Slope stability evaluation method based on subjective and objective combination weighting-cloud model

By combining subjective and objective weighting in the cloud model, and using the CRITIC and G1 methods to calculate the weights of indicators such as slope angle, a slope stability evaluation model is generated. This solves the problem of the lack of quantitative evaluation results and human consideration in existing technologies, and achieves a more accurate slope stability evaluation.

CN118941128APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12SOUTHWEAT UNIV OF SCI & TECH
View PDF 0 Cites 2 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310528198.X
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-11
Publication Date
2024-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing slope stability evaluation methods lack the precision of quantitative analysis and the insight into human behavior. Subjective methods rely on human feelings and experience, while objective methods rely on experimental data and lack human thought.

Method used

A cloud model based on a combination of subjective and objective weighting is adopted. The weights of indicators such as slope angle and slope height are calculated by combining the CRITIC method and the G1 method. A game-theoretic combination weighting method is used for comprehensive weighting, and a slope stability level evaluation model is generated through a positive cloud generator.

Benefits of technology

This approach improves the accuracy of quantitative analysis in slope stability evaluation and combines it with human consideration, enhancing the rationality and reliability of the evaluation results, which are consistent with the actual slope stability levels.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure FT_1
    Figure FT_1
  • Figure FT_2
    Figure FT_2
  • Figure FT_3
    Figure FT_3
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a slope stability evaluation method. Slope stability is researched by utilizing a cloud model, six evaluation indexes such as a slope angle and a slope height are selected, objective weights and subjective weights of the six evaluation indexes such as the slope angle and the slope height are respectively calculated by applying a CRITIC method and an order relation analysis method (G1 method), and the weights calculated by the CRITIC method and the G1 method are combined and weighted by using a game combination weighting method, so that the slope angle and the slope height are evaluated. And finally determining a comprehensive weight. In combination with a forward cloud generator, membership degrees of different grades of the slope are calculated and compared with an evaluation result of a CRTIC method and an actual grade, so that decision reference is provided for research of slope stability. According to the method, the limitation of a single weighting method is solved, and a subjective and objective combined slope stability evaluation method is established.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the field of slope safety and stability analysis, and in particular to a slope stability evaluation method based on a subjective and objective combined weighted-cloud model. Background Art

[0002] Although the existing cloud model slope stability evaluation method can provide a certain reference for the study of slope stability, it has the following disadvantages.

[0003] 1. Since the subjective slope stability analysis method is based on human consciousness to control everything, it mainly relies on human subjective feelings, experience, etc. for evaluation, resulting in the evaluation results lacking the accuracy of quantitative analysis.

[0004] 2. Since the objective slope stability analysis method is based on specific data to make judgments, it mainly relies on specific data obtained from experiments and evaluates the data according to the standards of system design, resulting in the shortcomings of the evaluation results lacking insights into human thinking and behavior. Summary of the invention

[0005] In order to overcome the shortcomings of the above-mentioned single analysis method, the purpose of the present invention is to provide a slope stability evaluation method based on subjective and objective combined weighting-cloud model. The cloud model is used to study the stability of the slope, and six evaluation indicators such as slope angle and slope height are selected. The objective weights and subjective weights of the six evaluation indicators such as slope angle and slope height are calculated by CRITIC method and ordinal relationship analysis method (G1 method), and the weights calculated by CRITIC method and G1 method are combined and weighted by game combination weighting method, and finally the comprehensive weight is determined. Combined with the forward cloud generator, the membership of different levels of the slope is calculated, and compared with the evaluation results of CRTIC method and the actual level, so as to provide a decision-making reference for the study of slope stability.

[0006] To achieve the above object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is:

[0007] A slope stability evaluation method based on a subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model specifically includes the following steps:

[0008] Step 1: Determine the slope stability classification and the classification standard of slope stability grades corresponding to each indicator.

[0009] Step 2: Determine the digital characteristics of each evaluation indicator of the cloud model.

[0010] Step 3: Use the forward cloud generator to generate the slope stability grade evaluation cloud model through Matlab.

[0011] Step 4: Use the CRITIC method to determine the objective weights and the G1 method to determine the subjective weights.

[0012] Step 5: Calculate the comprehensive weight of indicators using the game combination weighting method.

[0013] Step 6: Calculate the degree of membership of the slope instance in each stability level.

[0014] Step 7: Determine the slope stability grade according to the maximum membership principle.

[0015] The slope stability classification in step 1 is specifically as follows: referring to the slope stability classification standard, and classifying the slope stability into the following five levels: Level I (extremely stable), Level II (stable), Level III (basically stable), Level IV (unstable) and Level V (extremely unstable).

[0016] The specific evaluation indicators include: cohesion, internal friction angle, slope angle, slope height, pore water pressure ratio, and natural bulk density.

[0017] The digital features in step 2 specifically include: the expected E x , entropy E n and super entropy H e Three numerical eigenvalues, among which the super entropy H e Take 0.001.

[0018] Expectation E x , entropy E n and super entropy H e It is derived from the following formula:

[0019] In step 4, the Critic method obtains the indicator weight, and the specific process is as follows:

[0020] (1) Standardization Positive indicators (the bigger the better): ; Negative indicators (the smaller the indicator, the better):

[0021] Where: X ij Specific data expressed as indicators; x j It is expressed as the jth measured value associated with the i-th evaluation index; x max It is expressed as the maximum value of the i evaluation index, x min It is expressed as the minimum value of the evaluation index i.

[0022] (2) Calculate the standard deviation

[0023] In the formula: represents the average value of the sample data; n represents the sample size.

[0024] (3) Calculate the conflict.

[0025] Where: C i is the information content of indicator i relative to the evaluation object; r ij is the correlation coefficient, and the linear correlation coefficient is the main one.

[0026] (4) Calculate the objective weight W of the evaluation index i :

[0027] In step 4, the G1 method is used to obtain the index weights, and the specific process is as follows:

[0028] (1) Determine the order relationship.

[0029] For n evaluation indicators (x1, x2, ..., x n ) Arrange in descending order of importance and determine the order relationship:

[0030] (2) Determine the importance of adjacent indicators.

[0031]

[0032] (3) Determine the weight W n The formula is:

[0033]

[0034] (4) Determine the comprehensive weight.

[0035] In order to ensure that the evaluation index is more objective and comprehensive, S experts (S ≥ 1) are hired to conduct the evaluation. Let the value given by the mth expert among the S experts be denoted as B (m)k , we can get B (m)k The weight is W (m)k The comprehensive weight of each indicator is W k for:

[0036] In step 5, the game weighting method is used to obtain the comprehensive weight of the indicators. The specific process is as follows:

[0037] (1) Assuming that L weighting methods are used to weight n evaluation indicators, the basic weight matrix is:

[0038] In the formula, w kpIt is the weight value corresponding to the pth (p=1,2,...,n)th evaluation index of the kth (k=1,2,...,L)th weighting method.

[0039] (2) Perform linear combination of each weight vector:

[0040] In the formula, a k is the linear combination coefficient of the kth weighting method.

[0041] (3) In order to make w i and w k The deviation of L linear combination coefficients a is minimized. k Optimize and get the optimal w i ,Right now: (k=1,2,…,L )

[0042] Using the matrix differential properties, the above equation is equivalently transformed into a linear equation system that optimizes the first-order derivative conditions, namely:

[0043] (4) Calculate the optimized linear combination coefficient a according to the above formula k , and then by The combination coefficients are normalized and the combination weight w* is obtained. The formula is:

[0044] The specific process of determining the slope stability grade in step seven is as follows: calculating the comprehensive membership of each grade from step one to step six, determining the slope stability grades of the first 12 groups of samples respectively according to the maximum membership principle, and comparing the determination results with the CRITIC cloud model.

[0045] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages:

[0046] (1) The CRITIC method and the G1 method are combined and weighted using game theory, which adds subjective human consciousness and experience to the calculation of a large amount of objective data, thus overcoming the limitations of a single weighting method.

[0047] (2) The membership degree is calculated using the CRITIC-G1 method and the CRITIC method. The calculation results show that the rationality of the CRITIC-G1 method in slope stability analysis is better than that of the single CRITIC method. The CRITIC-G1 method is more reasonable and reliable in slope stability analysis.

[0048] (3) Five sets of data were randomly selected to test the rationality and reliability of the CRITIC-G1 cloud model. The test results showed that the slope stability grade evaluation results of the CRITIC-G1 cloud model were consistent with the actual slope stability grade and were suitable for the analysis and evaluation of slope stability. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0049] Figure 1 This is a digital feature representation diagram of the cloud model.

[0050] Figure 2 Flowchart of the CRITIC-G1 cloud model for slope stability assessment.

[0051] Figure 3 This is a cloud chart of cohesion indicators.

[0052] Figure 4 This is the index cloud diagram of the internal friction angle.

[0053] Figure 5 It is the index cloud diagram of slope angle.

[0054] Figure 6 It is the index cloud diagram of slope height.

[0055] Figure 7 It is the indicator cloud diagram of pore water pressure ratio.

[0056] Figure 8 This is an indicator cloud chart of natural bulk density.

[0057] Said Figures 3 to 8 A cloud map is generated for each evaluation index, and each cloud map is divided into the following five levels: Level I (extremely stable), Level II (stable), Level III (basically stable), Level IV (unstable) and Level V (extremely unstable). DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0058] The present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

[0059] refer to Figure 1 and Figure 2 Cloud model digital feature representation diagram and CRITIC-G1 cloud model flow chart for slope stability evaluation, using expected E x ,entropy E n and super entropy H e It is characterized by three values. Specifically, it includes the following steps:

[0060] Step 1: Determine the slope stability classification and the classification standard of slope stability grades corresponding to each indicator.

[0061] Step 2: Determine the digital characteristics of each evaluation indicator of the cloud model.

[0062] Step 3: Use the forward cloud generator to generate the slope stability grade evaluation cloud model through Matlab.

[0063] Step 4: Use the CRITIC method to determine the objective weights and the G1 method to determine the subjective weights.

[0064] Step 5: Calculate the comprehensive weight of indicators using the game combination weighting method.

[0065] Step 6: Calculate the degree of membership of the slope instance in each stability level.

[0066] Step 7. Calculate the comprehensive membership of each level from step 1 to step 6. According to the maximum membership principle, determine the slope stability level of the first 12 groups of samples respectively, and compare the determination results with the CRITIC cloud model.

[0067] The slope stability classification in step 1 is specifically as follows: referring to the slope stability classification standard, and classifying the slope stability into the following five levels: Level I (extremely stable), Level II (stable), Level III (basically stable), Level IV (unstable) and Level V (extremely unstable).

[0068] The specific evaluation indicators include: cohesion, internal friction angle, slope angle, slope height, pore water pressure ratio, and natural bulk density.

[0069] The evaluation index standards are shown in Table 1:

[0070] Table 1 Slope stability evaluation index classification standard

[0071] The digital features in step 2 specifically include: the expected E x , entropy E n and super entropy H e Three numerical eigenvalues, among which the super entropy H e Take 0.001.

[0072] Expectation E x , entropy E n and super entropy H e It is derived from the following formula:

[0073] The digital characteristics of the cloud model are shown in Table 2:

[0074] Table 2 Digital characteristics of cloud models at each level of evaluation indicators

[0075] In step 4, the Critic method obtains the indicator weight, and the specific process is as follows:

[0076] (1) Standardization

[0077] Positive indicators (the bigger the better):

[0078] Negative indicators (the smaller the indicator, the better):

[0079] Where: X ij Specific data expressed as an indicator; x j It is expressed as the jth measured value related to the i-th evaluation index; x max It is expressed as the maximum value of the i evaluation index, x min It is expressed as the minimum value of the evaluation index i.

[0080] (2) Calculate the standard deviation:

[0081] In the formula: represents the average value of the sample data; n represents the sample size.

[0082] (3) Calculate the conflict.

[0083]

[0084] Where: C i is the information content of index i relative to the evaluation object; r ij is the correlation coefficient, and the linear correlation coefficient is the main one.

[0085] (4) Calculate the objective weight W of the evaluation index i :

[0086] The objective weights of each evaluation index are shown in Table 3:

[0087] Table 3 Objective weights of each indicator

[0088] In step 4, the G1 method is used to obtain the index weights, and the specific process is as follows:

[0089] (1) Determine the order relationship.

[0090] For n evaluation indicators (x1, x2, ..., x n ) Arrange in descending order of importance and determine the order relationship:

[0091] (2) Determine the importance of adjacent indicators.

[0092]

[0093] (3) Determine the weight W nThe formula is:

[0094] (4) Determine the comprehensive weight.

[0095] In order to ensure that the evaluation index is more objective and comprehensive, S experts (S ≥ 1) are hired to conduct the evaluation. Let the value given by the mth expert among the S experts be denoted as B (m)k , we can get B (m)k The weight is W (m)k The comprehensive weight of each indicator is W k for:

[0096] The subjective weights of each evaluation index are shown in Table 4:

[0097] Table 4 Subjective weight of each indicator

[0098] In step 5, the game weighting method is used to obtain the comprehensive weight of the indicators. The specific process is as follows:

[0099] (1) Assuming that L weighting methods are used to weight n evaluation indicators, the basic weight matrix is:

[0100] In the formula, w kp It is the weight value corresponding to the pth (p=1,2,...,n)th evaluation index of the kth (k=1,2,...,L)th weighting method.

[0101] (2) Perform linear combination of each weight vector:

[0102] In the formula, a k is the linear combination coefficient of the kth weighting method.

[0103] (3) In order to make w i and w k The deviation of L linear combination coefficients a is minimized. k Optimize and get the optimal w i ,Right now: (k=1,2,…,L )

[0104] Using the matrix differential properties, the above equation is equivalently transformed into a linear equation system that optimizes the first-order derivative conditions, namely:

[0105] (4) Calculate the optimized linear combination coefficient a according to the above formula k , and then by The combination coefficients are normalized and the combination weight w* is obtained. The formula is:

[0106] The weights assigned by the Critic method and the G1 method using game theory are shown in Table 5:

[0107] Table 5 Combination weights of various indicators

[0108] The specific process of determining the slope stability grade in step seven is as follows: calculating the comprehensive membership of each grade from step one to step six, determining the slope stability grades of the first 12 groups of samples respectively according to the maximum membership principle, and comparing the determination results with the CRITIC cloud model.

[0109] The results predicted by the sample data are shown in Table 6:

[0110] Table 6 Sample data prediction results

[0111] The results predicted by the slope stability grade are shown in Table 7:

[0112] Table 7 Prediction results of slope stability grade

[0113] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages:

[0114] (1) The CRITIC method and the G1 method are combined and weighted using game theory, which adds subjective human consciousness and experience to the calculation of a large amount of objective data, thus overcoming the limitations of a single weighting method.

[0115] (2) The membership degree is calculated using the CRITIC-G1 method and the CRITIC method. The calculation results show that the rationality of the CRITIC-G1 method in slope stability analysis is better than that of the single CRITIC method. The CRITIC-G1 method is more reasonable and reliable in slope stability analysis.

[0116] (3) Five sets of data were randomly selected to test the rationality and reliability of the CRITIC-G1 cloud model. The test results showed that the slope stability grade evaluation results of the CRITIC-G1 cloud model were consistent with the actual slope stability grade and were suitable for the analysis and evaluation of slope stability.

Claims

1. A slope stability evaluation method based on a subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model, characterized by: The specific steps include: Step 1: Determine the slope stability classification and the classification standard of each index corresponding to the slope stability grade; Step 2: Determine the digital characteristics of each evaluation index of the cloud model; Step 3: Use the forward cloud generator to generate the slope stability grade evaluation cloud model through Matlab; Step 4: Use the CRITIC method to determine the objective weights and the G1 method to determine the subjective weights; Step 5: Calculate the comprehensive weight of indicators using the game combination weighting method; Step 6: Calculate the membership of the slope instance in each stability level; Step 7. Calculate the comprehensive membership of each level from step 1 to step 6. According to the maximum membership principle, determine the slope stability level of the first 12 groups of samples respectively, and compare the determination results with the CRITIC cloud model.

2. The slope stability evaluation method based on the subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The slope stability classification in step 1 is specifically as follows: refer to the slope stability classification standard and classify the slope stability into the following five levels: Level I (extremely stable), Level II (stable), Level III (basically stable), Level IV (unstable) and Level V (extremely unstable). The evaluation indicators specifically include: cohesion, internal friction angle, slope angle, slope height, pore water pressure ratio, and natural bulk density.

3. The slope stability evaluation method based on the subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The digital features in step 2 specifically include: the expected E x , entropy E n and super entropy H e Three numerical eigenvalues, among which the super entropy H e Take 0.

001.

4. The slope stability evaluation method based on the subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The CRITIC method in step 4 is a method for determining the weight of index correlation, and is also an objective weighting method. The G1 method, also known as the ordinal relationship analysis method, is a subjective weighting method based on the analytic hierarchy process. Compared with AHP, it has the advantages of less calculation and no need for consistency check.

5. The slope stability evaluation method based on the subjective and objective combined weighted cloud model according to claim 1 is characterized by: The game combination weighting method in step five is specifically as follows: according to the subjective and objective weights calculated by the CRITIC method and the G1 method in step four, the game theory is used to perform combined weighting, find the consistency between the two methods, avoid the limitations of a single weighting method, and thus improve the rationality and reliability of the obtained weights.

Citation Information

Cited By

  • Granite soil slope stability evaluation method based on combination weighting

    CN120031232A

  • Power transmission line lightning current measurement and trip-out rate correction method based on multi-source information fusion

    CN122262735A