Tire resilience simulation method and device, vehicle and readable storage medium
By detecting the steering wheel stop rotation and calculating the tire rebound force in the online control steering system, controlling the steering wheel to output torque in the opposite direction, simulating the tire rebound feeling, solving the problem that users are unable to adapt to the line control steering system, and real and accurate tire recovery Simulation of elasticity and reduces system costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411130418.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-16
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
The rebound feeling of the vehicle tires in the wire-controlled steering system cannot be felt by users, making it difficult for users to adapt to such vehicles.
By detecting that the steering wheel stops rotation and completes steering when the vehicle travels at a speed of less than or equal to the preset speed, determines the tire rebound force, and calculates the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor based on the rebound force, controls the steering wheel at the start and end time of rebound Output torque in the opposite direction to simulate tire rebound.
Real and accurate tire rebound sensing simulation is achieved, which improves users' recognition of the wire-controlled steering system and saves system costs without increasing hardware.
Smart Images

Figure CN118907214A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application relates to the field of vehicle technology, and more specifically, to a method, device, vehicle and computer-readable storage medium for simulating tire rebound feeling in the field of vehicle technology. Background Art
[0002] Steer-by-Wire (SBW) is an advanced automotive steering technology that overturns traditional mechanical or hydraulic power steering systems. It replaces the physical steering column and connecting rod with electronic signals, and realizes the electronic connection between the user's steering input and the wheel steering execution. Since the SBW system eliminates the mechanical connection between the steering wheel and the steering actuator, the rebound feeling of the vehicle tire cannot be felt by the user, making it difficult for users to adapt to vehicles with SBW systems. Therefore, for vehicles with SBW systems, how to simulate the rebound feeling of the vehicle tires has become an urgent problem to be solved. Summary of the invention
[0003] The present application provides a method, device, vehicle and computer-readable storage medium for simulating the rebound feeling of a tire. The present application realizes the simulation of the rebound feeling of a tire, making it easier for users to adapt to vehicles with a steer-by-wire system, which is conducive to improving users' recognition of the steer-by-wire system.
[0004] In a first aspect, a method for simulating the rebound feeling of a tire is provided, which is applied to a vehicle with a steer-by-wire system, and the simulation method comprises: when the driving speed of the vehicle is less than or equal to a preset speed, if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in a first direction and the steering tire has completed steering, determining the tire rebound force of the steering tire; determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force; determining a rebound start time and a rebound end time; when the rebound start time is reached, controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction; wherein the second direction is the opposite direction of the first direction; when the rebound end time is reached, controlling the steering wheel motor to stop outputting the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
[0005] In the above technical scheme, the embodiment of the present application adopts the following technical scheme: when the vehicle's driving speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in the first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering, the tire rebound force of the steering tire is determined, the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the wire steering system is determined according to the tire rebound force, the rebound start time and the rebound end time are determined, and when the rebound start time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to output the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to rotate in the second direction opposite to the first direction, and when the rebound end time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to stop outputting the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to stop rotating. On the one hand, a realistic and accurate simulation of the tire rebound feeling is achieved, so that users can more easily adapt to vehicles with wire steering systems, which is conducive to improving users' recognition of wire steering systems. On the other hand, the tire rebound force can be obtained by calculation without increasing the system hardware, which is conducive to saving the system cost.
[0006] In combination with the first aspect, in some possible implementations, determining the tire rebound force of the steering tire includes: obtaining an actual steering angle of the steering tire and a rack displacement of a rack in the wire-controlled steering system; obtaining a preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement; determining a difference between the actual steering angle and the preset tire steering angle; and determining a first preset rebound force corresponding to the difference as the tire rebound force.
[0007] In the above technical scheme, by adopting the above technical scheme, the tire rebound force with high authenticity can be calculated without using system hardware, and the calculation process is simple, which solves the problem of complex calculation of tire rebound force. It not only improves the calculation efficiency of tire rebound force, which is conducive to timely simulation of tire rebound feeling, but also reduces the computing power requirements and system costs for the system, and has high practical value.
[0008] In combination with the first aspect and the above-mentioned implementation manner, in some possible implementation manners, determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the wire-controlled steering system according to the tire rebound force includes: correcting the tire rebound force to obtain a corrected rebound force; and determining the target rebound torque according to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque. The target rebound torque is calculated by the steering wheel hand torque and the corrected rebound force. By correcting the tire rebound force, the accuracy of the tire rebound force calculation can be improved, thereby improving the accuracy of the target rebound torque calculation, which is conducive to improving the authenticity and accuracy of the tire rebound force simulation.
[0009] In combination with the first aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, the correcting the tire rebound force to obtain the corrected rebound force includes: acquiring first data, second data and third data; wherein the first data includes the duration of the steering wheel hand torque being less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed being less than or equal to the preset speed, and the rack force of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system, the second data includes the preset tire steering angle and the moving speed of the rack corresponding to the rack displacement of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system, and the third data includes the tire pressure and vehicle load of the steering tire; according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data, the tire rebound force is corrected to obtain the corrected rebound force.
[0010] In combination with the first aspect and the above implementations, in some possible implementations, the correcting the tire resilience according to at least one of the first data, the second data, and the third data to obtain the corrected resilience includes: obtaining preset correction coefficients corresponding to the first data, the second data, and the third data to obtain three preset correction coefficients; and multiplying at least one correction coefficient of the three preset correction coefficients by the tire resilience to obtain the corrected resilience. By applying the correction coefficient to the correction process of the tire resilience, more intelligent and accurate tire resilience feedback can be achieved, which is conducive to further improving the driving experience.
[0011] In combination with the first aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, determining the target rebound torque based on the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque includes: obtaining a mapping relationship between the second preset rebound force and the preset steering wheel hand torque and the preset motor torque; determining the preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the mapping relationship as the target rebound torque, so that the target rebound torque can be calculated quickly, saving the system's computing power.
[0012] In combination with the first aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, determining the rebound starting time includes: when the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to a preset torque, obtaining a first time when the steering wheel stops rotating; and determining the first time as the rebound starting time.
[0013] In combination with the first aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, determining the rebound end time includes: detecting the output torque of the steering actuator motor in the wire-controlled steering system while controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque; when the duration of the output torque being less than the preset torque is greater than the preset duration, if it is detected that the output torque increases, obtaining a second time when the output torque increases; and determining the second time as the rebound end time.
[0014] In a second aspect, a tire rebound feeling simulation device is provided, which is configured for a vehicle with a steer-by-wire system, and the simulation device comprises:
[0015] A first determination module is used to determine the tire resilience of the steering tire if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in the first direction and the steering tire has completed steering when the driving speed of the vehicle is less than or equal to a preset speed;
[0016] a second determination module, configured to determine a target rebound torque of a steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force;
[0017] The third determination module is used to determine the rebound start time and the rebound end time;
[0018] a first control module, configured to control the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque when the rebound start time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction; wherein the second direction is opposite to the first direction;
[0019] The second control module is used to control the steering wheel motor to stop outputting the target rebound torque when the rebound end time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
[0020] In combination with the second aspect, in some possible implementations, the first determination module is specifically used to obtain the actual steering angle of the steering tire and the rack displacement of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system; obtain the preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement; determine the difference between the actual steering angle and the preset tire steering angle; and determine the first preset rebound force corresponding to the difference as the tire rebound force.
[0021] In combination with the second aspect and the foregoing implementation manner, in some possible implementation manners, the second determining module includes:
[0022] A correction unit, used for correcting the tire resilience to obtain a corrected resilience;
[0023] The determination unit is used to determine the target rebound torque according to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque.
[0024] In combination with the second aspect and the above implementation manner, in some possible implementation manners, the correction unit includes:
[0025] an acquisition subunit, configured to acquire first data, second data, and third data; wherein the first data includes a duration during which the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset torque and the speed of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset speed, and a rack force of the rack in the steer-by-wire system; the second data includes a preset tire steering angle and a moving speed of the rack corresponding to the rack displacement of the rack in the steer-by-wire system; and the third data includes a tire pressure of the steering tire and a vehicle load;
[0026] The correction subunit is used to correct the tire resilience according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data to obtain the corrected resilience.
[0027] In combination with the second aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, the correction subunit is specifically used to obtain the preset correction coefficients corresponding to the first data, the second data and the third data respectively, so as to obtain three preset correction coefficients; multiply at least one correction coefficient of the three preset correction coefficients by the tire rebound force to obtain the corrected rebound force.
[0028] In combination with the second aspect and the above-mentioned implementation methods, in some possible implementation methods, the determination unit is specifically used to obtain the mapping relationship between the second preset rebound force and the preset steering wheel hand torque and the preset motor torque; and the preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the mapping relationship is determined as the target rebound torque.
[0029] In combination with the second aspect and the foregoing implementation manner, in some possible implementation manners, the third determining module includes:
[0030] A first time calculation unit is used to obtain a first time when the steering wheel stops rotating when the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset torque; and determine the first time as the rebound start time;
[0031] The second time calculation unit is used to detect the output torque of the steering execution motor in the wire-controlled steering system when controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque; when the duration of the output torque being less than the preset torque is greater than the preset time, if it is detected that the output torque increases, obtain a second time when the output torque increases; and determine the second time as the rebound end time.
[0032] In a third aspect, a vehicle is provided, comprising a memory and a processor. The memory is used to store executable program code, and the processor is used to call and run the executable program code from the memory, so that the vehicle executes the simulation method in the first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect.
[0033] In a fourth aspect, a computer program product is provided, which includes: a computer program code, which, when executed on a computer, enables the computer to execute the simulation method in the first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect.
[0034] In a fifth aspect, a computer-readable storage medium is provided, which stores a computer program code. When the computer program code runs on a computer, the computer executes the simulation method in the above-mentioned first aspect or any possible implementation of the first aspect. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0035] Figure 1 shows a structural diagram of a vehicle steer-by-wire system;
[0036] Figure 2 A schematic flow chart of a simulation method provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0037] Figure 3 A schematic block diagram of calculating the target rebound torque according to an embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0038] Figure 4 A schematic block diagram showing outputting and stopping outputting a target rebound torque according to an embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0039] Figure 5 A schematic structural diagram of a tire rebound feeling simulation device provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0040] Figure 6 A schematic structural diagram of a vehicle provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0041] The technical solution in the present application will be described clearly and in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. Among them, in the description of the embodiments of the present application, unless otherwise specified, " / " means or, for example, A / B can mean A or B: "and / or" in the text is only a description of the association relationship of associated objects, indicating that there can be three relationships, such as A and / or B, which can mean: A exists alone, A and B exist at the same time, and B exists alone. In addition, in the description of the embodiments of the present application, "multiple" refers to two or more than two. In the following, the terms "first" and "second" are used only for descriptive purposes and cannot be understood as implying or suggesting relative importance or implicitly indicating the number of technical features indicated. Therefore, the features defined as "first" and "second" may explicitly or implicitly include one or more of the features.
[0042] The steer-by-wire system is an advanced automotive steering technology that overturns the traditional mechanical or hydraulic power steering system. It replaces the physical steering column and connecting rod with electronic signals, and realizes the electronic connection between the user's steering input and the wheel steering execution. Figure 1 As shown, Figure 1 The structural diagram of the vehicle's wire-controlled steering system is shown. The vehicle's wire-controlled steering system (Steering-By-WireSystem, SBW) includes: a feel simulator and a steering actuator. The feel simulator includes a steering wheel 101, a feel controller 102, a first angle sensor 103, a torque sensor 104, a feel motor 105, a speed reduction mechanism 106, etc. Among them, the feel motor 105 can be understood as a steering wheel motor, and the first angle sensor 103, the torque sensor 104 and the feel motor 105 are all electrically connected to the feel controller 102. The steering actuator includes a steering motor 201, a steering execution controller 202, a second angle sensor 203, a gear 204, a rack 205, a front wheel 206, a speed reduction mechanism 207, etc. Among them, the steering motor 201 can be understood as a steering execution motor, also known as a road feel simulation motor, the speed reduction mechanism 106 and the second angle sensor 203 are both electrically connected to the steering execution controller 202, and the steering execution controller 202 is connected to the feel controller 102 in communication, and the two exchange information. Regarding the steering control of the front wheels 206: the hand feeling controller 102 sends the steering information of the steering wheel 101 to the steering execution controller 202, and the steering execution controller 202 controls the steering motor 201 to rotate, thereby driving the gear 204 to rotate, and the gear 204 rotates to drive the rack 205 to move, thereby realizing the steering of the front wheels 206. Regarding road feeling simulation: the steering execution controller 202 sends the road condition information to the hand feeling controller 102, and the hand feeling controller 102 controls the hand feeling motor 105 to output the corresponding torque, thereby realizing road feeling simulation.
[0043] Based on the structural characteristics of the wire-controlled steering system, the steering wheel torque felt by the driver is simulated by the steering wheel motor in the hand-feel simulator, providing the driver with the necessary steering force and road feedback. In order to better enable the driver to perceive the feedback from the ground, it is necessary to process the force exerted by the ground on the tire and convert it into the output torque of the steering wheel motor, which is the road-feel feedback force. As the only place where the vehicle contacts the ground, the influence of the tire deformation elastic force on the overall characteristic control of the vehicle cannot be ignored, especially in conditions such as low-speed reversing and automatic parking. In traditional steering control, the influence of tire rebound on the steering hand force is usually reduced, but not completely offset, so there will be a certain rebound feeling when the steering wheel stops turning. In order to better simulate the dynamic feeling of this steering wheel hand force, the wire-controlled steering system needs to simulate or selectively replay the tire rebound force to make the steering wheel hand force more realistic and more textured.
[0044] Since the deformation of vehicle tires is difficult to measure, there are individual differences, and they are greatly affected by the environment, it is difficult to digitally describe the resilience of tires with current common technical means. Whether it is directly measuring the elastic force of tire deformation by adding sensors or indirectly measuring the elastic force of tire deformation by the rack force of the rack in the steering actuator, it will greatly increase the cost of the wire control steering system.
[0045] Based on the above problems, the present application provides a method, device, vehicle and computer-readable storage medium for simulating the feeling of tire rebound. The present application can truly and accurately simulate the feeling of tire rebound without increasing the system hardware, making it easier for users to adapt to vehicles with steer-by-wire systems, which is conducive to improving users' recognition of steer-by-wire systems.
[0046] The following is an embodiment of a simulation method provided in the embodiments of the present application.
[0047] Figure 2 A schematic flow chart of a simulation method provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown, such as Figure 2 As shown, the simulation method provided in the embodiment of the present application is applicable to vehicles with a wire-controlled steering system. When the vehicle is stationary or driving at a low speed (for example, in a creeping state), the vehicle's tires have a large contact area with the road surface and a strong friction. When the driver turns the steering wheel, the tires need to overcome static friction before they can start to rotate, which creates a "sticky" feeling. Once the tires start to rotate, the friction decreases, and when the driver releases the steering force, the tires tend to return to their original position, creating a sense of rebound. The method for simulating the rebound feeling of the tire provided in the application aims to simulate the elastic feeling of the tire, and the simulation method includes the following schemes:
[0048] S110: When the driving speed of the vehicle is less than or equal to a preset speed, if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in the first direction and the steering tire has completed steering, determine the tire resilience of the steering tire.
[0049] In an exemplary embodiment, a vehicle's driving speed less than or equal to a preset speed indicates that the vehicle is stationary or driving at a low speed, the first direction is counterclockwise or clockwise, the steering tire refers to the tire of the vehicle's steering wheel, and the steering wheel usually refers to the front wheel.
[0050] Detecting that the steering wheel has stopped turning in the first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering indicates that the driver has controlled the steering tire to complete the steering by turning the steering wheel by a certain angle in the first direction. The judgment process of detecting that the steering wheel has stopped turning in the first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering is: obtaining the steering wheel hand torque and the steering wheel speed. If the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, and the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed for a period of time greater than the set time, it indicates that the driver has stopped turning the steering wheel in the first direction, that is, controlling the steering tire to complete the steering.
[0051] When it is detected that the vehicle is stationary or driving at a low speed, if it is further detected that the steering wheel has stopped turning in the first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering, the tire rebound force of the steering tire is calculated, and the subsequent tire rebound feeling is simulated based on the tire rebound force. Since the tire rebound force is obtained by calculation, there is no need to add additional sensors to measure the tire deformation elastic force, which is conducive to saving system costs.
[0052] S120: Determine a target rebound torque of a steering wheel motor in a steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force.
[0053] After the tire rebound force is obtained, the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system is calculated by the tire rebound force. The target rebound torque can be understood as the output torque used to simulate the tire rebound feeling.
[0054] S130: Determine the rebound start time and the rebound end time.
[0055] S140: When the rebound start time arrives, control the steering wheel motor to output a target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction.
[0056] S150: When the rebound end time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to stop outputting the target rebound torque, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
[0057] The rebound start time can be understood as the start time of simulating the tire rebound force, that is, the time when the steering wheel motor starts to output the target rebound torque. The rebound end time can be understood as the end time of simulating the tire rebound force, that is, the time when the steering wheel motor stops outputting the target rebound torque.
[0058] The second direction is the opposite direction of the first direction. For example, after the driver stops turning the steering wheel counterclockwise to control the steering tire to complete the steering, during the simulation of the tire rebound force, the steering wheel rotates clockwise, that is, the steering wheel rebounds in the clockwise direction; after the driver stops turning the steering wheel clockwise to control the steering tire to complete the steering, during the simulation of the tire rebound force, the steering wheel rotates counterclockwise, that is, the steering wheel rebounds in the counterclockwise direction.
[0059] The rebound start time is calculated, and when the rebound start time is detected to be reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to output the target rebound torque, thereby controlling the steering wheel to rotate in the second direction, thereby realizing the gradual rebound control of the steering wheel.
[0060] In the process of controlling the rebound of the steering wheel, the rebound end time is calculated. If it is detected that the rebound end time has arrived, the steering wheel motor is controlled to stop outputting the target rebound torque, thereby controlling the steering wheel to stop rotating and the rebound of the steering wheel stops, that is, the tire rebound force simulation is completed.
[0061] The embodiment of the present application adopts a technical solution that, when the vehicle's driving speed is less than or equal to a preset speed, if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in a first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering, the tire rebound force of the steering tire is determined, the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the wire steering system is determined according to the tire rebound force, the rebound start time and the rebound end time are determined, and when the rebound start time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to output the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction opposite to the first direction, and when the rebound end time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to stop outputting the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to stop rotating. On the one hand, a realistic and accurate simulation of the tire rebound feeling is achieved, making it easier for users to adapt to vehicles with a wire steering system, which is conducive to improving users' recognition of the wire steering system. On the other hand, the tire rebound force can be obtained by calculation without increasing the system hardware, which is conducive to saving the system cost.
[0062] The following Figure 1 The specific implementation methods of each step in the embodiment shown are described as follows:
[0063] Because the rebound force of the tire is more obvious when the vehicle is stationary or driving at a low speed, the tire rebound simulation when the vehicle is stationary or driving at a low speed needs to be considered in the wire control steering system. For the tire rebound simulation, multiple data curves are constructed in advance based on the actual vehicle conditions. The construction process is as follows:
[0064] Under the actual vehicle condition, the steering actuator motor in the steering actuator is controlled by the host computer to rotate at a speed v, thereby driving the rack to move, and then the rack drives the steering tire to steer, so that the actual steering angle of the steering tire reaches the target steering angle θ, and then the steering tire is controlled to maintain a certain time t at the target steering angle θ, and the torque output of the steering actuator motor is turned off, that is, the steering actuator motor is controlled to stop outputting torque, and then when the torque output of the steering actuator motor is turned off, the data of the tire rebound force, the rack force of the rack (obtained by collecting the pull rod data through the external sensor), the motor torque of the steering actuator motor, the rack stroke (i.e., rack displacement), and the rack moving speed are collected. Based on the above operations, different tire pressures, different vehicle loads, different steering wheel speeds (set by the host computer) and different target steering angles θ are set respectively, and then the corresponding tire rebound force, rack force, motor torque of the steering actuator motor, rack displacement, rack moving speed and other data under different tire pressures, different vehicle loads, different steering wheel speeds and different target steering angles θ are collected, so as to construct multiple data curves based on the collected data. The plurality of data curves include first to sixth curves.
[0065] The first curve is a curve about rack displacement and target steering angle θ, that is, the first curve can be understood as a mapping relationship between rack displacement and target steering angle θ, including multiple rack displacements, and target steering angles corresponding to each of the multiple rack displacements. The target steering angle in the first curve is called a preset tire steering angle.
[0066] The second curve is a curve about the steering angle difference and the tire resilience. The steering angle difference is the difference between the actual steering angle of the steering tire and the target steering angle θ collected when the steering tire is controlled to maintain the target steering angle θ for a certain period of time t and the torque output of the steering execution motor is turned off. The second curve can be understood as a mapping relationship between the steering angle difference and the tire resilience, including multiple steering angle differences and the tire resilience corresponding to each steering angle difference. The tire resilience in the second curve is called the first preset resilience.
[0067] The third curve is a curve about the target steering angle θ and the moving speed of the rack and the first correction coefficient. The third curve can be understood as the mapping relationship between the target steering angle θ and the moving speed of the rack and the first correction coefficient.
[0068] The fourth curve is a curve about the time length t and the rack force and the second correction coefficient. The fourth curve can be understood as the mapping relationship between the time length t and the rack force and the second correction coefficient.
[0069] The fifth curve is a curve about tire pressure, vehicle load and the third correction coefficient. The fifth curve can be understood as a mapping relationship between tire pressure, vehicle load and the third correction coefficient.
[0070] The sixth curve is a curve of the steering wheel hand torque and the tire rebound force and the motor torque. The sixth curve can be understood as the mapping relationship between the steering wheel hand torque and the tire rebound force and the motor torque. The steering wheel hand torque in the sixth curve is called the preset steering wheel hand torque, the tire rebound force is called the second preset rebound force, and the motor torque is called the preset motor torque.
[0071] In a possible implementation, the above-mentioned determination of the tire resilience of the steering tire includes the following scheme:
[0072] Get the actual steering angle of the steering tire and the rack displacement of the rack in the steer-by-wire system;
[0073] Obtaining a preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement;
[0074] determining a difference between an actual steering angle and a preset tire steering angle;
[0075] The first preset resilience corresponding to the difference is determined as the tire resilience.
[0076] When it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped turning in the first direction and the steering tire has completed the steering, the actual steering angle of the steering tire and the rack displacement of the rack are obtained, and the first curve is queried through the rack displacement to obtain the preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement in the first curve, and then the difference between the actual steering angle and the preset tire steering angle obtained by the query is calculated, and the second curve is queried through the calculated difference to obtain the first preset rebound force corresponding to the difference in the second curve, that is, the first preset rebound force corresponding to the difference in the second curve is the tire rebound force of the steering tire. By adopting the above technical solution, the present application can calculate the tire rebound force with high authenticity without using system hardware, and the calculation process is simple, which solves the problem of complex calculation of tire rebound force, not only improves the calculation efficiency of tire rebound force, which is conducive to timely simulation of the rebound feeling of the tire, but also reduces the computing power requirements and system cost for the system, and has high practical value.
[0077] In a possible implementation, determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force includes the following solutions:
[0078] Correcting the tire rebound force to obtain the corrected rebound force;
[0079] The target rebound torque is determined based on the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque.
[0080] After the tire rebound force is obtained, the tire rebound force is corrected to obtain the corrected rebound force, and then the steering wheel hand torque is obtained, and the target rebound torque is calculated by the steering wheel hand torque and the corrected rebound force. By correcting the tire rebound force, the accuracy of the tire rebound force calculation can be improved, thereby improving the accuracy of the target rebound torque calculation, which is conducive to improving the authenticity and accuracy of the tire rebound force simulation.
[0081] In the vehicle state, when the tire starts to turn from a stable angle and exceeds a certain angle, the tire's rebound force and the output torque of the steering actuator motor interact with the rack, that is, the tire's rebound force and the output torque generated by the steering actuator motor generate an interaction force on the rack, which jointly determines the tire's steering. When the rebound force and the output torque of the steering actuator motor are in a state of mutual balance, the tire's rebound force will gradually be released due to its own characteristics. If the torque output of the steering actuator motor is turned off in a certain equilibrium state, the tire's rebound force will push the rack to move until the rebound force is balanced with other resistances of the system. Based on the above tire rebound principle, according to actual verification and summary, factors such as the tire's steering angle, the rack's moving speed, the moment of turning off the steering actuator motor's torque, and the tire's tire pressure all have an impact on the tire rebound process.
[0082] Combined with the above analysis, under different conditions, the rack force, tire steering angle, rack moving speed, time t, tire pressure and load during the tire rebound process have an impact on the tire rebound force. The accuracy of the tire rebound force calculation can be improved by correcting the tire rebound force through the rack force, tire steering angle, rack moving speed, time t, tire pressure and load.
[0083] In a possible implementation, determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force includes the following solutions:
[0084] Acquire first data, second data, and third data;
[0085] The tire resilience is corrected according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data to obtain a corrected resilience.
[0086] The first data includes the duration during which the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, and the rack force of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system. The second data includes the preset tire steering angle and the rack movement speed corresponding to the rack displacement of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system. The third data includes the tire pressure of the steering tire and the vehicle load.
[0087] After obtaining the first data, the second data and the third data, the tire rebound force is corrected by using at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data, and then the corrected rebound force is used to participate in the calculation of the target rebound torque, which is conducive to more realistic tire rebound force simulation and further enhances the driving experience.
[0088] In a possible implementation, determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force includes the following solutions:
[0089] Obtaining preset correction coefficients corresponding to the first data, the second data, and the third data, respectively, to obtain three preset correction coefficients;
[0090] The corrected resilience is obtained by multiplying at least one of the three preset correction coefficients by the resilience of the tire.
[0091] The fourth curve is queried through the first data to obtain the second correction coefficient S2 corresponding to the first data; the third curve is queried through the second data to obtain the first correction coefficient S1 corresponding to the second data, and the fifth curve is queried through the third data to obtain the third correction coefficient S3 corresponding to the third data. Then, at least one of S1-S3 is multiplied by the tire resilience to obtain the corrected resilience. For example, the corrected resilience is expressed as F2, the tire resilience is expressed as F1, and F2 = F1×S1×S2×S3.
[0092] The above technical solution, by applying the correction coefficient to the correction process of the tire rebound force, can achieve more intelligent and accurate tire rebound force feedback, which is conducive to further improving the driving experience.
[0093] In a possible implementation, determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force includes the following solutions:
[0094] Acquire a mapping relationship between a second preset rebound force and a preset steering wheel hand torque and a preset motor torque;
[0095] The preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the mapping relationship is determined as the target rebound torque.
[0096] After obtaining the corrected rebound force and steering wheel hand torque, the mapping relationship between the second preset rebound force and the preset steering wheel hand torque and the preset motor torque is queried through the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque, that is, the sixth curve is queried to obtain the preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the sixth curve, that is, the preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque is the target rebound torque. In this way, the target rebound torque can be calculated quickly, saving the system's computing power.
[0097] In a possible implementation, the above-mentioned determination of the rebound starting time includes the following scheme:
[0098] When the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to the preset torque, obtaining the first time when the steering wheel stops rotating;
[0099] The first time is determined as the rebound starting time.
[0100] If the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to the preset torque, it means that the driver's hands have left the steering wheel or the driver is holding the steering wheel lightly; if the steering wheel speed is detected to be less than or equal to the preset speed, it means that the steering wheel has stopped turning; if the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, it means that the driver has stopped turning the steering wheel and controlled the steering tire to complete the steering. The first time can be understood as the moment when the driver stops turning the steering wheel and controls the steering tire to complete the steering. The first time is determined as the rebound start time. Then, when the driver stops turning the steering wheel and controls the steering tire to complete the steering, the steering wheel motor is controlled to output the target rebound torque, thereby starting to simulate the rebound force of the tire.
[0101] In a possible implementation, the above-mentioned determination of the rebound end time includes the following schemes:
[0102] Under the condition that the steering wheel motor is controlled to output a target rebound torque, the output torque of the steering actuator motor in the steer-by-wire system is detected;
[0103] When the duration of the output torque being less than the preset torque is longer than the preset duration, if it is detected that the output torque increases, obtaining a second time when the output torque increases;
[0104] The second time is determined as the rebound end time.
[0105] During the tire rebound process, when the tire deformation recovers to a certain extent, the torque output by the steering actuator motor will reach a minimum point and then begin to gradually increase. The reason behind this phenomenon is that when the tire starts to rebound from the deflected state, the elastic potential energy of the tire is released in the initial stage, so the torque that the steering actuator motor needs to output is small, and may even be close to zero. However, as the tire gradually returns to its natural state, factors such as the friction between the tire and the ground and the vehicle suspension system begin to play a role, which will increase the resistance that the steering actuator motor needs to overcome, causing the torque output by the steering actuator motor to gradually increase.
[0106] Based on the above reasons, the calculation process for the rebound end time includes: in the case of controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque, the output torque of the steering actuator motor is detected in real time, and the change of the output torque of the steering actuator motor is judged. If it is determined that the output torque is less than the preset torque, it is further detected whether the duration of the output torque less than the preset torque is greater than the preset duration. If the duration is greater than the preset duration, it means that the output torque of the steering actuator motor has been continuously less than the preset torque for a certain period of time. If the output torque is less than the preset torque for a duration greater than the preset duration, it is detected that the output torque increases, that is, it is greater than the preset torque, indicating that factors such as the friction between the tire and the ground and the vehicle suspension system begin to play a role, thereby increasing the resistance that the steering actuator motor needs to overcome, and the output torque of the steering actuator motor increases to counteract the resistance, then the second time when the output torque increases is obtained, and the second time is the rebound end time, that is, the time to end the simulation of the rebound force of the tire, so as to stop simulating the rebound force of the tire, control the steering wheel motor to stop outputting the target rebound torque, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating, and the simulation of the rebound force of the tire is completed.
[0107] Figure 3 A schematic block diagram of calculating the target rebound torque according to an embodiment of the present application is shown. Figure 3 As shown, L1-L6 correspond to the first curve to the sixth curve, J represents the preset torque, A represents the preset rotation speed, V represents the preset speed, and N represents the target rebound torque.
[0108] Regarding the calculation of the target rebound torque: if it is determined that the vehicle's driving speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, the preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement is obtained by querying L1 through the rack displacement, the tire rebound force F1 of the steering tire is obtained by querying L2 through the difference between the preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement and the actual steering angle of the steering tire, and the first correction coefficient S1 is obtained by querying L3 through the preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement and the moving speed of the rack.
[0109] If the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, obtain the duration for which the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, and obtain the second correction coefficient S2 by querying L4 through the maintenance duration and rack force, and obtain the third correction coefficient S3 by querying L5 through the tire pressure and vehicle load.
[0110] The corrected rebound force is expressed as F2, F2 = F1 × S1 × S2 × S3. By querying L6 with the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand force, the target rebound torque N is obtained.
[0111] Figure 4 A schematic block diagram of outputting and stopping outputting the target rebound torque according to an embodiment of the present application is shown, as shown in FIG. Figure 4 As shown, M represents the steering wheel motor, C represents the output torque of the steering wheel motor, and the y condition is that the output torque of the steering wheel motor is less than the preset torque for a duration greater than the preset time and an increase in the output torque is detected.
[0112] Regarding the output of target rebound torque: if it is detected that the steering wheel hand torque is less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed is less than or equal to the preset speed, the steering wheel motor is controlled to output torque according to the target rebound torque N, and it is determined whether the output torque of the steering wheel motor meets the y condition. If it does not meet the condition, it means that the tire rebound has not yet ended, that is, the simulation of the tire rebound feeling is still in progress, then the simulation of the tire rebound feeling continues; if it meets the condition, it means that the time to end the simulation of the tire rebound feeling has arrived, then the simulation of the tire rebound feeling is stopped.
[0113] Based on the above tire rebound simulation solution, not only the problem of complex calculation of tire rebound force is solved, but also the problem of difficulty or distortion in simulating tire rebound force is solved, which is conducive to saving the system's computing resources and costs. By taking tire rebound force as the basis and combining it with the steering wheel operation action to control the start and end of the tire rebound force simulation, a good tire rebound force simulation hand torque can be obtained, and a real and accurate tire rebound simulation is achieved, making it easier for users to adapt to vehicles with a wire-controlled steering system, which is conducive to improving users' recognition of the wire-controlled steering system.
[0114] The following is an embodiment of the device of the present application, which can be used to execute the embodiment of the method of the present application. For details not disclosed in the embodiment of the device of the present application, please refer to the embodiment of the method of the present application.
[0115] Figure 5 FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing a structure of a tire rebound simulation device provided in an embodiment of the present application. Figure 5 As shown, a tire rebound feeling simulation device 500 is configured on a vehicle with a steer-by-wire system, and the simulation device 500 includes:
[0116] A first determination module 510 is used to determine the tire resilience of the steering tire if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in the first direction and the steering tire has completed steering when the vehicle's driving speed is less than or equal to a preset speed;
[0117] A second determination module 520 is used to determine a target rebound torque of a steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force;
[0118] The third determination module 530 is used to determine the rebound start time and the rebound end time;
[0119] A first control module 540 is configured to control the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque when the rebound start time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction; wherein the second direction is opposite to the first direction;
[0120] The second control module 550 is configured to control the steering wheel motor to stop outputting the target rebound torque when the rebound end time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
[0121] In one possible implementation, the first determination module 510 is specifically used to obtain the actual steering angle of the steering tire and the rack displacement of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system; obtain a preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement; determine the difference between the actual steering angle and the preset tire steering angle; and determine a first preset rebound force corresponding to the difference as the tire rebound force.
[0122] In a possible implementation, the second determining module 520 includes:
[0123] A correction unit, used for correcting the tire resilience to obtain a corrected resilience;
[0124] The determination unit is used to determine the target rebound torque according to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque.
[0125] In a possible implementation, the correction unit includes:
[0126] an acquisition subunit, configured to acquire first data, second data, and third data; wherein the first data includes a duration during which the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset torque and the speed of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset speed, and a rack force of the rack in the steer-by-wire system; the second data includes a preset tire steering angle and a moving speed of the rack corresponding to the rack displacement of the rack in the steer-by-wire system; and the third data includes a tire pressure of the steering tire and a vehicle load;
[0127] The correction subunit is used to correct the tire resilience according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data to obtain the corrected resilience.
[0128] In one possible implementation, the correction subunit is specifically used to obtain the preset correction coefficients corresponding to the first data, the second data and the third data respectively, so as to obtain three preset correction coefficients; and multiply at least one correction coefficient among the three preset correction coefficients by the tire rebound force to obtain the corrected rebound force.
[0129] In one possible implementation, the determination unit is specifically used to obtain a mapping relationship between the second preset rebound force and the preset steering wheel hand torque and the preset motor torque; and determine the preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the mapping relationship as the target rebound torque.
[0130] In a possible implementation, the third determining module 530 includes:
[0131] A first time calculation unit is used to obtain a first time when the steering wheel stops rotating when the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to a preset torque; and determine the first time as the rebound start time;
[0132] The second time calculation unit is used to detect the output torque of the steering execution motor in the wire-controlled steering system when controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque; when the duration of the output torque being less than the preset torque is greater than the preset time, if it is detected that the output torque increases, obtain a second time when the output torque increases; and determine the second time as the rebound end time.
[0133] It should be noted that the tire rebound simulation device provided in the above embodiment only uses the division of the above functional modules as an example when executing the simulation method. In actual applications, the above functions can be assigned to different functional modules as needed, that is, the internal structure of the device can be divided into different functional modules to complete all or part of the functions described above. In addition, the tire rebound simulation device provided in the above embodiment and the simulation method embodiment belong to the same concept, so for details not disclosed in the device embodiment of the present application, please refer to the above simulation method embodiment of the present application, which will not be repeated here.
[0134] The serial numbers of the above-mentioned embodiments of the present application are for description only and do not represent the advantages or disadvantages of the embodiments.
[0135] Figure 6 A schematic diagram of the structure of a vehicle provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown. Figure 6 As shown, the vehicle 600 includes: a memory 601 and a processor 602, wherein the memory 601 stores an executable program code 6011, and the processor 602 is used to call and execute the executable program code 6011 to perform a simulation method.
[0136] In this embodiment, the functional modules of the vehicle can be divided according to the above method example. For example, each functional module can be corresponded, or two or more functions can be integrated into one processing module. The above integrated module can be implemented in the form of hardware. It should be noted that the division of modules in this embodiment is schematic and is only a logical function division. There may be other division methods in actual implementation.
[0137] In the case of dividing each functional module according to each function, the vehicle may include: a first determination module, a second determination module, a third determination module, a first control module, a second control module, etc. It should be noted that all relevant contents of each step involved in the above method embodiment can be referred to the functional description of the corresponding functional module, which will not be repeated here.
[0138] The vehicle provided in this embodiment is used to execute the above-mentioned simulation method, and thus can achieve the same effect as the above-mentioned implementation method.
[0139] In the case of an integrated unit, the vehicle may include a processing module and a storage module. The processing module may be used to control and manage the actions of the vehicle. The storage module may be used to support the vehicle in executing relevant program codes and data.
[0140] The processing module may be a processor or a controller, which may implement or execute various exemplary logic blocks, modules and circuits described in conjunction with the disclosure of this application. The processor may also be a combination that implements computing functions, such as a combination of one or more microprocessors, a combination of digital signal processing (DSP) and a microprocessor, etc. The storage module may be a memory.
[0141] This embodiment further provides a computer-readable storage medium, in which a computer program code is stored. When the computer program code is executed on a computer, the computer executes the above-mentioned related method steps to implement a simulation method in the above-mentioned embodiment.
[0142] This embodiment also provides a computer program product. When the computer program product runs on a computer, it enables the computer to execute the above-mentioned related steps to implement a simulation method in the above-mentioned embodiment.
[0143] In addition, the vehicle provided in the embodiments of the present application may specifically be a chip, component or module, and the vehicle may include a connected processor and memory; wherein the memory is used to store instructions, and when the vehicle is running, the processor may call and execute instructions so that the chip executes a simulation method in the above embodiments.
[0144] Among them, the vehicle, computer-readable storage medium, computer program product or chip provided in this embodiment are all used to execute the corresponding simulation methods provided above. Therefore, the beneficial effects that can be achieved can refer to the beneficial effects in the corresponding simulation methods provided above, and will not be repeated here.
[0145] Through the description of the above implementation methods, technical personnel in the relevant field can understand that for the convenience and simplicity of description, only the division of the above-mentioned functional modules is used as an example. In actual applications, the above-mentioned functions can be assigned to different functional modules as needed, that is, the internal structure of the device can be divided into different functional modules to complete all or part of the functions described above.
[0146] In the embodiments provided in the present application, it should be understood that the disclosed devices and methods can be implemented in other ways. For example, the device embodiments described above are only schematic, for example, the division of modules or units is only a logical function division, and there may be other division methods in actual implementation, such as multiple units or components can be combined or integrated into another device, or some features can be ignored or not executed. Another point is that the mutual coupling or direct coupling or communication connection shown or discussed can be through some interfaces, indirect coupling or communication connection of devices or units, which can be electrical, mechanical or other forms.
[0147] The above contents are only specific implementation methods of the present application, but the protection scope of the present application is not limited thereto. Any technician familiar with the technical field can easily think of changes or substitutions within the technical scope disclosed in the present application, which should be included in the protection scope of the present application. Therefore, the protection scope of the present application should be based on the protection scope of the claims.
Claims
1. A method for simulating tire rebound feeling, It is characterized in that Applied to a vehicle with a steer-by-wire system, the simulation method comprises: When the vehicle travels at a speed less than or equal to a preset speed, if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in a first direction and the steering tire has completed steering, determining the tire resilience of the steering tire; determining a target rebound torque of a steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force; Determine the rebound start time and rebound end time; When the rebound start time arrives, controlling the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction; wherein the second direction is opposite to the first direction; When the rebound end time is reached, the steering wheel motor is controlled to stop outputting the target rebound torque, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
2. The simulation method according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Determining the tire resilience of the steering tire comprises: Acquiring an actual steering angle of the steering tire and a rack displacement of a rack in the steer-by-wire system; Obtaining a preset tire steering angle corresponding to the rack displacement; Determining a difference between the actual steering angle and the preset tire steering angle; The first preset resilience corresponding to the difference is determined as the tire resilience.
3. The simulation method according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Determining the target rebound torque of the steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force comprises: Correcting the tire resilience to obtain a corrected resilience; The target rebound torque is determined according to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque.
4. The simulation method according to claim 3, It is characterized in that The correcting the tire resilience to obtain the corrected resilience comprises: Acquiring first data, second data, and third data; wherein the first data includes the duration of the steering wheel hand torque being less than or equal to the preset torque and the steering wheel speed being less than or equal to the preset speed, and the rack force of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system; the second data includes the preset tire steering angle and the moving speed of the rack corresponding to the rack displacement of the rack in the wire-controlled steering system; and the third data includes the tire pressure of the steering tire and the vehicle load; The tire resilience is corrected according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data to obtain the corrected resilience.
5. The simulation method according to claim 4, It is characterized in that The correcting the tire resilience according to at least one of the first data, the second data and the third data to obtain the corrected resilience comprises: Obtaining preset correction coefficients corresponding to the first data, the second data, and the third data, respectively, to obtain three preset correction coefficients; The corrected resilience is obtained by multiplying at least one of the three preset correction coefficients by the tire resilience.
6. The simulation method according to claim 3, It is characterized in that The determining the target rebound torque according to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque comprises: Acquire a mapping relationship between a second preset rebound force and a preset steering wheel hand torque and a preset motor torque; The preset motor torque corresponding to the corrected rebound force and the steering wheel hand torque in the mapping relationship is determined as the target rebound torque.
7. The simulation method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, It is characterized in that Determining the rebound start time includes: When the hand torque of the steering wheel is less than or equal to the preset torque, obtaining the first time when the steering wheel stops rotating; The first time is determined as the rebound starting time.
8. The simulation method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, It is characterized in that Determining the rebound end time includes: Under the condition that the steering wheel motor is controlled to output the target rebound torque, detecting the output torque of the steering actuator motor in the steer-by-wire system; In the case where the duration of the output torque being less than the preset torque is longer than the preset duration, if it is detected that the output torque increases, obtaining a second time when the output torque increases; The second time is determined as the rebound end time.
9. A device for simulating the rebound feeling of a tire. It is characterized in that Configured in a vehicle with a steer-by-wire system, the simulation device comprises: A first determination module is used to determine the tire resilience of the steering tire if it is detected that the steering wheel has stopped rotating in the first direction and the steering tire has completed steering when the driving speed of the vehicle is less than or equal to a preset speed; a second determination module, configured to determine a target rebound torque of a steering wheel motor in the steer-by-wire system according to the tire rebound force; The third determination module is used to determine the rebound start time and the rebound end time; a first control module, configured to control the steering wheel motor to output the target rebound torque when the rebound start time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to rotate in a second direction; wherein the second direction is opposite to the first direction; The second control module is used to control the steering wheel motor to stop outputting the target rebound torque when the rebound end time is reached, so as to control the steering wheel to stop rotating.
10. A vehicle, It is characterized in that The vehicle comprises: A memory for storing executable program codes; A processor, configured to call and run the executable program code from the memory, so that the vehicle executes the simulation method as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 8.
11. A computer-readable storage medium, It is characterized in that The computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program, and when the computer program is executed, the simulation method according to any one of claims 1 to 8 is implemented.
