Evaluation method, system, equipment and medium for judges in the field of bidding

By analyzing the scoring data of the judges, building an evaluation index system and identifying abnormal scoring behaviors, the problem of inability to effectively judge the scoring behaviors of the judges in the existing technology is solved, and a comprehensive understanding and supervision of the scoring habits and tendencies of the judges is achieved.

CN115099571BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-03南京市公共资源交易中心
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210566513.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-05-24
Publication Date
2024-12-03
Estimated Expiration
2042-05-24

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

There is a lack of comprehensive analysis and display of judges' scoring behavior in the digitalization and intelligence of existing public resource transactions, and it is impossible to effectively judge whether the judges have abnormal scoring behavior.

Method used

A judge's evaluation method based on the bidding field is proposed. By obtaining the jury's score value data of the judges' scores on bidders, calculating indicators such as scoring habits, review tendencies, and scoring deviations of winning bidders, building an evaluation index system, and identifying and warning abnormal scoring data.

Benefits of technology

An objective evaluation of the judges' scoring behavior has been achieved, a comprehensive understanding of the judges' scoring habits and tendencies, timely identify and warn of abnormal scoring behaviors, and strengthen supervision of the bid evaluation process.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN115099571B_ABST
    Figure CN115099571B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method, system and medium for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering, and belongs to the field of public resource trading technology. The present invention includes obtaining numerical data of bid evaluation scores of multiple judges on multiple bidders in multiple bidding sections; conducting a multi-faceted evaluation of the judges based on multiple calculation processes; and constructing an evaluation index system for evaluating the judges. The present invention focuses on displaying the scoring behavior, scoring habits and bid evaluation association of the judges, and by analyzing various elements of the judges, judging the scoring tendency and abnormal behavior of the judges, further strengthening the precise targeted supervision of the judges and the bid evaluation process.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a judge evaluation method, system, equipment and medium based on the bidding field, belonging to the technical field of public resource transactions. Background Art

[0002] Public resource trading refers to the trading, consulting and service provision of public welfare, monopoly and proprietary social public resources controlled by public resource management departments, such as municipal utility franchises, administrative and public institutions' logistics social service operating rights, outdoor billboard operating rights, anti-smuggling confiscated public property auctions, real estate and office building property leasing, rental car operating licenses, auspicious car license plates, administrative and public institutions' waste material disposal, etc. With the continuous development of information network technology, the digitalization and intelligence of public resource trading is becoming more and more popular.

[0003] In the existing digital and intelligent process of public resource transactions, there are already inventions of intelligent bidding and intelligent judgment of bidder qualifications. However, the existing technology still lacks comprehensive analysis and display of judges in the bidding process, and it is impossible to intuitively and comprehensively understand the information of expert judges. There is no digital and complete system for judging whether the judges have abnormal scoring behavior. Therefore, an objective evaluation scheme for judges is needed. Summary of the invention

[0004] The present invention proposes a judge evaluation method, system, equipment and medium based on the bidding field, in order to more comprehensively understand the judges' scoring behavior, scoring habits, evaluation correlation, etc., and to judge the scoring tendency and abnormal scoring behavior of the judges.

[0005] In order to achieve the above purpose, the technical solution adopted in this aspect is:

[0006] As a first aspect of the present invention, a method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering specifically comprises the following steps:

[0007] Obtain the numerical data of bid evaluation scores given by multiple evaluators to multiple bidders in multiple bidding sections;

[0008] Based on the bid evaluation scoring numerical data, the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of the certain evaluator to all bidders, the scoring habit of the certain evaluator is evaluated;

[0009] Based on the average of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge and the average of all the scoring values ​​of all the judges in the bid evaluation scoring numerical data, evaluating the evaluation tendency of the certain judge in relation to all the judges;

[0010] Based on the score value of a certain evaluator in a certain bidding section who gave the bidder as the winning bidder and the average score of all evaluators on the bidder in the bid evaluation score numerical data, an evaluation is performed on the deviation of the score of the certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the score of all evaluators on the winning bidder;

[0011] Based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all evaluators to the certain bidder in the bid evaluation score value data, the deviation of the tendency of the certain evaluator from all evaluators is evaluated;

[0012] Based on the score value of a certain evaluator in a certain bidding section to a certain bidder and the average score of all bidders given by the certain evaluator in the bid evaluation score value data, the evaluation tendency of the certain evaluator to the certain bidder is evaluated;

[0013] An evaluation index system for evaluating the judges is constructed, and the evaluation index system includes two first-level indicators: judges' inertia and bid section scoring; the judges' inertia includes three second-level indicators: scoring habits, review tendencies, and deviations from the scoring of the winning bidder; the bid section scoring includes two second-level indicators: deviation from the tendencies of all judges and review tendencies toward a certain bidder.

[0014] A further improvement of the above scheme is that: the scoring habit of a certain judge is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: Assume that the scoring data of a certain judge for n bidders in a certain bidding section are x1, x2, ..., x n , then the calculation formula for the standard deviation s of the judge's score in this bid section is: in The standard deviation is the divergence of the judges' scores.

[0015] A further improvement of the above scheme is that: the evaluation tendency between the certain judge and all the judges is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: suppose the mean value of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge is w, and the mean value of all the scoring values ​​of all the judges is p, then the scoring deviation value r is calculated as: This is the deviation of the judges' scores.

[0016] A further improvement of the above scheme is to evaluate the deviation between the score given by a certain judge to the winning bidder and the score given by all judges to the winning bidder, and the calculation process is as follows: let the score given by a certain judge to the bidder as the winning bidder be c, and the average score given by all judges to the bidder as the winning bidder be v, then the calculation formula for the deviation value b of the score given by a certain judge to the winning bidder is:

[0017] A further improvement of the above scheme is to evaluate the deviation of the tendency of a certain judge from all judges. The calculation process is as follows: suppose the score value k given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section, and the average score of all judges to the certain bidder is f. If there are i bidders in total, the calculation formula of the group deviation t of the judges is: t i =(k i -f i ) / f i .

[0018] A further improvement of the above scheme is that: the evaluation tendency of a certain judge to a certain bidder is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: suppose the score value g given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section, and the average score j given by the certain judge to all bidders, if there are d bidders in total, then the calculation formula of the judge's own deviation r value is:

[0019] r d =(g d -j d ) / j d .

[0020] A further improvement of the above scheme is that the method also includes classifying all judges based on the standard deviation of their scores in all bidding sections, and obtaining the following classifications: normal score difference, small score difference, large score difference, too small score difference and too large score difference.

[0021] A further improvement of the above scheme is that: the method further includes identifying abnormal scoring data of the judges, and issuing an early warning to the judges with the abnormal scoring data;

[0022] The early warning process includes:

[0023] S1: Obtain the evaluation index system;

[0024] S2: Setting the warning limits of the secondary indicators, i.e., the warning limits of the scoring habits, evaluation tendency, deviation of the scoring of the winning bidder, deviation of the tendency of all the evaluators, and evaluation tendency of a certain bidder;

[0025] S3: Obtain the bid evaluation score numerical data, calculate the scoring habits, evaluation tendency, deviation of the scoring of the bid winner, deviation from the tendency of all the judges and evaluation tendency for a certain bidder of the judges;

[0026] S4: Compare the secondary indicator of the judge with the warning limit:

[0027] If the judges' scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and evaluation tendencies toward a certain bidder are within the warning limits, the judges' behavior is considered normal;

[0028] If the judge's scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and evaluation tendencies toward a certain bidder exceed the warning limits, the judge's behavior is determined to be abnormal.

[0029] As a second aspect of the present invention, a judge evaluation system based on the bidding field includes: a data acquisition module for acquiring bid evaluation score numerical data of multiple judges in multiple bid sections based on public resource transactions;

[0030] The first evaluation module is used to evaluate the scoring habits of a certain evaluator based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of the certain evaluator to all bidders;

[0031] The second evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain judge in relation to all the judges based on the average of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge and the average of all the scoring values ​​of all the judges;

[0032] The third evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation between the score of a certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the scores of all evaluators on the winning bidder in a certain bidding section based on the score value of the certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the average score of all evaluators on the bidder;

[0033] A fourth evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation of a certain evaluator from all the evaluators based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all the evaluators to the certain bidder;

[0034] A fifth evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain evaluator towards a certain bidder based on the score value of the certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of the certain evaluator to all bidders;

[0035] A calculation module, used to implement the calculation process of the system;

[0036] The early warning analysis module is used to identify abnormal scoring data of the judges and issue early warnings to the judges with the abnormal scoring data.

[0037] As a third aspect of the present invention, a judge evaluation device based on the bidding field includes:

[0038] one or more processors;

[0039] A memory, in which computer program instructions are stored, and when the processor runs the computer program instructions, the judge evaluation device based on the bidding field executes the judge evaluation method based on the bidding field.

[0040] As a fourth aspect of the present invention, a computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program for executing a judge evaluation method based on the bidding field.

[0041] The present invention is suitable for conducting targeted evaluations of judges to provide objective indicators of whether the judges are conscientious and responsible; it centrally displays the judges' scoring behaviors, scoring habits, and evaluation correlations, and through analyzing various factors of the judges, judges' scoring tendencies and abnormal scoring behaviors are judged, thereby further strengthening the precise and targeted supervision of the judges and the evaluation process. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0042] By describing the embodiments of the present application in more detail in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, the above and other purposes, features and advantages of the present application will become more apparent. The accompanying drawings are used to provide a further understanding of the embodiments of the present application and constitute a part of the specification. Together with the embodiments of the present application, they are used to explain the present application and do not constitute a limitation of the present application. In the accompanying drawings, the same reference numerals generally represent the same components or steps.

[0043] Figure 1 The figure illustrates a flow chart of a judges evaluation method based on the bidding and tendering field according to an embodiment of the present application.

[0044] Figure 2 The figure illustrates a flow chart of early warning of abnormal judges according to an embodiment of the present application.

[0045] Figure 3 The figure shows a schematic diagram of a judge evaluation system based on the bidding field according to an embodiment of the present application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0046] Through the description of the embodiments, the specific implementation methods of the present invention, such as the relative positions and connection relationships between the various parts involved, the functions and working principles of the various parts, and the operation and use methods, are further explained in detail to help those skilled in the art to have a more complete, accurate and in-depth understanding of the concept and technical solution of the present invention.

[0047] Example

[0048] like Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the evaluation method for judges in the bidding field specifically includes the following steps:

[0049] S110: Obtaining numerical data of bid evaluation scores given by multiple evaluators to multiple bidders in multiple bidding sections.

[0050] S120: Based on the bid evaluation scoring numerical data, the scoring value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of a certain evaluator to all bidders, the scoring habit of a certain evaluator is evaluated.

[0051] S130: Based on the average of all the scoring values ​​of a certain evaluator and the average of all the scoring values ​​of all evaluators in the bid evaluation scoring numerical data, an evaluation tendency of the certain evaluator relative to all the evaluators is evaluated.

[0052] S140: Based on the bid evaluation score numerical data, the score given by a certain evaluator to the bidder as the winning bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score given by all evaluators to the bidder, evaluate the deviation between the score given by a certain evaluator to the winning bidder and the scores given by all evaluators to the winning bidder.

[0053] S150: Based on the bid evaluation score numerical data, the score value of a certain evaluator on a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all evaluators on the certain bidder, evaluate the deviation of the tendency of the certain evaluator from all evaluators.

[0054] S160: Based on the bid evaluation score numerical data, the score value given by a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score given by a certain evaluator to all bidders, an evaluation tendency of a certain evaluator towards a certain bidder is evaluated.

[0055] S170: Construct an evaluation index system for evaluating judges. The evaluation index system includes two first-level indicators: judges' inertia and section scoring. Judges' inertia includes three second-level indicators: scoring habits, review tendencies, and deviations from the scoring of the winning bidder. Section scoring includes two second-level indicators: deviation from the tendencies of all judges and review tendencies toward a certain bidder.

[0056] Specifically, in step S120, the scoring habit of a certain judge is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: Assume that the scoring data of a certain judge for n bidders in a certain bidding section are x1, x2, ..., x n , then the calculation formula for the standard deviation s of the judge's score in this bid section is: in The standard deviation is the divergence of the judges' scores.

[0057] Specifically, in step S130, the evaluation tendency between a certain judge and all judges is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: Assuming the mean value w of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge and the mean value p of all the scoring values ​​of all judges, the scoring deviation value r is calculated as: This is the deviation of the judges' scores.

[0058] Specifically, in step S140, the deviation between the score given by a certain judge to the winning bidder and the score given by all judges to the winning bidder is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: let the score given by a certain judge to the bidder as the winning bidder be c, and the average score given by all judges to the bidder as the winning bidder be v, then the calculation formula for the deviation value b of the score given by a certain judge to the winning bidder is:

[0059] Specifically, in step S150, the deviation of a certain judge from all the judges is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: suppose the score value k given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section, and the average score f given by all the judges to a certain bidder, if there are i bidders in total, then the calculation formula of the group deviation t of the judges is: t i =(k i -f i ) / f i .

[0060] Specifically, in step S160, a certain evaluator is evaluated for his / her evaluation tendency towards a certain bidder, and the calculation process is as follows: suppose a certain evaluator in a certain bidding section gives a certain bidder a score g, and a certain evaluator gives a certain average score j to all bidders. If there are d bidders in total, the calculation formula for the evaluator's own deviation r is:

[0061] r d =(g d -j d ) / j d .

[0062] Specifically, the method also includes classifying all judges based on the standard deviation of their scoring values ​​in all bidding sections, and obtaining the following classifications: normal scoring gap, small scoring gap, large scoring gap, too small scoring gap and too large scoring gap.

[0063] The process for categorizing all judges by type was as follows:

[0064] Step 1: Obtain the standard deviation of the scores given by all judges in all bid sections;

[0065] Step 2: Get the average of all standard deviations;

[0066] Step 3: Sort the standard deviations of all judges' scores from small to large, and sort the corresponding judges to obtain: Judge 1, Judge 2, ..., Judge n;

[0067] Classify the sorted judges:

[0068] For the 0% to 20% portion of the entire ranking, since the standard deviation of the scoring values ​​is the lowest among all judges, this type of judge is classified as having too small a scoring gap;

[0069] For the 80% to 100% portion of the entire ranking, since the standard deviation of the scoring values ​​is the highest among all the judges, this type of judges is classified as having too large a scoring gap;

[0070] For the 40% to 60% portion of the entire ranking, since the standard deviation of the scoring values ​​is closest to the average value of all judges, this type of judges is classified as having normal scoring differences;

[0071] For the 20% to 40% of the entire ranking, since the standard deviation of the scoring values ​​is lower than that of all judges, this type of judges is classified as having a small scoring gap;

[0072] For 60% to 80% of the entire ranking, since the standard deviation of the score values ​​is higher than that of all judges, this type of judges is classified as having a large score gap.

[0073] The method also includes identifying abnormal scoring data of judges and issuing early warnings to judges with abnormal scoring data;

[0074] The early warning process includes:

[0075] S1: Obtain the evaluation index system;

[0076] S2: Set warning limits for secondary indicators, i.e., scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations from the scoring of the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all evaluators, and warning limits for the evaluation tendencies of a particular bidder;

[0077] S3: Obtain the numerical data of bid evaluation scores, calculate the scoring habits, evaluation tendency, deviation of the score of the winning bidder, deviation from the tendency of all the judges, and evaluation tendency of a certain bidder;

[0078] S4: Compare the judges' secondary indicators with the warning limits:

[0079] If the judges' scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and evaluation tendencies toward a particular bidder are within the warning limits, the judges' behavior is considered normal;

[0080] If the judges' scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and evaluation tendencies toward a particular bidder exceed warning limits, the judges' behavior will be considered abnormal.

[0081] Furthermore, among the three secondary indicators of separation divergence, scoring deviation and winning deviation:

[0082] If the score dispersion is too large, it means that the difference between the scores given by a certain judge to each bidder is too large. If the score dispersion is too small, it means that the difference between the scores given by a certain judge to each bidder is too small.

[0083] If the scoring deviation is too large, it means that the gap between a certain judge and the overall evaluation tendency of all judges is too large. If the scoring deviation is too small, it means that the gap between a certain judge and the overall evaluation tendency of all judges is too small.

[0084] If the deviation of the winning bid is too large, it means that the difference between the score given by a certain judge to a certain winning bidder and the scores given to the winning bidder by all judges is too large. If the deviation of the winning bid is too small, it means that the difference between the score given by a certain judge to a certain winning bidder and the scores given to the winning bidder by all judges is too small.

[0085] Furthermore, among the two secondary indicators of group deviation and self deviation:

[0086] If the group deviation is too large, it means that the difference between the score value given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all judges to the bidder is too large. If the group deviation is too small, it means that the difference between the score value given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all judges to the bidder is too small.

[0087] If the deviation is too large, it means that the score given by a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section is too different from the average score given by the evaluator to all bidders. If the deviation is too small, it means that the score given by a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section is too different from the average score given by the evaluator to all bidders.

[0088] like Figure 3 As shown in the figure, the judges evaluation system based on the bidding field includes:

[0089] A data acquisition module is used to obtain the numerical data of bid evaluation scores of multiple evaluators in multiple bidding sections based on public resource transactions;

[0090] The first evaluation module is used to evaluate the scoring habits of a certain evaluator based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of a certain evaluator to all bidders;

[0091] The second evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain judge in relation to all the judges based on the average of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge and the average of all the scoring values ​​of all the judges;

[0092] The third evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation between the score of a certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the scores of all evaluators on the winning bidder based on the score value of a certain evaluator on the winning bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all evaluators on the bidder;

[0093] The fourth evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation of a certain judge from all the judges based on the score value of a certain judge on a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all the judges on the certain bidder;

[0094] The fifth evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain judge towards a certain bidder based on the score value of a certain judge on a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of a certain judge on all bidders;

[0095] A calculation module, used to implement the calculation process of the system;

[0096] The early warning analysis module is used to identify abnormal scoring data of judges and issue early warnings to judges with abnormal scoring data.

[0097] Judges evaluate equipment based on the bidding field, including:

[0098] one or more processors;

[0099] The memory stores computer program instructions, and when the computer program instructions are executed by the processor, the judge evaluation device based on the bidding field executes the judge evaluation method based on the bidding field.

[0100] It also includes a computer-readable storage medium, which stores a computer program for executing a judge evaluation method based on the bidding field.

[0101] The present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and any technical solutions formed by equivalent replacement shall fall within the protection scope required by the present invention.

Claims

1. The evaluation method for judges in the field of bidding is characterized by The specific steps include: Obtain the numerical data of bid evaluation scores given by multiple evaluators to multiple bidders in multiple bidding sections; Based on the bid evaluation scoring data, the scoring value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of a certain evaluator to all bidders, the scoring habit of a certain evaluator is evaluated; Based on the mean of all the scores of a certain judge and the mean of all the scores of all the judges in the bid evaluation score numerical data, an evaluation is made on the evaluation tendency of a certain judge compared with all the judges; Based on the bid evaluation score numerical data, the score value of a certain evaluator in a certain bidding section for a bidder to be the winning bidder and the average score of all evaluators on the bidder, the deviation between the score of a certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the score of all evaluators on the winning bidder is evaluated; Based on the bid evaluation score data, the score value of a certain evaluator on a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all evaluators on a certain bidder, the deviation of the tendency of a certain evaluator from all evaluators is evaluated; Based on the bid evaluation score data, the score value given by a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score given by a certain evaluator to all bidders, the evaluation tendency of a certain evaluator towards a certain bidder is evaluated; Construct an evaluation index system for evaluating judges. The evaluation index system includes two first-level indicators: judges' inertia and bid section scoring. Judges' inertia includes three second-level indicators: scoring habits, evaluation tendency, and deviation from the winning bidder's scoring. Bid section scoring includes two second-level indicators: deviation from the tendency of all judges and evaluation tendency for a certain bidder. The method further includes identifying abnormal scoring data of the judges and issuing an early warning to the judges with the abnormal scoring data; The early warning process includes: S1: Obtain the evaluation index system; S2: Setting the warning limits of the secondary indicators, i.e., the warning limits of the scoring habits, evaluation tendency, deviation of the scoring of the winning bidder, deviation of the tendency of all the evaluators, and evaluation tendency of a certain bidder; S3: Obtain the bid evaluation score numerical data, calculate the scoring habits, evaluation tendency, deviation of the score of the bidder, deviation from the tendency of all the judges, and evaluation tendency for a certain bidder of the judges; S4: Compare the secondary indicator of the judge with the warning limit: If the judges' scoring habits, evaluation tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and evaluation tendencies toward a particular bidder are within the warning limits, the judges' behavior is considered normal; If the judge's scoring habits, review tendencies, deviations in scoring the winning bidder, deviations from the tendencies of all judges, and review tendencies toward a certain bidder exceed the warning limits, the judge's behavior is determined to be abnormal.

2. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The evaluation of the scoring habits of a certain judge is calculated as follows: Assuming that the scoring data of a certain judge for n bidders in a certain bidding section is , then the calculation formula for the standard deviation s of the judge's scoring in this bidding section is: ,in , the standard deviation is the dispersion of the judge's scores.

3. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The evaluation of the evaluation tendency of a certain judge and all judges is calculated as follows: Assuming the mean of all the scores of a certain judge is w, and the mean of all the scores of all judges is p, the calculation formula of the score deviation value r is: , which is the deviation of the judges' scores.

4. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The deviation between the score given by a certain judge to the winning bidder and the score given by all judges to the winning bidder is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: Assume that the score given by a certain judge to the bidder as the winning bidder is c, and the mean score given by all judges to the bidder as the winning bidder is v, then the calculation formula for the score deviation value b of a certain judge's score for the winning bidder is: .

5. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The deviation of the tendency of a certain judge from all judges is evaluated. The calculation process is as follows: suppose the score k given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section, the average score f given by all judges to the certain bidder, and there are i bidders in total. The calculation formula of the group deviation t value of the judges is: .

6. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The evaluation tendency of a certain judge on a certain bidder is evaluated, and the calculation process is as follows: suppose the score value g given by a certain judge to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section, the average score j given by the certain judge to all bidders, and there are d bidders in total, then the calculation formula of the judge's own deviation r value is: .

7. The method for evaluating judges in the field of bidding and tendering according to claim 1 is characterized in that: in, The method further includes classifying all judges into types based on the evaluation of the judges' overall scoring habits, and obtaining the following classifications: normal scoring gap, small scoring gap, large scoring gap, too small scoring gap and too large scoring gap.

8. A judge evaluation system based on the bidding field, characterized in that: include: A public resource transaction data acquisition module is used to obtain the bid evaluation and scoring numerical data of multiple evaluators in multiple bidding sections based on public resource transactions; The first evaluation module is used to evaluate the scoring habits of a certain evaluator based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of the certain evaluator to all bidders; The second evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain judge in relation to all the judges based on the average of all the scoring values ​​of a certain judge and the average of all the scoring values ​​of all the judges; The third evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation between the score of a certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the scores of all evaluators on the winning bidder in a certain bidding section based on the score value of the certain evaluator on the winning bidder and the average score of all evaluators on the bidder; A fourth evaluation module is used to evaluate the deviation of a certain evaluator from all the evaluators based on the score value of a certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of all the evaluators to the certain bidder; A fifth evaluation module is used to evaluate the evaluation tendency of a certain evaluator towards a certain bidder based on the score value of the certain evaluator to a certain bidder in a certain bidding section and the average score of the certain evaluator to all bidders; The early warning analysis module is used to identify abnormal scoring data of the judges and issue early warnings to the judges with the abnormal scoring data.

9. A judge evaluation device based on the bidding field, characterized in that: include: one or more processors; A memory, in which computer program instructions are stored, and when the computer program instructions are executed by the processor, The judge evaluation device based on the bidding field is enabled to execute the method described in any one of claims 1-7.

10. A computer-readable storage medium, characterized in that: The storage medium stores a computer program, and the computer program is used to execute the method according to any one of claims 1 to 7.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Artificial intelligence bid evaluation method and system based on big data analysis

    CN110689282A

  • Bid evaluation data analysis system and bid evaluation data analysis method thereof

    CN112288305A