Impact fatigue simulation method based on weld principal stress equivalent: component wall thickness reduction design method

By adopting a wall thickness reduction design method based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld, the problem of difficulty in evaluating the fatigue performance of large-size welded structures on conventional test equipment in the existing technology is solved, and the effect of accurately reproducing the fatigue performance of the weld is achieved under reduced load.

CN123116679APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17CHINA NORTH VEHICLE RES INST
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611268603.9
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-08-20
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing methods for designing impact fatigue simulation components for welded structures cannot accurately reproduce the weld fatigue performance of original-sized structures while reducing test loads. In particular, the evaluation of large-sized structures is difficult to conduct on conventional testing equipment.

Method used

A wall thickness scaling design method based on equivalent principal stress of weld was adopted. The wall thickness of the simulated part was adjusted through finite element analysis and iterative adjustment to ensure that the maximum first principal stress of the dangerous point of the weld of the simulated part matches the original size structure. The test was carried out on a conventional test device.

Benefits of technology

This method enables accurate reproduction of weld fatigue performance of original-sized welded structures under reduced test loads, thereby reducing test costs and implementation difficulty, and ensuring the reliability and accuracy of test results.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123116679A_ABST
    Figure CN123116679A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention discloses a wall thickness scaling design method for impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent weld principal stress. The method includes first establishing a finite element model of the original-size welded structure, applying design loads for static analysis, and extracting the maximum first principal stress at the weld's critical point. Then, a geometrically similar simulation part model is constructed, using wall thickness as the single design variable, maintaining consistency with the original structure in weld geometry, weld leg size, and material properties. The wall thickness is iteratively adjusted to ensure that the relative deviation of the principal stress at the critical point of the weld between the simulation part and the original structure meets a preset threshold. This method, using equivalent weld principal stress as the criterion, can reproduce the stress level of the critical point of the weld in the original structure while significantly reducing the test load, thus solving the problem of load capacity limitations of conventional testing equipment in impact fatigue testing of large-size welded structures.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention relates to the field of structural fatigue testing technology, and in particular to a method for designing a wall thickness reduction model of an impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld. Background Technology

[0002] The fatigue performance evaluation of welded structures under impact loads typically requires verification using specialized fatigue testing equipment. For welded structural components with large actual dimensions, the designed impact load often far exceeds the rated loading capacity of conventional testing equipment, and the preparation and testing costs of full-scale tests are too high.

[0003] To reduce the difficulty of conducting tests, scaled-down replicas are commonly used in engineering to replace the original-sized structures for fatigue testing. Existing design approaches mainly fall into two categories. The first is a comprehensive scaling-down method based on geometric similarity theory, which scales all geometric dimensions of the structure to a uniform ratio. This method simultaneously reduces plate thickness and weld dimensions, altering welding metallurgical factors such as weld leg height and heat-affected zone range. It cannot accurately reproduce the intrinsic fatigue performance of the original structure's welds, resulting in a fundamental deviation between the fatigue life and failure patterns obtained from the test and the original-sized structure. The second is the equal-thickness scaling-down method, which keeps the shell plate thickness and weld dimensions unchanged, scaling only the cross-sectional dimensions of the structure. This method's design criterion is the maximum loading cross-sectional dimension constraint of the loading device, determining the scaling ratio only from a geometric adaptability perspective, without considering the core mechanical parameter of the stress state at the weld's critical points as a design basis. Furthermore, because the plate thickness remains unchanged, the overall structural stiffness is not significantly reduced, failing to effectively reduce the load magnitude required for the test and remaining difficult to adapt to conventional small-tonnage testing equipment.

[0004] In summary, existing simulation design methods all rely on geometric compatibility or spatial adaptability as the core criteria, which have drawbacks such as design guidance deviation, insufficient mechanical equivalence, and limited load reduction effect. They cannot simultaneously meet the requirements of consistent weld metallurgical performance and significant reduction of test load, making it difficult to achieve accurate fatigue performance evaluation of large-size, high-impact welded structures. Summary of the Invention

[0005] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for designing the wall thickness reduction ratio of impact fatigue simulation parts based on the equivalent principal stress of welds, so as to solve the above-mentioned technical problems existing in the prior art. The specific technical solution is as follows: A method for designing impact fatigue simulation parts with reduced wall thickness based on equivalent principal stress of welds includes establishing a finite element model of the original-size welded structure and constructing a finite element model of the simulation part that is geometrically similar to the original-size welded structure. The method comprises the following steps: S1: Apply design loads to the finite element model of the original-size welded structure and perform static analysis to extract the maximum first principal stress value of the weld critical point; S2: Using the wall thickness of the simulated part as the single design variable, the initial value of the wall thickness is set to be less than the wall thickness of the original welded structure, and the weld geometry, weld leg size and material properties of the simulated part are consistent with those of the original welded structure. S3: Apply the same type of load and boundary conditions as the original-sized welded structure to the simulated part, perform static analysis, and extract the maximum first principal stress value of the dangerous point of the weld in the simulated part; S4: Compare the maximum first principal stress value of the simulated part with that of the original welded structure. If the relative deviation exceeds the preset threshold, adjust the wall thickness and repeat step S3 until the deviation is less than the preset threshold. S5: Outputs the wall thickness of the simulated part that meets the deviation requirements, so that the simulated part can reproduce the stress level of the dangerous point of the weld of the original size welded structure under reduced test load.

[0006] Furthermore, in steps S1 and S3, a refined mesh is used in the dangerous areas of the weld, and the mesh scale of the dangerous areas of the weld in the simulated part is consistent with that in the original weld structure.

[0007] Furthermore, the dangerous area of ​​the weld is the stress concentration area at the edge of the weld leg.

[0008] Furthermore, in step S2, the weld type and weld leg geometry of the simulated component are consistent with the original welded structure.

[0009] Furthermore, the simulated component was prepared using the same welding process as the original-sized welded structure.

[0010] Furthermore, in step S4, the wall thickness adjustment rule is as follows: if the maximum first principal stress of the simulated part is lower than that of the original size welded structure, then the wall thickness is reduced; if the maximum first principal stress of the simulated part is higher than that of the original size welded structure, then the wall thickness is increased.

[0011] Furthermore, in step S2, the material mechanical properties of the simulated component are kept consistent with those of the original-sized welded structure.

[0012] Furthermore, in step S2, the relative geometric relationship between the load application position of the simulated component and the test part remains consistent with that of the original-sized welded structure.

[0013] Furthermore, the design load is the design impact load of the original-size welded structure, and the simulated part is used for impact fatigue testing of the original-size welded structure.

[0014] Furthermore, by reducing the wall thickness, the load required for impact fatigue testing is reduced to the rated load range of the electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing device.

[0015] The wall thickness reduction design method for impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent weld principal stress of the present invention has the following advantages: 1. By using the equivalent first principal stress at the maximum critical point of the weld as the core design criterion, and through iterative adjustment of a single wall thickness variable, the scaled-down design of the impact fatigue simulation part is achieved. This overcomes the limitations of existing equal-thickness scaling methods, which cannot reduce test loads, and full geometric scaling changes the intrinsic fatigue properties of the weld. Under the premise of significantly reducing test loads, the stress level of the critical point of the weld in the original-size welded structure can be accurately reproduced. This allows fatigue tests of large-tonnage impact welded structures to be carried out on conventional electro-hydraulic servo testing equipment, effectively reducing the threshold and cost of test implementation.

[0016] 2. By using a finer mesh at the critical location of the weld and maintaining the same mesh size between the simulated part and the original welded structure at the critical location, the high stress gradient distribution at the weld edge can be accurately captured, eliminating numerical calculation errors caused by differences in mesh size. This ensures that the stress calculation results of the original structure and the simulated part are comparable and provides a reliable calculation basis for the accurate determination of principal stress equivalence.

[0017] 3. The critical area of ​​the weld is identified as the stress concentration area at the edge of the weld leg. The target of the equivalent design is directly aimed at the initiation location of impact fatigue cracks in the welded structure, avoiding the design redundancy caused by the full-domain stress equivalence. This allows the scaled-down design to accurately act on the control area of ​​fatigue failure, ensuring that the test failure mode of the simulated part is consistent with that of the original welded structure.

[0018] 4. By keeping the weld type and weld leg geometry of the simulated part consistent with the original weld structure, the stress concentration factor at the weld can be matched with the original structure, the stress distribution pattern in the weld area remains unchanged, and the weld size scaling problem caused by full geometric scaling is avoided, providing an accurate geometric basis for reproducing the weld fatigue characteristics of the original structure.

[0019] 5. The simulated part should be prepared using the same welding process as the original welded structure to ensure that the metallographic structure, heat-affected zone range and properties, and initial defect level of the weld are consistent with the original structure, so that the intrinsic fatigue performance of the weld of the simulated part is consistent with the original structure, and the impact fatigue test results can truly reflect the fatigue failure law of the original welded structure.

[0020] 6. The corresponding adjustment rules for wall thickness and stress level are clarified. Based on the mechanical relationship between wall thickness and structural bending stiffness, the stress is directionally controlled, which can ensure that the iterative process always converges in the correct direction, reduce the number of invalid calculations, improve the calculation efficiency of principal stress equivalent design, and quickly obtain the simulated part wall thickness parameters that meet the deviation requirements. Attached Figure Description

[0021] Figure 1 This is a flowchart of the impact fatigue simulation component wall thickness reduction design method based on the equivalent principal stress of weld seams, according to the present invention.

[0022] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the finite element model for static analysis of the original-size welded structure in the impact fatigue simulation component wall thickness reduction design method based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld seam in this invention.

[0023] Figure 3 This invention provides a cloud map showing the stress distribution at the edge of the weld leg of a welded structure in the original-size welded structure, based on the impact fatigue simulation design method with wall thickness reduction using equivalent principal stress of welds.

[0024] Figure 4 This invention relates to a stress distribution cloud map at the weld foot edge of a simulated impact fatigue simulation part, based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld seam and the wall thickness reduction design method.

[0025] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram of the test fixture model of the impact fatigue simulation part in the present invention based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld and the wall thickness reduction design method.

[0026] Figure 6 This invention presents the load amplitude-life curve of the impact fatigue test simulation part in the wall thickness reduction design method of the impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld. Detailed Implementation

[0027] To better understand the purpose, structure, and function of this invention, the following detailed description of the wall thickness reduction design method for impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds is provided in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

[0028] like Figures 1 to 6 As shown, this embodiment takes the welded structure of a titanium alloy limiter 1 of a certain type of vehicle as the design object. This structure needs to withstand large-tonnage impact loads during operation. The rated load of conventional electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing devices cannot cover the test requirements of the full-size structure. Therefore, this method is used to design a scaled-down impact fatigue simulation part to reproduce the stress state of the dangerous point of the weld of the original-size welded structure under a reduced test load.

[0029] First, stress analysis of the weld critical point of the original-size welded structure is conducted. A finite element model of the original-size welded structure is established by cutting out limiter 1 and part of the vehicle body structure 2. Since impact fatigue cracks in welded structures usually initiate at the position of maximum tensile stress at the weld toe, the first principal stress corresponds to the maximum tensile stress component at this location and is the core mechanical index that determines the initiation and propagation rate of fatigue cracks. Therefore, this embodiment selects the maximum first principal stress at the weld critical point as the equivalent criterion, directly targeting the control factor of structural fatigue failure, and ensuring that the test results of the simulated part have a clear correspondence with the fatigue performance of the original-size welded structure. Considering that the stress gradient in the weld foot edge area is large, coarse mesh calculation is prone to large numerical errors. This embodiment uses a refined mesh in the stress concentration area at the weld foot edge to improve the accuracy of stress calculation. Limiter 1 is welded to the vehicle body structure 2 on one side, and the weld foot height between the two is 10mm. An arc-shaped rubber pad is installed on the impact surface of limiter 1 so that the load is concentrated in the middle of the impact surface. The hammer head impacting limiter 1 has a hemispherical surface with a radius of 200mm, and the center line of the hammer head is 50mm away from the connection surface between limiter 1 and the vehicle body. Fixed supports are applied to both sides of the vehicle body simulation component. The translational degree of freedom in the loading direction is released at the hammer head reference point, while all other degrees of freedom are constrained. A concentrated design impact load of 500kN is applied to the hammer head reference point, and linear elastic static analysis is performed. The maximum first principal stress value at the critical point of the weld is extracted as the benchmark for subsequent equivalent design. In this embodiment, the maximum first principal stress of the original-size welded structure is approximately 2362MPa. The high-stress area is concentrated at the edge of the weld leg, and the stress is mainly generated by the bending deformation of the impact surface of the limiter 1 after being loaded.

[0030] Subsequently, an initial finite element model of the simulated component was constructed. The overall geometry of the simulated component remained similar to that of the original-sized welded structure. During the design process, wall thickness was used as the sole design variable, and the initial wall thickness was set to a value smaller than that of the original-sized welded structure. Fatigue performance is determined by both metallurgical and mechanical factors. The weld leg geometry, weld type, and welding process directly determine the weld formation quality, the microstructure of the heat-affected zone, and the initial defect level, which are the core metallurgical factors affecting the intrinsic fatigue performance of the weld. If the weld size is scaled synchronously with the wall thickness, the fatigue characteristics of the weld itself will change, causing the simulated component test results to lose their reference value to the original structure. Therefore, in this embodiment, the weld type and weld leg geometry of the simulated component are consistent with the original-sized welded structure, and the same welding process is used to prepare it, ensuring that the metallurgical state of the weld area is homologous to the original structure. At the same time, the material mechanical properties of the simulated component are consistent with the original-sized welded structure, and the relative geometric relationship between the load application position and the weld test area remains unchanged with the original structure, ensuring that the stress mode and stress distribution of the simulated component match the original structure, and avoiding a fundamental change in stress state due to geometric deviation.

[0031] Next, static calculations were performed on the simulated component to obtain the stress levels at critical points in the weld. To ensure the reliability of the stress comparison and eliminate systematic errors caused by differences in calculation conditions, the simulated component was subjected to the same type of loads and boundary conditions as the original welded structure. Furthermore, static analysis was conducted at critical locations on the weld edge using the same mesh scale as the original structure, extracting the maximum first principal stress value at the corresponding location in the original structure. This uniformity of calculation conditions ensures that changes in stress levels are caused only by adjustments to the wall thickness parameters, providing a foundation for subsequent precise stress control through wall thickness.

[0032] Subsequently, principal stress equivalence is achieved by iteratively adjusting the wall thickness. Under the bending-dominated stress mode, the bending stiffness of the structural section is approximately positively correlated with the cube of the wall thickness. Reducing the wall thickness significantly decreases the structural stiffness, and the bending stress at the weld will increase accordingly under the same load; conversely, increasing the wall thickness will decrease the stress level. Based on this mechanical law, this embodiment uses an iterative method to adjust the wall thickness: the maximum first principal stress calculated from the simulated component is compared with the reference value of the original-size welded structure. If the stress of the simulated component is lower than the reference value, the wall thickness is further reduced to increase the stress level; if the stress of the simulated component is higher than the reference value, the wall thickness is increased to reduce the stress level. The stress calculation and wall thickness adjustment process is repeated until the relative deviation of the maximum first principal stress at the critical point of the weld between the simulated component and the original-size welded structure is less than a preset threshold, which is considered to satisfy the principal stress equivalence condition. In this embodiment, after multiple rounds of iterative calculations, the wall thickness of the simulated component was finally determined to be 7.7 mm. Under a test load of 100 kN, the maximum first principal stress at the critical point of the weld of the simulated component was approximately 2394 MPa, which was basically consistent with the elastic calculation results of the original structure. The maximum displacement of the simulated component in the loading direction was approximately 3.1 mm, and the equivalent accuracy met the test requirements.

[0033] Finally, the final design parameters are output and experimental verification is conducted. The wall thickness that satisfies the principal stress equivalence condition is used as the final design parameter of the simulation part. Based on this parameter, the test simulation part is fabricated and a matching test fixture is designed. The simulation part is connected to the fixed fixture through fasteners. Both the fixed fixture and the lower surface of the simulation part are in contact with the test platform surface to avoid the fasteners bearing shear loads. The loading point is located within the envelope of the contact area between the positioning fixture and the test platform surface to avoid the test part being subjected to additional bending moments. Through the wall thickness reduction design, the simulation part can achieve a weld critical point stress level comparable to that of the original-size welded structure under the design impact load under a significantly reduced test load. This reduces the load required for impact fatigue testing to within the rated load range of conventional electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing equipment, effectively solving the problem of equipment capacity limitations in impact fatigue testing of large-tonnage welded structures. In this embodiment, the original structure was designed with an impact load of 500kN, exceeding the rated load of a conventional 100kN electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing device. The simulated component designed using this method only requires a 100kN load to reproduce the stress level at the critical point of the original structure's weld, allowing for direct impact fatigue testing on a conventional testing device. This embodiment fabricated nine simulated components, and impact fatigue tests with loads of 2T, 4T, 6T, and 10T were applied to them on the electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing device. The number of impact fracture cycles for each sample was recorded, yielding the impact fatigue load amplitude-life curve, providing reliable experimental data for evaluating the fatigue performance of the original-size welded structure.

[0034] The terms “above,” “below,” and “within” as used above include the number itself; the terms “exceeding” and “excluding” do not include the number itself.

[0035] The present invention has been further described above with reference to specific embodiments. However, it should be understood that the specific descriptions herein should not be construed as limiting the substance and scope of the present invention. Various modifications made to the above embodiments by those skilled in the art after reading this specification are all within the scope of protection of the present invention. The various specific technical features described in the above embodiments can be combined in any suitable manner without contradiction. To avoid unnecessary repetition, the embodiments of the present invention will not further describe various possible combinations.

[0036] If the embodiments of the present invention involve directional indicators (such as up, down, left, right, front, back, etc.), the directional indicators are only used to explain the relative positional relationship and movement of each component in a certain specific posture (as shown in the figure). If the specific posture changes, the directional indicators will also change accordingly.

Claims

1. A method for designing impact fatigue simulation parts with reduced wall thickness based on equivalent principal stress of welds, comprising establishing a finite element model of the original-size welded structure and constructing a finite element model of the simulation part geometrically similar to the original-size welded structure, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: S1: Apply design loads to the finite element model of the original-size welded structure and perform static analysis to extract the maximum first principal stress value of the weld critical point; S2: Using the wall thickness of the simulated part as the single design variable, the initial value of the wall thickness is set to be less than the wall thickness of the original welded structure, and the weld geometry, weld leg size and material properties of the simulated part are consistent with those of the original welded structure. S3: Apply the same type of load and boundary conditions as the original-sized welded structure to the simulated part, perform static analysis, and extract the maximum first principal stress value of the dangerous point of the weld in the simulated part; S4: Compare the maximum first principal stress value of the simulated part with that of the original welded structure. If the relative deviation exceeds the preset threshold, adjust the wall thickness and repeat step S3 until the deviation is less than the preset threshold. S5: Outputs the wall thickness of the simulated part that meets the deviation requirements, so that the simulated part can reproduce the stress level of the dangerous point of the weld of the original size welded structure under reduced test load.

2. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds according to claim 1, characterized in that, In steps S1 and S3, a refined mesh is used in the dangerous areas of the weld, and the mesh scale of the dangerous areas of the weld in the simulated part is consistent with that of the original weld structure.

3. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds according to claim 2, characterized in that, The dangerous area of ​​the weld is the stress concentration area at the edge of the weld foot.

4. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds according to claim 1, characterized in that, In step S2, the weld type and weld leg geometry of the simulated part are consistent with the original welded structure.

5. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of an impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld, as described in claim 4, is characterized in that... The simulated component was prepared using the same welding process as the original-sized welded structure.

6. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of an impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of welds according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that, In step S4, the wall thickness adjustment rule is as follows: if the maximum first principal stress of the simulated part is lower than that of the original size welded structure, the wall thickness is reduced; if the maximum first principal stress of the simulated part is higher than that of the original size welded structure, the wall thickness is increased.

7. The method for designing wall thickness scaling of impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that, In step S2, the material mechanical properties of the simulated component are kept consistent with those of the original welded structure.

8. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of an impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of welds according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that, In step S2, the relative geometric relationship between the load application position of the simulated part and the test part is consistent with that of the original size welded structure.

9. The method for designing wall thickness scaling of impact fatigue simulation parts based on equivalent principal stress of welds according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that, The design load is the design impact load of the original-size welded structure, and the simulated component is used for impact fatigue testing of the original-size welded structure.

10. The method for designing the wall thickness ratio of an impact fatigue simulation part based on the equivalent principal stress of the weld, as described in claim 9, is characterized in that... By reducing the wall thickness, the load required for impact fatigue testing is reduced to the rated load range of the electro-hydraulic servo fatigue testing device.