A simple method for analyzing the stability of landfill slope using circular arc method

Through the combination of traditional mathematical analysis and Excel worksheets, slope stability analysis is simplified, the problem of cumbersome calculation of Swedish arc method is solved, the method of efficiently finding the minimum stability safety factor is achieved, and the calculation efficiency is improved.

CN111611639BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-01GUANGDONG ANYUAN MINING TECH SERVICE
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202010428014.9
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2020-05-20
Publication Date
2024-11-01
Estimated Expiration
2040-05-20

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In the prior art, the calculation process of the Swedish arc method for slope stability analysis is complicated, which makes it difficult for engineering designers to find the most dangerous sliding arc center and the minimum stability safety factor efficiently, which takes a long time.

Method used

Through traditional mathematical analytical operations and combined with the calculation function of Excel worksheets, an automatic calculation method for slope stability of hard foundation slag fields was established. The analytical method was used to calculate the radius and center coordinates of the sliding arc, and the radius was gradually changed to achieve minimum stability Sexual safety factor.

Benefits of technology

The slope stability analysis process is simplified, the calculation time is reduced, and the minimum stability safety factor is found through automated calculations, which improves the calculation efficiency.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN111611639B_ABST
    Figure CN111611639B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present application belongs to the field of mining and geotechnical engineering technology; for a slag field with a hard foundation, the sliding arc of the unstable slope is roughly tangent to the base line at the toe of the slope; based on this analysis, a series of formulas for calculating the stability coefficient can be obtained; the commonly used office software Excel worksheet is introduced and the corresponding calculation formula is implanted; the minimum stability safety factor and various parameters of the sliding arc can be easily obtained by using the insertion data trial calculation approximation method.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical field:

[0001] The present application belongs to the field of mining and geotechnical engineering technology. Technical background:

[0002] The Technical Code for Slope Engineering of Buildings (GB 50330-2002) stipulates in Section 5.2.2 that when analyzing slope stability, "the circular arc sliding method should be used for soil slopes and large-scale fractured rock slopes". The Technical Code for Slope Engineering of Non-coal Open-pit Mines (GB 51016-2014) and the Design Code for Metallurgical Mine Spoil Dumps (GB 51119-2015) also recommend the circular arc method for slope stability analysis. This circular arc method is the Swedish circular arc method (or Felsenius Terzaghi strip-divided circular arc method) known to industry insiders. Its general content is: the sliding arc of the slope instability of the landfill is close to a circular arc. The landfill body in the sliding arc is randomly divided into n vertical strips, and the deadweight of each strip is G. i =H i .b i .γ, where: H i is the average height of the bars, b i is the width of the strip, γ is the weight of the slag; the bottom arc inclination angle of each strip is α i , the sliding force is G i Sinα i , the friction resistance is ( is the internal friction angle of the soil), and the cohesion resistance is cS i (c is the cohesion, S i is the length of the bottom arc of the strip); for ordinary landfills, there is generally no underground water level effect in the accumulation body, and there is no additional building load on the top. When the seismic force is ignored, the slope stability safety factor calculation formula is: The key to the arc method calculation is that the final safety factor sliding arc must be the sliding arc with the smallest safety factor among all possible sliding arcs, and the calculated safety factor must be the minimum safety factor. This calculation method is well known to people in the industry, but the key is how to find the sliding arc with the smallest safety factor, which is what engineering and technical personnel in the industry often call finding the center of the most dangerous sliding arc.

[0003] In Chapter 9 of Soil Mechanics (a textbook for colleges and universities, edited by Yang Jinliang of Tianjin University, second edition), the application of the Swedish arc method is described in detail, and the probability interval of the most dangerous center is proposed; however, the specific operation is still very cumbersome: each time a sliding arc center is assumed, it must pass through the toe point - attached Figure 1 Make an imaginary sliding arc at point A in the figure (Fellenius believed that when the internal friction angle is small, the most dangerous sliding arc passes through or approaches the toe of the slope), then divide, measure and calculate Gi 、Cosα i 、Sinα i , S i etc. parameters, so as to obtain the stability safety factor of the first hypothetical sliding arc; after that, continue to calculate the stability safety factors of many hypothetical sliding arcs, and after repeated comparisons, finally determine the most dangerous sliding arc and the minimum stability safety factor; the workload of this method is so large that many engineering designers are daunted; engineering and technical personnel in the industry have experimented: according to this method recommended by "Soil Mechanics", using existing calculators and CAD drawing software, it takes several days or even more than ten days to find the most dangerous center of a case; therefore, "Soil Mechanics" also records in this chapter: "In recent years, some scholars and engineering and technical personnel have successfully studied the application of optimization methods to find arbitrary sliding surfaces with the minimum safety factor. ... This work must be done with the help of computers and compiled programs"; it can be seen that this arc method calculation is still a major problem in the engineering community.

[0004] The present invention aims to find a method that can be understood by people in the industry through analytical operations of traditional mathematics, and then use the calculation function of the conventional office software Excel worksheet to conveniently find the center of the most dangerous sliding arc and obtain the minimum stability safety factor. Summary of the invention:

[0005] The technical principle is as follows: when building a landfill on a hard foundation, because the strength, density, deformation modulus, cohesion and internal friction angle of the hard foundation are significantly greater than the landfill itself, it is believed that the sliding arc of the unstable slope cannot cut the hard foundation; and the site selection of the landfill generally chooses a hard foundation, and will not choose a site with dangerous weak and subsidence foundations; therefore, the method of analyzing and calculating the slope stability of the landfill under hard foundation conditions is universal. According to Ferenius's inference that the sliding arc passes through or approaches the toe of the slope, the sliding arc should be or must be: tangent to the hard foundation line approximately at the toe of the slope. This is Figure 1 The situation shown is: the inclination of the hard base AD is set to ε; the inclination of the slope line AB (slope angle) is set to β; the inclination of the top line BC is set to δ; the center of the sliding arc is located on the straight line AN passing through point A and perpendicular to the base AD. The sliding arc with the minimum radius R0 passes through the top point B, and the value of R0 can be calculated based on the known conditions; then set an increment z for R0 i >0, the sliding arc radius after increment If we use analytical method to find the value corresponding to the new radius R i The corresponding parameters of the slope stability safety factor K can be obtained i ; Constantly changing increment z i and the sliding arc radius R i , the corresponding multiple stability safety factors K can be obtainedi ; Then, the minimum value K i This is the minimum stability safety factor we need. In Excel worksheets, the data in each cell can be easily associated. When one data changes, all the associated data will change randomly, which is time-saving and convenient. In this way, the minimum stability safety factor can be easily calculated.

[0006] Analytical calculation method Figure 1 As shown: Establish the coordinate system XOY, the X axis passes through the slope foot point A, and the Y axis passes through the slope top point B.

[0007] The slope section (AB section) of the sliding arc is fixedly divided into 20 blocks - numbered 1, 2..., 20; the top section (BC section) of the sliding arc is divided into 5 blocks - numbered 21, 22..., 25; and a virtual 0 block is added for programming, and the width of 0 block is 0.

[0008] The coordinates of point B: X =0, B Y =h), coordinates of point A:

[0009] The slope of the slope AB is k1 = -Tanβ, and the equation of the line AB is y = k1x + h;

[0010] The slope of the top line BC is k2 = -Tanδ, and the equation of the line BC is y = k2x + h;

[0011] The inclination angle of the bottom plate line AD is ε, and the inclination angle of the straight line AN where the center of the sliding arc lies is (90-ε);

[0012] For the minimum sliding arc radius R0 passing through the slope vertex B, the coordinates of its center can be obtained as:

[0013]

[0014] Y0=R0.Sin(90-ε)=R0Cosε;

[0015] From the coordinates of point B (B X =0, B Y =h) Write the circle equation

[0016] Solving the equation yields:

[0017] For any incremental radius The coordinates of the center M are:

[0018]

[0019] Yi=R i.Sin(90-ε)=R i Cosε;

[0020] Corresponding to the incremental radius R i The circle equation is: In this example, the intersection of the sliding arc and the left line of each bar (vertical line) is located below the circle, so the coordinates of the intersection are: Y i-H represents the y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the i-th bar and the sliding arc, x i It is the x-coordinate value of the left line of bar number i.

[0021] The intersection of the sliding arc and the slope crest line BC is in the negative region of x; the equation of BC is y = k2x + h; substitute the new radius R i Solve the circle equation and get the x coordinate of the intersection point C of the arc and the top line of the slope:

[0022]

[0023] The width of the first set of bars (numbered 1, 2, ..., 20)

[0024] The width of the second group of bars (numbered 21, 22, ..., 25) ABS() means absolute value.

[0025] Through the above analytical relationship, the expressions of various parameters used to calculate the stability coefficient are obtained:

[0026] (1) The coordinates of the left line of the 0-20 block are: Where n i is the bar number;

[0027] The coordinates of the left line of the 21-25th block are: x i =(20-n i ).b2;

[0028] ⑵The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of each block and the sliding arc is:

[0029] ⑶ The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 0-20 block and the slope AB straight line is Y i-Z =k1x i +h;

[0030] The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 21-25 block and the BC line at the top is Y i-Z =k2x i +h;

[0031] Where Y i-Z It represents the y-coordinate of the intersection of the left line of bar i and the top straight line. The other symbols are the same as before.

[0032] ⑷ Fill in the value 0 for the inclination angle of virtual bar No. 0.

[0033] Bottom arc inclination of strips 1-25 Where: Y i-H , Y (i-1)-H Respectively represent the Y coordinate values ​​of the intersections of the left line of the i-th bar, the left line of the (i-1)-th bar and the sliding arc; i 、x i-1 They are the X coordinates of the left lines of the i-th bar and the (i-1)-th bar respectively; ATan() is the symbol of the inverse tangent in the Excel table; pay attention to the conversion between the units of 'radians' and 'degrees' in the Excel table; here, we approximate the bottom arc inclination angle to the bottom arc chord inclination angle, the error is very small and is allowed. Regarding the positive and negative signs of the angles: we set the angles diagonally downward along the sliding direction as positive values, and diagonally upward as negative values. In this example, no negative values ​​appear.

[0034] ⑸The average height of each block from No. 1 to No. 25 is: The meaning is: the height of the bar is equal to the average height of the left line of the current bar (bar No. i) and the left line of the previous bar (bar No. (i-1)). The average height of bar No. 0 is H0 = 0.

[0035] (6) The bottom arc of the bar No. 0 is S0 = 0; the bottom arc lengths of the bars No. 1 to No. 25 are or The chord length is used here instead of the arc length to simplify the calculation. The arc length can also be obtained analytically. The error between the two is very small, so the chord length can be used to approximately replace it.

[0036] ⑺1-25 block weight G i =(x i-1 -x i )×H i ×γ, weight of block No. 0 G i =0;

[0037] Where γ is the bulk density of the slag. When the slag composition is different, the average bulk density is used.

[0038] ⑻Sliding force F i =G i ×Sinα i (Note the unit system of angles in the Excel table);

[0039] ⑼ Strip friction resistance is the friction angle inside the soil;

[0040] Strip cohesion resistance N i =S i ×c, c is the cohesion of the soil body.

[0041] In the above formula: internal friction angle and cohesion c; when the soil composition is different, it is necessary to identify and select the corresponding parameters of the sliding arc location.

[0042] ⑽Stability safety factor

[0043] Description of the drawings:

[0044] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram to illustrate this calculation method. The meanings of the symbols in the figure are: AB is the slope line, β is the slope angle, AD is the base line, ε is the foundation inclination, BC is the slope top line, δ is the slope top inclination, h is the vertical height of the slope, the straight line AN⊥AD, and the center of the sliding arc is on AN; point M0 is the sliding arc passing through the slope vertex B - the center of the minimum radius sliding arc, R0 is the minimum sliding arc radius, and point M represents the center of the random radius sliding arc;

[0045] XOY is a plane coordinate system, where the X axis passes through point A at the foot of the slope, and the Y axis passes through point B at the top of the slope;

[0046] The AC curve represents the sliding arc, point C represents the rupture point at the top of the slope, the AB segment of the sliding body is divided into 20 blocks, namely 1, 2, ...20, block 0 is a virtual block for auxiliary calculations, and the BC segment of the sliding body is divided into 5 blocks, namely 21, 22, ...25.

[0047] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of an Excel table example of this calculation method. The symbols in the figure mean: the first row at the top of the table is the column number mark (A, B, ..., K) of the Excel table, the numbers 1, 2, ...32 in the first column on the left side of the table are the row number marks of the Excel table; the rest are calculation parameters. Specific implementation method:

[0048] Create an Excel worksheet named "Automatic calculation table of slope stability coefficient of hard foundation landfill", such as Figure 2 As shown; the calculation and operation methods are as follows:

[0049] (I) Fill in the known condition parameters in rows 1 and 2 of the Excel table: such as slope height (h), slope angle (β), etc.; among them, 'degree arc (k0)' is to convert the angle into radians as an auxiliary parameter for Excel worksheet calculation.

[0050] (ii) The 3rd and 4th rows in the Excel table are the common parameters for export; among them, the design increment (z i )' is randomly inserted during trial calculation, and the rest are automatically calculated by filling in formulas. According to Excel calculation rules, fill in the formulas in the corresponding cells; the calculation formulas for these common parameters are as follows:

[0051] minimum radius Random Radius New center coordinates

[0052] New center coordinates (Yi) = RiCosε;

[0053] X coordinate of the slope crack point

[0054] Width of the first group of strips in the slope section

[0055] Width of the second group of strips at the top of the slope ABS() means absolute value.

[0056] (iii) The fifth row of the table contains the names and symbols of the various parameters used in calculating the slope stability coefficient;

[0057] (IV) Rows 6 to 31 in the table are the calculation data of various specific parameters involved in the calculation of slope stability coefficient, among which the item number (n i )0, 1, 2, ... 25 are filled directly. For the parameters of the remaining columns, follow the rules of the Excel table and insert the following formulas into the corresponding cells (Note: when referencing the parameters of the 2nd and 4th rows, the column and row numbers must be prefixed with '$'):

[0058] (1) The coordinates of the left line of the 0-20 block are:

[0059] The coordinates of the left line of the 21-25th block are: x i =(20-n i ).b2;

[0060] ⑵The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of each block and the sliding arc is:

[0061] ⑶ The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 0-20 block and the slope AB straight line: Y i-Z =k1x i +h;

[0062] The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 21-25th block and the BC line at the top of the edge: Y i-Z =k2x i +h;

[0063] (4) The bottom arc inclination angle α of block No. 0 i =0;

[0064] Bottom arc inclination of strips 1-25 Where: Y i-H , Y (i-1)-HRespectively represent the Y coordinate values ​​of the intersections of the left line of the i-th bar, the left line of the (i-1)-th bar and the sliding arc; i 、x i-1 They are the X coordinates of the left lines of the i-th and (i-1)-th bars respectively; Tan() is the symbol for calculating the angle by the inverse tangent in the Excel table; Used to convert angles from radians to degrees.

[0065] ⑸The average height H of No. 0 bar i =0;

[0066] The average height of each block from 1 to 25 is:

[0067] (6) The bottom arc S of the No. 0 bar i =0;

[0068] The length of the bottom arc of the bars No. 1-25

[0069] ⑺1-25 block weight G i =(x i-1 -x i )×H i ×γ; No. 0 block weight G i =0;

[0070] Where γ is the bulk density of the slag. When the slag composition is different, the average bulk density is used.

[0071] ⑻Sliding force F i =G i ×Sinα i (Note: multiply the angle by k0 to get radians, and so on);

[0072] ⑼ Strip friction resistance

[0073] Strip cohesion resistance N i =S i ×c, c is the cohesion of the soil body.

[0074] In the above formula: c are the internal friction angle and cohesion of the slag body respectively; when the slag composition is different, it is necessary to identify and select the corresponding parameters of the sliding arc location.

[0075] (V) The data in the last three cells of row 32 in the table are: Where F 25 、M 25 、N 25 They represent the total sliding force, total friction resistance and total cohesion resistance of the 25 bars respectively.

[0076] Stability safety factor

[0077] (VI) Change Insertion' Design Increment (z i )' (i.e. the data in cell B4), the corresponding associated parameters change synchronously. You only need to pay attention to the data value of the stability safety factor - the change of the value of cell C32. When C32 reaches the minimum value, it is the minimum stability safety factor.

[0078] Examples: Figure 2 The "Automatic calculation table of stability coefficient of side slope of solid soil field with arc method (insert)" is an actual calculation case; the inserted z i When the values ​​are equal to 20, 15, 12, 10, 9, 8, 7, and 8.5, the corresponding stability safety factors are: 1.22715, 1.21861, 1.21749, 1.21725, 1.21726, 1.21753, and 1.21722;

[0079] Based on this, the stability safety factor is determined to be K = 1.21722; at this time, the sliding arc radius R = 225.4981, and the coordinates of the slope crack point C X =-9.016.

[0080] If a solid retaining structure is built at the toe of the slope, the tangent point of the sliding arc is not at the toe of the slope. At this time, the vertical line (AN) where the center of the circle is located can be translated into the soil, and the tangent point can be moved along the base line AD to an appropriate position where the sliding arc just passes over the structure. The minimum stability safety factor can still be calculated using the above method.

Claims

1. A simple method for analyzing the stability of landfill slopes using the circular arc method. Its technical features are as follows: According to the technical principle, when building a landfill on a hard foundation, since the strength, density, deformation modulus and other parameters of the foundation are obviously greater than the landfill itself, the sliding arc of the slope instability cannot cut the hard foundation, and should be tangent to the base line at the foot of the slope. Based on this, create an Excel worksheet and operate as follows: (I) Fill in the known condition parameters in the first and second rows of the Excel table, which are: slope height (h), slope angle (β), slope top inclination (δ), foundation inclination (ε), internal friction angle Cohesion (c), soil bulk density (γ), slope slope (k1), slope top slope (k2), and arc of change (k0); 'Convert to arc (k0)' is to convert the angle into radians as an auxiliary parameter for Excel worksheet calculations. (ii) The third and fourth rows in the Excel table are the exported common parameters, namely: minimum radius (R0), design increment (z i ), random radius (R i ), new circle center coordinates (X i ), new circle center coordinates (Y i ), X coordinate of the slope crack point (C x ), the first set of strip widths (b1), the second set of strip widths (b2); where 'design increment (z i )' is randomly inserted during the trial calculation, and the rest are automatically calculated by the formula. According to the Excel operation rules, fill in the following formula into the corresponding cell: Random Radius New center coordinates New center coordinates (Y i )=R i Cosε; X coordinate of the slope crack point Width of the first group of strips in the slope section Width of the second group of strips at the top of the slope ABS means absolute value; (III) The fifth row of the table contains the names and symbols of the various parameters used in calculating the slope stability coefficient; they are as follows: (IV) Rows 6 to 31 in the table are the calculation data of the specific parameters for calculating the slope stability coefficient, among which the item number (n i )0, 1, 2, ... 25 are filled directly. For the parameters in the remaining columns, follow the rules of the Excel table and insert the following formula into the corresponding cells: When referencing the parameters in the 2nd and 4th rows, the column and row numbers must be prefixed with '$': (1) The coordinates of the left line of the 0-20 bar are: The coordinates of the left line of the 21-25th bar are: x i =(20-n i ).b2; (2) The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of each block and the sliding arc is: (3) The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 0-20 block and the slope AB line: Y i-Z =k1x i +h; The Y coordinate of the intersection of the left line of the 21-25 block and the BC line at the top of the edge: Y i-Z =k2x i +h; (4) The bottom arc inclination angle a of the No. 0 bar i =0; Bottom arc inclination of No. 1-25 strips Where: Y i-H , Y (i-1)-H Respectively represent the Y coordinate values ​​of the intersections of the left line of the i-th bar, the left line of the (i-1)-th bar and the sliding arc; i 、x i-1 They are the X coordinates of the left lines of the i-th and (i-1)-th bars respectively; ATan is the symbol for the inverse tangent angle in the Excel table; Used to convert the angle of 'radians' to 'degrees'; (5) Average height H of No. 0 bar i =0; The average height of each block No. 1-25 is: (6) Bottom arc S of bar No. 0 i =0; The length of the bottom arc of the bars No. 1-25 Here, the chord length of the bottom arc of the bar is used instead of the arc length, and the error range is acceptable; (7) Weight of No. 1-25 blocks G i =(x i-1 -x i )×H i ×γ; No. 0 block weight G i =0; Where γ is the bulk density of the slag. When the slag has different components, the average bulk density is used. (8) Sliding force F of each strip i =G i ×Sinα i , Note: Multiply the angle by k0 to get radians, and so on; (9) Friction resistance of each strip Cohesion resistance of each strip N i =S i ×c, c is the cohesion of the soil body; In the above formula: c are the internal friction angle and cohesion of the slag body; when the slag composition is different, it is necessary to identify and select the corresponding parameters at the position of the sliding arc; (V) The data in the last three cells of row 32 in the table are: Where F 25 、M 25 、N 25 They represent the total sliding force, total friction resistance, and total cohesion resistance of the 25 bars respectively; Stability safety factor (VI) Change Insertion' Design Increment (z i )' is the data of cell B4, and the corresponding associated parameters change synchronously. You only need to pay attention to the data value of the stability safety factor - the change of the value in cell C32. When C32 reaches the minimum value, it is the minimum stability safety factor. (VII) If a solid retaining structure is built at the toe of the slope, the tangent point of the sliding arc is not at the toe of the slope. At this time, the vertical line (AN) where the center of the circle is located is translated into the soil, and the tangent point is moved along the base line AD to an appropriate position where the sliding arc just passes over the structure. The minimum stability safety factor is still calculated using the above method.