Method and system for determining reusability of a battery
The method and system for evaluating electric vehicle battery reusability through diagnostic and AC tests address inefficiencies in conventional methods, enabling efficient identification of suitable cells for reuse or recycling, thereby enhancing battery life and production efficiency.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- GB2022015774
- Authority / Receiving Office
- GB · GB
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-10-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-10-25
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods for determining the reusability of electric vehicle batteries are inefficient and unreliable, particularly on an industrial scale, as they require lengthy testing processes and are not designed to handle used batteries effectively.
A method and system that conduct safety diagnostic tests, measure Open Circuit Voltage, perform Electrochemical Dynamic Response tests to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters, and conduct AC tests to identify outlier cells, predicting their degradation pathway and determining suitability for reuse or recycling, thereby optimizing time and improving accuracy.
This approach allows for efficient and reliable evaluation of battery reusability, reducing testing time and maximizing production throughput by identifying suitable cells for replacement or reuse, thus extending battery life and improving capacity and power supply.
Smart Images

Figure 00000001_0000 
Figure 00000002_0000 
Figure 00000003_0000
Abstract
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD The present disclosure relates generally to the field of electric vehicles and battery testing; and more specifically, to a method and a system of determining reusability of a battery (e.g„ an electric vehicle battery pack). BACKGROUND W i th a rapi d i ncrease i n the use of el ectri c vehi cl es, the demand for high- performance energy storage systems (e.g„ a battery or a battery pack) has increased immensely. It is well known that understanding the phenomena and functionality of various components inside a battery i s requi red to promote the battery performance. G eneral ly, a number of el ectri c vehi cl e (EV) batteries are manufactured, processed, and tested at an electric vehicle service station, for use in electric vehi des, hybrid electric vehicles, plug-in hybrid electric vehi des, and the I ike. However, the testing is mostly limited to prototype testing or testing of newly manufactured batteries. In certain scenarios, for example, after prolonged use, some EV batteries may develop various kinds of defects and may not function properly. In such scenarios, a technical challenge associated with the uptake of EV batteries is how to manage the EV batteries when they are removed from an electric vehicle either because of a fault or because the EV batteries have reached the end of their usable life. The aforementioned technical challenge associated with the used or defective EV batteries can be addressed either on a small scale or on a large scale, depending on an application scenario. In a ty pi cal battery testi ng method, same tests are carri ed out on each battery pack or battery module or cell (i.e„ components of the battery), which is a tardy process. In conventional battery testing methods, it is typically required that each battery pack or battery module or cell needs to be pre-conditioned prior to testing which significantly adds to the testing time and makes the testing method complex in nature. Thus, there exists a technical problem of how to determine reusability of EV batteries (e.g„ a used EV battery) accurately on an industrial scale. Therefore, in light of the foregoing discussion, there exists a need to overcome the aforementioned drawbacks associated with the conventional methods of determining reusability of EV batteries SUMMARY The present disclosure provides a method and a system of determining reusability of a battery. T he present disciosure provides a sol uti on to the existi ng problem of how to devel op a holistic testing process that is efficient and reliable in determining reusability of EV batteries (e.g„ a used EV battery). An aim of the present disclosure is to provide a solution that overcomes at least partially the problems encountered in prior art and provides an improved method and an improved system of determining reusability of a battery. One or more objects of the present disclosure is achieved by the solutions provided in the enclosed independent claims. Advantageous implementations of the present disclosure are further defined in the dependent claims. According to an aspect of the present disclosure, there is provided a method of determining reusability of a battery comprising conducting one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery. The method further comprises measuring an Open Circuit Voltage (OCV) for each of a plurality of cells in the battery to determine a state of charge of the battery and performing an Electrochemical Dynamic Response (EDR) test on the battery to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters for each of the cells. The method further comprises analysi ng the derived i mpedance and Iithi um transport parameters to i dentify one or more outlier cells in the battery and conducting one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells to predict a degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery. The method further comprises designating the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on the predicted degradation pathway. The disclosed method is flexible and universal in use (i.e„ suitable to perform tests on all types of used EV batteri es i rrespective of thei r manufacturers or product type). T he disci osed method is a comprehensive test process to evaluate the remaining usable life of the battery after a prolonged use in an electric vehicle. The method includes conducting one or more tests on the battery to deci de whether one or more cel I s of the pl ural i ty of cel I s of the battery are replaced with healthy cells or the one or more cells of the plurality of cells are suitable for reuse in the second application or the one or more cells of the plurality of cells are recycled. Moreover, the decision about the suitability of the battery can be made by subjecting one or more damaged cells to deeper tests instead of subjecting the battery (i,e„ the whole battery) to all tests. This results in time optimization, and maximisation of production throughput with improved efficiency and reliability. For example, the steps of E D R test on the battery to derive i mpedance and I ithi um transport parameters for each of the cells, analysing the derived impedance and lithium transport parameters to identify one or more outl i er cel I s i n the battery and conducti ng one or more A C tests on the i denti f i ed outl i er cel I s to predi ct a degradati on pathway for the cel I s over the I ifeti me of the battery, as a whol e provides a technical effect of improved accuracy while surprisingly reducing the time to identify the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling. Conventional methods are mostl y not desi gned or meant to test a used battery. The testi ng of used batteri es requires laboratory setup and pre-conditioning (e.g„ chemical treatment of battery, etc. before testi ng) whi ch is very ti me i ntensive and not practi cal for high vol ume testi ng. In an implementationfornt the method further comprises determi ni ng whether the OCV for each of the plurality of cells in the battery is below a pre-defined threshold voltage. By virtue of determini ng whether the OCV for each of the plurality of cells in the battery is below the pre-defined threshold voltage, one or more cells are identified with high selfdischarge rate. In a further implementation form the method further comprises identifying one or more damaged cel Is i n the battery for replacement when the determi ned OCV is less than the pre-defined threshold voltage for the one or more damaged cells. The replacement of the one or more damaged cells in the battery results in an enhanced life of the battery. In a further implementation form the E DR test on the battery is further configured to derive a state of health of Direct Current (DC) discharge data of the battery based on at least one of: a correlation between capacity and temperature of the battery or a correlation between the capacity and voltage of the battery. The derivation of the state of health of DC discharge data of the battery leads to a reliable measurement of capacity fade, if any, of the battery. In a further implementation form, the method further comprises analysing the derived state of health to identify the one or more outlier cells in the battery. The identification of the one or more outlier cells in the battery leads to an accurate measurement of usable life of the battery. In a further implementation form the method further comprises comparing data from the derived state of health with a model dataset; having a plurality of predefined test values, of the battery to further eval uate the outl i er cel Is of the battery. The comparison of the derived state of health of the battery with the model dataset having the plurality of predefined test values results in an accurate prediction of the remaining age and a specific usage type of the battery. In a further i mpl ementati on form the one or more A C tests on the i dentifi ed outl i er cel I s are conducted either in-situ within the battery or ex-situ by removing the identified outlier cells from the battery. In a further implementation form, the one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outlier cells at different amplitudes and different frequencies. Performing the one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells at different amplitudes (e.g„ low and high amplitude) and different frequencies results in determination of whether the identified outlier cells are reusable or removable or recyclable. In a further implementation form the outlier cells are designated for reuse in the second application when the degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery is predi cted to be favourabl e for the reuse i n the second appl i cati on. In a further implementation form the outlier cells are designated for recycling when the degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery is predicted to be unfavourable for reuse. In a further implementation form the identified outlier cells are removed from the battery and replaced with cells having substantially similar impedance and state of health as that of healthy cells remaining in the battery. The removal and replacement of the identified outlier cells with the healthy cells increases the battery life by increasing the capacity and power that is supplied to a load connected to the battery. In another aspect; the present disclosure provides a system of determining reusability of a battery. The system comprises a control circuit communicatively coupled to a plurality of test equipment; wherein the control circuit causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment to conduct one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery. The control circuit further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment to measure an Open Circuit V oltage (OCV) for each of a pl ural ity of cel Is i n the battery to determi ne a state of charge of the battery and perform an EI ectrochemi cal Dynami c R esponse (E D R) test on the battery to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters for each of the cells. The control circuit further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment to analyse the derived impedance and lithium transport parameters to identify one or more outlier cells in the battery and conduct one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells to predict a degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery and designate the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on the predicted degradation pathway. The system achieves all the advantages and technical effects of the method after execution of the method. Itisto be appreciated that al I the aforementioned implementation forms can be combined. It has to be noted that all devices, elements, circuitry, unitsand means descri bed in the present application could be implemented in the software or hardware elements or any kind of combination thereof. All steps which are performed by the various entities described in the present application as well as the functionalities described to be performed by the various entities are i ntended to mean that the respective entity is adapted to or configured to perform the respective steps and functionalities. Even if, in the following description of specific embodiments, a specific functionality or step to be performed by external entities is not 5 reflected in the description of a specific detailed element of that entity which performs that specific step or functionality, it should be clear for a skilled person that these methods and functionalities can be implemented i n respective software or hardware elements, or any ki nd of combination thereof. It will be appreciated that features of the present disclosure are susceptible to being combined in various combinations without departing from the scope of the present disclosure as defined by the appended claims. Additional aspects, advantages, featuresand objects of the present disclosure would be made apparent from the drawings and the detailed description of the illustrative implementations construed in conjunction with the appended claims that fol low. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS The summary above, as well as the following detailed description of illustrative embodiments, is better understood when read in conjunction with the appended drawings. For the purpose of illustrating the present disclosure, exemplary constructions of the disclosure are shown in the drawings. However, the present disclosure is not limited to specific methods and instrumentalities disclosed herein. Moreover, those skilled in the art will understand that the drawings are not to scale. Wherever possible, like elements have been indicated by identical numbers. E mbodi ments of the present di sd osure wi 11 now be descri bed, by way of exampl e only, with reference to the fol I owi ng di agrams wherei n: FIG. 1 i s a fl owchart of a method of determi ni ng reusabi I ity of a battery, i n accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure; FIGs. 2A and2B collectively, is a flowchart that depicts a series of tests to be conducted on a battery for evaluation of specific battery parameters, in accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure; FIG. 3 is a diagram i 11 ustrati ng a system of determi ni ng reusabi I ity of a battery, i n accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure; and FIG. 4 is an exemplary illustration depicting performing one or more tests and identification of one or more outlier cells in a battery, in accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure. In the accompanying drawings, an underlined number is employed to representan item over which the underlined number is positioned or an item to which the underlined number is adjacent A non-underlined number relates to an item identified by a line linking the nonunderlined number to the item When a number is non-underlined and accompanied by an associated arrow, the non-underlined number is used to identify a general item at which the arrow is pointing. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF EMBODIMENTS The following detailed description illustrates embodiments of the present disclosure and ways in which they can be implemented. Although some modes of carrying out the present disclosure have been disclosed, those skilled in the art would recognize that other embodiments for carrying out or practising the present disclosure are also possible. FIG. 1 i s a fl owchart of a method of determi ni ng reusabi I ity of a battery, i n accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure. With reference to FIG. 1, there is shown a method 100 that includes steps 102 to 112. The method 100 is executed by a system, described in detail, for example, in FIG. 3. There is provided the method 100 of determining reusability of a battery. The battery refers to an electric vehicle (EV) battery pack, and the 'battery_ comprises cells or modules that are a group of cells within a battery pack. The battery may be used in the EV for long time therefore, the battery is removed from the EV either because of a fault or because the battery has reached the end of its usable life. In order to determine the fault and the reusability of the battery, the method 100 is used. In an implementation, the battery may include a number of cells, or battery modules or battery packs, or a combination thereof. The method 100 is a comprehensive test process used to ensure that EV batteries are processed quickly and screened reliably by focusing on finding the number of cells or battery modules or battery packs with specifi c types of damage(s) and use case. T he method 100 can eval uate the future value and reliability of the number of cells or battery modules of the battery. Additionally, the method 100 can also be used for determining the power fade, capacity fade and degradation pathways of the battery with improved accuracy. At step 102, the method 100 comprises conducting one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery. Initial ly, the one or more safety diagnostic tests (e.g„ high voltage, safety checks) are conducted on the battery. The one or more safety diagnostic tests may include, but are not limited to, connection of the battery to a ground wire, covering high voltage areas, sharing an awareness of any danger, paying attention to electric charge in cables, not touching high voltage areas with bare hands, use of gloves, and the like. At step 104, the method 100 further comprises measuring an Open Circuit Voltage (OCV) for each of a plurality of cells in the battery to determine a state of charge of the battery. After conducting the safety diagnostic tests on the battery, the OCV of each of the plurality of cel I s of the battery i s measured to i denti fy the el ectri cal potenti al capabi I i ty of the battery (e.g„ a rechargeable battery). Generally, the OCV is defined as a difference of electric potential between a positive and a negative terminal. While determining the OCV, any external load connected to the battery is removed. In an implementation, the method 100 further comprises determining whether the OCV for each of the plurality of cells in the battery is below a pre-defined threshold voltage. The measured OCV of each of the pl ural ity of cel I s of the battery i s analysed to determi ne whi ch cells from the plurality of cells have the OCV below the pre-defined threshold voltage. In an implementation, the method 100 further comprises identifying one or more damaged cells in the battery for replacement when the determined OCV is less than the pre-defined threshold voltage for the one or more damaged cells. In a scenario of identification of the one or more damaged cells having the OCV less than the pre-defined threshold voltage, the one or more damaged cells are replaced with cells having similar characteristics such as, voltage and current requirements, with those cells having the OCV greater than the predefined threshold voltage. At step 106, the method 100 further comprises performing an Electrochemical Dynamic Response (E DR) test on the battery to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters for each of the cel Is. After measuri ng the OCV of each of the pl ural ity of cells of the battery, the E DR test is conducted on each of the plurality of cel Is of the battery. Generally, the E DR test is conducted to measure the flow of ions between positive and negative termi nals of the battery. In an implementation, the E DR test may be carried out on each of the plurality of 8 cells of the battery while logging cell voltages which are measured either directly from the pl ural i ty of cel I s or by readi ng from a battery management system (BMS).TheEDR test has a low impact on the temperature of the battery and therefore, the E DR test can be preceded by other tests. The EDR test provides the information about the impedance (e.g„ ohmic resistance) and I ithi um transport parameters of each of the cel Is of the battery. At step 108, the method 100 further comprises analysi ng the derived i mpedance and I ithi um transport parameters to identify one or more outlier cells in the battery. The derived impedance and lithium transport parameters of each of the plurality of cells of the battery are analysed to identify the one or more outlier cells with high impedance and low capacity. L ow capacity means a reducti on i n the usabl e capacity of the battery. T he one or more outl i er cells are subjected to further tests for detailed analysis of their state of health (SoH). D ependi ng on the SoH of the one or more outl i er cel I s, the one or more outl i er cel I s are either repaired or replaced with other cells having similar characteristics. In an implementation, the E DR test on the battery is further configured to derive a state of health of Direct Current (DC) discharge data of the battery based on at least one of: a correlation between capacity and temperature of the battery or a correlation between the capacity and voltage of the battery. T he E D R test is further used to analyse the DC capacity of the battery. For analysis of the DC capacity, the battery is charged and then discharged either fully or partially, with all the cell voltages logged in. The charging / discharging of the battery provides the measurement of the capacity figure for each of the plurality of cells of the battery. The capacity figure of the battery can also be obtained by analysis of variation in the capacity (i,e„ charge) by varying the voltages (i.e„ dQ / dV) and analysis of variation in the capacity (i.e„ charge) by varying the temperature of the battery (i.e„ dQ / dT). In an implementation, the E DR test may include Coulomb counting, current pulse counting and measurement of AC impedance at 1kHz. The Coulomb counting refers to a reduced capacity of the battery and the current pulse counti ng refers to a reduced power output of the battery. In an implementation scenario, if the battery supplies a high percentage of charge energy in the discharge phase, it is determined that the battery has a good capacity, which can be expressed as a percentage of the pl ural ity of cel I s of the battery as a new capacity rati ng. For 9 example, a battery can be charged to 100% state of charge (SoC) and then, discharged to its minimum level, the total amount of energy discharged can be compared against the plurality of cells of the battery as the new capacity according to equation (1). In an i mplementation, the method 100 further comprises analysi ng the derived state of health to identify the one or more outlier cells in the battery. The equation (1) is used to determine the state of health of the one or more outlier cells in the battery with more reliability. In an implementation, the method 100 further comprises comparing data from the derived state of health with a model dataset; havi ng a pl ural i ty of predefi ned test val ues, of the battery to further eval uate the out! ier cel I s of the battery. T he derived state of health of DC discharge data of the battery and the state of health of the one or more outlier cells are compared with the model dataset; having the plurality of predefined test values, of the battery to identify whether the derived parameters are unusual with respect to a given battery type, an age of the battery, or a battery usage parameter. In an implementation, if voltages of the plurality of cells of the battery during the DC discharge data analysis have a delta of less than a required mi 11 i-V olt (mV) figure then, the plurality of cells of the battery can be assumed as healthy cells. At step 110, the method 100 further comprises conducting one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cel Is to predicta degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery. In a case, if analysis of the EDR test and the DC discharge data identifies one or more cells from the plurality of cells of the battery which perform unsatisfactorily (i,e„ the one or more outlier cells) then, part of battery containing the one or more cells whose performance is unsatisfactory, is separately subjected to the one or more AC tests instead of subjecting the battery (i.e., the whole battery) for further testing. In an implementation, an individual cell or a battery module may also be subjected to the one or more AC tests. The one or more A C tests are conducted to determi ne a root cause of fai I ure of the one or more out I i er cel I s. M oreover, the one or more A C tests are conducted to determi ne the degradati on pathway for the one or more outlier cells. The degradation pathway includes formation of sol id electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer, parti de fracture, lithium plating and dendrite growth, 10 structural disordering, graphite exfoliation, pore blockage, and the like. The aforementioned degradation pathways are generally considered to be the cause of the battery degradation during normal operation of the battery. The degradation pathway varies with change in the temperature, current and SoC of the battery. In an implementation, the one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells are conducted either in-situ within the battery or ex-situ by removing the identified outlier cells from the battery. In an implementation, the one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outl i er cel Is lyi ng withi n the battery (i.e„ in-situ). In another i mplementati on, the one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outlier cells after removing them from the battery (i.e„ ex-situ). In an i mpl ementati on, the one or more A C tests are conducted on the i dentifi ed outl i er cel I s at different amplitudes and different frequencies. T he testi ng data obtai ned after conduct! ng the one or more AC tests can be interpreted by use of either curve fitting, or an equivalent circuit model or analysis of distribution of relaxation times (DRT). Furthermore, the one or more AC tests conducted on the identified outlier cells includes analysing harmonics of AC data in which an ampl itude is greater than a pre-defined threshold val ue (i.e„ high ampl itude AC data), analysing the DRT oftheAC data in which the ampl itude is less than the defined threshold, or deriving an equivalent circuit fitting of the AC data in which the amplitude is I ess than the def i ned threshol d (i. e„ I ow ampl i tude A C data). M oreover, a few tests namely, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS), DRT and non-linear frequency response analysis (NFRA) tests may be conducted on the identified outlier cells to identify presence and severity of lithium plating. The EIS and DRT tests data may be used to distinguish the relative contributions of calendar and cycle ageing to impedance growth and capacity fade. Each of the EIS, DRT and NFRA tests is highly affected by temperature and SoC of the battery therefore, it is required to measure the temperature and OCV of each cell and correct for the effects of these noise factors. At step 112, the method 100 further comprises designating the outlier cells for reuse in a second appl i cati on or for recyd i ng based on the predi cted degradati on pathway. T he testi ng data obtained by conducting the one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells is used to decide whether the outlier cells are suitable for reuse in the second application or discard the outlier cells for recycling, based on the predicted degradation pathway. In an implementation, the outlier cells are designated for reuse in the second application when the degradati on pathway for the cel I s over the I i feti me of the battery i s predi cted to be favourable for the reuse in the second application. Based on the one or more AC tests conducted on the outlier cells, the outlier cells can be selected for reuse in the second application if the degradation pathway for each of the plurality of cells of the battery is favourabl e for reuse on the second appl i cati on, for the remai ni ng I i feti me of the battery. T he outlier cells selected for reuse in the second application may be sent to a remanufacturing i nventory. In an implementation, the outlier cells are designated for recycling when the degradation pathway for the cel I s over the I i feti me of the battery i s predi cted to be unfavourabl e for reuse. Based on the one or more AC tests conducted on the outlier cells, the outlier cells can be selected for recycling if the degradation pathway for each of the plurality of cells of the battery is unfavourable for reuse. In an implementation, the identified outlier cells are removed from the battery and replaced with cells having substantially similar impedance and state of health as that of healthy cells remaining in the battery. The outlier cells which are removed from the battery and do not indicate the unfavourable degradation pathway can be replaced with the cells having substantially similar (e.g„ WO. difference in impedance and state of health) impedance and state of health as that of healthy cel Is remaining in the battery. In an implementation, the similar characteristics may include capacity characteristics of those cells remaining in the battery, after adjusting the state of charge of the replaced cells, if required. After reassembling the cells in the battery, the battery can be subjected to a standard end of line testi ng. T hus, the method 100 i s a ti me-opti mi sed and a comprehensive test process to fi nd any future value left in the battery and to decide whether one or more cells of the plurality of cells of the battery are replaced with healthy cells or the one or more cells of the plurality of cells are suitable for reuse in the second application or the one or more cells of the plurality of cells are recycled. In the method 100, a series of tests including the EDR test; the DC 12 discharge data test and the one or moreAC tests are conducted on the battery. Moreover, in the method 100, the one or more cel I s of the pl ural i ty of cel I s of the battery fai I i ng the E D R test are subjected to the DC discharge data test and the part of battery comprising the one or more cel I s fai I i ng the D C di scharge data test i s subj ected to the one or more A C tests to f i nd the degradation pathway. In this way, the decision about the suitability of plurality of cells of the battery can be made by subjecti ng only a portion of the battery to deeper tests i nstead of subjecting the battery to all tests. Therefore, the method 100 results in maximising the production throughput with improved efficiency and reliability. FIGs. 2A and2B collectively, is a flowchart that depicts a series of tests to be conducted on a battery for eval uati on of specific battery parameters, i n accordance with an embodi ment of the present disclosure. FIGs. 2A and 2B are described in conjunction with elements from FIG. 1. With reference to FIGs. 2A and 2B, there is shown a flowchart 200 that includes operations 202 to 258. The operations 202 to 228 are shown in FIG. 2A and the operations 230 to 258 are shown in FIG. 2B. Referring to FIG. 2A, at operation 202, a battery is received at a battery servicing facility (e.g„ an electric vehicle service station). At operation 204, high voltage (HV) safety diagnostic tests are conducted on the battery. At operation 206, this is checked that whether the battery passes the safety diagnostic tests or not If the battery passes the safety diagnostic tests, then, operation 210 is executed else, an operation 208 is executed. At operation 208, the battery is subjected for teardown. At operation 210, a test equipment is connected to the battery. At operation 212, the OCV for each of a plurality of cells of the battery is measured to determine a state of change (SoC) of the battery. At operation 214, this is checked that whether one or more cells from the plurality of cells of the battery has the measured OCV less than a pre-defi ned threshold voltage. If the one or more cel Is from the plurality of cells of the battery has the measured OCV less than the pre defined threshold voltage then, an operation 216 is executed else, an operation 218 is executed. At operation 216, the one or more cells having the measured OCV less than the pre-defined threshold voltage are replaced by healthy cells and the operations from 204 to 214 are executed agai n on the battery. A t operati on 218, the one or more cel I s from the pl ural i ty of cel I s of the battery are subj ected to the E DR test Atoperation 220, from the EDR testing data, impedance (i.e„ ohmic resistance) for each of the cells of the battery is derived. At operation 222, from the EDR testing data, lithium transport parameters for each of the cells of the battery are derived. At operation 224, the battery is further subjected to the partial DC discharge data. At operation 226, from the partial DC discharge data, a state of health of the battery is derived by dQ / dV analysis (i.e„ analysis of change in charge by varying the voltage). At operati on 228, the derived i mpedance, I ithi um transport parameters and the state of health of the battery are used to i dentify the one or more outl i er cel Is of the battery. Now referri ng to FIG. 2B, at operation 230, it is checked whether any outl i er cel I is i dentifi ed or not If one or more outlier cells are identified then, an operation 232 is executed. At operation 232, the derived state of health of the battery is compared with a model dataset havi ng a pl ural ity of predefi ned test val ues, of the battery to further eval uate the outl i er cel Is of the battery. Atoperation 234, if the compared val ues seem ok then, the battery is discharged to 30% SoC and stored for future use. At operation 236, the control of the flowchart 200 moves to an end. At operation 238, the identified one or more outlier cells are removed from the battery and su bj ected to one or more A C tests at operati on 240.1n another i mpl ementati on, the i denti f i ed one or more outl i er cel I s are not requi red to be removed from the battery and the one or more AC tests can be conducted on the identified outlier cells lying inside the battery. At operation 240, the one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outlier cells at multiple amplitudes (e.g„ C / 20to3C) and multiple frequencies (e.g„ 10kHz-0.05Hz). At operation 242, the one or more AC tests can be conducted on the identified outlier cells by use of an equivalent circuit fitting of the AC data in which the amplitude is less than a def i ned threshol d val ue. At operation 244, the one or more AC tests can be conducted on the identified outlier cells by analysing a distribution of relaxation times (DRT) of the AC data in which the amplitude i s I ess than the def i ned threshol d val ue. At operation 246, the one or more AC tests can be conducted on the identified outlier cells by analysing harmonics of high amplitude AC data. At operation 248, by conducting the one or more AC tests, the outlier cells are designated for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on a predicted degradation pathway. At operation 250, it is checked if any outlier cell is on an unfavourable degradation pathway. If there exists any outlier cell on the unfavourable degradation pathway then, an operation 252 is executed else, an operation 254 is executed. At operation 252, the outlier cell on the unfavourable degradation pathway is discarded for recyd i ng. In an i mpl ementati on, if any outl i er cel I i s found on the unfavourabl e degradati on pathway, then rest of the cells of the battery can be assumed to be on the similar pathway. Therefore, if possible, each of the plurality of the cells of the battery are discarded for recycling. At operation 254, if there does not exist any outlier cells with the unfavourable degradation pathway, then the identified outlier cells can be reused in the second application. Therefore, the identified outl ier cel Is are sent to the remanufacturi ng i nventory. At operation 256, the identified one or more outlier cells are removed from the battery and replaced with cells having similar impedance (e.g„ 0M3EX difference of impedance) and state of health as that of healthy cells remaining in the battery. A t operati on 258, the battery i s subj ected to a standard end of I i ne testi ng. FIG. 3 illustrates a system of determining reusability of a battery, in accordance with an embodiment of the present disciosure. FIG. 3 is descri bed i n conjunction with elements from FIGs. 1 and 2. With reference to FIG. 3, there is shown a block diagram 300 of a system 302. The system 302 is used for determining reusability of a battery 304. The system 302 comprises a control circuit 306 communicatively coupled to a plurality of test equipment 308. Furthermore, the battery 304 comprises a plurality of cells 310 which includes one or more outl i er cel Is 312. T he control ci rcuit 306 of the system 302 is configured to execute the method 100 (of FIG. 1). The system 302 may include suitable logic, circuitry, interfaces, or code that is configured for determining reusability of the battery 304. The system 302 may be either automatic or semi -automati c i n nature. T he system 302 may be used at an el ectri c vehi cl e servi ce stati on. Moreover, the system 302 uses a comprehensive approach (i.e„ the method 100) in order to process the battery 304 quickly and to determine whether the battery 304 is reusable or not with reliability. The control circuit 306 may include suitable logic, circuitry, interfaces, or code that is configured to control the plurality of test equi pment 308 to conduct various tests on each of the pl ural ity of cel Is 310 of the battery 304. Exampl es of the control ci rcuit 306 may i nd ude, but are not limited to, a processor, a co-processor, a microprocessor, a microcontroller, a complex instruction set computing (CISC) processor, an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC) processor, a reduced instruction set(RISC) processor, avery long instruction word (V LIW) processor, a central process!ng unit (C PU), a state machine, a data process! ng unit; and other processors or circuits. Moreover, the control circuit 306 may refer to one or more individual processors, processing devices, a processing unit that is part of a machine There is provided the system 302 of determining reusability of the battery 304. The system 302 comprises the control circuit 306 communicatively coupled to the plurality of test 16 equipment 308, wherein the control circuit 306 causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to conduct one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery 304. Initially, each of the plurality of test equipment 308 is configured to conduct the one or more safety di agnosti c tests on the battery 304. T he safety di agnosti c tests have been descri bed i n detai I, for example, in FIG. 1. The control circuit 306 further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to measure an Open Circuit Voltage (OCV) for each of the plurality of cells 310 in the battery 304 to determine a state of charge of the battery 304. The OCV of each of the plurality of cells 310 of the battery 304 is measured to identify the electrical potential capabil ity of the battery 304. The control circuit 306 further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to perform an Electrochemical Dynamic Response (EDR) test on the battery 304 to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters for each of the cells. After measuring the OCV of each of the pl ural ity of cel Is 310 of the battery 304, the one or more of the pl urality of test equipment 308 is configured to perform the EDR test on each of the plurality of cells 310 of the battery 304 to compute the i mpedance (e.g„ ohmi c resistance) and I ithi urn transport (e.g„ I ithi um plati ng) parameters of each of the cel Is. The control circuit 306 further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to analyse the derived impedance and lithium transport parameters to identify one or more outl i er cel Is 312 i n the battery 304. T he derived i mpedance and I ithi um transport parameters of each of the plurality of cells 310 of the battery 304 are analysed to identify the one or more outlier cells 312 with high impedance and low capacity. The control circuit 306 further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to conduct one or more A C tests on the i denti f i ed outl i er cel I s to predi ct a degradati on pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery 304. If analysis of the E DR test identifies one or more cells from the plurality of cells 310 of the battery 304 which perform unsatisfactorily (i.e„ the one or more outlier cells 312) then, part of battery 304 containing the one or more outlier cells 312 whose performance is unsatisfactory, is separately subjected to the one or more A C tests. T he one or more A C tests are conducted to determi ne whether the degradati on pathway of the outl i er cel I s i s favourabl e or unfavourabl e for reuse. The control circuit 306 further causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment 308 to designate the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on the predi cted degradati on pathway. T he testi ng data obtai ned by conducti ng the one or more A C tests on the identified outlier cells is used to decide whether the outlier cells are suitable for reuse in the second application or discard the outlier cells for recycling, based on the predicted degradation pathway. FIG. 4 is an exemplary illustration to perform one or more tests and to identify one or more outlier cells in a battery, in accordance with an embodiment of the present disclosure. FIG. 4 is described in conjunction with elements from FIGs. 1, 2A-2B and 3. With reference to FIG. 4, there is shown an exemplary illustration 400 that depicts performing one or more tests on the battery 304 (of FIG. 3) comprising the plurality of cells 310 in order to identify the one or more outlier cells 312 in the battery 304. The battery 304 is represented by a dashed box, whi ch i s used for i 11 ustrati on purposes only and does not form a part of ci rcui try. The control circuit 306 of the system 302 causes the plurality of test equipment 308 to perform HV safety diagnostics tests on the battery 304. Thereafter, measuring the OCV of each of the plurality of cells 310 of the battery to determine the SoC of the battery 304. The plurality of test equipment 308 is further configured to perform the E DR test on the battery 304toderivetheimpedance(i.e„ ohmic resistance) and lithiumtransport parameters of each of the pl ural ity of cel Is 310 of the battery 304. T he derived i mpedance and I ithi um transport parameters are analysed to identify the one or more outlier cells 312 in the battery 304. The porti on of the battery 304 compri si ng the i denti f i ed one or more outl i er cel I s 312 i s subj ected to the one or more A C tests i nstead of subj ecti ng the compl ete battery (i. e„ the battery 304) to the AC tests. Consecutively, time optimization and reliability are obtained while testing the battery 304. The one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outlier cells to predict the degradation pathway and to decide which outlier cells are suitable for reuse in the second appl i cati on and whi ch one shoul d be recyd ed based on the predicted degradati on pathway. Modifications to embodiments of the present disclosure described in the foregoing are possible without departing from the scope of the present disclosure as defined by the accompanying claims. Expressions such as "including", "comprising", "incorporating", "have", "is" used to describe and claim the present disclosure are intended to be construed in a non-exdusive manner, namely allowing for items, components or elements not explicitly described also to be present Reference to the singular is also to be construed to relate to the plural. The word "exemplary" is used herein to mean "serving as an example, instance or illustration". Any embodiment described as 'exemplary, is not necessarily to be construed as preferred or advantageous over other embodiments and / or to exclude the incorporation of features from other embodiments. The word "optionally" is used herein to mean "is provided in some embodiments and not provided in other embodiments". It is appreciated that certain features of the present disclosure, which are, for clarity, described in the context of separate embodiments, may also be provided in combination in a single embodiment Conversely, various features of the present disclosure, which are, for brevity, described in the context of a single embodiment may also be provided separately or in any suitable combination or as suitable in any other described embodiment of the disclosure.
Claims
1. A method(100) of determining reusability of a battery (304) comprising: conducting one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery (304);measuring an Open Circuit Voltage (OCV) for each of a plurality of cells (310) in the battery (304) to determi ne a state of charge of the battery (304);performing an Electrochemical Dynamic Response (EDR) test on the battery (304) to derive i mpedance and I ithi um transport parameters for each of the cel I s;analysing the derived impedance and lithium transport parameters to identify one or more outlier cells (312) in the battery (304);conducting one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells to predict a degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery (304); anddesignating the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on the predicted degradation pathway.
2. T he method (100) accordi ng to cl ai m 1, further compri si ng determi ni ng whether the OCV for each of the plurality of cells (310) in the battery (304) is below a pre-defined threshold voltage.
3. The method (100) according to claim 2, further comprising identifying one or more damaged cells in the battery (304) for replacement when the determined OCV is less than the pre-defined threshold voltage for the one or more damaged cells.
4. The method (100) according to any of the preceding claims, wherein the E D R test on the battery (304) is further configured to derive a state of health of Direct Current (DC) discharge data of the battery (304) based on at least one of: a correlation between capacity and temperature of the battery (304) or a correlation between the capacity and voltage of the battery (304).
5. The method (100) according to daim4, further comprising analysing the derived state of health to i dentify the one or more outl i er cel I s (312) i n the battery (304).
6. The method (100) according to claim 4 or 5, further comprising comparing data from the derived state of health with a model dataset; having a plurality of predefined test values, of the battery (304) to further evaluate the outlier cells of the battery (304).
7. T he method (100) accordi ng to any one of the precedi ng cl ai ms, wherei n the one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells are conducted either in-situ within the battery (304) or ex-situ by removi ng the identified outlier cel Is from the battery (304).
8. T he method (100) accordi ng to any one of the precedi ng cl ai ms, wherei n the one or more AC tests are conducted on the identified outlier cells at different amplitudes and different frequencies.
9. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the outlier cells are designated for reuse i n the second appl i cati on when the degradati on pathway for the cel I s over the I ifeti me of the battery (304) i s predi cted to be favourabl e for the reuse i n the second application.
10. The method (100) accordi ng to any one of the preceding claims, whereinthe outlier cells are designated for recycling when the degradation pathway for the cells over the lifetime of the battery (304) is predicted to be unfavourable for reuse.
11. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the identified outlier cells are removed from the battery (304) and replaced with cells having substantially similar impedance and state of health as that of healthy cells remaining in the battery (304).
12. A system (302) of determining reusability of a battery (304), comprising:a control ci rcuit (306) communi catively coupl ed to a pl ural ity of test equi pment (308), wherein the control circuit (306) causes one or more of the plurality of test equipment (308) to:conduct one or more safety diagnostic tests on the battery (304);measure an Open Circuit Voltage (OCV) for each of a plurality of cells (310)i n the battery (304) to determi ne a state of charge of the battery (304);perform an Electrochemical Dynamic Response (EDR) test on the battery (304) to derive impedance and lithium transport parameters for each of the cells;analyse the derived impedance and lithium transport parameters to identify one or more outl ier cel Is i n the battery (304);conduct one or more AC tests on the identified outlier cells to predict a degradati on pathway for the cel I s over the I ifeti me of the battery (304); anddesignate the outlier cells for reuse in a second application or for recycling based on the predicted degradation pathway.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Device and method for calculating value of rechargeable battery
US20130057291A1
Secondary battery reuse method, vehicle drive power source, and vehicle
US20150093611A1
Reconditioned battery pack and method of making same
US20190207269A1
Estimation device, energy storage device, method for estimation, and computer program
US20210293892A1
Electric storage apparatus
US10012700B2
