Methods and sample separation equipment for determining the true parameter values of sample separation.
By using the absolute sample separation characteristics and numerical analysis of test samples, the true values of the operating parameters of the sample separation equipment were determined, solving the problem of the actual behavior of the sample separation equipment deviating from the target behavior, and realizing accurate characterization of the sample separation method and equipment calibration.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210297185.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-03-30
- Filing Date
- 2022-03-24
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-03-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing sample separation equipment exhibits a deviation from the target behavior during the separation process, making it impossible to accurately characterize the actual process of the sample separation method.
By using the absolute sample separation characteristics of the test samples and combining them with numerical analysis methods, the true values of the operating parameters of the sample separation equipment are determined, thereby achieving accurate characterization of the sample separation method.
This enables precise characterization of the actual operation of sample separation equipment without the need for external sensors, simplifies equipment calibration and fault diagnosis, and improves the accuracy and reliability of the separation method.
Smart Images

Figure CN115144483B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a method, a sample separation apparatus, program elements, and a computer-readable medium. Background Technology
[0002] Fluid actuators are used to perform various measurement tasks to measure any type of physical parameter. Each fluid actuator can have a dedicated driver with actuator-specific commands. Programming software allows users to design the operating modes of the fluid actuator. Due to this design, the fluid actuator can operate according to the designed operating mode.
[0003] More specifically, in liquid chromatography, a fluid analyte can be pumped through a column comprising a material capable of separating the different components of the fluid analyte. This material, known as beads, can be packed into a column tube, which can be connected to other components such as a control unit, a container containing the sample, and / or a buffer. Upstream of the column, the fluid sample or analyte is loaded into the liquid chromatography apparatus. The controller controls the amount of fluid pumped through the liquid chromatography apparatus, including controlling the composition and time dependence of the solvent interacting with the fluid analyte. This solvent can be a mixture of different components. The supply of these components for subsequent mixing is an example of an operation designed by the operator of the liquid chromatography apparatus.
[0004] However, when performing sample separation methods, the actual behavior during sample separation may deviate significantly from the target behavior. This may be due to the non-ideal behavior of the sample separation equipment.
[0005] The paper "Design and Use of a Simple System Suitability Test Mixture for a Universal Reversed-Phase HPLC-MS System and the Impact of Using Global Software Tracking on Automated System Monitoring" by Ian Mutton, Bob Boughtflower, Nick Taylor, and Daniel Brooke in *Chromatography Journal A*, 1218 (2011), pp. 3711-3717, discloses the development of a seven-component test mixture designed for universal gradient and reversed-phase HPLC-MS systems. Unlike many test mixtures formulated to characterize column quality at neutral pH, this test mixture is designed to allow for an overall suitability assessment of the entire LCMS system. The mixture is designed to test specific aspects of the column's chromatographic performance as well as the performance of individual instrument components of the system. The system suitability test mixture can be used for universal reversed-phase LCMS analysis at both low and high pH. Four phthalates are used: diethyl phthalate (DEP), dibutyl phthalate (DAP), di-n-hexyl phthalate (DHP), and dioctyl phthalate (DOP). Three additional probes are used: 8-bromoguanosine (8-BG), amitriptyline (Ami), and 4-clocinnamic acid (4-CCA). Analysis of this test mixture can alert the user if any part of the system (instrument or column) causes a loss of overall performance and may require remedial action. This test mixture provides information that enables the user to record data quality control. Summary of the Invention
[0006] The purpose of this invention is to accurately characterize the actual behavior during the execution of a separation method using a sample separation device.
[0007] According to an exemplary embodiment, a method is provided that, based on a provided test sample comprising a mixture of multiple known sample components and based on the provided absolute sample separation characteristics of each sample component (in particular, based on a provided dataset indicating the absolute sample separation characteristics of each sample component), the method includes experimentally determining a true sample separation result by performing a sample separation method for separating the test sample by a sample separation device, and determining a true value of at least one operating parameter based on a comparison between the absolute sample separation characteristics (in particular, provided in the form of a dataset) and the true sample separation result to characterize the true process (or operation) of the sample separation method.
[0008] According to another exemplary embodiment, a sample separation device for separating fluid samples is provided, wherein the sample separation device includes a fluid driver for driving a mobile phase and a fluid sample injected into the mobile phase, a sample separation unit for separating the fluid sample in the mobile phase, and a processor configured to use the sample separation device (in particular, the fluid driver and the sample separation unit of the sample separation device) and to use a test sample as a fluid sample to perform or control a method having the above-described features.
[0009] According to another exemplary embodiment of the present invention, a program element (e.g., a software routine in source code or executable code, for example configured as an application) is provided, which, when executed by a processor (e.g., a microprocessor or CPU, etc.), is adapted to control or perform a method having the above-described features.
[0010] According to yet another exemplary embodiment of the present invention, a computer-readable medium (e.g., CD, DVD, USB stick, floppy disk, or hard disk, for example, located in the cloud) is provided, wherein a computer program is stored, which, when executed by a processor (e.g., a microprocessor or CPU, etc.), is adapted to control or perform a method having the above-described features.
[0011] Data processing that can be performed according to embodiments of the invention can be implemented by computer programs (i.e., by software), by using one or more dedicated electronic optimization circuits (i.e., by hardware), or in a hybrid form (i.e. by means of software and hardware components).
[0012] In the context of this application, the term "sample separation apparatus" can specifically refer to any apparatus relating to the delivery, analysis, or processing of fluids for separating fluid samples. The fluid can represent a liquid, a gas, or a combination of liquids and gases, and may optionally include solid particles, such as those forming gels or emulsions. Such fluids may include a mobile phase (e.g., a fluid solvent or solvent composition) and / or the fluid sample to be analyzed. Examples of sample separation apparatuses are chemical analysis devices, life science devices, or any other biochemical analysis system, such as separation devices for separating different components of a sample, particularly liquid chromatography devices. For example, sample separation can be performed by chromatography or electrophoresis.
[0013] In the context of this application, the term "separation method" can specifically refer to instructions for a sample separation apparatus regarding how to separate a fluid sample, which will be carried out by the sample separation apparatus to complete the separation task associated with the separation method. Such a separation method can be defined by a set of parameter values (e.g., temperature, pressure, properties of the solvent composition, etc.) and the hardware components of the sample separation apparatus (e.g., the type of separation column used), as well as an algorithm having commands or instructions executed when performing the separation method. The corresponding set of technical parameters used to operate the sample separation apparatus during sample separation can be known, for example, stored in a database or memory accessible by a control unit that controls the operation of the sample separation apparatus. The physical properties or operating parameters characterizing the separation method can include transport characteristics, which may include values of physical parameters such as volume, size, pressure, or temperature, and / or physical effects such as frictional models occurring in the fluid conduit, which can be modeled, for example, according to Hagen-Poiseuille's law. More specifically, parameterization can take into account the dimensions of the sample separation device (e.g., the dimensions of the fluid channels), the volume of the fluid conduits of the sample separation device (e.g., dead volume), the pump performance of the sample separation device (e.g., pump power and / or pump capacity), the delay parameters for operating the sample separation device (e.g., the delay time after the sample separation device is turned on), the friction parameters for operating the sample separation device (e.g., characterizing the friction between the walls of the fluid conduits and the fluid flowing through the conduits), the flushing performance of the sample separation device (especially the performance related to cleaning or flushing the sample separation device before operating it or between two subsequent runs), and / or the coordination of different components of the sample separation device (e.g., the performance of the gradient applied to the column).
[0014] In the context of this application, the term "fluid sample" may specifically refer to a medium containing the actual substance being analyzed (e.g., a biological sample, such as a protein solution, a drug sample, etc.).
[0015] In the context of this application, the term "mobile phase" may specifically refer to a fluid (especially a liquid) used as a carrier medium for transporting a fluid sample from a fluid actuator (such as a high-pressure pump) to a sample separation unit (such as a liquid chromatography column) of a sample separation apparatus. For example, the mobile phase may be (e.g., an organic and / or inorganic) solvent or a solvent composition (e.g., water and ethanol).
[0016] In the context of this application, the term "test sample comprising a mixture of multiple known sample components" can specifically refer to a fluid sample that can be inserted into a sample separation device for separation by performing a separation method, wherein several different sample components having predetermined properties can form part of a sample mixture. By knowing or determining the properties of the sample components in advance, i.e., before separation, the test sample can serve as a standard or sensor that, when separated by the sample separation device, provides meaningful information about the actual behavior of the sample separation device when performing the separation method. Advantageously, the components of the test sample can be orthogonal in terms of their chromatographic behavior, i.e., the aspects of their behavior related in the chromatogram do not interact with each other.
[0017] In the context of this application, the term "absolute sample separation characteristic" can specifically refer to the inherent characteristic of each component of a test sample. During the execution of the separation method, at least a portion of the absolute sample separation characteristic can be related to the behavior of the individual components. This absolute separation characteristic can be particularly independent of the specific sample separation apparatus on which the separation method is performed, i.e., it can remain unchanged when the sample separation apparatus is changed. In other words, the absolute sample separation characteristics of the individual components can be the same on different types of sample separation apparatuses.
[0018] In the context of this application, the term "true sample separation result" (e.g., true chromatogram) can specifically refer to the actual or true result of performing a separation method on a sample separation device, reflecting its non-ideal behavior. Such non-ideal behavior may involve inaccuracies in the components of the sample separation device, as well as parasitic effects such as friction, thermal interaction with the environment, leakage, fluid delay phenomena, and the compressibility of liquids.
[0019] In the context of this application, the term "operating parameter" may specifically refer to a parameter in a set of parameters that define and / or exist during the respective separation method and describe the characteristics that are adjusted or occur during the operation of the sample separation apparatus when the separation method is performed. Such operating parameters may in particular include physical separation conditions (especially pressure and / or temperature (e.g. at sample separation units such as chromatographic columns), detector wavelength, integration parameters, etc.), the properties of the fluid used for operation (e.g., solvent composition of the mobile phase, gradient distribution, etc.), etc.
[0020] In the context of this application, the term "true value of at least one operating parameter" can specifically refer to the value of a corresponding operating parameter that is actually or practically present in the sample separation apparatus during the execution of the separation method. Such a true value may deviate from the target value that should ideally be present during the execution of the separation method. For example, the separation method may define a target temperature of 80°C in the stationary phase of the sample separation unit during the separation process. In practice, for example, the true value of the temperature due to non-ideal behavior could be 76°C.
[0021] In the context of this application, the term “characterizing the actual process of a sample separation method” can specifically refer to determining information about how the separation method is actually performed and behaves in practice (i.e., in reality rather than hypothesized ideal behavior).
[0022] In the context of this application, the term "comparison between absolute sample separation characteristics and true sample separation results" can specifically refer to any analysis, evaluation, calculation, and / or simulation that considers both absolute sample separation characteristics and true sample separation results. For example, in the case of such a comparison, actual sample separation results can be fitted to actual sample separation characteristics, particularly using the values of operating parameters as variable fitting parameters.
[0023] According to exemplary embodiments of the invention, a test sample having multiple known or determinable sample components and known or determinable absolute sample separation characteristics is used to experimentally determine true sample separation results (e.g., actual or true chromatograms obtained by performing a gradient run of a chromatographic separation method on a chromatographic sample separation device using the test sample for separation). Absolute sample separation characteristics can be known from or determined by calibration measurements of the test sample (e.g., by delivering chromatograms through isocratic runs), which provide information for different values and / or types of operating parameters for each individual component. Based on the well-characterized components of the test sample, true or actual values, rather than target values, of one or more operating parameters during the execution of the separation method on the sample separation device used to obtain true sample separation results can then be determined. Advantageously, such actual operating parameter values can be obtained by comparing absolute sample separation characteristics and true sample separation results. For example, the deviation identified by such comparison can be a fingerprint of the deviation of the true operating parameter value (e.g., the true temperature at the sample separation unit during separation) relative to the target operating parameter value (e.g., the desired target temperature at the sample separation unit during separation, as intended to be adjusted by the separation method). This allows for the acquisition of information to characterize how the sample separation method is actually performed. For example, embodiments may use test mixtures to allow the determination of true values of operating parameters (e.g., flow rate, column temperature, gradient accuracy) based on the comparisons described above. Therefore, embodiments may allow for characterization of the actual operation of the sample separation apparatus without the use of external sensors (although external sensors may be present in some embodiments). Descriptively speaking, the components of the test sample can act as fluid sensors, where the presence of several components can provide orthogonal or complementary (for delivering independent information) and / or redundant (for increasing accuracy) information. Various applications are possible according to exemplary embodiments of the invention, such as the transfer of separation methods between different sample separation apparatuses, precise diagnostic tools for potential problems with sample separation apparatuses, replacement or addition of inherent sensors of the test sample as external sensors, operational qualification of sample separation apparatuses, simulation of another sample separation apparatus, etc.
[0024] Other embodiments of the method, sample separation equipment, program elements, and computer-readable media will be explained below.
[0025] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes providing at least a portion of the sample components to the test sample, particularly at least one late-eluting sample component, which has absolute sample separation characteristics exhibiting a significant temperature dependence. In embodiments, the test sample components exhibiting significant temperature-dependent behavior in the chromatogram can replace conventional temperature sensors. Such components can be displayed in the chromatogram as temperature-sensitive retention times in the sample separation unit (e.g., chromatographic column, etc.) during the execution of the separation method. It has been demonstrated that late-eluting sample components, i.e., components on the right-hand side of the chromatogram, can exhibit such strong temperature dependence.
[0026] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes providing at least a portion of the sample components to the test sample, particularly at least one early-eluting sample component, which has absolute sample separation characteristics exhibiting a significant flow rate dependence. In such embodiments, the test sample components exhibiting significant flow rate-dependent behavior in the chromatogram can replace conventional flow meters. Such components can show retention times in the chromatogram that are sensitive to the flow rate of the mobile phase used during the separation method. It has been demonstrated that early-eluting components, i.e., components on the left side of the chromatogram, can exhibit such strong flow rate dependence.
[0027] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes providing at least a portion of the sample components to the test sample, particularly at least one sample component having an elution rate between at least one early-eluting sample component and at least one late-eluting sample component, exhibiting absolute sample separation characteristics that are significantly dependent on solvent composition, particularly gradient distribution. In such embodiments, components of the test sample that exhibit behavior in the chromatogram that strongly depends on the gradient distribution (i.e., time-dependent solvent composition) during gradient operation can be used to determine the actual gradient distribution or solvent composition. Such components can be displayed in the chromatogram with retention times sensitive to the gradient distribution or solvent composition during the execution of the separation method. It has been demonstrated that components having elution times between early-eluting and late-eluting components, i.e., components in the central portion of the chromatogram, can exhibit such significant sensitivity with respect to gradient distribution or solvent composition.
[0028] In this embodiment, the absolute sample separation characteristics are independent of the apparatus characteristics of the sample separation device on which the sample components are separated. Therefore, the sample separation characteristics can be solely properties of the components of the test sample and can be independent of the specific sample separation device on which the test sample is separated. Advantageously, this allows the components of the test sample to be calibrated only once, and simulations can be performed on any type of sample separation device using this calibration information (i.e., the absolute sample separation characteristics). Advantageously, recalibration can become optional, and this makes the architecture according to exemplary embodiments of the invention particularly simple.
[0029] In this embodiment, the absolute sample separation characteristics are chromatographic sample separation characteristics. For example, chromatographic sample separation characteristics can describe the dependence of each component of the test sample on the temperature of the chromatographic separation column, the flow rate of the mobile phase at the chromatographic separation column, the gradient distribution of the solvent composition flowing through the chromatographic separation column, etc.
[0030] In embodiments, the processor is configured such that / or the method includes changing at least one operating parameter (see, for example...). Figure 7 ), especially by changing multiple operating parameters (see, for example) Figure 5 and Figure 6 For each sample component, calibration measurements are performed to determine the absolute sample separation characteristics. For example, for different values of each operating parameter, chromatograms of the test sample and its components can be measured. Based on this information, two-dimensional, three-dimensional, four-dimensional, or more-dimensional characteristics of the test sample components can be established.
[0031] In embodiments, the processor is configured such that / or the method includes performing calibration measurements by executing a chromatographic sample separation method. Therefore, experimental chromatograms with test samples can be measured, wherein different operating parameter values can be adjusted to measure different chromatograms.
[0032] In an embodiment, the processor is configured and / or the method includes performing calibration measurements by changing at least one operating parameter from the group consisting of: the temperature of each sample component, the flow rate of the mobile phase used to deliver and / or separate each sample component, and the composition of the mobile phase used to deliver and / or separate each sample component. These parameters are of particular interest for chromatographic separation on chromatographic sample separation equipment.
[0033] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes performing calibration measurements in isocratic mode. Therefore, calibration measurements can preferably be performed in isocratic mode (i.e., for a single chromatogram, the solvent composition does not change over time), allowing each individual operating parameter to be calibrated individually. This can provide particularly meaningful calibration results because complex interactions between different operating parameters can be shut off or at least suppressed.
[0034] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes experimentally determining true sample separation results by performing a sample separation method in gradient mode. It is also possible that the method includes experimentally determining true sample separation results by performing a chromatographic sample separation method. In particular, experimentally determining true sample separation results may include measuring a chromatogram by performing a chromatographic separation method on a chromatographic sample separation device. Advantageously, this can be performed in a gradient run, during which the solvent composition of the mobile phase driven through the chromatographic separation column changes over time to individually desorb previously adsorbed components of the test sample from the stationary phase of the chromatographic separation column.
[0035] In an embodiment, the processor is configured and / or the method includes determining a true value for at least one operating parameter from the group consisting of: temperature during sample separation, flow rate of the mobile phase delivering and / or separating the test sample, composition of the mobile phase delivering and / or separating the test sample, and at least one performance value indicating the performance of the sample separation device, particularly indicating whether the performance of the sample separation device meets predetermined specifications. The parameters mentioned are particularly relevant to chromatographic separation operations. However, other operating parameters may also be considered additionally or alternatively. One or more determined operating parameter values may be numerical values (e.g., column temperature of 78°C) and / or logical values (e.g., logical values "true" or "false," indicating whether the sample separation device has passed a performance test, e.g., meets or does not meet predetermined specifications).
[0036] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes determining the true value of at least one operating parameter, including determining an ideal sample separation result as a preparatory stage. The ideal sample separation result can be the expected result when the separation method is performed on a sample separation device in a precise manner, i.e., without any inaccuracies caused by the sample separation device, the fluid sample to be separated, and the environment. Advantageously, such an ideal sample separation result, such as a simulated chromatogram, can be used as a basis for comparison with the true sample separation result to characterize the actual process of the sample separation method.
[0037] In embodiments, the processor is configured such that / or the method includes determining an ideal sample separation result by simulating absolute sample separation characteristics, particularly by simulating the execution of a sample separation method for separating a test sample using a sample separation device, based on absolute sample separation characteristics. Therefore, a simulated chromatogram can be determined by simulating the separation of the test sample in its components, taking into account the absolute sample separation characteristics of the test sample's components and without inaccurate assumptions.
[0038] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes iteratively determining an ideal sample separation result, particularly by simulating the execution of a sample separation method with different values of at least one operating parameter. Therefore, the simulation of the chromatogram described above can be iteratively repeated with different values of one or more operating parameters. As a result, multiple different simulated chromatograms can be obtained, each corresponding to an assigned set of operating parameter values.
[0039] In an embodiment, the processor is configured and / or the method includes determining the true value of the at least one operating parameter as a value corresponding to a true sample separation result, particularly an ideal sample separation result that best matches the true sample separation result among repeatedly and iteratively determined ideal sample separation results. Then, an appropriate or optimal match between the simulated chromatogram and the measured chromatogram can transmit the true value of the at least one operating parameter corresponding to the (particularly optimal) matched simulated chromatogram.
[0040] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes determining at least one true parameter value by performing numerical analysis while taking into account absolute sample separation characteristics. In the context of this application, the term "numerical analysis" can specifically refer to an algorithmic method for solving mathematical analysis problems using numerical approximations and / or algorithms. When applied to simulations for determining actual operating parameter values, the purpose of numerical analysis is to design and analyze techniques to provide approximate but accurate solutions to difficult problems related to determining at least one actual parameter value. Numerical analysis can create, analyze, and / or implement algorithms for obtaining numerical solutions to appropriateness judgment problems involving continuous variables.
[0041] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes performing numerical analysis using at least one of the group consisting of finite element method (FEM) analysis, finite difference method (FDM) analysis, boundary element method (BEM) analysis, control volume method (CVM) analysis, and random walk method analysis.
[0042] The finite element method (FEM) is preferred. Specifically, the finite element method (FEM) can be implemented as a specific numerical method for solving partial differential equations with two or three spatial variables. To solve the problem, the finite element method can subdivide a large system into smaller, simpler parts called finite elements. This can be achieved through spatial discretization in a specific spatial dimension, which can be achieved by constructing a mesh of the object (i.e., a numerical domain of solutions with a finite number of points). The finite element method formula for boundary value problems ultimately yields a system of algebraic equations. This method can approximate unknown functions over the domain. The simple equations simulating these finite elements can then be assembled into a larger system of equations simulating the entire problem. For example, the finite element method applied to sample separation equipment can spatially separate a sample separation unit (e.g., a chromatographic separation column) into a large number of volumetric elements. For each volumetric element, its behavior during the execution of operations such as the separation method can be calculated. By taking this approach, the behavior of the entire system, i.e., the entire sample separation unit, can be simulated. Accordingly, the moving phase pump, sample injector, etc., of the sample separation equipment can also be subjected to corresponding finite element analysis.
[0043] Alternatively or additionally, the finite difference method (FDM) can be performed, which performs discretization to approximate and solve differential equations by means of difference equations whose derivatives are approximated using finite differences. FDM can transform linear ordinary differential equations or nonlinear partial differential equations into a system of equations solvable using matrix algebra techniques.
[0044] Additionally or alternatively, the boundary element method (BEM) can be performed, which can be a numerical method for solving linear partial differential equations that have been formulated as integral equations. The integral equations can be viewed as exact solutions to the governing partial differential equations. The boundary element method attempts to fit boundary values to the integral equations using given boundary conditions, rather than values across the entire space defined by the partial differential equations. Once this is done, in the post-processing stage, the integral equations can then be used again to directly compute solutions numerically at any desired points within the solution domain.
[0045] Additionally or alternatively, in the control volume method (CVM), the entire region can be subdivided into control volumes. Nodes can be located at the center of the control volume. Difference equations can be formed using statements of the conservation equations, or the differential form of the conservation equations can be integrated over the control volume to form difference equations.
[0046] Additionally or alternatively, random walk methods can be performed, which can be considered as mathematical objects describing a path that consists of a series of random steps, such as integers, in a mathematical space.
[0047] Finite element analysis is particularly preferred. However, additionally or alternatively, one or more of the other mentioned and / or additional numerical analysis methods may also be advantageously implemented.
[0048] In an embodiment, the processor is configured and / or the method includes, based on a provided additional test sample comprising a mixture of multiple known additional sample components and based on the provided absolute sample separation characteristics for each of the additional sample components, experimentally determining another true sample separation result by a sample separation method for separating the additional test sample using a sample separation device, and determining the true value of at least one operating parameter based on a comparison between the absolute sample separation characteristics of the mixture and the additional mixture and the true sample separation result, to characterize the true method of the sample separation method. Therefore, instead of using a single test sample having a certain number of components (e.g., seven components), multiple test samples (e.g., two test samples), each comprising a smaller number of components (e.g., a first test sample with four components and a second test sample with three other components), can be used. By using different, less complex test samples that can be separated in different runs, interactions between the components of different test samples can be avoided during calibration and / or experimental determination of true sample separation results.
[0049] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes using the determined true value of at least one operating parameter as a sensed value of at least one operating parameter, particularly as at least one of the group consisting of sensed temperature, sensed flow rate, sensed solvent composition, and sensed gradient distribution. Hardware sensors (e.g., temperature sensors, flow rate sensors, pressure sensors) can then be partially or completely avoided. Hardware sensors can also be used additionally, wherein the hardware sensors and the composition of the test sample used as a fluid sensor can provide supplementary information for further refining the determination of the true value(s).
[0050] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes using the true value of at least one determined operating parameter as a performance indicator that indicates the performance of the sample separation device in experimentally determining true sample separation results, particularly as a performance indicator indicating whether the sample separation device conforms to predetermined specifications. Specifically, this performance indicator is used in at least one of the following situations: initial installation of the sample separation device, repair of the sample separation device, maintenance of the sample separation device, and the expiration of a predetermined time period from the prior determination of the performance indicator. Advantageously, embodiments of the invention can enable operational qualification of the sample separation device. After installation, after repair, and / or after maintenance of the sample separation device, such operational qualification can check whether the actual behavior of the sample separation device conforms to predetermined specifications (e.g., the deviation of the actual gradient distribution from the target gradient distribution is less than 1%). Such operational qualification can be performed in a fully automated manner by exemplary embodiments of the invention, for example, by executing software routines. Therefore, exemplary applications relate to sample separation devices that can perform performance checks without device sensors.
[0051] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes transferring a sample separation method between a sample separation device and another sample separation device using the true value of at least one determined operating parameter. Therefore, another advantageous application of exemplary embodiments of the invention relates to transferring a separation method from one separation device to another. Such a method transfer can be performed in a very simple manner, characterizing the components of the test sample by determining the device-independent absolute sample separation characteristics of the test sample through a single calibration. When the same test sample is used to measure chromatograms on different sample separation devices, simulations on different sample separation devices can use the same absolute sample separation characteristics without requiring device-specific calibration.
[0052] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes using the determined true values of at least one operating parameter to diagnose potential malfunctions of the sample separation device or a portion thereof. In such embodiments, for example, when it is determined that the gradient distribution of a liquid chromatography apparatus deviates significantly from target behavior, the system can be used as a diagnostic tool for problems with the sample separation device. The user can simply perform measurements on the sample separation device using a test sample and a specific separation method to determine the measured chromatogram. By comparing the measured chromatogram with a simulated chromatogram that takes into account the absolute sample separation characteristics of the test sample components, possible causes of the deviation (e.g., incorrect pump head or proportioning valve) can be identified.
[0053] In an embodiment, the processor is configured and / or the method includes simulating the execution of the sample separation method on another sample separation device using determined true values of the at least one operating parameter. In such an embodiment, the performance of one sample separation device can be simulated on another sample separation device, for example, based on simulations on different HPLC systems. Descriptively speaking, one sample separation device can then simulate the separation method executed on another sample separation device, i.e., chromatograms can be created, for example, when the separation method is executed on another sample separation device.
[0054] In embodiments, the processor is configured and / or the method includes evaluating the sample separation results obtained by performing a sample separation method on a sample separation device using the true value of at least one determined operating parameter, particularly by performing a sample separation method on a sensorless sample separation device and / or by a sample separation device without resources for controlling at least one operating parameter. Therefore, another advantageous application of exemplary embodiments of the invention is a sensorless sample separation device that does not include hardware sensors, but allows operation based on sensor data transmitted by the components of the test sample. For example, HPLC can be provided without column ovens and temperature control of the chromatographic separation column, but the actual column temperature (e.g., 26°C) can be simply determined based on the behavior of the components of the test sample. The chromatography can then be interpreted accordingly.
[0055] Examples can be implemented in commonly available HPLC systems, such as the analytical Agilent 1290 Infinity II LC system or the Agilent 1290 Infinity II preparative LC / MSD system (both provided by the applicant, Agilent Technologies, Inc. – see www.agilent.com – which should be incorporated herein by reference).
[0056] One embodiment of the sample separation apparatus includes a pump with a pump piston that reciprocates within a pump working chamber to compress a liquid in the working chamber to a high pressure, under which the compressibility of the liquid becomes apparent. The pump can be configured to know (through operator input, notification from another module of the instrument, etc.) or otherwise derive the properties of the solvent.
[0057] The sample separation unit of the sample separation apparatus preferably includes a chromatographic column providing the stationary phase (see, for example, http: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Column_chromatography). This column can be a glass or metal tube (e.g., 50 µm to 5 mm in diameter and 1 cm to 1 m in length) or a microfluidic column (as disclosed in EP 1577012 A1 or the Agilent 1200 series HPLC-Chip / MS system provided by the applicant, Agilent Technologies). As the eluent propagates through the column at different speeds, the individual components are retained differently by the stationary phase and are at least partially separated from each other. At the ends of the column, one component is eluted at a time, or at least not completely simultaneously. Throughout the chromatography process, the eluent may also be collected in a series of fractions. The stationary phase or adsorbent in column chromatography is typically a solid material. The most commonly used stationary phases in column chromatography are silica gel, surface-modified silica gel, and alumina. Cellulose powder has been frequently used in the past. Ion exchange chromatography, reversed-phase chromatography (RP), affinity chromatography, or expanded bed adsorption (EBA) can also be used. The stationary phase is typically a finely ground powder or gel, and / or microporous to provide an increased surface area.
[0058] The mobile phase (elution buffer) can be a pure solvent or a mixture of different volumes (e.g., water and organic solvents such as ACN, acetonitrile, etc.). It can be selected to, for example, adjust the retention rate of the target complex and / or the amount of mobile phase for running the chromatography. The mobile phase can also be selected to allow for efficient separation of different complexes or fractions of a fluid sample. The mobile phase can include organic solvents that are often diluted with water, such as methanol or acetonitrile. For gradient runs, water and organic matter are delivered in separate vials, from which a gradient pump delivers the planned mixture to the system. Other commonly used solvents can be isopropanol, THF, hexane, ethanol, and / or any combination thereof, or any combination of these with the aforementioned solvents.
[0059] According to exemplary embodiments of the present invention, the fluid samples analyzed by the sample separation device may include, but are not limited to, any type of process liquid, natural samples such as fruit juice, bodily fluids such as blood plasma, or the result of a reaction such as that from fermentation broth.
[0060] The pressure range in the moving phase generated by the fluid actuator can be 2-200 MPa (20 to 2000 bar), particularly 10-150 MPa (150 to 1500 bar), and even more particularly 50-120 MPa (500 to 1200 bar).
[0061] Sample separation equipment, such as an HPLC system, may also include a detector for detecting the separation complex of a fluid sample, a fractionation unit for discharging the separation complex of the fluid sample, or any combination thereof. For example, a fluorescence detector may be implemented.
[0062] Embodiments of the present invention may be embodied or supported, in part or in whole, by one or more suitable software programs, which may be stored on or provided on any type of data carrier and may be executed in or through any suitable data processing unit. The software programs or routines may preferably be in or applied by a control unit. Attached Figure Description
[0063] Other objects and numerous incidental advantages of the invention will be readily appreciated and better understood by referring to the following more detailed description of embodiments taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. Substantially or functionally equivalent or similar features will be referred to by the same reference numerals.
[0064] Figure 1 A liquid sample separation apparatus according to an embodiment of the present invention is shown, which is particularly used for high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).
[0065] Figure 2 A schematic diagram illustrates a method for performing on a sample separation device according to an exemplary embodiment.
[0066] Figure 3 An experimental chromatogram of a test sample comprising a mixture of various known sample components, measured by a sample separation device according to an exemplary embodiment, is shown.
[0067] Figure 4 Experimental and simulated chromatograms of a test sample according to an exemplary embodiment are shown. The test sample comprises a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties.
[0068] Figure 5 A three-dimensional graph showing the absolute sample separation characteristics of the components of a mixture according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0069] Figure 6 A three-dimensional graph showing the absolute sample separation characteristics of another component of the mixture according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0070] Figure 7 A two-dimensional graph showing the absolute sample separation characteristics of different components of a mixture according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0071] Figure 8 The illustration shows a gradient distribution and corresponding simulated chromatogram of a test sample simulated for a sample separation device according to an exemplary embodiment. The test sample comprises a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties.
[0072] Figure 9An experimental chromatogram of a test sample according to an exemplary embodiment is shown. The test sample comprises a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties.
[0073] Figure 10 It shows the relationship with Figure 9 Simulated chromatograms of the same test samples.
[0074] Figure 11 An experimental chromatogram using a first predetermined temperature is shown according to an exemplary embodiment, and a simulated chromatogram using a second simulated temperature of a test sample comprising a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties is also shown.
[0075] Figure 12 A sample separation unit of a sample separation apparatus subjected to finite element simulation according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0076] Figure 13 Different simulated chromatograms of a test sample according to an exemplary embodiment are shown. The test sample comprises a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties.
[0077] Figure 14 Show Figure 13 The details of the chromatogram illustrate how flow error affects all peaks.
[0078] Figure 15 Show Figure 13 Another detail in the chromatogram illustrates how gradient error affects all peaks.
[0079] Figure 16 The chromatogram of a test sample configured as a flow and gradient sensor according to an exemplary embodiment is shown. The test sample comprises a mixture of various known sample components with different chromatographic properties.
[0080] Figure 17 A diagram illustrating solvent management for a sample separation apparatus according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0081] Figure 18 Different details of a sample separation apparatus operating according to an exemplary embodiment are shown.
[0082] The illustrations in the attached diagram are schematic. Detailed Implementation
[0083] Before describing the accompanying drawings in more detail, some basic considerations of the invention will be summarized based on the exemplary embodiments developed.
[0084] According to an exemplary embodiment of the invention, a mixture of components can be used to provide a test sample. Absolute sample separation characteristics, particularly chromatographic characteristics, for each component can be provided (e.g., determined by calibration measurements). Advantageously, these absolute sample separation characteristics can be device-independent, i.e., independent of the characteristics of the sample separation apparatus on which a separation method (e.g., chromatographic) using the test sample is performed. The test sample can then be used to experimentally perform the separation method on the sample separation apparatus to separate the test sample, allowing for the acquisition of true separation results (particularly a measured chromatogram of the test sample). By comparing the obtained separation results with the absolute sample separation characteristics, one or more actual or true values of each of one or more operating parameters (e.g., temperature, flow rate, gradient distribution) can then be derived to characterize the actual process of the separation method performed on the sample separation apparatus. This can be achieved, for example, through software routines that can be executed on the sample separation apparatus or separately from it (e.g., installed on a dedicated device, provided as an application, and / or stored in the cloud). Descriptively speaking, the components of the test sample can be used as sensors for the operating parameters, where the true separation results can be considered sensor data. Therefore, the internal hardware sensors of the sample separation device may be optional, or they may be supplemented by complementary sensor data provided by the components of the test sample.
[0085] More specifically, exemplary embodiments provide test samples in the form of specific mixtures of several standard components. Ideal chromatograms of the test samples, when separated by a separation method on a sample separation device, can preferably be determined through simulation. Comparing such ideal chromatograms with actual chromatograms obtained when the separation method is experimentally performed on the sample separation device to separate the test samples allows identification deviations between chromatograms to be correlated with deviations of one or more actual operating parameter values relative to ideal values. In other words, analyzing such variations allows for performance ratings, temperature sensing, flow rate sensing, etc. More specifically, the composition of the test sample and its individual components can provide information about performance and / or parameter values.
[0086] Fitting (preferably based on finite element analysis, FEM) can then allow flow rate values, temperature values, or gradient distribution / solvent composition to be determined based on retention time characteristics. For example, the behavior of the components can be determined and the fitting performed in such a manner that operating parameters (e.g., temperature, flow rate, and / or gradient distribution) are the fitting parameters. The true values of the corresponding operating parameters determined can then correspond to fitting parameters that provide the best match with the separation results of the experimentally obtained real samples. In particular, experimentally measured chromatograms can be fitted relative to simulated chromatograms. The experimental chromatogram can be measured once, and the simulated chromatogram can be repeatedly or iteratively determined using variations in one or more operating parameters until a best or sufficiently good match (e.g., meeting a threshold criterion) is achieved with the experimentally measured chromatogram.
[0087] According to exemplary embodiments of the invention, absolute chromatographic assays can be provided for use as sensors, diagnostic and / or simulation tools. In particular, test mixtures (i.e., test samples comprising multiple sample components) can be used as flow sensors, temperature sensors and / or for determining gradient accuracy. Test mixtures can also be used to characterize sample separation devices, determine separation method transfer parameters, and / or as precise diagnostic tools, and / or as sensor alternatives for modular operation qualification tests. Advantageously, expensive external sensors used to test chromatographic systems according to their operating specifications, which require metrological experience to operate and need maintenance and recalibration, can therefore become unnecessary.
[0088] Advantageously, absolute chromatographic assays according to exemplary embodiments of the invention can utilize information about the test mixture concerning how each component or standard interacts during separation by a sample separation device. Through a complete characterization of the test mixture, absolute values can be obtained and compared with the behavior of the sample separation device. For example, this can allow for the determination of flow rates, column temperatures, gradient accuracy, etc., based on mathematical algorithms.
[0089] Advantageously, embodiments of the invention facilitate the determination of chromatographic system performance without the use of external sensors. Furthermore, embodiments of the invention allow chromatographic methods to be adapted to various system settings. Embodiments of the invention can also be used as precise diagnostic tools. In particular, embodiments of the invention can be used for operational identification instead of using external sensors. Additionally or alternatively, embodiments can be used to create accurate simulations of different chromatographic systems.
[0090] Absolute testing can be performed by utilizing sample separation equipment, and particularly by using chromatographic separation columns under various temperature conditions, to determine how each component or standard in a mixed test sample interacts. This information provides the basis for executing algorithms to determine what chromatograms should be produced from specific separation method parameters and sample separation equipment settings. Advantageously, testing obtained using absolute method parameters (e.g., flow rate, composition, temperature) allows for comparison of the instrument with absolute performance parameters. Results declared as "good" references are not required. Furthermore, knowledge of the absolute performance of different sample separation equipment allows for the calculation of method transfer from one sample separation equipment to another, and vice versa.
[0091] The key point of an exemplary embodiment of the present invention is to provide a dedicated sample mixture or test sample and determine an ideal chromatogram for such a test sample, i.e., a chromatogram obtained from an ideal sample separation device in which all set operating parameter values are 100% identical to actual conditions. For example, the actual flow rate, temperature, composition, etc., of the solvent composition and the sample separation device are precisely those set by the separation method. By comparing the actual chromatogram (obtained experimentally using an actual sample separation device for the dedicated sample mixture) with the ideal chromatogram (for the test sample), deviations between the actual and ideal parameters can be determined (e.g., the actual temperature is 68°C while the sample separation device displays "70°C"). Exemplary applications of embodiments of the present invention include procedures for checking whether a sample separation device is within specifications, method transfer from one sample separation device to another, etc. For example, embodiments of the present invention can be implemented as dedicated software (e.g., a program unit) that can be installed in the sample separation device itself; it can be separate control software or a web application, etc.
[0092] Highly advantageously, exemplary embodiments can use well-defined test samples (which can be used as a gold standard) to determine deviations in actual HPLC measurement settings. The defined multi-component test samples can be used to measure variations in certain parameters, such as deriving chromatograms for the test samples at multiple different temperatures. This allows for the derivation of models for sample separation equipment, particularly liquid chromatography devices such as HPLC. During normal operation of the sample separation equipment, the defined test samples can be used from time to time to determine the actual condition of the sample separation equipment by comparison with the model.
[0093] Now refer to the attached diagram for more details. Figure 1A general schematic diagram of a liquid separation system is depicted as an example of a sample separation apparatus 10 according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention. A fluid actuator 20 (e.g., a piston pump) receives the mobile phase from a solvent supply 25 via a degassing unit 27, which degasses the mobile phase and thus reduces the amount of dissolved gas in it. The fluid actuator 20 drives the mobile phase through a separation unit 30 (e.g., a chromatographic column) that includes a stationary phase. A sampler or injector 40 implementing a fluid valve 90 may be disposed between the fluid actuator 20 and the separation unit 30 to inject or add (generally referred to as sample introduction) a sample fluid into the mobile phase, thereby providing a fluid sample and mobile phase toward a separation path in which actual sample separation occurs. The stationary phase of the separation unit 30 is configured to separate complexes of the sample liquid. A detector 50 is provided for detecting the complexes of the separated sample fluid. A fractionation unit 60 may be provided for discharging the complexes of the separated sample fluid. Waste (not shown) may also be provided.
[0094] While the mobile phase may consist of only one solvent, it can also be a mixture of multiple solvents. This mixing can be low-pressure mixing and positioned upstream of the fluid drive 20, such that the fluid drive 20 has received and pumped the mixed solvent as the mobile phase. Alternatively, the fluid drive 20 may include multiple separate pumping units, each receiving and pumping a different solvent or mixture, such that mixing of the mobile phase (received by the separation unit 30) occurs at high pressure and downstream of (or as part of) the fluid drive 20. The composition of the mobile phase can remain constant over time (so-called isocratic mode) or vary over time (so-called gradient mode).
[0095] The data processing unit 110 or control unit 70, which may be a PC or workstation and may include one or more processors, may be coupled (as indicated by the dashed arrows) to one or more of the devices in the sample separation apparatus 10 to receive information and / or control operation. For example, the control unit 70 may control the operation of the fluid drive 20 (e.g., setting control parameters) and receive information from it about actual operating conditions (e.g., output pressure at the pump outlet). Optionally, the control unit 70 may also control the operation of the solvent supply 25 (e.g., setting the solvent or solvent mixture to be supplied) and / or the degassing unit 27 (e.g., setting control parameters and / or sending control commands), and may receive information from it about actual operating conditions (e.g., solvent composition supplied over time, vacuum level, etc.). The control unit 70 may further control the operation of the sampling unit or injector 40 (e.g., controlling sample injection or synchronizing sample injection with the operating conditions of the fluid drive 20). The separation unit 30 may also be controlled by the control unit 70 (e.g., selecting a specific flow path or column, setting the operating temperature, etc.), and—in turn—send information (e.g., operating conditions) to the control unit 70. Accordingly, detector 50 can be controlled by control unit 70 (e.g., regarding spectrum or wavelength settings, setting time constants, starting / stopping data acquisition), and information (e.g., regarding the detected sample complex) can be sent to control unit 70. Control unit 70 can also control the operation of fractionation unit 60 (e.g., combining data received from detector 50) and provide data back.
[0096] The sample separation unit 30, configured as a chromatographic separation column, is located inside a temperature-controlled chamber 96 (e.g., a column oven). The fluid sample and / or mobile phase pumped by the fluid driver 20 can be preheated in a preheater assembly 98 located upstream of the sample separation unit 30 within the temperature-controlled chamber 96.
[0097] The control unit 70 and processor 110 can be coupled to a database 82 (such as an electronic mass storage device, e.g., a hard disk) with read and / or write access. The database 82 can store information used by the control unit 70 and its processor 110 to perform calculations, particularly simulations, as described below. The stored data may include calibration data such as the absolute sample separation characteristics of sample components 102 of the test sample 100 described below, datasets related to one or more separation methods, data related to theoretical models and / or empirical data, etc. Furthermore, the control unit 70 is coupled to an input / output unit 84 through which the user can communicate with the sample separation device 10. For example, information (e.g., determined true values 108 of operating parameters, etc.) can be displayed to the user on the display of the input / output unit 84. In addition, the input / output unit 84 may include input elements such as a touchscreen, keyboard, etc. Through the input elements, the user can input commands (e.g., a command to start separation operation) and / or parameter values (e.g., desired flow rate).
[0098] The control unit 70, and specifically its processor 110, can be configured to execute a software-controlled method, which will be described below. As the basis for executing this method, a test sample 100 is provided, which comprises a variety of known sample components 102 (in... Figure 1 The mixture is schematically shown as dots, circles, crosses, and triangles. For example, test sample 100 can be placed in container 120 (e.g., vial, etc.) and injected via injector 40 for separation by sample separation device 10. As the basis for method execution, absolute sample separation characteristics 104 for each sample component 102 can also be provided. In the illustrated embodiment, absolute sample separation characteristics 104 are stored as a dataset in database 82. Descriptively speaking, absolute sample separation characteristics 104 can individually specify the behavior of the respective component 102 with respect to chromatographic separation for each component 102. For example, absolute sample separation characteristics 104 can indicate the retention time of each component 102 for different values of temperature, flow rate, etc. during chromatographic separation operation. Returning to the method, the latter includes experimentally determining the true sample separation result 106 by performing a sample separation method for separating test sample 100 by sample separation device 10. Therefore, according to Figure 1The liquid chromatography-type sample separation device 10 uses a test sample 100 and performs chromatographic separation measurements by executing a gradient run based on a specific chromatographic separation method. The chromatogram can be measured by detector 50 and can be provided as a true sample separation result 106 to control unit 70 and / or processor 110. Processor 110 can then process the true sample separation result 106 and absolute sample separation characteristics 104 to determine true values 108 of one or more operating parameters (e.g., actual temperature and / or actual flow rate of the mobile phase in sample separation unit 30). More specifically, this determination may include a simulation-based comparison between absolute sample separation characteristics 104 and true sample separation result 106 to characterize the actual process of the sample separation method. For example, the true value 108 can be output to the user via input / output unit 84.
[0099] Advantageously, the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 related to chromatography can be independent of the device characteristics of the sample separation apparatus 10 that separates the sample components 102; that is, it can be device-independent universal calibration data that depends only on the component properties. Therefore, the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 only need to be determined once, and can then be stored and used in any sample separation apparatus 10 without recalibration.
[0100] In determining the actual or true value 108 (e.g., the actual temperature in the stationary phase of the sample separation unit 30 during separation), the method executed by the processor 110 may include determining an ideal sample separation result, wherein the actual or true value 108 may deviate from the corresponding target or ideal value defined by the chromatographic separation method due to non-ideal behavior of the sample separation device 10 when the actual sample separation result 106 is measured. Such an ideal separation result can be calculated by the processor 110, for example, based on FEM simulation numerical calculations. In particular, the ideal sample separation result can be determined by simulating the execution of a sample separation method for separating the test sample 100 performed by the sample separation device 10 using the absolute sample separation characteristics 104. In this case, the method executed by the processor 110 can iteratively and repeatedly determine the ideal sample separation result by simulating the execution of the sample separation method using different values of various operating parameters. More specifically, processor 110 can calculate a theoretical or simulated chromatogram as an ideal sample separation result, obtained by performing a separation method on sample separation device 10 to separate test sample 100 under assumed ideal behavior and with specific operating parameters (e.g., temperature, flow rate, gradient distribution, etc.). The assumption of ideal behavior can ignore phenomena such as mobile phase leakage, thermal delay, friction, and interaction with the environment of sample separation device 10. The method executed or controlled by processor 110 can then determine the true values 108 of the various operating parameters as values corresponding to one of the ideal sample separation results that best matches the true sample separation result 106 among all the ideal sample separation results determined through repeated iterations. In other words, the fitting routine can identify a simulated chromatogram that best matches (e.g., with least-squares fitting) the measured chromatogram constituting the true sample separation result 106. One or more operating parameter values corresponding to the best-matched fit can then be output as true values 108. For example, the separation method can specify an ideal or target value for the temperature at sample separation unit 30 during the execution of the separation method at 80°C. However, during the separation method execution at 76°C, the fitting of the actual measured chromatogram to the simulated chromatogram can result in an optimal match of the actual temperature value at the sample separation unit 30. This latter value can be output as the true value 108, which, via the input / output unit 84, indicates to the user the actual deviation of the column temperature from the target value of 4°C defined by the separation method.
[0101] Therefore, the processor 110 can provide information about operational qualifications or performance indicators, which allows inferences about whether the actual operation of the sample separation device 10 meets predetermined specifications, such as whether a column temperature deviation of 4°C is still acceptable.
[0102] Descriptively speaking, component 102 can be used as an absolutely device-independent sensor for operating parameters (such as temperature, flow rate, or solvent composition during gradient operation), and thus hardware sensors are optional. Therefore, the described method enables sensorless sample separation equipment 10.
[0103] Other possible applications of the described method include the transfer of separation methods between different sample separation devices 10, simulation of the separation performance of one sample separation device 10 to another, and diagnosis of potential faults of the sample separation device 10 or its components.
[0104] Figure 2 A scheme for a method performed on a sample separation apparatus 10 according to an exemplary embodiment is shown.
[0105] As can be seen from reference numeral 122, the structure according to an exemplary embodiment of the present invention allows for absolute inspection of any sample separation device 10 without modification. In particular, this can check the absolute specifications of the sample separation device 10 (see block 124), and / or simply determine the parameters used for transferring the separation method between different sample separation devices 10 (see block 126).
[0106] Reference Figures 3 to 18 This section will explain a detailed example relating to the absolute characterization of a test sample 100 comprising multiple components 102. In particular, precise temperature control (e.g., using a water bath, in which the sample separation unit 30 can be placed during calibration) allows for the characterization of components 102. During calibration, each complex or component 102 of the test sample 100 can be eluted proportionally (i.e., with a constant solvent composition) and at multiple temperatures.
[0107] Figure 3 An experimental chromatogram of a test sample 100 comprising a mixture of various known sample components 102, measured by a sample separation device 10 according to an exemplary embodiment, is shown.
[0108] More specifically, Figure 3 The measurement chromatogram relates to the separation of a test sample 100, which comprises seven components 102, when a certain chromatographic separation method is performed on the chromatographic sample separation device 10. This measurement chromatogram can be used as an experimentally determined sample separation result 106. Retention time is plotted along the horizontal axis 128. The signal (e.g., intensity) detected by the detector 50 is plotted along the vertical axis 130. Figure 3 The seven peaks 132 in the sample correspond to the seven components 102 of the test sample 100.
[0109] Figure 4Experimental chromatogram 134 and simulated chromatogram 136 of a test sample 100 according to an exemplary embodiment are shown. The test sample 100 comprises a mixture of seven known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. It can be seen that there are slight differences between chromatograms 134 and 136.
[0110] Referring now to reference numeral 138 in the accompanying drawings, the first set of peaks associated with the test sample 100 corresponds to the early eluted sample component 102, which exhibits a distinct flow rate-dependent absolute sample separation characteristic 104. Therefore, the first set of early eluted sample components 102 is particularly sensitive to flow rate and can thus be used as a fluid flow rate sensor or probe.
[0111] Referring now to reference numeral 140 in the accompanying drawings, the second set of peaks associated with the test sample 100 corresponds to the late-eluting sample component 102 of the absolute sample separation characteristic 104, which exhibits a significant temperature dependence. Therefore, the second set of late-eluting sample components 102 is particularly sensitive to temperature and can thus be used as a fluid temperature sensor or probe.
[0112] Referring now to reference numeral 142 in the accompanying drawings, the third set of peaks associated with the test sample 100 corresponds to sample component 102 with elution rates between the early and late elution rates, exhibiting an absolute sample separation characteristic 104 that is significantly dependent on the gradient distribution. Therefore, this third set of sample components 102, with its intermediate elution rate, is particularly sensitive to the solvent composition and can thus be used as a fluid gradient sensor or probe.
[0113] Therefore, it has the basis Figure 4The test sample 100, comprising component 102 (used as multiple external standards), is a sample mixture serving as an internal probe for flow / delay volume, gradient accuracy, and temperature. The test sample 100 can be qualified in an absolute manner to obtain absolute values regarding instrument behavior. Requalification of system variants may be unnecessary if the instrument's behavior is known to be related to simulations of its actual behavior. One or more components 102 can be used as internal temperature probes. Friction heating can also be employed. In embodiments, the test sample 100 can also be used as a method compatibility tracer. Furthermore, one or more method transfer parameters can be predicted over a wide range. The performance of a pump with multiple solvent inlets can be highly dependent on its construction in complex ways. The mixing of several components 102 of the test sample 100 allows for the measurement of performance within a chromatographic environment. A Coriolis sensor can be added to improve accuracy. Therefore, when the test sample 100 is implemented as a fluid sensor, one or more hardware sensors may or may not be implemented in the sample separation device 10. In embodiments, samples operated remotely by the user can be analyzed in an absolute manner, for example, in terms of potential defects. Therefore, the mixed test sample 100 can be used as a standard for determining flow rate, delay, gradient accuracy, and / or temperature.
[0114] Compared to the sample separation device 10 that uses hardware sensors to determine operating parameter values, the advantages of this embodiment are that the exemplary embodiment can determine the operating behavior under chromatographic conditions, thus being highly accurate, and does not require external sensors or recalibration. Furthermore, users can be provided with the option to perform a one-click identification test kit (requiring sensor installation and / or removal).
[0115] Now for reference Figures 5 to 7 The embodiment can determine the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 of the components 102 of the mixed test sample 100 by performing calibration measurements on each sample component 102 during calibration by changing multiple operating parameters. More specifically, calibration measurements can be performed by changing operating parameters, such as the temperature of each sample component 102, the flow rate of the mobile phase through which each sample component 102 is transported and / or separated, and the composition of the mobile phase through which each sample component 102 is transported and / or separated (in particular, changing the corresponding gradient distribution). Advantageously, calibration measurements can be performed in isocratic mode, i.e., with a constant solvent composition of the mobile phase. Thus, multiple chromatograms can be measured in isocratic mode for each component 102 of the test sample 100. For example, in various chromatograms, the temperature can be varied, the solvent composition can be varied, the flow rate can be varied, and so on. The chromatograms can be used as calibration information conveying the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 for each sample component 102. Figures 5 to 7 It shows the basis Figure 3 and Figure 4The absolute sample separation characteristics 104 obtained by running absolute calibration in isocratic mode on test sample 100 are as follows: Figure 5 A three-dimensional plot 144 illustrates the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 of the early elution component 102 (nortryptyline hydrochloride) of the mixture according to an exemplary embodiment. Temperature is plotted along axis 146, and the percentage of organic solvent in the mobile phase is plotted along axis 148. The natural logarithm of the decreasing retention factor k' is plotted along axis 150. Descriptively speaking, the retention time increases in the upward direction along axis 150. Therefore, Figure 5 The results of absolute calibration obtained from an isocratic run of one component 102 of test sample 100 are shown. Descriptively, the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 of each component 102 are shown as a spatial response surface.
[0116] Figure 6 A three-dimensional diagram 152 is shown, illustrating the absolute sample separation characteristics 104 of the late-eluting sample component 102 (di-octylphthalate) of the mixture according to an exemplary embodiment. Figure 6 The spatial response surface exhibits a strong temperature dependence. To determine the corresponding calibration information, a mass spectrometer can be used as an additional detector (especially for peak identification).
[0117] Figure 7 A two-dimensional figure 154 is shown, illustrating the absolute sample separation characteristics of seven different components 102 of the mixture according to an exemplary embodiment. Figure 154 has a vertical axis 156 plotting parameters indicating retention time. The different curves 158 in Figure 154 relate to the different components 102 of the test sample 100 and indicate their respective experimental behavior according to a specific parameter (in the case of the organic solvent percentage). Figure 7 The projection of the response surface at 80°C is shown.
[0118] Challenges may arise when the different curves in Figure 154 intersect and when different components 102 can exchange elution positions. This can involve difficulties with automated analysis regarding potential suppression, given the interactions between different eluents. This can occur, for example, when the eluent is sensitive to buffer. The two eluents can then switch positions within the eluent. These problems can be overcome when using a mass spectrometer as the detector. Dividing a test sample 100 with a large number of components 102 into two or more distinct test samples, each with a smaller number of components, may also be helpful.
[0119] Figure 8A simulated chromatogram 160 is shown for a test sample 100 simulated by a sample separation device 10 according to an exemplary embodiment. The test sample 100 comprises a mixture of various known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. Figure 8 A gradient distribution 162 according to a chromatographic separation method used to separate test sample 100 by chromatographic sample separation device 10 is also shown. When the sample separation device 10 is used to perform a separation method for separating component 102 of test sample 100 using the illustrated gradient distribution 162, a chromatogram 160 can be obtained. The simulation shown can use calibration results from the aforementioned isocratic measurements. Descriptively speaking, each data point 164 on gradient distribution 162 can be assigned to a specific isocratic measurement. Therefore, taking into account the absolute calibration of test sample 100 and its component 102, a simulation of chromatogram 160 based on calibration data and gradient distribution 162 can be performed.
[0120] Figure 9 Chromatogram 166 of the experiment or measurement is shown. Figure 10 A simulated chromatogram 168 of a test sample 100 according to an exemplary embodiment is shown. The test sample 100 comprises a mixture of various known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. Therefore, Figure 10 A simulation of gradient operation for separating test sample 100 on sample separation device 10 is shown. Figure 9 The results of a gradient run measured under the same settings, i.e., based on the same separation method and using the same sample separation device 10, are shown. Although there are small variations in region 170 (which may be due to artifacts caused by the pH dependence of the fluid), a proper correspondence can be identified between the measured chromatogram 166 and the simulated chromatogram 168. Therefore, it can be concluded that the values of a set of operating parameters used to determine the simulated chromatogram 168 (e.g., a temperature of 68°C and a flow rate of 0.9 ml / min, etc.) are suitable fitting parameters for fitting the measured chromatogram 166. Therefore, it can be inferred that these operating parameters are the true values 108 in the sample separation device 10 when measuring chromatogram 166. If, for example, target operating parameters such as 70°C and a flow rate of 1 ml / min are defined in the separation method, it is possible to analyze whether the detected deviation is still within the specifications of the sample separation device 10 or has already exceeded the specifications of the sample separation device 10.
[0121] Figure 11An experimental chromatogram 172 using a first predetermined temperature (e.g., 80°C) according to an exemplary embodiment is shown, and a simulated chromatogram 174 using a second simulated temperature (e.g., 76 ± 1°C) is shown for a test sample 100 comprising a mixture of various known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. The test sample 100 (and particularly a subset of its components 102) can be used as a temperature sensor. A proper correspondence between simulation and measurement can be achieved by assuming an actual temperature of 76°C, i.e., a deviation of 4°C from the target temperature of 80°C according to the prescribed chromatographic separation method.
[0122] Figure 12 A model of a sample separation unit 30 for a sample separation device 10, used as the basis for finite element simulation (FEM) according to an exemplary embodiment, is shown. Figure 12 The FEM analysis models the environment of the chromatographic separation column used as sample separation unit 30. This environment includes a preheater assembly 98 and a capillary 176. Sample separation unit 30 itself can be modeled by a stationary phase 180 surrounded by a housing 182. The flow directions of the fluid sample and the mobile phase during separation are indicated by reference numeral 178. The model shown allows for temperature measurements using component 102 of the test sample 100 at an assumed flow rate (e.g., 1 ml / min). This can be referenced as... Figure 11 Temperature determination is performed as described.
[0123] Figure 13 Different simulated chromatograms 184, 186, and 188 are shown according to an exemplary embodiment of a test sample 100 comprising a mixture of various known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. Chromatogram 184 is used as a reference. Chromatogram 186 is obtained when the flow rate is changed by -2%. Chromatogram 188 is obtained when the gradient is changed by +2%. Therefore, Figure 13 The test sample 100 shown for the simulation can be used as a flow sensor and / or gradient sensor. Figure 14 Showing Figure 13 The details of the chromatogram illustrate how flow error affects all peaks. Figure 15 It shows Figure 13 Another detail shows that gradient error affects all peaks.
[0124] Figure 16 Chromatograms 184, 186, and 188 of a test sample 100 configured as a flow and gradient sensor according to an exemplary embodiment are shown. The test sample 100 comprises a mixture of various known sample components 102 with different chromatographic properties. Figure 16 Corresponding to a temperature of 40℃, and Figure 13 This corresponds to a temperature of 80℃.
[0125] Figure 17 Figure 190 illustrates solvent management for a sample separation apparatus 10 according to an exemplary embodiment. The horizontal axis 192 plots drift (in g / cm), while the vertical axis 194 plots frequency. Figure 190 shows the drift distribution for error per time.
[0126] according to Figure 17 Embodiments of the present invention can also be used for solvent management and / or level sensing. Assume the load sensor mass is 5 kg. A built-in analog-to-digital converter (ADC) from the degasser pressure measurement is used. The ADC is 16-bit and operates at 125 Hz (since analog circuitry is not intended for this purpose, this may correspond to non-ideal operating conditions).
[0127] Under these conditions, tests showed a drift of 21 mg / min, which allows for solvent identification. The load sensor can be specified to be 8 mg / min, thus flow accuracy is measurable (e.g., in the range of 10 µl / min to 50 µl / min). Drift can be less than or equal to the stroke of 4 mg / min, thus compositional accuracy is measurable.
[0128] Figure 18 Different details of the sample separation apparatus 10 according to an exemplary embodiment are shown. More specifically, Figure 18 This demonstrates how an automated test for operational identification can be performed using the sample separation device 10.
[0129] Reference numeral 195 illustrates the system testing of the liquid chromatography-type sample separation device 10. The user can install the operation qualification-specific sample separation unit 30, see reference numeral 196. As shown in reference numeral 197, the user can insert a consumable sample tray. Additionally, the user can attach a pre-prepared solvent, see reference numeral 198. The above-described method is then performed to determine whether the sample separation device 10 meets predetermined specifications, thereby passing or failing the operation qualification. If the test fails, the program will immediately stop and notify the user of the required operation, including any deviations from the protocol. The test results can be displayed on the input / output unit 84.
[0130] It should be noted that the term "comprising" does not exclude other elements, and "a" or "an" does not exclude multiple elements. Furthermore, elements described with respect to different embodiments can be combined. It should also be noted that the reference numerals in the claims should not be construed as limiting the scope of the claims.
Claims
1. A method for determining true parameter values for sample separation, based on a provided test sample (100) comprising a mixture of multiple known sample components (102) and based on the absolute sample separation characteristics (104) of each of the provided sample components (102), the method comprising: The true sample separation result (106) is experimentally determined by performing a sample separation method for separating the test sample (100) using a sample separation device (10). and The true value (108) of at least one operating parameter is determined by comparing the absolute sample separation characteristics (104) with the actual sample separation results (106) to characterize the actual process of the sample separation method.
2. The method according to claim 1, comprising at least one of the following features: in, The method includes providing at least a portion of the sample component (102) to the test sample (100), the at least portion of the sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is temperature-dependent. The method includes providing at least a portion of the sample component (102) to the test sample (100), the at least portion of the sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is flow rate dependent. The method includes providing at least a portion of the sample component (102) to the test sample (100), the at least portion of the sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is dependent on the composition of the mobile phase solvent.
3. The method according to claim 1, comprising at least one of the following features: in, The method includes providing the test sample (100) with at least one late-eluting sample component (102), the at least one late-eluting sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is temperature-dependent. The method includes providing at least one early elution sample component (102) to the test sample (100), the at least one early elution sample component (102) having flow rate-dependent absolute sample separation characteristics (104). The method includes providing the test sample (100) with at least one sample component (102) having an elution rate between at least one early eluted sample component (102) and at least one late eluted sample component (102), the at least one sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is dependent on the composition of the mobile phase solvent.
4. The method according to claim 1, wherein, The method includes providing at least a portion of the sample component (102) to the test sample (100), the at least portion of the sample component (102) having an absolute sample separation characteristic (104) that is dependent on the distribution of the mobile phase gradient.
5. The method according to any one of claims 1-4, comprising at least one of the following features: in, The absolute sample separation characteristics (104) are independent of the equipment characteristics of the sample separation device (10) that separates the sample components (102); The absolute sample separation characteristic (104) is the chromatographic sample separation characteristic.
6. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes determining the absolute sample separation characteristics (104) by performing calibration measurements for each of the sample components (102) with changes to at least one operating parameter.
7. The method according to claim 6, wherein, The method includes performing the calibration measurement by changing at least one of the following operating parameters: the temperature of each sample component (102), the flow rate of the mobile phase for conveying and / or separating each sample component (102), and the composition of the mobile phase for conveying and / or separating each sample component (102).
8. The method according to claim 6, wherein, The method includes performing the calibration measurement in a moving equivalence mode.
9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes experimentally determining the true sample separation result by performing the sample separation method in a moving phase gradient mode (106).
10. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes experimentally determining the separation result of the real sample by performing a chromatographic sample separation method (106).
11. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes determining the true value (108) of at least one operating parameter from the group consisting of: temperature during sample separation, flow rate of the mobile phase of the test sample (100) being transported and / or separated, composition of the mobile phase of the test sample (100) being transported and / or separated, and at least one performance value indicating the performance of the sample separation device (10).
12. The method according to claim 11, wherein, The at least one performance value indicates whether the performance of the sample separation device (10) meets the predetermined specifications.
13. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes determining the ideal sample separation result.
14. The method according to claim 13, wherein, The method includes determining the ideal sample separation result by simulating the absolute sample separation characteristics (104).
15. The method according to claim 14, wherein, The method includes determining the ideal sample separation result by simulating the execution of the sample separation method for separating the test sample (100) by the sample separation device (10) using the absolute sample separation characteristic (104).
16. The method according to claim 13, wherein, The method includes iteratively determining the ideal sample separation result by simulating the execution of the sample separation method with different values of at least one operating parameter.
17. The method according to claim 13, wherein, The method includes determining the true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter as the value of the at least one operating parameter, the value of the at least one operating parameter corresponding to the ideal sample separation result that conforms to the true sample separation result (106).
18. The method according to claim 17, wherein the value of the at least one operating parameter corresponds to the ideal sample separation result that best matches the true sample separation result (106) in the ideal sample separation result determined by repetition and iteration.
19. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The method includes determining at least one true parameter value by performing numerical analysis, taking into account the absolute sample separation characteristics (104).
20. The method according to claim 19, wherein, The numerical analysis mentioned is a finite element method analysis.
21. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, Based on additional test samples provided, comprising additional mixtures of multiple other known sample components, and based on provided absolute sample separation characteristics for each additional sample component, the method includes: The results of separating additional real samples are experimentally determined by performing a sample separation method for separating the additional test samples using the sample separation device; and The true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter is determined by comparing the absolute sample separation characteristic (104) with the true sample separation results (106) of the mixture of the test sample (100) and the other mixture, in order to characterize the true process of the sample separation method.
22. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, comprising at least one of the following features: in, The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter as the sensed value of the at least one operating parameter; The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter as a performance indicator indicating the performance of the sample separation device (10) for experimentally determining the true sample separation result (106), wherein the performance indicator is used in cases including at least one of the following: initial installation of the sample separation device (10), repair of the sample separation device (10), maintenance of the sample separation device (10), and expiration of a predetermined time from the prior determination of the performance indicator; The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter to switch the sample separation method between different sample separation devices; The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter to diagnose potential faults in the sample separation device (10) or a portion thereof; The method includes simulating the execution of the sample separation method on another sample separation device using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter; The method includes evaluating the sample separation result obtained by performing the sample separation method on the sample separation device (10) using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter.
23. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 4, comprising at least one of the following features: in, The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter as at least one of the group consisting of sensing temperature, sensing flow rate, sensing mobile phase solvent composition and sensing mobile phase gradient distribution; The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter as a performance indicator, which indicates whether the sample separation device (10) meets a predetermined specification; The method includes using the determined true value (108) of the at least one operating parameter to evaluate the sample separation result obtained by performing the sample separation method through a sensorless sample separation device (10) and / or through a sample separation device (10) without resources for controlling the at least one operating parameter.
24. A computer-readable medium storing a computer program that, when executed by one or more processors (110), is adapted to perform or control the method according to any one of claims 1 to 23.
25. A program element, wherein, The program element, when executed by one or more processors (110), is adapted to perform or control the method according to any one of claims 1 to 23.
26. A sample separation device (10) for separating fluid samples, wherein, The sample separation device (10) includes: A fluid actuator (20) for driving the mobile phase and the fluid sample injected into the mobile phase; Sample separation unit (30), which is used to separate the fluid sample from the mobile phase; and A processor (110) configured to perform or control the method according to any one of claims 1 to 23 using the sample separation device (10) and the test sample (100) as the fluid sample.
27. The sample separation device (10) according to claim 26, wherein, The sample separation device (10) includes at least one of the following features: The sample separation device (10) includes the test sample (100), which comprises a mixture of various known sample components (102); The sample separation device (10) is configured as a chromatographic sample separation device; The sample separation device (10) includes a detector (50) configured to detect the separated fluid sample. The sample separation device (10) includes a fractionation unit (60) configured to collect the separated fractions of the fluid sample. The sample separation device (10) includes an injector (40) configured to inject the fluid sample into the mobile phase.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Microfluidic chip frame
EP1577012A1
Liquid chromatography adjustment for method-conformally compensating deviations from ideal behavior
US20120096919A1
