Methods and apparatus for generating quantum entanglement
The optical network with passive interference devices and control system addresses inefficiencies in existing entanglement methods by allowing simultaneous entanglement of multiple quantum systems, reducing losses and eliminating reconfiguration needs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/IB2026/054253
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-08
- Filing Date
- 2026-04-29
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for generating quantum entanglement are inefficient and require dedicated devices for each pair of quantum systems, leading to high optical losses and time-consuming reconfigurations.
An optical network with a passive structure comprising multiple interference devices and input/output ports, allowing simultaneous interference of photon states from multiple quantum systems, and a control system to manage entanglement protocols and corrections.
Facilitates efficient generation of quantum entanglement across multiple quantum systems with reduced optical losses and no need for reconfiguration, enabling scalable and efficient entanglement generation.
Smart Images

Figure IB2026054253_12112026_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR GENERATING QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT Cross-Reference to Related Application
[0001] This application claims priority from US application No. 63 / 802455 filed 8 May 2025 and entitled METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR GENERATING QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT which is hereby incorporated herein by reference for all purposes. For purposes of the United States of America, this application claims the benefit under 35 U. S. C. §119 of US application No. 63 / 802455 filed 8 May 2025 and entitled METHODS AND APPARATUS FOR GENERATING QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT which is hereby incorporated herein by reference for all purposes.Field
[0002] This disclosure relates to methods and apparatus for generating entanglement of quantum systems. The present technology has example application to quantum informatics processing quantum communication and quantum cryptography.Background
[0003] Quantum information may, for example, be represented by the states of quantum systems as diverse as photons, Josephson junctions (superconducting qubits), the intrinsic spins of subatomic particles (e.g. electrons, atomic nuclei) or of quasi particles (e.g. holes, excitons), trapped ions, trapped neutral atoms and other physical systems that have quantum states that can be used to store information.
[0004] Since quantum systems can exist in superpositions of different quantum states, the stored information may be defined by a particular superposition of quantum states. For example, a quantum system may have first and second quantum basis states: |i l > and |i 2 >. Information may be stored in the quantum system by setting the system to a quantum state given by the superposition: a|i l > +p |i 2 > where a and p are complex valued coefficients. In this disclosure, the term “qubit” means a quantum system that has a quantum state which can represent information as a linear combination of basis states.
[0005] For example, a qubit may comprise a spin % particle, e.g. an electron, which has two basis spin states which may be represented as |T) and |i) (spin up and spin down respectively). For example, the spin up state may be associated with the value“1” or “TRUE” and the spin down state may be associated with the value “0” or “FALSE” or vice versa. At a given time, the qubit may be in either one of these basis spin states or in a quantum superposition of these basis spin states.
[0006] Two or more quantum systems are “entangled” with one another when the quantum state of any one of the entangled quantum systems cannot be described independently of the state of the other one(s) of the entangled quantum systems.
[0007] When two quantum systems are entangled, the results of measurements on the two quantum systems are correlated. For example, two electrons (or other spin % particles) may have an entangled state which forces measurements of the spins of the two electrons relative to a particular axis to yield the same result. Such a state may be represented as: \ = <z|TT) + 0| ). As another example, two electrons (or other spin % particles) may have an entangled state which forces measurements of the spins of the two electrons relative to a particular axis to yield opposite results. Such a state may be represented as: \ = a |U) + 0|iT).
[0008] Quantum entanglement is not limited to spin states of particles that have intrinsic spin. Other types of quantum system may be entangled. Quantum entanglement may result in correlations of observable properties of quantum systems other than spin.
[0009] Quantum entanglement may be exploited in various useful ways. For example, entanglement may be applied for: transferring a quantum state from one quantum system to another over an arbitrary distance using a protocol for quantum teleportation, quantum error correction, applying two qubit quantum gates to quantum systems that are separated by arbitrary distances using protocols for teleporting controlled gates, measurement-based computing, and so on. As a result, quantum entanglement has become a key resource for quantum informatics, quantum communication and quantum cryptography.Summary
[0010] The present technology relates to generating quantum entanglement. Aspects of the present technology include, without limitation, methods for generating quantum entanglement, apparatus for generating quantum entanglement, photonic networks useful for generating quantum entanglement, control systems configured to control apparats for generating quantum entanglement and tangible media including machinereadable instructions for controlling an apparatus to generate quantum entanglement.
[0011] A first aspect of the present technology provides apparatus for generating entanglement of quantum systems. The apparatus comprises an optical network comprising: four or more input ports; four or more output ports; and a plurality of interference devices. Each of the interference devices comprising first and second input ports and first and second output ports. The interference devices are configured to allow interference of first and second photons presented substantially simultaneously at the input ports. The plurality of interference devices are interconnected to provide a plurality of bundles of paths. Each of the bundles of paths comprises plural paths that originate from one of the four or more input ports of the optical network and extend through a plurality of the interference devices of the optical network to a corresponding one of the output ports of the optical network, with no two paths of the bundle of paths extending to the same one of the output ports of the optical network.
[0012] In some embodiments, for each of the bundles of paths, the intersection of a set of all of the interference devices that paths of the bundle of paths extend through with a set of all of the interference devices that paths of another one of the bundles of paths extend through is non-zero fora plurality of other ones of the bundles of paths.
[0013] In some embodiments, each of the bundles of paths bifurcates at each of a plurality of the interference devices to form a binary tree structure having nodes corresponding to the interference devices at which the bundle of paths bifurcates. In some embodiments, the binary tree structure corresponding to each of the bundles of paths has one or more nodes in common with each of the binary tree structures corresponding to each of the other bundles of paths.
[0014] In some embodiments, each of the paths of the bundles of paths passes through the same number of interference devices before reaching the output port to which the path extends.
[0015] In some embodiments, the interference devices are interconnected such that each of the interference devices belongs to one of a plurality of levels, wherein the interference devices of an Lthone of the levels are the Lthinterference devices encountered when traversing any of the paths of the bundles of paths that pass through the interference device starting from the respective input ports.
[0016] In some embodiments, a travel time fora photon along each path of thebundles of paths from the respective input port to a corresponding first level interference device are substantially the same for all of the paths of the bundles of paths.
[0017] In some embodiments, a travel time fora photon along each path of the bundles of paths from a corresponding 1stlevel interference device to a corresponding Lthlevel interference device are substantially the same for all of the paths of the bundles of paths for all values of L in the range of 2 to Lmax where Lmax is the highest level of interference devices in the network.
[0018] In some embodiments the apparatus further comprises a plurality of photon detectors, each of the photon detectors coupled to detect photons exiting the optical network at a corresponding one of the output ports of the optical network.
[0019] In some embodiments, the four or more input ports comprises at least 16 input ports.
[0020] In some embodiments, the apparatus comprises a plurality of quantum systems, each of the plurality of quantum systems optically coupled to a corresponding one of the input ports of the optical network and having a quantum state given by: α|0⟩ + β|1⟩ where a and p are complex valued coefficients and |0) and |1) are basis states and wherein applying a first stimulation to one of the quantum systems when the quantum system is in the state |1) causes the quantum system to emit a photon and applying the stimulus to the one of the quantum systems when the quantum system is in the state |0) causes the quantum system to emit zero photons.
[0021] In some embodiments, the quantum systems are on or in a substrate and the optical network is formed on the substrate. In some embodiments, the quantum systems comprise particles that have intrinsic spin and the basis states |0) and |1) correspond to distinct spin states of the particles. In some embodiments, the particles are spin % particles. In some embodiments, the particles are spin 1 particles. In some embodiments, the quantum systems comprise radiation damage centres in silicon. In some embodiments, the radiation damage centres comprise T centres, AI1 centres, Ga1 centres, I centres or M centres.
[0022] In some embodiments, the apparatus comprises a control system configured to execute an entanglement protocol to entangle the quantum states of two of the quantum systems wherein the entanglement protocol comprises: applying a first stimulus to each of the two quantum systems and processing first informationidentifying any photons detected at an output of the optical network as a result of the application of the first stimulus.
[0023] In some embodiments, the control system is further configured to determine a correction to be applied to a combined quantum state of the two quantum systems.
[0024] In some embodiments, determining the correction comprises looking up the correction using a key based on at least one of information identifying the two quantum systems and the first information.
[0025] In some embodiments, the interference devices comprise 2X2 devices selected from the group comprising 50:50 beamsplitters, multimode interference (MMI) devices and directional couplers. In some embodiments, the interference devices comprise bent directional couplers.
[0026] In some embodiments, the optical network comprises 2nof the input ports, where n is an integer and n >2.
[0027] In some embodiments, the optical network comprises n levels of the interference devices, each of the levels comprising 2n-1of the interference devices.
[0028] In some embodiments, each of the interference devices comprises two input ports and two output ports wherein: the input ports of the interference devices of a second one of the levels are optically connected 1:1 to corresponding ones of the output ports of the interference devices of a first one of the levels such that the output ports of each of the interference devices of the first level are optically coupled to the input ports of two different ones of the interference devices of the second level.
[0029] In some embodiments, the optical network is a passive network.
[0030] In some embodiments, the optical network comprises one or more tunable optical elements.
[0031] In some embodiments, the tunable optical elements comprise one or more waveguides and / or one or more of the interference devices.
[0032] In some embodiments, the tunable optical elements are operable to adjust optical path lengths within the optical network
[0033] In some embodiments, the bundles of paths are fixed.
[0034] A second aspect of the present technology provides a method for generating entanglement of quantum systems. The method comprises providing an optical network that includes: four or more input ports, four or more output ports, and a plurality of interference devices, each interference device having first and secondinput ports and first and second output ports. The interference devices are configured to allow interference of first and second photon states presented substantially simultaneously at the first and second input ports. The plurality of interference devices are interconnected so as to form a plurality of bundles of paths, each bundle of paths including plural paths that originate from one of the four or more input ports and extend through at least some of the interference devices to a corresponding one of the output ports. Each path of a given bundle terminating at one of the output ports. The method further includes injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems into two of the four or more input ports so that the injected photons states interfere at one or more of the interference devices, thereby generating entanglement of the two quantum systems.
[0035] In some embodiments, the network requires no changes in configuration to accept the injection of photon states at different ones of the input ports of the network.
[0036] In some embodiments, the method comprises detecting one or more photons exiting one or more of the output ports of the optical network using a plurality of photon detectors and determining that the entanglement is generated by identifying that the one or more detected photons correspond to a heralding pattern.
[0037] In some embodiments, the photon states are injected into the optical network substantially simultaneously.
[0038] In some embodiments, the plurality of interference devices are arranged in a plurality of levels such that each of the paths traverses an equal number of the interference devices before arriving at the corresponding output port.
[0039] In some embodiments, each of the bundles of paths forms a binary tree structure having nodes corresponding to the interference devices at which the bundle of paths bifurcates.
[0040] In some embodiments, injecting the photon states into the optical network comprises adjusting the timing of the stimuli applied to the two quantum systems to cause the respective photon states to arrive at the optical network substantially simultaneously.
[0041] In some embodiments, the method comprises using calibration data to apply a phase correction to the two quantum systems after entanglement of the two quantum systems is achieved. In some embodiments, using the calibration data comprises looking up a correction to be applied to the two quantum systems using a key basedon the heralding pattern.
[0042] In some embodiments, the method comprises obtaining the calibration data by splitting a beam of coherent light into first and second parts and introducing the first and second parts into first and second ones of the input ports of the optical network while obtaining light measurements at the output ports of the network and varying the wavelength of the coherent light, processing the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports and generating calibration data based on the phase differences.
[0043] In some embodiments, the method comprises generating the calibration data for a plurality of pairs of the input ports.
[0044] In some embodiments, the method comprises repeating the method to generate entanglement of another two quantum systems wherein photon states from the another two quantum systems are injected into the optical network at different ones of the input ports from the input ports used when generating entanglement of the two quantum systems.
[0045] In some embodiments, a configuration of interconnections of the plurality of interference devices in the optical network is unchanged over plural repetitions of the method.
[0046] In some embodiments, the interference devices are 2×2 devices selected from the group consisting of 50:50 beamsplitters, multimode interference devices, and directional couplers. In some embodiments, the interference devices comprise bent directional couplers.
[0047] In some embodiments, the optical network comprises at least 16 input ports.
[0048] In some embodiments, the optical network is a passive network.
[0049] In some embodiments, the optical network comprises one or more tunable optical elements and the method comprises adjusting optical path lengths within the optical network by tuning the tunable optical elements..
[0050] In some embodiments, the tunable optical elements comprise one or more waveguides and / or one or more of the interference devices.
[0051] In some embodiments, the bundles of paths are fixed.
[0052] In some embodiments, the method comprises preparing each of the two quantum systems a quantum states which is a superposition of basis states |0) and 11).
[0053] In some embodiments, injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems comprises delivering stimuli to the two quantum systems where the stimuli are selected so that for a quantum system in state |0) application of the stimuli will not cause the quantum system to emit a photon and when the quantum system is in the state |1) application of the stimuli will cause the quantum system to emit a photon.
[0054] In some embodiments, injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems comprises delivering stimuli to the two quantum systems, the stimuli comprising:a first stimulus delivered to a first one of the two quantum systems that causes emission of a photon from the first one of the two quantum systems if the first one of the quantum systems is in the state |0) and does not cause emission of a photon from the first one of the two quantum systems if the first one of the two quantum systems is in the state |1); anda second stimulus delivered to a second one of the two quantum systems that causes emission of a photon from the second one of the two quantum systems if the second one of the quantum systems is in the state |1) and does not cause emission of a photon from the second one of the two quantum systems if the second one of the two quantum systems is in the state |0);
[0055] In some embodiments, the method comprises performing an entanglement protocol on the two quantum systems comprising, after injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems into two of the four or more input ports, inverting quantum states of the two quantum systems and then again injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems into the two of the four or more input ports.
[0056] In some embodiments, the method comprises performing a BK entanglement protocol on the two quantum systems.
[0057] A third aspect of the present technology provides a method for entangling states of two quantum systems, the method comprising:a) applying first stimuli to cause the two quantum systems to each emit a photon state into a corresponding one of a plurality of input ports of an optical network comprising a plurality of output ports and a plurality of interference devices interconnected such that the photon states from the two quantum systems interfere with one another at one or more of the interference devices;b) making one or more photon detections, each of the photon detections associated with one of the output ports;c) determining from the one or more photon detections that entanglement of the two quantum systems has been generated; andd) based on the photon detections determining a correction to be applied to the two quantum systems.
[0058] In some embodiments, the method comprises, after step b) and before step c): inverting quantum states of the two quantum systems and then repeating steps a) and b).
[0059] In some embodiments, the method comprises applying the correction to the two quantum systems, wherein applying the corrections causes a joint quantum state of the two quantum systems to become closer to a maximally entangled state of the two quantum systems.
[0060] In some embodiments, determining the correction comprises looking up the correction based on the one or more photon detections and / or the input ports of the optical network into which the photon states were emitted from the two quantum systems.
[0061] In some embodiments, the correction comprises a phase.
[0062] In some embodiments, the optical network is a passive network.
[0063] A fourth aspect of the present technology provides a control system for an apparatus for generating entanglement of quantum systems. The control system comprises electronic logic configured to perform an entanglement protocol on two quantum systems by acts including: controlling delivery of stimuli to two quantum systems selected from a plurality of quantum systems. The stimuli effective to cause the two quantum systems to inject photon states into respective input ports of an optical network. The optical network comprises: four or more of the input ports;four or more output ports; and a plurality of interference devices, each of the interference devices comprising first and second input ports and first and second output ports. The interference devices are configured to allow interference of first and second photons presented substantially simultaneously at the input ports. The control system is further configured to receiving detection information indicating detection of one or more photons exiting one or more of the output ports of the optical networkand identify that the one or more detected photons correspond to a heralding pattern.
[0064] In some embodiments, the control system is further configured to determine a correction to be applied to correct a quantum state of the two quantum systems.
[0065] In some embodiments, the electronic logic is configured to determine the correction by looking up the correction based on the detection information and / or the input ports of the optical network into which the photon states were emitted from the
[0066] In some embodiments, the electronic logic is further configured to apply the correction to the two quantum systems.
[0067] In some embodiments, the electronic logic is further configured to repeat the entanglement protocol on each of a plurality of pairs of quantum systems selected from the plurality of quantum systems without changing a configuration of the optical network; wherein different ones of the plurality of pairs of quantum systems are associated with different pairs of the input ports of the optical network.
[0068] A fifth aspect of the present technology provides apparatus for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network. The apparatus comprises a coherent light source operable to emit a beam of coherent light; a beam splitter arranged to split the beam of coherent light into first and second parts; and optics arranged to respectively deliver the first and second parts into first and second selected input ports of the optical network. The apparatus includes a control system comprising electronic logic configured to: receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light; process the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; and generate calibration data based on the phase differences.
[0069] A sixth aspect of the present technology provides a control system for apparatus for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network. The control system comprises electronic logic configured to, while first and second parts of a coherent light beam are being delivered into first and second input ports of the optical network: receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light; process the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the outputports; and generate calibration data based on the phase differences.
[0070] A seventh aspect of the present technology provides a method for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network, the method comprising: a) introducing first and second coherent parts of a coherent light beam into respective input ports of the optical network;b) receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light; c) processing the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; and d) generate calibration data based on the phase differences.
[0071] An eighth aspect of the present technology provides apparatus having any new and inventive feature, combination of features, or sub-combination of features as described herein
[0072] A ninth aspect of the present technology provides methods having any new and inventive steps, acts, combination of steps and / or acts or sub-combination of steps and / or acts as described herein.
[0073] Further aspects and example embodiments are illustrated in the accompanying drawings and / or described in the following description.
[0074] It is emphasized that the invention relates to all combinations of the above features, even if these are recited in different claims. Apparatus described herein may include counterparts of any features relating to methods described herein and vice versa.Brief Description of the Drawings
[0075] The accompanying drawings illustrate non-limiting example embodiments of the present technology.
[0076] Figs. 1 A and 1 B are schematic illustrations showing prior art apparatus for entangling quantum states of two quantum systems.
[0077] Fig. 2 is a schematic illustration of an optical network of an apparatus according to an example embodiment of the present technology.
[0078] Fig. 3 is a schematic illustration of an apparatus operable to entangle quantum states of any pair of quantum systems selected from four quantum systems.
[0079] Fig. 3A is a schematic illustration showing paths taken through an optical network by parts of a split laser beam to photon detectors at which interferencebetween the two parts provides information that can be used to determine a correction for undesired phase in quantum states of entangled pairs of quantum systems.
[0080] Fig. 4 is a flow chart illustrating a method for entangling two quantum systems according to an example embodiment of the present technology.
[0081] Fig. 5 is a schematic illustration of an apparatus operable to entangle quantum states of any pair of quantum systems selected from sixteen quantum systems.
[0082] Fig. 5A shows the system of Fig. 5 annotated to illustrate use of the apparatus to entangle quantum systems coupled to input ports that connect to two interference devices in a block of interference devices.
[0083] Fig. 5B shows an alternative topology for interconnecting interference devices in a manner that reduces waveguide crossings.
[0084] Figs. 6A and 6B illustrate two binary trees of paths of the network of the apparatus of Fig. 5.
[0085] Fig. 7 is a schematic illustration showing an example quantum system, an optical interface for the quantum system and various means for controlling aspects of photons emitted by the quantum system, delivering stimuli to the quantum system and adjusting coupling of photons emitted from the quantum system to an optical network.Detailed Description
[0086] Throughout the following description, specific details are set forth in order to provide a more thorough understanding of the invention. However, the invention may be practiced without these particulars. In other instances, well known elements have not been shown or described in detail to avoid unnecessarily obscuring the invention. Accordingly, the specification and drawings are to be regarded in an illustrative, rather than a restrictive sense.Prior art
[0087] Various protocols for generating entanglement of quantum systems are known. A heralded entanglement protocol is an entanglement protocol that provides an indication when an attempt to entangle quantum systems (an “entanglement attempt”) succeeds. An example of a heralded entanglement protocol is described in S. D. Barrett and P. Kok, Phys. Rev. A 71, 060310(R) (2005) which is herebyincorporated herein by reference for all purposes.
[0088] The Barrett Kok protocol (“BK protocol”) exploits a property of certain quantum systems, which is that the quantum systems can be caused to emit a photon having a quantum state (“photon state”) that is entangled with the quantum state of the quantum system in response to a stimulus. The BK protocol includes two steps in which indistinguishable photons from two quantum systems that are to be entangled to interfere with one another. One or more photons are subsequently detected.
[0089] For the BK protocol to succeed, it is important that the photons that are detected are indistinguishable (i.e. the steps are performed in such a way that it is not possible to determine which quantum system a detected photon originated from). Conceptually, information about the path taken by photons from quantum systems 11 A and 11 B must be “erased”.
[0090] Fig. 1A is a schematic illustration of an example prior art apparatus 10A for generating entanglement of two quantum systems 11 A and 11 B (generally and collectively quantum systems 11). Quantum systems 11 have quantum states that may be used to store quantum information. Quantum systems 11 each have the property that they can be caused to emit a photon that is entangled with their quantum state in response to application of a stimulus.
[0091] Apparatus 10A includes one or more stimulators 12 that are operable to deliver stimuli to each of quantum systems 11 A and 11 B. The stimuli cause quantum systems 11A and 11B to emit corresponding photons 13A, 13B. Photons 13A, 13B have photon states that are respectively entangled with the quantum states of quantum systems 11 A and 11 B.
[0092] Optical waveguides 14 carry photons 13A, 13B respectively to inputs 15A, 15B of a device 15 that is constructed to allow photons 13A, 13B to interfere with one another. Device 15 has first and second output ports 15C, 15D that are respectively coupled to first and second single photon detectors 16A, 16B. It is not possible to determine whether a photon detected by detector 16A or 16B entered device 15 at port 15A or port 15B since a photon 13 received at either input port 15A, 15B may exit device 15 at either output port 15C, 15D.
[0093] Device 15, together with single photon detectors 16A, 16B, form a “Bell state analyzer” or“BSA” 17.
[0094] A control system 18 controls apparatus 10 to execute the BK protocol onquantum systems 11 A and 11 B. Control system 18 may, for example cause stimulator(s) 12 to apply stimuli to quantum systems 11 A and 11 B respectively. The stimuli are timed so that any resulting photons emitted from quantum systems 11A and 11 B will arrive at input ports 15A and 15B of device 15 essentially simultaneously so that the photons 13A, 13B are present at device 15 at the same time and have the opportunity to interfere with one another. Photons 13A, 13B are indistinguishable from one another so that it is not possible to tell from which quantum system 11 a photon detected at detector 16A or 16B originated.
[0095] Apparatus 10A has the disadvantage that apparatus 10A can generate entanglement only of the quantum states of quantum systems 11 A, 11 B. In general, it is not efficient to provide a separate device 15 dedicated to entangling quantum states of each pair of quantum systems 11 for which it might be desirable to create entanglement.
[0096] Fig. 1 B is a schematic illustration of a prior art apparatus 10B that is similar to apparatus 10A with the addition of an active optical switching network 19 which is configurable (e.g. by control signals from control system 18) to connect any of a plurality of different pairs of quantum systems 11 (individually identified as quantum systems 11-1, 11-2... 11-N) to input ports 15A and 15B. In apparatus 10B, device 15 may be used to generate entanglement of any pair of quantum systems 11 for which network 19 can be configured to provide simultaneous connections from each quantum system of the pair of quantum systems 11 to a corresponding one of input ports 15A, 15B. Network 19 may provide all-to-all connectivity (i.e. network 19 may be configurable to entangle of any pair of quantum systems selected from quantum systems 11-1 to 11-N). However, using a large number of switches increases optical losses, and requires more electrical drives to control the switches. In addition, changing the state of switches in active switching network 19 takes time.Example apparatus
[0097] Fig. 2 shows an apparatus 20 according to an example embodiment of the present technology. Apparatus 20 comprises an optical network 22. Optical network 22 is made up of a plurality of devices 15. Each device 15 is a 2X2 device (meaning that each device 15 has two input ports and two output ports). Devices 15 are interconnected in network 22 by optical paths 25 (only some of which are shown in Fig. 2). Optical paths may, for example, comprise optical waveguides. In someembodiments, no more than one optical path 25 is connected to any input port or any output port of any of the devices 15.
[0098] If a photon is received at one input port of a device 15 at a time when no other photon is received at the other input port of the device 15 then the photon has a 50% probability of exiting the device 15 at each of the output ports of the device 15. If one photon is received at each input port of the device 15 at substantially the same time such that the photons interfere at device 15, and the photons are indistinguishable, then both photons will exit device 15 by the same one of the outputs of the device 15 due to the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect (HOM). A device 15 may be called an “interference device” or a “one-way interference device”.
[0099] Each device 15 may, for example, comprise: a beamsplitter (e.g. a 50:50 beamsplitter), a 2X2 directional coupler (e.g. a bent directional coupler), a 2X2 multimode interference (MMI) coupler, or the like.
[0100] Optical network 22 includes four or more input ports 23 and four or more output ports 24. In some embodiments, network 22 includes 2ninput ports 23 and 2noutput ports 24 where n is an integer and n>2. Each of output ports 24 may be optically connected to a corresponding single photon detector 16. Photon detectors 16 are optionally photon number resolving photon detectors. Each input port 23 may be optically connected to a corresponding quantum system 11 by way of a suitable optical interface such that photons emitted from the quantum system can enter network 22 by the corresponding input port 23. Network 22 may be connected to up to 2nquantum systems 11. In some embodiments, network 22 includes enough input ports 23 such that network 22 may be simultaneously optically connected to up to 16 or 32 or 64 or 128 or 256 or 512 or 1024 or more quantum systems 11.
[0101] The interconnections of devices 15 in network 22 are such that a photon that enters network 22 at any one of input ports 23 can follow a plurality of paths through network 22. Each of the plurality of paths terminates at one of outputs 24. At most there is one path which originates at a particular input port 23 of network 22 and extends to an output port 24 of network 22. The set of all paths that originate from the same input port 23 and extend to different output ports 24 may be called a “bundle” of paths. In some embodiments network 22 is structured so that each bundle of paths includes paths that extend to each of output ports 24 of network 22.
[0102] ln some embodiments, network 22 is constructed such that the paths thatoriginate from each input port 23 (i.e. each bundle of paths) form a binary tree, wherein each node of the binary tree corresponds to a device 15 of network 22. Two paths that originate from the same input port 23 and have a node in common bifurcate at the node. In some embodiments, the binary tree of paths that originates at each input port 23 includes a plurality of paths that includes one path that terminates at each one of output ports 24 of network 22. The paths that belong to a single binary tree do not interfere with themselves (i.e. none of the paths includes any closed loops and none of the binary trees of paths includes two paths that respectively enter the same device 15 at different input ports of the device 15). Each path that enters a device 15 bifurcates at the device 15, since the path can continue via either one of the output ports of the device 15.
[0103] In some embodiments, each of the paths of the bundles of paths passes through the same number of devices 15 before reaching the output port 24 to which the path extends. Devices 15 may be interconnected in such a way that each device 15 belongs to a level. The first level includes the first devices 15 encountered when traversing each path starting from an input port 23, the second level includes those devices 15 that are the second devices 15 encountered when traversing a path starting at an input path 23 and so on. In some embodiments, each device 15 belongs to exactly one level.
[0104] In some embodiments, for each of the bundles of paths, the intersection of a set of all of the devices 15 that paths of the bundle of paths extend through with a set of all of the devices 15 that paths of another one of the bundles of paths extend through is non-zero for a plurality of other ones of the bundles of paths. In some embodiments, the intersections of these sets is non-zero for all other bundles of paths in the network 22.
[0105] In some embodiments, network 22 is arranged so that the optical path length along each path, from the input port 23 at which the path starts to the first level device 15 that the path enters are equal such that the time taken for a photon to travel from an input port 23 to a first level device 15 along any of the paths is substantially the same. Similarly, the portions of each path between the first and second level devices 15 that the path passes through may be made equal such that the time taken for a photon to travel from an input port 23 to a second level device 15 along any of the paths is substantially the same, and so on for each level included in network 22.
[0106] In some embodiments, the binary tree of paths that originate at one input port 23 shares at least one common node with the binary trees that originate from each of the other input ports 23 of network 22. A common node shared by binary trees that respectively originate from first and second ones of input ports 23 corresponds to a device 15 at which photons that enter network 22 at the first and second ones of input ports 23 can interfere with one another. In some embodiments, the binary tree of paths that originate at any input port 23 shares at least one common node with the each of the binary trees that respectively originate from each of the other input ports 23 of network 22.
[0107] In some embodiments, network 22 includes n×2n-1devices 15 (e.g. four devices 15 for n=2, 32 devices 15 for n=4 etc.). Fig. 3 shows an example apparatus 30 that includes a passive optical network 22A for the case n=2. Network 22A comprises four devices 15 arranged in two levels, L1 and L2. Devices 15 are individually identified as 15-1, J where I and J are indices that respectively indicate a level and column in which the device 15 is located.
[0108] Quantum systems 11-1 through 11-4 are respectively optically coupled to input ports 23-1 to 23-4. Single photon detectors 16-1 to 16-4 are respectively coupled to output ports 24-1 to 24-4.
[0109] When a photon enters an input port 23 of network 22, the photon can travel to a detector 16 via any path in the binary tree of paths that originate from the input port 23 at which the photon entered network 22. Until the photon is detected or participates in some other interaction that collapses the wavefunction of the photon, the photon can be in a superposition of states that explore all paths of the binary tree corresponding to the input port 23 at which the photon entered network 22.
[0110] Apparatus 10A can be used to attempt entanglement of any pair of quantum systems 11-1 to 11-4 by causing the quantum systems of the pair to emit photons into network 22A.
[0111] The simplest case to understand is the case where the two input ports 23 that receive photons from quantum systems 11 are two input ports 23 that connect to input ports of the same device 15 in level L1 (e.g. input ports 23-1 and 23-2 of apparatus 10A which receive photons from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-2 respectively). In this example, photons from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-2 interfere at the first device 15 that they encounter (here device 15-1,1). Quantum interferenceat device 15-1,1 eliminates path information.
[0112] The rest of network 22 effectively acts as two single-photon detectors. Any photons that are detected by detector 16-1 and / or 16-2 must have left device 15-1,1 through output port 15C and passed through device 15-2,1. Thus, detectors 16-1 and 16-2 together can effectively act as a single detector 16 connected to detect photons that leave device 15-1,1 through output port 15C. Any photons that are detected by detector 16-3 and / or 16-4 must have left device 15-1,1 through output port 15D and passed through device 15-2,2. Thus, detectors 16-3 and / or 16-4 together can effectively act as a single detector 16 connected to detect photons that leave device 15-1,1 through output port 15D.
[0113] In another case, the two input ports 23 that receive photons from quantum systems 11 are two input ports 23 that connect to input ports of different devices 15 (e.g. input ports 23-1 and 23-4 of apparatus 10A which receive photons from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 respectively). In this example, a photon from quantum system 11-1 reaches device 15-1,1. With 50% probability, the photon leaves device 15-1,1 at output port 15C to arrive at device 15-2,1 and with 50% probability the photon leaves device 15-1,1 at output port 15D to arrive at device 15-2,2. Similarly, a photon from quantum system 11-4 reaches device 15-1,2. With 50% probability, the photon leaves device 15-1,2 at output port 15C to arrive at device 15-2,1 and with 50% probability the photon leaves device 15-1,2 at output port 15D to arrive at device 15-2,2. As mentioned above, until it is detected, the wavefunction for each photon includes components that correspond to each of these possibilities. Also, if two indistinguishable photons interfere with one another at a device 15 and a photon is detected at a detector 16 at the end of a path that passes through that device 15, then it is not possible to determine from which quantum system 11 the detected photon originated from.
[0114] Where a particular stimulus is delivered to each of two participating quantum systems 11 (e.g. quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4) the quantum systems each emit a photon state into network 22. This may be described as “injecting” photon states into network 22. The photon states can be visualized as wavefunctions which propagate through network 22 on all available paths which begin at the input port 23 at which the photon state entered network 22.
[0115] The photon states from the two participating quantum systems interfere withone another at each device 15 that is along at least one path available to the photon state from a first one of the participating quantum systems and at least one path available to the photon state of a second one of the participating quantum systems. For the case where the participating quantum systems are quantum system 11 -1 and quantum system 11-4, interference of the photon states occurs at devices 15-2,1 and 15-2,2.
[0116] If each of the participating quantum systems is in a superposition of a state for which no photon is emitted from the quantum system when the particular stimulus is delivered to the quantum system and a state for which one photon is emitted from the quantum system when the particular stimulus is delivered to the quantum system then, assuming no photon loss, either zero, one or two photons are available for detection by detectors 16. Where two photons are detected, there are six possibilities for the detectors 16 at which those photons may be detected. Four of those possibilities are that both photons may be detected at detector 16-1, 16-2, 16-3, or 16-4. A result of the Hong-Ou-Mandel effect is that detection of one photon at each of detectors 16-1 and 16-2 should not occur and detection of one photon at each of detectors 16-3 and 16-4 should not occur. In the fifth and sixth possibilities, one photon is detected at one of detectors 16-1 and 16-2 and another photon is detected at one of detectors 16-3 and 16-4. Only two of the four possible combinations of one of detectors 16-1 and 16-2 with one of detectors 16-3 and 16-4 are possibilities because for the other two of these combinations, phase differences between the photon states results in destructive interference which reduces the probability that one photon will be detected at each of the photon detectors of these combinations to zero.
[0117] In the case where only one photon is detected, the photon may be detected at any of detectors 16-1 to 16-4.
[0118] In each of these cases, where the photons are indistinguishable, it is not possible to determine which one of the participating quantum systems 11 emitted any detected photon. The interactions of the photons with one another in network 22 eliminates path information.
[0119] As described in more detail below, for any selected pair of quantum systems 11, certain patterns of photon detections (clicks) at one or more stages of an entanglement protocol can herald entanglement of the pair of quantum systems.
[0120] Apparatus 30 includes a control system 28. Control system 28 may be configured to control apparatus 30 to entangle selected pairs of quantum systems 11 according to an entanglement protocol. In some embodiments, in response to a request to attempt to entangle the quantum states of two selected quantum systems 11 (“participating quantum systems”) control system 28 may generate control signals which implement an entanglement protocol. The specific steps coordinated by control system 28 will depend on the entanglement protocol. Method S40 (see Fig. 4) is one example of an entanglement protocol that may be coordinated by control system 28. Control system 28 may for example, generate control signals which control apparatus 10A to perform one or more of:• determine a pair of quantum systems that will participate in an entanglement attempt (these may be called “participating quantum systems”);• apply stimulation to be applied to two participating quantum systems;• apply quantum gates to one or more quantum systems 11;• modify quantum states of one or more quantum systems 11;• obtain information identifying any photon detections (e.g. which detector(s) 16 clicked in response to delivery of stimuli to two participating quantum systems); and• process photon detection information to determine whether a pattern of photon detections matches an entanglement heralding pattern.
[0121] Control systems incorporated into the present technology (e.g. a control system 28) may, for example, be implemented using: specifically designed hardware, configurable hardware, programmable data processors configured by the provision of software (which may optionally comprise “firmware”) capable of executing on the data processors, special purpose computers or data processors that are specifically programmed, configured, or constructed to perform one or more steps in a method as explained in detail herein and / or combinations of two or more of these. All of these can be generally described as “electronic logic”.
[0122] Examples of specifically designed hardware are: logic circuits, applicationspecific integrated circuits (“ASICs”), large scale integrated circuits (“ LSIs”), very large-scale integrated circuits (“VLSIs”), and the like. Examples of configurable hardware are: one or more programmable logic devices such as programmable array logic (“PALs”), programmable logic arrays (“PLAs”), and field programmable gatearrays (“FPGAs”).
[0123] Examples of programmable data processors are: microprocessors, digital signal processors (“DSPs”), embedded processors, graphics processors, math coprocessors, general purpose computers, server computers, cloud computers, mainframe computers, computer workstations, and the like. For example, one or more data processors in a control circuit for a device may implement methods as described herein by executing software instructions in a program memory accessible to the processors.
[0124] In some embodiments, control systems include both data processors that execute software instructions and fast electronics that perform synchronized control of actions performed on quantum systems 11 on fast time scales). For example, a control system 28 may comprise a plurality of instruction queuing units (IQUs). Each of the IQUs comprises a data processor that executes software instructions, a queue, and queue control logic. Each of the IQUs is associated with a corresponding controllable device that can influence the state of a quantum system 11 and / or otherwise influence operation of apparatus as described herein. Each queue is configured to hold: a plurality of micro-instructions for control of the corresponding device; and a time point associated with each of the plurality of micro-instructions. The data processor of each IQU may be configured to process instructions for the corresponding device and, in response to the instructions, insert micro-instructions for controlling the corresponding device and the time point associated with each inserted micro-instruction into the queue of the IQU. The queue control logic is configured to release the micro-instructions for controlling the corresponding device at times based on the time point associated with each of the micro-instructions. Execution of the micro-instructions may occur in a deterministic domain.
[0125] Coordination of operations on quantum systems 11 may be facilitated by a precision timing system such as a distributed global clock signal or a precision timing system such as the Precision Time Protocol (PTP) extensions to the Ethernet protocol to achieve nanosecond or sub-nanosecond synchronization across all hardware control systems.
[0126] Apparatus as described herein may be used to implement an entanglement protocol to entangle any pair of quantum systems 11 that are each coupled to corresponding inputs 23 of network 22. For example, Fig. 4 is a flow chart for anexample method S40 for generating entanglement of the quantum states of two quantum systems 11. Method S40 is a modified version of the BK protocol.
[0127] In this example, each quantum system 11 has quantum basis states |0) and |1). The quantum state of the quantum system 11 may be |0) or |1) ora superposition of |0) and |1). If quantum system 11 is stimulated (e.g. by delivering an appropriate stimulus such as an optical pulse to the quantum system 11) when in state 10>, no photon is emitted. If quantum system 11 is stimulated when in state 11>, one photon is emitted. For example, qubits 11 may comprise particles that have an intrinsic spin of1 / 2 and quantum states |0) and |1) may comprise spin states of the particle.
[0128] At block S41, the two quantum systems 11 to be entangled are each initialized in a superposition of basis states |0) and |1) (e.g. (|0) + |1) )).
[0129] At block S42, the two quantum systems 11 to be entangled, and only those two quantum systems, are stimulated to emit photons having photon states that are entangled with the respective quantum states of the two participating quantum systems 11. The photons are received at the corresponding input ports 23 of network 22. As a result of interactions of each of the photons with network 22 as described herein, the photons will interfere with one another at a device 15. Consequently, one or more of single photon detectors 16 may detect a photon (a “click”).
[0130] At block S43, the quantum state of each of the two participating quantum system 11 is inverted (i.e. |0) |l) and |1) |0)). Inversion may, for example comprise applying a suitable electromagnetic waveform, such as a pulse or series of pulses, to each of the two participating quantum systems 11. In embodiments where the quantum states comprise intrinsic spin states, block S43 may comprise flipping the spins (e.g. so that spin up becomes spin down and vice versa).
[0131] At block S44, the two quantum systems 11 to be entangled, and only those two quantum systems, are stimulated a second time to emit photon states that are entangled with the respective quantum states of the two quantum systems 11. As in block S42, the photon states are received at the corresponding input ports 23 of network 22. As a result of interactions of each of the photon states with network 22 as described herein the photon states will interfere with one another at a device 15. Consequently, one or more of single photon detectors 16 detect a photon (a “click”).
[0132] At block S45, clicks detected in blocks S42 and S44 are processed to determine whether the patterns of clicks correspond to a pattern that heraldsentanglement of the two participating quantum systems 11. If the pattern of clicks is not a pattern that heralds entanglement of the two participating quantum systems, then block S46 returns to block S41 to repeat the attempt to entangle the two participating quantum systems (or to attempt to entangle a different pair of two quantum systems 11). If the pattern of clicks does correspond to heralded entanglement, then block S46 causes method S40 to proceed to block S48.
[0133] The particular patterns that herald entanglement of the two participating quantum systems 11 depend on which ones of quantum systems 11 are the two participating quantum systems 11 and may also depend on the entanglement protocol that is being implemented.
[0134] For the case of the entanglement protocol implemented in method S40 and other similar methods, entanglement is heralded whenever one and only one photon is detected in each of blocks S42 and S44 so long as each detector that registers a click is downstream from an output port of a devices 15 at which interference between photon states from the two participating quantum systems 11 could occur.
[0135] A complete set of heralding patterns for a particular pair of participating quantum systems 11 in a particular network 22 may be identified by finding all common nodes of the binary trees corresponding to the two participating quantum systems 11 (i.e. finding all devices 15 at which interference between photon states from the two participating quantum systems could occur). Each device 15 at which such interference could occur has two output ports. Identify a first set of one or more detectors 16 that can be reached via a first one of those output ports and identify a second set of one or more detectors 16 that can be reached via a second one of those output ports. Because of the binary tree structure of paths in network 22, these two sets of detectors 16 will be disjoint.
[0136] Where the entanglement protocol that is being implemented is method S40 or similar methods, entanglement may be heralded when one of these two sets of detectors registers zero clicks and the other one of these two sets of detectors registers one click in each of blocks S42 and S44 while other detectors 16 that are not reachable from either of these output ports record zero clicks.
[0137] For example, with apparatus 10 of Fig. 3, where the two participating quantum systems are quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4, interference of photon states may occur at device 15-2,1 or device 15-2,2. Furthermore, the BK protocol is designed toherald entanglement in either one of the Bell states |Ψ+⟩ and |Ψ-⟩ in which spins of the participating quantum systems are anti-correlated. Therefore, for successful heralding using the modified BK protocol of method S40, only one photon should be detected in each of blocks S42 and S44. For example, entanglement is heralded if any of the following patterns is detected in block S42 and any of the following patterns are detected in block S44:• A click at detector 16-1 and no click for any other detector 16;• A click at detector 16-2 and no click for any other detector 16;• A click at detector 16-3 and no click for any other detector 16; and• A click at detector 16-4 and no click for any other detector 16.Any pattern not in the preceding list (i.e. no click in any detector 16 or clicks in two or more of detectors 16) in block S42 or S44 indicates that entanglement of quantum systems 11-1 and 11-2 was not successfully heralded.
[0138] Successful heralding of quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 under the modified BK protocol of method S40 can correspond to any of the following combinations of detected clicks in blocks S42 and S44:where the first number indicates a detector that clicks at block S42 and the second number identifies the detector that clicks at block S44. For example, {1,2} indicates that block S42 resulted in a detection of a click at detector 16-1 and block S44 resulted in detection of a click at detector 16-2.
[0139] For the case where the pair of participating quantum systems are quantum systems 11-1 and 11-2 in Fig. 3, entanglement is heralded by a click at only one of photon detectors 16-1 to 16-4 in block S42 and a click at only one of photon detectors 16-1 to 16-4 in block S42. Whether the heralded entangled state is |Ψ+⟩ or |Ψ-⟩ can be determined from the specific photon detectors which click in blocks S42 and S44 and the identity of the participating quantum systems 11.
[0140] For example, any of the following patterns herald entanglement of quantum systems 11-1 and 11-2:
[0141] Block S48 applies a phase correction to the participating quantum systems 11to compensate for differences in the optical path lengths from the two participating quantum systems to the device 15 at which interference between photon states from the two participating quantum systems can occur. In most cases, these path length differences will not be zero due to device-level imperfections. As a result, there will typically be some nonzero phase which differentiates the heralded state from the desired maximally entangled state (e.g. a Bell state). If the path length differences are static (i.e. do not change over the time required to perform method S40), then the undesired phase can be determined and compensated for. In some embodiments, phase corrections are determined in advance (for example, by performing a calibration process as described elsewhere herein), and determining the phase correction may comprise looking up a predetermined phase correction based on the identities of the participating quantum systems 11 and the pattern of detector clicks in blocks S42 and S44 that heralded entanglement of the participating quantum systems.
[0142] Block S48 includes block S48A which determines a value of a correction to compensate for the undesired phase and block S48B which alters the heralded state to compensate for the undesired phase using the correction determined in block S48A. Block S48A determines the correction based at least in part on the heralding pattern (i.e. which detectors 16 recorded clicks in each of blocks S42 and S44). The heralding pattern, taken together with the identities of the participating quantum systems, indicates the device(s) 15 at which interference of photon states occurred in each of blocks S42 and S44. Block S48A may use information about network 22 (e.g. information derived from the design of network 22 and / or calibration measurements performed on network 22) which can be used as a basis for determining the value of the undesired phase.
[0143] In some embodiments, block S48A comprises looking up a phase correction in a lookup table. Looking up the phase correction may use a key based on the detector clicks in blocks S42 and S44 as well as the identities of the participating quantum systems 11.
[0144] In some embodiments, block S48A uses the heralding pattern as a key to look up values that are combined to determine a value for the undesired phase or a correction to be applied to compensate for the undesired phase or a specific correction to be applied to compensate for the undesired phase (e.g. specification ofone or more stimuli, such as optical or other electromagnetic pulses, to be applied to one or both of the two participating quantum systems 11 to compensate for the undesired phase).
[0145] In some embodiments, block S48A comprises calculating a correction to be applied to the participating quantum systems 11.
[0146] Block S48B may, for example, comprise applying a partial Z-rotation to the heralded state with the angle of the partial Z rotation depending on the result of the determination made in block S48A. In some embodiments performing the phase correction comprises driving the two participating quantum systems 11 with optical or other electromagnetic pulses.
[0147] In some embodiments, block S48B is combined with another operation to be performed on the participating quantum systems 11. For example, the participating quantum systems 11 may be used in performance of a quantum informatics process which involves a specified Z-rotation. Instead of performing block S48B and the specified Z-rotation separately, a single Z rotation that combines the correction of block S48B and the specified Z rotation of the quantum informatics process into a single Z rotation is applied to the participating quantum systems 11.Example
[0148] Consider the example of an attempt to entangle quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 of apparatus 30. In block S42 a photon is detected at detector 16-a (where a G {1,2, 3, 4} and in block S44 a photon is detected at detector 16-b where b G {1,2, 3, 4}. Including phases relevant to the optical path length after block S42, and post-selecting for the heralding condition {a,b}, since the stimulation in block S42 is state selective and only selects the |1> state, the combined state for quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 is given by:Where: a is an index which indicates which detector 16 clicked in block S42 (since the photons are indistinguishable it is impossible to know which quantum system 11-1 or 11-4 emitted the photon that caused detector a to click), k is the wavenumber of the emitted indistinguishable photons, φ1(a) and φ4(a) respectively represent the phase resulting from the path length from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 to the device 15 at which interference occurred in block S42 (that device 15 is uniquely identified by theknowledge that the photon was detected at detector 16-a). The notation 101, 0) indicates a quantum state in which quantum system 11-1 is in the state |0) and no photon was emitted by quantum system 11-1 in block S42, the notation |14, la) indicates a quantum state in which quantum system 11-4 is in the state |1>, one photon was emitted by quantum system 11-4 in block S42 and the photon was detected at detector 16-a.
[0149] In cases where the wavenumber of photons in network 22 is sufficiently constant, the phase φ4(a) may be given by kx4(a) where k is the wavenumber for the photons and x4(a) is a distance from quantum system 11-4 to the device 15 at which interference of the photon states occurred. Similarly, the phase φ1(a) may be given by kx1(a) where x1(a) is a distance from quantum system 11-1 to the device 15 at which interference of the photon states occurred.
[0150] After the inversion of block S43, and the interference at block S44, with post selection for the heralding condition {a,b}, the combined quantum state of quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 is:where b is an index as defined above, φ1(b) and φ4(b) are the phases introduced as a result of the optical path lengths from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 respectively to the device 15 at which interference occurs in block S44 (which device 15 is uniquely identified by the fact that the photon was detected by detector 16-b in block S44). If the optical path lengths from quantum systems 11 to devices 15 are stable over the course of one iteration of method S40, one can assume that where a and b both indicate that interference occurred at the same device 15 in blocks S42 and S44 then φ1(b) = φ1(a) and also that φ4(b) = φ4(a). There are many cases where one iteration of method S40 can be executed in a time that is on the order of microseconds ( / zs). For many possible constructions of network 22, the optical paths lengths are stable at this time scale (and even much longer time scales). This example assumes that φ1(b) = φ1(a) and φ4(b) = φ4(a). when interference occurs at the same device 15 in block S42 and S44 in an iteration of method S40.
[0151] Expanding expression (2) and post-selecting on one of the heralding conditions given above, shows that the combined state of quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 after block S44 is a heralded Bell state with some undesired phase φ. For the case where the heralding condition is {1,1}, the heralded state after block S40 is:After factoring out a global phase, we can write this state as:For the heralding condition {1,1}, there is no unwanted phase. This makes sense since the same device 15 (in this case, device 15-2,1) is the only device 15 that contributes to the path erasure for the heralding condition {1,1}.
[0152] The same approach can be used to determine the combined state of quantum systems 11 -1 and 11 -4 for the case where the heralding pattern is {1,3}. This heralding pattern again heralds the state |'P+). However, in this case, photon states from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 interfere at device 15-2,1 in block S42 and photon states from quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 interfere at device 15-2,2 in block S44. In this case the heralded state is:After factoring out a global phase, the heralded state can be written as the desired Bell state with the added phase <p as follows:The value of φ given by expression (7) may be non-zero, in which case there will be a non-zero phase φ differentiating the heralded state from the desired Bell state. Where the path length differences are static, the undesired phase φ can be calibrated out in block S48.
[0153] Equation (7) can be generalized to the heralding pattern {a,b} for the case where the participating quantum systems 11 are at input ports 23-e and 23-f as follows:Calibration
[0154] As described elsewhere herein, an entangled state of two quantum systems 11 can differ from a desired maximally entangled state by a phase, φ, which can result from differences in path lengths from the participating quantum systems 11 to devices 15 at which interference between photon states of photons emitted from the participating quantum systems 11 can occur. A correction can be applied to theparticipating quantum systems to reduce or eliminate the undesired phase. The magnitude of the correction depends on which quantum systems 11 are the participating quantum systems 11 and in which device(s) 15 did interference between photon states occur during the process of entangling the participating quantum systems. The corrections may be determined in advance.
[0155] One way to find the corrections (which is equivalent to determining the phase φ) is to perform entanglement attempts on different pairs of participating quantum systems 11 and to determine the phase, <p’ by performing measurements on the pairs of participating quantum systems 11 for which entanglement is heralded. This may be repeated until the phase, φ, is known for each pair of participating quantum systems for each heralding condition. As mentioned elsewhere herein, for certain pairs of quantum systems 11 and / or for certain heralding conditions, it may be known without measurement that φ = 0. It may be considered unnecessary to make measurements to determine the value for, φ, for these cases.
[0156] A disadvantage of this approach is that the number of entanglement attempts that would need to be performed in order to determine the phase, φ, for all pairs of quantum systems 11 and all heralding conditions for each pair increases rapidly as the size of network 22 and the numbers of quantum systems 11 are scaled up.
[0157] Another approach to determining values of the phase, φ, for the possible heralding conditions for possible pairs of quantum systems 11 may be called “laser calibration”. Laser calibration involves two beams of coherent light that are phase matched. The two beams of coherent light could be obtained for example by splitting a coherent light beam (e.g. a laser beam) into two parts (e.g. by a beamsplitter) or by using beams output by two phase locked lasers. Each of the coherent beams (which may be called beam parts) are delivered into one of a pair of input ports 23 of a network 22.
[0158] The laser light (more generally coherent light) from each beam part will propagate through network 22 to each of output ports 24 by following the bundle of paths through network 22 that originate at the corresponding input port 23.Consequently, each output port 24 will receive light from both beam parts. If the path lengths from the point at which the laser beam is split or the two phase locked laser beams are generated to an output port 24 differ by an integer number (i.e. 0, 1, 2, 3, etc.) of wavelengths of the laser light then the two parts of the laser beam willconstructively interfere at the output port 24. If the path lengths from the point at which the laser beam is split or the phase locked beams are generated to the output port 24 differ by an odd number of half wavelengths of the laser light (i.e. %, 1 %, 2% wavelengths etc.) then the two beam parts will destructively interfere at the output port 24. The difference in path lengths for the two parts of the laser light may vary among output ports 24.
[0159] For any wavelength of the laser light, the interference between the two parts of the laser light may be at a different phase between maximum constructive interference and maximum destructive interference. The phase difference between the interference at two output ports 24 is equivalent (up to a wavelength dependence) to the phase accumulated during an entanglement attempt that is heralded by photon detections at those output ports 24. The wavelength dependence may be accounted for by sweeping the wavelength of the laser. In many practical cases, the dispersion is very small so that over the sweep window there is no significant wavelength dependence.
[0160] The wavelength of the laser light is varied (e.g. swept). As the wavelength is varied, the intensity of the laser light detected at the output port 24 (e.g. by the corresponding detector 16) will change, depending on the relative phases of the two parts of the laser beam at the output port 24. For example, as the wavelength of the laser light is swept, at each output port 24, the intensity of the laser light 24 will form a fringe pattern made up of alternating peaks (corresponding to constructive interference) and valleys (corresponding to destructive interference). Measurements of the intensity of the laser light at each output port 24 may be performed concurrently.
[0161] For example, Fig. 3A shows a laser 33 which emits a laser beam 34 that is split into two parts, 34A and 34B by a beam splitter 35. Parts 34A and 34B are delivered into two input ports 23 of a network 22. In this example, network 22 is the same as network 22 of apparatus 30 and has four input ports 23 and four output ports 24. Laser beam part 34A is delivered into input port 23-1 and laser beam part 34B is delivered into input port 23-4. Laser beam parts 34A and 34B can interfere at devices 15-2,1 and 15-2,2.
[0162] A goal of this example is to find phases, φ, that correspond to particular heralding patterns. For example, the setup shown in Fig. 3A could be used todetermine the phase corresponding to the heralding pattern {1,3} for the case where photon states are injected into optical network 22 at input ports 11-1 and 11-4. The same setup coud be used to assess phse differences corresponding to other possible heralding patterns.
[0163] The phase difference between fringe patterns at detectors 16-1 and 16-3 is equivalent to the phase <p (see equation (7)) that would accumulate on an entangled state heralded by clicks on detectors 16-1 and 16-3 in blocks S42 and S44 of method S40 respectively.
[0164] In the example of Fig. 3A, the difference between the phases of the first part 34A of laser beam 34 and the second part 34B of laser beam 34 at detector 16-1 is:where xpalh 37Ais the optical path length from the point at which first part 34A separates from second part 34B at beamsplitter 35 to detector 16-1 via input port 23-1 following path 37A and xpalh 37Bis the optical path length from the point at which second part 34B separates from first part 34A at beamsplitter 35 to detector 16-1 via input port 23-4 following path 37B.
[0165] Similarly, the difference between the phases of the first part 34A of laser beam 34 and the second part 34B of laser beam 34 at detector 16-3 is:where xpalh 37Cis the optical path length from the point at which first part 34A separates from second part 34B at beamsplitter 35 to detector 16-3 via input port 23-1 following path 37C and xpath 37Dis the optical path length from the point at which second part 34B separates from first part 34A at beamsplitter 35 to detector 16-3 via input port 23-4 following path 37D. Note that in Fig. 3A, paths 37A to 37D are shown schematically. Fig. 3A is not intended to accurately depict these paths.
[0166] Therefore, the phase <p can be expressed as:where paths 37A’ through 37D’ are respectively the portions of paths 37A through 37D located between lines 38-1 and 38-2 of Fig. 3A.
[0167] Equation (10) may be modified to include a correction to account for phasedifferences between laser beam parts 34A and 34B caused by differences in the optical path lengths from the point at which laser beam parts 34A and 34B are separated and the points at which the laser beam parts enter the corresponding optical ports 23 of network 22.
[0168] The value of <p determined by measuring the phase differences between laser beam parts 34A and 34B which enter network 22 at two input ports 23 at two of detectors 16 is the same as the undesired phase <p in the quantum state of two quantum systems 11 associated with the same two input ports 23 where the entanglement is heralded by photons detected at the same two detectors (in this example, the undesired phase acquired in an entanglement attempt between quantum systems 11-1 and 11-4 which are respectively coupled to input ports 23-1 and 23-4 where entanglement is heralded by clicks at detectors 16-1 and 16-3).
[0169] In some embodiments, quantum systems 11 are each associated with an optical cavity 39. The optical cavity 39 may improve coupling of photons emitted from the quantum system 11 into network 22. For example, the optical cavity may function as an optical resonator that has or can be tuned to have a resonant frequency that coincides with a frequency of photons emitted from the quantum system 11 (e.g. in performance of a method as described herein). In some embodiments, the optical cavities are photonic crystal cavities (e.g. 1D photonic crystal nanocavities). In some embodiments cavities 39 are incorporated into an optical path, such as an optical waveguide, that is connected to or incorporated into network 22. Cavities 39 may be asymmetric.
[0170] In some embodiments, laser beam parts 34A and 34B are each introduced into network 22 by way of a cavity 39. For example, the laser beam parts may each be reflected from a cavity 39 that is optically connected to an input port 23 of network 22. A measurable amount of laser light will be reflected from each cavity 39 and directed into a corresponding input port 23 of network 22. In this manner, laser beam parts 34A, 34B may be directed into different pairs of input ports 23 of network 22. Resulting detections of light from laser beam parts 34A and 34B to detectors 16 may be processed to obtain calibration information as described herein.
[0171] In some embodiments, laser beam parts 34A, 34B are directed into selected input ports 23 of a network 22 by way of an optical switch. The optical switch may be configurable to direct laser beam parts 34A, 34B into any pair of input ports 23 forwhich an undesired phase, <f>, may be included in the quantum state of entangled quantum systems 11 that are associated with the pair of ports. In some embodiments, laser beam parts 34A, 34B are introduced into network 22 via optical paths that are separate from optical paths that carry photons from quantum systems 11 into network 22.
[0172] In some embodiments, calibration involves: a) introducing first and second coherent parts of a coherent light beam into respective input ports of an optical network 22; b) receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light; c) processing the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; and generating calibration data based on the phase differences. These steps may be repeated while delivering the first and second parts of the coherent light beam into different pairs of the input ports of the optical network 22.Larger Networks
[0173] Networks 22 as described herein may be scaled up to allow for entanglement of pairs of quantum systems selected from a larger number of quantum systems 11 than the four quantum systems 11 of apparatus 10A.
[0174] Fig. 5 shows apparatus 50 which is similar to apparatus 30 but for the case n=4. In this example, network 22A is made up of 32 interconnected devices 15 and has sixteen input ports 23 and sixteen output ports 24. Quantum systems 11-1 to 11-16 are respectively optically coupled to input ports 23-1 to 23-16 and single photon detectors 16-1 to 16-16 are respectively optically coupled to output ports 24-1 to 24-16.
[0175] In apparatus 50, from any input port 23 sixteen paths extend through network 22A. Each of these paths extends to a different output port 24 of network 22A. The collection of these sixteen paths forms a binary tree that begins at the corresponding input port 23.
[0176] Using network 22, quantum systems 11 that are optically connected to any two of input ports 23 can be entangled - provided that photons from other quantum systems 11 do not enter network 22 at the same times as the photons from the two quantum systems that are to be entangled.
[0177] As is the case with apparatus 30 of Fig. 3, the simplest case to analyze iswhere the two quantum systems to be entangled are respectively coupled to one of two input ports 23 which connect to the same first level device 15. In this case, interference between photons emitted from the two participating quantum systems occurs at that first level device 15. In this scenario, the rest of the network effectively acts as two single-photon detectors which respectively detect photons that exit the first level device 15 from the first and second output ports 15C, 15D of that device 15.
[0178] In this scenario, the detection signals for the eight photon detectors which can be reached by paths which leave the first level device 15 through a first output port 15C may be summed as can detection signals from the eight other photon detectors which can be reached by paths which leave the first level device 15 through a second output port 15D.
[0179] The interconnections of network 22A, are such that the first two levels of network 22A can be viewed as being made up of four adjacent blocks of four interconnected devices 15, one of which is indicated as block 51. Each of these blocks 51 can be seen to have the same interconnections as network 22 of apparatus 30. In the case where two quantum systems which will participate in an entanglement protocol are coupled to input ports 23 respectively connected to a different one of the two first level devices 15 in the same block 51 then the rest of network 22A can be visualized as a set of four detectors which respectively detect photons from a different one of the four output ports of the two second level devices of the block 51. This is illustrated in Fig. 5A. In this example, the summed detection(s) of detectors 16-1 through 16-4; 16-5 to 16-8, 16-9-16-12 and 16-13 to 16-16 are respectively equivalent to the outputs of detectors 16-1, 16-2, 15-3 and 16-4 of apparatus 30.
[0180] For the case where two quantum systems to be entangled are separated more widely, interference occurs at higher level devices 15. For example, Figs, 6A and 6B are schematic illustrations showing two example binary trees 61 and 62 respectively provided by network 22A of apparatus 50. Binary tree 61 begins at input port 23-6. Binary tree 62 begins at input port 23-11. In this example, each binary tree comprises sixteen paths (where each output port 24-1 to 24-16 is at the end of a separate path of the bundle of paths). Eight pairs of the paths respectively pass through a corresponding one of devices 15-4,1 to 15-4,8 in the fourth level of network 22. Each path passes through four devices 15 before it reaches an output port 24 of network 22.
[0181] Comparing Figs. 6A and 6B it can be seen that interference between photons which enter network 22 can occur in any of the devices 15 in the fourth level of network 22 (i.e. devices 15-4,1 to 15-4,8) but not at any other devices 15 of network 22 of apparatus 50.
[0182] In this scenario, a successful round of the entangling protocol of method S40 may produce the following heralding conditions (where p and q respectively represent the number of the detector which detects a photon in blocks S42 and S44. For example, if detector 16-1 clicks in block S42 then p=1, if detector 11 detects a photon in block S44 then q=11.
[0183] In networks 22 like those shown in Figs. 3 and 5, the depth of binary trees (the number of levels in the network) increases at a rate of log2(N) where N is the number of input ports 23 in the network. That is a very desirable feature. However, the total number of crossings of waveguides 25 scales with O(N). Each waveguide crossing can be a very low loss element. But many of them at large N can result in considerable photon losses.
[0184] Fig. 5B illustrates a network 22B that has an alternative interconnection topology that provides the same number of input ports 23 and output ports 24 while reducing the number of waveguide crossings by about one half while preserving the same functionality.
[0185] An advantage of the present technology is that network 22 may be passive (without switches that are controlled to change a configuration of network 22). This can facilitate making network 22 more reliable, less expensive to produce and / or lower loss than active switching networks for supporting entanglement of similar numbers of quantum systems 11. In addition, network 22 does not require time to change the states of active switches.
[0186] In some embodiments, network 22 is completely passive (i.e. lacks any components such as optical switches that can be controlled to alter a configuration of network 22). In such embodiments, network 22 does not include controllable components.
[0187] In some embodiments, network 22 includes one or more controllablecomponents (e.g. devices 15 and / or optical paths 25). For example, network 22 may comprise one or more tunable optical elements. The optical elements may, for example, be tuned to frequencies corresponding to frequencies of photons emitted from quantum systems 11. For example, devices 15 may include controllable elements that are adjustable to optimize devices 15 to promote interference between photon states having a particular frequency (or equivalently wavelength).
[0188] As another example, optical path lengths within network 22 may be adjusted (e.g. by varying the refractive indices in one or more optical paths). Such adjustment of optical path lengths may be used to adjust (e.g. reduce) the phase of quantum states acquired during performance of blocks S42 and S44 of method S40.
[0189] In some such embodiments the controllable elements be maintained in a static state while network 22 is being used. For example, after the controllable elements are initially set in an adjustment or tuning process, control inputs to the controllable elements may remain fixed while network 22 is used (e.g. in performance of method S40 and / or in performing a calibration process as described herein). The adjustment or tuning process may include measuring properties of network 22 (e.g. as described in the section entitled “Calibration” and tuning control inputs to the controllable elements based on results of the measurements.
[0190] In some embodiments, network 22 includes one or more optical switches that are controllable to reconfigure optical connectivity of network 22 for other applications. In cases where such switches are kept in states so that the network 22 remains in a fixed configuration as described herein while network 22 is being used as described herein (e.g. in method S40) network 22 may be considered to be a passive network even though it may include some optical switches that could be used to change a configuration of interconnections of network 22.Example Quantum Systems
[0191] The present technology may be practiced with quantum systems of a wide variety of types. In some embodiments, quantum systems 11 have transitions that correspond to optical wavelengths, the stimuli applied to the quantum systems and the photon states that are emitted by the quantum systems and detected by detector units 14 comprise optical radiation. In some embodiments the optical radiation comprises infrared light. In some embodiments the optical radiation comprises light having a wavelength that corresponds to a telecommunication wavelength band (e.g.O, E, S, C, L or U band).
[0192] It is not mandatory that quantum systems 11 emit optical photons in response to stimulation. In some embodiments, quantum systems 11 emit other electromagnetic photons such as microwave photons. In some such embodiments, apparatus as described herein includes a transducer which converts microwave photons to optical photons. Examples of transducers and associated methods are described, for example in PCT patent publication W02022020951 - STORAGE AND TRANSDUCTION OF QUANTUM INFORMATION, which is hereby incorporated herein by reference for all purposes.
[0193] In some embodiments, quantum systems 11 comprise intrinsic spins and the quantum states of quantum systems 11 that are entangled comprise spin states. For example, the quantum states |0) and |1) may respectively correspond to spin down and spin up spin states |i) and |T) or vice versa.
[0194] In some embodiments the intrinsic spins comprise spin1In some embodiments the quantum systems comprise spin % particles such as electrons, atomic nuclei, and / or holes. In some embodiments the intrinsic spins comprise spin 1 particles, such as an atomic nucleus that has a spin of 1 ora spin 1 hole.
[0195] In some embodiments, the quantum systems are supported in or on a solid substrate. The substrate may, for example, comprise a crystalline material such as silicon, diamond, silicon nitride, gallium arsenide or diamond. In some such embodiments, quantum systems 11 may, for example, comprise impurity atoms, defects, radiation damage centres, quantum dots, or the like. In some such embodiments, other elements of apparatus as described herein are supported on and / or formed in the substrate. For example, waveguides, detectors 16, optical devices (e.g. optical resonators) for coupling to quantum systems 11 may be supported on and / or formed in the substrate.
[0196] In some embodiments, a network 22 is formed on and / or in the same substrate that supports quantum systems 11. In some embodiments, network 22 is formed of a material that is different from a material of the substrate that supports quantum systems 11. For example, network 22 may be formed of a material such as silicon nitride (SiN). In some embodiments, network 22 is formed on a substrate that is separate from a substrate on which quantum systems 11 are supported. In some embodiments, photon detectors 16, network 22, and / or quantum systems 11 aredistributed among two or more separable components connected by optical paths, which may, for example, be provided by optical fibers.
[0197] In some embodiments, quantum systems 11 comprise radiation damage centres in silicon such as T, AI1, Ga1, 1, or M centres.
[0198] In some embodiments quantum systems 11 are of another type that can be optically coupled to a network 22 such as quantum dots, trapped ions, trapped neutral atoms, dopant atoms (e.g. erbium), or the like.Example apparatus for control of quantum systems
[0199] Fig. 7 shows a portion of an apparatus 70 according to an example embodiment of the present technology. Apparatus 70 includes a substrate 11 that supports a plurality of quantum systems 11. Each quantum system 11 is associated with an optical resonator 72 that is formed in or on substrate 71. Optical resonators 72 may, for example, comprise 1D photonic crystal nanocavity resonators.
[0200] When an emission wavelength of a quantum system 11 (e.g. a wavelength of a photon emitted as a result of an optical transition of the quantum system 11 from a higher energy excited state to a lower energy state) matches a resonance wavelength of a resonator72, the decay of the excited state is enhanced by the Purcell effect, the lifetime of the excited state is reduced and the likelihood that the photon will be coupled to a resonant mode of the optical resonator is increased.
[0201] In apparatus 70, one or both of the resonance wavelengths of optical resonators 72 and the emission wavelengths of the associated quantum system 11 are controllable. The resonance wavelength of an optical resonator 72 may, for example, be controlled by varying properties of an electro optic material that is integrated into the optical resonator 72. Apparatus 70 includes electrodes 73A. The resonance wavelength of each optical resonator 82 may be tuned by varying an electrical potential between electrodes 73A.
[0202] In some embodiments, methods as described herein comprise adjusting optical wavelengths of photons emitted from two quantum systems 11 to match one another before stimulating the two quantum systems 11 to emit photons into a network 22.
[0203] The emission wavelength of a quantum system 11 may be controlled by adjusting an electric field at a location of the quantum system 11 (by the Stark effect) Apparatus 70 includes electrodes 73B. The wavelength of photons emitted fromquantum system 11 may be adjusted by varying an electrical potential difference between electrodes 73B.
[0204] The emission wavelength of a quantum system 11 may be controlled by adjusting a strain in substrate 71 in the vicinity of the quantum system 11. Apparatus 70 includes a device 73C that is operable to vary a strain in substrate 71 in the vicinity of the quantum system 11. Device 73C may, for example, comprise a piezoelectric actuator.
[0205] The emission wavelength of a quantum system 11 may be adjusted by altering a magnetic field at the location of the quantum system 11. Device 80 includes an electromagnet 73D that is operable to alter a magnetic field in the vicinity of each quantum system 11.
[0206] Device 70 includes one or more stimulators 12. In this example, stimulators 12 include one or more laser light sources 12A, one or more microwave radiation sources 12B and / or one or more radiofrequency radiation sources 12C. Stimulators 12 are operable to deliver stimulation to quantum systems 11. The stimulation may be provided to implement an entanglement protocol, for example. In some embodiments a single stimulator 12 is arranged to deliver stimulation simultaneously to each of plural quantum systems 11 or to multiple quantum systems 11 on one or more substrates 81 or to all quantum systems 11 in an apparatus 80. In some embodiments, separate stimulators 12 are provided for individual quantum systems 11 or individual groups of quantum systems 11 or quantum systems 11 on different substrates.Program products
[0207] Some aspects of the present technology provide a program product. The program product may comprise any non-transitory medium which carries a set of computer-readable instructions which, when executed by a data processor, cause the data processor to execute a method as described herein. Program products invention may be in any of a wide variety of forms. The program product may comprise, for example, non-transitory media such as magnetic data storage media including floppy diskettes, hard disk drives, optical data storage media including CD ROMs, DVDs, electronic data storage media including ROMs, flash RAM, EPROMs, hardwired or preprogrammed chips (e.g., EEPROM semiconductor chips), nanotechnology memory, or the like. The computer-readable signals on the program product mayoptionally be compressed or encrypted.Variations
[0208] Apparatus and methods as described herein may be applied to implement entanglement protocols other than the protocol exemplified by method S40. For example, other entanglement protocols, such as: a frequency bin protocol, a polarization bin protocol, a single photon protocol ora GHZ state protocol, or the like may be implemented.
[0209] Another example of an entanglement protocol that may be implemented in the present technology is a modified BK protocol in which entanglement of the <t>+and re¬ states is heralded. These are entangled states in which quantum states of the entangled quantum systems are correlated. The <t>+and <t>- states are defined as:Where the states are spin states, <t>+and <t>- may be defined as:Method S40 may be modified to provide an entanglement protocol that heralds the <t>+and <t>- entangled states by modifying steps S42 and S44 to apply stimuli that cause different transitions in the two participating quantum systems. In particular, in blocks S42 and S44 a first one of the quantum systems may be stimulated with a first stimulus that causes emission of a photon if the quantum system is in the state |0) and does not cause emission of a photon if the quantum system is in the state |1). The other participating quantum system may be stimulated with a second stimulus that causes emission of a photon if the quantum system is in the state 11) and does not cause emission of a photon if the quantum system is in the state |0). For example, the first and second stimuli may be selected to excite different transitions of the quantum systems.
[0210] The two quantum systems may be tuned (e.g. by applying electric fields to one or both of the two quantum systems to shift energy levels of the quantum systems by the Stark effect) so that any photons emitted from either of the two quantum systemshave the same wavelength and are indistinguishable.The modified method S40 may be otherwise the same as or similar to method S40.Interpretation of Terms
[0211] Where a component (e.g. a software module, control system, stimulator, optical path, device, device, detector, etc.) is referred to herein, unless otherwise indicated, reference to that component (including a reference to a “means”) should be interpreted as including as equivalents of that component any component which performs the function of the described component (i.e., that is functionally equivalent), including components which are not structurally equivalent to the disclosed structure which performs the function in the illustrated exemplary embodiments of the invention.
[0212] Headings in this document are for convenience only and are not intended to be used in interpreting any terminology used herein..
[0213] Unless the context clearly requires otherwise, throughout the description and the claims:• “comprise”, “comprising”, and the like are to be construed in an inclusive sense, as opposed to an exclusive or exhaustive sense; that is to say, in the sense of “including, but not limited to”;• “connected”, “coupled”, or any variant thereof, means any connection or coupling, either direct or indirect, between two or more elements; the coupling or connection between the elements can be physical, logical, ora combination thereof;• “herein”, “above”, “below”, and words of similar import, when used to describe this specification, shall refer to this specification as a whole, and not to any particular portions of this specification;• “or”, in reference to a list of two or more items, covers all of the following interpretations of the word: any of the items in the list, all of the items in the list, and any combination of the items in the list;• the singular forms “a”, “an”, and “the” also include the meaning of any appropriate plural forms. These terms (“a”, “an”, and “the”) mean one or more unless stated otherwise;• “and / or” is used to indicate one or both stated cases may occur, for example A and / or B includes both (A and B) and (A or B);• “approximately” when applied to a numerical value means the numerical value ± 10%;• where a feature is described as being “optional” or “optionally” present or described as being present “in some embodiments” it is intended that the present disclosure encompasses embodiments where that feature is present and other embodiments where that feature is not necessarily present and other embodiments where that feature is excluded. Further, where any combination of features is described in this application this statement is intended to serve as antecedent basis for the use of exclusive terminology such as "solely," "only" and the like in relation to the combination of features as well as the use of "negative" limitation(s)” to exclude the presence of other features; and• “first” and “second” are used for descriptive purposes and cannot be understood as indicating or implying relative importance or indicating the number of indicated technical features.
[0214] Words that indicate directions such as “vertical”, “transverse”, “horizontal”, “upward”, “downward”, “forward”, “backward”, “inward”, “outward”, “left”, “right”, “front”, “back”, “top”, “bottom”, “below”, “above”, “under”, and the like, used in this description and any accompanying claims (where present), depend on the specific orientation of the apparatus described and illustrated. The subject matter described herein may assume various alternative orientations. Accordingly, these directional terms are not strictly defined and should not be interpreted narrowly.
[0215] Where a range fora value is stated, the stated range includes all sub-ranges of the range. It is intended that the statement of a range supports the value being at an endpoint of the range as well as at any intervening value to the tenth of the unit of the lower limit of the range, as well as any subrange or sets of sub ranges of the range unless the context clearly dictates otherwise or any portion(s) of the stated range is specifically excluded. Where the stated range includes one or both endpoints of the range, ranges excluding either or both of those included endpoints are also included in the invention.
[0216] Certain numerical values described herein are preceded by "about". In this context, "about" provides literal support for the exact numerical value that it precedes, the exact numerical value ±5%, as well as all other numerical values that are near toor approximately equal to that numerical value. Unless otherwise indicated a particular numerical value is included in “about” a specifically recited numerical value where the particular numerical value provides the substantial equivalent of the specifically recited numerical value in the context in which the specifically recited numerical value is presented. For example, a statement that something has the numerical value of “about 10” is to be interpreted as: the set of statements:• in some embodiments the numerical value is 10;• in some embodiments the numerical value is in the range of 9.5 to 10.5;and if from the context the person of ordinary skill in the art would understand that values within a certain range are substantially equivalent to 10 because the values with the range would be understood to provide substantially the same result as the value 10 then “about 10” also includes:• in some embodiments the numerical value is in the range of C to D where C and D are respectively lower and upper endpoints of the range that encompasses all of those values that provide a substantial equivalent to the value 10.
[0217] Specific examples of systems, methods and apparatus have been described herein for purposes of illustration. These are only examples. The technology provided herein can be applied to systems other than the example systems described above. Many alterations, modifications, additions, omissions, and permutations are possible within the practice of this invention. This invention includes variations on described embodiments that would be apparent to the skilled addressee, including variations obtained by: replacing features, elements and / or acts with equivalent features, elements and / or acts; mixing and matching of features, elements and / or acts from different embodiments; combining features, elements and / or acts from embodiments as described herein with features, elements and / or acts of other technology; and / or omitting combining features, elements and / or acts from described embodiments.
[0218] As will be apparent to those of skill in the art upon reading this disclosure, each of the individual embodiments described and illustrated herein has discrete components and features which may be readily separated from or combined with the features of any other described embodiment(s) without departing from the scope ofthe present invention.
[0219] Any aspects described above in reference to apparatus may also apply to methods and vice versa.
[0220] Any recited method can be carried out in the order of events recited or in any other order which is logically possible. For example, while processes or blocks are presented in a given order, alternative examples may perform routines having steps, or employ systems having blocks, in a different order, and some processes or blocks may be deleted, moved, added, subdivided, combined, and / or modified to provide alternative or subcombinations. Each of these processes or blocks may be implemented in a variety of different ways. Also, while processes or blocks are at times shown as being performed in series, these processes or blocks may instead be performed in parallel, simultaneously or at different times.
[0221] Various features are described herein as being present in “some embodiments”. Such features are not mandatory and may not be present in all embodiments. Embodiments of the invention may include zero, any one or any combination of two or more of such features. All possible combinations of such features are contemplated by this disclosure even where such features are shown in different drawings and / or described in different sections or paragraphs. This is limited only to the extent that certain ones of such features are incompatible with other ones of such features in the sense that it would be impossible for a person of ordinary skill in the art to construct a practical embodiment that combines such incompatible features. Consequently, the description that “some embodiments” possess feature A and “some embodiments” possess feature B should be interpreted as an express indication that the inventors also contemplate embodiments which combine features A and B (unless the description states otherwise or features A and B are fundamentally incompatible). This is the case even if features A and B are illustrated in different drawings and / or mentioned in different paragraphs, sections or sentences.
[0222] It is therefore intended that the following appended claims and claims hereafter introduced are interpreted to include all such modifications, permutations, additions, omissions, and sub-combinations as may reasonably be inferred. The scope of the claims should not be limited by the preferred embodiments set forth in the examples, but should be given the broadest interpretation consistent with the description as a whole.
Claims
WHAT IS CLAIMED IS:
1. Apparatus for generating entanglement of quantum systems, the apparatus comprising:an optical network comprising:four or more input ports;four or more output ports;a plurality of interference devices, each of the interference devices comprising first and second input ports and first and second output ports, and being configured to allow interference of first and second photons presented substantially simultaneously at the input ports; andwherein:the plurality of interference devices are interconnected to provide a plurality of bundles of paths, each of the bundles of paths comprising plural paths that originate from one of the four or more input ports of the optical network and extend through at least some of the interference devices of the optical network to a corresponding one of the output ports of the optical network, with no two paths of the bundle of paths extending to the same one of the output ports of the optical network.
2. The apparatus according to claim 1 wherein for each of the bundles of paths, the intersection of a set of all of the interference devices that paths of the bundle of paths extend through with a set of all of the interference devices that paths of another one of the bundles of paths extend through is non-zero for a plurality of other ones of the bundles of paths.
3. The apparatus according to claim 1 wherein each of the bundles of paths bifurcates at each of a plurality of the interference devices to form a binary tree structure having nodes corresponding to the interference devices at which the bundle of paths bifurcates.
4. The apparatus according to claim 3 wherein the binary tree structure corresponding to each of the bundles of paths has one or more nodes in commonwith each of the binary tree structures corresponding to each of the other bundles of paths.
5. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims wherein each of the paths of the bundles of paths passes through the same number of interference devices before reaching the output port to which the path extends.
6. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims wherein the interference devices are interconnected such that each of the interference devices belongs to one of a plurality of levels, wherein the interference devices of an Lthone of the levels are the Lthinterference devices encountered when traversing any of the paths of the bundles of paths that pass through the interference device starting from the respective input ports.
7. The apparatus according to claim 6 wherein a travel time for a photon along each path of the bundles of paths from the respective input port to a corresponding first level interference device are substantially the same for all of the paths of the bundles of paths.
8. The apparatus according to claim 6 wherein a travel time for a photon along each path of the bundles of paths from a corresponding 1stlevel interference device to a corresponding Lthlevel interference device are substantially the same for all of the paths of the bundles of paths for all values of L in the range of 2 to Lmax where Lmax is the highest level of interference devices in the network.
9. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims further comprising a plurality of photon detectors, each of the photon detectors coupled to detect photons exiting the optical network at a corresponding one of the output ports of the optical network.
10. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims wherein the four or more input ports comprises at least 16 input ports.
11. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims comprising a plurality of quantum systems, each of the plurality of quantum systems optically coupled to a corresponding one of the input ports of the optical network and having a quantum state given by: α|0⟩ + β|1⟩ where a and p are complex valued coefficients and |0) and |1) are basis states and wherein applying a first stimulation to one of the quantum systems when the quantum system is in the state |1) causes the quantum system to emit a photon and applying the stimulus to the one of the quantum systems when the quantum system is in the state |0) causes the quantum system to emit zero photons.
12. The apparatus according to claim 11 wherein the quantum systems are on or in a substrate and the optical network is formed on the substrate.
13. The apparatus according to claim 11 or 12 wherein the quantum systems comprise particles that have intrinsic spin and the basis states |0) and |1) correspond to distinct spin states of the particles.
14. The apparatus according to claim 13 wherein the particles are spin % particles.
15. The apparatus according to claim 13 wherein the particles are spin 1 particles.
16. The apparatus according to claim 13 wherein the quantum systems comprise radiation damage centres in silicon.
17. The apparatus according to claim 16 wherein the radiation damage centres comprise T centres, AI1 centres, Ga1 centres, I centres or M centres.
18. The apparatus according to any of claims 11 to 17 comprising a control system configured to execute an entanglement protocol to entangle the quantum states of two of the quantum systems wherein the entanglement protocol comprises: applying a first stimulus to each of the two quantum systems and processing first information identifying any photons detected at an output of the optical network as a result of the application of the first stimulus.
19. The apparatus according to claim 18 wherein the control system is further configured to determine a correction to be applied to a combined quantum state of the two quantum systems.
20. The apparatus according to claim 19 wherein determining the correction comprises looking up the correction using a key based on at least one of information identifying the two quantum systems and the first information.
21. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims wherein the interference devices comprise 2X2 devices selected from the group comprising 50:50 beamsplitters, multimode interference (MMI) devices and directional couplers.
22. The apparatus according to claim 21 wherein the interference devices comprise bent directional couplers.
23. The apparatus according to any of the preceding claims wherein the optical network comprises 2nof the input ports, where n is an integer and n >2.
24. The apparatus according claim 23 wherein the optical network comprises n levels of the interference devices, each of the levels comprising 2n-1of the interference devices.
25. The apparatus according to claim 24 wherein each of the interference devices comprises two input ports and two output ports;wherein:the input ports of the interference devices of a second one of the levels are optically connected 1:1 to corresponding ones of the output ports of the interference devices of a first one of the levels such that the output ports of each of the interference devices of the first level are optically coupled to the input ports of two different ones of the interference devices of the second level.
26. The apparatus according to any of claims 1 to 25 wherein the optical network is a passive network.
27. The apparatus according to any of claims 1 to 26 wherein the optical network comprises one or more tunable optical elements.
28. The apparatus according to claim 27 wherein the tunable optical elements comprise one or more waveguides and / or one or more of the interference devices.
29. The apparatus according to claim 27 or 28 wherein the tunable optical elements are operable to adjust optical path lengths within the optical network30. The apparatus according to any of claims 1 to 29 wherein the bundles of paths are fixed.
31. A method for generating entanglement of quantum systems, the method comprising:providing an optical network that includes:four or more input ports,four or more output ports, anda plurality of interference devices, each interference device having first and second input ports and first and second output ports, and being configured to allow interference of first and second photon states presented substantially simultaneously at the first and second input ports;wherein the plurality of interference devices are interconnected so as to form a plurality of bundles of paths, each bundle of paths including plural paths that originate from one of the four or more input ports and extend through at least some of the interference devices to a corresponding one of the output ports, each path of a given bundle terminating at one of the output ports; andinjecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems into two of the four or more input ports so that the injected photons states interfere at one or more of the interference devices, thereby generating entanglement of the two quantum systems.
32. The method of claim 31, comprising detecting one or more photons exiting one or more of the output ports of the optical network using a plurality of photon detectorsand determining that the entanglement is generated by identifying that the one or more detected photons correspond to a heralding pattern.
33. The method of claim 31 or 32, wherein the photon states are injected into the optical network substantially simultaneously.
34. The method of any of claims 31 to 33, wherein the plurality of interference devices are arranged in a plurality of levels such that each of the paths traverses an equal number of the interference devices before arriving at the corresponding output port.
35. The method of claim 34, wherein each of the bundles of paths forms a binary tree structure having nodes corresponding to the interference devices at which the bundle of paths bifurcates.
36. The method of any of claims 31 to 35, wherein injecting the photon states into the optical network comprises adjusting the timing of the stimuli applied to the two quantum systems to cause the respective photon states to arrive at the optical network substantially simultaneously.
37. The method according to any of claims 31 to 36 comprising using calibration data to apply a phase correction to the two quantum systems after entanglement of the two quantum systems is achieved.
38. The method according to claim 37 wherein using the calibration data comprises looking up a correction to be applied to the two quantum systems using a key based on the heralding pattern.
39. The method of any of claims 37 to 38, comprising obtaining the calibration data by splitting a beam of coherent light into first and second parts and introducing the first and second parts into first and second ones of the input ports of the optical network while obtaining light measurements at the output ports of the network and varying the wavelength of the coherent light, processing the light measurements todetermine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports and generating calibration data based on the phase differences.
40. The method according to 39 comprising generating the calibration data for a plurality of pairs of the input ports.
41. The method of any of claims 31 to 40, comprising repeating the method to generate entanglement of another two quantum systems wherein photon states from the other two quantum systems are injected into the optical network at different ones of the input ports from the input ports used when generating entanglement of the two quantum systems.
42. The method according to claim 41 wherein a configuration of interconnections of the plurality of interference devices in the optical network is unchanged over plural repetitions of the method.43 The method of any of claims 31 to 42 wherein the interference devices are 2×2 devices selected from the group consisting of 50:50 beamsplitters, multimode interference devices, and directional couplers.
44. The method of claim 43, wherein the interference devices comprise bent directional couplers.
45. The method according to any of claims 31 to 44 wherein the optical network comprises at least 16 input ports.
46. The method according to any of claims 31 to 44 wherein the optical network is a passive network.
47. The method according to any of claims 31 to 45 wherein the optical network comprises one or more tunable optical elements and the method comprises adjust optical path lengths within the optical network by tuning the tunable optical elements.
48. The method according to claim 47 wherein the tunable optical elements comprise one or more waveguides and / or one or more of the interference devices.
49. The apparatus according to any of claims 31 to 48 wherein the bundles of paths are fixed.
50. The method according to any of claims 31 to 49 comprising preparing each of the two quantum systems a quantum states which is a superposition of basis states |0) and |1).
51. The method according to claim 50 wherein injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems comprises delivering stimuli to the two quantum systems where the stimuli are selected so that for a quantum system in state |0) application of the stimuli will not cause the quantum system to emit a photon and when the quantum system is in the state |1) application of the stimuli will cause the quantum system to emit a photon.
52. The method according to claim 50 wherein injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems comprises delivering stimuli to the two quantum systems, the stimuli comprising:a first stimulus delivered to a first one of the two quantum systems that causes emission of a photon from the first one of the two quantum systems if the first one of the quantum systems is in the state |0) and does not cause emission of a photon from the first one of the two quantum systems if the first one of the two quantum systems is in the state |1); anda second stimulus delivered to a second one of the two quantum systems that causes emission of a photon from the second one of the two quantum systems if the second one of the quantum systems is in the state |1) and does not cause emission of a photon from the second one of the two quantum systems if the second one of the two quantum systems is in the state |0);53. The method according to any of claims 31 to 52 comprising performing an entanglement protocol on the two quantum systems comprising, after injecting photonstates emitted from two quantum systems into two of the four or more input ports, inverting quantum states of the two quantum systems and then again injecting photon states emitted from two quantum systems into the two of the four or more input ports.
54. The method according to any of claims 31 to 53 comprising performing a BK entanglement protocol on the two quantum systems.
55. A method for entangling states of two quantum systems, the method comprising:a) applying first stimuli to cause the two quantum systems to each emit a photon state into a corresponding one of a plurality of input ports of an optical network comprising a plurality of output ports and a plurality of interference devices interconnected such that the photon states from the two quantum systems interfere with one another at one or more of the interference devices;b) making one or more photon detections, each of the photon detections associated with one of the output ports; andc) determining from the one or more photon detections that entanglement of the two quantum systems has been generated; andd) based on the photon detections determining a correction to be applied to the two quantum systems.
56. The method according to claim 55 comprising, after step b) and before step c):inverting quantum states of the two quantum systems and then repeating steps a) and b).
57. The method according to claim 55 or 56 comprising applying the correction to the two quantum systems, wherein applying the corrections causes a joint quantum state of the two quantum systems to become closer to a maximally entangled state of the two quantum systems.
58. The method according to any of claims 55 to 57 wherein determining the correction comprises looking up the correction based on the one or more photon detections and / or the input ports of the optical network into which the photon stateswere emitted from the two quantum systems.
59. The method according to any of claims 55 to 58 wherein the correction comprises a phase.
60. The method according to any of claims 55 to 59 wherein the optical network is a passive network.
61. A control system for an apparatus for generating entanglement of quantum systems, the control system comprising electronic logic configured to perform an entanglement protocol on two quantum systems by acts including:controlling delivery of stimuli to two quantum systems selected from a plurality of quantum systems, the stimuli effective to cause the two quantum systems to inject photon states into respective input ports of an optical network comprising:four or more of the input ports;four or more output ports;a plurality of interference devices, each of the interference devices comprising first and second input ports and first and second output ports, and being configured to allow interference of first and second photons presented substantially simultaneously at the input ports; andreceiving detection information indicating detection of one or more photons exiting one or more of the output ports of the optical network andidentifying that the one or more detected photons correspond to a heralding pattern.
62. The control system according to claim 61 wherein the control system is further configured to determine a correction to be applied to correct a quantum state of the two quantum systems.
63. The control system according to claim 62 wherein the electronic logic is configured to determine the correction by looking up the correction based on the detection information and / or the input ports of the optical network into which the photon states were emitted from the two quantum systems.
64. The control system according to claim 62 or 63 wherein the electronic logic is further configured to apply the correction to the two quantum systems.
65. The control system according to any of claims 61 to 64 wherein the electronic logic is further configured to repeat the entanglement protocol on each of a plurality of pairs of quantum systems selected from the plurality of quantum systems without changing a configuration of the optical network,wherein:different ones of the plurality of pairs of quantum systems are associated with different pairs of the input ports of the optical network.
66. Apparatus for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network, the apparatus comprising:a coherent light source operable to emit a beam of coherent light;a beam splitter arranged to split the beam of coherent light into first and second parts;optics arranged to respectively deliver the first and second parts into first and second selected input ports of the optical network;a control system comprising electronic logic configured to:receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light;processing the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; and generate calibration data based on the phase differences.
67. A control system for apparatus for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network, the control system comprising:electronic logic configured to, while first and second parts of a coherent light beam are being delivered into first and second input ports of the optical network:receive results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light;process the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; andgenerate calibration data based on the phase differences.
68. A method for determining phase corrections for entangled states of quantum systems entangled using an optical network, the method comprising:a) introducing first and second parts of a coherent light beam into respective input ports of the optical network;b) receiving results of light measurements made at the output ports of the optical network for different wavelengths of the coherent light;c) processing the results of the light measurements to determine phase differences between light of the first and second parts at the output ports; andd) generating calibration data based on the phase differences.
69. Apparatus having any new and inventive feature, combination of features, or sub-combination of features as described herein70. Methods having any new and inventive steps, acts, combination of steps and / or acts or sub-combination of steps and / or acts as described herein.
