A method and system for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants

By screening and modeling the analysis of the planned outage operation projects of the nuclear power plant, establishing a network diagram and solving the critical path, the complexity and uncertainty of the evaluation of the planned outage time of the nuclear power plant is solved, and the accuracy of the planned outage time is achieved. Evaluate.

CN112070335BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-19CHINA NUCLEAR POWER ENGINEERING CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202010684935.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2020-07-16
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2040-07-16

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing technology is difficult to accurately evaluate the planned downtime of a nuclear power plant, resulting in complex assessments and high uncertainty, affecting the calculation of the availability of a nuclear power plant.

Method used

采用筛选、模型化分析和网络图建模的方法,筛选运行必要性和安全相关的操作项目,进行分层简化和分类,建立网络图并求解关键路径,计算评估计划停运时间。

Benefits of technology

By finding the critical path with the longest time and the strongest logical causal relationship in the system, accurately grasp the planned downtime, reduce the complexity and uncertainty of the evaluation, and improve the evaluation accuracy.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112070335B_ABST
    Figure CN112070335B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention discloses a method and system for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, the method comprising: screening evaluation items according to preset requirements; analyzing each evaluation item; establishing a network diagram and solving critical paths and calculating evaluations according to the analysis results. The system comprises: a screening module, screening evaluation items according to preset requirements; an analysis module, analyzing each evaluation item; an evaluation module, establishing a network diagram and solving critical paths and calculating evaluations according to the analysis results. The beneficial effect of the present invention is that the present invention can find a critical path with the longest time consumption and logical causal relationship from a complex system with high uncertainty by screening, analyzing and establishing a network diagram for the items of planned outages, and grasping the time of the critical path means grasping the time of the planned outage.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the field of nuclear power, and in particular relates to a method and system for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant. Background Art

[0002] The availability of a nuclear power plant reflects the proportion of time that a nuclear power plant can generate electricity each year. The factors that affect the availability of a nuclear power plant include the following two parts of non-generation time: unplanned outage time and planned outage time.

[0003] Planned outages are long and account for the largest part of the annualized unavailability of nuclear power plants. In order to evaluate the economic indicators of nuclear power plants, it is necessary to calculate the unavailability of planned outages as accurately as possible. This process is used to evaluate the availability and reliability of the overall technical scheme and technical level of nuclear power plants during the design phase of nuclear power plants, rather than based on practical experience data from operating nuclear power plants.

[0004] The typical planned outage of a nuclear power plant is a refueling outage, which adds a large number of operations to ensure the special operating functions of refueling and maintenance, as well as regular tests and preventive maintenance projects to ensure the nuclear safety of the unit, based on the normal necessary operations of raising and lowering power, temperature, pressure, and refueling. The main characteristics of planned outages are the large number of project types and complex logical relationships; thousands and tens of thousands of tasks are required to be completed within a certain period of time, and these tasks also have mutual influence relationships, which are difficult to calculate through simple mathematical processes. Therefore, evaluating the complete time of a planned outage will be a very complicated process.

[0005] In addition to the conditions of many items and complex logic, there are also a large number of uncertain factors in the material replacement overhaul. The uncertain factors mainly include the handling after the test fails, the large differences in some operation times due to the operating proficiency of personnel, and other operation time uncertainties caused by system uncertainties.

[0006] In view of this, the present invention is proposed. Summary of the invention

[0007] In view of the defects existing in the prior art, the purpose of the present invention is to provide a method and system for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant, which can effectively evaluate the planned outage of a nuclear power plant and calculate its availability.

[0008] The technical solution of the present invention is:

[0009] A method for assessing the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant, comprising:

[0010] Screening of assessment items based on preset requirements;

[0011] Conduct model analysis on each assessment project;

[0012] Based on the analysis results, a network diagram is created and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated.

[0013] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant, the evaluation items screened according to preset requirements include operation necessity operation items and safety-related operation items.

[0014] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for assessing the availability of planned outage of a nuclear power plant, the operation necessity operation items include:

[0015] Operation items related to system operation functions;

[0016] The non-safety functions of the system are related to the operation of the unit in non-power operation mode and the state transition process and are necessary conditions for the normal operation of the unit or are beneficial to shortening the process.

[0017] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for evaluating the availability of planned outage of a nuclear power plant, the screening of evaluation items according to preset requirements includes:

[0018] Screening of necessary operation items;

[0019] Screening of safety-related operational items;

[0020] Simplify the selected items in layers;

[0021] Categorize the hierarchically simplified items.

[0022] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for assessing the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, the hierarchical simplification of the screened items includes:

[0023] The screened items are stratified; if an item exists in the lower part as an implementation condition of other items, the item is deleted in the higher part.

[0024] Furthermore, the above-mentioned method for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant classifies the projects after hierarchical simplification into: framework projects, branch line projects and special projects; the framework projects are projects that directly change the status of the unit; the branch line projects are projects that do not change but need to maintain the status of the unit; the special projects are projects that start and end across multiple operating states.

[0025] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, the analysis of each evaluation item includes performing a logic analysis on the evaluation item and a time attribute analysis on the evaluation item.

[0026] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned method for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, when establishing a network diagram based on the analysis results and solving the critical path and calculating the evaluation, if an item of a non-final node lacks input or output, the item is deleted.

[0027] Accordingly, the present invention also provides a system for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, comprising:

[0028] Screening module, which screens assessment items according to preset requirements;

[0029] The analysis module conducts model analysis on each assessment project;

[0030] The evaluation module builds a network diagram based on the analysis results and solves the critical path and calculates the evaluation.

[0031] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned evaluation system for the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant, the screening and evaluation items according to the preset requirements include operation necessity operation items and safety-related operation items;

[0032] The screening and evaluation items according to the preset requirements include:

[0033] Screening of necessary operation items;

[0034] Screening of safety-related operational items;

[0035] Simplify the selected items in layers;

[0036] Categorize the hierarchically simplified items.

[0037] Furthermore, in the above-mentioned evaluation system for the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant, when the network diagram is established based on the analysis results and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated, if an item of a non-final node lacks input or output, the item is deleted.

[0038] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:

[0039] The present invention can find a critical path with the longest time consumption and logical cause and effect relationship from a complex system with high uncertainty by screening, analyzing and establishing a network diagram for the projects of planned shutdown. Grasping the time of the critical path means grasping the time of planned shutdown. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0040] Figure 1 The present invention is a flowchart of a method for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant.

[0041] Figure 2 A block diagram of a system for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant according to the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0042] The following is an introduction to an embodiment of a method for manufacturing a test piece of the present invention in conjunction with the accompanying drawings:

[0043] According to the inventor's research, the critical path solving process for planned outages is a process of highly summarizing and sorting out the project time information and logic information. For this reason, the model established should be able to fully and accurately express these two important attributes. Therefore, the present invention adopts the form of a network diagram as a modeling and evaluation method for planned outage time.

[0044] like Figure 1 As shown, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the planned outage availability of a nuclear power plant, comprising:

[0045] S100 screens and evaluates projects based on preset requirements;

[0046] S200 conducts model analysis on each assessment item;

[0047] S300 builds a network diagram based on the analysis results and solves the critical path and calculates the evaluation.

[0048] In this embodiment, the screening and evaluation items according to the preset requirements include operation necessity operation items and safety-related operation items.

[0049] The operation necessity operation items include: operation items related to the system operation functions; operation items in the system non-safety functions that are related to the operation of the unit in non-power operation mode and the state transition process and are necessary conditions for the normal operation of the unit or are beneficial to shortening the process.

[0050] The safety-related operational items are necessary conditions for ensuring the safety of the unit, including operational items with clear requirements in the operational safety management document system, and non-operating items with clear safety-related guidance documents such as periodic test supervision requirements or preventive maintenance outlines.

[0051] The operation items selected in this embodiment are the items that must be executed during the planned outage process. Their necessity is that there are clear requirements in the safety operation documents of the nuclear power plant to ensure the necessary measures to be taken to ensure safety, or the operation items taken to ensure the smooth or more efficient execution of the normal process of the refueling overhaul. Other operation items are not considered, so that the project selection can be guaranteed to meet the requirements of the availability assessment and the analysis items can be minimized.

[0052] In this embodiment, screening evaluation items according to preset requirements includes:

[0053] S101 Screening of necessary operation items;

[0054] S102 Screening of safety-related operational items;

[0055] S103 simplifies the selected items in layers;

[0056] S104 classifies the hierarchically simplified items.

[0057] The order of S101 and S102 can be swapped.

[0058] The purpose of layering and simplifying the selected projects is to include work projects with similar goals and similar execution in the description of a higher level, so that the analysis objects can be further reduced. In this embodiment, different types of projects can be divided into 2-3 levels or even more levels for evaluation. Specifically, the selected projects are layered; if a project exists in the lower part as an implementation condition of other projects, the project is deleted in the higher part.

[0059] The purpose of classifying the selected projects is to enable the projects to be implemented in a targeted manner according to their characteristics in the modeling analysis, model establishment and model building procedures, and to make the model more accurate. Projects are divided into three types: framework projects (projects that directly change the unit status), branch line projects (projects that do not change but need to maintain the unit status), and special projects (projects start and end across multiple operating states). Among them, framework projects should be built first, and their content constitutes the main framework of the planned outage process; branch line projects should be added as supplementary projects after the completion of the framework project construction, and their content serves as a branch of the main framework; special projects refer to projects that span multiple unit states, and such projects can modify the local content of the model.

[0060] In a specific implementation process of the present invention, the power plant mode conversion required by the planned shutdown is "de-coupling" -> "subcritical" -> "evaporator heat conduction cooling and pressure reduction" -> "residual exhaust system heat conduction cooling and pressure reduction" -> "cold shutdown" -> "refueling" -> "cold shutdown" -> "residual exhaust heat conduction temperature increase and pressure increase" -> "evaporator heat conduction temperature increase and pressure increase" -> "critical" -> "rushing and grid connection" as the basic process, and all relevant systems of the power plant are functionally decomposed, and the necessity of each function and configuration to maintain the unit status or the unit status conversion process or optimize the planned shutdown process is analyzed. For the safety demand analysis part, the operating technical specifications including chemical specifications, safety-related system periodic test supervision requirements and physical test requirements, and in-service inspection outline are used as requirement documents, and the required contents are used as analysis boundaries. The system function analysis is performed on the system and chemical requirements specified in the operating technical specifications, and the system operation items required by safety are determined.

[0061] Different classification forms are adopted for operation, periodic testing and preventive maintenance. From low to high, operation is divided into equipment operation, system operation and target operation; periodic testing is divided into two levels: equipment / function testing and system testing; preventive maintenance is divided into three levels: maintenance items, equipment, isolation windows or main isolation windows. If a low-level item is used as an implementation condition for other items, it should not be divided into a high-level item to ensure that the simplification of the number of items does not deviate from reality.

[0062] The analyzing of each evaluation item includes performing logic analysis on the evaluation item and performing time attribute analysis on the evaluation item.

[0063] In terms of logical analysis, for each project, the implementation conditions of the project (including the requirements for other auxiliary systems in terms of cold source, heat source, electrical system, working medium, etc.), the operating project boundaries and isolation status, the unit status requirements, and the safety requirements for the project are analyzed in sequence according to the process sequence. At the same time, it is also analyzed whether the project meets the conditions of other projects, so as to determine the complete logical relationship from both positive and negative aspects.

[0064] The modeling of time information is carried out in different ways for different types of projects. For projects with typical shortening of time as the operator becomes more proficient in behavior, learning curves or standard work are used for modeling; for projects with clear positive and negative behaviors such as test projects, probability is used to express them, and a certain amount of additional time is superimposed; for projects such as maintenance projects and test projects, standardization or probability distribution such as normal distribution is used to describe the time content; for projects with obvious random effects, a certain probability distribution is used to describe them. The above time information also needs to be determined based on the statistics of practical data in operating power plants and the results of processing and analysis.

[0065] In the network diagram, a point represents a unit status point or the start of a project, and a line represents a directed logical relationship and the time information of the project. When establishing a network diagram based on the analysis results, solving the critical path, and calculating the evaluation, if a non-final node project lacks input or output, the project is deleted. After sampling the probability distribution using the Monte Carlo method, the critical path can be solved using a computer solution method based on graph theory, and the value after statistical processing is the evaluation value of the planned outage availability.

[0066] Accordingly, if Figure 2 As shown, the present invention also provides a system for evaluating the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants, comprising:

[0067] Screening module 100, screening evaluation items according to preset requirements;

[0068] The analysis module 200 performs model analysis on each evaluation item;

[0069] The evaluation module 300 establishes a network diagram based on the analysis results and solves the critical path and calculates the evaluation.

[0070] The screening of evaluation items according to preset requirements includes operation items of operational necessity and operation items related to safety; the screening of evaluation items according to preset requirements includes: screening operation items of operational necessity; screening operation items related to safety; layering and simplifying the screened items; and classifying the layered and simplified items.

[0071] When the network diagram is established according to the analysis results and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated, if an item of a non-final node lacks input or output, the item is deleted.

[0072] The technical solution of the present invention screens out a complete and minimized project scope, and has the following advantages: 1. The screening results are based on the decomposition and sorting of operation and safety requirements, the analysis process is clear, and the operation can be streamlined, so the screening results can be guaranteed to be complete and accurate; 2. The screening results are based on the minimum operation and minimum safety requirements, and the screening results obtained by this process are the minimum project set; 3. The hierarchical method is adopted to minimize the number of model nodes and simplify the evaluation process; 4. The screened projects are completely based on the design perspective, which meets the requirements of overall parameters based on design.

[0073] At the same time, the present invention fully considers the influence of uncertainty factors and random factors, and the analysis object conforms to the actual process; the time information is expressed in mathematical form using probabilistic methods or standardized methods, which can effectively provide a basis for considering its content in the model, which conforms to the statistical properties of the research object.

[0074] Furthermore, the present invention adopts the network diagram form, which has the following advantages:

[0075] 1. It can intuitively display all the content and processes of the complete planned outage, and accurately express the project logic and project execution time;

[0076] 2. The network diagram has a relatively mature mathematical solution method for the critical path or computer solution capability;

[0077] 3. There are relatively simple solutions to random and probabilistic problems;

[0078] 4. The network diagram format provides a platform for deeper analysis of planned outages.

[0079] Obviously, those skilled in the art can make various changes and modifications to the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Thus, if these modifications and variations of the present invention fall within the scope of the claims of the present invention and their equivalents, the present invention is also intended to include these changes and variations. The above-mentioned embodiments are merely illustrative of the present invention, and the present invention may also be implemented in other specific ways or other specific forms without departing from the gist or essential features of the present invention. Therefore, the described embodiments should be considered illustrative rather than restrictive in any respect. The scope of the present invention shall be described by the appended claims, and any changes equivalent to the intent and scope of the claims shall also be included within the scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A method for assessing the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants. It is characterized in that include: Screening of assessment items based on pre-set requirements, including: Screening of necessary operation items; Screening of safety-related operational items; Simplify the selected items in layers; Classify the hierarchically simplified items; Modeling analysis is performed on each assessment item, including logic analysis and time attribute analysis of the assessment item; the logic analysis includes: analyzing the implementation conditions, operation item boundaries and isolation status, unit status requirements and safety requirements of each item in accordance with the process sequence, and analyzing whether the item is used as a condition for other items, and determining the complete logical relationship from both positive and negative aspects; the time attribute analysis includes: modeling time information for different types of items in different ways, using learning curves or standard work to model projects with shortened time as the operator becomes more proficient; for projects with positive and negative behaviors, using probability to express and superimposing additional time; for maintenance items and test items, using standardization or probability distribution to describe time content; for projects with random effects, using probability distribution to describe; Based on the analysis results, a network diagram is established and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated. In the network diagram, points represent unit status points or project starts, and lines represent directed logical relationships and project time information.

2. The method for evaluating the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant according to claim 1, Features: The necessary operation items include: Operation items related to system operation functions; The non-safety functions of the system are related to the operation of the unit in non-power operation mode and the state transition process and are necessary conditions for the normal operation of the unit or are beneficial to shortening the process.

3. The method for evaluating the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant according to claim 1, Features: The hierarchical simplification of the screened items includes: The screened items are stratified; if an item exists in the lower part as an implementation condition of other items, the item is deleted in the higher part.

4. The method for evaluating the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant according to claim 1, Features: The classification of the projects after hierarchical simplification includes: framework projects, branch line projects and special projects; the framework projects are projects that directly change the status of the unit; the branch line projects are projects that do not change but need to maintain the status of the unit; the special projects are projects that start and end across multiple operating states.

5. The method for evaluating the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant according to claim 1, Features: When the network diagram is established according to the analysis results and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated, if an item of a non-final node lacks input or output, the item is deleted.

6. A system for assessing the availability of planned outages of nuclear power plants. It is characterized in that include: Screening module, which screens assessment items according to preset requirements, including: Screening of necessary operation items; Screening of safety-related operational items; Simplify the selected items in layers; Classify the hierarchically simplified items; The analysis module analyzes each evaluation item, including logic analysis and time attribute analysis of the evaluation items. The logic analysis includes: analyzing the implementation conditions, operation item boundaries and isolation status, unit status requirements and safety requirements of each item in accordance with the process sequence, and analyzing whether the item is used as a condition for other items, and determining the complete logical relationship from both positive and negative aspects. The time attribute analysis includes: modeling time information for different types of items in different ways, using learning curves or standard work to model projects with shortened time as the operator becomes more proficient; using probability to express projects with positive and negative behaviors, and superimposing additional time; using standardization or probability distribution to describe time content for maintenance items and test items; using probability distribution to describe projects with random effects; The evaluation module establishes a network diagram based on the analysis results and solves the critical path and calculates the evaluation. In the network diagram, points represent unit status points or project starts, and lines represent directed logical relationships and project time information.

7. The method for evaluating the availability of a planned outage of a nuclear power plant according to claim 6, Features: When the network diagram is established according to the analysis results and the critical path is solved and the evaluation is calculated, if an item of a non-final node lacks input or output, the item is deleted.