows 141, 142 is completed, the inspection operator operates the next button 144. When the back button 143 is operated on the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 in Fig. 4, the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 in Fig. 4 is displayed again on the display unit 16.

[0039] When the inspection operator operates the "Next" button 144, a pre-preparation procedure screen 150 shown in Fig. 6 is displayed on the display unit 16. As shown in Fig. 6, the pre-preparation procedure screen 150 includes a first preparation procedure window 151, a second preparation procedure window 152, a "Go Back" button 153, and an "Execute" button 154.

[0040] The first and second preparation procedure windows 151, 152 display preparation procedures that an inspection operator should perform before the first and second system tests. The preparation procedures include preparation of a mobile phase, preparation of a resistance tube, preparation of a flow path, preparation of a sample, etc. The inspection operator performs preparations for the first and second system tests of the analyzer 20 in FIG. 1 according to the preparation procedures displayed in the first and second preparation procedure windows 151, 152.

[0041] The first preparation procedure window 151 of this example displays, as preparation procedures for the first system test, the following: preparing mobile phases M1, M2 and rinse solution RI, connecting the resistance tubes R1, R2 in FIG. 1, setting the mobile phases M1, M2 and rinse solution RI, purging the liquid remaining in the flow path including the detector DA with the rinse solution and replacing the rinse solution with the mobile phase, and preparing a sample. As for sample preparation, it displays that a plurality of vials V1, V2, and V3 containing linearity standard solutions of different concentrations are prepared in the sample introduction section SI.

[0042] In the second preparation procedure window 152 of this example, the second system test preparation procedure is , Inspection It is shown that the flow path including the extractor DB is purged with a rinse solution to replace the rinse solution with the mobile phase, and that a sample is prepared. As for sample preparation, it is shown that a number of vials V11, V12, and V13 containing linearity standard solutions of different concentrations are prepared in the sample introduction section SI.

[0043] The inspection operator performs advance preparations for the first and second system tests according to the preparation procedures displayed in the first and second preparation procedure windows 151, 152. When the advance preparations for the first and second system tests are completed, the inspection operator operates the execute button 154. This starts the continuous testing of the first and second system tests. Note that when the back button 153 is operated on the advance preparation procedure screen 150 in FIG. 6, the execution file selection screen 140 in FIG. 5 is displayed again on the display unit 16.

[0044] (3) Functional Configuration of the Qualification Evaluation Apparatus 100 7 is a block diagram showing a functional configuration of the qualification evaluation device 100. The qualification evaluation device 100 includes a display control unit 101, a system test selection unit 102, a report file acquisition unit 103, a meta information extraction unit 104, an executable file acquisition unit 105, a test execution control unit 106, a pass / fail determination unit 107, a report file creation unit 108, and a deviation report file creation unit 109. The components (101 to 109) of the qualification evaluation device 100 are realized by the CPU 11 in FIG. 2 executing a qualification evaluation program stored in the storage unit 14. Note that some or all of the components (101 to 109) of the qualification evaluation device 100 may be realized by hardware such as electronic circuits.

[0045] The display control unit 101 causes the display unit 16 to display the operation screens of Figs. 3 to 6. The display control unit 101 also determines whether or not a selection button that should be selected on the operation screens of Figs. 3 to 6 has been selected and whether or not a button that should be operated has been operated. The system test selection unit 102 selects one or more system tests from a plurality of system tests prepared in advance based on the operation of the operation unit 15 by the inspection operator. In the example of Fig. 3, the system test selection unit 102 selects the first and second system tests selected in the selection field 123 of the successive execution selection screen 120 of Fig. 3.

[0046] The memory unit 14 stores a plurality of report files corresponding to a plurality of system tests, as well as a plurality of executable files. The report file acquisition unit 103 acquires from the memory unit 14 one or more report files corresponding to one or more system tests selected by the system test selection unit 102. Each report file includes an unrecorded report area and meta information indicating the result of the corresponding system test. The meta information includes evaluation information such as the evaluation content, the executable file to be used, and the preparation procedure in the corresponding system test. The evaluation content includes evaluation items, evaluation procedures, evaluation condition values, and reference values. In the example of FIG. 3, the report file acquisition unit 103 acquires report files corresponding to the first and second system tests.

[0047] The meta information extraction unit 104 extracts meta information included in one or more report files acquired by the report file acquisition unit 103. In the example of Fig. 3, meta information corresponding to the first and second system tests is extracted. The executable file acquisition unit 105 acquires executable files to be used in one or more system tests selected by the system test selection unit 102 from the storage unit 14 based on the meta information extracted by the meta information extraction unit 104. In the example of Fig. 5, the executable file acquisition unit 105 acquires executable files to be used in the first and second system tests selected on the executable file selection screen 140.

[0048] The test execution control unit 106 controls the analysis device 20 to execute one or more system tests selected by the system test selection unit 102, based on the one or more executable files acquired by the executable file acquisition unit 105 and the meta information extracted by the meta information extraction unit 104. The pass / fail determination unit 107 determines whether the results of the first and second system tests are pass or fail, based on a chromatogram generated by the output signals of the detectors DA and DB of the analysis device 20.

[0049] When the results of the first and second system tests are judged to be pass by the pass / fail judging unit 107, the report file creating unit 108 records the results in a blank report area of ​​the report file acquired by the report file acquiring unit 103. This creates a report file. When the results of the first and second system tests are judged to be fail by the pass / fail judging unit 107, the deviation report file creating unit 109 creates a deviation report file, which will be described later.

[0050] (4) Operation of the Qualification Evaluation Apparatus 100 8 to 10 are flowcharts showing an example of the operation of the qualification evaluation device 100 of FIG. 2. First, as shown in FIG. 8, the display control unit 101 causes the display unit 16 to display the successive execution selection screen 120 of FIG. 3 (step S1). The system test selection unit 102 selects one or more system tests based on the operation of the operation unit 15 by the user. Then, the system test selection unit 102 judges whether the selection on the successive execution selection screen 120 is completed (step S2). In this case, the system test selection unit 102 judges whether the selection is completed based on whether the completion button 129 of FIG. 3 is operated. If the selection on the successive execution selection screen 120 is not completed, the system test selection unit 102 repeats the judgment of step S1.

[0051] When the selection on the successive execution selection screen 120 is completed, the report file acquisition unit 103 acquires one or more report files corresponding to the one or more system tests selected by the system test selection unit 102 from the storage unit 14 (step S3). In the example of Fig. 3, the report file acquisition unit 103 acquires first and second report files corresponding to the first and second system tests, respectively. Note that, if the storage unit 14 stores one report file for the first and second system tests, the report file acquisition unit 103 may acquire that report file.

[0052] The meta information extraction unit 104 extracts meta information contained in one or more report files acquired by the report file acquisition unit 103 (step S4). In the example of Fig. 3, the meta information extraction unit 104 extracts first and second meta information contained in the first and second report files.

[0053] The display control unit 101 causes the display unit 16 to display the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 of Fig. 4 based on the meta information extracted by the meta information extraction unit 104 (step S5). In the example of Fig. 4, the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 includes first and second confirmation windows 131 and 132.

[0054] The display control unit 101 determines whether confirmation of the evaluation contents displayed on the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 has been completed (step S6). In this case, the display control unit 101 determines whether confirmation of the evaluation contents has been completed based on whether the next button 134 in Fig. 4 has been operated. If confirmation of the evaluation contents displayed on the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 has not been completed, the display control unit 101 repeats the determination of step S5.

[0055] When the confirmation of the evaluation contents displayed on the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 is completed, the display control unit 101 causes the display unit 16 to display the executable file selection screen 140 of FIG. 5 (step S7). In the example of FIG. 5, the executable file selection screen 140 includes first and second file selection windows 141, 142. The inspection operator confirms or changes the multiple executable files displayed on the executable file selection screen 140. The display control unit 101 judges whether or not the confirmation or change of the executable file selection screen 140 is completed (step S8). In this case, the display control unit 101 judges whether or not the confirmation or change of the executable file selection screen 140 is completed based on whether or not the next button 144 of FIG. 5 is operated. When the confirmation or change of the executable file selection screen 140 is not completed, the display control unit 101 repeats the judgment of step S7.

[0056] When the confirmation or change of the executable file selection screen 140 is completed, the executable file acquisition unit 105 acquires one or more executable files selected on the executable file selection screen 140 from the storage unit 14 (step S9).

[0057] Thereafter, the display control unit 101 displays the advance preparation procedure screen 150 of FIG. 6 on the display unit 16 (step S10). In the example of FIG. 6, the advance preparation procedure screen 150 includes first and second preparation procedure windows 151 and 152. The inspection operator performs advance preparation for one or more system tests according to the preparation procedure displayed on the advance preparation procedure screen 150. In the example of FIG. 6, the inspection operator performs advance preparation for the first system test according to the display contents of the first preparation procedure window 151, and performs advance preparation for the second system test according to the display contents of the second preparation procedure window 152. The display control unit 101 judges whether the advance preparation is completed based on the display contents of the advance preparation procedure screen 150 (step S11). In this case, the display control unit 101 judges whether the advance preparation is completed based on whether the execute button 154 of FIG. 6 is operated. If the advance preparation is not completed, the display control unit 101 repeats the judgment of step S10.

[0058] When preparation of the analysis device 20 is completed according to the advance preparation procedure displayed on the execution file selection screen 140, the test execution control unit 106, the pass / fail determination unit 107, the report file creation unit 108, and the deviation report file creation unit 109 control the analysis device 20 so that one or more system tests are executed (step S12). In the examples of Figs. 3 to 6, the first and second system tests are executed.

[0059] 9 and 10 show the operation of serial execution of the first and second system tests. In this example, the first system test includes both test A and test B or only test B. In test A, the second resistor tube R2 in FIG. 1 is used. In test B, the first resistor tube R1 in FIG. 1 is used. In the second system test, the first resistor tube R1 in FIG. 1 is used.

[0060] First, the test execution control unit 106 starts the first system test (step S21 in FIG. 9). At the start of the first system test, the test execution control unit 106 switches the switching valve SW2 so that the detector DA in FIG. 1 is connected to the first resistance tube R1.

[0061] The test execution control unit 106 judges whether or not the first system test includes test A (step S22). If the first system test does not include test A, the test execution control unit 106 proceeds to step S27 described below. If the first system test includes test A, the test execution control unit 106 switches the switching valves SW1 and SW2 so that the second resistance tube R2 is connected to the sample introduction unit SI and the detector DA (step S23). In this state, the test execution control unit 106 controls the analysis device 20 so that test A is executed (step S24). The pass / fail determination unit 107 judges whether or not the result of test A is pass (step S25).

[0062] If the result of test A is not a pass, the deviation report file creation unit 109 performs deviation processing of the first system test (step S31). The deviation processing of the system test includes creating a deviation report file indicating that the result of test A is a fail. The deviation report file creation unit 109 stores the deviation report file in the memory unit 14. The test execution control unit 106 determines whether or not the first system test can be re-executed (step S32). If the first system test can be re-executed, the test execution control unit 106 returns to step S21 after performing a return process. This causes test A to be executed again.

[0063] Here, an example of the recovery process will be described. For example, if a spike-like noise signal appears in the chromatogram generated by test A, the result of test A will be a failure. The spike-like noise signal is determined to be caused by air bubbles in the piping. Therefore, it is determined that the first system test can be re-executed. In this case, as a recovery process, the mobile phase is supplied into the piping with the supply pressure of pumps PM1 and PM2 increased. This removes the air bubbles in the piping. If it is determined in step S32 that the first system test cannot be re-executed, the process proceeds to step S41, which will be described later.

[0064] If the result of test A is pass in step S25, the test execution control unit 106 switches the switching valves SW1 and SW2 so that the second resistance tube R2 is connected to the sample introduction unit SI and the detector DA (step S26). In this state, the test execution control unit 106 controls the analysis device 20 so that test B is executed (step S27). The pass / fail determination unit 107 determines whether the result of test B is pass or not (step S28). If the result of test B is not pass, the test execution control unit 106 proceeds to step S31. In this case, a deviation report file indicating that the result of test B is fail is created, and the deviation report file is stored in the memory unit 14.

[0065] If the result of test B is a pass, the report file creation unit 108 records the result of the first system test in the report file (step S29). In this case, it is recorded in the report file that the result of the first system test is a pass.

[0066] The test execution control unit 106 starts the second system test (step S41 in FIG. 10). In this case, the first resistance tube R1 is connected to the sample introduction unit SI by step S26. At the start of the second system test, the test execution control unit 106 switches the switching valve SW2 so that the detector DB is connected to the first resistance tube R1. In this state, the test execution control unit 106 controls the analysis device 20 so that the second system test is executed.

[0067] The pass / fail determination unit 107 determines whether the result of the second system test is pass or not (step S42). If the result of the second system test is not pass, the deviation report file creation unit 109 performs deviation processing of the second system test (step S51). The deviation processing of the second system test includes creating a deviation report file indicating that the result of the second system test is fail. The deviation report file creation unit 109 stores the deviation report file in the memory unit 14. The test execution control unit 106 determines whether the second system test can be re-executed (step S52). If the second system test can be re-executed, the test execution control unit 106 returns to step S41 after performing the above-mentioned return processing.

[0068] If the result of the second system test is a pass, the report file creation unit 108 records the result of the second system test in the report file (step S43). In this case, the result of the second system test is recorded as a pass in the report file. The report file creation unit 108 stores the report file in the storage unit 14.

[0069] If re-execution of the second system test is not possible in step S52, the test execution control unit 106 ends the second system test.

[0070] (5) Effects of the embodiment According to the qualification evaluation device of the above embodiment, the display unit 16 displays an evaluation condition confirmation screen 130 (FIG. 4), an execution file selection screen 140 (FIG. 5), and a pre-preparation procedure screen 150 (FIG. 6) for a plurality of system tests. The inspection operator can perform pre-preparation for a plurality of system tests at once before consecutively executing the plurality of system tests according to the contents of the operation screens of FIGS. 4 to 6 displayed by the display unit 16. Therefore, the inspection operator does not need to perform pre-preparation for another system test after executing one system test. Therefore, for example, even when the inspection operator is absent, such as at night or on a holiday, the plurality of system tests can be executed. Thereby, the plurality of system tests can be executed continuously and automatically. As a result, it becomes possible to efficiently perform operational qualification evaluation of a plurality of analysis systems.

[0071] Furthermore, since the contents of advance preparations for multiple system tests (FIGS. 4 to 6) are displayed, the inspection worker can visually recognize the contents of the advance preparations. As a result, the burden on the inspection worker is reduced.

[0072] In addition, the separation column CL or resistance tubes R1 and R2 used for multiple system tests is examined The detector DA and the detector DB are automatically and selectively connected to the separation column CL or the resistor tubes R1 and R2. This eliminates the need for an inspection worker to perform the work of connecting either the separation column CL or the resistor tubes R1 and R2 for the other system test after the execution of one of the multiple system tests. Therefore, even when an inspection worker is not present, it is possible to automatically execute multiple system tests that require switching of the separation column CL or the resistor tubes R1 and R2.

[0073] Furthermore, even if one of the multiple system tests fails, the other system tests continue to be executed, so that the multiple system tests are executed more efficiently.

[0074] Furthermore, if one of the multiple system tests results in a failure, the failed system test is automatically executed again, eliminating the need for an inspection operator to execute the failed system test again. This allows the multiple system tests to be automatically executed so that the multiple system tests result in a pass without the need for an inspection operator. As a result, it becomes possible to more efficiently perform operational qualification of multiple analytical systems.

[0075] Furthermore, since the multiple system tests are controlled so that they can be executed in parallel or serially, it is possible to reduce the overall time required for the multiple system tests depending on the contents of the multiple system tests.

[0076] (6) Other embodiments (a) In the examples of Figs. 9 and 10, the first and second system tests are executed in series as a continuous execution of a plurality of system tests, but the first and second system tests may be executed in parallel as a continuous execution of a plurality of systems. Fig. 11 shows the first and second system tests. Te Test parallel 11 is a flowchart showing the execution of the parallel In execution, a first system test (step S61) and a second system test (step S62) are executed in parallel in time.

[0077] In this case, even if the result of one of the first and second system tests is not a pass, the other system test continues. Also, after all system tests are completed, a check is made for whether the system test has failed. In this example, the overall execution time of multiple system tests is reduced.

[0078] (b) In the above embodiment, multiple report files and multiple executable files are stored in storage unit 14, but multiple report files and multiple executable files may be stored in an external server or a server on the Internet, etc. In this case, report file acquisition unit 103 acquires report files from the external server or a server on the Internet, etc. Executable file acquisition unit 105 acquires executable files from the external server or a server on the Internet, etc.

[0079] (c) In the above embodiment, analytical device 20 is a liquid chromatograph, but analytical device 20 may be another type of chromatograph, such as a supercritical fluid chromatograph or an ion chromatograph, or may be another type of analytical device, such as a mass spectrometer.

[0080] (7) Correspondence between each component of the claims and each part of the embodiment An example of the correspondence between each component of the claims and each element of the embodiment will be described below. In the above embodiment, the system test selection unit 102 is an example of a reception unit, the report file acquisition unit 103 is an example of an acquisition unit, the display unit 16 is an example of a presentation unit, and the test execution control unit 106 is an example of an execution control unit. In addition, the report file creation unit 108 and the deviation report file creation unit 109 are examples of an output unit, and the evaluation condition confirmation screen 130, the execution file selection screen 140, and the advance preparation procedure screen 150 are examples of images showing the contents of advance preparation.

[0081] (8) Description It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that the exemplary embodiments described above are examples of the following aspects.

[0082] (1) A qualification evaluation device according to one aspect comprises: A qualification evaluation apparatus for performing operational qualification of an analytical apparatus, a reception unit configured to be capable of receiving a selection of a plurality of system tests for performing operational qualification of a plurality of analytical systems constituted by analytical devices; an acquisition unit that acquires evaluation contents based on the plurality of system tests received by the reception unit as a plurality of pieces of evaluation information; a presentation unit that presents details of advance preparations to be made before execution of the plurality of system tests based on the plurality of acquired evaluation information; an execution control unit that controls the analysis device so that the multiple system tests are executed after the completion of advance preparations for the multiple system tests; The system may further include an output section that outputs the results of the multiple system tests performed by the execution control section.

[0083] According to a qualification evaluation device according to one aspect, the content of advance preparation based on the plurality of evaluation information acquired by the acquisition unit is presented by the presentation unit. The inspection operator can perform advance preparation for the plurality of system tests at once before the execution of the plurality of system tests according to the content of advance preparation presented by the presentation unit. Therefore, the inspection operator does not need to perform advance preparation for other system tests after the execution of each system test. This makes it possible to execute the plurality of system tests continuously and automatically. As a result, it becomes possible to efficiently perform operational qualification of the plurality of analytical systems.

[0084] (Paragraph 2) In the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 1, the contents of the advance preparation may include at least one of confirmation of evaluation conditions for multiple system tests, preparatory work to be performed in the analytical device in response to the multiple system tests, and confirmation or modification of one or more executable files used to execute the multiple system tests.

[0085] According to the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 2, the work to be performed by an inspection operator for a plurality of system tests can be performed at once. After the execution of each system test, the inspection operator does not need to perform work for other system tests.

[0086] (3) In the qualification evaluation device according to the above (2), The presentation unit may present an image showing the contents of advance preparations for the multiple system tests.

[0087] According to the qualification evaluation device described in the third aspect, an inspection operator can visually recognize the contents of advance preparations for a plurality of system tests. Therefore, the burden on the inspection operator is reduced.

[0088] (4) In the qualification evaluation device according to the second or third aspect, The analytical device includes a separation column and a plurality of detectors; each of the plurality of analytical systems includes any of a plurality of detectors; The preparation operation includes preparing one or more resistance tubes and enabling the separation column and each resistance tube to be selectively connected to one of a plurality of detectors; The execution control unit may control the analysis device so that either the separation column or each resistance tube is selectively connected to any one of a plurality of detectors depending on the content of each system test.

[0089] According to the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 4, when multiple system tests are performed, the presentation unit automatically connects either the separation column or each resistance tube to the detector. This eliminates the need for the inspection worker to connect either the separation column or each resistance tube for another system test after each system test is performed. This reduces the burden on the inspection worker.

[0090] (Item 5) In the qualification evaluation device according to any one of Items 1 to 4, the execution control unit may control the analysis device so that a plurality of system tests are executed in parallel or serially in time.

[0091] According to the qualification evaluation device described in the fifth aspect, it is possible to reduce the overall time required for a plurality of system tests depending on the contents of the plurality of system tests.

[0092] (Item 6) In the qualification evaluation device according to item 5, the execution control unit may control the analytical device so that other system tests are executed regardless of whether a result of at least one system test is pass or fail.

[0093] According to the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 6, even if at least one system test results in a failure, other system tests continue to be performed, thereby making it possible to execute multiple system tests more efficiently.

[0094] (7) In the qualification evaluation device according to the 5th or 6th aspect, The execution control unit may control the analysis device to execute the at least one system test again if the result of the at least one system test is not pass.

[0095] According to the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 7, when at least one system test results in a fail, the failed system test is automatically executed again, eliminating the need for an inspection operator to execute the failed system test again. This allows multiple system tests to be automatically executed so that the multiple system tests result in a pass, without the need for an inspection operator to do anything. As a result, it becomes possible to more efficiently perform operational qualification of multiple analytical systems.

[0096] (Item 8) In the qualification evaluation device according to any one of items 1 to 7, The execution control unit may control the analysis device so that, after the advance preparation is completed, a plurality of system tests are executed in series or in parallel in time.

[0097] According to the qualification evaluation device described in paragraph 8, it is possible to execute a plurality of system tests in series or in parallel in time according to the contents of the plurality of system tests. As a result, it is possible to perform operational qualification evaluation of a plurality of analytical systems more efficiently. (Item 9) Another aspect of the eligibility assessment method is: A qualification method for performing operational qualification of an analytical device, comprising: receiving a selection of a plurality of system tests for operational qualification of a plurality of analytical systems constituted by the analytical device; acquiring evaluation contents based on the received system tests as a plurality of pieces of evaluation information; presenting content of advance preparations to be made before execution of the plurality of system tests based on the plurality of pieces of acquired evaluation information; controlling the analytical device to execute the multiple system tests after completing the pre-preparation for the multiple system tests; and outputting results of the plurality of system tests that have been performed.

[0098] According to the qualification method described in paragraph 9, the content of advance preparation based on the multiple evaluation information acquired by the acquisition unit is presented by the presentation unit. The inspection operator can perform advance preparation for multiple system tests at once before executing the multiple system tests according to the content of advance preparation presented by the presentation unit. Therefore, the inspection operator does not need to perform advance preparation for other system tests after executing each system test. This makes it possible to execute multiple system tests continuously and automatically. As a result, it becomes possible to efficiently perform operational qualification of multiple analytical systems. [Explanation of symbols]

[0099] 10...analysis control device, 11...CPU, 12...RAM, 13...ROM, 14...storage unit, 15...operation unit, 16...display unit, 17...input / output I / F, 18...bus, 20...analysis device, 100...qualification evaluation device, 101...display control unit, 102...system test selection unit, 103...report file acquisition unit, 104...meta information extraction unit, 105...execution file acquisition unit, 106...test execution control unit, 107...pass / fail judgment unit, 108...report file creation unit, 109...deviation report file creation unit, 130...evaluation condition confirmation screen, 140...execution file selection screen, 150...preparation procedure screen, CL...separation column, CO...column oven, DA, DB...detector, PM1, PM2...pump, R1...first resistance tube, R2...second resistance tube, SI...sample introduction unit, SW1, SW2...switching valve

Claims

1. A qualification evaluation apparatus for performing operational qualification of an analytical apparatus, a reception unit configured to be capable of receiving selection of a first system test and a second system test for each of the first and second analytical systems configured with the analytical device, for performing operational qualification of the first and second analytical systems; an acquisition unit that acquires the evaluation contents based on the first and second system tests received by the reception unit as a plurality of pieces of evaluation information; a presentation unit that presents details of advance preparations for executing both the first and second system tests based on the acquired plurality of pieces of evaluation information; an execution control unit that controls the analysis device so that the first and second system tests are executed in this order after the advance preparations for the first and second system tests are completed; and an output unit that outputs results of the first and second system tests performed by the execution control unit.

2. The qualification evaluation device of claim 1, wherein the contents of the advance preparation include at least one of confirmation of evaluation conditions for the first and second system tests, preparatory work to be performed in the analytical device in response to the first and second system tests, and confirmation or modification of one or more executable files used to execute the first and second system tests.

3. The qualification evaluation device according to claim 2 , wherein the presentation unit presents an image showing the contents of the advance preparations for the first and second system tests.

4. The analytical device includes a separation column and a plurality of detectors; each of the first and second analysis systems includes any of the plurality of detectors; The preparation operation includes preparing one or more resistance tubes and making the separation column and each resistance tube selectively connectable to any one of the plurality of detectors; The qualification evaluation device according to claim 2 or 3, wherein the executive control unit controls the analytical device so that either the separation column or each resistance tube is selectively connected to either of the plurality of detectors depending on the content of each system test.

5. The qualification evaluation device according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein the execution control unit controls the analysis device so that the first and second system tests are executed in parallel or serially in time.

6. The qualification evaluation device according to claim 5 , wherein the execution control unit controls the analysis device so that other system tests are executed regardless of whether a result of at least one system test is a pass or a fail.

7. 7. The qualification evaluation device according to claim 5, wherein the execution control unit controls the analysis device so that, if a result of at least one system test is not pass, the at least one system test is executed again.

8. A qualification evaluation device described in any one of claims 1 to 7, wherein the execution control unit controls the analytical device so that the first and second system tests are executed in series or in parallel in time after the preliminary preparation is completed.

9. A qualification method for performing operational qualification of an analytical device, comprising: receiving selections of first and second system tests for each of the first and second analytical systems configured with the analytical device for operational qualification of the first and second analytical systems; acquiring evaluation contents based on the received first and second system tests as a plurality of pieces of evaluation information; presenting details of advance preparations for executing both the first and second system tests based on the acquired evaluation information; controlling the analysis device such that the first and second system tests are executed in that order after the pre-preparation for the first and second system tests is completed; and outputting results of the performed first and second system tests.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Validity confirming method for analyzer, analyzer with validity confirming function, and recording medium recording validity confirming program of analyzer

    JP2000275253A

  • Validation apparatus

    JP2002340907A

  • Device validation system

    JP2013015399A

  • Analysis device validation system, and program therefor

    JP2014029282A

  • Analysis system

    JP2016061607A