Combustion facility system, and information processing method
The combustion equipment system and information processing method generate Pareto solutions for control parameters using a hierarchical analysis method, addressing the challenge of determining optimal parameters for incineration facilities, thereby improving efficiency and automation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/JP2024/017425
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-02
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies face challenges in appropriately determining parameters related to combustion equipment, such as incineration facilities, which affects their efficiency and control.
A combustion equipment system and information processing method that generate Pareto solutions for control parameters using a hierarchical analysis method based on indicators like CO and NOx generation, temperature, and other combustion state metrics, allowing for the determination of optimal control parameters.
Enables the appropriate determination of control parameters for combustion equipment, enhancing operational efficiency and automation by considering multiple objectives and seasonal changes in fuel properties.
Smart Images

Figure JP2024017425_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Combustion equipment system and information processing method
[0001] This application claims priority to Japanese Patent Application No. 2023-91600, filed on June 2, 2023, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
[0002] Patent Document 1 discloses a decision-making support device used to determine the level of demand for the renewal of automatic control equipment in a building, which includes a display means for displaying on a screen a hierarchical structure formed by setting a final goal at the top level, listing multiple evaluation criteria for solving a problem or selecting an alternative below that and connecting them with lines to the final goal, and listing multiple alternatives below that and connecting them with lines to the evaluation criteria; input means for an operator to input comparison values obtained by pairwise comparison of each evaluation criterion in the hierarchical structure displayed on the screen, names of alternatives evaluated by quantitative values or absolute evaluation values, and their quantitative values or absolute evaluation values; and calculation processing means for calculating weights based on the pairwise comparison and absolute evaluation or quantitative values of each evaluation criterion based on the data input from the input means, and performing an arithmetic process to determine the importance of each alternative in the hierarchical structure by adding up the weights of all the evaluation criteria to obtain an overall weight, and outputting the results.
[0003] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 9-69051
[0004] However, with the technique described in Patent Document 1, it is difficult to appropriately determine parameters related to the combustion equipment.
[0005] The present disclosure has been made to solve the above-mentioned problems, and aims to provide a system for combustion equipment and an information processing method that make it possible to appropriately determine parameters related to the combustion equipment.
[0006] In order to solve the above problems, the system for combustion equipment according to the present disclosure includes a Pareto solution generation unit that generates a plurality of Pareto solutions related to control parameters of the combustion equipment based on a model of the combustion equipment, using a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions, and a preferred solution determination unit that determines one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying an analytical hierarchy process to the plurality of Pareto solutions generated by the Pareto solution generation unit.
[0007] In order to solve the above problem, the information processing method disclosed herein includes one or more computers generating a plurality of Pareto solutions related to control parameters of the combustion equipment based on a model of the combustion equipment, using a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions, and determining one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying an analytical hierarchy process to the generated plurality of Pareto solutions.
[0008] According to the combustion equipment system and information processing method of the present disclosure, it becomes possible to appropriately determine parameters related to the combustion equipment.
[0009] 1 is a diagram showing the overall configuration of a combustion facility according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure; FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of an incineration facility according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure; FIG. 3 is a diagram for explaining an overview of a plant model according to a first embodiment of the present disclosure; 2 1 is a diagram showing the relationship between the O concentration and the CO concentration of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. 2 1 is a diagram showing the relationship between the O concentration and the NOx concentration of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. 2FIG. 1 is a diagram for explaining a concentration change pattern. FIG. 2 is a diagram for explaining a Pareto solution related to model parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 3 is a diagram illustrating the flow of the Analytic Hierarchy Process used in the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 4 is a diagram for explaining a hierarchical structure related to derivation of optimal model parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 5 is a diagram conceptually illustrating processing of paired comparison between model parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 6 is a diagram for explaining a Pareto solution related to control parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 7 is a diagram for explaining a hierarchical structure related to derivation of optimal control parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 8 is a diagram illustrating an example of a result of paired comparison between evaluation criteria for control parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 9 is a diagram conceptually illustrating processing of paired comparison between control parameters of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 10 is a diagram illustrating an example of a control parameter set of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 11 is a flowchart illustrating the flow of information processing of the first embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 12 is a block diagram illustrating the functional configuration of an incineration facility of a second embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 13 is a flowchart illustrating the flow of information processing of the second embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 14 is a hardware configuration diagram illustrating the configuration of a computer of an embodiment of the present disclosure.
[0010] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. In the following description, components having the same or similar functions will be assigned the same reference numerals. Duplicate descriptions of those components may be omitted. In this disclosure, "based on XX" means "based on at least XX" and may include cases where the component is based on another element in addition to XX. Furthermore, "based on XX" is not limited to cases where XX is directly used, but may also include cases where XX has been calculated or processed. In this disclosure, "XX or YY" is not limited to cases where either XX or YY is used, but may include cases where both XX and YY are used. This also applies when there are three or more optional elements. "XX" and "YY" are arbitrary elements (e.g., arbitrary information).
[0011] In this application, "acquire" is not limited to actively acquiring by sending a transmission request, but may also include passively receiving information transmitted from another device. Furthermore, "acquire" is not limited to directly acquiring target information (information to be acquired) from outside, but may also include generating and acquiring target information by performing calculations or processing on information acquired from outside.
[0012] (First embodiment) <1. Overall configuration of incineration facility> Fig. 1 is a diagram showing the overall configuration of combustion facility 1 according to the first embodiment. The combustion facility 1 is an incineration facility for incinerating materials G, such as municipal waste, industrial waste, or biomass. For ease of explanation, "materials to be incinerated" may be referred to as "waste" below. The combustion facility 1 is, for example, a stoker furnace. Note that the combustion facility 1 is not limited to a stoker furnace and may be another type of combustion facility. In this embodiment, the combustion facility 1 includes, for example, an incinerator 2, a heat recovery boiler 3, a cooling tower 4, a dust collector 5, a flue 6, a chimney 7, and a control device 100.
[0013] The incinerator 2 is a furnace that combusts materials G to be incinerated that have been placed in a hopper 21, which will be described later, while transporting them. Exhaust gas is generated in the incinerator 2 as the materials G to be incinerated are burned inside the incinerator 2. The generated exhaust gas is sent to a heat recovery boiler 3 located at the top of the incinerator 2. The heat recovery boiler 3 heats water and generates steam by exchanging heat between the exhaust gas generated in the incinerator 2 and water. The exhaust gas that passes through the heat recovery boiler 3 is cooled in a cooling tower 4 and then sent to a dust collector 5. After soot and dust are removed from the exhaust gas in the dust collector 5, it is discharged into the atmosphere through a flue 6 and a chimney 7.
[0014] 2. Incinerator Next, a detailed description will be given of the incinerator 2. The incinerator 2 has, for example, a supply mechanism 20, a furnace body 30, a stoker 40, a discharge chute 43, a plurality of wind boxes 50, a furnace 60, and a blower mechanism 70.
[0015] 2.1 Supply Mechanism The supply mechanism 20 is a mechanism that temporarily stores the materials G to be incinerated that have been transported by, for example, a crane (not shown), and sequentially supplies the temporarily stored materials G to the treatment space V of the furnace body 30, which will be described later. The supply mechanism 20 has, for example, a hopper 21, a feeder 22, an extrusion device 23 (see FIG. 2), and a moisture meter 24.
[0016] (Hopper) The hopper 21 is a storage section provided to supply the materials to be incinerated G into the furnace body 30. The hopper 21 has an inlet section for introducing the materials to be incinerated G and an outlet section that leads to the processing space V of the furnace body 30, which will be described later. The materials to be incinerated G are introduced into the hopper 21 after being transported by a crane.
[0017] (Feeder) The feeder 22 is a device for pushing the materials G to be incinerated in the hopper 21 toward the treatment space V of the furnace body 30. The feeder 22 is provided at the bottom of the hopper 21. The feeder 22 is formed, for example, in the shape of a plate that fits along the bottom of the hopper 21. The feeder 22 is driven by the extrusion device 23 and is capable of reciprocating movement in the direction from the hopper 21 toward the treatment space V of the furnace body 30. The feeder 22 is driven by the extrusion device 23 and pushes the materials G to be incinerated stored inside the hopper 21 toward the treatment space V of the furnace body 30.
[0018] (Moisture Meter) The moisture meter 24 is a meter that detects information (e.g., moisture percentage or moisture amount) related to the moisture content of the incineration material G placed in the hopper 21. For example, the moisture meter 24 includes an irradiation unit, a detection unit, and an analysis unit, all of which are provided in the hopper 21. The irradiation unit irradiates electromagnetic waves of a predetermined frequency band onto the incineration material G piled up in the hopper 21. The detection unit receives the electromagnetic waves irradiated from the irradiation unit and transmitted through or reflected by the incineration material G. The analysis unit pre-stores correlation information indicating the relationship between the moisture percentage and changes in the electromagnetic wave characteristics (e.g., changes in amplitude or phase). The analysis unit detects the moisture percentage of the incineration material G based on the correlation information and the changes in the electromagnetic wave characteristics between the irradiation unit and the detection unit. The moisture meter 24 may also detect the moisture content of the incineration material G based on the moisture percentage and the weight of the incineration material G placed in the hopper 21.
[0019] 2.2 Furnace Body The furnace body 30 is located adjacent to the hopper 21 and is equipment that combusts the incineration material G while transporting it. Hereinafter, the transport direction of the incineration material G in the combustion equipment 1 will be referred to as the "transport direction D." The furnace body 30 has, from upstream to downstream in the transport direction D, a drying stage 30a, a combustion stage 30b, and a post-combustion stage 30c, in this order. The drying stage 30a is located upstream of the combustion stage 30b and the post-combustion stage 30c, and is a region in which the incineration material G supplied from the hopper 21 is dried prior to combustion on the stoker 40. The combustion stage 30b and the post-combustion stage 30c are regions in which the incineration material G that has passed through the drying stage 30a and is dried is combusted on the stoker 40. In the combustion stage 30b, diffusion combustion occurs due to pyrolysis gases generated from the incineration material G, generating a flame F. In the post-combustion stage 30c, the combustion of fixed carbon occurs after the diffusion combustion of the incineration material G, so that the flame F is not generated.
[0020] 2.3 Stoker The stoker 40 includes multiple grates 41 and a grate drive device 42 (see FIG. 2). The multiple grates 41 form a stoker surface 40a, which is the bottom surface of the furnace body 30. The material to be incinerated G is supplied in layers to the stoker surface 40a by the supply mechanism 20. The stoker surface 40a is provided across the drying stage 30a, combustion stage 30b, and post-combustion stage 30c described above. The multiple grates 41 include a fixed grate and a movable grate. The fixed grate is fixed to the upper surface of the wind box 50, which will be described later. The movable grate moves back and forth at a constant speed along the transport direction D, stirring and mixing the material to be incinerated G located on the movable grate and the fixed grate (on the stoker surface 40a) while transporting it downstream.
[0021] <2.4 Discharge Chute> The discharge chute 43 is a device that drops the incineration material G that has been burned and turned into ash into an ash extrusion device located below the furnace body 30. The discharge chute 43 is provided at the end of the furnace body 30.
[0022] <2.5 Wind Boxes> A plurality of wind boxes 50 are provided below the stoker 40 and supply primary air for combustion to the inside of the furnace body 30 through the stoker 40. The primary air is an example of "combustion air." In this embodiment, the plurality of wind boxes 50 are arranged side by side in the conveying direction D corresponding to, for example, the plurality of fire grates 41.
[0023] <2.6 Furnace> The furnace 60 extends upward from the top of the furnace body 30. The furnace 60 is disposed above the grate 41, and post-combustion gas flows into the furnace 60. In other words, the exhaust gas generated by the combustion of the materials G to be incinerated in the furnace body 30 flows through the furnace 60 to the heat recovery boiler 3.
[0024] 2.7 Blower Mechanism The blower mechanism 70 supplies combustion air to the inside of the furnace body 30 and the furnace 60. The blower mechanism 70 has, for example, a blower 71, a primary air line 72, an air preheater 73, a secondary air line 74, and a damper 75.
[0025] The blower 71 is a forced draft blower that pressurizes and sends combustion air into the furnace body 30 and the furnace 60. The blower 71 includes, for example, a first blower 71A and a second blower 71B. The first blower 71A pressurizes and sends primary air for combustion into the furnace body 30 (e.g., the treatment space V) through the primary air line 72 and the multiple air boxes 50. Meanwhile, the second blower 71B pressurizes and sends secondary air for combustion into the furnace 60 through the secondary air line 74. The secondary air is another example of "combustion air."
[0026] The primary air line 72 connects the first blower 71A and the multiple wind boxes 50. One or more (e.g., multiple) primary air dampers 75A are provided along the primary air line 72. In this embodiment, the multiple primary air dampers 75A are provided in one-to-one correspondence with the multiple wind boxes 50. The primary air dampers 75A change the flow rate of primary air supplied into the furnace body 30 from the wind box 50 corresponding to the primary air damper 75A depending on the opening degree of the primary air damper 75A.
[0027] The air preheater 73 is a heat exchanger that preheats the primary air compressed and sent from the first blower 71 A. For example, the air preheater 73 is provided midway along the primary air line 72.
[0028] The secondary air line 74 connects the second blower 71B and the furnace 60. The secondary air line 74 has a supply port that opens into the wall of the furnace 60 and supplies secondary air to the space (exhaust gas flow path) within the furnace 60. One or more (e.g., multiple) secondary air dampers 75B are provided along the secondary air line 74. The secondary air dampers 75B change the flow rate of secondary air supplied into the furnace 60 from the supply port corresponding to the secondary air damper 75B depending on the opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B. For ease of explanation, the primary air damper 75A and the secondary air damper 75B will hereinafter be collectively referred to as "damper 75."
[0029] <3. Various Sensors> Next, various sensors provided in the combustion equipment 1 will be described.
[0030] <3.1 Radiation Temperature Sensor> The radiation temperature sensor (infrared temperature sensor) 81 is provided, for example, inside the furnace 60 and detects the temperature inside the furnace 60. Alternatively / in addition to this, the radiation temperature sensor 81 may be provided inside the heat recovery steam generator 3 and detect the temperature inside the heat recovery steam generator 3.
[0031] 3.2 Steam flow rate sensor Steam flow rate sensor 82 is provided midway through a pipe in heat recovery boiler 3 and detects the flow rate of steam flowing through the pipe. For example, steam flow rate sensor 82 includes a first steam flow rate sensor 82A that detects the flow rate of steam passing through the primary attemperator (primary superheater attemperator flow rate) and a second steam flow rate sensor 82B that detects the flow rate of steam passing through the secondary attemperator (secondary superheater attemperator flow rate). In the following description, "detection result of steam flow rate sensor 82" includes, for example, the detection result of first steam flow rate sensor 82A and the detection result of second steam flow rate sensor 82B.
[0032] 3.3 Gas Sensor The gas sensor 83 is provided, for example, in the flue 6, and detects the oxygen concentration, carbon monoxide concentration, carbon dioxide concentration, or NOx concentration contained in the exhaust gas flowing through the flue 6. Note that the gas sensor 83 may be provided in the furnace 60, the heat recovery boiler 3, the cooling tower 4, the dust collector 5, the chimney 7, or the like, instead of or in addition to the flue 6.
[0033] 3.4 External Environment Sensor The external environment sensor 84 (see FIG. 2 ) is exposed to the outside of the combustion equipment 1, for example, and detects values related to the environment in which the combustion equipment 1 is installed (for example, values that fluctuate with seasonal changes). The external environment sensor 84 is, for example, a temperature sensor that detects the outside air temperature, but is not limited to this. The external environment sensor 84 may be any sensor that can detect values that fluctuate with seasonal changes. For example, the moisture meter 24 may be an example of the external environment sensor 84.
[0034] 4. Control Device Next, the control device 100 will be described. FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the incineration facility 1. The control device 100 comprehensively controls the incineration facility 1. In this embodiment, the control device 100 uses the analytical hierarchy process to identify a mathematical model simulating the combustion facility 1 and determine control parameters, and then performs combustion control based on the determined control parameters. In this disclosure, "combustion control" broadly refers to control of the combustion of the materials G to be incinerated, and refers to control of, for example, one or more of the supply amount of the materials G to be incinerated (e.g., the movement speed of the feeder 22), the conveying speed of the materials G to be incinerated (e.g., the drive speed of the grate 41), the flow rate of primary air, the amount of primary air allocated to the multiple wind boxes 50, the preheating temperature of the primary air, the flow rate of secondary air, and the amount of secondary air allocated to the multiple supply ports of the furnace 60.
[0035] In this embodiment, the control device 100 includes, for example, an information acquisition unit 110, a monitoring unit 120, a model identification unit 130, a control parameter determination unit 140, a control unit 150, and a storage unit 160. Devices to be controlled by the control unit 150 (hereinafter referred to as "controlled devices VD") include the extrusion device 23, the grate driving device 42, the blower 71, the air preheater 73, and the damper 75.
[0036] In the following, an example will be described in which both model identification and control parameter determination are performed using the analytic hierarchy process, but it is also possible to use the analytic hierarchy process to perform only one of model identification and control parameter determination.
[0037] 4.1 Information Acquisition Unit The information acquisition unit 110 acquires the detection results detected by the various sensors provided in the incineration facility 1. For example, the information acquisition unit 110 acquires the detection results of the moisture meter 24 (information regarding the moisture content of the material to be incinerated G), the detection results of the radiation temperature sensor 81, the detection results of the steam flow sensor 82, the detection results of the gas sensor 83, and the detection results of the external environment sensor 84.
[0038] 4.2 Monitoring Unit The monitoring unit 120 monitors the state of the external environment, such as the season. The state of the combustion equipment 1 (e.g., the properties of the material G to be incinerated) varies depending on the external environment, such as the season. For this reason, it is necessary to identify the model for the combustion equipment 1 and determine the control parameters each time the external environment, such as the season, changes.
[0039] In this embodiment, the monitoring unit 120 monitors a predetermined index value related to seasonal variations to determine whether processing by the model identification unit 130 and processing by the control parameter determination unit 140 are required. An example of the predetermined index value is the average value over a predetermined period of a detected value (e.g., outside air temperature) detected by the external environment sensor 84. Note that instead of the above example, the predetermined index value may be the average value over a predetermined period of the moisture content of the incineration material G measured by the moisture meter 24.
[0040] The monitoring unit 120 repeatedly performs the determination at a predetermined cycle (for example, once a day). When the predetermined index value of the monitored object changes beyond a predetermined threshold, the monitoring unit 120 outputs a signal indicating that re-identification of the model is necessary to the model identification unit 130, and outputs a signal indicating that re-determination of the control parameters is necessary to the control parameter determination unit 140.
[0041] 4.3 Model Identification Unit Next, the model identification unit 130 will be described. The model identification unit 130 identifies a plant model M as a model related to the combustion equipment 1. The plant model M is a mathematical model (computational model) that simulates the characteristics of the actual combustion equipment 1. In this embodiment, the model identification unit 130 identifies the plant model M using the Analytic Hierarchy Process. The model identification unit 130 identifies one or more parameters (hereinafter referred to as "model parameters") that define the plant model M so that the behavior of the actual combustion equipment 1 is consistent with calculated values derived by calculation using the plant model M. The model identification unit 130 includes, for example, a Pareto solution generation unit 131 and a preferred solution determination unit 132.
[0042] (Outline of Plant Model) First, an outline of the plant model M will be described. Fig. 3 is a diagram for explaining the outline of the plant model M. As shown in Fig. 3, the furnace 60 includes an exhaust gas header 61 and a secondary combustion header 62 provided downstream of the exhaust gas header 61. The secondary air line 74 includes a secondary air header 74a.
[0043] In the plant model M, for example, the conditions are set as follows: First, the reaction of the solid fuel (material to be incinerated G) is set as follows: C + 1 / 2O 2 →CO2H+1 / 2O 2 →H 2 O
[0044] When solid fuel is excessively supplied to the furnace body 30, carbon (C) and hydrogen (H) in a part of the solid fuel volatilize, and the volatilized carbon and hydrogen flow through the exhaust gas header 61 into the secondary combustion header 62, where they react. In the furnace body 30, the gaseous fuel (nitrogen (N) and oxygen (O)) is gasified, and nitrogen (N) is released. 2 ) and oxygen (O 2 ) occurs.
[0045] Furthermore, when a command to reduce carbon monoxide (CO) is output and exhaust gas containing a large amount of oxygen (IGR gas) is generated, part of the IGR gas is used as part of the secondary air via the secondary air header 74a. The reaction of secondary combustion in the exhaust gas header 61 is set as follows: CO + 1 / 2O 2 →CO 2
[0046] In this embodiment, the model identification unit 130 uses the Analytic Hierarchy Process to identify the plant model M. In this application, "identifying a model" means, for example, determining one or more model parameters that define the model.
[0047] For example, in this embodiment, parameters for simulating the relationship between the supply state of the incineration material G and one or more indices (one or more process values) related to the combustion state are determined as model parameters for the plant model M. The one or more indices may be, for example, the amount of carbon monoxide generated (CO generation amount), the amount of nitrogen oxides generated (NOx generation amount), the oxygen concentration (O 2 The temperature sensor 81 detects the temperature (IR temperature), or the like.
[0048] In this embodiment, in order to simplify the calculation, the CO generation amount and the NOx generation amount are calculated as follows: 2 It is defined as a function of concentration.
[0049] FIG. 2 1 is a graph showing the relationship between the O concentration and the CO concentration based on the actual measurement data in the combustion equipment 1. 2 The relationship between the O concentration and the CO concentration is defined as shown in FIG. 2 1 is a diagram showing the relationship between the concentration of O and the concentration of NOx based on actual measurement data in the combustion equipment 1. 2 The relationship between the concentration and the NOx concentration is defined as shown in FIG.
[0050] On the other hand, O 2The concentration is defined as follows to take into account the effect of the incineration material G falling down. In this application, "falling down" means that a predetermined amount or more of the incineration material G pushed toward the furnace body 30 by the feeder 22 falls (is supplied) unintentionally all at once onto the stoker 40. The occurrence of "falling down" varies depending on the properties of the incineration material G, and therefore changes with the season.
[0051] FIG. 2 1 is a diagram illustrating a concentration change pattern. In this embodiment, the change pattern (change pattern of supply rate) of the incineration material G supplied to the stoker 40 when a drop occurs is simulated in a trapezoidal shape. Specifically, assuming that the time when the drop occurs is t0, the time when the increase in the supply rate of the incineration material G stagnates is t1, the time when the supply rate of the incineration material G starts to decrease is t2, and the time when the supply rate of the incineration material G returns to its initial value is t3, the drop of the incineration material G is simulated using four model parameters: the maximum supply rate S of the incineration material G per hour, the time T (= t2 - t0) until the increased supply rate of the incineration material G starts to decrease, the rate of increase α (= S / (t1 - t0)) of the supply rate of the incineration material G, and the rate of decrease β (= S / t3 - t2) of the supply rate of the incineration material G. Each of these four model parameters (maximum supply rate S, time T, rate of increase α, and rate of decrease β) is a model parameter that defines the plant model M. And O 2 The density change pattern is simulated as a downwardly convex arc between time t0 and time t3.
[0052] (Pareto Solution Generator for Model Parameters) Next, a description will be given of the Pareto solution generator 131. Based on detected values detected in the actual combustion equipment 1 and calculated values derived by calculation using the plant model M, the Pareto solution generator 131 generates Pareto solutions for one or more (e.g., multiple) model parameters that define the plant model M, with minimizing the error between the detected values and the calculated values of multiple indicators (e.g., two or more indicators, or even three or more indicators) related to the combustion state of the combustion equipment 1 as an objective function.
[0053] For example, the Pareto solution generating unit 131 may use a plurality of indices related to the combustion state of the combustion equipment 1, such as the amount of CO generated, the amount of NOx generated, the IR temperature, and the O 2 For each concentration, multiple Pareto solutions are generated for one or more (e.g., multiple) model parameters that minimize the error between the detected value (e.g., the detected value by the radiation temperature sensor 81 or the gas sensor 83) detected in the actual combustion equipment 1 and the calculated value derived by calculation using the plant model M.
[0054] In this embodiment, the plurality of model parameters include the four model parameters described above (maximum supply amount S, time until decrease T, increase rate α, decrease rate β). In addition to the four model parameters described above, the plurality of model parameters may also include model parameters related to one or more of the moisture content of the incineration material G, the calories of the incineration material G, the supply amount of the incineration material G, the transport speed of the incineration material G, the flow rate of primary air, the amount of primary air allocated to the plurality of wind boxes 50, the temperature of the primary air, the flow rate of secondary air, and the amount of secondary air allocated to the plurality of supply ports of the furnace 60.
[0055] The Pareto solution generator 131 generates the multiple Pareto solutions using, for example, an evolutionary multi-objective algorithm (MOEA / D) based on decomposition. However, the algorithm for generating the Pareto solutions is not limited to the above example, and other methods may be used.
[0056] Fig. 7 is a diagram illustrating multiple Pareto solutions of model parameters generated by the Pareto solution generation unit 131. Each of the multiple black triangles in Fig. 7 represents multiple Pareto solutions (Pareto solution sets) related to a model parameter set. A "model parameter set" refers to a combination of multiple model parameters from which a Pareto solution is generated. The multiple black triangles, each a Pareto solution, represent multiple model parameter sets (model parameter set A, model parameter set B, model parameter set C, ...) in which the values of one or more model parameters differ from one another.
[0057] In FIG. 7, for convenience of explanation, the IR temperature and O 2 The Pareto solutions are shown on a two-dimensional plane with two indices of CO generation, NOx generation, IR temperature, and O concentration as evaluation functions. 2 The Pareto solution is found in four dimensions using four indexes of concentration as an evaluation function. However, the Pareto solution is not limited to the above example, and may be found based on two or three indexes, or five or more indexes.
[0058] (Model Parameter Preferred Solution Determination Unit) Next, we will explain the preferred solution determination unit 132. The preferred solution determination unit 132 determines (selects) one or more preferred solutions (optimal model parameter sets) from among the multiple Pareto solutions generated by the Pareto solution generation unit 131 using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (ANAH).
[0059] 8 is a diagram showing the flow of the ANAP used in this embodiment. In the ANAP, the process proceeds in the following order: construction of a hierarchical structure (S101), execution of paired comparison (S102), calculation of importance (S103), and overall evaluation (S104).
[0060] (Construction of hierarchical structure) First, the preferred solution determination unit 132 performs a process of constructing a hierarchical structure. Fig. 9 is a diagram for explaining a hierarchical structure related to the derivation of optimal model parameters generated by the preferred solution determination unit 132. In this embodiment, the CO generation amount, NOx generation amount, IR temperature, and O 2 Four evaluation criteria for the concentration are set: (1) minimizing the error between the actual detected value and the calculated value of the CO generation amount, (2) minimizing the error between the actual detected value and the calculated value of the NOx generation amount, (3) minimizing the error between the actual detected value and the calculated value of the IR temperature, and (4) minimizing the error between the actual detected value and the calculated value of the O 2 The evaluation criteria are set to minimize the error between the actual detected concentration value and the calculated concentration value. The "calculated value" here refers to a calculated value derived by calculation (simulation) using the plant model M.
[0061] In this embodiment, the weights of the four evaluation criteria are all the same. Therefore, the paired comparison process between the four evaluation criteria is omitted. However, the four evaluation criteria may be weighted according to their priorities. In this case, scores may be assigned based on the paired comparison between the four evaluation criteria as part of the paired comparison process described below.
[0062] In this embodiment, the preferred solution determiner 132 sets multiple alternatives as part of the process of constructing a hierarchical structure. For example, the preferred solution determiner 132 sets multiple model parameter sets (model parameter set A, model parameter set B, model parameter set C, ...) that are each a Pareto solution generated by the Pareto solution generator 131 as alternatives.
[0063] (Performing Paired Comparison) Next, the preferred solution determination unit 132 performs a paired comparison process between a plurality of alternatives. FIG. 10 is a diagram conceptually showing the paired comparison process regarding model parameters. For example, FIG. 10 shows O 2 The results of paired comparison of multiple model parameter sets when the evaluation criterion is minimizing the error between the actual detected value of concentration and the calculated value are shown in Figure 10. 2 This is a classification based on a predetermined standard, which classifies the magnitude of the error between the actual concentration detected by the device and the calculated value.
[0064] (Calculation of Importance) Next, the preferred solution determiner 132 calculates the importance of each model parameter set based on the results of the paired comparison. For example, the preferred solution determiner 132 calculates an evaluation value of the importance of each model parameter set with respect to each evaluation criterion by using, for example, the geometric mean method based on the scores previously set for the above categories 1 to 9.
[0065] (Overall Evaluation) Next, the preferred solution determiner 132 calculates an overall evaluation value for each model parameter set. For example, the preferred solution determiner 132 calculates an overall evaluation value for each model parameter set by summing, for each model parameter set, the evaluation values of the importance calculated for each evaluation criterion for the multiple evaluation criteria. Then, the preferred solution determiner 132 derives the model parameter set with the highest overall evaluation value from among the multiple model parameter sets as the optimal model parameter set, thereby identifying the plant model M. Then, the preferred solution determiner 132 outputs information indicating the identified plant model M (for example, information indicating the derived optimal model parameter set) to the control parameter determiner 140.
[0066] <4.4 Control Parameter Determination Unit> Next, the control parameter determination unit 140 will be described. The control parameter determination unit 140 determines the control parameters used to control the combustion equipment 1. In this embodiment, the control parameter determination unit 140 determines the control parameters using the Analytic Hierarchy Process. The control parameter determination unit 140 includes, for example, a Pareto solution generation unit 141 and a preferred solution determination unit 142.
[0067] (Pareto Solution Generator for Control Parameters) First, we will describe the Pareto solution generator 141. The Pareto solution generator 141 generates multiple Pareto solutions for the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 based on the plant model M identified by the model identification unit 130, using multiple indicators (e.g., two or more indicators, or even three or more indicators) related to the combustion state of the combustion equipment 1 as objective functions.
[0068] For example, the Pareto solution generating unit 141 may use a plurality of indices related to the combustion state of the combustion equipment 1, such as the amount of CO generated, the amount of NOx generated, the IR temperature fluctuation, and the O 2 For each concentration fluctuation, a plurality of Pareto solutions are generated for one or more control parameters that minimize the calculated value derived by calculation using the plant model M.
[0069] The control parameter is, for example, the opening degree of the combustion air damper 75. In the following, an example will be described in which the opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B is derived as the control parameter by the Analytic Hierarchy Process. However, the control parameters derived by the analytic hierarchy process may, instead of or in addition to the above examples, include control parameters related to one or more of the moisture content of the incineration material G, the calories of the incineration material G, the supply amount of the incineration material G (e.g., the speed of the feeder 22), the transport speed of the incineration material G (e.g., the moving speed of the grate 41), the flow rate of primary air (e.g., the opening degree of the primary air damper 75A and / or the driving amount of the first blower 71A), the distribution amount of primary air to multiple air boxes 50 (e.g., the opening degree of the primary air damper 75A), the temperature of primary air (e.g., the heating amount of the air preheater 73), the flow rate of secondary air (e.g., the driving amount of the secondary air damper 75B and / or the second blower 71B), and the distribution amount of secondary air to multiple supply ports of the furnace 60 (e.g., the secondary air damper 75B).
[0070] The Pareto solution generator 141 generates multiple Pareto solutions for the control parameters using, for example, the evolutionary multi-objective algorithm MOEA / D. However, the algorithm for generating the Pareto solutions is not limited to the above example, and other methods may be used.
[0071] 11 is a diagram illustrating multiple Pareto solutions related to control parameters (e.g., the opening degree of secondary air damper 75B) generated by the Pareto solution generator 141. Each of the multiple white triangles in FIG. 11 represents multiple Pareto solutions (a set of Pareto solutions) for the control parameters. The multiple white triangles, each a Pareto solution, represent multiple opening degrees (opening degree A, opening degree B, opening degree C, ...) of secondary air damper 75B as multiple control parameters with different values for the control parameters.
[0072] 11, for the sake of convenience, the Pareto solutions are shown on a two-dimensional plane in which two indexes, the amount of CO generated and the amount of NOx generated, are used as evaluation functions. In reality, the Pareto solutions are calculated using, for example, the amount of CO generated, the amount of NOx generated, the amount of IR temperature fluctuation, and the amount of O 2The Pareto solution is found in four dimensions using four indexes of the concentration fluctuation amount as an evaluation function. However, the Pareto solution is not limited to the above example, and may be found based on two or three indexes, or five or more indexes.
[0073] (Control Parameter Preferred Solution Determiner) Next, a description will be given of the preferred solution determiner 142. The preferred solution determiner 142 applies the AHP to the multiple Pareto solutions related to the control parameters generated by the Pareto solution generator 141, thereby selecting and determining one or more preferred solutions (optimum control parameters, for example, the optimum opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) from among the Pareto solutions.
[0074] The flow of the ANALYSIS for control parameters is the same as the flow of the ANALYSIS for model parameters explained with reference to Fig. 8. Therefore, a duplicated explanation will be omitted. Specific processing of the ANALYSIS for control parameters will be explained below.
[0075] (Construction of hierarchical structure) First, the preferred solution determination unit 142 performs a process of constructing a hierarchical structure. Fig. 12 is a diagram for explaining a hierarchical structure related to the derivation of optimal control parameters generated by the preferred solution determination unit 142. In this embodiment, the CO generation amount, NOx generation amount, IR temperature fluctuation, and O 2 Four evaluation criteria for concentration fluctuations are set: (1) minimization of the calculated CO emission amount, (2) minimization of the calculated NOx emission amount, (3) minimization of the calculated IR temperature fluctuation amount (or fluctuation rate), and (4) minimization of the O 2 The minimization of the calculated value of the concentration fluctuation amount (or fluctuation rate) is set as the evaluation criterion. The "calculated value" here means a calculated value derived by a calculation (simulation) using the optimal model parameter set derived by the model identification unit 130 and the plant model M.
[0076] In this embodiment, the preferred solution determiner 142 sets a plurality of alternatives as part of the process of constructing the hierarchical structure. For example, the preferred solution determiner 142 sets a plurality of control parameters (e.g., opening degree A, opening degree B, opening degree C, ... for the secondary air damper 75B) that are each a Pareto solution generated by the Pareto solution generator 141 as alternatives.
[0077] (Performing Paired Comparison) Next, the preferred solution determination unit 142 performs paired comparison processing for each of the multiple evaluation criteria and the multiple alternatives. First, the paired comparison processing for each of the multiple evaluation criteria will be described. In the case where there are four criteria as in this embodiment, (i) CO generation priority and O 2 (ii) CO generation priority and NOx generation priority; (iii) CO generation priority and IR temperature fluctuation priority; (iv) NOx generation priority and O 2 Fluctuation priority, (v) NOx generation priority vs. IR temperature fluctuation priority, (vi) O 2 Six pairwise comparisons of fluctuation priority and IR temperature fluctuation priority are performed.
[0078] Fig. 13 is a diagram showing an example of the results of paired comparisons between evaluation criteria for control parameters. In this embodiment, in the paired comparisons between evaluation criteria for control parameters, different priorities are assigned to multiple operating conditions that may occur in the combustion equipment 1. Fig. 13 shows paired comparisons for each of three operating conditions: (a) a CO-prioritized operating condition, (b) a NOx-prioritized operating condition, and (c) an IR temperature (steam flow rate)-prioritized operating condition.
[0079] The "CO priority" operating state refers to a state in which the calculated value of the CO generation amount is equal to or greater than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a high CO threshold), but the calculated value of the NOx generation amount is less than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a low NOx threshold), and the CO generation amount is severe but there is room for the NOx generation amount. In this case, the first priority is given to fluctuations in the CO generation amount, followed by fluctuations in the IR temperature (steam flow rate), and then fluctuations in the O 2 Priority is given to fluctuations in concentration or fluctuations in NOx (for example, from the viewpoint of stable operation of the combustion equipment 1, 2Scores are assigned to multiple evaluation criteria so that the CO concentration fluctuations are prioritized over the NOx concentration fluctuations. In FIG. 13, a larger number indicates a higher priority. For example, the score "7" assigned to the intersection indicated by A in FIG. 13 indicates that the CO concentration fluctuations are prioritized seven times more than the NOx concentration fluctuations.
[0080] The "NOx priority" operating condition refers to a condition in which the calculated value of the CO generation amount is less than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a lower threshold for CO), but the calculated value of the NOx generation amount is equal to or greater than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a higher threshold for NOx), and there is a margin for CO generation amount, but the NOx generation amount is severe. In this case, the first priority is given to the fluctuation of the NOx generation amount, followed by the fluctuation of the IR temperature (steam flow rate), and then the O 2 Scores are assigned to a plurality of evaluation criteria so that the fluctuation in concentration or the fluctuation in CO is given priority (for example, from the viewpoint of stable operation of the combustion equipment 1, the fluctuation in the amount of CO generated is given priority).
[0081] The "IR temperature (steam flow rate) priority" situation indicates a situation in which the calculated value of the CO generation amount is less than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a lower threshold for CO) and the calculated value of the NOx generation amount is less than a predetermined threshold (e.g., a lower threshold for NOx), and there is a margin for both the CO generation amount and the NOx generation amount. In this case, the first priority is given to the fluctuation of the IR temperature (steam flow rate), followed by the fluctuation of the CO generation amount, and then the O 2 Priority is given to fluctuations in concentration or fluctuations in NOx (for example, from the viewpoint of stable operation of the combustion equipment 1, 2 Scores are assigned to multiple evaluation criteria, with priority given to fluctuations in the amount of waste generated.
[0082] Next, the preferred solution determination unit 142 performs a paired comparison process between the multiple alternatives. In this embodiment, the preferred solution determination unit 142 performs the following process for each of the three driving situations.
[0083] 14 is a diagram conceptually illustrating the process of pairwise comparison between control parameters. 2 The results of paired comparisons between multiple control parameters (e.g., multiple opening degrees of the secondary air damper 75B) when minimizing concentration fluctuations is the evaluation criterion are shown. 2The size of the density fluctuation is divided according to a predetermined standard.
[0084] (Calculation of Importance) Next, the preferred solution determination unit 142 calculates the importance of each evaluation criterion based on the results of the paired comparison between the multiple evaluation criteria. For example, the preferred solution determination unit 142 calculates an evaluation value of the importance of each evaluation criterion (hereinafter referred to as "evaluation criterion importance") by using, for example, the geometric mean method based on the scores set in the paired comparison.
[0085] Next, the preferred solution determiner 142 calculates the importance of each control parameter (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) based on the results of paired comparisons between the multiple control parameters (e.g., multiple opening degrees of the secondary air damper 75B). For example, the preferred solution determiner 142 calculates an evaluation value of the importance of each control parameter (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) for each evaluation criterion by using, for example, the geometric mean method based on the scores previously set for the above categories 1 to 9.
[0086] (Overall Evaluation) Next, the preferred solution determiner 142 calculates an overall evaluation value for each control parameter (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B). For example, the preferred solution determiner 142 calculates an overall evaluation value for each control parameter (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) by reflecting (e.g., multiplying) the evaluation criterion importance of each evaluation criterion for each control parameter (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) and then summing the evaluation values of the importance of the control parameters (e.g., each opening degree of the secondary air damper 75B) with respect to the multiple evaluation criteria. Then, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives the control parameter with the highest overall evaluation value from among the multiple control parameters (e.g., multiple opening degrees of the secondary air damper 75B) as the optimal control parameter (e.g., the optimal opening degree).
[0087] In this embodiment, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives (determines) the above-mentioned optimal control parameters (e.g., optimal openings) for each of the above-mentioned multiple operating conditions based on the results of paired comparisons between the multiple evaluation criteria for each of the above-mentioned multiple operating conditions (e.g., three). For example, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives an optimal control parameter S1 (e.g., optimal opening S1) for a "CO priority" operating condition, an optimal control parameter S2 (e.g., optimal opening S2) for a "NOx priority" operating condition, and an optimal control parameter S3 (e.g., optimal opening S3) for an "IR temperature (steam flow rate) priority" operating condition. Then, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives a control parameter set that can accommodate a wider variety of operating conditions based on the multiple optimal control parameters S1, S2, and S3 derived for each operating condition.
[0088] FIG. 15 is a diagram showing an example of a control parameter set derived by the preferred solution determination unit 142. (a) in FIG. 15 shows a control parameter set for the maximum opening (unit: [%]) of the secondary air damper 75B. (b) in FIG. 15 shows a control parameter set for the intermediate opening (unit: [%]) of the secondary air damper 75B. The "maximum opening" is, for example, an opening set by the control unit 150 for a predetermined time (first predetermined time) when the CO concentration or NOx concentration increases beyond a predetermined standard (e.g., when a "drop" occurs). The "intermediate opening" is, for example, an opening set by the control unit 150 for a predetermined time (second predetermined time) after the secondary air damper 75B has been set at the maximum opening for a predetermined time.
[0089] In this embodiment, the preferred solution determiner 142 determines, as the control parameter sets, a control parameter set corresponding to the "maximum opening" and a control parameter set corresponding to the "intermediate opening."
[0090] For example, when deriving a control parameter set corresponding to the "maximum opening," the preferred solution determiner 142 performs the processes from S101 to S104 described above under the constraint that the opening be between 20% and 100%, thereby deriving a plurality of optimal control parameters S1A, S2A, and S3A suitable for each of the above driving situations as the plurality of optimal control parameters S1, S2, and S3. Then, the preferred solution determiner 142 performs linear interpolation based on the control parameters S1A, S2A, and S3A, for example, to derive the control parameter set shown in (a) of FIG.
[0091] Similarly, when deriving a control parameter set corresponding to an "intermediate opening," the preferred solution determiner 142 performs the processes from S101 to S104 described above under the constraint that the opening be between 10% and 60%. As a result, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives a plurality of optimal control parameters S1B, S2B, and S3B suitable for each of the above-mentioned operating conditions as the plurality of optimal control parameters S1, S2, and S3. Then, the preferred solution determiner 142 performs linear interpolation based on the control parameters S1B, S2B, and S3B, for example, to derive the control parameter set shown in (b) of FIG.
[0092] In FIG. 15 , for each of the CO concentration and NOx concentration, a smaller numerical category among categories 1 to 5 indicates a severe situation, while a larger numerical category indicates a more lenient situation. For example, category 1 for CO concentration indicates that the CO generation amount is equal to or greater than the CO upper threshold. For example, category 5 for CO concentration indicates that the CO generation amount is less than the CO lower threshold. Similarly, category 1 for NOx concentration indicates that the NOx generation amount is equal to or greater than the NOx upper threshold. For example, category 5 for NOx concentration indicates that the NOx generation amount is less than the NOx lower threshold. Note that the CO concentration and NOx concentration categories 1 to 5 set in (a) of FIG. 15 and the CO concentration and NOx concentration categories 1 to 5 set in (b) of FIG. 15 may be the same or different.
[0093] 4.5 Control Unit The control unit 150 comprehensively manages the entire combustion equipment 1. In the present embodiment, the control unit 150 controls the controlled device VD based on various detection values acquired by the information acquisition unit 110 and control parameters determined by the control parameter determination unit 140, thereby performing combustion control for the combustion equipment 1. For example, in the present embodiment, the control unit 150 controls the secondary air damper 75B based on detection values related to CO and NOx acquired by the information acquisition unit 110 (e.g., detection values by the gas sensor 83) and control parameters determined by the control parameter determination unit 140 (e.g., the control parameter set shown in (a) or (b) in FIG. 15 ).
[0094] For example, when the CO concentration (amount of CO generated) or NOx concentration (amount of NOx generated) detected by the gas sensor 83 increases beyond the above-mentioned predetermined standard (for example, when a "drop" occurs), the control unit 150 controls the secondary air damper 75B to an opening degree (first opening degree) corresponding to the CO concentration (amount of CO generated) and NOx concentration (amount of NOx generated) detected by the gas sensor 83, from among the multiple opening degrees shown in (a) of Figure 15.
[0095] Then, the control unit 150 sets the secondary air damper 75B to the first opening degree and operates the combustion equipment 1 for a predetermined time, and then controls the secondary air damper 75B to an opening degree (second opening degree) among the multiple opening degrees shown in Fig. 15(b) that corresponds to the CO concentration (amount of CO generated) and NOx concentration (amount of NOx generated) detected by the gas sensor 83. Thereafter, the control unit 150 sets the secondary air damper 75B to the second opening degree and operates the combustion equipment 1 for a predetermined time, and then returns the secondary air damper 75B to the preset reference opening degree.
[0096] 5. Information Processing Flow Next, the flow of information processing by the control device 100 will be described. Fig. 16 is a flowchart showing the information processing flow. In this embodiment, first, the monitoring unit 120 calculates and acquires a predetermined index value related to seasonal fluctuations (for example, an average value of the detection values detected by the external environment sensor 84 over a predetermined period) based on the detection values acquired by the information acquisition unit 110 (S111). Then, the monitoring unit 120 determines whether the acquired predetermined index value has changed beyond a predetermined threshold (S112).
[0097] If it is determined that the predetermined index value has not changed beyond the predetermined threshold (S112: NO), the monitoring unit 120 waits for a predetermined time (for example, one day) and repeats the process of S111. On the other hand, if it is determined that the predetermined index value has changed beyond the predetermined threshold (S112: YES), the monitoring unit 120 proceeds to the process of S121.
[0098] In this embodiment, if it is determined that the predetermined index value has changed beyond a predetermined threshold (S112: YES), model re-identification and control parameter resetting are performed. For example, the information acquisition unit 110 acquires various data related to the combustion equipment 1, which is the target plant (S121). For example, the information acquisition unit 110 acquires the detection results of the radiation temperature sensor 81 and the gas sensor 83. Then, the information acquisition unit 110 acquires the necessary detection values by, for example, correcting each detection value according to a time delay or time advance.
[0099] Next, the Pareto solution generating unit 131 of the model identifying unit 130 determines, based on the detected values acquired by the information acquiring unit 110 in the process of S121 and the calculated values derived by calculation using the plant model M, for example, the amount of CO generated, the amount of NOx generated, the IR temperature, and O 2 Using the minimization of the error between the detected value and the calculated value of the concentration as an objective function, a plurality of Pareto solutions are generated for one or more model parameters that define the plant model M (S131).
[0100] Next, the preferred solution determiner 132 of the model identifier 130 determines one or more preferred solutions (optimal model parameter sets) from among the multiple Pareto solutions by applying the Analytic Hierarchy Process to the multiple Pareto solutions related to the model parameters generated by the Pareto solution generator 131 (S132). In this way, the plant model M is identified.
[0101] Next, the Pareto solution generating unit 141 of the control parameter determining unit 140 determines, based on the plant model M identified by the model identifying unit 130, the amount of CO generated, the amount of NOx generated, the IR temperature fluctuation, and the O 2 A plurality of Pareto solutions relating to the control parameters that minimize the calculated value relating to the density fluctuation are generated (S141).
[0102] Next, the preferred solution determiner 142 of the control parameter determiner 140 determines one or more preferred solutions (optimal control parameters) from among the multiple Pareto solutions by applying the AHP to the multiple Pareto solutions related to the control parameters generated by the Pareto solution generator 141 (S142). In this embodiment, the preferred solution determiner 142 derives a control parameter set based on the multiple preferred solutions (control parameters S1, S2, S3) obtained by determining one or more preferred solutions for each operating state of the combustion equipment 1 (S143).
[0103] Next, the control unit 150 performs combustion control for the combustion equipment 1 based on one or more preferred solutions determined by the control parameter determination unit 140 (for example, based on the derived control parameter set) (S151). Then, after a predetermined period (for example, one day) has elapsed, the process returns to S111, and the series of processes from S111 onwards are repeated.
[0104] 6. Effects and Benefits The combustion equipment 1 requires optimization of control parameters to accommodate, for example, the unique characteristics of each combustion equipment 1 and / or seasonal changes in fuel properties. However, determining the optimal control parameters requires plant model identification and selection of a solution from Pareto solutions that involve trade-offs among multiple objectives, making full automation difficult.
[0105] On the other hand, in this embodiment, the control device 100 has a Pareto solution generation unit 141 that generates a plurality of Pareto solutions related to the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 based on the plant model M, using a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions, and a preferred solution determiner 142 that determines one or more preferred solutions from the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying the Analytic Hierarchy Process to the plurality of Pareto solutions generated by the Pareto solution generation unit 141. With this configuration, the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 can be appropriately determined by the control device 100, and automation of the operation of the combustion equipment 1 can be promoted.
[0106] Second Embodiment Next, a second embodiment will be described. The second embodiment differs from the first embodiment in that a response surface related to a plant model M is generated and optimization calculations are performed based on the generated response surface. Note that the configuration other than that described below is the same as the configuration of the first embodiment.
[0107] 17 is a block diagram showing the functional configuration of the incineration facility 1 of the second embodiment. In this embodiment, the control device 100 has a response surface generator 170. The response surface generator 170 generates a response surface for the plant model M using a response surface generation method (e.g., linear interpolation). For example, the response surface generator 170 generates a response surface for the plant model M by changing target parameters (model parameters) for the plant model M.
[0108] 18 is a flowchart showing the flow of information processing in the second embodiment. In this embodiment, the response surface generator 170 generates a response surface (S161). Then, the Pareto solution generator 131 of the model identification unit 130 performs optimization calculations based on the response surface generated by the response surface generator 170 (S131).
[0109] According to this configuration, similar to the first embodiment, the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 can be appropriately determined by the control device 100, and the operation of the combustion equipment 1 can be automated. Furthermore, by generating a response surface as in this embodiment, the calculation time for the optimization calculation by the model identification unit 130 can be shortened, and optimal control parameters can be quickly derived depending on the combustion state. Note that the response surface creation method is not limited to linear interpolation, and the Kriging method, etc., may also be used.
[0110] Other Embodiments Although the embodiments of the present disclosure have been described above, the specific configuration is not limited to these embodiments, and design changes within the scope of the present disclosure are also included.
[0111] 15 is a hardware configuration diagram showing the configuration of a computer 1100 according to this embodiment. The computer 1100 includes, for example, a processor 1110, a main memory 1120, a storage 1130, and an interface 1140.
[0112] Each of the functional units of the control device 100 described above is implemented in a computer 1100. The operation of each of the functional units described above is stored in the form of a program in a storage 1130. The processor 1110 reads the program from the storage 1130, loads it into the main memory 1120, and executes the above-described processing in accordance with the program. The processor 1110 also allocates storage areas in the main memory 1120 to be used by each of the functional units described above in accordance with the program.
[0113] The program may be for realizing some of the functions to be performed by the computer 1100. For example, the program may be combined with other programs already stored in the storage 1130 or other programs implemented in other devices to perform the functions. Furthermore, the computer 1100 may include a custom large-scale integrated circuit (LSI) such as a programmable logic device (PLD) in addition to or instead of the above configuration. Examples of PLDs include programmable array logic (PAL), generic array logic (GAL), complex programmable logic device (CPLD), and field programmable gate array (FPGA). In this case, some or all of the functions realized by the processor 1110 may be realized by the integrated circuit.
[0114] Examples of storage 1130 include a magnetic disk, a magneto-optical disk, and a semiconductor memory. Storage 1130 may be an internal medium directly connected to the bus of computer 1100, or an external medium connected to computer 1100 via interface 1140 or a communication line. Furthermore, when this program is distributed to computer 1100 via a communication line, computer 1100 that receives the program may deploy the program in main memory 1120 and execute the above-described processing. Furthermore, the program may be a program for realizing part of the above-described functions. Furthermore, the program may be a so-called differential file (differential program) that realizes the above-described functions in combination with another program already stored in storage 1130.
[0115] <Additional Notes> The combustion facility system and the information processing method described in each embodiment can be understood, for example, as follows.
[0116] (1) A first aspect of the combustion equipment system (e.g., the control device 100) includes a Pareto solution generator 141 that generates a plurality of Pareto solutions related to control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 based on a model of the combustion equipment 1, with a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions, and a preferred solution determiner 142 that determines one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying the Analytic Hierarchy Process to the plurality of Pareto solutions generated by the Pareto solution generator 141. With this configuration, the control device 100 can appropriately determine the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1, thereby facilitating automation of the operation of the combustion equipment 1.
[0117] (2) A second aspect of the combustion equipment system is the combustion equipment system described in (1), wherein the plurality of indices are indices related to two or more of the amount of carbon monoxide generated, the amount of nitrogen oxide generated, the oxygen concentration fluctuation, the gas temperature fluctuation, and the steam flow rate fluctuation. With this configuration, the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 can be appropriately determined based on the components contained in the exhaust gas or the steam flow rate.
[0118] (3) A third aspect of the combustion equipment system is the combustion equipment system described in (1) or (2), wherein the control parameters are one or more control parameters related to the moisture content of the incinerated materials, the calories of the incinerated materials, the supply amount of the incinerated materials, the transport speed of the incinerated materials, the flow rate of the combustion air, the distribution amount of the combustion air, or the temperature of the combustion air. This configuration allows the moisture content of the incinerated materials, the calories of the incinerated materials, the supply amount of the incinerated materials, the transport speed of the incinerated materials, the flow rate of the combustion air, the distribution amount of the combustion air, or the temperature of the combustion air to be appropriately adjusted as the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1. This allows for more automated control of the combustion equipment 1.
[0119] (4) In a fourth aspect of the combustion equipment system, in the combustion equipment system described in any one of (1) to (3), the preferred solution determiner 142 determines the preferred solution for each operating situation in which a value for a first index included in the plurality of indexes is equal to or greater than a predetermined threshold, and for each operating situation in which a value for the first index is less than the threshold. With this configuration, it is possible to appropriately determine control parameters appropriate for each operating situation in accordance with a plurality of operating situations.
[0120] (5) A fifth aspect of the combustion facility system is the combustion facility system according to any one of (1) to (4), further comprising a monitoring unit 120 that monitors a predetermined index value related to seasonal fluctuations, and a model identification unit 130 that re-identifies the model when the predetermined index value monitored by the monitoring unit 120 changes beyond a threshold value. With this configuration, it is possible to appropriately determine control parameters using a model according to the external environment.
[0121] (6) A sixth aspect of the information processing method includes one or more computers generating a plurality of Pareto solutions for control parameters of the combustion equipment 1 based on a model of the combustion equipment 1, using a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions, and determining one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying an analytical hierarchy process to the generated plurality of Pareto solutions. This configuration makes it possible to appropriately determine the control parameters of the combustion equipment 1, thereby facilitating automation of the operation of the combustion equipment 1.
[0122] According to the combustion equipment system and information processing method of the present invention, it becomes possible to appropriately determine parameters related to the combustion equipment.
[0123] DESCRIPTION OF SYMBOLS 1...Combustion equipment 2...Incinerator 21...Hopper 22...Feeder 23...Extrusion device 24...Moisture meter 30...Furnace body 40...Stoker 50...Wind box 60...Furnace 70...Blower mechanism 71...Blower 73...Air preheater 75...Damper 81...Radiation temperature sensor 82...Steam flow sensor 83...Gas sensor 100...Control device 110...Information acquisition unit 120...Monitoring unit 130...Model identification unit 131...Pareto solution generation unit 132...Preferred solution determination unit 140...Control parameter determination unit 141...Pareto solution generation unit 142...Preferred solution determination unit 150...Control unit 170...Response surface generation unit G...Material to be incinerated
Claims
1. A system for combustion equipment comprising: a Pareto solution generation unit that generates a plurality of Pareto solutions related to control parameters of the combustion equipment based on a model of the equipment, with a plurality of indexes related to the combustion state as objective functions; and a preferred solution determination unit that determines one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying an analytic hierarchy process to the plurality of Pareto solutions generated by the Pareto solution generation unit, wherein the plurality of indexes include a first index and a second index different from the first index, and the preferred solution determination unit differs in priority in a pairwise comparison of the first index and the second index in the analytic hierarchy process between a first operating condition in which the first index is prioritized over the second index and a second operating condition in which the second index is prioritized over the first index, and determines the preferred solution for each of the first operating condition and the second operating condition.
2. The system for combustion equipment according to claim 1, wherein the plurality of indices are indices relating to two or more of an amount of carbon monoxide generated, an amount of nitrogen oxide generated, an oxygen concentration fluctuation, a gas temperature fluctuation, or a steam flow rate fluctuation.
3. A system for combustion equipment as described in claim 1 or claim 2, wherein the control parameters are one or more control parameters relating to the moisture content of the material to be incinerated, the calories of the material to be incinerated, the supply amount of the material to be incinerated, the transport speed of the material to be incinerated, the flow rate of the combustion air, the distribution amount of the combustion air, or the temperature of the combustion air.
4. A combustion equipment system as described in claim 1 or claim 2, further comprising: a monitoring unit that monitors a specified index value related to seasonal fluctuations; and a model identification unit that re-identifies the model when the specified index value monitored by the monitoring unit changes beyond a threshold value.
5. An information processing method comprising: one or more computers generating a plurality of Pareto solutions for control parameters of the combustion equipment based on a model of the combustion equipment, with a plurality of indicators related to the combustion state as objective functions; and determining one or more preferred solutions from among the plurality of Pareto solutions by applying an analytic hierarchy process to the plurality of Pareto solutions generated, wherein the plurality of indicators include a first indicator and a second indicator different from the first indicator; and determining the preferred solution includes different priorities in a pairwise comparison of the first indicator and the second indicator in the analytic hierarchy process for a first operating condition in which the first indicator is prioritized over the second indicator, and a second operating condition in which the second indicator is prioritized over the first indicator, and determining the preferred solution for each of the first operating condition and the second operating condition.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Control method and control device for combustion furnace in natural gas purification process
CN114427684A
Method for preventing clogging of incinerator, device for calculating addition amount of agent for preventing clogging of incinerator, and program for calculating addition amount of agent for preventing clogging of incinerator
JP2019027688A
State monitoring device for railway, truck for railway vehicle, railway vehicle, brake control device for railway
JP2021046191A
Information processing method, information processing device, and program
JP7250206B1
