Device and method

The apparatus and method support authenticity determination by acquiring and rating metadata to evaluate content truthfulness, addressing metadata falsification issues and ensuring accurate authenticity assessment.

WO2026234786A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-12NTT DOCOMO INC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2025/016979
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2025-05-09
Publication Date
2026-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing systems fail to adequately support authenticity determination of content due to metadata falsification, which can compromise the truthfulness of information such as imaging position and time, leading to factual inaccuracies.

Method used

An apparatus and method that includes an acquisition unit to gather metadata related to content, a rating unit to assign ratings based on multiple types of metadata, and an output unit to present the ratings, enabling multifaceted authenticity evaluation.

Benefits of technology

Enables users to determine the authenticity of content from various angles, supporting accurate truthfulness assessment by providing detailed and reliable rating results.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2025016979_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2025016979_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

An authenticity determination assistance device according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention includes: an acquisition unit that acquires a content item and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content item; a rating unit that, on the basis of the plurality of types of metadata, assigns one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of categories for evaluating the authenticity of the content; and an output unit that outputs results of the rating assigning performed by the rating unit.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Apparatus and Method

[0001] The present disclosure relates to an apparatus and a method for supporting authenticity determination of content.

[0002] Patent Document 1 discloses that an imaging apparatus generates metadata related to a captured image, and records an image file including the captured image and the metadata.

[0003] Japanese Unexamined Patent Publication No. 2022-47787

[0004] For example, by referring to metadata associated with content such as a captured image, it is possible to grasp information related to the content, such as the imaging position and imaging time of the content. If such metadata is falsified, various problems may occur. For example, if the imaging position or imaging time of the content is falsified, this leads to falsification of facts such as the time or position at which the user actually performed imaging. In this case, the authenticity of the content is impaired.

[0005] An object of the present disclosure is to provide a technique that supports authenticity determination of content.

[0006] An example apparatus according to the present disclosure includes an acquisition unit that acquires content and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content, a rating unit that assigns one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of items for evaluating the authenticity of the content based on the plurality of types of metadata, and an output unit that outputs a result of the rating assignment by the rating unit.

[0007] In the above apparatus, since the results of assigning ratings regarding the authenticity of the content for the plurality of items are output, the user can determine the authenticity of the content from multifaceted viewpoints based on the plurality of items. As described above, according to the above apparatus, it is possible to support the user's authenticity determination regarding the content.

[0008] According to the present disclosure, authenticity determination of content can be supported.

[0009] This figure shows the configuration of an example truth-of-fact judgment support device. This figure illustrates the classification of judgments in an example rating. This figure illustrates the perspectives used in rating by an example truth-of-fact judgment support device. This figure illustrates an example of the output of the rating result by an example truth-of-fact judgment support device. This flowchart shows the truth-of-fact judgment support method, which is the process performed by an example truth-of-fact judgment support device. This figure shows the hardware configuration of an example truth-of-fact judgment support device.

[0010] The embodiments of the truthfulness determination support device and truthfulness determination support method relating to this disclosure will be described in detail below, along with the drawings. In the description of the drawings, the same elements will be denoted by the same reference numerals, and redundant explanations will be omitted.

[0011] Figure 1 shows the configuration of the truthfulness determination support device 10 according to this embodiment. The truthfulness determination support device 10 is a device (system) that assists users in determining the truthfulness of content. One example of the truthfulness determination support device outputs a rating result for determining the truthfulness of content. The content is newly generated digital content. The content may be, for example, an image (photograph or video) generated by imaging (photography). The content may also be an image generated by means other than imaging. The content may be any data such as text or audio (recorded data), as long as metadata is associated with it. For example, the content may be data relating to temperature, humidity, illuminance, smell, or taste.

[0012] Metadata is data related to the content data. For example, metadata may directly or indirectly indicate the location where the content was created, the time the content was created, the person who created the content, the device used to create the content, etc. For example, if the content is image data generated by imaging, the metadata would be data indicating the location where the imaging took place, the time the imaging took place, the person who performed the imaging, the device used to perform the imaging, etc.

[0013] The truthfulness determination support device 10 may have a function to generate (create) content and metadata. For example, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may have a function to capture images and generate images, such as a camera. In this case, the truthfulness determination support device 10 outputs a rating result for determining the truthfulness of the content generated by its own device. The truthfulness determination support device 10 may be composed of a terminal device that has a function to generate content, such as a smartphone, tablet terminal, or PC (personal computer). The truthfulness determination support device 10 may also be a wearable terminal (e.g., glasses or a watch), a camera, an in-vehicle terminal, a recording microphone, etc. The truthfulness determination support device 10 may also be an IoT (Internet of Things) terminal installed in a remote location, such as a smart speaker or an LPWA (Low Power Wide Area) temperature sensor.

[0014] Alternatively, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may evaluate the truthfulness of metadata of content generated by other devices. For example, if the device that generates the content does not have sufficient information processing capabilities, the truthfulness determination support device 10 other than the device that generates the content may evaluate the truthfulness of the content. In this case, the truthfulness determination support device 10 is composed of computers such as PCs and server devices. The truthfulness determination support device 10 may be composed of multiple computers. Furthermore, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may be composed of a device that generates content and other devices (for example, a server device). The truthfulness determination support device 10 may be able to send and receive information with other devices via a network in order to acquire information necessary for realizing its functions.

[0015] The truthfulness of content refers to whether or not the content is based on truth. The content in this disclosure is accompanied by metadata related to the data of the content. For example, if the metadata is falsified through tampering, the truthfulness of the content is compromised. In other words, the truthfulness of the content can be said to be the truthfulness of the metadata. Tampering with metadata can be carried out by the person who generates the content, or by someone other than the person who generates the content. Note that the metadata related to the content may be data extracted from the content itself. If the content is not based on truth, then the metadata extracted from the content will also not be based on truth.

[0016] The truthfulness determination support device 10 according to this embodiment comprises an acquisition unit 11, a rating unit 12, and an output unit 13. In this embodiment, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may have a function to generate content and some metadata. Also, as shown in Figure 1, one example of the truthfulness determination support device 10 may have a display unit 14 and a measurement unit 15.

[0017] The acquisition unit 11 is a functional unit that acquires content and multiple types of metadata related to the content. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire multiple metadata at the time the content is generated. The metadata may be generated by the truthfulness determination support device 10, or it may be acquired from an external server or the like in conjunction with the generation of the content.

[0018] The acquisition unit 11 may acquire data related to the time the content was created (hereinafter referred to as time-related data) as metadata. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire data related to the location where the content was created (hereinafter referred to as location-related data) as metadata. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire data related to the person who created the content (hereinafter referred to as person-related data) as metadata. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire data related to the device that created the content (hereinafter referred to as device-related data) as metadata. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire other information related to the content as metadata.

[0019] Time-related data includes time information. Time information is information indicating the date the content was created and the time on that date. In this embodiment, time-related data includes first time information and second time information as time information. The first time information is data obtained by the clock function of the device that generates the content (e.g., the truthfulness determination support device 10). The second time information is data obtained by the clock function of an external device that generates the content. The second time information may be, for example, data obtained from an NTP (Network Time Protocol) server. In this case, the second time information may be multiple pieces of time information obtained from multiple NTP servers. For example, the acquisition unit 11 of this embodiment acquires data related to the second time information from three or more NTP servers. Note that the second time information may be obtained from sources other than NTP servers, as long as it is data obtained from outside the device that generates the content.

[0020] Location-related data includes location information. Location information indicates the location where the content was generated, that is, the location of the device generating the content at the time the content was generated. Location information is, for example, Geometry type data that includes information indicating the latitude and longitude of the location. Location-related data includes first location information and second location information as location information. First location information is data obtained by the device generating the content determining its own position using a positioning function such as GPS (Global Positioning System) or QZSS (Quasi-Zenith Satellite System) (GNSS (Global Navigation Satellite System)). Second location information may be data obtained from a location information service or the like provided outside the device generating the content. The second location information may be, for example, location information provided by an external system (external API (Application Programming Interface)) that utilizes base station information, Wi-Fi® access point information, etc. Furthermore, the second location information may be obtained from any location information service, as long as it is information acquired from outside the device that generates the content.

[0021] Furthermore, location-related data may include data other than location information obtained using QZSS, etc. Such data may include the type of satellite received by the content generating device, the satellite's elevation angle, and the strength of the received signal (e.g., CNR: Carrier-to-Noise Ratio).

[0022] Person-related data is data used to verify the authenticity of the person who generated the content. Person-related data includes biometric authentication data and PIN code data. Biometric authentication data may be data indicating whether or not biometric authentication was successful at the device that generates the content when the content is generated. PIN code data may be data indicating whether or not the correct PIN code was entered at the device that generates the content when the content is generated.

[0023] Device-related data includes device information. Device information is information that indicates the device that generated the content. For example, device information is data that indicates the device stored in the device that generated the content. The data indicating the device may include, for example, the device name, manufacturer name, device model number, display name, manufacturer's product ID, chipset model, number of CPU cores, etc.

[0024] Other information related to the content, if the content is an image, may include Exif (Exchangeable Image File Format) data. Exif data is generated by the device that generates the content when the content is created. Exif data may include information such as exposure time, aperture value, ISO sensitivity, focal length, white balance, and whether or not a flash was used.

[0025] Furthermore, the acquisition unit 11 may acquire data measured by a measurement unit 15 provided in the content generating device as metadata. The measurement unit 15 may be one or more sensors. For example, the measurement unit 15 may include an acceleration sensor, a gyro sensor, an illuminance sensor, a barometric pressure sensor, a geomagnetic sensor, a temperature sensor, etc. One example of a measurement unit 15 acquires acceleration data acquired by an acceleration sensor, gyro data acquired by a gyro sensor, illuminance data acquired by an illuminance sensor, barometric pressure data acquired by a barometric pressure sensor, geomagnetic data acquired by a geomagnetic sensor, and temperature data acquired by a temperature sensor.

[0026] If the device that generates the content is the truthfulness determination support device 10 and the metadata is stored in the truthfulness determination support device 10, the acquisition unit 11 reads and acquires the metadata from its own device 10. If the device that generates the content is not the truthfulness determination support device 10, or if the metadata is not stored in the truthfulness determination support device 10, the acquisition unit 11 receives and acquires the metadata from the device in which the metadata is stored. Acquisition of metadata from the device in which the metadata is stored may be performed, for example, by the acquisition unit 11 requesting the metadata from the device, or the device may be configured in advance to transmit the metadata to the acquisition unit 11.

[0027] The acquisition unit 11 may acquire metadata at the time the content is generated. For example, the acquisition unit 11 may detect that the content has been generated and acquire metadata. The detection of content generation can be performed using conventional methods. The acquisition unit 11 may also acquire metadata at a time other than when the content is generated.

[0028] The rating unit 12 is a functional unit that assigns one of a predetermined number of ratings to each of several viewpoints (items) for evaluating the truthfulness of content, based on multiple types of metadata. Based on the metadata corresponding to each of the viewpoints, the rating unit 12 assigns the truthfulness of each viewpoint to one of the multiple ratings. In this embodiment, for example, ratings from 0 to 7 may be provided. The truthfulness of viewpoints assigned ratings 1 and 2 is negative, while the truthfulness of viewpoints assigned ratings 3 to 7 is positive.

[0029] A rating of 0 corresponds to cases where metadata cannot be obtained. If the metadata necessary for assigning a rating cannot be obtained, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to the relevant viewpoint. When a rating of 0 is assigned, the evaluation of the truthfulness of the relevant viewpoint is suspended.

[0030] Rating 1 corresponds to cases where it can be determined that intentional tampering has occurred in the metadata. If it can be determined that intentional tampering has occurred in the metadata necessary for assigning a rating, the rating unit 12 assigns Rating 1 to the relevant aspect.

[0031] Rating 2 is used when there is a high suspicion of tampering with the metadata. If there is a high suspicion of tampering with the metadata necessary for assigning a rating, the rating unit 12 assigns Rating 2 to the relevant aspect.

[0032] Rating 3 is used when consistency can be confirmed using only a single data point. If the metadata required for rating is reasonable, consistency can be confirmed using only a single data point, and therefore the rating unit 12 assigns Rating 3 to the relevant aspect.

[0033] The rating unit 12 according to this embodiment verifies the consistency of deterministic data or analogical data based on an analogical algorithm or an affirmative algorithm. An analogical algorithm is an algorithm that includes uncertain judgment elements such as prediction and inference in at least part. For example, stating that the weather is sunny if there is high pressure is an analogical algorithm. Image analysis using a large-scale language model is also an analogical algorithm. A deterministic algorithm is a predetermined rule-based algorithm whose truthfulness can be verified. For example, when metadata is a physical quantity, an algorithm that can make a reliable determination using a threshold or the like is deterministic.

[0034] Each of the various types of metadata can be classified as either analogical data or deterministic data. Analogical data is data that includes uncertain elements such as prediction and inference during its generation process. For example, predictive data inferred from accumulated historical data, and data inferred based on the content are analogical. Deterministic data is data based on actual measurements, such as data acquired by a device that generates content. Deterministic data may also be historical data such as real-time data or historically accumulated data.

[0035] Figure 2 is a diagram illustrating the classification of judgments in an example rating system. As shown in Figure 2, a judgment of truthfulness based on deterministic data and a deterministic algorithm can be called a deterministic judgment. On the other hand, a judgment of truthfulness based on at least one of analogical data and an analogical algorithm can be called an analogical judgment. In this example, the rating unit 12 assigns a higher rating to a deterministic judgment than to an analogical judgment when truthfulness is affirmed. The rating unit 12 may also assign a higher rating to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm than to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on an analogical algorithm. Furthermore, the rating unit 12 may also assign a higher rating to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on deterministic data than to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on analogical data.

[0036] When the rating unit 12 assigns a truthfulness rating by comparing metadata, it may change the rating assigned depending on whether the metadata being compared are of the same type or different type. For example, the rating unit 12 may assign a higher rating to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on different types of metadata compared to a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on similar types of metadata. Similar types refer to cases where the content of the metadata being compared is the same. For example, comparing a physical quantity acquired (measured) by a content generating device with data corresponding to that physical quantity received from an external server can be said to be a similar type comparison. Different types refer to cases where the content of the metadata being compared is different. For example, comparing a physical quantity acquired (measured) by a content generating device with data corresponding to that physical quantity that is calculated or estimated from data different from that physical quantity can be said to be a different type comparison.

[0037] Rating 4 corresponds to cases where the consistency of similar metadata can be affirmed through analogical judgment. That is, if an analogical judgment result is obtained that affirms the truthfulness of similar metadata, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 4 to the relevant viewpoint.

[0038] Rating 5 corresponds to cases where heterogeneous consistency can be affirmed through analogical judgment. That is, if an analogical judgment result is obtained that affirms the truthfulness of heterogeneous metadata, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 5 to the relevant aspect.

[0039] Rating 6 corresponds to cases where the same consistency can be affirmed by a definitive judgment. That is, when a definitive judgment result is obtained that affirms the truthfulness of the same type of metadata, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 6 to the relevant aspect.

[0040] Rating 7 corresponds to cases where heterogeneous consistency can be affirmed by a definitive judgment. That is, when a definitive judgment result is obtained that affirms the truthfulness of heterogeneous metadata, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 7 to the relevant aspect.

[0041] The rating unit 12 according to this embodiment assigns ratings to multiple viewpoints that may correspond to any of the six principles (5W1H). The rating unit 12 according to this embodiment also assigns ratings to viewpoints other than those corresponding to the six principles. The following describes viewpoints 1 to 11 as an example, but the viewpoints to which ratings are assigned by the rating unit 12 may include other viewpoints. Figure 3 is a table showing an overview of viewpoints 1 to 11.

[0042] [Perspective 1] Perspective 1 corresponds to "When" of the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the truthfulness of the content based on time information. For example, the rating unit 12 determines whether the first time information is correct or not. In one example, the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether the first time information and the second time information have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because there is metadata that has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to Perspective 1. If the metadata has been acquired, it determines whether the time zone has been changed or not. If the time zone has been changed, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 1 to Perspective 1. If the time zone has not been changed, the rating unit 12 calculates the time difference between the first time information and the second time information. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating 6 if the time difference is within a predetermined time, and assigns a rating 2 if the time difference exceeds the predetermined time. The predetermined time is the time required to acquire the second time information, and may be, for example, a few seconds.

[0043] [Aspect 2] Aspect 2 corresponds to "Where" in the 5W1H principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the content based on position information. For example, the rating unit 12 determines whether the first position information is correct. In one example, the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is in an online state. If the device is offline, offline-compatible processing is executed, and the process waits until the device returns to online. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether the first position information and the second position information have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. When it is difficult to evaluate the rating because there is metadata that has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 for Aspect 2. If the metadata has been acquired, it is determined whether a Mock flag is set. When the Mock flag is set, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 1 for Aspect 2. When the Mock flag is not set, the rating unit 12 calculates a positional deviation between the first position information and the second position information. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 6 when the deviation is within a predetermined distance, and assigns a rating of 2 when the deviation exceeds the predetermined distance.

[0044] [Aspect 3] Aspect 3 corresponds to "Who" in the 5W1H principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the content based on person-related data. For example, the rating unit 12 determines whether biometric authentication and a PIN code are correctly used. In one example, when it is determined based on biometric authentication data that biometric authentication has succeeded, and it is determined based on PIN code data that a correct PIN code has been input, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 6. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 when either the biometric authentication or the PIN code has failed.

[0045] [Perspective 4] Perspective 4 corresponds to the "How" of the Six Hows principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the app installed on the device that generates the content. For example, the rating unit 12 uses specific security check functions and integrity verification functions to verify the authenticity of the app itself. One example of the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether a security check token has been obtained by the acquisition unit 11. The security check token is issued using a specific security check function and is used to determine whether the app has been illegally modified. The rating unit 12 checks whether it can access a specific server using the security check token, assigns a rating of 6 for Perspective 4 if the access is successful, and assigns a rating of 1 if the access fails.

[0046] [Perspective 5] Perspective 5 corresponds to the "How" of the Six Hows principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the truthfulness of the content based on device-related data. For example, the rating unit 12 determines whether the device information is correct or not. In one example, the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether the device information has been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because there is device information that has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to perspective 5. If the device information has been acquired, the rating unit 12 acquires data about the device from an external server using the device name as the key. If the acquired data and the device information match, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 6 to perspective 5. If the acquired data and the device information do not all match, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 1 to perspective 5. Furthermore, if only a portion of the device information is obtained, and the data obtained from the external server matches the device information, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 2 to perspective 5.

[0047] [Perspective 6] Perspective 6 is a perspective that does not correspond to the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the truthfulness of the content from the perspective of the truthfulness of the acceleration sensor and gyro sensor. For example, the rating unit 12 determines the degree of correlation between the acceleration sensor and the gyro sensor. In one example, the rating unit 12 first determines whether the acceleration data, gyro data and time stamp have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. The acceleration data is data that shows the acceleration for the three axes, the X axis, the Y axis and the Z axis, and the gyro data is data that shows the angular velocity for the three axes, pitch, yaw and roll. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because any of the data has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to perspective 6. If all the data has been acquired, the rating unit 12 evaluates the correlation between each axis of the acceleration data and gyro data using correlation coefficients such as Pearson's correlation coefficient and Sperman's rank correlation coefficient. For example, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating 7 to perspective 6 if the calculated correlation coefficient exceeds a preset threshold, and assigns a rating 2 to perspective 6 if it is below the threshold.

[0048] [Aspect 7] Aspect 7 is an aspect that does not correspond to the 5W1H principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the content from the perspective of the correlation between the movement direction and the geomagnetic sensor. For example, the rating unit 12 compares the movement direction estimated from GNSS with geomagnetic data to verify the authenticity of the geomagnetic sensor. The rating unit 12 according to an example first determines whether GNSS data and geomagnetic data have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. The GNSS data includes a series of position information (latitude, longitude) and a time stamp, and the geomagnetic data includes a compass value (azimuth) indicating the direction of the device that generates the content. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because any of the data cannot be acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 for Aspect 7. If all the data can be acquired, the rating unit 12 evaluates the degree of coincidence between the movement direction over a certain period of time and the orientation of the device that generates the content. When a user is moving while carrying the device that generates the content, it is assumed that the device is often oriented in the moving direction of the user. For example, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 5 to Aspect 7 when the movement direction over a certain period of time matches the orientation of the device that generates the content, and assigns a rating of 2 to this aspect when they do not match.

[0049] [Perspective 8] Perspective 8 is a perspective that does not correspond to the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the content in terms of the shooting direction. For example, the rating unit 12 compares the shooting direction in Exif with the value from the acceleration sensor to verify the authenticity of the shooting direction in Exif. In one example, the rating unit 12 first determines whether Exif data and acceleration data have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because either data has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 for perspective 8. If all data has been acquired, the rating unit 12 compares the rotation information included in Exif with the value of the acceleration data to evaluate their consistency. Rotation information is information that indicates the rotational position of the device at the time of shooting. A device that generates content generates rotation information as metadata that indicates the rotational position, such as 0 degrees, 90 degrees, 180 degrees, or 270 degrees, in order to correctly display the top and bottom (up and down) of the generated image. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 7 to viewpoint 8 if the rotational position indicated by the rotational information included in Exif matches the rotational position estimated from the acceleration data, and assigns a rating of 2 to viewpoint 8 if they do not match.

[0050] [Perspective 9] Perspective 9 is a perspective that does not correspond to the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the authenticity of the content from the perspective of the device's height position. For example, the rating unit 12 compares the height from the ground calculated from the barometric pressure sensor and weather data with the height from the ground calculated from GPS information and verifies the authenticity of the height calculated from GPS information. One example of the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether location information, barometric pressure data, and weather data have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. Barometric pressure data is acquired by the barometric pressure sensor. Weather data may be data on the barometric pressure, temperature, and humidity at the location of the location information, acquired from an external server. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because any of the data has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to perspective 9. If all data has been acquired, the rating unit 12 calculates the height of the device from the ground based on the weather data and barometric pressure data, and evaluates its consistency with the height calculated from the GPS information. The height calculated from the GPS information may be the difference between the ellipsoid height and the geoid height. For example, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 5 to viewpoint 9 if the difference between the calculated height from the ground and the value calculated from the GPS information is less than or equal to a predetermined threshold, and assigns a rating of 2 to viewpoint 9 if it is greater than the threshold.

[0051] [Perspective 10] Perspective 10 is a perspective that does not correspond to the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the truthfulness of the content in terms of consistency between location information and the barometric pressure sensor. For example, the rating unit 12 compares the value of the barometric pressure calculated from the height from the ground and weather data with the value from the barometric pressure sensor to verify the truthfulness of the barometric pressure sensor value. One example of the rating unit 12 first determines whether the device that generates the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether location information, barometric pressure data, and weather data have been acquired. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because any of the data has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to perspective 10. If all data has been acquired, the rating unit 12 calculates the barometric pressure from the location information, weather data, and height from the ground information, and evaluates the consistency between the calculated value and the value from the barometric pressure sensor. For example, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 5 to viewpoint 10 if the difference between the calculated atmospheric pressure and the atmospheric pressure data from the atmospheric pressure sensor is less than or equal to a predetermined threshold, and assigns a rating of 2 to viewpoint 10 if the difference is greater than the threshold.

[0052] [Perspective 11] Perspective 11 is a perspective that does not correspond to the Six-Way Principle. The rating unit 12 assigns a rating to the truthfulness of the content from the perspective of consistency between location information, time information, and temperature information. For example, the rating unit 12 verifies the truthfulness of the temperature sensor value by comparing it with the temperature calculated from the indoor / outdoor determination result, weather data, etc. The indoor / outdoor determination result may be generated, for example, based on the QZSS value acquired by the device that generates the content. In one example, it may be determined that it is outdoors if the CNR on a high-elevation satellite is higher than the standard, and indoors if it is lower. For example, in summer the indoor temperature is lower than the outdoor temperature, and in winter the indoor temperature is higher than the outdoor temperature.

[0053] One example of a rating unit 12 first determines whether the device generating the content is online or not. If the device is offline, it performs offline processing and waits until it returns to the online state. If the device is online, the rating unit 12 determines whether location information, temperature data, and indoor / outdoor determination results have been acquired by the acquisition unit 11. If it is difficult to evaluate the rating because any of the data has not been acquired, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 0 to aspect 11. If all the data has been acquired, the rating unit 12 acquires weather data from an external server using the location information as a key. Then, the rating unit 12 calculates the temperature by correcting the weather data based on the indoor / outdoor determination results and evaluates the consistency with the value of the terminal's temperature sensor. For example, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating of 5 to aspect 11 if the difference between the calculated temperature and the device's temperature data is less than or equal to a predetermined threshold, and assigns a rating of 2 to aspect 11 if it is greater than the threshold.

[0054] The output unit 13 outputs the rating results assigned by the rating unit 12 for each perspective. In this embodiment, the output unit 13 outputs the total number of perspectives for each rating as the rating result. For example, the output unit 13 aggregates the rating results for each perspective assigned by the rating unit 12 for each rating and displays them on the display unit 14 (display device) so that the total number of perspectives to which each rating has been assigned can be understood. Figure 4 shows an example of the rating results output by the output unit 13. The content of the rating results displayed on the display unit 14 may be presented in a way that allows each rating and its aggregated result to be viewed at a glance, as shown in Figure 4. In Figure 4, each rating is shown as a "check result," and the aggregated result for each rating is shown as a "total." The presence or absence of an alert for each rating is also indicated.

[0055] The example in Figure 4 shows that there are five viewpoints assigned a rating of 7, five viewpoints assigned a rating of 6, and two viewpoints assigned a rating of 5. It also shows that one of the viewpoints assigned a rating of 6 and one of the viewpoints assigned a rating of 5 contain errors. In the example shown, it is pointed out that there is insufficient data in the viewpoint corresponding to "Where." For example, in a case where the validity of the first location information is to be determined using multiple second location information, an error due to insufficient data may be pointed out if some of the second location information could not be obtained. In addition, it is pointed out that there is a mismatch error in the viewpoint corresponding to "Cross." For example, in a case where the data being compared could be perfectly identical, an error due to mismatch may be pointed out if the data are not perfectly identical but are judged to be sufficiently consistent based on reasonable judgment criteria. "Cross" refers to viewpoints where the metadata being compared are different from each other.

[0056] The output unit 13 may output detailed rating information and error information to the display unit 14 when the user selects an aggregate result displayed on the display unit 14. If the display unit 14 is configured as a touchscreen, the user may select an aggregate result by tapping the screen. For example, tapping the number in the "Total" column may display detailed information for the corresponding aspect. Alternatively, tapping the "Alerts" column may display detailed error information. For example, the detailed information or error information for aspect 1 may consist of location information acquired by the content generation device and location information acquired from the NTP server.

[0057] Next, using the flowchart in Figure 5, we will explain the truthfulness determination support method, which is a process (a method of operation performed by the truthfulness determination support device 10) executed by the truthfulness determination support device 10 according to this embodiment. In this process, first, the acquisition unit 11 acquires metadata used for truthfulness rating (step S1). In one example, metadata may be acquired at the time when content is generated by the truthfulness determination support device 10.

[0058] Next, the rating unit 12 assigns a rating to each aspect based on the metadata acquired by the acquisition unit 11 (step S2). Subsequently, the output unit 13 outputs the rating results assigned by the rating unit 12 to the display unit 14 (step S3). The above is the truthfulness determination support method, which is the process performed by the truthfulness determination support device 10 according to this embodiment.

[0059] As described above, the truthfulness determination support device 10, an example of the present disclosure, comprises an acquisition unit 11 that acquires content and multiple types of metadata related to the content; a rating unit 12 that assigns one of a predetermined number of ratings to each of a number of viewpoints (items) for evaluating the truthfulness of the content based on the multiple types of metadata; and an output unit 13 that outputs the rating assignment results from the rating unit 12.

[0060] Furthermore, an example of a truth-of-fact determination support method relating to this disclosure includes the steps of: acquiring content and multiple types of metadata related to the content; assigning one of a predetermined number of ratings to each of a number of items used to evaluate the truth-of-fact nature of the content based on the multiple types of metadata; and outputting the results of the ratings assigned to the number of items.

[0061] When evaluating the truthfulness of content based on multiple perspectives, one possible approach is to present users with an overall score calculated from the evaluation results of all perspectives. However, since each perspective has a different significance, the importance of each perspective may differ from user to user. For example, even when evaluating the truthfulness of the same content, one user might prioritize location information, while another might prioritize time information. In this case, if the evaluation results of each perspective are reflected in the overall score based on a fixed standard, there is a risk that the score will deviate from the evaluation criteria desired by the user. Furthermore, if there are many perspectives to evaluate truthfulness, the contribution rate of each perspective to the overall score may decrease, potentially resulting in a score that is not useful.

[0062] In the truthfulness judgment support device 10 of this disclosure, instead of presenting an overall score, the rating unit 12 outputs the results of ratings assigned to multiple perspectives. Therefore, users can use the assigned ratings as a reference to judge the truthfulness of content from multiple perspectives, from various angles, and with a focus on their own unique perspectives. Furthermore, since an overall score is not calculated, there is no drawback such as a decrease in the contribution rate of each perspective when there are many perspectives. As described above, the above device and method can appropriately support users in judging the truthfulness of content.

[0063] This disclosure does not negate the possibility that the truthfulness determination support device 10 may set a comprehensive evaluation axis for each user with a certain degree of freedom. For example, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may allow each user to set which aspects they prioritize and which they do not, and may output a comprehensive judgment result by weighting the rating results of each aspect based on the set content. Furthermore, the user may be able to freely set the weighting of the rating results for each aspect. For example, if a user prioritizes the aspect related to "Where," even if the rating results for other aspects are high, the device may output a judgment result that denies truthfulness as an overall evaluation.

[0064] In one example, multiple ratings may have a unified evaluation standard across multiple items. For instance, if a rating of 6 is assigned to either criterion 1 or criterion 2, it means that the same kind of consistency has been affirmed by a definitive judgment. This structure makes it difficult for superiority or inferiority in evaluation to arise between different criterions. In other words, bias in evaluation between criterions is suppressed.

[0065] In one example, the output unit 13 may output the total number of perspectives assigned to each of the multiple ratings. With this configuration, the overall trend of the assigned ratings can be easily recognized.

[0066] In one example, the truthfulness judgment support device 10 may include a display unit 14 that displays the rating assignment results output by the output unit 13. In this configuration, the rating assignment results are visually presented by the display unit 14, allowing the user to easily understand the rating assignment results.

[0067] In one example, the rating unit 12 may rate a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm more highly than a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on an analogical algorithm. This configuration allows for a more reliable rating overall.

[0068] In one example, each of the multiple types of metadata may be classified as either analogical data or definitive data. The rating unit 12 may rate a judgment result affirming truthfulness based on definitive data more highly than a judgment result affirming truthfulness based on analogical data. This configuration allows for a more reliable rating overall.

[0069] In one example, each of the multiple types of metadata may be classified as either analogical data or deterministic data. The rating unit 12 may rate a deterministic judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm and deterministic data more highly than an analogical judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on at least one of the analogical algorithm and the analogical data. This configuration allows for a more reliable rating overall.

[0070] In one example, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may include a measurement unit 15 that acquires physical quantities. The acquisition unit 11 may acquire the physical quantities acquired by the measurement unit 15 at the time of content generation as one of several types of metadata. This configuration allows for a more multifaceted evaluation of truthfulness.

[0071] In one example, the acquisition unit 11 may acquire external data from an external server to verify the physical quantity. Multiple perspectives may include at least one perspective corresponding to the physical quantity. The rating unit 12 may assign a rating to at least one perspective based on the comparison result between the physical quantity and the external data. In this configuration, the truthfulness of the physical quantity can be appropriately confirmed by verifying the consistency between the physical quantity and the external data.

[0072] The criteria for rating truthfulness are not limited to the examples described above. For example, if the content is an image, a rating may be assigned based on the consistency between the time estimated from the image and the first time information obtained by the device that generates the content. If consistency is affirmed from this perspective, a rating of 4 may be assigned. The information regarding the time estimated from the image may be linked to the image as metadata. The process of estimating the time from the image may be performed by the truthfulness judgment support device or by an external server.

[0073] Furthermore, if the device that generates the content has a measurement unit 15, there is a risk that the physical quantities measured by the measurement unit 15 may be tampered with. Therefore, a rating may be assigned from the perspective of whether the physical quantities measured by the measurement unit 15 are normal or not (whether or not values ​​that would not be possible in a normal environment are being measured). If such a perspective is affirmed, a rating of 3 may be assigned.

[0074] Furthermore, while examples of biometric authentication and PIN codes being used as person-related data have been shown, the examples are not limited to these. For example, if a truth-finding support device can authenticate a unique identifier that identifies the user, such an identifier may be used as person-related data. For example, such an identifier may be a personal identification number issued by a public institution.

[0075] The apparatus and method of the present disclosure have the following configurations: [1] an apparatus comprising: an acquisition unit that acquires content and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content; a rating unit that assigns one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of items for evaluating the truthfulness of the content based on the plurality of types of metadata; and an output unit that outputs the rating assignment results by the rating unit. [2] the apparatus according to [1], wherein the plurality of ratings have a unified evaluation standard among the plurality of items. [3] the apparatus according to [1] or [2], wherein the output unit outputs the total number of items assigned to each of the plurality of ratings. [4] the apparatus according to [3], further comprising a display unit that displays the rating results output by the output unit. [5] the apparatus according to any one of [1] to [4], wherein the rating unit values ​​a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm more highly than a judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on an analogical algorithm. [6] The apparatus according to any one of [1] to [5], wherein each of the plurality of types of metadata is classified into either analogical data or deterministic data, and the rating unit values ​​a judgment result affirming truthfulness based on deterministic data more highly than a judgment result affirming truthfulness based on analogical data. [7] The apparatus according to any one of [1] to [6], wherein each of the plurality of types of metadata is classified into either analogical data or deterministic data, and the rating unit values ​​a deterministic judgment result affirming truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm and deterministic data more highly than an analogical judgment result affirming truthfulness based on at least one of an analogical algorithm and analogical data. [8] The apparatus according to any one of [1] to [7], further comprising a measurement unit for acquiring physical quantities, wherein the acquisition unit acquires the physical quantities acquired by the measurement unit at the timing of content generation as one of the plurality of types of metadata.[9] The apparatus according to [8], wherein the acquisition unit acquires external data for verifying the physical quantity from an external server, the plurality of items include at least one item corresponding to the physical quantity, and the rating unit assigns a rating to the at least one item based on the result of comparing the physical quantity with the external data.

[10] A method comprising the steps of acquiring content and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content, assigning one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of items for evaluating the truthfulness of the content based on the plurality of types of metadata, and outputting the result of assigning ratings to the plurality of items.

[0076] The block diagrams used in the description of the above embodiments show functional units. These functional blocks (components) are realized by any combination of at least one of hardware and software. Furthermore, the method of realizing each functional block is not particularly limited. That is, each functional block may be realized using one device that is physically or logically coupled, or it may be realized using two or more physically or logically separated devices that are directly or indirectly connected (for example, using wired or wireless connections). A functional block may also be realized by combining software with the one or more of the above devices.

[0077] Functions include, but are not limited to, judgment, decision, determination, calculation, calculation, processing, derivation, investigation, exploration, confirmation, reception, transmission, output, access, resolution, selection, selection, establishment, comparison, assumption, expectation, assumption, broadcasting, notifying, communicating, forwarding, configuring, reconfiguring, allocating (mapping), and assigning. For example, a functional block (configuration part) that enables transmission is called a transmitting unit or transmitter. In all cases, as mentioned above, the method of implementation is not particularly limited.

[0078] For example, the truthfulness determination support device 10 in one embodiment of the present disclosure may function as a computer that performs information processing according to the present disclosure. Figure 6 is a diagram showing an example of the hardware configuration of the truthfulness determination support device 10 according to one embodiment of the present disclosure. The truthfulness determination support device 10 described above may be physically configured as a computer device including a processor 1001, memory 1002, storage 1003, communication device 1004, input device 1005, output device 1006, bus 1007, etc.

[0079] In the following explanation, the term "device" can be replaced with "circuit," "device," "unit," etc. The hardware configuration of the truthfulness determination support device 10 may include one or more of the devices shown in the figure, or it may be configured to omit some of the devices.

[0080] Each function in the truthfulness determination support device 10 is realized by loading predetermined software (programs) onto hardware such as the processor 1001 and memory 1002, which causes the processor 1001 to perform calculations, control communication by the communication device 1004, and control at least one of the reading and writing of data in the memory 1002 and storage 1003.

[0081] The processor 1001 controls the entire computer, for example, by running the operating system. The processor 1001 may be composed of a central processing unit (CPU) that includes interfaces with peripheral devices, control devices, arithmetic units, registers, etc. For example, each function in the truthfulness determination support device 10 described above may be implemented by the processor 1001.

[0082] Furthermore, the processor 1001 reads programs (program code), software modules, data, etc., from at least one of the storage 1003 and the communication device 1004 into the memory 1002 and executes various processes accordingly. The program used is one that causes the computer to execute at least a part of the operations described in the above embodiment. For example, each function of the truthfulness determination support device 10 may be implemented by a control program stored in the memory 1002 and operated on the processor 1001. Although the above-described processes have been explained as being executed by one processor 1001, they may be executed simultaneously or sequentially by two or more processors 1001. The processor 1001 may be implemented by one or more chips. The program may also be transmitted from a network via a telecommunications line.

[0083] The memory 1002 is a computer-readable recording medium and may consist of at least one of the following: ROM (Read Only Memory), EPROM (Erasable Programmable ROM), EEPROM (Electrically Erasable Programmable ROM), RAM (Random Access Memory), etc. The memory 1002 may also be called a register, cache, main memory, etc. The memory 1002 can store executable programs (program code), software modules, etc., for carrying out information processing according to one embodiment of the present disclosure.

[0084] The storage 1003 is a computer-readable recording medium and may consist of at least one of the following: an optical disc such as a CD-ROM (Compact Disc ROM), a hard disk drive, a flexible disk, a magneto-optical disk (e.g., a compact disk, a digital multipurpose disk, a Blu-ray® disc), a smart card, flash memory (e.g., a card, a stick, a key drive), a floppy® disk, a magnetic strip, etc. The storage 1003 may also be called an auxiliary storage device. The storage medium provided by the truthfulness determination support device 10 may be, for example, a database, server, or other suitable medium including at least one of the memory 1002 and the storage 1003.

[0085] The communication device 1004 is hardware (transceiver / receiver device) for communicating between computers via at least one of a wired network and a wireless network, and is also referred to as a network device, network controller, network card, communication module, etc.

[0086] The input device 1005 is an input device that accepts input from an external source (e.g., a keyboard, mouse, microphone, switch, button, sensor, etc.). The output device 1006 is an output device that outputs to an external source (e.g., a display, speaker, LED lamp, etc.). The input device 1005 and the output device 1006 may be configured as an integrated unit (e.g., a touch panel).

[0087] Furthermore, each device, such as the processor 1001 and memory 1002, is connected by a bus 1007 for communicating information. The bus 1007 may be configured using a single bus, or different buses may be configured for each device.

[0088] Furthermore, the truthfulness determination support device 10 may be configured to include hardware such as a microprocessor, a digital signal processor (DSP), an ASIC (Application Specific Integrated Circuit), a PLD (Programmable Logic Device), and an FPGA (Field Programmable Gate Array), and some or all of each functional block may be realized by such hardware. For example, the processor 1001 may be implemented using at least one of these hardware components.

[0089] The processing procedures, sequences, flowcharts, etc., of each aspect / embodiment described in this disclosure may be reordered, provided they do not contradict each other. For example, the methods described in this disclosure present various step elements using exemplary order and are not limited to the specific order presented.

[0090] Input and output information may be stored in a specific location (e.g., memory) or managed using a management table. Input and output information may be overwritten, updated, or appended to. Output information may be deleted. Input information may be transmitted to other devices.

[0091] The determination may be made by a value represented by one bit (0 or 1), by a boolean value (true or false), or by a numerical comparison (for example, by comparing with a predetermined value).

[0092] Each aspect / embodiment described in this disclosure may be used individually, in combination, or switched between as needed during implementation. Furthermore, notification of specific information (e.g., notification that "X is") is not limited to explicit notification, but may also be implicit (e.g., by not providing such notification).

[0093] Although the present disclosure has been described in detail above, it will be clear to those skilled in the art that the present disclosure is not limited to the embodiments described herein. The present disclosure can be implemented in modified and altered forms without departing from the intent and scope of the present disclosure as defined by the claims. Therefore, the descriptions in the present disclosure are illustrative and not intended to be restrictive in any way.

[0094] Software should be broadly interpreted to mean instructions, instruction sets, code, code segments, program code, programs, subprograms, software modules, applications, software applications, software packages, routines, subroutines, objects, executable files, execution threads, procedures, functions, and so on, whether they are called software, firmware, middleware, microcode, hardware description languages, or by any other name.

[0095] Furthermore, software, instructions, information, etc., may be transmitted and received via a transmission medium. For example, if software is transmitted from a website, server, or other remote source using at least one of wired technology (such as coaxial cable, fiber optic cable, twisted pair, or digital subscriber line (DSL)) and wireless technology (such as infrared or microwave), then at least one of these wired and wireless technologies is included in the definition of a transmission medium.

[0096] The terms “system” and “network” as used in this disclosure are interchangeable.

[0097] Furthermore, the information, parameters, etc., described in this disclosure may be expressed using absolute values, relative values ​​from a predetermined value, or corresponding other information.

[0098] As used in this disclosure, the terms “determining” and “determining” may encompass a wide variety of actions. “Determining” may include, for example, judging, calculating, computing, processing, deriving, investigating, looking up, searching, or inquiring (e.g., searching in a table, database, or other data structure), or ascertaining. “Determining” may also include receiving (e.g., receiving information), transmitting (e.g., sending information), inputting, outputting, or accessing (e.g., accessing data in memory). Furthermore, "judgment" and "decision" can include considering something as having been "judged" or "decided" after resolving, selecting, choosing, establishing, comparing, etc. In other words, "judgment" and "decision" can include considering something as having been "judged" or "decided" after some action. Also, "judgment (decision)" can be reinterpreted as "assuming," "expecting," or "considering."

[0099] The terms “connected,” “coupled,” or any variation thereof, mean any direct or indirect connection or coupling between two or more elements, and may include the presence of one or more intermediate elements between two elements that are “connected” or “coupled” with each other. The coupling or connection between elements may be physical, logical, or a combination thereof. For example, “connection” may be reinterpreted as “access.” As used in this disclosure, two elements may be considered to be “connected” or “coupled” with each other using at least one of one or more wires, cables, and printed electrical connections, and, in some non-limiting and non-exclusive examples, electromagnetic energy having wavelengths in the radio frequency domain, microwave domain, and optical (both visible and invisible) domain.

[0100] In this disclosure, the phrase "based on" does not mean "based solely on" unless otherwise specified. In other words, the phrase "based on" means both "based solely on" and "based at least on."

[0101] Any reference to elements using the designations “first,” “second,” etc., as used in this disclosure does not generally limit the quantity or order of those elements. These designations may be used in this disclosure as a convenient way to distinguish between two or more elements. Accordingly, references to the first and second elements do not imply that only two elements may be employed, or that the first element must precede the second element in any way.

[0102] Where the terms “include,” “including,” and variations thereof are used in this disclosure, these terms are intended to be inclusive, as is the term “comprising.” Furthermore, the term “or” as used in this disclosure is not intended to mean exclusive OR.

[0103] In this disclosure, if articles are added through translation, such as a, an, and the in English, this disclosure may include the fact that the noun following these articles is plural.

[0104] In this disclosure, the term "A and B are different" may mean "A and B are different from each other." The term may also mean "A and B are each different from C." Terms such as "separate" and "combine" may be interpreted similarly to "different."

[0105] 10... Truthfulness determination support device, 11... Acquisition unit, 12... Rating unit, 13... Output unit, 14... Display unit, 15... Measurement unit (sensor), 1001... Processor, 1002... Memory, 1003... Storage, 1004... Communication device, 1005... Input device, 1006... Output device, 1007... Bus.

Claims

1. An apparatus comprising: an acquisition unit that acquires content and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content; a rating unit that assigns one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of items for evaluating the truthfulness of the content based on the plurality of types of metadata; and an output unit that outputs the rating results from the rating unit.

2. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the plurality of ratings have a unified evaluation standard for the plurality of items.

3. The apparatus according to claim 2, wherein the output unit outputs the total number of items assigned to each of the plurality of ratings.

4. The apparatus according to claim 3, further comprising a display unit for displaying the rating result output by the output unit.

5. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein the rating unit evaluates the judgment result affirming the truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm more highly than the judgment result affirming the truthfulness based on an analogical algorithm.

6. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein each of the plurality of types of metadata is classified as either analogical data or deterministic data, and the rating unit evaluates the judgment result affirming truthfulness based on the deterministic data more highly than the judgment result affirming truthfulness based on the analogical data.

7. The apparatus according to claim 1, wherein each of the plurality of types of metadata is classified as either analogical data or deterministic data, and the rating unit values ​​a deterministic judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on a deterministic algorithm and deterministic data more highly than an analogical judgment result that affirms truthfulness based on at least one of the analogical algorithm and the analogical data.

8. The apparatus according to claim 1, further comprising a measurement unit for acquiring physical quantities, wherein the acquisition unit acquires the physical quantities acquired by the measurement unit as one of the plurality of types of metadata at the timing of content generation.

9. The apparatus according to claim 8, wherein the acquisition unit acquires external data for verifying the physical quantity from an external server, the plurality of items include at least one item corresponding to the physical quantity, and the rating unit assigns a rating to the at least one item based on the comparison result between the physical quantity and the external data.

10. A method comprising: acquiring content and a plurality of types of metadata related to the content; assigning one of a plurality of predetermined ratings to each of a plurality of items for evaluating the truthfulness of the content based on the plurality of types of metadata; and outputting the results of assigning ratings to the plurality of items.