Wind turbine with control of cooling FANS to mask tonal noise

By controlling cooling fans to generate noise within a masking frequency range, the method effectively reduces the annoyance of tonal noise from wind turbines, allowing closer placement to dwellings without additional costs.

WO2026233518A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-12VESTAS WIND SYSTEMS AS
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/DK2026/060056
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-07
Filing Date
2026-05-04
Publication Date
2026-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Wind turbines generate external tonal acoustic noise, which is perceived as more annoying and requires greater distance from dwellings or operational restrictions, making passive noise attenuation techniques costly and ineffective.

Method used

Control the rotation speed of the cooling fans in a wind turbine to generate noise within a masking frequency range that overlaps with the tonal noise from the gearbox, ensuring the fans meet cooling requirements while masking the dominant tonal noise.

Benefits of technology

The method reduces the perceived annoyance of tonal noise by using cooling fans to generate noise that masks the gearbox noise, avoiding the 'pure tone penalty' and allowing closer proximity to dwellings.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure DK2026060056_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure DK2026060056_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. The method comprises determining (D_TC) one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine, e.g. tonal noise from the gearbox. Further, determining (D_MFR) a masking frequency range (MFR) in response to a frequency of the one or more tonal components. Further, identifying (I_F1) at least one fan of a cooling system of the wind turbine which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with a frequency which is within said masking frequency range. Further, determining (D_CR) cooling requirements of the cooling system of the wind turbine, and determining (D_CR_F) if said cooling requirements can be fulfilled in case said at least one fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within said masking frequency range. Finally, controlling (C_RS_F1) rotation speed of said at least one fan to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled. In this way (tonal) acoustic noise from cooling fans can be used to mask a critical tonal component of the wind turbine gearbox, still ensuring that the fans comply with cooling requirements. Thus, external noise from the wind turbine can be less annoying by utilizing the masking effect.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] WIND TURBINE WITH CONTROL OF COOLING FANS TO MASK TONAL NOISE

[0002] FIELD OF THE INVENTION

[0003] The present invention relates to the field of wind turbines. More specifically, the invention relates to a method for controlling tonal acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine by controlling fans of a cooling system of a wind turbine to mask tonal acoustic noise e.g. tonal noise generated by the gearbox of the wind turbine.

[0004] BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION

[0005] Apart from turbulent aerodynamic noise from the blades, wind turbines often generate external tonal acoustic noise to the environment, e.g. caused by gear wheel meshing in the gearbox connecting the rotor and generator. If noise is dominated by tonal noise components, it is perceived more annoying compared to wideband noise at the same sound pressure level.

[0006] For this reason, legal practice for regulation of external noise in some countries includes a so-called “pure tone penalty”, i.e. a “penalty” value to be added to a sound pressure level measured from the noise source, if the noise has a pure tone character. This means that if the noise is found to be tonal, a value of e.g. 5 dB will added before comparing the measured noise level with noise level limits setup.

[0007] Therefore, if a wind turbine generates noise with a tonal character, it is required that it is placed at a significant larger distance from dwellings compared to the same wind turbine without tonal noise. Alternatively, its mode of operation will be significantly restricted compared to the same wind turbine without tonal noise.

[0008] Thus, it is desirable to attenuate external tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. However, classical passive noise attenuation techniques for reducing tonal noise from the gearbox, generator or other source of tonal noise in MW size wind turbines is complicated, expensive and often with limited effect.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION

[0009] Thus, according to the above description, it is an object of the present invention to provide a method to effectively eliminate tonal acoustic noise from a wind turbine.

[0010] In a first aspect, the invention provides a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine, said method comprising:

[0011] - determining one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine,

[0012] - determining a masking frequency range in response to a frequency of the one or more tonal components of noise generated by the wind turbine,

[0013] - identifying at least one fan of a cooling system of the wind turbine which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with a frequency which is within said masking frequency range,

[0014] - determining cooling requirements of the cooling system of the wind turbine, and - determining if said cooling requirements can be fulfilled in case said at least one fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within said masking frequency range, and

[0015] - controlling rotation speed of said at least one fan to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled.

[0016] Such method is advantageous, since it has proven possible to use the wind turbine’s own cooling fans to mask tonal noise from the potential source, e.g. the gearbox. This is done by controlling the cooling fans to operate with rotation speeds so that they generate noise, e.g. tonal noise, with different frequencies than the tonal noise components generated by the source, but still within what is known as the masking frequency range. Thereby, the cooling fans can generate the psychoacoustic effect of masking the tonal noise from the tonal noise source.

[0017] Even though it is ensured that the fans of the cooling system operate to fulfill the actual cooling requirements, it is possible to operate the fans at a higher rotation speed than required for cooling, thereby allowing at least some control of the noise caused by their blades, namely noise, e.g. tonal noise, centered around afrequency determined by the blade passing frequency (rotation speed times the number of fan blades). Thus, cooling fans can cooperate to generate different noise components which are distributed within a certain frequency range of the annoying tonal noise from the wind turbine, e.g. the tonal noise from the gearbox.

[0018] With this masking effect, the total noise from the wind turbine will be perceived as less annoying, since the dominating tonal component from the source can be masked by the noise from the cooling fans. This may be so, in spite the tonal components from the cooling fans have lower noise levels than the dominating tonal component from the source, e.g. the gearbox.

[0019] Rotation speeds of the cooling fans can be controlled to follow one or more known tonal noise components from the potential source(s), e.g. the gearbox, even if the rotor speed changes, and a masking effect can be obtained to ensure that the external noise from the wind turbine is not perceived as tonal, and thus less annoying. At the same time, the so-called “tonal noise penalty” can be avoided when evaluating external noise effect from the wind turbine.

[0020] The invention can for example be implemented in software on existing wind turbine controllers and utilizing existing fans of cooling system of the wind turbine. However, in some cases, it may be possible to improve the masking effect, if the number of fans and / or their blade numbers are selected especially to allow generation of tonal noise at a frequency for masking a known problematic tonal noise component.

[0021] In the following, preferred features and embodiments will be described.

[0022] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining a frequency of at least one tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a gearbox connecting a rotor and an electric generator of the wind turbine. E.g. the first harmonic but most preferably both the first and second harmonics of the gearbox noise.

[0023] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining first and second frequencies of respective first and second most important or relevant tonal components of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine, especially the twomost important or dominant tonal components, such as first and second harmonic of acoustic noise generated by the gearbox. Especially, the method may comprise determining the masking frequency range to be an interval between the first and second frequencies, so as to allow masking of both the first and second tonal components of acoustic noise.

[0024] In some embodiments, the method comprises identifying a plurality of fans of the cooling system which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with different frequencies within said masking frequency range, and controlling rotation speed of said at plurality of fans to generate (tonal) noise at different frequencies, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled. Especially, the method may comprise controlling rotation speed of a first fan to generate (tonal) noise at a first frequency range and controlling rotation speed of a second fan to generate (tonal) noise at a second frequency range. In this way, an improved masking effect can be obtained. More specifically, the first frequency may be selected within a masking frequency range around a frequency of a first tonal component of noise generated by the wind turbine, and wherein the second frequency is selected within a masking frequency range around a frequency of a second tonal component of noise generated by the wind turbine. In this way two fans can be used for masking of individual critical tone components, e.g. first and second harmonics of the gearbox noise.

[0025] In some embodiments, the method comprise prioritizing an identified fan which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with a frequency which is below the one or more tonal component of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled when the identified fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with said frequency. In this way the fan is operated with minimal electrical energy required, and still fulfils cooling requirements and provides an acoustic masking effect.

[0026] In some embodiments, the method comprises identifying at least one fan of a first group of the cooling system and at least one fan of a second group of the cooling system which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with frequencies which are within said masking frequency range, determining first coolingrequirements of the first group of the cooling system and determining second cooling requirements of the second group of the cooling system, and controlling rotation speed of said at least one fan of each of the first and second groups of the cooling systems to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that both of the first and second cooling requirements can be fulfilled. Thus, separate groups of fans of the cooling system can cooperate to provide optimal masking of a critical tone component, e.g. tonal gearbox noise.

[0027] In some embodiments, the method comprises identifying first and second fans of the cooling system, controlling rotation speed of the first fan to generate (tonal) acoustic noise at a first frequency which is below a first tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine, and controlling rotation speed of the second fan to generate (tonal) acoustic noise at a second frequency which is above the first tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine.

[0028] In some embodiments, the method comprises controlling at least one fan to operate at an oscillating rotation speed to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range. Especially, said at least one fan may be controlled to operate at an oscillating rotation speed which in a part of an oscillating cycle exceeds maximum allowable rotation speed of said at least one fan. In this way, the fan may contribute to the masking effect at a tonal noise component even outside its maximum allowable rotation speed.

[0029] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining a minimum rotation speed of fans in each of a plurality of groups of the cooling system. Hereby, separate cooling requirements of separate groups of the cooling system can be complied with.

[0030] In some embodiments, the method comprises operating at least two fans at rotation speeds sequenced so that the at least two fans spin in phase or out of phase.In some embodiments, a further constraint in the control of rotation speed of said at least one fan is that the total sound power generated from the wind turbine is below a preset limit.

[0031] In some embodiments, the method comprises determining a frequency of said one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine in response to a rotation speed of the rotor or generator of the wind turbine.

[0032] Especially, a control system of the wind turbine can have a table of frequencies of critical tonal components e.g. of the gearbox which are known for a given wind turbine type, and thus a signal of actual rotation speed of rotor or gearbox can be translated into these critical frequencies.

[0033] In some embodiments, a control system of the wind turbine has stored information about each controllable fan of the cooling system, e.g. maximum allowable rotation speed and its number of fan blades, so as to allow calculation between rotation speed and frequency of acoustic (tonal) noise generated at said rotation speed.

[0034] In a second aspect, the invention provides a wind turbine comprising

[0035] - a rotor comprising a plurality of rotor blades,

[0036] - an electric generator coupled to the rotor,

[0037] - a gearbox connecting the rotor and the electric generator,

[0038] - a cooling system comprising at least one fan, and

[0039] - a controller for controlling operation of the wind turbine, wherein the controller comprises a processor, and wherein the controller is arranged to cause the wind turbine to perform the method according to the first aspect.

[0040] In preferred embodiments, the wind turbine comprises a tower, a nacelle in which the electric generator is arranged, and wherein the rotor comprises three rotor blades. Especially, the wind turbine may be configured to produce at least 1 MW electric power, such as 1 -10 MW, or more than 10 MW of electric power.

[0041] In a third aspect, the invention provides a wind farm comprising a plurality of wind turbines according to the second aspect. The wind turbines may be operatedindividually with respect to check of cooling requirements and control of rotation speed of fans to obtain a masking effect accordingly.

[0042] It is to be understood that the same advantages and preferred embodiments and features described for the first aspect apply as well for the second and third aspects, and the aspects may be mixed in any way.

[0043] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE FIGURES

[0044] The invention will now be described in more detail with regard to the accompanying figures of which

[0045] FIG. 1 illustrates a wind turbine embodiment,

[0046] FIG. 2 illustrates frequencies of tonal components as an example of how to operate two fans at higher rotation speeds than required for cooling thereby masking frequency range around a critical tonal noise component from the wind turbine gearbox,

[0047] FIG. 3 illustrates steps of a method embodiment, and

[0048] FIG. 4 illustrates an example of simple steps of a control algorithm for implementing the method according of the invention.

[0049] The figures illustrate specific ways of implementing the present invention and are not to be construed as being limiting to other possible embodiments falling within the scope of the attached claim set.

[0050] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

[0051] FIG. 1 illustrates a wind turbine embodiment. Typically, the wind turbine has two or three rotor blades BL which serve to drive an electric generator GN located inside the nacelle NC on top of a tower TW. A gearbox GBX is located inside the nacelle to connect an axle of the rotor and the generator GN. Such wind turbine may generate an electric power of at least 1 MW, such as 1 -10 MW, or more than 10 MW.The gearbox GBX is known to be a source of external acoustic tonal noise from various wind turbines due to gear wheel meshing. Vibrations from the gearbox GXB are transmitted to the tower TW and blades BL which in turn radiate tonal acoustical noise to the environment with a frequency of F_GB determined by the gear wheel meshing of the gearbox GBX.

[0052] It is to be understood that the tonal noise source may be other than the gearbox GBX, and still the principle of the invention can be applied.

[0053] The wind turbine further comprises a cooling system CLS comprising a plurality of cooling fans F1 , F2 serving to provide air cooling of components inside the nacelle NC, e.g. electric power converter components etc. Depending on their rotation speed and the number of blades on the fans F1 , F2, the fans will generate acoustical (tonal) noise components at or around frequencies F_F1 , F_F2 determined by rotation speed times the number of blades on the fan. E.g. 5 rotations per second with 8 blades will result in a tonal noise component frequency of 40 Hz.

[0054] Typically, the noise level of each noise component F_F1 , F_F2 of the fans F1 , F2 will be lower than the critical tonal component F_GB from the gearbox GBX.

[0055] However still, if these components F_F1 , F_F2 are arranged inside the so-called masking frequency range around the critical component F_GB, but with a frequency difference from the critical component F_GB, it is possible to obtain a psychoacoustic masking effect. This means that the fan (tonal) noise components F_F1 , F_F2 can provide a masking effect which causes the critical component F_GB to be less audible and especially less annoying.

[0056] Further, with respect to fulfil limits for external noise from the wind turbine, it can be possible to avoid a so-called “pure tone penalty” and thereby the wind turbine can be located at a lower distance from dwellings than if its noise was dominated by the tonal component F_GB.

[0057] The fans F1 , F2 are controllable with respect to rotation speed by means of a control system C_S, so as to allow the cooling system CLS to vary the coolingprovided by the fans F1 , F2 according to actual conditions, e.g. sensed temperature T and humidity H, i.e. actual cooling requirements.

[0058] According to the invention, the control system C_S further receives information regarding rotation speed RS of the rotor or gearbox GBX. From this rotation speed RS, the control system C_S determined, e.g. from tabulated values, a critical gearbox GBX tonal noise component F_GB. Based on a tabulated masking frequency range around this critical gearbox tonal noise component F_GB, the actual cooling requirements based on the actual conditions T, H, the control system C_S can determine if it is possible to control one or more of the fans F1 , F2 to operate at a rotation speed which fulfils both of:

[0059] 1 ) the determined cooling requirements, and

[0060] 2) that the fan F1 , F2 will generate a (tonal) noise component with a frequency F_F1 , F_F2 within the masking frequency range around the critical tonal component F_GB.

[0061] I n case both of 1 ) and 2) can be fulfilled, the control system C_S will generate a control signal FSC to control the rotation speed of the fan F1 , F2 to such rotation speed. This rotation speed will typically be higher than the rotation speed required for fulfilling cooling requirements. In general, it cannot be accepted to operate fans F1 , F2 at a lower rotation speed than that require for fulfilling the cooling requirements, even if this could be used to provide tonal fan noise within the masking frequency range. However, it may be possible to decrease rotation speed of one fan F1 , while increasing rotation speed of another fan F2 in order to still fulfil the cooling requirements, if it is then possible to bring the (tonal) acoustic noise component of that fan F1 within the masking frequency range.

[0062] In practical implementations, the control system C_S will determine cooling requirements based on updated temperature T and humidity H inputs and further determine rotation speed demands for tonal masking by the fans F1 , F2 based on updated rotor rotation speed RS of the wind turbine and accordingly determine fan rotation speeds FSC, e.g. by running a predetermined algorithm on a regular basis, e.g. once every X seconds. In general, this time period X for running the algorithm can be preset or calculated or identified based on certain metacharacteristics of the specific wind turbine, e.g. regarding location, operation mode etc.

[0063] FIG. 2 illustrates a specific example of a graph illustrating a horizontal frequency axis FRQ. A dominating and therefore critical gearbox tonal component F_GB is illustrated to be the highest (loudest) component. Further, (tonal) acoustic components are illustrated including (tonal) components generated by fans F1 , F2, namely at frequencies F_F1 and F_F2 which as seen to be positioned inside the masking frequency range MFR and thereby contribute to provide a masking effect on the dominating gearbox tonal component F_GB.

[0064] In FIG. 2 the dashed vertical lines indicate (tonal) acoustic components generated by fans F1 , F2 if operated at a rotation speed which just fulfils the cooling requirements. However, these frequencies are seen to be too low to be within the masking frequency range MFR, and thus in this case the control system C_S will determine to increase rotation speed of the fans F1 , F2, indicated by the curved and dashed arrows, so they both end up generating (tonal) components F_F1 , F_F2 within the masking frequency range MFR. One F_F1 at a frequency lower than the critical component F_GB, and the other one F_F2 at a frequency higher than the critical component F_GB. In this way, the two fans F1 , F2 contribute to generate (tonal) noise that masks the critical component F_GB.

[0065] As seen in FIG. 2, there are further frequency components within the masking frequency range MFR, illustrating further fans which are controlled to operate at rotation speeds so they generate frequency components within the masking frequency range, but with different frequencies such that the fan (tonal) component frequencies are distributed within the masking frequency range MFR. These frequency components from further fan components within the masking frequency range MFR may or may not be included. Thus, such further components may be existent or non-existent.

[0066] In some cases it may be preferred to operate two or more fans at rotations speeds so they generate the same (tonal) component, e.g. if their noise levels individually are very low compared to the critical component F_GB.Generally, each fan has a maximum allowable rotation speed which cannot be exceeded even though it may be preferred to do so with respect to the masking effect. However, it may be possible to operate the fans at an oscillating varying speed which in a limited period of time exceeds its maximum allowable rotation speed.

[0067] In some cases where cooling requirements are high, e.g. at high temperatures and / or high humidity, it may not be possible to operate any of the fans at rotation speeds which are low enough to provide a masking effect.

[0068] FIG. 3 illustrates steps of a method embodiment, i.e. a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. The method comprises determining D_TC one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine, for example this may be first and / or second harmonic frequency of noise generated by the gearbox at the actual rotor speed of the wind turbine. Next, determining D MFR a masking frequency range in response to a frequency of the one or more tonal components. Next, identifying l_F1 one or more fans of a cooling system of the wind turbine which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with a frequency which is within the masking frequency range. Further, determining D OR cooling requirements of the cooling system of the wind turbine, e.g. for cooling of electric converter components of the wind turbine. Next, determining D_CR_F if said cooling requirements can be fulfilled in case the one or more fans are operated at a rotation speed to generate (tonal) noise within said masking frequency range. Finally, controlling C_RS_F1 rotation speed of the one or more fans to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled.

[0069] Preferably, it is determined to operate fans at the lowest rotation speed which both fulfills the cooling requirements and being within the masking frequency range. Further, if possible with respect to cooling requirements, it is preferred to determine to control a plurality of fans at different rotation speeds so as to cause the fans to generate (tonal) noise at different frequencies within the masking frequency range. Most preferably, if possible with respect to cooling requirements, at least one fan is controlled to generate (tonal) noise at or around frequencies below the critical tonal component to be masked, while another fan is controlledto generate (tonal) noise at or around frequencies above the critical tonal component to be masked.

[0070] FIG. 4 illustrates an example of a practical algorithm. The basis is to start with determining critical tone frequency, e.g. based on rotation speed which can be translated to the critical tone frequency for a given specific wind turbine, e.g. the rotation speed may be gearbox rotation speed or rotor speed. For example, this step may comprise calculating frequency of gearbox harmonics and identifying which one of these is the most critical one to mask. Next, calculate the masking frequency range around the critical tone frequency and calculate fan rotation speed range for one or more fans which can offer tonality masking. Still, it should be further checked that the rotation speed range is within the maximum allowable for each fan.

[0071] Further, based on actual conditions such as temperature and humidity, cooling requirements can be determined to arrive at a fan speed range for acceptable cooling. Then, it is determined if there is an overlap between fan speed range determined for acceptable cooling and for tonality masking. If not, then it is not possible to obtain a masking effect, and the fans are operated for cooling only for a certain period, e.g. X seconds.

[0072] If it is determined that there is an overlap, one or more fans are operated at rotations speeds for tonal masking, also for a certain period of time, e.g. X seconds. Preferably, these fans are operated at the lowest possible rotations speeds which can mask the critical tone component in order to minimize electric energy for driving the fans.

[0073] In this way, a stable operation is maintained for a period of time after which the algorithm repeats itself. For example, the period of time may be 5-60 seconds or in general this period of time is selected based on various conditions.

[0074] It is to be understood that the algorithm illustrated in FIG. 4 is simplified to illustrate the invention. For example, the cooling system may include a plurality of separate groups of fans each with separate cooling requirements which need to be taken into account individually. Further, in case many fans are available for tonalmasking, it may be preferred to have a specific strategy regarding how to distribute their (tonal) frequency components in an optimal way for masking, without the risk that the total tonal noise level by the fans themselves exceeds the noise level of the critical component to be masked.

[0075] Still further, it may for some wind turbines preferable to determine the masking frequency range to be an interval between first and second frequencies, so as to allow masking of both of the first and second tonal components of acoustic noise, e.g. first and second harmonic frequencies of the gearbox noise. Thus, handling two separate critical tone components will cause the control algorithm to be more complex.

[0076] To sum up, the invention provides a method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine. The method comprises determining D_TC one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine, e.g. tonal noise from the gearbox. Further, determining D MFR a masking frequency range MFR in response to a frequency of the one or more tonal components. Further, identifying l_F1 at least one fan of a cooling system of the wind turbine which can be controlled to generate (tonal) acoustic noise with a frequency which is within said masking frequency range. Further, determining D_CR cooling requirements of the cooling system of the wind turbine, and determining D_CR_F if said cooling requirements can be fulfilled in case said at least one fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within said masking frequency range. Finally, controlling C_RS_F1 rotation speed of said at least one fan to generate (tonal) acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled. In this way (tonal) noise from cooling fans can be used to mask a critical tonal component of the wind turbine, e.g. the gearbox, still ensuring that the fans comply with cooling requirements. Thus, external noise from the wind turbine can be less annoying by utilizing the masking effect.

[0077] Although the present invention has been described in connection with the specified embodiments, it should not be construed as being in any way limited to the presented examples. The scope of the present invention is to be interpreted inthe light of the accompanying claim set. In the context of the claims, the terms “including” or “includes” do not exclude other possible elements or steps. Also, the mentioning of references such as “a” or “an” etc. should not be construed as excluding a plurality. The use of reference signs in the claims with respect to elements indicated in the figures shall also not be construed as limiting the scope of the invention. Furthermore, individual features mentioned in different claims, may possibly be advantageously combined, and the mentioning of these features in different claims does not exclude that a combination of features is not possible and advantageous.

Claims

CLAIMS1 . A method for controlling tonal noise generated by a wind turbine, said method comprising:- determining (D_TC) one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine,- determining (D_MFR) a masking frequency range (MFR) in response to a frequency of the one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine,- identifying (l_F1 ) at least one fan of a cooling system of the wind turbine which can be controlled to generate acoustic noise with a frequency which is within said masking frequency range,- determining (D_CR) cooling requirements of the cooling system of the wind turbine, and- determining (D_CR_F) if said cooling requirements can be fulfilled in case said at least one fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate acoustic noise within said masking frequency range, and- controlling (C_RS_F1) rotation speed of said at least one fan to generate acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled.

2. The method according to claim 1 , comprising determining a frequency of at least one tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a gearbox connecting a rotor and an electric generator of the wind turbine.

3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, comprising determining first and second frequencies of respective first and second tonal components of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine, such as first and second harmonic of acoustic noise generated by the gearbox.

4. The method according to claim 3, comprising determining the masking frequency range to be an interval between the first and second frequencies, so as to allow masking of both of the first and second tonal components of acoustic noise.

5. The method according to any of the preceding claims, identifying a plurality of fans of the cooling system which can be controlled to generate acoustic noise with different frequencies within said masking frequency range, and controlling rotation speed of said plurality of fans to generate noise at different frequencies, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled.

6. The method according to claim 5, comprising controlling rotation speed of a first fan to generate noise at a first frequency, and controlling rotation speed of a second fan to generate noise at a second frequency.

7. The method according to claim 6, wherein the first frequency is selected within a masking frequency range around a frequency of a first tonal component of noise generated by the wind turbine, and wherein the second frequency is selected within a masking frequency range around a frequency of a second tonal component of noise generated by the wind turbine.

8. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising prioritizing an identified fan which can be controlled to generate acoustic noise with a frequency which is below the one or more tonal component of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine, in case it is determined that said cooling requirements can be fulfilled when the identified fan is operated at a rotation speed to generate acoustic noise with said frequency.

9. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising identifying at least one fan of a first group of the cooling system and at least one fan of a second group of the cooling system which can be controlled to generate acoustic noise with frequencies which are within said masking frequency range, determining first cooling requirements of the first group of the cooling system and determining second cooling requirements of the second group of the coolingsystem, and controlling rotation speed of said at least one fan of each of the first and second groups of the cooling systems to generate acoustic noise within the masking frequency range, in case it is determined that both of the first and second cooling requirements can be fulfilled.

10. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising identifying first and second fans of the cooling system, controlling rotation speed of the first fan to generate acoustic noise at a first frequency which is below a first tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine, and controlling rotation speed of the second fan to generate tonal acoustic noise at a second frequency which is above the first tonal component of acoustic noise generated by a wind turbine.

11. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising controlling at least one fan to operate at an oscillating rotation speed to generate acoustic noise within the masking frequency range.

12. The method according to claim 11 , wherein said at least one fan is controlled to operate at an oscillating rotation speed which in a part of an oscillating cycle exceeds maximum allowable rotation speed of said at least one fan.

13. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising determining a minimum rotation speed of fans in each of a plurality of groups of the cooling system .

14. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising operating at least two fans at rotation speeds sequenced so that the at least two fans spin in phase or out of phase.

15. The method according to any of the preceding claims, comprising determining a frequency of said one or more tonal components of acoustic noise generated by the wind turbine in response to a rotation speed of the rotor or generator of the wind turbine.

16. A wind turbine comprising- a rotor comprising a plurality of rotor blades (BL),- an electric generator (GN) coupled to the rotor,- a gearbox (GBX) connecting the rotor and the electric generator,- a cooling system (CLS) comprising at least one fan (F1 ), and- a controller (CL) for controlling operation of the wind turbine, wherein the controller comprises a processor, and wherein the controller is arranged to cause the wind turbine to perform the method according to any of claims 1 -15.