Method and system for assessing the health of a mechanical system

By combining discontinuous and continuous data to generate an overall health index, the problem of insufficient health assessment of mechanical systems in the prior art is solved, more accurate failure prevention and risk management is achieved, and the safety and reliability of the system are improved.

CN115146895BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-06SCHNEIDER ELECTRIC SYSTEMS USA INC
View PDF 2 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210320023.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2021-03-31
Filing Date
2022-03-29
Publication Date
2024-12-06
Estimated Expiration
2042-03-29

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing discontinuous preventive maintenance and condition monitoring methods are not sufficient to effectively avoid failures in mechanical systems, especially in critical systems such as pressure vessels, where failures can lead to dangerous and catastrophic consequences.

Method used

Using a computer-implemented approach, by receiving and combining discontinuous and continuous system data, discontinuous and continuous health indexes are generated and combined into an overall health index to automatically take action to maintain or improve the health of mechanical systems, avoiding risk. The method includes receiving discontinuous data, generating discontinuous health index, receiving continuous data, generating continuous health index, and combining it to generate an overall health index, based on which action is taken automatically.

Benefits of technology

By combining discontinuous and continuous data, a more comprehensive mechanical system health assessment can be provided, which can promptly identify potential problems and take preventive measures to reduce the risk of failure and improve the reliability and safety of the system.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN115146895B_ABST
    Figure CN115146895B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A method for assessing the health of a mechanical system is provided. The method includes: receiving discontinuous system data obtained intermittently and associated with the health of the system; generating a discontinuous health index based on the discontinuous system data; receiving continuous system data obtained continuously and associated with the health of the system; and generating a continuous health index based on the continuous system data, wherein the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable. The method also includes combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; generating an overall health index based on the combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; and automatically taking one or more actions to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system and / or avoid risks based on the overall health index.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present disclosure relates to health assessment of mechanical systems, and more particularly, to health assessment using discontinuously acquired data. Background Art

[0002] Preventive maintenance and condition monitoring can be used to monitor mechanical systems at periodic or non-periodic times, generating discontinuous data. For example, non-destructive testing (NDT) inspections can be performed at discrete times, requiring the execution of various checklist inspection items. Some examples of NDT inspections include infrared imaging, ultrasonic thickness measurement surveys, crack indication detection (e.g., using magnetic particle inspection), etc. Inspections can indicate the beginning of a problem, such as when a threshold variable is exceeded. However, this discontinuous type of monitoring by itself is not sufficient to avoid failure of a mechanical system. Even when all items on the checklist indicate satisfactory performance, a mechanical system may fail.

[0003] Pressure vessels are an example of a mechanical system that is monitored using maintenance and condition monitoring. Failure of a pressure vessel can be dangerous and catastrophic. Therefore, it would be beneficial to improve the monitoring of mechanical systems rather than relying solely on discontinuous preventive maintenance and condition monitoring.

[0004] While conventional methods and systems have been generally considered satisfactory for their intended purposes, there remains a need in the art for improved health assessment of mechanical systems that have traditionally been monitored through discontinuous preventative maintenance and condition monitoring. The present disclosure provides a solution. Summary of the invention

[0005] The objects and advantages of the illustrated embodiments described below will be set forth and apparent from the subsequent description. Additional advantages of the illustrated embodiments will be realized and obtained by the devices, systems, and methods particularly pointed out in the written description and claims herein and in the accompanying drawings. To achieve these and other advantages, and in accordance with the objects of the illustrated embodiments, in one aspect, a computer-implemented method for assessing the health of a mechanical system is disclosed. The method includes: receiving discontinuous system data obtained intermittently and associated with the health of the system; generating a discontinuous health index based on the discontinuous system data; receiving continuous system data obtained continuously and associated with the health of the system; and generating a continuous health index based on the continuous system data. The discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable. The method also includes combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index, which includes combining one or more discontinuous health indexes generated over time with one or more continuous health indexes generated over time. The method also includes generating an overall health index based on the combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; and automatically taking one or more actions to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system and / or avoid risks based on the overall health index.

[0006] In one or more embodiments, combining the discontinuous system data and the continuous system data may include applying a combining method to combine one or more discontinuous and continuous health indices generated over time.

[0007] In one or more embodiments, the method may further include capturing at least one of discontinuous system data and continuous system data.

[0008] In one or more embodiments, the one or more actions may include adjusting the manner in which discontinuous system data and / or continuous system data is captured.

[0009] In one or more embodiments, the one or more actions may include performing an emergency shutdown of related equipment associated with the mechanical system to avoid the risk.

[0010] In one or more embodiments, the one or more actions may include providing a notification to a system user or operator indicating a change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system and / or a recommendation to respond to the change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system.

[0011] In one or more embodiments, the overall health index can be represented as a score, and combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index into the overall health index can also include combining one or more previously determined overall health indices, wherein generating the overall health index can be based on a combination of the discontinuous health index, the continuous health index, and one or more previously determined overall health indices.

[0012] In one or more embodiments, the method may further include updating the discontinuous health index in real time in response to receiving the discontinuous system data when new discontinuous system data is received; and updating the overall health index in real time in response to updating the discontinuous health index.

[0013] In one or more embodiments, the method may further include determining at least one of a discontinuous confidence indicator (DC-CI) and a continuous confidence indicator (C-CI). The DC-CI indicates a confidence level of at least one of the received discontinuous system data and the determined discontinuous health index. The C-CI indicates a confidence level of at least one of the received continuous system data and the determined continuous health index. The method may further include generating an overall confidence indicator (O-CI), which is a function of at least one of the DC-CI and the C-CI and / or a trend of at least one of the DC-CI and the C-CI. The determination of whether to automatically take one or more actions and / or the selection of one or more actions to be taken can be based on the O-CI and / or a change in the O-CI.

[0014] In one or more embodiments, a combined method for combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index applies a weight to each of the discontinuous system data and the continuous system data.

[0015] In one or more embodiments, the weights applied to the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are dynamically determined as a function of the DC-CI and the C-CI, respectively. According to other aspects of the present disclosure, a health assessment system for assessing the health of a mechanical system is provided. The health assessment system includes a memory configured to store a plurality of programmable instructions, and at least one processing device in communication with the memory, wherein when executing the plurality of programmable instructions, the at least one processing device is configured to perform the disclosed method.

[0016] In one or more embodiments, a mechanical system may be associated with an industrial process.

[0017] In one or more embodiments, the mechanical system may include a pressure vessel.In one or more embodiments, the pressure vessel may be a pulp digester associated with a papermaking process.

[0018] According to yet another aspect of the present disclosure, a non-transitory computer-readable storage medium having one or more computer programs embedded therein, which, when executed by a computer system, causes the computer system to perform the disclosed method. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0019] A more detailed description of the disclosure briefly summarized above can be obtained by reference to various embodiments, some of which are illustrated in the accompanying drawings. Although the drawings illustrate selected embodiments of the disclosure, these drawings are not to be considered limiting of its scope, as the disclosure may admit to other equally effective embodiments.

[0020] Figure 1 is a block diagram illustrating an example health assessment system according to an embodiment of the present disclosure;

[0021] Figure 2 The present invention is a diagram showing an embodiment of the present invention. Figure 1 A block diagram of an example continuous data processor is shown;

[0022] Figure 3 The present invention is a diagram showing an embodiment of the present invention. Figure 1 A block diagram of an example discontinuous data processor is shown;

[0023] Figure 4 is a diagram showing other components of a health assessment system and / or communicating with one or more other health assessment systems according to an embodiment of the present disclosure Figure 1 A block diagram of an example combined health assessor is shown;

[0024] Figure 5 is a flow chart of an example method of assessing the health of a mechanical system according to an embodiment of the present disclosure; and

[0025] Figure 6 According to the implementation of the embodiment of the present disclosure Figure 1 A block diagram of an exemplary computer system illustrating components of a health assessment system is shown.

[0026] Wherever possible, identical reference numerals are used to designate identical elements that are common to the figures. However, elements disclosed in one embodiment may be beneficially utilized in other embodiments without specific recitation. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0027] Reference will now be made to the accompanying drawings, wherein like reference numerals identify similar structural features or aspects of the subject disclosure. For purposes of explanation and illustration, and not limitation, a schematic diagram of an exemplary embodiment of a health assessment system according to the present disclosure is shown in FIG. Figure 1 , and generally designated by reference numeral 100. Other embodiments of health assessment systems or aspects thereof according to the present disclosure are described in Figure 2-Figure 6 provided in, as will be described.

[0028] The health assessment system 100 includes one or more continuous system data sources 102 and one or more discontinuous system data sources 112, which respectively sense and output continuous system data and discontinuous system data related to a mechanical system whose health is being assessed, such as a pressure vessel, boiler piping, feedwater heater, heat recovery steam generator, fermentation or bioreactor, and catalyst cracker in a refinery.

[0029] The continuous system data is provided to a continuous data processor 104 which outputs a continuous health index. The discontinuous system data is provided to a discontinuous data processor 114 which outputs a discontinuous health index. The combined health evaluator 120 evaluates the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index by applying a combined algorithm. The combined health evaluator 120 may also receive external data from one or more external data sources 122 and apply the external data to the combined algorithm or its results. The external data may be applied before, during, or after executing the combined algorithm.

[0030] A fault-free evaluation of a mechanical system can be performed under a fault-free condition to obtain fault-free continuous system data and / or discontinuous system data under a fault-free condition. For example, the fault-free evaluation can be physically performed or simulated when the mechanical system is new, just repaired, etc. The continuous health index can be a function of a comparison between the fault-free continuous system data and the continuous system data obtained during the operation of the monitored mechanical system. Similarly, the discontinuous health index can be a function of a comparison between the fault-free discontinuous system data and the discontinuous system data obtained during the operation of the monitored mechanical system. In one or more embodiments, the fault-free discontinuous system data can be classified as fault-free when certain conditions are met. For example, a thermal change of a thermal image that is less than a predetermined threshold indicating a minimum change, or a mean and standard deviation of a measured distribution of magnetic particle crack indications within a predetermined range indicating low expenditure can be determined as fault-free.

[0031] The continuous data processor 104, the discontinuous data processor 114, and the combined health evaluator 120 are implemented on one or more computer systems and may be integrated in a single device (e.g., housed in the same housing) or provided in one or more separate devices. Any of the continuous data processor 104, the discontinuous data processor 114, and the combined health evaluator 120 may share one or more components and / or functions, or may be completely separate from each other.

[0032] The combined health assessor 120 assesses the health of the mechanical system based on the output of the combined algorithm, which may optionally include the application of external data. The health assessment may be performed by applying the health assessment algorithm. The output of the health assessment algorithm may be represented as a health assessment score. The health assessment score may include one or more scores representing respective characteristics of the mechanical system and / or an overall score representing the overall health of the mechanical system.

[0033] Based on the health assessment score, the combined health assessor 120 outputs commands and / or notifications to the system-related components 130. The commands and notifications may cause the system-related components 130 to take one or more automatic actions to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system and / or avoid risks. These actions may include, for example, performing an emergency shutdown of related equipment associated with the mechanical system to avoid risks, or adjusting the manner in which discontinuous system data and / or continuous system data is captured by the corresponding discontinuous system data source 112 and / or continuous system data source 102. In addition, the action may include displaying and / or announcing notifications to a system user or operator to indicate changes in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system and / or recommendations for changes in the assessment of the health of the response system. Example recommendations may include sounding an alarm and flashing lights to alert nearby personnel to evacuate the area. Another example recommendation may be a notification that the condition has stabilized so that it is safe to return to the area.

[0034] In one or more embodiments, the health assessment score can be output as assessment feedback data, which is provided as input to the combined health assessor 120. In this manner, the combined health assessor 120 processes the assessment feedback data with the next iteration of application of the health assessment algorithm, such as the combined output of the combined algorithm applied to subsequently received continuous health indices and discontinuous health indices. The assessment feedback data can be applied to the health assessment algorithm before, during, or after execution of the health assessment algorithm.

[0035] For example, the continuous system data sources 102 may include cameras that constantly monitor the mechanical system and output continuous system data, temperature sensors, flow sensors, pressure sensors, pH sensors, speed sensors, chemical concentration sensors, imagers such as infrared or visible spectrum, vibration sensors, etc. The output of each continuous system data source 102 may provide a continuous system data channel.

[0036] The continuous system data source 102 may be permanently installed. Furthermore, the continuous system data source may be continuously sensed in real time during operation of the mechanical system as opposed to in conjunction with a specific inspection or test. The continuous system data may be raw data, or may be processed data. Processing of the continuous system data may be performed by the continuous system data source using an intermediate device. The processing may include, for example, aggregation, conversion from analog to digital, enhancement or filtering using signal processing techniques, and the like.

[0037] The continuous data processor 104 evaluates the received continuous system data and outputs a continuous health index that is a function of the continuous system data channels to provide a quantitative measure of the health of the mechanical system based on the continuous system data.

[0038] refer to Figure 2 , the continuous data processor 104 includes a continuous data analyzer 202 and a continuous health index estimator 204. The continuous data analyzer 202 receives the continuous system data from the continuous system data source 102. The continuous data analyzer 202 applies an algorithm and / or a model (such as a continuous model 212) to the continuous system data and outputs continuous evaluation data. Without being limited to a specific device or technology, the continuous data analyzer 202 can be implemented as, for example, AVEVA TM Predictive Analytics Software (formerly PRiSM Predictive Asset Analytics), General Electric TM Predix TM and Siemens TM MindSphere TM .

[0039] The continuous data analyzer 202 can use the continuous model 212 to apply one or more algorithms, such as statistical analysis, probability analysis, machine learning, or numerical solver techniques. The numerical solver technique can apply an objective function to compare the continuous system data with the optimal operating point. The numerical solver technique can include one or more of a least squares technique, a linear programming (LP) technique, a quadratic programming technique, a regression technique, a mixed integer linear programming technique, a mixed integer nonlinear programming technique, etc. The output from the continuous model is output as continuous evaluation data. The continuous evaluation data can be provided to the continuous data analyzer 202 as feedback, such as for detecting trends.

[0040] The continuous health index estimator 204 receives and processes the continuous assessment data and transforms it into a continuous health index, which is a numerical value representing the health of the mechanical system indicated by the continuous system data. The continuous health index is provided in a predetermined format compatible with the combined health evaluator 120. The continuous health index estimator 204 may determine it in real time as the continuous system data is received.

[0041] A continuous confidence indicator (C-CI) is determined that indicates the confidence level in the continuous system data and the continuous assessment data determined therefrom. The C-CI can be considered a measure of the + / - variability associated with the continuous health index. Techniques for determining the C-CI can include, for example, statistical techniques, application of business rules, etc.

[0042] For example, the C-CI may be lowered when the confidence level decreases due to undesirable variability detected in the continuous system data in view of historical continuous system data as indicated by feedback from the continuous assessment data.

[0043] The C-CI may also be affected by positive or negative changes in the envelope of range values ​​of the measured combination of physical characteristics of the continuous system data related to stability, such as the flight envelope indicative of aerodynamic stability. The C-CI may be increased when the continuous system data is consistent with expectations and / or the resolution of the continuous system data is relatively high. The C-CI may be decreased when the envelope deviates from stable conditions, the continuous system data is inconsistent with expectations, and / or the resolution of the continuous system data is low.

[0044] The C-CI may be provided as feedback to the continuous data analyzer 202 to detect trends in the C-CI, such as a decrease in the C-CI, which may be attributed to possible errors in the continuous system data or possible errors in the techniques used by the continuous data analyzer 202 to analyze the continuous system data. As the C-CI decreases (indicating a decrease in confidence in the continuous health index), the importance of the next and subsequent calculations of the continuous health index may be reduced, such as by adjusting the weight applied to the continuous health index for future calculations. Return to Reference Figure 1 The discontinuous system data sources 112 may include, for example, but are not limited to, cameras (which acquire still photos or videos), acoustic sensors, thermal sensors, thermal imagers, X-ray imagers, pressure sensors, spectrometers, current sensors, ultrasonic sensors, laboratory results (such as for measuring metallurgical properties or pulp kappa number), manually or automatically generated lists of input data therein. The output of each discontinuous system data source 112 may provide a discontinuous system data channel.

[0045] The discontinuous system data source 112 provides discontinuous system data to the discontinuous data processor 114, with intervals between data provision. The discontinuous system data source 112 can be activated to sense or measure physical properties during a periodic or non-periodic inspection process, or to obtain manually entered data. The inspection process can be obtained by managing tests, such as using non-destructive testing methods, which can involve the application of energy fields, energy pulses, fluids, etc., and sensing, measuring and / or observing physical characteristics of the mechanical system as it responds.

[0046] In contrast to continuous system data, discontinuous system data is obtained intermittently. Different types of discontinuous system data can be obtained by administering different tests. Tests can be performed separately by different entities at different times. The results of various tests can be compared to various thresholds to determine whether the health of the mechanical system has deteriorated. In some cases, individual tests may not indicate degradation of health, and the combination of these individual results can indicate that degradation of health has occurred. In addition, even when the combination of discontinuous system data sensors 112 does not output a result indicating degradation of health, health degradation can be notified based on the combination of discontinuous system data from one or more discontinuous system data sources 112 and the output from the continuous system data source 102.

[0047] The discontinuous data processor 114 receives and evaluates the discontinuous system data. An individual discontinuous health score may be generated for each discontinuous system data channel, for example, as a function of the fault-free discontinuous system data corresponding to the particular discontinuous system data channel. The discontinuous data processor 114 may calculate and output a discontinuous health index as a function (e.g., a weighted average) of the individual discontinuous health scores. The discontinuous health index provides a quantitative measure of the health of the mechanical system based on the discontinuous system data.

[0048] The continuous health index and the discontinuous health index are provided to the combined health evaluator 120. The combined health evaluator 120 can combine the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index to generate an overall assessment of the health of the mechanical system. The overall health assessment can be output, such as to a display module 132 for display. In addition, the overall health assessment can be output to the combined health evaluator 120 as assessment feedback data, such as for tracking historical health assessments, comparing with historical health assessments, and / or detecting trends.

[0049] The overall health assessment can be evaluated by the combined health evaluator 120 to determine whether action is needed, such as maintaining or improving the health of the mechanical system, avoiding risks, and / or collecting additional continuous system data or discontinuous system data. When it is determined that action is needed, the combined health evaluator 120 submits commands and / or notifications to the system-related components 130. For example, a command can be sent to shut down one or more components of the mechanical system. In another example, maintenance or repair of components of the mechanical system can be requested. In a further example, an alarm can be activated to warn individuals to evacuate the vicinity of the mechanical system. In yet another example, a command can be issued to commission additional continuous system data sources or discontinuous system data sources, or to change the settings (e.g., sensitivity or resolution) of existing continuous system data sources 102 and discontinuous system data sources 112.

[0050] Additionally, external data sources 122 may provide external data other than continuous system data and discontinuous system data directly to combined health evaluator 120. External data sources 122 may be external to the mechanical system, or external to a network used by continuous system data source 102 and discontinuous system data source 112 for communicating with continuous data processor 104 and discontinuous data processor 114, respectively. For example, external data sources may measure environmental physical properties, such as temperature or seismic properties, or provide predictions regarding extreme temperatures, extreme wind forces, or seismic activity.

[0051] refer to Figure 3 , the discontinuous data processor 114 includes a discontinuous data analyzer 302 and a continuous health index estimator. The discontinuous data analyzer 302 receives discontinuous system data from the discontinuous system data source 112. The discontinuous data analyzer 302 applies an algorithm and / or a model (such as a discontinuous model 312) to the discontinuous system data and outputs discontinuous evaluation data. The applied techniques may include one or more of a least squares technique, a linear programming (LP) technique, a quadratic programming technique, a regression technique, a mixed integer linear programming technique, a mixed integer nonlinear programming technique, etc. The discontinuous evaluation data may be provided to the discontinuous data analyzer 302 as feedback, such as for detecting trends.

[0052] The discontinuous health index estimator 304 processes the discontinuous assessment data and transforms it into a discontinuous health index. The discontinuous health index can be a function of an individual discontinuous health score corresponding to a corresponding discontinuous system data channel. The individual discontinuous health score is a function of the discontinuous system data corresponding to the corresponding discontinuous system data channel, and in one or more embodiments can be a function of the corresponding non-fault discontinuous system data. The discontinuous health index can be a quantitative (e.g., a number) or qualitative (e.g., a qualitative range, such as excellent, good, fair, poor, or severe) value representing the health of the mechanical system. The discontinuous health index is provided in a predetermined format compatible with the combined health evaluator 120. The discontinuous health index estimator 204 can be determined in real time as the discontinuous system data is received.

[0053] A discontinuity confidence indicator (DC-CI) is determined that indicates discontinuous system data and thereby determines a confidence level of the discontinuous rating data. Techniques for determining the DC-CI may include, for example, statistical techniques, application of business rules, and the like.

[0054] For example, DC-CI may be lowered when confidence is reduced due to discontinuous system data or a trend in the discontinuous system data over time, as indicated by discontinuous feedback data or feedback from discontinuous evaluation data, the discontinuous system data or a trend in the discontinuous system data over time indicating a reduction in stability (e.g., an acceleration of a trend toward a value associated with instability) and / or unexpected variability detected in the discontinuous system data in light of historical discontinuous system data.

[0055] In the former example, the DC-CI may be affected by positive or negative changes in the envelope of the range values ​​of the measured combination of the physical characteristics of the discontinuous system data related to stability. The DC-CI may be increased when the discontinuous system data is consistent with expectations and / or the resolution of the discontinuous system data is relatively high. The DC-CI may be decreased when the envelope deviates from a stable condition, the discontinuous system data is inconsistent with expectations, and / or the resolution of the discontinuous system data is low.

[0056] The DC-CI may be provided as feedback to the discontinuous data analyzer 302 to detect trends in the DC-CI, such as a decrease in the DC-CI, which may be attributed to possible errors in the discontinuous system data or possible errors in the techniques used by the discontinuous data analyzer 302 to analyze the discontinuous system data. As the DC-CI decreases (indicating a decrease in confidence in the discontinuous health index), the importance of the next and subsequent calculations of the discontinuous health index may be reduced, such as by adjusting the weight applied to the discontinuous health index for future calculations.

[0057] In the latter example, as indicated by the discontinuity feedback data, when it is determined that the most recently measured discontinuity system data logically deviates from the historical trend, the DC-CI may be reduced. However, the discontinuity crack indication or measurement should not decrease over time as this would be illogical. The reason for this illogical behavior indicates that there is an undesirable variability in the discontinuity system data, which indicates a decrease in confidence in the discontinuity system data and therefore a decrease in the discontinuity health index, as indicated by a decrease in the DC-CI.

[0058] refer to Figure 4 , the combined health evaluator 120 includes a combining module 402 and an overall health evaluator 404. The combining module 402 receives the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index and the associated corresponding C-CI and DC-CI, and combines them into an overall health index with an associated overall confidence index (O-CI). The received continuous health index and discontinuous health index and the C-CI and DC-CI can be stored as historical data.

[0059] In one or more embodiments, the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index can be combined by applying a combination method to determine O-CI. The combination method can utilize the most recent values ​​and / or one or more historical values ​​of C-CI and DC-CI. When multiple values ​​of C-CI or DC-CI are used to determine O-CI, a combination method can be used to combine multiple values, such as selecting the highest value, selecting the lowest value, and / or averaging, but not limited to this. When combining C-CI and DC-CI to determine O-CI, a combination method can be used, such as selecting the highest value, selecting the lowest value, and / or averaging, but not limited to this. When combining C-CI and DC-CI to determine O-CI, weights can be used, such as for weighted averaging. Weights can be determined based on C-CI and DC-CI values ​​and / or trends of C-CI and DC-CI values. For example, when DC-CI is below a threshold, significantly less than C-CI, or DC-CI is on a downward trend, the weight applied to DC-CI can be reduced.

[0060] The continuous health index and the discontinuous health index may be provided in the same predetermined format and scale to facilitate the combination, or the combination module 402 may perform a translation operation on the continuous health index and / or the discontinuous health index to facilitate the combination. Similarly, the DC-CI and the C-CI may be provided in the same predetermined format and scale to facilitate the combination, or the combination module 402 may perform a translation operation on the DC-CI and / or the C-CI to facilitate the combination.

[0061] The combination of the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index, and the combination of the C-CI and the DC-CI are performed by applying a combination algorithm, without limitation to a particular algorithm. In one or more embodiments, the combination algorithm may select the lowest or highest value to represent all combined values, or weight the selected values ​​and combine all combined weighted and unweighted values ​​using an equation, such as an equation that calculates a mean or average.

[0062] In one or more embodiments, the weights used by the combination algorithm can be dynamic. For example, when a mechanical system is first deployed, the discontinuous system data can be sparse and can be weighted very lightly. Over time, as more discontinuous system data becomes available, the weight applied to the discontinuous health index can increase, such as to 50%. Conversely, if the time between the collection of discontinuous system data increases, the weight applied to the discontinuous health index can decrease.

[0063] In one or more embodiments, the overall health index may be a function not only of the most recent continuous health index and the most recent discontinuous health index, but also of stored historical continuous health indexes and / or historical discontinuous health indexes, thereby using historical data to predict future health-related events.

[0064] Determination of an initial overall health index and associated O-CI or updating of the overall health index and O-CI may be triggered by execution of a check resulting in the receipt of new discontinuous system data by the discontinuous data processor or by receipt of an updated discontinuous health index by the combined health evaluator 120 .

[0065] The overall health index and associated O-CI may be provided to display module 132, which may cause the overall health index and O-CI (and / or commands or notifications) to be displayed. The overall health index and O-CI may further be provided as feedback to a combination module for use with a combination method for determining the overall health index and / or O-CI. The combination method may utilize the most recent value and / or one or more historical values ​​of the overall health index and / or O-CI.

[0066] In one or more embodiments, the overall health index can be provided as feedback to the combined health evaluator 120, such as to trigger commands and / or notifications based on changes in the overall health index. For example, a response to a determination that the overall health index is decreasing or has fallen below a threshold value can include a suggestion to collect additional discontinuous system data, such as increasing the resolution of data collection or adding additional continuous system data sources or discontinuous system data sources. Another example response to a determination that the overall health index is decreasing or has fallen below a threshold value can include reducing the performance of the mechanical system (e.g., reducing an operating setting of the mechanical system) or temporarily removing power from the mechanical system to allow for an offline inspection.

[0067] In one or more embodiments, the O-CI is based on the reliability of the data used to determine the overall health index. For example, the data reliability can be a function of the number of continuous system data sources and discontinuous system data sources (102 and 112) used to provide continuous system data and discontinuous system data to the corresponding continuous data processor 104 and discontinuous data processor 114. An increase in the number of continuous system data sources and / or discontinuous system data sources (102 and 112) used to provide continuous system data and / or discontinuous system data can increase the C-CI and / or DC-CI, respectively, and thus can increase the value of the O-CI. In another example, the O-CI can be a function of the rate of change of a particular continuous or discontinuous system data channel (as indicated by the C-CI and DC-CI), the corresponding continuous health score or discontinuous health score, and / or the continuous health index or discontinuous health index.

[0068] The overall health index and associated O-CI are provided to an overall health assessor 404. The overall health assessor 404 applies an assessment algorithm to determine whether to output a command or notification, for example, to a system-related component 130. Examples of system-related components 130 and actions applied to components include, for example, but not limited to, a valve closed by an action, an alarm system activated by an action to alert individuals that an evacuation is in progress, a continuous system data source or a discontinuous system data source (102 or 112) commissioned by an action to change its sensitivity (higher for more refined data or lower due to nuisance alarms), a mechanism (e.g., a pump or valve) bypassed by an action and replaced by a redundant mechanism, a mechanism sent a notification to a supplier or mechanic to replace or provide service, and the like. In one or more embodiments, an action may include a recommendation to perform an action on a particular component.

[0069] In one or more embodiments, the overall health evaluator 404 can determine when to output commands and / or notifications and / or the urgency of commands and / or notifications based on the trend of the overall health index and / or O-CI. For example, when it is determined that the rate of change of the overall health index and / or O-CI exceeds a threshold, an action can be triggered. Multiple thresholds can be associated with corresponding different actions and urgency levels.

[0070] In one or more embodiments, the overall health evaluator 404 may apply, for example, statistical analysis, probabilistic analysis, machine learning, and / or numerical solver techniques to determine when to output commands and / or notifications. The overall health index may be stored with its associated O-CI for new mechanical systems and stored as a baseline overall health index. When a fault occurs, the most recent overall health index and associated O-CI may be determined and stored as a fault overall health index. The O-CI associated with each baseline and / or fault overall health index may be used to determine an updated overall health index.

[0071] Learning data (such as baseline and / or failure overall health indexes and their associated O-CIs) may be aggregated from multiple health assessment systems 100, such as by a health assessment server 406, to provide aggregated learning data with an aggregate confidence index (A-CI). In addition, the aggregated learning data may be distributed to the health assessment systems 100. The health assessment server 406 may increase or decrease the A-CI based on similarities or differences between baseline and / or failure overall health indexes received from the various health assessment systems 100.

[0072] Each time the overall health evaluator 404 evaluates the overall health in real time (e.g., in response to receipt of new discontinuous system data), the overall health evaluator 404 can compare the calculated overall health index with the baseline and fault overall health indexes. The results of the comparison can be used to determine whether to send commands and / or notifications. The determination of whether to send commands and / or notifications can be based on the results of the comparison of the O-CI associated with the baseline and fault overall health indexes and the current overall health index, the baseline overall health index, and / or the fault overall health index determined in real time.

[0073] Commands and / or notifications may be adjusted based on the associated O-CI. For example, a low O-CI associated with a current and faulty overall health index may result in the provision of a notification with a weak recommendation. The strength of the recommendation may increase as the strength of the associated O-CI increases and / or the rate of change of the continuous health index, discontinuous health index, or overall health index increases. When the associated OCI exceeds a predetermined confidence threshold, the recommendation may be accompanied by a command that causes a strong action, such as shutting down a component and / or alarming evacuation.

[0074] When it is determined that action is required, the combined health assessor 120 submits commands and / or notifications to the system-related components 130. For example, a command may be sent to shut down one or more components of the mechanical system. In another example, maintenance or repair of a component of the mechanical system may be requested. In another example, an alarm may be activated to warn individuals to evacuate the vicinity of the mechanical system. In yet another example, a command may be issued to commission additional continuous system data sources or discontinuous system data sources, or to change settings (e.g., sensitivity or resolution) of existing continuous system data sources 102 and discontinuous system data sources 112.

[0075] External data from external data source 122 may be received by combination module 402 and / or overall health assessor 404. The combination algorithm and / or assessment algorithm may be configured to use the external data to determine a corresponding overall health index, an associated O-CI, and / or commands and / or notifications.

[0076] In the example, and not limited to this particular example, the mechanical system is a pressure vessel. The continuous data processor 104 can be obtained from the continuous system data source 102 (such as Figure 1As shown), a historical library that stores and provides historical continuous system data, one or more programmable logic controllers (PLCs), supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA) systems and / or distributed control systems (DCS) receive continuous system data. The discontinuous data processor 114 can receive pressure and video data and / or data from non-destructive testing (obtained by intermittent inspection) as discontinuous system data, as well as historical discontinuous system data. The combined health evaluator 120 combines the continuous health index and the discontinuous health index received from the continuous data processor 104 and the discontinuous data processor 114. When the overall health index is determined in real time to be similar to the baseline overall health index, the goal will be to maintain the current status unchanged, and the commands and / or notifications can be neutral. When the overall health index is determined in real time to be similar to the fault overall health index, the goal of the commands and / or notifications will be to avoid potential failures. The commands and / or notifications may include emergency messages and / or actions.

[0077] Figure 5 An exemplary and non-limiting flowchart is shown that illustrates a method for generating a software application according to certain illustrated embodiments. The example method may be performed by a health assessment system, such as Figure 1 The health assessment system 100 is shown. Figure 5 Before describing, note that although Figure 5 The flowcharts in the Figures show examples of operation blocks that are performed in a specific order as indicated by the lines connecting these blocks, but the individual blocks shown in these flowcharts can be performed in a different order or in a different combination or sub-combination. It should be understood that in some embodiments, some of the blocks described below can be combined into a single block. In some embodiments, one or more additional blocks can be included. In some embodiments, one or more blocks can be omitted.

[0078] At box 502, discontinuous health-related information about a mechanical system is received. At box 504, a discontinuous health index is generated based on the discontinuous system data. At box 506, continuous health-related information about the mechanical system is received. At box 508, a continuous health index is generated based on the continuous system data. The discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable. At box 510, the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are combined, such as by applying a combination algorithm. At box 512, an overall health index is generated based on the combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index. In one or more embodiments, the overall health index can be expressed as a score. At box 518, automatic actions are caused to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system and / or avoid risks.

[0079] At block 514, in one or more embodiments, a confidence score may optionally be associated with the overall health index based on the reliability of the data used to determine the overall health index. At block 516, in one or more embodiments, the overall health index may optionally be applied as feedback to be combined with the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index for future determinations of the overall health index. For example, a previously determined overall health index as feedback may be combined with the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index for determining an updated overall health index.

[0080] In one or more embodiments, when new discontinuous system data is received, the discontinuous health index is updated in response to the receipt of the discontinuous system data, and the overall health index is updated in response to the update of the discontinuous health index.

[0081] Some examples of actions include adjusting the manner in which discontinuous system data and / or continuous system data is captured; performing an emergency shutdown of related equipment associated with the mechanical system to avoid risk; and providing a notification to a system user or operator to indicate a change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system and / or a recommendation to respond to the change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system.

[0082] refer to Figure 6 , a block diagram of an example computing system 600 is shown, which provides an example configuration of the processing components of the health assessment system 100, namely the continuous data processor 104, the discontinuous data processor 114, and the combined health assessor 120. Additionally, all or part of the processing components of the health assessment system 100 may be configured as software, and the computing system 600 may represent these parts. The computing system 600 is merely an example of a suitable system and is not intended to provide any limitation on the scope of use or functionality of the embodiments of the present disclosure described herein. The computing system 600 may be implemented using hardware, software, and / or firmware. Regardless, the computing system 600 is capable of implementing and / or performing the functions set forth in the present disclosure.

[0083] Computing system 600 is shown in the form of a general purpose computing device. Computing system 600 includes a processing device 602, memory 604, an input / output (I / O) interface (I / F) 606 that can communicate with internal components such as a user interface 610, and optional external components 608.

[0084] Processing device 602 may include, for example, a programmable logic device (PLD), a microprocessor, a DSP, a microcontroller, an FPGA, an ASIC, and / or other discrete or integrated logic circuits with similar processing capabilities.

[0085] The processing device 602 and the memory 604 may be included in components provided in, for example, an FPGA, an ASIC, a microcontroller, or a microprocessor. The memory 604 may include, for example, volatile and non-volatile memory for temporary or long-term storage of data and for storing programmable instructions executable by the processing device 602. The memory 604 may be a removable (e.g., portable) memory for storage of program instructions. The I / OI / F 606 may include interfaces and / or conductors to couple to one or more internal components 610 and / or external components 608.

[0086] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable medium, which can instruct a computer, other programmable data processing device, or other equipment to operate in a specific manner so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable medium produce a product including instructions for implementing the functions / actions specified in one or more boxes of the flowchart and / or block diagram.

[0087] Computer program instructions may also be loaded onto a computer, other programmable data processing apparatus, or other devices to cause a series of operations to be performed on the computer, other programmable apparatus, or other devices to produce a computer-implemented process, such that the instructions executed on the computer or other programmable apparatus provide a process for implementing the functions / actions specified in one or more blocks of the block diagram.

[0088] Embodiments of the processing component of the health assessment system 100 may be implemented or executed by one or more computer systems, such as microprocessors. Each computer system 600 may be included in a processing component of the health assessment system 100 or multiple instances thereof. In the example shown, the computer system 600 is embedded in the processing component of the health assessment system 100. In various embodiments, the computer system 600 may include one or more of a microprocessor, an FPGA, an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a microcontroller. The computer system 600 may be provided as an embedded device. Portions of the computer system 600 may be provided externally, such as by a central computer, a data concentrator, a cockpit computing device that controls the display of gap status (e.g., notifications or alerts about gaps), etc.

[0089] Computer system 600 is only one example of a suitable system and is not intended to suggest any limitation on the scope of use or functionality of the embodiments of the disclosure described herein. Regardless, computer system 600 is capable of implementing and / or performing any of the functions set forth above.

[0090] Computer system 600 may be described in the general context of a computer system executing computer system executable instructions, such as program modules. Generally, program modules may include routines, programs, objects, components, logic, data structures, etc. that perform particular tasks or implement particular abstract data types.

[0091] In the foregoing, reference is made to various embodiments. However, the scope of the present disclosure is not limited to the specifically described embodiments. Rather, any combination of the described features and elements, whether or not related to different embodiments, is contemplated as implementing and practicing the contemplated embodiments. Furthermore, although embodiments may achieve advantages over other possible solutions or prior art, whether or not a given embodiment achieves a particular advantage does not limit the scope of the present disclosure. Therefore, the foregoing aspects, features, embodiments, and advantages are merely illustrative and are not considered elements or limitations of the appended claims unless explicitly detailed in the claims.

[0092] The various embodiments disclosed herein may be implemented as systems, methods, or computer program products. Therefore, various aspects may take the form of full hardware embodiments, full software embodiments (including firmware, resident software, microcode, etc.), or embodiments combining software and hardware aspects, which are generally referred to herein as "circuits," "modules," or "systems." In addition, various aspects may take the form of a computer program product contained in one or more computer-readable media having a computer-readable program code contained thereon.

[0093] Any combination of one or more computer-readable media may be utilized. The computer-readable medium may be a non-transitory computer-readable medium. The non-transitory computer-readable medium may be, but is not limited to, for example, an electronic, magnetic, optical, electromagnetic, infrared or semiconductor system, device or apparatus, or any suitable combination of the foregoing. More specific examples (non-exhaustive list) of non-transitory computer-readable media may include the following: an electrical connection with one or more wires, a portable computer disk, a hard disk, a random access memory (RAM), a read-only memory (ROM), an erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM or flash memory), an optical fiber, a portable compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM), an optical storage device, a magnetic storage device, or any suitable combination of the foregoing. The program code contained on the computer-readable medium may be sent using any appropriate medium, including but not limited to wireless, wired, fiber optic cable, RF, etc., or any suitable combination of the foregoing.

[0094] The computer program code for performing the operation of various aspects of the present disclosure can be written in any combination of one or more programming languages. In addition, this computer program code can be performed using a separate computer system or by multiple computer systems that communicate with each other (for example, using a local area network (LAN), a wide area network (WAN), the Internet, etc.). Although the aforementioned various features are described with reference to flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams, it will be understood by those of ordinary skill in the art that each frame of the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams and the combination of frames in the flowchart illustrations and / or block diagrams can be implemented by computer logic (for example, computer program instructions, hardware logic, a combination of the two, etc.). Typically, computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, or other programmable data processing device. In addition, the execution of this computer program instruction using a processor produces a machine that can perform the function or action specified in one or more frames of a flowchart and / or block diagram.

[0095] The flow charts and block diagrams in the accompanying drawings illustrate the architecture, functions and / or operations of the possible implementations of various embodiments of the present disclosure. In this regard, each frame in the flow chart or block diagram may represent a module, a fragment of code or a portion of code, which includes one or more executable instructions for implementing a specified logical function. It should also be noted that in some alternative implementations, the functions noted in the frame may not appear in the order noted in the figure. For example, the two frames shown in succession can actually be performed substantially simultaneously, or these frames can sometimes be performed in reverse order, depending on the functions involved. It will also be noted that each frame in the block diagram and / or flow chart illustration and the combination of frames in the block diagram and / or flow chart illustration can be implemented by a system based on dedicated hardware or a combination of dedicated hardware and computer instructions that performs a specified function or action.

[0096] It should be understood that the above description is intended to be illustrative, rather than restrictive. After reading and understanding the above description, many other implementation examples are apparent. Although the present disclosure describes specific examples, it should be appreciated that the systems and methods of the present disclosure are not limited to the examples described herein, but can be practiced with modifications within the scope of the appended claims. Therefore, the description and the drawings are to be regarded as illustrative, rather than restrictive. Therefore, the scope of the present disclosure should be determined with reference to the appended claims and the full scope of equivalents to which these claims grant rights.

Claims

1. A method for assessing the health of a mechanical system (100), the method comprising: receiving discontinuous system data obtained intermittently and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100) from one or more first sources (112); as well as receiving continuous system data continuously obtained and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100) from one or more second sources (102); It is characterized by that it also includes generating a single discontinuous health index based on the discontinuous system data; generating a single continuous health index based on the continuous system data, wherein the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable; Combining the discontinuous health index with the continuous health index comprises combining one or more discontinuous health indexes generated over time with one or more continuous health indexes generated over time; generating an overall health index based on a combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; and Based on the overall health index, one or more actions are automatically taken to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system (100) and / or avoid risks.

2. The method according to claim 1, wherein: Combining the discontinuous system data and the continuous system data includes applying a combining method to combine the one or more discontinuous and continuous health indices generated over time. 3 . The method of claim 1 , further comprising capturing at least one of the discontinuous system data and the continuous system data.

4. The method according to claim 3, wherein: The one or more actions include adjusting a manner in which the discontinuous system data and / or the continuous system data is captured.

5. The method according to claim 1, wherein: The one or more actions include performing an emergency shutdown of relevant equipment associated with the mechanical system (100) to avoid a risk.

6. The method according to claim 1, wherein: The one or more actions include providing a notification to a system user or operator indicating a change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system (100) and / or a recommendation to respond to the change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system (100).

7. The method according to claim 1, wherein: The overall health index is represented as a score, and combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index into the overall health index also includes combining one or more previously determined overall health indexes, wherein generating the overall health index is based on a combination of the discontinuous health index, the continuous health index and the one or more previously determined overall health indexes.

8. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: When new discontinuous system data is received, updating the discontinuous health index in real time in response to the receipt of the discontinuous system data; as well as In response to the updating of the discontinuous health index, the overall health index is updated in real time.

9. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: determining at least one of a discontinuous confidence indicator (DC-CI) indicating a confidence level of at least one of the received discontinuous system data and the determined discontinuous health index and a continuous confidence indicator (C-CI) indicating a confidence level of at least one of the received continuous system data and the determined continuous health index; as well as Generate an overall confidence indicator (O-CI), wherein the overall confidence indicator is a function of at least one of the discontinuous confidence indicator and the continuous confidence indicator, a trend of at least one of the discontinuous confidence indicator and the continuous confidence indicator, and / or one or more previously determined O-CIs, wherein a determination of whether to automatically take the one or more actions and / or a selection of the one or more actions to be taken is based on the O-CI and / or a change in the O-CI.

10. The method according to claim 2, wherein: The combining method for combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index applies a weight to each of the discontinuous system data and the continuous system data.

11. The method according to claim 10, wherein: The weights applied to the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are dynamically determined as a function of a discontinuous confidence indicator and a continuous confidence indicator, respectively.

12. A health assessment system for assessing the health of a mechanical system (100), the health assessment system comprising: a memory (604) configured to store a plurality of programmable instructions; as well as At least one processing device (602) in communication with the memory (604), wherein when executing the plurality of programmable instructions, the at least one processing device (602) is configured to: receiving, from one or more first data sources (112), discontinuous system data obtained intermittently and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100); receiving continuous system data continuously acquired and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100) from one or more second data collection sources (102); Characterized in that, when executing the plurality of programmable instructions, the at least one processing device (602) is further configured to generate a single discontinuous health index based on the discontinuous system data; generating a single continuous health index based on the continuous system data, wherein the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable; combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; generating an overall health index based on a combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; and Based on the overall health index, one or more actions are automatically taken to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system (100) and / or avoid risks.

13. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: The one or more actions include at least one of: performing an emergency shutdown of related equipment associated with the mechanical system (100) to avoid a risk, providing a notification to a system user or operator to indicate a change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system (100) and / or a recommendation to respond to the change in the assessment of the health of the mechanical system (100), and adjusting the manner in which the discontinuous system data and / or the continuous system data is captured by the first and / or second data collection sources.

14. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: The mechanical system (100) is associated with an industrial process.

15. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: The mechanical system (100) includes a pressure vessel.

16. The health assessment system according to claim 15, wherein: The pressure vessel is a pulp digester associated with a papermaking process.

17. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: The overall health index is represented as a score, and combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index into an overall health index also includes combining a previously determined overall health index as feedback, wherein generating the overall health index is based on a combination of the discontinuous health index, the continuous health index and the previously determined overall health index.

18. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: When executing the plurality of programmable instructions, the processor (602) is further configured to: When new discontinuous system data is received, updating the discontinuous health index in real time in response to the receipt of the discontinuous system data; and In response to the updating of the discontinuous health index, the overall health index is updated in real time.

19. The health assessment system according to claim 12, wherein: When executing the plurality of programmable instructions, the processor (602) is further configured to: determining at least one of a discontinuous confidence indicator (DC-CI) indicating a confidence level of at least one of the received discontinuous system data and the determined discontinuous health index and a confidence indicator (C-CI) indicating a confidence level of at least one of the received continuous system data and the determined continuous health index; as well as generating an overall confidence indicator (O-CI) that is a function of at least one of the discontinuous confidence indicator and the confidence indicator and / or a trend of at least one of the discontinuous confidence indicator and the confidence indicator, wherein a determination of whether to automatically take the one or more actions and / or a selection of the one or more actions to be taken is based on the O-CI and / or a change in the O-CI.

20. A non-transitory computer-readable storage medium (604) having one or more computer programs embedded therein, which, when executed by a computer system, cause the computer system to: receiving discontinuous system data obtained intermittently and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100) from one or more first data sources (112); as well as receiving continuous system data continuously acquired and associated with the health of the mechanical system (100) from one or more second data collection sources (102); It is characterized in that The one or more embedded computer programs, when executed by the computer system, also cause the computer system to: generating a discontinuous health index based on the discontinuous system data; generating a continuous health index based on the continuous system data, wherein the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index are configured to be combinable; combining the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; generating an overall health index based on a combination of the discontinuous health index and the continuous health index; and Based on the overall health index, one or more actions are automatically taken to maintain or improve the health of the mechanical system (100) and / or avoid risks.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Health degree monitoring equipment for framework type antenna cover structure and monitoring method

    CN109855827A

  • Distribution transformer health index evaluation method, device and system

    CN111080072A