Analyzing mass of sensed force response data during testing and mitigating output of undesirable mass

Through automated MIMO force response characterization method and signal quality test, the problems of long data collection time and large errors in vibration test of complex structure MIMO systems are solved, and efficient and automated SRF measurement is achieved.

CN118946787APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12ROBERT BOSCH GMBH
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202380030015.X
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2022-01-25
Filing Date
2023-01-20
Publication Date
2024-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art has problems such as long data collection time, large experimental error, and unauthorized data processing in the vibration test of multiple input and multiple output (MIMO) systems with complex structures, resulting in low testing efficiency and unstable data quality.

Method used

Using an automated MIMO force response characterization method, the excitation signal is automatically iteratively applied through the combination of multiple exciters and response sensors, and the excitation signal is adjusted to improve data quality by using signal quality testing and post-processing methods to achieve fully automated SRF measurements. .

Benefits of technology

It significantly reduces data collection time, improves test efficiency and data quality, reduces experimental errors, and realizes efficient MIMO system vibration testing.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118946787A_ABST
    Figure CN118946787A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a system and method for automated MIMO force response characterization of a structure under test. The structure under test is coupled to the plurality of exciter devices and the plurality of response sensors. An excitation signal is automatically and iteratively applied to each exciter device while collecting sensor data from each response sensor to collect response data for a plurality of different exciter-sensor combinations (i.e., response data collected by a single response sensor when the excitation signal is applied to a single exciter device). A signal quality test is applied to the collected sensor data, and in response to determining that the collected response data quality for a particular exciter-sensor combination is insufficient, data collection is automatically repeated for that exciter-sensor combination. The excitation signal may be automatically adjusted prior to repeating data collection to improve the quality of the collected data for the exciter-sensor combination.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Background Art

[0001] The present invention relates to systems and methods for testing the response of a device or structure to an applied excitation (eg, vibration) condition. Summary of the invention

[0002] In one embodiment, the present invention provides a method for automated MIMO force response characterization of a structure under test. The structure under test is connected to a plurality of exciter devices and a plurality of response sensors. An excitation signal is automatically and iteratively applied to each of the plurality of exciter devices to cause each exciter device to impart an excitation force to the structure under test (e.g., to one exciter device at a time). When the excitation signal is iteratively applied to the exciter device, sensor data is collected from each response sensor. The collected sensor data includes response data collected by a single response sensor when an excitation force is imparted by a single exciter device for each of a plurality of different exciter-sensor combinations. A signal quality test is applied to the collected sensor data, and in response to determining that the collected response data for a particular exciter-sensor combination does not meet a defined signal quality condition, data collection is automatically repeated for the exciter-sensor combination. In some embodiments, the excitation signal applied to the exciter device is adjusted before repeating the data collection to improve the quality of the collected data.

[0003] Other aspects of the invention will become apparent by consideration of the detailed description and accompanying drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0004] Figure 1A is a perspective view of a vibration testing system according to one embodiment.

[0005] Figure 1B yes Figure 1A A perspective view of the exciter setup of a vibration test system.

[0006] Figure 1C yes Figure 1B Cross-sectional view of the actuator device.

[0007] Figure 2 Is Figure 1A Graph of the frequency response function measured for a system expressed as a frequency dependent acceleration function.

[0008] Figure 3 A schematic diagram of the mathematical relationship between a Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) System Response Function (SRF) measurement and the corresponding MIMO SRF matrix.

[0009] Figure 4 is used for Figure 1AA block diagram of a control system of a test system configured to perform MIMO system vibration testing by sequentially implementing single-input multiple-output (SIMO) SRF data collection and processing.

[0010] Figure 5 is used for Figure 1A A block diagram of a control system of a test system configured to perform MIMO system vibration testing by sequentially implementing single-input single-output (SIMO) SRF data collection and processing.

[0011] Figure 6 yes Figure 4 and / or Figure 5 Block diagram of a control unit of a control system.

[0012] Figure 7 Is used for Figure 5 control system and Figure 6 Flowchart of a method for a control unit to perform SISO SRF data collection and processing.

[0013] Figure 8 It is used to analyze the execution Figure 7 Flow chart of the method used to determine the quality of the data collected.

[0014] Fig. 9 is a list of Figure 8 Table of examples of data quality tests performed as part of the methodology.

[0015] Fig.10 is Figure 8 Graph of SRF reciprocity data collected during quality testing of the method.

[0016] Fig.11 is Figure 8 A series of graphs of response consistency data collected during quality testing of the method.

[0017] Fig.12 is Figure 8 A graph of the Interface Integrity Criteria (ICC) data collected during quality testing of the method.

[0018] Fig.13A is based on Figure 8 The quality test results of the method are Figure 7 Schematic diagram of an example of adjusting an applied excitation signal during a method.

[0019] Fig. 13B is based on Figure 8 The quality test results of the method to adjust the excitation signal are shown in the graph before and after the excitation signal is applied.

[0020] Fig. 13C is a graph of the force spectrum of the applied excitation signal before and after adjusting the excitation signal.

[0021] Fig.13D is a graph of the response spectrum before and after adjusting the excitation signal. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0022] Before any embodiments of the invention are explained in detail, it will be understood that the invention is not limited in its application to the details of construction and the arrangement of components set forth in the following description or illustrated in the following drawings. The invention is capable of other embodiments and of being practiced or carried out in various ways.

[0023] Excitation testing may be performed on a device or structure (e.g., an automotive component) to simulate how the structure responds to different applied forces (e.g., sound, vibration, shock, etc.). In some embodiments, the test may involve applying an excitation force to the device or structure at a first location and measuring the response at a second location. For example, a vibration force may be applied at a first location and acceleration may be measured at another location. The difference between the applied excitation force and the measured response is indicative of the system response. In other embodiments, the force excitation and response measurement may be co-located (e.g., an exciter device is mounted on an accelerometer, which in turn is connected to the structure under test (see, e.g., below)). Figure 4 Sensor 107A)) is used to capture driving point SRF measurements.

[0024] In order to deal with the problem of structure-borne sound and vibration in its full complexity (e.g., multi-path and multi-degree-of-freedom (DoF) systems), the characterization of the structural dynamic properties of mechanical devices is extremely important. Although feasible for simple structures, accurate numerical modeling of structural and / or vibroacoustic properties remains difficult for most complex technical components and assemblies. Instead, in some embodiments, their dynamic behavior can be experimentally characterized with the help of system response function (SRF) measurements, such as employed during modal testing. The nature of the system response function (SRF) can be quite general and can include structural, acoustic, vibroacoustic or other descriptions of the propagation properties of the structure (e.g., hydraulic (fluid) pressure response to an imparted force excitation). In addition, the SRF can be expressed in the time domain, the modal domain, the state space domain, the physical domain, or the frequency domain. A specific example of a method for determining the SRF is the measurement of a frequency response function (FRF), such as flexibility, mobility, or acceleration.

[0025] Experimentally, the FRF can be determined by applying some force excitation to a predetermined input degree of freedom (DoF) and measuring the resulting system response(s) at one or more spatial observer DoFs. For example, an instrumented hammer (modal hammer) and / or a shaker can be used as an excitation source to provide an external force excitation to the structure, and a motion sensor (e.g., a displacement probe, a velocity sensor, and / or an accelerometer) is used to capture at least one system response per excitation test. Other types of sensors can be used to account for other types of system responses, such as acoustic pressure in the case of vibroacoustic FRF measurements.

[0026] For simple FRF tests (e.g., where the setup and complexity of the instrumentation is relatively simple and the number of SRFs to be measured is small), the experiments can be performed manually—e.g., where all measurement equipment is installed and all FRFs are measured in parallel before the first measurement. Alternatively, for more complex structures or where the availability of measurement equipment is limited, the experiments can be implemented in a "roving instrument" manner, where at least some of the exciters and / or sensors are moved to different locations after each excitation test. The related measurement techniques may be referred to as "roving exciter (hammer, vibrator)" or "roving sensor (accelerometer, etc.)" experiments. Flowing instrument techniques are advantageous in terms of cost and / or availability of the required equipment. These techniques can not only significantly reduce the number of exciters and / or sensors required, but can also be performed using low channel count DAQ systems. However, some disadvantages of flow instrument testing include: (1) increased measurement time and workload as the complexity of the structure being tested increases; (2) introduction of experimental errors due to the need to reposition the instrument between different tests (e.g., consistent positioning of the device, correct attachment / application of the force excitation member, correct alignment of the excitation / response DoF, etc.); and (3) increased sensitivity to errors during subsequent manual data processing steps and lack of automated synchronization between data collection and data post-processing steps.

[0027] For these reasons, in some embodiments, SRF testing of more complex multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) systems is performed in a partially or fully automated manner, where all required measurement equipment is mounted on the test structure before the measurement begins. In some embodiments, FRF measurements are then performed simultaneously for all response and force excitation DoFs. Simultaneous measurements greatly reduce data collection time, but unfortunately, the reduced data collection time comes at the expense of higher equipment costs required for high channel count DAQ systems to acquire all force excitations and system responses in parallel, and the flexibility to excite the structure with arbitrary excitation functions (e.g., swept sine, random noise, shock, etc.) in order to employ multi-reference FRF post-processing methods.

[0028] In some embodiments, such "automated" simultaneous FRF measurement methods may utilize specially designed excitation sequences and associated post-processing methods, such as multi-reference random methods (e.g., burst random excitation) and / or vibration testing using multiple sine sweep excitations. These types of methods may be utilized, for example, in instrument-intensive experimental studies (such as ground vibration testing of aircraft), where the measurement equipment is mounted directly on the test structure and removed after the test is completed. Therefore, the data collection time for "single sample" SRF measurements is relatively small compared to the total test time (including time for preparing the measurements and instruments, data collection time, data post-processing steps, and time to remove the measurement equipment after the test). Similar considerations are valid for similarly complex but more compact structures such as automotive components and / or component assemblies (e.g., electric power steering (EPS) systems, transmission gearboxes, engines, etc.). However, automotive applications may require repeated vibration testing of multiple parts in order to evaluate the overall noise-vibration-harshness ("NVH") performance on a statistically relevant number of test samples. These "multi-sample" SRF measurements would greatly benefit from improved SRF measurement techniques that can quickly and efficiently collect high-quality SRF data in a fully automated manner without the need for labor-intensive instrumentation steps and / or expensive DAQ systems to provide a sufficient number of independent measurement channels.

[0029] Figure 1A An example of an SRF test system 100 is illustrated. A fixture 101 includes two arms configured to hold a device / structure under test 103 . Figure 1A In the example of , the fixture 101 is configured to hold an electric power steering system for SRF testing. A plurality of excitation units 105 are configured to controllably apply excitation forces to a device / structure under test 103, and are coupled to the device / structure under test 103 directly or indirectly by coupling to the fixture 101 (which in turn is coupled to the device / structure under test 103). Similarly, a plurality of response sensors 107 (e.g., accelerometers) are also coupled to the device / structure under test (directly or indirectly).

[0030] like Figure 1B As further illustrated in detail in Figure 1A In the example of FIG. 1 , each excitation unit 105 includes a vibration exciter 109 (ie, a “vibrator”) and a load sensor 111. Figure 1CAs shown in , the vibration exciter 109 is a magnetically actuated exciter device that includes a cylindrical body 113 with a pair of electromagnet coils 115 coupled to the cylindrical body 113. A piston 117 (e.g., also referred to as a "table") mounted with a permanent annular magnet 119 is at least partially positioned within the cylindrical body 113, but is not fixedly coupled to the cylindrical body 113. Thus, a magnetic field controllably applied by the electromagnet coils 115 interacts with the permanent annular magnet(s) 119 to cause the cylindrical body 113 to move relative to the piston 117. For example, when one end of the piston 117 is coupled to the device / structure under test 103 and an alternating current is applied to the electromagnet coils 115, the resulting alternating magnetic field causes the cylindrical body 113 to perform a corresponding alternating motion relative to the piston 117, which in turn causes a controllable vibration force to be applied to the device / structure under test 103 through the piston 117. By controlling the amplitude and frequency of the current applied to the electromagnet coil 115 (which in turn controls the amplitude and frequency of the magnetic field applied by the electromagnet coil 115 to the permanent ring magnet 119), the amplitude and frequency of the applied vibratory force can be adjusted and regulated. Figures 1A to 1C The example of illustrates the use of a vibration exciter 109, but in some embodiments, other types of exciter devices may be used instead of or in addition to the vibration exciter 109. The exciter device may include a mechanical or electromechanical device configured to apply vibrations, pulsations, oscillations, transients, or other dynamically varying forces, such as, for example, a speaker, a rotating eccentric mass actuator, an electric motor, a solenoid actuator, a piezoelectric actuator, or any other actuation mechanism that can dynamically excite a physical structure.

[0031] Thus, the exciter device (e.g., vibration exciter 109) is used to generate a "known" dynamic force input to the device / structure under test 103, and as described in further detail below, the force / load generated by the excitation source and imparted to the device / structure under test 103 can be used as a reference signal to calculate the system response function (SRF) in a data post-processing step. The actual dynamic force / load applied by the exciter device (e.g., vibration exciter 109) is, for example, measured using a load sensor 111 (e.g., coupled between the exciter device and the device / structure under test 103). Figure 1B) as shown in . In other embodiments, other mechanisms for measuring the applied excitation force may be used, including, for example, one or more force transducers embedded within the excitation source. Other techniques and methods may also be used to determine the actual dynamic force excitation imparted to the device / structure under test 103, including, for example, inverse measurement techniques (e.g., inverse force synthesis), model-based force reconstruction methods (e.g., analytical, numerical, experimental and / or hybrid methods), or measurements of other load indicators (e.g., current, voltage, strain, etc.) that are (e.g., mathematically) mapped to the force / load excitation space. In the examples described herein, the term "load" is a generalization of the term "force" to account for other types of dynamic excitations that may be applied to the device / structure under test 103, such as, for example, sound pressure (for an acoustic actuator).

[0032] The response sensor 107 is configured to sense / determine the actual response of the device / structure under test 103 to a dynamic force excitation imparted by one or more exciter devices (e.g., a vibration exciter 109). In some embodiments, the response sensor 107 can be viewed as a dynamic transducer mechanically coupled to the device / structure under test. The response sensor 107 measures the manner in which the device / structure under test 103 (and any test bench components coupled thereto, such as, for example, the fixture 101) responds to the excitation signal. The response sensor 107 provides a signal and / or data representing the output response to a connected data acquisition system (as further described below). Depending on the type of system response function (SRF) to be determined, different types of sensors may be used, including, for example, accelerometers and / or microphones. In Figure 1A In the example of , the response sensor 107 includes an accelerometer. In some other embodiments, the test system 100 can be configured to measure / determine the response of the device / structure under test 103 without a mechanically coupled sensor by using a non-contact sensor (such as, for example, a laser-based measurement device). In some embodiments, the response of the device / structure under test can be determined at some locations without physical instrumentation, such as by using system equivalent model mixing.

[0033] like Figure 2 As illustrated in , in some embodiments, the frequency response function between two locations (e.g., the location of the vibration actuator 109 and the location of the response sensor 107) can be defined as "accelerometer", or in other words, as the ratio between the frequency domain representation of the measured acceleration response and the frequency domain representation of the applied dynamic force. Figure 2 The frequency response function is graphed as both magnitude and phase as a function of frequency (ie, a frequency-dependent acceleration function (A / F)).

[0034] like Figure 3As further illustrated in , by calculating the acceleration between different combinations of input (ie, applied dynamic excitation force) and output (ie, response acceleration), several different frequency response functions of the device / structure under test can be calculated. Figure 3 The schematic diagram on the left illustrates a simplified example of a plate-like structure with multiple input forces (F) and multiple output responses (A). Each input and output provides another degree of freedom. In order to characterize the ability of the structure to propagate structural transfer energy between the input and output degrees of freedom (DoF), a complex SRF network is measured / determined. In this example, the test structure is assumed to be linear and time-invariant, and therefore the SRF characterization can be performed simultaneously. Alternatively, the SRF characterization can also be performed as a series of subsequent measurements that apply one excitation at the input DoF at a time and observe the associated dynamic response. In some embodiments (as described in further detail below), the associated dynamic response for each input DoF is also measured one at a time (SISO), while in other embodiments, multiple output DoFs are measured simultaneously (SIMO).

[0035] Figure 3 An example of how a complete MIMO SRF matrix can be reconstructed from a separate SISO or SIMO SRF experiment is also illustrated. In a SISO experiment, each entry in the MIMO matrix corresponds to a separate measurement, while in a SIMO experiment, a whole column of the MIMO SRF matrix can be filled simultaneously. For this reason, no additional assumptions are imposed on the utilized force excitation in order to obtain the correct reference signal required to construct the mathematical SRF ratio defined in the complex space.

[0036] Figure 4 and Figure 5 Examples of systems configured to perform fully automated system response function (SRF) measurements, including structural and vibroacoustic frequency response functions (FRFs), for example, for complex multiple-input multiple-output (MIMO) vibration problems, are illustrated. In particular, these systems are configured to perform single-input multiple-output (SIMO) data collection (e.g., Figure 4 ) and single-input single-output (SISO) SRF data collection (as shown in Figure 5 A post-processing routine is then applied to the collected data to reassemble the associated data to obtain a complete MIMO SRF measurement (e.g., by filling Figure 3 MIMO SRF matrix shown in ).

[0037] In both examples ( Figure 4 and Figure 5), the test system includes a single channel (SISO) signal generator 501 configured to provide continuous, transient and / or other types of dynamic signals. The SISO signal generator 501 is coupled to a SISO power amplifier 503, which is configured to output a properly conditioned driver signal. The driver signal is then routed to each vibration exciter 109 one at a time through a SIMO exciter router 505. The SIMO exciter router 505 includes a controllable switch device and / or other control logic of a certain configuration, which is configured to selectively couple the output from the SISO power amplifier 503 to a different one of the plurality of vibration exciters 109 during each vibration test in a series of vibration tests, while electronically isolating other unused vibration exciters 109 to ensure optimal signal / data conditioning and quality. As described above, in this example, each vibration exciter 109 is coupled to a load sensor 111 to determine the actual dynamic load imparted to the device / structure under test 103 by the "operational" vibration exciter 109.

[0038] The plurality of load sensors 111 are all communicatively coupled to a MISO load router 507, which is configured to electronically and / or digitally (if numerical methods are used to determine the actual force excitation) connect an "operational" load sensor 111 (i.e., a load sensor 111 coupled to the currently "operational" vibration exciter 109) to a single input channel of a data acquisition system 509 / 603 and to electronically isolate other unused load sensors 111. The MISO load router 507 helps ensure optimal signal / data conditioning and quality while also reducing the number of data acquisition input channels required by the data acquisition system 509 / 603.

[0039] In use Figure 4 or Figure 5 During SRF testing of the system, the operational vibration exciter 109 generates dynamic forces so that vibrations are imparted to the device / structure under test 103 and any structure connected thereto (e.g., fixture 101). The provided structural transfer energy is then propagated through different paths of the coupled device / structure under test 103 (and radiated by the device / structure under test), thereby inducing a motion response at each of a plurality of response locations (each location provides an additional DoF of response for the SRF experiment). The motion response at each different location is measured by a corresponding response sensor 107 of a plurality of response sensors 107. Figure 4 In the example of , each response sensor 107 in the plurality of sensors is coupled to a different input channel of the data acquisition system 509, and thus, during each data collection step, the outputs of the plurality of response sensors 107 are measured in parallel with the measurement from the single load sensor 111. However, in Figure 5 In the example of FIG. 6 , each response sensor 107 is coupled to a MISO sensor router 601. The MISO sensor router 601 is configured to electronically and / or digitally (if digital methods are used to determine the response) couple a single response sensor 107 to the data acquisition system 603 and to electronically isolate other unused response sensors 107. Thus, multiple response sensors 107 may be selectively and controllably coupled to the same input channel of the data acquisition system 603, thereby reducing the number of required input channels. In another embodiment, multiple MISO sensor routers 601 may be used to simultaneously measure responses from a subset of the response sensors 107 being used. In this case, the data acquisition system 603 may include multiple channels to measure the subset of sensors 107 in parallel, but it is not required that the data acquisition system 603 have enough input channels to measure all sensors 107 simultaneously.

[0040] like Figure 6 As illustrated in FIG. 1 , controller 701 includes an electronic processor 703 and one or more non-transitory computer-readable memories 705. Memory 705 stores data (e.g., data collected from sensors during SRF experiments) and computer-executable instructions that are accessed and executed by electronic processor 703 to provide the functionality of controller 701, including, for example, the functionality described herein. Controller 701 is communicatively coupled to Figure 4 and Figure 5 The controller 701 is a data acquisition system 509 / 603 of the system and is configured to receive response signal data collected during the SRF experiment. The controller 701 is also communicatively coupled to the SISO signal generator 501 and is configured to generate control signals that define and / or modify the signals generated by the SISO signal generator 501. The controller 701 is also communicatively coupled to the SIMO exciter router 505 and the MISO load router 507 and is configured to transmit control signals to the routers 505, 507 to selectively control which vibration exciter 109 is coupled to receive the excitation signal and which corresponding load sensor 111 is coupled to the input channel of the data acquisition system 509 / 603. Similarly, in Figure 5 In the system, the controller 701 is coupled to the MISO sensor router 601 and is configured to transmit control signals to the MISO sensor router 601 to selectively control which response sensor 107 is coupled to an input channel of the data acquisition system 509 / 603.

[0041] Figure 7 The method performed by the controller 701 is illustrated to operate Figure 5The system is used to perform a multiple input multiple output (MIMO) system vibration test by sequentially implementing multiple single input single output (SISO) data collection and processing routines. The controller 701 causes the SISO signal generator 501 to generate an excitation signal (step 801). Then, the controller causes the SIMO exciter router 505 to connect the excitation signal to the first vibration exciter 109 and causes the MISO load router 507 to connect the first load sensor 111 to the load sensor input channel of the data acquisition system 603 (step 803). Similarly, the controller causes the MISO sensor router 601 to connect the first response sensor 107 to the response input channel of the data acquisition system 603 (step 805).

[0042] With the first vibration exciter 109 coupled to receive the excitation signal and the first load sensor 111 and the first response sensor 107 coupled to respective input channels of the data acquisition system 603, the controller 701 then begins collecting and storing data from the data acquisition system (step 807). In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to wait using a trigger mechanism until one or more predefined conditions are met before recording the received data. Triggers may be employed to control data capture based on detection of certain events in applied or sensed vibrations or another type of signal. Examples may include exceeding a certain force level, exceeding or experiencing a certain vibration level when applying excitation with an impact hammer or vibrator during modal testing.

[0043] In some embodiments, the data acquisition system 603 is configured to utilize a trigger mechanism so that data acquisition and processing is not started (or stopped) until a certain signal level (e.g., voltage) is detected in the input channel. After the trigger is armed, the controller 701 will be initialized to wait for a signal event to occur (e.g., the rising flank of the trigger signal exceeds 50% of the maximum channel range), and then acquire / store data and / or continue to store data received from the data acquisition system 603 until a predefined stop condition is met. In some embodiments, the stop condition is defined as a duration (e.g., the controller 701 starts storing 5 seconds of data when a signal event is detected) or another stop trigger criterion (e.g., the falling flank of the trigger signal is below 50% of the maximum channel range). In some embodiments, the trigger can be set so that it is automatically re-armed after each trigger, so that several measurements can be performed one after another (e.g., to automatically collect and store multiple measurements).

[0044] In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to utilize a trigger that is controlled based on the ability of the device / structure under test 103 to vibrate in response to an applied vibration. For example, it may take some time for the device / structure under test 103 to respond to an applied stimulus in a sufficiently linear manner. Therefore, starting data acquisition at the same time as the stimulus signal is applied to the vibration exciter 109 will not provide high-quality SRF data. Instead, the trigger start event can be configured to delay data acquisition relative to the stimulus start time; thus, giving the device / structure under test 103 more time to respond before the measurement begins. The same applies to the triggered stop of the measurement. If the measurement is stopped while the vibration exciter 109 is disconnected from the stimulus signal, the structure may still be unable to respond to the most recent stimulus signal. Instead, in some embodiments, the controller 701 can be configured to stop the measurement while the stimulus signal is still applied to the vibration exciter 109. This stop condition trigger also prevents the nonlinear behavior of the vibration exciter 109 during a sudden start or stop from completely corrupting the measurement. In some embodiments; (multiple) synchronization triggers can be automatically executed by the control logic based on the stimulus type, frequency range or other test-specific criteria.

[0045] Return to Figure 7 In the method, after reading the data from the connected response sensor and storing it in the memory 705, the controller 701 increments the MISO sensor router 601 to connect the next response sensor 107 to the response input channel of the data acquisition system 603 (step 805). Therefore, this process of collecting response sensor data (step 807) and incrementing the MISO sensor router 601 (step 805) is repeated until sensor data has been captured from each response sensor 107 when the excitation signal is applied by the same single vibration actuator 109 (step 813). After the sensor data has been collected by each response sensor 107 in the sequence (step 813), the controller 701 increments the SIMO actuator router 505 and the MISO load router 507 (step 803), thereby causing the excitation signal to be applied to a different vibration actuator 109. In this example, as the SIMO exciter router 505 and the MISO load router 507 are incremented to apply excitation signals to different vibration exciters 109, the increment of the MISO sensor router 601 is reset to capture sensor data from the first sensor in the sequence. This process continues until the excitation signal has been applied to each vibration exciter 109, and sensor data from each responding sensor 107 is recorded when the excitation signal is applied to the vibration exciter 109.

[0046] For example, consider an arrangement in which three vibration actuators 109 and three response sensors 107 are coupled to the device / structure under test 103. The controller 701 will apply an excitation signal to the first vibration actuator 109 and collect sensor data from each of the three response sensors 107. Then, the controller 701 will apply an excitation signal to the second vibration actuator 109 and again collect sensor data from each of the three response sensors 107. Finally, the controller 701 will apply an excitation signal to the third vibration actuator 109 and again collect sensor data from each of the three response sensors 107. Thus, the controller 701 will capture nine different sets of sensor data—one set of sensor data for each possible different combination of vibration actuators 109 and response sensors 107.

[0047] When sensor data has been recorded for each response sensor 107 in the sequence (step 813) when the excitation signal is applied to the last vibration actuator 109 in the sequence (step 819), one or more post-processing routines are applied to the collected data (step 821) to reconstruct and / or update the associated MIMO SRF model / measurement indicative of the dynamic behavior of the entire device / structure under test 103. For example, in some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to populate the MIMO SRF matrix with a frequency response function (FRF) for each different combination of vibration actuator 109 / load sensor 111 and response sensor 107, as described above in Figure 3 As shown in the figure.

[0048] In some embodiments, to ensure consistently high data quality, a data acquisition system (DAQ) cooperates with the controller 701 to receive correct parameterization before each individual measurement (or, in some embodiments, before each group of measurements or each measurement sequence). The DAQ itself can be configured to provide high-level functions (formulas / algorithms) to correctly adjust the individual transducers (e.g., load sensors 111 and response sensors 107) connected to each DAQ measurement channel. In some embodiments, the DAQ provides multiple functions to automatically adjust the range settings based on the "strength" of the incoming measurement signal. This process can be called "autoranging" and in some embodiments is fully automated for the DAQ to perform immediately before taking a measurement. This can be accomplished, for example, by operating one or more exciter devices 109 under multiple conditions in which the exciter device generates the highest vibration level for a period of time (e.g., a few seconds) while sensing and adjusting the connected sensor signals in such a way that no unwanted overloading (clipping) occurs. The purpose of a parameterization procedure (such as "auto-range") is to maximize the sensitivity of the measurement chain (transducer, cable, DAQ) without negatively affecting data quality. For example, in some embodiments, the DAQ system is configured to measure an input signal of + / -5V (discretized by 24 bits), which corresponds to a vibration amplitude (e.g., 10m / s^2). For small vibration amplitudes (e.g., 1m / s^2), the effective range observed by the DAQ is reduced to + / -1V (auto-range). In this case, the 24-bit resolution remains the same to achieve higher measurement accuracy (e.g., to more clearly distinguish between the signal and the sensitivity threshold of the measurement device). In some embodiments, the DAQ features a communication and / or control interface to allow communication with other types of devices via compatible protocols (such as, serial bus, Ethernet, USB or other communication interfaces).

[0049] In some embodiments, the controller 701 is further configured to analyze the data received from the load sensor 111 and / or the response sensor 107 to determine whether the captured data meets certain data quality conditions. In response to determining that the data captured for a particular response sensor 107, load sensor 111, or various combinations thereof do not meet the data quality conditions, the controller 701 is configured to repeat the data collection for one or more combinations of the vibration actuator 109 and the response sensor 107. In some embodiments, the controller 701 may repeat the data collection by applying the same excitation signal to the vibration actuator 109 and collecting data from the response sensor 107. In some embodiments, the controller 701 may be configured to adjust the excitation signal applied to the vibration actuator 109 in addition to or in lieu of repeating the data collection using the same excitation signal previously applied.

[0050] For example, as illustrated in the figure, the controller 701 can be configured to apply one or more quality tests (step 809) to the collected sensor data after each sensor reading step (step 807). As described in further detail below, in some embodiments, the quality tests can be designed to analyze the data of a single vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combination, and in other embodiments, the quality tests can be designed to analyze the data of the vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combination relative to the sensor data collected for other vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combinations.

[0051] like Figure 7 As also illustrated in the example of , in some embodiments, the controller 701 is further configured to apply one or more quality tests (step 815) after collecting data from all sensors in the sequence when the excitation signal is applied by the same vibration actuator 109, in addition to or in lieu of applying the one or more quality tests (step 809) after each response sensor reading. In other words, the one or more quality tests (step 815) are applied before incrementing the SIMO actuator router 505 and the MISO load router 507 (step 803) to apply the excitation signal to the next vibration actuator 109 and connecting the corresponding load sensor 111 to the data acquisition system 603. Again, in some embodiments, in response to determining that the collected data fails one or more of the quality tests (step 815), the controller 701 is configured to adjust the excitation signal applied to the vibration actuator 109 (step 817) and repeat the data collection from one or more of the response sensors in the sequence before continuing to the next vibration actuator 109.

[0052] Additionally, in some embodiments, the controller 701 may be configured to apply one or more quality tests to the collected data after all SRF data is collected (i.e., after data is collected from each vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combination) to supplement or replace the quality checks performed after each individual sensor reading and after each complete sensor reading sequence. Furthermore, in some embodiments, as described above, the controller 701 is configured to transmit control signals to the SIMO actuator router 505, the MISO load router 507, and the MISO sensor router 601, and thereby can selectively activate any specific combination of vibration actuators 109 and response sensors 107. Therefore, in some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to analyze the captured data after collecting data for all vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combinations, identify one or more combinations that do not meet data quality conditions, and repeat data collection only for combinations identified as insufficient data quality. In some embodiments, data collection for these defective combinations is performed by adjusting the excitation signal, operating the SIMO exciter router 505 to couple the adjusted excitation signal to the vibration exciters 109 identified in the combination with defective data, operating the MISO sensor router 601 to couple the response sensors 107 identified in the combination with defective data to the response input channels of the data acquisition system 603, and then collecting data from the coupled response sensors 107. This process is then repeated for each combination that has been identified as having insufficient data quality.

[0053] As described above, in some embodiments, multiple data quality checks may be applied to the collected data simultaneously (i.e., after collecting data from individual sensors, after collecting data from the entire sensor sequence, and / or after collecting data from all vibration actuator 109 / response sensor 107 combinations). Figure 8An example of a method performed by the controller 701 is illustrated for applying a plurality of different quality tests to the collected data. After receiving input data (e.g., from one or more load sensors 111 and / or a plurality of response sensors 107) (step 901), the controller 701 applies a first signal quality test (step 903). If the collected data fails the first signal quality test (step 905), a first adjustment is applied to the excitation signal (step 907) and data collection is repeated (step 909). However, if the collected data passes the first signal quality test (step 905), the controller 701 proceeds to apply a second signal quality test (step 911). Again, if the collected data fails the second signal quality test (step 913), a second adjustment is applied to the excitation signal (step 915) and data collection is repeated (step 909). However, if the collected data passes the second signal quality test (step 913), the controller 701 proceeds to apply a third signal quality test (step 917). If the collected data does not pass the third signal quality test (step 919), a third adjustment is applied to the excitation signal (step 921) and data collection is repeated (step 909). However, if the collected data passes all three signal quality tests, the controller 701 proceeds to the next data collection step, or, if all data has been collected, the controller 701 proceeds to apply an applicable post-processing routine to the collected data (e.g., to populate the MIMO SRF matrix) (step 923).

[0054] In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to perform each test in series, such that the controller 701 proceeds to the second signal quality test only if the collected data passes the first signal quality test, and similarly, the controller 701 proceeds to the third signal quality test only if the collected data passes both the first signal quality test and the second signal quality test. However, in other embodiments, the controller is configured to perform each test in parallel, such that the controller 701 proceeds to the second signal quality test (e.g., whether the collected data has passed the first signal quality test or not) regardless of whether the collected data has passed the first signal quality test. Figure 8 ), and similarly, regardless of whether the collected data has passed the first and / or second data quality tests, the controller 701 proceeds to the third signal quality test (as indicated by Figure 8915 and step 917 in ). In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to apply multiple signal quality tests as a combination of serial and parallel tests. For example, in some embodiments, the controller 701 may be configured to perform both the first signal quality test (step 903) and the second signal quality test (step 911) on the collected data, regardless of whether the collected data passes the first signal quality test or the second signal quality test, but is configured to perform the third signal quality test (step 917) only if the collected data passes the second signal quality test (or alternatively, in some embodiments, only if the collected data passes both the first signal quality test and the second signal quality test).

[0055] Finally, in some embodiments, the controller 701 can be configured to apply the same type of signal adjustment regardless of which signal quality test is failed (e.g., the first excitation signal adjustment (step 907), the second excitation signal adjustment (step 915), and the third excitation signal adjustment (step 921) are the same type of signal adjustment). However, in other embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to apply different types of signal adjustments to the excitation signal depending on which signal quality test is failed. For example, the controller 701 can be configured to: in response to determining that the collected data fails the first signal quality test, change the excitation signal from a random signal to a logarithmic sweep signal (as described below with reference to Fig. 13B and in response to determining that the collected data does not pass the second signal quality test, applying a low pass (or high pass) filter to the excitation signal (as described below with reference to Fig. 13C Thus, in some embodiments, in response to determining that the collected data fails both the first signal quality test and the second signal quality test, the controller 701 is configured to do both of the following: (1) convert the excitation signal to a logarithmic scan signal; and (2) apply a low-pass (or high-pass) filter to the logarithmic scan excitation signal.

[0056] In various embodiments, data quality testing (e.g., Figure 8The signal quality test in the example of (i) may include data processing and quality assurance steps, wherein the data quality of each individual SIMO or SISO experiment sequence is verified, each individual SIMO or SISO experiment may be transformed into a certain SRF, and the individual SRF may be temporarily arranged in one or more partial MIMO matrices; and / or the data quality of the entire MIMO matrix (or multiple partial MIMO matrices) is verified. In the embodiment in which the individual SRF is temporarily arranged in one or more partial MIMO matrices, the controller 701 may be further configured to perform additional data transformation, manipulation or enhancement routines involving numerical, model-based and / or hybrid methods. Such methods may include, for example, geometric reduction and / or transformation techniques (e.g., finite difference approximation and virtual point transformations), data manipulation techniques to numerically change the boundary conditions under which the SRF experiments are conducted (e.g., dynamic substructuring for coupling and decoupling), data dimensionality reduction and / or regularization techniques (e.g., principal component analysis, truncation, or Tikhonov regularized singular value decomposition), and augmentation techniques to model additional data at degrees of freedom (e.g., locations on the device / structure under test) where physical measurements are not made (e.g., system equivalent model mixture (SEMM) techniques, in which experimental data are combined with other measured / simulated data). Fig. 9 Some specific examples of metrics and calculations that may be used to ensure high quality experimental data during the automated SRF measurement process in various embodiments are summarized in the table of FIG. Fig. 9 Fewer calculations, metrics, and tests are listed in the table, and some embodiments may include other calculations, metrics, and tests in addition to or in place of Fig. 9 The calculations, measurements, and tests are listed in the table.

[0057] In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to use additional data (e.g., data specific to the test setup) to perform data processing and quality assurance steps. Such data may include, for example, geometric relationships between the stimulus and response DoFs (e.g., Euclidean distances, Euler angles, etc.), metadata related to the experiment, and / or metadata required for billing purposes (e.g., data required to arrange the MIMO matrix).

[0058] In various embodiments, the analysis results of the data processing and quality assurance steps applied by the controller 701 may or may not be provided as feedback to the user during the automated SRF measurement process (e.g., via a display screen of the user interface 707). In embodiments where feedback of the quality tests is provided to the user, the results may be summarized in a variety of ways, such as ranging from a single numerical value to a complex graphical representation of the data quality to help the user interpret the individual and / or overall data quality. Fig.10 , Fig.11 and Fig.12 An example of a mechanism for displaying data quality feedback information to a user via the display screen of user interface 707 is illustrated.

[0059] Fig.10 An example of a graph that may be displayed to a user via a display screen of the user interface 707 indicating SRF reciprocity between automated measurement locations as a single value matrix representation is illustrated. Fig.10 In the example of , relative data quality is indicated by the relative darkness of each displayed square (e.g., darker squares represent higher quality data). In some embodiments, this analysis is a collection quality test ( Figure 7 , part of step 815).

[0060] Fig.11 An example of a series of graphs that may be displayed to a user via a display screen of user interface 707, the graphs indicating measures of response consistency. The top graph indicates overall response consistency as a spectrum, the middle graph illustrates individual specific response consistency as a spectrum, and the bottom graph illustrates specific response consistency as a single value. Fig.11 In the graph of , values ​​closer to 100% indicate higher quality data. In some embodiments, the controller 701 may be configured to simultaneously display on the screen Fig.11 , while in other embodiments, the controller 701 may be configured to display only Fig.11 One or both of the diagrams and / or selectively and interchangeably displayed Fig.11 of different charts.

[0061] Fig.12 An example of a graph that may be displayed to a user via a display screen of user interface 707 indicating an interface integrity criterion (ICC) as a frequency spectrum is illustrated. Values ​​close to one ("1") indicate frequencies at which the MIMO system is well described and further analysis should be performed if the measurement results are not satisfactory.

[0062] As mentioned above Figure 8 and Fig. 9As described, in some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to adjust the applied excitation signal to further improve data quality. In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to attempt to apply an excitation signal that imparts a force input to the device / structure under test in such a way that a desired vibration output is obtained that satisfies as many defined quality conditions as possible. Adjustments to the excitation signal may include, for example: (1) duration (due to averaging effects, longer measurements can provide clearer (e.g., less noisy) results, but increase the overall data acquisition time); (2) type (e.g., impact / transient excitation, burst / random excitation, pseudo-random excitation, swept sine, stepped sine, etc.); (3) amplitude (e.g., amplitude scaling of the entire signal or time / frequency-dependent amplitude scaling); (4) frequency content (e.g., frequency-dependent filtering / equalization (e.g., amplifying the excitation at lower frequencies to obtain sufficient signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) in the elastic coupling assembly)), or (5) a combination of some or all of the above (e.g., transmission loss compensation via transmissivity filtering).

[0063] In some embodiments, the controller 701 is configured to determine whether the applied excitation signal needs adjustment based on: (1) feedback-free adjustment using an integrated "exciter calibration database"; (2) feedback from a connected data acquisition system (DAQ); and / or (3) feedback from a MIMO data processing system. In some embodiments, the "exciter calibration database" used by the controller 701 to perform feedback-free adjustment contains information about the connected vibration exciters along with knowledge of which vibration exciter is currently operating (e.g., applying a predefined exciter-specific equalization filter to the excitation signal in order to linearize the exciter output each time the exciter is operated). In some embodiments, the DAQ itself may be configured to perform internal data quality checks to analyze the most recent individual SIMO / SISO experiments and communicate the results to the controller 701 via an appropriate protocol. Finally, in some embodiments, the controller 701 (or a separate MIMO data processing system) is configured to process and analyze individual SIMO / SISO measurements and / or entire sets of measurements reorganized into one or more MIMO matrices. As discussed above, in some embodiments, a system (such as, Figures 4 to 6 ) is constructed to address both individual and overall data quality / consistency simultaneously.

[0064] FIG. 13A to FIG. 13D The test system (e.g. Figures 4 to 6The example of a system configured to adjust the applied force (X) in response to a sensed vibration response (Y) (i.e., the actual vibration applied to the device / structure under test in response to the excitation signal). The test system in this example is configured to apply a signal quality test to evaluate the signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). Fig.13A Examples include: a separate MIMO data processing system 1301, which is configured to analyze the collected data; and control logic 1303, which is configured to adjust the excitation signal in response to feedback received by the control logic 1303 from the MIMO data processing system 1301. In some embodiments, a single controller (e.g., controller 701) can be configured to provide the functionality of both the MIMO data processing system 1301 and the control logic 1303, as described in this example. In other embodiments, a controller (e.g., controller 701) can be configured to provide the functionality of the control logic 1303, and the data acquisition system 509 / 603 can be configured to provide the functionality of the MIMO data processing system 1301. In other embodiments, other combinations of logic components and functional distributions are also possible.

[0065] like Fig.13A As illustrated in (and as described above in other examples), the SISO signal generator 501 is configured to generate an excitation signal in response to a control signal received from the control logic 1303, which in this example is configured to normalize the excitation signal output for each individual vibration exciter 109 (i.e., an excitation signal with an amplitude of + / -1). An example of a normalized signal x(t) generated by the SISO signal generator 501 is shown in Fig. 13B The normalized excitation signal x(t) is then provided as an input to the SISO power amplifier 503, which in turn outputs a conditioned excitation signal that is routed to the vibration exciter 109. The vibration exciter 109 imparts a vibration excitation force x(t) into the device / structure under test, and the actual vibration is measured by the corresponding load sensor 111. An example of the actual applied vibration X as measured by the load sensor 111 is shown in Fig. 13C The applied force is transmitted through the device / structure under test 103, and the actual vibration at another location on the device / structure under test is routed to the data acquisition system 509 / 603, and the data input indicative of the sensed vibration y(t) is collected by or transmitted to the MIMO data processing system 1301. An example of the sensed vibration Y as measured by the response sensor 107 is shown in Fig.13D It is illustrated in the frequency domain representation (i.e., the response spectrum Y(ω)).

[0066] exist Fig.13AIn the example of , MIMO data processing system 1301 is configured to apply one or more signal quality tests to the captured data, the one or more signal quality tests including at least one signal quality test designed to determine whether the collected data exhibits a sufficient signal-to-noise ratio. MIMO data processing system 1301 transmits feedback indicating the results of the (multiple) signal quality tests (i.e., where the SNR is sufficient) to control logic 1303, and based on the received feedback, control logic 1303 determines whether adjustments to the excitation signal are appropriate.

[0067] To demonstrate in more detail Fig.13A The adjustment mechanism in the example of FIG. 13B to FIG. 13D Examples of various signals both before and after the control logic applies adjustments to the excitation signal are shown. Fig. 13B In , the top graph illustrates the original excitation signal, and the bottom graph illustrates the adjusted excitation signal. Fig. 13C In FIG. 1 , the top graph illustrates the force spectrum X(ω) of the actual force (as measured by load cell 111) applied to the device / structure under test in response to the original excitation signal, and the bottom graph illustrates the force spectrum X(ω) of the actual force applied in response to the adjusted excitation signal. Fig.13D , the top graph illustrates a response spectrum Y(ω) based on the output of the response sensor 107 when the original excitation signal is applied, and the bottom graph illustrates a response spectrum based on the output of the response sensor 107 when the adjusted excitation signal is applied.

[0068] The original stimulus signal (such as Fig. 13B The force applied in response to this raw excitation signal (as shown in the top graph of Fig. 13C The force drop-off in the higher frequency range is evident in the top graph of Figure 1 ) and is characterized by a medium amplitude, broadband spectrum X(ω) with a clear force drop-off in the higher frequency range. In this example, the excitation frequency range extends to the low frequency region (in Fig. 13C However, this low frequency excitation component may limit the vibration actuator 109 to operate in a more relevant frequency region (e.g., a higher frequency range where Fig. 13C The signal in the top graph of FIG. 104 begins to drop off). In practice, the illustrated force drop towards high frequencies may be caused by internal damping due to exciting all frequencies simultaneously (e.g., using a random white noise excitation signal). Therefore, the vibration exciter 109 attempts to overcome the large strokes at low frequencies while simultaneously superimposing the small stroke motions at high frequencies. The applied vibration causes the linear and time-invariant (LTI) device / structure under test 103 to vibrate in response to the applied force, which is then sensed by the response sensor(s) 107.

[0069] exist Fig.13D In the top graph of , the spectrum of the sensed response vibration Y(ω) is plotted together with the spectrum of the sensor noise floor. In some embodiments, the sensor noise floor can be measured in the same setup when no excitation is applied to the device / structure under test 103. As discussed above, the "quality" of the sensed vibration can be analyzed in a variety of different ways. However, in this example, Fig.13D The top graph of illustrates the signal-to-noise problem in the area where the sensed vibration spectrum Y(ω) is close to the sensor noise floor. In some embodiments, the data quality condition can be defined as a sensed signal that is at least 10 dB higher than the sensor noise floor at that frequency. Fig.13D In the example of the top graph of , due to the relatively low force excitation (as a result of the high internal damping of the vibration exciter), the sensed vibration Y(ω) suffers from insufficient signal-to-noise distance at the expected anti-resonance of the structure and typically at high frequencies.

[0070] In this example, the MIMO data processing system 1301 is configured to analyze the sensed vibration to identify insufficient data quality (i.e., insufficient SNR) and transmit a feedback message to the control logic 1303. In response, the control logic 1303 initiates automated adjustments to the applied vibration to mitigate the detected signal quality issues. In some embodiments, the control logic 1303 is configured to identify appropriate adjustments to the excitation signal based on detailed feedback on the frequency ranges where the excitation is insufficient, along with additional metadata provided by the user regarding the targeted frequency ranges and / or the time requirements of the measurement(s).

[0071] In this particular example, the configuration of the control logic 1303 causes it to determine, based on feedback from the MIMO data processing system 1301, that the “type” of the excitation signal should be selected from a random broadband white noise excitation signal (in Fig. 13B ) into a logarithmic sweep signal (in the top graph of Fig. 13B ). Doing so will cause the vibrator to generate vibrations at a single frequency at a time, thus preventing internal damping of the vibrator while maximizing force output. In this example, a logarithmic frequency sweep is used rather than a linear sweep to provide the device / structure under test 103 with sufficient time to respond to the applied vibrations, especially for the lower frequency ranges that are more difficult to excite.

[0072] In this example, the configuration of the control logic 1303 also causes it to determine, based on feedback from the MIMO data processing system 1301, that additional adjustments to the excitation frequency range may be appropriate (e.g., to prevent damage to the vibration exciter due to over-excursion at low frequencies beyond the frequency range of interest and / or to minimize the duration of the measurement). In this example, this is achieved by causing the SISO signal generator 501 to apply a high pass filter during the signal generation process. The high pass filter prevents the vibration exciter from operating at low frequencies, and as in Fig. 13C As illustrated in the bottom graph of , the applied force spectrum X(ω) after adjusting the excitation signal has now been optimized to favor the frequency range of interest. It is also noteworthy that due to the exciter operating at one frequency at a time, the same signal amplification is sufficient to achieve significantly higher exciter force output. Moreover, in some embodiments, a similar filter may be applied as a low pass filter to cut off higher frequencies in order to avoid high vibrator temperatures during continuous operation. Other adjustments to the force signal x(t) may include changes in the signal amplitude. For example, certain frequencies may be amplified or attenuated. Fig. 13B The sine wave characteristics of the signal in order to "shape" Fig. 13C The force characteristic X(ω) in . In some embodiments, the signal generator is configured to apply these adjustments. This allows, for example, higher forces to be applied at low frequencies, which is helpful, for example, for structures connected using rubber isolators, where high excitation energy is required to induce low frequency response signals on the structure due to energy dissipation at the rubber isolators.

[0073] The vibration spectrum X(ω) applied in response to the adjusted excitation signal results in a better overall excitation of the device / structure under test, as given by Fig.13D , which exhibits a significantly higher vibration response spectrum Y(ω) with increased separation between the sensed signal and the sensor noise floor. Thus, when the MIMO data processing system 1301 receives the updated sensed signal and applies the same signal quality test, the output of the signal quality test indicates that the signal quality issue (i.e., insufficient SNR) has been substantially mitigated and even the anti-resonance of the device / structure under test (i.e., the minimum measured amplitude level of the response signal) is clearly separated from the sensor noise floor. The higher quality response spectrum can now be fully used along with the measured force spectrum of the applied vibration to determine a high quality SRF between the corresponding excitation and response degrees of freedom (i.e., the corresponding vibration exciter 109 / response sensor 107 combination).

[0074] exist FIG. 13A to FIG. 13DIn the example of , the excitation signal adjustment strategy is fully automated and executed by the MIMO data processing system 1301 and the control logic 1303 (e.g., in some embodiments, both are implemented in the controller 701) without any direct input from the user. However, in some embodiments, the control logic 1303 can be configured to output feedback indicating the quantized signal quality to the user and receive user feedback indicating adjustments to the excitation signal. In some such embodiments, the control logic 1303 can be configured to prioritize such direct user feedback over the automated adjustment strategy.

[0075] In some embodiments, similar excitation signal adjustment strategies can be implemented based on the received feedback, taking into account one or more data quality indicator criteria, such as adjusting the applied vibration based on: (i) only the applied vibration (e.g., force); (ii) only the sensed vibration (e.g., acceleration), or (iii) both the applied vibration and the sensed vibration. In some embodiments, the output of the SISO signal generator 501 or the SISO power amplifier 503 is used as a basis for adjusting the downstream applied vibration, such as using numerical data representing the normalized or adjusted desired signal output together with additional performance-related criteria (e.g., the frequency response function of the amplifier or the "output vibration" to "input current" transfer function of the vibration exciter) to estimate and adjust the expected applied vibration.

[0076] Thus, the systems and methods described herein facilitate decomposing complex experimental MIMO vibration tests into multiple sequentially executed SIMO or SISO SRF experiments following a fully automated process, such as in Figure 7After the initial test system setup (including instrumented device / structure under test 103 and / or specially designed fixture 101), the controller 701 is able to autonomously perform all experiments, including data quality checks, complex data-based decisions, and data post-processing. For example, according to one embodiment, a MIMO SRF vibration test may include the following process control steps: (1) system setup and instrumentation (one-time setup; special fixtures may be used to facilitate measurements); (2) routing of excitation hardware (vibration excitation source and associated load sensors) and / or additional / alternative methods to determine the actual force excitation; (3) routing of response sensor hardware and / or additional / alternative methods to determine the actual response of the test structure to the applied force excitation; (4) parameterization of the data acquisition (DAQ) system according to the current SIMO or SISO experiment sequence (e.g., sensor calibration, dynamic range, sampling frequency, sampling duration, filtering, triggering, etc.); (5) collection of all SIMO or SISO experiment sequence data; (6) data post-processing of the current SIMO or SISO experiment sequence, including (in some embodiments) quality assurance methods and associated process flow control (e.g., if the quality assurance methods indicate poor results, repeat the experiment with improved excitation strategy or data collection parameterization); (7) evaluation of successful SIMO or SISO experiments. SRF experiment data is post-processed (and stored) and initiates subsequent SIMO or SISO experiments, and (8) post-processes and provides reconstructed / updated MIMO SRF measurements (additional numerical / model-based / hybrid data manipulations / transformations may be performed).

[0077] Thus, various embodiments of the systems and methods described herein may provide the following advantages over other MIMO test methods: (1) all exciters may share a single signal generator and power amplifier; (2) the number of excitation DoFs and response DoFs is not limited by the DAQ channel count; (3) any excitation signal (transient, continuous, etc.) may be used while ensuring optimal phase reference and improved signal-to-noise ratio (SNR); (4) the DAQ may employ an automatic calibration process to adjust the measurement range for each excitation employed; (5) challenging measurements may be split into multiple sections to allow the exciter to cool down between measurements (data post-processing methods may reassemble the segmented measurements); (6) challenging measurements may be subsequently made using different excitation sources through control strategies (data post-processing methods may be used to reassemble / merge different data (e.g., different exciters for different frequency ranges)); (7) a reciprocity calibration method may be used to perform in situ exciter output calibration and / or reduce the number of exciter output sensors (e.g., load sensors) required; (8) local nonlinearities may be detected using appropriate signal generation and / or post-processing methods; and (9) signal generation is independent of the number of SRFs to be determined.

[0078] Further features and advantages of the invention are set forth in the following claims.

Claims

1. A method for automated MIMO force response characterization of a structure under test, the method comprising: coupling the structure under test to a plurality of actuator devices and a plurality of response sensors; generating an excitation signal; iteratively and automatically applying the excitation signal to each of the plurality of actuator devices, wherein applying the excitation signal to the actuator device causes the actuator device to impart an excitation force to the structure under test; collecting sensor data from each of the plurality of response sensors while iteratively applying the excitation signal to the plurality of actuator devices, wherein the collected sensor data includes response data for each of a plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations, wherein the response data for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations includes the sensor data collected by a single response sensor when the excitation force is imparted to the structure under test by a single actuator device; applying a signal quality test to the collected sensor data to determine whether the collected response data for a first actuator-sensor combination of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations does not satisfy a defined signal quality condition; and In response to determining that the collected response data for the first exciter-sensor combination does not meet the defined signal quality condition, repeating data collection for the first exciter-sensor combination, wherein repeating the data collection for the first exciter-sensor combination includes: applying the excitation signal to a first exciter device in the first exciter-sensor combination; and collecting updated sensor data from a first response sensor in the first exciter-sensor combination when the excitation signal is applied to the first exciter device.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein: Repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination further comprises adjusting the excitation signal, and wherein repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination comprises: applying the excitation signal to the first exciter device by applying the adjusted excitation signal to the first exciter device, and The updated sensor data is collected from the first responsive sensor by collecting the updated sensor data from the first responsive sensor while applying the adjusted excitation signal to the first actuator device.

3. The method according to claim 2, wherein: iteratively applying the excitation signal to each of the plurality of exciter devices comprises applying a white noise excitation signal, wherein applying the signal quality test comprises analyzing a spectral signal-to-noise ratio of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination, and Wherein, repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination comprises: In response to determining that the spectral signal-to-noise ratio of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination is below a threshold, repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination, and The excitation signal is adjusted by changing a type of the excitation signal from the white noise excitation signal to at least one selected from the group consisting of a logarithmic scanning excitation signal and a linear scanning excitation signal.

4. The method according to claim 2, wherein: applying the signal quality test comprises analyzing frequency domain amplitude of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination over a defined frequency range, and Wherein, repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination comprises: in response to determining that the frequency domain magnitude of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination within the defined frequency range exceeds a threshold, repeating the data collection, and The excitation signal is adjusted by applying a frequency filter to the excitation signal, wherein the frequency filter includes at least one selected from the group consisting of a low pass filter, a high pass filter, and a band pass filter, wherein the frequency filter is configured to filter out components of the excitation signal corresponding to the defined frequency range used in the signal quality test.

5. The method according to claim 2, wherein: Adjusting the excitation signal comprises at least one selected from the group consisting of: Apply multiple sine sweep excitation signals, and At least one parameter of the multiple sinusoidal scan excitation signal is adjusted.

6. The method according to claim 1, wherein: Applying the signal quality test includes applying at least one selected from the group consisting of: signal conditioning statistical analysis, signal-to-noise ratio analysis, coherence function analysis, data consistency analysis, and interface integrity criteria analysis.

7. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: calculating a frequency response function for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations, the frequency response function comprising a ratio of the excitation force applied by the actuator device in the actuator-sensor combination to the sensed excitation force sensed by the response sensor in the actuator-sensor combination, wherein calculating the frequency response function of each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations comprises: determining the frequency response function of the first actuator-sensor combination based on the updated sensor data collected by the first response sensor after repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination; and determining a system response function based on a plurality of frequency response functions, the plurality of frequency response functions including the calculated frequency response function for each actuator-sensor combination, Wherein, determining the system response function based on the plurality of frequency response functions comprises populating a system response function matrix with the plurality of frequency response functions.

8. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: applying a collective quality test to a set of collected response data to determine whether the set of collected response data does not satisfy a collective quality condition, wherein the set of collected response data includes the collected response data for the first actuator-sensor combination and collected response data for a plurality of actuator-sensor combinations collected prior to the collected response data for the first actuator-sensor combination; and In response to determining that the set of collected response data does not satisfy the collective quality condition, data collection is repeated for one or more actuator-sensor combinations of the plurality of actuator-sensor combinations.

9. The method according to claim 1, wherein: The response data for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations includes: acceleration response data collected by the single response sensor when the excitation force is imparted to the structure under test by the single actuator device, and Applied force data is collected by a load sensor corresponding to the single actuator device, wherein the applied force data is indicative of an actual excitation force applied to the structure under test by the single actuator device.

10. The method according to claim 1, wherein: Collecting the sensor data from each of the plurality of response sensors when the excitation signal is iteratively applied to the plurality of actuator devices includes iteratively connecting each of the plurality of response sensors to an input channel of a data acquisition system when the excitation signal is applied to the same actuator device among the plurality of actuator devices.

11. A system for automated MIMO force response characterization of a structure under test, the system comprising: a plurality of exciter devices; Multiple response sensors; Excitation signal generator; an exciter router configured to selectively couple an excitation signal generated by the excitation signal generator to a selected exciter device of the plurality of exciter devices; as well as An electronic controller configured to: operating the actuator router to iteratively and automatically apply the excitation signal to each of the plurality of actuator devices, wherein applying the excitation signal to the actuator device causes the actuator device to impart an excitation force to the structure under test, collecting sensor data from each of the plurality of response sensors while iteratively applying the excitation signal to the plurality of actuator devices, wherein the collected sensor data includes response data for each of a plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations, wherein the response data for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations includes the sensor data collected by a single response sensor when the excitation force is imparted to the structure under test by a single actuator device, applying a signal quality test to the collected sensor data to determine whether the collected response data for a first actuator-sensor combination of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations does not satisfy a defined signal quality condition, and In response to determining that the collected response data for the first exciter-sensor combination does not meet the defined signal quality condition, repeating data collection for the first exciter-sensor combination, wherein the electronic controller is configured to repeat the data collection for the first exciter-sensor combination by: applying the excitation signal to a first exciter device in the first exciter-sensor combination; and collecting updated sensor data from a first response sensor in the first exciter-sensor combination when the excitation signal is applied to the first exciter device.

12. The system according to claim 11, wherein: The electronic controller is configured to repeat the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination by: adjusting the excitation signal, applying the adjusted excitation signal to the first exciter device, and The updated sensor data is collected from the first responsive sensor while applying the adjusted excitation signal to the first actuator device.

13. The system according to claim 12, wherein: The electronic controller is configured to iteratively apply the excitation signal to each of the plurality of exciter devices by applying a white noise excitation signal, wherein the electronic controller is configured to apply the signal quality test by analyzing a spectral signal-to-noise ratio of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination, and Wherein, the electronic controller is configured to repeat the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination by the following steps: In response to determining that the spectral signal-to-noise ratio of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination is below a threshold, repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination, and The excitation signal is adjusted by changing a type of the excitation signal from the white noise excitation signal to at least one selected from the group consisting of a logarithmic scanning excitation signal and a linear scanning excitation signal.

14. The system according to claim 12, wherein: The electronic controller is configured to apply the signal quality test by analyzing the frequency domain amplitude of the response data for the first exciter-sensor combination within a defined frequency range, and Wherein, the electronic controller is configured to repeat the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination by the following steps: in response to determining that the frequency domain magnitude of the response data for the first actuator-sensor combination within the defined frequency range exceeds a threshold, repeating the data collection, and The excitation signal is adjusted by applying a frequency filter to the excitation signal, wherein the frequency filter includes at least one selected from the group consisting of a low pass filter, a high pass filter, and a band pass filter, wherein the frequency filter is configured to filter out components of the excitation signal corresponding to the defined frequency range used in the signal quality test.

15. The system of claim 12, wherein: The electronic controller is configured to adjust the excitation signal by at least one selected from the group consisting of: Apply multiple sine sweep excitation signals, and At least one parameter of the multiple sinusoidal scan excitation signal is adjusted.

16. The system according to claim 11, wherein: The electronic controller is configured to apply the signal quality test by applying at least one selected from the group consisting of: signal conditioning statistical analysis, signal-to-noise ratio analysis, coherence function analysis, data consistency analysis, and interface integrity criteria analysis.

17. The system of claim 11, wherein: The electronic controller is further configured to: calculating a frequency response function for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations, the frequency response function comprising a ratio of the excitation force applied by the actuator device in the actuator-sensor combination to the sensed excitation force sensed by the response sensor in the actuator-sensor combination, wherein the electronic controller is configured to calculate the frequency response function for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations by: determining the frequency response function for the first actuator-sensor combination based on the updated sensor data collected by the first response sensor after repeating the data collection for the first actuator-sensor combination; and determining a system response function based on a plurality of frequency response functions, the plurality of frequency response functions including the calculated frequency response function for each actuator-sensor combination, Wherein, the electronic controller is configured to determine the system response function based on the plurality of frequency response functions by the following steps: populating a system response function matrix with the plurality of frequency response functions.

18. The system of claim 11, wherein: The electronic controller is further configured to: applying a collective quality test to a set of collected response data to determine whether the set of collected response data does not satisfy a collective quality condition, wherein the set of collected response data includes the collected response data for the first actuator-sensor combination and collected response data for a plurality of actuator-sensor combinations collected prior to the collected response data for the first actuator-sensor combination; and In response to determining that the set of collected response data does not satisfy the collective quality condition, data collection is repeated for one or more actuator-sensor combinations of the plurality of actuator-sensor combinations.

19. The system of claim 11, wherein: The response data for each of the plurality of different actuator-sensor combinations includes: acceleration response data collected by the single response sensor when the excitation force is imparted to the structure under test by the single actuator device, and Applied force data is collected by a load sensor corresponding to the single actuator device, wherein the applied force data is indicative of an actual excitation force applied to the structure under test by the single actuator device.

20. The system of claim 11, further comprising: Data acquisition system; as well as a sensor router configured to selectively couple selected ones of the plurality of responsive sensors to a shared input channel of the data acquisition system, Wherein, the electronic controller is configured to collect the sensor data from each of the multiple response sensors when the excitation signal is iteratively applied to the multiple exciter devices by the following steps: operating the sensor router to iteratively connect each of the multiple response sensors to the shared input channel of the data acquisition system when the excitation signal is applied to the same exciter device among the multiple exciter devices.