Method and apparatus for controlled neural stimulation
By configuring multiple stimulation electrodes and phase distribution technologies, the signal attenuation and artifact interference problems in composite action potential measurement are solved, and more accurate neural response measurement is achieved, which is suitable for applications such as spinal cord stimulation therapy.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN201980085396.5
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2018-10-23
- Filing Date
- 2019-10-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-22
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to effectively measure the composite action potential (CAP) induced by electrical stimulation applied to the neural pathway. Due to the small amplitude of the signal, obvious attenuation and easy to be confused with the stimulation artifact, it makes measurement difficult, especially in the deep brain stimulation. The object cannot be measured effectively.
Using a configuration of at least three stimulation electrodes, the components are distributed to different electrodes by delivering super-threshold and sub-threshold stimulation components of different phases using the control unit to achieve faster spatiotemporal separation and reduce the impact of stimulation artifacts, thereby improving Accuracy of CAP measurements.
Through this configuration, the composite action potential can be measured more accurately, the interference of stimulation artifacts can be reduced, the signal-to-noise ratio can be improved, and the measurement ability of nerve response can be enhanced. It is suitable for applications such as spinal cord stimulation therapy.
Smart Images

Figure CN113226449B_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0002] This application claims the benefit of Australian Provisional Patent Application No. 2018904011 filed on 23 October 2018, which is incorporated herein by reference. Technical Field
[0003] The present invention relates to applying electrical nerve stimulation to generate a compound action potential in a nerve, and in particular, the present invention relates to configuring the stimulation to controllably induce a compound action potential having a desired morphology. Background of the Invention
[0005] There are many situations where it is desirable to apply neurostimulation in order to generate a compound action potential (CAP). For example, neuromodulation is used to treat a variety of conditions, including chronic pain, Parkinson's disease, and migraine. Neuromodulation systems apply electrical pulses to tissues in order to produce a therapeutic effect. When used to relieve chronic pain, electrical pulses are applied to the dorsal column of the spinal cord (DC), known as spinal cord stimulation (SCS). Neuromodulation systems typically include an implantable electrical pulse generator and a power source, such as a battery that can be recharged by transcutaneous inductive transmission. An electrode array is connected to the pulse generator and positioned in the dorsal epidural space above the dorsal column. The electrical pulses applied to the dorsal column by the electrode cause neuronal depolarization and generate a propagating action potential. The fibers stimulated in this way inhibit the transmission of pain from that section of the spinal cord to the brain. In order to maintain the pain relief effect, stimulation is applied continuously, for example, at a frequency in the range of 50 Hz to 100 Hz.
[0006] Neuromodulation can also be used to stimulate efferent nerve fibers, for example, to induce motor function. Generally speaking, the electrical stimulation generated in a neuromodulation system triggers a nerve action potential, which later has either an inhibitory effect or a stimulatory effect. The inhibitory effect can be used to modulate an undesirable process such as pain transmission, or to induce a desired effect such as muscle contraction.
[0007] There are a range of situations where it is desirable to obtain electrical measurements of compound action potentials (CAPs) induced on a neural pathway by an electrical stimulus applied to the neural pathway. However, this can be a difficult task because the observed CAP signal will typically have a maximum amplitude of tens of microvolts or less, while the stimulus applied to induce the CAP is typically several volts. Electrode artifacts are typically generated by the stimulus and appear as a decaying output of a few millivolts or hundreds of microvolts over the time the entire CAP occurs, which poses a significant obstacle to isolating the much smaller CAP of interest. Because neural responses can occur simultaneously with stimulation and / or stimulation artifacts, CAP measurements present difficult challenges to implant design. In practice, many non-ideal aspects of the circuit lead to artifacts, and because these primarily have decaying exponential characteristics that can have either positive or negative polarity, identification and elimination of the source of the artifacts can be laborious. Many methods have been proposed to record CAP, including those of King (US Pat. No. 5,913,882), Nygard (US Pat. No. 5,785,651), Daly (US Pat. App. No. 2007 / 0225767), and the present applicant (US Pat. No. 9,386,934).
[0008] When evoked responses occur later than the time at which the artifacts occur, or when the signal-to-noise ratio is high enough, they are less difficult to detect. Artifacts are typically confined to a time of 1-2 ms after stimulation and therefore data can be obtained if neural responses are detected after this time window. This is the case in surgical monitoring, where the distance between the stimulating and recording electrodes is large, so that the neural response propagation time from the stimulation site to the recording electrode exceeds 2 ms. However, in order to characterize responses evoked by a single implant (such as responses from the dorsal columns to the SCS, for example), high stimulation currents and close proximity between electrodes are required, and therefore the measurement process must directly overcome simultaneous artifacts, which greatly exacerbates the difficulty of neural measurements.
[0009] Similar considerations may arise in deep brain stimulation, where it may be desirable to stimulate a neural structure and measure the evoked compound action potential generated in that structure immediately before the neural response propagates elsewhere in the brain. Artifacts remain a significant obstacle to measuring neural responses near the stimulation site, with the result that most, if not all, conventional neural stimulation implants (which must be compact devices) are unable to make any measurements of neural responses evoked by the implant's stimulation anyway.
[0010] Any discussion of documents, acts, materials, devices, articles and the like that has been included in this specification is solely for the purpose of providing a context for the present invention. It is not to be taken as an admission that any or all of these matters form part of the prior art base or were common general knowledge in the field relevant to the present invention simply because they existed before the priority date of each claim of this application.
[0011] Throughout this specification, the word "comprise", or variations such as "comprises" or "comprising", will be understood to imply the inclusion of a stated element, integer or step, or group of elements, integers or steps, but not the exclusion of any other element, integer or step, or any other group of elements, integers or steps.
[0012] In the present specification, a statement that an element may be “at least one of” a list of options will be understood that the element may be any one of the listed options, or may be any combination of two or more of the listed options. Summary of the invention
[0013] According to a first aspect, the present invention provides a nerve stimulation device, the nerve stimulation device comprising:
[0014] at least three stimulation electrodes configured to deliver electrical stimulation to neural tissue; and
[0015] A control unit is configured to deliver a first stimulation phase, wherein a first stimulation electrode delivers a suprathreshold stimulation component returned by at least two other stimulation electrodes among the stimulation electrodes, and the control unit is further configured to deliver at least a second stimulation phase, wherein at least two of the stimulation electrodes deliver a subthreshold stimulation component returned by the first stimulation electrode.
[0016] According to a second aspect, the present invention provides a method for neural stimulation, the method comprising:
[0017] Electrical stimulation is delivered to neural tissue using at least three stimulation electrodes, the electrical stimulation comprising a first stimulation phase in which a first stimulation electrode delivers a suprathreshold stimulation component that is returned by at least two other of the stimulation electrodes, and the electrical stimulation further comprising at least a second stimulation phase in which at least two of the stimulation electrodes deliver a subthreshold stimulation component that is returned by the first stimulation electrode.
[0018] According to another aspect, the invention provides a computer program product comprising computer program code means for causing a neurostimulator to execute a program for neurostimulation, the computer program product comprising computer program code means for executing the method of the second aspect.
[0019] Typically, the suprathreshold stimulation component will be the cathodal stimulation phase within the conventional meaning given to that term in the field of neurostimulation. In many neurostimulation applications, the cathodal stimulation threshold is lower than the anodal stimulation threshold, such that a cathodal stimulation of a given amplitude can induce a response, while anodal stimulation of equal amplitude and duration will not. However, the present invention should not be construed as being limited by this theory, and it should be understood that in some embodiments, the suprathreshold stimulation component may be the anodal stimulation phase, for example, in which case a certain neurostimulation application operates in an environment where the anodal stimulation threshold is lower than the cathodal stimulation threshold, or even in which case alternative nomenclature is applied to the terms anode and cathode in a particular stimulation mode or field. Therefore, if applicable, references herein to suprathreshold cathodal stimulation components should be understood to apply to anodal suprathreshold stimulation components in such alternative embodiments.
[0020] Preferred embodiments of the invention include at least three phases delivered by at least three electrodes, and the electrical stimulation is configured such that in one of the phases only one stimulation component from only one electrode is a suprathreshold cathodal stimulation component. Such embodiments recognize that when three or more stimulation phases are utilized, there is a greater opportunity to maintain all of the stimulation components except the suprathreshold cathodal stimulation component below the stimulation threshold. For example, in such embodiments, the return current stimulation component and the charge balancing stimulation component can be distributed over a greater number of phases and can therefore take a reduced amplitude in each such phase.
[0021] The suprathreshold cathode stimulation component is preferably delivered in the last phase of the stimulation, such as during the second phase of biphasic stimulation. Such an embodiment provides the maximum spatiotemporal separation of the stimulation from the start of the ECAP, thereby allowing the ECAP measurement to occur faster without saturation due to the stimulation or stimulation artifacts. In such an embodiment, it should be noted that the first phase partial depolarization can change the membrane potential and affect the recruitment of the cathode stimulation component in the second phase, but this can be solved by appropriate stimulation amplitude control. However, alternative embodiments within the scope of the present invention can deliver suprathreshold cathode stimulation in the first phase, the penultimate phase, or other non-last phase of the stimulation. For example, for a three-phase stimulation, the suprathreshold cathode stimulation component is typically delivered in the second phase of the three phases.
[0022] Some embodiments may utilize three stimulation electrodes to deliver tripolar stimulation. Other embodiments may utilize four stimulation electrodes to deliver quadrupolar stimulation. For example, offset quadrupolar stimulation may be delivered whereby the suprathreshold stimulation component is delivered by one electrode and returned by three electrodes. Other embodiments may utilize five or more stimulation electrodes to deliver pentapolar stimulation or deliver stimulation from a greater number of electrodes. Some embodiments may adaptively select the number of stimulation electrodes in order to find which of the tripolar, quadrupolar, pentapolar, etc. configurations best minimizes the second cathode stimulation by switching between such stimulation modes.
[0023] In some embodiments, the current carried by the first stimulation electrode can be equally distributed between the two or more other stimulation electrodes. For example, in the case of tripolar stimulation with two return electrodes, each return electrode can carry 50% of the current delivered by the first stimulation electrode. Alternatively, the current carried by the first stimulation electrode can be unequally distributed between the two or more other stimulation electrodes, while each is maintained at a subthreshold level, and such unequal currents can be configured to adopt unequal amounts, which minimize stimulation artifacts, for example, in accordance with the teachings of the applicant's international patent application publication number WO 2017 / 219096, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference.
[0024] The current carried by each respective stimulation electrode can be controlled by providing each electrode with a respective current source, the current source being configured to drive the desired current through the respective electrode in each phase of the stimulation. Alternatively, a respective current source can be provided between adjacent stimulation electrode pairs, the current source being used to achieve differential drive of the desired current through each electrode. Such an embodiment may be particularly useful when it is desired to share unequal currents between stimulation electrodes. Alternatively, one or more of the stimulation electrodes may be grounded to act, for example, as a passive return electrode.
[0025] In some embodiments, the first stimulation electrode is between the two or more other electrodes, such as on an epidural lead array.
[0026] In alternative embodiments, the first stimulation electrode may be positioned to one side of two or all of the return electrodes. Such embodiments recognize that it is desirable to record ECAPs as close to the stimulation site as possible before the ECAP propagation effects of the composite response cause dispersion and amplitude reduction of the initial neural response. In such embodiments, by driving each return electrode with a corresponding current source, the return electrode stimulation components may be maintained at equal levels or at least at corresponding subthreshold levels.
[0027] Embodiments of the present invention may further include recording electrodes and measurement circuit systems, which are configured to obtain one or more records of neural responses induced by the stimulation. In some such embodiments, the one or more records of the neural responses are evaluated to identify whether a second cathode stimulation is occurring. For example, the second cathode stimulation detection can be achieved by applying a stimulus having a constant amplitude but having (multiple) different interphase gaps, observing the ECAP induced by each such stimulus, and comparing the morphology of each such observed ECAP to find a marker for the second cathode stimulation. Additionally or alternatively, the second cathode stimulation detection can be achieved by applying a stimulus having a constant amplitude but having a different stimulation phase sequence (such as having an alternating phase delivery selection, whether cathode first or anode first). Similarly, in such an embodiment, the ECAP induced by each such stimulus can be observed and their morphology can be compared to detect any markers of the second cathode stimulation.
[0028] In embodiments where detection of secondary cathodal stimulation is provided, the results of such detection are preferably used to adjust the stimulation paradigm when detected to seek to prevent or reduce secondary cathodal stimulation. Accordingly, preferred embodiments of the present invention further provide for feedback control of the suprathreshold stimulation component, the feedback control being configured to repeatedly or continuously evaluate one or more records of compound action potentials generated by previous stimulations and refine stimulation including the suprathreshold stimulation component to seek to maintain neural recruitment solely from the suprathreshold stimulation component.
[0029] Embodiments of the present invention may utilize any suitable ECAP detector to evaluate neural recordings to evaluate recruitment, such as an ECAP vector detector. The vector detector may utilize a four-petal or five-petal matched filter template, for example, in accordance with the teachings of the applicant's International Patent Publication No. WO 2015 / 074121, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. Particularly preferred embodiments may apply stimulation according to the present invention, detect evoked responses using an ECAP vector detector, and use the output of the detector to control a stimulation feedback loop.
[0030] While safety requirements impose restrictions on stimulation configurations, it should be noted that in some embodiments of the invention, the stimulation itself may not be strictly charge balanced and the net charge difference may be restored by alternative means, such as passive charge recovery by shorting one or more electrodes to ground when appropriate.
[0031] Some embodiments of the present invention may provide automatic stimulation amplitude determination by occasionally applying stimulation with subthreshold and suprathreshold amplitudes and observing the induced ECAP response, determining therefrom the stimulation amplitude threshold for the first induced ECAP response, and setting the ongoing treatment stimulation amplitude to a multiple of the stimulation amplitude threshold. The multiple may be determined when the device is installed on the patient on a patient-by-patient basis. Alternatively, the multiple may be selected to take a value in the range of 1.05 to 1.8, more preferably, a value in the range of 1.1 to 1.4, more preferably, a value in the range of 1.15 to 1.25, more preferably, 1.2 or about 1.2. Such embodiments recognize that clinical observations of the applicant have revealed that a patient's preferred tripolar stimulation amplitude is typically about 1.2 times the patient's stimulation threshold. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0032] Examples of the present invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0033] Figure 1 An implantable spinal cord stimulator is schematically shown;
[0034] Figure 2 is a block diagram of an implantable neurostimulator;
[0035] Figure 3 is a schematic diagram showing the interaction of an implanted stimulator with a nerve;
[0036] Figure 4A The current profile of the prior art biphasic bipolar stimulation over time is shown. Figure 4B and Figure 4C demonstrates the delivery of each stimulation phase to the nerve, and Figure 4D The corresponding electrode waveforms are shown;
[0037] Figure 5A and Figure 5B An embodiment of the present invention utilizing biphasic tripolar stimulation is presented;
[0038] Figure 6 Demonstrated through Figure 5A and Figure 5B Some ECAP morphological parameters improved by the embodiment;
[0039] Figure 7 An embodiment of the invention is shown driving a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement using a first arrangement of current sources according to one embodiment of the invention.
[0040] Figure 8 Another embodiment of the invention is shown using a second arrangement of current sources to drive a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement according to another embodiment of the invention;
[0041] Fig. 9Another embodiment of the invention is shown using a further arrangement of current sources according to a further embodiment of the invention to drive a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement;
[0042] Fig. 10A and Fig. 10B Demonstrates misalignment of the electrodes with the axis of propagation of the action potential.
[0043] Fig.11A shows the polarized and partially depolarized regions of the nerve induced by the first phase of stimulation, and Fig. 11B The additional polarization region induced by the second stimulation phase is demonstrated;
[0044] Fig.12 We further demonstrated the problem of nonlinear ECAP growth caused by multiple stimulation sites and times in conventional biphasic bipolar stimulation;
[0045] FIG13 illustrates a method for detecting the presence of a second cathode stimulus; and
[0046] Fig.14 A further embodiment of the invention is presented which further provides for automatic optimization of the stimulation sequence to remove the second cathode effect;
[0047] Fig.15 A system for feedback-controlled neural stimulation according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically illustrated;
[0048] Fig.16 A three-phase tripolar stimulation configuration according to another embodiment of the present invention is shown;
[0049] Fig.17A and Fig. 17B The polarity of electrodes in a single phase of a quadripolar stimulation configuration and a pentapole stimulation configuration, respectively, according to further embodiments of the present invention are shown; and
[0050] Fig.18 A three-phase quadrupolar stimulation configuration according to yet another embodiment of the present invention is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0051] Figure 1 An implantable spinal cord stimulator 100 is schematically illustrated. The stimulator 100 includes an electronic device module 110 implanted at a suitable location in the patient's lower abdominal region or upper posterior buttock region, and an electrode assembly 150 implanted in the epidural space and connected to the module 110 by suitable leads. Many aspects of the operation of the implantable neural device 100 can be reconfigured by an external control device 192. In addition, the implantable neural device 100 functions as a data acquisition device, wherein the acquired data is transmitted to an external device 192 via any suitable percutaneous communication channel 190.
[0052] Figure 2 1 is a block diagram of an implantable neurostimulator 100. The module 110 includes a battery 112 and a telemetry module 114. In an embodiment of the present invention, the telemetry module 114 can use any suitable type of transcutaneous communication 190 such as infrared (IR) transmission, electromagnetic transmission, capacitive transmission, and inductive transmission to transmit power and / or data between an external device 192 and the electronic device module 110. The module controller 116 has an associated memory 118 that stores patient settings 120, a control program 122, etc. The controller 116 controls the pulse generator 124 to generate stimulation in the form of current pulses according to the patient settings and the control program 122. The electrode selection module 126 switches the generated pulses to the appropriate electrode(s) of the electrode array 150 for delivering the current pulses to the tissue surrounding the selected electrode(s). The measurement circuit system 128 is configured to capture measurements of the neural responses sensed at the sensing electrode(s) of the electrode array as selected by the electrode selection module 126.
[0053] Figure 3 1 is a schematic diagram illustrating the interaction of an implantable stimulator 100 with a nerve 180, however, in this case, the spinal cord alternative embodiment may be positioned adjacent to any desired neural tissue, including peripheral nerves, visceral nerves, parasympathetic nerves, or brain structures. The electrode selection module 126 selects stimulation electrode 2 of the electrode array 150 to deliver current pulses to the surrounding tissue including the nerve 180, and also selects two return electrodes 1 and 3 of the array 150 for stimulation current recovery to maintain zero net charge transfer.
[0054] Appropriate stimulation is delivered to the nerve 180 to induce a neural response, which includes a compound action potential that will propagate along the nerve 180 as shown for therapeutic purposes, which in the case of a spinal cord stimulator for chronic pain can be to produce paresthesia at a desired location. To this end, the stimulating electrodes are used to deliver stimulation at any therapeutically suitable frequency (e.g., 30 Hz, but other frequencies including up to the kHz range can also be used), and / or the stimulation can be delivered in a non-periodic manner (depending on the patient), such as in bursts or sporadic. In order to adapt the device, clinicians apply various configurations of stimulation that attempt to produce the sensation that the user experiences as paresthesia. When a stimulation configuration that induces paresthesia is found, the location and size of the paresthesia is consistent with the area of the user's body affected by pain, and the clinician recommends continued use of the configuration.
[0055] The device 100 is further configured to sense the presence and strength of a compound action potential (CAP) propagating along the nerve 180, whether such CAP is induced by stimulation from electrodes 1 to 3 or otherwise. To this end, the electrode selection module 126 can select any electrode in the array 150 to act as a measurement electrode 6 and a measurement reference electrode 8. The signals sensed by the measurement electrodes 6 and 8 are transmitted to the measurement circuit system 128, which can, for example, operate according to the teachings of the applicant's international patent application publication number WO 2012155183, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. The controller 116 uses the output of the circuit system 128 in a feedback arrangement to control the application of subsequent stimulation, and the controller 116 also stores a record of the neural response or one or more parameters thereof (such as ECAP amplitude) to the clinical data storage device 120.
[0056] To ensure patient safety, it is necessary to ensure that stimulation is delivered in a charge-balanced manner and that bidirectional current flows through each stimulation electrode to counteract the electrochemical effects that inevitably occur at the electrode-tissue interface. This imposes some restrictions on the permissible stimulation configurations that can be used in any practical neurostimulation device. 4A to 4D As depicted in , the conventional stimulation used in such devices is biphasic bipolar stimulation. Figure 4A The distribution of stimulation current over time is shown. Figure 4B and Figure 4C The delivery of each corresponding stimulation phase to the nerve is shown. Figure 4D demonstrated that biphasic bipolar stimulation inevitably delivers at least two suprathreshold stimulation components.
[0057] In this conventional biphasic bipolar stimulation arrangement, the first stimulation phase delivers current from electrode 402, and current is returned by electrode 401. In the second phase, equal and opposite currents are delivered, that is, current is delivered from electrode 401 and returned by electrode 402. Thus, the stimulation is biphasic because it delivers two phases, and bipolar because it utilizes two electrodes. Figure 4D As shown, for effective treatment, the stimulation amplitude must be set to the cathodic comfort level. The magnitude of the cathodic comfort level is usually less than the anodal threshold level, which means that only the cathodic stimulation component of each phase will cause neural recruitment.
[0058] However, due to the above safety restrictions, the first phase ( Figure 4B ) the cathode excitation of electrode 402 is equal to the second phase ( Figure 4C ) the cathode of electrode 401 is excited, but separated in time by t1. At the first time, in phase 1 ( Figure 4B), cathodic excitation of electrode 402 induces neural responses only at the node(s) of Ranvier 422 triggered by electrode 402, depicted for illustration purposes by excitation range 412. At a second time later than the first time t1, at a second phase ( Figure 4C ), cathodic excitation of electrode 401 induces neural responses only at the node(s) of Ranvier 421 triggered by electrode 401, depicted for illustration purposes by excitation range 411. It should be noted that excitation range 412 is adjacent to electrode 402 and is not connected to excitation range 411 of adjacent electrode 401. Thus, the stimulation sites in the first phase are at least partially different, or even completely different, from the stimulation sites in the second phase of stimulation.
[0059] Although for typical values of t1, a given axon recruited in the first phase will typically be refractory during the second phase and will not be recruited again, other axons that were not recruited in the first phase (not in the 4A to 4D ) are still available for being excited by the second phase in the manner described. The corresponding fiber subpopulation available for recruitment in the second phase is unknown or at least poorly understood, which introduces considerable uncertainty into the corresponding amplitude of the composite response that may occur in the second phase.
[0060] Thus, biphasic bipolar stimulation typically induces a composite response consisting of neural response components that occur at different times and in different locations with unequal amplitudes to an unknown degree. These neural response components overlap in and jointly contribute to the electrical observation of the overall neural response, which greatly hinders attempts to accurately understand the actual recruitment effect of each component of the stimulation.
[0061] and 4A to 4D In contrast to conventional bipolar biphasic stimulation as shown in , the present invention proposes a tripolar (or larger) stimulation that is configured in a specific way to seek a paradigm in which only one component of the stimulation recruits any neural response. When implemented, the result means that the compound action potential generated can be associated with a specific single stimulation site and a specific single stimulation time for purposes such as those described in International Patent Publication No. WO 2016 / 161484 of the applicant, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. The determination of conduction velocity can also be improved because the stimulation site and time are known with greater accuracy, and because the time span of the observed response is smaller, resulting in sharper peaks, and thus the resolution of the time of occurrence of such peaks can be improved when evaluating arrival times for conduction velocity determination.
[0062] Figure 5A and Figure 5B An embodiment of the present invention implemented by biphasic tripolar stimulation is shown. Figure 5AIn the first phase shown, stimulation electrodes 501 and 503 are cathodic and deliver current to the tissue, with all current returned by central anodal stimulation electrode 502. For purposes of illustration, electrodes 501 and 503 deliver a nominal 0.5 unit of current, while electrode 502 returns 1 unit of current. Figure 5B In the second phase shown, electrode 502 delivers 1 unit of current, while electrodes 501 and 503 each return 0.5 unit of current. According to the present invention, the current amplitude delivered is carefully selected to ensure that the cathode stimulation threshold is within the range of 0.5 to 1 unit of current, and to ensure that the anode stimulation threshold is greater than 1 unit of current. Therefore, this arrangement provides recruitment caused by a single cathode, with anodes attached to both sides of the single cathode. Therefore, only one phase (the second phase) of the stimulation pattern and only one electrode (electrode 502) will cause any neural recruitment, thereby ensuring that the time and position of the stimulation can be known with the greatest possible accuracy. For example, this can allow the ECAP morphology to be evaluated when it is certain that the second stimulation site and time do not contribute to the ECAP.
[0063] In particular, at stimulation levels of typical neurostimulation practice, the anode currents of electrode 502 in phase 1 and electrodes 501 and 503 in phase 2 can be neglected. This is because the typical stimulation levels required for effective treatment are between the electrophysiological threshold (the current at which ECAP may first be detected) and approximately twice that threshold current. Although anodal recruitment is possible, the threshold current for the anode to produce an action potential is much higher, with the threshold current for anodal excitation typically being about 5 to 8 times that for cathode excitation. The present invention recognizes that this provides a useful operating range within which a single suprathreshold stimulation component can be maintained. In embodiments where tripolar stimulation is used for this purpose, this ensures that the additional cathodes produced on the flanking electrodes (501, 503) in the additional phases are below the threshold for stimulation when the stimulation current is maintained below 2 times the threshold. Therefore, this particular configuration of stimulation ensures that the action potential is produced by a single cathode, i.e., by a single suprathreshold stimulation component of the overall biphasic tripolar stimulation. Our goal was to measure ECAP as close to the location of stimulation as possible and as quickly as possible after stimulation, so stimulation was presented with the anode on the central electrode of the triode in the first phase, allowing the cathodic stimulation component to be presented in the second and last phase of stimulation, allowing measurements to start immediately thereafter.
[0064] For example, ECAP morphological parameters that can be assessed include Figure 6Parameters shown in. A single action potential includes a P1 peak indicating initial depolarization (cell capacitance), followed by an N1 valley or negative peak indicating depolarization (sodium channel activation), and finally a P2 peak indicating hyperpolarization (potassium channel activation). For example, the ECAP morphological parameters that can be evaluated include the following characteristics: such as P1-N1 peak-to-peak amplitude, N1-P2 peak-to-peak amplitude, P1 peak time, P1 peak amplitude, P1 half-peak width, P1-N1 zero-crossing time, P1-N1 zero-crossing slope, N1 peak time, N1 peak amplitude, N1 half-peak width, N1-P2 zero-crossing time, N1-P2 zero-crossing slope, P2 peak time, P2 peak amplitude, P2 half-peak width, etc. Since all of these parameters can respond to the stimulation amplitude nonlinearly if the stimulation recruits neurons at multiple different sites and multiple different times, the embodiments of the present invention can significantly improve the reliability of any or all of such ECAP morphological parameters when used as feedback variables or as diagnostic indicators, etc.
[0065] Figure 7 An embodiment of the invention is shown that utilizes a first arrangement of current sources to drive a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement according to one embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, two current sources 710 and 720 are used to achieve unequal current sharing between electrodes 1 and 3. Electrode 2 is simply grounded to provide a return path for the entire current delivered by the current sources.
[0066] Figure 8 Another embodiment of the invention is shown that uses a second arrangement of current sources to drive a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement according to another embodiment of the invention. In this embodiment, each of electrode 1, electrode 2 and electrode 3 is provided with a corresponding single-ended current source 810, 820, 830. The current sources are configured to deliver corresponding individual single-ended drive current distributions represented by e1, e2 and e3.
[0067] Fig. 9 Another embodiment of the invention is shown which uses another arrangement of current sources to drive a tripolar stimulation electrode arrangement according to another embodiment of the invention. This is equivalent to Figure 8 A single-ended drive arrangement is a differential drive arrangement.
[0068] Thus, using three electrodes in this manner to achieve tripolar stimulation in this embodiment means that in the first phase of biphasic stimulation, the stimulation current is supplied from electrodes 1 and 3 ( Figure 3 , Figure 7 , Figure 8 , Fig. 9) (in this first phase, the electrode is cathodic), and the entire return current is carried by electrode 2, which is anodal. And, in the second phase of biphasic stimulation, the entire stimulation current is delivered from electrode 2, which is cathodic in this phase, and the return current is shared between return electrode 1 and return electrode 3 (in this phase, the electrodes are anodic). Therefore, in the first and second phases of stimulation, the sum of the current through electrode 1 (I1) and the current through electrode 3 (I3) is equal and opposite to the current through electrode 2 (I2). That is, I1+I3=-I2.
[0069] The present invention recognizes that it is possible to ensure that only one of these stimulation components will induce a neural response, namely the cathodic current on electrode 2. This is because tripolar stimulation can be arranged so that the cathodic current on electrodes 1 and 3 in phase 1 never exceeds about half of the cathodic current delivered by electrode 2 in phase 2. Thus, the cathodic current on electrodes 1 and 3 can be maintained below the stimulation threshold in the first phase, while the cathodic current on electrode 2 in the second phase is maintained above the stimulation threshold. And, although for safety reasons the anodic current on electrode 2 in the first phase must typically be substantially equal (but opposite) to the cathodic current on electrode 2 in the second phase, the anodic stimulation threshold is typically greater than the cathodic stimulation threshold, so that the anodic current on electrode 2 in the first phase can be maintained below the anodic stimulation threshold, while the (equal but opposite) cathodic current on electrode 2 in the second phase is maintained above the cathodic stimulation threshold.
[0070] Thus, biphasic tripolar stimulation can be configured to meet the requirement of charge balance and further meet the requirement to reverse all electrochemical effects at the electrode-tissue interface by using alternating current at each electrode, while still delivering stimulation in which only one stimulation component induces a neural response.
[0071] Further benefits and embodiments of the present invention are also contemplated. In this regard, it should be noted that one area of application of some embodiments of the present invention is spinal cord stimulation therapy, which achieves its therapeutic benefits by stimulating the dorsal columns of the spinal cord using electrodes placed in the epidural space. The dorsal columns are arranged so that the layers within the dorsal columns that diverge away from the midline carry nerve fibers that innervate specific areas (or dermatomes) of the body. The goal of spinal cord electrical stimulation therapy is to recruit those fibers that correspond to the dermatomes where pain is present. Stimulating in adjacent areas where pain is not present may be uncomfortable for the recipient of the device, to the extent that stimulation in unwanted areas may cause the recipient to discontinue their treatment.
[0072] There is considerable variation in the current required to achieve consistent recruitment of dorsal column fibers, and feedback loops have been established to maintain recruitment at a constant desired level. One technique relies on the use of electrically evoked compound action potentials as a measure of spinal cord excitation, as described in International Patent Publication No. WO 2012 / 155188 of the present applicant, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. When considering the use of ECAPs as an aid in establishing programming parameters that can be used to maintain consistent recruitment of a desired dermatomal area as much as possible, the present invention recognizes that ECAPs induced by conventional biphasic bipolar stimulation at multiple sites and / or at multiple different times can complicate the task of interpreting the observed ECAPs, thereby hindering effective treatment.
[0073] Cathodic current has a higher recruitment efficiency than anodic current, so it is desirable to use cathodic current, but monophasic pulses are unsafe, so the anodic current must be followed shortly after the cathodic current to reverse the potential. This has the effect of reversing any electrochemical processes that have occurred on the electrode surface. The duration and amplitude of this balancing pulse can be different from the duration and amplitude of the cathodic pulse (but of opposite sign), provided that the charge delivered during these two phases (duration*amplitude) is the same.
[0074] The simplest form of charge reversal is to use a biphasic stimulation pulse. The spread of the electric field from the stimulation is controlled by the spacing between the electrodes, which for SCS devices are usually electrodes on the same lead. As shown in Figure 4, stimulation occurs first at the cathode or anode. In the illustration, the cathode phase and the anode phase have the same pulse width but opposite signs, which causes the current to flow to negative (from positive, as per convention) in the first phase and then reverse in the second phase, where the positions of the anode and cathode are swapped.
[0075] The net result of this is that for each single biphasic stimulus, two cathodes are produced, one from the first phase and one from the second phase. In an ideal situation, with the cathode first, the stimulation recruits fibers, which then enter their refractory period and remain so during the presentation of the second phase. In this ideal situation, the recruitment of any additional fibers does not occur, and the stimulation location is mapped to a single electrode.
[0076] However, the present invention recognizes that in practice this is not possible. In addition to the reasons discussed above, it is important to note the possibility of misalignment of the electrodes with the axis of propagation of the action potential, such as Fig. 10A and Fig. 10BThis misalignment can be due to surgical misalignment of the electrode leads adjacent to the nerve, and / or due to individual nerve fibers taking a slightly tortuous path within the nerve (which is known to occur). In the case of such misalignment of the electrodes with the axis of propagation of the action potential, the first cathode will produce a partially depolarized membrane but will not be able to initiate an action potential, whereas the second cathode can initiate an action potential if it is present within a sufficiently short window. This geometric limit is Fig. 10A and Fig. 10B The first phase of stimulation recruits one group of fibers, and the second phase recruits some additional fibers that were not recruited by the first phase of stimulation. When the fibers recruited in these two phases correspond to different dermatomal areas, this will result in the stimulation being perceived at different locations and may result in stimulation at undesired locations. Indeed, in Fig. 10B In some cases, such misalignment may even result in the recruitment of dermatomes on the wrong side of the body, e.g., if stimulation of the right side is desired, such a geometric misalignment may inappropriately increase the chances of erroneous stimulation of the left side of the body.
[0077] Maintaining recruitment at a single site has not only geometrical limitations but also temporal limitations. The stimulating current not only depolarizes a region of the nerve to generate an action potential, but also, because of the nature of the electric field, partially depolarizes a larger region surrounding the region where the action potential has already been generated. Fig.11A Bipolar stimulation is often used during SCS, and the first phase anode 1120 is often the electrode adjacent to the cathode stimulation electrode 1110. Fig.11A As shown, a first phase of cathodal stimulation delivered by electrode 1110 produces an area on the nerve where the axon will depolarize and initiate an action potential. In the annular region surrounding this area is a second area where the excitation is sufficient to cause partial depolarization of the membrane to an extent that will not cause an action potential, but will cause a change in membrane conditions after the second phase is applied.
[0078] Fig. 11B The regions of the nerve excited by the second phase are shown. In these cases, even if the geometric alignment of the electrode array to the nerve is precise and the field from the second cathode is applied only to fibers recruited by the first phase, the second phase produces a second partially depolarized region, and the overlap of this region with the partially depolarized region produced by the first phase produces additional action potentials, thereby creating another undesirable mechanism whereby the timing and location of recruitment are confounded by the configuration of the applied stimulation.
[0079] The situation is further complicated when other confounding factors are considered. For example, the stimulation thresholds of the two different locations of the first cathode 1110 and the second cathode 1120 may be different from each other. In the case where the activation threshold is higher under the second cathode 1120, the stimulation intensity in the undesirable corresponding dermatome location will be stronger. In the most extreme case, that is, the threshold of the first cathode 1110 is the highest among all available electrodes, but it is the most suitable electrode to use corresponding to the painful dermatome, then without the stimulation of the electrode 1120 in the unwanted area, the stimulation of the painful area can never be achieved with biphasic stimulation, which can lead to non-acceptance of treatment or decreased performance.
[0080] Variations in recruitment with changes in posture further confuse the intended target of stimulation. It is desirable to produce a device that achieves closed-loop control of the ECAP amplitude to provide additional benefits to the recipient, the most important of which is the elimination of therapeutic variations due to postural effects. Ideally, the ECAP amplitude will maintain the same shape, but the amplitude will grow as the stimulation current increases, in the form of k(IT)x(t), where T is the threshold and k is the gain term. That is, in this ideal case, the shape of the ECAP is linearly proportional to the current. This will provide the key benefit of allowing simple detector designs, one of which may include simply calculating the dot product of the signal with a suitably designed filter function, as described in WO 2015 / 074121 of the present applicant. In the case of any stimulation design that produces recruitment at two locations and two different times, any small threshold change between the two locations will produce an ECAP shape that changes with increasing current, thereby invalidating the assumption of a linear ECAP amplitude response and greatly complicating the task of evaluating recruitment from the detected ECAP.
[0081] Fig.12 The problem of nonlinear ECAP growth caused by multiple stimulation sites and times in conventional biphasic bipolar stimulation is further demonstrated. Between the threshold of the first cathode and the threshold of the second cathode, there is a first ECAP shape A. Above the threshold of the second cathode, another ECAP shape B appears. For certain combinations of distance between electrodes and fiber population conduction velocity, the negative and positive peaks of the ECAP can align with each other, thereby canceling each other out. This in turn creates the following situation, that is, increasing the stimulation current will conversely produce a decrease in the ECAP amplitude, which leads to feedback loop instability during closed-loop control. Therefore, it is very desirable to detect and eliminate any second cathode effect, especially for closed-loop controlled neuromodulation, because this allows the detector to be simplified and the loop stability to be improved.
[0082] Because the two stimulation modes (first cathode, second cathode) can have different thresholds and ECAPs are initiated at different locations along the dorsal column, the ECAP morphology can vary with current. When the stimulation current increases from a subthreshold level to reach the first threshold, ECAP shape A appears. When the stimulation current is further increased and reaches the second threshold, a second ECAP B appears. ECAP B has the same shape as ECAP A, but is offset in time from the first. The sum of A and B has a different shape, and this composite response can be observed by the recording electrode and the accompanying measurement circuit system and ECAP detector module. The second ECAP may cause the detector output to drop instead of rise, resulting in loop instability or performance degradation.
[0083] These nonlinear effects do not occur when recruitment occurs only at a single stimulation site at a single time, as occurs according to embodiments of the present invention. In such cases, ECAPs with constant shape emerge and grow linearly with stimulation amplitude, which is desirable to alleviate the difficult ECAP detection task.
[0084] In order to optimize the stimulation paradigm to better target the desired dermatome, some embodiments of the present invention further take steps to actively identify whether secondary cathodal stimulation is occurring, and take steps to prevent secondary cathodal stimulation when detected. It is not possible to detect the occurrence of secondary cathodal stimulation based on patient feedback because as the current increases in a uniform manner in both desired and undesired areas, the perceived intensity also increases, making it impossible for the patient to discern any useful distinction to report. However, these embodiments of the present invention recognize that identification of the secondary cathodal effect can be achieved through measurement of electrically evoked compound action potentials.
[0085] like Fig.12 As depicted in , the recorded potential is the sum of the potentials generated by the first cathode and the second cathode. Therefore, the ECAP actually measured by the recording electrode at a distance from the stimulation electrode is the sum of the responses 1210 and 1220 from these two cathodes, which are initiated at different times during the stimulation cycle. Although the record obtained from the recording electrode can only reflect the composite response 1230 composed of components 1210 and 1220 together, the present invention recognizes that there are multiple ways to detect whether the second cathode stimulation is occurring.
[0086] A first way to detect a second cathodal stimulation is to examine the recorded responses 1230 to identify if there are two observable N1 peaks, which may occur when the two cathodes are separated by a suitable distance. However, this method fails to identify many scenarios where a second cathodal stimulation occurs but does not exhibit two observable N1 peaks.
[0087] Therefore, an alternative method of detecting the presence of a second cathodal stimulus involves changing pulse parameters that do not affect recruitment but that would cause changes in the observed compound action potential if any second cathodal stimulus occurred. One example shown in Figure 13 involves changing the interphase gap. A first stimulus 1310 is applied having a first interphase gap between two phases of the stimulus. A first record 1340 of the resulting ECAPs is obtained. A second stimulus 1360 is applied at another time having a second interphase gap that is different from the first interphase gap. Both the first interphase gap and the second interphase gap should be maintained within the absolute refractory period, which can be measured, for example, according to the teachings of the applicant's International Patent Publication No. WO 2012 / 155189, the contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. As Fig.13A and Fig. 13B As shown, because each phase of stimulation 1310 and 1360 is the same, the corresponding reaction components 1320 and 1370 are the same, and the corresponding reaction components 1330 and 1380 are the same. However, the time intervals between the various reaction components are different, so that the composite reactions 1340 and 1390 are different and can therefore be examined for indicia of a second cathodal stimulation. For example, a comparison of ECAP parameters (such as one or more peak amplitudes, one or more peak-to-peak amplitudes, and / or one or more peak widths) allows the detection of different morphologies of reactions 1340 and 1390. The degree to which such metrics (or combinations thereof) differ can be considered to indicate the degree to which a second cathodal stimulation occurred, which in turn can be used, for example, to control a feedback loop gain or assist in PID loop control to, for example, avoid overshoot and thereby control the speed of the system's reaction to a detected second cathodal stimulation.
[0088] According to embodiments of the present invention, there are many alternatives for detecting the presence of a second cathode stimulation. For example, one such embodiment may utilize a set of stimulation electrodes, and deliver a first stimulation from a subset of these electrodes and measure a first neural response induced by the first stimulation. Then, a second stimulation may be delivered from a different subset of these electrodes and a second neural response induced by the second stimulation may be measured. As long as the position of the stimulation electrodes relative to each other remains the same, and assuming the threshold for cathode stimulation is the same, a comparison of the first neural response with the second neural response will produce an indication of whether a second cathode stimulation is present.
[0089] Fig.14A further embodiment of the present invention is presented which further provides for automatic optimization of the stimulation sequence to remove the second cathodal effect. This detection method provides a means of optimizing the stimulation parameters to avoid the undesirable effects of the second cathodal stimulation described above. It should be noted that even when utilizing tripolar stimulation such as taught in FIG. 5 , it is still possible that the cathodal stimulation thresholds of electrodes 501 and / or 503 may feasibly be significantly lower than the cathodal stimulation threshold of electrode 502, and in such a case, the 0.5 unit of cathodal excitation delivered from electrodes 501 and 503 in phase 1 may induce a second or even a third cathodal stimulation. Therefore, even when utilizing such a tripolar stimulation configuration, it is still desirable to monitor for any instances of second cathodal stimulation. Therefore, in Fig.14 In an embodiment of the present invention, the following process is implemented: tripolar stimulation is automatically adjusted based on the detection of any second cathode effect, thereby iteratively adjusting one or more stimulation parameters. For example, in the tripolar stimulation mode, the stimulation threshold can be increased by extending the pulse width of the corresponding anodic phase and reducing the current amplitude (i.e., the recruitment of electrodes 501 and 503 can be reduced and preferably eliminated), which is therapeutically acceptable, provided that (1) the total time of the two phases is less than the refractory period and (2) the same charge is delivered in the two phases. Within these limits, the stimulation can be adjusted to prevent any form of second cathode stimulation.
[0090] In further embodiments of the present invention, further parameters may be modified to seek to eliminate the second cathode effect, including, for example, increasing the number of anodes, increasing the number of stimulation electrodes from three to five in order to transition from tripolar to pentapolar stimulation, or using four stimulation electrodes and three return electrodes in an offset-quadrupole arrangement, adjusting the current sharing between electrodes to be unequal to improve elimination of the second cathode secondary, increasing the number of stimulation phases to provide greater ability to keep subthreshold components further below the corresponding stimulation threshold, and the like.
[0091] Fig.15 The system for implementing feedback-controlled neural stimulation using the above principles according to an embodiment of the present invention is schematically shown. In particular, the control block 1510 is configured to control the current sharing ratio defined by parameter A, and is also configured to control multipolar mode selection and multiphase mode selection according to the above principles.
[0092] Fig.16 A three-phase tripolar stimulation configuration according to another embodiment of the present invention is shown. In this embodiment, the second phase (denoted as 1624) delivered on electrode E2 is configured as the only cathode stimulation component that triggers a neural response. This is because the stimulation component 1624 is the only component that exceeds the stimulation threshold (i.e., the cathode stimulation threshold 1650). The stimulation component 1624 is set to an amplitude that triggers a desired therapeutic effect, referred to as a cathode comfort level 1662.
[0093] All other components of the stimulation can then be derived from the amplitude of the stimulation component 1624. Specifically, if we define the amplitude of the stimulation component 1624 as X, then the anodal stimulation components 1614 and 1634 delivered by electrodes E1 and E3, respectively, should take an amplitude of 0.5X to achieve 100% current return in the second phase. The anodal stimulation components 1614 and 1634 may take alternative amplitudes (such as 0.7 and 0.3, respectively), provided that the net anodal amplitude adds to X to achieve 100% current return in the second phase.
[0094] Similarly, the anodal stimulation components 1622 and 1626 delivered by electrode E2 in the first phase and the third phase, respectively, should each take an amplitude of 0.5X to achieve current balance of electrode E2 over the three phases. Anodal stimulation components 1622 and 1626 may take alternative amplitudes (such as 0.7 and 0.3, respectively), provided that the net anodal amplitudes of these components add to X to achieve current balance of electrode E2 over the three phases.
[0095] Finally, the cathodal stimulation components 1612 and 1632 delivered by electrodes El and E3, respectively, in the first phase should each take a value of 0.25X, or should at least sum to 0.5X, to achieve 100% current return in the first phase. Similarly, the cathodal stimulation components 1616 and 1636 delivered by electrodes El and E3, respectively, in the third phase should each take a value of 0.25X, or these components should at least sum to 0.5X, to achieve 100% current return in the third phase. A further limitation is that over these three phases, current balance should be achieved for electrode El and current balance should be achieved for electrode E3, which can be easily achieved across.
[0096] therefore, Fig.16 The embodiment of provides that the cathodal stimulation component 1624 is four times greater than any other cathodal stimulation component (1612, 1616, 1632, 1636), thereby allowing the amplitude of component 1624 to vary significantly for therapeutic purposes while keeping all other cathodal stimulation components below threshold. It is further noted that the anodal stimulation component delivered by any electrode does not exceed the corresponding anodal stimulation threshold (1641, 1642, 1643). Therefore, Fig.16 The stimulation configuration provides the desired single cathode neural excitation.
[0097] exist Fig.16 In the example of FIG. 1 , the anode threshold is indicated as being twice the size of the cathode threshold, but it should be understood that in other embodiments within the scope of the present invention, this relationship may be different.
[0098] Fig.17Ashows the polarity of the electrodes in a single phase of a quadripolar stimulation configuration according to another embodiment of the present invention, and Fig. 17B The polarity of the electrodes in a single phase of a pentapole stimulation configuration according to a further embodiment of the present invention is shown. Fig.16 Describing the principles in detail, these multipolar configurations enable current returns to be shared among a large number of return electrodes and thus introduce greater freedom to configure biphasic or multiphasic stimulation in a manner that ensures that only one stimulation component causes neural recruitment.
[0099] For example, Fig.18 A three-phase quadrupolar stimulation configuration according to yet another embodiment of the present invention is shown. This configuration allows the amplitude of the cathode stimulation component delivered by electrodes E1, E3 and E4 in the first and third phases to be only one-sixth of the amplitude of the suprathreshold stimulation component delivered by electrode E2 in the second phase. This provides additional operational freedom for selecting the amplitude of a single suprathreshold stimulation component while maintaining all other stimulation components below threshold. Fig. 17B The pentapole configuration can be used to provide one-eighth the three-phase amplitude, while increasing the number of phases can additionally or alternatively be used to provide further operational freedom in selecting the amplitude of a single suprathreshold stimulation component.
[0100] Those skilled in the art will appreciate that, without departing from the spirit or scope of the invention as broadly described, many changes and / or modifications may be made to the invention as shown in the specific embodiments. Therefore, the present embodiments should be considered in all aspects as illustrative rather than restrictive or limiting.
Claims
1. A neural stimulation device comprising: at least three stimulation electrodes configured to deliver electrical stimulation to neural tissue; as well as A control unit is configured to deliver a first stimulation phase, wherein a first stimulation electrode among the stimulation electrodes delivers a suprathreshold stimulation component returned by at least two return electrodes among the stimulation electrodes, and the control unit is further configured to deliver at least a second stimulation phase, wherein the at least two return electrodes deliver a subthreshold stimulation component returned by the first stimulation electrode.
2. The device according to claim 1, wherein: The electrical stimulation comprises at least three phases delivered by at least three electrodes, and the electrical stimulation is configured such that in one of the phases only one stimulation component from one electrode is a suprathreshold cathodal stimulation component.
3. The device of claim 2, wherein: The suprathreshold cathodal stimulation component is delivered in the final phase of the stimulation.
4. The device of claim 1 configured to deliver quadripolar stimulation using four stimulation electrodes.
5. The device of claim 4 configured to deliver offset quadripolar stimulation whereby the suprathreshold stimulation component is delivered by one electrode and returned by three electrodes.
6. The device of claim 1, further configured to adaptively select the number of stimulation electrodes to optimally minimize the second cathode stimulation by switching between multipolar stimulation modes.
7. The device of claim 1, wherein: The current carried by the first stimulation electrode is returned equally between two or more return electrodes.
8. The device of claim 1, wherein: The current carried by the first stimulation electrode is returned unequally between two or more return electrodes.
9. The device of claim 8, wherein: The unequal currents carried by the two or more return electrodes are configured to employ unequal amounts that minimize stimulation artifacts at the recording electrode.
10. The apparatus of claim 1, comprising: a respective current source for each electrode, the current source being configured to drive a desired current through the respective electrode during each phase of the stimulation.
11. The apparatus of claim 1, comprising: Respective current sources are located between adjacent pairs of stimulation electrodes, the current sources being used to achieve differential drive of the desired current through each electrode.
12. The device of claim 1 configured to selectively connect one or more of the stimulation electrodes directly to a power supply rail to act as a return electrode.
13. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein: The first stimulation electrode is interposed between two or more return electrodes.
14. The apparatus of claim 1, wherein: The first stimulation electrode is positioned to one side of all return electrodes of the two or more return electrodes.
15. The apparatus of claim 1, further comprising: Recording electrodes and measurement circuitry configured to obtain one or more recordings of neural responses evoked by the stimulation.
16. The device of claim 15, further configured to evaluate the one or more recordings of the neural responses and identify whether a second cathodal stimulation is occurring.
17. The apparatus of claim 16, configured to apply stimulation having a constant amplitude but having one or more different interphase gaps, observe the evoked compound action potential ECAP induced by each such stimulation, and compare the morphology of each such observed ECAP to detect a marker of a second cathode stimulation.
18. The apparatus of claim 16, configured to detect a second cathode stimulation by applying stimulation having a constant amplitude but having a different stimulation phase sequence, observing an evoked compound action potential ECAP induced by each such stimulation, and comparing the morphology of each such observed ECAP to detect a marker of the second cathode stimulation.
19. The device of claim 16, further configured to use the results of the second cathodal stimulation when detected to adjust the stimulation paradigm to seek to prevent or reduce the second cathodal stimulation.
20. The device as described in claim 15 is further configured to perform automatic stimulation amplitude determination by applying stimulation with subthreshold amplitude and suprathreshold amplitude and observing the corresponding induced ECAP response, determining the stimulation amplitude threshold for the first induced ECAP response therefrom, and setting the ongoing treatment stimulation amplitude to a multiple of the stimulation amplitude threshold.
21. The apparatus of claim 20, wherein: The ongoing therapeutic stimulation amplitude is set to a multiple within the range of 1.05 to 1.8 of the stimulation amplitude threshold.
22. The device of claim 21 configured to set the ongoing therapeutic stimulation amplitude to a multiple of 1.2 times the stimulation amplitude threshold.
23. A computer program product comprising computer program code means for causing a neurostimulator to execute a program for neurostimulation, the computer program product comprising computer program code means for: Electrical stimulation is delivered to neural tissue using at least three stimulation electrodes, the electrical stimulation comprising a first stimulation phase, wherein: A first one of the stimulation electrodes delivers a suprathreshold stimulation component that is returned by at least two return electrodes of the stimulation electrodes, and the electrical stimulation further includes at least a second stimulation phase, wherein the at least two return electrodes deliver a subthreshold stimulation component that is returned by the first stimulation electrode.
