Method of quantitative determination of boron in a solid material

Low-field NMR spectroscopy enables rapid and precise boron quantification in solid materials, overcoming the limitations of traditional methods by eliminating wet chemistry and high-cost equipment, facilitating on-site quality control.

WO2026233522A1PCT designated stage Publication Date: 2026-11-12NANONORD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/DK2026/060060
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2025-05-07
Filing Date
2026-05-07
Publication Date
2026-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current methods for determining boron content in solid materials are time-consuming, laborious, and prone to inaccuracies due to sample preparation, especially when dealing with volatile boron compounds, and require expensive high-field NMR spectrometers.

Method used

A method using time-domain low-field NMR spectroscopy to directly quantify boron in solid materials without wet chemistry pre-processing, utilizing a compact and cost-effective low-field NMR spectrometer, which includes acquiring a solid sample, applying it to an NMR tube, and performing NMR readings with RF pulse sequences to determine boron content.

Benefits of technology

The method provides fast, accurate, and reliable quantification of boron content, suitable for on-site quality control, eliminating the need for expensive equipment and complex sample preparation, with measurement times typically under 5 minutes.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure DK2026060060_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure DK2026060060_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for quantitative determination of boron in a solid material is discloses. The method comprises acquire a solid sample of the solid material; applying the solid sample into an NMR tube; applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer; performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data; correlating the NMR intensity data to calibration data, and determine the content of boron in the solid material.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] 86303PC01

[0002] 1

[0003] METHOD OF QUANTITATIVE DETERMINATION OF BORON IN A SOLID MATERIAL

[0004] TECHNICAL FIELD

[0005] The invention relates to a method for quantitative determination of boron in a solid material

[0006] BACKGROUND ART

[0007] Boron is a versatile element used in a wide range of industries due to its unique chemical, physical, and nuclear properties. Boron has been extensively used in various glass materials and ceramic materials as a means to significantly influence the properties of the material and its processing. Boron is often used in production of implants due to its high biocompatibility. Furthermore, the use of boron in semiconductor compounds such as boron nitride has shown to be very valuable and also the use of boron within nanotechnology paradigm has shown to be very valuable. For example, boron nanotubes can provide significant weight and cost reduction in aerospace and automotive industries due to their low density as well as high mechanical strength and chemical stability.

[0008] Generally, the content of boron in the various products is highly important for physical and / or chemical properties of the products. In glass production and related industrial applications, it is very important to know the content of boron. Boron significantly influences the properties of the material and its performance in different applications. This includes mechanical, thermal stability / expansion, and chemical durability of the material, which is highly important for the production optimization of and use of glass materials in different applications. The boron content is important for manufacturing processes due to alteration of melting temperature and viscosity being important for molding, fiber formation etc., which may have large impact on efficiency, energy consumption, and economy. In medical applications, such as implants, the content of boron influences bioactivity, stability, and degradation.

[0009] Knowledge to the boron content is also important for regulatory compliance. This includes health risk and environmental safety, including handing of waste material.

[0010] Thus, there is a need for an effective method of determining the boron content of a material.86303PC01

[0011] 2

[0012] The boron content of glass and glass-based materials is currently measured with different methods, which all have their features in terms of complexity of measurements, and accuracy. These methods include wet chemistry methods, ICP (Inductively Coupled Plasma) methods or laser ablation inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-MS), Laser Induced Breakdown Spectroscopy (LIBS), electron probe microanalysis (EPMA), X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopy, flame emission spectroscopy, and neutron activation analysis (NAA) depending on the concentration of boron and the need for accuracy. LA-ICP-MS is often chosen for compositional analysis through high sensitivity and accuracy (although we note that sample preparation may challenge this, as elaborated on later). It is noted that as a light element, boron detection may cause issues for many analytical techniques such as scanning electron microscopy (SEM).

[0013] A challenge with the above-mentioned techniques is the administration of the sample to the measurement in terms physical / chemical state - typically requiring dissolution of the glass or glass material in very strong acids. This may be time consuming, laborious, and involve adherence to safety procedures. Also such sample preparation may impact the accuracy of measurement, e.g., in presence of volatile boron compounds, incomplete dissolution, precipitation etc.

[0014] It has been demonstrated in literature* that NMR spectroscopy may be used to obtain information about the coordination state of boron in glasses through measurement of 11B (or less favorably 10) on glass samples in the solid-state. As both NMR active isotopes are so-called quadrupolar nuclei measurement of details of the observed NMR line shapes in the frequency domain (Fourier transform, high-resolution) spectroscopy may be provide information about the coordination and dynamics of boron in the glasses. As the focus is these studies has structure and dynamics information that can be extracted from details in 11B or 10B line shapes and resolution of resonances from different sites (boron coordination) these studies advantageously are - and has mainly been - performed at high field, as the chemical shift separation scales linearly with the field and as the second-order line broadening of the resonance scales inversely proportional to the field.

[0015] Furthermore, earlier studies used magic-angle spinning (i.e. , rotating the sample around an axis being 54.7 away from the field direction) which also improves spectral resolution although obviously requiring specialized probes allowing for this. The focus has not been to quantitatively access the amount of boron.86303PC01

[0016] 3

[0017] For example, the article “Effect of Temperature and Thermal History on Borosilicate Glass Structure”

[0018] By Frederic Angeli et al. Physical Review B ■ February 2012, describes an analysis of borosilicate glass structure, using NMR technology to analysis qualitative change in boron coordination with temperature was examined. The examination comprised acquisition of boron spectra at two high field magnetic fields of respectively 11.7 and 17.6 T using Magic-Angle Spinning (MAS)11B NMR and Multiple-Quantum Magic- Angle Spinning (QMAS)11B NMR.

[0019] DISCLOSURE OF THE INVENTION

[0020] An objective of the present invention is to provide a new method of performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material.

[0021] In an embodiment, an objective of the present invention is to provide a system for performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, which method is very fast.

[0022] In an embodiment, an objective of the present invention is to provide a method of performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, which method is very cost-effective.

[0023] In an embodiment, an objective of the present invention is to provide a method of performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, which method provide a very accurate determination of the boron content.

[0024] In an embodiment, an objective of the present invention is to provide a method of performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, which method does not require wet chemistry pre-processing of the sample, e.g., using strong acids and therefore also increases the accuracy of the determination, since it prevents volatile boron components disappearing prior to or during measurement.

[0025] In an embodiment, an objective of the present invention is to provide a method of performing a quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, which method may be86303PC01

[0026] 4

[0027] performed on-site, i.e. it does not require large and very expensive spectrometer, but may for example be performed on-site in a production site, e.g. for quality control purposes.

[0028] These and other objects have been solved by the invention or embodiments thereof as defined in the claims and as described herein below.

[0029] It has been found that the invention or embodiments thereof have a number of additional advantages, which will be clear to the skilled person from the following description.

[0030] The inventors of the present invention have found that the content of boron in a solid material may in fact be determined by the use of time-domain low-field NMR spectroscopy. In addition, it was found that the content of boron in solid materials, such glass materials, ceramics, and composite may be determined quantitatively using timedomain low-field NMR with a desired high accuracy. The method of the invention is quantitatively highly reliable as it through the measured intensity of11B or10B isotope signals measures essentially all or even all boron in the solid sample.

[0031] It has been found that the method is relatively simple to perform for an operator and may be performed on-site, e.g. in a factory for quality control of intermediate or final products. Despite of the use of the low-field NMR, which as explained further below, may have a relatively low signal-to-noise (SNR), it was found that highly reliable determinations may be obtained surprisingly fast.

[0032] The method for quantitative determination of boron in a solid material comprises

[0033] • acquire a solid sample of the solid material;

[0034] • applying the solid sample into an NMR tube;

[0035] • applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;

[0036] • performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data,

[0037] • correlating the NMR intensity data to calibration data, and

[0038] • determine the content of boron in the solid material.86303PC01

[0039] 5

[0040] The method and systems of the invention and preferred embodiments thereof will be described further below.

[0041] It should be emphasized that the term “comprises / comprising” when used herein is to be interpreted as an open term, i.e. it should be taken to specify the presence of specifically stated feature(s), such as element(s), unit(s), integer(s), step(s) component(s) and combination(s) thereof, but does not preclude the presence or addition of one or more other stated features. Reference made to “one embodiment” or “an embodiment” means that a particular feature, structure, or characteristic described in connection with an embodiment is included in at least one embodiment of the subject matter disclosed. Thus, the appearance of the phrases “in one embodiment” or “in an embodiment” in various places throughout the specification is not necessarily referring to the same embodiment. Further, the skilled person will understand that particular features, structures, or characteristics may be combined in any suitable manner within the scope of the invention as defined by the claims.

[0042] The term "substantially" should herein be taken to mean that ordinary product variances and tolerances are comprised.

[0043] Throughout the description or claims, the singular encompasses the plural, and the plural encompasses the singular unless otherwise specified or required by the context.

[0044] The “an embodiment” should be interpreted to include examples of the invention comprising the feature(s) of the mentioned embodiment.

[0045] Unless other is specified, any properties, ranges of properties and / or determination and / or assay condition is given or provided at 1 atmosphere and 37 °C.

[0046] All features of the invention and embodiments of the invention as described herein including ranges and preferred ranges may be combined in various ways within the scope of the invention, unless there are specific reasons not to combine such features.

[0047] The term “solid material” is herein used to denote materials that retain their shape and volume under normal conditions (at 1 atmosphere and 37 °C and in unloaded condition).86303PC01

[0048] 6

[0049] The solid material may bend depending of its shape, e.g. when shaped as a thin plate or an optical fiber.

[0050] The solid sample may be any kind of solid sample suspected for containing boron e.g. as further described below.

[0051] Advantageously, the low field NMR spectrometer is adapted for operating at a low magnetic field. Thereby the NMR spectrometer may be a very compact NMR spectrometer which are generally much less costly than a high field NMR spectrometer, which are usually applied for laboratory use and often may usually cost more than $500,000.

[0052] In an embodiment, the low field NMR spectrometer has a magnetic field up to 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT.

[0053] The low field NMR spectrometer may e.g. be movable e.g. by being carried directly or on a wheeled wagon e.g. for being operated on-site e.g. in a factory.

[0054] The NMR reading of the solid sample may preferably be performed in the magnetic field B field, wherein the magnetic field B does not exceed 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT.

[0055] Using a low field NMR spectrometer results in a significant loss in signal-to-noise (SNR) compared to using a higher field NMR spectrometer. For example, performing a NMR recording in a magnetic field of 1 T will result in a SNR lower than when performing a corresponding recording in a magnetic field of 2.5 T. I.e. going from a 2.5 T NMR spectrometer to a 1 T NMR spectrometer results in a SNR reduction of 75-85 %.

[0056] Going from a 2 T NMR spectrometer to a 1 T NMR spectrometer results in a SNR reduction of 65-75 %.

[0057] 1.6 T NMR spectrometer to a 1 T NMR spectrometer results in a SNR reduction of 50-60 %.86303PC01

[0058] 7

[0059] To determine the content of boron by a quantity unit of the solid sample, it is desired to know the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample. Therefore, in an embodiment, the method comprises determining the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample.

[0060] The weight of the solid sample may be determined by any method, such as measure its volume and multiply by known density and / or determine the weight of the sample by using a weighing system.

[0061] The volume of the solid sample may e.g. be determined using 3D imaging, using laser scanning and / or by calculation, e,g. by mathematically determining the volume based on the geometrical shape of the solid sample.

[0062] The skilled person will know that there are many valid ways of determine the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample.

[0063] In an embodiment, the determination of the weight of the solid sample comprises weighing the sample.

[0064] The determination of the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample may in principle be performed any time. For example, the determination of the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample may be performed prior to applying the sample in the NMR tube, after applying the sample in the NMR tube and / or after performing the NMR reading in or withdrawn from the NMR tube. If the weighing of the sample is performed in the NMR tube the weight of the NMR tube is withdrawn from the total weight of the sample and the NMR tube.

[0065] In an embodiment, the method comprises determine the content of boron in the solid material in the form of at least one of weight of boron per weight unit of solid material (w / / w), volume of boron per volume unit of solid material (vol / vol), molar content of boron per weight unit of solid sample, molar content of boron per volume unit of solid sample, weight % of boron and / or molar % of boron.

[0066] Advantageously, the determination of the content of boron in the solid material in the form of at least one of quantity unis applied in the calibration data.86303PC01

[0067] 8

[0068] Generally, the volume and space in an NMR tube is relatively narrow, such as 10 mm in outer diameter or less and often 8 mm in inner diameter or even less, such as 3 mm in inner diameter. Therefore, the solid sample may not fit into the NMR tube.

[0069] In an embodiment, the method comprises dividing the solid sample into smaller pieces to fit the solid sample into the NMR tube. The solid sample may be divided into smaller pieces by any method, such as any mechanical method. In an embodiment, the solid sample is divided into smaller pieces by cutting and / or grinding of the solid sample. Other suitable methods include graining, crushing, shattering, pulverize or in other way break into pieces. Advantageously, the step of dividing the solid sample into smaller pieces may be performed during the acquisition of the solid sample from the solid material and / or after the acquisition of the solid sample from the solid material.

[0070] Advantageously, the method is performed without any preparation of the solid sample except optionally dividing the solid sample into smaller pieces as described above.

[0071] Many NMR tubes comprise boron, such as NMR tubes of borosilicate glass. Where such NMR tubes with a boron is used, the method may comprise performing an NMR reading of the NMR tube in empty condition and determine intensity data of the NMR tube and subtracting the intensity data of the NMR tube of the intensity data of the solid sample in the NMR tube.

[0072] However, to avoid “noise” caused by using an NMR tube with substantial amounts of boron, it is preferential to select and use an NMR tube with no boron or with only traces of boron, such as an NMR tube comprising less than 5 ppm by weight, such as less than 1 ppm by weight, such as less than 0.1 ppm by weight.

[0073] The NMR tube may conveniently be of a material selected from Teflon, quartz or combinations thereof.

[0074] Nuclear magnetic resonance - abbreviated NMR - is a phenomenon, which occurs when the nuclei of an isotope with a nuclear spin in a magnetic field absorb and re-emit electromagnetic radiation. The emitted electromagnetic radiation has a specific resonance frequency, which depends on the strength of the magnetic field and the magnetic properties of the isotope. NMR allows the observation of specific quantum mechanical86303PC01

[0075] 9

[0076] magnetic properties of the atomic nucleus. Many scientific techniques exploit NMR phenomena to study molecular physics, liquids, crystals, and non-crystalline materials through NMR spectroscopy. NMR is also routinely used in advanced medical imaging techniques, such as in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).

[0077] An NMR measurement may be performed by NMR spectrometer or NMR relaxometer, here also referred to as an NMR spectroscope.

[0078] The terms "spectroscopy" and "spectrometry" are used interchangeable and in the same way a spectroscope is the same as a spectrometer.

[0079] NMR spectroscopy is well known in the art and has for many years been applied for laboratory measurements in particular where other measurement methods could not be used. NMR spectroscopy is performed using an NMR spectrometer. Examples of spectrometers are e.g. described in US 6,310,480 and in US 5,023,551. The term NMR spectrometer also includes an NMR relaxometer.

[0080] General background of NMR formation evaluation can be found, for example in U.S 5,023,551.

[0081] A general background description of NMR measurement can be found in "Understanding NMR Spectroscopy" by James Keeler, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 2005 or in a practically oriented setting in, e.g., "NMR Logging Principles and Applications" by George R. Coates et al, Halliburton Energy Services, 1999. See in particular chapter 4.

[0082] In an embodiment, the at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises at least one NMR signal of the isotope 11 B and / or the isotope 10B, preferably the isotope 11 B.

[0083] The 11B or 10B low-field NMR spectroscopy may be applied directly on the solid sample, such as one or more glass samples in the NMR tube.

[0084] In particular, according to the invention 11 B or 10B time domain, low-field NMR analysis may be performed directly on the solid sample without dissolution. This reduces the risks of inaccuracies involved in wet chemistry sample preparation as described above.86303PC01

[0085] 10

[0086] The method is very fast, typical measurement times will be in the order of 5 minutes and in most cases 1 min or even faster depending on the boron concentration.

[0087] The NMR reading and intensity determination is advantageously performed using time domain low field spectroscopy.

[0088] The NMR reading is advantageously performed using static NMR reading.

[0089] Whereas, Magic-Angle Spinning (MAS) NMR and Multiple-Quantum Magic - Angle Spinning (QMAS) NMR may be applied, this is generally not preferred, since this requires a more expensive NMR instrumentation and usually also takes longer time to perform the NMR reading(s), in particular when taking into account time needed to pack the samples sufficiently homogeneous to allow for spinning and time needed to spin up and down prior to and after the NMR recording.

[0090] Generally, it is preferred to use11B time domain, low-field NMR spectroscopy. The11B (spin I = 3 / 2) isotope is the preferred boron isotope to measure relative to the10B (spin l=3) isotope, because the11B isotope has higher abundance (80.1% for11B) relative to the abundance of the10B isotope (19.9 for10B).

[0091] In addition, it has been found that the11B isotope has into an NMR tube sensitivity relative to the NMR sensitivity of1H that is 0.178, whereas the10B isotope has into an NMR tube sensitivity relative to the NMR sensitivity of1H that is much lower, namely about 0.0003.

[0092] The quadrupole moment of11B is about half of that of10B, implying that11B gives easier interpretable signals.

[0093] Conveniently, the at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises an average of a plurality of NMR signals of the isotope11B and / or the isotope10B, preferably the isotope11B.

[0094] Advantageously, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data.86303PC01

[0095] 11

[0096] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses wherein the RF pulses comprise at least one exciting RF pulse and at least one refocusing RF pulse.

[0097] The exciting RF pulse and the refocusing pulse or pulses may for example be in the form of a train of RF pulses. The exciting RF pulse is preferably as described above and may in an embodiment be pulsed.

[0098] Useful duration and amplitude of the exciting RF pulses are well known in the art and optimization can be done systematically or by a simple trial and error.

[0099] In an embodiment the exciting RF pulse is in the form of a 90° pulse.

[0100] A 90° pulse is an RF pulse designed to rotate the net magnetization vector 90° from its initial direction in the rotating frame of reference. If the spins are initially aligned with the static magnetic field, this pulse produces transverse magnetization and free induction decay (FID).

[0101] In an embodiment the refocusing RF pulse(s) is in the form of a 180° pulse, preferably the method comprises subjecting the sample to a plurality of refocusing RF pulses, such as one or more trains of refocusing RF pulses.

[0102] It has been found to be highly advantageous to use at least one echo sequence. In prior art application it has been believed that using echo sequences would tend to make accurate quantitative determination practically impossible due to distorted lineshapes. Surprisingly it was found that using at least one echo sequence in the method of an embodiment of the present invention may result in a highly accurate quantitative determination.

[0103] A 90° pulse is an RF pulse designed to rotate the net magnetization vector 180° in the rotating frame of reference. Ideally, the amplitude of a 180° pulse multiplied by its duration is twice the amplitude of a 90° pulse multiplied by its duration. Each 180° pulse in the sequence (called a CPMG sequence after Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill) creates an echo.

[0104] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses comprising a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill sequence.86303PC01

[0105] 12

[0106] In an embodiment the refocusing RF pulse(s) is / are applied with an echo-delay time after the exciting RF pulse. The echo-delay time (also called wait time TW) is preferably of about 500 ps or less, more preferably about 150 ps or less, such as in the range from about 50 ps to about 100 ps.

[0107] This method is generally called the “spin echo” method and was first described by Erwin Hahn in 1950. Further information can be found in Hahn, E.L. (1950). "Spin echoes". Physical Review 80: 580-594, which is hereby incorporated by reference.

[0108] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses comprising one or more of the sequences an inversionrecovery pulse sequence, a CPMG sequence and / or a spin-echo sequence or any combinations comprising at least one of these.

[0109] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to a sequence of RF pulses and delays comprising a sub sequence S1

[0110] i. applying a 180° RF pulse

[0111] ii. applying an inversion recovery delay (I RD)

[0112] iii. applying a 90° RF pulse and

[0113] iv. determine a resonance intensity, directly or throughout an echo sequence, such as CPMG,

[0114] preferably the method comprises repeating the S1 subsequence.

[0115] In an embodiment, the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to a sequence of RF pulses and delays comprising a sub sequence S2 i. applying a 90° RF

[0116] ii. applying an echo delay

[0117] iii. applying a 180° RF pulse

[0118] iv. repeating steps ii and iii

[0119] v. applying a recycle delay,

[0120] preferably, the method comprises repeating the S2 subsequence optionally applying different recycle delays.86303PC01

[0121] 13

[0122] For example, the NMR reading may comprise subjecting the solid sample to a repeated sequence of RF exiting signals comprising:

[0123] >n> |NV > / 2 > ^E / 2 >71> ?E >n> ?w > invert IRD excite 1stED 1strefocus ED refocus wait RD repeat x (N-l)

[0124] wherein and / 2 designates radio-frequency pulses with pulse duration and radiofrequency pulse field strengths adjust to provide pulse flip angles of (such as 180°) and / 2 (such as 90°), respectively, Tmv is the inversion recovery delay (IRD), TE is the echo delay (ED), Tn / the recycle delay (RD), and N the number of echoes.

[0125] Additional pulse sequences and / or enhancements may be applied. In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to at least one of WURST-QCPMG, WASP-CPMG (or other combinations of CPMG with adiabatic pulses, hypersecant or similar pulses, sensitivity enhancement utilizing other single- or multiple-quantum transitions), BRAIN-CP, PRESTO, RINEPT, TEDOR, REDOR, RESPDOR, TRAPDOR, or REAPDOR (or other techniques exploiting coherence transfer from other nuclei), RAS NMR (or similar methods using relaxation parameters to resolve overlapping resonances), overtone spectroscopy (e.g., for 10B), dipolar DQ-SQ (double quantum - single quantum) correlation, HMQC or D-HMOC (heteronuclear multiple-quantum correlation), HETCOR, MQ-HETCOR, MQ-SPAM, and magic-angle spinning or turning experiments such as MQMAS.STMAS, DOR, RESPDOR, MAT, or MATPASS.

[0126] The boron atom may be bound in compounds where it is directly bound with 3 other atoms. Such a boron atom is called a 3 - coordinated boron component. Typically a 3 -coordinated boron component has six electrons around it, which means that it is electrondeficient and is reactive.

[0127] The boron atom may be bound in compounds where it is directly bound with 4 other atoms. Such a boron atom is called a 4 - coordinated boron component, Typically a 4 -coordinated boron component has a complete octet (eight electrons around it), which means that it is electron-rich, and is more stable than the 3 - coordinated boron component.86303PC01

[0128] 14

[0129] Typical 3-coordinated boron has a large quadrupolar coupling, implying that boron isotope signals, preferably11B signals, should be recorded using very low flip angles, such as TT / 8 or less. Also recording of boron isotopes that are 4-corrdinated boron, which have a relative small quadrupolar coupling are usually recorded with a very low flip angle, when the sample consists of both 3- and 4-coordinated boron.

[0130] In an embodiment of the invention, it was surprisingly found that higher flip angles may be applied successfully for the excitation and quantification of boron isotopes.

[0131] Thus, in a preferred embodiment11B signals may be recorded using full flip angles (for large quadrupolar couplings preferably scaling by 1 / (1+ 1 / 2) with the spin quantum number I being 3 / 2 for11B). For the recording of signals from 4-corrdinated boron which may have very small quadrupolar couplings, standard flip angles applied in fluid state NMR may be used. It has been found that a combination of experiments may be applied to capture both the 3-coordinated boron component and the 4-coordinated boron component. Also, it has been found that a flip angle between the solid- and fluid-state optimum may be applied.

[0132] Using a higher flip angle (up to pulse optimum, e.g. 90 degrees for the excitation pulse) generally results in a higher sensitivity and thereby a more accurate result compared to using a lower flip angle.

[0133] In addition, it has been found that relaxation NMR data may be used to differentiate between differently coordinated boron components (e.g., 3- and 4 coordinated).

[0134] Thus, in an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence comprising a plurality of pulses 90°(x) — [T — 180°(y) — T — echo]nto determine the intensity of 4-coordinated boron and subjecting the solid sample to one or more modified Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequences comprising a plurality of pulses, where 90°(x) — [T — 90°(y) — T — echo]nto determine the intensity of 3-coordinated boron, wherein T is the spacing.

[0135] “n” may be any integer of 2 and more, such as an integer from 2 to 1000 or more

[0136] Optionally adding the intensity of 4-coordinate angled boron and the intensity of 3-coordinated boron to obtain the total boron NMR intensity signal.86303PC01

[0137] 15

[0138] In some embodiments, depending on the composition of the solid sample the NMR reading comprising the CPMG sequence comprising a plurality of pulses 90°(x) — [T — 180°(y) — T — echo]n, may include a minor amount of intensity originating from the 3-coordinated boron in addition to the intensity originating from the 4-coordinated boron. In such cases, it may be useful for record more than two different CPMG experiment with different pulse angle adjustments.

[0139] In addition, the NMR reading comprising the CPMG sequence comprising a plurality of pulses 90°(x) — [T — 90°(y) — T — echo]n, may include a minor amount of intensity originating from the 4-coordinated boron in addition to the intensity originating from the 3-coordinated boron.

[0140] In most situation the error introduced by a slight overlap of intensities included twice are in most situations negligible.

[0141] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises determining and recording at least one relaxation time selected from a spin-lattice (or longitudinal) relaxation time Ti and a spinspin (or transverse) relaxation time T2..

[0142] The at least one relaxation time may conveniently be applied to distinguish between intensity of 3-coordinated boron and intensity of the 4-coordinated boron.

[0143] In an embodiment, the quantitative determination of boron in the solid material is based on either the11B isotope or on the10B isotope and the performing of the NMR reading comprises performing time-domain low-field NMR determination of the content of boron in the solid sample comprising a total NMR intensity of11B or10B, comprising applying a CPMG pulse train e.g. as described above. Determining and recording a first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope which mainly or exclusively comprises the NMR intensity of the 4-coordinate boron11B or10B isotope.

[0144] Applying one or more modified CPMG pulse trains using halved flip angles of the refocusing pulse and determining and recording a second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope which mainly or exclusively comprising the NMR intensity of the 3-coordinate boron11B or10B isotope, and summarizing the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope.86303PC01

[0145] 16

[0146] In an embodiment, the NMR reading comprises determination of an adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B comprising determining at least one of Ti and T2 based on the CPMG pulse train, determining a first redundant intensity portion originating from the 3-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the first redundant intensity portion from the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope,

[0147] determining a first adjusted NMR intensity and determining at least one of T1 and T2 based on the one or more modified CPMG pulse trains, determining a second redundant intensity portion originating from the 4-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the second redundant intensity portion from the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and

[0148] determining a second adjusted NMR intensity and summarizing the first adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope

[0149] The solid material may advantageously be a solid material comprising boron atoms. In some embodiments, it may be desired to measure on a zero boron content solid sample to determine possibly noise.

[0150] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of inorganic material

[0151] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of semiconductor material, such as semiconductor material comprising boron, such as Boron-doped semiconductor material.

[0152] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of ceramic materials, such as ceramic materials comprising boron, such as Boron carbide (B4C) and / or Boron nitride (BN).

[0153] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of mineral material, such as boron containing mineral material, such as mineral wool

[0154] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of glass material, such as fiberglass, glass fiber composites, glass wool and glass-ceramic materials, glass containing implants, glazes and enamels, preferably the glass is boron containing glass,86303PC01

[0155] 17

[0156] such as borosilicate glass, aluminosilicate glass, glass ceramic, bioactive glass, optical glass and / or phosphate glass.

[0157] The glass fiber composites may for example comprise glass fibers, such as bundles of glass fibers, such as stranded, braided or twisted glass fibers embedded in thermoset or thermoplastic polymer, such as epoxy polyurethane, polyethylene etc.

[0158] Boron is incorporated into certain biomedical implants, especially in the form of boron-containing glasses and ceramics, due to its bioactivity, biocompatibility, and ability to stimulate bone regeneration.

[0159] Boron is mainly used in bioactive glass and ceramic implants, where it enhances bone regeneration, vascular growth, and biocompatibility. These materials are used in orthopedic, dental, and bone tissue engineering applications.

[0160] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of non-paramagnetic metal alloys, such as alloyed metals comprising boron e.g. ferroboron alloys and / or Boron austenitic steel.

[0161] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of construction materials, such as roofing materials, wallboard, fiberglass insulation and cellulose insulation and construction materials treated with boron containing material, such as wood, plastic, bricks, pipes and wires. Boron helps to protect from mold, fungus and insects and is therefore often used as coatings of construction materials.

[0162] In an embodiment, the solid material comprises or consists of materials containing organoboron and / or solid medicines containing boron, such as boron-containing drugs like bortezomib and ixazomib

[0163] The method may in an embodiment, comprise generating the calibration data.

[0164] The method of generating the calibration data comprises acquiring at least one and preferably a plurality of reference samples, wherein the reference samples comprises different and known content of boron, and for each reference sample

[0165] • applying the reference sample into an NMR tube;86303PC01

[0166] 18

[0167] • applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;

[0168] • performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data, and associating the determined NMR intensity data to the known boron content of the each reference sample to generate a reference data set comprising the known boron content and the determined NMR intensity data , and

[0169] wherein the method comprises collecting the respective sets of reference data sets to generate the calibration data.

[0170] The invention also comprises a method of generating calibration data for use in quantitative determination of boron in a solid material e.g. as described elsewhere herein.

[0171] The method of generating the calibration data comprises acquiring at least one and preferably a plurality of reference samples, wherein the reference samples comprises different and known content of boron, and for each reference sample

[0172] • applying the reference sample into an NMR tube;

[0173] • applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;

[0174] • performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data, and associating the determined NMR intensity data to the known boron content of said each reference sample to generate a reference data set comprising the known boron content and the determined NMR intensity data , and

[0175] wherein the method comprises collecting the respective sets of reference data sets to generate the calibration data.

[0176] In an embodiment, the at least one reference sample comprises a solid reference sample.86303PC01

[0177] 19

[0178] In an embodiment, the at least one reference sample comprises a fluid reference sample, such as one or more reference samples comprising one or more boron compounds in solution.

[0179] The reference samples may conveniently be sample of any of the solid materials described above.

[0180] Preferably, the reference samples comprises glass, ceramic and / or composite material as described above.

[0181] The number of reference samples may be any number. Considering that a zero boron materials provides zero NMR intensity the number of reference materials may in an embodiment be one boron containing reference material. Thereby the calibration data may be generated in the form of a linear calibration curve comprising intensity (Y-axis) as a function of NMR intensity, wherein the linear calibration curve passes through the x,y coordinate of the data set comprising the known boron content of the single reference sample and the NMR intensity of the single reference sample and the coordinate (0,0).

[0182] Advantageously, the at least one of reference samples comprises at least two reference samples, such as at least 5 reference samples, such as from 2 to hundred reference samples or even more. In general a few reference samples are sufficient to obtain a highly accurate boron content determination of a solid material.

[0183] The low field NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading each of the at least one reference sample may be as described above. Preferably the field NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading of the reference samples is identical to or is the NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.

[0184] The NMR reading is performed in the magnetic field B as described above. Preferably the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample are performed in a magnetic field B identical to the magnetic field used for NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.86303PC01

[0185] 20

[0186] In an embodiment, the weight and / or the volume of each of the at least one reference sample is known or the method comprises determine the weight and / or the volume of each of the at least one reference sample, e.g. using the methods as described above.

[0187] In an embodiment, the known content of boron in each of the at least one reference sample are known in the form of at least one of weight of boron per weight unit of reference sample (w / / w), volume of boron per volume unit of reference sample (vol / vol), molar content of boron per weight unit of reference sample, molar content of boron per volume unit of reference sample, weight % of boron of the reference sample and / or molar % of boron of the reference sample.

[0188] The determination of boron content in the solid material may conveniently comprise a determination in the same quantity unit as the quantity unit of the known boron content of each of the at least one reference sample. If another quantity unit is desired, the value obtained in the same quantity unit as the quantity unit of the known boron content may be converted to another quantity unit.

[0189] In an embodiment, the at least one NMR signal of the reading of each of the at least one reference sample of the at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises at least one NMR signal, such as an average of a plurality of NMR signals of the isotope11B and / or the isotope10B, preferably the isotope11B.

[0190] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data.

[0191] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses wherein the RF pulses comprise at least one exciting RF pulse and at least one refocusing RF pulse.

[0192] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses comprising a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill sequence.86303PC01

[0193] 21

[0194] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the each of the at least one reference sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses comprising one or more of the sequences an inversionrecovery pulse sequence, a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence and / or a spinecho sequence or any combinations comprising at least one of these.

[0195] Preferably the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses, identical to one or more sequences of RF pulses applied in the NMR reading of the NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.

[0196] Advantageously, the NMR reading and the intensity determination of each of the at least one reference sample is performed using time domain low field spectroscopy.

[0197] Advantageously, the NMR reading and the intensity determination of each of the at least one reference sample is performed using static NMR reading.

[0198] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises determining and recording at least one relaxation time selected from a spinlattice (longitudinal) relaxation time Ti and a spin-spin (transverse) relaxation time T2..

[0199] In an embodiment, the performing of the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises performing time-domain low-field NMR determination of the content of boron in the solid sample comprising a total NMR intensity of11B or10B (depending on which of the11B or10B isotope is applied in the quantitative determination of boron in the solid material), comprising applying a CPMG pulse train, determining and recording a first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope (mainly or exclusively comprising the NMR intensity of the 4-coordinate boron11B or10B isotope) and applying one or more modified CPMG pulse train using halved flip angles of the refocusing pulse and determining and recording a second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope (mainly or exclusively comprising the NMR intensity of the 3-coordinate boron11B isotope) and summarizing the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope.86303PC01

[0200] 22

[0201] In an embodiment, the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises determination an adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B comprising

[0202] • determining at least one of Ti and T2 based on the CPMG pulse train, determining a first redundant intensity portion originating from the 3-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the first redundant intensity portion from the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to determining a first adjusted NMR intensity and

[0203] • determining at least one of T1 and T2 based on the one or more modified CPMG pulse trains, determining a second redundant intensity portion originating from the 4-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the second redundant intensity portion from the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to determining a second adjusted NMR intensity and

[0204] • adding the first adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to obtain the adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B.

[0205] BRIEF DESCRIPTIONS OF EMBODIMENTS AND EXAMPLES

[0206] In the following, the invention will be further illustrated by the description of a number of illustrative and non-limiting embodiments and examples of the present invention, with reference to the appended drawings.

[0207] The figures are schematic and are not drawn to scale and may be simplified for clarity. Throughout, the same reference numerals are used for identical or corresponding parts.

[0208] Figures 1 show a calibration curve associated to the examples.

[0209] Figure 2a shows a process diagram for an example of generation of a calibration curve.

[0210] Figure 2b shows an example of an on-site boron content determination of an intermediate produced product, here a glass cob.

[0211] Figure 2c shows an example of an on-site boron content determination of a final product, here a final produced glass product.

[0212] Example 1 - Preparing of glass materials86303PC01

[0213] 23

[0214] Seven glass materials with different and unknown composition were obtained. The glass material were numbered 1-7, A portion of each of the seven glass materials were and sieved through a 500 pm sieve grinded to obtain a grinded material portion from each of the seven glass materials.

[0215] Example 2 - Generation of calibration data.

[0216] Two of the glass materials were randomly selected to be used for generation of the calibration data. The randomly selected glass materials were glass material 1 and glass material 5.

[0217] A first reference sample was acquired from of each of the grinded material portion of glass material 1 and glass material 5. Each of the grinded reference sample 1 and the grinded reference sample 5 was applied into an NMR tube of PTFE and applied in a low field NMR spectrometer. NMR readings were performed by subjecting the respective reference samples to a magnet field of about 1.5 T and to a train of CPMG pulse sequences and reading the intensity per volume reference sample.

[0218] The packing density of the grinded reference samples 1 and 5 were determined and by dividing the intensity per volume reference sample with the packing density, the NMR intensity of the respective reference samples by weight (g) were determined.

[0219] “packing density” means the density of the sample. Using a finely grinded glass sample, the packing density of the sample will be practically identical to the density of the original glass material.

[0220] A second reference sample was acquired from of each of the grinded material portion of glass material 1 and glass material 5 and sent to the laboratory for determining the boron content by standard laboratory techniques.

[0221] The result is shown in table 1

[0222] Table 186303PC01

[0223] 24

[0224] Sample Boron Intensity by Density Intensity Boron

[0225] No. Lab Laboratory vol. (Packing) by weight determined weight % g / cm3by NMR

[0226] weight %

[0227] 1 4 2123,45 1,33 1594.16 4.01

[0228]

[0229] 5 0.47 254.27 1.40 182.08 0.46

[0230] The calibration data comprises the data sets of the known boron content by weight % from the laboratory determination and the determined NMR density by weight.

[0231] Example 3 - Quantitative determination of boron in solid glass material

[0232] A first reference solid sample was acquired from of each of the grinded material portion of glass materials 2, 3, 4, 6 and 7. Each of the grinded solid samples was applied into an NMR tube of PTFE and applied in a low field NMR spectrometer. NMR readings were performed by subjecting the respective reference samples to a magnet field of about 1.5 T and to a train of CPMG pulse sequences and reading the intensity per volume solid sample.

[0233] The packing density of the grinded solid samples 2, 3, 4, 6 and 7 were determined and by dividing the intensity per volume solid sample with the packing density, the NMR intensity of the respective solid samples by weight (g) were determined.

[0234] The result is shown in table 2

[0235] Table 2

[0236] Sample Intensity by Density Intensity Boron

[0237] No. Lab vol. (Packing) by weight determined

[0238] g / cm3by NMR

[0239] weight %

[0240] 2 1810.95 1.44 1260.54 3.17

[0241] 3 1216.36 1.51 804.09 2.02

[0242] 4 560.33 1.37 407.68 1.02

[0243] 6 102.07 1.40 72.84 0.18

[0244] 7 1.88 1.26 1.49 0.00

[0245]

[0246] 86303PC01

[0247] 25

[0248] The NMR intensity by weight can now be correlated with the calibration data determined in example 2.

[0249] A second reference sample was acquired from of each of the grinded material portion of glass material 1 and glass material 5 and sent to the laboratory for determining the boron content by standard laboratory techniques.

[0250] Example 4 - Verification of determinations

[0251] To verify the determinations, a second solid sample was acquired from of each of the grinded material portion of glass material s 2, 3, 4, 6 and 7 and sent to the laboratory for determining the boron content by standard laboratory techniques.

[0252] In addition, a calibration curve was generated as shown in figure 1. As seen in figure 1 the coefficient of determination, R2, there is a statistically significant relationship within a 99% confidence interval. Thus, it is illustrated that the method of the invention can be used to determine a boron in a solid material.

[0253] In addition, the NMR intensity by weight for each of the reference samples were correlated to the calibration curve and is shown in figure 1. It can be seen, that the data are fully compliant.

[0254] All the determinations are shown in table 3.

[0255] Table 3

[0256] Sample Boron Intensity Density Intensity Boron

[0257] No. Laboratory by vol. (Packing) by weight determined

[0258] weight % g / cm3by NMR

[0259] weight %

[0260] 1 4 2123,45 1,33 1594.16 4.01 Reference 2 3.02 1810.95 1.44 1260.54 3.17

[0261] 3 1.99 1216.36 1.51 804.09 2.02

[0262] 4 1.05 560.33 1.37 407.68 1.02

[0263] 5 0.47 254.27 1.40 182.08 0.46

[0264] 6 0.20 102.07 1.40 72.84 0.18 Reference

[0265]

[0266] 7 0.00 1.88 1.26 1.49 0.0086303PC01

[0267] 26

[0268] The calibration factor can be determined to be 0.002513.

[0269] This means that the Boron weight % of a solid sample may be determined as follows: The NMR intensity by vol. / packing density * the NMR calibration factor.

[0270] The process diagram shown in figure 2a illustrates schematically an example of generating a calibration curve for an example of generation of a calibration curve.

[0271] In step 1, a reference sample is obtained of a produced product with a high quality. The reference sample may be grinded if required. In step 2, the reference sample is send for boron content determination at the laboratory.

[0272] A further reference sample is used for boron isotope NMR intensity determinations by volume e,g. as described above and the NMR intensity determined result is in step 3 converted to NMR intensity by weight and the calibration data comprising the laboratory determined boron content by weight in step 4 and the NMR intensity by weight is thereby generated.

[0273] Figure 2b illustrates an example of an on-site boron content determination of an intermediate produced product, here a glass cob.

[0274] A glass cob is an intermediate product in glass production, i.e. a glass product prior to shaping and annealing.

[0275] In step 11, a sample of the glass cob is acquired and allowed to cool to a solid sample. In step 12, a boron isotope NMR intensity determinations by volume is determined e.g. as described above.

[0276] In step 13, the NMR intensity by volume is converted to NMR intensity by weight.

[0277] In step 14, the NMR intensity by volume is correlated to the calibration data and the boron content of the glass cob is determined.

[0278] Figure 2c illustrates an example of an on-site boron content determination of a final produced product, here a final produced glass product.

[0279] In step 21, a final glass product is produced from the glass cob of figure 2b.86303PC01

[0280] 27

[0281] In step 22, a solid sample of the final product is obtained.

[0282] In step 23, a boron isotope NMR intensity determinations by volume is determined e.g. as described above.

[0283] In step 24, the NMR intensity by volume is converted to NMR intensity by weight.

[0284] In step 25, the NMR intensity by volume is correlated to the calibration data and the boron content of the final glass product is determined.

[0285] Example 5 - Correlation study

[0286] For further validation of the method, a set of 21 samples were analyzed. The samples are given in Table 4, and include samples of various glassware (crushed to pieces < ~2 mm), fiberglass, glass wool, CRM / SRM (certified / standard reference material), and a sample of pure boron oxide (B2O3).

[0287] For reference, aliquots of most samples were sent for external laboratory analysis (Activation Laboratories - Actlabs, Canada) where they were analyzed for B / B2O3 contents using either Prompt Gamma Neutron Activation Analysis (PGNAA) or ICP after sodium peroxide fusion (FUS-Na2O2). The remaining samples were CRM / SRM samples with known reference values. In all cases, the B contents were either provided in B2O3-equilents and converted to B2O3-equilents (B contents multiplied by 3.220 to B2O3-equilents).

[0288] For NMR measurements, samples of crushed glass and powders were loaded to NMR tubes (o.d. 12 mm) using a funnel. Samples of fiberglass material and glass wool were stuffed into NMR tubes by hand. The packing density for each sample tube were determined as the sample weight (weight of filled vs empty tube) dived by the length of the packed sample.

[0289] In this example,11B CPMG NMR measurements were conducted using a 2 min measuring time (at a static magnetic field strength of about 1 T) and obtained echo intensities were fitted to a bi-exponential decay of the form ltotai = h*exp(-t / T2,i) + I2 *exp(-t / 2,2) to find the total intensity (ltotai), which can is scaled by a calibration factor to compute the final calibrated NMR measurement result.

[0290] Table 4 shows an overview of the samples including brief sample description, packing density (in actual NMR tubes), final NMR results, and reference values (obtained from86303PC01

[0291] 28

[0292] external laboratory analyses and / or reference results provided with CRMs). The NMR and reference concentrations are both given in B2C>3-equilents and in weight-%.

[0293] Figures 3a-c show the NMR results plotted against the reference values. Figures 3b and 3c are two different zoom levels of Figure 3a. The figures (3a-c) show an excellent agreement between NMR measurements and reference values. The coefficient of determination (R2) is 0.9985 and indicates excellent correlation.

[0294] Table 4

[0295] Packing B2O3(%), B2O3(%),

[0296] Tag Sample Type Reference type density (g / ml) NMR Reference

[0297] Al Duralex drinking glass Soda-lime glass 1.64 0.03 0.037 Actlabs (PGNAA)

[0298] Actlabs (FUS- B1 Duran lab glassware Borosilicate glass 1.53 12.48 12.40

[0299] Na2O2) Actlabs (FUS- B2 0rskov drinking glass Borosilicate glass 1.22 14.58 12.75

[0300] Na2O2) Actlabs (FUS- B3 Fisherbrand lab glassware Borosilicate glass 1.49 15.28 13.36

[0301] Na2O2) Actlabs (FUS- B5 Duplicate of Bl Borosilicate glass 1.56 12.24 12.49

[0302] Na2O2) AWT twill fiberglass fabric Actlabs (FUS- F1 Fiberglass 0.73 7.54 6.34

[0303] (HF Industri & Marine) Na2O2) Milled glass fibre blend

[0304] F2 Fiberglass 0.54 0.03 0.019 Actlabs (PGNAA) (West System)

[0305] Fiberglass mat (Plastic

[0306] F3 Fiberglass 0.78 0.02 0.032 Actlabs (PGNAA) Padding).

[0307] Actlabs (FUS- F4 Duplicate of Fl. Fiberglass 0.77 7.88 6.34

[0308] Na2O2) U1 Hilgenberg glass tubes Unknown 1.39 1.32 0.712 Actlabs (PGNAA) U2 Week ovenproff glass Unknown 1.84 0.05 0.030 Actlabs (PGNAA) Glass wool strip (unknown Actlabs (FUS- W1 Glass wool 0.22 7.25 5.15

[0309] manufacturer) Na2O2) Glass wool insulation Actlabs (FUS- W2 Glass wool 0.34 3.76 4.25

[0310] (Isover) Na2O2)

[0311] Actlabs (FUS- W3 Duplicate of W2 Glass wool 0.31 3.75 4.12

[0312] Na2O2) C4 CRM Glass 4 Fluoride Opal Glass 1.55 0.47 0.19 CRM value Lead Oxide-Potassium

[0313] C8 CRM Glass 8 2.03 0.33 0.36 CRM value Oxide-Silica Glass86303PC01

[0314] 29

[0315] Soda-Lime-Silica

[0316] CIO CRM Glass 10- Amber 1.72 0.01 0 CRM value Container Glass

[0317] SX Standard glass DGG X Soda-lime glass 1.42 0.03 0 SRM value S2 Standard glass 2 Soda-lime glass 1.51 0.00 0 SRM value SRM value / Standardglass III (SRM Borosilicate glass, 12.7 /

[0318] S3 / B4 1.27 13.68 Actlabs (FUS- sample) powder 12.91

[0319] Na202) Pure chemical (99.98

[0320] B2O3B203, Sigma-Aldrich 1.20 99.98 99.98 Pure chemical %)

[0321] Example 6 - Correlation study with additional data analysis

[0322] For further validation and demonstration, a set of samples were analyzed using multiple11B CPMG NMR acquisitions with intermediate-length echo delay (TE / 2 = 150 ps) and additional data processing.

[0323] The samples analyzed include the samples in Table 4 (as also examined in Example 5) plus seven additional samples. The additional samples include four ore / rock OREAS CRM samples representing different geological matrixes (OREAS 144, 150, 460b, and 553, with boron contents of 1662, 3938, 848, and 309 ppm B) and three test samples of undisclosed origin (X1-3 with 6.54, 4.60, and 8.15 % B2O3, Actlabs FUS-Na2O2).

[0324] Samples were packed in NMR tubes, and packing densities were determined. In this example, the reference values were converted from mass per mass concentrations to mass per volume (units mg / L in this case) using the packing densities. Similarly, NMR measurements in mass per volume units are obtained using calibration samples with known contents in mass per volume units (e.g. converting the reference values for calibration samples using the packing densities of the calibration samples). Likewise, mass per mass contents of measured samples may trivially be calculated using the packing densities of the samples.

[0325] The samples (packed in NMR tubes) were analyzed11B CPMG measurements acquired at three different frequencies (0, + / -25 kHz relative to the standard11B resonance frequency of 14.168 MHz in the present case at a static magnetic field of about 1.04 T) to cover a broader spectral range of the11B resonance. To better resolve boron components with low and high quadrupolar coupling constants (low and high CQ, typically representing 4- and 3-coodinated boron), a Fourier transform of every echo was conducted and86303PC01

[0326] 30

[0327] combined across the experiments at different frequencies. Integrals representing components with low and high CQ were extracted, and for each sample the values of these integrals were used to construct a new time-domain data set with intensities for low / high-CQ components vs time, which is possible due to the echo-train (CPMG) acquisition. This data set was then used to fit T2 relaxation rates for each of the two components, thus obtaining time-zero intensities for each component.

[0328] For illustration, Figures 4a-b show frequency-stepped spectra (Fig. 4a) and T2 fits for the low / high CQ component (Fig. 4b) obtained from measuring a borosilicate glass SRM sample (Standard glass III). For clarity, Figure 4a show the spectra from 911B CPMG measurements acquired at frequencies of 0, + / -25, + / -50, + / -75, and + / -100 kHz each conducted with 20 echoes and one spectrum shown for each echo. Note that a broad range with 9 frequency steps is shown here for better visualization, whereas in the present example only the 3 central frequency steps were used for the correlation results. The more narrow, central peak is ascribed to the IOW-CQ component, whereas the broader pattern is ascribed to the second-order line-shape of the central transition of the high-Co component.

[0329] Figure 4b show the intensities of the low (left) and high(right) CQ components extracted from the spectra for each echo, the associated T2 fits, and the resulting parameter values for the shown measurement of the sample.

[0330] To account for inequal contributions from the components with low vs high CQ, in this example, the calibrated, total NMR intensity ( ) is obtained using the following model:

[0331] INMR = bO + b1* howCQ*e p(b3 / T2,lowCQ) + b2*lhighCQ *exp(b4 / T2,highCQ') , with IIOWCQ and ImghCQ being the intensities of the low / high-Co components, and T IOWCQ and T2,highCQ the T2 relaxation times of the low / high-Co components. In the present case, good correlation were found using the coefficients set to bO = 0, b1 = 0.00851, b2 = 0.01884, b3 = 0.00075, and b4 = 0.

[0332] In general, to account in more detail, for effects of for example low / high CQ, line shape widths, selective pulses, spin diffusion, and T1 suppression, further detailed models may be constructed using larger data sets.86303PC01

[0333] 31

[0334] Figures 5a-c show the NMR results vs the reference values (weight per volume concentrations). Figures 5b and 5c are different zoom levels of Figure 5a. An excellent agreement between NMR measurements and reference values is observed. The coefficient of determination (R2) is 0.9994, and the relative standard deviation of the difference between measurements and references (calculated as standard deviation of differences divided by the mean (arithmetic mean) of the reference values, 28 samples) is 5.9%.

[0335] We note that the precision at low concentrations is expected to improve if the measuring time is increased (i.e. , using a larger number of scans) as usual in NMR experiments.

Claims

86303PC0132PATENT CLAIMS1. A method for quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, the method comprising:• acquire a solid sample of the solid material;• applying the solid sample into an NMR tube;• applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;• performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data,• correlating the NMR intensity data to calibration data, and• determine the content of boron in the solid material.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein the low field NMR spectrometer is adapted for operating at a low magnetic field, such as a magnetic field up to 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT.

3. The method of claim 1 or claim 2, wherein the NMR reading is performed in the magnetic field B field not exceeding 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT.

4. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method comprises determine the weight and / or the volume of the solid sample.

5. The method of claim 4, wherein the determination of the weight of the solid sample comprises weighing the sample.

6. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method comprises determine the content of boron in the solid material in the form of at least one of weight of boron per weight unit of solid material (w / / w), volume of boron per volume unit of solid material (vol / vol), molar content of boron per weight unit of solid sample, molar content of boron per volume unit of solid sample, weight % of boron and / or molar % of boron.86303PC01337. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method comprises dividing the solid sample into smaller pieces, such as by cutting and / or grinding of the solid sample, wherein the step of dividing the solid sample into smaller pieces may be performed during the acquisition of the solid sample from the solid material and / or after the acquisition of the solid sample from the solid material.

8. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR tube comprises less than 5 ppm by weight of boron, such as less than 1 ppm by weight, such as less than 0.1 ppm by weight, preferably the NMR tube is a boron free NMR tube.

9. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR tube is of a material selected from Teflon, quartz and / or combinations thereof.

10. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises at least one NMR signal of the isotope11B and / or the isotope10B, preferably comprising a signal of the isotope11B.

11. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises an average of a plurality of NMR signals of the isotope11B and / or the isotope10B, preferably comprising a signal of the isotope11B.

12. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data.

13. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses wherein the RF pulses comprise at least one exciting RF pulse and at least one refocusing RF pulse.

14. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses comprising a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG)sequence.86303PC013415. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses comprising one or more of the sequences an inversion-recovery pulse sequence, a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence and / or a spin-echo sequence or any combinations comprising at least one of these.

16. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to a sequence of RF pulses and delays comprising a sub sequence S1i. applying a 180° RF pulseii. applying an inversion recovery delay (I RD)iii. applying a 90° RF pulse andiv. determine a resonance intensity, directly or throughout an echo sequence, such as CPMG,preferably the method comprises repeating the S1 subsequence.

17. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to a sequence of RF pulses and delays comprising a sub sequence S2i. applying a 90° RFii. applying an echo delayiii. applying a 180° RF pulseiv. repeating steps ii and iiiv. applying a recycle delay,preferably, the method comprises repeating the S2 subsequence optionally applying different recycle delays.

18. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to a repeated sequence of RF exiting signals comprising>71> T|NV > ir / 2 > ?E / 2 > n > > n > Tw > invert IRD excite 1stED 1strefocus ED refocus wait RD repeat x (N-l)86303PC0135wherein TT and / 2 designates radio-frequency pulses with pulse duration and radiofrequency pulse field strengths adjust to provide pulse flip angles of (such as 180°) and / 2 (such as 90°), respectively, Tmv is the inversion recovery delay (I RD), TE is the echo delay (ED), Tn / the recycle delay (RD), and N the number of echoes.

19. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to at least one of WURST-QCPMG, WASP-CPMG , BRAIN-CP, PRESTO, RINEPT, TEDOR, REDOR, RESPDOR, TRAPDOR, or REAPDOR, RAS NMR, overtone spectroscopy (e.g., for 10B), dipolar DQ-SQ (double quantum - single quantum) correlation, HMQC or D-HMOC (heteronuclear multiplequantum correlation), HETCOR, MQ-HETCOR and / or MQ-SPAM,20. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to at least one sequence comprising a combination of CPMG with additional pulses, wherein the additional pulses preferably is selected from adiabatic pulses, hypersecant pulses, sensitivity enhancement pulses and / or pulses utilizing single- or multiple-quantum transitions.

21. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to at least one pulse technique comprising exploiting coherence transfer from other nuclei and / or at least one pulse technique comprising using relaxation parameters to resolve overlapping resonances.

22. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to at least one of magic-angle spinning or turning experiment, such as a pulse sequence comprising MQMAS.STMAS, DOR, RESPDOR, MAT and / or MATPASS.

23. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises subjecting the solid sample to Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence comprising a plurality of pulses 90°(x) — [T — 180°(y) — T — echo]nto determine the intensity of 4-coordinated boron and subjecting the solid sample to one or more modified Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence comprising a plurality of pulses, where 90°(x) — [T — 90°(y) — T — echo]nto determine the intensity of 3-coordinated boron,86303PC0136wherein T is the spacing, and optionally adding the intensity of 4-coordinated boron and the intensity of 3-coordinated boron to obtain the total boron NMR intensity signal.

24. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading and intensity determination is performed using time domain low field spectroscopy.

25. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading is performed using static NMR reading.

26. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the NMR reading comprises determining and recording at least one relaxation time selected from a spinlattice relaxation time Ti and a spin-spin relaxation time T2.

27. The method of claim 26, wherein the method comprises applying the at least one relaxation time to distinguish between intensity of 3-coordinated boron and intensity of the 4-coordinated boron.

28. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the performing of the NMR reading comprises performing time-domain low-field NMR determination of the content of boron in the solid sample comprising a total NMR intensity of11B or10B, comprising applying a CPMG pulse train, determining and recording a first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and applying one or more modified CPMG pulse trains using halved flip angles of the refocusing pulse and determining and recording a second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and summarizing the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope.

29. The method of claim 28, wherein the performing of the NMR reading comprises determination an adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B comprising determining at least one of T1 and T2 based on the CPMG pulse train, determining a first redundant intensity portion originating from the 3-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the first redundant intensity portion from the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope determining a first adjusted NMR intensity and determining at least one of T1 and T2 based on the one or more modified CPMG pulse train, determining a second redundant intensity portion originating from the 4-coordinate boron11B and withdrawing the second redundant intensity portion from the second intensity portion of the11B isotope and86303PC0137determining a second adjusted NMR intensity portion and summarizing the first adjusted intensity portion of the11B isotope and the second adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope.

30. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material is a solid material comprising boron atoms.

31. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of inorganic material.

32. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of semiconductor material, such as semiconductor material comprising boron, such as Boron-doped semiconductor material.

33. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of ceramic materials, such as ceramic materials comprising boron, such as Boron carbide (B4C) and / or Boron nitride (BN).

34. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of mineral material, such as boron containing mineral material, such as mineral wool.

35. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of glass material, such as fiberglass, glass fiber composites, glass wool and glass-ceramic materials, glass containing implants, glazes and enamels, preferably the glass is boron containing glass, such as borosilicate glass, aluminosilicate glass, glass ceramic, bioactive glass, optical glass and / or phosphate glass.

36. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of non-paramagnetic metal alloys, such as alloyed metals comprising boron e.g. ferroboron alloys and / or Boron austenitic steel.

37. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of construction materials, such as roofing materials, wallboard,86303PC0138fiberglass insulation and cellulose insulation and construction materials treated with boron containing material, such as wood, plastic, bricks, pipes and wires.

38. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the solid material comprises or consists of materials containing organoboron and / or solid medicines containing boron, such as boron-containing drugs like bortezomib and ixazomib.

39. The method of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the method comprises generating the calibration data, the method comprises acquiring a plurality of reference samples, wherein the reference samples comprises different and known content of boron, and for each reference sample• applying the reference sample into an NMR tube;• applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;• performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data, and associating the determined NMR intensity data to the known boron content of said each reference sample to generate a reference data set comprising the known boron content and the determined NMR intensity data , andwherein the method comprises collecting the respective sets of reference data sets to generate the calibration data.

40. A method of generating calibration data for use in quantitative determination of boron in a solid material, the method comprising acquiring at least one and preferably a plurality of reference samples, wherein the reference samples comprises different and known content of boron, and for each reference sample• applying the reference sample into an NMR tube;• applying the NMR tube in a nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectrometer, wherein the NMR spectrometer is a low field spectrometer;• performing an NMR reading comprising subjecting the material sample to a magnetic field B and one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and determining and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data, and86303PC0139associating the determined NMR intensity data to the known boron content of said each reference sample to generate a reference data set comprising the known boron content and the determined NMR intensity data, andwherein the method comprises collecting the respective sets of reference data sets to generate the calibration data.

41. The method of claim 39 or claim 40 wherein the at least one reference sample comprises a solid reference sample.

42. The method of any one of claims 39-41 , wherein the at least one reference sample comprises a fluid reference sample, such as one or more reference samples comprising one or more boron compounds in solution.

43. The method of any one of claims 39-42, wherein the at least one of reference sample comprises at least two reference samples, such as at least 5 reference samples, such as from 2 to hundred reference samples or even more.

44. The method of any one of claims 39-43, wherein the low field NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample is adapted for operating at a low magnetic field, such as a magnetic field up to 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT, preferably the field NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading of the reference samples is identical to or is the NMR spectrometer used for NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.

45. The method of any one of claims 39-44, wherein the NMR reading is performed in the magnetic field B field not exceeding 2 T, such as up to 1 T, such as up to 750 mT, preferably the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample are performed in a magnetic field B identical to the magnetic field used for NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.

46. The method of any one of claims 39-45, wherein the weight and / or the volume of each of the at least one reference sample is known or the method comprises determine the weight and / or the volume of each of the at least one reference sample.86303PC014047. The method of any one of claims 39-46, wherein the known content of boron in each of the at least one reference sample are known in the form of at least one of weight of boron per weight unit of reference sample (w / / w), volume of boron per volume unit of reference sample (vol / vol), molar content of boron per weight unit of reference sample, r molar content of boron per volume unit of reference sample, weight % of boron of the reference sample and / or molar % of boron of the reference sample.

48. The method of any one of claims 39-47, wherein the at least one NMR signal of the reading of each of the at least one reference sample of the at least one NMR active boron isotope comprises at least one NMR signal, such as an average of a plurality of NMR signals of the isotope11B and / or the isotope10B, preferably the isotope11B.

49. The method of any one of claims 39-48, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to one or more RF (radio frequency) pulse sequences and recording at least one NMR signal of at least one NMR active boron isotope, wherein the NMR signal comprises NMR intensity data.

50. The method of any one of claims 39-49, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses wherein the RF pulses comprise at least one exciting RF pulse and at least one refocusing RF pulse.

51. The method of any one of claims 39-50, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to the magnetic field B and a plurality of RF pulses comprising a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill sequence.

52. The method of any one of claims 39-51, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the each of the at least one reference sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses comprising one or more of the sequences an inversion-recovery pulse sequence, a Carr-Purcell-Meiboom-Gill (CPMG) sequence and / or a spin-echo sequence or any combinations comprising at least one of these.86303PC014153. The method of any one of claims 39-52, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises subjecting each of the at least one reference sample to one or more sequences of RF pulses, identical to one or more sequences of RF pulses applied in the NMR reading of the NMR reading of the solid sample and / or a solid sample of the solid material.

54. The method of any one of claims 39-53, wherein the NMR reading and the intensity determination of each of the at least one reference sample is performed using time domain low field spectroscopy.

55. The method of any one of claims 39-54 wherein the NMR reading and the intensity determination of each of the at least one reference sample is performed using static NMR reading.

56. The method of any one of claims 39-55, wherein the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises determining and recording at least one relaxation time selected from a spin-lattice relaxation time Ti and a spin-spin relaxation time T2..

57. The method of any one of claims 39-56, wherein the performing of the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises performing time-domain low-field NMR determination of the content of boron in the solid sample comprising a total NMR intensity of11B or10B, comprising applying a CPMG pulse train, determining and recording a first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and applying one or more modified CPMG pulse trains using halved flip angles of the refocusing pulse and determining and recording a second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and summarizing the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope.

58. The method of claim 57, wherein the performing of the NMR reading of each of the at least one reference sample comprises determination an adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B comprising• determining at least one of T 1 and T2 based on the CPMG pulse train, determining a first redundant intensity portion originating from the 3-coordinate boron11B or10B86303PC0142and withdrawing the first redundant intensity portion from the first intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to determining a first adjusted NMR intensity and• determining at least one of T 1 and T2 based on the one or more modified CPMG pulse trains, determining a second redundant intensity portion originating from the 4-coordinate boron11B or10B and withdrawing the second redundant intensity portion from the second intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to determining a second adjusted NMR intensity and• adding the first adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope and the second adjusted intensity portion of the11B or10B isotope to obtain the adjusted total NMR intensity of11B or10B.