Substation system anti-seismic vulnerability evaluation method based on success flow model
Through successful flow model and Monte Carlo simulation combined with expert experience, the seismic vulnerability of the substation system is evaluated, and the problem of ignoring the impact of the secondary system in the existing technology is solved, and more accurate seismic evaluation is provided, which improves the seismic resistance of the substation. and the safety of the power system.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311866227.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-12-28
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology ignores the impact of secondary systems on system functions when evaluating the seismic resistance of substations, and the damage to system functions of building collapse under earthquake conditions has not been fully considered, resulting in high vulnerability in earthquakes and difficult to repair. , affects the safe and reliable operation of the power system.
The seismic vulnerability evaluation method of substation system based on the successful flow model is adopted. By defining functional evaluation indicators, a successful flow model of substation system is established, combined with the seismic vulnerability curve at the equipment level, and the secondary system and cognitive uncertainty are considered. Divide the deterministic and uncertainty subsystems, perform Monte Carlo simulation and optimization solutions, draw the seismic vulnerability curve of the system, and evaluate the seismic resistance of the substation.
Comprehensively evaluate the seismic resistance of the substation system, consider the uncertainty of secondary systems and seismic vulnerability data, provide more accurate vulnerability assessment results, help improve the seismic resistance of the substation and reduce the risk of earthquake damage.
Smart Images

Figure CN119047897A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of seismic vulnerability assessment of power systems, and in particular to a substation vulnerability assessment method based on a success flow model and taking into account secondary systems and cognitive uncertainties. Technical Background
[0002] Substations are complex systems composed of a series of electrical equipment, including transformers, circuit breakers, disconnectors, voltage transformers, current transformers, etc. The power system is widely distributed, and earthquake disasters frequently occur in some parts of my country, which inevitably threaten the safe and reliable operation of the power system. Substations, as important places for power conversion and transmission in power systems, are an indispensable part of the power transmission and distribution network. In recent years, the experience of power system earthquake damage at home and abroad has shown that substations are highly vulnerable to earthquakes, and their earthquake resistance issues deserve attention.
[0003] However, it is difficult to repair a damaged substation, and the inability to restore power transmission for a long time has a serious negative impact on social functions and economic development. Therefore, it is particularly important to analyze the earthquake resistance of substations and improve their earthquake resistance.
[0004] At present, the research on substation seismic resilience is still focused on the electrical equipment level. The research on the system level simplifies the conditions too much and ignores the impact of the substation secondary system on the system function. The damage to the system function caused by the collapse of buildings under earthquake conditions is also worthy of attention. Summary of the invention
[0005] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to comprehensively evaluate the earthquake risk of the substation system and provide a method for evaluating the seismic vulnerability of the substation system based on the success flow model. The present invention first defines the functional evaluation index of the substation system, establishes the success flow model of the substation system according to the layout of each electrical equipment and core building in the primary system and secondary system of the substation system, the functional logic relationship and the necessary operating conditions, and performs system analysis in combination with the seismic vulnerability curve at the equipment level, thereby realizing the seismic vulnerability evaluation of the substation system.
[0006] The technical solution adopted by the present invention is:
[0007] A method for assessing the seismic vulnerability of a substation system based on a success flow model is implemented in the following steps:
[0008] Step 1: Define the evaluation index of the substation system residual function as the sum of the residual transmission capacity of each branch after the earthquake;
[0009] Step 2: Comprehensively consider the primary and secondary systems of the substation, and establish a successful flow model of the substation system according to the layout of various electrical equipment and core buildings in the substation, functional logical relationships and necessary operating conditions;
[0010] Step 3: Determine the seismic vulnerability parameters of each electrical equipment in the primary system of the substation;
[0011] Step 4: For electrical equipment and core buildings whose seismic vulnerability parameters cannot be determined, consider the problem of epistemic uncertainty and use the expert experience method to give their seismic failure probability interval;
[0012] Step 5: Based on whether to use the seismic failure probability, the system is divided into a deterministic subsystem and an uncertain subsystem, where the uncertain subsystem uses the seismic failure probability interval;
[0013] Step 6: Determine the earthquake parameters and experimental range for the experiment;
[0014] Step 7: For the deterministic subsystem, start the Monte Carlo simulation cycle, and judge the equipment status by comparing the generated random number with its failure probability and record it;
[0015] Step 8: For the uncertain subsystem, use the optimization method to find the upper and lower boundaries of the system failure probability interval when the constraints are each failure probability interval;
[0016] Step 9: Multiply the failure probability of the uncertain subsystem under a certain earthquake condition by the failure probability of the certain subsystem to obtain the failure probability of the substation system under a certain earthquake condition, and these probability points form the seismic vulnerability curve of the system;
[0017] Step 10: Repeat the above simulation experiment n times for each value of earthquake condition, record the system status and end the experiment;
[0018] Step 11: Record the probability of each line remaining state, calculate the cumulative probability of each state, define substation function indicators, and evaluate substation vulnerability;
[0019] Furthermore, in the step 2, when establishing the model, it is assumed that each device in the substation has only two states, namely normal and failure, and the problem of wire damage and common cause failure of the equipment is not considered.
[0020] Furthermore, the functional relationship between the failure probability of each electrical device for determining the seismic vulnerability parameter in step 3 and the ground motion intensity characterization parameter (PGA) is assumed to obey the log-normal cumulative distribution of formula 1: Where Ls represents the limit state, μ is the median, and β is the logarithmic standard deviation.
[0021] Furthermore, for the electrical equipment and core buildings whose seismic vulnerability parameters cannot be determined in step 4, the failure probability interval under earthquake is given using expert experience, taking into account the cognitive uncertainty problem.
[0022] Furthermore, in step six, in each simulation experiment, the evaluation of the state of the deterministic subsystem is divided into two stages: first, the failure probability under a certain PGA is obtained through the fragility curve determined by formula 1, and the size is compared with the positive random number within 1 to determine the device state; secondly, the state of the loop in which each device is located is judged by the state of each device, and the loop state and the device state together constitute the state of the deterministic subsystem.
[0023] Furthermore, in step eight, in the simulation experiment cycle, the failure probability of the non-deterministic subsystem is a probability interval contained in the boundary obtained by the probability interval given by the experience of each expert. The specific method is to solve the optimization problem: Constraints: P1∈[a,b] (2) P2∈[A,B] (3) Objective function: Max f max =f1f2...f n (4) Min f min =f1f2...f n (5) Among them, P i represents the failure probability of equipment i given by expert experience, a and b represent the minimum and maximum values of the failure probability interval respectively, and f i Represents a probability value that equipment i takes within its failure probability interval.
[0024] Compared with the prior art, the advantages of the present invention are: taking into account the influence of the substation secondary system on the seismic resistance of the entire station, taking into account the cognitive uncertainty of earthquake vulnerability data, establishing a success flow model of the substation system according to the layout of each electrical equipment and core building in the substation system, functional logical relationship and necessary operating conditions, defining the system transmission power indicators, and realizing the earthquake vulnerability assessment of the substation system. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0025] Figure 1 It is a flow chart of a method for assessing seismic vulnerability of a substation system based on a success flow model proposed by the present invention;
[0026] Figure 2 is a schematic diagram of a typical substation system in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0027] Figure 3 is a success flow model corresponding to a typical substation system in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0028] Figure 4 This is the result of the vulnerability assessment experiment of the substation system of the present invention. Specific implementation methods
[0029] The technical solutions in the present invention are described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0030] See also Figure 1 , Figure 1 The present invention shows a method for assessing the seismic vulnerability of a substation system based on a success flow model, which includes the following steps:
[0031] Step 1: Figure 2 The figure shows a schematic diagram of a typical substation system according to an embodiment of the present invention. The system is divided into seven parts according to the functions, including: 6 groups of 220kV incoming line units, 2 groups of 220kV busbar units, 3 groups of transformer units, 2 groups of 110kV busbar units, 12 groups of 110kV outgoing line units, station power supply system and control and communication system. The primary system includes incoming line unit, outgoing line unit, transformer unit and busbar unit. The secondary system includes station power supply system and control and communication system, which correspond to 10kv power distribution device room and main control communication room respectively.
[0032] The evaluation index of the substation system residual function is defined as the sum of the residual transmission capacity of each branch after the earthquake. Assuming that the system is operating normally, each branch can output the same amount of power. When a branch is interrupted, its output capacity becomes 0.
[0033] Step 2: Establish a successful flow model of the substation system based on the layout of the electrical equipment and core buildings in the substation, the functional logic relationship and the necessary operating conditions, such as Figure 3 shown.
[0034] Step 3: The functional relationship between the failure probability of each electrical equipment and the ground motion intensity characterization parameter (PGA) that can determine the seismic vulnerability parameters is assumed to obey the log-normal cumulative distribution of formula 1: Where Ls represents the limit state, μ is the median, and β is the logarithmic standard deviation.
[0035] The values of the seismic vulnerability curve parameters of each equipment in the substation are shown in Table 1: Table 1 Equipment seismic vulnerability curve parameters
[0036] Step 4: For electrical equipment and core buildings whose seismic vulnerability parameters cannot be determined, consider the problem of cognitive uncertainty and use expert experience to give the failure probability interval under earthquake. The failure probability interval of the main control room and the distribution room is shown in Formula 6:
[0037] Step 5: Determine the ground motion condition parameters. The peak acceleration (PGA) of the ground motion ranges from 0.2 to 1 g, with a calculation step of 0.04 g, where g is the acceleration due to gravity.
[0038] Step 6: Start the simulation cycle of the substation system seismic vulnerability analysis, obtain the failure probability of the deterministic subsystem and the non-deterministic subsystem respectively, multiply them to get the failure probability of the system, and draw the system vulnerability curve. The vulnerability curve obtained in this experiment has a certain width, which describes the error caused by the uncertainty of the cognition of the seismic vulnerability of electrical equipment. Compared with the curve without width, the experimental results are more in line with the general cognition. Secondly, through the analysis of the vulnerability curve obtained by the experiment, it can be seen that under the conditions of this experiment, the substation begins to rise rapidly under the condition of PGA greater than 0.4, and the seismic protection of the substation that may be located in this PGA earthquake condition should be focused on.
[0039] The above are only specific steps of the present invention and specific descriptions of feasible embodiments of the present invention, and do not constitute any limitation to the protection scope of the present invention; it can be extended to the field of seismic vulnerability assessment of converter station systems with other structural forms, and any technical solutions formed by equivalent transformation or equivalent replacement fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for assessing seismic vulnerability of a substation system based on a success flow model, characterized in that: The implementation steps are as follows: Step 1: Define the evaluation index of the substation system residual function as the sum of the residual transmission capacity of each branch after the earthquake; Step 2: Comprehensively consider the primary and secondary systems of the substation, and establish a success flow model of the substation system according to the layout of various electrical equipment and core buildings in the substation, functional logic relationships and necessary operating conditions; Step 3: Determine the seismic vulnerability parameters of each electrical equipment in the substation system; Step 4: For electrical equipment and core buildings whose seismic vulnerability parameters cannot be determined, consider the problem of epistemic uncertainty and use the expert experience method to give their seismic failure probability interval; Step 5: Based on whether to use the seismic failure probability, the system is divided into a deterministic subsystem and an uncertain subsystem, where the uncertain subsystem uses the seismic failure probability interval; Step 6: Determine the earthquake parameters and experimental range for the experiment; Step 7: For the deterministic subsystem, start the Monte Carlo method simulation cycle, and judge the equipment status by comparing the generated random number with its failure probability and record it; Step 8: For the uncertain subsystem, use the optimization method to find the upper and lower boundaries of the system failure probability interval when the constraints are each failure probability interval; Step 9: Multiply the failure probability of the uncertain subsystem under a certain earthquake condition with the failure probability of the certain subsystem to obtain the failure probability of the substation system under a certain earthquake condition, and these probability points form the seismic vulnerability curve of the system; Step 10: Repeat the above simulation experiment n times for each value of earthquake condition, record the system status and end the experiment; Step 11: Record the probability of each line retention state, calculate the cumulative probability of each state, define the substation function indicators, and evaluate the substation vulnerability.
2. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: It is assumed that each device in the substation has only two states, normal and failure, and the problems of wire damage and common cause failure of equipment are not considered.
3. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: The earthquake condition is expressed using Peak Ground Acceleration (PGA).
4. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: The functional relationship between the failure probability of each electrical device that can determine the seismic vulnerability parameter and the ground motion intensity characterization parameter (PGA) is assumed to obey the log-normal cumulative distribution of formula 1: Where Ls represents the limit state, μ is the median, and β is the logarithmic standard deviation.
5. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: For electrical equipment and core buildings whose seismic vulnerability parameters cannot be determined, the problem of cognitive uncertainty is considered and expert experience is used to give the failure probability range under earthquake.
6. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: In each simulation experiment, the evaluation of the state of the deterministic subsystem is divided into two stages: first, the failure probability under a certain PGA is obtained through the fragility curve determined by Formula 1, and the size is compared with the positive random number within 1 to determine the device state; secondly, the state of the loop in which each device is located is determined by the state of each device, and the loop state and the device state together constitute the state of the deterministic subsystem.
7. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the simulation experiment cycle, the ratio of the frequency of the deterministic subsystem being judged as failure to the number of repetitions n of the simulation experiment is used as the failure probability of the deterministic subsystem.
8. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: In the simulation experiment cycle, the failure probability of the non-deterministic subsystem is the probability interval contained in the boundary obtained by the probability interval given by the experience of each expert. The specific method is to solve the optimization problem: Constraints: P1∈[a,b] (2) P2∈[a,b] (3) Objective function: Max f max =f1f2...f n (4) Min f min =f1f2...f n (5) Among them, P i represents the failure probability of equipment i given by expert experience, a and b represent the minimum and maximum values of the failure probability interval respectively, and f i Represents a probability value that equipment i takes within its failure probability interval.
9. The method for seismic vulnerability assessment of a substation system based on a success flow model according to claim 1, characterized in that: The substation system vulnerability curve is determined to be a rising function with width and no time interval.
