Content evaluation system, content evaluation method, and content evaluation program
The system uses NFTs and blockchain to objectively evaluate content by considering individual evaluator abilities, correcting evaluation values to ensure accurate and consistent ratings.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023085185
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-05-24
AI Technical Summary
Existing content evaluation technologies lack objectivity as they do not consider the evaluation ability of individual viewers, leading to inconsistent and subjective content ratings.
A system that generates content evaluation information based on the evaluation ability of individual evaluators using non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and blockchain technology, correcting evaluation values using evaluation ability information to ensure objectivity.
The system provides objective and reliable content evaluation by adjusting for differences in evaluation ability among viewers, resulting in more accurate and consistent content ratings.
Smart Images

Figure 2024168471000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a technique for evaluating the value of content consisting of moving images, images, specific information, or a combination of these. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, with the development of SNS (social networking services), a vast amount of content, consisting of creative works such as videos and images, as well as other prescribed information, has been created and distributed compared to the past. The existence of a vast amount of content is very desirable from the perspective of diversity, but on the other hand, it is also true that the quality of the content is a mixed bag. For this reason, technology related to content evaluation has been developed so that viewers can selectively view high-quality content.
[0003] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a technology for estimating the concentration level of a viewer based on a pulse wave, which is a waveform representing the volume change of the viewer's internal blood vessels from an image of the viewer while viewing content, and giving a high rating to content that has a high level of concentration. Patent Document 2 discloses a technology for evaluating content by detecting a visual target toward which the viewer's gaze is directed while eliminating the attractiveness that reflexively attracts the gaze. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2022-169224 A [Patent Document 2] Patent Publication No. 2022-138858 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] However, the technologies disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2 have a problem in that the obtained evaluation value of the content depends on the viewer and cannot guarantee objectivity. Specifically, the technologies disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2 are configured to perform content evaluation in the same way for all viewers regardless of the level of evaluation ability for the content, so that a situation may occur in which content of a quality that would never be evaluated by a viewer with excellent evaluation ability is highly evaluated by a viewer with poor evaluation ability. In other words, the technologies disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2 have a problem in that the evaluation value of the content is determined according to the popularity among a large number of viewers, regardless of the level of the viewer's evaluation ability, and an objective evaluation value cannot be calculated.
[0006] The present invention has been made in consideration of the above-mentioned problems, and aims to provide a technology for objectively evaluating content consisting of creative works such as videos and images, as well as other specified information, depending on the viewer's level of evaluation ability. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] In order to achieve the above object, the content evaluation system of claim 1 comprises a content evaluation information generating means for generating content evaluation information, which is information regarding the evaluation of a content to be evaluated, based on the result of a correction process performed on evaluation values created by multiple evaluators for the content to be evaluated, using evaluation ability information related to the evaluators who created the evaluation values; an evaluation ability information generating means for generating the evaluation ability information based on the result of a correction process performed on evaluation values created by the evaluators to be evaluated for the multiple contents, using content evaluation information created by the content evaluation information generating means for the contents; and an output means for outputting the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputting the evaluation ability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators, wherein the content evaluation information generating means performs a second correction process using the evaluation ability information generated by the evaluation ability information generating means, and corrects the content evaluation information based on the information obtained by the second correction process, and the output means outputs the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generating means to the first distributed network.
[0008] In addition, in order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the content evaluation system of claim 2, in the above-mentioned invention, is characterized in that the content evaluation information generating means performs processing including, as the correction processing and the re-correction processing, a processing of multiplying the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator by the evaluation ability information consisting of numerical information regarding the evaluator who created the evaluation value.
[0009] In addition, in order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the content evaluation system of claim 3 is characterized in that, in the above-mentioned invention, the evaluation capability information generation means performs a process including, as the correction process, a process of calculating a difference value between the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator who is the subject of evaluation for a plurality of contents, and the content evaluation information consisting of numerical information created by the content evaluation information generation means for the contents.
[0010] In addition, in order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the content evaluation method of claim 4 includes a content evaluation information generating step of generating content evaluation information, which is information regarding the evaluation of a content to be evaluated, based on the result of a correction process for evaluation values created by each of a plurality of evaluators for the content to be evaluated, using evaluation ability information related to the evaluators who created the evaluation values; an evaluation ability information generating step of generating the evaluation ability information based on the result of a correction process for evaluation values created by the evaluators to be evaluated for a plurality of contents, using content evaluation information created by the content evaluation information generating step for the contents; an output step of outputting the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputting the evaluation ability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators; a second evaluation ability information generating step of performing a second correction process using the evaluation ability information generated by the evaluation ability information generating step, and correcting the content evaluation information based on the information obtained by the second correction process; and a second output step of outputting the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generating step to the first distributed network.
[0011] In addition, in order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the content evaluation method of claim 5, in the above-mentioned invention, is characterized in that in the evaluation capability information generation step, the correction process includes a process of calculating a difference value between the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator who is the subject of evaluation for a plurality of contents, and the content evaluation information consisting of numerical information created in the content evaluation information generation step for the contents.
[0012] In order to achieve the above object, a content evaluation program according to claim 6 is a content evaluation program for causing a computer to generate content evaluation information for a content to be evaluated, the content evaluation program including: a content evaluation information generating function for generating content evaluation information, which is information regarding evaluation of the content to be evaluated, based on a result of correction processing of evaluation values generated by a plurality of evaluators for the content to be evaluated, using evaluation ability information for the evaluators who generated the evaluation values; and an evaluation ability information generating function for generating the evaluation ability information based on a result of correction processing of evaluation values generated by the evaluators for the plurality of contents to be evaluated, using content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generating function for the content. The present invention realizes an output function that outputs the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputs the evaluation ability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators, wherein the content evaluation information generation function causes the computer to perform a re-correction process using the evaluation ability information generated by the evaluation ability information generation function and correct the content evaluation information based on the information obtained by the re-correction process, and the output function causes the computer to output the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generation function to the first distributed network. Effect of the Invention
[0013] According to the present invention, it is possible to realize a system or the like that objectively evaluates content consisting of creative works such as videos and images, as well as other specified information, etc., according to the viewer's level of evaluation ability. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0014] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a configuration of a content evaluation system according to a first embodiment. [Diagram 2] 4 is a flowchart showing a process of generating content evaluation information in the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment. [Diagram 3] 10 is a flowchart showing a process of generating evaluation capability information in the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 11 is a schematic diagram showing a configuration of a content evaluation system according to a second embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0015] Hereinafter, the embodiments of the present invention will be described in detail with reference to the drawings. In the following embodiments, examples considered to be the most appropriate embodiments of the present invention will be described, and it goes without saying that the contents of the present invention should not be interpreted as being limited to the specific examples shown in the present embodiments. Of course, any configuration that achieves the same action and effect, even if it is a specific configuration other than that shown in the embodiments, is included in the technical scope of the present invention. (Embodiment 1)
[0016] First, the configuration of the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment will be described. As shown in Fig. 1, the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment includes a content information input unit 1 for inputting information about the content to be evaluated, a content token generation unit 2 for generating a content token, which is a non-fungible token having a one-to-one correspondence with the content, based on the input information, an evaluator information input unit 3 for inputting information about an evaluator who evaluates the content, an evaluator token generation unit 4 for generating an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token having a one-to-one correspondence with the evaluator, based on the input information, a holder name change information generation unit 5 for generating holder name change information which is information for changing the holder name of the content token in conjunction with a name change of the holder of the content, a content evaluation value input unit 6 for inputting an evaluation value for each piece of content generated by the evaluator, and a content evaluation value generation unit 7 for calculating the evaluation value using evaluation ability information (described later) for the input evaluation value. the content evaluation information generation unit 7 generating content evaluation information, which is evaluation information for each piece of content, based on the results of correction processing using the content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generation unit 7 for the same content as the subject of the evaluation value; an evaluation ability information generation unit 8 generating evaluation ability information, which is evaluation information on the evaluation ability of the evaluator who created the evaluation value, based on the results of correction processing using the content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generation unit 7 for the same content as the subject of the evaluation value; a transaction generation unit 9 generating a transaction including the evaluation value, the content evaluation information, and the evaluation ability information; an electronic signature generation unit 10 generating an electronic signature, which is data proving that the content of the transaction is in line with the intentions of the token holder; an output unit 11 outputting the transaction and the electronic signature to the distributed network; and a display unit 12 acquiring and displaying the information output on the distributed network.
[0017] The content information input unit 1 is for inputting information about the content to be evaluated. Specifically, the content information input unit 1 has a function of inputting at least the identification information of the content, and preferably also inputs the date and time of content generation, an outline of the content, information about the person inputting the content information, etc. Note that the "content" in the present embodiment 1 includes creative works such as videos, still images, music, and combinations of these, as well as information itself introducing recommended restaurants, dishes, clothing, power spots, goods, etc.
[0018] The content token generating unit 2 is for generating content tokens, which are non-fungible tokens corresponding to individual contents. The term "non-fungible token" refers to a so-called NFT (Non-Fangible-Token), that is, a token that has unique data and is therefore non-fungible with other tokens, and is issued based on, for example, ERC721, which is the standard of Ethereum (registered trademark). The content token in the present embodiment 1 is issued based on ERC721 or other predetermined standards, and its transaction history is stored on the blockchain.
[0019] "Blockchain" is a technology that uses encryption technology to synchronize data between multiple computers that make up a distributed network. Specifically, each block is made up of a collection of agreed-upon transaction records and information for connecting each block (information from the previous block), and a blockchain is made up of multiple blocks linked together. Even if data is tampered with on some of the multiple computers, the correct data is selected by majority vote among the other computers, making it extremely difficult to destroy or tamper with data.
[0020] The correspondence between the content token and the content is a one-to-one association between the content token identifier and the content identification information. More directly, the content token identifier and the content identification information may be the same, but a correspondence may be set between different character strings or the like.
[0021] In addition, when a content token is generated, information on the holder name of the corresponding content at the time of token generation is generated as the initial holder name of the content token. The information on the initial holder name is stored on the blockchain as part of the information stored in the blocks constituting the distributed ledger. The information on the holder name of the content token may be configured by a character string directly related to a specific name in the case of an individual, or a trade name in the case of a corporation, but it may also be configured by an account or the like consisting of a character string different from a specific name, and a correspondence between the account and the holder name may be set separately. In this way, the holder name of the content is set as the holder name of the content token in the initial state, and the holder name of the content token is similarly changed every time the content is transferred and the holder name is changed, thereby maintaining the identity of the holder name of the content and the holder name of the content token in the first embodiment.
[0022] The content token may be generated by the content token generating unit 2 itself, or may be generated by an external system that is directly or indirectly connected to the content token generating unit 2 by issuing a predetermined command to the external system. The specific format of the corresponding token is not limited to one that complies with ERC721, which is the standard of Ethereum (registered trademark), and may be any format as long as it has non-fungible properties and transaction history, etc. are stored on the blockchain.
[0023] The evaluator information input unit 3 is for inputting information about an evaluator who generates an evaluation value for the content to be evaluated. Specifically, the evaluator information input unit 3 has a function of inputting at least identification information of the evaluator, and preferably also inputs information such as the history and attributes of the evaluator. Note that the "evaluator" in the present embodiment 1 is not limited to a natural person, but may be a corporation, or a group of natural persons without legal personality. Furthermore, the "evaluator" in the present embodiment 1 includes inorganic concepts such as a computer program capable of determining an evaluation value for content according to a predetermined algorithm, AI (Artificial Intelligence), etc.
[0024] The evaluator token generation unit 4 is for generating evaluator tokens, which are non-fungible tokens corresponding to individual evaluators. As with content tokens, evaluator tokens are issued based on, for example, ERC721, which is a standard of Ethereum (registered trademark), and information on the evaluation value for each piece of content, which will be described later, is stored in a distributed ledger installed on a corresponding distributed network. Note that the distributed network for content tokens and the distributed network for evaluator tokens may be the same, or may be configured separately and independently.
[0025] The holder name change information generating unit 5 is for generating holder name change information, which is information for changing the holder name of the content token recorded in the distributed ledger, so that the holder name of the content token matches the holder name of the content token after the change when the holder name of the content token changes. Note that, with respect to the evaluator token, in the first embodiment, the evaluator does not change and holder name change information is not generated. However, if the change of the evaluator is allowed for some reason, holder name change information may be generated as information for changing the holder name for the evaluator token as in the case of the content token.
[0026] The content evaluation value input unit 6 is for inputting evaluation values for the content to be evaluated, which are created by individual evaluators. In the first embodiment, the content evaluation value is expressed as an integer (for example, an integer N that satisfies the range of 0≦N≦100), but it may be a real number or other numerical value, or may be expressed as letters such as S, A, B, C, or excellent, average, poor, etc. If expressed as letters, it is converted into numerical information before processing in the content evaluation information generation unit 7. The input evaluation value is used to generate content evaluation information in the content evaluation information generation unit 7, and is also used to generate evaluation capability information in the evaluation capability information generation unit 8, and is output to the transaction generation unit 9 to be included in the contents of the transaction.
[0027] The content evaluation information generation unit 7 is for correcting the evaluation value created by an evaluator for the content to be evaluated using evaluation ability information (described later), which is information calculated according to the evaluation ability of the evaluator, and then generating content evaluation information, which is evaluation information for the content. Here, "correction" means that in generating the content evaluation information, a correction is made to lower the influence of evaluation values created by evaluators with low evaluation ability information and to increase the influence of evaluation values created by evaluators with high evaluation ability information. In the present embodiment 1, specifically, content evaluation information is generated as follows.
[0028] That is, the content evaluation information generating unit 7 generates content evaluation information by multiplying two or more evaluation values for a specific content by the evaluation ability information of the evaluators who created the evaluation values, adding them up, and dividing the sum by the total value of the evaluation ability information of each evaluator. A is the evaluation value V of content A created by rater 1, rater 2, rater 3, ... rater n. A1 , V A2 , V A3 , V An and the evaluation capability information of each evaluator R1, R2, R3, ... Rn This is expressed by the following formula: E A =(V A1 R1+V A2 R2+V A3 R3+···+V An R n ) / (R1+R2+R3+···+R n ) (1)
[0029] By processing according to the above formula, the content evaluation information generation unit 7 increases the influence of evaluation values by evaluators with high evaluation ability information while making corrections to decrease the influence of evaluation values by evaluators with low evaluation ability information, and then generates content evaluation information based on the evaluation values created by each evaluator.
[0030] Note that the evaluation capability information of each evaluator is set to a predetermined initial value (e.g., "1") before processing by the evaluation capability information generating unit 8 described below, and then correction processing etc. expressed by the above formula (1) is performed. In this case, after the content evaluation information is generated according to formula (1), the evaluation capability information generating unit 8 generates new evaluation capability information using the content evaluation information, and the content evaluation information generating unit 7 also has a function of updating (regenerating) the content evaluation information as needed by performing correction processing again using the newly generated evaluation capability information.
[0031] In addition, the content evaluation information in this embodiment 1 is expressed as numerical information as shown in the above formula, and may be expressed as an integer value by rounding off the decimal point, or may be expressed in letters such as S, A, B, C or excellent, average, poor, etc. based on the numerical information.
[0032] The evaluation ability information generating unit 8 is for generating evaluation ability information, which is information on the evaluation ability of an evaluator, based on the degree of discrepancy between the content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generating unit 7 and the evaluation value for the content created by the evaluator. Specifically, in this embodiment 1, the evaluation ability information generating unit 8 derives a value for each individual evaluator by dividing the difference value (absolute value) between the content evaluation information and each content for which the evaluator created an evaluation value by the content evaluation information, calculates the average value of the values for each content, and then generates the difference value from a reference value (a value equal to or greater than 1; in this embodiment, 1) as evaluation ability information. Specifically, it generates content evaluation information E for contents A, B, C, ... (note that the number of contents for which the evaluator created an evaluation value is m), A , E B , E C , ..., and the evaluation value for each content by evaluator n is V An , V Bn , V Cn , ..., the evaluation capability information R n is expressed by the following formula: R n =1-[{|E A -V An | / E A}+{|E B -V Bn | / E B}+{|E C -V Cn | / E C}+···] / m···(2)
[0033] By generating evaluation capability information according to the above formula, the evaluation capability information generation unit 8 generates evaluation capability information based on the degree of deviation between the evaluation value created by the evaluator himself / herself and the content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generation unit 7, so that if the degree of deviation is large, the evaluation capability information is generated to a low value, and if the degree of deviation is small, the evaluation capability information is generated to a high value.
[0034] In addition, the evaluation capability information generation unit 8 in this embodiment 1 also has the function of updating the evaluation capability from time to time by performing correction processing using new content evaluation information, when the content evaluation information generation unit 7 generates new content evaluation information for the same content using new evaluation capability information, etc., after first generating evaluation capability information.
[0035] Furthermore, like the content evaluation information, the evaluation capability information is in principle composed of numerical information, but may be expressed using letters such as S, A, B, C or excellent, average, poor, etc. based on the numerical information.
[0036] The transaction generation unit 9 is for generating transactions to be stored in the distributed ledger. The transaction generation unit 9 includes, as the contents of a transaction corresponding to a content token, content identification information, ownership name change information, content evaluation information, and information on the evaluation value of the content created by each evaluator, and, as the contents of a transaction corresponding to a rater token, includes the identification information of the rater, evaluation ability information on the rater, and information on the evaluation value of each content created by the rater. However, it is not necessary to interpret the contents of the transaction as being limited to the above configuration, and information other than the above may be included, and for example, the evaluation value may be included only in either the transaction corresponding to the content token or the transaction corresponding to the rater token.
[0037] The electronic signature generating unit 10 generates an electronic signature, which is data that proves that the creation and output of information included in a transaction is in accordance with the intention of the holder of the content token and the evaluator token. Specifically, the electronic signature generating unit 10 generates a hash value of the transaction generated by the transaction generating unit 9 for both the transaction corresponding to the content token and the transaction corresponding to the evaluator token, and generates an electronic signature by encrypting the hash value with a private key held by the holder. Note that a "hash value" is a fixed-length value obtained by performing a certain calculation procedure on the original data. Since the calculation procedure is irreversible, it is considered impossible to restore the original data from the hash value. Also, a "private key" is a number sequence used in the encryption process, and is configured to be decryptable with a corresponding "public key."
[0038] The output unit 11 outputs the transaction generated by the transaction generation unit 9 and the electronic signature generated by the electronic signature generation unit 10 to a distributed network associated with the content token or the evaluator token, respectively. The output unit 11 is directly or indirectly connected to the distributed network, and is configured in a manner capable of outputting predetermined data to the distributed network. The distributed network generates a hash value of the output transaction, and compares it with data obtained by decrypting the electronic signature with a public key (= hash value of the transaction). If the two values are different, it determines that the transaction is not in accordance with the holder's intention and rejects registration, and if the two values match, it determines that the transaction is in accordance with the holder's intention, and stores the information constituted by the transaction in a block constituting the distributed ledger. Among the transactions output by the output unit 11, the transaction corresponding to the content token includes content identification information, ownership name change information, content evaluation information, and information regarding the evaluation value for the content created by each evaluator, and the transaction corresponding to the evaluator token includes evaluator identification information, evaluation ability information regarding the evaluator, and information regarding the evaluation value for each piece of content created by the evaluator. By outputting these transactions to the corresponding distributed network, each piece of information included in the transaction is stored in a block that constitutes a distributed ledger established on the distributed network.
[0039] The display unit 12 is for displaying information stored in blocks constituting the distributed ledger. Specifically, the display unit 12 has a function of displaying at least content evaluation information and information on the evaluation value created by each evaluator among the information included in the transaction corresponding to the content token, and evaluation ability information and information on the evaluation value created by the evaluator among the information included in the transaction corresponding to the evaluator token. The display form may be a form of visual display on a display, a form of printing and displaying on a medium such as paper, or a form of displaying the contents of the information by voice or the like.
[0040] Next, a description will be given of a process for generating content evaluation information and a process for generating evaluation capability information out of the operations of the content evaluation system according to the present embodiment 1. As shown in Fig. 2, the content evaluation system according to the present embodiment 1 inputs an evaluation value created by an evaluator for content for which evaluation information is to be generated in the content evaluation value input unit 6 (step S101), inputs evaluation capability information of the evaluator who created the evaluation value (which is a predetermined initial value (e.g., "1") before being generated by the evaluation capability information generation unit 8) (step S102), and multiplies the input evaluation value and the evaluation capability information in the content evaluation information generation unit 7 (step S103).
[0041] Thereafter, the content evaluation information generating unit 7 judges whether or not the multiplication process has been performed for all combinations of evaluation value and evaluation capability information related to the target content (step S104), and if there are any combinations of evaluation value and evaluation capability information for which the multiplication process has not been completed (step S104, No), the content evaluation information generating unit 7 returns to step S103 and performs the multiplication process. If the multiplication process has been completed for all combinations of evaluation value and evaluation capability information (step S104, Yes), the content evaluation information generating unit 7 calculates an addition value for the result of each multiplication process (step S105), calculates an addition value for each piece of evaluation capability information (step S106), and finally divides the addition value for the result of each multiplication process by the addition value for each piece of evaluation capability information (step S107), thereby completing the content evaluation information generation process.
[0042] As for the process of generating evaluation capability information, as shown in FIG. 3, the content evaluation value input unit 6 inputs an evaluation value created by an evaluator for the content for which evaluation information is to be generated (step S201), and inputs content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generation unit 7 for the content (step S202). The evaluation capability information generation unit 8 generates a difference value (absolute value) between the evaluation value and the content evaluation information for the same content (step S203), and divides the difference value by the content evaluation information (step S204).
[0043] After that, the evaluator capability information generating unit 8 checks whether the calculation process up to step S204 has been performed for all the contents for which the evaluators who are the targets of the evaluation capability generation have created evaluation values (step S205), and if there is any content for which the calculation process has not been performed (step S205, No), the unit returns to step S203 and performs the calculation process. If the calculation process has been completed for all the contents (step S205, Yes), the unit 8 further calculates an addition value for the result of each calculation process (step S206), divides the addition value by the number of contents for which the evaluators have created evaluation values (step S207), and calculates the difference between the division result and a reference value (set to "1" in this embodiment) (step S208), thereby completing the generation process of the evaluator capability information.
[0044] 2 and 3 are complementary to each other. For example, after the process shown in Fig. 3 is performed, the process shown in Fig. 2 is performed again to correct the content evaluation information, and the process shown in Fig. 3 is performed again using the corrected content evaluation information to correct the evaluation capability information. This process can be repeated.
[0045] Next, advantages of the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment will be described. First, the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment generates content evaluation information after correcting the evaluation value created by the evaluator for the content to be evaluated using evaluation ability information, which is information related to the evaluation ability of the evaluator. By adopting such a configuration, the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment has an advantage that it is possible to suppress fluctuations in content evaluation information due to differences in evaluation ability between evaluators, and to generate more objective and reliable content evaluation information.
[0046] Furthermore, in the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment, evaluation ability information for the evaluator is generated based on the result of correcting the evaluation value created by the evaluator using content evaluation information for the same content as the target of the evaluation value. By adopting such a configuration, it becomes possible to calculate the evaluation ability information of the evaluator according to the degree of deviation between the content evaluation information, which is more objective and reliable information, and the evaluation value by the evaluator, which is somewhat subjective information, and thus the content evaluation system according to the first embodiment has the advantage of being able to generate evaluation ability information that is objective and reliable. (Embodiment 2)
[0047] Next, a content evaluation system according to the embodiment 2 will be described. In the embodiment 2, components having the same names and the same reference numerals as those in the embodiment 1 have the same functions as those in the embodiment 1, unless otherwise specified.
[0048] Fig. 4 is a schematic diagram showing the configuration of the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment. As shown in Fig. 4, the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment includes a content evaluation value input unit 14 for inputting content review information, which is specific content of the content evaluation by the evaluator, in addition to the evaluation value, a transaction generation unit 15 for generating content including the content review information in addition to the content shown in the first embodiment as a transaction corresponding to the evaluator token, an electronic signature generation unit 16 for generating an electronic signature corresponding to the transaction, an output unit 17 for outputting the transaction and the electronic signature, a display unit 18 for displaying specific content of the content evaluation in addition to the information shown in the first embodiment in a state linked to the evaluator, a view count count unit 19 for counting the evaluation value and the number of views of the content review information for each evaluator, and an evaluation ability information generation unit 20 for generating evaluation ability information based on the content evaluation information, the evaluation value for the content, and the number of views.
[0049] The content review information includes information related to the content evaluation, such as the basis for creating the evaluation value by the evaluator who created the evaluation value for the content, the evaluator's impression and thoughts on the content, and other information related to the content evaluation, and may be in any specific form, including general expressions in any form such as text, video, audio, or a combination of these. In the second embodiment, the content review information is input together with the evaluation value, included in the contents of the transaction, recorded in a block of the distributed network, and widely disclosed by the display unit 18.
[0050] The display unit 18 has a function of displaying the evaluation value and content review information created by the evaluator for each evaluator and each content. As a specific display mode, the evaluation value and content review information may be displayed as they are, or may be displayed after undergoing a predetermined processing. Furthermore, for the same content and the same evaluator, the evaluation value and content review information may be displayed integrally on the same screen, or may be displayed as separate content. Note that the content displayed by the display unit 18 may be viewable by any number of people without restrictions, for example, via the Internet, but in the present embodiment 2, the evaluation value and content review information may be viewable only by evaluators other than the evaluator who created the evaluation value and content review information.
[0051] The view count tallying unit 19 has a function of tallying the number of views for the rating value and content review information displayed by the display unit 18, and outputting the tallying result to the rating capability information generating unit 20. Specifically, the view count tallying unit 19 has a function of tallying the number of views by other evaluators for each rating value and content review information (collectively if both are displayed together), and in this embodiment 2, has a function of calculating the total number of views for the rating value and content review information created by the same evaluator, and dividing the total number of views by the number of contents to be evaluated, and outputting the calculated value to the rating capability information generating unit 20.
[0052] The evaluation capability information generating unit 20 has a function of generating evaluation capability information based on the evaluation value created by the evaluator for which the evaluation capability information is to be generated and the content evaluation information related to the content corresponding to the evaluation value, as well as the numerical value calculated by the number of views counting unit 19 for the evaluator. Specifically, the evaluation capability information generating unit 20 generates evaluation capability information based on R n The view count counting unit 19 has a function of calculating evaluation capability information by multiplying the total number of views of the evaluation value and content review information created by the target evaluator divided by the number of contents.
[0053] Next, advantages of the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment will be described. In addition to the advantages of the first embodiment, the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment employs a configuration that generates evaluation ability information based on information regarding evaluations by other evaluators, who are the subject of information generation. By employing such a configuration, the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment can generate evaluation ability information based on a wider range of perspectives. In particular, since the second embodiment employs a configuration that utilizes information regarding evaluations by other evaluators who are in the same industry, it is possible to obtain evaluation information that is more reliable than the case of subjective evaluations by the general public, and this has the advantage of enabling the generation of more reliable evaluation ability information.
[0054] In addition, the content evaluation system according to the second embodiment employs a configuration in which the number of views of the evaluation value and content review information created by the evaluator who is the information generation target is used as information on the evaluation from others of the evaluator who is the information generation target. By using such a configuration, in the second embodiment, it is possible to obtain more objective information on the ability evaluation free from personal influence, compared to the case where opinions and questionnaires on the ability of the target evaluator are directly collected from other evaluators. In other words, since the reason why the evaluation value and content review information created by other evaluators are viewed is solely for the purpose of evaluating the ability of the evaluator and for reference, using the number of views as an index of evaluation by other evaluators leads to more objective evaluation information on the evaluator who is the target of the evaluation ability information generation by other evaluators, and thus has the advantage of being able to generate more accurate evaluation ability information. [Industrial Applicability]
[0055] INDUSTRIAL APPLICABILITY The present invention can be used as a technology for realizing a system or the like that objectively evaluates content consisting of creative works such as videos and images, as well as other specified information, etc., according to the viewer's level of evaluation ability. [Explanation of symbols]
[0056] 1 Content information input section 2 Content Token Generation Unit 3. Evaluator information input section 4. Evaluator Token Generation Unit 5 Ownership change information generation unit 6, 14 Content evaluation value input section 7 Content evaluation information generation unit 8, 20 Evaluation capability information generation unit 9, 15 Transaction Generation Unit 10, 16 Electronic signature generation section 11, 17 Output section 12, 18 Display section 19. View Count Counting Department
Claims
1. a content evaluation information generating means for generating content evaluation information, which is information regarding evaluation of the content to be evaluated, based on a result of correcting evaluation values generated by a plurality of evaluators for the content to be evaluated using evaluation ability information related to the evaluators who generated the evaluation values; an evaluation capability information generating means for generating the evaluation capability information based on a result of a correction process performed on evaluation values generated by an evaluator for a plurality of contents, the evaluation capability information being generated by the content evaluation information generating means for the contents; an output means for outputting the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputting the evaluation ability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators; Equipped with the content evaluation information generating means performs a second correction process using the evaluation capability information generated by the evaluation capability information generating means, and corrects the content evaluation information based on the information obtained by the second correction process; The content evaluation system according to claim 1, wherein the output means outputs the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generating means to the first distributed network.
2. The content evaluation system according to claim 1, characterized in that the content evaluation information generating means performs, as the correction process and the second correction process, a process of multiplying the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator by the evaluation ability information consisting of numerical information regarding the evaluator who created the evaluation value.
3. The content evaluation system according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the evaluation capability information generation means performs a process including, as the correction process, a process of calculating a difference value between the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator who is the subject of evaluation for a plurality of contents, and the content evaluation information consisting of numerical information created by the content evaluation information generation means for the contents.
4. a content evaluation information generating step of generating content evaluation information, which is information regarding evaluation of the content to be evaluated, based on a result of correcting evaluation values generated by a plurality of evaluators for the content to be evaluated using evaluation ability information related to the evaluators who generated the evaluation values; an evaluation capability information generating step of generating the evaluation capability information based on a result of a correction process performed on evaluation values generated by an evaluator for a plurality of contents, the evaluation values being the subject of evaluation, using content evaluation information generated in the content evaluation information generating step for the contents; an output step of outputting the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputting the evaluation capability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators; a re-generation step of generating evaluation capability information, in which a correction process is performed again using the evaluation capability information generated by the evaluation capability information generating step, and the content evaluation information is corrected based on the information obtained by the re-correction process; a second output step of outputting the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generating step to the first distributed network; A content evaluation method comprising:
5. The content evaluation method according to claim 4, characterized in that in the evaluation capability information generation step, the correction process includes a process of calculating a difference value between the evaluation value consisting of numerical information created by the evaluator who is the subject of evaluation for a plurality of contents, and the content evaluation information consisting of numerical information created in the content evaluation information generation step for the contents.
6. A content evaluation program that causes a computer to generate content evaluation information regarding a content to be evaluated, The computer is a content evaluation information generating function that generates content evaluation information, which is information regarding the evaluation of the content to be evaluated, based on a result of correcting evaluation values generated by a plurality of evaluators for the content to be evaluated using evaluation ability information related to the evaluators who generated the evaluation values; an evaluation capability information generating function that generates the evaluation capability information based on a result of a correction process performed on evaluation values generated by an evaluator for a plurality of contents, the evaluation values being the subject of evaluation, using content evaluation information generated by the content evaluation information generating function for the contents; an output function that outputs the content evaluation information to a first distributed network corresponding to a content token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the contents, and outputs the evaluation ability information to a second distributed network corresponding to an evaluator token, which is a non-fungible token corresponding to each of the evaluators; Realize this, The content evaluation information generating function causes the computer to perform a second correction process using the evaluation capability information generated by the evaluation capability information generating function, and corrects the content evaluation information based on the information obtained by the second correction process; The content evaluation program, wherein the output function causes the computer to output the content evaluation information corrected by the content evaluation information generating function to the first distributed network.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Video contents evaluation system and video contents evaluation method
JP2022138858A
Content evaluation device, content evaluation method, and content evaluation program
JP2022169224A
