Periodical group subject distribution characteristic analysis method
By constructing a discipline index system model and analyzing the discipline distribution characteristics of journal groups, the problem of being unable to dynamically analyze journal discipline changes in the existing technology is solved, and the interdisciplinary feature analysis of journal groups and the improvement of international influence is achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410847513.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-03
AI Technical Summary
The existing journal discipline distribution analysis method relies on a static journal-level classification system and cannot effectively reflect the dynamic changes and interdisciplinary characteristics of disciplines, resulting in the inability to accurately analyze the diversity, balance and knowledge fusion of journal disciplines.
By constructing a discipline index system model, including discipline richness index, concentration index, similarity index and difference index, combined with the discipline classification data of journal references, analyzing the integration of discipline types and knowledge, realizing dynamic analysis of the discipline distribution characteristics of journal groups .
It has realized the interdisciplinary characteristics of journals from different angles, reflect the diversity, balance and knowledge integration of disciplines, enhance the international influence and competitiveness of journal groups, and solves the problem that the characteristics of grade journals cannot be discovered in the existing technology.
Smart Images

Figure CN119066602A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of periodical group subject analysis, and in particular relates to a method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a periodical group. Background Art
[0002] The layout of scientific and technological journals is an important issue faced in the construction of scientific and technological journals. Reasonable layout of journal groups is conducive to improving the efficiency of academic resource utilization, promoting the rapid and orderly development of my country's journal groups to the maximum extent, improving the international influence of my country's journal groups, promoting the exchange and progress of scientific research, enhancing the country's international academic discourse power, and protecting the security of national academic resources. Discipline distribution is the most critical link in the layout of scientific and technological journals. The research on the discipline layout of journals relies on the discipline classification system. At present, the journal level classification system with journals as the classification object is mainly used in related research. With the continuous development of scientific research towards interdisciplinary and professional, and the continuous adjustment and change of the themes of scientific and technological journals, the limitations of the journal level classification system in the analysis of journal discipline layout are becoming increasingly prominent, which limits the analysis of journal discipline layout, especially in the study of journal discipline distribution and the analysis of journal characteristics.
[0003] The disciplinary distribution of journals is dynamically evolving. These journal hierarchical classification systems that rely on expert construction are often highly abstract and generalized versions of domain knowledge by experts. They are a relatively stable knowledge structure. Although they are more acceptable to managers, decision makers, and funders, the disciplinary classification system itself is usually updated slowly, and the adjustment and update of the correspondence between journals and disciplines is also slow. This is not suitable for the exploration of dynamic changes in journal disciplines.
[0004] Therefore, there is an urgent need for an analysis method for the disciplinary distribution characteristics of journal groups, and to establish an indicator system to reflect the interdisciplinary characteristics of typical journals at different levels from different perspectives: the disciplinary diversity, balance, and professionalism of academic journals can be reflected by the discipline type; the interdisciplinary knowledge integration and innovation characteristics of academic journals can be reflected by the relationship between disciplines, so as to realize the exploration of the dynamic changes of journal disciplines. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a method for analyzing the characteristics of the subject distribution of a journal group, which is characterized by comprising the following steps:
[0006] Step S1: Collecting subject classification data of references of each journal in the journal group based on the journal service platform;
[0007] Step S2: Based on the subject classification data in step S1, a subject indicator system model is constructed, wherein the subject indicator system model includes: a subject richness index, a subject concentration index, a subject similarity index, and a subject difference index;
[0008] Step S3: Based on the subject richness index and subject concentration index in step S2, a subject type analysis model is constructed; based on the subject similarity index and subject difference index in step S2, an inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model is constructed;
[0009] Step S4: Conduct empirical analysis based on the discipline type analysis model to analyze the diversity, balance, and professionalism of disciplines; conduct empirical analysis based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model to analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge fusion and knowledge innovation;
[0010] Step S5: Based on the empirical analysis results of the discipline type analysis model and the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, the discipline distribution characteristics of the journal group are analyzed.
[0011] The subject richness index is:
[0012] k=∑esS(1)
[0013] In the formula, k represents the total number of subject categories; i represents the literature belonging to subject S; S i Indicates the number of disciplines included in document i.
[0014] The subject concentration index includes: subject specialization and subject distribution balance;
[0015] The subject specializations are:
[0016]
[0017] Where P is the degree of subject expertise, P∈[0,1], f k The frequency of occurrence of the disciplines covered by the journal;
[0018] The balance of subject distribution is:
[0019]
[0020] In the formula, p i (x) is the probability distribution of different subjects; H(x) is the information entropy.
[0021] The subject similarity index is:
[0022]
[0023] Where, J0 is the subject similarity index, J0∈[0,1]; F m 、F n They represent the proportion of references belonging to the mth and nth disciplines in the journal respectively; cos(m, n) represents the cosine similarity of the two disciplines quantified by the co-occurrence pattern of the mth and nth disciplines.
[0024] The subject difference index is:
[0025]
[0026] In the formula, J c is the subject difference index, J c ∈[0,1]; F m 、F n They represent the proportion of references belonging to the mth and nth disciplines in the journal respectively; cos(m, n) represents the cosine similarity of the two disciplines quantified by the co-occurrence pattern of the mth and nth disciplines.
[0027] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:
[0028] According to the method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group disclosed in the present invention, subject classification data of references of each journal in the journal group are collected based on a journal service platform; a subject indicator system model is constructed, and the subject indicator system model includes: subject richness index, subject concentration index, subject similarity index and subject difference index; based on the subject richness index and subject concentration index, a subject type analysis model is constructed; based on the subject similarity index and subject difference index, an inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model is constructed; based on the subject type analysis model, an empirical analysis is performed to analyze the diversity, balance and professionalism of the disciplines; based on the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, an empirical analysis is performed to analyze the degree of fusion of subject knowledge and knowledge innovation; based on the empirical analysis results of the subject type analysis model and the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, the subject distribution characteristics analysis of the journal group is realized.
[0029] The index system reflects the interdisciplinary characteristics of typical journals at different levels from different perspectives: the disciplinary diversity, balance, and professionalism of academic journals are reflected by the discipline type, and the interdisciplinary knowledge integration and innovation characteristics of academic journals are reflected by the relationship between disciplines, thus realizing the exploration of the dynamic changes in journal disciplines.
[0030] In the analysis of journal characteristics, the international influence and competitiveness of the State Grid journal group are enhanced, and attention is paid to the two important characteristics of journal research topic overlap and journal influence. This solves the problem in the existing technology that when comparing the subject distribution of journals of different levels, it is impossible to find that journals with the same content quality classification have different characteristics from journals of other levels. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0031] Figure 1 The present invention is a flowchart of a method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] The present invention provides a method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group, which will be further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0033] like Figure 1 The embodiment of the present invention shown discloses a method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group, comprising:
[0034] Step S1: Collecting subject classification data of references of each journal in the journal group based on the journal service platform;
[0035] Step S2: Based on the subject classification data in step S1, a subject indicator system model is constructed, wherein the subject indicator system model includes: a subject richness index, a subject concentration index, a subject similarity index, and a subject difference index;
[0036] Step S3: Based on the subject richness index and subject concentration index in step S2, a subject type analysis model is constructed; based on the subject similarity index and subject difference index in step S2, an inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model is constructed;
[0037] Step S4: Conduct empirical analysis based on the discipline type analysis model to analyze the diversity, balance, and professionalism of disciplines; conduct empirical analysis based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model to analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge fusion and knowledge innovation;
[0038] Step S5: Based on the empirical analysis results of the discipline type analysis model and the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, the discipline distribution characteristics of the journal group are analyzed.
[0039] In a specific embodiment, the journal service platform uses the VIP Chinese journal service platform to obtain the subject classification data of the references of each journal in the journal group from the VIP Chinese journal service platform; establish an indicator system of four indicator disciplines, namely, the subject richness index, the subject concentration index, the subject similarity index and the subject difference index; conduct empirical analysis from the perspective of subject type, using the subject richness index and the subject concentration index, and from the perspective of inter-disciplinary knowledge integration, using the subject similarity index and the subject difference index; analyze the diversity, balance and professionalism of the subject with the subject richness index and the subject concentration index. The subject similarity index and the subject difference index analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge integration and knowledge innovation; and obtain the subject distribution characteristics of each journal in the journal group.
[0040] Each step is described in detail below in conjunction with embodiments.
[0041] Step S1: Collecting subject classification data of references of each journal in the journal group based on the journal service platform;
[0042] In this embodiment, the journal service platform uses the VIP Chinese journal service platform, collects journal references in the journal group through the VIP Chinese journal service platform, obtains journal data corresponding to the journal references, and obtains subject classification data of each journal reference in the journal group;
[0043] Step S2: Based on the subject classification data in step S1, a subject indicator system model is constructed, wherein the subject indicator system model includes: a subject richness index, a subject concentration index, a subject similarity index, and a subject difference index;
[0044] The interdisciplinary measurement indicators in the prior art include: disciplinary diversity indicators, disciplinary expertise indicators, disciplinary differentiation indicators, disciplinary balance indicators, network characteristic indicators (betweenness centrality, network density, average path, cohesive subgroup density, etc.). Based on the relevant indicators in the prior art, the present invention constructs a disciplinary indicator system model for the analysis of the interdisciplinary characteristics of academic journals from three dimensions: disciplinary type, interdisciplinary knowledge integration, and interdisciplinary knowledge dissemination, and analyzes the interdisciplinary characteristics of academic journals.
[0045] Step S3: Based on the subject richness index and subject concentration index in step S2, a subject type analysis model is constructed; based on the subject similarity index and subject difference index in step S2, an inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model is constructed;
[0046] In this embodiment, the subject type analysis model includes: subject richness index and subject concentration index;
[0047] The subject richness index is:
[0048] k=∑esS(1)
[0049] In the formula, k represents the total number of subject categories; i represents the literature belonging to subject S; S i Indicates the number of disciplines included in document i;
[0050] The subject concentration index includes: subject specialization and subject distribution balance;
[0051] The subject specializations are:
[0052]
[0053] Where P is the degree of subject expertise, P∈[0,1], f k The frequency of occurrence of the disciplines covered by the journal;
[0054] The balance of subject distribution is:
[0055]
[0056] In the formula, p i (x) is the probability distribution of different subjects; H(x) is the information entropy;
[0057] The interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model includes: a discipline similarity index and a discipline difference index;
[0058] The subject similarity index is:
[0059]
[0060] Where, J0 is the subject similarity index, J0∈[0,1]; F m 、F n Respectively represent the proportion of references belonging to the mth and nth categories of disciplines in the journal; cos(m, n) represents the cosine similarity of the two disciplines quantified by the co-occurrence pattern of the mth and nth categories of disciplines;
[0061] The subject difference index is:
[0062]
[0063] In the formula, J c is the subject difference index, J c ∈[0, 1];
[0064] Step S4: Conduct empirical analysis based on the discipline type analysis model to analyze the diversity, balance, and professionalism of disciplines; conduct empirical analysis based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model to analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge fusion and knowledge innovation;
[0065] In this embodiment, the discipline type analysis model includes: a discipline richness index and a discipline concentration index; and the empirical analysis based on the discipline type analysis model includes:
[0066] Based on the disciplinary richness index defined in formula (1), the disciplinary diversity is analyzed, and the disciplinary richness is measured by the number of disciplinary categories involved in the references of journal articles. The total number of disciplinary categories k is the number of different disciplinary categories involved in the journal, which is used to describe the diversity characteristics of the discipline. The larger the total number of disciplinary categories k is, the greater the disciplinary richness of the journal knowledge source is.
[0067] The subject concentration index includes: subject specialization and subject distribution balance;
[0068] The disciplinary specialization defined in formula (2) is used to analyze disciplinary specialization. The larger the disciplinary specialization P value, the higher the disciplinary specialization, the fewer disciplines involved, and the more professional the journal content; the smaller the disciplinary specialization P value, the lower the disciplinary specialization, the larger the disciplinary span, and the relatively broad the journal content.
[0069] The discipline balance is analyzed using the discipline distribution balance defined in formula (3). The discipline distribution balance refers to the uniformity of the journal discipline distribution, which is calculated using information entropy H(x). Information entropy is used to describe the uncertainty of the information source. The larger the entropy value, the more balanced the information distribution. The larger the H(x) value, the more balanced the journal discipline distribution; the smaller the H(x) value, the more unbalanced the discipline distribution.
[0070] In this embodiment, empirical analysis is performed based on the discipline type analysis model to analyze the diversity, balance, and professionalism of disciplines; the discipline professionalism is measured by the discipline breadth and depth of the journal content. The discipline breadth is measured by the total number of discipline categories k, and the discipline depth is measured by the frequency of occurrence of the disciplines involved in the journal f. k The balance of subject distribution is measured by information entropy H(x).
[0071] In this embodiment, the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model includes: a subject similarity index and a subject difference index; and the empirical analysis based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model includes:
[0072] The disciplinary knowledge integration degree is analyzed using the disciplinary similarity index defined in formula (4). Disciplinary similarity refers to the closeness of the relationship between disciplines, which can be measured by the co-occurrence relationship of CLCN. CLCN co-occurrence is the phenomenon that CLCNs of different disciplines appear at the same time. The disciplinary similarity of journals is calculated using the document intersection formula in the prior art. In this embodiment, the disciplinary similarity index J0 is used to measure disciplinary similarity. The larger the J0 value, the higher the similarity between disciplines, and the stronger the cross-disciplinary knowledge integration ability of the journal.
[0073] The knowledge innovation of journals is analyzed by using the subject difference index defined in formula (5). Subject difference can also reflect the distance between the subject sources of journal knowledge. The knowledge innovation of journals is measured by subject difference. The subject difference index J is used to c To measure, J c The larger the value, the fewer the number of CLCN co-occurrences, the greater the disciplinary distance, the higher the knowledge difference, and the journal absorbs more interdisciplinary new knowledge and has higher knowledge innovation.
[0074] Based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, empirical analysis is carried out to analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge integration and knowledge innovation.
[0075] Step S5: Based on the empirical analysis results of the discipline type analysis model and the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, the discipline distribution characteristics of the journal group are analyzed.
[0076] In this embodiment, the interdisciplinary characteristics of different levels of typical journals are reflected from different perspectives based on the index system: the disciplinary diversity, balance, and professional characteristics of academic journals are reflected by the discipline type, and the interdisciplinary knowledge integration and innovation characteristics of academic journals are reflected by the relationship between disciplines, so as to realize the exploration of the dynamic changes of journal disciplines. In the analysis of journal characteristics, the international influence and competitiveness of the State Grid journal group are enhanced, and attention is paid to the two important characteristics of journal research topic overlap and journal influence. The problem that the existing technology cannot find that journals with the same content quality classification have characteristics different from those of journals of other levels when comparing the disciplinary distribution between journals of different levels is solved.
Claims
1. A method for analyzing the disciplinary distribution characteristics of a journal group, characterized in that: The steps include: Step S1: Collecting subject classification data of references of each journal in the journal group based on the journal service platform; Step S2: Based on the subject classification data in step S1, a subject indicator system model is constructed, wherein the subject indicator system model includes: a subject richness index, a subject concentration index, a subject similarity index, and a subject difference index; Step S3: Based on the subject richness index and subject concentration index in step S2, a subject type analysis model is constructed; based on the subject similarity index and subject difference index in step S2, an inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model is constructed; Step S4: Conduct empirical analysis based on the discipline type analysis model to analyze the diversity, balance, and professionalism of disciplines; conduct empirical analysis based on the interdisciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model to analyze the degree of disciplinary knowledge fusion and knowledge innovation; Step S5: Based on the empirical analysis results of the discipline type analysis model and the inter-disciplinary knowledge fusion analysis model, the discipline distribution characteristics of the journal group are analyzed.
2. The method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group according to claim 1, characterized in that: The subject richness index is: k=∑esS(1) In the formula, k represents the total number of subject categories; i represents the literature belonging to subject S; S i Indicates the number of disciplines included in document i.
3. The method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group according to claim 1, characterized in that: The subject concentration index includes: subject specialization and subject distribution balance; The subject specializations are: In the formula, P is the degree of discipline expertise, P∈[0,1], and fk is the frequency of occurrence of the discipline involved in the journal; The balance of subject distribution is: H(x)=-pi(x)·log2pi(x)(3) Where pi(x) is the probability distribution of different subjects; H(x) is the information entropy.
4. The method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group according to claim 1, characterized in that: The subject similarity index is: Where, J0 is the subject similarity index, J0∈[0,1]; F m 、F n They represent the proportion of references belonging to the mth and nth disciplines in the journal respectively; cos(m, n) represents the cosine similarity of two subjects quantified by the co-occurrence pattern of the m-th and n-th subjects.
5. The method for analyzing the subject distribution characteristics of a journal group according to claim 1, characterized in that: The subject difference index is: In the formula, J c is the subject difference index, J c ∈[0,1]; F m 、F n They represent the proportion of references belonging to the mth and nth disciplines in the journal respectively; cos(m, n) represents the cosine similarity of two subjects quantified by the co-occurrence pattern of the m-th and n-th subjects.
