Method and system for calculating optimal aim point distributions for area targets
An analytical method using an expected damage rate formula and derivative-based optimization addresses the inefficiencies of Monte Carlo simulations by optimizing aiming points for area targets, improving computational efficiency and effectiveness in combat scenarios.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- KR1020260050200
- Authority / Receiving Office
- KR · KR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-03-20
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
- Estimated Expiration
- 2046-03-20
AI Technical Summary
Conventional Monte Carlo simulation methods for calculating weapon effectiveness against area targets are computationally intensive and inefficient, especially in real-time combat scenarios, and fail to account for weapon delivery errors and target characteristics, leading to suboptimal aiming point distributions.
An analytical method using an expected damage rate formula that considers geometric target information, weapon delivery errors, and various attack methods, combined with derivative-based optimization to iteratively adjust aiming points, maximizing the expected damage rate.
This approach reduces computational burden and ammunition consumption while enhancing attack effectiveness by deriving an optimal aiming point distribution that accounts for weapon delivery errors and target characteristics.
Smart Images

Figure 112026033932439-PAT00055_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technology Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a method and system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a weapon to attack a local target, and more specifically, to a method and system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution using an analytical solution that calculates the expected damage rate of multiple weapons. Background Technology
[0003] Weapon effectiveness is an indicator that statistically expresses the probability that a specific weapon can inflict damage exceeding a certain lethality threshold on a specific target. In particular, for area targets, the Expected Damage Difference (EFD) is used as a primary measure. When attacking an area target using multiple weapons, the lethality of each weapon overlaps, making it essential to calculate a composite effectiveness that takes this into account.
[0004] Traditionally, Monte Carlo simulation techniques have been primarily utilized to calculate the effectiveness of multiple weapons. Meanwhile, since tactics must be determined based on highly reliable estimates, the standard specification for damage assessment using Monte Carlo simulation is to meet a 95% confidence level and an error margin of ±0.01. To obtain reliable results that satisfy these criteria, thousands to millions of iterative Monte Carlo simulations are required depending on the nature of the problem (quantity of weapons, number of aiming points, target size, various errors, etc.), which leads to problems such as long computation times and the consumption of massive computational resources. In particular, such time delays act as a critical limitation in urgent combat situations where the optimal aiming point must be determined in real time.
[0005] Furthermore, as weapon allocation methods or attack scenarios become more complex, computational complexity increases exponentially, making it difficult to derive the optimal aiming point distribution by flexibly responding to various variable changes. In particular, Monte Carlo-based approaches can significantly increase the computational burden when applied to optimization problems that require iterative objective function evaluation. Therefore, there is a need for a new approach capable of calculating the optimal aiming point with high accuracy while maximizing computational efficiency. The problem to be solved
[0007] The present invention aims to solve the problems of the aforementioned conventional technology by efficiently deriving the optimal aiming point distribution for a regional target using an analytical expected damage rate formula for three attack methods that reflects target damage caused by the superposition of lethal effects of multiple weapons, average point of impact error, and ballistic error, thereby reducing ammunition consumption and maximizing attack effectiveness.
[0008] The problems that the present invention aims to solve are not limited to those mentioned above, and other unmentioned problems will be clearly understood by a person skilled in the art from the description below. means of solving the problem
[0010] The present invention provides a method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution. In one embodiment, a method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target comprises: defining a delivery accuracy parameter including geometric information of the local target, a damage function of the weapon, and an average impact error and a ballistic error, and setting the number of aiming points and the number of weapons delivered per aiming point; selecting one of various attack methods that reflect the influence of the impact point distribution occurring according to the delivery method of multiple weapons, and calculating the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution using an analytical solution of the expected damage rate (EFD) corresponding to the selected attack method; and calculating an optimal aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate by iteratively adjusting the aiming point position by performing derivative-based optimization with the expected damage rate as the objective function, starting from a randomly generated initial aiming point distribution.
[0011] In one embodiment, various attack methods include a first attack method in which a weapon projected onto each aiming point is independently re-aimed and projected each time; a second attack method in which multiple shots are projected continuously after being aimed at each aiming point once; and a third attack method in which the aiming error of multiple aiming points is deflected in the same direction and magnitude, and the analytical solution of the expected damage rate may be set to correspond to the first attack method, the second attack method, and the third attack method, respectively.
[0012] In one embodiment, derivative-based optimization may include iteratively updating the aiming point position in a direction that increases the expected damage rate using partial derivatives with respect to the aiming point coordinates.
[0013] In one embodiment, after performing derivative-based optimization, the method may further include the step of repeatedly performing optimization on a plurality of different initial aiming point distributions, and determining the result of a plurality of expected damage rate values as the global maximum expected damage rate when the calculated values converge to the same value.
[0014] In one embodiment, the initial aiming point distribution may be randomly generated within an extended area set by considering the boundary of the local target and the transport accuracy parameter.
[0015] In one embodiment, the weapon's damage function may include a Carlton damage function.
[0016] In one embodiment, the method may further include the step of calculating the required amount of ammunition or the number of salvos to achieve the desired effect based on the global maximum expected damage rate.
[0017] In one embodiment, the geometric information of the local target may include the width (Lx) and length (Ly) of the local target, and center coordinates (α, β).
[0018] In addition, the present invention provides a system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution. In one embodiment, a system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target comprises: a processor; and a memory storing instructions executed by the processor, wherein the instructions may cause the processor to perform a method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution. Effects of the invention
[0020] According to the present invention, by utilizing an analytical expected damage rate formula that reflects errors of multiple weapons occurring in various attack methods, the optimal aiming point distribution for a regional target is efficiently derived, thereby providing the advantage of reducing ammunition consumption and maximizing attack effectiveness.
[0021] The effects of the present invention are not limited to the effects described above, and unmentioned effects will be clearly understood by those skilled in the art from this specification and the attached drawings. Brief explanation of the drawing
[0023] Figure 1 shows a conceptual diagram of the traditional aiming point distribution for a local target. FIG. 2 shows a flowchart illustrating a procedure for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target according to one embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 3 shows a conceptual diagram of the aiming point, average impact point, and impact point distribution according to the first attack method of one embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 4 shows a conceptual diagram of the aiming point, average impact point, and impact point distribution according to the second attack method of one embodiment of the present invention. FIG. 5 shows a conceptual diagram of the aiming point, average impact point, and impact point distribution according to the third attack method of one embodiment of the present invention. Figures 6a to 6d each show examples of optimal aiming point distributions calculated according to attack method and carrying accuracy conditions. Specific details for implementing the invention
[0024] The present invention is described in detail through embodiments with reference to the accompanying drawings. These embodiments are merely illustrative, and the scope of the invention should be understood to include all modifications and substitutions within the spirit and technical scope, rather than being limited to the forms described in the specification. Connections of components include both direct connections and connections mediated by intermediate elements. Singular notations in the specification include plurals, and terms such as "include" or "have" merely specify the existence of a particular component and do not preclude the possibility of adding other components. All terms are interpreted in accordance with the relevant technical context and are not interpreted in an overly formal sense unless explicitly defined otherwise.
[0025] The present invention provides a method and system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target by utilizing an analytical solution of the expected damage rate that reflects the influence of the impact point distribution according to the firing method of multiple weapons.
[0026] More specifically, the present invention relates to a method for calculating multiple aiming point positions such that the Expected Fractional Damage (EFD) is maximized by considering the shape and size of the area target, the lethal range of the weapon, and the characteristics of the delivery error occurring during weapon delivery, in a situation where an area target is attacked by multiple weapons.
[0027] The present invention comprises the steps of: defining a delivery accuracy parameter including geometric information of a local target, a damage function of a weapon, and an average point of impact error and a ballistic error, and setting the number of aiming points and the number of weapons delivered per aiming point; selecting one of various attack methods that reflect the superposition of lethal effects on target elements, average point of impact error, and ballistic error occurring according to the delivery method of multiple weapons, and calculating the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution using an analytical solution of the expected damage rate (EFD) corresponding to the selected attack method; and calculating an optimal aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate by iteratively adjusting the aiming point positions by performing derivative-based optimization with the expected damage rate as the objective function, starting from a randomly generated initial aiming point distribution.
[0028] In other words, the present invention analytically calculates the expected damage rate by reflecting the spatial characteristics of local targets, weapon carrying accuracy, and the influence of average impact point error and ballistic error by attack method, and provides an optimal aiming point distribution suitable for actual operating conditions by iteratively optimizing this.
[0029] Figure 1 illustrates a conceptual diagram of traditional aiming points for a local target. As shown in Figure 1, conventionally, multiple aiming points are arranged at generally equal intervals within a rectangular local target so that each aiming point represents a certain area of the local target. For example, in Figure 1, multiple aiming points are arranged to have a fixed positional relationship on a coordinate system including a center point (0,0) based on the width Lx and length Ly of the local target. While this method has the advantage of being simple to calculate and operate, it does not fully account for the fact that in actual weapon delivery, average impact error and ballistic error exist, meaning the weapon often does not reach the intended aiming point accurately. In other words, the conventional method only arranges aiming points based on the geometric shape of the local target and fails to comprehensively consider the lethal range and transport accuracy parameters of the weapon, as well as the influence of errors that vary depending on the attack method. Consequently, an evenly distributed aiming point distribution like that shown in Figure 1 may not match the distribution that maximizes the actual expected damage rate.
[0030] FIG. 2 is a flowchart showing the overall flow of the optimal aiming point calculation procedure according to an embodiment of the present invention. Referring to FIG. 2, first, area target definition, aiming point / weapon count input, damage function definition, and carrying accuracy (average impact error and ballistic error) input are performed.
[0031] In one example, defining a local target is a step of establishing the geometric characteristics of the local target to be attacked. Specifically, in the local target definition step, geometric information indicating the size and location of the local target may be established.
[0032] In one example, geometric information of a local target may include the width Lx and length Ly of the local target, and center coordinates (α, β). This information is used as basic data to determine the physical range of the area to be struck. Additionally, it can be used to form a reference coordinate system for setting the aiming point distribution and calculating the expected damage rate.
[0033] In one example, the input of the number of aiming points / weapons is a step for inputting the number of aiming points set for area target attacks and the quantity of weapons assigned to each aiming point. For example, the total number of aiming points can be set, and the number of weapons ' to be fired at each aiming point can be set. This information is used as an input variable to determine the deployment and firing structure of multiple weapons, and can subsequently be reflected in the process of calculating the expected damage rate and the optimal aiming point distribution.
[0034] In one example, defining the damage function is a step of establishing a damage function to quantitatively model the damage effect caused by weapon delivery. For example, parameters representing the weapon's lethal radius or damage range may be set, and in one embodiment, the Carlton damage function may be used. In this case, the lethal radius R x , R y A damage function including shape factor Do, etc., can be defined, and such a damage function can be used to calculate the probability or degree of damage that individual target elements within a regional target, i.e., specific points, will receive from weapon delivery.
[0035] In one example, the delivery accuracy input is a step of inputting delivery accuracy parameters that represent error characteristics that may occur when a weapon travels from an intended aiming point to an actual point of impact. For example, parameters Σx and Σy representing average impact error and parameters σx and σy representing ballistic error may be input. These delivery accuracy parameters are used to model the impact distribution that occurs during weapon delivery and can be reflected in the process of calculating the analytical solution of the expected damage rate.
[0036] In one example, the analytical solution for the expected damage rate is derived by assuming the spatial distribution of target elements within the area target is a uniform distribution and modeling the weapon delivery error as a normal distribution.
[0037] In FIG. 2, for convenience of explanation, the area target definition, aiming point / weapon count input, damage function definition, and transport accuracy input are listed in a specific order, but the execution order of the present invention is not limited thereto. That is, the area target definition step, aiming point / weapon count input step, damage function definition step, and transport accuracy input step can be performed without being restricted in order to one another, and depending on the system implementation method or user input method, they may be performed in a different order or some steps may be performed simultaneously.
[0038] Afterwards, the attack method selection step can be performed.
[0039] In one example, the attack method selection step is a step of selecting the type of attack method to be applied when attacking a local target using multiple weapons. Specifically, in the attack method selection step, one of three attack methods may be selected by considering the weapon delivery means and method. For example, the attack method may include a first attack method, a second attack method, and a third attack method. The first attack method may be an attack method in which weapons delivered to each aiming point are re-aimed independently of one another; the second attack method may be an attack method in which multiple weapons are continuously delivered after being aimed at the same aiming point once; and the third attack method may be an attack method in which aiming errors occurring for multiple aiming points are deflected in the same direction and magnitude. However, the specific error structure and expected damage rate calculation method for each of these attack methods will be explained in detail with reference to FIGS. 3 to 5 described later.
[0040] In one example, in the first attack method, the number of aiming points does not necessarily have to be equal to the number of launch systems. If the movement or defensive actions of target elements within the area target can be ignored, a scenario is possible in which a single projectile repeatedly aims at each aiming point and attacks each aiming point N′ times. Furthermore, if the movement or defensive actions of target elements cannot be ignored, a scenario is possible in which M projectiles repeatedly aim and fire N′ times toward their respective assigned aiming points. Additionally, a scenario is possible in which N′ launch systems among N (=M×N′) launch systems each aim at and fire at their respective aiming points. Meanwhile, the M aiming points may be distinct points, or two or more may be set to overlap at the same location. In the second attack method as well, the number of aiming points does not necessarily have to be equal to the number of launch systems. If the movement or defensive actions of target elements can be ignored, a scenario is possible in which a single projectile aims at each aiming point once in sequence and then fires N′ times at each aiming point. Additionally, in cases where the movement or defensive actions of target elements cannot be ignored, a scenario is possible in which M projectiles aim once at their respective assigned aiming points and fire N′ times. The third attack method can basically be applied to a scenario where M projectiles fire in a salvo, and M aiming points—identical to the number of launch systems—can be considered; in this case, the M aiming points may be in different locations or may share the same location.
[0041] After the attack method is selected, the simulation setup step can be performed.
[0042] In one example, the simulation setup step is the step of setting iterative calculation conditions to explore the optimal aiming point distribution. For example, the number of sets to be used in the simulation
[0043] and the number of iterations performed in each set, which is the number of times per set. These can be configured. These simulation settings can be used as parameters to determine the search range and the number of iterations during the subsequent aiming point optimization process. More specifically, the number of iterations per set may refer to the number of iterations for generating random initial aiming point distributions within a single simulation set and exploring the local maximum expected damage rate by performing derivative-based optimization starting from each initial aiming point distribution. Additionally, the number of simulation sets may refer to the number of external iterations for performing the above set-unit iteration process multiple times, and can be used to more stably search for the aiming point distribution corresponding to the global maximum expected damage rate by comparing the maximum expected damage rate results calculated from each set.
[0044] Next, as illustrated in the flowchart on the right side of FIG. 2, a set-based simulation process can be performed. Specifically, first, The nth set simulation start step can be performed. Here represents the set currently being executed out of the total simulation sets, and the number of sets set. It can be performed repeatedly while increasing within the following range.
[0045] Afterwards, within each set A step for generating the nth initial aiming point set may be performed. In this step, an initial aiming point distribution may be generated randomly within or around the local target. This initial aiming point set can be used as a starting point for subsequent optimization calculations.
[0046] In one example, the initial aiming point may be randomly generated within an extended area set considering the boundaries of the local target and the transport accuracy parameter. For example, regarding the direction of deviation, The section can be set, and regarding the direction of the intersection A range can be set, and M initial aiming points can be randomly selected within the area thus set. By setting such an extended area, aiming points that are outside the physical range of the area target can also be included as search targets within a certain range, thereby enabling the finding of a more effective optimal aiming point distribution that takes into account actual carrying error and lethal radius.
[0047] When an initial set of aiming points is generated, a step for calculating the local maximum expected damage rate (EFD) and the corresponding set of aiming points may be performed. In this step, the expected damage rate is calculated using the currently generated initial set of aiming points as a starting point, and derivative-based optimization is performed with the expected damage rate as the objective function to iteratively adjust the aiming point positions in the direction of increasing the expected damage rate. As a result, a local maximum expected damage rate (local maximum EFD) converging from the corresponding initial set of aiming points and the corresponding aiming point distribution can be calculated. In one example, the aiming point positions can be updated using the slope or partial derivative of the expected damage rate, which is the objective function, in a 2M-dimensional variable space corresponding to the number of aiming point coordinates, and accordingly, the local maximum can be explored by performing iterative calculations for each initial set of aiming points until the expected damage rate no longer increases significantly.
[0048] since, The number of repetitions set It is possible to determine whether it is less than or equal to. If ≤ In this case, a new set of initial aiming points can be regenerated to repeat the same procedure. On the other hand, > In such cases, the aiming point set having the maximum expected damage rate among the multiple results generated within the corresponding set may be selected. Once the calculation for each set is completed in this manner, Total number of sets It is possible to determine whether it is less than or equal to. If ≤ In this case, the same simulation procedure can be repeated for the next set. On the other hand, > In this case, the aiming point set with the maximum expected damage rate among the results calculated from the entire set can be finally selected.
[0049] The present invention performs iterative optimization calculations based on a plurality of initial aiming point distributions and determines the aiming point distribution that yields the maximum expected damage rate as the final optimal solution. This iterative optimization using a multi-starting-point approach overcomes the limitation of convergence to a local optimum depending on specific initial conditions and enables the search for a global optimum more stably.
[0050] Specifically, within individual sets After first selecting the maximum expected damage rate among the results of the repeated cycles, again The results between sets are compared to select the aiming point distribution that maximizes the overall expected damage rate as the candidate optimal solution.
[0051] In addition, multiple optimization results derived from different initial conditions are compared and analyzed. In one embodiment, if the calculated expected damage rate values are identical or converge to a constant value within a set tolerance range, this is determined as the Global Maximum Expected Damage Rate (Global Maximum EFD). By mitigating the local maximum collapse problem through this comparative verification process, the aiming point distribution corresponding to the global optimal solution can be reliably derived.
[0052] Furthermore, in one embodiment of the present invention, the required amount of ammunition or the number of salvos to achieve the desired effect can be calculated based on the global maximum expected damage rate calculated as above. For example, if a specific damage level or target effect is set, the quantity of weapons or the number of shots required to achieve the target effect can be calculated using the global maximum expected damage rate. Through this, the present invention does not stop at merely calculating the optimal aiming point distribution, but can provide quantitative information that can be utilized in establishing actual weapon operation plans or firing plans. That is, the present invention does not stop at simply searching for aiming point locations, but can be extended to calculate the number of salvos or the required amount of ammunition, which are practical operational indicators, based on the finally derived global maximum expected damage rate and optimal aiming point distribution.
[0053] As such, the present invention calculates the expected damage rate by comprehensively considering geometric information of local targets, the lethal range of weapons, transport accuracy parameters including average impact error and ballistic error, the number of aiming points and the number of weapons per aiming point, and error characteristics according to the attack method, and can calculate an optimal aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate by iteratively performing derivative-based optimization starting from a random initial aiming point distribution. Furthermore, by performing iterative optimization on multiple initial aiming point distributions and comparing the results, an aiming point distribution corresponding to the global maximum expected damage rate can be stably derived, and based on this, the amount of ammunition required or the number of salvos can be calculated.
[0054] FIG. 3 is a conceptual diagram for explaining a first attack method according to an embodiment of the present invention, FIG. 4 is a conceptual diagram for explaining a second attack method according to an embodiment of the present invention, and FIG. 5 is a conceptual diagram for explaining a third attack method according to an embodiment of the present invention. In one example, the first attack method is a method of independently re-aiming and firing a weapon fired at each aiming point each time. The second attack method is a method of firing multiple shots in succession after aiming at each aiming point once. The third attack method is a method in which the aiming error of multiple aiming points is biased in the same direction and magnitude. The analytical solution of the expected damage rate is individually set to reflect the influence of the impact point distribution in each of these first attack method, second attack method, and third attack method. In one example, the expected damage rates corresponding to the first attack method, second attack method, and third attack method, respectively, can be expressed by Equation 1, Equation 2, and Equation 3 described below, respectively.
[0055] Referring to FIG. 3, the local target is represented as an area with width Lx and length Ly, and its center coordinates are denoted as (α, β). Additionally, there are multiple aiming points inside the local target. This can be set. Here It refers to the nth aiming point, and multiple weapons can be fired targeting that aiming point. In Fig. 3 It refers to the actual point of impact of the th weapon, and represents the mean point of impact or reference point reflecting the aiming error for weapons fired toward the i-th aiming point. Additionally, P may represent any target element within a region target.
[0056] The first attack method is characterized by the fact that re-aiming is performed independently each time a weapon is launched. That is, the same aiming point Even when multiple weapons are fired at a given target, the aiming process of each weapon can be performed independently of one another; accordingly, the average impact point error and ballistic error of each weapon can also be modeled as independent random variables. Therefore, as illustrated in FIG. 3, multiple weapon impact points targeting the same aiming point These form mutually independent distributions. This characteristic is an attack method that reflects a situation where aiming is performed anew with every shot during weapon operation. In one example, the first attack method can be implemented by distributing N weapons to M aiming points and delivering N′ (=N / M) rounds to each aiming point. Additionally, this can correspond to cases where an aircraft drops weapons one by one toward each aiming point and repeats this within a sortie, or where field artillery re-aims toward the assigned aiming point with every shot while in a special sheaf state.
[0057] Referring to Fig. 4, in the second attack method as well, the geometric structure of the area target and the aiming point , impact point , average impact point , and the target element P can be defined similarly to Fig. 3. However, the second attack method is characterized by firing multiple rounds of weapons continuously after aiming once at each aiming point. That is, the same aiming point When multiple weapons are fired consecutively, these weapons share the same aiming reference. Therefore, the impact point of each weapon can be determined by the error arising from the same aiming reference, and consequently, a certain correlation may exist between weapons fired from the same aiming point. In other words, the second attack method has a structure where the error of each weapon does not occur completely independently but is influenced by the same aiming reference. In one example, the second attack method can be implemented in a form where M firing systems aim at a specific aiming point only once and then fire N′ rounds consecutively. In this case, the N′ rounds of weapons fired at a specific aiming point have the average impact point at that time. They become distributed in the surrounding area. Additionally, this can correspond to cases where M aircraft each aim at a target point and drop N′ weapons at once, or where each gun in a battery aims at a designated target point once and then fires N′ rounds of ammunition in a batch.
[0058] Referring to Fig. 5, the structure of the area target and the aiming point in the third attack method as well , impact point , average impact point The basic concepts are the same as the attack methods explained earlier. However, the third attack method is characterized by the aiming error occurring across multiple aiming points being deflected in the same direction and magnitude.
[0059] Specifically, in the third attack method, a deviation error in the same direction may occur due to the weapon operation system or external environmental factors, and this deviation error may commonly affect multiple aiming points. In Figure 5, this deviation error appears in the μ direction indicated by the arrow, and accordingly, the impact point of the weapon fired from each aiming point tends to move in the same direction. Therefore, in the third attack method, the error occurring at each aiming point is not independent of one another but can be modeled as a structure containing a common deviation component.
[0060] In one example, the third attack method may take the form of M launchers firing N′ rounds each, similar to the second attack method, but the aiming of each launcher may be integratedly controlled by a central fire control computer system. As a result, aiming errors occurring at all aiming points may be deflected in the same direction and magnitude, and all average impact points is the corresponding aiming point It can be equally biased from. That is, each average impact point = It can be expressed as a relationship of + μ. In addition, this can correspond to parallel sheaf firing, in which a central fire control computer system precisely coordinates all guns in a battery to fire in the same direction and with the same charge.
[0061] As such, the present invention may consider attack methods having different impact point distributions, such as a first attack method, a second attack method, and a third attack method, and can calculate the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution using the analytical solution of the expected damage rate corresponding to each attack method. Furthermore, as previously explained, by performing derivative-based optimization with this expected damage rate as the objective function, an optimal aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate can be calculated. In addition, the analytical solution of the expected damage rate for each of the above attack methods can be calculated using the size of the area target, weapon lethal radius, number of weapons, number of aiming points, aiming point location, average impact point error, and ballistic error as inputs.
[0062] As such, the structure of weapon delivery error generation may vary depending on each attack method, and accordingly, the formula for calculating the Expected Fractional Damage (EFD) for area targets may also be defined differently. In this invention, the following mathematical model may be applied to analytically calculate the expected damage corresponding to each attack method.
[0063] First, in this invention, it can be assumed that target elements within a local target are spatially uniformly distributed, and errors occurring during the weapon delivery process can be modeled as a normal distribution including average impact point error and ballistic error. Under these assumptions, the expected damage rate for each attack method can be calculated in an analytical form.
[0064] In one example, the analytical solution of the expected damage rate can be expressed in the form of a finite binomial-type combinatorial expansion whose sign and magnitude oscillate until convergence, and the number of terms to be calculated can increase rapidly as the number of aiming points and weapons increases. Nevertheless, in actual operational range, numerically calculating the expected damage rate using such an analytical solution can be more accurate and faster than probabilistic simulation, and can be utilized more efficiently, particularly in the iterative optimization process of determining the optimal aiming point.
[0065] In one example, the expected damage rate for the first attack method can be expressed as follows in Equation 1.
[0066] Mathematical formula 1:
[0067]
[0069] Here,
[0070]
[0071]
[0073] Here, the above mathematical formula 1 represents the expected damage rate reflecting a situation where re-aiming is performed independently each time a weapon is fired, and corresponds to a case where the error of each weapon fired at the same aiming point is modeled as an independent random variable.
[0074] In one example, the expected damage rate for the second attack method can be expressed as follows in Equation 2.
[0075] Mathematical formula 2:
[0076] Here,
[0077]
[0078]
[0079]
[0080] The above mathematical formula 2 represents the expected damage rate reflecting a situation in which multiple weapons are fired continuously after being aimed once at each aiming point. In this case, since multiple weapons fired at the same aiming point share the same aiming standard, the impact distribution of each weapon can be calculated by reflecting the error characteristics arising from the same aiming standard.
[0081] In one example, the expected damage rate for the third attack method can be expressed as follows in Equation 3.
[0082] Mathematical formula 3:
[0083] Here,
[0084]
[0085]
[0087] The above mathematical formula 3 represents the expected damage rate reflecting a situation where aiming errors occurring at multiple aiming points are biased in the same direction and magnitude. In this case, the errors for each aiming point are not independent of one another but may include a common bias component, and such bias errors can be reflected in the calculation of the expected damage rate.
[0088] Here, the meaning of each variable and symbol used in mathematical formulas 1 to 3 is as shown in Table 1 and Table 2 below.
[0089] [Table 1]
[0090]
[0092] [Table 2]
[0093]
[0095] As such, in the present invention, the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution can be calculated by utilizing an analytical solution of the expected damage rate that considers the influence of different impact point distributions depending on the attack method, and an aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate can be calculated through derivative-based optimization with the expected damage rate as the objective function.
[0096] According to one embodiment, the method for calculating the optimal aiming point distribution described above may be performed by a computer system. Such a system may include a processor and memory for calculating the optimal aiming point distribution for a local target. The memory may store instructions for receiving inputs such as geometric information of the local target, lethal range of the weapon, average impact error, and ballistic error, setting the number of aiming points and the number of weapons delivered per aiming point, calculating the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution using an analytical solution of the expected damage rate corresponding to the attack method, and calculating an aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate by performing derivative-based optimization with this as the objective function. By executing the instructions stored in the memory, the processor may perform a series of computational processes such as generating an initial aiming point distribution, calculating the expected damage rate, iteratively updating the aiming point positions, and deriving the optimal aiming point distribution. Such systems can be implemented in computer devices, tactical planning systems, or weapon operation analysis systems, and can be utilized to establish optimal attack tactics against area targets and calculate ammunition requirements.
[0097] FIG. 6 is a diagram illustrating an example of an optimal aiming point distribution according to attack method and transport accuracy conditions calculated through the implementation of the present invention. In FIG. 6, for all examples, the area target size is set to Lx=8.0 and Ly=6.0, and the weapon's lethal radius is set to Rx=1.0 and Ry=0.6. Additionally, for comparison purposes, a multiple of the reference value is applied to the transport accuracy. The reference average impact point error is Σx=0.114 and Σy=0.248, and the reference ballistic error is
[0098] σx=0.003 and σy=0.059. In each row of Fig. 6, the results of the optimal aiming point distribution calculated by applying the first attack method, the second attack method, and the third attack method in order from left to right are shown.
[0099] Figure 6a shows the optimal aiming point distribution when the standard carrying accuracy is applied. In this case, since the weapon carrying accuracy is relatively high, the optimal aiming point distribution according to each attack method appears in a relatively balanced form, and the aiming points tend to be distributed relatively evenly within the area target. However, the exact location of the aiming points may differ depending on the attack method, which is due to differences in the aiming error structure and weapon delivery method assumed in each attack method.
[0100] Figure 6b shows the optimal aiming point distribution when four times the standard carrying accuracy is applied. As the carrying accuracy decreases below the standard, the influence of weapon delivery error increases, and accordingly, the optimal aiming point distribution also differs from the distribution under the standard carrying accuracy condition. In particular, in some attack methods, the aiming point is characterized by moving toward the center of the area target or being repositioned at different intervals.
[0101] Figure 6c shows the optimal aiming point distribution when applying 8 times the standard carrying accuracy. In this case, as the projectile error becomes larger, the aiming point distribution exhibits a pattern that differs evenly from the existing uniform distribution. In particular, for some attack methods, aiming points may be arranged along a specific axis or some aiming points may be concentrated in positions close to each other. These results demonstrate that as the projectile error increases, the aiming point placement strategy to maximize the expected damage rate can differ significantly from the existing uniform distribution.
[0102] Figure 6d shows the optimal aiming point distribution when 30 times the standard carrying accuracy is applied. This corresponds to a situation where the carrying accuracy is very low, and the optimal aiming point distribution differs significantly from the distribution under standard carrying accuracy conditions. In particular, in some attack methods, the aiming points appear to be concentrated at the center of the area target or shift significantly in a specific direction. These results demonstrate that when weapon carrying accuracy is significantly reduced, the existing strategy of evenly distributing aiming points may no longer be optimal.
[0103] As such, FIGS. 6a to 6d show that the optimal aiming point distribution can vary depending on changes in transport accuracy, and it can be confirmed that by using the method proposed in the present invention, an aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate can be effectively calculated according to the attack method and transport accuracy conditions. In addition, the results of FIG. 6 show that the conventional uniform aiming point placement method is not optimal under all transport accuracy conditions, and indicate that the method of the present invention can provide a more effective aiming point placement under various operating conditions.
[0104] According to the present invention, there is an advantage in efficiently calculating the optimal aiming point distribution for a local target by utilizing an analytical solution of the expected damage rate that considers the independence or dependence of errors according to the delivery method of multiple weapons. Furthermore, by applying a derivative-based optimization technique, the aiming point placement that maximizes the expected damage rate can be rapidly identified, and there is an advantage in rationally determining the optimal attack tactics and ammunition requirements for various transport accuracy conditions and attack methods.
[0105] Although preferred embodiments of the present invention have been described above, the embodiments disclosed in the present invention are intended only to illustrate, not to limit, the technical scope of the present invention. Accordingly, the technical scope of the present invention includes not only each disclosed embodiment but also combinations of the disclosed embodiments, and furthermore, the scope of the technical scope of the present invention is not limited by such embodiments. In addition, a person skilled in the art to which the present invention pertains can make numerous changes and modifications to the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the appended claims, and all such appropriate changes and modifications should be deemed to fall within the scope of the present invention as equivalents.
Claims
Claim 1 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target, comprising: a step of defining a delivery accuracy parameter including geometric information of the local target, a damage function of a weapon, and an average impact error and ballistic error, and setting the number of aiming points and the number of weapons delivered per aiming point; a step of selecting one of various attack methods that reflect the influence of the impact point distribution occurring according to the delivery method of multiple weapons, and calculating the expected damage rate for a given aiming point distribution using an analytical solution of the expected damage rate (EFD) corresponding to the selected attack method; and a step of calculating an optimal aiming point distribution that maximizes the expected damage rate by iteratively adjusting the aiming point positions by performing derivative-based optimization with the expected damage rate as the objective function, starting from a randomly generated initial aiming point distribution. Claim 2 In claim 1, the various attack methods include a first attack method in which a weapon to be fired at each aiming point is independently re-aimed and fired each time; a second attack method in which multiple shots are fired continuously after being aimed at each aiming point once; and a third attack method in which the aiming error of multiple aiming points is deflected in the same direction and magnitude, and the analytical solution of the expected damage rate is set to correspond to the first attack method, the second attack method, and the third attack method, respectively, a method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution. Claim 3 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution according to claim 1, wherein the derivative-based optimization includes iteratively updating the aiming point position in a direction in which the expected damage rate increases using partial derivative values with respect to the aiming point coordinates. Claim 4 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution according to claim 1, further comprising the step of, after performing the derivative-based optimization, repeating the optimization for a plurality of different initial aiming point distributions, and determining the plurality of calculated expected damage rate values as the global maximum expected damage rate when they converge to the same value. Claim 5 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution, wherein, in claim 1, the initial aiming point distribution is randomly generated within an extended area set considering the boundary of a local target and a transport accuracy parameter. Claim 6 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution, wherein the damage function of the weapon in claim 1 includes a Carlton damage function. Claim 7 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution, further comprising the step of calculating the amount of ammunition required or the number of volleys to achieve the desired effect based on the above-mentioned global maximum expected damage rate in paragraph 4. Claim 8 A method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution according to claim 1, wherein the geometric information of the area target includes the width (Lx) and length (Ly) of the area target and center coordinates (α, β). Claim 9 A system for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution for a local target, comprising: a processor; and a memory storing instructions executed by said processor, wherein the instructions cause said processor to perform a method for calculating an optimal aiming point distribution according to any one of claims 1 to 8.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
How to optimize the explosion point
JP2022551575A
Method for evaluating weapon effectiveness on area target of weapons
KR101355932B1
Monte Carlo simulation-based optimal aiming point calculation method, system and computer readable recording medium
KR1020220111348A
Appratus and method for aiming point selection using scattering center extraction results
KR102136270B1
