Improved performance of technical ceramics
ALD-coated ceramic particles with conformal sintering aid films address high temperature challenges in SOFCs and 3D printing by achieving reduced sintering temperatures and improved mechanical strength, enhancing ionic conductivity and part reliability.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024145029
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2017-06-16
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-27
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Existing 8YSZ-based solid oxide fuel cells face high operating and sintering temperatures, which limit material choices and require long start-up times, and 3D printed ceramic parts suffer from poor adhesion and resolution issues, especially in the Z-axis, leading to fragility and poor mechanical strength.
Ceramic particles with a core substrate coated by a thin, conformal sintering aid film using atomic layer deposition (ALD), allowing for lower sintering temperatures and improved mechanical strength, and the development of optimized 3D ink formulations for uniform distribution and improved part integrity.
The ALD-coated ceramic particles achieve near-theoretical density at reduced temperatures, enhance ionic conductivity, and improve the reliability and consistency of 3D printed parts, enabling lower operating temperatures for SOFCs and better mechanical properties.
Smart Images

Figure 2024164202000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to technical ceramics. [Background technology]
[0002] (Government Support) This invention was made in part with U.S. Government support under Contract NSF CMMI 1563537 awarded by the National Science Foundation and Grant APP-43889 awarded by the State of Colorado's Advanced Industries Accelerator Program. The U.S. Government has certain rights in this invention.
[0003] (Related Applications) This application claims priority to U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62 / 418,666, filed November 7, 2016, and U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62 / 520,655, filed June 16, 2017, which are incorporated herein by reference.
[0004] Eight mole percent (8 mol%) yttria-stabilized cubic zirconia ("8YSZ") has practical applications in solid oxide fuel cells ("SOFCs"), but has several inherent drawbacks, such as high operating temperatures, high sintering temperatures, low ionic conductivity, and weak mechanical strength. The addition of alumina (Al2O3) by ball milling, a process that uses high-energy collisions of hard balls with a powder mixture of Al2O3 and 8YSZ, has been shown to reduce the sintering temperature and increase the mechanical strength and ionic conductivity.
[0005] 8YSZ is most commonly used as a solid electrolyte in SOFCs because it is a chemically stable and inexpensive option. SOFCs must be operated at high temperatures, over 700 °C, to have adequate ionic conductivity. This high operating temperature also limits the use of potential construction materials and requires long start-up times. Further limiting the applications of 8YSZ are the high sintering temperatures required to produce a dense SOFC electrolyte. Typically, commercially available electrolytes are sintered at 1450 °C for about 4 hours. Since an attractive route to SOFC fabrication is to co-sinter the electrolyte with all other components, such as the anode, cathode, and interconnects, the material requiring the highest sintering temperature (typically 8YSZ) dictates the co-sintering temperature. However, exposing components other than 8YSZ to 1450 °C for several hours can have a detrimental effect on performance. Minimizing both the high sintering temperature and the time required has been an unmet need.
[0006] Expectations for the quality and variety of products currently produced by 3D printing with available 3D inks are still not being met. 3D printing, including fused deposition modeling (FDM), places layers of ink material with the intent that the layers will fuse together to form a layered three-dimensional part. 3D printing, including FDM, places layers of ink material with the intent that the layers will fuse together to form a layered three-dimensional part. However, the final parts or output from 3D printing is not consistently good. The final 3D parts are often fragile or peel off easily. Layered 3D parts do not bond well in the Z axis as they do in the XY plane, and as a result, forces from the side can easily destroy the part.
[0007] Additionally, current 3D part printing is generally not suitable for producing small parts where high resolution is required. Because the print is three-dimensional, the resolution depends on the minimum feature dimension in the XY plane and the Z-axis resolution. The Z-axis resolution is related to the layer height and less to the print quality. The XY resolution, or minimum feature dimension, is measured by microscopic imaging and is the more important of the two as it allows for the production of fine detail in the part. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0008] [Patent Document 1] U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62 / 418,666 [Patent Document 2] U.S. Provisional Patent Application No. 62 / 520,655 Summary of the Invention
[0009] The invention relates, in part, to the discovery of ceramic particles comprising: a core substrate selected from yttria stabilized zirconia, partially stabilized zirconia, zirconium oxide, aluminum nitride, silicon nitride, silicon carbide, and cerium oxide; and a conformal coating of a sintering aid film overlying the core substrate, the conformal coating having a thickness of less than 3 nanometers. In one embodiment of the invention, the conformal coating of the sintering aid film overlying the core substrate has a thickness of less than 1 nanometer to 1 nanometer. In another embodiment, the conformal coating of the sintering aid film overlying the core substrate has a thickness of about 2 nanometers.
[0010] In yet another embodiment, the conformal coating of the sintering aid film is a uniform conformal coating of the core substrate. In another embodiment, the conformal coating of the core substrate comprises islands of the film uniformly distributed across the surfaces of the ceramic particles.
[0011] Disclosed herein are ceramic particles in which the core comprises yttria stabilized zirconia or partially stabilized zirconia and the sintering aid film comprises alumina.
[0012] Disclosed herein is a method of forming a ceramic particle comprised of a core substrate having a conformal coating of a sintering aid film having a thickness of less than 3 nanometers, where the sintering aid film covering the core substrate is formed by atomic layer deposition ("ALD"). In one embodiment of the present invention, the ceramic particle having a conformal coating of a sintering aid film is prepared using one cycle of atomic layer deposition of the sintering aid film; then sintered at about 1350°C for about 2 hours in air. In another embodiment of the present invention, the ceramic particle is prepared by about 1 cycle to about 9 cycles of atomic layer deposition of the sintering aid.
[0013] Also disclosed are methods and compositions relating to colloidal gels or slurries suitable for producing 3D inks for three-dimensional printing, the 3D inks having ceramic particles as disclosed herein, the ceramic particles comprising a core substrate and a conformal coating of a sintering aid film less than 3 nanometers thick over the core substrate.
[0014] Another embodiment of the invention is a solid oxide fuel cell electrolyte comprising a ceramic particle as disclosed herein, the ceramic particle having a core substrate and a conformal coating of a sintering aid film overlying the core substrate, the conformal coating being less than 3 nanometers thick. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0015] Embodiments of the invention are further described below with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which: [Figure 1] 1 is a graph of volumetrically measured relative density for various sample types sintered at 1350° C. for 2 hours in air as a function of ALD cycle number, where “BM” represents prior art ball milled samples. [Diagram 2] FIG. 1 is a graphical representation of the oxygen ion conductivity at various temperatures measured using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy for different types of samples sintered at 1350° C. for 2 hours in air, where “BM” represents prior art ball milled samples. [Figure 3A-D] FIG. 3A is a graph of the relative density (% theoretical) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate at a heating rate of 10° C. / min in the dilatometer experiments for all samples analyzed (coated and uncoated). FIG. 3B is a graph of the relative density (% theoretical) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate at a heating rate of 15° C. / min in the dilatometer experiments for all samples analyzed (coated and uncoated). FIG. 3C is a graph of the densification rate (1 / K) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate at a heating rate of 10° C. / min in the dilatometer experiments for all samples analyzed (coated and uncoated). FIG. 3D is a graphical representation of the densification rate (1 / K) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate at a heating rate of 15° C. / min in the dilatometer experiments for all samples analyzed (coated and uncoated). [Figure 4] FIG. 1 is a graph of apparent activation energy for densification as a function of ALD cycle number; the activation energy was determined from a series of constant heating rate dilatometer experiments. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a graph showing the decrease in ionic conductivity (S / cm) as a function of measurement temperature and ALD cycle number when the sintering temperature is decreased from 1450° C. to 1350° C.; the conductivity was measured using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy. [Figure 6] Bar graph showing the increase in R GB / R bulk at 300 °C, defined as the ratio of grain boundary resistivity to bulk resistivity after sintering at 1450 °C for 2 hours minus the ratio of grain boundary resistivity to bulk resistivity after sintering at 1350 °C for 2 hours, for 0 to 5 ALD cycles, measured using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy at 300 °C in air. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0016] The present invention includes, inter alia, the following exemplary embodiments, either alone or in combination. It will be understood that the specific embodiments of the invention are shown by way of illustration and not as limitations of the invention. The invention will first be described in its broadest overall aspect, followed by a more detailed description.
[0017] Disclosed herein are methods, and products formed thereby, that include adding a thin film of a ceramic sintering aid of a desired thickness (wt%) to a primary ceramic powder, for example by atomic layer deposition using an agitated powder reactor. For use, for example, in the preparation of 3D inks, the incorporation of a conformal coating of sintering aid around each primary ceramic substrate grain improves properties of fabricated parts related to grain boundary phenomena such as impurity removal, grain boundary diffusion, grain growth, liquid phase sintering, ionic conductivity, thermal conductivity, and others, and has improved homogeneity of dense parts compared to conventional techniques such as ball milling, spray drying, and sol-gel processing. Sintering is the process of reducing a material to a coherent or compact dense mass by the application of heat and / or pressure without melting or liquefying the material. As used herein, "densification" and "sintering," and grammatical variations thereof, have the same meaning. Sintering aids help impart integrity and compressive strength to the material being sintered.
[0018] Furthermore, in the production of ceramic slurries or colloids, for example in additive manufacturing via tape casting or direct ink writing, a thin film of sintering aid allows for easy rheology control by exposing only one side (sintering aid) compared to traditional sintering aid incorporation methods where multiple surfaces and therefore multiple surface charges are present (i.e., sintering aid and primary ceramic). For fine ceramic precursor powders, such as aluminum nitride (AlN), which tend to degrade in aqueous environments, a thin, pinhole-free conformal coating of oxide ceramic sintering aid makes the particles resistant to degradation by water, thereby enabling aqueous processing, which is important, for example in direct ink writing (additive manufacturing). 3 wt. % yttrium oxide is an excellent sintering agent for aluminum nitride. A more detailed explanation follows.
[0019] Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD), a thin film deposition technique, is a self-limiting surface reaction that deposits a uniform layer of a desired precursor on the particle surface. This is done by fluidizing the particles and adding two different precursors in sequence, resulting in two reactions occurring in succession. To add Al2O3 to 8YSZ, the reaction utilizes trimethylaluminum (TMA) and water as precursors, adding first TMA, then water, then TMA, and so on in the same order. One addition of TMA and one addition of water constitutes one cycle. The reaction proceeds in a fluidized bed reactor, helping to ensure coating of all surfaces.
[0020] Previous studies have investigated the effect of Al2O3 on the kinetics of 8YSZ densification. These studies compared unadded 8YSZ to samples mixed with Al2O3 concentrations ranging from 0.1 to 10 wt% Al2O3, where Al2O3 was incorporated in amounts typically less than 1 wt%, optimal for minimizing sintering temperatures and apparent activation energies, using conventional processes such as milling, spray drying, and sol-gel type processing.
[0021] According to the present invention, a method is provided for adding Al2O3 as a sintering aid to 8YSZ using atomic layer deposition (ALD). The effect of the ALD-produced mixture on sintering behavior, kinetics, and ionic conductivity, and on as-received 8YSZ for comparison, was tested. Al2O3 was deposited as a conformal coating on 8YSZ particles at concentrations ranging from about 1 to about 4 weight percent, corresponding to 1 to 9 ALD cycles, respectively. According to another embodiment of the present invention, the mass or weight of alumina in the sintering aid film is from about 0.2 weight percent to about 2 weight percent of the ceramic particles. The addition of Al2O3 reduces the temperature required for sintering by about 100° C. in all samples and reduces the apparent activation energy of densification. The optimal concentration of Al2O3 was found to be about 2.2 weight percent, corresponding to about 5 ALD cycles that reduces the apparent activation energy from about 700 kJ / mol to about 400 kJ / mol. The ceramic particles prepared according to one embodiment of the present invention are non-reactive with water.
[0022] (Ink for 3D printing) In the 3D ink industry, there is a continuing need for methods to achieve more uniform distribution of ceramic and sintering aids, improving the reliability and consistency of the parts produced, as well as densification through closer packing of particles, which is critical for the production of small parts.
[0023] We investigated the effect of Al2O3 addition by ALD on densification and ionic conductivity, developed a robust 3D ink formulation, and successfully printed 3D lattice structures that were further analyzed. Different amounts of Al2O3 were added to 8YSZ to study the effect on densification behavior through constant rate heating experiments using a horizontal push rod dilatometer. The effects examined included the sintering temperature, the temperature at which the maximum densification rate occurs, the kinetics at which densification proceeds, the overall ionic conductivity as a function of temperature, and the relative contributions of grain boundary and bulk resistivity. Ink formulations were determined by preparing multiple ink batches and varying the solids loading and relative polymer amounts to obtain the desired rheology for printing at the maximum solids volume percent. The optimized ink was then used to print 3D structures, which were sintered and examined under SEM.
[0024] One embodiment of the present invention is a material composition for 3D printing, which includes solids dispersed in a colloid, the solids conformally coated with a solid-state sintering additive. In another embodiment, the dispersed solids are conformally coated with a solid-state sintering additive by atomic layer deposition (ALD). In yet another embodiment, the conformal coating is also uniform throughout. The present invention includes, among others, the following, alone or in combination:
[0025] Prior art ball milling of Al2O3 and 8YSZ results in only a reasonably uniform distribution of ceramic and sintering aids. However, using ALD coating of particles, in contrast to ball milling, results in precise, uniform conformal coating of the 8YSZ ceramic particles with Al2O3. In coating all substrate particles uniformly by ALD, one can be sure that the sintering aids are utilized throughout the densified matrix. The uniform conformal coating also allows for the use of lower temperatures for densification, which would also reduce the tendency for grain size / defect dimensions to grow. The lower temperatures also appear to reduce the amount of sintering aid required to be deposited on the substrate particles to achieve high density during part fabrication.
[0026] In prior art methods, the incorporation of sintering aids as particulate additives is expected to result in particulate inclusions at triple grain junctions in the densified matrix. In contrast, when sintering aid additives are deposited as conformal or uniform conformal coatings by ALD in accordance with one embodiment of the present invention, the additives are present as intergranular amorphous thin films rather than as particulates. The presence of an amorphous, uniform, conformal film coating between the ceramic grains allows for lower temperature densification and improved homogeneity of the densified part.
[0027] Stability is very important for use in 3D printing or additive manufacturing, and colloidal gels need to be prepared from core / shell substrate / sintering aid particles. Since the colloidal properties are a result of fine-tuning the dispersion to suspend the particles in the ink / gel, it is important to optimize the chemical properties of the suspended ceramic particles. For traditional ball-milled precursors, there are two surfaces that require stabilization (the substrate ceramic and the sintering aid), and the gel formulation will be a compromise of the properties of the substrate and the sintering aid. For particulate ALD coatings, there is only one surface to be optimized, and that is the surface of the sintering aid surrounding each particle. Therefore, not only is it easier to prepare a colloidal gel, but it is also easier to prepare a gel that is truly optimized for that system. This leads to improved preparation of 3D inks / gels with improved flowability for additive manufacturing and ultimately improved part-to-part reliability.
[0028] Importantly, by using ALD rather than ball milling, smaller sized substrate ceramic particles can be used, thus achieving denser packing and overall improved densification uniformity. This unexpected result demonstrates the importance of using ALD to conformally coat substrate ceramic particles in producing 3D inks, which is critical for the fabrication of very small 3D parts where complete densification is required.
[0029] (Solid oxide fuel cell) The cost of operating SOFCs currently remains high because they must be operated at high temperatures, at least due to the ionic resistance of 8YSZ increasing with decreasing temperature. Thus, there is an unmet need to be able to lower the operating temperature of fuel cells, which can be realized by improving the properties of 8YSZ. 8YSZ has a high sintering temperature of 1450°C. However, the addition of Al2O3 has been demonstrated to lower this temperature, as well as reducing the manufacturing costs of SOFCs. It also has a positive effect on improving ionic conductivity at lower temperatures, which in turn reduces the operating temperature of SOFCs. It can be important that the ionic conductivity of 8YSZ remains fairly stable when used in SOFCs.
[0030] (Example) The main equipment used for the dilatometric studies included a dilatometer, a planetary centrifugal mixer, a hydraulic press, and a cylindrical steel die. The dilatometer requires a cylindrical ceramic powder compact. To accomplish this, 8YSZ powder with or without Al2O3 was mixed with a polymeric binder, a solution of 2 wt% poly(vinyl alcohol) (Acros Organics, 98.0-98.8% hydrolyzed, average molecular weight approximately 31,000-50,000 g / mol), and 98 wt% deionized water. The binder was incorporated by mixing 4 grams of binder, 20 grams of 8YSZ powder, and 25 grams of grinding media (Tosoh Corp, 5 mm diameter, YTZ grinding media) in a planetary centrifugal mixer at 1100 rpm for 30 seconds. The planetary centrifugal mixer thoroughly disperses the binder throughout the ceramic powder by simultaneously undergoing high speed revolution and rotation while the grinding media aids in dispersion.
[0031] After thorough mixing, the 8YSZ powder / binder mixture was separated from the grinding media. Cylindrical compacts were produced by placing 0.45 grams of the 8YSZ powder / binder mixture, subjected to 1 ton of pressure for 90 seconds using a hydraulic press, into a cylindrical die with an inner diameter of 6 mm. The compact was then removed from the die and assigned a compact number. Samples were pressed for 8YSZ powder with 0 to 9 Al2O3 ALD cycles.
[0032] The dilatometer includes a sample holder, a furnace, and a push rod to measure the displacement. A constant force of 35 centiNewtons (35 cN) was applied to the push rod to maintain constant contact with the test sample as the sample contracted during heating.
[0033] Each sample was sintered in air. Before inserting the compact into the dilatometer, the length was measured and recorded using calipers. The compact number was recorded along with the heating test to be performed. Constant rate heating experiments were then performed as follows: heating from room temperature to 600°C (binder burnout) at a heating rate of 1°C / min, heating from 600°C to 1550°C at the desired heating rate (5, 10, 15, or 20°C / min), cooling to room temperature at 20°C / min. During these experiments, the linear contraction was recorded by the dilatometer, calibrated using a sapphire standard. The contraction was then related to density by correcting for the thermal expansion of the sample using the cooling portion of the curve and assuming isotropic contraction. Thus, these experiments make it possible to produce density as a function of temperature, heating rate, and type of sample. The densification rate is then taken as the first derivative of density with respect to temperature and approximated using finite differences. The density and densification rate can then be used to estimate the apparent activation energy of densification by exploiting the Arrhenius-type dependence of the densification rate on temperature.
[0034] The main equipment for ink formulation is a high precision scale accurate to 0.1 milligrams and a planetary mixer. The planetary mixer allows for thorough mixing of high viscosity inks. It works by orienting the container at 45° to a vertical axis and spinning the container counterclockwise. As the container spins counterclockwise on its own axis, it rotates in a clockwise direction along the vertical axis, which creates vertical spiral convection and exerts a force of 400G on the ink, effectively expelling all the air as well. Ink formulation starts with a small container that fits into the planetary mixer. The planetary mixer is where the ink is manufactured and stored. First, YTZ grinding media is added to aid in mixing. 11.56 grams of water was added, followed by 3.86 grams of ammonium polyacrylate (Darvan 821A) as a dispersant. A large amount of powder was added in two parts to help ensure a uniform mix. First, 37 grams of 8YSZ powder (coated or uncoated) was added to the aqueous solution, which was then placed in a planetary centrifugal mixer and set to mix at 1100 rpm for 30 seconds. An additional 37 grams of 8YSZ powder was added to a total of 74 grams of powder. It was mixed again for the same time and speed. Next, 1.08 grams of hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC) was added as a thickener to prevent the ink from separating into its component parts. The colloidal ink was mixed once more, then scraped down the sides and mixed again. The final component addition was polyethyleneimine (PEI), which is in a 40% by weight solution with water to reduce viscosity and allow handling. One drop, or about 0.02 grams, was added as a flocculant. The final ink was mixed to a final solids volume of 43.5%. The ink was then sealed from air until use.
[0035] The main equipment for direct ink writing and sintering of the parts includes a 3D printer, an oil bath, and a high-temperature furnace. The 3D printer utilizes magnets for actuation so that it operates with great precision. The printer was connected to a computer from which it was operated with a specially designed program. First, the prepared 3D ink was loaded into a syringe and fitted with a tip with a diameter of 330 microns. An oil bath was placed under the 3D printer, and the printing substrate was placed in the oil bath. The substrate is ceramic and dark in color to allow visualization of the white ink. To start the printing, the syringe was placed in the printer and the printer was lowered until it just touched the surface of the substrate; it was then raised 200 microns. Before starting the printing job, a raster, or a series of parallel scan lines, was started to ensure the ink flowed smoothly. Using a computer program, the desired shape was selected, and when ready, the printer automatically performed the printing job. Once the printing was completed, the part piece was removed from the oil bath and dried in air for 48 hours. The part piece was sintered in a high-temperature tubular furnace. The sintering process started with binder burnout, then heating to 1450°C at a rate of 1.5°C / min, followed by holding at the maximum temperature for 1 hour, and then cooling to room temperature at a rate of 20°C / min.
[0036] The main equipment for ionic conductivity measurements is a mechanical press, a sintering furnace, and an electrochemical impedance spectrometer. 8YSZ powder (coated or uncoated) was mixed with 2-3 drops of poly(vinyl alcohol) and compressed to a thickness of approximately 0.5 inches by a mechanical press. The compressed pellets were then densified in air at either 1350°C or 1450°C for 2 hours. The sintered pellets were then painted with conductive platinum paste and inserted into a furnace for electrochemical impedance spectroscopy measurements. Ionic conductivity was measured in air at temperatures ranging from 300 to 800°C.
[0037] (Results and Discussion) Al2O3 was deposited by ALD onto commercial 8YSZ powder. The ALD process exhibited a nearly linear growth rate versus cycle number, thereby enabling the deposition of Al2O3 in controllable concentrations. Al2O3 was precisely deposited as a uniform, conformal coating covering each primary 8YSZ particle as a thin amorphous film. The presence of Al2O3 by ALD allows the pellets to reach near theoretical density (>94%) after sintering at 135 °C for 2 hours in air. As can be seen in Figure 1, neither YSZ without Al2O3 nor YSZ with Al2O3 incorporated by ball milling reaches this same density.
[0038] The precise incorporation of Al2O3 by ALD reduced the temperature required for sintering / densification by approximately 100°C for all Al2O3 concentrations investigated. Figure 3A shows the relative density (% theoretical) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate of 10°C / min. Figure 3B shows the relative density (% theoretical) as a function of temperature during a constant heating rate of 15°C / min. For both heating rates, the uncoated samples had lower relative densities than the coated samples. Similarly, in the early stages of sintering (relative density < 80% theoretical), all coated samples were found to have a higher densification rate than the uncoated samples at all temperatures in this regime (Figures 3C and 3D). The temperature at which the maximum densification rate is obtained is similarly reduced by approximately 100°C for all coated samples compared to uncoated 8YSZ, except for the 9ALD sample, where the temperature was reduced by less than 100°C.
[0039] An Arrhenius-type analysis of the densification rate as a function of temperature at early stage densities (60–80% density) reveals the apparent activation energy of densification for each sample type. The activation energy is highest for the uncoated samples, decreases slightly at low (1, 3 cycles) and high (7, 9 cycles) Al2O3 concentrations, and decreases significantly after 5 ALD cycles or an optimal concentration of about 2.2 wt% Al2O3 (among those evaluated) (Figure 4). This dramatic change in activation energy at 5 ALD incorporation levels suggests that conformal ALD films of this thickness (~0.5–0.7 nm) allow low activation energy diffusion processes to occur. From ~1 to ~3 ALD cycles, one would expect the absence of a monolayer around each 8YSZ particle, instead favoring the formation of small Al2O3 islands that form a submonolayer of the coating. Five ALD cycles produced a conformal monolayer of Al2O3 around each substrate grain, approximately 0.5 nm thick. As the number of ALD cycles increased, this monolayer increased in thickness, reaching a thickness of approximately 1-1.4 nm after nine ALD cycles. The minimum activation energy was found for a five-ALD film approximately 0.5 nm thick, which indicates that sufficient cations (Zr 4+ (2003) suggest that an optimal thickness is thick enough to dissolve the ZnO (ZnO-containing ZnO) and thin enough to allow easy diffusion from grain to grain. At thinner thicknesses, the formation of intergranular diffusion paths becomes insufficient. At thicker thicknesses, the film becomes thick enough to partially act as a barrier to grain boundary diffusion.
[0040] Decreasing the sintering temperature is expected to have a detrimental effect on the ionic conductivity of the 8YSZ electrolyte, due in part to the retention of pores or defects in the microstructure. Ionic conductivity measurements were obtained for 8YSZ (coated and uncoated) using electrochemical impedance spectroscopy following two sintering procedures - 2 h at 1450 °C and 2 h at 1350 °C. The decrease in conductivity with decreasing sintering temperature was found to be reduced for all coated samples evaluated (1 to 7 ALD cycles). The decrease in conductivity is similarly expected to be dependent on the measurement temperature. However, we found that the decrease in ionic conductivity was nearly constant as a function of impedance temperature, except for the sample with 3 ALD cycles. Thus, the ALD coating of Al2O3 demonstrates that decreasing the sintering temperature is not accompanied by a decrease in ionic conductivity (electrolyte performance) as is the case for the uncoated samples. The ionic conductivity of the samples sintered at 135 °C for 2 h was found to be optimized or maximized with one ALD cycle of Al2O3 (0.7 wt%), as can be seen in Figure 5. The performance of this sample was found to be superior to YSZ without Al2O3 and to YSZ with Al2O3 incorporated by ball milling. The reduction in ionic conductivity is defined as (conductivity after sintering at 1450°C minus the conductivity after sintering at 1350°C). The coated samples performed better than the uncoated samples at all temperatures. The benefit of the ALD coating increases with temperature.
[0041] Using low-temperature (300 °C) electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, the relative contributions of grain boundaries and grain interiors to the total resistivity of the electrolyte can be decoupled. After sintering at the two temperatures described above, the increase in grain boundary resistivity is significant in the uncoated sample but is less pronounced in the coated samples, especially the five-times ALD sample (Figure 6). This suggests that the ALD coating sufficiently alters the microstructure, especially the grain boundary microstructure, such that the resistivity at the grain boundaries is reduced after low-temperature sintering compared to the uncoated sample.
[0042] Colloidal gel ink formulations were developed for 8YSZ with 0, 1, and 3 cycles of ALD of Al2O3. For 8YSZ with 0 cycles of ALD of Al2O3, the optimal solids volume percent was found to be between 43.5 vol.% and 44 vol.%. Printable 8YSZ inks could be produced at 44 vol.% solids, but tended to thicken over time, clogging and stalling the printer and rendering the printed parts unusable. However, inks comprised of 43.5 vol.% solids could be printed reliably and had high viscosity to resist deformation and retain their shape after extrusion. Furthermore, ink formulations with 43.5 vol.% solids content were shown to experience minimal warping and uniform shrinkage after densification. Solids loadings above 44 vol.% caused the colloidal ink to collapse and become unprintable and rigid. The polyelectrolyte, Darvan, no longer effectively disperses the mixture, and the liquid and powder phases begin to separate. Solids loadings below 43 vol% increase the likelihood of deformation after extrusion, as well as warping and cracking during drying and densification. The final optimized ink formulation for 8YSZ with 0 cycles of Al2O3 was 43.5 vol% 8YSZ powder, 41.5 vol% water, 11.1 vol% Darvan, 3.8 vol% hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, and 0.2 vol% PEI.
[0043] The optimized ink formulation for 8YSZ was then extended to 8YSZ with one and three cycles of ALD of Al2O3. The optimal ink formulation for 8YSZ with one cycle of ALD of Al2O3 was 42.4 vol.% 8YSZ / Al2O3 powder, 42.0 vol.% water, 11.4 vol.% Darvan, 4.1 vol.% hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, and 0.2 vol.% PEI. Furthermore, the optimal ink formulation for 8YSZ with three ALD cycles of Al2O3 was 39.4 vol.% 8YSZ / Al2O3 powder, 44.8 vol.% water, 12.2 vol.% Darvan, 3.4 vol.% hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, and 0.2 vol.% PEI. Both of these formulations were successfully used to fabricate 3D square lattice structures using direct ink writing, with no clogging during printing and no warping or deformation of the final parts.
[0044] The rheology (fluid dynamics) of the selected ink is highly dependent on the surface chemistry of the ceramic particles. A solution of 8YSZ and water has a pH of about 7, and at the basic isoelectric point, the 8YSZ surface becomes positively charged. Because van der Waals forces cause the 8YSZ particles to aggregate, Darvan, a negatively charged polyelectrolyte, was added to disperse the 8YSZ powder uniformly by electrosteric repulsion. Although the dispersant allows for ink homogeneity, a flocculant must be added to ensure that the ink is stronger and has the desired mechanical properties to resist deformation. The flocculant added was PEI (polyethyleneimine), which is a positively charged polyelectrolyte. A small amount was added so that some, but not all, of the dispersant effect was counteracted. The viscosity was adjusted by adding hydroxypropyl methylcellulose and ensured that the ink did not separate into individual components. The end result was a homogeneous, viscous ink that printed without separation and retained its shape during extrusion, drying, and densification.
[0045] It was discovered that the ink formulations for 8YSZ with 0, 1, and 3 cycles of ALD of Al2O3 required the same amount of dispersant and flocculant with slightly different water and Darvan contents to control the particle surface chemistry and produce inks with the required rheology. The ink formulation depends on the particle surface chemistry, and for 1 and 3 cycles of ALD of Al2O3, only a submonolayer of Al2O3 is present. The particle surface is composed of both 8YSZ and Al2O3. Thus, it can be seen that the particle surface chemistries of both 8YSZ with 1 cycle of Al2O3 and 8YSZ with 3 cycles of Al2O3 respond similarly to the polyelectrolyte utilized in the production of colloidal gel inks.
[0046] It was also found that a significant amount of shrinkage occurs during densification of the 3D printed colloidal gel ink. For 8YSZ with 0 cycles of ALD of Al2O3, the initial dimensions of all printed parts are approximately 35.3 mm × 35.5 mm. After drying, the dimensions are 34.7 mm × 34.8 mm, which is approximately 4% shrinkage. The dimensions of the sintered pieces average 27.3 mm × 26.9 mm, which is approximately 40% shrinkage. This is due to the expulsion of water, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, Darvan, and PEI from the parts and the reduction of pores from between the ceramic particles.
[0047] According to one embodiment of the present invention, the ceramic particles have a conformal coating of a sintering aid film over a core substrate and are formed by atomic layer deposition using a system selected from a fluidized bed reactor, a vibrating reactor, a rotating reactor, a spatial system in which precursor gases are spatially separated, and a batch reactor, and any desired combination thereof.
[0048] A ceramic particle according to one embodiment of the invention has a core comprising cerium oxide and a sintering aid film selected from alumina, titanium oxide, yttrium oxide, calcium oxide, iron oxide, copper oxide, chromium oxide, boron oxide, silicon dioxide, nickel oxide, and any desired combination thereof. In another embodiment, the ceramic particle core comprises aluminum nitride and the sintering aid film is selected from yttrium oxide, magnesium oxide, calcium oxide, silicon dioxide, lanthanum oxide, and any desired combination thereof.
[0049] Ceramic particles according to one embodiment of the present invention have a core selected from silicon nitride and silicon carbide, and the sintering aid film is selected from yttrium oxide, alumina, magnesium oxide, lutetium oxide, ytterbium oxide, and any desired combination thereof.
[0050] (Analysis and Recommendations) The precise coating of Al2O3 by ALD on 8YSZ is effective in reducing the sintering temperature and the temperature at which maximum densification rates are obtained by approximately 100°C. The apparent activation energy for densification was found to be similarly reduced for all coated samples when compared to uncoated 8YSZ. The optimal level of ALD incorporation to maximize the reduction in apparent activation energy was found to be 5 ALD cycles or approximately 2.2 wt% Al2O3.
[0051] A precise conformal coating of Al2O3 by ALD on 8YSZ is similarly effective in allowing sufficient electrolyte conductivity when using reduced sintering temperatures. One ALD cycle or about 0.7 wt% Al2O3 was found to be optimal for this application, but five and seven ALD cycles (about 2.2% and about 3.3 wt%) work as well. At low temperatures (300 °C), coated samples, especially those with five ALD cycles, experience a significant decrease in grain boundary resistivity after sintering at low temperatures.
[0052] For uncoated 8YSZ powder, a colloidal gel ink formulation with the highest solids loading was determined to reliably produce 8YSZ ceramic parts that do not warp or deform during sintering. The colloidal gel ink formulation for 8YSZ powder was then modified for 8YSZ powder with 1 and 3 cycles of ALD Al2O3 coating, and a formulation was determined to reliably print ceramic parts from 8YSZ / Al2O3 core / shell powder that do not warp or deform during sintering. The addition of the Al2O3 coating to the 8YSZ powder reduces the sintering temperature compared to uncoated 8YSZ powder; that is, uncoated 8YSZ powder can be printed and sintered / densified, but it requires a higher densification temperature than is required for parts made from 8YSZ powder with 1 and 3 cycles of ALD Al2O3 coating.
[0053] 3YSZ stands for zirconia doped with three mole percent (3 mol%) yttria. 3YSZ is also called "Y-TZP." We have tailored and optimized a colloidal gel ink formulation for 3YSZ (partially stabilized zirconia or Y-TZP) conformally coated with alumina by atomic layer deposition. The ALD coating of zirconium ceramic particles with alumina should be beneficial as a sintering aid for any level of yttrium doping of zirconium oxide. In practice, we have found that the doping amount can be varied slightly from about 3 percent to about 8 percent to obtain different properties.
[0054] The dopant concentration in zirconia determines the crystal structure of the material. Zirconia doped with 3 mole percent, 3YSZ, is a mechanically strong tetragonal phase and has been used in dental ceramics. This specification discloses that when 20 wt. % Al2O3 is added as a conformal coating to 3YSZ (ATZ) by ALD, the mechanical properties are further improved. Alumina-toughened zirconia (ATZ) ceramics, where alumina is added as a conformal coating by ALD, may be an important material for use in biomedical implants and other engineering applications requiring high strength and wear resistance at ambient temperatures.
[0055] As used herein, the number before "YSZ" indicates the mole percentage doped with yttria. 8 mol% doping optimally stabilizes the cubic structure of ZrO2, which is suitable for oxygen ion conduction (e.g., in solid-state electrochemical devices). 8YSZ is commonly referred to as "yttria-stabilized zirconia," "yttria-stabilized cubic zirconia," "cubic stabilized zirconia," or "fully stabilized zirconia." 3YSZ can also be referred to as "yttria-stabilized zirconia," but is more commonly referred to as "tetragonal zirconia polycrystalline," "TZP," "Y-TZP," "tetragonal polycrystalline zirconia," "yttria-stabilized tetragonal zirconia," or "partially stabilized zirconia."
[0056] Other "stabilizers" such as Sc2O3 can also be used to control the crystal structure of ZrO2 in the same manner as Y2O3. In yet another embodiment of the present invention, Al2O3 sintering aids deposited by atomic layer deposition should also be beneficial in these cases.
[0057] It should be understood that features, integers, properties, compounds, chemical moieties or groups described in connection with a particular aspect, embodiment or example of the invention are applicable to other aspects, embodiments or examples described herein, unless incompatible. All features disclosed herein (including the accompanying drawings), and / or all steps of any method or process so disclosed, may be combined in any combination, except combinations in which at least some of such features and / or steps are mutually exclusive. The figures in the drawings are not necessarily to scale. The invention is not limited to the details of the foregoing embodiments. The invention extends to any novel, or any novel combination of features disclosed herein (including the accompanying drawings), or any novel, or any novel combination of steps of any method or process so disclosed.
[0058] (equivalent) Although the present invention has been particularly shown and described with reference to preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail can be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention.
Claims
1. Ceramic particles, a core substrate selected from yttria stabilized zirconia, partially stabilized zirconia, zirconium oxide, aluminum nitride, silicon nitride, silicon carbide, and cerium oxide; and a coating of a sintering aid film having a thickness of less than 3 nanometers covering the core substrate; and ceramic particles having the following structure: Water; and one or more of a dispersant, a viscosity modifier, and a flocculating agent; having 1. A colloidal gel or slurry comprising:
2. 10. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 1, wherein the coating of the sintering aid film over the core substrate has a thickness less than the thickness of one monolayer.
3. 10. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 1, wherein the coating comprises alumina.
4. 4. A colloidal gel or slurry according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the coating of sintering aid film over the core substrate comprises islands of film across the surfaces of the ceramic particles.
5. 10. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 1, wherein the core substrate is yttria stabilized zirconia and the sintering aid film coating comprises alumina.
6. 2. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 1, wherein the core substrate is yttria partially stabilized zirconia and the sintering aid film coating comprises alumina.
7. 4. The colloidal gel or slurry of any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the core substrate is cerium oxide and the sintering aid film is selected from alumina, titanium oxide, yttrium oxide, and any combination thereof.
8. A colloidal gel or slurry according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that the colloidal gel or slurry has a viscosity modifier comprising hydroxypropylmethylcellulose.
9. 9. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 8, wherein the colloidal gel or slurry has a dispersant comprising ammonium polyacrylate.
10. 10. The colloidal gel or slurry of claim 9, wherein the colloidal gel or slurry has a flocculant comprising polyethyleneimine.
11. 4. The colloidal gel or slurry of any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the core substrate is yttria stabilized zirconia and the yttrium oxide doping of the yttria stabilized zirconia is 8 mole percent.
12. A colloidal gel or slurry according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that the gel or slurry contains 42.0% to 44.8% water by volume.
13. 13. A method of forming a three-dimensional sintered structure using the colloidal gel or slurry of claim 1, said method comprising: printing a component piece using the colloidal gel or slurry; drying the piece; and sintering the piece; having the grain boundary resistivity between the core substrate and the coating is reduced after sintering; A method comprising:
14. A colloidal gel or slurry according to any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that it comprises a dispersant, a viscosity modifier and a flocculating agent.
15. A solid oxide fuel cell made by sintering the particles of claim 1.
16. 10. The colloidal gel of claim 1, wherein the core substrate comprises scandium oxide.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
3D printing method for biological ceramic green body
CN106003363A
Coating ceramic particles and manufacture thereof
JP1991187978A
Solid electrolyte fuel cell
JP2002134121A
Method for insulating and functionalizing metal-containing fine particles having conformal ultra-thin films
JP2005501176A
Method for manufacturing soft magnetic compact
JP2006351946A
