Automatic verification methods, devices, electronic equipment, and storage media for poles in modal analysis of switching equipment
By acquiring frequency response function data of switching equipment through automatic verification methods, and performing representative pole cluster merging and contribution verification, the problem of accuracy in modal pole identification is solved, the consistency and reliability of modal analysis results are achieved, and the analysis efficiency is improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611415956.7
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-09-10
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
In structural dynamics, existing technologies struggle to effectively identify and verify the modal poles of switching devices, leading to inaccurate modal parameters and impacting the reliability of structural optimization design. In particular, manual verification is time-consuming, labor-intensive, and difficult to guarantee consistency in complex assembly scenarios.
The frequency response function data is obtained through an automatic verification method to generate a steady-state diagram. The first-level verification merges representative pole clusters, and the second-level contribution verification removes false poles. Finally, the data is compared with preset reference data to solidify the standardized process and achieve consistency and reliability in pole identification.
This improves the automation and accuracy of modal pole identification, reduces manual intervention, ensures the consistency and reliability of analysis results, and enhances analysis efficiency.
Smart Images

Figure CN123115731A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This application relates to the field of structural dynamics technology, and more specifically, to an automatic verification method, apparatus, electronic device, and storage medium for poles in modal analysis of switching equipment. Background Technology
[0002] In the field of structural dynamics, modal analysis is a fundamental technique for understanding and characterizing the dynamic behavior of physical structures. Obtaining the frequency response function data of a structure through modal testing and constructing a steady-state diagram to identify modal poles that reflect the true vibration characteristics of the structure is a crucial step in the modal analysis process. In recent years, with the development of data processing methods such as clustering algorithms, automatic pole identification technology based on steady-state diagrams has made some progress, reducing the workload of manual point-by-point interpretation to a certain extent.
[0003] However, the initial results output by automatic pole identification algorithms still cannot completely avoid spurious poles introduced by factors such as test noise, numerical calculation errors, or boundary effects. These spurious poles are not physical reflections of the true modes of the structure. If they are directly used in subsequent analyses without verification, the accuracy of modal parameters will be reduced, thus affecting the reliability of structural optimization design. To address this issue, current engineering practices typically employ manual verification or expert experience comparison. However, these methods lack a unified quantitative evaluation benchmark, and the analysis results are prone to deviation due to differences in personnel experience. Especially in complex assemblies with dense modalities, such as switchgear, the steady-state diagram shows overlapping peaks and complex pole distributions. Manual verification is not only time-consuming and laborious, but its consistency is also difficult to guarantee. Therefore, there is still a gap between automatic pole identification and reliable verification that requires a systematic technical solution to bridge. Summary of the Invention
[0004] In view of this, this application provides an automatic pole verification method, apparatus, electronic device, and storage medium for modal analysis of switching equipment, to ensure the consistency and reliability of pole identification results in modal analysis.
[0005] To achieve the above objectives, the following solution is proposed:
[0006] An automatic pole verification method for modal analysis of switching equipment, applied to electronic devices, the automatic verification method includes the following steps:
[0007] The frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed is obtained and a steady-state diagram is generated accordingly. The modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram are then obtained.
[0008] The first-level verification of the pole clusters is performed: representative poles of each pole cluster are extracted, the damping ratio of the representative poles is compared with a preset reference damping ratio to determine the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles; the similarity between different pole clusters is calculated, and pole clusters whose similarity meets the preset conditions are merged to obtain updated pole clusters.
[0009] The updated pole cluster is then subjected to a second-level verification: the modal contribution of each pole is calculated, the modal contribution is compared with a preset reference contribution, and poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions are removed as false poles.
[0010] The pole results after the second-level verification are compared with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process.
[0011] Optionally, calculating the similarity between different clusters of poles includes the following steps:
[0012] Calculate the frequency distance between representative poles of each pole cluster, and the modal confidence criterion values between the modal participation factors corresponding to each representative pole;
[0013] When the frequency distance is less than a first preset threshold and the modal confidence criterion value is less than a second preset threshold, it is determined that the similarity between the corresponding pole clusters meets the preset conditions, and the corresponding pole clusters are merged.
[0014] Optionally, the first-level verification of the pole cluster includes the following steps:
[0015] The first contribution value is calculated based on the change in the fitting residual of the frequency response function with and without the corresponding poles.
[0016] When the first contribution value is negative, the corresponding pole is directly determined to be a false pole and removed.
[0017] When the first contribution value is positive and less than a first preset multiple of the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the corresponding pole is determined to be a false pole and is removed.
[0018] Optionally, the first-level verification of the pole cluster further includes the step of:
[0019] Before calculating the modal contribution of each pole, it is determined whether the damping ratio of each pole is less than a preset multiple of the maximum damping ratio of the reference pole. Poles with damping ratios greater than or equal to the preset multiple are discarded as false poles.
[0020] Optionally, the first-level verification of the pole cluster further includes the step of:
[0021] Based on the combined scaling values of the mode shape, participation factor, natural frequency and damping ratio at the corresponding pole, the summation is applied to all output channels and input points, and then normalized by the total contribution of all modes to calculate the second contribution value.
[0022] When the second contribution value is less than the second preset ratio of the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the corresponding pole is determined to be a false pole and is removed.
[0023] Optionally, comparing the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data includes the following steps:
[0024] Compare the difference in the number of modes between the pole results and the preset reference data;
[0025] Compare the difference in synthesized frequency response function between the pole results and the preset reference data;
[0026] The frequency of the pole results is compared with that of the selected mode in the preset reference data.
[0027] Optionally, the step of solidifying the verification method into a standardized verification process includes the following steps:
[0028] Establish a verification parameter library according to the structural type of the object to be analyzed;
[0029] For objects to be analyzed that have the same structure type as those already existing in the verification parameter library, the automatic verification method is executed by directly calling the corresponding parameters in the verification parameter library.
[0030] For objects with entirely new structural types to be analyzed, after comparing and confirming the automatic verification results with expert analysis data, the corresponding verification parameters are included in the verification parameter library.
[0031] An automatic pole verification device for modal analysis of switching equipment, applied to electronic devices, the automatic verification device includes:
[0032] The data acquisition module is configured to acquire the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generate a steady-state diagram accordingly, and acquire the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram;
[0033] The first verification module is configured to perform a first-level verification on the pole clusters: extract representative poles of each pole cluster, compare the damping of the representative poles with a preset reference damping, and determine the rationality of the damping of the representative poles; calculate the similarity between different pole clusters, and merge the pole clusters whose similarity meets the preset conditions to obtain an updated pole cluster.
[0034] The second verification module is configured to perform a second-level verification on the updated pole cluster: calculate the modal contribution of each pole, compare the modal contribution with a preset reference contribution, and remove poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions as false poles.
[0035] The result comparison and solidification module is configured to compare the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process.
[0036] An electronic device includes at least one processor and a memory connected to the processor, wherein:
[0037] The memory is used to store computer programs or instructions;
[0038] The processor is used to execute the computer program or instructions to enable the electronic device to implement the automatic verification method as described in any of the preceding claims.
[0039] A computer-readable storage medium is applied to an electronic device, the storage medium carrying one or more computer programs that can be executed by the electronic device to enable the electronic device to perform the automatic verification method as described in any of the preceding claims.
[0040] As can be seen from the above technical solution, this application discloses an automatic verification method, device, electronic device, and storage medium for poles in modal analysis of switching equipment. The method and device are applied to electronic devices, specifically: acquiring the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generating a steady-state diagram accordingly; acquiring the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram; performing a first-level verification on the pole clusters: extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, comparing the damping ratio of the representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio, and judging the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles; calculating the similarity between different pole clusters, merging pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions, and obtaining updated pole clusters; performing a second-level verification on the updated pole clusters: calculating the modal contribution of each pole, comparing the modal contribution with a preset reference contribution, and removing poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions as false poles; comparing the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data, and when the comparison results meet the preset conditions, solidifying the verification method into a standardized verification process. The aforementioned technical means can transform expert experience into objective quantitative criteria, and can perform layer-by-layer verification and iterative optimization of the identification results through automated processes, thereby improving analysis efficiency while ensuring the consistency and reliability of modal pole identification results. Attached Figure Description
[0041] To more clearly illustrate the technical solutions in the embodiments of this application or the prior art, the drawings used in the description of the embodiments or the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of this application. For those skilled in the art, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative effort.
[0042] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating an automatic pole verification method in modal analysis of switching equipment according to an embodiment of this application;
[0043] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the principle of representative pole verification and cluster merging in the embodiments of this application;
[0044] Figure 3a This is a schematic diagram of multiple pole clusters in the second-level verification of this application embodiment;
[0045] Figure 3b This is a schematic diagram of the distribution of contribution values calculated by Formula 3 in the embodiments of this application;
[0046] Figure 3c This is a schematic diagram of the distribution of contribution values calculated by formula 4 in the embodiments of this application;
[0047] Figure 3d This is a schematic diagram showing the removal of spurious poles in an embodiment of this application;
[0048] Figure 4 This is a block diagram of an automatic pole verification device in modal analysis of switching equipment according to an embodiment of this application;
[0049] Figure 5 This is a block diagram of an electronic device according to an embodiment of this application. Detailed Implementation
[0050] The technical solutions of the embodiments of this application will be clearly and completely described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only some embodiments of this application, and not all embodiments. Based on the embodiments of this application, all other embodiments obtained by those of ordinary skill in the art without creative effort are within the scope of protection of this application.
[0051] Figure 1 This is a flowchart illustrating an automatic pole verification method in modal analysis of a switching device according to an embodiment of this application.
[0052] The automatic verification method provided in this application is applied to an electronic device for automatic verification and optimization of poles in modal analysis. This electronic device can be a workstation, server, cloud platform, or embedded computing device with data computing and information processing capabilities, equipped with memory, processor, and communication interface for storing, processing, and outputting modal data. The automatic verification method provided in this application includes a data acquisition stage, a first-level verification stage, a second-level verification stage, and a result comparison and consolidation stage. Each stage is sequentially connected via data flow, with the output of the previous stage serving as the input of the next, forming a complete technical chain of progressive automatic verification and optimization iteration. The specific process is as follows:
[0053] S1. Obtain the steady-state diagram and the initial pole cluster.
[0054] That is, the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed is obtained and a steady-state diagram is generated accordingly, and then the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram are obtained.
[0055] Specifically, the first step is to deploy sensors to perform modal testing on the object to be analyzed. The object to be analyzed can be switching equipment such as circuit breakers and GIS systems, or electrical equipment such as transformer tanks, cable terminals, bushings, and busbars. During the modal testing, accelerometers or force sensors are used to collect the dynamic response signals of the object under different excitation conditions. After signal conditioning and analog-to-digital conversion, the frequency response function (FRF) data is calculated.
[0056] In one specific embodiment of this application, a modal parameter estimator is used to process the frequency response function data to generate a steady-state plot. The modal parameter estimator can be a PolyMAX modal parameter estimator. The PolyMAX estimator fits the frequency response function data by constructing a right-matrix fractional model, solves for the poles at different model orders, and presents the pole frequencies and damping ratios at each order in the form of a steady-state plot. The horizontal axis of the steady-state plot represents frequency, and the vertical axis represents the model order. The plot indicates the locations of the poles identified at different orders.
[0057] Furthermore, the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state graph are obtained. A pole cluster refers to a set of physically related steady-state poles identified near the same modal frequency, but belonging to different model orders or under different test conditions. The modal poles and their respective pole clusters can be obtained manually or through an automatic identification method based on clustering algorithms. After this operation, N pole clusters are obtained, each containing several modal poles, denoted as the initial pole cluster set, where N is an integer greater than or equal to 1.
[0058] S2. Perform first-level verification on the pole cluster, specifically representative pole verification and cluster merging.
[0059] Specifically, the process involves extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, comparing the damping ratio of these representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio to determine their rationality, and then calculating the similarity between different pole clusters. Pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions are merged to obtain updated pole clusters. The detailed process is as follows:
[0060] First, representative poles are extracted and the damping ratios are compared.
[0061] For the N pole clusters mentioned above, representative poles are extracted from each cluster. In modal analysis, a representative pole is a pole that can represent the overall characteristics of the cluster, usually located in the central region or the region with the highest density of the cluster. For each pole cluster, the representative pole is determined by calculating the mean frequency and the mean damping ratio of all poles in the cluster, and the pole closest to the mean value is denoted as rn (m=1,2,…,N).
[0062] Subsequently, the damping ratio of the representative pole is compared with a preset reference damping ratio. Specifically, the damping ratio of the representative pole is compared with the maximum reference damping ratio, which is a pre-set reference threshold used to measure the rationality of pole damping. When the damping ratio of the representative pole is greater than the maximum reference damping ratio, the corresponding pole cluster is determined to not meet the damping ratio rationality requirement. At this time, the pole cluster corresponding to the representative pole is marked as an object requiring special attention, and will undergo further contribution verification in subsequent operations to determine whether it is a spurious mode.
[0063] Then, the inter-cluster similarity is calculated and the clusters are merged.
[0064] After extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, the similarity between different pole clusters is calculated. The similarity calculation includes two metrics: frequency distance and modal confidence criterion (MAC) value. Frequency distance measures the proximity of two representative poles along the frequency axis. Assume two representative poles are r... i and r j The corresponding modal frequencies are f i and f j The frequency distance can then be calculated using the following formula 1:
[0065] (1)
[0066] in, For frequency spacing, Let be the natural angular frequency of the representative pole of the i-th mode. Let be the natural angular frequency of order j.
[0067] This formula represents the relative frequency difference between two representative poles, where the first preset threshold is 5%, meaning that when the frequency difference is less than 5%, the two representative poles are considered to be highly similar in frequency.
[0068] The Modal Confidence Criterion (MAC) value is used to measure the correlation between the mode shapes corresponding to two representative poles. Assuming the modal participation factors PF corresponding to the two representative poles are PFi and PFj, respectively, the MAC value can be calculated according to Formula 2:
[0069] (2)
[0070] in, The i-th modal participation factor vector. The modal participation factor vector of the j-th mode, where t is the transpose, i and j are the modal order indices, and N is the total order.
[0071] The MAC value ranges from 0 to 1, with values closer to 1 indicating a higher similarity between the two mode shapes. The second preset threshold is 25%, meaning that when the MAC value is less than 25%, the mode shapes corresponding to the two representative poles are considered to be significantly different and do not belong to the same physical mode; conversely, when the MAC value is small, i.e., the mode shape similarity is high, it may indicate that the two pole clusters actually originate from the same physical mode.
[0072] When the two distances mentioned above are less than 5% and 25% respectively, the similarity between the corresponding pole clusters is determined to meet the preset conditions, and the corresponding pole clusters are then merged. During merging, one pole cluster is designated as the primary pole cluster, and the other as the secondary pole cluster. Only the representative poles of the primary pole cluster are retained, and the poles in the secondary pole cluster are either merged into the primary pole cluster or directly removed. After merging, the representative poles of the updated pole clusters are recalculated to form an updated set of pole clusters, which then proceeds to the second level of verification.
[0073] This application passed the first-level verification, effectively solving the pole redundancy divergence problem caused by large differences in the damping ratios of poles calculated for the same mode. It merges multiple pole clusters with similar frequencies and modes into a single cluster, providing concise and standardized input data for subsequent contribution verification. Figure 2 As shown, the middle column of poles originally appeared as two distinct clusters, which were merged after the first-level verification.
[0074] S3. Perform a second-level verification on the updated pole cluster, specifically contribution verification and spurious pole removal.
[0075] Specifically, the modal contribution of each pole is calculated, and the modal contribution is compared with the preset reference contribution. Poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions are removed as spurious poles.
[0076] After the first-level validation and merging, the updated pole cluster may still contain spurious poles introduced by test noise, numerical calculation errors, or an excessively high model order. The second-level validation uses a two-dimensional contribution evaluation mechanism to accurately identify and remove these spurious poles from the perspective of their actual contribution to the structural dynamic response. The specific process is as follows:
[0077] First, the damping ratio of the pole clusters is pre-screened.
[0078] In one specific embodiment of this application, a damping ratio pre-screening is first performed before calculating the modal contribution of each pole. It is determined whether the damping ratio of each pole is less than a preset multiple of the maximum damping ratio of the reference pole, which is 8 times. Specifically, the damping ratio of the current pole to be verified is compared with 8 times the maximum damping ratio of the reference pole; if the damping ratio of the pole is greater than or equal to 8 times the maximum damping ratio of the reference pole, the pole is directly discarded as a false pole and will not proceed to the subsequent contribution calculation stage. This pre-screening condition serves as a prerequisite for contribution verification, quickly filtering out obvious false poles caused by damping estimates that deviate significantly from the physically reasonable range.
[0079] Then, the first contribution value is calculated and determined.
[0080] For poles pre-screened by damping ratio, their modal contributions are further calculated. Specifically, the first contribution value can be calculated based on the change in the fitting residual of the frequency response function with and without the corresponding pole. Assume there exists a mode set containing all poles of the modes to be evaluated, and a certain mode is denoted as i, represented by its representative pole pi. The measured FRF is denoted as Hr, and the FRF synthesized using pole pi without pole pi is denoted as... The FRF synthesized using all modes is denoted as Ha. The first contribution value is then defined. The calculation can be performed using Formula 3:
[0081] (3)
[0082] in, extreme point First contribution This represents the residual when excluding this mode. This represents the residual containing all modes, divided by This is to achieve dimensionless measurement, which facilitates the comparison of results across measurement points and datasets.
[0083] After calculating the first contribution value, the following judgment is performed: When the first contribution value is negative, it indicates that removing the mode actually reduces the fitting residual, meaning the presence of the mode is detrimental to the fitting and is a typical overfitting phenomenon; the corresponding pole is directly judged as a spurious pole and removed. When the first contribution value is positive but extremely small, it indicates that the mode contributes to the fitting to a certain extent but negligibly. When the first contribution value is less than 8 times the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the corresponding pole is judged as a spurious pole and removed. The reference cluster refers to those mode clusters that have been identified as physical modes, are state-stable, and have reasonable contributions; the 8-fold threshold is derived from engineering practice experience.
[0084] Finally, the second contribution value is calculated and determined.
[0085] Simultaneously or subsequently, based on the combined scaling values of the mode shape, participation factor, natural frequency, and damping ratio of the corresponding pole, the summation is applied to all output channels and input points, and then normalized to the total modal contribution value to calculate the second contribution value.
[0086] Specifically, the second contribution value is calculated by determining the proportion of the composite weight of mode i in the total weight of all modes. This calculation can be performed using Equation 4:
[0087] (4)
[0088] In the formula, Li represents the mode shape, and Li represents the participation factor, which is the ratio of the natural frequency to the damping ratio. Scaling is then applied. Finally, scaling is applied to all output channels. and all input points Summing the values and then normalizing them by the norm of the total contribution of all modes, we finally obtain a dimensionless value:
[0089] The second contribution value calculated using the above formula will not be negative. When the second contribution value is less than one-third of the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the mode is considered to have extremely low influence on the overall mode, and the corresponding pole is determined to be a spurious pole and removed. The one-third ratio is also derived from engineering experience.
[0090] Through this second-level verification, the first contribution value based on the change of the FRF fitting residual and the second contribution value based on the proportion of absolute participation complement and synergistically achieve a two-dimensional cross-screening of spurious poles. Only poles that pass the damping ratio pre-screening and do not fall into the elimination interval in both the two-dimensional contribution evaluation are confirmed as true physical modes and retained.
[0091] like Figure 3aAs shown, there are initially nine distinct pole clusters, seven of which are aligned with the FRF peaks, while the other two are not aligned. Figure 3b and Figure 3c The graphs show the contribution value distributions calculated using Formulas 3 and 4, respectively. It is clear from the graphs that the two modes with the lowest contribution values exhibit a consistent trend in both graphs, and are ultimately identified as spurious poles and removed. Figure 3d As shown.
[0092] S4. The method for comparing and verifying execution results is solidified.
[0093] Here, the pole results after the second-level verification are compared with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process. Specifically:
[0094] First, three quantitative indicators are compared, that is, the extreme point results after the second-level verification are compared with the preset reference data. Specifically, this includes a comparison of the following three indicators one by one:
[0095] Indicator 1: Comparison of the number of modalities.
[0096] The number of modal poles obtained above is compared with the number of modes selected by experts. Taking a circuit breaker product as an example, the experts selected 139 modes, while the automatic method obtained 128 modes, with an error of less than 10%. The allowable error for the difference in the number of modes is no more than 10%. When the difference exceeds 10%, it indicates that the automatic verification method may have systematic missed detections or false detections, and the verification parameters or judgment thresholds need to be retrospectively checked and corrected.
[0097] Indicator 2: Comparison of FRF synthesis errors.
[0098] This index is used to evaluate the degree to which the selected modal set characterizes the structural dynamics. The synthesis error can be calculated according to Equation 5:
[0099] (5)
[0100] In the formula, This is the measured frequency response function, that is, the structural dynamic response data obtained directly through experiments; The synthesized frequency response function is based on the FRF reconstructed from the final selected set of modes according to the modal superposition formula. The difference between the two represents the residual vector of the measured FRF and the synthesized FRF at each frequency point, which represents the difference between the measured true dynamics and the model dynamics composed only of the selected set of modes. The L1 norm represents the summation of the absolute values of all elements in the residual vector, or the integration / summation over the entire frequency band, giving the total absolute magnitude of the residuals. The L1 norm is less sensitive to individual large errors than the L2 norm (sum of squares), making it more robust in assessing overall trends. The L1 norm of the measured FRF is used as a normalization factor.
[0101] Formula 5 yields a dimensionless relative composition error, expressed as a percentage, facilitating comparisons across datasets. For example, a... =0.05, which can be roughly understood as the unexplained dynamic difference between the synthesized FRF and the measured FRF, whose total intensity accounts for about 5% of the total intensity of the measured signal, indicating that the selected mode set matches the experimental data well and effectively captures the core dynamic characteristics of the structure. As described in claim 15, the difference in the synthesized frequency response function error does not exceed 10%, that is, the difference in the synthesized FRF error between the automatic method and the expert result should be controlled within 10%.
[0102] Indicator 3: Comparison with the frequency of expert selection.
[0103] This indicator is used to determine whether the modes selected by the automated method are consistent with those selected by experts. The correlation between the two is determined using the aforementioned Formulas 1 and 2, and the consistency data is statistically analyzed to highlight the differences from the expert analysis results. When there are additional modes of order 20 or higher in the pole results that were not selected by the preset reference data, the frequency consistency requirement is deemed not met. In this case, the additional modes need to be thoroughly reviewed to determine whether they are newly discovered physical modes or misjudged by the automated verification method.
[0104] After systematically comparing the above three indicators, if the deviations between the results of the automatic verification method and the expert data are within the allowable range, the rationality and effectiveness of the automatic verification method can be confirmed, and the verification method can enter the solidification stage.
[0105] Then, the classification and validation parameter library is established.
[0106] The verification method is formalized into a standardized verification process, including: establishing a verification parameter library according to the structural type of the object to be analyzed. In switchgear, common products such as circuit breakers and GIS are typically classified according to structural characteristics and adapted to voltage levels. For example, circuit breakers can be classified as single-break or double-break based on the number of breaks, and as self-energized or compressed air-operated based on the arc-extinguishing chamber structure.
[0107] For objects to be analyzed that have the same structural type as those already in the verification parameter library, the corresponding parameters in the verification parameter library are directly called to execute the automatic verification method. For products of the same structural type, the same set of verification parameters can be used to complete the verification and optimization when performing modal testing and automatic verification and optimization iterations of poles, and an experience system can be gradually accumulated to form a standardized automatic verification method.
[0108] For objects with entirely new structural types to be analyzed, due to the complexity of actual electrical equipment structures and the influence of fixed boundary conditions and various nonlinear connection relationships, measured data often introduce additional modes beyond the inherent vibration characteristics of the structure itself. Therefore, the pole results obtained from the initial automatic verification need to be compared with the results of expert manual analysis to ensure accuracy. Specifically, more than 10 testing experts are organized to participate in modal analysis simultaneously. After the automatic verification results are compared and confirmed with the expert analysis data, the corresponding verification parameters are included in the verification parameter library. This allows the verification method to be continuously accumulated and improved with product iterations, forming an enterprise-level standardized knowledge asset for modal analysis.
[0109] As can be seen from the above technical solution, this embodiment provides an automatic pole verification method in modal analysis. This method is applied to electronic devices, specifically by acquiring the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generating a steady-state diagram accordingly, obtaining the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram; performing a first-level verification on the pole clusters: extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, comparing the damping ratio of the representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio to determine the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles; calculating the similarity between different pole clusters, merging pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions to obtain updated pole clusters; performing a second-level verification on the updated pole clusters: calculating the modal contribution of each pole, comparing the modal contribution with a preset reference contribution, and removing poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions as false poles; comparing the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data, and when the comparison results meet the preset conditions, solidifying the verification method into a standardized verification process. The aforementioned technical means can transform expert experience into objective quantitative criteria, and can perform layer-by-layer verification and iterative optimization of the identification results through automated processes, thereby improving analysis efficiency while ensuring the consistency and reliability of modal pole identification results.
[0110] Although the operations are described in a specific order, this should not be construed as requiring these operations to be performed in the specific order shown or in a sequential order. In certain environments, multitasking and parallel processing may be advantageous.
[0111] It should be understood that the steps described in the method embodiments of this disclosure may be performed in different orders and / or in parallel. Furthermore, the method embodiments may include additional steps and / or omit the steps shown. The scope of this disclosure is not limited in this respect.
[0112] Computer program code for performing the operations of this disclosure can be written in one or more programming languages or a combination thereof, including but not limited to object-oriented programming languages such as Java, Smalltalk, and C++, as well as conventional procedural programming languages such as C or similar languages. The program code can be executed entirely on the user's computer, partially on the user's computer, as a standalone software package, partially on the user's computer and partially on a remote computer, or entirely on a remote computer or server. In cases involving remote computers, the remote computer can be connected to the user's computer via any type of network—including a local area network (LAN) or a wide area network (WAN)—or can be connected to an external computer.
[0113] Figure 4 This is a block diagram of an automatic pole verification device in modal analysis of a switching device according to an embodiment of this application.
[0114] The automatic verification device provided in this application is applied to an electronic device for automatically verifying and optimizing poles in modal analysis. This electronic device can be a workstation, server, cloud platform, or embedded computing device with data computing and information processing capabilities, equipped with a memory, processor, and communication interface for storing, processing, and outputting modal data. Specifically, the automatic verification device includes a data acquisition module 10, a first verification module 20, a second verification module 30, and a result comparison and solidification module 40.
[0115] The data acquisition modulus is used to obtain the steady-state diagram and the initial pole cluster.
[0116] This method is used to acquire the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generate a steady-state diagram based on it, thereby obtaining the modal poles and their respective pole families in the steady-state diagram. The specific operation process has been described in detail above and will not be repeated here.
[0117] The first verification module is used to perform first-level verification on the pole cluster, specifically representative pole verification and cluster merging.
[0118] Specifically, the process involves extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, comparing the damping ratio of these representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio to determine their rationality, and then calculating the similarity between different pole clusters. Pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions are then merged to obtain updated pole clusters. The specific process has been detailed above and will not be repeated here.
[0119] The second verification module is used to perform a second-level verification on the updated pole cluster, specifically contribution verification and spurious pole removal.
[0120] Specifically, the modal contribution of each pole is calculated, and the modal contribution is compared with the preset reference contribution. Poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions are removed as spurious poles.
[0121] After the first-level verification and merging, the updated pole cluster may still contain spurious poles introduced by test noise, numerical calculation errors, or an excessively high model order. The second-level verification uses a two-dimensional contribution evaluation mechanism to accurately identify and remove these spurious poles from the perspective of their actual contribution to the structural dynamic response. The specific process has been described in detail above and will not be repeated here.
[0122] The results comparison and solidification module is used to solidify the results comparison and verification methods.
[0123] Here, the pole results after the second-level verification are compared with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process. The specific process has been described in detail above and will not be repeated here.
[0124] As can be seen from the above technical solution, this embodiment provides an automatic pole verification device for modal analysis of switching equipment. This device is applied to electronic equipment and specifically acquires the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generates a steady-state diagram accordingly. It then acquires the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram. The device performs a first-level verification on the pole clusters: extracting representative poles from each pole cluster, comparing the damping ratio of the representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio, and determining the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles; calculating the similarity between different pole clusters, merging pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions, and obtaining updated pole clusters; performing a second-level verification on the updated pole clusters: calculating the modal contribution of each pole, comparing the modal contribution with a preset reference contribution, and removing poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions as false poles; comparing the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data, and when the comparison results meet the preset conditions, solidifying the verification method into a standardized verification process. The aforementioned technical means can transform expert experience into objective quantitative criteria, and can perform layer-by-layer verification and iterative optimization of the identification results through automated processes, thereby improving analysis efficiency while ensuring the consistency and reliability of modal pole identification results.
[0125] The units described in the embodiments of this disclosure can be implemented in software or in hardware. The name of a unit does not necessarily limit the unit itself; for example, the first acquisition unit can also be described as "a unit that acquires at least two Internet Protocol addresses".
[0126] The functions described above in this document can be performed at least in part by one or more hardware logic components. For example, exemplary types of hardware logic components that can be used, without limitation, include: field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs), application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs), application-specific standard products (ASSPs), system-on-a-chip (SoCs), complex programmable logic devices (CPLDs), and so on.
[0127] Figure 5 This is a block diagram of an electronic device according to an embodiment of this application.
[0128] The following is for reference. Figure 5 This document illustrates a structural diagram suitable for implementing the electronic device in the embodiments of this disclosure. The terminal device in the embodiments of this disclosure may include, but is not limited to, mobile terminals such as mobile phones, laptops, digital broadcast receivers, PDAs (personal digital assistants), PADs (tablet computers), PMPs (portable multimedia players), in-vehicle terminals (e.g., in-vehicle navigation terminals), and fixed terminals such as digital TVs and desktop computers. This electronic device is merely an example and should not impose any limitations on the functionality and scope of use of the embodiments of this disclosure.
[0129] The electronic device may include a processing unit (e.g., a central processing unit, a graphics processing unit, etc.) 501, which can perform various appropriate actions and processes according to a program stored in a read-only memory (ROM) 502 or a program loaded from an input device 506 into a random access memory (RAM) 503. The RAM also stores various programs and data required for the operation of the electronic device. The processing unit, ROM, and RAM are interconnected via a bus 504. An input / output (I / O) interface 505 is also connected to the bus 504.
[0130] Typically, the following devices can be connected to the I / O interface: input devices including, for example, touchscreens, touchpads, keyboards, mice, cameras, microphones, accelerometers, gyroscopes, etc.; output devices 507 including, for example, liquid crystal displays (LCDs), speakers, vibrators, etc.; storage devices 508 including, for example, magnetic tapes, hard disks, etc.; and communication devices 509. Communication device 509 allows the electronic device to communicate wirelessly or wiredly with other devices to exchange data. Although electronic devices with various devices are shown in the figures, it should be understood that it is not required to implement or possess all of the devices shown. More or fewer devices may be implemented or possessed alternatively.
[0131] This application also provides an embodiment of a computer-readable storage medium.
[0132] The aforementioned computer-readable storage medium is applied to an electronic device and carries one or more computer programs. When the electronic device executes these programs, it acquires the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generates a steady-state diagram accordingly. The modal poles and their respective pole clusters are then obtained from the steady-state diagram. A first-level verification is performed on the pole clusters: representative poles of each pole cluster are extracted, and the damping ratio of these representative poles is compared with a preset reference damping ratio to determine the rationality of the damping ratio. The similarity between different pole clusters is calculated, and pole clusters whose similarity meets preset conditions are merged to obtain updated pole clusters. A second-level verification is performed on the updated pole clusters: the modal contribution of each pole is calculated, and the modal contribution is compared with a preset reference contribution. Poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions are removed as false poles. The pole results after the second-level verification are compared with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process. The aforementioned technical means can transform expert experience into objective quantitative criteria, and can perform layer-by-layer verification and iterative optimization of the identification results through automated processes, thereby improving analysis efficiency while ensuring the consistency and reliability of modal pole identification results.
[0133] It should be noted that the computer-readable medium described above in this disclosure can be a computer-readable signal medium or a computer-readable storage medium, or any combination of the two. A computer-readable storage medium can be, for example,—but not limited to—an electrical, magnetic, optical, electromagnetic, infrared, or semiconductor system, apparatus, or device, or any combination thereof. More specific examples of a computer-readable storage medium may include, but are not limited to: an electrical connection having one or more wires, a portable computer disk, a hard disk, random access memory (RAM), read-only memory (ROM), erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), optical fiber, portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), optical storage device, magnetic storage device, or any suitable combination thereof.
[0134] In this disclosure, a computer-readable storage medium can be any tangible medium that contains or stores a program that can be used by or in connection with an instruction execution system, apparatus, or device. In this disclosure, a computer-readable signal medium can include a data signal propagated in baseband or as part of a carrier wave, carrying computer-readable program code. Such propagated data signals can take various forms, including but not limited to electromagnetic signals, optical signals, or any suitable combination thereof. A computer-readable signal medium can also be any computer-readable medium other than a computer-readable storage medium, which can send, propagate, or transmit a program for use by or in connection with an instruction execution system, apparatus, or device. The program code contained on the computer-readable medium can be transmitted using any suitable medium, including but not limited to: wires, optical fibers, RF (radio frequency), etc., or any suitable combination thereof.
[0135] It should also be noted that the device embodiments described above are merely illustrative. The units described as separate components may or may not be physically separate, and the components shown as units may or may not be physical units; that is, they may be located in one place or distributed across multiple network units. Some or all of the modules can be selected to achieve the purpose of this embodiment according to actual needs. In addition, in the device embodiment drawings provided in this application, the connection relationship between modules indicates that they have a communication connection, which can be implemented as one or more communication buses or signal lines.
[0136] Through the above description of the embodiments, those skilled in the art can clearly understand that this application can be implemented by means of software plus necessary general-purpose hardware, or it can be implemented by special-purpose hardware including application-specific integrated circuits, special-purpose CPUs, special-purpose memory, special-purpose components, etc. Generally, any function performed by a computer program can be easily implemented by corresponding hardware, and the specific hardware structure used to implement the same function can also be diverse, such as analog circuits, digital circuits, or special-purpose circuits. However, for this application, software program implementation is more often the preferred implementation method. Based on this understanding, the technical solution of this application, in essence, or the part that contributes to the prior art, can be embodied in the form of a software product. This computer software product is stored in a readable storage medium, such as a computer floppy disk, USB flash drive, mobile hard disk, ROM, RAM, magnetic disk, or optical disk, etc., and includes several instructions to cause a computer device (which may be a personal computer, training equipment, or network device, etc.) to execute the methods described in the various embodiments of this application.
[0137] In the above embodiments, implementation can be achieved, in whole or in part, through software, hardware, firmware, or any combination thereof. When implemented in software, it can be implemented, in whole or in part, as a computer program product.
[0138] The computer program product includes one or more computer instructions. When the computer program instructions are loaded and executed on a computer, all or part of the processes or functions described in the embodiments of this application are generated. The computer may be a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, a computer network, or other programmable device. The computer instructions may be stored in a computer-readable storage medium or transmitted from one computer-readable storage medium to another. For example, the computer instructions may be transmitted from one website, computer, training device, or data center to another website, computer, training device, or data center via wired (e.g., coaxial cable, fiber optic, digital subscriber line (DSL)) or wireless (e.g., infrared, wireless, microwave, etc.) means. The computer-readable storage medium may be any available medium that a computer can store or a data storage device such as a training device or data center that integrates one or more available media. The available media may be magnetic media (e.g., floppy disks, hard disks, magnetic tapes), optical media (e.g., DVDs), or semiconductor media (e.g., solid-state drives (SSDs)).
Claims
1. A method for automatically verifying poles in modal analysis of a switching device, applied to an electronic device, characterized in that, The automatic verification method includes the following steps: The frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed is obtained and a steady-state diagram is generated accordingly. The modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram are then obtained. The first-level verification of the pole clusters is performed: representative poles of each pole cluster are extracted, and the damping ratio of the representative poles is compared with the preset reference damping ratio to determine the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles. Calculate the similarity between different pole clusters, merge pole clusters whose similarity meets the preset conditions, and obtain updated pole clusters; The updated pole cluster is then subjected to a second-level verification: the modal contribution of each pole is calculated, the modal contribution is compared with a preset reference contribution, and poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions are removed as false poles. The pole results after the second-level verification are compared with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process.
2. The automatic authentication method of claim 1, wherein, The calculation of the similarity between different pole clusters includes the following steps: Calculate the frequency distance between representative poles of each pole cluster, and the modal confidence criterion values between the modal participation factors corresponding to each representative pole; When the frequency distance is less than a first preset threshold and the modal confidence criterion value is less than a second preset threshold, it is determined that the similarity between the corresponding pole clusters meets the preset conditions, and the corresponding pole clusters are merged.
3. The automatic authentication method of claim 1, wherein, The first-level verification of the pole cluster includes the following steps: The first contribution value is calculated based on the change in the fitting residual of the frequency response function with and without the corresponding poles. When the first contribution value is negative, the corresponding pole is directly determined to be a false pole and removed. When the first contribution value is positive and less than a first preset multiple of the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the corresponding pole is determined to be a false pole and is removed.
4. The automatic authentication method of claim 3, wherein, The first-level verification of the pole cluster further includes the following steps: Before calculating the modal contribution of each pole, it is determined whether the damping ratio of each pole is less than a preset multiple of the maximum damping ratio of the reference pole. Poles with damping ratios greater than or equal to the preset multiple are discarded as false poles.
5. The automatic authentication method of claim 3, wherein, The first-level verification of the pole cluster further includes the following steps: Based on the combined scaling values of the mode shape, participation factor, natural frequency and damping ratio at the corresponding pole, the summation is applied to all output channels and input points, and then normalized by the total contribution of all modes to calculate the second contribution value. When the second contribution value is less than the second preset ratio of the minimum contribution value in the reference cluster, the corresponding pole is determined to be a false pole and is removed.
6. The automatic authentication method of claim 1, wherein, The step of comparing the pole results after the second-level verification with the preset reference data includes the following steps: Compare the difference in the number of modes between the pole results and the preset reference data; Compare the difference in synthesized frequency response function between the pole results and the preset reference data; The frequency of the pole results is compared with that of the selected mode in the preset reference data.
7. The automatic authentication method of claim 1, wherein, The step of solidifying the verification method into a standardized verification process includes the following steps: Establish a verification parameter library according to the structural type of the object to be analyzed; For objects to be analyzed that have the same structure type as those already existing in the verification parameter library, the automatic verification method is executed by directly calling the corresponding parameters in the verification parameter library. For objects with entirely new structural types to be analyzed, after comparing and confirming the automatic verification results with expert analysis data, the corresponding verification parameters are included in the verification parameter library.
8. An apparatus for automatically verifying poles in modal analysis of a switching device, applied to an electronic device, characterized by, The automatic verification device includes The data acquisition module is configured to acquire the frequency response function data of the object to be analyzed and generate a steady-state diagram accordingly, and acquire the modal poles and their respective pole clusters in the steady-state diagram; The first verification module is configured to perform a first-level verification on the pole clusters: extract representative poles of each pole cluster, compare the damping ratio of the representative poles with a preset reference damping ratio, and determine the rationality of the damping ratio of the representative poles. Calculate the similarity between different pole clusters, merge pole clusters whose similarity meets the preset conditions, and obtain updated pole clusters; The second verification module is configured to perform a second-level verification on the updated pole cluster: calculate the modal contribution of each pole, compare the modal contribution with a preset reference contribution, and remove poles whose contribution does not meet the preset conditions as false poles. The result comparison and solidification module is configured to compare the pole results after the second-level verification with preset reference data. When the comparison results meet the preset conditions, the verification method is solidified into a standardized verification process.
9. An electronic device, comprising: The electronic device includes at least one processor and a memory connected to the processor, wherein: The memory is used to store computer programs or instructions; The processor is used to execute the computer program or instructions to enable the electronic device to implement the automatic verification method as described in any one of claims 1 to 7. 10.A storage medium readable by a computer, applied to an electronic device, and having stored thereon a plurality of instructions which, when executed by the electronic device, cause the electronic device to perform the method of any one of claims 1 to 9. The storage medium carries one or more computer programs that can be executed by the electronic device, thereby enabling the electronic device to implement the automatic verification method as described in any one of claims 1 to 7.
