Evaluation method and program
The evaluation method and program efficiently calculate system reliability by identifying all sequences and evaluating physical behavior, reducing computational demands and enhancing accuracy in assessing low-probability events.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021105894
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-06-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-11
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-06-25
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for evaluating system reliability require numerous trial calculations, especially for events with low probabilities, leading to significant computational burden and time consumption.
An evaluation method and program that calculates all sequences of component transitions, evaluates physical behavior, and assesses reliability based on occurrence probability and physical behavior, reducing the need for extensive trial calculations by using random number generation to set failure times and calculate cumulative failure rates.
Enables efficient evaluation of system risk with a reduced number of calculations and shorter time, accurately assessing sequences with low occurrence probabilities while improving computational efficiency.
Smart Images

Figure 0007580344000002 
Figure 0007580344000003 
Figure 0007580344000004
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to an evaluation method and a program. [Background technology]
[0002] In general, when evaluating the reliability of a system such as a plant, various events occurring in the plant are assumed, and the overall system is evaluated by adding up the occurrence probability and impact of each event. For example, when using an evaluation model that simulates the state and operation of a plant, various calculation conditions are set using the Monte Carlo method, and repeated calculations are performed to reproduce the event of interest, and the occurrence probability and impact of the event are evaluated. If the event of interest is relatively likely to occur, the event is reproduced by the evaluation model while repeated calculations are performed, and the impact of the event of interest can be evaluated based on the process values such as temperature calculated at that time, and the occurrence probability of the event of interest can be estimated by analyzing the probability of occurrence of various conditions required to reproduce the event. On the other hand, if the occurrence probability of the event to be evaluated is low, it may be necessary to repeat trial calculations many times to reproduce the event, which requires a huge amount of calculation and calculation time.
[0003] Patent Document 1 discloses an apparatus that simplifies the creation of a data set required for constructing a fault tree or the like that is required for carrying out a probabilistic risk assessment. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2020-27523 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] What is needed is a method for performing reliability assessment without requiring numerous trial calculations.
[0006] The present disclosure provides an evaluation method and program capable of solving the above problems. [Means for solving the problem]
[0007] The evaluation method disclosed herein is an evaluation method executed by a computer, and includes the steps of calculating all patterns of sequences showing all combinations of transition patterns of components that make up the system to be evaluated, calculating an occurrence probability for each of the sequences, performing a physical behavior evaluation for each of the sequences, and evaluating the reliability of each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior evaluation.
[0008] The program disclosed herein causes a computer to execute the steps of: calculating all patterns of sequences indicating all combinations of transition patterns of components that make up a system to be evaluated; calculating an occurrence probability for each of the sequences; performing a physical behavior evaluation for each of the sequences; and evaluating the reliability of each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior evaluation. Effect of the Invention
[0009] According to the above-mentioned evaluation method and program, the risk of an event can be evaluated with a small number of calculations and in a small amount of time. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0010] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system according to an embodiment. [Figure 2A] FIG. 1 is a first diagram illustrating a reliability evaluation process according to an embodiment. [Figure 2B] FIG. 2 is a second diagram illustrating the reliability evaluation process according to the embodiment. [Diagram 3] 10 is a flowchart illustrating an example of a reliability evaluation process according to the embodiment. [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing a comparison of the number of trial calculations in reliability evaluation. [Diagram 5] FIG. 1 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of an evaluation system according to an embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0011] Hereinafter, the reliability evaluation method according to the present disclosure will be described with reference to FIGS. <Embodiment> (composition) FIG. 1 is a block diagram illustrating an example of an evaluation system according to an embodiment. The evaluation system 10 includes an input receiving unit 11, an evaluation process control unit 12, an output unit 13, and a storage unit 14.
[0012] The input receiving unit 11 is configured using input devices such as a keyboard, a mouse, a touch panel, buttons, etc. The input receiving unit 11 receives various information such as calculation conditions used for reliability evaluation inputted using the input device to the evaluation system 10. The input receiving unit 11 outputs the received input information to the evaluation process control unit 12.
[0013] The evaluation process control unit 12 controls the process of evaluating the reliability of the system to be evaluated. As an example, the following description will be given assuming that the system to be evaluated is system 1 and that system 1 includes devices A and B. The evaluation process control unit 12 includes a sequence calculation unit 121, a failure time setting unit 122, an occurrence probability calculation unit 123, a state evaluation unit 124, and a reliability calculation unit 125. The functions of each of the functional units 121 to 125 will be described with reference to FIGS. 2A and 2B.
[0014] The sequence calculation unit 121 calculates all events that occur in the system 1. The sequence calculation unit 121 calculates all patterns of combinations of transition patterns that occur for each of the devices A and B that are components of the system 1, including differences in the order of occurrence of the transitions. An event that occurs in the system 1 that is configured by a combination of transition patterns that occur in the devices A and B is called a sequence. Here, a transition means that a component fails and is restored from a failure. In this embodiment, an example will be described in which only failures are focused on as transition patterns. For example, in the case of the system 1, the sequence calculation unit 121 calculates sequence 1 in which both devices A and B remain in a healthy state, sequence 2 in which device A fails and device B remains in a healthy state, sequence 3 in which device A fails and then device B fails, sequence 4 in which device B fails and device A remains in a healthy state, and sequence 5 in which device B fails and then device A fails (if recovery from a failure is included, the number of sequences will be even more diverse). This process is shown in FIG. 2A.
[0015] The failure time setting unit 122 generates a random number for each component of the system 1, and sets the time at which a transition (in this embodiment, a failure) occurs based on the random number. For example, for the above sequence 2, the failure time setting unit 122 generates a random number, and calculates the time t A Then, the failure time setting unit 122 converts the time t A is set as the time when device A fails. Similarly, the failure time setting unit 122 sets the time when device B fails for sequence 4. The failure time setting unit 122 also generates a random number for sequence 3 and sets it as time t A and time t A The failure time setting unit 122 further generates a random number and sets the time t A A time t later than B Calculate the time t B The calculation method is, for example,A The failure time setting unit 122 may add a newly generated random number to the calculated time t B As the failure time of device B, the failure time setting unit 122 sets the time t B and the time t when device A fails. A Calculate.
[0016] The occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates a time-dependent cumulative failure rate up to the failure time set by the failure time setting unit 122 based on transition rate data (failure rate data in this embodiment) that defines the relationship between the usage time (operation time) of each component and the transition rate (failure rate or recovery rate from failure, failure rate in this embodiment), and calculates the occurrence probability for each sequence by multiplying the time-dependent cumulative failure rates calculated for each component in which a failure occurs. In the failure rate data, failure rates according to the usage time are set for each of the devices A and B. For example, in the failure rate data for the device A, a failure rate per unit time from the start of use to one year is set to X1%, a failure rate per unit time from one to two years is set to X2%, ..., and the like, and a failure rate per unit time according to the usage time is also set for the device B. In the case of sequence 2, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the time-dependent cumulative failure rate t A The cumulative failure rate is calculated based on the failure rate data of equipment A. For example, if the evaluation period starts at year 0 and the failure time is t A If the unit time is one month after two years, add up the failure rate per unit time (=1 month) x 1% for the first year for 12 months, and then add up the failure rate per unit time x 2% for the next year for 12 months. The total of these is calculated and the failure time t AThe time-dependent cumulative failure rate {(X1×12)+(X2×12)}% of device A until failure time t is calculated. Similarly, the probability that device B will not fail during a predetermined evaluation period is calculated based on the failure rate data of device B by (1-time-dependent cumulative failure rate of device B during the evaluation period). Then, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the probability that device B will not fail during a predetermined evaluation period based on the failure rate data of device B by (1-time-dependent cumulative failure rate of device B during the evaluation period). A Time-dependent cumulative failure rate at which equipment B does not fail and equipment A fails by failure time t A The probability of occurrence of sequence 2 during the evaluation period is expressed as ω A0 In the same manner, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probabilities ω for the other sequences 1, 3 to 5 (FIG. 2B).
[0017] As shown in FIG. 2B, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability ω0 of sequence 1 during the evaluation period by (the probability that device A does not fail during the evaluation period) × (the probability that device B does not fail during the evaluation period). The occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability of sequence 3 (fault time t A Time-dependent cumulative failure rate at which equipment B does not fail and equipment A fails by failure time t A If device B does not fail by failure time t A ~Failure time t B The probability of occurrence of sequence 3 during the evaluation period is expressed as ω AB Calculate. The occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability of sequence 4 (fault time t B Time-dependent cumulative failure rate at which equipment A does not fail and equipment B fails by failure time t B The probability of occurrence of sequence 3 during the evaluation period is expressed as ω B0 Calculate. The occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability of sequence 5 (fault time t B Time-dependent cumulative failure rate at which equipment A does not fail and equipment B fails by failure time t B ~Failure time t AThe probability of occurrence of sequence 5 during the evaluation period is given by the time-dependent cumulative failure rate of device A during BA Calculate.
[0018] The state evaluation unit 124 performs physical behavior evaluation for each of sequences 1 to 5. For example, the state evaluation unit 124 uses an evaluation model that simulates the operation and state of the system 1 to have the evaluation model simulate the behavior of the system 1 during a predetermined evaluation period. The evaluation model calculates the state of the system 1 from moment to moment during the evaluation period. For example, the evaluation model calculates process values of physical quantities (e.g., temperature, pressure, flow rate, etc.) in a plant (a plant is an example of the system 1) at a predetermined cycle. For example, for sequence 2, the state evaluation unit 124 uses the evaluation model to calculate the time when device A will fail at failure time t A The state evaluation unit 124 calculates process values such as temperature at every moment during the evaluation period, and calculates a time-series transition of temperature. The state evaluation unit 124 also calculates the process values such as temperature at every moment during the evaluation period, and calculates a time-series transition of temperature at every moment during the evaluation period. A The state evaluation unit 124 compares the temperature transition when the device A fails with a predetermined threshold to evaluate whether the temperature exceeds the threshold. If the temperature exceeds the threshold, it means that the temperature at a certain point in the system 1 has reached an abnormal level due to the failure of the device A. The state evaluation unit 124 calculates the time series values of the physical quantities representing the state of the system 1 while reproducing the healthy or failed state of the devices A and B for sequences 1 to 5 using the evaluation model, and evaluates the state of the system 1 based on whether the physical quantities deviate from the judgment criterion (threshold). In the example of FIG. 2B, the temperature, which is the physical quantity of interest, reaches the threshold in sequences 3 and 5.
[0019] The reliability calculation unit 125 calculates the unreliability of each sequence based on the occurrence probability calculated by the occurrence probability calculation unit 123, the state of the system evaluated by the state evaluation unit 124, and the number of times the physical quantity deviates from the judgment criterion. The reliability calculation unit 125 also calculates the reliability of the system 1 by summing up the unreliability calculated for each of the sequences 1 to 5.
[0020] In this way, the evaluation process control unit 12 (each of the functional units 121 to 125) extracts all possible sequences that may occur in the system 1 based on the failure patterns (presence or absence of failure, order of failure) of the components, and calculates the occurrence probability of the sequence by randomly setting the failure time t for each sequence. By setting the failure time t using random numbers and calculating the failure probability (time-dependent cumulative failure rate) at the set failure time t based on failure rate data, the occurrence probability of the sequence can be calculated without performing numerous trial calculations. On the other hand, the evaluation process control unit 12 evaluates the physical behavior of the system 1 when a component such as device A fails at the set failure time t, and performs reliability evaluation of the entire system 1 from the sequence occurrence probability and the results of the physical behavior evaluation. In order to improve the accuracy of the reliability evaluation, the evaluation process control unit 12 sets the failure time t using random numbers multiple times and performs a probabilistic reliability evaluation of the system 1. By randomly setting the failure time t multiple times and performing the evaluation, it is possible to perform the occurrence probability of the sequence and physical behavior evaluation under various conditions.
[0021] The output unit 13 outputs the reliability of the system 1 calculated by the reliability calculation unit 125 to a display device or an electronic file. The storage unit 14 stores various information necessary for evaluating the reliability of the system 1. For example, the storage unit 14 stores information about the components of the system 1, failure rate data for each component, an evaluation model of the system 1, and the like.
[0022] (operation) Next, the operation of the evaluation system 10 will be described with reference to FIG. FIG. 3 is a flowchart illustrating an example of the reliability evaluation process according to the embodiment. A user sets in advance, through the input receiving unit 11, calculation conditions such as the fact that the system 1 is to be evaluated, the evaluation period for the reliability evaluation, the number of samplings, the type of physical quantity to focus on in the physical behavior evaluation and its judgment criteria (threshold value). The storage unit 14 records the fact that the system 1 is composed of devices A and B, failure rate data of devices A and B, etc. First, the sequence calculation unit 121 organizes all possible sequences (step S11). The sequence calculation unit 121 reads out information on the components that configure the system 1, that is, devices A and B, from the storage unit 14, and calculates all possible patterns of sequences that may occur. For example, the sequence calculation unit 121 calculates five sequences: a sequence in which devices A and B are both healthy (sequence 1); a sequence in which devices A and B are both healthy and only device A fails (sequence 2); a sequence in which devices A and B are both healthy and first device A fails and then device B fails (sequence 3); a sequence in which devices A and B are both healthy and only device B fails (sequence 4); and a sequence in which devices A and B are both healthy and first device B fails and then device A fails (sequence 5).
[0023] Next, the evaluation process control unit 12 performs sampling for each sequence (step S12: loop 1). First, the evaluation process control unit 12 selects the first sampling target from the five sequences and performs sampling N times (step S13: loop 2). For example, the evaluation process control unit 12 selects sequence 1. Next, the evaluation process control unit 12 repeats the setting of failure time (step S15) and the calculation of failure rate (step S16) by the number of components i (assumed to be m) for which failure is assumed (i=1 to m) (step S14: loop 3). In the case of sequence 1, since there is no component i for which failure is assumed (m=0), the process of step S15 is skipped, and in the calculation of failure rate (step S16), the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the probability that the devices A and B will not fail during the evaluation period based on the failure rate data of the devices A and B (loop 3 completed). In addition, in the case of sequence 3, the devices A and B will fail in this order (m=2). The failure time setting unit 122 randomly sets a failure time ti Next, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 sets the time from time 0 to failure time t based on the failure rate data of the device A (step S15). i The failure rate of device A up to the time of failure (time-dependent cumulative failure rate) P i Next, the failure time setting unit 122 calculates the failure time t i At a later time, t i+1 Next, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 randomly sets the time t i ~Failure time t i+1 The failure rate (time-dependent cumulative failure rate) of device B in i+1 (step S16) (loop 3 completed). Next, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability ω of the sequence by the following formula (1) (step S17).
[0024]
number
[0025] For example, the occurrence probability calculation unit 123 calculates the occurrence probability ω of sequence 1 by multiplying the probabilities that the devices A and B will not fail during the evaluation period, and calculates the failure rate P i and the failure rate P of device B i+1 to calculate the occurrence probability ω of sequence 3. The occurrence probability calculation unit 123 records the occurrence probability ω in the first sampling in the storage unit 14.
[0026] Next, the state evaluation unit 124 calculates the failure time t i (i=1 to m) to evaluate the physical behavior (step S18). In the case of sequence 1, the state evaluation unit 124 uses the evaluation model of the system 1 to calculate the values of physical quantities that represent the state of the system 1 at every moment during the evaluation period when the devices A and B do not fail. In the case of sequence 3, the state evaluation unit 124 uses the evaluation model of the system 1 to calculate the values of physical quantities that represent the state of the system 1 at every moment during the evaluation period when the devices A and B do not fail. i and equipment B fails at failure time t i+1The values of the physical quantities of system 1 at each time when the system fails are calculated.
[0027] The state evaluation unit 124 compares the calculated transition of the physical quantity (e.g., temperature) of the evaluation target with the judgment criterion and judges whether the physical quantity of the evaluation target deviates from the judgment criterion (step S19). If the judgment criterion is deviated from during the evaluation period (step S19; Yes), the state evaluation unit 124 counts the number of times the judgment criterion is deviated from (step S20). The state evaluation unit 124 records the number of times the judgment criterion is deviated from in the first sampling in the storage unit 14.
[0028] Next, the evaluation process control unit 12 executes a second sampling for sequence 1, for example. In the second sampling, the evaluation process control unit 12 also performs the following steps: setting the failure time (step S15), calculating the failure rate (step S16), calculating the sequence occurrence probability (step S17), calculating the physical behavior (step S18), and counting the number of deviations from the judgment criterion (step S20). The evaluation process control unit 12 performs N samplings for one sequence (loop 2 completed). When N samplings for one sequence are completed, the evaluation process control unit 12 calculates the unreliability of the sequence based on the N sampling results (sequence occurrence probability and number of deviations from the judgment criterion) (step S21). Specifically, the reliability calculation unit 125 sets the judgment criterion flag δ to 0 when the number of deviations from the judgment criterion is 1 or more in the j-th sampling. j is set to 1, and the judgment criterion flag δ j Next, the reliability calculation unit 125 sets the occurrence probability ω j Using this, the unreliability of the sequence of interest is calculated using the following formula: Sequence unreliability = (ω1×δ1+ω2×δ2+···+ω N ×δ N )÷N
[0029] The evaluation process control unit 12 changes the sequence of interest, samples each of sequences 1 to 5 N times, and calculates the unreliability of each sequence (loop 1 completed). Finally, the reliability calculation unit 125 evaluates the reliability of the entire system based on the sum of the unreliability of each sequence (step S22). The reliability calculation unit 125 calculates the reliability of the system 1 by adding up the unreliability calculated for sequences 1 to 5. In addition, in the calculation of the unreliability of the sequence, the judgment criterion flag δ is set according to whether the number of deviations from the judgment criterion is 0 or 1 or more. j The decision was made to set 0 or 1 to the judgment criterion flag δ j Alternatively, the unreliability may be calculated by setting the value of the number of deviations from the judgment criterion itself to .
[0030] (effect) In the case of a method of reproducing sequences using an evaluation model while changing calculation conditions by the Monte Carlo method and evaluating the reliability of a system, many trials are often required for sequences with low occurrence probability. In an actual system, various fault countermeasures such as redundancy are implemented as a countermeasure against equipment failure, etc., so the occurrence probability of many sequences is low, and a huge amount of calculation is required to reproduce all of those sequences and evaluate the entire system. In contrast, according to this embodiment, all sequences are calculated in advance, and the occurrence probability of each sequence is calculated based on the occurrence probability of a basic event such as equipment failure that constitutes the sequence. This makes it possible to perform a high-precision evaluation with a small number of trial calculations and calculation time, even for evaluation of the unreliability of a sequence with a low occurrence probability, without performing unnecessary calculations (calculation for reproducing an event with a low occurrence probability). FIG. 4 shows a comparison of the number of trial calculations (N times in step S13 of FIG. 3) between reliability evaluation by a general Monte Carlo method and reliability evaluation by this embodiment. Graph 41 shows the relationship between the number of trial calculations and the reliability calculated in the reliability evaluation process (the reliability calculated in step S22 in FIG. 3) according to this embodiment, and graph 42 shows the relationship between the number of trial calculations and the reliability calculated in the reliability evaluation process by a general method. As shown in the figure, according to this embodiment, the reliability can be converged with a small number of trial calculations.
[0031] FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of a hardware configuration of the evaluation system according to the embodiment. The computer 900 includes a CPU 901, a main memory device 902, an auxiliary memory device 903, an input / output interface 904, and a communication interface 905. The above-mentioned evaluation system 10 is implemented in the computer 900. The above-mentioned functions are stored in the auxiliary memory device 903 in the form of a program. The CPU 901 reads the program from the auxiliary memory device 903, loads it in the main memory device 902, and executes the above-mentioned processing in accordance with the program. The CPU 901 also secures a storage area in the main memory device 902 in accordance with the program. The CPU 901 also secures a storage area in the auxiliary memory device 903 for storing data being processed in accordance with the program.
[0032] A program for realizing all or part of the functions of the evaluation system 10 may be recorded on a computer-readable recording medium, and the program recorded on the recording medium may be read into a computer system and executed to perform processing by each functional unit. The term "computer system" as used herein includes hardware such as an OS and peripheral devices. In addition, if a WWW system is used, the term "computer system" also includes a homepage providing environment (or display environment). In addition, the term "computer-readable recording medium" refers to a portable medium such as a CD, DVD, or USB, or a storage device such as a hard disk built into a computer system. In addition, if the program is distributed to the computer 900 via a communication line, the computer 900 that receives the program may expand the program in the main storage device 902 and execute the above processing. In addition, the above program may be for realizing part of the above-mentioned functions, and may further be capable of realizing the above-mentioned functions in combination with a program already recorded in the computer system.
[0033] As described above, several embodiments according to the present disclosure have been described, but all of these embodiments are presented as examples and are not intended to limit the scope of the invention. These embodiments can be implemented in various other forms, and various omissions, substitutions, and modifications can be made without departing from the gist of the invention. These embodiments and their modifications are included in the scope of the invention and its equivalents as described in the claims, as well as in the scope and gist of the invention.
[0034] <Additional Notes> The evaluation method and program described in each embodiment can be understood, for example, as follows.
[0035] (1) The evaluation method according to the first aspect is an evaluation method executed by a computer, and includes the steps of: calculating all sequences indicating combinations of patterns of transitions (transitions of states / statuses of the components, such as failures and recovery from failures) of components that make up a system to be evaluated (S11); calculating an occurrence probability for each of the sequences (S17); evaluating a physical behavior of each of the sequences (S18); and evaluating the reliability of each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior evaluation (S21). System reliability is evaluated by organizing all sequences in advance and calculating the occurrence probability for each sequence, and then judging the occurrence of events based on an evaluation of the physical behavior of each sequence. Regardless of occurrence probability or impact level, all sequences are identified, and the occurrence probability of each sequence is calculated based on the occurrence probability of equipment failures that make up the sequence, so that reliability can be evaluated with fewer trial calculations and in less calculation time, even for sequences with low occurrence probability.
[0036] (2) A second aspect of the evaluation method is the evaluation method of (1), wherein in the step of calculating all patterns of the sequence, all patterns of combinations of transitions that occur for each of the components are calculated, including differences in the order in which the transitions occur. This makes it possible to extract all sequences without omission.
[0037] (3) An evaluation method according to a third aspect is the evaluation method of (1) to (2), wherein in the step of calculating the occurrence probability, a transition time at which the transition occurs is set for each of the components in which a failure occurs in the sequence of interest, a time-dependent cumulative transition rate is calculated based on transition rate data defining a relationship between a usage time of the component and a transition rate and the usage time up to the transition time, and the time-dependent cumulative transition rate calculated for each of the components in which a transition occurs is multiplied to calculate the occurrence probability of the sequence. By arbitrarily setting the failure time (the time when the status of the component changes), it is possible to calculate the probability of equipment failure based on the usage time of the equipment up to that failure time and the failure rate (transition rate) corresponding to that usage time. By calculating the occurrence probability of each equipment failure in the same way, it is possible to combine them to calculate the occurrence probability of each sequence.
[0038] (4) A fourth aspect of the evaluation method is the evaluation method of (3), wherein the step of calculating the occurrence probability and the step of evaluating the physical behavior are repeatedly executed multiple times for one of the sequences, and in the step of calculating the occurrence probability, a random number is generated for each of the components for each of the multiple executions, and the transition time for each of the components is set based on the random number. By generating random numbers and setting various times for the time at which a failure occurs, and evaluating the occurrence probability and physical behavior of the sequence, it is possible to evaluate the reliability of each sequence and the entire system under various conditions.
[0039] (5) A fifth aspect of the evaluation method is the evaluation method of (4), wherein in the step of evaluating the physical behavior, a time series of one or more physical quantities indicating the state of the system is calculated during a predetermined evaluation period when the sequence occurs, and the number of times that the value of the physical quantity deviates from a judgment criterion during the evaluation period is evaluated. This allows the impact of each sequence on the system to be evaluated.
[0040] (6) A sixth aspect of the evaluation method is the evaluation method of (5), wherein in the step of evaluating the reliability, a degree of unreliability of the one sequence is calculated based on the occurrence probability and the number of times that the state of the system deviates from the judgment criterion obtained from the multiple executions. The reliability of each sequence is evaluated based on both the occurrence probability of the sequence evaluated under various conditions and the impact of the sequence when it occurs, which allows for highly accurate evaluation.
[0041] (7) An evaluation method according to a seventh aspect is an evaluation method according to (6), further comprising a step of summing the unreliability calculated for each of the sequences of all the patterns to evaluate the reliability of the system. Since the reliability of the entire system is evaluated based on the evaluation results of the reliability of the sequence evaluated under various conditions, a highly accurate evaluation can be performed.
[0042] (8) A program according to an eighth aspect causes a computer 900 to execute the steps of: calculating all patterns of all sequences that indicate combinations of transition patterns of components that constitute a system to be evaluated; calculating an occurrence probability for each of the sequences; performing a physical behavior evaluation for each of the sequences; and evaluating the reliability of each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior evaluation. [Explanation of symbols]
[0043] 10. Rating System 11 Input reception section 12 Evaluation processing control section 121 Sequence calculation unit 122...Failure time setting section 123...Occurrence probability calculation unit 124... Condition evaluation unit 125... Reliability calculation section 13 Output section 14...Storage section 900...Computer 901···CPU 902...Main memory 903...Auxiliary storage device 904 Input / Output Interface 905 Communication Interface
Claims
1. 1. A computer-implemented evaluation method comprising: calculating all patterns of all sequences indicating combinations of transition patterns of components constituting the system to be evaluated; calculating a probability of occurrence for each of said sequences; performing a physical behavior evaluation for each of the sequences; performing a reliability assessment for each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior assessment; An evaluation method having the following:
2. In the step of calculating all patterns of the sequence, Calculating all patterns of combinations of transitions occurring for each of the components, including differences in the order of occurrence of the transitions; The evaluation method according to claim 1 .
3. In the step of calculating the occurrence probability, a transition time at which the transition occurs for each of the components in the sequence of interest is set, a time-dependent cumulative transition rate is calculated based on transition rate data that defines a relationship between a use time and a transition rate of the components and the use time up to the transition time, and a probability of occurrence of the sequence is calculated by multiplying the time-dependent cumulative transition rates calculated for each of the components in which a transition occurs; The evaluation method according to claim 1 or 2.
4. Repeating the steps of calculating the occurrence probability and evaluating the physical behavior for one of the sequences a number of times; In the step of calculating the occurrence probability, a random number is generated for each of the components for each of the multiple executions, and the transition time for each of the components is set based on the random number. The evaluation method according to claim 3.
5. In the step of evaluating the physical behavior, calculating a time series of one or more physical quantities indicative of a state of the system during a predetermined evaluation period when the sequence occurs; evaluating the number of times that the value of the physical quantity deviates from a judgment criterion during the evaluation period; The evaluation method according to claim 4.
6. In the step of evaluating the reliability, calculating an unreliability of the one sequence based on the occurrence probability and the number of times the state of the system deviates from the judgment criterion obtained from the multiple executions; The evaluation method according to claim 5.
7. summing the unreliability values calculated for each of the sequences of all the patterns to evaluate the reliability of the system; The evaluation method according to claim 6, further comprising:
8. On the computer, calculating all patterns of all sequences indicating combinations of transition patterns of components constituting the system to be evaluated; calculating a probability of occurrence for each of said sequences; performing a physical behavior evaluation for each of the sequences; performing a reliability assessment for each of the sequences based on the occurrence probability and the physical behavior assessment; A program that executes the following.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Safety analysis of complex system using component-oriented fault trees
JP2015111402A
Storage system reliability verification program, reliability verification method, and reliability verification device and storage system
JP2016143220A
Data group creation assisting device, input data creation device for analyzer, and data group creation assisting method
JP2020027523A
