Method for increasing the reliability of the electric drive by early and unambiguous detection of a thermal fault in the electrical energy storage system
By employing two temperature sensors in a cooling medium circuit to differentiate between sensor faults and thermal defects, the method ensures precise error diagnosis in electrical components, enhancing reliability and preventing unnecessary shutdowns.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- DE102023205035
- Authority / Receiving Office
- DE · DE
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-30
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods struggle to accurately distinguish between temperature sensor failures and thermal defects in electrical components, particularly in electrical energy storage devices, leading to potential misdiagnosis and unnecessary shutdowns.
The use of two temperature sensors arranged in a cooling medium circuit, where one sensor is positioned before and one after the electrical component, allows for comparison of their readings and simulated values to differentiate between sensor faults and thermal defects, enabling precise error diagnosis.
This approach enhances the reliability of electrical devices by accurately identifying sensor errors or thermal defects, preventing unnecessary shutdowns and maintaining optimal operating conditions.
Smart Images

Figure 00000000_0000_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for operating an electrical device and an electrical device according to the preamble of the independent patent claims. State of the art
[0002] From the document DE 10 2018 110 807 A1 a temperature measuring system for a fuel cell is known, which comprises a temperature estimation device which estimates an effective surface coolant temperature from a coolant outlet temperature.
[0003] DE 10 2012 210 262 A1 describes a method in which a temperature sensor is mounted outside and a temperature sensor inside the battery housing. If a threshold value of the temperature dynamics of the temperature sensor mounted inside the battery housing is exceeded, the battery is disconnected from the power supply. Another temperature sensor, located in the cooling system for the battery cell, can be used for plausibility checks after a longer inactivity period with the temperature sensor mounted outside the battery. The temperature dynamics of the three temperature sensors can also be mutually verified.
[0004] DE 10 2020 112 440 A1 describes a method for detecting a deviation of a state variable of a battery at different times with subsequent replacement of the battery cell.
[0005] DE 103 29 039 B3 describes a method for testing the functionality of a temperature sensor for detecting a temperature in a motor vehicle component, wherein at least one second temperature measuring device is provided in addition to the temperature sensor to be tested, wherein the method is characterized in that when the internal combustion engine of the motor vehicle is started, the temperature value measured by the temperature sensor is compared with a comparison value measured by the second temperature measuring device.
[0006] US 2006 / 0196954 A1 describes a temperature management device for managing the temperature of battery cells, which device includes an air inlet duct, a fan unit, a first temperature sensor for detecting the temperature of the cells and a second temperature sensor for detecting the ambient temperature, and cools or heats the battery depending on the two temperature values relative to each other.
[0007] DE 10 2018 210 411 A1 shows a method for checking a temperature measurement value recorded in a battery system, which is compared with an estimation method, and wherein, in the event of a deviation of the values, a check information is sent. Disclosure of the invention
[0008] In the method according to the invention for operating an electrical device, comprising at least a first electrical component with at least one first internal temperature sensor, and a cooling medium circuit for tempering at least the first electrical component, in which a first temperature sensor and a second temperature sensor are arranged, a temporal profile of a measured value of the first internal temperature sensor is compared with a temporal profile of a measured value of the second temperature sensor in order to distinguish a sensor defect of the first internal temperature sensor from a thermal defect of the first electrical component.
[0009] The first electrical component is, for example, an electrical energy storage device with, for example, 10 to 12 electrical energy storage cells, which operates optimally in a temperature range of approximately 20°C to approximately 40°C when used in an electrically powered vehicle. To ensure these optimal temperature limits are maintained, the electrical device is cooled, for example, by a water cooling circuit. The temperature is measured using one or more temperature sensors attached to the electrical device. Either a belt-driven pump or an electronically controlled pump with a variable flow rate can be used to transport the cooling medium.
[0010] Advantageously, two temperature sensors are attached to the first electrical component. If one temperature sensor fails due to a fault, the temperature of the first electrical component can be detected by at least one of the still fault-free temperature sensors. If, for example, an electrical energy storage cell fails due to a thermal fault, the temperature sensors detect a temperature increase. Precise fault assignment becomes difficult if a double fault occurs—i.e., a temperature sensor fault and a cell defect at the same time. To prevent the electrical device from being accidentally shut down for safety reasons, a clear fault diagnosis must be carried out. By comparing the temperature of the first electrical component with the coolant temperature, the aforementioned double fault can be identified early and clearly.
[0011] The provision of two temperature sensors has the advantage over only one temperature sensor that, if one temperature sensor is defective, the temperature of the device is detected by the other temperature sensor that is still functioning.
[0012] Further advantageous embodiments of the present invention are the subject of the subclaims.
[0013] According to an advantageous embodiment, a cooling medium flow of the cooling medium circuit, in particular originating from a cooling medium pump, first flows around the first temperature sensor, then at least partially around the first electrical component, and then around the second temperature sensor. Thus, heating of the first electrical component causes heating of the cooling medium, which can be detected by the second temperature sensor.
[0014] It is advantageous if a temporal progression of the measured value of the first temperature sensor is taken into account when considering the temporal progression of the measured value of the second temperature sensor, so that a heating of the cooling medium due to a heating of the first electrical component can be detected.
[0015] Furthermore, it is advantageous if, in the event of a failure of the second temperature sensor, a simulated temperature value is used at the position of the second temperature sensor. This further improves the reliability and fail-safety of the electrical device.
[0016] It is advantageous if the simulated temperature value at the position of the second temperature sensor is determined by means of • a measured value from the first temperature sensor • Measured values of the first and / or second internal temperature sensor • a simulated temperature of the first electrical component • a cooling medium flow rate • an ambient temperature and / or • a measured value from the second temperature sensor. This enables a simple plausibility check with the physical sensor, namely the second temperature sensor, without the need for additional sensors or procedures for unambiguous error assignment.
[0017] Advantageously, the simulated temperature at the position of the second temperature sensor is determined using an external computing unit, for example, in a cloud. This is advantageous because even error states that were unknown at the time of manufacture of the electrical device can be incorporated into the thermal model through updates at later times.
[0018] According to a further advantageous embodiment, the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor is first compared with a measured value of a second internal temperature sensor of the first electrical component and / or with a simulated temperature of the first electrical component. This allows a plausibility check of the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor. In the event of a failure of the control and / or data processing of the temperature sensors, the simulated temperature can be used.
[0019] It is advantageous if the simulated temperature of the first electrical component is determined by means of • a low-pass filtered torque curve and / or current curve of the first electrical component • a power supplied or a power consumed by the first electrical component • a thermal internal resistance of the first electrical component • an aging condition of the first electrical component • a cooling medium flow rate • a measured value from the first temperature sensor • a measured value from the second temperature sensor • a simulated temperature value at the position of the second temperature sensor and / or • an ambient temperature.
[0020] If the first or second internal temperature sensor delivers an implausible value, the temperature is determined by the other, still functioning, internal temperature sensor. To prevent the performance of the electrical device from being reduced or the electrical device from being shut down due to a temperature sensor error, it is important to distinguish between a sensor error and a thermal defect in the first electrical component, since such an implausible value can be caused by either a sensor error or a thermal defect. If a thermal defect occurs, the temperature in its surroundings rises.If the thermal defect is located in the immediate vicinity of a defective internal temperature sensor, for example the first internal temperature sensor, it takes too long for the functioning second internal temperature sensor to detect a temperature increase. Due to the temperature increase of the first electrical component, the cooling medium in its surroundings also heats up. For example, the cooling medium temperature is recorded first, and then the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor is determined. By comparing the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor with the measured value of the second temperature sensor in the cooling medium flow, it is determined whether the temperature of the cooling medium has increased compared to the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor, which would be attributable to a thermal defect.
[0021] If the first and second internal temperature sensors fail simultaneously or transmit implausible temperature values, the correlation between the simulated temperature of the first electrical component and the measured value of the second temperature sensor is used to check whether there is a discrepancy between the two temperature values. If a discrepancy is found, a thermal defect in the first electrical component is concluded.
[0022] If the first and second internal temperature sensors deliver different measured values, a comparison of the measured values of the first and second internal temperature sensors with the simulated temperature of the first electrical component only provides information about which measured value of the internal temperature sensors corresponds to the simulated temperature, but not whether the internal temperature sensor that does not correspond to the simulated temperature of the first component is operating correctly or whether a thermal defect exists in the immediate vicinity of this temperature sensor. Clarity about this fault pattern is also provided here by first comparing the measured value of the first or second internal temperature sensor with the simulated temperature and then comparing the measured value with the measured value of the second temperature sensor in the cooling medium flow that shows a smaller difference to the simulated temperature.For example, if the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor differs less from the simulated temperature than the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor, and if there is also a deviation between the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor and the cooling medium temperature, then a thermal defect exists in the immediate vicinity of the first internal temperature sensor. Otherwise, there is a defect in the first internal temperature sensor. In the first case, for example, the power of the electrical device must be reduced immediately and the electrical device switched off as quickly as possible. In the second case, the electrical device continues to operate without reduced power, since only a sensor defect exists.
[0023] It is advantageous if at least one temperature sensor is implemented as a physical model or a data-based model in a data network. The Dante network is preferably a cloud-based data network.
[0024] The core of the invention in the electrical device, in particular which can be operated by means of a method as described above or according to one of the claims related to the method, comprising at least one first electrical component with at least one first internal temperature sensor, and a cooling medium circuit for controlling the temperature of at least the first electrical component, in which a first temperature sensor and a second temperature sensor are arranged, consists in that the first temperature sensor is arranged in a flow direction of the cooling medium circuit upstream of the first electrical component and that the second temperature sensor is arranged behind the first electrical component in the flow direction of the cooling medium circuit.
[0025] The background of the invention is that a defect in the first electrical component and / or a temperature sensor can be detected at an early stage, so that the reliability is improved.
[0026] According to an advantageous embodiment, the electrical device has at least one second electrical component, which can be temperature-controlled by means of the cooling medium circuit and is arranged downstream of the first electrical component in the flow direction. The second temperature sensor is arranged between the first electrical component and the second electrical component. This allows heating of the first electrical component to be differentiated from heating of the second electrical component.
[0027] Furthermore, it is advantageous if the electrical device has a virtual temperature sensor configured to simulate a temperature at the position of the second temperature sensor. This enables redundant temperature determination.
[0028] The electrical device according to the invention is used in an electric vehicle (EV), in a hybrid vehicle (HEV), in a plug-in hybrid vehicle (PHEV) or in a fuel cell vehicle (FCEV). Short description of the characters
[0029] Advantageous embodiments of the present invention are illustrated in the drawings and explained in more detail in the following description of the figures. They show: Fig. 1 is a sectional view of an electrical device 1 according to an embodiment of the present invention, Fig. 2 shows a further sectional view of the electrical device 1 with an electrical component 7, in particular an electrical energy storage device, and Fig. 3 shows an exemplary flowchart of a method for operating an electrical device according to an embodiment of the present invention.
[0030] In Fig. 1 is a schematic sectional view of an electrical device 1 according to an embodiment of the present invention.
[0031] The electrical device 1 has a cooling medium circuit 4 in which a first temperature sensor 2 and a second temperature sensor 3 are arranged, at least one first electrical component 7, in particular an electrical energy store, and / or a second electrical component 6, in particular an electronic control device for an electric drive, and / or a third electrical component 5, in particular an electric drive.
[0032] A cooling medium of the cooling medium circuit 4 can be driven by a cooling medium pump 8. The cooling medium pump 8 is either part of the electrical device 1 or arranged outside the electrical device 1. The cooling medium pump 8 can be designed as a belt-driven pump or as an electronically controlled pump with a variable flow rate.
[0033] The cooling medium circuit 4 has a flow direction which is in the Fig. 1 is indicated by arrows. The first electrical component 7 is arranged first downstream of the cooling medium pump 8 in the direction of flow. The second electrical component 6 is arranged downstream of the first electrical component 7 in the direction of flow. The third electrical component 5 is arranged downstream of the second electrical component 6 in the direction of flow. The first temperature sensor 2 is arranged between the cooling medium pump 8 and the first electrical component 7. The first temperature sensor 2 is arranged upstream of the first electrical component 7 in the direction of flow. The second temperature sensor 3 is arranged between the first electrical component 7 and the cooling medium pump 8. The second temperature sensor 3 is arranged downstream of the first electrical component 7 in the direction of flow.
[0034] In Fig. Figure 2 shows the first electrical component 7 in detail. The first electrical component has a first internal temperature sensor 72 and a second internal temperature sensor 73. The first and second internal temperature sensors (72, 73) are arranged spaced apart from one another within a housing of the first electrical component 7. The first internal temperature sensor 72 is arranged in a first third of the first electrical component 7, and the second internal temperature sensor 73 is arranged in a third third of the first electrical component 7.
[0035] The first electrical component 7 has a control unit 70 for controlling the first electrical component 7. The control unit 70 is connected in a data-conducting manner to the internal temperature sensors (72, 73) and / or other sensors of the first electrical component 7. The control unit 70 is configured to read and evaluate operating parameters of the first electrical component and, for example, to simulate a simulated temperature of the first electrical component using the operating parameters. In the case of an electrical energy storage device, the control unit 70 is designed as a battery management system.
[0036] In the example shown, the first electrical component 7 is designed as an electrical energy storage device and has, for example, twelve identical electrical energy storage cells (71, 74) which are electrically connected to one another in series and / or parallel. The electrical energy storage cells (71, 74) are, for example, lithium-ion battery cells arranged next to one another to form the electrical energy storage device. A first electrical energy storage cell 71 is arranged in the front third of the electrical energy storage device, and a second electrical energy storage cell 74 is arranged in the rear third of the electrical energy storage device. The internal temperature sensors (72, 73) are each arranged between two electrical energy storage cells (71, 74).
[0037] The simulated temperature of the first electrical component 7 is simulated in the example of the electrical energy storage device using the following operating parameters: • Low-pass filtered torque / current curve (discharge or charge current) • power provided or received • thermal internal resistance of the electrical energy storage device • Ageing condition of the electrical energy storage device • Cooling medium flow rate • Coolant temperature from the first temperature sensor 2 • Coolant temperature from the second temperature sensor 3 • modeled cooling medium temperature at the position of the second temperature sensor 3 and / or • Ambient temperature.
[0038] The first electrical component 7 can be cooled by means of the cooling medium. For this purpose, the cooling medium circuit 4 at least partially surrounds the first electrical component 7. The first temperature sensor 2 is arranged upstream of the first electrical component 7 in the flow direction, and the second temperature sensor 3 is arranged downstream of the first electrical component 7 in the cooling medium circuit 4.
[0039] A so-called virtual temperature sensor 3a is configured to simulate the temperature of the cooling medium at the position of the second temperature sensor 3. A thermal model for the cooling medium outlet temperature behind the first electrical component 7 is used, in particular, one that is executed in an external data storage device, for example, a cloud. This thermal model uses the following parameters, at least in part: • a temperature of the first temperature sensor 2 • Temperatures of the internal temperature sensors (72, 73) • a simulated temperature of the first electrical component 7 • a cooling medium flow rate • an ambient temperature and / or • a temperature of the second temperature sensor 3.
[0040] A physical model or a data-based model, i.e. a characteristic curve, characteristic map or look-up table, can be used as the thermal model.
[0041] In Fig. 3 schematically shows an exemplary flowchart of a method 200 for operating an electrical device according to an embodiment of the present invention. The electrical device is configured, for example, as shown in the Fig. 1 and Fig. 2 shown executable.
[0042] In a first method step 202 of method 200, a measured value of the first internal temperature sensor 72 and a measured value of the second internal temperature sensor 73 and a simulated temperature value of the first electrical component 7 are compared. If the values match, there is neither a thermal defect in the first electrical component 7 nor a defective first and / or second internal temperature sensor (72, 73).
[0043] In a second method step 204, it is determined whether the first or the second internal temperature sensor (72, 73) has failed.
[0044] If it is determined in the second method step 204 that one of the two internal temperature sensors (72, 73), for example the first internal temperature sensor 72, is not outputting a temperature value or is outputting a temperature value that lies outside the value range of, for example, approximately 20°C to approximately 40°C, the temporal profile of the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor 73 is subsequently compared with the temporal profile of the measured value of the second temperature sensor 3 in a third method step 206. If the temporal profiles of these measured values essentially match, a sensor defect in the first internal temperature sensor 72 is diagnosed in a fourth method step 208.If the temporal profiles of these measured values deviate significantly from one another, an internal defect in the first electrical component 7 is diagnosed in the fourth method step 208, for example, a cell defect in one of the electrical energy storage cells (71, 74) is diagnosed. The result of this fault diagnosis can be displayed, for example, to the driver of an electric vehicle, in a final method step 210.
[0045] When evaluating the temporal progression of the measured value of the second temperature sensor 3, this is considered in relation to a respective measured value of the first temperature sensor 2, so that a heating of the cooling medium caused by the first electrical component 7 can be detected.
[0046] If it is determined in the second method step 204 that both internal temperature sensors (72, 73) are not providing temperature values, a fifth method step 214 subsequently diagnoses that both the first and second temperature sensors (72, 73) have failed. Then, in a sixth method step 216, a temporal profile of the simulated temperature of the first electrical component 7 is compared with the temporal profile of the measured value of the second temperature sensor 3. If the temporal profiles of these measured values essentially match, a sensor defect in the first internal temperature sensor 72 and the second internal temperature sensor 73 is diagnosed in a subsequent seventh method step 218.If the temporal profiles of these measured values deviate significantly from one another, an internal defect in the first electrical component 7 is diagnosed in the seventh method step 218, for example, a cell defect in one of the electrical energy storage cells (71, 74) is diagnosed. The result of this fault diagnosis can be displayed, for example, to the driver of an electric vehicle in the final method step 210.
[0047] If it is determined in the second and fifth method steps (204, 214) that the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor 72 and the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor 73 lie within a value range of approximately 20°C to approximately 40°C, then in an eighth method step 224 it is determined whether the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor 72 and the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor 73 differ significantly from one another. In the event of a significant deviation, in a ninth method step 226 it is first determined which of the measured values of the first and second internal temperature sensors (72, 73) has a smaller value difference from the simulated temperature of the first electrical component 7.If, for example, the second internal temperature sensor has a smaller value difference, then in the ninth method step 226, a temporal profile of the measured value of the second internal temperature sensor 73 is compared with the temporal profile of the measured value of the second temperature sensor 3. If these temporal profiles differ significantly from one another, then in a tenth method step 228 it is determined that a thermal defect is present in the immediate vicinity of the first internal temperature sensor 72, in particular a cell defect in an electrical energy storage cell 71 positioned in the immediate vicinity of the first internal temperature sensor 72. If the temporal profiles of the measured values of the second internal temperature sensor 73 and the second temperature sensor 3 correlate with one another, then in the tenth method step 228 it is determined that a sensor defect is present in the first internal temperature sensor 72.The result of this fault diagnosis can be displayed in the final process step 110, for example, to the driver of an electric vehicle.
[0048] If the second temperature sensor 3 fails, the simulated temperature value of the virtual sensor 3a can be used instead. In this case, the simulated temperature value of the virtual sensor 3a is used instead of the measured value of the second sensor 3.
[0049] The electrical device 1 is used, for example, in an electric vehicle (EV), in a hybrid vehicle (HEV), in a plug-in hybrid vehicle (PHEV) or in a fuel cell vehicle (FCEV). QUOTES CONTAINED IN THE DESCRIPTION
[0000] This list of documents submitted by the applicant was generated automatically and is included solely for the convenience of the reader. This list is not part of the German patent or utility model application. The DPMA assumes no liability for any errors or omissions. Cited patent literature
[0000] DE 10 2018 110 807 A1
[0002] DE 10 2012 210 262 A1
[0003] DE 10 2020 112 440 A1
[0004] DE 103 29 039 B3
[0005] US 2006 / 0196954 A1
[0006] DE 10 2018 210 411 A1
[0007]
Claims
[1] Method (200) for operating an electrical device (1), comprising at least one first electrical component (7) with at least one first internal temperature sensor (72), and a cooling medium circuit (4) for controlling the temperature of at least the first electrical component (7), in which a first temperature sensor (2) and a second temperature sensor (3) are arranged, characterized by that a temporal profile of a measured value of the first internal temperature sensor (72) is compared with a temporal profile of a measured value of the second temperature sensor (3) in order to distinguish a sensor defect of the first internal temperature sensor (72) from a thermal defect of the first electrical component (7). [2] Method (200) according to claim 1, characterized byin that a cooling medium flow of the cooling medium circuit (4), in particular starting from a cooling medium pump (8), first flows around the first temperature sensor (2), then at least partially flows around the first electrical component (7) and then flows around the second temperature sensor (3). [3] Method (200) according to one of claims 1 to 2, characterized by that a temporal progression of the measured value of the first temperature sensor (2) is taken into account when considering the temporal progression of the measured value of the second temperature sensor (3), so that a heating of the cooling medium due to a heating of the first electrical component (7) can be detected. [4] Method (200) according to one of the preceding claims, characterized by that in the event of a failure of the second temperature sensor (3), a simulated temperature value at the position of the second temperature sensor (3) is used. [5] Method (200) according to claim 4, characterized bythat the simulated temperature value at the position of the second temperature sensor (3) is determined by means of • a measured value of the first temperature sensor (2) • Measured values of the first and / or second internal temperature sensor (72, 73) • a simulated temperature of the first electrical component (7) • a cooling medium flow rate • an ambient temperature and / or • a measured value from the second temperature sensor (3). [6] Method (200) according to one of the preceding claims, characterized by that the measured value of the first internal temperature sensor (72) is first compared with a measured value of a second internal temperature sensor (73) of the first electrical component (7) and / or with a simulated temperature of the first electrical component (7). [7] Method (200) according to claim 6, characterized bythat the simulated temperature of the first electrical component (7) is determined by means of • a low-pass filtered torque curve and / or current curve of the first electrical component (7) • a power supplied or a power consumed by the first electrical component (7) • a thermal internal resistance of the first electrical component (7) • an aging condition of the first electrical component (7) • a cooling medium flow rate • a measured value of the first temperature sensor (2) • a measured value from the second temperature sensor (3) • a simulated temperature value at the position of the second temperature sensor (3) and / or • an ambient temperature. [8] Electrical device (1), in particular which can be operated by means of a method according to one of the preceding claims, comprising at least one first electrical component (7) with at least one first internal temperature sensor (72), and a cooling medium circuit (4) for controlling the temperature of at least the first electrical component (7), in which a first temperature sensor (2) and a second temperature sensor (3) are arranged, characterized by , that the first temperature sensor (2) is arranged in a flow direction of the cooling medium circuit (4) upstream of the first electrical component (7) and that the second temperature sensor (3) is arranged behind the first electrical component (7) in the flow direction of the cooling medium circuit (4). [9] Electrical device (1) according to claim 8, characterized by , that the electrical device (1) has at least one second electrical component (6) which can be tempered by means of the cooling medium circuit and is arranged downstream of the first electrical component (7) in the flow direction, wherein the second temperature sensor (3) is arranged between the first electrical component (7) and the second electrical component (6). [10] Electrical device (1) according to claim 8 or 9, characterized by that the electrical device (1) has a virtual temperature sensor (3a) which is configured to simulate a temperature at the position of the second temperature sensor (3).
Citation Information
Patent Citations
modeling AND USE OF A VIRTUAL TEMPERATURE SENSOR AT THE EFFECTIVE SPACE OUTLET OF A FUEL CELL STACK WITH STACK COOLANT BYPASS
DE102018110807A1
Method for verifying a temperature measurement recorded in a battery system and battery system
DE102018210411A1
Method for operating a control unit for an energy storage device, method for operating an energy storage device and control unit
DE102020112440A1
Function checking method for temperature sensor associated with automobile component using comparison of temperature values provided by temperature sensor and by second temperature measuring device
DE10329039B3
Temperature management apparatus and power supply
US20060196954A1
