Method and system for managing alarms in modular production facilities
The method and system for managing alarms in modular production facilities integrate PEA modules with programmable controllers to simulate and automatically detect alarm chains, addressing integration challenges and improving alarm management efficiency.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- KR1020237044594
- Authority / Receiving Office
- KR · KR
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-05-28
- Filing Date
- 2022-05-11
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-11
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-05-11
AI Technical Summary
Existing modular production facilities face challenges in integrating controllers from different manufacturers, leading to difficulties in alarm management due to frequent facility structure changes, and existing methods are limited in detecting alarm chains and require manual tracing and conversion.
A method and system for managing alarms in modular production facilities by integrating PEA modules with programmable controllers, simulating defect scenarios, and automatically detecting and logging alarm chains using a digital twin model, enabling automated alarm management.
Automated detection and logging of alarm chains in a standardized format, reducing manual analysis and re-execution of alarm management measures, and ensuring precise detection of both linear and interconnected alarm chains.
Smart Images

Figure R1020237044594_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technology Field
[65535] The present invention relates to a method for managing alarms in modular production installations according to the preamble of patent claim 1 and a system for managing alarms in modular production installations according to the preamble of patent claim 5. Background Technology Modular production facilities are increasingly being used in manufacturing and process engineering, and manufacturing and process engineering are interconnected with modular automation. Using modular design can significantly reduce planning time and engineering costs for both new facilities and the retrofitting of existing ones. Particularly regarding the retrofitting of "old" facilities, if the goal is to reduce downtime and time-to-market, executing this quickly must play a crucial role. Until now, modular engineering considering modular automation was impossible because controllers from different manufacturers could not be used in production facilities. However, to enable continuous modular engineering and modular automation, "Process Equipment Assembly <pea>Standards were defined in VDI / VDE / NAMUR Directive 2658, which includes modules, thereby describing standard PEA module automation in a manufacturer-independent manner and, in the process orchestration process, PEA modules from various manufacturers with PEA controllers and the "Process Orchestration Layer" <pol>It has become possible to integrate into ". In this case, the integration of PEA modules is a "Module Type Package" created by the PEA manufacturer <mtp>It is accomplished through a mechanism, and using this, "process equipment assembly <pea>All essential information, PEA operating screens as structural descriptions, services as encapsulated process functions, and, for example, alarm and diagnostic modes are described. In the case of modular production facilities, the importance of alarm management increases because the facility structure changes frequently, making implementation experience more difficult. One option to improve this is a model describing alarm chains, which is also described in the standard VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658. This model can be used to describe alarm chains within modules by PEA modules and to provide alarm chains to both the production facility controller and the production facility operator. However, to do this, the PEA manufacturer must first determine the alarm chains and then convert the determined alarm chains into a standardized format. One option to achieve this is for the PEA manufacturer to utilize expertise to manually trace the alarm chains, determine these alarm chains accordingly, and then perform manual detection according to the standard. A method and device for computer-aided simulation of a modular technology system, in which a virtual model corresponding to each actual module of the modular technology system is created, EP 3 650 Disclosed in 970 A1. A virtual module comprises a controller for controlling a module-specific process and at least one module-specific simulation model having related model type information for simulating the module-specific process. The virtual module is configured to replicate the module-specific process controlled by the controller through the module-specific simulation model and / or the controller of the actual module, and is provided as a data container for computer-aided simulation of a module-specific technical system. The disclosed method or system, in particular, allows for the virtual commissioning of modular process facilities. In this case, various tasks, various system specifications, and / or fault scenarios can be executed in particular.It is known from the IEEE publication by MANCA GIANLUCA et al. [by MANCA GIANLUCA ET AL: "Detection of Historical Alarm Subsequences Using Alarm Events and a Coactivation Constraint", IEEE ACCESS, IEEE, USA, Vol. 9, March 22, 2021 (2021 / 03 / 22), pages 46851-46873] that detection of historical partial alarm sequences is used in methods for analyzing alarm bursts. Unlike previous methods that have limitations in overcoming this, a new approach is proposed that uses the detection of anomalies in the time distances between alarm events (activation and return to normal state) and a coactivation constraint for alarms. This is based on the 'Tennessee Eastman Process' as a comparative standard in process automation. The present invention aims to provide a dataset suitable for developing and evaluating alarm management methods in complex industrial processes by utilizing both quantitative and qualitative information from various sources. Furthermore, it demonstrates that integrating additional information into the proposed procedure is advantageous for overall performance and robustness. Consequently, the proposed procedure can more precisely detect consistent past abnormal situations, including stages with active cause defects and subsequent normalization stages. Additionally, compared to previous approaches, the proposed procedure has the advantage that detection results are less affected by the number of alarms, propagation speed, duration of the situation, and the time distance between two causally independent situations.Service orchestration in modular process plants is considered, according to the IEEE publication [by BLOCH, HENRY ET AL: "Orchestration of Services in Modular Process Plants", IECON 2018 - 44TH ANNUAL CONFERENCE OF THE IEEE INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS SOCIETY, IEEE, October 21, 2018 (2018 / 10 / 21), pages 2935-2940], as an approach to addressing the increasing flexibility requirements in the process industry by orchestrating the modularization of process plants. In this case, since existing distributed control systems cannot support adequate flexibility for production systems, modular process plants are constructed by combining modules to enhance production flexibility. The modules must encapsulate process functions as services. These services must be discoverable and controllable through standards-based controllers. The proposed orchestration includes an approach for controlling services based on standards according to a defined state model tested in two case studies and two different implementations. Thus, it can be used, for example, in simulation environments based on Matlab Simulink Stateflow and in industrial implementations of pumps and controllers. The objective on which the present invention is based is to specify a method and a system for managing alarms in modular production facilities and to use them to automate alarm management in modular production facilities. This objective is achieved through the features specified in the feature portion of Claim 1 based on the method defined in the preamble of Claim 1. Additionally, this objective is achieved through the features specified in the feature portion of Claim 5 based on the system defined in the preamble of Claim 5. As claimed in Claims 1 and 5, the underlying concept of the present invention is—modular manufacturers of modular production facilities—for independent design and operation, "process equipment assembly <pea>Modules (PEA-MD) are integrated into the production facility (PRAL) in such a way that they are controlled by a programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) and simulated using a projectable PEA simulation (PEA-SM) during the process orchestration (PO) process, and in particular, a "module type package" for describing PEA modules <mtp>In relation to a modular production facility, e.g., an industrial automation facility (see claims 4 and 8) that is standardized according to the VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658 standard through a mechanism (MTP-MC)—virtually execute and simulate all states of the modular production facility in relation to triggered defects of defect cases that may occur in the production facility,—simultaneously logging the simulated defects occurring in this case in the form of alarm signals, e.g., by providing labeling by signaling, and generating an alarm signal log,—identifying alarm chains from the alarm signal log, or in the case of alarm management in identifying alarm chains and determining alarm correlations in alarm chains.Specifically, alarm management consists of the following seven measures: (1) a measure to virtually trigger corresponding defects in relation to potential, known, and searchable defect cases of the production facility—for each defect case, the defect is virtually triggered by the activation of the corresponding PEA module in the PEA simulation—(2) a measure to simulate the simulation case belonging to the defect virtually triggered in each case through a PEA simulation in which at least one simulation defect is determined in each case; (3) a measure to detect the simulation defect through a programmable PEA controller and execute all simulation defect-based switching actions according to programming; (4) a measure to generate at least one alarm signal for alarm chain tracing for each detected simulation defect through a PEA controller; (5) a measure to detect the alarm signals generated for all defect cases and to log the alarm signals by generating an alarm signal log; (6) a measure to analyze the alarm signal log and, based on this analysis, identify alarm chains or identify alarm chains and determine alarm correlations in the alarm chains; (7) the analysis results and / or the results of the determination are in a "module type package. <mtp>A measure to transmit to the mechanism and include this in the PEA module description. Accordingly, in the alarm management system, alarm management measures (1) and (5) can be executed in the alarm chain tracking component, alarm management measure (2) can be executed during the PEA simulation process, for example, on a simulation platform of the SIMIT type, and alarm management measures (3) and (4) can be executed, for example, on a "programmable logic controller" of the SIMATIC S7-1500 type <sps>"In the platform, the PEA control process can be executed, and the alarm management measures (6) and (7) are executed in the alarm chain analysis component. The alarm chain tracking component and the alarm chain analysis component are, in this case, preferably—as claimed in claim 6, in the alarm management process in a modular production facility, a computer program product having a component of a program module in which control program instructions are in the non-volatile, readable memory of a computer-implemented tool, preferably designed as, for example, an app and connected to memory in addition to the memory to execute the control program instructions of the program module, and / or—as claimed in claim 7, a production facility test system, for example, a "Factory Acceptance Tool" <fat>It is included in ". For example, an alarm chain tracing component designed as an alarm chain tracer handles the target configuration and execution of each individual fault scenario, and detects and logs all alarms occurring in chronological order using alarm signals generated by and received from the PEA controller. After executing all fault scenarios, the alarm signal log containing the logged alarm signals is transmitted by the alarm chain tracing component or the alarm chain tracer to an alarm chain analysis component designed, for example, as an alarm chain analyzer. This alarm chain analysis component or alarm chain analyzer analyzes the alarm signal log to identify the alarm chain, and the alarm chain identified in this process is "module type package" according to the VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658 standard. <mtp>It is processed by transmitting it to the mechanism to include the alarm chain in the PEA module description. Alarm management performed in this manner has the following advantages: - Alarm chains are automatically detected and saved in the correct format. - Because all defect states are simulated in the PEA simulation through a digital twin of the production facility consisting of models of sensors, actuators, and processors, and emulated PEA automation, alarm chains are perfectly detected, and the alarm chain identical to that of the "genuine" production facility is triggered. - Both linear and interconnected alarm chains can be determined. - "Programmable logic controller <plc>When changing the PLC code, existing automated alarm management measures need to be re-executed only once, and manual analysis of the changes and their impact is not required. Brief explanation of the drawing Further advantages of the present invention will be highlighted from the following description of two exemplary embodiments of the present invention with reference to a single drawing. In the drawing, the drawing illustrates a system for managing alarms in a modular production facility. Specific details for implementing the invention The drawing illustrates a system (SYS) for managing alarms in a modular production facility (PRAL) designed, for example, as an industrial automation facility. For alarm management, the system (SYS) comprises the following system components: (i) the modular manufacturer of the production facility (PRAL)—a "process equipment assembly" for independent design and operation. <pea>"modules (PEA-MD), (ii) a programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) that controls the PEA modules (PEA-MD) can be executed, for example, a "programmable logic controller" of the SIMATIC S7-1500 type <sps>" Platform (SPS-PF) (iii) is projectable (e.g., for alarm management) <pea>A PEA simulation (PEA-ST) simulating the modules (PEA-MD) can be executed, and a simulation platform (SPF) of the SIMIT type, for example, functionally and bidirectionally connected to the SPS platform (SPS-PF), (iv) a "module type package" that allows the PEA modules (PEA-MD) to be integrated into the production facility (PRAL) during the process orchestration (PO) process, and is preferably standardized according to the VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658 standard for PEA module description. <mtp>" mechanism (MTP-MC), and (v) production facility test system (PRAL-TS), e.g. " factory approval tool" <fat>"Equated with, where, - according to Option "A", includes an alarm chain tracing component (AKVK) and an alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) that functionally interact for alarm management, or - according to Option "B", a computer-implemented tool (CIW), for example, preferably a computer program product (CPP) designed as an app, having a non-volatile, readable memory (SP) in which processor-readable control program instructions of a program module (PGM) are stored, and a processor (PZ) connected to the memory (SP) and executing the control program instructions of the program module (PGM), wherein in the alarm management process, the program module (PGM) is a computer-implemented tool (CIW) that is a computer program product (CPP) including an alarm chain tracing component (AKVK) and an alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) that functionally interact. According to Option "A", the alarm chain tracing component (AKVK) and the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) are included as hardware components (hardware system components) of a system (SYS), and according to Option "B", the alarm chain The tracking component (AKVK) and the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) are included as software components of the system (SYS) (software system components) in a computer program product (CPP) designed as a program module (PGM) or app of a computer-implemented tool (CIW). In both cases—as illustrated in the drawings—the alarm chain tracking component (AKVK) and the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK), designed as hardware system components or software system components, are components of the production facility test system (PRAL-TS). However, although not explicitly illustrated, it is entirely possible for the hardware system components or software system components to operate independently of the production facility test system (PRAL-TS) during the alarm management process.In this alarm management and standardized process orchestration (PO) process, in relation to all relevant or potential fault cases (FHLF) of the production facility (PRAL) together with corresponding faults (FHL) stored in the alarm chain trace component (AKVK) or searchable by the alarm chain trace component (AKVK), "Fault . <fhl>alarm signal <am>In the context of the "cycle," the fault corresponding to each fault case is virtually triggered in the Alarm Chain Trace Component (AKVK) for alarm management by the corresponding PEA Module Activation (PEA-MA) in the PEA Simulation (PEA-SM) of the Simulation Platform (SPF). <fhl>alarm signal <am>In the context of the "cycle," the PEA simulation (PEA-SM) of the simulation platform (SPF) simulates simulation cases belonging to defects that are virtually triggered in each case, and in this process determines at least one simulation defect (SMF) in each case. <fhl>alarm signal <am>In the context of the "cycle," the programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) of the SPS platform (SPS-PF) detects simulation faults (SMF) through a functional bidirectional connection to the PEA simulation (PEA-SM) of the simulation platform (SPF), and then executes all simulation fault-based switching actions according to the program. Subsequently, the programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) generates at least one alarm signal (AM) for each detected simulation fault (SMF) based on the simulation fault-based switching actions executed for alarm chain tracing. Subsequently, the alarm chain tracing component (AKVK) "fault <fhl>alarm signal <am>In the context of the "cycle," alarm signals (AM) generated for all fault cases (FHLF) are detected and logged to the alarm signal log (AMP); the alarm signal log (AMP) is then transmitted to the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK). The alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) first analyzes the alarm signal log (AMP) and then identifies alarm chains (AKE) based on this analysis. Alternatively, however, the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) may first re-analyze the alarm signal log (AMP), and then, based on this analysis, re-identify the alarm chains and further determine alarm correlations (AZH) in the alarm chains (AKE). As results of the analysis or analysis and determination, the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) generates analysis results (AEG) and / or determination results (EEG), and these are "module type packages" <mtp>It is transmitted via the mechanism (MTP-MC) and included in the PEA module description.< / mtp> < / am> < / fhl> < / am> < / fhl> < / am> < / fhl> < / am> < / fhl> < / fat> < / mtp> < / pea> < / sps> < / pea> < / plc> < / mtp> < / fat> < / sps> < / mtp> < / mtp> < / pea> < / pea> < / mtp> < / pol> < / pea>
Claims
Claim 1 As a method for managing alarms in modular production facilities, - for the modular manufacturer-independent design and operation of the production facility (PRAL), "Process Equipment Assembly (PEA)" modules (PEA-MD) are integrated into the production facility (PRAL) in such a manner controlled by a programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) in a process orchestration (PO) process by a "Module Type Package (MTP)" mechanism (MTP-MC) for PEA module description, and are simulated using a projectable PEA simulation (PEA-SM); - for corresponding virtual triggered faults (FHL) regarding potential, stored, or retrieveable fault cases (FHLF) of the production facility (PRAL), for each fault case, the corresponding fault is virtually triggered by a corresponding PEA module activation (PEA-MA) in the PEA simulation (PEA-SM); - in each case, the simulation case belonging to the virtual triggered fault is the PEA A simulation is performed by a simulation (PEA-SM), wherein at least one simulation fault (SMF) is determined in each case during the process, and the simulation fault (SMF) is detected by a programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST), and accordingly, the programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) executes all simulation fault-based switching operations according to its programming, and the method comprises: a) generating at least one alarm signal (AM) for alarm chain tracing for each simulation fault (SMF) detected by the PEA controller (PEA-ST), b) detecting the alarm signals (AM) generated for all fault cases (FHLF) by alarm chain tracing (AKVK), andA method for managing alarms in modular production facilities, comprising: a step of generating an alarm signal log (AMP) to log the alarm signals (AM); c) a step of analyzing the alarm signal log (AMP) by an alarm chain analysis (AKAK) and identifying alarm chains (AKE) based on the analysis, or identifying alarm chains (AKE) and determining alarm correlations (AZH) within the alarm chains (AKE); and d) a step of transmitting the analysis results (AEG) during the identification of the alarm chains (AKE) and / or the determination results (EEG) during the determination of the alarm correlations (AZH) within the alarm chains (AKE) to the module type package (MTP) mechanism (MTP-MC) to include in the PEA module description. Claim 2 A method for managing alarms in modular production facilities according to claim 1, wherein alarm log analysis including virtual fault triggering, alarm signal detection and logging, and alarm chain identification or alarm chain identification and alarm correlation determination is performed in a computer-implemented manner. Claim 3 A method for managing alarms in modular production facilities, wherein, in claim 1 or 2, alarm log analysis including virtual fault triggering, alarm signal detection and logging, and alarm chain identification or alarm chain identification and alarm correlation determination is performed by a production facility test system (PRAL-TS). Claim 4 A method for managing alarms in modular production facilities, wherein, in claim 1 or 2, the production facility (PRAL) is an industrial automation facility. Claim 5 In claim 1, the process orchestration (PO) is a method for managing alarms in modular production facilities, standardized according to standard VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658. Claim 6 A system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities, comprising: - "Process Equipment Assembly (PEA)" modules (PEA-MD) for the modular manufacturer-independent design and operation of the production facility (PRAL); - a programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) executable on a "Programmable Logic Controller (SPS)" platform (SPS-PF) — said PEA modules (PEA-MD) are controlled by said programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST); - a projectable PEA simulation (PEA-SM) executable on a simulation platform (SPF) — said PEA modules (PEA-MD) are simulated using said projectable PEA simulation (PEA-SM); and - a "Module Type Package (MTP)" mechanism (MTP-MC) for integrating said PEA modules (PEA-MD) into said production facility (PRAL) in a standardized process orchestration (PO) process for PEA module description, wherein said PEA In the simulation (PEA-SM), for corresponding faults (FHL) in relation to potential, stored, or retrievable fault cases (FHLF) of the production facility (PRAL), for each fault case, the corresponding fault is virtually triggered by the corresponding PEA module activation (PEA-MA); the PEA simulation (PEA-SM) simulates the simulation case belonging to the virtually triggered fault in each case, and in the process determines at least one simulation fault (SMF) in each case; the programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) detects the simulation fault (SMF) and, accordingly, executes all simulation fault-based switching operations according to its programming; a) the programmable PEA controller (PEA-ST) generates at least one alarm signal (AM) for alarm chain tracing for each detected simulation fault (SMF); b) the alarm chain tracing component (AKVK)A system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities, wherein alarm signals (AM) generated for all fault cases (FHLF) are detected, logged in an alarm signal log (AMP), and said alarm signal log (AMP) is transmitted to an alarm chain analysis component (AKAK); c) said alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) analyzes said alarm signal log (AMP) and, based on said analysis, identifies alarm chains (AKE), or identifies alarm chains (AKE) and determines alarm correlations (AZH) within said alarm chains (AKE); and d) said alarm chain analysis component (AKAK) transmits the analysis results (AEG) during the identification of said alarm chains (AKE) and / or the results of the determination (EEG) during the determination of the alarm correlations (AZH) within said alarm chains (AKE) to a "module type package (MTP)" mechanism (MTP-MC) to include in said PEA module description. Claim 7 In claim 6, a system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities comprises a non-volatile, readable memory (SP) in which processor-readable control program instructions of a program module (PGM) are stored, and a computer-implemented tool (CIW) having a processor (PZ) connected to said memory (SP) to execute the control program instructions of said program module (PGM), wherein in the alarm management process, said program module (PGM) comprises said alarm chain tracking component (AKVK) and said alarm chain analysis component (AKAK). Claim 8 A system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities, comprising, in claim 6 or 7, a production facility test system (PRAL-TS) including the alarm chain tracking component (AKVK) and the alarm chain analysis component (AKAK). Claim 9 In claim 6 or 7, the production facility (PRAL) is a system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities, which are industrial automation facilities. Claim 10 In claim 6, for each defect case, the alarm chain tracking component (AKVK) virtually triggers the corresponding defect by the corresponding PEA module activation (PEA-MA), a system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities. Claim 11 In claim 6, the process orchestration (PO) is a system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities, standardized according to standard VDI / VDE / NAMUR 2658. Claim 12 In claim 7, the computer implementation tool (CIW) is a computer program product (CPP) and is a system (SYS) for managing alarms in modular production facilities.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Automation Programming in a 3D Graphics Editor Using Tight Coupling Logic and Physical Simulation
JP2018501532A
