Selective concentration of PFAS and natural organics from spent-media regenerant solutions
The use of poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membranes effectively concentrates PFAS from spent media regenerant solutions, addressing disposal challenges and improving the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of PFAS treatment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/IB2026/051164
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-07
- Filing Date
- 2026-02-06
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for regenerating spent PFAS adsorption media generate hazardous waste solutions that are difficult to dispose of, and existing concentration technologies are inefficient or economically unviable for treating low-concentration PFAS waste streams.
A process using a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to separate PFAS from an aqueous stream, followed by distillation and membrane separation to concentrate PFAS and recover solvents and salts, minimizing waste volume and enabling efficient destruction.
The process achieves a 6-20 times concentration of PFAS, producing a smaller volume of PFAS-rich waste suitable for efficient destruction, while recovering solvents and salts for reuse, reducing capital and operating costs.
Smart Images

Figure IB2026051164_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491TITLE OF THE INVENTION
[0001] Selective Concentration of PF AS and Natural Organics from Spent-Media Regenerant SolutionsCROSS REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATION
[0002] This application claims priority to co-pending U. S. provisional patent application number 63 / 801,389, filed May 7, 2025, the disclosure of which is herein incorporated by reference in its entirety.BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
[0003] The invention generally relates to the field of pollution control and, in particular, to the selective concentration and destruction of PF AS from spent-media regenerant solutions.
[0004] Per- and poly-fluoroalkyl (PF A) substances (PF AS) have become a class of chemicals posing a serious threat to the safety of the world’s potable water supply. This class of chemicals includes more than 10,000 different species having carbon-fluorine bonds, and are known to resist chemical, biological, and thermal degradation. These specialty chemicals have a variety of sizes and molecular architectures but were produced and used by industry due to their unique physical properties, such as their ability to resist wetting by water, oil, and grease. As a result, PFAS have been widely used in a variety of applications, including stain-resistant carpets, clothing, non-stick pan coatings, cosmetics, firefighting foams, and food packaging, to name a few. Unfortunately, these desirable properties come with a significant downside. Their waste solutions disposed to the environment can persist for years, decades, or even longer. Thus, they have been labeled “The Forever Chemical” since they do not naturally breakdown and are not removed by most conventional treatment methods.
[0005] In addition to posing environmental concerns, these chemicals can cause serious human health effects, including increased blood pressure, decreased immune response, increasedAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491risk of thyroid disease as well as cancers which affect the kidney and reproductive glands. To counter this growing health concern, governmental authorities have issued regulations setting maximum limits on their discharge into the environment.
[0006] Many technologists have sought methods to reduce PFAS in source water used for making potable water to meet government regulations, while also preventing recontamination by destroying the PFAS. Technologies such as electro-oxidation, plasma treatment, supercritical water oxidation (SCWO), hydrothemial alkaline treatment, photocatalyst treatment, and sonolysis have been considered and show some promise. However, treating large volumes of water containing low concentrations (<100 ng / L) of PFAS is currently uneconomical with these existing technologies.
[0007] Many municipalities use media adsorption or membrane separation to remove PFAS from their water supplies. Both processes are well known in the industry and can achieve the high removal rates required to meet government regulations. But membrane treatment is more expensive in terms of capital and operating expenses and is typically chosen only when other contaminants such as dioxane, arsenic, hardness, and salinity also need to be removed.
[0008] Regarding adsorbent media, a range of materials can be utilized, including powdered and granular activated carbon (PAC, GAC), ion exchange resins (IER), and novel adsorbents. Various anion exchange resins (AERs) have been developed to selectively target PFA chemicals. These AERs show better performance than GAC for PFAS-holding capacity, fast reaction kinetics, and selectivity. Although more costly than GAC, less AER media is required to treat the same volume of water, thereby simplifying logistics and disposal.
[0009] Examples of the novel media include Cyclopure™ media based on dextrin chemicals, Fluoro-sorb™ media based on specialized clay, and Puraffinity™ media based on amine-coated porous ceramic support. These materials claim higher PFAS uptake and faster kinetics; however, all media face disposal issues once saturated with PFAS. Spent media are typically sent to landfills or incinerators, which can reintroduce PFAS into the environment.
[0010] To address waste disposal concerns, many technologists have pursued regenerating and reusing the spent media, usually involving chemical extraction of PFAS to restore >90% ofAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491the media adsorption capability for multiple reuse cycles. This process generates a PFAS waste stream, often stronger than the original treated stream and is considered hazardous.
[0011] PFAS-rich extract or regeneration solutions vary widely but typically contain mixtures of water, organic solvent, salts, and possibly caustics, to solubilize and extract the PFAS from the media. The resulting waste solutions may contain from 10-100 pg / L of the PFAS, which is still relatively dilute for destruction technologies.
[0012] To address some of these issues, Kondo et al. (US 2004 / 0010156 Al) observed that the recovery of PFAS from adsorbent media can be improved by using a high concentration of solvent (75-95% ). However, large quantities of water are needed to rinse the remaining solvent from the media, which creates a large waste solution. As a result, they proposed regenerating the media using a mixture of alkali, water, and a reduced amount of solvent (10-25%). Additionally, they proposed that the PFAS compound could be isolated and recovered from the excess alkali and solvent by distillation and neutralization with mineral acid. However, Kondo et al. do not teach how to substantially concentrate the PFAS or to recover more solvent for reuse in the process; nor do they teach how to safely destroy or mineralize the PFAS waste, leaving behind a hazardous solution that is difficult to dispose.
[0013] Subsequently, Nickelsen et al. (US 10,287,185) proposed a regeneration process of AERs with a regenerant solution composed of a salt or a base, a solvent, and water. The salt or base would be in the range of 1-5%, and a solvent could range from 10% to as high as 90%. They explained that the separation and recovery process may include one or more of evaporation, distillation, and membrane separation. This is in line with Kondo’s patent application; however, Nickelsen et al. added the step of treating the concentrated PFAS from the evaporation, distillation, or membrane separation process with a super-loading ion exchange resin (IEX) recovery subsystem to further remove and concentrate the recovered PFAS. No comment was made about what is to be done with this concentrated waste, which would be considered hazardous by today’s regulations. Additionally, they proposed treating the recovered, purified solvent by a super-loading recovery subsystem to further remove the residual PFAS from the recovered solvent with an AER to create an ultra-concentrated waste. Their approach proposed reusing the recovered solvent. However, Nickelsen et al. provided no details aboutAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491how a membrane is to be used to treat solutions with such high solvent and salt concentrations. A 5% NaCl salt solution has an osmotic pressure in the range of 500 psi, and a 10% ethanol solution has a 400-psi osmotic pressure. At even a modest treatment of 50% water recovery, the osmotic pressure would be well beyond the 1200 psi limit of typical high-pressure RO membranes. Furthermore, the concentrated solution is only half the volume of the original solution, so there remains a significant issue of handling a large volume of hazardous concentrated PF AS solution. Thus, their patent teaches recovery of the solvent with multiple complicated steps and teaches how to concentrate the PFAS onto an AER through super-loading, but does not teach what can be done with this solid waste or how the waste solution can be concentrated beyond the degree resulting from removal of the solvent. Their premise is that the super-loaded media can be sent offsite for thermal destruction. However, there are many emerging environmental regulations that limit incineration of PFAS-containing solids.
[0014] Singh et al. (“Removal of Poly- and Per-Fluorinated Compounds from Ion Exchange...,” Em 'iron. Sei. Teclmol. 2020, 54, 21, 13973—13980) stated that solvents can be recovered from IEX regenerant solutions, but this leaves behind a highly saline solution of concentrated PFAS, which would be difficult to manage. They proposed IEX treatment with a regenerable resin that can remove and concentrate PFAS, where the regenerant solution is treated by a plasma reactor in a two-stage process. Their process is more complicated since they have issues with foaming and require a second polishing plasma treatment process. The process is also relatively large since it is designed to treat the still bottoms from a distillation process; thus, it still contains a large volume of PFAS-containing solution.
[0015] Dejarme et al. (US 11,401,180) proposed a process to destroy the PFAS by using supercritical water oxidation (SCWO). To treat the raw PFAS-containing water, they first disclose using extensive pretreatment, such as particle removal (media filters, membrane filters, etc.) and softening (ion exchange resins, lime softening, chelating agents), and / or treatment through an electric field. The pretreated PF AS-enriched water can then be treated by SCWO. However, if this water does not have a high fuel (organic matter) content, the SCWO process requires that fuel be added to the water. These organics would be oxidized in the reactor and provide the energy required to achieve the supercritical conditions (374-1200°C and 221-300 barAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491(3200 - 4350 psi)). Thus, this system has multiple drawbacks, including needing extensive pretreatment, addition of organic fuel, creation of more greenhouse gases, and operation at extremely high pressures / temperatures.
[0016] Chiang et al. (US 11,512,012) proposed the combined use of sorbents or filters to remove PFAS from aqueous solutions and electro-oxidation (EO) to destroy the PF AS contained in the spent regenerant. In some cases, the spent regenerant, typically containing PFAS, solvents, organic material (also referred to as total organic carbon, TOC) and salts, can be reclaimed, but it produces a residual stream called “still bottoms” or “regeneration wastes.” This concentrated PFAS waste stream is treated by EO to destroy the PFAS. In one example, they treated a “still bottoms” solution containing 68 mg / L PFOS, 92 mg / L PFOA, and 6810 mg / L TOC for 17 hours using EO. As a result, 77.2% of the PFOA was removed and 96.5% of the PFOS was removed. However, their data also show that the efficiency of the process declined rapidly as the PFAS concentration dropped as it was being destroyed. In 4 hours, the PFOA concentration dropped from 25.5 mg / L to 3.7 mg / L (85%). In the next 4 hours, it dropped from 3.7 to 2 mg / L (45%). This points to the need to keep PFAS concentration high to improve EO efficiency. They do not teach how the concentration of PFAS can be increased to levels where PFAS destruction can be done efficiently. They also did not address the issue of solvent. The EO process would oxidize all organic material, including the solvent, the organic (TOC), and the solvent. Due to the high concentration of solvents used in the regeneration process, this puts additional demand on the EO process, causing an increase in both the capital cost and the operating cost of the system. They do not teach how the solvent load can be decreased, while keeping the PFAS and natural organic concentration high.
[0017] More recently, Chen et al. (US 2022 / 0402794) proposed a system for treating a wash solution from regenerating media contaminated with PFAS. The wash or regeneration solution contains solvent, salts, and PFAS. They proposed treating this complex solution with distillation or nanofiltration (NF) membranes to recover a PFAS-free solvent and thus reduce the volume of the stream to be treated by a PFAS-specific destruction process. Treating the PFAS-containing wastewater using NF membranes and / or distillation can reduce the volume of the solvent in the original solution. Typically, the volume reduction is around 50%, whereby PFASAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491is concentrated by two times prior to treatment by the destruction process. They envisioned washing the PFAS off the adsorption media using a regenerant solution composed of solvent (methanol) and caustic. Once the solvent is mostly recovered, they proposed a treatment step to remove hardness and finally the treated waste solution is sent to a PFAS destruction process. The PFAS elimination step would include one of the following destruction processes: electrochemical; plasma; or photochemical oxidation. Optionally, they also proposed NF diafiltration to further remove residual PFAS from the effluent of the destruction process, but this creates a large volume of PFAS containing wastewater form the NF diafiltration process. Essentially, they only disclose the use membranes or distillation to remove purified solvent from the PFAS solution, which provides only minimal concentration of the PFAS; they do not propose a treatment step to concentrate the aqueous solution further once the solvent is removed. Each of the destruction processes mentioned would not be very efficient treating large volumes of dilute PFAS solution expected in their distillation or NF treated solution. Unfortunately, Chen et al. do not teach how to significantly concentrate the PFAS chemicals from the aqueous solution once the solvent is removed. Thus, their process is still very expensive and not commercially viable.
[0018] During the examination of Chen et al., the examiner cited technical information on NF membranes provided by Boo et al. in the paper “High Performance Nanofiltration Membrane for Effective Removal of Perfluoroalkyl Substances at High Water Recovery” (Environ. Sei. Technol. 2018, 52, 7279-7288). In that article, Boo et al. show that their uniquely synthesized piperazine-based amide NF membranes can have moderately high PFOA rejection, in the range of 85-90%, while having a lower rejection of monovalent salt (NaCl), in the range of 20-70%. However, firstly, the rejection of PFOA remains relatively low, and it would still pass significant amounts of PFOA into the permeate, particularly shorter chain PFAS compounds (C<4). This would make the permeate stream hazardous, with a concentration exceeding 4 ng / L. Secondly, even at a 20+% rejection of salts, the recovery would be limited to less than 75% (4 times concentration) due to the high pressures that would result from the big osmotic pressure differences between the concentrate and the permeate at high recovery. Therefore, this NF performance would allow some PFAS concentration, but it does not teach the practitioner how to achieve very high recovery (80% or more) and concentration of PFAS greater than 6 times toAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491thereby increase the PFAS concentration to high levels required for efficient PFAS destruction. Finally, this paper does not comment on the potential effect of solvent, which is also present in the PFAS solution, and how the membrane may or may not concentrate the solvent. One skilled in the art would likely assume that a membrane that has a high rejection of a 4-carbon PFAS compound (PFBS) would also have a high rejection of a solvent with 2-4 carbon atoms. Again, any significant concentration of the solvent would lead to a large osmotic difference between the concentrate and permeate, limiting recovery to low values.
[0019] In short, PFA compounds can be concentrated using distillation, AER, and membrane technologies, but the complex mixture composition poses many treatment challenges.
[0020] Due to these challenges, there has been no widespread practice for regenerating the spent media, and most remain single-use materials.
[0021] Thus, there is a significant need for improved processes to treat spent-regeneration solutions and highly concentrate the PFAS for treatment by emerging destruction technologies. In particular, there is a need to improve the treatment process utilizing a technology that can selectively concentrate the PFAS by 6 times, 10 times, or as much as 20 times, while creating a nearly PFAS-free stream that contains most of the water, solvent, and salts originally present in the spent-regenerant solution. Such a treatment process would provide an ideal solution for emerging PFAS destruction processes, return the purified water, solvent, and salts for reuse in the regeneration process, and minimize the size and cost of the PFAS destruction process.
[0022] The present invention addresses these needs as well as others, which will become apparent from the following description and the appended claims.SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
[0023] Briefly, in one aspect, the present disclosure provides a process for separating per- or poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from an aqueous stream. The process comprises contacting an aqueous feed stream comprising PFAS and an organic solvent having less than 5 carbon atoms with a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to form a retentate stream rich inAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491the PFAS and poor in the mass of the organic solvent, and a permeate stream depleted in the PF AS and rich in the mass of the organic solvent.
[0024] In a second aspect, the disclosure provides a system for selective concentration of per- or poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from a spent-medium regenerant stream.
[0025] In one embodiment, the system comprises a distillation zone inlet configured to introduce a spent-medium regenerant stream comprising PFAS, a monovalent salt, an organic solvent having less than 5 carbon atoms, natural organic compounds, and water into a distillation zone. The distillation zone is configured to generate a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent and a distillation bottoms stream rich in the PFAS, the monovalent salt, and the natural organic compounds. The system further includes a membrane separation zone inlet configured to convey the distillation bottoms stream into a membrane separation zone. The membrane separation zone comprises a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane and is configured to generate a retentate stream, rich in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, and having salt and solvent concentrations similar to the feed concentrations.
[0026] Advantageous refinements of the invention, which can be implemented alone or in combination, are specified in the dependent claims.
[0027] For convenience, a summary of various exemplary embodiments of the invention is set forth below:
[0028] Embodiment 1: A process for separating per- or poly-fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution (a) comprising an organic solvent having less than five carbon atoms (or preferably less than four carbon atoms or more preferably less than 3 carbon atoms), a monovalent inorganic salt, and PFAS, and (b) having an osmotic pressure of greater than 500 psi (3.45 MPa),the process comprising at least one step of contacting the spent-regenerant solution with a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to form a retentate stream enriched in PFAS and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS,wherein a majority of the mass of the organic solvent and the monovalent inorganic salt from the spent-regenerant solution are in the permeate stream.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0029] Embodiment 2: The process of Embodiment 1, wherein the contacting step is carried out at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
[0030] Embodiment 3: The process of Embodiments 1 or 2, wherein the spent-regenerant solution has a pH of 6 to 11, of 7 to 11, of 8 to 11, of 9 to 11, or of 10 to 11.
[0031] Embodiment 4: The process of any of Embodiments 1-3, wherein the retentate stream comprises at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the spent-regenerant solution.
[0032] Embodiment 5: The process of any of Embodiments 1 -4, wherein the organic solvent comprises methanol, ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, t-butanol, acetone, ethyl acetate, acetonitrile, or combinations thereof.
[0033] Embodiment 6: The process of any of Embodiments 1-5, wherein the monovalent inorganic salt comprises sodium bromide (NaBr), sodium iodide (Nal), sodium bicarbonate (NaHCO₃), potassium chloride (KC1), potassium bromide (KBr), potassium iodide (KI), ammonium chloride (NH₄Cl), or combinations thereof.
[0034] Embodiment 7: The process of any of Embodiments 1-6, wherein the spent-regenerant solution further comprises natural organic compounds and water;wherein the spent-regenerant solution is distilled before contacting with the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to generate (a) a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent which is recycled to a fresh regenerant storage vessel and (b) a distillation bottoms stream enriched in the PFAS, the monovalent salt, and the natural organic compounds and depleted in the organic solvent; andwherein the distillation bottoms stream is contacted with the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to generate the retentate stream enriched in the PFAS and the permeate stream depleted in the PFAS.
[0035] Embodiment 8: The process of Embodiment 7, wherein at least a portion of the permeate stream is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0036] Embodiment 9; The process of any of Embodiments 1-8, which further comprises treating the retentate stream in an oxidation zone to mineralize the PFAS to fluoride salt.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0037] Embodiment 10: The process of Embodiment 9, wherein the oxidation zone generates an effluent stream comprising the monovalent salt, and wherein at least a portion of the effluent stream is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0038] Embodiment 11: The process of any of Embodiments 9-10, wherein the oxidation zone comprises a blowdown to intermittently remove undesired products from the effluent stream.
[0039] Embodiment 12: The process of Embodiment 11, wherein the blowdown stream further comprises unoxidized PFAS, and wherein the effluent stream is contacted with a PFAS-selective adsorption medium to polish the residual PFAS that has not been fully oxidized to F salt.
[0040] Embodiment 13: Tire process of any of Embodiments 1-12, wherein at least 90%, at least 95%, at least 98%, or at least 99% of the monovalent salt, the organic solvent, or both in the spent-regenerant solution are recovered for reuse.
[0041] Embodiment 14: A system for selective concentration of per- or poly- fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution, the system comprising:a distillation zone inlet configured to introduce an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution comprising PFAS, a monovalent inorganic salt, an organic solvent with less than five carbon atoms (or preferably less than 4 carbon atoms or more preferably less than 3 carbon atoms), natural organic compounds, and water into a distillation zone;wherein the distillation zone is configured to generate a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent and a distillation bottoms stream rich in the PFAS, the monovalent inorganic salt, and the natural organic compounds; anda membrane separation zone inlet configured to convey the distillation bottoms stream into a membrane separation zone;wherein the distillation bottoms stream has an osmotic pressure of at least 500 psi (3.45 MPa);wherein the membrane separation zone comprises a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane and is configured to generate a retentate stream rich in the PFAS and the naturalAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491organic compounds, and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, andwherein a majority of the mass of the monovalent inorganic salt and the organic solvent from the distillation bottoms stream are in the permeate stream.
[0042] Embodiment 15: The system of Embodiment 14, wherein the membrane separation zone is configured to operate at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
[0043] Embodiment 16: The system of any of Embodiments 14-15, wherein the membrane separation zone is configured to generate a retentate stream comprising at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the distillation bottoms stream.
[0044] Embodiment 18: Tire system of any of Embodiments 14-17, which further comprises an oxidation zone inlet configured to convey the retentate stream to an oxidation zone, wherein the oxidation zone is configured to mineralize the PFAS in the retentate stream to fluoride salt.
[0045] Embodiment 19: The system of Embodiment 18, wherein the oxidation zone is further configured to generate an effluent stream comprising the monovalent salt, and wherein the system further comprises a conduit configured to convey at least a portion of the effluent stream to a fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0046] Embodiment 20: The system of any of Embodiments 18-19, wherein the oxidation zone comprises a blowdown stream to intermittently remove undesirable products from the effluent stream, and wherein the effluent stream is contacted with a PFAS-selective adsorption medium to polish the residual PFAS that has not been fully oxidized to F salt.
[0047] Embodiment 21: The process of any of Embodiments 1-13, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane has a flux rate of 27.5 GFD at a 110-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSOt feed solution.
[0048] Embodiment 22: The process of any of Embodiments 1-13 or 21, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane passes greater than 50%, at least 75%, or at least 85% of the mass of the organic solvent in the spent-regenerant solution to the permeate stream and concentrates the PFAS in the spent-regenerant solution by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0049] Embodiment 23: The process of any of Embodiments 1-13 or 21-22, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane passes at least 85% of the mass of the monovalent inorganic salt in the spent-regenerant solution to the permeate stream and concentrates the PF AS in the spent-regenerant solution by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.
[0050] Embodiment 24: The system of any of Embodiments 14-20, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane has a flux rate of 27.5 GFD at a 110-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSO4 feed solution.
[0051] Embodiment 25: The system of any of Embodiments 14-20 or 24, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane passes greater than 50%, at least 75%, or at least 85% of the mass of the organic solvent in the distillation bottoms stream to the permeate stream and concentrates the PFAS in the distillation bottoms stream by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.
[0052] Embodiment 26: The system of any of Embodiments 14-20 or 24-25, wherein the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane passes at least 85% of the mass of the monovalent inorganic salt in the distillation bottoms stream to the permeate stream and concentrates the PFAS in the distillation bottoms stream by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.sBRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE SEVERAL VIEWS OF THE DRAWINGS
[0053] The foregoing summary, as well as the following detailed description of the invention, will be better understood when read in conjunction with the appended drawings. For the purpose of illustrating the invention, there are shown in the drawings embodiments which are presently preferred. It should be understood, however, that the invention is not limited to the precise arrangements and instrumentalities shown, hi the drawings:
[0054] Figure 1 is a graph of a column adsorption trial using an AmberLite™ PSR2 Plus ion exchange resin to treat PF AS-contaminated ground water.
[0055] Figure 2 is a process flow diagram of an illustrative treatment process and system to concentrate a PFAS-rich regenerant solution for mineralization according to the invention.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0056] Figure 3 is a graph of the composition of the initial charge, the final still bottoms, and the distillate from Example 1.
[0057] Figure 4 is a graph of the operating conditions and performance for the stirred cell from Example 3 at pH 7.7.
[0058] Figure 5 is a graph of the feed and permeate concentration profile from Example 3.
[0059] Figure 6 is a graph of the concentration factors for each species in the regenerant solution from Example 3.
[0060] Figure 7 is a graph of the operating conditions and performance for the stirred cell from Example 4 at pH 10.
[0061] Figure 8 is a graph of the feed and permeate concentration profile from Example 4.
[0062] Figure 9 is a graph of the concentration factors for each species in the regenerant solution from Example 4.
[0063] Figure 10 is a graph of the system performance of a PPA NF membrane treated with a 2% ethanol solution at 90% recovery as shown in Example 9.
[0064] Figures 11A and B are graphs of the flow performance of two different NF membranes treating a synthetic regeneration solution.
[0065] Figures 12A and B are graphs of the selectivity performance of two different NF membranes treating a synthetic regeneration solution.
[0066] Figure 13 is a graph of sodium chloride rejection by two different NF membranes treating a synthetic regeneration solution.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE IN VENTIONGlossary
[0067] To facilitate understanding the invention, several terms are defined below. Those left undefined have meanings as commonly understood by a person of ordinary skill in the technical areas relevant to the present invention.
[0068] As used herein, the indefinite articles “a” and “an” mean one or more, unless the context clearly suggests otherwise. Similarly, the singular form of nouns includes their plural form, and vice versa, unless the context clearly suggests otherwise. For example, the term “medium” includes the plural form “media,” and vice versa.
[0069] An “effluent” or a “feed” is sometimes also called a “stream” in this disclosure. Where two or more streams are shown to form a joint stream and then supplied into a vessel, it should be interpreted to include alternatives where the streams are supplied separately to the vessel where appropriate. Likewise, where two or more streams are supplied separately to a vessel, it should be interpreted to include alternatives where the streams are combined before entering the vessel as joint stream(s) where appropriate.
[0070] The terms “natural organic compounds” and “natural organics” are used interchangeably. They refer to organic compounds that are produced by living organisms, such as plants and animals. Natural organics include carbohydrates, lipids, proteins, and nucleic acids.
[0071] The term “rich” or “enriched,” when describing a component in a stream, means that the concentration or mass of the recited component is higher or greater in that stream than in the stream from which the component is derived. Similarly, the term “depleted,” “poor,” or “lean,” when describing a component in a stream, means that the concentration or mass of the recited component is lower or less in that stream than in the stream from which the component is derived.
[0072] The term “solution” refers to a liquid mixture (at ambient temperature and pressure) in which one or more minor components are distributed or dispersed within a major component. The term includes single-phase mixtures as well as multi-phase mixtures.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0073] The terms “solvent,” “organic solvent,” and “volatile organic solvent” are used interchangeably. They refer to organic solvents that have boiling points below that of water at atmospheric pressure.Aspects and Exemplary Embodiments
[0074] It has been surprisingly discovered that a special class of nanofiltration (NF) membranes have unique selectivity that is ideal for treating a wide range of PFAS adsorption media regenerant solution waste. This class of NF membranes can greatly reduce the cost of regenerating the media and mineralizing the waste organic stream that comes from the spent media, all while maximizing the reclamation, purification, and reuse of chemicals and water used in the regeneration and destruction processes.
[0075] In particular, it has been unexpectedly found that poly(piperazine-amide) (PPA) NF membranes can selectively pass the high concentration of salts and solvent in the regenerant solution and only reject and concentrate the PFAS and natural organics which are intended to be destroyed. The permeate from the NF membrane contains low levels of the PFAS and natural organics, but essentially the same solvent and salt levels as the feed solution. The membrane can achieve over 90% recovery of the solvent / salt solution for reuse and a 10% by volume of PFAS-enriched waste (7-8 times higher PFAS concentration), which can be treated by a variety of destruction processes, including electro-oxidation, supercritical water oxidation, plasma, sonolysis, incineration, and ball-milling. Along with the greater recovery of the solvent for reuse, the membrane can also generate a smaller volume, higher concentration PFAS waste solution which can be more efficiently mineralized to CCh, SO4 salts, F salts, and other minor components.
[0076] Additionally, superior results were unexpectedly obtained when the pH of the solution contacting the membrane was increased from 8 to 10. The elevated pH yielded even higher concentration factors for the PFAS.
[0077] Thus, in various aspects and embodiments, the present disclosure is aimed at regenerating media that have a high PFAS-adsorption capacity, extracting the PFAS and natural organics with an aqueous mixture of volatile organic solvent and monovalent salt, optionally atAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491high pH, followed by concentrating the PFAS and recovering the solvent and salt by distillation, and using a PPA NF membrane to concentrate the PFAS and natural organics, but not significantly concentrating the solvent or salt. The invention can provide a much smaller volume of waste liquid and a much lower organic load to be treated by the PFAS destruction process. The invention can also greatly reduce the capital and operating cost to mineralize / destroy the concentrated waste stream.Process for Separating PFAS from Aqueous Stream
[0078] In one aspect, the present disclosure provides a process for separating per- or polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from an aqueous feed stream, which is, in some embodiments, an aqueous solution comprising PFAS, a monovalent inorganic salt, and an organic solvent, and having an osmotic pressure of greater than 500 psi. The process includes the step of contacting the aqueous feed stream with a poly(piperazine-amide) (PPA) nanofiltration (NF) membrane to form a retentate stream rich in the PFAS and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS.
[0079] The aqueous feed stream may be derived from any source. In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream may be derived from a spent-media regenerant solution. Spent PFAS-adsorption media are typically regenerated or refreshed with a regenerant solution containing a mixture of water, organic solvent, and salt or base. After usage to regenerate the spent PFAS-adsorption media, the spent-media regenerant solution would typically further include the extracted PFAS and, optionally, natural organic compounds.
[0080] In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream may be derived from or comprises an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution. The spent-regenerant solution refers to a regenerant solution that has been used to regenerate spent PFAS-adsorption media. The spent-regenerant solution would typically include extracted PFAS, natural organic compounds (if any), water, organic solvent, and salt or base.
[0081] The amount of PFAS in the aqueous feed stream is not limited. For example, the concentration of PFAS in the aqueous feed stream can range from 100 ng / L to 1000 mg / L.
[0082] Examples of the PFAS that can be in the aqueous feed stream include perfluorobutyric acid (PFBA), perfluorobutane sulfonate (PFBS), perfluoropentanoic acidAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491(PFPA), perfluorohexanoic acid (PFHxA), perfluorohexane sulfonate (PFHxS), perfluoroheptanoic acid (PFHpA), perfluoroheptane sulfonate (PFHpS), perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS), perfluorononanoic acid (PFNA), and combinations thereof.
[0083] The amount of natural organics in the aqueous feed stream can vary over a wide range. For example, the aqueous feed stream may typically include up to 10 mg / L of natural organics.
[0084] In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream to the membrane may further comprise an organic solvent and / or a monovalent inorganic salt. In which case, the retentate / concentrate stream should have a relatively small increase in the concentration of the organic solvent and the monovalent salt to prevent a significant difference in the osmotic pressure between the brine and the permeate. Too large of a difference would then require an operating pressure exceeding the limit of the NF element (600 psi or 4.14 MPa).
[0085] Examples of monovalent inorganic salts include sodium bromide (NaBr), sodium iodide (Nal), sodium bicarbonate (NaHCOs), potassium chloride (KC1), potassium bromide (KBr), potassium iodide (KI), ammonium chloride (NH4CI), and combinations thereof.
[0086] In various embodiments, the organic solvent in the aqueous feed stream to the membrane comprises less than 5 carbon atoms.
[0087] In various embodiments, the organic solvent in the aqueous feed stream to the membrane comprises less than 4 carbon atoms.
[0088] In various embodiments, the organic solvent in the aqueous feed stream to the membrane comprises less than 3 carbon atoms.
[0089] Examples of such organic solvents include methanol, ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, t-butanol, ethyl acetate, acetonitrile, and combinations thereof.
[0090] Generally, the regenerant solution may contain from 50 to 90 vol% of organic solvent, from 10 to 50 vol% of water, and from 1 to 5 wt% of salt or base.
[0091] In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream to the membrane has a pH of 6 to 11, of 7 to 11, of 8 to 11, of 9 to 11, or of 10 to 11.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0092] As noted, it has been surprisingly discovered that if the pH of the regenerant solution contacting the PPA NF membrane is elevated to 10 or higher, the PFAS rejection is improved and the PFAS can be concentrated to a higher degree. Thus, in accordance with the invention, it is possible to further enhance the performance of the PPA NF membrane, to improve the rejection of PFAS and natural organic compounds, and to allow for higher levels of concentration by increasing the pH of the aqueous feed stream to the membrane to 10 or higher.
[0093] In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream to the membrane further comprises a base. Examples of the base include potassium hydroxide (KOH), ammonium hydroxide (NH4OH), sodium hydroxide (NaOH), lithium hydroxide (LiOH), sodium bicarbonate (NaHCOs), or a combination of these.
[0094] The PPA NF membrane for use in the present invention has been known to treat seawater (3-4% salinity) to remove and concentrate sulfates, thus producing a low sulfate water for enhanced oil recovery in the petroleum industry. Although this type of NF membrane is known to have a relatively higher passage rate of monovalent salts compared to reverse osmosis (RO) membranes, recent studies by Boo et al. demonstrated its ability to also achieve moderately high rejection of 8-carbon PFAS compounds. However, it remained unknown whether the PPA NF membrane could highly reject the shorter chain PFAS molecules (e.g., those with 5 carbon atoms or less), while simultaneously allowing small solvent molecules to pass through at a high rate. If the solvent is also moderately rejected, the osmotic pressure difference between the concentrate and the permeate will become significant, necessitating high operating pressure and limiting recoveries to low values.
[0095] As opposed to using RO membranes or even conventional NF membranes to concentrate all the dissolved species in the regenerant solution, which would produce a relatively pure water permeate, it was surprisingly found that a certain class of NF membranes can highly reject and concentrate the PFAS and natural organics, producing a permeate that has minimal PFAS and natural organics, but having solvent and salt concentrations similar to the original concentrations of the regenerant solution before exposure to tire spent media.
[0096] Suitable PPA NF membranes may be prepared by interfacial polymerization of trimesoyl chloride (TMC) and piperazine (PIP), where PIP diffuse from water into oil, and thenAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491react with TMC via the Schotten-Baumann reaction. Such membranes are also commercially available, such as the NANO-SW membrane from Hydranautics (Oceanside, CA) and the FilmTec™ SR90 line of NF membranes from DuPont Water Solutions.
[0097] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane for use in the present invention has a flux rate of 27.5 GFD at a 110-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSO4feed solution.
[0098] For high osmotic strength regenerant solutions, it may be advantageous to maintain less than 20% rejection of solvent and salt to achieve recoveries of 90% or more without requiring pressures greater than 600 psig (4.14 MPa). However, treatment with solvent rejection up to about 50% is possible, as explained in Examples 8-10.
[0099] Generally, the feed pressure should be greater than the osmotic pressure difference between the feed and the permeate solutions, with some added pressure to move the water through the membrane at an economically viable rate, typically 10-15 gal / ft2 / day (GFD). The exact value will depend on the rejection of salts and solvents by the membrane. The higher the rejection, the higher the osmotic pressure difference, and thus the higher the pressure difference. The pressure limit of a RO membrane spiral element is up to 1200 psi (8.3 MPa), while most NF membrane spiral elements are limited to 600 psi (4.14 MPa).
[0100] In various embodiments, the contacting step is carried out at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
[0101] The contacting step may be carried out at a temperature up to the maximum operating temperature of the PPA NF membrane (e.g., up to 45°C). Typically, the contacting step may be carried out at around ambient temperature (e.g., 20-25°C).
[0102] Similarly, the contacting step may be carried out at up to the maximum feed flow of the PPA NF membrane (e.g., up to 85 gpm (19.3 m3 / h)).
[0103] In various embodiments, the permeate stream comprises 10% or less, 5% or less, or 1% or less of the PFAS in the aqueous feed stream.
[0104] In various embodiments, the retentate stream comprises at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the aqueous feed stream.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0105] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane passes greater than 50%, preferably greater than 75%, or more preferably greater than 85% of the mass of the organic solvent in the aqueous feed stream to the permeate stream while concentrating the PF AS in the aqueous feed stream by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.
[0106] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane passes at least 85 % of the mass of the monovalent inorganic salt in the aqueous feed stream to the permeate stream and concentrates the PFAS in the aqueous feed stream by 6X or greater in the retentate stream.
[0107] In various embodiments, the process according to the invention further includes a step of distilling a spent-medium regenerant stream comprising the PFAS, the monovalent inorganic salt, an organic solvent, natural organic compounds, and water to generate (a) a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent and (b) a distillation bottoms stream rich in the PFAS, the monovalent inorganic salt, and the natural organic compounds.
[0108] In various embodiments, at least a portion of the distillation overhead stream is recycled to a fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0109] In various embodiments, at least a portion of the permeate stream is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0110] In various embodiments, the aqueous feed stream to the membrane comprises the distillation bottoms stream.
[0111] In various embodiments, at least 90% by volume of the distillation bottoms stream is recovered in the permeate stream.
[0112] In various embodiments, 10% by volume or less of the distillation bottoms stream is recovered in the retentate stream.
[0113] The present process not only can recover most of the solvent and salts for reuse but can also highly concentrate the PFAS and natural organics so they may be efficiently destroyed by one of many destruction technologies, such as electro-oxidation, plasma, super critical water oxidation (SCWO), sonolysis, ball-milling, hydrothermal oxidation, and UV degradation. In general, these destructive processes involve oxidizing the PFAS to ultimately convert them to FLO, CO2, and O2 gas, as well fluoride and sulfate salt (for SO4 containing PFAS).Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0114] Thus, in various embodiments, tire process according to the invention further includes the step of treating the retentate stream in an oxidation zone to mineralize the PF AS to fluoride salt.
[0115] The oxidation zone may include one or more of the known oxidative destruction processes that can destroy or mineralize the organics in the retentate stream. The organics in the retentate stream include the PFAS and the natural organics, and minimal amounts of salt and solvent. According to various embodiments of the invention, most of the solvent has been separated from the PFAS and the natural organics via the distillation and / or the membrane separation steps.
[0116] According to the invention, the PPA NF membrane can reclaim 90+% of the solvent going into the membrane, as it would pass the solvent to the permeate side to be recycled. When operated at 90+% recovery, less than 10% of the flow would then be passed to the oxidative destruction zone.
[0117] If the rejection rate of PFAS is high, as observed when using the current PPA NF membrane, the PFAS can be concentrated by tenfold (10 times) or more. This would make the destruction process much more economical and reduces the creation of greenhouse gases. In addition to recycling the treated distillate and the NF permeate, this invention contemplates recycling the residual treated effluent from the destruction process, as the effluent may still contain salts that are desirable for producing a new regenerant solution. The effluent would also contain parts per billion levels of PFAS, which cannot be easily disposed.
[0118] Thus, in various embodiments, the oxidation zone generates an effluent stream comprising the monovalent inorganic salt.
[0119] In various embodiments, at least a portion of the effluent stream from the oxidation zone is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
[0120] After multiple cycles of reusing the distillate, the NF permeate, and the oxidative zone effluent, some undesirable species may gradually build up in the oxidative reaction product. At some point, these species should be purged from the system through a blowdown stream. This small stream can be directly sent to a waste treatment system, or if the PFAS levels areAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491higher than desired, the stream can be passed through a bed of PFAS-selective adsorbent media. Ultimately, this media will become “spent” and need to be regenerated as well.
[0121] Thus, in various embodiments, the oxidation zone according to the invention comprises a blowdown stream to intermittently remove undesired products from the oxidation zone effluent stream.
[0122] In various embodiments, the blowdown stream from the oxidation zone further comprises unoxidized PFAS.
[0123] In various embodiments, the blowdown stream is contacted with a PFAS-selective adsorption medium to remove the unoxidized PFAS.
[0124] In various embodiments, at least 90%, at least 95%, at least 98%, or at least 99% of the monovalent inorganic salt, the organic solvent, or both in the spent-medium regenerant stream are recovered for reuse.Media Adsorption of PFAS
[0125] As noted above, PFAS can be effectively removed from dilute aqueous solutions using various adsorption media, including powdered or activated carbon, ion exchange resin, or other specialized media, such as Cyclopure’s Dexsorb cyclodextrin polymer media (Evanston, IL, USA), CETCO’s Fluoro-sorb clay-based media (Minerals Technologies, Inc., Bethlehem, PA, USA), and Puraffinity’s Puratech coated ceramic media (London, England). These all show varying degrees of PFAS adsorption from dilute aqueous streams. Typically, these media will fully adsorb PFAS from the dilute, contaminated stream for many days or months, but eventually, the PFAS will start to break through and exhibit measurable quantities of PFAS in the effluent. An example of this is shown in Figure 1, which shows the ratio of the effluent concentration of a PFA species divided by the feed concentration of the species versus the number of bed volumes of feed that were processed through a column of AmberLite™ PSR2 Plus ion exchange resin (DuPont, Wilmington, DE, USA).
[0126] In this trial, the bed volume was 1.2 mL of media, the empty bed contact time was 7 seconds, and the flow rate through the column at room temperature was 11 mL / min. The source water was from a wastewater treatment plant and contained 160 ng / L of PFOS (perfluorooctaneAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491sulfonate), 110 ng / L of PFHxS (perfluorohexanesulfonic acid), 47 ng / L of PFBS (perflurobutanesulfonic acid), and 48 ng / L of PFOA (perfluorooctanoic acid).
[0127] As the C / Co ratio exceeded zero, Figure 1 indicates that some PFAS were passing through the column without being adsorbed. As the column adsorption sites become filled, more of the PFAS passed through the column without being adsorbed, eventually reaching C / Co = 1, where there is no further adsorption.
[0128] Commercially, plants will remove the spent media from service before it reaches C / Co = 1. When the effluent of the final or lag filter reaches the maximum allowed concentration of PFAS, the spent media is typically replaced with new media. At this point, the spent media becomes a candidate for regeneration, with the waste PFAS extract needing to be treated before discharge or disposal.Recovery of Regenerant Solution and PFAS Concentration
[0129] Figure 2 shows a representative integrated process and system for regenerating a spent PFAS-adsorption media zone with a regenerant solution and for concentrating the PFAS-rich regenerant solution for mineralization according to the invention.
[0130] A make-up regenerant solution may be provided via conduit 10 to a fresh regenerant solution storage vessel 11. The make-up regenerant solution may contain a combination of water, a volatile organic solvent, a chloride-based salt, and optionally a base. When needed, fresh regenerant solution may be withdrawn from the storage vessel 11 via conduit 12 and introduced into a spent PFAS-adsorption media zone 13. Zone 13 may contain one or more spent adsorption beds. The fresh regenerant solution desorbs or extracts PFAS from the spent adsorption beds.
[0131] The used regenerant stream now contains PFAS and, optionally, natural organics. The stream may be withdrawn from the spent media zone 13 via conduit 14 and introduced into a used regenerant solution storage vessel 15.
[0132] This regenerant solution in storage vessel 15 is expected to have a high osmotic strength due to the high concentration of solvent and salts. It may or may not have a high pH,Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491depending on the properties of the spent media, the PFA species, and other organic material present on the spent media.
[0133] The used regenerant solution may be withdrawn from storage vessel 15 via conduit 16 and introduced into a distillation zone 17. The distillation zone 17 may contain one or more distillation columns configured to recover an overhead stream 18 (sometimes referred to as “distillate stream”) comprising the volatile solvent for additional spent-media regeneration via conduit 27, while concentrating the PF AS and natural organics in a distillation bottoms stream 19 (sometimes referred to as “still bottoms”).
[0134] The still bottoms stream 19 (or non-distillate) retains most of the PFAS since they typically have boiling points much higher than 100°C. For example, the eight-carbon PFOA has a boiling point of 188°C, while the four-carbon PFBA has a boiling point of 120°C. In contrast, ethanol has a boiling point of 80°C.
[0135] The still bottoms stream 19 is then passed to a membrane separation zone 20. The zone 20 includes one or more membrane separation units (“MSUs”) which include a poly(piperazine-amide) NF membrane separating layer. If multiple MSUs are employed, they may be arranged in series or in parallel to each other.
[0136] The membrane separation zone 20 is configured to highly reject and concentrate the PFAS and natural organics in a retentate stream 22 and produce a permeate stream 21 which has minimal or is depleted in the PFAS and natural organics but has solvent and salt concentrations similar to their original concentrations in the regenerant solution in conduit 12 before exposure to the spent media zone 13.
[0137] The distillate stream 18, the NF permeate stream 21, or both may be recycled back to the fresh regenerant tank 11 via line 27 for use as subsequent regenerant solution. This process and system can thus preserve and recycle nearly 100% of the salts, and nearly 99% of the solvent. These streams 18, 21 may be directly reusable since they contain very low levels of PFAS and natural organics.
[0138] The retentate stream 22, which is rich in the PFAS and natural organics, may be conveyed to a PFAS oxidation zone 23. Zone 23 is configured to destroy or mineralize the organics in solution, such as the PFAS to fluoride salt. The zone may employ one or moreAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491destruction technologies, such as electro-oxidation, plasma, super critical water oxidation (SCWO), sonolysis, ball-milling, hydrothermal oxidation, and UV degradation.
[0139] The PFAS oxidation zone 23 produces an effluent stream 24. In addition to recycling the distillate stream 18 and the NF permeate stream 21, at least a portion of the effluent stream 24 may be recycled via line 27 to the fresh regenerant storage vessel 11, as stream 24 may still contains salts which can be useful for producing new regenerant solution.Systems for Selective Concentration of PFAS
[0140] In a second aspect, the present invention provides a system for selective concentration of per- or poly- fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from a spent-medium regenerant stream.
[0141] Referring again to Figure 2, the system comprises a distillation zone inlet 25 configured to introduce a spent-medium regenerant stream 16 comprising PFAS, a monovalent salt, an organic solvent, natural organic compounds, and water into a distillation zone 17. The distillation zone 17 is configured to generate a distillation overhead stream 18 rich in the organic solvent and a distillation bottoms stream 19 rich in the PFAS, the monovalent salt, and the natural organic compounds. The system further includes a membrane separation zone inlet 26 configured to convey the distillation bottoms stream 19 into a membrane separation zone 20. The membrane separation zone 20 comprises a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane and is configured to generate a retentate stream 22 rich in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, and a permeate stream 21 depleted in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds. The membrane separation zone 20 is also configured such that a majority of the monovalent salt and organic solvent mass from the distillation bottoms stream 19 is in the permeate stream.
[0142] The membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to generate a permeate stream 21 comprising 30% or less, 20% or less, or 10% or less of the PFAS in the distillation bottoms stream 19.
[0143] The membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to generate a retentate stream 22 comprising at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the distillation bottoms stream 19.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0144] The system may further comprise a conduit 27 configured to convey at least a portion of the distillation overhead stream 18 to a fresh regenerant storage vessel 11.
[0145] The membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to recover at least 90% by volume of the distillation bottoms stream 19 in the permeate stream 21.
[0146] The membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to recover 10% by volume or less of the distillation bottoms stream 19 in the retentate stream 22.
[0147] The system may be configured to recover and recycle at least 90%, at least 95%, at least 98%, or at least 99% of the monovalent salt, the organic solvent, or both in the spent-medium regenerant stream 16 to the fresh regenerant storage vessel 11.
[0148] In various embodiments, the membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to operate at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
[0149] In various embodiments, the membrane separation zone 20 may be configured to operate at a pH of 6 to 11, of 7 to 11, of 8 to 11, of 9 to 11, or of 10 to 11.
[0150] In various embodiments, the membrane separation zone 20 comprises the spent-medium regenerant stream.
[0151] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane in the membrane separation zone 20 has a flux rate of 27.5 GFD at a 110-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSCU feed solution.
[0152] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane is configured to pass greater than 50%, preferably greater than 75%, or more preferably greater than 85% of the mass of the organic solvent in the distillation bottoms stream 19 to the permeate stream 21 and concentrate the PF AS in the distillation bottoms stream 19 by 6X or greater in the retentate stream 22.
[0153] In various embodiments, the PPA NF membrane is configured to pass at least 85% of the monovalent salt in the distillation bottoms stream 19 to the permeate stream 21 and concentrate the PFAS in the distillation bottoms stream 19 by 6X or greater in the retentate stream 22.
[0154] In various embodiments, the system further comprises a conduit 27 configured to convey at least a portion of the permeate stream 21 to the fresh regenerant storage vessel 11.
[0155] In various embodiments, the system further comprises an oxidation zone inlet 28.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0156] In various embodiments, the oxidation zone 23 is configured to mineralize the PFAS in the retentate stream 22 to fluoride salt.
[0157] In various embodiments, the oxidation zone 23 is further configured to generate an effluent stream 24 comprising the monovalent salt.
[0158] In various embodiments, the system further comprises a conduit 27 configured to convey at least a portion of the effluent stream 24 to the fresh regenerant storage vessel 11.
[0159] In various embodiments, the oxidation zone 23 comprises a blowdown stream (not shown) to intermittently remove undesirable products from the effluent stream 24.
[0160] In various embodiments, the blowndown stream further comprises unoxidized PFAS.
[0161] In various embodiments, the system further comprises a PFAS-selective adsorption zone (not shown) configured to remove the unoxidized PFAS from the blowdown stream (not shown).General Provisions
[0162] To remove any doubt, the present invention includes and expressly contemplates and discloses any and all combinations of embodiments, features, characteristics, parameters, and / or ranges mentioned herein. That is, the subject matter of the present invention may be defined by any combination of embodiments, features, characteristics, parameters, and / or ranges mentioned herein.
[0163] It is contemplated that any ingredient, component, or step that is not specifically named or identified as part of the present invention may be explicitly excluded.
[0164] Any process / method, system, apparatus, compound, composition, embodiment, or component of the present invention may be modified by the transitional terms “comprising,” “consisting essentially of,” or “consisting of,” or variations of those terms.
[0165] Unless otherwise stated, any numerical value is to be understood as being modified in all instances by the term “about.” Thus, a numerical value typically includes ± 10% of the recited value. For example, the recitation of a temperature such as “10°C” or “about 10°C” includes 9°C and 11°C and all temperatures therebetween.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0166] All numerical ranges expressed in this disclosure expressly encompass all possible subranges, all individual numerical values within that range, including integers within such ranges and fractions and decimal amounts of the values unless the context clearly indicates otherwise. For example, a pH range of 6 to 11 includes pHs of 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11, as well as all intervening pHs and ranges.
[0167] The content of all documents cited herein, including patents as well as non-patent literature, is hereby incorporated by reference in their entirety'. To the extent that any incorporated subject matter contradicts with any disclosure herein, the disclosure herein shall take precedence over the incorporated content.
[0168] Unless stated to the contrary', implicit from the context, or customary in the art; all parts and percentages are based on weight and all test methods are current as of the filing date of this specification.
[0169] This invention can be further illustrated by the following working examples, although these examples are included merely for purposes of illustration and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention.EXAMPLESExample 1 - DistillationLaboratory Distillation Setup
[0170] A two-neck round-bottom flask was equipped with a 100-mm distillation column in one neck. The second neck was used as a charge port. The top of the distillation column was connected to a nearly horizontal 20 cm long glass transfer tube, which was connected to the top of the vapor inlet of a vertically mounted 24 cm water-cooled condenser. The condenser outlet was connected to a one-neck round bottom flask to collect the condensed overhead vapor. The two-neck round-bottom flask was secured in a hot water bath heated by a hot plate. The one-neck round bottom flask was secured in an ice water bath to cool the condensed liquid.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491Procedure
[0171] A representative spent-medium regenerant solution was prepared using the ingredients listed in Table 1. PFOA in the table represents perfluorooctanoic acid, and PFBA represents perfluorobutanoic acid.Table 1. Composition of Charge Solution
[0172] The regenerant solution was added to the two-neck round bottom flask and heated to the desired temperature to evaporate the ethanol. Salt was added to the hot water bath, allowing the temperature to rise slightly above 100°C, which was needed for the final portion of the distillation process. The temperature of the charge solution and the vapor temperature at the top of the column were measured by a thermocouple. When the charge solution reached 80°C, the ethanol began evaporating. The vapor was collected after the condenser in the one-neck collection flask. As the ethanol was removed, the temperature of the charge solution began to rise. The experiment was run until the still bottoms reached a temperature of 103°C. Once the distillation was terminated, the still bottoms contained 35% of the original solution mass; the balance had become distillate. Samples of the still bottoms solution were taken along with the distillate for analysis. The samples were tested for total organic content (TOC) (solvent indicator), conductivity, Na and Cl ions, and PFAS by liquid chromatography / mass spectrometry. Some of the results are shown in Figure 3.
[0173] Figure 3 shows that, as expected, most of the ethanol was distilled off and recovered as distillate. The objective was to minimize the amount of ethanol in the final still bottoms, while concentrating the PFOA in the still bottoms.
[0174] As shown in Figure 3, the ethanol concentration was reduced from 477,000 mg / L to 14,700 mg / L in the charge flask. Thus, 97% of the ethanol was distilled off. Tire final distillateAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491solution contained 1,000,000 mg / L of ethanol. The PFOA concentration in the charge flask increased from 85,000 ng / L to 180,000 ng / L in the final still bottoms. Thus, the PFOA was concentrated by 2.1 times. The PFOA in the distillate was 3400 ng / L, which means that 96% of the PFOA remained in the still bottoms.
[0175] The conductivity of the original charge solution (237,000 pS / cm) and the distillate (<5 pS / cm) were measured and show that no salt was removed during distillation. The salt concentration was increased by ~2.8 times.
[0176] This example demonstrates that distillation is an effective means to (a) recover the solvent, (b) minimize solvent in the still bottoms, and (c) concentrate the PFAS by about 2 times. Since this was a simple distillation setup, the extent of separation was limited. Using a multitray distillation column would further reduce the solvent in the still bottoms and would reduce the carryover of PFAS to the distillate. Therefore, an even higher concentration of PFAS should be achievable with a commercial distillation system.Example 2 - Regenerant Solution Preparation
[0177] Four simulated spent-medium regenerant solutions were prepared by mixing the ingredients in the proportions shown in Table 2 below. PFBS in the table represents perfluorobutanesulfonic acid.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491Table 2. Regenerant Solution Feed Compositions to MembranesExample 3 - Flat Sheet Membrane Separation in Test Cell
[0178] A 2.26-in2circular piece of poly(piperazine-amide) membrane was placed on the porous steel support of a stirred cell. An O-ring was placed on top of the membrane, and the top of the cell was connected to seal the membrane to the porous steel support and to prevent leakage around the O-ring seal. The cell was filled with 290 mL of the simulated regenerant Solution A, and then the cell was connected to a nitrogen tank. Nitrogen pressure to the stirred cell was regulated to 400 psi, and the internal stir bar was initiated. The experiment was run at room temperature. Permeate samples were collected approximately every 1.5-2 hours until the remaining solution in the cell reached approximately 50 mL. The experiment was paused, and an additional volume of the original feed solution was added to fill the cell. The cell wasAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491repressurized and permeate samples were collected until the volume in the cell reached the minimum allowable level. The experiment was concluded and samples of the original feed, the permeate, and the final concentrate in the cell were submitted for analytical testing. Tests were conducted for conductivity (salinity indicator), UV254 adsorption (humic acid indicator), Na+, Cl-, PFAS, and TOC (solvent indicator). The results of the tests are shown in Figure 4.
[0179] The feed pressure was set at 400 psi with no subsequent adjustment, and the pH averaged 7.7. The flux averaged around 15 gallons ft-2day-1(GFD) and showed no significant decline during the entirety of the trial. The volume of solution in the stirred cell declined with time, resulting in an increase in the brine or concentrate concentration. At 80% permeate recovery, there was only 60 mL left in the cell, so additional starting regenerant solution was added to fill the cell. This reduced the total solution recovery but allowed the experiment to continue a final higher recovery. A total of 515 mL of regenerant solution was added to the cell, and the final remaining amount of solution was 43 mL which equated to 92% recovery of permeate from the total feed solution. Samples of the initial feed and the final concentrate were collected for analysis. Multiple permeate samples were collected throughout the trial and analyzed.
[0180] The concentrations of the fluid in the cell at the start and end of the run, as well as the permeate concentrations are shown in Figure 5. TOC measurement was used to estimate the solvent concentration, since 99.99% of the TOC in the system was due to the ethanol solvent. Conductivity was used to estimate the NaCl concentration in Solution A since the Na and Cl ions were the main species contributing to the conductivity of the solution. (Na and Cl' were directly measured in Solution B and trended the same as conductivity.) The PFA species were measured by an outside lab using the procedure defined by the EPA 537.1 test method.
[0181] The data show that the PFOA increased significantly from the first feed sample to the last concentrate sample, which indicates that the PFOA species was well-rejected by the membrane. In contrast, the ethanol solvent and the NaCl salt were virtually unchanged. The permeate concentration and the feed concentration of these species were about the same.
[0182] Not shown in Figure 5 is the UV 254 data. This value, representing the humic acid concentration, increased from 0.0326 Absorbance in the feed to 0.183 Absorbance in the finalAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491concentrate. The permeate was consistently below 0.025 Absorbance, which shows that the humic acid was also being rejected and concentrated in the stirred cell.
[0183] The final concentration factors for each species in the test were calculated from the ratio of the final brine versus the initial feed concentrations. The results are shown in Figure 6. As seen in the figure, humic acid exhibited the highest concentration, increasing by a factor of 5.5, whereas the concentrations of PFOA and PFBA both increased by a factor of 3. In contrast, the salts and the ethanol were not concentrated at all. The remarkable performance of this membrane is ideal for concentrating PFAS and natural organics in regenerant solutions. An additional benefit observed with this approach is the consistent feed pressure and permeate flux throughout the test. In typical reverse osmosis (RO) and nanofiltration (NF) processes, all the ions would be concentrated, which increases osmotic pressure, and decreases the driving force. At a fixed feed pressure, this would lead to ever decreasing permeate flux. This is demonstrated in the comparative examples below.
[0184] The results in Figures 5 and 6 are especially surprising. They demonstrate that the four-carbon PFBA molecule can be highly rejected and concentrated, while the two-carbon alcohol does not exhibit any concentration. It can be fairly concluded that this type of NF membrane (poly(piperazine-amide)) would be effective in concentrating the entire spectrum of per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) present in contaminated waters.Example 4 - Flat Sheet Membrane Separation in Test Cell at Elevated pH
[0185] A second trial was run in the same membrane stirred cell setup as described in Example 3. In this case, a higher concentration of PFAS was used, a third PFAS species (PFBS) was added, and the pH of the feed was increased and kept at 10. Also, recovery was increased from 92% to 95%. The composition of the feed liquid is shown in Table 2 above as Solution B.
[0186] The operating conditions and basic flow data for the test are shown in Figure 7. In this example, the starting solution in the cell was 270 mL, which was treated at 400 psi of feed pressure. The permeate was collected and set aside at regular intervals. When there was only 46 mL of concentrated regenerant solution left in the stirred cell, 267 mL of fresh regenerantAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491solution was added to the cell, and the separation experiment was continued until there was just 21 mL left in the cell. This equates to a 95.1% recovery.
[0187] As seen in Figure 7, the pH of the permeate was around 10, which was the same as the initial feed sample and the final concentrate sample. The flux rate was constant throughout the test at 14.2 GFD.
[0188] The concentration profile of the various species in the trial is shown in Figure 8. Like Example 3 above, the PFAS and humic acid species were highly concentrated as recovery increased, while the permeate concentration of both remained quite low, indicating good rejection. The conductivity (salinity) and the TOC value (solvent) remained about the same for the feed, the concentrate, and the permeate samples. These results align with those presented in Example 3; however, in this instance, the PFAS concentration was significantly higher, as illustrated in Figure 8.
[0189] Figure 9 also shows the result for the Na and Cl ions, as these were directly measured by standard analytical methods. The Na, Cl ions and ethanol were not concentrated when treated by this membrane. The PFOA, PFBA, and PFBS were all highly concentrated, even more than in Example 3, 6.5-8 times versus 3 times. The higher concentration of the PFAS compounds in this trial was surprising and cannot be explained solely on the slightly higher recovery of 95% versus 92%. It can be fairly concluded then that the elevated feed pH enhanced the membrane's capacity to reject PFAS compounds, while it did not impact the rejection rate of NaCl or ethanol. It was also unexpected that a higher recovery of 95% could be achieved without increasing the feed pressure. It should therefore be feasible to recover even more regenerant solution while minimizing the passage of PFAS or natural organic matter.
[0190] To summarize, Examples 1 and 3-4 show the surprising result that regenerant solutions, which have high concentrations of salts and / or solvents, can be treated by distillation to recover a majority of the solvent and by a poly(piperazine-amide) NF membrane to reduce the volume of PFAS-rich waste streams, maximize the recovery of the solvents and salts for reuse in future regenerant solutions, minimize waste disposal, reduce energy consumption during regenerant concentration, and provide a high PFAS and salt concentration stream for treatmentAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491by electro-oxidation, or other destruction technologies, without loading those solutions with a large amount of solvent.Comparative Examples 1-3 and Example 5 - Flat Sheet Membrane Separation in Test Cell
[0191] For comparison purposes, two conventional aromatic polyamide (APA) RO flat sheet membranes and one of the leading APA NF flat sheet membranes commonly used for water treatment, along with a poly(piperazine-amide) (PPA) NF membrane according to the invention, were tested with the synthetic regenerant Solution C detailed in Table 2 above.
[0192] The membranes tested are listed in Table 3 below.Table 3. Comparative Flat Sheet Membrane Test Cell Examples
[0193] The CPA7 membrane (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a high-rejection brackish water RO membrane. It typically has a flux rate of 32 GFD at a 225-psi feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 1500 mg / L NaCl feed solution.
[0194] The ESPA4 membrane (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a high-flow brackish water RO membrane. It typically has a flux rate of 34 GFD at a 75-psi feed pressure and a rejection of 99.2% when tested on a 500 mg / L NaCl feed solution.
[0195] The ESNA1-LF membrane (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a high-flow polyamide NF membrane. It typically has a flux rate of 29 GFD at a 75-psi feed pressure and a rejection of 93% when tested on a 500 mg / L CaCh feed solution.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491
[0196] The NANO-SW membrane (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a high-rejection brackish water poly(piperazine-amide) NF membrane. It typically has a flux rate of 27.5 GFD at a 110-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSO4 feed solution.
[0197] The stirred cell was filled with regenerant Solution C and pressurized to generate permeate flow. The membrane area for each test was 0.0157 ft2.
[0198] The same result was seen for all three comparative membrane types. At 1200 psi, there was no flow. Pressure was increased to the maximum level, 1480 psi, but there was essentially no flow. Less than 1 mL per hour permeated the membrane. There was not enough sample to make any analytical measurements. No significant permeate was generated.
[0199] The rejection by all comparative membranes was sufficiently high to conclude that the osmotic pressure difference between the feed solution and the permeate solution was greater than the feed pressure (1480 psi). Therefore, only the poly(piperazine-amide) NF membrane could pass enough salt to make the osmotic pressure difference sufficiently small so that permeate could be generated at a reasonable pressure of 400 psi. However, it was unexpected that the membrane could have such a good rejection of the PFAS compounds, especially the very short, 4-carbon PFAS compounds, while having no rejection for ethanol.Examples 6-8 - Flat Sheet Membrane Separation in Cross Flow Test Cell
[0200] As previously mentioned, the solvent used in the regeneration solution needs to have an osmotic pressure difference between the concentrate and the permeate of less than about 500 psi to ensure that the operation pressure would be less than 600 psi, which is the limit of conventional NF spiral elements. To estimate the limit of osmotic pressure difference, 3 different alcohols / solvents were tested with NANO SW membrane (Hydranautics) in a crossflow test cell unit at a concentration of 2000 mg / L in water and at a test pressure of 145 psi. The cross-flow test cell has a membrane area of 0.038 ft2and a recovery rate of less than 1%. The permeate collected during a 60-min test was measured to determine alcohol concentration and flux rate. The results are shown in Table 4. As expected, the rejection of the alcohol increases dramatically as the carbon number increases.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491Table 4. Measurement of Alcohol Rejection and Flux for Solvents with Differing Carbon NumbersExamples 9-11 - Mass Balance-Calculated Performance of PPA Spiral Would Element Membrane Treating a 2% Ethanol Solution at 90% Recovery
[0201] Based on the rejection values in Table 4, it is possible to calculate the performance of a similar membrane running at high recovery. An example for 2% ethanol / water mixture at 90% hydraulic recovery is shown in Figure 10. Using the rejection of 13.5% (Example 6), the composition of the concentrate can be calculated based on mass balance. In this case, the permeate concentration would be 19,450 mg / L of ethanol and the concentrate would have 24,950 mg / L. Using the Ideal Gas Law equation (P=nRT / V), the osmotic pressure of the permeate would be 152 psi and the concentrate osmotic pressure would be 195 psi. The difference between these two osmotic pressures is 43 psi as shown in Table 5, Example 9. To have any permeate flow, feed pressure greater than 43 psi would be needed.
[0202] When these calculations are extended to the other two alcohols. Examples 10 and 11, the osmotic pressure difference between the concentrate solution and the permeate solution greatly increases as shown in Table 5. The calculation for the C5 alcohol shows that the osmotic pressure is 515 psi. With an operation pressure limit of 600 psi for the spiral element, this leaves less than 85 psi to generate permeate, which is not practical for achieving reasonable flux rates. Thus, treatment of alcohols with less than 5 carbon atoms should be considered for this novel treatment. From the reported standard performance of NANO SW element, the permeability of the membrane is calculated to be 0.33 GFD / psi and the pressure drop due to hydraulic frictionAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491loss for a 90% recovery system would be 30 psi, so the total required pressure for the C5 alcohol would be sum of the pressure for osmotic pressure difference, the pressure for permeating solution and the pressure from the hydraulic losses. The sum of these is shown below.Required Feed Pressure = 515 psi + 77 psi + 30 psi = 622 psi
[0203] In this case, the required feed pressure exceeds the operation limit of the NANO SW element. Therefore, treatment of solvents is possible only for solvents with less than 5 carbon atoms, as that will result in lower rejection and lower osmotic pressure difference between the concentrate and permeate streams.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491 Table 5. Calculated Osmotic Pressure Difference, Concentrate Minus Permeate, for Three Different AlcoholsAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491Comparative Example 6 and Example 12 - Spiral Element Membrane Separation
[0204] In addition to testing NF membranes in a small test cell, the PPA NF membrane was also tested in a spiral element format at high recovery. Both conventional APA NF membrane and the novel PPA NF membrane were tested and performance compared. The spiral element membranes tested are listed in Table 6 below.Table 6. Comparative Spiral Element Membrane Examples
[0205] The ESNA1-LF2 2540 element (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a 2.5-inch diameter by 40-inch-long spiral element utilizing a high-flow polyamide NF membrane. It typically has an element flow rate of 930 GPD at a 75-psi feed pressure and a rejection of 91% when tested on a 500 mg / L CaCh feed solution at 25 degrees C and 15% recovery. This membrane is a looser NF membrane compared to ESNA1 LF membrane used in CE3.
[0206] The NANO-SW 2540 element membrane (Hydranautics, Oceanside, CA, USA) is a sulfate-selective poly(piperazine-amide) NF membrane. It typically has a flow rate of 660 GPD at a 130-psig feed pressure and a rejection of 99.8% when tested on a 2000 mg / L MgSO4feed solution at 25 degrees C and 15% recovery. This NF membrane is similar to that tested in Table 3 (ESNA1 LF), but has lower rejection and higher flow. This looser membrane was chosen since the membrane used in CE3 had very low flow rate.
[0207] The element test rig comprised a feed tank, a high-pressure pump, a chiller for temperature control, a single 2540 element and a permeate tank. The feed solution was treated by the membrane, producing a permeate which was collected in the permeate tank. The residual concentrate was recycled back to the feed tank. During the trial, the volume of liquid in the feed tank decreased over time and was enriched in the species that were rejected by the membrane. The permeate volume increased over time and contained species that passed through the membrane. The initial feedwater was composed of synthetic regenerantAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491Solution D (Table 2) and pressurized to generate permeate flow. The membrane area for each element was 28 ft2.
[0208] The performance of the two elements is shown in Figures 11A and 11B. Figure 11 A shows the flow performance of the NANO SW during the separation of the Solution D. As recovery increases, the flux and feed pressure remain constant. This is contrary to most RO membranes which would create greater osmotic pressure difference between the concentrate and the permeate, resulting in decreasing flux at a fixed pressure. At 90% of liquid recovery, the performance was still stable and the PFOA was concentrated by 8.5 times. This performance was even better than the data from the flat sheet membrane cell test.
[0209] Figure 11B shows that the PFOA was highly concentrated, while the ethanol and NaCl were essentially unchanged. These results indicate that recovery higher than 90% is quite feasible using PPA-type NF membrane. Based on the stable flux and pressure, it was possible to reach recoveries of 98 or 99%, greatly reducing the fluid to be treated by electrooxidation and minimizing the ethanol that would need to be oxidized as well.
[0210] In contrast, the ESNA1 LF22540 element ran at 2 times higher pressure than the NANO SW and had a 75% lower flux. As a result, the PFOA was minimally concentrated. After 2.5 hrs of operation, the recovery only reached 27.5% compared to 90% in 2 hrs of operation for the NANO SW 2540. The reason for the low flow rates and low recovery was due to the NF membrane rejecting the NaCl.
[0211] Figures 12A and 12B show the big difference in sodium chloride rejection for the two membranes. The NANO SW had 6.4% sodium chloride rejection at the end of the trial, compared to 33.9% for the ESNA1 LF2 at the end of the test. This greatly affected the flow of permeate and limited recovery.
[0212] Based on the results of the element testing, the PPA-type of NF membrane had surprisingly superior performance. It could concentrate the PFOA to a much higher level, pass significantly more sodium chloride, and operate at much higher flux compared to the APA-type NF membrane. This superior performance -would greatly reduce the cost of the electrooxidation step, making the regeneration of the PFAS adsorption media very economical.
[0213] Figure 13 shows the results of a test where a synthetic spent-regenerant solution was treated with a PPA membrane in the form of a 2.5-inch by 40-inch spiral wound element. As the recovery of the permeate increased, the concentrations of PFOA, Cl, Na, and ethanolAttorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491were measured. This figure shows the concentration factor of each species relative to the starting concentrations. The PFOA was concentrated by 8 times, as desired. In contrast, the salt components (Cl and Na) were only concentrated by 1.11 times, and the ethanol was actually enriched in the permeate, not in the concentrate. The effect of the salt and the solvent were all in the desired range, where a majority of the initial solvent and salt mass in the feed solution ended up in the permeate stream.
[0214] The invention has been described in detail with particular reference to preferred embodiments thereof, but it will be understood that variations and modifications can be made within the spirit and scope of the invention.
Claims
Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ0491CLAIMSWe claim:
1. A process for separating per- or poly-fluoroalkyi substances (PFAS) from an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution (a) comprising an organic solvent having less than five carbon atoms, a monovalent inorganic salt, and PFAS, and (b) having an osmotic pressure of greater than 500 psi (3.45 MPa),the process comprising at least one step of contacting the spent-regenerant solution with a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to form a retentate stream enriched in PFAS and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS,wherein a majority of the mass of the organic solvent and the monovalent inorganic salt from the spent-regenerant solution are in the permeate stream.
2. The process of claim 1, wherein the contacting step is carried out at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
3. The process of claim 1, wherein the spent-regenerant solution has a pH of 6 to 11, of 7 to 11, of 8 to 1 I, of 9 to 11, or of 10 to 11.
4. The process of claim 1, wherein the retentate stream comprises at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the spent-regenerant solution.
5. The process of claim 1, wherein the organic solvent comprises methanol, ethanol, isopropyl alcohol, t-butanol, acetone, ethyl acetate, acetonitrile, or combinations thereof.
6. The process of claim 1, wherein the monovalent inorganic salt comprises sodium bromide (NaBr), sodium iodide (Nal), sodium bicarbonate (NaHCC ), potassium chloride (KC1), potassium bromide (KBr), potassium iodide (KI), ammonium chloride (NH4Q), or combinations thereof.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ04917. The process of claim 1, wherein the spent-regenerant solution further comprises natural organic compounds and water;wherein the spent-regenerant solution is distilled before contacting with the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to generate (a) a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent which is recycled to a fresh regenerant storage vessel and (b) a distillation bottoms stream enriched in the PFAS, the monovalent inorganic salt, and the natural organic compounds and depleted in the organic solvent; andwherein the distillation bottoms stream is contacted with the poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane to generate the retentate stream enriched in the PFAS and the permeate stream depleted in the PFAS.
8. The process of claim 7, wherein at least a portion of the permeate stream is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
9. The process of claim 7, which further comprises treating the retentate stream in an oxidation zone to mineralize the PFAS to fluoride salt.
10. The process of claim 9, wherein the oxidation zone generates an effluent stream comprising tire monovalent inorganic salt, and wherein at least a portion of the effluent stream is recycled to the fresh regenerant storage vessel.
11. The process of claim 9, wherein the oxidation zone comprises a blowdown to intermittently remove undesired products from the effluent stream.
12. Tire process of claim 11, wherein the blowdown stream further comprises minute amounts of unoxidized PFAS, and wherein the effluent stream is contacted with a PFAS-selective adsorption medium to polish the residual PFAS that has not been fully oxidized to F salt.
13. The process of claim 7, wherein at least 90%, at least 95%, at least 98%, or at least 99% of the monovalent inorganic salt, the organic solvent, or both in the spent-regenerant solution are recovered for reuse.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ049114. A system for selective concentration of per- or poly- fluoroalkyl substances (PFAS) from an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution, the system comprising:a distillation zone inlet configured to introduce an adsorption media spent-regenerant solution comprising PFAS, a monovalent inorganic salt, an organic solvent with less than five carbon atoms, natural organic compounds, and water into a distillation zone;wherein the distillation zone is configured to generate a distillation overhead stream rich in the organic solvent and a distillation bottoms stream rich in the PFAS, the monovalent inorganic salt, and the natural organic compounds; anda membrane separation zone inlet configured to convey the distillation bottoms stream into a membrane separation zone;wherein the distillation bottoms stream has an osmotic pressure of at least 500 psi (3.45 MPa);wherein the membrane separation zone comprises a poly(piperazine-amide) nanofiltration membrane and is configured to generate a retentate stream rich in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, and a permeate stream depleted in the PFAS and the natural organic compounds, andwherein a majority of the mass of the monovalent inorganic salt and the organic solvent from the distillation bottoms stream are in the permeate stream.
15. The system of claim 14, wherein the membrane separation zone is configured to operate at a feed pressure of 600 psi (4.14 MPa) or less.
16. The system of claim 14, wherein the membrane separation zone is configured to generate a retentate stream comprising at least 6 times, at least 10 times, or at least 20 times the concentration of the PFAS compared to the distillation bottoms stream.
18. The system of claim 14, which further comprises an oxidation zone inlet configured to convey the retentate stream to an oxidation zone, wherein the oxidation zone is configured to mineralize the PFAS in the retentate stream to fluoride salt.Attorney Docket No. 208327.0260 / 259WO Nitto Ref: NLQ049119. The system of claim 18, wherein the oxidation zone is further configured to generate an effluent stream comprising the monovalent salt, and wherein the system further comprises a conduit configured to convey at least a portion of the effluent stream to a fresh regenerant storage vessel.
20. The system of claim 18, wherein the oxidation zone comprises a blowdown stream to intermittently remove undesirable products from the effluent stream, and wherein the effluent stream is contacted with a PFAS-selective adsorption medium to polish the residual PFAS that has not been fully oxidized to F salt.
