A method and system for evaluating lane closure schemes

By using microscopic traffic simulation software and traffic conflict analysis, lane closure schemes for the maintenance operation control zone of a two-way ten-lane highway are quantitatively evaluated. This solves the problem of strong subjectivity in the evaluation methods of existing technologies and achieves quantitative comparison and selection of schemes while balancing safety and efficiency.

CN123117934APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17JIANGSU MODERN ENG TESTING CO LTD +1
View PDF 1 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611622075.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-10-20
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies lack methods for quantitatively evaluating lane closure schemes in the maintenance control zone of a two-way ten-lane highway, making it difficult to balance safety and efficient service. They rely heavily on experience or on-site tests, which are highly subjective and have limited evaluation dimensions.

Method used

A model of the maintenance operation control area was built using microscopic traffic simulation software. The average delay, queue length, number of conflicts and encounter time were output through simulation. The normalized scores of traffic capacity and safety performance were calculated and weighted to determine the optimal lane closure scheme.

Benefits of technology

It enables quantifiable comparison of lane closure schemes that are calculable, reproducible, and verifiable, allowing for a comprehensive evaluation of multiple schemes before maintenance work, balancing traffic efficiency and safety performance, and reducing accident risks.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN123117934A_ABST
    Figure CN123117934A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention belongs to the field of traffic safety technology, and specifically relates to a method for evaluating lane closure schemes. This method involves comprehensively evaluating the performance of six lane closure schemes for the maintenance of the third lane of a ten-lane highway. A higher comprehensive performance score for scheme i indicates better overall performance (where i is the sequence number of each lane closure scheme, a positive integer less than or equal to n, where n is the total number of schemes). This evaluation method comprehensively considers the traffic capacity and safety performance of the ten-lane maintenance section, and can objectively and directly determine the optimal lane closure scheme for maintaining the third lane.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention belongs to the field of traffic safety technology, and in particular relates to a method and system for evaluating lane closure schemes. Background Technology

[0002] During highway operation, periodic maintenance work is required on the road surface, bridges, and traffic safety facilities. During maintenance, some lanes must be closed, forming a maintenance control zone consisting of a warning zone, upstream transition zone, buffer zone, work zone, downstream transition zone, and termination zone. Which lanes are closed directly determines the traffic efficiency and operational risks of vehicles within the work zone: too few closed lanes result in concentrated lateral interference between the work zone and passing vehicles, frequent merging and diverging, and a decline in the safety performance of the work zone; too many closed lanes reduce the number of available lanes, drastically reducing the section's capacity and rapidly increasing vehicle delays and queue lengths. Therefore, the rational selection of lane closure schemes is a core aspect of the layout of maintenance control zones.

[0003] Compared to traditional eight-lane or smaller expressways, ten-lane expressways have five lanes in each direction. These expressways experience higher traffic volumes, a greater number of lanes, and significant functional differences between lanes, significantly increasing the complexity of maintenance control zone layout. Due to the significantly increased number of lane combinations available for closure and utilization, lane closure schemes within maintenance control zones exhibit diversity, making it impossible to simply apply the layout methods provided by existing standards for eight-lane or smaller expressways. Taking the third lane in a five-lane roadway as an example, in addition to closing only the third lane, the second and third lanes, the third and fourth lanes, or multiple lanes can be closed while opening one or both emergency lanes on each side. There are at least six possible solutions, and the advantages and disadvantages of each solution in terms of traffic capacity and safety performance often differ between directions.

[0004] However, the current standards and specifications, such as the "Technical Standards for Highway Engineering" (JTG B01-2014), the "Safety Operation Procedures for Highway Maintenance" (JTGH30-2015), the "Road Traffic Signs and Markings Part 4: Work Zones" (GB 5768.4-2017), and the "Technical Specifications for Construction Safety of Expressway Maintenance Engineering" (DB32 / T 1363-2017), mainly stipulate the safety of maintenance operations for expressways with eight lanes or less. They lack safety layout regulations for maintenance operation control zones of expressways with ten lanes or more in both directions, and do not provide a method for comparing lane closure schemes.

[0005] Existing research has explored the layout schemes of highway maintenance work zones (e.g., application publication number CN117746656 A), but research on maintenance work control zones for ten-lane highways is limited, especially lacking a reasonable method for quantitatively evaluating lane closure schemes. In engineering practice, closure schemes are often determined based on the experience of technical personnel or through on-site test comparisons. This approach is highly subjective and has a single evaluation dimension, often focusing only on traffic capacity or a single aspect of safety. It is impossible to objectively compare multiple schemes before operations begin, and it is also difficult to quantitatively characterize the comprehensive differences between schemes in terms of delays, queuing, and conflicts. As a result, it is difficult to balance safety and efficient service in ten-lane highway maintenance operations. Summary of the Invention

[0006] The purpose of this invention is to address the aforementioned technical problems by providing a method and system for evaluating lane closure schemes.

[0007] In view of this, the present invention provides a method for evaluating lane closure schemes, comprising the following steps: Step 1: Determine the n lane closure schemes to be evaluated, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 3, and the sequence number of each lane closure scheme is i, i=1,2,...,n. Each lane closure scheme is used to specify the lanes closed in the maintenance operation control area of ​​the third lane of a ten-lane highway and the lanes available for vehicle passage. Step 2: Using microscopic traffic simulation software, build simulation models of the maintenance operation control areas corresponding to the n lane closure schemes and run the simulations. After the simulations are completed, output the average delay of each lane closure scheme. Queue length And vehicle trajectory files; Step 3: Based on the average delay of each lane closure plan and queue length Calculate the normalized passability score of scheme i. The normalized score of the traffic capacity With average delay and queue length The decrease increases; Step 4: Import the vehicle trajectory files for each lane closure scheme into the traffic conflict analysis software, and output the number of conflicts for each lane closure scheme. and encounter time The encounter time The statistical value of the conflict time corresponding to the identified traffic conflict; the larger the value, the more moderate the conflict between vehicles. Step 5: Based on the number of conflicts for each lane closure plan. and encounter time Calculate the normalized score of the safety performance of scheme i. The security performance normalization score With the number of conflicts The reduction and encounter time It increases with the increase of; Step 6: Normalize the traffic capacity score of scheme i. With safety performance normalized score After weighting, the overall performance score of scheme i is obtained:

[0008] In the formula, The weights for the normalized score of traffic capacity, The weights for the normalized safety performance score, and k is a correction coefficient greater than 0, used to adjust the overall magnitude of the comprehensive performance score. Its value does not change the relative size and ranking of the comprehensive performance scores of each scheme. Step 7: Compare the comprehensive performance scores of the n lane closure schemes, and select the lane closure scheme corresponding to the maximum comprehensive performance score as the recommended lane closure scheme for the maintenance of the third lane of the ten-lane highway. Step 8: According to the lane closure scheme selected in Step 7, which closes the lanes and allows vehicle passage, in accordance with the requirements of the Highway Maintenance Safety Operation Regulations regarding the layout of warning zones, upstream transition zones, buffer zones, work zones, downstream transition zones, and termination zones, install signs, markings, and isolation facilities in the corresponding zones of the maintenance operation control area.

[0009] Furthermore, the n lane closure schemes are 6 in total, including: ① Only the third lane is closed; ② Close the second and third lanes; ③ Close the third and fourth lanes; ④ The first, second, and third lanes are closed, while the outer emergency lane is open for vehicle passage; ⑤ Close lanes 3, 4, and 5; the inner emergency lane is open to traffic. ⑥ The second, third, and fourth lanes are closed, while the emergency lanes on both sides are open to traffic.

[0010] Furthermore, in step three, the traffic capacity normalization score... Calculate using the following formula:

[0011]

[0012]

[0013] In the formula, Let i be the normalized value of the average delay for scheme i. Let i be the normalized value of the queue length for scheme i; smaller and The smaller the value, the better the traffic capacity of scheme i. The larger.

[0014] Furthermore, in step five, the security performance normalization score... Calculate using the following formula:

[0015]

[0016]

[0017] In the formula, Let i be the normalized value of the number of conflicts. Let i be the normalized value of the encounter time of scheme i; smaller and The larger the value, the better the security performance of scheme i. The larger.

[0018] Furthermore, the normalized score for traffic capacity... With the aforementioned safety performance normalized score All scores are relative, and their values ​​vary depending on the composition of the set of alternative lane closure schemes. The merits of each lane closure scheme are determined based on the relative magnitude of the comprehensive performance score.

[0019] Furthermore, in step two, the micro-traffic simulation software is VISSIM, and the average delay... and queue length Output after running the simulation with VISSIM.

[0020] Furthermore, in step four, the traffic conflict analysis software is SSAM, and the number of conflicts... and encounter time The SSAM performs conflict detection based on the vehicle's kinematic parameters in the vehicle trajectory file and then outputs the result.

[0021] Furthermore, in step six, the weights and The requirements for road capacity and traffic safety performance in the work area are determined based on the needs of the road management authority for the maintenance work section; when both road capacity and traffic safety performance in the work area are equally important, .

[0022] Furthermore, in step eight, the deployment of signs, markings, and isolation facilities is a conventional deployment carried out in each zone according to the provisions of GB 5768.4-2017, including: setting up construction warning signs, speed limit signs, and lane reduction signs in the warning zone; setting up directional arrows and cone-shaped traffic signs in the upstream transition zone; setting up crash barriers, water-filled barriers, and mobile sign vehicles in the buffer zone; setting up isolation facilities along the closed lanes in the work zone to confine the working machinery and personnel within the work zone; setting up cone-shaped traffic signs in the downstream transition zone; setting up speed limit cancellation signs in the termination zone; and when the selected lane closure scheme includes opening the emergency lane, setting up emergency lane opening signs, guide signs, and isolation facilities at the beginning and end of the open section of the emergency lane.

[0023] A lane closure scheme evaluation system for performing the above method includes: The scheme determination module is used to determine the n lane closure schemes to be evaluated and their sequence numbers i, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 3; The simulation module is used to build and run simulation models of maintenance operation control zones corresponding to various lane closure schemes based on microscopic traffic simulation software, and outputs the average delay. Queue length and vehicle trajectory files; The traffic capacity assessment module is used to evaluate traffic based on average delay. and queue length Calculate the normalized capacity score ; The safety performance evaluation module is used to import vehicle trajectory files into traffic conflict analysis software to obtain the number of conflicts. and encounter time Based on this, a normalized safety performance score is calculated. ; The comprehensive evaluation module is used to evaluate... and The overall performance score is obtained by weighting. , ; The scheme output module is used to output the lane closure scheme corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive performance score, as well as the location of the closed lane, the length of the operation control zone, and the layout parameters of the signs and markings corresponding to the lane closure scheme.

[0024] The beneficial effects of this invention are: This invention addresses the specific scenario of maintenance work on the third lane of a two-way ten-lane highway, providing a complete technical chain from scheme enumeration, simulation modeling, index extraction, normalized scoring, weighted synthesis to on-site deployment. This transforms the determination of lane closure schemes from experience-based judgment to a calculable, reproducible, and verifiable quantitative comparison.

[0025] In terms of traffic capacity, average delay and queue length are used as evaluation indicators, while in terms of safety performance, the number of conflicts and encounter time are used as evaluation indicators. Both types of indicators are normalized and then weighted. The scheme with the fewest closed lanes usually has the best traffic capacity but the worst safety performance, while the scheme with more closed lanes and open emergency lanes has the opposite effect. Comparing single indicators will lead to contradictory conclusions. This invention, through weighted synthesis, can select a scheme that balances traffic efficiency and work area safety.

[0026] Average delay and queue length are output by microscopic traffic simulation software, while the number of conflicts and encounter time are obtained by traffic conflict analysis software from vehicle trajectory files. There is no need to close real road sections for actual measurement, nor is there a need to wait for the accident to occur before counting conflicts. Multiple schemes can be evaluated in parallel before maintenance work is carried out, and simulations can be repeated for different traffic volume conditions.

[0027] Average delay, queue length, number of conflicts, and encounter time are measured in seconds per vehicle, meters, times, and seconds, respectively, and their dimensions and orders of magnitude are different. This invention first normalizes each indicator to a dimensionless value according to its proportion in the scheme set, and then performs weighting, avoiding the problem of large-order-of-magnitude indicators masking small-order-of-magnitude indicators when directly weighting.

[0028] Weight and The adjustment is determined by the management based on their priorities regarding traffic capacity and safety performance; sections with high traffic pressure may have their rates increased. Sections with high accident risk can be heightened. Since both types of normalized scores are dimensionless values ​​of the same magnitude, the ranking of the optimal scheme remains stable within the commonly used weight range. The scores are output in percentage form, which is intuitive and convenient for decision-making. Furthermore, since the sum of the normalized scores for traffic capacity and the sum of the normalized scores for safety performance of each scheme are both 1, the sum of the comprehensive performance scores of each scheme is always equal to 100k. This relationship is independent of the values ​​of α and β and can be used to verify whether the calculation process is correct, as well as to calibrate the value of the correction coefficient k.

[0029] The selected scheme is not only output in the form of a score, but also further transformed into the requirements for the layout of signs, markings and isolation facilities in the maintenance operation control area. The evaluation conclusions directly affect the physical object of road facilities, forming a complete technical solution from simulation evaluation to on-site layout.

[0030] The set of schemes used for evaluation is not limited to six. The management can add new closed combinations and recalculate. This evaluation framework can also be used for scheme comparison for maintenance operations on other lanes of a ten-lane highway, as well as for scheme verification under different traffic volume levels and speed limits. It provides a quantitative basis for the layout of maintenance operation control zones for similar road sections, which helps to reduce accidents and mortality rates in maintenance operation zones. Attached Figure Description

[0031] Figure 1 This is a flowchart of a lane closure scheme evaluation method proposed in this invention. Detailed Implementation

[0032] To facilitate review and implementation, this embodiment provides the following description of the internal implementation of the method, including the definition of terms and indicators, model structure, data processing, model parameter calibration and validity verification (i.e., the model training phase), and scenario integration.

[0033] Terminology conventions and indicator definitions: This embodiment applies to a ten-lane, two-way highway section, with five lanes in each direction. Starting from the side closest to the central divider, the lanes are numbered sequentially from the inside out: lane 1, lane 2, lane 3, lane 4, and lane 5. An emergency lane is also provided on the outer side. Lane 3 is the lane requiring maintenance, i.e., the middle lane of the five lanes in one direction. The lane numbers increase sequentially from the inside out, and this numbering method is uniquely determined by the alternative schemes: "Lane 1, 2, and 3 are closed, and the outer emergency lane is available" and "Lane 3, 4, and 5 are closed, and the inner emergency lane is available."

[0034] The maintenance operation control area is divided into six zones along the driving direction: warning zone, upstream transition zone, buffer zone, work zone, downstream transition zone, and termination zone. The functions of each zone are well known in the art: the warning zone is used to alert the driver that there is work ahead; the upstream transition zone is used to guide vehicles to gradually change from their original lane to a passable lane; the buffer zone provides a buffer space for vehicles that accidentally enter the work zone; the work zone is the area where maintenance work is carried out; the downstream transition zone is used to guide vehicles back to the normal lane; and the termination zone is used to remove the speed limit warning.

[0035] The four evaluation indicators used in this invention are defined as follows: Average delay The unit is s / veh, which refers to the average delay of all vehicles affected by the maintenance operation under scheme i. It is the average difference between the actual travel time of the vehicles and the travel time required to travel at the free flow speed. The smaller the value, the better the traffic capacity. Queue length The unit is m, which refers to the maximum length of vehicle queues formed upstream of the road segment affected by maintenance work under scheme i, or the average queue length during the evaluation period. The smaller the value, the better the traffic capacity. Number of conflicts The unit is "times," which refers to the total number of traffic conflicts identified by the traffic conflict analysis software based on vehicle trajectories under scheme i. The smaller the value, the better the safety performance. Encounter Time The unit s refers to the statistical value of the encounter time corresponding to the traffic conflict identified under scheme i. In this embodiment, the average value of the encounter time PET output by SSAM is taken. The larger the value, the more moderate the conflict between vehicles and the better the safety performance.

[0036] Structure of a microscopic traffic simulation model: This invention uses VISSIM microscopic traffic simulation software to build a simulation model of the maintenance operation control area. The model is functionally divided into six layers from top to bottom: road network topology layer, lane layer, operation control area layer, driving behavior layer, traffic demand layer, and data acquisition layer. The composition and parameter settings of each layer are as follows: Road network topology layer: The road topology of the maintenance operation section and the upstream and downstream impact range is constructed using Link and Connector. The simulation range extends upstream from the upstream end of the operation area by no less than 2 km and downstream from the downstream end of the operation area by no less than 1 km to cover the process of vehicle queue overflow and speed recovery. The horizontal and vertical alignment of the road section is set according to the measured design data.

[0037] Lane layer: Modeled as a five-lane road plus an outer emergency lane in one direction, with a single lane width of 3.75 m and an emergency lane width of 3.00 m; set lane function constraints according to the actual management rules of the road section, such as prohibiting large vehicles from entering the first lane and setting the expected lane selection behavior for each lane; the expected speed distribution of each lane is set according to the lane speed limit, with the expected speed of the inner lane being higher than that of the outer lane.

[0038] The operation control zone layer is modeled sequentially as follows: warning zone, upstream transition zone, buffer zone, work zone, downstream transition zone, and termination zone. Closed lanes are implemented using lane closure elements, meaning a no-entry zone is set at the corresponding lane at the start of the closed section. Speed ​​limits in the operation zone are implemented using reduced speed area elements, setting the desired vehicle speed distribution in the corresponding sections according to the speed limit grading scheme. When the emergency lane is open, the emergency lane section is modeled as a normally passable lane and its speed limit is set separately.

[0039] Driving behavior layer: The vehicle following adopts the Wiedemann 99 following model, which uses parameters CC0 to CC9 to describe the stopping distance between vehicles, headway, following fluctuation, threshold for entering following state, acceleration and deceleration threshold, vehicle speed vibration, and acceleration characteristics. The vehicle lane changing adopts the VISSIM lane changing model, which uses the maximum deceleration, acceptable deceleration, and safe distance reduction factor to describe the vehicle's lane changing decision.

[0040] Traffic demand layer: The vehicle composition is divided by vehicle type, including at least four categories: passenger cars, medium-sized cars, large cars, and container trucks. The length, acceleration and deceleration performance, expected speed distribution, and expected lane selection behavior of each type of vehicle are set. The vehicle input is set according to the traffic volume of the evaluation period in 15-minute increments to ensure that the traffic demand in the simulation changes with time and is consistent with the actual measurement. The path and turning ratio of vehicles in the road network are set according to the measured OD or cross-sectional turning observation results.

[0041] Data Acquisition Layer: In the simulation model, a travel time measurement segment is set to collect average delays, a queue counter is set to collect queue lengths, and data collection points are set to collect cross-sectional flow and vehicle speed to verify the model's validity. Vehicle trajectory recording is enabled to output vehicle trajectory files at fixed sampling periods for use in conflict analysis.

[0042] Of the six layers mentioned above, except for the closed lanes, passable lanes, and emergency lanes, whose open status is set separately for each alternative scheme, the remaining model structures and parameters remain completely consistent across the n alternative schemes, thereby ensuring that the evaluation results of each scheme are comparable.

[0043] Data Acquisition and Data Processing: Basic data collection: Collect the following basic data for the maintenance operation section: mainline cross-section traffic volume by vehicle type (veh / h) and its time distribution, lane-by-lane traffic flow distribution, segment operating speed and travel time, vehicle type composition ratio, peak hour traffic flow and peak hour coefficient, segment design speed and speed limit, road geometric parameters (number of lanes, lane width, horizontal and vertical alignment, emergency lane configuration), and maintenance operation organization plan (operation content, operation duration, operation period). Data collection can be conducted using methods such as loop detectors, video detection, radar detection, or floating car data. The collection period should cover both off-peak and peak hours for the evaluation.

[0044] Data cleaning and conversion: The collected data was processed according to the following rules: Abnormal records with speeds greater than 120 km / h or less than 20 km / h were removed; abnormal data periods caused by non-maintenance factors such as accidents or severe weather were removed; missing data periods were interpolated using the mean of adjacent workdays; traffic volume by vehicle type was converted to standard passenger car traffic volume (pcu / h) using vehicle conversion factors; the conversion factors for passenger cars, medium-sized vehicles, large vehicles, and container trucks were determined according to actual road section measurements or current highway capacity research regulations; peak hour coefficients were calculated using the following formula:

[0045] The simulation input timing was based on a 15-minute flow rate.

[0046] Extraction and processing of simulation output indicators: After the simulation runs, the travel time and actual speed of each vehicle are output by the travel time measurement segment, and the average delay is obtained by processing it according to the following formula. :

[0047] The free-flow travel time is obtained by dividing the road segment length by the free-flow speed of each lane; the queue length is output by a queue counter, which is set upstream of the work area along the driving direction. Its starting section is set at the beginning of the upstream transition zone, and its ending section is set at the upstreammost position where the queue may extend. The queue judgment speed threshold is 5 km / h, and the queue length is the average queue length during the evaluation period. To eliminate the influence of simulation randomness, each scheme was simulated repeatedly using no fewer than five different random seeds, and the arithmetic mean of the simulation results was taken as the scheme's... and .

[0048] Vehicle trajectory data processing: The vehicle trajectory files output from the simulation (recording vehicle number, time, position coordinates, speed, and acceleration at a sampling period of 0.1 s) are imported into the SSAM traffic conflict analysis software. After setting the conflict discrimination threshold, SSAM completes the conflict discrimination. Alternative safety evaluation indicators are used for conflict discrimination: the conflict time (TTC) discrimination threshold is set to 1.5 s, and the encounter time (PET) discrimination threshold is set to 5.0 s. Both thresholds can be adjusted according to the actual operating characteristics of the road segment. SSAM outputs the total number of conflicts and the conflict type (rear-end collision, lane change, intersection), conflict time, and conflict location for each conflict. The processing rule is: number of conflicts. Take the total number of conflicts during the evaluation period of the plan; the time of occurrence. Take the average PET (Peak Response Time) of all conflicts for the given scheme. When the simulation duration or traffic volume differs among the schemes, the number of conflicts is first normalized to the conflict rate per thousand passing vehicles before being included in the scoring calculation, in order to eliminate the impact of simulation duration differences on the number of conflicts.

[0049] Parameter calibration and validity verification of the simulation model: The VISSIM microscopic traffic simulation model used in this invention is a mechanistic model based on vehicle kinematics, and its parameters are not obtained through data-driven backpropagation training. Correspondingly, the "training" stage is characterized by parameter calibration and validity verification based on measured data. The complete process of this stage is as follows.

[0050] 1. Calibration Parameter Set: The calibration parameters consist of two parts: First, Wiedemann 99 car-following model parameters, including CC0 (stationary headway when stopped), CC1 (expected headway), CC2 (longitudinal fluctuation distance during following), CC3 (threshold time for entering following mode), CC4 and CC5 (acceleration and deceleration thresholds under following vibration conditions), CC6 (speed-related following distance influence coefficient), CC7 (following vibration acceleration), CC8 (expected acceleration when starting from a stop), and CC9 (expected acceleration at 80 km / h); Second, lane-changing behavior parameters, including maximum deceleration, acceptable deceleration, and safe distance reduction factor. Other parameters (vehicle composition ratio, traffic volume, geometric parameters) are directly given by measured data and are not included in the calibration.

[0051] 2. Calibration of the objective function: The objective function is constructed with the goal of achieving optimal consistency between the simulation output and the measured data.

[0052] in The relative error of the cross-sectional average vehicle speed The relative error of the travel time of the route segment, The relative error in the traffic flow distribution by lane, , , As the weighting coefficient, this embodiment takes... , , .

[0053] Calibration is the process of finding the combination of parameters that minimizes F.

[0054] 3. Calibration Process: First, determine the parameter range based on the empirically derived values ​​of each parameter to be calibrated. Second, use Latin hypercube sampling to generate at least 100 parameter combinations within the parameter range, run simulations for each set of parameters, and calculate the objective function F. Third, sort the parameters by F from smallest to largest, retaining the top 10% as the optimal domain. Fourth, within the optimal domain, perform a localized, refined iterative search starting with the optimal combination, gradually reducing the parameter step size until convergence. Fifth, output the parameter combination that minimizes F as the calibration result. The convergence criterion is: the improvement in the objective function is less than 1% after two consecutive iterations, or the number of iterations reaches the set upper limit.

[0055] 4. Validation Verification: After calibration, the model is validated using measured data from another time period, independent of the calibration data. The validation indicators and their qualification criteria are as follows: the proportion of points with a GEH statistic of cross-sectional flow less than 5 is not less than 85%; the mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of the average travel time of the road segment is not greater than 15%; and the relative error of the maximum queue length is not greater than 20%. When all three criteria are met, the model is deemed valid and can be used for comparative evaluation of various alternative schemes; if any one criterion is not met, return to step 3 for recalibration.

[0056] 5. Randomness control and simulation settings: The simulation warm-up time is set to 900 s to eliminate the deviation caused by the initial empty road network; the duration of a single simulation is set to 3600 s and covers the entire evaluation period; for each scheme, the simulation is repeated with no less than 5 different random seeds, and the mean value is taken as the index value of the scheme. The standard deviation and coefficient of variation of the simulation results are calculated. When the coefficient of variation is greater than 10%, the number of random seeds is increased.

[0057] After the above calibration and verification, the model has the ability to reproduce the traffic operation status of the maintenance section. The average delay, queue length, and vehicle trajectory output by the model can serve as a reliable basis for scheme comparison. Since all alternative schemes share the same set of calibrated parameters and the same simulation settings, the differences between the schemes only come from the lane closure method itself, and the evaluation conclusions have clear physical attributions.

[0058] The above method is combined with the maintenance scenario of the third lane of a ten-lane road: Determination of alternative lane closure schemes: Based on the fact that the maintenance target is the third lane in a five-lane one-way road, a total of 6 lane closure schemes to be evaluated were determined (n=6, i=1,2,...,6), as shown in the table below:

[0059] Work control zone length and speed limit settings: The lengths of each zone are determined according to GB 5768.4-2017, combined with the road section design speed and operation type. Exemplary values ​​for this embodiment are shown in the table below. The length of the upstream transition zone is estimated using the following formula:

[0060] In the formula, L is the length of the upstream transition zone (m), V is the speed limit of the work area (km / h), and W is the total width of the closed lane (m).

[0061]

[0062] 3. Speed ​​Limit Classification: The speed limit in the work area is set in a graded decreasing manner. In this embodiment, the speed limit for normal road sections is 120 km / h, the speed limit at the end of the warning zone is 80 km / h, and the speed limit for the work area is 60 km / h. The desired vehicle speed distribution is set in the corresponding sections by the deceleration zone element, so that the vehicles decelerate before entering the work area and avoid rear-end collisions caused by sudden speed changes.

[0063] 4. Modeling and Layout of Emergency Lane Opening: When the scheme includes an open emergency lane, the simulation model models the emergency lane section on that side as a passable lane and sets its expected speed at a speed lower than that of the main lane; during on-site layout, opening signs and guide markings are set at the starting point of the open emergency lane section, merging guide signs are set at the ending point, and the work area is isolated by cone-shaped traffic signs within the open section to prevent work vehicles from mixing with passing vehicles.

[0064] 5. Operating Conditions: To verify the applicability of the evaluation conclusions under different traffic loads, three traffic volume levels (0.6C, 0.8C, and 1.0C, where C represents the actual one-way traffic capacity of the maintenance section) were set for simulation evaluation. Each alternative scheme was compared under the same operating condition, and the adaptability of the recommended scheme to traffic volume changes could be judged by comparing the changes in scores under different operating conditions.

[0065] The evaluation process is carried out in steps: Step 1: Determine 6 alternative lane closure schemes, with scheme number i ranging from 1 to 6.

[0066] Step 2: In the VISSIM model that has been calibrated and validated, set the closed lane, passable lane, and emergency lane opening status for each scheme, keeping other parameters unchanged; run the simulation one by one and output the average delay for each scheme. Queue length And vehicle trajectory files.

[0067] Step 3: Calculate the normalized capacity score using the following formula:

[0068]

[0069]

[0070] because and , so the denominator , is a constant independent of the scheme number, therefore Completely by Decide: and The smaller the value, the lower the proportion of delays and queuing in the total number of possible solutions. The larger the size, the better the traffic capacity.

[0071] Step 4: Import the vehicle trajectory files for each scheme into SSAM, set the TTC threshold to 1.5 s and the PET threshold to 5.0 s, and output the number of collisions for each scheme. and the time of encounter .

[0072] Step 5: Calculate the normalized safety performance score using the following formula:

[0073]

[0074]

[0075] Similarly, the denominator , is a constant; The smaller The larger, The larger the size, the better the safety performance.

[0076] Step Six: Take k=1, according to Calculate the overall performance score of each scheme.

[0077] Step 7: Compare the different options The scheme corresponding to the maximum value is selected as the recommended scheme.

[0078] Step 8: Conduct on-site deployment according to the recommended plan. Taking Plan 6 (closing lanes 2, 3, and 4, with emergency lanes on both sides open for vehicle passage) as an example, the specific deployment is as follows: Warning Zone: A "Construction ahead 1600 m" warning sign is set at the starting point, and 80 km / h speed limit signs and lane reduction signs are set sequentially along the warning zone; Upstream transition zone: Deploy directional arrows and channelize traffic with cone-shaped road signs spaced no more than 5 m apart to guide vehicles sequentially to the unclosed lanes; Buffer zone: equipped with crash barriers, water-filled barriers, and mobile marker vehicles with flashing arrows; Work area: Conical traffic signs are continuously set up along the perimeter of the work area, and maintenance machinery and personnel are restricted to working within the work area; Downstream transition zone: Conical traffic signs spaced no more than 10 m apart guide vehicles back to their lanes; Termination Zone: A sign indicating the end of the 80 km / h speed limit limit will be placed at the finish line; Emergency lane open sections: Emergency lane open signs and guidance signs are set at the beginning of the emergency lane open sections on both sides, and merging guidance signs are set at the end. The work area is separated by cone-shaped traffic signs within the open sections; Nighttime operations: Add lighting facilities and active luminous signs to warning and buffer zones.

[0079] The remaining options will adjust the placement of traffic signs and barriers according to the same rules, with the closed lanes corresponding to the passable lanes.

[0080] Examples and calculation results: The original indices obtained from simulation and conflict analysis of each scheme are shown in the table below:

[0081] The normalized values ​​and scores calculated accordingly are shown in the table below:

[0082] Therefore, if only traffic capacity is considered, Option 1 is the optimal choice. If only safety performance is considered, option 6 is the best. The two conclusions are contradictory, confirming the limitations of comparing options based on a single dimension. Based on comprehensive performance scoring, Option 6 has the highest comprehensive performance score. ), followed by Scheme 3 (17.18) and Scheme 1 (17.01), so Scheme 6, namely "closing the second, third and fourth lanes, and allowing vehicles to pass through the emergency lanes on both sides", was selected as the recommended lane closure scheme for the maintenance of the third lane of this section, and the on-site layout was completed according to step eight.

[0083] Simultaneously, it can be verified that the sum of the comprehensive performance scores of each scheme is: 100.00 (17.01+16.54+17.18+15.17+15.65+18.45=100.00), which meets the requirements. , hour The theoretical relationship can be used to determine whether there are errors in the calculation process; when k takes other positive real numbers, the sum of the comprehensive performance scores of each scheme is 100k, and the ranking of the schemes remains unchanged.

[0084] The embodiments of this application have been described above with reference to the accompanying drawings. Unless otherwise specified, the embodiments and features in the embodiments of this application can be combined with each other. This application is not limited to the specific embodiments described above. The specific embodiments described above are merely illustrative and not restrictive. Those skilled in the art can make many other forms under the guidance of this application without departing from the spirit and scope of the claims, and all of these forms are within the protection scope of this application.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating lane closure schemes, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: Step 1: Determine the n lane closure schemes to be evaluated, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 3, and the sequence number of each lane closure scheme is i, i=1,2,...,n. Each lane closure scheme is used to specify the lanes closed in the maintenance operation control area of ​​the third lane of a ten-lane highway and the lanes available for vehicle passage. Step 2: Using microscopic traffic simulation software, build simulation models of the maintenance operation control areas corresponding to the n lane closure schemes and run the simulations. After the simulations are completed, output the average delay of each lane closure scheme. Queue length And vehicle trajectory files; Step 3: Based on the average delay of each lane closure plan and queue length Calculate the normalized passability score of scheme i. The normalized score of the traffic capacity With average delay and queue length The decrease increases; Step 4: Import the vehicle trajectory files for each lane closure scheme into the traffic conflict analysis software, and output the number of conflicts for each lane closure scheme. and encounter time The encounter time The statistical value of the conflict time corresponding to the identified traffic conflict; the larger the value, the more moderate the conflict between vehicles. Step 5: Based on the number of conflicts for each lane closure plan. and encounter time Calculate the normalized score of the security performance of scheme i. The security performance normalization score With the number of conflicts The reduction and encounter time It increases with the increase of; Step 6: Normalize the traffic capacity score of scheme i. With safety performance normalized score After weighting, the overall performance score of scheme i is obtained: In the formula, The weights for the normalized score of traffic capacity, The weights for the normalized safety performance score, and k is a correction coefficient greater than 0, used to adjust the overall magnitude of the comprehensive performance score. Its value does not change the relative size and ranking of the comprehensive performance scores of each scheme. Step 7: Compare the comprehensive performance scores of the n lane closure schemes, and select the lane closure scheme corresponding to the maximum comprehensive performance score as the recommended lane closure scheme for the maintenance of the third lane of the ten-lane highway. Step 8: According to the lane closure scheme selected in Step 7, which closes the lanes and allows vehicle passage, in accordance with the requirements of the Highway Maintenance Safety Operation Regulations regarding the layout of warning zones, upstream transition zones, buffer zones, work zones, downstream transition zones, and termination zones, install signs, markings, and isolation facilities in the corresponding zones of the maintenance operation control area.

2. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 1, characterized in that, The n lane closure schemes are 6 in total, including: ① Only the third lane is closed; ② Close the second and third lanes; ③ Close the third and fourth lanes; ④ The first, second, and third lanes are closed, while the outer emergency lane is open for vehicle passage; ⑤ Close lanes 3, 4, and 5; the inner emergency lane is open to traffic. ⑥ The second, third, and fourth lanes are closed, while the emergency lanes on both sides are open to traffic.

3. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 2, characterized in that, In step three, the normalized traffic capacity score is... Calculate using the following formula: In the formula, Let i be the normalized value of the average delay for scheme i. Let i be the normalized value of the queue length for scheme i; smaller and The smaller the value, the better the traffic capacity of scheme i. The larger.

4. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 3, characterized in that, In step five, the security performance normalization score Calculate using the following formula: In the formula, Let i be the normalized value of the number of conflicts. Let i be the normalized value of the encounter time of scheme i; smaller and The larger the value, the better the security performance of scheme i. The larger.

5. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 4, characterized in that, The traffic capacity normalization score With the aforementioned safety performance normalized score All scores are relative, and their values ​​vary depending on the composition of the set of alternative lane closure schemes. The merits of each lane closure scheme are determined based on the relative magnitude of the comprehensive performance score.

6. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 5, characterized in that, In step two, the micro-traffic simulation software is VISSIM, and the average delay... and queue length Output after running the simulation with VISSIM.

7. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 6, characterized in that, In step four, the traffic conflict analysis software is SSAM, and the number of conflicts... and encounter time The SSAM outputs the results after performing conflict detection based on the vehicle's kinematic parameters in the vehicle trajectory file.

8. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 7, characterized in that, In step six, the weight and The requirements for road capacity and traffic safety performance in the work area are determined based on the needs of the road management authority for the maintenance work section; when both road capacity and traffic safety performance in the work area are equally important, .

9. The method for evaluating lane closure schemes according to claim 8, characterized in that, In step eight, the placement of signs, markings, and isolation facilities is a routine placement carried out in each zone according to the provisions of GB 5768.4-2017, including: setting up construction warning signs, speed limit signs, and lane reduction signs in the warning zone; setting up directional arrows and cone-shaped traffic signs in the upstream transition zone; setting up crash barriers, water-filled barriers, and mobile sign vehicles in the buffer zone; setting up isolation facilities along the closed lanes in the work zone to confine the working machinery and personnel within the work zone; setting up cone-shaped traffic signs in the downstream transition zone; setting up speed limit release signs in the termination zone; and when the selected lane closure scheme includes opening the emergency lane, setting up emergency lane opening signs, guide signs, and isolation facilities at the beginning and end of the open section of the emergency lane.

10. A lane closure scheme evaluation system, used to perform the method according to any one of claims 1-9, characterized in that, include: The scheme determination module is used to determine the n lane closure schemes to be evaluated and their sequence numbers i, where n is a positive integer greater than or equal to 3; The simulation module is used to build and run simulation models of maintenance operation control zones corresponding to each lane closure scheme based on microscopic traffic simulation software, and output the average delay. Queue length and vehicle trajectory files; The traffic capacity assessment module is used to evaluate traffic based on average delay. and queue length Calculate the normalized capacity score ; The safety performance evaluation module is used to import vehicle trajectory files into traffic conflict analysis software to obtain the number of conflicts. and encounter time Based on this, a normalized safety performance score is calculated. ; The comprehensive evaluation module is used to evaluate... and The overall performance score is obtained by weighting. , ; The scheme output module is used to output the lane closure scheme corresponding to the maximum value of the comprehensive performance score, as well as the location of the closed lane, the length of the operation control zone, and the layout parameters of the signs and markings corresponding to the lane closure scheme.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Early warning, prevention and control safety system for expressway maintenance operation area and layout method of early warning, prevention and control safety system

    CN117746656A