Method for evaluating oxidation risk of separation membrane, oxidation risk evaluation program, recording medium, and evaluation device
By assessing the oxidation potential of membrane deposits using sulfite or bisulfite solutions, the method addresses the challenge of evaluating oxidation risk in separation membranes, facilitating quick and economical risk assessment and maintenance in water treatment plants.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023574231
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-11-25
- Filing Date
- 2023-11-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-11-22
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods struggle to accurately evaluate the oxidation risk of separation membranes in water treatment plants, particularly when oxidation reaction promoters are present in trace amounts, due to the complexity and expense of existing detection techniques.
The method involves collecting deposits from the surface of separation membranes and contacting them with a sulfite or bisulfite solution to assess the oxidation potential based on generated oxidizing substances, using a catalytic reaction to evaluate indices such as maximum and rate of change in oxidizing power index values.
This approach allows for rapid and cost-effective evaluation of oxidation risk, enabling timely identification and mitigation of membrane deterioration, thereby improving the operational stability of water treatment plants.
Smart Images

Figure 0007593509000001 
Figure 0007593509000002 
Figure 0007593509000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for evaluating the risk of oxidation of a separation membrane, a program for evaluating the risk of oxidation, a recording medium, and an evaluation device. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, water treatment technologies using various separation membranes such as gas separation membranes, reverse osmosis membranes, nanofiltration membranes, ultrafiltration membranes, and microfiltration membranes have attracted attention as highly accurate and energy-saving treatment processes, and their application to various water treatments is being promoted. For example, in the reverse osmosis separation method using a reverse osmosis membrane, a solution containing solutes such as salt is passed through the reverse osmosis membrane at a pressure equal to or higher than the osmotic pressure of the solution, thereby making it possible to obtain a liquid with a reduced concentration of solutes such as salt. This method is widely used in the desalination of seawater and brackish water, the production of ultrapure water, the concentration and recovery of valuable materials, and is the core of membrane separation technology for water treatment.
[0003] The main problems when using reverse osmosis membranes for the above-mentioned purposes include surface contamination of the semipermeable membrane, called fouling, and chemical deterioration of the semipermeable membrane. One method for preventing the former is to add an oxidizing substance such as sodium hypochlorite to sterilize microorganisms. However, the oxidizing substance contained in such pretreatment is one of the causes of oxidative deterioration. Methods for detecting oxidizing substances include oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) measurement, the N,N-diethylparaphenylenediamine (DPD) method, which is a color reaction, and the Fujiwara Test described in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1. On the other hand, substances that are not oxidizing substances but play an important role in the oxidation reaction process include oxidation reaction promoters, represented by certain transition metals. The amount of such substances is difficult to evaluate using the above-mentioned oxidizing substance detection method, and another method is to examine the elemental composition of the feed water contents using high-frequency inductively coupled plasma (ICP) emission spectrometry. However, such spectroscopic analysis methods require advanced and expensive equipment, require specialized analysis institutions, and require a long time and high cost to obtain results. In addition, when the amount of the oxidation reaction promoting substance contained in the feed water is equal to or less than the detection limit of the spectroscopic analysis method, it is difficult to evaluate the oxidation risk. On the other hand, Patent Document 2 discloses a method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane in a water treatment plant by passing the membrane-filtered feed water through an oxidizing substance sensitive material. However, there is a problem that when the oxidation reaction promoting substance contained in the feed water is in a trace amount, it is difficult to detect it with this method. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2020-6322 [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2016-190212 [Patent Document 3] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2021-63335 [Non-patent literature]
[0005] [Non-Patent Document 1] Journal of Membrane Science, 2010, Vol.347, P.159-164. Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] The present invention makes it possible to easily and quickly evaluate the risk of oxidation, which was difficult to evaluate using conventional methods, by evaluating the oxidation potential using the deposits on the surface of the separation membrane. In addition, since the method can be easily and quickly performed and only a small amount of deposits is required, it is useful for avoiding risks and quickly resolving operational problems in water treatment plants. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] The present invention provides an oxidation risk assessment method, which comprises recovering deposits on the surface of a separation membrane, contacting the deposits with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, and evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits based on the oxidizing substances generated.
[0008] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention has the following features.
[0009] (1) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, comprising contacting a deposit recovered from a used separation membrane with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, and evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit based on the oxidizing substances generated.
[0010] (2) The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to (1), characterized in that a deposit extract is used instead of the deposit.
[0011] (3) The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to (1) or (2), wherein the separation membrane is any one of the following: A: Separation membrane taken from a semipermeable membrane element that separates feed water into permeate and concentrated water at a water treatment plant. B: Separation membrane installed inside a water-permeable member installed in the supply water line of a water treatment plant C: A semipermeable membrane element is used in a water treatment plant to separate the feed water into permeate and concentrated water. The separation membrane is installed inside the water-permeable member installed in the concentrated water line.
[0012] (4) The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to any one of (1) to (3), wherein the method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane is a method for evaluating the risk of oxidation due to a catalytic reaction, and the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit is a method for measuring the change over time in an oxidation power index value of a solution in contact with the deposit, and is characterized in that any of the following is evaluated: A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time
[0013] (5) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to any one of (1) to (4), characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits is a method for changing the sulfite or bisulfite concentration of a solution in contact with the deposits by adding sulfite or bisulfite to the solution in contact with the deposits, and measuring the oxidizing power index value when the deposits are contacted.
[0014] (6) A method for evaluating the oxidation potential of a separation membrane according to any one of (1) to (5), characterized in that the solution with which the deposits are contacted is a sulfite or bisulfite solution of two or more different concentrations, and the oxidation power index value when the deposits are contacted is measured.
[0015] (7) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to (5) or (6), characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit according to (5) or (6) evaluates at least one of the following: A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
[0016] (8) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to any one of (5) to (7), characterized in that the oxidation index value is measured when sulfite or bisulfite is further added after the oxidation index value has reached a maximum.
[0017] (9) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to any one of (5) to (7), characterized in that after the oxidation index value reaches a maximum, a different solution with a higher concentration is used and the oxidation index value is measured when the adhesion material is brought into contact with the solution.
[0018] (10) A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to (7) or (8), characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit according to (7) or (8) is a method for evaluating at least one of the following: A: The sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is lower than before contact with the deposit B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
[0019] (11) A method for evaluating the risk of oxidation of a separation membrane according to any one of (1) to (10), characterized in that an adhesion is brought into contact with a solution containing the sulfite or bisulfite and having a hydrogen ion concentration exponent (pH) of 9.0 or more.
[0020] (12) An oxidation risk assessment program for a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, which causes a computer to function as a data recording means for recording input data in the computer and as a means for evaluating the oxidation potential of deposits based on the recorded data in order to assess the oxidation risk, and which utilizes the oxidation risk assessment method described in (1), wherein the input data are the conditions and the oxidizing power index value when the deposits recovered from the separation membrane used are contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite.
[0021] (13) The oxidation risk assessment program according to (12), wherein the oxidation risk assessment method for a water treatment plant is a method for assessing an oxidation risk due to a catalytic reaction, and the means for assessing the oxidation potential of the deposit is a means for assessing at least one of the following based on time-course data of an oxidation power index value: A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time
[0022] (14) The oxidation risk assessment program according to (12), characterized in that the means for evaluating the oxidation potential of the adhesion is a means for evaluating any one of the following based on the relationship of the oxidation power index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration. A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
[0023] (15) The oxidation risk assessment program according to (12), characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the adhesion is a method for evaluating any one of the following based on the relationship of the oxidation power index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration after the oxidation power index value has reached a maximum. A: The sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is lower than before contact with the deposit B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
[0024] (16) A recording medium storing the oxidation risk assessment program according to any one of (12) to (15).
[0025] (17) An oxidation risk evaluation device for a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, comprising: a computer for evaluating an oxidation risk; a data input means for inputting into the computer the conditions and an oxidation power index value when an adhesion material recovered from a used separation membrane is brought into contact with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite; a data recording means for recording the conditions and the oxidation power index value in the computer; and a means for evaluating an oxidation potential by any of the methods described in (1) to (11). Effect of the Invention
[0026] According to the present invention, it is possible to easily and quickly evaluate the risk of oxidation of a separation membrane, which was difficult to determine using conventional evaluation methods. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0027] [Figure 1] 1 shows an example of the flow of a water treatment plant. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram showing an example of a water-permeable member used in the present invention. [Diagram 3] An example of a separable water-passing container (unit water-passing member) constituting the water-passing member used in the present invention is shown below. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between the time elapsed since contact with adhesion and the oxidation power index value, and an example of a method for evaluating the maximum value of the oxidation power index value, in the first embodiment of evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention. [Diagram 5] FIG. 2 is a graph showing an example of a method for evaluating the relationship between the time elapsed since contact with adhesion and the oxidation power index value, and the rate of change of the oxidation power index value per time, in the first embodiment for evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention. [Figure 6] FIG. 11 is a graph showing the relationship between the sulfite or bisulfite concentration and the oxidizing power index value, and an example of a method for evaluating the maximum oxidizing power index value in the second or third embodiment of the present invention for evaluating the oxidation potential. [Figure 7]FIG. 11 is a graph showing an example of a method for evaluating the relationship between sulfite or bisulfite concentration and an oxidation power index value, and a rate of change in the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration, in the second or third form of evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention. [Figure 8] FIG. 11 is a graph showing the relationship between the sulfite or bisulfite concentration and the oxidation power index value in the fourth or fifth form of evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention, and an example of a method for evaluating the sulfite or bisulfite concentration that is equal to or lower than the oxidation power index value before contact with the attached matter. [Figure 9] FIG. 11 is a graph showing an example of a method for evaluating the relationship between the sulfite or bisulfite concentration and the oxidizing power index value, and the rate of change of the oxidizing power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration, in the fourth or fifth form of evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention. [Figure 10] 1 is an example of a program for executing oxidation risk judgment using the first embodiment of the present invention on a computer. [Figure 11] 1 is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the second or third embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 12] This is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidizing power index value is equal to or lower than that before contact with an attached matter, according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 13] 1 is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the rate of change in the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 14] 1 is an example of a program for executing oxidation risk judgment using the first embodiment of the present invention on a computer. [Figure 15] 1 is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the second or third embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 16] This is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidizing power index value is equal to or lower than that before contact with an attached matter, according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 17] 1 is an example of a program for executing, on a computer, the oxidation risk judgment using the rate of change in the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite according to the fourth embodiment of the present invention. [Figure 18] FIG. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between the time elapsed from contact with a sulfite or bisulfite and the oxidation-reduction potential according to Example 1 of the present invention. [Figure 19] FIG. 3 is a graph showing the relationship between the time elapsed from contact with a sulfite or bisulfite and the oxidation-reduction potential according to Example 3-1 of the present invention. [Figure 20] FIG. 2 is a graph showing the relationship between sulfite or bisulfite concentration and oxidation-reduction potential according to Example 3-2 of the present invention. [Figure 21] FIG. 11 is a graph showing the relationship between the time elapsed from contact with a sulfite or bisulfite and the oxidation-reduction potential according to Example 4 of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0028] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention has the following features: The present invention will be described in detail below with reference to the drawings, but the contents of the present invention are not limited to these drawings.
[0029] The present invention is a method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane, and in one embodiment, the method comprises recovering deposits on the surface of the separation membrane, contacting the deposits with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, and evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits based on the oxidizing substances generated. The deposits accumulate on the surface of the separation membrane, trapping oxidizing substances and oxidation reaction promoting substances in the feed water and accumulating on the surface of the separation membrane. As a result, the substances are present in higher concentrations on the surface of the separation membrane than in the feed water or concentrated water. Therefore, even if the content of the substances in the feed water is very small, the oxidation risk can be evaluated by evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits.
[0030] The catalytic reaction in one embodiment of the present invention refers to the reaction between an oxidizing substance and an oxidation reaction promoting substance, and a sulfite or bisulfite, as described above and in the Background Art.
[0031] An example of the separation membrane in one embodiment of the present invention is a separation membrane installed in a water treatment plant.
[0032] For example, an example of the flow of a water treatment plant is shown in Figure 1. The water treatment plant shown in Figure 1 is composed of a raw water storage tank 1 for storing water to be treated (hereinafter, raw water), a raw water supply pump 2 for supplying the raw water, a pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3 for filtering the raw water, a pretreatment membrane filtration water storage tank 4 for storing the filtered water from the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3, a separation membrane filtration unit 5, a booster pump 6 for supplying the filtered water from the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3 to the separation membrane filtration unit 5, and a booster pump 7 for boosting the pressure of the filtered water from the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3 so that it can be separated into permeate and concentrated water in the separation membrane filtration unit 5.
[0033] The raw water storage tank 1 and the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3 are connected by a raw water pipe 8, the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3 and the pretreatment membrane filtered water storage tank 4 are connected by a pretreatment membrane filtered water pipe 9, and the pretreatment membrane filtered water storage tank 4 and the separation membrane filtration unit 5 are connected by a separation membrane filtration supply water pipe 10. In the water treatment plant, raw water is treated in the pretreatment membrane filtration unit 3, and the pretreatment membrane filtered water is temporarily stored in the pretreatment membrane filtered water storage tank 4, then supplied to the booster pump 7 by the booster pump 6, and after being pressurized by the booster pump 7, it is supplied to the separation membrane filtration unit 5, where it is separated into permeate from which solutes such as salt have been removed and concentrated water from which solutes such as salt have been concentrated, and is discharged through the separation membrane filtration permeate pipe 11 and the separation membrane filtration concentrated water pipe 12, respectively.
[0034] Examples of separation membranes in one embodiment of the present invention include separation membranes taken from components installed in a separation membrane filtration unit, and separation membranes in components installed in piping within a plant, such as raw water piping 8, pretreated filtrate piping 9, separation membrane filtration feed water piping 10, separation membrane filtration permeate piping 11, and separation membrane filtration concentrated water piping 12.
[0035] The separation membrane in one embodiment of the present invention can be a microfiltration membrane (MF) or an ultrafiltration membrane (UF membrane) as applied to the pretreatment filtration unit 3, but is particularly suitable for plants that separate and concentrate solute components using semipermeable membranes such as nanofiltration membranes (NF membranes) and reverse osmosis membranes (RO membranes), and is suitable for desalinization of seawater or brine, production of industrial water, concentration of fruit juice, advanced treatment of water supply, etc. Furthermore, when the separation membrane of the present invention is a semipermeable membrane, the oxidation reaction promoting substance is concentrated and accumulated on the semipermeable membrane surface without passing through, resulting in a higher concentration than in the raw water or concentrated water, which is more preferable because it improves the evaluation accuracy according to the present invention. These are usually installed in the separation membrane filtration unit 5.
[0036] A semipermeable membrane is a membrane that has semipermeability that allows some components in the raw water, such as solvents, to pass through but not solute components such as salt, and examples of such membranes include nanofiltration membranes (NF membranes) and reverse osmosis membranes (RO membranes). Membrane structures include asymmetric membranes with a dense separating layer on one side of the membrane, with gradually larger micropores from the dense separating layer toward the inside of the membrane or the other side, and composite membranes with a very thin separating functional layer made of a different material on top of the dense layer of the asymmetric membrane. Membrane forms include hollow fiber membranes and flat membranes.
[0037] Semipermeable membranes are generally used as elements of an appropriate form according to the membrane form. The semipermeable membrane element in the present invention is not particularly limited as long as it has substantial liquid chambers on both sides of the semipermeable membrane and can pressurize and permeate a liquid from one surface of the semipermeable membrane to the other surface of the semipermeable membrane. One example is a spiral-type semipermeable membrane element having a flat membrane-type semipermeable membrane. A spiral-type semipermeable membrane element is generally composed of a feed-side flow passage material that guides the feed water to the semipermeable membrane surface, a semipermeable membrane, and a permeation-side flow passage material that guides the liquid (permeate) that has permeated the semipermeable membrane to a water collection pipe, and the feed-side flow passage material, the semipermeable membrane, and the permeation-side flow passage material are spirally wound around the water collection pipe. As described above, from the viewpoint of improving the evaluation accuracy, the separation membrane of the present invention is preferably a separation membrane taken from a spiral-type semipermeable membrane element.
[0038] In addition, by carrying out the evaluation method according to one embodiment of the present invention periodically, for example, regularly at a frequency of once a day to once a week, it becomes easy to identify the time of occurrence of a sudden increase in the risk of oxidation, and it becomes possible to take measures quickly. In this case, when it is difficult to collect a separation membrane from an installation member of the separation membrane filtration unit, for example, a semipermeable membrane element, it is desirable to use a separation membrane installed in a pipe close to the separation membrane filtration unit, for example, a separation membrane filtration supply water pipe 10, a separation membrane filtration permeate water pipe 11, or a separation membrane filtration concentrated water pipe 12, since the oxidation risk in the separation membrane filtration unit 5 can be accurately and quickly evaluated. In particular, the higher the concentration of the oxidation-promoting substance in the solution in the pipe, the higher the evaluation accuracy of the present invention, so that a separation membrane filtration supply water pipe or a separation membrane filtration concentrated water pipe is preferable, and a separation membrane filtration concentrated water pipe is more preferable. An example of a form of installing the separation membrane in the pipe is to install a water-passing member having a separation membrane inside in the pipe.
[0039] The water-passing member in one embodiment of the present invention is not particularly limited as long as it has a separation membrane inside and the solution moves from one end of the water-passing member to the other end. In addition, as described above, in order to enable regular and frequent oxidation risk evaluation, it is desirable that the water-passing member is easily attached and detached to the water treatment plant piping. As an example, as illustrated in FIG. 2, it is desirable that certain unit structures can be continuously connected and separated via a connecting member having a screw structure or a fitting structure (such as a joint such as a one-touch joint 15), or that the hose 13 has a structure that can be easily cut or partially separated using scissors or the like. For example, as shown in FIG. 2 and FIG. 3, a water-passing container 19 can be exemplified as a preferred form by connecting one or more unit water-passing members 19a having a connectable structure in which a thread groove is provided at both ends of the longitudinal direction (water passing direction 18) of the cylindrical unit water-passing member 19a and a separation membrane 20 is installed, and further connecting the unit water-passing container opening / closing portion 16 to the water-passing container opening / closing portion 16. It is preferable to provide a water leakage prevention measure such as packing, sealing tape, or O-ring at the connection part depending on the shape. In this case, the area of the separation membrane 20 is not particularly limited, but it is preferable that the area is 0.01 m 2 It is preferable that the thickness is 0.03m or more.2 More preferably, the separation membrane 20 is disposed perpendicular to the water flow direction.
[0040] As a simple water passage container, a member such as a hose can be used. In this case, the water passage container is preferably cylindrical and made of a soft material. This allows it to be easily cut with scissors or the like to remove the separation membrane inside. Also, a flowmeter 14 and a flow rate control valve 17 may be inserted in the middle of the hose 13.
[0041] When the water-permeable member is installed in piping within a plant other than in the vicinity of the separation membrane filtration unit, it is also possible to evaluate the oxidation risk in and around each piping.
[0042] The material (component) constituting the separation membrane or semipermeable membrane is not particularly limited, but preferred are cellulose acetate compounds, vinyl polymer compounds, polyamide compounds, polyester compounds, polyimide compounds, etc., and in particular, cellulose acetate compounds and polyamide compounds, which are widely used as semipermeable membrane materials, are preferred.
[0043] The sulfite or bisulfite is not particularly limited, but examples include sodium sulfite, potassium sulfite, magnesium sulfite, calcium sulfite, sodium bisulfite, potassium bisulfite, magnesium bisulfite, calcium bisulfite, etc. Commonly available commercially available products can be used, and among these, sodium sulfite, potassium sulfite, sodium bisulfite, and potassium bisulfite are particularly preferred.
[0044] In one embodiment of the present invention, the adhesions on the surface of the separation membrane are collected by a physical method, and then subjected to oxidation risk evaluation. The method for collecting the adhesions is not particularly limited as long as it is a method with a high recovery rate and quantitative, but for example, a method of immersing the membrane in pure water and dispersing the adhesions in the pure water by ultrasonic pulverization and collecting them can be mentioned. In addition, as a method for reliably peeling off and collecting the adhesions stuck to the separation membrane, a method of collecting the adhesions on the surface of the separation membrane using a wiping tool, immersing the wiping tool in pure water, and dispersing the adhesions in the pure water and collecting them can be mentioned. Examples of wiping tools include cotton swabs, spatulas, scrapers, rubber spatulas, etc., and it is preferable that these do not contain an oxidizing agent-based disinfectant. In addition, in order to prevent the destruction and peeling of the separation membrane, examples of suitable tools include cotton swabs and silicon tools, but are not particularly limited. As the pure water, distilled water, reverse osmosis membrane (RO membrane) water and ion-exchanged water immediately after purification, commercially available ultrapure water, etc. are preferable. Another example is a method in which the separation membrane is dried and then the deposits on the surface of the separation membrane are collected in a container using the above-mentioned wiping tool. In this case, the method for drying the separation membrane is not particularly limited as long as it is a method that can easily peel off the deposits on the surface of the separation membrane, but examples include natural drying at room temperature and a method of leaving the membrane in a heated dryer and drying it. The collected deposits are preferably dried at room temperature or by heating. In this case, it is preferable to heat the membrane to 30°C to 120°C using a thermostatic dryer and dry it until the weight change is less than ±0.1g. In one embodiment of the present invention, the adhesion is brought into contact with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, and the oxidation potential of the adhesion is evaluated based on the generated oxidizing substances. The method of bringing the adhesion into contact with the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite is not particularly limited, but for example, a method of putting the recovered adhesion into a solution prepared by dissolving sulfite or bisulfite in pure water can be mentioned. At this time, in order to increase the contact area between the adhesion and the solution, it is desirable to vibrate and stir the solution into which the adhesion is put using a stirring jig, a stirrer, a shaker, etc. Examples of the stirring jig, a stirrer, and a shaker include a medicine spoon, a spatula, a magnetic stirrer, a stirring rod with a stirring blade at the tip, a stirrer such as Three-One Motor (manufactured by Shinto Scientific Co., Ltd.), an ultrasonic cleaner, etc.
[0045] Another example of evaluating the oxidation potential of an adhesion based on the generated oxidizing substances by contacting the adhesion with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite is a method using an adhesion extracting solution obtained by treating the adhesion with a chemical solution. By using the adhesion extracting solution, the catalytic reaction between the oxidation reaction promoting substance in the adhesion and the sulfite or bisulfite is promoted, and a more accurate evaluation of the oxidation potential of the adhesion is possible. A general extraction process can be used as a method of treating and extracting the adhesion with a chemical solution. For example, a method is included in which the adhesion is added to the chemical solution, and the chemical solution is left to stand or stirred using a stirring tool, a stirrer, or a shaker described below, and the chemical solution is collected after a certain period of time has passed. Examples of methods for collecting the chemical solution at this time include collecting the chemical solution using a tool such as a dropper, and removing the adhesion by a filtering process and collecting the chemical solution. An acidic chemical solution is preferably used as the chemical solution. In other words, it is preferable to use a chemical solution with a hydrogen ion concentration of pH 6 or less, more preferably pH 3 or less, and examples thereof include sulfuric acid, nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, phosphoric acid, citric acid, oxalic acid, acetic acid, formic acid, etc., among which nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, and phosphoric acid are particularly preferable. These chemical solutions are generally commercially available, and it is possible to use them.
[0046] In addition, the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite in one embodiment of the present invention may contain other inorganic salts in order to reproduce the conditions in an actual water treatment plant. In particular, it is preferable that the solution contains sodium chloride. The sodium chloride concentration is preferably 500 to 80,000 mg / L, more preferably 1,000 to 50,000 mg / L.
[0047] A first embodiment of the present invention for evaluating the oxidation potential includes a method of contacting a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite with the deposits recovered from the surface of the separation membrane and measuring the change over time in the oxidation power index value of the solution. As an example of the first embodiment, at least one of the following evaluation methods is exemplified, as shown in FIG. 4 or FIG. 5. In this case, the degree of oxidation risk is determined according to the method for determining the oxidation power index value used, as described below, but generally, in any of the following cases, the larger the value, the greater the oxidation potential and the higher the oxidation risk.
[0048] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time The rate of change in the oxidation index value over time is calculated by dividing the difference in the oxidation index value by the difference in the elapsed time from the contact with the corresponding attached matter. For example, in the case of FIG. 5, it is calculated using Equation 1.
[0049] (Change rate of oxidation index value over time) = (y2-y1) ÷ (t2-t1) (Equation 1) In formula 1, y1 represents the oxidation power index value when the time elapsed from contact with the deposit is t1, and y2 represents the oxidation power index value when the time elapsed from contact with the deposit is y2. However, t2>t1. When calculating multiple t2 and t1 in one evaluation in which the deposit is contacted once, the maximum value among the values calculated by formula 1 is adopted. In addition, the moving average value of the oxidation power index value refers to the arithmetic mean of the oxidation power index values of the most recent N (an integer of 2 or more) points. As a second embodiment for evaluating the oxidation potential of the present invention, there is a method in which two or more solutions having different sulfite or bisulfite concentrations are used, and the oxidation power index value is measured when the deposit recovered from the surface of the separation membrane is contacted with each of them. As an example of the second embodiment, there is a method for evaluating at least one of the following as shown in FIG. 6 or FIG. 7. In this case, the degree of oxidation risk is determined according to the method for determining the oxidation power index value used, as described later, but generally, in any of the following cases, it is determined that the larger the value, the higher the oxidation potential and the higher the oxidation risk.
[0050] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration The rate of change in the oxidizing power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration is calculated by dividing the difference in the oxidizing power index value by the difference in the corresponding sulfite or bisulfite concentration. For example, in the case of FIG. 8, it is calculated using Equation 2.
[0051] (Rate of change in oxidative power index per sulfite or bisulfite concentration) =(y4-y3)÷(c4-c3) (Formula 2) In formula 2, y3 represents the oxidizing power index value when the sulfite or bisulfite concentration is c3, and y4 represents the oxidizing power index value when the sulfite or bisulfite concentration is c4, where c4>c3.
[0052] When calculating multiple values for c4 and c3 in a single evaluation in which the attached object is contacted once, the maximum value among the values calculated by formula 2 is used. When measuring the oxidizing power index value over time under each concentration condition, one of the following oxidizing power index values is used under each concentration condition.
[0053] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time As a third embodiment of the present invention for evaluating the oxidation potential, there is a method in which a sulfite or bisulfite is further added to a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite with which an adhesion is contacted, thereby changing the sulfite or bisulfite concentration of the solution, and the oxidation power index value when the adhesion is contacted is measured. As an example of the third embodiment, there is a method for evaluating at least one of the following, as shown in FIG. 6 or FIG. 7. In this case, the degree of oxidation risk is determined according to the method for determining the oxidation power index value used, as described later, but generally, in any of the following cases, it is determined that the larger the value, the higher the oxidation potential and the higher the oxidation risk.
[0054] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration The rate of change in the oxidizing power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration is calculated by dividing the difference in the oxidizing power index value by the difference in the corresponding sulfite or bisulfite concentration. For example, as described above, in the case of FIG. 7, it is calculated using Equation 2.
[0055] A fourth embodiment of the present invention for evaluating the oxidation potential includes a method for measuring the oxidation power index value when the adhesion is contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite and having a higher concentration than any of the solutions described in the first to third embodiments. As an example of the fourth embodiment, at least one of the following methods for evaluation is exemplified, as shown in Figure 8 or Figure 9. In this case, the degree of oxidation risk is determined according to the method for measuring the oxidation power index value used, as described below, but generally, in any of the following cases, the larger the value, the higher the oxidation potential and the higher the oxidation risk.
[0056] A: Sulfite or sulfite concentration at which the oxidation power index value is equal to or less than that before contact with the deposit B: Rate of change of the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration Note that the rate of change of the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration is calculated by dividing the difference in the oxidation power index value by the difference in the corresponding sulfite or bisulfite concentration. For example, in the case of Figure 9, it is calculated by Equation 3.
[0057] (Rate of change of the oxidation power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration) =(y6 - y5) ÷ (c6 - c5) (Equation 3) In Equation 3, y5 represents the oxidation power index value when the sulfite or bisulfite concentration is c5, and y6 represents the oxidation power index value when the sulfite or bisulfite concentration is c6. However, c6 > c5. Usually, since y6 < y5, the value calculated by Equation 3 is negative, and the larger the absolute value, the smaller the value.
[0058] Note that when calculating for multiple c5 and c6 in a single evaluation of contacting the deposit once, the maximum value among the values calculated by Equation 3 is adopted.
[0059] Also, when measuring the oxidation power index value over time under each concentration condition, the oxidation power index value under each concentration condition uses any one of the following.
[0060] A: Maximum value of the oxidation power index value B: Rate of change of the oxidation power index value per unit time C: Maximum value of the moving average value of the oxidation power index value D: Rate of change of the moving average value of the oxidation power index value per unit time A fifth embodiment of the present invention for evaluating the oxidation potential includes a method for measuring the oxidation index value when sulfite or bisulfite is further added after the oxidation index value of the sulfite or bisulfite-containing solution contacted with the deposit in any one of the first to third embodiments reaches a maximum. An example of the fifth embodiment includes at least one of the following methods for evaluating the oxidation potential as shown in FIG. 8 or FIG. 9. In this case, the degree of oxidation risk is determined according to the method for determining the oxidation index value used, as described below, but generally, in any of the following cases, the higher the value, the higher the oxidation potential and the higher the oxidation risk.
[0061] A: Sulfite or sulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is lower than before contact with the deposit B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration The rate of change in the oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration is calculated by dividing the difference in the oxidative power index value by the difference in the corresponding sulfite or bisulfite concentration, and is generally a negative value. For example, as described above, in the case of FIG. 9, it is calculated using Equation 3.
[0062] By using any of the first to third forms, it is possible to quickly and easily evaluate the oxidation potential. For example, when evaluating the oxidation risk at a specified concentration or amount, such as the concentration of sulfite or bisulfite used in an actual plant, the first form is preferred. On the other hand, when it is desired to know the maximum oxidation risk of concern, the second or third form is preferred. Moreover, by using the fourth or fifth form, it is possible to know the sulfite or bisulfite concentration required to fully counteract this oxidation potential.
[0063] Furthermore, in the first to fifth embodiments, if the membrane area used for collecting the deposits and the number of years of use (operation) of the element or water-permeable member containing the membrane can be known, the oxidation risk in an actual plant can be evaluated more accurately by dividing the index obtained in each embodiment by the membrane area and / or the number of years of use. For example, when the first embodiment is used, the oxidation risk can be evaluated more accurately by using the value calculated by Equation 4.
[0064] (Oxidation index value per unit area / years of use) =z÷((area of membrane used for collecting deposits)×(years of use of the membrane)) (Equation 4) Here, z is the oxidation risk index value evaluated in the first mode, that is, any one of the following:
[0065] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time Similarly, in other embodiments, a more accurate oxidation risk evaluation can be achieved by using the oxidation risk index value evaluated by each method as z and the value calculated by Equation 4.
[0066] The method for measuring the oxidizing power index value is not particularly limited, but a method that reacts sensitively to oxidizing substances is preferable. Common methods include, for example, oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) measurement, measurement of free residual chlorine concentration or combined and / or total chlorine concentration by the N,N-diethylparaphenylenediamine (hereinafter, DPD) method, Fujiwara Test described in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1, and dissolved oxygen (DO) measurement. In particular, from the viewpoint of ease of measurement, ORP measurement and measurement of free residual chlorine concentration, combined and / or total chlorine concentration by the DPD method are preferable.
[0067] The oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) is an index of the oxidation or reduction of a solution, and is determined by the equilibrium state of electron acceptance occurring between an oxidant and a reductant coexisting in a solution. It is generally measured based on the Nernst equation as the potential difference between a metal electrode and a reference electrode. The indicator can be measured using an oxidation-reduction potentiometer. There are no particular restrictions on the oxidation-reduction potentiometer, but it is preferable to use an oxidation-reduction potentiometer that measures the oxidation-reduction potential based on the Nernst equation using a platinum electrode and a reference electrode, or a composite electrode of a platinum electrode and a reference electrode. It is more preferable to use a saturated calomel electrode or a saturated silver / silver chloride electrode as the reference electrode, and a 3.3 mol / L silver chloride electrode as the reference electrode.
[0068] The DPD method is a method for measuring the free residual chlorine concentration and the combined and / or total chlorine concentration based on the color reaction between oxidizing substances present in water and a DPD reagent. When measuring the indicators, commercially available measuring devices and DPD reagents can be used.
[0069] When using an index that is affected by the measurement conditions as the oxidizing power index value, it is desirable to use a value under any one of the conditions, or to use a value that is uniquely corrected for the influence of the measurement conditions. For example, when using the oxidation-reduction potential (ORP) as the above-mentioned index, it is desirable to use a value under any of the measurement conditions, particularly at any one of the solution temperatures and pH, and it is preferable to use a value under any one of the conditions of a solution temperature of 20 to 35°C and a pH of 1 to 8. Hereinafter, unless otherwise specified, the value at a solution temperature of 25°C and a pH of 7 is described.
[0070] As an example of a method for determining the oxidation risk, when the oxidation potential is evaluated by the maximum value of the oxidation index value or the maximum value of the moving average value of the oxidation index value among the first to third forms, for example, when the redox potential is used as the oxidation index value, it can be judged that the oxidation risk is low (mild) if it is less than 300 mV, that there is an oxidation risk (moderate) if it is 300 mV or more and less than 600 mV, and that there is a high oxidation risk (severe) if it is 600 mV or more. When the free residual chlorine concentration or the total chlorine concentration is used as the oxidation index value, it can be judged that the oxidation risk is low (mild) if it is less than 0.01 mg / L, that there is an oxidation risk (moderate) if it is 0.01 mg / L or more and less than 0.5 mg / L, and that there is a high oxidation risk (severe) if it is 0.5 mg / L or more.
[0071] In addition, as an example of the oxidation risk determination method, in the first embodiment, when the oxidation potential is evaluated by the rate of change of the oxidation index value per time or the rate of change of the moving average value of the oxidation index value, for example, when the oxidation-reduction potential is used as the oxidation index value, it can be determined that the oxidation risk is low (mild) if it is less than 50 mV / min, that there is an oxidation risk (moderate) if it is 50 mV / min or more and less than 300 mV / min, and that there is a high oxidation risk (severe) if it is 300 mV / min or more. When the free residual chlorine concentration or total chlorine concentration is used as the oxidation index value, it can be determined that the oxidation risk is low (mild) if it is 0.1 mg / L / min, that there is an oxidation risk (moderate) if it is 0.1 mg / L / min or more and less than 0.5 mg / L / min, and that there is a high oxidation risk (severe) if it is 0.5 mg / L / min or more.
[0072] In addition, in the second or third form, when the oxidation potential is evaluated by the rate of change of the oxidation index value per concentration, for example, when the redox potential is used as the oxidation index value, the oxidation risk is judged to be low (mild) if it is less than 50 mV / (mg / L), to be present (moderate) if it is 50 mV / (mg / L) or more and less than 100 mV / (mg / L), and to be high (severe) if it is 100 mV / (mg / L) or more. When the free residual chlorine concentration or total chlorine concentration is used as the oxidation index value, the oxidation risk is judged to be low (mild) if it is 0.1 mg / L / (mg / L), to be present (moderate) if it is 0.1 mg / L / (mg / L) or more and less than 0.5 mg / L / (mg / L), and to be high (severe) if it is 0.5 mg / L / (mg / L) or more.
[0073] In the fourth or fifth embodiment, when the oxidation potential is evaluated based on the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is equal to or lower than the value before contact with the deposit, the oxidation risk is judged to be low (mild) if it is less than 5 mg / L, to be present (moderate) if it is 5 mg / L or more but less than 100 mg / L, and to be high (severe) if it is 100 mg / L or more. In addition, when the oxidation potential is evaluated based on the rate of change in the oxidation index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration, for example, when the oxidation-reduction potential is used as the oxidation index value, the oxidation risk is judged to be low (mild) if it is less than -100 mV / (mg / L), to be present (moderate) if it is -100 mV / (mg / L) or more but less than -5 mV / (mg / L), and to be high (severe) if it is -5 mV / (mg / L) or more. When using free residual chlorine concentration or total chlorine concentration as the oxidizing power index, if it is less than -0.01 mg / L / (mg / L), the risk of oxidation is low (mild), and if it is -0.01 mg / L / (mg / L) or more, it is -5.0 x 10 -3 mg / L / (mg / L) indicates a moderate risk of oxidation, -5.0×10 -3 If it is mg / L / (mg / L) or higher, the risk of oxidation is judged to be high (severe).
[0074] When contacting an adhesion with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, if the hydrogen ion concentration index (pH) of the contact solution is 9.0 or higher, the generation of oxidizing substances is promoted. This allows the oxidizing potential of the adhesion to be evaluated quickly and with high accuracy, so it is preferable to contact the adhesion with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite with a hydrogen ion concentration index (pH) of 9.0 or higher.
[0075] A method for adjusting the hydrogen ion concentration exponent (pH) of a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite to 9.0 or more includes adding a basic substance to the solution, which is not particularly limited, but includes, for example, sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, calcium hydroxide, magnesium hydroxide, sodium carbonate, potassium carbonate, sodium hydrogen carbonate, potassium hydrogen carbonate, etc.
[0076] In addition, the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite in one embodiment of the present invention preferably contains chloride ions and / or bromide ions. The presence of these ions generates oxidizing substances such as hypochlorite ions and hypobromite ions, which increases the risk of oxidation, making it possible to more accurately estimate the oxidation potential in a water treatment plant. In addition, by making the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite have a composition similar to that of raw water or feed water used in an actual water treatment plant, it becomes possible to more accurately evaluate the risk of oxidation in a water treatment plant.
[0077] An example of the use of the present invention is to judge the oxidation risk in a water treatment plant based on the oxidation potential evaluated in any one of the first to fifth embodiments of the present invention. In this case, the magnitude of the oxidation risk is determined according to the judgment method of the measurement method of the oxidizing power index value used. For example, in the ORP or DPD method, the higher the measured value, the higher the oxidation risk, and in the Fujiwara test described in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1, the oxidation risk is judged to be high when coloration occurs. Furthermore, an example of the use of the present invention is to judge the oxidation risk at different water treatment plants, piping locations, and different times by comparing the oxidation potentials evaluated using a certain specified amount of deposits using the same method in any one of the first to fifth embodiments of the present invention. For example, when deposits are recovered from a semipermeable membrane element or a water-permeable member having a separation membrane used in different plants and the oxidation potentials of each deposit are evaluated using the same amount of each deposit using the same method in any one of the first to fifth embodiments, it is possible to compare the magnitude of the oxidation risk in each plant from the magnitude of the oxidation potentials. In addition, for example, water-permeable members having separation membranes are installed in different pipes in the same plant, and the oxidation potential of the deposits recovered from each separation membrane is evaluated using the same amount of each deposit by the same method among the first to fifth forms, thereby making it possible to judge the magnitude of the oxidation risk in each pipe. This makes it easy to identify the cause, for example, when the oxidation risk in the plant increases. In addition, by periodically evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits in the same plant by any of the first to fifth forms of the present invention, the oxidation risk of the plant can be monitored, and even if the oxidation risk increases, a quick response is possible. For example, an increase in the oxidation risk due to excessive addition of reducing agent in the supply water line or a trouble in the previous process can be detected. In addition, the presence or absence of an oxidation risk (trouble with oxidation reaction-promoting substances being mixed into the permeate) in the permeate line due to deterioration of the semipermeable membrane or damage to the members can be found. In this way, the present invention makes it possible to easily and quickly judge the oxidation risk, which was difficult to do using conventional methods, and is useful for risk avoidance and early resolution of operational troubles.
[0078] Another embodiment of the present invention is an oxidation risk assessment program for a water treatment plant, which includes a computer for evaluating the oxidation risk, a data recording means for recording input data in the computer, and a means for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit based on the input data, and the input data is the condition and the oxidizing power index value when the deposit recovered from the separation membrane used is contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite. In this embodiment, a computer having each means is made to function to evaluate the oxidation risk of the separation membrane. This embodiment can be recorded in a recording device such as a computer memory or a hard disk, and the recording form is not particularly limited. In addition, another embodiment of the present invention is a recording medium in which the above-mentioned evaluation risk assessment program is stored.
[0079] The computer has a data recording means for recording the conditions and the oxidizing power index value when the deposit recovered from the used separation membrane is contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite.Furthermore, using the data recorded in the data recording means, the computer determines or calculates and outputs an oxidation risk index value.Alternatively, the oxidation risk of the separation membrane is evaluated and output based on a predetermined determination criterion.
[0080] For example, there is a program that evaluates the oxidation risk based on the time-course data of the oxidation power index value as shown in Figure 10 or Figure 14. That is, from the oxidation power index value of the sulfite- or bisulfite-containing solution with which the inputted attached matter has been brought into contact and the elapsed time from contact with the attached matter at the time the oxidation power index value is measured, the oxidation potential is evaluated by determining or calculating one of the following, and an oxidation risk judgment result is output.
[0081] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of the moving average of the oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index over time In this case, in order to accurately grasp the oxidation risk, it is preferable that the output judgment result is the oxidation potential evaluation result itself, which is an oxidation risk index value, as shown in Figure 10. On the other hand, in order to make it simple and easy to distinguish, it is preferable to judge the level of oxidation risk, for example, the degree of oxidative deterioration (mild, medium, severe), based on a predetermined judgment criterion (index value) as shown in Figure 14. As described above, the index value and judgment criterion at this time can be a value or judgment criterion that is in line with the evaluation method of the oxidation potential, such as the redox potential, the free residual chlorine concentration, or the combined (total) chlorine concentration.
[0082] Among the oxidation potential evaluation methods, when it is desired to perform the evaluation quickly, it is preferable to use the rate of change (B) of the oxidation power index value per time. On the other hand, from the viewpoint of the accuracy of the evaluation, the maximum value (A) of the oxidation power index value is preferable. Also, for example, when it is desired to accurately grasp the oxidation risk over a certain period of time, the oxidation risk can be determined by calculating a moving average value from the recorded data over time and evaluating the oxidation potential with its maximum value (C) or rate of change (D). In this case, when it is desired to obtain the result quickly, it is preferable to use the rate of change (D) of the moving average value, and when it is desired to accurately grasp the oxidation risk, it is preferable to use the maximum value (C) of the moving average value.
[0083] Also, for example, there is a program that evaluates the oxidation risk based on the relationship of the oxidation power index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration as shown in Figure 11 or Figure 15. That is, the oxidation potential is evaluated by determining or calculating one of the following from the oxidation power index value of the sulfite or bisulfite-containing solution with which the attached matter has been brought into contact and the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at the time when the oxidation power index value is measured, and an oxidation risk judgment result is output.
[0084] A: Maximum value of the oxidation index B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration In this case, in order to accurately grasp the oxidation risk, it is preferable that the output judgment result is the value of the oxidation potential evaluation result itself, which indicates the magnitude of the oxidation risk, as shown in Figure 11. On the other hand, in order to make it simple and easy to distinguish, it is preferable that the judgment result is based on a predetermined judgment criterion (index value) as shown in Figure 15.
[0085] As described above, the index value in this case can be a value or a judgment standard according to the evaluation method of the oxidation potential.
[0086] Similarly to the above, when it is desired to perform the judgment quickly, the rate of change of the oxidizing power index value per sulfite or bisulfite (B) can be used. On the other hand, from the viewpoint of the accuracy of the judgment, the maximum value of the oxidizing power index value (A) is preferable.
[0087] Another example is a program that evaluates the oxidation risk based on the relationship of the oxidation index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration after the oxidation index value has reached its maximum. That is, for example, as shown in FIG. 12 or 16, a program that determines the oxidation risk based on the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value becomes equal to or lower than the concentration before contact with the adhesion, based on the oxidation index value of the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite that has been brought into contact with the adhesion, the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at the time when the oxidation index value is measured, and the oxidation index value of the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite before contact with the adhesion. Another example is a program that evaluates the oxidation potential and determines the oxidation risk by calculating the rate of change in the bisulfite or bisulfite concentration based on the relationship of the oxidation index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration after the oxidation index value has reached its maximum, based on the oxidation index value of the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite that has been brought into contact with the adhesion, based on the sulfite or bisulfite concentration at the time when the oxidation index value is measured, based on the oxidation index value of the solution containing sulfite or bisulfite that has been brought into contact with the adhesion, as shown in FIG. 13 or 17.
[0088] In these cases, in order to accurately grasp the oxidation risk, it is preferable that the output judgment result be the value of the oxidation potential evaluation result itself, which indicates the magnitude of the oxidation risk, as shown in Figure 12 or Figure 13. On the other hand, in order to make it simple and easy to distinguish, it is preferable to judge the magnitude of the oxidation risk based on an index value that serves as a predetermined judgment criterion, as shown in Figure 16 or Figure 17.
[0089] As described above, which of the programs utilizing the first to fifth aspects is to be used can be arbitrarily selected depending on the situation and purpose.
[0090] Another embodiment of the present invention is an oxidation risk evaluation device for a water treatment plant, comprising: a computer for evaluating the oxidation risk; a data input means for inputting the conditions and the oxidation index value when the deposit recovered from the separation membrane used is contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite into the computer; a data recording means for recording the conditions and the oxidation index value in the computer; and a means for evaluating the oxidation potential by the above-mentioned method. The evaluation device comprises a computer for evaluating the oxidation risk, a data input means for inputting the conditions and the oxidation index value when the deposit recovered from the separation membrane is contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite, a data recording means for recording the input data in the computer, a data recording means for recording the input data in the computer, and a method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit based on the input data.
[0091] Examples of the conditions when the deposit is contacted include the time elapsed since contact, the sulfite or bisulfite concentration, and the oxidizing power index value before contact with the deposit. As a data input means, the conditions when the deposit recovered from the separation membrane used in a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite is contacted and the oxidizing power index value are input based on the evaluation results, and these can be input by manually inputting numerical values or by automatically inputting the conditions by providing the evaluation device itself with a method for evaluating and measuring these conditions. As an automatic input method, for example, the evaluation device is provided with an evaluation and measurement method capable of determining the time elapsed since contact and the sulfite or bisulfite concentration, and the results are recorded and input at any time. As such an evaluation and measurement method, for example, a colorimetric method using a chemical that reacts with sulfite or bisulfite to color or change color is used, and the sulfite or bisulfite concentration is determined based on the created calibration curve, and the time elapsed since contact is determined from the time.
[0092] The oxidation potential can be evaluated based on the time course data of the oxidation index value or the relationship of the oxidation index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration as shown in the present invention, i.e., as described above and in Figures 10 to 17, and the determined and calculated oxidation risk index value is output. Alternatively, the oxidation risk of the separation membrane is evaluated and output based on a predetermined determination criterion. EXAMPLES
[0093] The present invention will be described in more detail below using examples, but the present invention is not limited to these examples in any way.
[0094] <Example 1> A tendency for the quality of the produced water to deteriorate was observed in water treatment plant A that had been in operation for about two months. A semipermeable membrane element TM820C-400 (manufactured by Toray Industries, Inc.) used in the plant was disassembled, and the separation membrane was collected. The separation membrane was dried at room temperature for 24 hours, and the deposit was collected using a silicon jig and placed in a glass petri dish. This was dried for two hours in a dryer set at 120°C. This is referred to as deposit A-1.
[0095] To prepare 400 mL of an aqueous solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 20 mg / L, seawater, sodium bisulfite, and a stir bar were placed in a 1 L beaker, and the solution was stirred with a magnetic stirrer to dissolve. 1 mol / L aqueous sodium hydroxide solution and 1 mol / L sulfuric acid were added to adjust the pH to 7. 10 mg of the above-mentioned deposit A-1 was added to this solution, and the change in the redox potential over time was measured using an oxidation-reduction potentiometer while stirring. The pH and solution temperature were also measured using a hydrogen ion concentration (pH) meter and an alcohol thermometer. The results are shown in Figure 18. The maximum value of the redox potential was 459 mV. The pH at this time was 7, and the solution temperature was 25°C. Since the redox potential was 300 mV or more, the oxidation potential of the deposit was high, and the risk of oxidation in this plant was considered to be high.
[0096] In order to check for oxidation degradation of the separation membrane, 6 g of pyridine and 2 g of 3 mol / L aqueous sodium hydroxide solution were put into a 20 mL glass bottle and mixed. The separation membrane disassembled and collected from the above element was cut into 10 cm squares, rinsed with pure water, and the base material was peeled off and removed. This was put into the above pyridine-sodium hydroxide aqueous solution and left at room temperature for 8 hours, and the solution turned red. From this result, it is considered that the separation membrane has been oxidized and deteriorated, as described in Non-Patent Document 1. In addition, the elemental composition of the above-mentioned deposit was examined by high-frequency inductively coupled plasma (ICP) emission spectrometry, and it was found to contain copper (1.1 wt%) and manganese (32 wt%).
[0097] <Comparative Example 1> The filter media (sand) of a gravity filter (DMF) used in water treatment plant A at the same time as in Example 1 was immersed in concentrated nitric acid for 20 hours to obtain a DMF filter media extract. In order to prepare 400 mL of an aqueous solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 20 mg / L in a 1 L beaker, seawater, sodium bisulfite, and a stir bar were placed in the beaker, and the solution was stirred with a magnetic stirrer to dissolve the sodium bisulfite. 5 g of the above-mentioned DMF filter media extract was added to the solution, and the change in redox potential over time was measured while stirring. The results are also shown in Figure 18. The maximum value of the redox potential was 220 mV.
[0098] From the results of Example 1 and Comparative Example 1, it is considered that the separation membrane element used in water treatment plant A was oxidized and deteriorated, and that the oxidation risk in water treatment plant A is high. As described above, the high oxidation risk in water treatment plant A can be quickly determined by evaluating the oxidation potential using the deposits on the separation membrane used. Furthermore, the elemental composition analysis of the deposits detected large amounts of copper and manganese, which suggests that these are causing a high oxidation risk in the separation membrane, as described above. On the other hand, when the evaluation is performed using a filter medium extract of DMF, the oxidation potential is low and the oxidation risk in water treatment plant A cannot be evaluated correctly, but the oxidation risk can be evaluated by using the deposits on the separation membrane.
[0099] <Example 2> A separation membrane was collected from the semipermeable membrane element TM820C-400 (manufactured by Toray Industries, Inc.) similar to that in Example 1. The separation membrane was dried at room temperature for 24 hours, and the deposit was collected using a silicon jig and placed in a glass petri dish. This was dried for 2 hours in a dryer set at 120°C. This is referred to as deposit A-2.
[0100] To prepare 400mL of an aqueous solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 20mg / L, seawater, sodium bisulfite, and a stir bar were placed in a 1L beaker and stirred with a magnetic stirrer to dissolve the sodium bisulfite. 1mol / L aqueous sodium hydroxide solution and 1mol / L sulfuric acid were then added to adjust the pH to 7. 10mg of the deposit A-2 was added to this solution and stirred for 15 minutes. The free chlorine concentration of this solution was measured using a residual chlorine meter and found to be 4.34mg / L.
[0101] Since the free chlorine concentration was 0.5 mg / L or more, it was determined that the oxidation potential of the deposit was high, as in Example 1, and the oxidation risk in this plant was high.
[0102] <Example 3-1> For water treatment plant B, which had been in operation for about 0.5 months, the oxidation risk was examined using a method for evaluating oxidation risk due to catalytic reaction in order to confirm the plant operation status. A semipermeable membrane element TML10D (manufactured by Toray Industries, Inc.) used in the plant was disassembled, and the separation membrane was collected. A deposit was collected from the separation membrane using a silicon jig and placed in a glass petri dish. This was dried for 2 hours in a dryer set at 120°C. This was designated as deposit B.
[0103] Put 20mL of 1mol / L nitric acid solution into a sealable glass bottle, add 1.0g of deposit B, seal it, and leave it at room temperature. After one night, use a dropper to collect the supernatant into another glass bottle. This is deposit extract B.
[0104] To prepare 500mL of sodium chloride solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 10mg / L and a sodium chloride concentration of 32000mg / L, sodium chloride, sodium bisulfite, pure water, and a stir bar were placed in a 1L beaker and stirred with a magnetic stirrer to dissolve. While stirring the solution, 5mL of the deposit extract was added, and the change in the redox potential over time was measured for 8 minutes using an oxidation-reduction potentiometer. At this time, the pH and temperature of the solution were also measured using a hydrogen ion concentration (pH) meter and an alcohol thermometer. The maximum value of the redox potential in 8 minutes was 436mV.
[0105] On the other hand, 5 mL of 1 mol / L nitric acid was added to an aqueous sodium chloride solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 10 mg / L and a sodium chloride concentration of 32,000 mg / L, and the redox potential, pH, and temperature were measured, resulting in a value of 338 mV at pH 2 and 26°C.
[0106] The results are shown in Figure 19. In each case, the hydrogen ion concentration (pH) of the aqueous sodium bisulfite solution was 2 and the solution temperature was 26°C during the measurement of the change over time.
[0107] From these results, it was determined that the oxidation potential of deposit extract B was 98 mV higher than when only 1 mol / L nitric acid was added to an aqueous sodium bisulfite solution without any deposits, and therefore the oxidation potential of deposit B was high and there was a risk of oxidation.
[0108] <Example 3-2> Sodium bisulfite was further added to the sodium bisulfite aqueous solution to which the deposit extract of Example 3-1 was added so that the sodium bisulfite concentration was 50 mg / L, and measurements were performed for 8 minutes in the same manner as in Example 3-1. Sodium bisulfite was further added so that the sodium bisulfite concentration was 100 mg / L, and measurements were performed in the same manner. As a result, the maximum values of the oxidation-reduction potential in 8 minutes were 344 mV and 329 mV, respectively. In both cases, the hydrogen ion concentration (pH) of the sodium bisulfite aqueous solution during the measurement of the change over time was 2, and the solution temperature was 26°C.
[0109] The relationship between the bisulfite (sodium bisulfite) concentration and the maximum value of the redox potential obtained from the above results is shown in FIG.
[0110] From the above results, the maximum value at each bisulfite concentration was the largest at 436 mV when bisulfite was 10 mg / L, as shown in Figure 20, and this result was determined to be the oxidation potential of the deposit. This is similar to the oxidation potential obtained in Example 3-1, and it was determined that the oxidation potential of deposit B was high and there was an oxidation risk. On the other hand, this value was lower than 600 mV at which the oxidation risk is determined to be severe at pH 7, and taking into consideration that the oxidation-reduction potential generally increases when the pH is low, the oxidation risk was determined to be moderate. In addition, when taking into account the change in pH before and after the addition of the adhesion extract solution, if only the pH changes without the addition of the adhesion extract solution, the redox potential of the aqueous solution is considered to be equivalent to the value of the redox potential at 1 mol / L nitric acid in Example 3-1, which is 338 mV.Since the oxidation potential when the bisulfite concentration is 100 mg / L when the adhesion extract solution is used is equivalent to this value, it was estimated that a bisulfite concentration of 100 mg / L is necessary to sufficiently reduce the risk of oxidation of adhesion B.
[0111] <Example 4> Water treatment plant C had been in operation for about two months, and the RO module differential pressure had risen, raising concerns about the risk of oxidation due to an increase in deposits on the membrane surface. Therefore, it was decided to investigate the risk of oxidation using a method for evaluating oxidation risk through catalytic reactions. A semipermeable membrane element SU-720 (manufactured by Toray Industries, Inc.) used in the plant was disassembled, and the separation membrane was sampled. The deposits were collected from the separation membrane using a silicon jig and placed in a glass petri dish. This was dried for two hours in a dryer set at 120°C. This was designated deposit C.
[0112] 20 mL of 1 mol / L nitric acid was placed in a sealable glass bottle, and 4.0 g of deposit C was added. The bottle was then sealed and left to stand at room temperature. After about 70 hours, the supernatant was collected using a dropper into another glass bottle. This was called deposit extract C.
[0113] To prepare 400 mL of an aqueous solution with a sodium bisulfite concentration of 10 mg / L and a sodium chloride concentration of 32,000 mg / L, sodium chloride, sodium bisulfite, pure water, and a stir bar were placed in a 1 L beaker and stirred with a magnetic stirrer to dissolve. 5 mL of the above-mentioned deposit extract C was added to this solution, and the oxidation-reduction potential was measured every minute for 10 minutes while stirring using an oxidation-reduction potentiometer to measure the change over time. In addition, the pH and solution temperature were measured using a hydrogen ion concentration (pH) meter and an alcohol thermometer. The results are shown in Figure 21. The maximum value of the oxidation-reduction potential was 633 mV. The pH at this time was 2, and the solution temperature was 25°C.
[0114] From the above and the results of Example 3-1, the oxidation potential of deposit C was high, and was also higher than the oxidation potential of deposit B, and the oxidation risk was determined to be severe.
[0115] Although various embodiments have been described above, it goes without saying that the present invention is not limited to such examples. It is clear that a person skilled in the art can come up with various modified or revised examples within the scope of the claims, and it is understood that these also naturally belong to the technical scope of the present invention. Furthermore, the components in the above-mentioned embodiments may be arbitrarily combined within the scope of the invention.
[0116] This application is based on a Japanese patent application (Patent Application No. 2022-188059) filed on November 25, 2022, the contents of which are incorporated by reference into this application. [Industrial Applicability]
[0117] According to the present invention, it is possible to evaluate the oxidation risk of separation membranes, which was difficult to judge using conventional evaluation methods. In addition, it is possible to easily and quickly grasp the oxidation risk, which makes it easier to identify the cause of deterioration and select measures to be taken, and is expected to steadily improve the operating conditions of water treatment plants. [Explanation of symbols]
[0118] 1: Raw water storage tank 2: Raw water supply pump 3: Pretreatment membrane filtration unit 4: Pre-treatment membrane filtered water storage tank 5: Separation membrane filtration unit 6: Booster pump 7: Booster pump 8: Raw water piping 9: Pre-treatment membrane filtered water piping 10: Separation membrane filtration supply water piping 11: Separation membrane filtration permeate piping 12: Separation membrane filtration concentrated water piping 13: Hose 14:Flow meter 15: One-touch joint 16: Water passage container opening and closing part 17: Flow control valve 18:Water flow direction 19: Water passing container 19a: Unit water-permeable member 20: Separation membrane
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, comprising recovering a deposit from a used separation membrane, contacting the deposit with a solution containing a sulfite or bisulfite, and evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit based on the oxidizing substances generated.
2. The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to claim 1, characterized in that a deposit extract is used instead of the deposit.
3. The method for evaluating the risk of oxidation of a separation membrane according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the separation membrane is any one of the following: A: Separation membrane taken from a semipermeable membrane element that separates feed water into permeate and concentrated water at a water treatment plant. B: Separation membrane installed inside a water-permeable member installed in a supply water line of a water treatment plant C: A semipermeable membrane element is used in a water treatment plant to separate feed water into permeate and concentrated water, and a separation membrane is installed inside a water-permeable member installed in a concentrated water line.
4. The oxidation risk evaluation method for a separation membrane according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the oxidation risk evaluation method for the separation membrane is a method for evaluating an oxidation risk due to a catalytic reaction, and the oxidation potential of the deposit is evaluated by measuring a change over time in an oxidation power index value of a solution in contact with the deposit, and evaluating any one of the following: A: Maximum value of oxidation index value B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of moving average value of oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index value over time
5. The oxidation risk evaluation method for a separation membrane according to claim 4, characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit comprises adding sulfite or bisulfite to a solution in contact with the deposit to change the sulfite or bisulfite concentration of the solution, and measuring the oxidizing power index value when the deposit is contacted.
6. The method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposits according to claim 4, characterized in that the solution with which the deposits are contacted is a sulfite or bisulfite solution of two or more different concentrations, and the oxidation power index value of the deposits is measured by contacting the deposits.
7. The method for evaluating an oxidation potential of a deposit according to claim 5, characterized in that the method evaluates at least one of the following: A: Maximum value of oxidation index value B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
8. A method for evaluating the oxidation potential of an adhesion material described in claim 6, characterized in that the method evaluates at least one of the following: A: Maximum value of oxidation index value B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
9. The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to claim 4, characterized in that the oxidation index value is measured when sulfite or bisulfite is further added after the oxidation index value has reached a maximum.
10. The method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane according to claim 4, characterized in that after the oxidation power index value reaches a maximum, a different solution with a higher concentration is used and the oxidation power index value is measured when the adhesion material is brought into contact with the solution.
11. The method for evaluating an oxidation potential of a deposit according to claim 9, wherein the method for evaluating an oxidation potential of a deposit according to claim 9 is a method for evaluating at least one of the following: A: The sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is equal to or lower than that before contact with the deposit. B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
12. A method for evaluating the oxidation risk of a separation membrane as described in claim 10, characterized in that the method for evaluating the oxidation potential of the adhesion material described in claim 10 is a method for evaluating at least one of the following: A: The sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is equal to or lower than that before contact with the deposit B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
13. 3. The method for evaluating the risk of oxidation of a separation membrane according to claim 1, characterized in that an adhesion is brought into contact with a solution containing the sulfite or bisulfite and having a hydrogen ion concentration exponent (pH) of 9.0 or more.
14. 2. An oxidation risk assessment program for a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, the oxidation risk assessment program making use of the oxidation risk assessment method according to claim 1, which causes a computer to function as a data recording means for recording input data in the computer and as a means for evaluating the oxidation potential of deposits based on the recorded data in order to assess the oxidation risk, the input data being the conditions and the oxidizing power index value when the deposits recovered from the separation membrane used are contacted with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite.
15. The oxidation risk assessment program according to claim 14, characterized in that the oxidation risk assessment method for a water treatment plant is a method for assessing an oxidation risk due to a catalytic reaction, and the means for assessing the oxidation potential of the deposit is a means for assessing at least one of the following based on time-course data of the oxidation power index value: A: Maximum value of oxidation index value B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value over time C: Maximum value of moving average value of oxidation index value D: Rate of change in the moving average value of the oxidation index value over time
16. 15. The oxidation risk assessment program according to claim 14, wherein the means for evaluating the oxidation potential of the deposit is a means for evaluating any one of the following based on the relationship of the oxidation power index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration: A: Maximum value of oxidation index value B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
17. The oxidation risk assessment program according to claim 14, characterized in that the means for evaluating the oxidation potential of the attachment is a means for evaluating any one of the following based on the relationship of the oxidation power index value to the sulfite or bisulfite concentration after the oxidation power index value has reached a maximum: A: The sulfite or bisulfite concentration at which the oxidation index value is equal to or lower than that before contact with the deposit. B: Rate of change in oxidative power index value per sulfite or bisulfite concentration
18. A recording medium storing the oxidation risk assessment program according to any one of claims 14 to 17.
19. An oxidation risk evaluation device for a separation membrane in a water treatment plant, comprising: a data input means for inputting into a computer the conditions and an oxidation power index value when an adhesion material recovered from a used separation membrane is brought into contact with a solution containing sulfite or bisulfite; a data recording means for recording the conditions and the oxidation power index value in the computer; and a means for evaluating the oxidation potential by any of the methods according to claim 1 or 2.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Device for evaluation of biofilm formation potential
JP2015163869A
Oxidation risk evaluation method of separation membrane in separation membrane filtration plant
JP2016190212A
Evaluation method of selective permeable membrane
JP2020006322A
Oxidation risk evaluation method of separation membrane in separation membrane plant and fresh water generator
JP2021006335A
Form support structure
JP2021063335A
Cited By
Chemical type selection method, program therefor, and recording medium
WO2026205454A1
