Simulation device, simulation method, and simulation program
By using the acquisition and classification units of the simulation device to calculate the similarity of the output waveforms of multiple processing systems, the problem of inconsistent calculation results in collaborative simulation of processing systems is solved, and appropriate calculation results and system selection are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202480090354.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2024-04-04
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-22
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing processing systems produce inconsistent or failed calculation results in co-simulation, and cost-benefit evaluation is complex, making it difficult to select a processing system.
The simulation device acquires output waveforms from multiple processing systems through its acquisition and classification units, calculates waveform similarity, classifies the processing systems into one or more groups, and selects representative processing systems and output waveforms to obtain appropriate calculation results.
It enables consistent computational results in immature processing systems, simplifies the selection process of processing systems, and improves the reliability and efficiency of computational results.
Smart Images

Figure CN123076869A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This disclosure relates to techniques for simulation using immature processing systems. Background Technology
[0002] In recent years, the industry has been promoting model-based systems engineering to balance the overall quality assurance and development efficiency of products and services. Furthermore, model-based development, primarily focusing on software simulation, is becoming increasingly common for the individual devices and equipment that constitute a system.
[0003] Consider applying device or equipment simulation technology to overall system quality assurance and development efficiency. For example, consider using the Modelica language to model the system and using a processing system based on FMI and SSP as standard technologies for co-simulation (see Non-Patent Literature 1, 2). FMI is short for Functional Mock-up Interface. SSP is short for System Structure and Parameterization. The processing system is also called a simulation tool, simulation engine, or numerical solver, etc.
[0004] Existing technical documents
[0005] Non-patent literature
[0006] Non-patent document 1: "FMI Utilization Guide Ver. 1.0.1" published by the Automotive Technology Association, November 2018.
[0007] Non-patent literature 2: Open Simulation Platform, https: / / open-simulation-platform.github.io Summary of the Invention
[0008] The problem the invention aims to solve
[0009] However, the processing systems used for co-simulation are not yet fully mature in technology. Depending on the processing system, even if the system can be modeled, the calculation results can sometimes differ, or the calculation may fail. In addition, the existence of a large number of processing systems makes cost-effectiveness evaluation difficult, thus becoming an obstacle to the selection of a processing system.
[0010] The purpose of this disclosure is to provide a structure that enables the acquisition of satisfactory computational results using immature processing systems.
[0011] means for solving problems
[0012] The simulation apparatus disclosed herein includes: an acquisition unit that acquires output waveforms as time-series data, which are output from multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object by respectively inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform as time-series data provided to the simulated object; and a classification unit that calculates the waveform similarity of the output waveforms acquired by the acquisition unit from the multiple processing systems, and classifies the multiple processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
[0013] Invention Effects
[0014] In this disclosure, waveform similarity of the output waveforms is calculated, and multiple processing systems are classified into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity. By using the classification results to select appropriate processing systems and output waveforms, appropriate calculation results can be obtained. Attached Figure Description
[0015] Figure 1 This is a functional structure diagram of the simulation device 10 in Implementation Method 1.
[0016] Figure 2 This is a hardware structure diagram of the simulation device 10 according to implementation method 1.
[0017] Figure 3 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 1.
[0018] Figure 4 This is an explanatory diagram of the input waveform 32 and the output waveform 33 of Embodiment 1.
[0019] Figure 5 This is an explanatory diagram of the similarity calculation process in Implementation Method 1.
[0020] Figure 6 This is an explanatory diagram of the classification process, group selection process, and processing system selection process of Implementation Method 1.
[0021] Figure 7 This is a functional structure diagram of the simulation device 10 of Implementation Method 1 applied to HILS.
[0022] Figure 8 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 2.
[0023] Figure 9 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Modified Example 3.
[0024] Figure 10 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Modified Example 4.
[0025] Figure 11 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Modified Example 5.
[0026] Figure 12 This is a flowchart illustrating the processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Modified Example 6. Detailed Implementation
[0027] Implementation method 1. Structural description
[0028] Reference Figure 1 The functional structure of the simulation device 10 in Implementation Method 1 will be explained.
[0029] The simulation device 10 includes multiple processing systems 21, an acquisition unit 22, a classification unit 23, and a selection unit 24. Figure 1 In the diagram, processing systems 21A to 21Z are shown as multiple processing systems 21, but the number of processing systems 21 can be any number.
[0030] Each processing system 21 is also referred to as a simulation tool, simulation engine, or numerical solver. Each processing system 21 takes the system model 31 and the input waveform 32 as inputs to perform co-simulation by simulating the actions of the simulated object. Each processing system 21 outputs the output waveform 33 as the result of the co-simulation.
[0031] The acquisition unit 22 acquires the output waveform 33 output by each processing system 21. The classification unit 23 classifies each processing system 21 into one or more groups based on the output waveform 33. The selection unit 24 selects any group from the one or more groups as a specific group. Then, the selection unit 24 selects a representative processing system 34 from the processing systems 21 classified into the specific group, and extracts the output waveform 33 obtained from the representative processing system 34 as a representative waveform 35.
[0032] Reference Figure 2 The hardware structure of the simulation device 10 in Implementation Method 1 will be described.
[0033] The simulation device 10 is a computer.
[0034] The simulation device 10 includes hardware such as a processor 11, a memory 12, a storage device 13, and a communication interface 14. The processor 11 is connected to other hardware via signal lines and controls these other hardware components.
[0035] Processor 11 is the IC that performs processing. IC is short for Integrated Circuit. Specifically, processor 11 can be a CPU, DSP, or GPU. CPU is short for Central Processing Unit. DSP is short for Digital Signal Processor. GPU is short for Graphics Processing Unit.
[0036] Memory 12 is a storage device for temporarily storing data. Specifically, memory 12 is SRAM or DRAM. SRAM is short for Static Random Access Memory. DRAM is short for Dynamic Random Access Memory.
[0037] Storage device 13 is a storage device for storing data. As a specific example, storage device 13 is an HDD. HDD is short for Hard Disk Drive. Alternatively, storage device 13 can also be a removable recording medium such as an SD (trademarked) memory card, CompactFlash (trademarked), NAND flash memory, floppy disk, optical disc, compressed disc, Blu-ray disc, or DVD. SD is short for Secure Digital. DVD is short for Digital Versatile Disk.
[0038] Communication interface 14 is an interface used for communicating with external devices. Specifically, communication interface 14 is a port for Ethernet (registered trademark), USB, or HDMI (registered trademark). USB is short for Universal Serial Bus. HDMI is short for High-Definition Multimedia Interface.
[0039] The memory 13 stores programs that implement the functions of each functional structural element of the simulation device 10. These programs are read into the memory 12 by the processor 11 and executed by the processor 11. Thus, the functions of each functional component of the simulation device 10 are implemented.
[0040] exist Figure 1 Only one processor 11 is shown in the diagram. However, there can be multiple processors 11, and multiple processors 11 can cooperate to execute programs that implement various functions.
[0041] Reference Figures 3 to 7 The operation of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 1 will be explained.
[0042] The operation steps of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 1 are equivalent to the simulation method in Embodiment 1. Furthermore, the program that implements the operation of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 1 is equivalent to the simulation program in Embodiment 1.
[0043] Reference Figure 3 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Implementation Method 1 will be explained.
[0044] (Step S11: Input Processing)
[0045] The acquisition unit 22 acquires the system model 31 and the input waveform 32, and inputs them to multiple processing systems 21 respectively. Then, each processing system 21 uses the system model 31 and the input waveform 32 to simulate the actions of the simulated object, thus performing co-simulation. Finally, each processing system 21 outputs an output waveform 33 as the result of the co-simulation.
[0046] System model 31 illustrates the specifications of the simulated object. System model 31 is a specification description of the controller and the controlled object, which serve as the simulated object. The controller is a device or equipment that implements control. The controller is also called a controllator. The controlled object is a physical phenomenon or artificial object to which control is applied. The controlled object is also called a controlled object (plant). The specifications are described using languages such as Modelica.
[0047] Input waveform 32 is time-series data provided from the outside as input to system model 31. Output waveform 33 is time-series data representing the results of the system model 31 being analyzed in each processing system 21. For example... Figure 4 As shown, waveform data is obtained by plotting the values at each moment in the time series data and interpolating them. Here, the input waveform 32 and the output waveform 33 are waveform data obtained from the time series data.
[0048] (Step S12: Obtain processing)
[0049] The acquisition unit 22 acquires the output waveforms 33 output from each processing system 21. That is, the acquisition unit 22 acquires the same number of output waveforms 33 as the number of processing systems 21. The output waveforms 33 correspond to the processing system 21 that serves as the output source.
[0050] Here, if the processing by the processing system 21 is successful, waveform data is obtained as output waveform 33. However, if the calculation fails in the processing system 21, time series data is not obtained as output waveform 33, and information indicating calculation failure is received.
[0051] (Step S13: Exclusion process)
[0052] The classification unit 23 excludes the output waveform 33 indicating calculation failure from the output waveform 33 obtained in step S12 from the processing objects. Thus, among the output waveforms 33 obtained in step S12, only the output waveform 33 output from the processing system 21 that has successfully completed the processing remains.
[0053] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0054] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity among the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13. Waveform similarity is the degree to which the output waveforms 33 are similar in features such as value and shape. The classification unit 23 calculates waveform similarity, for example, using Euclidean distance or Manhattan distance between the output waveforms 33. Figure 5 As shown, the waveform similarity between the remaining output waveforms 33 is calculated. Here, the closer the similarity value is to 1, the more similar they are.
[0055] (Step S15: Sorting and processing)
[0056] The classification unit 23 classifies the multiple processing systems 21 into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity calculated in step S14.
[0057] Here, the classification unit 23 considers output waveforms 33 with waveform similarity higher than a threshold as consistent time-series data. Furthermore, the classification unit 23 classifies multiple processing systems 21 into one or more groups based on the processing systems 21 that are the output sources of output waveforms 33 with waveform similarity higher than the threshold, grouping them into the same group. For example... Figure 5 The waveform similarity is calculated as shown. When the threshold is set to 0.8, as shown... Figure 5 as well as Figure 6 As shown, the output waveforms 33 output by multiple processing systems 21 are classified into more than one group.
[0058] (Step S16: Group selection process)
[0059] The selection unit 24 selects an arbitrary group as a specific group based on the processing systems 21 that are classified into more than one group. For example, the selection unit 24 selects an arbitrary group as a specific group based on the number of processing systems 21 that are classified into more than one group. As a specific example, the selection unit 24 selects the group with the largest number of classified processing systems 21 as the specific group.
[0060] If the group with the largest number of classified processing systems 21 is selected as the specific group, then... Figure 6In the example, group α is selected as the specific group.
[0061] Alternatively, the selection unit 24 can select multiple groups as specific groups. For example, the selection unit 24 can select all groups whose number of classified processing systems 21 is greater than a certain number as specific groups.
[0062] (Step S17: Processing system selects processing)
[0063] The selection unit 24 selects a representative processing system 34 from the processing systems 21 classified into the specific group selected in step S16. For example, the selection unit 24 selects the processing system 21 classified into the specific group that has the highest average waveform similarity among the processing systems 21 classified into that specific group as the representative processing system 34. Figure 6 In the example, group α is selected as a specific group, and in the case where the processing system 21 with the highest average waveform similarity is selected as the representative processing system 34, processing system 21A is selected as the representative processing system 34.
[0064] At this time, if multiple groups are selected as specific groups in step S16, the selection unit 24 selects a representative processing system 34 from each specific group. Alternatively, the selection unit 24 may select multiple processing systems 21 as representative processing systems 34 from one specific group.
[0065] The selection unit 24 extracts the output waveform 33 from the representative processing system 34 as the representative waveform 35. Figure 6 In the example, when processing system 21A is selected as the representative processing system 34, the output waveform 33a is extracted as the representative waveform 35.
[0066] about Figure 1 The functional structure of the simulation device 10 shown uses specifications rather than physical objects for the controller and controlled objects, which is generally referred to as MILS. MILS is short for Model In the Loop Simulation.
[0067] As variations of MILS, there are SILS, SPILS, PILS, HILS, RCP, etc. SILS stands for Software In the Loop Simulation. SPILS stands for Simulation-based Processor In the Loop Simulation. PILS stands for Processor In the Loop Simulation. HILS stands for Hardware In the Loop Simulation. RCP stands for Rapid Control Prototyping. The simulation device 10 of Implementation Method 1 can be applied not only to MILS, but also to various other methods such as SILS, SPILS, PILS, HILS, and RCP.
[0068] For example, when the simulation device 10 of Embodiment 1 is applied to HILS, it becomes Figure 7 The structure shown is such that the controller is not modeled, and the system model 31 contains only the specification description of the controlled object. Then, the input waveform 32 is input to the controller, and the input data corresponding to the input waveform 32 is input to each processing system 21 through the controller.
[0069] Effects of Implementation Method 1
[0070] As described above, the simulation apparatus 10 of Embodiment 1 calculates the waveform similarity of the output waveform 33 and classifies the multiple processing systems 21 into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity. By using the classification results to select appropriate processing systems 21 and output waveforms 33, appropriate calculation results can be obtained.
[0071] The processing system 21 used in the co-simulation is not technically mature, and sometimes the calculation results are different or the calculation fails. Thus, even when co-simulation is performed using the immature processing system 21, appropriate calculation results can still be obtained.
[0072] In Implementation 1, the simulation apparatus 10 selects a specific group based on the number of processing systems 21 classified into each group, and selects a representative processing system 34 from the processing systems 21 classified into the specific group. Then, the simulation apparatus 10 extracts the output waveform 33 output by the representative processing system 34 as a representative waveform 35. By using the representative processing system 34 and the representative waveform 35, a proper calculation result can be obtained.
[0073] Other Structures
[0074] <Modification 1>
[0075] In Embodiment 1, each functional component is implemented by software. However, as Modification 1, each functional component may also be implemented by hardware. Regarding this Modification 1, the differences from Embodiment 1 will be described.
[0076] In the case where each functional component is implemented by hardware, the simulation apparatus 10 is provided with an electronic circuit in place of the processor 11, the memory 12, and the storage 13. The electronic circuit is a dedicated circuit that implements the functions of each functional component, the memory 12, and the storage 13.
[0077] As the electronic circuit, a single circuit, a composite circuit, a programmed processor, a parallel-programmed processor, a logic IC, a GA, an ASIC, and an FPGA are conceivable. GA is the abbreviation of Gate Array. ASIC is the abbreviation of Application Specific Integrated Circuit. FPGA is the abbreviation of Field-Programmable Gate Array.
[0078] Each functional component may be implemented by one electronic circuit, or each functional component may be distributed and implemented in a plurality of electronic circuits.
[0079] <Modification 2>
[0080] As Modification 2, it is also possible that a part of each functional component is implemented by hardware, and the other each functional component is implemented by software.
[0081] The processor 11, the memory 12, the storage 13, and the electronic circuit are referred to as a processing circuit. That is, the function of each functional component is implemented by the processing circuit.
[0082] Further, the "unit" in the above descriptions may be replaced with "circuit", "process", "step", "processing", or "processing circuit".
[0083] Embodiment 2.
[0084] In Embodiment 2, a method for calculating waveform similarity will be described. In Embodiment 2, points different from Embodiment 1 will be described, and descriptions of the same points will be omitted.
[0085] In embodiment 2, the classification unit 23 uses DTW as the method for calculating waveform similarity. DTW is short for Dynamic Time Warping.
[0086] Description of the action
[0087] Reference Figure 8 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in Embodiment 2 will be explained. The processing in step S14 and... Figure 3 different.
[0088] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0089] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity between the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13 using DTW.
[0090] Effects of Implementation Method 2
[0091] When using DTW to calculate waveform similarity, waveform similarity can be appropriately determined even if the lengths or periods of the two output waveforms 33 as time series data differ, compared to using Euclidean distance or Manhattan distance. By appropriately calculating waveform similarity, a representative processing system 34 can be appropriately selected.
[0092] Other structures
[0093] <Variation Example 3>
[0094] As a method for calculating waveform similarity, Derivative DTW (Derivative Dynamic Time Warping) can also be used.
[0095] Reference Figure 9 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in modified example 3 will be explained. The processing of step S14 is as follows: Figure 8 different.
[0096] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0097] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity among the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13 using Derivative DTW. Derivative DTW is an improved method of DTW. Compared with DTW, Derivative DTW has the feature of considering both upward and downward trends when calculating waveform similarity.
[0098] By using Derivative DTW to calculate waveform similarity, waveform similarity can be appropriately determined. By appropriately calculating waveform similarity, representative processing system 34 can be appropriately selected.
[0099] <Variation Example 4>
[0100] k-shape can also be used as a method for calculating waveform similarity.
[0101] Reference Figure 10 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in modified example 4 will be explained. The processing of step S14 is as follows: Figure 8 different.
[0102] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0103] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity among the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13 using k-shape. k-shape has the feature of using a distance scale that focuses on phase and amplitude as characteristics of waveforms to determine similarity.
[0104] By using k-shape to calculate waveform similarity, waveform similarity can be appropriately determined. By appropriately calculating waveform similarity, a representative processing system 34 can be appropriately selected.
[0105] <Variation Example 5>
[0106] PCA can also be used as a method for calculating waveform similarity.
[0107] PCA is short for Principal Component Analysis.
[0108] Reference Figure 11 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in modified example 5 will be explained. The processing of step S14 is as follows: Figure 8 different.
[0109] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0110] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity among the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13 using PCA. PCA has the characteristic of compressing data by constructing variables that can most efficiently describe the data from a large number of variables.
[0111] By using PCA to calculate waveform similarity, waveform similarity can be appropriately determined. By appropriately calculating waveform similarity, a representative processing system 34 can be appropriately selected.
[0112] <Variation Example 6>
[0113] t-SNE can also be used as a method for calculating waveform similarity. t-SNE is short for t-distributedStochastic Neighbor Embedding.
[0114] Reference Figure 12 The processing flow of the simulation device 10 in modified example 6 will be explained. The processing of step S14 and... Figure 8 different.
[0115] (Step S14: Similarity calculation and processing)
[0116] The classification unit 23 calculates the waveform similarity among the remaining output waveforms 33 that were not excluded in step S13 using t-SNE. t-SNE has the following characteristics: after compressing high-dimensional data into low-dimensional data in a way that makes the original data as close to each other as possible, it determines how many nearby points exist.
[0117] By using t-SNE to calculate waveform similarity, waveform similarity can be appropriately determined. By appropriately calculating waveform similarity, representative processing system 34 can be appropriately selected.
[0118] The various methods disclosed herein are summarized below as appendices.
[0119] (Note 1)
[0120] A simulation apparatus includes: an acquisition unit that acquires output waveforms as time-series data, the output waveforms being output from multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object by respectively inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform as time-series data provided to the simulated object; and a classification unit that calculates waveform similarity between the output waveforms acquired by the acquisition unit from the multiple processing systems, and classifies the multiple processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
[0121] (Note 2)
[0122] According to the simulation apparatus described in Appendix 1, the simulation apparatus further includes a selection unit that, based on the processing system that classifies the data into the more than one group by the classification unit, selects any group as a specific group from the more than one group, and extracts a representative waveform from the output waveform obtained by the processing system that classifies the data into the specific group.
[0123] (Note 3)
[0124] According to the simulation apparatus described in Appendix 2, the selection unit selects any processing system from the processing systems classified into the specific group as a representative processing system, and extracts the output waveform obtained from the representative processing system as the representative waveform.
[0125] (Note 4)
[0126] According to the simulation apparatus described in Appendix 2 or 3, the selection unit selects any group as a specific group from the more than one group based on the number of processing systems classified into each group.
[0127] (Note 5)
[0128] According to any one of the appendices 1 to 4, the simulation apparatus wherein the classification unit calculates the waveform similarity by any one of DTW (Dynamic Time Warping), Derivative DTW (Dynamic Time Warping), k-shape, PCA (Principal Component Analysis), and t-SNE (t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding).
[0129] (Note 6)
[0130] A simulation method in which a computer acquires output waveforms as time-series data, the output waveforms being output from multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object by inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform provided as time-series data to the simulated object, respectively. The computer calculates the waveform similarity of the output waveforms acquired from the multiple processing systems and classifies the multiple processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
[0131] (Note 7)
[0132] A simulation program enables a computer to function as a simulation device, the simulation device performing the following processes: an acquisition process, acquiring an output waveform as time-series data, the output waveform being output from multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object by respectively inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform as time-series data provided to the simulated object; and a classification process, calculating the waveform similarity of the output waveforms acquired from the multiple processing systems through the acquisition process, and classifying the multiple processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
[0133] The embodiments and variations of this disclosure have been described above. Several of these embodiments and variations may also be combined. Furthermore, any one or more of them may be implemented partially. Moreover, this disclosure is not limited to the above embodiments and variations, and various modifications can be made as needed.
[0134] Label Explanation
[0135] 10 Simulation device, 11 Processor, 12 Memory, 13 Storage, 14 Communication interface, 21 Processing system, 22 Acquisition unit, 23 Classification unit, 24 Selection unit, 31 System model, 32 Input waveform, 33 Output waveform, 34 Representative processing system, 35 Representative waveform.
Claims
1. A simulation device comprising: The acquisition unit acquires an output waveform as time-series data. This output waveform is generated by inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform as time-series data provided to the simulated object into multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object, and then outputting them from the multiple processing systems respectively. The classification unit calculates the waveform similarity of the output waveforms obtained by the acquisition unit from the plurality of processing systems respectively, and classifies the plurality of processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
2. The simulation device according to claim 1, wherein, The simulation device further includes a selection unit that, based on the processing system that classifies the data into the more than one group by the classification unit, selects any group as a specific group from the more than one group, and extracts a representative waveform from the output waveform obtained by the processing system that classifies the data into the specific group.
3. The simulation device according to claim 2, wherein, The selection unit selects any processing system from the processing systems classified into the specific group as a representative processing system, and extracts the output waveform obtained from the representative processing system as the representative waveform.
4. The simulation device according to claim 2 or 3, wherein, The selection unit selects any group as a specific group from the more than one groups based on the number of processing systems in each group that are classified into the more than one group.
5. The simulation apparatus according to any one of claims 1 to 4, wherein, The classification unit calculates the waveform similarity using any of the following methods: Dynamic Time Warping (DTW), Derivative DTW, k-shape, Principal Component Analysis (PCA), and t-distributed Stochastic Neighbor Embedding (t-SNE).
6. A simulation method, wherein, The computer acquires an output waveform as time-series data. This output waveform is generated by inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform, provided as time-series data to the simulated object, to multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object, and then outputting the waveform from each of these multiple processing systems. The computer calculates the waveform similarity of the output waveforms obtained from the plurality of processing systems respectively, and classifies the plurality of processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
7. A simulation program that enables a computer to function as a simulation device, the simulation device performing the following processing: The process involves obtaining an output waveform as time-series data. This output waveform is generated by inputting a system model representing the specifications of the simulated object and an input waveform as time-series data provided to the simulated object into multiple processing systems that simulate the simulated object, and then outputting them from those multiple processing systems. The classification process involves calculating the waveform similarity of the output waveforms obtained from the multiple processing systems through the acquisition process, and classifying the multiple processing systems into one or more groups based on the waveform similarity.
