Deep-sea mining water surface support ship safety assessment method based on FMEA-BN model

By combining the FMEA-BN model with Bayesian networks to conduct risk assessment of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining, the problem of incomplete risk assessment in existing technologies is solved. This enables comprehensive risk identification and ranking of complex systems, improving the accuracy and reliability of the assessment.

CN118916624AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-08TIANJIN UNIV

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410737153.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-06-07
Publication Date
2024-11-08
Estimated Expiration
2044-06-07

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies lack comprehensive risk assessment methods for surface support vessels in deep-sea mining, resulting in limited risk analysis results that cannot effectively identify and manage variable failure modes and cascading effects in complex systems.

Method used

A risk assessment method based on the FMEA-BN model is adopted. Potential risk factors are identified through failure mode and impact analysis. A risk assessment system is established by combining a multi-level comprehensive evaluation method. A Bayesian network model is used to perform fuzzy rating and ranking of risk factors. Expert opinions are incorporated to improve the accuracy of the assessment.

Benefits of technology

It enables comprehensive and reliable risk assessment of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining, identifies key risk factors and provides accurate risk ranking, thereby improving the scientific nature and reliability of risk management.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118916624A_ABST
    Figure CN118916624A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention belongs to the technical field of deep-sea mining risk identification and risk assessment, and particularly relates to a deep-sea mining water surface support ship safety assessment method based on an FMEA-BN model, and the method comprises the following steps: S1, identifying potential risk factors of a deep-sea mining water surface support ship; s2, fuzzy rating of risk factors; s3, an FMEA-BN model is constructed; and S4, sorting the risk factors. According to the method, the risk factors are evaluated under the condition of limited data sources, so that the safety level of the deep-sea mining water surface support ship is comprehensively and objectively reflected, and theoretical and technical support is provided for the safety of a deep-sea mining system.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of deep-sea mining risk identification and risk assessment, and in particular relates to a deep-sea mining surface support vessel safety assessment method based on a FMEA-BN model. Background Art

[0002] Surface support vessels are basic equipment for the development of deep-sea mineral resources. They are mainly responsible for the deployment and recovery of underwater equipment and the temporary storage and transportation of minerals. As a new type of ship operation, the overall performance of surface support vessels is quite different from that of previous ships. They have complex structures, high system integration, and span multiple disciplines. The performance data is multivariate, heterogeneous, and has a small sample. In addition, due to the characteristics of deep-sea mining operations with the coupling of multiple mining equipment, surface support vessels are not only affected by wind, waves, and currents, but also by the linkage of other systems. Therefore, the failure modes of surface support vessels are complex and changeable and have significant correlations. The cascade effect caused by a single failure mode will cause the performance of the surface support ship system to degrade or even lose control, which may lead to accidents. In order to ensure the robustness and reliability of deep-sea mining operations, it is urgent to conduct a comprehensive risk assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels. Currently, there are few analyses on surface support vessels. Reliability and safety analyses of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining by various countries are basically limited to aspects such as stability, safety analysis, and longitudinal strength. There is little discussion on other key factors of safety and reliability, and there is a lack of multi-factor and systematic considerations. As a result, the reliability of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining has not been fully verified, and the results have certain limitations. Summary of the invention

[0003] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a deep-sea mining surface support vessel safety assessment method based on the FMEA-BN model to solve the problems existing in the background technology.

[0004] To achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following technical solution: a method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model, comprising the following steps:

[0005] S1: Identify potential risk factors of deep-sea mining surface support ships; Deep-sea mining surface support ships undertake multiple tasks, including operation, navigation and living, etc. The complexity of their systems and the close relationship between various tasks increase the difficulty of analysis. Therefore, the present invention combines multi-level comprehensive evaluation and failure mode and effect analysis to conduct a comprehensive risk identification of deep-sea mining surface support ships. The factors considered include not only the surface support ship system itself, but also the operating environment and operating process of the surface support ship, thereby constructing a risk assessment index system for deep-sea mining surface support ships.

[0006] S2: Fuzzy rating of risk factors; In view of the relative lack of reliability and safety analysis of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining, there are certain deficiencies in risk data. Therefore, based on the identified risk factors, a questionnaire is used to collect information related to surface support vessels for deep-sea mining. The questionnaire designed by the present invention mainly consists of four parts: basic information of participants, measure of the possibility of risk factors, measure of the severity of risk factors, and measure of the detectability of risk factors. In order to obtain more comprehensive and reliable evaluation opinions, 5 experts with rich experience in the field of deep-sea mining or related industries and research are invited.

[0007] S3: Constructing a FMEA-BN model; the present invention constructs a Bayesian network model of a deep-sea mining surface support vessel.

[0008] S4: Rank the risk factors.

[0009] Preferably, in S1, a failure mode and effects analysis method (FMEA) is used to identify risks of deep-sea mining surface support vessels in operation, and a multi-index deep-sea mining surface support vessel assessment system is established using a multi-level comprehensive evaluation method based on the identified risk factors.

[0010] Preferably, in S2, a questionnaire is used to collect information related to deep-sea mining surface support vessels. The questionnaire mainly consists of four parts: basic information of participants, measure of the possibility of risk factors, measure of the severity of risk factors, and measure of the detectability of risk factors.

[0011] Preferably, in S2, the three risk parameters of the risk factors, namely, possibility (O), severity (S), and detectability (D), are divided into five levels according to the risk matrix of Guidance Notes on Risk Assessment Applications for the Marine and Offshore Industries proposed by the American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), namely, very high (VH), high (H), medium (M), low (L), and very low (VL). These risk parameters are used as indicators for evaluating risk factors.

[0012] Preferably, in S3, the specific construction method is as follows: 1) Calculate the prior probability of the leaf node. The present invention converts the semantic information of the expert on the risk parameter into a fuzzy value by using a Gaussian function. The specific level conversion formula is as follows:

[0013]

[0014] In the formula, S vnrepresents the membership function of the nth level of risk, σ represents the expert's uncertainty, and u represents the membership center corresponding to different levels;

[0015] According to the membership function in formula (1), the probability value distribution matrix H of the five experts is determined m :

[0016]

[0017] In the formula, the elements in the matrix represents the probability of the mth expert evaluating the risk parameter of the nth level, and the sum of the elements in each row of the matrix is ​​1;

[0018] Take the matrix H m One line With another line H j Multiply to get a new matrix NM:

[0019]

[0020] Based on the improved DS evidence theory, the expert evaluation results are integrated by combining two pieces of evidence and recursive calculation. The improved synthesis formula is shown in formula (4), and the result is the prior probability of the leaf node.

[0021]

[0022] In the formula, is the sum of all non-main diagonal elements of the matrix NM, representing the degree of conflict k between the evidences. f(NM)=kq(NM) is the probability distribution function of the evidence conflict, that is, the degree of conflict k between the evidences is distributed to each element in the matrix;

[0023] 2) Constructing a conditional probability table; Based on the confidence of the fuzzy IF-THEN rule base, the present invention uses the proportional method to convert the different levels of risk parameter combinations into conditional probabilities on the basis of the relative weights of the three risk parameters. The specific rule conversion paraphrase is as follows:

[0024]

[0025] in, Indicates that the input satisfies the prerequisite When I z is considered to be the confidence distribution of the result, and z is the number of all possible results.

[0026] Preferably, the utility value Reg is introduced rlThe confidence distribution of the risk status is converted into numerical values ​​for comparison. The risk number (RN) is used to quantitatively describe the value of the parent node. The risk parameter is scored according to its level, with a value range of [1,5]. 1 point indicates the least contribution to the risk, and 5 points indicates the greatest contribution to the risk. Based on the above fuzzy rules, the utility value of the risk factor can be calculated according to formula (7):

[0027] Reg rl =RN(O n )×RN(S n )×RN(D n )(7)

[0028] Among them, Reg r1 It is based on a combination of specific fuzzy rules and associated risk scores;

[0029] Therefore, a new risk ranking number RRN (Risk Rank Number) can be introduced to calculate and rank risk factors. The specific formula is as follows:

[0030]

[0031] Where m(rl) is the probability that the risk state takes the / th reference value.

[0032] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: the present invention proposes a method suitable for risk assessment of complex systems under incomplete data conditions - a risk assessment method based on the improved FMEA-BN model of confidence rules: taking the assessment of the risk of surface support ships for deep-sea mining as an example. The method combines subjective and objective data, calculates the prior probability through evidence theory, then calculates the node probability through the fuzzy rule base, and finally quantifies the risk level of the risk factor. The above implementation example uses the risk assessment method proposed by the present invention to conduct a comprehensive risk analysis of surface support ships. The results show that this method can obtain reliable and accurate risk assessment results. The present invention mainly uses the improved FMEA-BN model based on confidence rules to carry out risk assessment research on surface support ships for deep-sea mining, and uses the probability of conflicting supporting evidence to integrate the evaluation opinions of the expert group, thereby improving the ability to handle multi-source uncertain information, while overcoming the shortcomings of traditional methods that rely too much on subjective judgment of expert scoring. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0033] Figure 1 It is a technical route for risk assessment of surface support vessels for deep-sea mining;

[0034] Figure 2 It is a Bayesian network for deep sea mining surface support vessels. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0035] The specific implementation of the present invention is described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and preferred embodiments.

[0036] like Figure 1-2 As shown in Figure 1, a safety assessment method for deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on the FMEA-BN model, Step 1: Identify risk factors

[0037] Referring to the relevant reliability guidance documents for deep-sea mining surface support vessels, considering the floating production storage and offloading unit (FPSO) with similar operation cycle and the ore carrier with similar structure, the failure mode and effects analysis method (FMEA) was used to identify the risks of deep-sea mining surface support vessels in operation. The results are shown in Table 1. Based on the identified risk factors, a multi-level comprehensive evaluation method was used to establish a multi-indicator deep-sea mining surface support vessel evaluation system, as shown in Table 2. A total of 35 four-level indicators were identified. On this basis, a Bayesian network model was established, as shown in Table 2. Figure 2 As shown, it can be divided into 35 root nodes.

[0038] Table 1 Risk factor identification results

[0039]

[0040] Table 2 Evaluation system for surface support vessels for deep-sea mining

[0041]

[0042] Step 2: Calculate the prior probability of risk factor-related parameters

[0043] Invite 5 experts in related fields with rich experience to evaluate the risk parameters of the four-level indicators using fuzzy semantic words, and convert them into fuzzy numbers according to Gaussian functions. The evaluation results are fused through improved evidence theory. Since the 5 experts involved in the present invention have similar qualifications, they are given the same weight when synthesizing their evaluation results. Taking the risk parameter S of the risk factor "real-time measurement and control system failure" as an example, the evaluation results of the 5 experts, the probability value distribution, and the probability value after data fusion are shown in Table 3-5.

[0044] Table 3 Evaluation results of the failure modes of the real-time measurement and control system

[0045]

[0046] Table 4. Distribution of probability values ​​of fault mode severity of real-time measurement and control system

[0047]

[0048] Table 5 Results of risk factor severity fusion

[0049]

[0050] Step 3: Establish a confidence rule base for risk factor evaluation

[0051] On the basis of “IF-THEN”, combined with the relevant risk status of deep-sea mining surface support risk factors, a confidence rule base is constructed, which has a total of 125 rules (5×5×5). The extended confidence rules are stipulated as follows:

[0052] 1) IF: Occurrence VL, severity VL, detectability VH,

[0053] THEN risk status{(Low,1),(Med i um,0),(H i gh,0)};

[0054] 2) IF: Occurrence degree M, severity M, detectability M,

[0055] THEN risk status{(Low,0),(Med i um,1),(H i gh,0)};

[0056] 3) IF: Occurrence VH, severity VH, detectability VL,

[0057] THEN risk status{(Low,0),(Med i um,0),(H i gh,1)};

[0058] Through Bayesian network modeling, the risk parameters are converted into parent nodes, the risk status is converted into child nodes, and the rules of the confidence rule base are converted into conditional probability form. Finally, the confidence rule base is converted into a Bayesian network. The conditional probability table is shown in Table 6. The risk reasoning results are shown in Figure 2 shown.

[0059] Table 6 Conditional probability table

[0060]

[0061] Step 4: Quantify the risk value

[0062] According to formula (7), the confidence distribution of different risk states of risk factors is calculated as follows:

[0063] Reg r1 =RN(O1)×RN(S1)×RN(D1)=1 3 =1

[0064] Reg r2 =RN(O2)×RN(S2)×RN(D2)=2 3 =8

[0065] Reg r2=RN(O3)×RN(S3)×RN(D3)=3 3 =27

[0066] Reg r2 =RN(O4)×RN(S4)×RN(D4)=4 3 =64

[0067] Reg r3 =RN(O5)×RN(S5)×RN(D5)=5 3 =125

[0068] The risk ranking number is calculated by formula (8), and the RRN of all risk factors is shown in Table 7. During the calculation process, the update of the parent node data will cause the change of the child node distribution, so it can be updated in real time, which is more suitable for practical applications.

[0069] Table 7 Calculation of risk factor RRN

[0070]

[0071]

[0072] The results of Table 7 show that among the factors affecting the safety of deep-sea mining surface support vessels, the top five risk factors are: X29 low operator operation level, X23 too close siding distance, X30 high sea state level, X15 tower and base failure, and X26 wire rope breakage. These five factors have a greater impact on deep-sea mining surface support vessels and are serious risk factors that should be paid attention to. It is necessary to strengthen their monitoring and management.

[0073] In summary, the present invention proposes a method suitable for risk assessment of complex systems under incomplete data conditions - a risk assessment method based on the FMEA-BN improved model of confidence rules: taking the assessment of the risk of surface support ships for deep-sea mining as an example. This method combines subjective and objective data, calculates the prior probability through evidence theory, then calculates the node probability through the fuzzy rule base, and finally quantifies the risk level of the risk factor. The above implementation example uses the risk assessment method proposed in the present invention to conduct a comprehensive risk analysis of surface support ships. The results show that this method can obtain reliable and accurate risk assessment results.

[0074] It should be pointed out that for ordinary technicians in this technical field, several improvements and modifications can be made without departing from the principles of the present invention, and these improvements and modifications should also be regarded as within the scope of protection of the present invention.

Claims

1. A safety assessment method for deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model, characterized in that : Includes the following steps: S1: Identify potential risk factors for surface support vessels in deep-sea mining; S2: Fuzzy rating of risk factors; S3: Construct FMEA-BN model; S4: Rank the risk factors.

2. The method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on the FMEA-BN model according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In S1, the failure mode and effects analysis method (FMEA) is used to identify the risks of deep-sea mining surface support vessels in operation, and a multi-indicator deep-sea mining surface support vessel assessment system is established using a multi-level comprehensive evaluation method based on the identified risk factors.

3. The method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In S2, a questionnaire was used to collect information related to surface support vessels for deep-sea mining. The questionnaire mainly consisted of four parts: basic information of participants, measurement of the possibility of risk factors, measurement of the severity of risk factors, and measurement of the detectability of risk factors.

4. The method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In S2, the three risk parameters of risk factors, namely possibility (O), severity (S), and detectability (D), are divided into five levels according to the risk matrix of Guidance Notes on Risk Assessment Applications for the Marine and Offshore Industries proposed by the American Bureau of Shipping (ABS), namely very high (VH), high (H), medium (M), low (L), and very low (VL). These risk parameters are used as indicators for evaluating risk factors.

5. The method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In S3, the specific construction method is as follows: 1) Calculate the prior probability of the leaf node. The present invention converts the semantic information of the expert on the risk parameter into a fuzzy value by using a Gaussian function. The specific level conversion formula is as follows: In the formula, S vn represents the membership function of the nth level of risk, σ represents the expert's uncertainty, and u represents the membership center corresponding to different levels; According to the membership function in formula (1), the probability value distribution matrix H of the five experts is determined m : In the formula, the elements in the matrix represents the probability of the mth expert evaluating the risk parameter of the nth level, and the sum of the elements in each row of the matrix is ​​1; Take the matrix H m One line With another line H j Multiply to get a new matrix NM: Based on the improved DS evidence theory, the expert evaluation results are integrated by combining two pieces of evidence and recursive calculation. The improved synthesis formula is shown in formula (4), and the result is the prior probability of the leaf node. In the formula, is the sum of all non-main diagonal elements of the matrix NM, representing the degree of conflict k between the evidences. f(NM)=kq(NM) is the probability distribution function of the evidence conflict, that is, the degree of conflict k between the evidences is distributed to each element in the matrix; 2) Constructing a conditional probability table; Based on the confidence of the fuzzy IF-THEN rule base, the present invention uses the proportional method to convert the different levels of risk parameter combinations into conditional probabilities on the basis of the relative weights of the three risk parameters. The specific rule conversion paraphrase is as follows: in, Indicates that the input satisfies the prerequisite When I z is considered to be the confidence distribution of the result, and z is the number of all possible results.

6. The method for safety assessment of deep-sea mining surface support vessels based on FMEA-BN model according to claim 5 is characterized in that: Introducing the utility value Reg rl The confidence distribution of the risk status is converted into a numerical value for comparison. The risk number (RN) is used to quantitatively describe the value of the parent node. The risk parameter is scored according to its level. The value range is [1,5]. 1 point indicates the least contribution to the risk, and 5 points indicates the greatest contribution to the risk. Based on the above fuzzy rules, the utility value of the risk factor can be calculated according to formula (7): Reg rl =RN(O n )×RN(S n )×RN(D n )(7) Among them, Reg r1 It is based on a combination of specific fuzzy rules and associated risk scores; Therefore, a new risk ranking number RRN (Risk Rank Number) can be introduced to calculate and rank risk factors. The specific formula is as follows: Where m(rl) is the probability that the risk state takes the / th reference value.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Roll-on transport ship instant state evaluation method

    CN101149621A

  • Method for assessing reliability of gas fire-extinguishing systems

    CN108595847A

  • Gas turbine system fault mode and influence analysis method based on fuzzy theory

    CN111859809A

  • Evaluation method for marine autonomous surface ship collision accident

    CN118095616A

  • Radar embedded health management system

    WO2021218003A1

Cited By

  • Radiation safety management risk assessment method and system

    CN120125020A