A method for evaluating instrument response parameters of broadband seismic arrays

By receiving and processing seismic signals, calculating the maximum amplitude ratio of the seismic event waveform, the problem that the response parameters of the earthquake station cannot be regularly corrected is solved, and the accuracy of the instrument response parameters is quickly judged without affecting the observation continuity. , improves the reliability of seismic observation data.

CN118519197BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-19INST OF GEOPHYSICS CHINA EARTHQUAKE ADMINISTRATION
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410609888.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-05-16
Publication Date
2024-11-19
Estimated Expiration
2044-05-16

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art cannot effectively and regularly correct the response parameters of the earthquake station instrument, resulting in the accuracy of the instrument response parameters, especially when the instrument cannot be taken back to the vibration table for calibration, which affects the continuity and accuracy of the observation data.

Method used

By receiving seismic signals, format conversion and filtering, the maximum amplitude ratio of the seismic event waveform is calculated, and the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument are evaluated, including calculating the epicenter distance, obtaining the maximum in the P-wave theory arrival and selected time window Amplitude, use the long-term window ratio method to obtain the first arrival time, and compare the maximum amplitude ratio of the three-components to achieve a fast batch evaluation of the instrument response parameters.

Benefits of technology

Without the need to get the vibration table back, it can quickly batch judge whether the response parameters of the seismic observation instrument are consistent with the manufacturer's nominal value, ensure the normal operation of the instrument, and improve the reliability of the deep structure research on the earth and the continuity of observation data.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118519197B_ABST
    Figure CN118519197B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses an evaluation method for response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments, comprising: S1, receiving seismic signals through broadband seismic array instruments, and converting the format of observation records of broadband seismic array instruments to obtain seismic waveforms after format conversion; S2, intercepting the seismic waveforms after format conversion according to a global earthquake catalog to obtain seismic event waveform records; S3, filtering the seismic event waveform records, and obtaining the first arrival time of the filtered seismic event waveform records; S4, obtaining the maximum amplitude in a selected time window according to the first arrival time, and calculating the maximum amplitude ratio of three-component seismic records of the station to complete the evaluation of response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments. The invention does not need to take the observation instrument back to the vibration table for calibration to ensure the continuity of the observation record, and can quickly evaluate the instrument response parameters of a large number of array seismometers.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the field of instrument parameter measurement, and in particular to an evaluation method for response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments. Background Art

[0002] In recent years, a number of studies conducted by multiple stations of the Global Seismic Network (GSN) and the United States Mobile Seismic Array Program (USArray) have confirmed that the instrument response of broadband seismometers, namely parameters such as system sensitivity and zero poles, differ from the manufacturer's nominal values ​​over time and frequency, and the instrument response data needs to be calibrated regularly.

[0003] For my country's current seismic observation network consisting of more than 1,000 fixed seismic stations and thousands of mobile seismic stations, there are problems such as instrument replacement, parameter consistency differences in batch equipment, and performance parameter changes due to circuit aging after years of use. The accuracy of instrument response parameters will inevitably be affected accordingly. However, the current instrument response files of seismic stations are basically based on the factory parameters of the instrument, and there is almost no subsequent detection and calibration work. Even if the seismometer is calibrated before the seismic array observation, it is difficult to ensure that the instrument response parameters will not suddenly change or gradually change over time during the continuous operation of the observation instrument. In the process of station observation, in order to ensure the continuity of observation data, it is impossible to take the instrument back to the shaking table for regular calibration. Even if the seismometer can be taken back to the shaking table for calibration, the calibration workload will be huge when facing thousands of seismometers. Summary of the invention

[0004] In view of the above-mentioned deficiencies in the prior art, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the response parameters of a broadband seismic array instrument, which solves the problem that the instrument cannot be brought back to the shaking table for regular calibration.

[0005] In order to achieve the above-mentioned invention object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is: a method for evaluating the response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments, comprising:

[0006] S1. receiving seismic signals through a broadband seismic array instrument, and converting the format of the observation records of the broadband seismic array instrument to obtain a seismic waveform after the format conversion;

[0007] S2. According to the global earthquake catalog, the earthquake waveform after format conversion is intercepted to obtain the earthquake event waveform record;

[0008] S3, filtering the earthquake event waveform record, and obtaining the first arrival time of the earthquake event waveform record after filtering;

[0009] S4. According to the first arrival time, the maximum amplitude in the selected time window is obtained, and the maximum amplitude ratio of the three-component records of the station is calculated to complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument.

[0010] Further: S2 includes:

[0011] S21. Calculate the epicenter distances of different stations in the seismic array based on the global earthquake catalog;

[0012] S22, select earthquake events with epicentral distances between 30° and 90°, and calculate the theoretical arrival time of P waves of the earthquake events at each station;

[0013] S23, obtaining the seismic event waveform of the selected time window including the theoretical arrival time and the intercepted P-wave arrival time as the seismic event waveform record.

[0014] Further: S3 includes:

[0015] S1, band-pass filtering the earthquake event waveform record to obtain a filtered earthquake event waveform record;

[0016] S2. For the filtered earthquake event waveform records, the long-short time window ratio method is used to obtain the first arrival time of different events at different stations.

[0017] Further: S4 includes:

[0018] S41, according to the first arrival time, obtaining the maximum amplitude of all earthquake event records in the selected time window of each station;

[0019] S42, summing and averaging the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components of all earthquake event records at each station to obtain an average value of the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components;

[0020] S43. Compare the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of each earthquake event record with the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the station, and compare the maximum amplitudes of the three components of each earthquake record with each other, and complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument based on the compared deviation values.

[0021] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:

[0022] 1. By analyzing the amplitude ratios between different components of teleseismic event data recorded by broadband seismographs, it is possible to quickly and simultaneously determine in batches whether there is a deviation between the response parameters of seismic observation instruments and the instrument parameters specified by the manufacturer without taking the seismographs back to the shaking table for calibration; it is possible to determine in near real time whether the observation instruments are working properly while ensuring the continuity of instrument observation;

[0023] 2. For existing observation records, we can select data with problems in the corresponding instrument parameters and eliminate these data when conducting deep structure research, thereby improving the reliability of the results of the deep structure research of the Earth. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0024] Figure 1 Flow chart of the evaluation method for broadband seismic array instrument response parameters.

[0025] Figure 2 This is the distribution diagram of the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of all earthquake events recorded at stations X2.15667, X2.15669, X2.15670 and X2.15703 to the average maximum amplitude of their vertical components.

[0026] Figure 3 Distribution diagram of the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the east-west component to the maximum amplitude of the north-south component recorded for all earthquake events at stations X2.15592 and X2.15595.

[0027] Figure 4 Schematic diagram of the station where the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Nmax, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax do not change with time.

[0028] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the station where the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax change over time.

[0029] Figure 6 Schematic diagram of the stations where the average value of Zmax / aveZ does not change with time, while the average values ​​of Emax / Nmax, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax change with time.

[0030] Figure 7 Schematic diagram of the stations where the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Nmax, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax change over time.

[0031] Figure 8 These are the cross-correlation superposition results and dispersion extraction diagrams of data at different stages at stations X2.61073 and X2.WT71.

[0032] Fig. 9 This is the distribution diagram of the amplitude ratio and Rayleigh wave ZH ratio of stations X2.62380 and X2.62408. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0033] The specific implementation modes of the present invention are described below so that those skilled in the art can understand the present invention. However, it should be clear that the present invention is not limited to the scope of the specific implementation modes. For those of ordinary skill in the art, as long as various changes are within the spirit and scope of the present invention as defined and determined by the attached claims, these changes are obvious, and all inventions and creations utilizing the concept of the present invention are protected.

[0034] like Figure 1 As shown, in one embodiment of the present invention, a method for evaluating response parameters of a broadband seismic array instrument is provided, comprising:

[0035] S1. receiving seismic signals through a broadband seismic array instrument, and converting the format of the observation records of the broadband seismic array instrument to obtain a seismic waveform after the format conversion;

[0036] S2. According to the global earthquake catalog, the earthquake waveform after format conversion is intercepted to obtain the earthquake event waveform record;

[0037] S3, filtering the earthquake event waveform record, and obtaining the first arrival time of the earthquake event waveform record after filtering;

[0038] S4. According to the first arrival time, the maximum amplitude in the selected time window is obtained, and the maximum amplitude ratio of the three-component records of the station is calculated to complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument.

[0039] The S2 includes:

[0040] S21. Calculate the epicenter distances of different stations in the seismic array based on the global earthquake catalog;

[0041] S22, select earthquake events with epicentral distances between 30° and 90°, and calculate the theoretical arrival time of P waves of the earthquake events at each station;

[0042] S23, obtaining the seismic event waveform of the selected time window including the theoretical arrival time and the intercepted P-wave arrival time as the seismic event waveform record.

[0043] The S3 includes:

[0044] S1, band-pass filtering the earthquake event waveform record to obtain a filtered earthquake event waveform record;

[0045] S2. For the filtered earthquake event waveform records, the long-short time window ratio method is used to obtain the first arrival time of different events at different stations.

[0046] The S4 includes:

[0047] S41, according to the first arrival time, obtaining the maximum amplitude of all earthquake event records in the selected time window of each station;

[0048] S42, summing and averaging the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components of all earthquake event records at each station to obtain an average value of the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components;

[0049] S43. Compare the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of each earthquake event record with the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the station, and compare the maximum amplitudes of the three components of each earthquake record with each other, and complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument based on the compared deviation values.

[0050] In one embodiment of the present invention, the response parameters of the three-component sensor are evaluated. The three-component sensor has independent instrument response parameters, so the original seismic record contains three components, which are generally divided into vertical (UD), north-south (NS) and east-west (EW). In order to verify whether the instrument parameters of the three-component sensor change over time, whether it is a seismic record retrieved in the field or a seismic record acquired by real-time transmission, the three-component seismic record needs to be separated from an overall data packet, and the format needs to be converted to sac format;

[0051] Download the global earthquake catalog provided by USGS and calculate the epicentral distance of different stations in the seismic array. Select earthquake events with an epicentral distance of 30°-90° and calculate the theoretical arrival time of P waves at each station. According to the theoretical arrival time, intercept the earthquake records of 150 seconds before and after the arrival of the P wave for 50 seconds. The reason why earthquake events with an epicentral distance of 30°-90° are selected is that the seismic rays in this epicentral distance range do not contain interference from other seismic phase signals in the P wave signal window we intercepted. In order to minimize the interference of environmental noise and ensure that the seismic signal is significantly stronger than the environmental noise, it is necessary to select earthquake events with larger magnitudes. At the same time, since this method is based on statistical judgments, a certain number of data samples are required. If the magnitude is too large, the sample size will be small. After comprehensive consideration, earthquake events with a magnitude greater than 5 are selected, which not only ensures the magnitude but also the number of samples.

[0052] Each seismic event record recorded by different stations in the seismic array is subjected to a 0.1-1Hz bandpass filter to enhance the signal-to-noise ratio and highlight the seismic signal. Next, the long-short time window ratio (STA / LTA) method is used to obtain the first arrival time of different events at different stations. Obtaining a more reliable first arrival time is to ensure that the maximum amplitude of the three components obtained in the target time window in the next step comes from the seismic signal, rather than the spur caused by human activities.

[0053] Based on the different earthquake records obtained from different stations, the maximum amplitude of the vertical, north-south and east-west earthquake records within a 20-second time window of 10 seconds before and after the first arrival time is obtained, taking the first arrival time as the benchmark. Next, the vertical maximum amplitude of the target window of all earthquake event records at each station is summed and averaged. This average amplitude can represent the benchmark value of the vertical amplitude recorded by the seismograph vertical component sensor for earthquake events with a distance of 30-90° from the epicenter and a magnitude greater than 5 when the instrument response is normal. Then, the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of each earthquake record is compared with the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the station, which can intuitively reflect whether the instrument response parameters of the vertical component of the seismometer change over time. If the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the earthquake event record within a period of time has a significant deviation from the average value of its maximum amplitude, it reflects that its vertical component has an abnormal instrument response during this period.

[0054] like Figure 2 As shown, this is a distribution diagram of the vertical maximum amplitude of all earthquake events at stations X2.15667, X2.15669, X2.15703 and X2.15703 compared with their vertical average maximum amplitude. From the figure, it can be seen that the ratio of the vertical maximum amplitude to the average maximum amplitude of these four stations changes with time, indicating that the instrument response of the vertical component sensor changes with time.

[0055] Under normal circumstances, the horizontal component particle vibrations of the teleseismic P-wave seismic records recorded by the station all come from the P-wave vibration energy. Since the seismic events recorded by each station may have different azimuths, the polarization components obtained from the two horizontal components of different events are also different. However, if a station can record a large number of seismic events from different azimuths, the average value of the maximum amplitude ratio of the two horizontal components (i.e., the east-west component and the north-south component) of a large number of seismic events should be used to represent the ratio of the instrument response parameters of the two components. By calculating the maximum amplitude ratio of the east-west component to the north-south component of tens of millions of seismic events recorded by 3,000 broadband stations, it was found that the average value of the ratio of the two horizontal components of the seismic event records of most broadband stations is close to 1, and the average value of the two horizontal components does not change with time.

[0056] like Figure 3 The figure shows the distribution of the ratio of the maximum amplitude in the east-west direction to the maximum amplitude in the north-south direction for all earthquake events at stations X2.15592 and X2.15595. The black dots in the figure represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude in the east-west direction to the maximum amplitude in the north-south direction of different earthquake events -1, and the red dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude in the north-south direction to the maximum amplitude in the east-west direction of different earthquake events +1.

[0057] In order to determine whether the three-component seismic instrument response parameters change over time, and if so, which component instrument response parameters have changed, it is necessary to compare the maximum amplitude of the east-west component with the maximum amplitude of the north-south component, and the maximum amplitude of the east-west component and the maximum amplitude of the north-south component with the maximum amplitude of the vertical component. Combined with the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the previous station to the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of this station, it can be determined whether the three-component instrument response of the seismic instrument is normal.

[0058] There are several specific situations:

[0059] To simplify the description, aveZ is used below to represent the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of all earthquake events at a station, Zmax represents the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of an earthquake event recorded by a station, Emax represents the maximum amplitude of the east-west component of an earthquake event recorded by a station, and Nmax represents the maximum amplitude of the north-south component of an earthquake event recorded by a station.

[0060] Case 1:

[0061] like Figure 4 As shown, if the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Nmax, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax of the earthquake events recorded by the station do not change with time, it means that the instrument responses of the three components are normal.

[0062] Case 2:

[0063] like Figure 5 As shown in the figure, if the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax of earthquake events recorded by the station during a period of time change with time, and the average value of Emax / Nmax does not change with time, it can be judged that there is an abnormality in the instrument response of the vertical component during this period of time.

[0064] Case 3:

[0065] like Figure 6 As shown in the figure, if the average value of Zmax / aveZ of earthquake events recorded by the station during a period of time remains unchanged, but the average value of Emax / Nmax changes, it can be judged that the instrument response of one of the east-west component and the north-south component during this period of time is abnormal;

[0066] At this time, combined with the average values ​​of Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax in the corresponding time period, if the average value of Emax / Zmax changes, it means that the instrument response of the east-west component is abnormal during this period. If the average value of Nmax / Zmax changes, it means that the instrument response of the north-south component is abnormal. If the average values ​​of Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax both change, it means that the instrument responses of both the east-west component and the north-south component are abnormal.

[0067] Case 4:

[0068] like Figure 7 As shown in the figure, if the average values ​​of Zmax / aveZ, Emax / Nmax, Emax / Zmax and Nmax / Zmax of earthquake events recorded by the station during a period of time all change with time, it can be determined that the instrument responses of the three components during this period of time are abnormal.

[0069] Figure 4-Figure 7 In the figure, the horizontal axis represents time, and the vertical axis represents different amplitude ratios; Zmax / aveZ: the black dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of each earthquake record to the average vertical maximum amplitude of all events at the station; Emax / Nmax: the black dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the east-west component of each earthquake record to the maximum amplitude of the north-south component -1, and the red dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the north-south component to the maximum amplitude of the east-west component +1; Emax / Zmax: the black dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the east-west component of each earthquake record to the maximum amplitude of the vertical component -1, and the red dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component to the maximum amplitude of the east-west component +1; Nmax / Zmax: the black dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the north-south component of each earthquake record to the maximum amplitude of the vertical component -1, and the red dots represent the ratio of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component to the maximum amplitude of the north-south component +1.

[0070] By analyzing the above amplitude ratio results, if the average value of the above amplitude ratio of the station during the operation time of the station changes within 5%, it can be considered that the instrument response parameters of the three components of the station basically do not change over time during operation. If the amplitude ratio of different components changes more than 5% from the corresponding average amplitude ratio of all events of the station over a period of time, it means that there is a deviation between the instrument response parameters and the manufacturer's nominal instrument response parameters, and the instrument being observed needs to be inspected, repaired or replaced. At the same time, before conducting deep structure research, the data with abnormal amplitude ratios should be eliminated.

[0071] Many existing seismological inversion methods (such as receiver function, noise imaging, shear wave splitting, ZH amplitude ratio) require not only a large amount of data to obtain deep structures, but also rely on the reliability of waveform information. In order to verify whether these potentially problematic data will affect the stability and reliability of deep structure research results, the cross-correlation function and dispersion curve of waveform records of some stations that may have problems can be calculated and extracted, and the results can be compared and analyzed.

[0072] Figure 8 It shows that the amplitude ratio of different components at station X2.61073 remains constant during the observation period, e.g. Figure 4 ) and the cross-correlation functions and extracted dispersion curves of the data from the X2.WT71 station from January to October 2014 (hereafter referred to as Phase 1), from November 2014 to July 2015 (hereafter referred to as Phase 2), and from January 2014 to July 2015 (hereafter referred to as all data). Figure 8 In the figure, the grey boxes represent stage 1 data, the red boxes represent stage 2 data, the blue boxes represent all data, and the red, grey and blue arrows indicate the cross-correlation superposition results and the extracted dispersion curves of stage 2, stage 1 and all data, respectively.

[0073] No effective signal can be seen in the cross-correlation function of the stage 2 data superposition, and the dispersion curve cannot be extracted; the cross-correlation function of the stage 1 and the entire data superposition can see an obvious signal. If the dispersion curve is extracted with a signal-to-noise ratio greater than 5 as the standard, the cross-correlation function of the stage 1 data superposition can extract dispersion data with a period of 8-47s, while the cross-correlation function of the entire data superposition can only extract dispersion data with a period of 8-42s. By carefully comparing the differences between the dispersion velocities extracted from stage 1 and the entire data, as shown in Table 1:

[0074] Table 1 Comparative analysis of data dispersion at different stages

[0075]

[0076] It can be found that in the range of 30-42s, there is a velocity difference of about 1%-3% between the two, and the velocity difference of 1%-3% will have a significant impact on the subsequent analysis of the composition and physical and chemical properties of crustal materials.

[0077] In addition to analyzing the cross-correlation functions of some stations, the necessity of evaluating the response of seismic instruments can also be shown by calculating the amplitude ratio of Rayleigh waves ZH at stations with possible abnormalities;

[0078] Fig. 9Two stations (stations X2.62380 and X2.62408) with abnormal ZH ratios due to abnormal instrument responses are shown. In the figure, ZH represents the ZH ratio of a 10s period Rayleigh surface wave, and the black dots represent the ZH ratios of different events.

[0079] From the ZH ratio results of X2.62380 and X2.62408, we can see that during the period of time when the amplitude ratios between different components changed abnormally in 2014 and 2016, the corresponding ZH ratio results (period of 10s) also changed significantly. The average ZH ratio of Rayleigh waves from January to September 2014 at X2.62380 was about 0.74, while the average ZH ratio of Rayleigh waves from October 2014 to May 2016 was about 1.00. The average ZH ratio of Rayleigh waves from January to August 2014 at X2.62408 was about 1.06, while the average ZH ratio of Rayleigh waves from December 2014 to May 2016 was about 0.14. The calculation results of the actual station observation data above show that there is a very large difference between the results obtained using reliable data and problematic data. Therefore, it is very necessary to evaluate the instrument response parameters of seismic instruments when using seismic observation data for deep structure research.

[0080] The above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present application, rather than to limit them. Although the present application has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or make equivalent replacements for some of the technical features therein. However, these modifications or replacements do not deviate the essence of the corresponding technical solutions from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present application.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments, characterized in that: include: S1. receiving seismic signals through a broadband seismic array instrument, and converting the format of the observation records of the broadband seismic array instrument to obtain a seismic waveform after the format conversion; S2. According to the global earthquake catalog, the earthquake waveform after format conversion is intercepted to obtain the earthquake event waveform record; S3, filtering the earthquake event waveform record, and obtaining the first arrival time of the earthquake event waveform record after filtering; S4. According to the first arrival time, the maximum amplitude in the selected time window is obtained, and the maximum amplitude ratio of the three-component records of the station is calculated to complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument; The S4 includes: S41, according to the first arrival time, obtaining the maximum amplitude of all earthquake event records in the selected time window of each station; S42, summing and averaging the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components of all earthquake event records at each station to obtain an average value of the maximum amplitudes of the vertical components; S43. Compare the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of each earthquake event record with the average value of the maximum amplitude of the vertical component of the station, and compare the maximum amplitudes of the three components of each earthquake record with each other, and complete the evaluation of the response parameters of the broadband seismic array instrument based on the compared deviation values.

2. The method for evaluating the response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments according to claim 1, characterized in that: The S2 includes: S21. Calculate the epicenter distances of different stations in the seismic array based on the global earthquake catalog; S22, select earthquake events with epicentral distances between 30° and 90°, and calculate the theoretical arrival time of P waves of the earthquake events at each station; S23, obtaining the seismic event waveform of the selected time window including the theoretical arrival time and the intercepted P-wave arrival time as the seismic event waveform record.

3. The method for evaluating the response parameters of broadband seismic array instruments according to claim 1, characterized in that: The S3 includes: S1, band-pass filtering the earthquake event waveform record to obtain a filtered earthquake event waveform record; S2. For the filtered earthquake event waveform records, the long-short time window ratio method is used to obtain the first arrival time of different events at different stations.