A method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization

Automatically delete column unit groups through strain energy topology optimization method, optimize column mesh layout of concrete frame structure, solve the problems of complex design and insufficient performance in the existing technology, realize efficient structural design and material configuration, and improve design efficiency and performance.

CN118627356BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-05HUNAN UNIV OF SCI & TECH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411080417.3
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-08
Publication Date
2024-11-05
Estimated Expiration
2044-08-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art lacks automation, digitalization and intelligence in the design of concrete frame structures, especially column mesh layout, resulting in complex design, large calculation amount, and may lead to insufficient structural stiffness and poor dynamic performance.

Method used

Using a method based on strain energy topology optimization, through finite element analysis and sensitivity value calculation, column unit groups are automatically deleted and column mesh structure is optimized to achieve efficient configuration of material distribution and structural performance improvement.

Benefits of technology

It achieves maximum structural stiffness under the same material consumption or minimum material consumption under the same rigidity, improves design efficiency and rationality, reduces designers' subjective dependence, meets structural performance requirements under multi-load conditions, and reduces Material consumption.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118627356B_ABST
    Figure CN118627356B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to the technical field of civil engineering, and discloses a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization. An initial domain for optimizing the column grid of a concrete frame structure is established according to a design scheme of the column grid of the concrete frame structure, a finite element model of the corresponding concrete frame structure to be analyzed is constructed, and a vertical load is applied to the finite element model; a horizontal load is applied to the finite element model to obtain a first finite element analysis result, and a horizontal load is reversely applied to the finite element model to obtain a second finite element analysis result; the sensitivity of the column unit group is calculated by combining the results of the two finite element analyses, and a predetermined number of column unit groups are deleted according to the sensitivity value; it is determined whether the total volume ratio of the columns after deleting the column unit group this time satisfies the constraint of the total volume ratio of the columns, and if so, the optimization is terminated and the optimal column grid topology is output, and if not, the analysis is repeated. The problem that the column grid arrangement of the frame structure in civil engineering cannot be carried out automatically, digitally and intelligently is solved.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of civil engineering, and in particular to a method for generating a concrete frame structure. Background Art

[0002] Concrete frame structure is one of the most widely used structural forms in the field of civil engineering. Their stress performance is largely affected by the arrangement and design of components, especially the arrangement of frame columns, which plays a key role in the bearing capacity, stiffness, stability and seismic performance of frame structures. For the design of concrete frame structures, current projects often use methods that combine statics principles and strength theory with a certain empirical color. This type of method has a certain mechanical theoretical basis and introduces a variety of approximate assumptions and simplifications, which is conducive to designers' mastery and use. However, in design practice, especially for relatively irregular building plans, there are many factors to consider when using this method, and there may be a large workload of calculation and design. It is difficult to carry out purely manual work. It may also be due to insufficient pertinence of the distribution details of some specific effects, or incomplete consideration of the local stress characteristics of some special buildings, which may easily make the designed structure have defects in some aspects of stress performance, such as insufficient overall or local stiffness, poor dynamic performance, etc.

[0003] To address the above problems, people use topology optimization based on mathematical optimization and computer programs to optimize the material distribution in a given area according to given load conditions, constraints and performance indicators. However, although the current application of topology optimization in concrete structure design, especially in the arrangement of components therein, has good prospects, the relevant research is still insufficient and lacks specific application generation methods. Summary of the invention

[0004] The present invention provides a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization, so as to solve the problem that the column grid arrangement of the frame structure in civil engineering cannot be carried out automatically, digitally and intelligently.

[0005] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention is implemented by the following technical solutions:

[0006] In a first aspect, the present invention provides a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization, comprising the following steps:

[0007] Step 1: According to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan, the initial domain of concrete frame structure column grid optimization is established, a finite element model is constructed for the corresponding concrete frame structure to be analyzed, and a vertical load is applied to the finite element model;

[0008] Step 2: Apply horizontal load to the finite element model, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the first finite element analysis result, apply horizontal load to the finite element model in the reverse direction, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the second finite element analysis result;

[0009] Step 3: Calculate the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result, and delete a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity value;

[0010] The column unit group is to divide the frame columns, beams and slabs in the concrete frame structure into finite element units within a predetermined size limit when constructing a finite element model, and define the units contained in all frame columns as a group in terms of column units;

[0011] Step 4: Determine whether the total volume ratio of the columns after deleting the column unit group meets the total volume ratio constraint. If so, terminate the optimization and output the optimal column network topology structure. If not, return to step 2.

[0012] Furthermore, the step 1 comprises the following steps:

[0013] Step 101: Optimize the initial domain of the concrete frame structure column grid according to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan and set optimization parameters;

[0014] Step 102: setting the cross-sectional dimensions of each component in the concrete frame structure and defining the design domain;

[0015] Step 103: Construct a finite element model, perform unit meshing, set up boundary constraints, and apply vertical loads to the finite element model.

[0016] Furthermore, the establishment of an initial domain for optimizing the column grid of a concrete frame structure according to the column grid design scheme of the concrete frame structure includes: without affecting the function of the building, frame columns are arranged at all corners and other locations where columns can be arranged to form an initial domain for optimizing the column grid of the concrete frame structure.

[0017] Furthermore, in step 2, before applying the horizontal load and reversely applying the horizontal load, the horizontal load and analysis result information on the finite element model need to be cleared.

[0018] Furthermore, in step 3, the calculation of the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis results and the second finite element analysis results includes: calculating the sum of strain energies of all units in each column unit group according to the first finite element analysis results and the second finite element analysis results, and calculating and selecting the sensitivity value based on the above strain energy sum.

[0019] Furthermore, the calculation and selection of sensitivity values ​​based on the above strain energy sum includes: for each column unit group, selecting the larger value of the strain energy sums calculated according to two finite element analysis results as the sensitivity value of the column unit group.

[0020] Furthermore, the sum of strain energies of all units in each column unit group is calculated by the following formula:

[0021] ;

[0022] in, Represents any j The sum of strain energies of all elements in a column element group; n Indicates the number of units contained in this column unit group; Indicates the first i The displacement vector of each unit; T represents the vector transposition operation; Indicates the first i The stiffness matrix of the element.

[0023] Furthermore, deleting a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity values ​​includes: sorting all column unit groups from large to small according to their sensitivity values, and deleting the predetermined number of column unit groups at the end of the sorting.

[0024] Further, in step 4, the volume rate constraint is expressed as:

[0025] ;

[0026] in, Indicates the total volume ratio of the column after deleting the column unit group; Represents the column total volume rate constraint, that is, the target total volume rate of the column.

[0027] Beneficial effects:

[0028] The present invention provides a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization. By using this method, a frame structure with the maximum stiffness under the same material consumption or the lowest material consumption under the same structural stiffness can be designed. At the same time, the column grid design process can be completed automatically, which can not only improve the efficiency of engineering design and the rationality of the scheme, but also greatly reduce the dependence of the structural layout on the subjective level of the designer.

[0029] Based on the determined load conditions, the frame structure is optimized and designed. Under multiple load conditions of engineering design such as earthquake load and wind load, the corresponding structural performance can meet the requirements of the current specifications, and the displacement caused is smaller than that of the traditional design.

[0030] Compared with the actual engineering frame structure, the materials consumed in the optimized design frame structure contribute more to the structural stiffness. That is, a structural design scheme with better performance is obtained through a more reasonable material distribution. This not only reflects the principle of topology optimization, but also proves the value of topology optimization. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0031] Figure 1 A flowchart of a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization according to an embodiment of the present invention;

[0032] Figure 2 Schematic diagram of two horizontal load applications in Example 1 of the present invention, wherein A is a column;

[0033] Figure 3 Schematic diagram of the initial domain of column grid optimization of Example 2 of the present invention, wherein AF represents the arrangement position of the column in the Y-axis direction in the floor plan, and 1-8 represents the arrangement position of the column in the X-axis direction in the floor plan;

[0034] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the frame structure of Example 2 of the present invention;

[0035] exist Figure 4 In the figure, (a) to (e) are schematic diagrams of the optimal column grid topology of the frame structure from the 1st floor to the 6th floor;

[0036] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology under the 15.80 mm structural maximum displacement constraint of Example 2 of the present invention;

[0037] exist Figure 5 In the figure, (a) is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the first floor under the maximum structural displacement constraint of 15.80 mm;

[0038] (b) is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology from the 2nd to the 4th floor under the constraint of a maximum structural displacement of 15.80 mm;

[0039] (c) is the schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the 5th floor under the maximum structural displacement constraint of 15.80mm;

[0040] (d) is the schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the 6th floor under the maximum structural displacement constraint of 15.80 mm;

[0041] Figure 6 This is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology under the 16.80 mm structural maximum displacement constraint of Example 2 of the present invention;

[0042] exist Figure 6 In the figure, (a) is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology from the 1st floor to the 4th floor under the constraint of the maximum structural displacement of 16.80 mm;

[0043] (b) is the schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the 5th floor under the maximum structural displacement constraint of 16.80mm;

[0044] (c) is a schematic diagram of the optimal column grid topology of the 6th floor under the maximum structural displacement constraint of 16.80 mm. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0045] The technical solution of the present invention is described clearly and completely below. Obviously, the described embodiments are only a part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0046] Unless otherwise defined, the technical terms or scientific terms used in the present invention shall have the common meanings understood by persons with ordinary skills in the field to which the present invention belongs. The words "first", "second" and similar words used in the present invention do not indicate any order, quantity or importance, but are only used to distinguish different components.

[0047] Example 1, see Figure 1 .

[0048] Step 1: According to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan, the initial domain of concrete frame structure column grid optimization is established, a finite element model is constructed for the corresponding concrete frame structure to be analyzed, and a vertical load is applied to the finite element model;

[0049] Step 2: Apply horizontal load to the finite element model, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the first finite element analysis result, apply horizontal load to the finite element model in the reverse direction, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the second finite element analysis result;

[0050] Step 3: Calculate the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result, and delete a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity value;

[0051] When constructing a finite element model, the column unit group is to divide the frame columns, beams and slabs in the concrete frame structure into finite element units within a predetermined size limit, and define the units contained in all frame columns as a group in column units;

[0052] Step 4: Determine whether the total volume ratio of the columns after deleting the column unit group meets the total volume ratio constraint. If so, terminate the optimization and output the optimal column network topology structure. If not, return to step 2.

[0053] In this method, the sum of strain energies of all elements in each column element group is calculated as follows:

[0054] ;

[0055] in, Represents any j The sum of strain energies of all elements in a column element group; n Indicates the number of units contained in this column unit group; Indicates the first i The displacement vector of each unit; T represents the vector transposition operation; Indicates the first i The stiffness matrix of the element.

[0056] Considering that in the column grid design of concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization, the finite element units contained in each frame column should be regarded as a whole to participate in the optimization, that is, they are organized into discrete "column units". At this time, the overall stiffness matrix of the frame structure, K, can be expressed as:

[0057] ;

[0058] Then the objective function is transformed into:

[0059] ;

[0060] Where C is the total strain energy of the structure; m represents the total number of column unit groups; is a design variable, which takes 1 for column element groups and 0 for deleted column element groups; and it must always meet the following requirements during the structural analysis process:

[0061] And K and u satisfy:

[0062] ;

[0063] Where P represents the load matrix;

[0064] When the i-th column is deleted, the stiffness change of the frame structure is:

[0065] ;

[0066] in, represents the overall stiffness matrix of the frame structure after the i-th column is deleted;

[0067] Since the load matrix is ​​a constant that has nothing to do with the deletion or storage status of the frame column in the optimization, it satisfies:

[0068] ;

[0069] Removal of high-order trace , , the change in structural displacement caused by the deletion of the i-th column is:

[0070] ;

[0071] The sensitivity is therefore defined as:

[0072] ;

[0073] See also Figure 2 , considering the randomness of the direction of horizontal loads (such as earthquake force), two horizontal loads need to be applied in each optimization iteration, such as Figure 2 As shown, and complete the corresponding structural analysis respectively.

[0074] For each column, the sensitivity value is calculated based on the results of the two analyses, and the larger value is taken as the final sensitivity value of the column in this optimization iteration. For example, Figure 2 The final sensitivity value of column A in the jth optimization iteration is for:

[0075] ;

[0076] In the formula, and are the sensitivity values ​​of column A calculated in the jth optimization iteration according to the structural analysis results under the two horizontal loads;

[0077] It should be noted that before applying the two horizontal loads, the horizontal loads on the finite element model must be removed.

[0078] Example 2

[0079] See also Figure 1 The present application embodiment provides a method for generating a column grid of a concrete frame structure based on strain energy topology optimization, comprising the following steps:

[0080] Step 1: According to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan, the initial domain of concrete frame structure column grid optimization is established, a finite element model is constructed for the corresponding concrete frame structure to be analyzed, and a vertical load is applied to the finite element model;

[0081] Step 101: Optimize the initial domain of the concrete frame structure column grid according to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan and set optimization parameters;

[0082] Specifically, according to the building plan, frame columns are arranged at all corners and other locations where columns can be arranged without affecting the building function, so as to form an initial domain for optimizing the concrete frame structure column grid;

[0083] Step 102: setting the cross-sectional dimensions of each component in the concrete frame structure and defining the design domain;

[0084] Based on the above, the cross-sectional dimensions of all columns and beams in the initial optimization domain are preset to 500 mm × 600 mm and 350 mm × 600 mm respectively, and the concrete elastic modulus is .

[0085] Step 103: Construct a finite element model, perform unit meshing, set up boundary constraints, and apply vertical loads to the finite element model.

[0086] When constructing a finite element model, the columns, beams and slabs in the concrete frame structure must be divided into finite element units within a predetermined size limit, and the units contained in all frame columns are defined as groups based on columns, namely column unit groups.

[0087] See also Figure 3 , a concrete frame structure, the axis grid is as follows Figure 3 As shown, there are 6 floors in total, each floor height is 3500mm, and the slab thickness is preset to 100 mm. The vertical load design values ​​of the 2nd to 6th floors are , design value of roof vertical load , the outer edge beams of each floor also bear vertical uniform line loads, with a design value of 10.29 kN / m. The secondary horizontal loads are of the same magnitude, respectively along the positive and negative y directions, in the form of uniform line loads applied to the outside of the top of the Ⓕ axis or Ⓐ axis beams of each floor, 4.83 kN / m, 9.67 kN / m, 14.50 kN / m, 19.36 kN / m, 24.19 kN / m for floors 2 to 6, and 29.03 kN / m for the roof.

[0088] Step 2: Apply a horizontal load to the finite element model, conduct a finite element analysis and obtain a first finite element analysis result, apply a horizontal load to the finite element model in the opposite direction, conduct a finite element analysis and obtain a second finite element analysis result;

[0089] Among them, when conducting finite element analysis, the columns, beams and slabs in the concrete frame structure need to be divided into finite element units within predetermined size limits. Before applying horizontal loads and reversely applying horizontal loads, the horizontal loads and analysis result information on the finite element model need to be cleared.

[0090] Step 3: Calculate the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result, and delete a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity value;

[0091] According to the first finite element analysis results and the second finite element analysis results, the sum of strain energies of all units in each column group is calculated respectively, and the sensitivity value is calculated and selected based on the above sum of strain energies.

[0092] Specifically, for each column element group, the larger value of the sum of strain energies calculated from two finite element analysis results is selected as the sensitivity value of the column element group;

[0093] The sum of the strain energies of all elements in each column element group is calculated by the following formula:

[0094] ;

[0095] in, Represents any j The sum of strain energies of all elements in a column element group; n Indicates the number of units contained in this column unit group; Indicates the first i The displacement vector of each unit; T represents the vector transposition operation; Indicates the first i The stiffness matrix of the element.

[0096] All column unit groups are sorted from small to large according to their sensitivity values, and a predetermined number of column unit groups are deleted from small to large.

[0097] Step 4: Determine whether the total volume ratio of the columns after deleting the column unit group meets the total volume ratio constraint. If so, terminate the optimization and output the optimal column network topology structure. If not, return to step 2.

[0098] The volume rate constraint is expressed as:

[0099] ;

[0100] in, Indicates the total volume ratio of the column after deleting the column unit group; Represents the column total volume rate constraint, that is, the target total volume rate of the column.

[0101] In the ANSYS software platform, topology optimization and corresponding finite element analysis were carried out through the APDL command stream. The target volume ratio of the optimization was 0.63. In each optimization iteration, the number of columns to be deleted was preset to 4. The optimal column grid topology was obtained as follows: Figure 4 As shown, in Figure 4 In the diagram, 1F~6F refer to the 1st to 6th floors respectively.

[0102] The structure with the column grid arrangement obtained by topological optimization in Example 2 is named frame structure I, and the other two methods are selected to arrange the column grid to obtain frame structure II and frame structure III. The cross-sectional dimensions of the columns and beams are shown in Table 1 and Table 2, respectively. Frame structure III is designed by the empirical method, that is, the cross-sectional dimensions of the beams and columns are selected according to the span of the beams. In order to make the columns and beams in this structure have a total volume equivalent to that of the first two structures, the side lengths of all column sections are taken as , is the span of the beam in the corresponding direction. When the spans of the beams on both sides of the column are different, the larger value is taken; the height h of all beam sections is taken as the span of the beam , the width b is taken as h / 2, and the cross-sectional dimensions of the columns and beams are shown in Table 3. The remaining design parameters of frame structures II and III, such as plate thickness, concrete strength grade, etc., are the same as those of frame structure I. The total volume of the columns of frame structures I~III are , and The total volume of the beam is , that is, in the three frame structures, the total volumes of beams and columns are respectively equivalent.

[0103] Table 1: Frame structure II column cross-sectional dimensions (unit: mm)

[0104]

[0105] Note: The cross-sectional dimensions of the remaining columns not listed in the table are determined based on symmetry.

[0106] Table 2: Frame structure II column cross-sectional dimensions (unit: mm)

[0107]

[0108] Note: All are square cross-sections, i.e. ; The cross-sectional dimensions of the remaining beams not listed in the table are determined based on symmetry.

[0109] Table 3: Frame structure III beam and column cross-sectional dimensions (unit: mm)

[0110]

[0111] Under the design load condition, frame structures I~III are modeled and their displacements are solved, as shown in Table 4. As shown in Table 4, although the three frame structures have the same total component volume (i.e., the same material consumption), in comparison, the maximum displacement of the top floor of frame structure I is the smallest, and the inter-layer displacement distribution is the most uniform, showing the most typical shear deformation characteristics, which confirms the advantage of the frame structure designed based on strain energy topology optimization to arrange the column grid in terms of overall structural stiffness.

[0112] Table 4 Comparison of structural displacement (unit: mm)

[0113]

[0114] Taking the maximum displacement of frame structures II and III as optimization constraints, column grid topology optimization was carried out, and the column grid layout was obtained as follows: Figure 5 and Figure 6 As shown, according to statistics, their total column volume is and , which is 16% and 18% less than that of frame structure II and structure III, respectively. This shows that under the premise of ensuring the same overall structural stiffness, the column grid topology optimization method can reduce the consumption of raw materials.

[0115] The preferred specific embodiments of the present invention are described in detail above. It should be understood that a person skilled in the art can make many modifications and changes based on the concept of the present invention without creative work. Therefore, any technical solution that can be obtained by a person skilled in the art through logical analysis, reasoning or limited experiments based on the concept of the present invention on the basis of the prior art should be within the scope of protection determined by the claims.

Claims

1. A method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization, characterized in that: The steps include: Step 1: According to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan, the initial domain of concrete frame structure column grid optimization is established, a finite element model is constructed for the corresponding concrete frame structure to be analyzed, and a vertical load is applied to the finite element model; Step 2: Apply horizontal load to the finite element model, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the first finite element analysis result, apply horizontal load to the finite element model in the reverse direction, conduct finite element analysis and obtain the second finite element analysis result; Step 3: Calculate the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result, and delete a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity value; The column unit group is to divide the frame columns, beams and slabs in the concrete frame structure into finite element units within a predetermined size limit when constructing a finite element model, and define the units contained in all frame columns as a group in terms of column units; Calculating the sensitivity value of the column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result comprises: calculating the sum of strain energies of all units in each column unit group according to the first finite element analysis result and the second finite element analysis result, and calculating and selecting the sensitivity value based on the above sum of strain energies; The calculation and selection of sensitivity values ​​based on the above strain energy sum includes: for each column unit group, selecting the larger value of the strain energy sums calculated according to two finite element analysis results as the sensitivity value of the column unit group; The sum of strain energies of all elements in each column element group is calculated by the following formula: ; in, Represents any j The sum of strain energies of all elements in a column element group; n Indicates the number of units contained in this column unit group; Indicates the first i The displacement vector of each unit; T represents the vector transposition operation; Indicates the first i The stiffness matrix of each element; Deleting a predetermined number of column unit groups according to the sensitivity values ​​includes: sorting all column unit groups from small to large according to their sensitivity values, and deleting a predetermined number of column unit groups in order from small to large; Step 4: Determine whether the total volume ratio of the columns after deleting the column unit group meets the total volume ratio constraint. If so, terminate the optimization and output the optimal column network topology structure. If not, return to step 2.

2. The method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The step 1 comprises the following steps: Step 101: Optimize the initial domain of the concrete frame structure column grid according to the concrete frame structure column grid design plan and set optimization parameters; Step 102: setting the cross-sectional dimensions of each component in the concrete frame structure and defining the design domain; Step 103: Construct a finite element model, perform unit meshing, set up boundary constraints, and apply vertical loads to the finite element model.

3. The method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that: The method of establishing an optimized initial domain of the concrete frame structure column grid according to the concrete frame structure column grid design scheme includes: arranging frame columns at all wall corners and other locations where columns can be arranged without affecting the building function, so as to form an optimized initial domain of the concrete frame structure column grid.

4. The method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step 2, the horizontal load on the finite element model must be cleared before applying the horizontal load and reversing the horizontal load.

5. The method for generating column grids of concrete frame structures based on strain energy topology optimization according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step 4, the total volume rate constraint is expressed as: ; in, Indicates the total volume ratio of the column after deleting the column unit group; Represents the total column volume ratio constraint.