Methods for estimating and determining nugget diameter
The method improves nugget diameter estimation in spot welding by measuring expansion and contraction, along with electrical resistance, providing accurate welding quality assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2022109710
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-07-07
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-07-07
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for estimating nugget diameter in spot welding lack accuracy, as they rely on physical quantities that do not sufficiently reflect the actual nugget diameter, leading to inaccurate welding quality evaluation.
A method that estimates nugget diameter by measuring the expansion and contraction of metal plates during the welding process, using electrical resistance values, and applying formulas that incorporate these measurements to improve accuracy.
Enhances the estimation accuracy of nugget diameter by considering the expansion, contraction, and electrical resistance values, allowing for better evaluation of welding quality.
Smart Images

Figure 0007582268000001 
Figure 0007582268000002 
Figure 0007582268000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present disclosure relates to a method for estimating and determining a nugget diameter. [Background technology]
[0002] Conventionally, spot welding is a method for welding multiple overlapping metal plates (for example, Patent Document 1). In spot welding, the vicinity of the surfaces to be joined of the metal plates is melted by heat generated by passing an electric current, and then solidified and welded. The nugget diameter of the nugget formed by solidifying the molten metal can be used as an index for evaluating welding quality such as joint strength. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] International Publication No. WO2017 / 212916 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] Instead of measuring the nugget diameter, attempts have been made to measure physical quantities that change during the welding process and estimate the nugget diameter using the measured physical quantities. There is a demand for improving the accuracy of estimating the nugget diameter. [Means for solving the problem]
[0005] The present disclosure can be realized in the following forms.
[0006] (1) According to one embodiment of the present disclosure, a method for estimating a nugget diameter of a nugget formed by resistance spot welding is provided. The resistance spot welding according to this estimation method includes a first step of sandwiching two or more overlapping metal sheets between a pair of electrode tips, applying pressure to the metal sheets, and applying current to the metal sheets, and a second step of stopping the current application in the first step and applying pressure to the metal sheets by the pair of electrode tips. This estimation method includes a thickness estimation step of estimating a nugget thickness using an expansion amount in a thickness direction of the two or more metal sheets in the first step and an electrical resistance value between the pair of electrode tips in the first step, and a diameter estimation step of estimating the nugget diameter using the expansion amount and the electrical resistance value when it is estimated that the nugget has reached the interface between two adjacent metal sheets using each of the thicknesses of the two or more metal sheets and the estimated nugget thickness. According to this embodiment, it is possible to exclude a nugget diameter estimated with low accuracy when the nugget has not reached the interface. Therefore, it is possible to improve the estimation accuracy of the estimated nugget diameter. (2) In the estimation method of the above embodiment, in the thickness estimation step, the nugget thickness may be estimated using the amount of contraction in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates in the second step in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value, and in the diameter estimation step, the nugget diameter may be estimated using the amount of contraction in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value. In the second step, the current supply is stopped to stop the expansion of the metal plates, and the molten part contracts in the thickness direction and spreads in the interface direction due to the pressure applied by the electrode tip. Therefore, according to this embodiment, by estimating the nugget diameter using the amount of contraction, the amount of expansion of the nugget, which is the molten part in the interface direction in the second step, can be reflected, and the estimation accuracy can be further improved. (3) In the estimation method of the above aspect, the shrinkage amount may be a value obtained by subtracting the thickness at the end of the second process from the thickness of the two or more metal plates at the start of the second process. According to this aspect, the value obtained by subtracting the thickness at the end of the second process from the thickness of the two or more metal plates at the start of the second process can be used as the shrinkage amount, and the calculation load for finding the shrinkage amount can be reduced. (4) In the estimation method of the above embodiment, the electrical resistance value may be an average of the electrical resistance values from a point going back a predetermined acquisition time from the end of the first process to the end of the first process, and the acquisition time may be less than half the process time of the first process. There is a good correlation between the average of the electrical resistance value from a point going back a predetermined acquisition time from the start of the second process to the start of the second process, and each of the nugget thickness and the nugget diameter. Therefore, according to this embodiment, it is possible to further improve the estimation accuracy of each of the nugget thickness and the nugget diameter. (5) In the estimation method of the above embodiment, it may be possible to estimate that the nugget has reached the interface when the estimated half of the nugget thickness is longer than the distance between the center position in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates and the interface farthest from the center position. According to this embodiment, it is possible to estimate that the nugget has reached the interface when the estimated half of the nugget thickness is longer than the distance between the center position in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates and the interface farthest from the center position. (6) In the estimation method of the above embodiment, when the nugget thickness is NT [mm], the nugget diameter is ND [mm], the expansion amount is E [mm], the contraction amount is S [mm], the electrical resistance value is R [Ω], and predetermined constants are C1 to C8, the nugget thickness may be calculated using the following equation (1), and the nugget diameter may be calculated using the following equation (2). NT=C1×E+C2×S+C3×R+C4 (1) ND=C5×E+C6×S+C7×R+C8 (2) The nugget thickness and nugget diameter are proportional to the amount of expansion, the amount of contraction, and the electrical resistance, respectively, so that according to this embodiment, the nugget thickness and nugget diameter can be estimated using formula (1) and formula (2). (7) In a determination method using the estimation method of the above aspect, when it is estimated that the nugget does not reach the interface using the thicknesses of the two or more metal plates and the estimated nugget thickness, it may be determined that the welding is defective. According to this aspect, the welding quality can be appropriately determined. The present disclosure may be realized in various forms other than an estimation method, for example, an estimation device, a control method for an estimation device, a computer program for implementing the control method, a non-transitory recording medium on which the computer program is recorded, etc. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0007] [Figure 1] 1 is a schematic diagram showing a schematic configuration of a resistance spot welding device according to an embodiment; [Diagram 2] FIG. 4 is a diagram showing the relationship between time and the amount of displacement in a welding process. [Diagram 3] 5A to 5C are schematic diagrams showing cross-sectional views of members to be welded in each welding process; [Figure 4] FIG. 13 is a diagram for explaining a case where the accuracy of the estimation formula is insufficient. [Diagram 5] FIG. 4 is a graph showing the relationship between the actually measured nugget diameter and the amount of expansion. [Figure 6] FIG. 4 is a graph showing the relationship between the actually measured nugget diameter and the amount of shrinkage. [Figure 7] FIG. 4 is a graph showing the relationship between the actually measured nugget diameter and the electrical resistance value. [Figure 8] 4 is a flowchart of a nugget diameter estimation process. [Figure 9] Estimated result of half the nugget thickness length. [Figure 10] 4 is an estimation result of the nugget diameter according to the first embodiment. [Figure 11] 13 is an estimation result of the nugget diameter according to Example 2. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0008] A. Embodiment: A1. Configuration of resistance spot welding equipment Fig. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a general configuration of a resistance spot welding apparatus 100. In the following description, the up-down direction shown in Fig. 1 is used. The up-down direction is parallel to the ascending and descending direction of an electrode tip 21, which is a movable electrode and will be described later.
[0009] Resistance spot welding apparatus 100 welds a workpiece W which is made up of two or more overlapping metal plates. Fig. 1 illustrates an example in which the workpiece W is made up of two or more overlapping metal plates, a first metal plate W1 and a second metal plate W2. Resistance spot welding apparatus 100 includes a welding gun 10, a power supply device 30, and a control device 80.
[0010] The welding gun 10 is attached to the tip of a robot arm (not shown). The gun body 11 is moved by the robot arm to a target welding point of the workpiece W. The welding gun 10 has the gun body 11, a moving mechanism 20, a pair of electrode tips 21, 22, and a pressure device 40. The gun body 11 has a U-shape, and the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 are attached to it. One electrode tip 21 of the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 is a movable electrode and is attached to the upper part of the gun body 11. The other electrode tip 22 of the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 is a fixed electrode and is attached to the lower part of the gun body 11 at a position facing the electrode tip 21.
[0011] The moving mechanism 20 raises and lowers the electrode tip 21. The moving mechanism 20 has a servo motor (not shown), converts the rotational force of the servo motor into a linear movement force in the raising and lowering direction, and raises and lowers the electrode tip 21 by transmitting the converted linear movement force to the electrode tip 21. The power supply device 30 supplies a welding current of a target current value between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22. The pressure device 40 has a cylinder (not shown), and presses the electrode tip 21 against the workpiece W to apply pressure.
[0012] The resistance spot welding apparatus 100 further includes an encoder 51, a strain gauge 52, a current sensor 53, and a voltage sensor 54. The encoder 51 detects the amount of rotation of the servo motor of the movement mechanism 20 at predetermined time intervals, and transmits a signal indicating the detected amount of rotation to the control device 80. The strain gauge 52 is attached near the electrode tip 22, and detects the amount of displacement due to an external force at predetermined time intervals, and transmits a signal indicating the amount of displacement to the control device 80. The encoder 51 and the strain gauge 52 are used to detect the amount of change in the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, as will be described later.
[0013] The current sensor 53 detects the current value of the welding current supplied from the power supply device 30 at predetermined time intervals and transmits a signal indicating the current value to the control device 80. The current sensor 43 is realized using, for example, a toroidal coil. The voltage sensor 54 detects the voltage value between the electrode tip 21 and the electrode tip 22 at predetermined time intervals and transmits a signal indicating the voltage value to the control device 80.
[0014] The control device 80 is configured as a computer including a processor (not shown), a storage device (not shown), and an interface circuit (not shown) for exchanging signals between each sensor and the processor. The control device 80 has a welding control unit 81 and an estimation unit 82 as functional units. The welding control unit 81 and the estimation unit 82 are realized by the processor of the control device 80 executing a program stored in the storage device. The welding control unit 81 controls each unit such as the power supply unit 30 in each step of spot welding (described later). After the spot welding is completed, the estimation unit 82 estimates a nugget diameter ND of a nugget N (described later) formed during welding.
[0015] A2.Welding process Fig. 2 is a diagram showing the relationship between time in the welding process and the amount of displacement, which is the amount of change in the distance between a pair of electrode tips 21, 22. The horizontal axis of Fig. 2 is the elapsed time [ms] from the start point of the preload process P10. The vertical axis of Fig. 2 is the amount of displacement [mm]. The data on the amount of displacement in Fig. 2 is data for each sample of Example 2, which will be described later. Fig. 3 is a schematic diagram showing the state of a cross section of a workpiece W in each welding process.
[0016] When welding is started, in a preparation step, the welding gun 10 is positioned so that the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 sandwich the workpieces W and the electrode tip 22 contacts the lower surface of the second metal plate W2, as shown in Fig. 1. Thereafter, the electrode tip 21 is lowered by the moving mechanism 20 to a position where it contacts the upper surface of the first metal plate W1.
[0017] Next, in a pre-pressure step P10 shown in Fig. 2, the electrode tip 21 is pressed against the workpiece W by the pressurizing device 40. As a result, the workpiece W is pressurized at a target pressure. This pressurization is also called pre-pressure because it is pressurized prior to energization. The pressure value is about several thousand N. This makes it possible to stabilize the pressurization.
[0018] In the current application step P20, two or more overlapping metal plates are pressed and current is applied while being sandwiched between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22. Specifically, while the workpieces W are pressed by the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, a welding current is supplied between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, and current is applied. This generates Joule heat according to the electrical resistance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, and metal melting begins near the center position in the thickness direction of the workpieces W. As the current application time increases, a nugget N, which is a molten metal portion, grows as shown in the current application step P20 in Fig. 3. In Fig. 3, the nugget N is shown by diagonal hatching.
[0019] 2, in the holding step P30, the current flow in the current flow step P20 is stopped, and two or more metal plates are pressed by the pair of electrode tips 21, 22. Specifically, after the nugget N has grown sufficiently in the current flow step P20, in the holding step P30, current flow between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 is stopped while maintaining the pressure. As a result, the nugget N is cooled, the molten metal solidifies, and the first metal plate W1 and the second metal plate W2 are welded together. After the holding step P30 is completed, the electrode tip 21 is raised, and the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 that had been clamping the workpieces W are released.
[0020] In the following description, the start point of the preloading process P10 is referred to as the start of welding, and the process from the preloading process P10 to the holding process P30 is referred to as the welding process. The preloading process P10 is also referred to as the first process, and the current application process P20 is also referred to as the second process.
[0021] 2 is the amount of change in the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 detected by the encoder 51 and the strain gauge 52. The amount of displacement is the amount of change when the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 at the start of welding is set to zero.
[0022] As shown in the current application step P20 in Fig. 3, in the current application step P20, due to thermal expansion of the metal, a force is applied to the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 being pressed in a direction that widens the gap between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, that is, in the opposite direction to the pressure application direction, as shown by the outlined arrows in Fig. 3. Therefore, in the current application step P20, as the nugget N grows, the amount of displacement gradually increases as shown in Fig. 2.
[0023] Here, the method of detecting the amount of displacement will be explained by taking the energization step P20 as an example. As described above, in the energization step P20, a force in the direction opposite to the pressure direction is applied to the pair of electrode tips 21, 22. This force causes the rotation shaft of the servo motor of the moving mechanism 20 to rotate in a direction corresponding to the direction in which the electrode tip 21 rises. Therefore, the amount of displacement of the electrode tip 21 can be obtained from the amount of rotation detected by the encoder 51. In addition, the position of the welding gun 10 changes from the position at the start of welding due to the expansion of the workpiece W. The strain gauge 52 detects the amount of change in this position. Therefore, the amount of change in the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22, that is, the amount of displacement, can be detected from the detection value of the encoder 51 and the detection value of the strain gauge 52.
[0024] As shown in Fig. 2, the amount of displacement decreases during the holding step P30. This is because, as shown in the holding step P30 of Fig. 3, the thermal expansion subsides when the current flow is stopped, and the pressure applied by the pressure device 40 exceeds the force that widens the gap between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 due to the thermal expansion.
[0025] The cross-sectional shape of the nugget N formed by welding at the interface between the first metal plate W1 and the second metal plate W2 is approximately circular. The nugget diameter ND (FIG. 4), which is the diameter of the cross-sectional shape at the interface of the nugget N, correlates with the weld strength. For this reason, the nugget diameter ND is used to control the welding quality, etc. Instead of actually measuring the nugget diameter ND, attempts have been made to estimate the nugget diameter ND using an estimation formula that uses physical quantities detected during the welding process. Here, the inventors have found that there are cases in which the accuracy of the estimation formula is insufficient.
[0026] 4 is a diagram for explaining a case where the accuracy of the estimation formula is insufficient. The inventors have found that the accuracy of the estimation formula is insufficient when the nugget center NC, which is the center of the nugget N, does not coincide with the interface between two adjacent metal plates of the welded members W and the nugget N does not reach the farthest interface. In this embodiment, the center position of the welded members W in the thickness direction is considered to be the center position of the nugget N.
[0027] As shown in “(A) Case where they coincide” in Figure 4, when the first metal plate W1 and the second metal plate W2, which are the welded members W, are metal plates of the same thickness, the nugget center NC and the interface of the welded members W coincide.
[0028] On the other hand, as shown in (B1) of "(B) Case where they do not match" in FIG. 4, when the first metal plate W1 and the second metal plate W2, which are the welded members W, are metal plates of different thicknesses, the nugget center NC does not match the interface of the welded members W. Also, as shown in (B2), when the welded members W are a set of three metal plates, the first metal plate W1, the second metal plate W2, and the third metal plate W3, which have the same thickness, the nugget center NC does not match the interface of the welded members W. Also, as shown in (B3), when the welded members W are a set of three metal plates, the first metal plate W1, the second metal plate W2, and the third metal plate W3, and the first metal plate W1 and the third metal plate W3 on both sides have different thicknesses, the nugget center NC does not match the interface of the welded members W.
[0029] Therefore, in the nugget diameter estimation process described below, the nugget diameter ND is estimated when it is estimated that the nugget N has reached the farthest interface. This makes it possible to eliminate the nugget diameter ND estimated with low accuracy when the nugget N has not yet reached the interface. This makes it possible to improve the estimation accuracy of the estimated nugget diameter ND.
[0030] Furthermore, the inventors have found that the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter ND can be improved by adding the amount of displacement during the holding step P30 shown in Fig. 2 as a parameter to the estimation formula for the nugget diameter ND. As shown in Fig. 3, in the holding step P30, the nugget N is crushed by the pressure applied by the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 and deforms so as to expand in the interface direction, that is, so that the nugget diameter ND becomes longer. Therefore, the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter ND can be improved by adding this amount of displacement to the estimation formula for the nugget diameter ND.
[0031] In the estimation formula of the nugget diameter ND, in addition to the displacement amount during the holding process P30, the displacement amount during the current application process P20 and the electrical resistance value during the current application process P20 are used. The electrical resistance value is a value calculated by dividing the voltage between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 by the welding current. Specifically, the electrical resistance value is a value calculated by dividing the voltage value detected by the voltage sensor 54 by the current value detected by the current sensor 53. In this embodiment, as the electrical resistance value during the current application process P20, an average value of the electrical resistance values from a point that is a predetermined acquisition time GT (FIG. 2) back from the end point of the current application process P20 to the end point of the current application process P20 is used. The end point of the current application process P20 and the start point of the holding process P30 are the same point. The acquisition time GT is less than half the process time of the current application process P20. In this embodiment, the process time of the current application process P20 is about 260 ms, and the acquisition time GT is about 30 ms. The reason why the displacement amount during the current application process P20 and the electrical resistance value at the acquisition time GT of the current application process P20 are used is because both physical quantities have a good proportional relationship with the nugget diameter ND. Here, the displacement amount during the current application process P20 is called the expansion amount, and the displacement amount during the holding process P30 is called the contraction amount. Thus, in the present disclosure, the increase in the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 is used as the expansion amount in the thickness direction of the welded members W during the current application process P20. Also, the decrease in the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 is used as the contraction amount in the thickness direction of the welded members W during the holding process P30. In this way, by using the distance between the pair of electrode tips 21, 22 as the thickness of the welded members W, the thickness of the welded members W can be detected with high accuracy.
[0032] The inventors have confirmed that the measured value of the nugget diameter ND is in a good proportional relationship with the amount of expansion, the amount of contraction, and the electrical resistance. FIG. 5 is a diagram showing the relationship between the measured nugget diameter ND [mm] and the amount of expansion [mm]. As the amount of expansion, an integral value during the energization process P20 is used when the characteristic line connecting the detection points of the displacement illustrated in FIG. 2 is regarded as a function showing the relationship between time and the amount of displacement. As shown in FIG. 5, the measured nugget diameter ND [mm] and the amount of expansion [mm] are in a good positive proportional relationship.
[0033] Fig. 6 is a diagram showing the relationship between the measured nugget diameter ND and the amount of shrinkage. The amount of shrinkage is calculated by subtracting the amount of displacement at the end of the holding process P30 (Fig. 2) from the amount of displacement at the start of the holding process P30. As shown in Fig. 6, there is a good positive proportional relationship between the measured nugget diameter ND and the amount of shrinkage.
[0034] Fig. 7 is a diagram showing the relationship between the measured nugget diameter ND [mm] and the electrical resistance value [Ω]. As described above, the electrical resistance value is the average value of the electrical resistance values from the point that is the acquisition time GT (Fig. 2) before the end of the current application process P20 to the end of the current application process P20. As shown in Fig. 7, there is a good negative proportional relationship between the measured nugget diameter ND [mm] and the electrical resistance value [Ω].
[0035] In the nugget diameter estimation process described later, the nugget thickness NT is also estimated using the same estimation formula as the nugget diameter ND. That is, an estimation formula is used that uses the amount of expansion, the amount of contraction, and the electrical resistance value as parameters. As with the nugget diameter ND, the amount of expansion, the amount of contraction, and the electrical resistance value are each in good proportional relationship with the nugget thickness NT.
[0036] In the nugget diameter estimation process described below, the nugget thickness NT and nugget diameter ND are estimated using estimation equations. The estimation equations are equations obtained by applying a multiple regression method to the results of experiments conducted in advance to obtain the estimation equations. The nugget thickness estimation equation (1) is an equation for estimating the nugget thickness NT [mm]. The nugget diameter estimation equation (2) is an equation for estimating the nugget diameter ND [mm]. The nugget thickness estimation equation (1) and the nugget diameter estimation equation (2) are stored in a storage device provided in the control device 80. NT=C1×E+C2×S+C3×R+C4 (1) ND=C5×E+C6×S+C7×R+C8 (2) The parameters are as follows: E [mm]: Expansion amount S [mm]: Shrinkage amount R[Ω]: Electrical resistance value C1~C8: Constants
[0037] A3. Estimation of nugget diameter FIG. 8 is a flowchart of a nugget diameter estimation process that realizes a method for estimating the nugget diameter ND. In the welding process, the estimation unit 82 associates the detection values transmitted from each sensor with the elapsed time from the start of welding and stores them in a storage device provided in the control device 80. When the welding process is completed, the estimation unit 82 uses the stored detection values to calculate the expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value in the same manner as described above, and stores them in a storage device provided in the control device 80. Then, the estimation unit 82 estimates the nugget diameter ND using the calculated expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value. The calculation of the expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value may be performed when the next step S10 is executed.
[0038] In step S10 as a thickness estimation process, the estimation unit 82 estimates the nugget thickness NT using the expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value calculated in advance and the above nugget thickness estimation formula (1). In step S20, the estimation unit 82 judges whether the nugget N has reached the interface. Specifically, the estimation unit 82 estimates that the nugget N has reached the interface when half the length of the nugget thickness NT is longer than the distance ID (FIG. 4) between the center position WC in the thickness direction of the welded members W (FIG. 4) and the interface farthest from the center position WC.
[0039] When it is determined that the nugget N has reached the interface (step S20: YES), in step S30 as a diameter estimation process, the estimation unit 82 estimates the nugget diameter ND using the previously calculated expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value, and the above nugget diameter estimation formula (2). Then, the estimation unit 82 stores the estimated nugget diameter ND in a storage device provided in the control device 80, and ends this processing routine.
[0040] On the other hand, when it is determined that the nugget N has not reached the interface (step S20: NO), the estimation unit 82 does not estimate the nugget diameter ND and ends this processing routine. According to this method, the estimated nugget diameter ND does not include the estimated nugget diameter ND that is estimated with low accuracy when the nugget N has not reached the interface, so that the estimation accuracy of the nugget diameter ND can be improved.
[0041] A4. Example 1 Three hot-dip galvanized steel sheets with a thickness of 0.7 mm were stacked and spot-welded, and the nugget diameter ND was estimated according to the above estimation method. In Example 1 and Example 2, the definition of the nugget diameter ND is different from that described above, and the length of the nugget N at the interface is used as the nugget diameter ND. The length of the nugget N at the interface here is the distance from one of two intersections between the nugget N and the interface of one metal plate to the other intersection in the nugget N that appears in a cross section that passes through the nugget center NC and is parallel to the thickness direction of the welded member W. Since there is a correlation between the nugget diameter ND and the length of the nugget N at the interface, it is possible to apply the above estimation method by regarding the length of the nugget N at the interface as the nugget diameter ND. In other words, the length of the nugget N at the interface is one aspect of the nugget diameter ND.
[0042] The number of samples was 20. The welding conditions were the same, but the welding current conditions were varied. Specifically, four current patterns were prepared by changing the current value of the welding current, and welding was performed.
[0043] FIG. 9 shows the results for half the length of the estimated nugget diameter ND. For convenience, the data is arranged in order of the length of the nugget diameter ND. Since a metal plate with a thickness of 0.7 mm is used, the distance ID is 0.35 mm. In Example 1, 6 out of 20 samples are 0.35 mm or less. Therefore, the nugget diameter ND was estimated by excluding the samples with a length of 0.35 mm or less.
[0044] Fig. 10 shows the results of the estimated nugget diameter ND according to Example 1. The horizontal axis of Fig. 10 is the estimated nugget diameter [mm]. The vertical axis of Fig. 11 is the actually measured nugget diameter [mm]. The same applies to Fig. 11 described later.
[0045] As shown in FIG. 10, in Example 1, the accuracy was improved compared to an estimation method that did not exclude cases in which it was estimated that the nugget N had not reached the interface, and the nugget diameter ND could be estimated with an accuracy of -10% or more and 9% or less.
[0046] A5. Example 2 A hot-dip galvanized steel sheet having a thickness of 1.8 mm and a hot-dip galvanized steel sheet having a thickness of 0.9 mm were overlapped and spot welded, and then the nugget diameter ND was estimated according to the above estimation method. As in Example 1, in Example 2, welding was performed by setting various welding current conditions without changing the pressure condition among the welding conditions.
[0047] 11 shows the results of the estimated nugget diameter ND according to Example 2. In Example 2, the accuracy was improved compared to the estimation method that does not add the amount of shrinkage to the parameters of the estimation formula, and the nugget diameter ND could be estimated with an accuracy of -9% or more and 7% or less.
[0048] According to the embodiment described above, the nugget thickness NT is estimated in step S10, and when it is estimated that the nugget N has reached the interface using the estimated nugget thickness NT, the nugget diameter ND is estimated in step S20. Therefore, since it is possible to exclude a low-accuracy estimated nugget diameter ND calculated when the nugget N has not reached the interface, it is possible to improve the estimation accuracy of the estimated nugget diameter ND.
[0049] In step S10, the nugget thickness is estimated using the amount of shrinkage in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value, and in step S30, the nugget diameter ND is estimated using the amount of shrinkage in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value. Thus, by estimating the nugget thickness NT and the nugget diameter ND using the amount of shrinkage that is in good proportional relationship with each of the nugget thickness NT and the nugget diameter ND, the estimation accuracy can be further improved.
[0050] Moreover, the shrinkage amount is calculated by subtracting the thickness of the welded member W at the end of the holding step P30 from the thickness of the welded member W at the start of the holding step P30. This reduces the calculation load of the shrinkage amount. The electrical resistance value used in the estimation formula is the average of the electrical resistance values from a point that is an acquisition time GT before the end of the current application step P20 to the end of the current application step P20, and the acquisition time GT is equal to or less than half the process time of the current application step P20. There is a good correlation between the average electrical resistance value during this period and each of the nugget thickness NT and the nugget diameter ND, and therefore the estimation accuracy can be further improved.
[0051] Furthermore, in step S20, if half the length of the estimated nugget thickness NT is longer than the distance ID between the center position WC of the welded parts W and the interface farthest from the center position WC, it is estimated that the nugget N has reached the interface. Therefore, it is possible to estimate whether the nugget N has reached the interface by using the distance ID determined by the thickness of the welded parts W.
[0052] Furthermore, in step S10, nugget thickness estimation formula (1) is used, and in step S30, nugget diameter estimation formula (2) is used. As a result, the nugget thickness NT and nugget diameter ND can be estimated with high accuracy using the estimation formulas that reflect the proportional relationships between the nugget thickness NT and nugget diameter ND and the expansion amount, contraction amount, and electrical resistance value, respectively.
[0053] B. Other embodiments: (B1) Using the above estimation method, a method for determining poor welding can be implemented. In the nugget diameter estimation process, when it is determined that the nugget N has not reached the interface (step S20: NO), the estimation unit 82 may determine that there is poor welding, and store the determination value of poor welding in a storage device provided in the control device 80. This allows the welding quality to be appropriately determined.
[0054] (B2) In the above embodiment, the amount of shrinkage is used as a parameter in each of the nugget thickness estimation formula (1) and the nugget diameter estimation formula (2), but the amount of shrinkage does not have to be used. When estimating each of the nugget thickness estimation formula (1) and the nugget diameter estimation formula (2), the nugget thickness NT and the nugget diameter ND can be estimated by using at least the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value.
[0055] (B3) In the above embodiment, the amount of shrinkage is calculated by subtracting the amount of displacement at the end of the holding step P30 from the amount of displacement indicating the thickness of the welded workpieces W at the start of the holding step P30. The amount of shrinkage is not limited to this, and an integral value calculated in the same manner as the amount of expansion may be used, for example.
[0056] (B4) In the above embodiment, the average of the electric resistance values from the time obtained by counting back the end of the energizing process P20 by the acquisition time GT to the end of the energizing process P20 is used as the electric resistance value used in each estimation formula, but this is not limited to this. For example, the average of the electric resistance values during the entire period of the energizing process P20 may be used, or the electric resistance value at a predetermined time may be used instead of the average.
[0057] The present disclosure is not limited to the above-mentioned embodiment, and can be realized in various configurations without departing from the spirit of the present disclosure. For example, the technical features of the embodiments corresponding to the technical features in each aspect described in the Summary of the Invention can be appropriately replaced or combined to solve some or all of the above-mentioned problems or to achieve some or all of the above-mentioned effects. Furthermore, if a technical feature is not described as essential in this specification, it can be appropriately deleted. [Explanation of symbols]
[0058] 10...welding gun, 11...gun body, 20...movement mechanism, 21, 22...electrode tip, 30...power supply device, 40...pressure device, 51...encoder, 52...gauge, 53...current sensor, 54...voltage sensor, 80...control device, 81...welding control unit, 82...estimation unit, 100...resistance spot welding device, GT...acquisition time, NC...nugget center, P10...preload step, P20...energization step, P30...holding step, N...nugget, ND...nugget diameter, NT...nugget thickness, ID...distance, W...welded material, W1...first metal plate, W2...second metal plate, W3...third metal plate, WC...center position
Claims
1. A method for estimating a nugget diameter of a nugget formed by resistance spot welding, comprising the steps of: The resistance spot welding is A first step of sandwiching two or more overlapping metal plates between a pair of electrode tips and applying pressure to the metal plates to pass an electric current through the metal plates; a second step of stopping the current supply in the first step and pressing the two or more metal plates with the pair of electrode tips, The estimation method includes: a thickness estimating step of estimating a nugget thickness using an expansion amount in a thickness direction of the two or more metal plates in the first step and an electrical resistance value between the pair of electrode tips in the first step; and a diameter estimation process of estimating the nugget diameter using the expansion amount and the electrical resistance value when it is estimated that the nugget has reached the interface between two adjacent metal plates using the thicknesses of each of the two or more metal plates and the estimated nugget thickness.
2. The estimation method according to claim 1, In the thickness estimation step, The nugget thickness is estimated using the amount of contraction in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates in the second process in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value, In the diameter estimation step, the nugget diameter is estimated using the amount of shrinkage in addition to the amount of expansion and the electrical resistance value.
3. The estimation method according to claim 2, The amount of shrinkage is The estimation method includes subtracting the thickness at the end of the second process from the thickness of the two or more metal plates at the start of the second process.
4. The estimation method according to claim 2, The electrical resistance value is an average of the electrical resistance values from a time point that is a predetermined acquisition time before the end time of the first process to the end time of the first process, The estimation method, wherein the acquisition time is equal to or less than half the process time of the first process.
5. The estimation method according to claim 1, An estimation method in which, if half the length of the estimated nugget thickness is longer than the distance between the central position in the thickness direction of the two or more metal plates and the interface that is farthest from the central position, it is estimated that the nugget has reached the interface.
6. The estimation method according to claim 2, When the nugget thickness is NT [mm], the nugget diameter is ND [mm], the expansion amount is E [mm], the contraction amount is S [mm], the electrical resistance value is R [Ω], and the predetermined constants are C1 to C8, The estimation method includes calculating the nugget thickness using the following formula (1) and calculating the nugget diameter using the following formula (2). NT=C1×E+C2×S+C3×R+C4...(1) ND=C5×E+C6×S+C7×R+C8...(2)
7. A determination method using the estimation method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, comprising: A method for determining that a weld is defective when it is estimated that the nugget has not reached the interface using the thicknesses of each of the two or more metal plates and the estimated nugget thickness.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method and device for controlling welding current of spot welding machine
JP1992022584A
Estimation method for nugget diameter in spot welding
JP1999058028A
Method of estimating nugget diameter in resistance welding and control method of resistance welding
JP2000079482A
Resistance spot welding device
JP2020171942A
Resistance spot welding method
WO2017212916A1
