Battery Energy Storage Systems

By monitoring the battery SoC and using alternative assets to optimize response, the problem of high cost and slow response in grid balance is solved, and the grid is quickly responded and flexible, reducing battery capacity requirements and costs.

CN112567585BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-05OPEN ENERGI LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN201980055606.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2018-08-24
Filing Date
2019-08-23
Publication Date
2024-11-05
Estimated Expiration
2039-08-23

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

When existing battery systems meet grid balance requirements, they are too expensive and difficult to respond quickly to power imbalances, especially in the environment of renewable energy generation, which is difficult to meet the requirements of FFR and EFR.

Method used

By monitoring the status of the battery -of-charge (SoC), charge and discharge within the optimal range to offset grid imbalance, use alternative assets to provide balance services at SoC critical values, reduce battery capacity requirements, and pass non-battery assets Combined optimized response systems to reduce battery burden.

Benefits of technology

It reduces the capacity requirements and costs of the battery system, extends the battery life, improves the rapid response ability to grid imbalance, and meets the flexibility requirements of FFR and EFR.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN112567585B_ABST
    Figure CN112567585B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A battery energy storage system for providing balancing services to a distribution network is configured to monitor the state of charge (SoC) of a storage battery (26). If the SoC is within an optimal range (48), the balancing service is provided by the battery alone, which is charged and discharged. If the battery SoC drops below a predetermined low threshold value (52), a first non-battery asset is operated to increase the power supplied to the network. Similarly, if the battery SoC rises above a predetermined high threshold value (50), a second non-battery asset is operated to provide balancing services. With this configuration, the energy storage capacity requirements of the battery are reduced. In order for the system to meet the balancing service specification requirements, the battery only needs to maintain the ability to charge or discharge above each threshold value (50, 52) for a period of time that covers the time when each asset reaches operating capacity.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to electrical power distribution networks, a large example of which is managed by the National Grid in England and Wales. In particular, the present invention relates to a battery system arranged to store electrical charge for balancing electricity supply and demand. Background Art

[0002] In any distribution network, it is important to balance the power supplied to the network with the power drawn from it. Any imbalance, even a short-term one, can lead to problems ranging from reduced transmission efficiency, unpredictable fluctuations in power supply to more serious effects such as power blackouts.

[0003] In the UK, electricity supply mainly comes from electricity generated by power stations. Each station informs the grid of how much power it will feed into the network, and the grid supplies a forecast of expected electricity demand. In the first instance, supply and demand are balanced by the grid requesting power stations to generate more or less electricity to match the forecast demand.

[0004] Modern grids are balanced on a second-by-second basis, with far greater complexity than this basic model would suggest. Any imbalance between power generation and power consumption caused by the load on the network manifests itself as a deviation between the operating characteristics of the power supply and its set, expected value. Monitoring such parameters allows imbalances to be detected and corrected accordingly. Most commonly, the frequency of power supplied through the grid is monitored for this purpose. In the UK, mains electricity is supplied at 50Hz. If the total load on the network draws more power than is supplied, the frequency will drop. In broad terms, the effect can be understood as an increase in the load on the generator causing the generator to run (rotate) slower. Conversely, if there is an imbalance due to overgeneration, the frequency will rise above its nominal 50Hz value.

[0005] There are many factors that may cause an imbalance in the power grid. It may be on the supply side, such as a technical problem on a generator, or on the demand side, such as a surge in demand during a televised sporting event. Similarly, corrections can be applied by adjusting the power generated or consumed. To make corrections on the supply side, the network will usually supply it with a backup system of assets (generators) that can be brought online or disconnected from the grid on demand. On the demand side, the network will additionally have a mechanism by which at least the load on the network can be selected at different power levels. The response can be dynamic, working in response to second-by-second changes in the operating frequency, or non-dynamic, usually a discrete service triggered in response to a predetermined frequency deviation. In the UK, suppliers who supply balancing services to the grid network monitor frequency deviations themselves. In other jurisdictions, the network operator will perform its own monitoring and will communicate a signal to the supplier indicating the required balancing service.

[0006] With the shift from 100% coal-fired generation to renewable energy, the task of maintaining predictable supply levels becomes more difficult. Although power plants typically go offline only in relatively unlikely failure scenarios, renewable energy sources are fundamentally less reliable. Wind plants are less productive if the wind is weak; they must also shut down in high winds; solar power output is reduced if clouds appear, and hydroelectric power generation will also depend on the weather. Supply levels, like demand, have therefore become more unpredictable. This has led to an increase in the demand side of the distribution network requiring balancing. Overall, a flexible balancing system that can respond quickly to imbalances is needed.

[0007] Therefore, from a practical point of view, the grid must contain a series of mechanisms for power adjustment. Mandatory frequency response is required for all generators connected to the grid system, and standards are set for the timescale (timescale) in which power adjustment must be made and its minimum duration. Frequency Control by Demand Management (FCDM) is the provision of a network of loads that can be shut down for a set maximum duration to manage large frequency deviations that may occur with the loss of, for example, a significant generator. Fixed Frequency Response (FFR) sets standards in terms of response energy: such assets / loads must operate dynamic and non-dynamic responses and supply at least 1 megawatt (MW) of response energy. Among other embodiments, FFR can be supplied by responsive loads that can operate at reduced power for a short period of time without a significant drop in performance. Response, which is usually aggregated in sub-groups of available responsive loads, helps to balance supply and demand. Sub-groups are selected so that power reduction of individual loads is required only for a limited period of time. Recently, the establishment of a grid function of Enhanced Frequency Response (EFR) has begun. This is a service that can supply a full power adjustment within 1 second (or less) of a recorded frequency deviation. This is in contrast to existing response providers, where assets are required to come online within 10 or 30 seconds of detecting a frequency deviation. Typically, EFR is supplied by assets that store power that can be supplied to the grid at any time, rather than by assets that must be switched on to supply additional power.

[0008] On the surface, the inclusion of batteries in FFR and EFR functionality is attractive. It can store electrical energy that can be quickly supplied in response to frequency deviations from the grid. US2016 / 0099568 describes only this application of energy storage devices such as batteries. However, meeting the requirements of the National Grid in other respects is not so simple. In addition to the required energy storage, FFR activities in the UK also require that batteries have 30 minutes of available energy storage at any given point in time, which can be charged and discharged from the power supply to the National Grid. Depending on the State of Charge (SoC) management technology used, an additional 15 to 30 minutes of energy storage is required to perform the actual frequency regulation activities. The consequences of this requirement are shown in Figure 2. Figure 1. The figure shows the capacity of an exemplary battery to store charge 10. When the battery is used efficiently to supply and extract power, there is an optimal SoC range 12 for operation. That is, the amount of electricity stored in the battery should be kept within defined upper and lower limits at all points in time as far as possible. Ideally, the intended balancing function of this battery supply can be achieved by operating within the optimal SoC range 12. However, FFR requirements stipulate that the battery must have an additional 30 minutes of available time at any point in time before it is disconnected from the grid. This translates into additional storage capacity 14, shown at Figure 1 The battery SoC must always be above level 16 to allow for 30 minutes of power supply.

[0009] As can be seen in the figure, this results in a battery system with an oversized and mostly unused energy storage component. This is a problem because, while batteries have many advantages in balancing services, their cost is primarily determined by the size of the energy storage supplied. As a result, the cost of meeting grid requirements is high, thus discouraging the use of battery storage components in balancing systems supplying FFR.

[0010] To date, prior art grid balancing systems utilizing batteries have focused on the performance of the battery itself. For example, US2016 / 0099568 cited above is concerned with optimizing the performance of a battery as it supplies frequency balancing. This can be achieved by building various protections into the system, such as a Power Absorbing Load, which together ensure that the battery operates within an optimal SoC range and that the charging rate is below a level that could damage the battery. Operation above the optimal SoC increases the rate at which the battery deteriorates due to charging and discharging; operation below it reduces the available power to a point where the battery cannot perform its intended function. Summary of the invention

[0011] There is a need for an alternative system suitable for providing an FFR response that exploits the response speed of a battery but without the costs implied by the battery-enabled systems of the prior art.

[0012] Therefore, the present invention provides a method for balancing a power distribution network, the method comprising:

[0013] (a) directly or indirectly by means of a parameter which is a function of the SoC stored in a battery connected to the network, the battery being adapted to draw power from the network when charging and to add power to the network when discharging,

[0014] (b) responding to a detected imbalance in the network by adding power to the network or extracting power from the network in accordance with:

[0015] (i) if the battery SoC is within an optimal range, charging and discharging the battery to offset the imbalance in the network;

[0016] (ii) if the battery SoC falls below a low threshold, selecting an alternative asset (low) suitable for increasing power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network, and in response to a critical low signal, switching on the alternative asset (low) to provide a balancing service to the network; and

[0017] (iii) if the battery SoC rises above a high threshold, selecting an alternative asset (high) suitable for extracting power from the network relative to power supplied to the network, and in response to a critical high signal, switching on the alternative high asset to provide a balancing service to the network;

[0018] wherein the low threshold is determined so that, after a low critical signal is generated, the battery remains dischargeable for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected low asset (asset (low)) to reach its operating capacity; and

[0019] The high threshold is determined such that, after a high critical signal is generated, the battery remains able to charge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected high asset (high) to reach its operating capacity.

[0020] In a second aspect, the present invention provides a system for providing balancing services to a power distribution network connected thereto, the system comprising:

[0021] A battery having a detector adapted to directly or indirectly monitor the state of charge (SoC) of the battery;

[0022] at least one non-battery low asset adapted to increase power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network;

[0023] at least one non-battery high asset adapted to increase the power drawn from the network relative to the power supplied to the network; and

[0024] a central controller adapted to respond to an imbalance detected in the network to receive information from the SoC detector and generate signals for controlling the operation of the battery and the asset; characterized in that

[0025] The central controller is further configured to respond to imbalances as follows:

[0026] (a) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is within an optimal range, charging and discharging the battery to offset the imbalance, the optimal range extending between a predetermined lower threshold value and a predetermined upper threshold value;

[0027] (b) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is below the predetermined lower threshold, increasing the power supplied to the network relative to the power drawn from the network by operating a low asset; and

[0028] (c) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is above the predetermined high threshold, increasing the power drawn from the network relative to the power supplied to the network by operating a high asset;

[0029] Wherein, the lower threshold value and the upper threshold value are determined so that:

[0030] With the SoC at the low threshold, the battery remains able to discharge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected low asset to reach its operating capacity; and

[0031] With the SoC at the high threshold, the battery remains able to discharge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected high asset to reach its operating capacity.

[0032] With the present invention, the battery is primarily responsible for providing response services to network imbalances. Only when a more extreme response is required, such as a sustained discharge to the network, is an alternative, slower asset required to provide rebalancing services. By providing a battery rebalancing service supported by a supplemental asset, the regulatory requirement to retain a certain reserve of power for the response system is met by the supplemental asset, thereby reducing the capacity requirements of the battery. This reduces the cost of batteries, which is a significant barrier to using batteries in rebalancing services.

[0033] In a third aspect, the present invention provides a method of selecting a non-battery asset from a portfolio of non-battery assets to supplement a balancing service provided by a battery to a network, the battery having a detector adapted to directly or indirectly monitor a state of charge (SoC) of the battery, and if the detector indicates that the battery SoC exceeds an upper threshold value or is below a lower threshold value, the method comprises the following steps:

[0034] (a) identifying from the asset set some combination of aggregated assets where:

[0035] (i) if the method is triggered by exceeding the upper threshold, each asset is operable to provide a balancing response commensurate with the extraction of power from the network;

[0036] (ii) if the method is triggered by falling below the lower threshold, each asset is operable to provide a balancing response equivalent to supplying electricity to the network; and

[0037] (iii) each combination includes at least one asset and each has a delay time, which is the time required for the combination of each aggregated asset to reach its operating capacity;

[0038] (b) For each identified combination of aggregated assets, verify that:

[0039] (i) the combination, when performing its balancing service, is capable of operating at a power level sufficient to match the power level of the battery; and

[0040] (ii) the battery threshold value that triggers the method enables the battery to continue its charge or discharge balancing function without reaching full capacity or being completely exhausted within the delay time of the corresponding combination;

[0041] (c) for all combinations verified in step (b), identify the lowest cost combination, taking into account operating costs and costs associated with asset degradation;

[0042] (d) the lowest cost combination of the aggregated assets identified in step (c); and

[0043] (e) after delaying the delay time associated with the lowest cost combination, and if the battery SoC has not returned to a level between the lower threshold and the upper threshold, shutting down the balancing service provided by the battery. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0044] The present invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:

[0045] Figure 1 represents the battery capacity required to supply frequency response to the grid;

[0046] Figure 2 A power supply system incorporating a battery suitable for the present invention is shown;

[0047] Figure 3a Indicate how other assets can be used in conjunction with batteries to ensure the availability of the additional 30 minutes of energy storage that the National Grid requires from the FFR system;

[0048] Figure 3b is a schematic diagram of the battery state of charge, showing the threshold levels at which these other assets are called on-line to provide rebalancing services; and

[0049] Figure 4a and Figure 4bA flow chart illustrating the processing steps involved in supplying battery-based FFR services to a power distribution network in accordance with the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0050] exist Figure 2 2 shows an electric power supply system generally indicated at 20. The electric power supply system 20 includes one or more generators 22, a plurality of electric loads 24 and a battery 26. The generators 22 supply electric energy to the electric loads 24 via a power distribution network 28 (hereinafter referred to as "network 28").

[0051] As previously mentioned, in such a power distribution network 28, it is important to balance supply and demand. Essentially, this is about monitoring the network 28 for changes in certain characteristics of the network, such as the supply frequency. Therefore, the system 20 also includes a frequency monitor 30 in communication with the battery 26. In this embodiment, the frequency monitor 30 is located in the vicinity of the battery 26, but this is not required. Monitoring momentary fluctuations in frequency is currently the preferred method of detecting imbalances in the supply of electricity across the network 28, but alternative monitors 30 suitable for detecting fluctuations in other characteristics of the power supply network 28 that are representative of imbalances in the supply of electricity across the network 28 are envisioned and may replace the frequency monitor 30.

[0052] Despite Figure 2 , but the generators 22 should not be considered to be of the same type. Some may be coal-fired power stations, others may be wind farms, hydroelectric generators, or any of a number of known systems capable of generating electricity and supplying it to a network. Generally, each generator will be configured with the network manager to supply a specified amount of electricity to the network. This specified amount can be adjusted according to the contractual requirements of the generator to supply a certain degree of balance to the grid. The speed at which this balancing response can be supplied varies greatly between generator types. For example, diesel generators, wind farms, and anaerobic digesters are relatively slow power generation mechanisms. Generators based on hydroelectric power generation mechanisms are faster and therefore have faster balancing response capabilities.

[0053] The electrical loads 24 are more diverse in nature. Typically, they draw power from the grid on demand, with only a limited subset capable of supplying responsive services to address network imbalances. However, those capable of supplying responsive services may be operated together on an individual basis or as an aggregation of multiple loads to supply responsive load services suitable for assisting in balancing network supply and demand, as is known in the art.

[0054] Figure 2An example 32 of a plurality of loads 24 operating together to supply a responsive service is shown. Such electrical loads 24 may be connected to and communicate with a semi-autonomous load controller 34. The semi-autonomous load controller 34 is adapted to control the amount of electrical energy drawn from the network 28 by the electrical loads 24. Preferably, the semi-autonomous load controller 34 is physically close to and, optionally, integrated into one or more electrical loads 24 connected to the load controller 34 to minimize communication delays between the load controller 34 and its corresponding one or more electrical loads 24. A plurality of electrical loads 24 may be collectively controlled as a group by a single load controller 34. In this case, the electrical load components of the group may be selected as part of a subgroup based on, for example, common end users of the electrical loads 24 and / or similar electrical energy requirements, such as, but not limited to, similar duty cycles and / or different but complementary electrical energy requirements. However, like generators, the speed at which each responsive load can respond to grid imbalances will vary. Again, this depends primarily on the operating parameters of the loads, and also on the manner in which the loads may be grouped together to supply responsive load services. Loads that can supply relatively fast responses include compressors, commercial refrigerators, and supercapacitors. Water pumps and waste-water treatment blowers can provide slower balancing responses.

[0055] The battery 26 may be any of a variety of devices suitable for storing electrical charge. Thus, it may be an accumulator or an electrochemical or electromechanical storage device. Although the battery 26 is referred to herein in the singular, it may more likely be any combination of a battery pack or an electrical storage device. In contrast to other devices connected to the network 28, the battery 26 may both draw power from the network and supply it to the network.

[0056] As is common in the art, the battery 26 is provided with a battery controller (not shown). The battery controller is adapted to infer the instantaneous state of charge (SoC) of the battery 26 from observations of the voltage of the battery 26 as it is charged or discharged. That is, the battery controller supplies an indication of the battery SoC for use by the network of which it is a part. In other embodiments, the SoC is derived from observations of parameters that are functions of the battery SoC (e.g., the net energy input to the battery system).

[0057] In the system 20 according to the present invention, the method of balancing the network is controlled by a central controller 36, which is usually remote from the generator 22, the load 24 and the battery 26. The central controller 36 communicates with the frequency monitor 30, the generator 22 and the load 24 (or its controller 34) for example via a virtual private network (VPN).

[0058] Transmission system operators in Europe require that stabilization measures be taken immediately once the grid frequency deviates from the target frequency of 50 Hz by more than 0.01 Hz. In system 20, the frequency of the grid is monitored by a frequency monitor 30. If the grid frequency rises to 50.01 Hz, the threshold value is recorded by the frequency monitor 30 and a signal is sent to the battery 26 to increase its stored charge to extract power from the grid. The battery 26 will increase its stored charge until the grid frequency returns to 50 Hz, or until its contractual FFR or EFR response is completed. The current minimum contractual requirement in the UK is to extract 1MW of electricity within 30 minutes. Similarly, if the grid frequency drops to 49.99 Hz, the frequency monitor 30 sends a signal to the battery to reduce its stored charge, thereby inputting power to the grid. The battery will continue to supply power to the network until the frequency rises to 50 Hz again or the FFR / EFR contractual obligations are completed.

[0059] It will be appreciated that the battery 26 of the system is configured to supply FFR or EFR. That is, a specified amount of power (e.g. 1 MW) needs to be delivered quickly, but only over a relatively short time scale (e.g. 30 minutes maximum). If, within this time scale, the grid frequency has not recovered to 50 Hz, then other, slower rebalancing mechanisms will take over.

[0060] However, in the system 20 of the present invention, the battery 26 itself is not capable of delivering full FFR. Rather than using a battery with a 30 minute capacity in both high and low frequency excursions, the battery 26 of the present system utilizes its full capacity under normal operating conditions. Figure 3a The response capacity of the FFR / EFR system 20 is shown graphically. The battery 26 has sufficient capacity 38 to supply or extract power over a total operating range of 15 minutes. The central controller 36 (see Figure 2) communicates with a battery controller which supplies an indication of the SoC charge of the battery 26. Thus, while the battery 26 is supplying power to the grid, the central controller 36 is able to determine that if the grid frequency shifts such that it drops below the nominal frequency for a period of time, the battery's ability to supply power is close to exhaustion. The controller 36 will, in this case, send a signal to one or more generators 22 connected to the system to supply more power. Alternatively, a signal may be sent to one or more responsive loads 24 to reduce consumption. Either way, an alternative mechanism for supplying power to the network 28 is implemented, in Figure 3a Asset 1 or the combination of assets that can supply low-balance response has sufficient capacity to supply the full 1 MW of electricity within 30 minutes as required by FFR40.

[0061] Similarly, if the grid frequency increases for a period of time that exceeds the battery capacity to store charge, the controller 36 will signal one or more generators to go offline, or equivalently, one or more responsive loads to increase consumption. That is, "Asset 2" encompasses the reserve response 42 in response to a high balancing need.

[0062] The composite system of battery 26 and assets 22, 24 can meet FFR and EFR requirements with a battery that only needs to supply power for 15 minutes, with a range close to its maximum and minimum capacity. This allows the use of smaller capacity batteries, and therefore lower costs. The degree to which the normal operating range approaches the maximum and minimum SoC limits will depend primarily on the specific characteristics of the battery used. The normal operating range should be within the effective battery operating range, which depends on the specifics of the battery charging and discharging mechanism.

[0063] Figure 3b 4 shows how the system 20 is configured to respond to the state of charge of the battery 26. When the battery 26 is fully charged, its SoC 44 is 100%; when it is completely depleted, its SoC is 0%. The battery 26 is required to be within the range (band) Δ SoC 48 without taking any additional action, i.e. without resorting to alternative balancing mechanisms when performing its FFR or EFR functions. Upper SoC range SoC Thr High Within the normal operating range Δ SoC The upper threshold 50 of 48 extends to 100% charge, and the system 20 calls on other slower assets to supply FFR. Likewise, if the battery is depleted, causing its SoC to move to a lower SoC range SoC Thr Low , from the normal operating range Δ SoCThe lower threshold 52 of 48 extends to when the SoC battery is depleted to 0%, the system 20 calls for a replacement asset to supply the FFR.

[0064] By ensuring that sufficient power can be supplied / drawn before the relevant asset (1 or 2) comes online, the operating criteria that the battery must meet can be derived. Consider the following situation: In FFR operation, a low asset (Asset Low), such as a diesel generator, can be used to supply reserve response to the battery 26. After receiving the signal from the controller 36 to come online, the Asset Low can only be used with a low latency ( Lag Time Low Once started, the asset must be operational for at least a short period of time ( Duration Low ) and continuously start and supply the following power within the minimum time period of: Low asset power ( Power Asset Low That is, the cost of turning on the asset is not economically worthwhile unless the asset supplies a certain amount of energy. Once started, the asset is able to supply low-energy electricity indefinitely.

[0065] The battery itself cannot be 100% efficient in converting stored charge into electrical energy supplied to the network, and extracting electrical energy from the network to increase its stored power. That is, it operates at a charging efficiency of the battery efficiency when charging and a discharge efficiency of the battery efficiency when discharging, where both efficiency variables are between 0 and 100%.

[0066] The battery must always have Power Asset Low "Discharge rate Lag Time Low Sufficient energy for the time period ( E B (low), "low" means low ) so that it covers turning on the Asset Low "The time required. That is:

[0067] .

[0068] Therefore, the lower threshold value 52 of the battery 26 is set so that the range SoC Thr Low Equal to the stored energy E B (low) .

[0069] Similarly, if high assets ( Asset High ) is represented by a power-consuming device such as a loadbank, it is assumed that after receiving a signal from the controller to the line, it will be in high latency ( Lag Time High Once started, the asset must be operational for at least the duration of high duration ( Duration High ) and continuously start and supply the following power within the minimum time period of: High asset power ( Power Asset High ).

[0070] Therefore, the SoC high threshold 50 of the battery 26 is set such that the range SoC Thr High Includes sufficient battery storage capacity (( E B (high), "high" means high) to cover the time it takes to start Asset High. That is:

[0071] .

[0072] In other words, the range SoC Thr High Extended from SoC high threshold 50 to 100% SoC, covering battery energy E B (high) sufficient storage capacity.

[0073] Note that once started, both Asset 1 and Asset 2 must maintain a minimum duration. For the case of undergeneration and AssetLow is a diesel generator, this means that the minimum energy that must be imported into the grid via Asset Low is:

[0074] .

[0075] In the worst case, the asset is switched on immediately (without time delay) as soon as it is called, and the FFR response is required to stop immediately. For example, the grid frequency increases rapidly from below 50 Hz to above 50 Hz. In this case, the battery must have sufficient capacity (in SoC thr low ) to increase its SoC to compensate for the additional energy supplied by assets that no longer need FFR response commands. That is, the battery capacity ΔSoC must satisfy:

[0076] .

[0077] Similarly, to compensate in the case where Asset 2 is called upon and at the same time, the grid frequency recovers such that the FFR response is no longer required:

[0078] .

[0079] Therefore, the total battery capacity Cap B Determined by the following formula:

[0080] .

[0081] Right now:

[0082]

[0083] Example

[0084] The diesel generator takes 2 minutes to start up and then supplies 1MW of electricity for at least 3 minutes.

[0085] At both high and low SoC, the battery supplied 1MW of power with an efficiency of 90%.

[0086] Therefore, the low SoC threshold 52 of the battery 26 must be set so that the range SoC Thr Low ( E B (low)) is at least 2 / 60 × (1000 / 0.9) = 37 kW.h. That is, it must be able to supply 1MW of electricity at 90% efficiency within 2 minutes of turning on the diesel generator. It needs to be able to charge (ΔSoC + E B The minimum amount of electricity that can be reached at (high) and then no longer required is 3 / 60 × (1000 / 0.9) = 56 kW.h.

[0087] The load bank takes 1 minute to start up and then draws 1 MW of power for at least 1 minute. Therefore, a high SoC threshold of 50 must be set to keep the range SoC Thr High ( E B The minimum value of (high) is 1 / 60 × (1000 / 0.9) = 19 kW.h. It needs to be able to discharge (ΔSoC + E B The minimum amount of electricity that is no longer needed after reaching (low) is also 1 / 60 × (1000 / 0.9) = 19 kW.h.

[0088] In this example, the diesel generator is the one that needs the most compensation, so that determines the battery capacity. The total capacity is therefore at least 93 kW.h: 37 kW.h to "fill in" the generator delay, and 56 kW.h to compensate when the FFR is no longer needed. Of this 56 kW.h, 19 kW.h ( E B (high)) to “fill” the load group delay, and the ΔSoC is 37kW.h.

[0089] These values ​​represent the minimum parameters of the battery to supply an effective FFR / EFR in combination with a specific generator and load group. That is, the normal operating range must extend to at least 37 kW.h and at any time within this range, without any assistance from other assets, there must be a reserve of 19 kW.h above the upper threshold of 50 and a reserve of 37 kW.h below the lower threshold of 52.

[0090] This significantly reduces the battery capacity compared to prior art batteries used to supply the FFR response. The National Grid's requirement for FFR to be supplied solely by batteries results in a high and low reserve of approximately 500 kW.h.

[0091] The present invention relates to an electric distribution system 20 in which multiple assets such as generators 22 and loads 24 are aggregated to provide reserve cover for a battery energy storage system 26 while providing a stable frequency response to imbalances in the network.

[0092] Potentially, this provides a number of advantages. First and foremost, the total capacity of the battery 26 used to supply FFR is reduced. This represents a significant reduction in capital costs. Secondly, the throughput of the battery 26 is reduced as another asset fills in part of the work previously performed only by the battery. This slows the degradation of the battery, thereby extending the useful life of the battery. Furthermore, the system according to the present invention employs batteries in the supply of FFR services without the need to use current SoC management techniques, such as rebalancing within deadbands or biasing the response of a collection of assets.

[0093] When operating a system according to the invention, a number of factors must be considered. These include physical and commercial constraints. Examples of the former include the length of time it takes for an asset to switch, the power the asset can supply and whether this power can be varied. Commercial constraints include the duration an asset must remain switched on to be cost-effective and the cost of calling the asset on-line. Figure 2 In the embodiment of the system shown, the controller 36 includes a processor programmed to run an algorithm that balances the operating state of the network with the state of charge of the battery and the cost and available performance of the assets that can supply coverage at any particular time. If the environment indicates that a particular asset is to be turned on, the controller 36 sends a signal to the asset 22, 24, instructing it to respond with supply balancing. The signal may indicate that the asset 22, 24 is only operable for a set period of time, such as its minimum contract period, or remains turned on until the controller 36 is notified that the network has returned to a specific operating state, for example, the battery SoC has returned to a specific level.

[0094] exist Figure 4a and 4b , which shows an example of an algorithm that runs within controller 36 to enable management of system 20 to provision FFR.

[0095] When implementing the system of the present invention, the battery SoC is monitored with a 1 second resolution. In the first step S10 of the method for supplying FFR or EFR according to the present invention, the current battery SoC is checked to see if it is within or outside the normal operating range (ΔSoC), whether it is above the upper threshold value of 50 and thus within the range SoC Thr High Within or below the lower threshold value 52 and within the range SoC Thr Low If it is within the normal range ΔSoC, the battery 26 supplies network services in a "normal operation mode". The battery SoC is within the acceptable range and no emergency SoC correction measures are required. Figure 4b If the battery SoC is above the upper threshold 50 or below the lower threshold 52, the system 20 will enter a "critical operating mode" and require SoC rebalancing. Reference will now be made to Figure 4a Describe the pattern.

[0096] In the next step S12, one or more assets that can be used to supply an appropriate response are selected. This involves the aggregation of asset groups that are adjusted together to supply the desired response. When the response is supplied by load sub-devices, a collection of assets is particularly suitable, and these loads are able to supply a dynamic increase or decrease in power consumption that is proportional to the frequency deviation. Responsive loads such as these are particularly attractive because they can respond to high-frequency and low-frequency excursions (as well as SoC changes). The reduction in load demand is equivalent to additional power generation, and reference to one scenario should be understood to cover other situations. It should also be understood that the reference to an aggregation of assets or an aggregated collection of assets only reflects the fact that this is a better configuration. That is, the use of a single asset, generator or load to supply SoC rebalancing is not excluded and may in fact be better in some cases.

[0097] In step S14, a first combination of assets (which may specifically include a single asset) is analyzed to see if the size (in kW) of the load that can be brought into or removed from the system 20 is sufficient to supply the required response. That is, whether it not only has enough power to take over the balancing role currently supplied by the battery 26, but also has a total amount of power available to charge / discharge the appropriate amount of power to ensure that the system 20 supplies a response consistent with the service contracted by the network operator. That is, supply the specified maximum power within the specified maximum duration. If the power of the selected set of assets is insufficient, this combination is no longer considered. The method then checks in step S16 to see if an alternative combination of the aggregated assets is available. If so, the alternative is selected in step S18, and the power evaluation step S14 is repeated for the alternative combination. If the combination under consideration does supply enough power for the response, the process proceeds to check the required delay time for the selected asset combination in step S20. That is, the time delay inherent to the asset between the asset receiving a signal command to change consumption or to bring it online and the asset being able to supply active response services to the network. In step S20, the delay time for turning on the selected combination is checked against the SoC of the battery. The delay time must be short enough so that when the asset comes online, the battery has sufficient capacity to continue to supply balancing services even if it needs to operate at its maximum potential response. If the delay time is too long, the asset combination cannot be used, and if another asset combination can be used, the method returns to the first check step S14 using the other asset combination S18.

[0098] If the delay time is acceptable, the asset set selected in step S22 is considered to be a suitable asset set for supplying a response. In step 24, it is checked whether a previously suitable asset set has been found. If not, the current asset set is set S26 as a preferred asset set. The method then returns to step S16 to select another asset combination to test its suitability for supplying a response. If no other combination is available, the assets in the current preferred asset set are called online S28 to supply a response.

[0099] Alternatively, if it is determined at step S24 that the currently selected set of assets is not the set of assets that first meets the basic criteria, the method continues to examine business considerations. Therefore, at step S30, the cost of activating the currently selected set of assets to supply the response is compared to the cost of the previously selected better set of assets. In determining the cost, many factors are taken into account. These include not only operating costs, such as the cost of fuel required to power a diesel generator, and the cost of electricity required to power a load group or slow load, but also the marginal costs associated with starting on demand rather than scheduled operating hours, and the additional degradation and wear of assets.

[0100] If the sum of the current assets is more cost-effective than the previous better asset set, it will take over S32 and the new better asset set. Otherwise, the previous better selection will be retained. In either case, the process then returns to step S16 to check whether there is another asset combination to choose from.

[0101] In this way, all possible options for selecting an asset from all available assets of the system are examined to determine its ability to meet the technical requirements. From those that meet the requirements, the lowest cost selection is performed S28.

[0102] After sending the S28 command to call the current preferred asset set online, the battery 26 will continue its charge or discharge into the network for the period of time required to bring the selected asset set online. That is, for low latency ( lag time low) or high latency ( lag time high) , depending on the FFR response achieved. Only after this period does the battery cease to supply the FFR service. It is then free to charge or discharge as needed to keep its SoC within its normal operating range ΔSoC.

[0103] In many cases, the asset that is activated to supply reserve to the battery FFR is of a type that is either on or off. That is, it contributes a specified amount of power to the network, or extracts power from the network. It cannot supply the precise tracking of frequency deviations that the battery 26 is capable of. Therefore, in these cases, the battery SoC will be monitored after the asset is activated. Once back within its normal operating range ΔSoC, the battery 26 will cooperate with the backup asset to provide a response to fine-tune the power supplied to or extracted from the network, allowing the system to track frequency deviations more closely. The condition of this joint FFR response will last for a period of time corresponding to the minimum operating time of the asset (high duration or low duration) before it can be taken offline and the full FFR response returned to the battery. This process of operating a battery in conjunction with a less responsive asset is described in US 2016 / 0099568.

[0104] Generally, activated assets do not come online instantaneously, and there will be some ramp-up period where, in the case of, for example, a generator, more and more power is supplied to the network until maximum capacity is reached. This is particularly true for a collection of assets where each asset may have a different start-up time. In the embodiment of the invention described above, the battery 26 maintains its full power operation when discharging to the network to cover the time it takes for the generator to become fully operational. That is, the entire time after the battery SoC reaches its low SoC threshold 52 lag time lowIn an alternative embodiment, the asset power output during this acceleration phase is monitored and communicated to the central controller 36. The central controller 36 then adjusts the operating power of the battery 26 so that the battery discharge power decreases in accordance with the increase in generator supply. In this way, the total output power of the battery and the asset will remain unchanged.

[0105] Many assets connected to the network will have a well-defined startup sequence, resulting in a known pattern of power increase during the acceleration phase. Therefore, for these assets, there is no need to monitor the power output. Instead, the central controller 36 will be able to utilize stored sets of voltages at which the batteries should be operated, each set corresponding to each asset set of available assets. By operating the batteries at the voltages contained in the relevant set, the battery output power will decrease in a pattern that reflects the increase in power output as the selected set of assets comes online. That is, the total power output remains unchanged during startup.

[0106] An advantage of these embodiments is that the battery does not need to ensure sufficient remaining capacity to cover the delay time of the asset at full discharge / charge power, but rather at a reduced power level. This reduces the unutilized available SoC capacity in the battery and enables improved FFR tracking during system startup of the asset.

[0107] Returning now to step S10, if it is determined that the battery SoC is within an acceptable range, the method enters a "normal operating mode". If the non-battery asset is of a type that is either on or off and cannot adjust its response level according to the deviation from the network nominal frequency, then in this mode, the frequency response will be provided by the battery alone. If appropriate, the battery will be charged or discharged to closely track the frequency deviation.

[0108] However, if the aggregated asset collection includes a response payload ( Figure 2 , 32)), the normal operating mode may be modified based on similar technical and economic considerations as those described with respect to the critical operating mode. The responsive loads 32 are loads that are able to supply dynamic responses and adjust their supply to or extraction of power from the network according to the degree of network frequency deviation. Therefore, it may be more economical to use these assets to supply ancillary services to the battery 26 in the normal operating mode. This is shown in Figure 4b middle.

[0109] Thus, in the normal operating mode, an initial step S34 will determine whether the system can use any responsive load devices to supply reserve services to the battery. If not present, only the battery is able to track frequency changes and therefore only the FFR grid service S36 is supplied by the battery. If such a responsive load asset is available, the process moves to step S38, where the cost of using the battery is compared to the cost of using the aggregated load. The costs associated with the total load are evaluated according to similar criteria to the costs of bringing the assets online in the "critical operating mode". Battery throughput can be used as a cost indicator in terms of battery degradation: it is well known that batteries degrade with constant charging and discharging. In addition, due to the efficiency being less than 100%, there are inherent losses in the battery system when performing FFR balancing. This also plays a role in the cost.

[0110] If it proves to be more expensive to use aggregated assets than to use batteries for FFR, the flow returns to step S36 and services are provided by batteries only. If it proves to be cheaper to aggregate the loads, a final assessment is made S40 as to whether the selected loads are already providing network services. If so, their response is increased accordingly S42. If not, they are brought online S44 to provide the scope of services required by the contract. In both cases, the faster response time of the batteries is used to supplement the response of the load provision in order to better track frequency changes.

[0111] Several simulations have been performed to demonstrate the effectiveness of supplying FFR using a battery system backed by multiple assets in a collection of assets for the load. These are compared to a prior art system using battery power for FFR with dead-zone balancing. For a battery supplying 1 MW of power, the simulations show the following results:

[0112] • Battery capacity reduced to 250kW.h without affecting service supplied to the grid;

[0113] • Successfully used slow loads to achieve battery SoC management, with the battery SoC always kept within the desired range without the need for other SoC management techniques such as dead-time rebalancing;

[0114] • Reducing battery throughput by relying more on backup assets, especially those that have the ability to follow frequency deviations; and

[0115] • From grid data taken in January 2015, it was found that the system of the present invention can be used to keep the SoC of a 1 MW / 2 MW.h battery within a narrow boundary of ±125 kW.h, while when using dead-band rebalancing, 22% of the values ​​fall outside this interval.

Claims

1. A method for balancing a power distribution network, the method comprising: (a) directly or indirectly by monitoring the level of charge, SoC, of ​​a parameter which is a function of SoC stored in a battery connected to the network, the battery being adapted to draw power from the network when charging and to add power to the network when discharging, (b) responding to a detected imbalance in the network by adding power to the network or extracting power from the network in accordance with: (i) if the battery SoC is within an optimal range, charging and discharging the battery to offset the imbalance in the network; (ii) if the battery SoC drops below a low threshold, selecting an alternative low asset suitable for increasing power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network, and in response to a low criticality signal, switching on the alternative low asset to provide a balancing service to the network; and (iii) if the battery SoC rises above a high threshold, selecting an alternative high asset suitable for drawing power from the network relative to power supplied to the network, and in response to a high criticality signal, switching on the alternative high asset to provide a balancing service to the network; wherein the low threshold is determined so that, after the low critical signal is generated, the battery remains able to discharge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected low asset to reach its operating capacity; and The high threshold is determined so that, after the high critical signal is generated, the battery remains able to charge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected high asset to reach its operating capacity.

2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The alternative low asset has a first minimum operating time and the alternative high asset has a second minimum operating time, the first minimum operating time and the second minimum operating time being the time the respective assets should remain operating after being turned on, and wherein the optimal range of battery control balancing is determined such that: After generating the low criticality signal, the battery has a capacity to: charge with a power equal to a relative increase in power supplied to the network resulting from operation of the alternative low asset during the first minimum operating time; and After generating the high critical signal, the battery has a capacity to discharge within the second minimum operating time with power equal to the relative reduction in power supplied to the network resulting from operation of the replacement high asset.

3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The lower threshold value is determined so that the battery remains able to discharge at its maximum contracted power throughout the delay time.

4. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The upper threshold value is determined so that the battery remains capable of being charged at its maximum contracted power throughout the delay time.

5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that In step (b) (ii) of claim 1, the battery continues to offset the imbalance in the network for a period of time equal to the delay time associated with the selected low asset.

6. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that During the delay time, the battery is discharged at its maximum contracted power.

7. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that During the delay time, the battery is discharged at a varying power level so that the impact of the selected low asset on the network balance plus the impact of the battery is equal to the impact of the battery being discharged at its maximum contracted power.

8. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (b) (iii) of claim 1, the battery continues to offset the imbalance in the network for a period of time equal to the delay time associated with the selected high asset.

9. The method according to claim 8, characterized in that During this delay time, the battery is charged at its maximum contracted power.

10. The method according to claim 8, characterized in that During the delay time, the battery is charged at a varying power level such that the impact of the selected high asset on the network balance plus the impact of the battery is equal to the impact of the battery being charged at its maximum contracted power.

11. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The method further comprises the step of monitoring a parameter of the network, the parameter having a nominal operating value, fluctuations relative to the nominal operating value being indicative of the imbalance of the network to which the method responds in step (b).

12. The method according to claim 11, characterized in that The monitored parameter is the network frequency.

13. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The selected low assets include an aggregated group of assets, each of which contributes to the overall ability of the aggregated group to increase power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network.

14. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The step of selecting a replacement low asset in (ii) of step (b) comprises the step of selecting at least one low asset from a set of low assets, each of the low assets in the set of assets firstly having a respective delay time and secondly being suitable for increasing the power supplied to the network relative to the power drawn from the network.

15. The method according to claim 14, characterized in that The low threshold value is determined so that the battery remains dischargeable for the longest time of the respective delay times of the low assets within the entire low asset set.

16. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The selected high assets include aggregated groups of assets, each of which contributes to the overall ability of the aggregated group to reduce power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network.

17. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The step of selecting a replacement high asset in (iii) of step (b) comprises the step of selecting at least one high asset from a set of high assets, each of the high assets in the set of assets firstly having a respective delay time and secondly being adapted to reduce power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network.

18. The method according to claim 17, characterized in that The high threshold value is determined so that the battery remains dischargeable for the longest time within the delay time of each of the high assets within the entire high asset set.

19. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that In case of high assets or low assets providing the balancing service to the network, the method comprises the further step of charging or discharging the battery for the time required to bring the SoC into the optimal range.

20. The method according to claim 19, characterized in that When a low asset provides balancing service to the network and the time elapsed from the generation of the low critical signal is less than the first minimum operating time; or when a high asset provides balancing service to the network and the time elapsed from the generation of the high critical signal is less than the second minimum operating time, if the battery SoC returns to the optimal range, the battery is charged or discharged as needed to supply additional balancing service to the network.

21. A system for providing balancing services to a power distribution network to which it is connected, the system comprising: A battery having a detector adapted to directly or indirectly monitor the state of charge, or SoC, of ​​the battery; at least one non-battery low asset adapted to increase power supplied to the network relative to power drawn from the network; at least one non-battery high asset adapted to increase power drawn from the network relative to power supplied to the network; and a central controller adapted to respond to an imbalance detected in the network to receive information from the SoC detector and to generate signals for controlling the operation of the battery and the asset; characterised in that The central controller is further configured to respond to imbalances as follows: (a) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is within an optimal range, charging and discharging the battery to offset the imbalance, the optimal range extending between a predetermined lower threshold value and a predetermined upper threshold value; (b) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is below the predetermined lower threshold, increasing the power supplied to the network relative to the power drawn from the network by operating a low asset; and (c) when the information received from the SoC detector indicates that the battery SoC is above the predetermined high threshold, increasing the power drawn from the network relative to the power supplied to the network by operating a high asset; Wherein, the lower threshold value and the upper threshold value are determined so that: With the SoC at the low threshold, the battery remains able to discharge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected low asset to reach its operating capacity; and With the SoC at this high threshold, the battery remains able to charge for a delay time equal to the time required for the selected high asset to reach its operating capacity.

22. A method of selecting a non-battery asset from a set of non-battery assets to supplement a balancing service provided by a battery to a network, the battery having a detector adapted to directly or indirectly monitor the battery's state of charge (SoC), and if the detector indicates that the battery SoC exceeds an upper threshold value or falls below a lower threshold value, the method comprising the steps of: (a) identifying from the asset set some combination of aggregated assets where: (i) if the method is triggered by exceeding the upper threshold, each asset is operable to provide a balancing response commensurate with the extraction of power from the network; (ii) if the method is triggered by falling below the lower threshold, each asset is operable to provide a balancing response equivalent to supplying electricity to the network; and (iii) each combination includes at least one asset and each has a delay time, which is the time required for the combination of each aggregated asset to reach its operating capacity; (b) For each identified combination of aggregated assets, verify that: (i) the combination, when performing its balancing service, is capable of operating at a power level sufficient to match the power level of the battery; and (ii) the battery threshold value that triggers the method enables the battery to continue its charge or discharge balancing function without reaching full capacity or being completely exhausted during the delay time of the corresponding combination; (c) for all combinations verified in step (b), identify the lowest cost combination, taking into account operating costs and costs associated with asset degradation; (d) launching the lowest cost combination of aggregated assets identified in step (c); and (e) after delaying the delay time associated with the lowest cost combination, and if the battery SoC has not returned to a level between the lower threshold and the upper threshold, shutting down the balancing service provided by the battery.