Imposing frequency difference between cooling FANS to mask tonal noise
By controlling fan speeds to distribute tonal noise frequencies, the method reduces the annoyance and regulatory impact of wind turbine cooling fan noise, ensuring compliance with noise regulations and enabling closer proximity to residential areas.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/DK2026/060055
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-07
- Filing Date
- 2026-05-04
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Wind turbines generate tonal acoustic noise from cooling fans, which are perceived as more annoying and incur penalties in noise regulations, making them require greater distances from dwellings or operational restrictions, and passive noise attenuation techniques are costly and ineffective.
Control the rotation speeds of cooling fans to distribute tonal noise frequencies by a predetermined frequency difference, such as 10 Hz, using an algorithm to identify and adjust fan speeds to avoid dominant noise frequencies and create masking effects.
Redistributing tonal noise frequencies reduces the perceived annoyance and avoids regulatory penalties, allowing wind turbines to operate closer to residential areas while maintaining cooling efficiency.
Smart Images

Figure DK2026060055_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] IMPOSING FREQUENCY DIFFERENCE BETWEEN COOLING FANS TO MASK TONAL NOISE
[0002] FI ELD OF THE INVENTION
[0003] The present invention relates to the field of wind turbines. More specifically, the invention relates to a method for controlling tonal acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine by controlling fans of a cooling system of a wind turbine to generate (tonal) noise components with a predetermined minimum frequency difference.
[0004] BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0005] Apart from turbulent aerodynamic noise from the blades, wind turbines often generate external tonal acoustic noise to the environment. One source of such tonal noise is the cooling system of the wind turbine, where rotation speed of cooling fans are controlled to provide air cooling according to actual operating conditions of the wind turbine. Such cooling fans generate noise, typical tonal noise dominated by their blade passing frequencies, i.e. noise at a frequency determined by the number of blades and rotation speed of each fan. Such noise can at times be perceived as tonal.
[0006] If noise is dominated by tonal noise components, it is perceived more annoying compared to wideband noise at the same sound pressure level. For this reason, legal practice for regulation of external noise in some countries includes a so-called “pure tone penalty”, i.e. a “penalty” value to be added to a sound pressure level measured from the noise source, if the noise has a pure tone character. This means that if the noise is found to be tonal, a value of e.g. 5 dB will be added before comparing the measured noise level with noise level limits setup.
[0007] Therefore, if a wind turbine generates noise with a tonal character, it is required that it is placed at a significant larger distance from dwellings compared to the same wind turbine without tonal noise. Alternatively, its mode of operation will be significantly restricted compared to the same wind turbine without tonal noise.Thus, it is desirable to attenuate external tonal noise generated by a wind turbine caused by its cooling fans. However, classical passive noise attenuation techniques for reducing tonal noise from cooling fans is complicated, expensive and often with limited effect.
[0008] SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0009] Thus, according to the above description, it is an object of the present invention to provide a method for reducing problems with tonal acoustic noise caused by cooling fans of a wind turbine.
[0010] In a first aspect, the invention provides a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine, said method comprising:
[0011] - identifying frequencies of tonal acoustic noise of a plurality of fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine, such as based on determining current rotation speed of the plurality of fans combined with knowledge about number of fan blades on the fans,
[0012] - generating an ordered list of said frequencies,
[0013] - determining frequency differences between neighboring frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies,
[0014] - in case a frequency difference between neighboring frequencies is below a predetermined frequency difference, e.g. a Af of 5 - 60 Hz, increasing one or more of said frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies to obtain a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference between neighboring frequencies,
[0015] - determining rotation speeds of said plurality of fans to cause the fans to generate tonal acoustic noise with said redistributed list of frequencies, and - controlling rotation speed of said plurality of fans according to said determined rotation speeds.
[0016] Such method is advantageous, since it has proven possible to avoid tonal character of external noise from a wind turbine cooling fans by appropriately controlling the cooling fans to distribute tonal components of the blade passing frequency noise generated by the fans. For example, if these tonal components of the fans are distributed by a frequency difference, e.g. Af= 10 Hz, the total noisefrom the fans will be perceived as less tonal, and thus the noise is perceived as less annoying. At the same time, the so-called “tonal noise penalty” can be avoided when evaluating external noise effect from the wind turbine.
[0017] In this way it can be avoided that cooling requirements determine that a group of similar fans (fans with the same number of blades) are determined to operate at the same rotation speed due to cooling requirements. This will result in all of these fans generating the same tonal noise frequency which may cause the total noise from the wind turbine being dominated by this noise frequency. With the method according to the invention, rotation speeds of some of the fans will be increased to ensure distribution of tonal noise frequencies by e.g. 10 Hz, thus eliminating the common contribution to noise at one single tonal component. Since only rotation speeds are increased, the cooling requirements can still be complied with.
[0018] Furthermore, the distributed (tonal) noise of the cooling fans can be used to generate the psychoacoustic effect of masking tonal noise generated by any other component(s) of the wind turbine, e.g. the gearbox. In this way a possible dominating tonal noise component from said component(s) can be effectively eliminated, if the tonal components of the cooling fans are distributed around the tonal component of the said component(s).
[0019] The invention can for example be implemented in software on existing wind turbine controllers and utilizing existing fans of the cooling system of the wind turbine. However, in some cases, it may be possible to select the number of fans and / or their blade numbers especially to allow generation of (tonal) noise at different frequencies, thus facilitating the distribution of their (tonal) noise components at normal operating conditions.
[0020] US 2024 / 026859A1 discloses a wind turbine with at least one fan for cooling the nacelle and / or generator. The fan rotational speed of the at least one fan is set in such a way on the basis of the rotor rotational speed that the fan sound frequency deviates from the at least one generator sound frequency.US 2024 / 026859A1 does not disclose a step identifying frequencies of tonal acoustic noise of the fans, but discloses that the fan speed of different fans is set so that tonal noise frequencies deviates by desired amounts. Particularly, US 2024 / 026859A1 does not disclose generating an ordered list of the tonal frequencies, determining frequency differences, and obtaining a redistributed list of frequencies with predetermined frequency difference between neighboring frequencies by increasing fan speeds. Thus, US 2024 / 026859A1 does not address the problem where fan speeds may vary over time due to changing cooling requirements. The present solution addresses this problem by adjusting fan speed to obtain tonal frequencies of the fans that are suitably distributed to avoid a concentration of tonal noise and / or to obtain masking noise effects of the noise produced by fans.
[0021] In the following, preferred features and embodiments will be described.
[0022] The step of identifying frequencies of tonal acoustic noise of a plurality of fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine can be based on: 1 ) determining minimum fan speed, and 2) calculating the blade passing frequency accordingly. The identifying step may also be a determination step where the frequencies of tonal acoustic noise are calculated as minimum frequencies to meet the minimum cooling requirement. Thus, the method may comprise determining minimum fan speeds of the plurality of fans so that the minimum cooling requirements are met. The method may further comprise controlling the fans to operate at the determined minimum fan speeds. As explained, these minimum fan speeds may be increased to obtain the desired distribution of tonal frequencies.
[0023] The determination of minimum fan speed may be performed repeatedly so that the minimum cooling requirements are met. Different fans may meet different cooling requirements over time and therefore tonal acoustic noise of the fans may change over time, particularly the frequencies of tonal acoustic noise for different fans may change over time. Therefore, the steps of identifying frequencies of tonal acoustic noise of a plurality of fans, ordering the frequencies, determining differences between neighboring frequencies, adjusting frequencies and determining adjusted rotation speeds, ensure that the tonal fan emissions arealways optimal with respect to ensuring an optimum distribution of tonal frequencies and / or masking effects.
[0024] In some embodiments, the method comprises repeating performing said steps at a predetermined interval, such as a predetermined interval selected within 5-100 seconds. In this way, it is ensured that the frequency distribution is updated at regular intervals to follow changes in cooling requirements which may itself demand a change in rotation speed of the fans.
[0025] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining if the determined rotation speeds of each of said plurality of fans exceed maximum allowable rotation speed for said fans before controlling rotation speed of said fans accordingly. It may be preferred not to change rotation speed of a fan to a rotations speed exceeding its maximum allowable rotation speed, if this would be required to provide the predetermined frequency difference.
[0026] Especially, it may be preferred to set rotation speed equal to maximum allowable rotation speed for each of the fans where said determined rotation speed was determined to exceed maximum allowable rotation speed. Especially, at least one of the fans where said determined rotation speed was determined to exceed maximum allowable rotation speed, said at least one fan is controlled to operate at an oscillating rotation speed which in a part of an oscillating cycle exceeds maximum allowable rotation speed of said at least one fan. This may be seen as a preferable compromise between optimal noise performance and acceptable operation of the fan.
[0027] In some embodiments, the method comprises controlling at least one fan to operate at an oscillating rotation speed. This may be preferred, if it is not otherwise possible to distribute tonal frequencies in a proper manner. Especially, a group of fans may be controlled to operate at oscillating rotation speeds, e.g. out of phase to avoid overlapping tonal frequencies. Especially, said at least one fan is controlled to operate with an oscillating rotation speed so as to generate tonal acoustic noise oscillating around a predetermined center frequency. Especially, said at least one fan is controlled to generate tonal acoustic noise between a minimum frequency and a maximum frequency, wherein a difference between themaximum frequency and the minimum frequency is selected to be within 5 -60 Hz. Another difference between the maximum frequency and the minimum frequency may be preferred.
[0028] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining if cooling requirements of the cooling system is fulfilled with current rotation speeds of the plurality of fans, and adjusting rotation speeds of the plurality of fans to fulfil the cooling requirements. Especially, the method may comprises iteratively changing between:
[0029] - determining if cooling requirements of the cooling system are fulfilled with current rotation speeds of the plurality of fans, and
[0030] - said step of generating a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference (Af), and controlling rotation speeds of said plurality of fans accordingly.
[0031] In some embodiments, the method comprises controlling two or more of the plurality of fans to generate (tonal) acoustic noise at one frequency, in case it is determined that it is not possible to distribute tonal acoustic noise frequency for all fans with said predetermined frequency difference (Af).
[0032] In some embodiments, the method comprises controlling one or more of the plurality of fans according to an offset fan rotation speed mode of operation. Specifically, the offset rotation speed mode may be spinning fans at higher speed with defined margin to tonal frequency, which fulfills the other constraints, e.g. cooling requirements and overall sound power generated by the wind turbine. Furthermore, humidity may be a limiting factor in the selection of fan rotation speed.
[0033] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining a minimum rotation speed of fans in each of a plurality of groups of the cooling system. However, in other embodiments, all groups of fans of the cooling system are considered individually with respect to distribution of their tonal frequencies.In some embodiments, the predetermined frequency difference Af is selected to be within 5-60 Hz, such as within 8-12 Hz. This is found as suitable for distribution of frequencies in the relevant tonal frequency range for tonal fan noise.
[0034] In some embodiments, a control system of the wind turbine has stored information about each controllable fan of the cooling system, e.g. maximum allowable rotation speed and its number of fan blades, so as to allow calculation between rotation speed and frequency of acoustic tonal noise generated at said rotation speed.
[0035] In a second aspect, the invention provides a wind turbine comprising
[0036] - a rotor comprising a plurality of rotor blades,
[0037] - an electric generator coupled to the rotor,
[0038] - a gearbox connecting the rotor and the electric generator,
[0039] - a cooling system comprising a plurality of fans, and
[0040] - a controller for controlling operation of the wind turbine, wherein the controller comprises a processor, and wherein the controller is arranged to cause the wind turbine to perform the method according to the first aspect.
[0041] In preferred embodiments, the wind turbine comprises a tower, a nacelle in which the electric generator is arranged, and wherein the rotor comprises three rotor blades. Especially, the wind turbine may be configured to produce at least 1 MW electric power, such as 1 -10 MW, or more than 10 MW of electric power.
[0042] In a third aspect, the invention provides a wind farm comprising a plurality of wind turbines according to the second aspect.
[0043] It is to be understood that the same advantages and preferred embodiments and features described for the first aspect apply as well for the second and third aspects, and the aspects may be mixed in any way.
[0044] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES
[0045] The invention will now be described in more detail with regard to the accompanying figures of whichFIG. 1 illustrates a wind turbine embodiment,
[0046] FIG. 2 illustrates an example of simple steps of a control algorithm for implementing the method according of the invention,
[0047] FIG. 3 illustrates steps of a method embodiment, and
[0048] FIG. 4 illustrates frequencies of tonal components of fans as an example of how to increase rotation speeds of fans to distribute tonal noise components of the fans.
[0049] The figures illustrate specific ways of implementing the present invention and are not to be construed as being limiting to other possible embodiments falling within the scope of the attached claim set.
[0050] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0051] FIG. 1 illustrates a wind turbine embodiment. Typically, the wind turbine has two or three rotor blades BL which serve to drive an electric generator GN located inside the nacelle NC on top of a tower TW. A gearbox GBX is located inside the nacelle to connect an axle of the rotor and the generator GN. Such wind turbine may generate an electric power of at least 1 MW, such as 1 -10 MW, or more than 10 MW.
[0052] The wind turbine further comprises a cooling system CLS comprising a plurality of cooling fans F1 , F2 serving to provide air cooling of components inside the nacelle NC, e.g. electric power converter components etc. Depending on their rotation speed and the number of blades on the fans F1 , F2, the fans will generate acoustical tonal noise components at frequencies F_F1 , F_F2 determined by rotation speed times the number of blades on the fan. E.g. 5 rotations per second (300 RPM) with 8 blades will result in a tonal noise component frequency of 40 Hz.
[0053] If two or more similar fans F1 , F2 are controlled to operate at the same rotation speed, they will generate the same tonal noise frequency, and thus the total noise from the wind turbine will be dominated by that tone, which cases an annoying effect. Further, with respect to fulfil limits for external noise from the wind turbine, it can be possible to avoid a so-called “pure tone penalty” and therebythe wind turbine can be located at a lower distance from dwellings than if its noise was dominated by a tonal component F_F1 , F_F2.
[0054] The fans F1 , F2 are controllable with respect to rotation speed by means of a control system C_S, so as to allow the cooling system CLS to vary the cooling provided by the fans F1 , F2 according to actual conditions, e.g. sensed temperature T and humidity H, i.e. actual cooling requirements.
[0055] Further, the constraint of a total sound power limit generated by the wind turbine may be taken into account. A limiting factor to not allow the fans to have an increased speed to avoid the same tonal frequency, could be the fact that the wind turbine (or fans) are already causing too high sound power levels, or too close (or above) the sound power limits.
[0056] According to the invention, the control system C_S further executes an algorithm which determines the tonal noise frequencies F_F1 , F_F2 current generated by the fans F1 , F2, and in case it is determined that two tonal noise frequencies are within a predetermined frequency distance Af, the algorithm calculates new higher rotation speeds for at least some of the fans F1 , F2, so preferably all tonal components are distributed, so neighbour frequencies are separated at least by the predeterm ined frequency distance Af, e.g. Af= 10 Hz. The control system C_S will then generate a control signal FSC to control the rotation speeds of the fans F1 , F2 according to the changed rotation speeds that will ensure distributed tonal components F_F1 , F_F2.
[0057] If a plurality of tonal components are spaced apart, humans will perceive the plurality of tonal components as separate tones. Thus, the total noise will be perceived as less annoying.
[0058] Thus, with the proposed method, annoying tonal noise from the wind turbine caused by the fans F1 , F2 can be avoided, still complying with the cooling requirements, since the fans F1 , F2 are only changed to a higher rotation speed than required to comply with the cooling requirements.In practical implementations, the control system C_S will determine cooling requirements based on updated temperature T and humidity H inputs and further determine the changed rotation speeds for tonal noise distribution and accordingly control fan rotation speeds FSC, e.g. by running a predetermined algorithm on a regular basis, e.g. once every X seconds. X may be selected based on various specific conditions, but especially X may be selected to be within 5-300 seconds.
[0059] FIG. 2 illustrates an example of a practical algorithm. The basis is to start with determining fan speeds for all N fans to be considered in a cooling system to ensure that cooling requirements can be fulfilled. Next, the corresponding tonal frequency components f caused by the blade passing frequencies of each of the fans are sorted, starting from the lowest frequency. Then the frequency distance between two neighbor frequencies is checked, and if the distance is found to be smaller than a predetermined frequency difference Af, e.g. Af being a frequency value within 5-20 Hz, such as 10 Hz, the speed of the fan with the highest tonal component frequency is increased so its frequency distance to the lower frequency is Af. This is continued for all N fans.
[0060] When completed, the N fans are controlled to operate at the changed rotation speeds to ensure distributed tonal frequencies for a period of X seconds, and after that, the algorithm is repeated now with updated cooling requirements. The period X seconds can be such as 5-300 seconds.
[0061] FIG. 3 illustrates steps of a method embodiment, i.e. a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. The method comprises identifying I FF frequencies of tonal acoustic noise generated by a plurality of fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine. Next, generating G_O_L an ordered list of said frequencies. Further, determining D DF frequency differences between neighbor frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies. In case a frequency difference between neighbor frequencies is below a predetermined frequency difference Af, e.g. 10 Hz, then increasing I F one or more of said frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies to obtain a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference Af between neighbor frequencies. Further, determining D_RS rotation speeds of said plurality of fans to cause the fans to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with said redistributed list of frequencies. Finally, controlling C_RSrotation speed of said plurality of fans according to said determined rotation speeds.
[0062] FIG. 4 illustrates a specific example of a graph illustrating a horizontal frequency axis FRQ. The straight vertical lines indicate tonal components generated by respective cooling fans. In a preferred algorithm for redistributing the tonal components to ensure a frequency distance of at least Af, the lowest frequency components are first considered.
[0063] In the example, initially, the lowest frequency component and its nearest neighbor, the frequency component of fan F1 is indicated by the dashed vertical line. As seen, this distance between frequency components was found to be too small, i.e. smaller than Af. Thus, as indicated by the dashed arrow, the algorithm determines to increase rotation speed of fan F1 , to increase its frequency component to F_F1 , i.e. with a difference of Af from its lower neighbor. In a similar manner, the rotation speed of fan F2 is also increased from its initial frequency (vertical dashed line) to result in an increased frequency component F_F2.
[0064] As a result, tonal components of all fans are distributed with a mutual distance of at least Af, and thus the total noise from the fans will be perceived as less annoying. In some cases, different fans may generate acoustic noise with the same frequency which will then result in a higher overall amplitude.
[0065] In some cases it may be preferred to operate two or more fans at rotations speeds so they generate the same tonal component, e.g. if it is not possible to distribute frequency components from all fans.
[0066] Generally, each fan has a maximum allowable rotation speed which can not be exceeded even though it may be preferred to do so with respect to the masking effect. However, it may be possible to operate the fans at an oscillating varying speed which in a limited period of time exceeds its maximum allowable rotation speed.In a specific example, if a fan is allowed to operate at a maximum rotation speed to result in a maximum frequency of 100 Hz, whereas the desired frequency is 110 Hz, then the fan may be operated alternatively at rotations speeds providing 90 Hz and 110 Hz respectively, thus providing an average of 100 Hz. This is acceptable with respect to operation of the fan, and at least the fan can contribute to optimal tonal masking in a part of the time of operation.
[0067] In case it would be intended to operate a plurality fans with alternating rotation speeds, two or more fans may be operated to alternate rotation speeds in inverse order, so the two fans generate acoustic noise at inverse frequencies.
[0068] In some cases where cooling requirements are high, e.g. at high temperatures and / or high humidity, it may not be possible to operate any of the fans at rotation speeds which are low enough to provide a distribution of frequency components.
[0069] To sum up, the invention provides a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. The method comprises identifying I FF frequencies of tonal acoustic noise generated by a plurality of fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine. Further, generating G_O_L an ordered list of said frequencies, and determining D DF frequency differences between neighboring frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies. In case a frequency difference between neighboring frequencies is below a predetermined frequency difference, then it is determined to increase l_F one or more of said frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies to obtain a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference between neighboring frequencies. Further, determining D_RS rotation speeds of said plurality of fans to cause the fans to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with said redistributed list of frequencies, and finally controlling C_RS rotation speed of said plurality of fans according to said determined rotation speeds. In this way, tonal character in the total noise from all fans can be avoided, thereby avoiding tonal character in the total noise from the wind turbine.
[0070] Although the present invention has been described in connection with the specified embodiments, it should not be construed as being in any way limited to the presented examples. The scope of the present invention is to be interpreted in the light of the accompanying claim set. In the context of the claims, the terms“including” or “includes” do not exclude other possible elements or steps. Also, the mentioning of references such as “a” or “an” etc. should not be construed as excluding a plurality. The use of reference signs in the claims with respect to elements indicated in the figures shall also not be construed as limiting the scope of the invention. Furthermore, individual features mentioned in different claims, may possibly be advantageously combined, and the mentioning of these features in different claims does not exclude that a combination of features is not possible and advantageous.
Claims
CLAIMS1 . A method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine, said method comprising:- identifying (l_FF) frequencies of tonal acoustic noise of a plurality of fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine,- generating (G_O_L) an ordered list of said frequencies,- determining (D DF) frequency differences between neighboring frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies,- in case a frequency difference between neighboring frequencies is below a predetermined frequency difference, increasing (l_F) one or more of said frequencies in said ordered list of frequencies to obtain a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference between neighboring frequencies,- determining (D_RS) rotation speeds of said plurality of fans to cause the fans to generate tonal acoustic noise with said redistributed list of frequencies, and- controlling (C_RS) rotation speed of said plurality of fans according to said determined rotation speeds.
2. The method according to claim 1 , comprising repeating performing the steps of the method at a predetermined interval, such as a predetermined interval selected within 5-300 seconds.
3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, further comprising determining if the determined rotation speeds of each of said plurality of fans exceed maximum allowable rotation speed for said fans before controlling rotation speed of said fans accordingly.
4. The method according to claim 3, comprising setting rotation speed equal to maximum allowable rotation speed for each of the fans where said determined rotation speed was determined to exceed maximum allowable rotation speed.
5. The method according to claim 3 or 4, wherein at least one of the fans where said determined rotation speed was determined to exceed maximum allowable rotation speed, said at least one fan is controlled to operate at an oscillating rotation speed which in a part of an oscillating cycle exceeds maximum allowable rotation speed of said at least one fan.
6. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising controlling at least one fan to operate at an oscillating rotation speed.
7. The method according to claim 6, wherein said at least one fan is controlled to operate with an oscillating rotation speed so as to generate tonal acoustic noise oscillating around a predetermined center frequency.
8. The method according to claim 6 or 7, wherein said at least one fan is controlled to generate tonal acoustic noise between a minimum frequency and a maximum frequency, wherein a difference between the maximum frequency and the minimum frequency is selected to be within 5-60 Hz.
9. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising determining if cooling requirements of the cooling system is fulfilled with current rotation speeds of the plurality of fans, and adjusting rotation speeds of the plurality of fans to fulfil the cooling requirements.
10. The method according to claim 9, comprising iteratively changing between:- determining if cooling requirements of the cooling system are fulfilled with current rotation speeds of the plurality of fans, and- said step of generating a redistributed list of frequencies with said predetermined frequency difference (Af), and controlling rotation speeds of said plurality of fans accordingly.
11. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising controlling two or more of the plurality of fans to generate acoustic noise at one frequency, in case it is determined that it is not possible to distribute tonal acoustic noise frequency for all fans with said predetermined frequency difference (Af).
12. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising controlling one or more of the plurality of fans according to an offset rotation speed mode of operation.
13. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising determining a minimum rotation speed of fans in each of a plurality of groups of the cooling system .
14. The method according to any of the preceding claims, wherein said predetermined frequency difference (Af) is selected to be within 5-60 Hz.
15. The method according to any of the preceding claims, further comprising determining minimum fan speeds of the plurality of fans so that the minimum cooling requirements are met.
16. A wind turbine comprising- a rotor comprising a plurality of rotor blades (BL),- an electric generator (GN) coupled to the rotor,- a cooling system (CLS) comprising a plurality of fans (F1 , F2), and- a controller (C_SA) for controlling operation of the wind turbine, wherein the controller comprises a processor, and wherein the controller is arranged to cause the wind turbine to perform the method according to any of claims 1 -14.
