Method for predicting the diameter of inclusions in steel
The combination of ultrasonic flaw detection and fatigue testing addresses the inefficiency and inaccuracy of conventional methods by accurately predicting the maximum inclusion size in steel materials, enhancing the reliability of steel parts.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021032403
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-03-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-03-02
AI Technical Summary
Conventional methods for predicting the maximum diameter of nonmetallic inclusions in steel materials are inaccurate and inefficient, leading to premature fatigue failure in steel parts due to larger inclusions not detected during the prediction process.
A method combining ultrasonic flaw detection and ultrasonic fatigue testing to identify and measure the largest inclusions, involving multiple test pieces and statistical analysis to derive the maximum inclusion diameter accurately and efficiently.
The method enables high-accuracy and efficient prediction of the maximum inclusion size in large volumes of steel materials, reducing the risk of premature fatigue failure by identifying and measuring the largest inclusions using commercially available devices.
Smart Images

Figure 0007588006000001 
Figure 0007588006000002 
Figure 0007588006000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for predicting the maximum diameter (maximum size) of inclusions present in a steel material, and more particularly, to a method for predicting the maximum size of inclusions by a combination of ultrasonic flaw detection testing and ultrasonic fatigue testing. [Background technology]
[0002] Bearings made of high-strength steel may break down during use. One of the causes of this breakage is stress concentration on nonmetallic inclusions in the steel caused by repeated fatigue, known as rolling fatigue, during use of the bearing. These nonmetallic inclusions are inevitably generated during the steel manufacturing process. The range of influence of stress concentration around the inclusions is thought to correlate with the size of the nonmetallic inclusions. Therefore, it is important to understand the size of the inclusions when estimating the life of the bearing. It is also important to understand the size of the nonmetallic inclusions when estimating the life of steel parts other than bearings. In particular, it is important to understand the diameter (maximum diameter) of the largest nonmetallic inclusion among multiple nonmetallic inclusions present in order to ensure the reliability of the parts.
[0003] "Metal Fatigue: The Effects of Micro Defects and Inclusions" (Yokendo, written by Murakami Yoshiyoshi) published in 1993 discloses a method for predicting the maximum diameter of an inclusion within a standard volume by microscopy and extreme value statistics.
[0004] JP 2009-281738 A discloses a method for predicting the maximum diameter of inclusions in steel. In this method, the diameter of inclusions present on the fracture surface is actually measured by ultrasonic fatigue testing. The maximum diameter is calculated based on this diameter value by the extreme value statistics method.
[0005] JP 2020-34292 A also discloses a method for predicting the maximum diameter of inclusions by ultrasonic fatigue testing and extreme value statistics. In this method, a test piece charged with hydrogen is subjected to ultrasonic fatigue testing. The hydrogen charging is performed for the purpose of promoting the destruction of the test piece by utilizing hydrogen embrittlement. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0006] [Patent Document 1] JP2009-281738A [Patent Document 2] Patent Publication No. 2020-34292 [Non-patent literature]
[0007] [Non-Patent Document 1] "Metal Fatigue: The Effects of Micro Defects and Inclusions" (Yokendo, by Takayoshi Murakami) published in 1993 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0008] In steel parts such as bearings, fatigue failure may occur earlier than the life expected based on the maximum diameter of nonmetallic inclusions predicted using extreme value statistics. Such fatigue failure occurs because the volume affected by fatigue in mass-produced steel parts may be larger than the volume inspected for the prediction, and nonmetallic inclusions with diameters larger than the predicted maximum diameter may be included. Therefore, the conventional method for predicting the maximum diameter has room for improvement in terms of accuracy.
[0009] If the diameters of the inclusions are actually measured by observing a large number of cross sections, the maximum diameter can be predicted with high accuracy. However, the task of actually measuring the diameters at a large number of cross sections is time-consuming and not realistic.
[0010] An object of the present invention is to provide a method for predicting the maximum size of inclusions in a large volume of steel product efficiently and accurately. [Means for solving the problem]
[0011] The method for predicting the maximum size according to the present invention comprises the steps of: (A) taking a first test specimen from a steel material; (B) subjecting the first test piece to an ultrasonic flaw detection test to identify a detection point where the presence of an inclusion is suspected; (C) collecting a second test piece including the detection site from the first test piece; (D) subjecting the second test piece to an ultrasonic fatigue test to fracture the second test piece and obtain a fracture surface; (E) measuring the size of an inclusion present at the origin on the fracture surface; and (F) performing the steps (A) to (E) multiple times, and deriving the size of the largest inclusion present in the steel material having a volume larger than the volume inspected by the ultrasonic inspection using a statistical method based on the sizes of the multiple inclusions obtained; Includes.
[0012] Preferably, the statistical method in step (F) is extreme value statistics.
[0013] Preferably, in the ultrasonic flaw detection test in step (B), ultrasonic waves having a frequency of 10 MHz or more and 25 MHz or less are incident on the first test piece.
[0014] Preferably, in step (B), the evaluation volume of the first test piece subjected to the ultrasonic flaw detection test is 100,000 mm 3 That's all.
[0015] Preferably, in the ultrasonic fatigue test of step (D), a load having a stress of 550 MPa or more is applied to the second test piece.
[0016] According to another aspect, a method for producing a test strip according to the present invention comprises the steps of: taking a first test piece from the steel material; subjecting the first test piece to an ultrasonic flaw detection test to identify a detection point where the presence of an inclusion is predicted; and A step of collecting a second test strip including the detection site from the first test strip. Includes. Effect of the Invention
[0017] The method according to the present invention allows the maximum size of inclusions in steel to be predicted with high accuracy, and is highly efficient as a means of evaluating large volumes. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0018] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a flowchart showing a prediction method according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a perspective view showing an example of a first test piece used in the prediction method of FIG. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 is a perspective view showing an example of a second test piece used in the prediction method of FIG. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is an enlarged cross-sectional view taken along line IV-IV in FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0019] Hereinafter, the present invention will be described in detail based on preferred embodiments with reference to the drawings as appropriate.
[0020] In the prediction method shown in Fig. 1, a steel bar is first prepared (STEP 1). This steel bar is a target for predicting the maximum size of inclusions. Instead of a steel bar, a steel material having another shape may be prepared.
[0021] A first test piece 2 is taken from this steel bar (STEP 2). This first test piece 2 is shown in FIG. 2. This first test piece 2 has a cylindrical shape. In the example shown here, the first test piece 2 has a diameter of 63 mm and a length of 250 mm. The evaluation volume of this first test piece 2 is determined by the diameter and length of the test piece, the length that can be detected by the ultrasonic flaw detector, and the detection area (corresponding to the detection area excluding the dead zone of the steel surface in ultrasonic flaw detection). This evaluation volume is the reference evaluation volume. The reference evaluation volume may be changed as appropriate in the implementation. This first test piece 2 is obtained by subjecting the raw material, such as a steel bar, to cutting processing, plastic processing, etc. Prior to processing, the steel bar may be subjected to heat treatment to facilitate processing or to suppress attenuation of ultrasonic waves during ultrasonic flaw detection. The heat treatment is, for example, normalizing, but may also be annealing or spheroidizing annealing. The conditions of these heat treatments are determined based on the chemical composition of the steel to be inspected. The means for determining the conditions may be calculation of an equilibrium diagram using thermodynamic calculation software or verification by preliminary experiments, and if the conditions are already known in literature or materials, the conditions may be used. The shape of the first test piece 2 is not limited to a cylinder. Various shapes may be adopted for the first test piece 2.
[0022] This first test piece 2 is subjected to ultrasonic testing (STEP 3). The equipment for ultrasonic testing is equipped with an ultrasonic probe. Ultrasonic waves are emitted from this probe. These ultrasonic waves are incident on the first test piece 2. If the first test piece 2 has an internal defect such as a non-metallic inclusion, the ultrasonic waves are reflected by this internal defect. The reflected wave (echo from the internal defect) generated by this reflection is detected by the probe, and the internal defect is detected. The probe moves relative to the first test piece 2 while emitting ultrasonic waves, thereby inspecting a wide range of the first test piece 2 and detecting a single internal defect or multiple internal defects. If multiple internal defects are detected, the largest internal defect within the measurement volume is identified based on the reflected wave intensity (echo height) from that defect.
[0023] The direct contact method and the water immersion method can be used for the ultrasonic testing. Here, the water immersion method is preferred from the viewpoint of enabling stable transmission and reception of ultrasonic waves. The frequency of the ultrasonic waves emitted from the probe in the ultrasonic testing is preferably 10 MHz or more and 25 MHz or less, and more preferably 20 MHz or more, which provides high detection accuracy for internal defects. The focal depth of the ultrasonic probe in the steel from the surface of the first test piece 2 is preferably about 5 mm or more from the steel surface, in consideration of processing the second test piece 4 following the first test piece 2 and incorporating the internal defects detected by the first test piece 2 in the test piece, as described below.
[0024] The ultrasonic testing identifies the location where the internal defect exists. In other words, the location where the presence of an inclusion is suspected (detection location) is identified. The detection location that is considered to be the largest among them is marked (STEP 4). The marking can be drawn on the surface of the first test piece 2. The marking may also be achieved by electronic recording to identify the position. This is used when the information on the marking position on the first test piece 2 can be reflected as processing position information for the processing device for processing the second test piece 4 that follows.
[0025] A second test piece 4 is taken from this first test piece 2 (STEP 5). In this taking, the first test piece 2 is processed while referring to the above-mentioned marking position. Specifically, the processing is performed so that the detection point is included in the second test piece 4. One second test piece 4 can be taken from one first test piece 2. Specific examples of the processing procedure include rough processing, quenching and tempering, and finish processing. In the rough processing, cutting processing or the like is performed on the first test piece 2. As a guideline for the hardness by quenching and tempering of the second test piece 4, it is preferable to ensure 450 HV or more. This is because if the hardness is lower than 450 HV, it may not be possible to break the inclusions by ultrasonic fatigue testing even if hydrogen charging is performed. More preferably, it is 500 HV or more. Note that there may be cases where the second test piece 4 cannot be taken from the first test piece 2 depending on the location where the internal defect exists, and in that case, the first test piece 2 is not included in the evaluation.
[0026] An example of the second test piece 4 to be subjected to the ultrasonic fatigue test is shown in Figs. 3 and 4. The second test piece 4 has a dumbbell shape with a straight portion. The second test piece 4 has a central portion 6, a pair of large diameter portions 8, and a male thread portion at one end. The male thread portion is a portion that connects to a horn of an ultrasonic fatigue tester in the ultrasonic fatigue test described later. The central portion 6 has a straight portion 10 and a pair of tapered portions 12. When the second test piece 4 shown in Figs. 3 and 4 is taken, the straight portion 10 is processed so that the detection point is included. Since the second test piece 4 having the straight portion 10 is made to include the maximum internal defect contained in the first test piece 2, the actual evaluation volume in this case can be regarded as the evaluation volume (reference evaluation volume) in the ultrasonic flaw detection test of the first test piece 2, not the volume of the straight portion of the second test piece 4. The shape of the second test piece 4 is not limited to the shape of this embodiment, and other shapes may be adopted.
[0027] Next, the resonance frequency of the second test piece 4 is confirmed (STEP 6). The resonance frequency of the second test piece 4 connected to the ultrasonic horn of the ultrasonic fatigue tester is compared with the reference frequency to determine whether it passes or fails (STEP 7). The reference frequency is the frequency of ultrasonic vibration applied to the second test piece 4 in the ultrasonic fatigue test, which will be described in detail later. The pass / fail determination is made based on the degree of deviation between the resonance frequency and the reference frequency. For example, when the reference frequency of the ultrasonic fatigue tester is 20,000 Hz, the second test piece 4 having a resonance frequency of 19,800 Hz or more and 20,200 Hz or less passes. The second test piece 4 having a resonance frequency less than 19,800 Hz and the second test piece 4 having a resonance frequency exceeding 20,200 Hz fails. According to an even stricter standard, the second test piece 4 having a resonance frequency of 19,970 Hz or more and 20,030 Hz or less passes. The second test piece 4 that fails the test is corrected by processing (STEP 8). A typical correction is to change the length of the second test piece 4. The change in length causes the resonance frequency of the second test piece 4 to vary. The resonance frequency of the corrected second test piece 4 is checked again (STEP 6), and the pass / fail judgment is made (STEP 7). The second test piece 4 that fails the test may be discarded without being corrected.
[0028] Hydrogen is charged to the second test piece 4 that passed the test (STEP 9). This charging may cause hydrogen embrittlement in the second test piece 4. The second test piece 4 that has experienced hydrogen embrittlement may break with a small stress and a small number of repeated cycles in an ultrasonic fatigue test that will be described in detail later. Hydrogen charging is performed for the purpose of facilitating and speeding up the breaking in this ultrasonic fatigue test.
[0029] The method of charging hydrogen is as follows: (1) Immersion of the second test piece 4 in the electrolyte (2) Exposure of the second test piece 4 to high pressure hydrogen gas and (3) Electrolysis in an electrolyte with the second test piece 4 as the cathode is an example. Other methods may be used for charging hydrogen. In the case of electrolysis, for example, an electrolyte in which 3% sodium chloride and 0.3% ammonium thiocyanate are added to pure water may be used. The diffusion coefficient of hydrogen atoms into steel is temperature dependent. Therefore, if an electrolyte with a temperature higher than room temperature is used, charging can be performed with high efficiency, i.e., in a shorter time. If the second test piece 4 contains a sufficiently large internal defect, fracture becomes easy, so charging with hydrogen (STEP 9) may be omitted.
[0030] After charging with hydrogen, the second test piece 4 is subjected to ultrasonic fatigue testing (STEP 10). The hydrogen introduced into the second test piece 4 during charging (STEP 9) is gradually released into the atmosphere. Due to the release, the amount of hydrogen contained in the second test piece 4 gradually decreases. However, if the ultrasonic fatigue testing (STEP 10) is performed shortly after charging (STEP 9), a second test piece 4 containing sufficient hydrogen can be subjected to the ultrasonic fatigue testing. Therefore, the test can be performed under conditions where hydrogen embrittlement occurs.
[0031] In the ultrasonic fatigue test, a tensile load and a compressive load are alternately and repeatedly applied to the second test piece 4 connected to the ultrasonic horn by ultrasonic vibration. The direction of action of these loads is the axial direction of the second test piece 4. As the load is applied, stress is generated in the second test piece 4. At this time, the load is preferably applied to the second test piece 4 so that a stress of 550 MPa or more is generated. Note that this stress may be adjusted to a higher stress to promote rapid fracture, on the premise that heat generation during the ultrasonic fatigue test of the second test piece 4 as described later is suppressed.
[0032] During the ultrasonic fatigue test, the second test piece 4 is heated due to internal friction caused by repeated stress loading. This temperature rise promotes hydrogen release from the second test piece 4, inhibits brittle fracture of the test piece, and prevents the test from being completed. Therefore, the temperature rise needs to be suppressed. The temperature rise can be suppressed by blowing cooled air onto the second test piece 4. Furthermore, the temperature rise can also be suppressed by intermittently inputting ultrasonic vibration to the second test piece 4. Since the degree of temperature rise due to friction depends on the hardness of the test piece and the composition of the alloy, frictional heat can also be suppressed by selecting and applying an appropriate load. Usually, all of the following are performed: blowing air, intermittent input of ultrasonic vibration, and selection of an appropriate test load.
[0033] In the second test piece 4 to which a load is applied, stress is concentrated on the nonmetallic inclusions. As the load is repeatedly applied, fatigue fracture occurs from the largest nonmetallic inclusion contained in the evaluation volume of the second test piece 4 (which refers to the volume of the straight part with a diameter of 6 mm in the case of the test piece illustrated in FIG. 3). This fatigue fracture causes the second test piece 4 to break, and a fracture surface is obtained. Usually, the fracture occurs in a plane perpendicular to the load direction (the axial direction of the second test piece 4). By observing the starting point of this fracture, the nonmetallic inclusion that caused the fracture can be observed. There may be cases where the nonmetallic inclusion does not appear at the starting point, but the test results in such cases will not be included in the analysis data using the extreme value statistics method described below.
[0034] The diameter of the nonmetallic inclusion present at the starting point on the fracture surface is measured (STEP 11). This measurement is usually performed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM). The diameter (size) of the nonmetallic inclusion is measured by taking the square root of the product of the long diameter and short diameter of the inclusion on the observed cross section ((long diameter × short diameter) 1 / 2 ) or the cross-sectional area of the inclusion may be calculated by analyzing an observed image and converted into a circle-equivalent diameter. In addition to measuring the diameter, the chemical composition of the inclusion may be analyzed using an energy dispersive X-ray analyzer or wavelength dispersive X-ray analyzer attached to a scanning electron microscope. This can be used as data showing the characteristics of the inclusions contained in the steel material.
[0035] By conducting an ultrasonic fatigue test (STEP 10) on a plurality of second test pieces 4 taken from a plurality of first test pieces 2, a plurality of fracture surfaces are obtained. By observing these, the diameters of a plurality of nonmetallic inclusions are measured. Based on the data group of the diameters of these nonmetallic inclusions and the reference evaluation volume (the evaluation volume per one first test piece 2 by ultrasonic flaw detection testing), the diameter of the largest inclusion present in the steel bar is derived by a statistical method (STEP 12). Here, extreme value statistics is used as a typical statistical method. The extreme value statistics method derives the maximum value of the diameters of nonmetallic inclusions within a predicted volume that is determined for convenience based on an extreme value distribution model. In other words, the diameter of the largest inclusion that can be contained in the steel bar is predicted.
[0036] The volume of the area of one second test piece 4 where a stress of 90% or more of the load stress in the ultrasonic fatigue test acts (the "evaluation volume of the ultrasonic fatigue test") is normally considered to be the evaluation volume, but as described above, the second test piece 4 is taken out from the original first test piece 2 from which the second test piece 4 was taken out so that the largest inclusion in the evaluation volume in the ultrasonic testing is included therein, so the evaluation volume in the ultrasonic testing for each first test piece 2 can be considered to be the substantial "evaluation volume of the ultrasonic fatigue test." This evaluation volume becomes the reference evaluation volume for predicting the diameter of the largest inclusion.
[0037] In the present invention, with regard to the "evaluation volume for ultrasonic fatigue testing", which is actually only an extremely small volume, the steel bar is subjected to ultrasonic flaw detection testing (STEP 3), and from this extremely large volume, the target area for ultrasonic fatigue testing (STEP 10) (the area where the largest inclusion is expected to be present) is identified, and from there, an ultrasonic fatigue test specimen is extracted, and this extremely large volume region becomes the target area for evaluation with the aim of predicting the actual diameter of the largest inclusion.
[0038] In this way, the prediction method according to the present invention can predict the diameter of the largest inclusion with high accuracy by using the "evaluation volume of ultrasonic testing", which can be easily made large, as the target area for evaluation aimed at predicting the diameter of the largest inclusion. On the other hand, since the ultrasonic fatigue test piece used for the evaluation can be made small, equipment that is already commercially available can be used for the ultrasonic fatigue test, and therefore the method can be easily realized. In addition, the test time (time required for the test piece to break) can be shortened by using both the ultrasonic fatigue test and the embrittlement effect caused by hydrogen charging of the test piece, so that the test piece can be broken quickly. Therefore, the prediction method according to the present invention can efficiently predict the diameter of the largest inclusion. Furthermore, the prediction method according to the present invention is excellent in both accuracy and efficiency.
[0039] From the viewpoint of accuracy, the evaluation volume of the first test piece 2 subjected to the ultrasonic flaw detection test is 100,000 mm 3 More preferably, it is 200,000 mm 3 That's all.
[0040] The present invention is also directed to a method for manufacturing a test specimen, the method comprising the steps of: A step of taking a first test piece 2 from the steel material; A step of subjecting the first test piece 2 to an ultrasonic flaw detection test and identifying a detection point where the presence of an inclusion is predicted; and A step of collecting a second test piece 4 including the detection site from the first test piece 2. Includes.
[0041] This manufacturing method makes it possible to easily obtain test specimens, which can contribute to highly accurate evaluation of the size of inclusions. [Industrial Applicability]
[0042] The prediction method according to the present invention can be applied to steel materials. [Explanation of symbols]
[0043] 2. First test piece 4. Second test piece 6...Central part 8...Large diameter part 10 Straight section 12 Tapered section
Claims
1. (A) taking a first test piece from a steel material; (B) subjecting the first test piece to an ultrasonic flaw detection test to identify a detection point where the presence of an inclusion is suspected; (C) collecting a second test piece including the detection site from the first test piece; (D) subjecting the second test piece to an ultrasonic fatigue test to fracture the second test piece and obtain a fracture surface; (E) measuring the size of an inclusion present at the origin on the fracture surface; and (F) performing the steps (A) to (E) a plurality of times, and deriving, based on the obtained plurality of inclusion sizes, the size of the largest inclusion present in the steel material having a volume larger than the volume inspected by the ultrasonic inspection test, by a statistical method; How to predict the maximum size, including:
2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the statistical method in step (F) is an extreme value statistical method.
3. 3. The prediction method according to claim 1, wherein in the ultrasonic flaw detection test in step (B), ultrasonic waves having a frequency of 10 MHz or more and 25 MHz or less are incident on the first test piece.
4. The prediction method according to claim 1 , wherein in step (B), the evaluation volume of the first test piece subjected to the ultrasonic flaw detection test is 100,000 mm 3 or more.
5. 5. The prediction method according to claim 1, wherein in the ultrasonic fatigue test of step (D), a load having a stress of 550 MPa or more is applied to the second test piece.
6. taking a first test piece from the steel material; subjecting the first test piece to an ultrasonic flaw detection test to identify a detection point where the presence of an inclusion is predicted; and A step of taking a second test piece from the first test piece, the second test piece having a dumbbell shape with a straight portion, the straight portion including the detection point, and being subjected to an ultrasonic fatigue test. A method for manufacturing a test piece, comprising:
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Detection method of foreign matter in metal material
JP2001242146A
Steel inclusion detection method by water immersion ultrasonic inspection
JP2004093227A
Prediction method of largest inclusion diameter in steel product, and estimation method of rolling fatigue life of steel product
JP2009281738A
Ultrasonic flaw detection method
JP2019215227A
Method for predicting maximum inclusion diameter in steel product by ultrasonic fatigue test
JP2020034292A
