Conflict resolution method of closed-loop control loop and related device

By detecting and updating the control goals and execution timing of the closed-loop control loops, the problem of conflicts in closed-loop control loops in 5G networks is solved, the level of automation and autonomy of network management is improved, and the complexity of network management is reduced.

CN119031410APending Publication Date: 2024-11-26ASIAINFO TECH CHINA INC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411002655.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-25
Publication Date
2024-11-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The conflict problem between closed-loop control loops in 5G networks has not been effectively resolved, resulting in an increase in network management complexity and affecting the implementation of network automation and autonomy.

Method used

Before the first closed loop control loop of the current management unit is executed, it is detected whether it has conflicts with the second closed loop control loop in the management domain, and in the event of conflict, update the execution timing of the control target and action plan to avoid Conflict between goals and action plans.

Benefits of technology

It effectively avoids the conflicts between goals and action plans between closed-loop control loops, avoids the adverse impact of conflicts on network management, and improves the efficiency of network automation and autonomy.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119031410A_ABST
    Figure CN119031410A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a conflict resolution method of a closed-loop control loop and a related device, and belongs to the technical field of mobile communication networks, whether target (control target) conflict of the closed-loop control loop exists or not is detected before the closed-loop control loop is executed, and the control target is updated by executing first conflict processing under the condition that the conflict exists, so that the conflict resolution of the closed-loop control loop is realized. Target (control target) conflicts between closed-loop control loops are effectively avoided; before the action plan of the closed-loop control loop is executed, whether an action plan conflict of the closed-loop control loop exists or not is detected, and if the conflict exists, the execution timing of the action plan is determined by executing second conflict processing, and the action plan is executed based on the determined execution timing. The action plan conflict between the closed-loop control loops is avoided, so that the conflict problem of the closed-loop control loops is solved, and the adverse effect of the conflict problem of the closed-loop control loops on network management is avoided.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present application belongs to the field of mobile communication network technology, and in particular, relates to a conflict resolution method for a closed-loop control loop and a related device. Background Art

[0002] Due to the large number of devices and diverse services, 5G advanced networks bring more operational complexity. Network automation / intelligence is one of the important themes of 5G advanced networks, among which closed-loop automation is an integral part of network automation, which requires zero-touch network management so that the network can monitor, analyze and adjust itself.

[0003] 3GPP SA5 studied closed-loop control loops from the perspective of network management. Different closed-loop control loops exist in different management domains or network functions to support automated and autonomous networks. Different management domains may involve overlapping or non-overlapping coverage areas. The purpose and results of closed-loop control loops may affect other closed-loop control loops, resulting in conflicts between closed-loop control loops and affecting network management. Currently, there is no solution to the conflict of closed-loop control loops in the field of network management. Summary of the invention

[0004] In view of this, the present application provides a closed-loop control loop conflict resolution method and related devices to resolve the closed-loop control loop conflict problem and avoid the adverse effects of the closed-loop control loop conflict problem on network management.

[0005] The specific technical solutions are as follows:

[0006] A conflict resolution method for a closed control loop, comprising:

[0007] Acquire a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture;

[0008] Detecting whether the first control target conflicts with the second control targets of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0009] If there is a conflict, performing a first conflict processing to update at least the first control target, and performing a first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan that matches the updated first control target;

[0010] Detecting whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0011] If there is a conflict, a second conflict processing is performed to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, a second step in the first closed-loop control loop is triggered, and the second step is used to execute the action plan.

[0012] Optionally, the communication service architecture includes multiple layers, different layers are correspondingly provided with different management units, and each management unit of the same layer constitutes a corresponding management domain;

[0013] The obtaining of the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop to be executed by the current management unit in the communication service architecture includes:

[0014] Acquire a control target corresponding to the current layer obtained by decomposing the global control target level by level according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture as the first control target;

[0015] The current layer is the layer where the current management unit is located, and the global control target is the control target of the closed-loop control loop in the communication service architecture currently issued to the communication service architecture.

[0016] Optionally, performing the first conflict processing to at least update the first control target includes:

[0017] Reporting corresponding conflict loop information to a management party, so that the management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict loop information;

[0018] Among them, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop is a second closed-loop control loop whose corresponding second control target conflicts with the first control target; the conflicting loop information is at least used to indicate the control target value that conflicts between the first closed-loop control loop, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop.

[0019] Optionally, the conflict loop information includes: position information corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, respectively, a control target value conflicting between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and a cause of the conflict;

[0020] The updating of the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop by the management party based on the conflict loop information includes:

[0021] The management party may modify or create a new control target value that conflicts between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict cause.

[0022] Optionally, executing the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan matching the updated first control target includes:

[0023] Executing the monitoring step and the analyzing step in the first closed-loop control loop, so as to monitor the status of the network equipment and traffic of the communication network based on the monitoring step to obtain network status monitoring information, and analyzing the network status monitoring information based on the analyzing step to obtain a network status analysis result;

[0024] According to the network status analysis result and the updated first control target, a decision step in the first closed-loop control loop is executed to obtain the first action plan based on the decision step.

[0025] Optionally, performing the second conflict processing to determine the execution timing of the first action plan includes:

[0026] Determine whether the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, whose corresponding action plans are in conflict, have the same upper-level closed-loop control loop;

[0027] If so, determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy;

[0028] If not, determine the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy.

[0029] Optionally, determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy includes:

[0030] Triggering an upper-level management unit to determine the execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on business requirements; the upper-level management unit is the management unit corresponding to the same upper-level closed-loop control loop;

[0031] Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

[0032] Optionally, determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy includes:

[0033] determining an execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the priorities respectively corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop;

[0034] Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

[0035] A conflict resolution device for a closed-loop control circuit, comprising:

[0036] An acquisition module, used for acquiring a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture;

[0037] A first detection module, used to detect whether the first control target conflicts with the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0038] A first processing module, configured to, if there is a conflict, perform a first conflict processing to at least update the first control target, and perform a first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan matching the updated first control target;

[0039] A second detection module, used to detect whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0040] The second processing module is used to perform a second conflict processing if there is a conflict to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, trigger a second step in the first closed-loop control loop, wherein the second step is used to execute the action plan.

[0041] A computer-readable medium stores a computer program thereon, and when the computer program is executed by a processor, the computer program can be used to implement the conflict resolution method of the closed-loop control loop as described in any one of the above.

[0042] According to the above scheme, the conflict resolution method and related device for closed-loop control loops provided by the present application effectively avoid the conflict between the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit and the target (control target) of other closed-loop control loops in the management domain by detecting whether there is a conflict between the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop and the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain before the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit is executed, and in the case of a conflict, updating the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop by executing the first conflict processing; by detecting whether there is a conflict between the first action plan and the second action plan of the second closed-loop control loop in the management domain before the first action plan of the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit is executed, and in the case of a conflict, determining the execution timing of the first action plan by executing the second conflict processing, and executing the first action plan based on the execution timing, thereby avoiding the conflict between the action plans of the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit and other closed-loop control loops in the management domain, so that the present application solves the conflict problem of closed-loop control loops and avoids the adverse effects of the conflict problem of closed-loop control loops on network management. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0043] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present application or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only embodiments of the present application. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on the provided drawings without paying any creative work.

[0044] Figure 1 It is a process flow chart of a closed-loop control loop;

[0045] Figure 2 is a flow chart of a conflict resolution method for a closed-loop control loop provided by the present application;

[0046] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the target layer-by-layer distribution and target conflict layer-by-layer reporting provided by this application;

[0047] Figure 4 This is the overall process of conflict resolution of a closed-loop control loop in an application example provided by this application;

[0048] Figure 5 It is an interactive sequential logic for closed-loop control loop conflict resolution in an application example provided by this application;

[0049] Figure 6 It is a structural diagram of the closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution device provided in this application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0050] For ease of reference or clarity, the technical terms, abbreviations or nouns involved in this application are first explained as follows:

[0051] 5G: 5th Generation Mobile Communication Technology, the fifth generation of mobile communication technology;

[0052] 3GPP: 3rd Generation Partnership Project, the third generation partnership project;

[0053] SA: Service and System aspect, service and system aspect;

[0054] RAN: Radio Access Network, wireless access network;

[0055] KPI: Key Performance Indicator, key performance indicator;

[0056] QoS: Quality of Service, quality of service.

[0057] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present application to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present application. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present application, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments in the present application, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of this application.

[0058] 3GPP SA5 studies closed-loop control loops from the perspective of network management. Different closed-loop control loops exist in different management domains or network functions to support automated and autonomous networks. The embodiments of this application mainly provide conflict resolution solutions for closed-loop control loops for management domain application scenarios. Management domain is a logical concept mainly used for network management and monitoring, such as core network management domain, RAN management domain, etc.

[0059] See also Figure 1 The processing flow of the closed-loop control loop includes the steps of monitoring, analysis, decision-making and execution. The detailed processing involved in each step is as follows:

[0060] Monitoring: The system continuously monitors the status of network devices and traffic in the communication network, and collects performance indicators and log information;

[0061] Analysis: Analyze the collected performance indicators and log information to determine whether there are any anomalies (such as device / traffic anomalies) or performance degradation.

[0062] Decision-making: Based on the analysis results, decide whether to take action and what action to take to solve the problem or optimize the network in order to achieve or approach the control goal issued by the operator or other management party;

[0063] Execution: If action is required, the action plan containing relevant policies or commands is automatically executed to solve the problem or optimize the network. The results of the execution are monitored and analyzed again to form a closed loop to ensure that the problem is solved or performance is continuously optimized.

[0064] The purpose and result of a closed-loop control loop may affect other closed-loop control loops, thereby causing conflicts between closed-loop control loops. The applicant has found that the conflicts that may occur in a closed-loop control loop of network management are usually distributed in the following two stages of the closed-loop control loop:

[0065] Phase 1: Phase 1 is the target (control target of the closed-loop control loop) conflict, which occurs before the closed-loop control loop is executed. In order to ensure end-to-end closed-loop control loop management, operators will set multiple closed-loop targets for different management domains. The closed-loop control loop in the same management domain will also have multiple closed-loop targets. The multi-target configuration may succeed or fail in some management domains. There is often a conflict between the new closed-loop control target and the existing closed-loop control target being executed.

[0066] The second stage: The second stage is the conflict of execution plans, which occurs before the "execution" step in the execution of the closed-loop control loop. When there are multiple closed-loop control loops in the management domain, the execution plans of multiple closed-loop control loops may cause conflicts.

[0067] The conflict problem of closed-loop control loops will have an adverse impact on network management. To solve this problem, the embodiment of the present application provides a closed-loop control loop conflict resolution method and related devices. The provided closed-loop control loop conflict resolution method and related devices mainly target the above two stages, perform conflict detection on the closed-loop control loop and provide corresponding solutions.

[0068] See also Figure 2 As shown in the method flow chart, the conflict resolution method of the closed-loop control loop provided by the embodiment of the present application includes at least the following processing steps:

[0069] Step 201: Obtain a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture.

[0070] In order to ensure end-to-end closed-loop control loop management, operators and other management parties will issue global control objectives for the closed-loop control loops in the communication service architecture to the communication service architecture, including but not limited to target values ​​for network latency, throughput, interference, etc., so as to achieve multi-closed-loop control target configuration for different management domains of the communication service architecture.

[0071] The communication service architecture includes multiple layers, which are divided into the communication service layer, network slice layer, network slice subnet layer and network element layer from top to bottom. Different layers are correspondingly provided with different management units. For the above four layers, the communication service management unit, network slice management unit, network slice subnet management unit and network element management unit are provided in sequence. Each management unit of the same layer constitutes the corresponding management domain.

[0072] Among them, the communication service management unit is used to manage one or more services implemented by multiple network elements. It can be oriented to the services and services of operators, and provide functions and services such as billing, settlement, accounting, customer service, business, and network monitoring. The communication service management unit can be oriented to operators or to vertical industries. The network slice management unit is responsible for network lifecycle management, network deployment, network fault management, network performance management, network configuration management, network assurance, and network optimization functions. The network slice subnet management unit is responsible for the lifecycle management of network slice subnets, slice subnet performance management, slice subnet fault management, and slice subnet optimization management. The network element management unit is responsible for network element lifecycle management, network element performance management, network element fault management, and network optimization management.

[0073] After receiving the global control target sent down, the communication service architecture can decompose the received global control target level by level according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture to obtain the control targets corresponding to the closed-loop control loops to be executed by the management units at each level.

[0074] Among them, the received global control target is first decomposed into the closed-loop control loop target of the communication service management unit, and then decomposed into the closed-loop control loop target of the network slice management unit according to the closed-loop control loop target of the communication service management unit, and decomposed into the control loop target of the network slice subnet management unit according to the closed-loop control loop target of the network slice management unit, and decomposed into the closed-loop control loop target of the network element management unit according to the control loop target of the network slice subnet management unit, so that the management units at each layer of the communication service architecture can respectively obtain the control targets corresponding to their respective closed-loop control loops.

[0075] Optionally, the method provided in the embodiment of the present application can be applied to the management units in each layer of the communication service architecture, that is, the management units in each layer of the communication service architecture can be used as the executors of the method in the embodiment of the present application, which are respectively responsible for conflict detection of the closed-loop control loops to be executed.

[0076] In this step 201, the current management unit can be a management unit of any layer in the communication service architecture (that is, the execution subject of the method of the embodiment of the present application), depending on the actual application situation. In this step 201, the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop to be executed by the current management unit in the communication service architecture is obtained, which can be implemented as follows: obtaining the control target corresponding to the current layer obtained by decomposing the global control target step by step according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture as the first control target.

[0077] The current layer is the layer where the current management unit is located.

[0078] Step 202: Detect whether the first control target conflicts with the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain.

[0079] After obtaining the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop to be executed by the current management unit, the current management unit may perform a feasibility check on the first control target to identify whether there is a conflict between the first control target and the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located, including but not limited to identifying whether there is a parameter conflict (different target values ​​for the same parameter) or an indirect conflict (that is, the values ​​of multiple different targets such as different indicators cannot be met at the same time).

[0080] For the multiple layers included in the communication service architecture, the feasibility check can be performed on the decomposed targets (i.e., the closed-loop control loop targets corresponding to each layer) layer by layer in the management unit of each layer to identify whether there is a target conflict between the closed-loop control loop to be executed by the management unit of each layer and other closed-loop control loops in the management domain to which it belongs.

[0081] Step 203: If there is a conflict, perform a first conflict processing to at least update the first control target, and execute the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan that matches the updated first control target.

[0082] Optionally, the first conflict processing may be implemented as: reporting corresponding conflict loop information to a management party, so that the management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict loop information.

[0083] The corresponding second closed-loop control loop here is a second closed-loop control loop whose corresponding second control target conflicts with the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop.

[0084] The conflict loop information is used to at least indicate a control target value that conflicts between the first closed-loop control loop, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop.

[0085] Optionally, the conflict loop information includes the position information corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, the conflicting control target value between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and the conflict reason. The management party may specifically modify or create a new conflicting control target value between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict reason in the reported conflict loop information.

[0086] The management party may be, but is not limited to, an operator, a management personnel, or a host computer or software for providing management functions.

[0087] There are two ways to report conflict loop information (referred to as "conflict reporting"): step-by-step reporting and direct reporting. During implementation, one of the two ways can be selected for conflict reporting according to needs.

[0088] Among them, the step-by-step reporting method refers to reporting the conflict loop information layer by layer in the communication service architecture in a bottom-up order until it is reported to the communication service management unit of the communication service layer, and then the communication service management unit of the communication service layer reports the conflict loop information to the management party, such as reporting to the operator. Taking the current layer where the current management unit is located as the network element management layer as an example, the conflict loop information can be reported from the network element management layer to the network slice subnet layer, and then from the network slice subnet layer to the network slice management layer, and from the network slice management layer to the communication service management layer, and then from the communication service management layer to the operator. Refer to Figure 3 , provides a schematic diagram of reporting conflict loop information to operators in a step-by-step reporting manner, Figure 3 At the same time, the schematic logic of decomposing and issuing the issued global control target layer by layer in the communication service architecture is shown.

[0089] The direct reporting method means that the four single layers in the communication service architecture can directly report the conflict loop information of their respective layers to the operator.

[0090] The conflict causes in the conflict loop information include, but are not limited to, parameter conflicts (such as conflicts between KPI thresholds), indirect conflicts (such as conflicts between the goals of improving energy efficiency and resource power optimization, etc.).

[0091] Operators and other management parties can select corresponding solutions based on the reported conflict loop information, change or create new target values, such as changing or creating a new control target value that conflicts between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, so as to avoid target conflicts between closed-loop control loops.

[0092] The following provides an exemplary solution for parameter conflicts and indirect conflicts:

[0093] 1) Parameter conflict

[0094] Optionally, for parameter conflicts, a new target value of the conflicting parameter may be determined by, but not limited to, a compromise / average or weighted average method, and the target value of the conflicting parameter is updated to the compromise / average or weighted average value. An embodiment may be: the target 1 of the first closed-loop control loop is the delay T <t 1 , the target 2 of the second closed-loop control loop is the delay T <t 2 , then the compromise method is to update the target value of the delay T of the two loops to T<(t 1 +t 2 ) / 2.

[0095] 2) Indirect conflict

[0096] For indirect conflicts, if there are multiple targets that cannot be met at the same time, such as the indirect conflict indicators target_1 and target_2, assuming that the targets of target_1 and target_2 (such as target_1=:throughput>threshold_1 and target_2=:interference<threshold_2) cannot be met at the same time, the common factors of different indicators can be determined, the common factors required by them can be extracted, and the values ​​of the common factors can be compromised / averaged or weighted averaged. The target values ​​of different indicators are determined based on the values ​​after compromise / average or weighted average of the common factors, such as averaging the values ​​of the common factors required by target_1 and target_2, and determining the target values ​​of target_1 and target_2 based on the values ​​of the common factors after the average.

[0097] After the operator or other management party completes the target update, the updated target is issued so that the closed-loop control loop is executed based on the updated target. More specifically, after the operator or other management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, the updated first control target and the second control target are issued to the corresponding management unit in the communication service architecture according to the corresponding position information of the first closed-loop control loop and the position information of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, respectively. On this basis, the corresponding management unit executes the corresponding closed-loop control loop based on the updated control target.

[0098] For the current management unit, the current management unit may specifically execute the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan that matches the updated first control target.

[0099] The first step here may specifically include monitoring, analysis and decision-making steps in a first closed-loop control loop.

[0100] Executing the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target may be further implemented as follows:

[0101] 1) Execute the monitoring step and the analyzing step in the first closed-loop control loop to monitor the status of the network equipment and traffic of the communication network based on the monitoring step to obtain network status monitoring information, and analyze the network status monitoring information based on the analyzing step to obtain a network status analysis result.

[0102] Network status monitoring information may include, but is not limited to, performance indicators and log information of network devices in the communication network, as well as traffic indicators and related logs, etc. By monitoring the status of network devices and traffic, performance indicators and other indicator data and related log information are collected.

[0103] Afterwards, the collected network status monitoring information can be further analyzed to determine whether there are any anomalies (traffic anomalies, equipment anomalies, etc.) or performance degradation, thereby obtaining network status analysis results.

[0104] 2) Execute the decision-making steps in the first closed-loop control loop according to the network status analysis result and the updated first control target, so as to obtain the first action plan based on the decision-making steps.

[0105] After obtaining the network status analysis result by executing the monitoring step and the analysis step in the first closed-loop control loop, further based on the current network status analysis result (such as whether there is anomaly or performance degradation, etc.) and the updated first control target, the subsequent steps of the monitoring step and the analysis step in the first closed-loop control loop are executed, that is, the decision step is executed to determine the first action plan that matches the updated first control target through the decision step, and the first action plan aims to make the network status reach or approach the first control target to optimize the network.

[0106] It is easy to understand that for the management units at each layer in the communication service architecture, if there is no target conflict between the closed-loop control loop to be executed and other closed-loop control loops in the management domain, the monitoring, analysis and decision-making steps in the closed-loop control loop can be directly executed based on its closed-loop control loop target (different from the updated control target).

[0107] Step 204: Detect whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of the second closed-loop control loops in the management domain.

[0108] After obtaining the first action plan, before executing the first action plan, the current management unit first detects whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain.

[0109] Action plan conflicts may include, but are not limited to, situations where different action plans cannot be executed simultaneously, or are not suitable for being executed simultaneously (for example, if they are executed simultaneously, it will affect the customer's service experience).

[0110] Step 205: If there is a conflict, perform a second conflict processing to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, trigger a second step in the first closed-loop control loop, wherein the second step is used to execute the action plan.

[0111] If an action plan conflict is detected, a second conflict handling is performed. Optionally, the second conflict handling includes a coordination handling of the conflict. The coordination handling of the conflict may include feeding back the detection result of the action plan conflict to an operator, and the operator requests a conflict coordination strategy for resolving the conflict, but is not limited thereto, and the conflict coordination strategy may also be automatically determined by the corresponding management unit.

[0112] The detection result of the action plan conflict includes, but is not limited to, the location information of each closed-loop control loop where the action plan conflict exists in the communication service architecture, and indication information for indicating the action plan conflict.

[0113] An optional specific implementation method for conflict coordination processing is provided below. In this implementation method, it is first determined whether the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop in which the corresponding action plan conflicts have the same upper-level closed-loop control loop. On this basis, if it is determined that the same upper-level closed-loop control loop exists, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined based on the first strategy. If not, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined based on the second strategy.

[0114] The execution timing of the action plan may be a specific time when the action plan is to be executed.

[0115] Determining the execution time of the first action plan based on the first strategy can be further implemented as: triggering the upper-level management unit to determine the execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on business needs; and determining the execution time of the first action plan based on the execution order. The upper-level management unit is the management unit corresponding to the same upper-level closed-loop control loop.

[0116] In this case, the superior management unit may determine the execution order of the conflicting action plans based on business needs, and avoid executing the conflicting action plans at the same time by determining the execution order of the conflicting action plans, thereby avoiding conflicts in the execution of these action plans.

[0117] For example, suppose there are three closed-loop control loops: a closed-loop control loop for managing energy saving in the RAN domain, a closed-loop control loop for QoS optimization, and a closed-loop control loop for energy efficiency optimization, wherein the first closed-loop control loop is an upper-level closed-loop control loop, and the remaining two closed-loop control loops are lower-level closed-loop control loops of the upper-level closed-loop control loop, and the management units corresponding to the three closed-loop control loops are also upper-lower-higher ...

[0118] Determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy can be further implemented as follows: determining the execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the priorities corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop respectively; determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the execution order.

[0119] In this case, the priorities of different closed-loop control loops can be determined in advance based on business needs. The execution order of conflicting action plans is then determined based on the priorities of the closed-loop control loops, and then the execution timing of the conflicting action plans is determined based on the corresponding execution order, so as to avoid action plan conflicts between closed-loop control loops.

[0120] After determining the execution timing of the first action plan, the second step in the first closed-loop control loop can be triggered when the execution timing is reached.

[0121] The second step is used to execute the action plan, which may be specifically the "execution" step among the steps of monitoring, analysis, decision-making and execution included in the closed-loop control loop. Through the "execution" step, the implementation of the first action plan is achieved.

[0122] It is easy to understand that if there is no action plan conflict, the action plan of the first closed-loop control loop can be directly executed without executing the second conflict processing.

[0123] The same is true for the management units in each layer of the communication service architecture. Before executing the action plan of its closed-loop control loop, the management units at each layer first perform conflict detection on the action plan. Once a conflict is detected, the second conflict processing is performed to determine the execution timing of the action plan of its closed-loop control loop, and when the corresponding execution timing is reached, the "execution" step in its closed-loop control loop is triggered to implement its action plan.

[0124] Subsequently, the results of the first action plan will be monitored and analyzed again to form a closed loop. Similarly, the closed-loop control loops of each layer in the communication service architecture, after the corresponding action plan is executed, the execution results will be monitored and analyzed again to form a closed loop to ensure that communication network problems (such as anomalies, performance degradation, etc.) are resolved or performance is continuously optimized.

[0125] According to the above scheme, the conflict resolution method for closed-loop control loops provided by the present application is to detect whether there is a conflict between the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop and the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain before the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit is executed, and in the case of a conflict, update the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop by executing the first conflict processing, so as to effectively avoid the target (control target) conflict between the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit and other closed-loop control loops in the management domain; before the first action plan of the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit is executed, detect whether there is a conflict between the first action plan and the second action plan of the second closed-loop control loop in the management domain, and in the case of a conflict, determine the execution timing of the first action plan by executing the second conflict processing, and execute the first action plan based on the execution timing, so as to avoid the action plan conflict between the first closed-loop control loop of the current management unit and other closed-loop control loops in the management domain, so that the present application solves the conflict problem of closed-loop control loops and avoids the adverse effects of the conflict problem of closed-loop control loops on network management.

[0126] An application example of the present application method is provided below.

[0127] In this example, conflict resolution for the closed-loop control loop includes target conflict resolution in the first stage and execution plan conflict resolution in the second stage, wherein the target conflict resolution in the first stage involves feasibility check of target conflict, conflict reporting method and conflict resolution method, and the execution plan conflict resolution in the second stage involves feasibility check of execution plan and conflict coordination method.

[0128] See also Figure 4 The overall conflict resolution process of the closed-loop control loop in this example is shown, and Figure 5 The interactive timing logic of conflict resolution is shown. In this example, the conflict resolution process for the closed-loop control loop can be implemented as follows:

[0129] Step 1: The target of the closed-loop control loop is issued.

[0130] The target delivery here specifically refers to delivering the global control target of the closed-loop control loop to the communication service architecture.

[0131] Step 2: Decompose the issued target value layer by layer.

[0132] Specifically, the global control target issued can be decomposed layer by layer according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture to obtain the control target corresponding to the closed-loop control circuit of each layer management unit in the communication service architecture.

[0133] Step 3: Perform feasibility checks on the decomposed targets layer by layer to identify whether there are conflicts with the target values ​​of other closed-loop control loops in the current management domain.

[0134] Step 4: If there is a conflict, the operator will be fed back the information of the conflicting closed-loop control loop, which can be reported directly or layer by layer. If there is no conflict, the closed-loop control loop process will continue.

[0135] Step 5: The operator selects a corresponding solution based on the reported conflicting closed-loop control loop information, and changes or newly establishes the target value to avoid conflict with the target value of the closed-loop control loop being executed.

[0136] Step 6: After determining the target of the change, issue the target, execute the closed-loop control loop, and determine the optimized action plan.

[0137] Specifically, an action plan that matches the modified target (control target), ie, the optimized action plan, can be determined by executing the monitoring, analysis and decision-making steps in the closed-loop control loop.

[0138] Step 7: Each layer management unit will perform conflict detection on the action plan before executing the action plan. Once a conflict is detected, the detection result will be fed back to the operator, who will request a conflict coordination method.

[0139] Step 8: The conflicting management units perform conflict coordination.

[0140] Step 9: Manage the unit to execute the action plan.

[0141] Subsequently, the execution results will be monitored and analyzed again to form a closed loop to ensure that communication network problems (such as anomalies, performance degradation, etc.) are resolved or performance is continuously optimized.

[0142] This example avoids the goal conflict and action plan conflict between closed-loop control loops by performing goal conflict resolution in the first phase and execution plan conflict resolution in the second phase, thereby resolving the conflict problem of the closed-loop control loop and avoiding the adverse effects of the conflict problem of the closed-loop control loop on network management.

[0143] Corresponding to the above method, the embodiment of the present application also provides a closed-loop control loop conflict resolution device, see Figure 6 The schematic diagram of the composition structure of the device comprises:

[0144] An acquisition module 601 is used to acquire a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture;

[0145] A first detection module 602 is used to detect whether the first control target conflicts with the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0146] A first processing module 603 is used to perform a first conflict processing to update at least the first control target if there is a conflict, and to perform a first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan matching the updated first control target;

[0147] A second detection module 604 is used to detect whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain;

[0148] The second processing module 605 is used to perform a second conflict processing if there is a conflict, so as to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, trigger the second step in the first closed-loop control loop, wherein the second step is used to execute the action plan.

[0149] In an optional implementation, the communication service architecture includes multiple layers, different layers are correspondingly provided with different management units, and each management unit of the same layer constitutes a corresponding management domain;

[0150] The acquisition module 601 is specifically used to: acquire a control target corresponding to the current layer obtained by decomposing the global control target level by level according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture as the first control target;

[0151] The current layer is the layer where the current management unit is located, and the global control target is the control target of the closed-loop control loop in the communication service architecture currently issued to the communication service architecture.

[0152] In an optional implementation manner, the first processing module 603, when performing the first conflict processing to at least update the first control target, is specifically configured to:

[0153] Reporting corresponding conflict loop information to a management party, so that the management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict loop information;

[0154] Among them, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop is a second closed-loop control loop whose corresponding second control target conflicts with the first control target; the conflicting loop information is at least used to indicate the control target value that conflicts between the first closed-loop control loop, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop.

[0155] In an optional implementation manner, the conflict loop information includes: position information corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, respectively, a control target value and a conflicting cause between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop;

[0156] When the management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict loop information, it is specifically used to: based on the conflict cause, modify or create a control target value that conflicts between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop.

[0157] In an optional implementation manner, the first processing module 603, when executing the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain the first action plan matching the updated first control target, is specifically configured to:

[0158] Executing the monitoring step and the analyzing step in the first closed-loop control loop, so as to monitor the status of the network equipment and traffic of the communication network based on the monitoring step to obtain network status monitoring information, and analyzing the network status monitoring information based on the analyzing step to obtain a network status analysis result;

[0159] According to the network status analysis result and the updated first control target, a decision step in the first closed-loop control loop is executed to obtain the first action plan based on the decision step.

[0160] In an optional implementation manner, the second processing module 605, when performing the second conflict processing to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, is specifically configured to:

[0161] Determine whether the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, whose corresponding action plans are in conflict, have the same upper-level closed-loop control loop;

[0162] If so, determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy;

[0163] If not, determine the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy.

[0164] In an optional implementation manner, the second processing module 605, when determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy, is specifically configured to:

[0165] Triggering an upper-level management unit to determine the execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on business requirements; the upper-level management unit is the management unit corresponding to the same upper-level closed-loop control loop;

[0166] Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

[0167] In an optional implementation manner, the second processing module 605, when determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy, is specifically configured to:

[0168] determining an execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the priorities respectively corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop;

[0169] Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

[0170] As for the conflict resolution device for the closed-loop control loop disclosed in the embodiment of the present application, since it corresponds to the conflict resolution method for the closed-loop control loop disclosed in the above method embodiment, the description is relatively simple. For relevant similarities, please refer to the description of the above method embodiments, which will not be described in detail here.

[0171] In addition, the present application also provides a computer-readable medium having a computer program stored thereon, wherein the computer program includes a program code for executing a conflict resolution method for a closed-loop control loop as disclosed in any of the above method embodiments.

[0172] In the context of the present application, a computer readable medium (machine readable medium) may be a tangible medium that may contain or store a program for use by or in conjunction with an instruction execution system, device, or equipment. A machine readable medium may be a machine readable signal medium or a machine readable storage medium. A machine readable medium may include, but is not limited to, an electronic, magnetic, optical, electromagnetic, infrared, or semiconductor system, device, or device, or any suitable combination of the foregoing. A more specific example of a machine readable storage medium may include an electrical connection based on one or more lines, a portable computer disk, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), an optical fiber, a portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), an optical storage device, a magnetic storage device, or any suitable combination of the foregoing.

[0173] It should be noted that the various embodiments in this specification are described in a progressive manner, and each embodiment focuses on the differences from other embodiments. The same or similar parts between the various embodiments can be referenced to each other.

[0174] For the convenience of description, the above system or device is described by dividing it into various modules or units according to its functions. Of course, when implementing the present application, the functions of each unit can be implemented in the same or multiple software and / or hardware.

[0175] It can be known from the description of the above implementation methods that those skilled in the art can clearly understand that the present application can be implemented by means of software plus a necessary general hardware platform. Based on such an understanding, the technical solution of the present application can be essentially or partly contributed to the prior art in the form of a software product, which can be stored in a storage medium such as ROM / RAM, a magnetic disk, an optical disk, etc., and includes several instructions for enabling a computer device (which can be a personal computer, a server, or a network device, etc.) to execute the methods described in the various embodiments of the present application or certain parts of the embodiments.

[0176] Finally, it should be noted that, in this article, relational terms such as first, second, third and target are only used to distinguish one entity or operation from another entity or operation, and do not necessarily require or imply any such actual relationship or order between these entities or operations. Moreover, the terms "include", "comprise" or any other variants thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusion, so that a process, method, article or device including a series of elements includes not only those elements, but also other elements not explicitly listed, or also includes elements inherent to such process, method, article or device. In the absence of further restrictions, the elements defined by the statement "comprise a ..." do not exclude the existence of other identical elements in the process, method, article or device including the elements.

[0177] The above is only a preferred implementation of the present application. It should be pointed out that for ordinary technicians in this technical field, several improvements and modifications can be made without departing from the principles of the present application. These improvements and modifications should also be regarded as the scope of protection of the present application.

Claims

1. A method for solving a conflict in a closed-loop control loop, characterized in that: include: Acquire a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture; Detecting whether the first control target conflicts with the second control targets of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain; If there is a conflict, performing a first conflict processing to update at least the first control target, and performing a first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan that matches the updated first control target; Detecting whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain; If there is a conflict, a second conflict processing is performed to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, a second step in the first closed-loop control loop is triggered, and the second step is used to execute the action plan.

2. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The communication service architecture includes multiple layers, different layers are correspondingly provided with different management units, and each management unit of the same layer constitutes a corresponding management domain; The obtaining of the first control target of the first closed-loop control loop to be executed by the current management unit in the communication service architecture includes: Acquire a control target corresponding to the current layer obtained by decomposing the global control target level by level according to the layer structure of the communication service architecture as the first control target; The current layer is the layer where the current management unit is located, and the global control target is the control target of the closed-loop control loop in the communication service architecture currently issued to the communication service architecture.

3. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The performing of the first conflict processing to at least update the first control target includes: Reporting corresponding conflict loop information to a management party, so that the management party updates the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict loop information; Among them, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop is a second closed-loop control loop whose corresponding second control target conflicts with the first control target; the conflicting loop information is at least used to indicate the control target value that conflicts between the first closed-loop control loop, the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, and the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop.

4. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 3, characterized in that: The conflict loop information includes: position information corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, respectively, a control target value and a conflicting reason between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop; The updating of the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop by the management party based on the conflict loop information includes: The management party may modify or create a new control target value that conflicts between the first control target and the second control target of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the conflict cause.

5. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step of executing the first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan matching the updated first control target includes: Executing the monitoring step and the analyzing step in the first closed-loop control loop, so as to monitor the status of the network equipment and traffic of the communication network based on the monitoring step to obtain network status monitoring information, and analyzing the network status monitoring information based on the analyzing step to obtain a network status analysis result; According to the network status analysis result and the updated first control target, a decision step in the first closed-loop control loop is executed to obtain the first action plan based on the decision step.

6. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The performing of the second conflict processing to determine the execution timing of the first action plan includes: Determine whether the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop, whose corresponding action plans are in conflict, have the same upper-level closed-loop control loop; If so, determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy; If not, determine the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy.

7. The closed-loop control circuit conflict resolution method according to claim 6, characterized in that: The determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the first strategy includes: Triggering an upper-level management unit to determine the execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on business requirements; the upper-level management unit is the management unit corresponding to the same upper-level closed-loop control loop; Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

8. The method for solving the conflict of the closed-loop control circuit according to claim 6, characterized in that: The determining the execution timing of the first action plan based on the second strategy includes: determining an execution order between the first action plan and the second action plan of the corresponding second closed-loop control loop based on the priorities respectively corresponding to the first closed-loop control loop and the corresponding second closed-loop control loop; Based on the execution order, the execution timing of the first action plan is determined.

9. A conflict resolution device for a closed-loop control circuit, characterized in that: include: An acquisition module, used for acquiring a first control target of a first closed-loop control loop to be executed by a current management unit in a communication service architecture; A first detection module, used to detect whether the first control target conflicts with the second control target of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain where the current management unit is located; the each second closed-loop control loop includes a closed-loop control loop other than the first closed-loop control loop in the management domain; A first processing module, configured to, if there is a conflict, perform a first conflict processing to at least update the first control target, and perform a first step in the first closed-loop control loop based on the updated first control target to obtain a first action plan matching the updated first control target; A second detection module, used to detect whether the first action plan conflicts with the second action plans of each second closed-loop control loop in the management domain; The second processing module is used to perform a second conflict processing if there is a conflict to determine the execution timing of the first action plan, and based on the execution timing, trigger a second step in the first closed-loop control loop, wherein the second step is used to execute the action plan.

10. A computer readable medium having a computer program stored thereon, characterized in that: When the computer program is executed by a processor, it can be used to implement the conflict resolution method of the closed-loop control loop as described in any one of claims 1-8.