Accident analysis influence evaluation method and device
By obtaining and analyzing the differential information between the comprehensive utilization of nuclear energy and the standard design, determining the originating events of new hypotheses and evaluating them, the time-consuming and labor-intensive accident analysis in the existing technology is solved, and the rapid and economical comprehensive utilization of nuclear energy is achieved. Project accident analysis impact assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411022888.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
AI Technical Summary
When conducting accident analysis in a nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, the existing technology is time-consuming and laborious and uneconomic, and it is impossible to comprehensively evaluate the impact of changes in nuclear power plant configuration on accident analysis.
By obtaining the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design, determine whether a new hypothetical origination event is generated, and an accident analysis impact evaluation is carried out according to the preset evaluation rules, including identifying the initial hypothetical origination event, grouping, and comparing Quantitative and qualitative analysis to determine the impact of accident analysis results and conclusions.
A rapid and economic assessment of the impact of accident analysis of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects has been achieved, reducing manpower and economic costs, while ensuring the integrity and correctness of the evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure CN118966828A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application belongs to the field of nuclear industry technology, and specifically relates to an accident analysis impact assessment method and device. Background Art
[0002] my country's nuclear power companies have been actively exploring the multi-purpose nuclear energy market before this, and gradually implementing cogeneration of nuclear power units based on market demand and corresponding conditions. In the field of nuclear energy district heating, the Haiyang Nuclear Energy Heating Project and the Qinshan Nuclear Energy Heating Project have been completed and put into operation. In the field of nuclear energy industrial heating, my country's first nuclear energy heating project, the Tianwan Nuclear Power Plant Steam Energy Supply Project, was officially completed and put into operation on June 19, 2024. The application of nuclear energy in industrial refrigeration, seawater desalination, nuclear energy hydrogen production and isotope production is also being actively explored.
[0003] The basis of comprehensive utilization of nuclear energy is nuclear energy. In my country, the main form of nuclear energy utilization is large commercial pressurized water reactor nuclear power plants. Therefore, the current comprehensive utilization of nuclear energy relies on large commercial pressurized water reactor nuclear power plants in service. For nuclear power plants, safety analysis reports are an important basis for the approval of nuclear power plant licenses, and accident analysis is an important part of safety analysis reports.
[0004] Compared with nuclear power plants used only for power generation (hereinafter referred to as standard design), nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects such as operating nuclear power plants and newly built nuclear energy projects have added nuclear energy utilization forms, which means that the configuration of the nuclear power plant has changed, and the accident analysis applicable to the standard design will also change accordingly, thus requiring a re-evaluation of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects.
[0005] The existing technology usually re-evaluates the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project by re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis on the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project. Due to the systematic and complex nature of the accident analysis work, changes in the configuration of nuclear power plants do not always have a comprehensive impact on the accident analysis. In some cases, these changes have no impact on the accident analysis. In some cases, the impact of these changes on the accident analysis is local. Therefore, the above method is time-consuming, labor-intensive and uneconomical. Summary of the invention
[0006] The technical problem to be solved by the present application is to provide an accident analysis impact assessment method and device in view of the above-mentioned deficiencies in the prior art. The use of this method to conduct accident analysis impact assessment is more time-saving, labor-saving and economical than the prior art of re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis for nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects.
[0007] In a first aspect, an embodiment of the present application provides an accident analysis impact assessment method, comprising:
[0008] Obtain information on the differences between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design;
[0009] Determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event based on the difference information to obtain a first determination result;
[0010] Based on the first determination result and preset evaluation rules, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
[0011] In some embodiments of the first aspect, the preset evaluation rules include a preset first acceptance criterion, a preset computer program, and a preset assumption;
[0012] Based on the first determination result and the preset evaluation rules, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis, including:
[0013] In the case where the first determination result includes that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project does not generate a new hypothetical initiating event, for each initial hypothetical initiating event in the target hypothetical initiating event list, determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion, so as to obtain a plurality of second determination results;
[0014] In the case that the plurality of second determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program, so as to obtain a plurality of third determination results;
[0015] In the case that the plurality of third determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumption condition, so as to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results;
[0016] When multiple fourth determination results are applicable, determining the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
[0017] In some embodiments of the first aspect, the difference information includes at least one of structural difference information and operational difference information, the operational difference information includes design parameters of the standard design, a first operational state of the standard design, and a second operational state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project,
[0018] Based on the difference information, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates new hypothetical initiating events, including:
[0019] Identify the difference information to obtain an initial assumed initiating event list, which includes multiple initial assumed initiating events;
[0020] For the list of initial assumed initiating events, multiple initial assumed initiating events are grouped to obtain multiple groups of initial assumed initiating event sets, each group of initial assumed initiating event sets including at least one initial assumed initiating event;
[0021] According to the multiple sets of initial assumed initiating events, a target assumed initiating event list is generated, wherein the target assumed initiating event list includes the multiple sets of target assumed initiating event sets;
[0022] Compare the first accident analysis results and conclusions of the standard hypothetical initiating event list of the standard design with the second accident analysis results and conclusions of the target hypothetical initiating event list to obtain a comparative result;
[0023] Based on the comparison results, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project will generate new hypothetical initiating events.
[0024] In some implementations of the first aspect, the difference information is identified to obtain an initial hypothesized initiating event list, including:
[0025] Using a failure mode and effects analysis method to identify the difference information, and obtaining a first identification result;
[0026] Using the main logic diagram method to test the first recognition result, to obtain a first test result;
[0027] The engineering judgment method is used to identify the first test results and obtain an initial list of hypothesized initiating events.
[0028] In some implementations of the first aspect, determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the comparison result includes:
[0029] In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are covered by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, it is determined that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has not generated any new hypothetical initiating event;
[0030] Alternatively, when the comparison results are used to characterize that the second accident analysis results and conclusions are not encompassed by the first accident analysis results and conclusions, it is determined that a new hypothetical initiating event has occurred in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
[0031] In some embodiments of the first aspect, the method further comprises:
[0032] In a case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not covered by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, determining a new set of assumed initiating events, wherein the new set of assumed initiating events includes at least one new assumed initiating event;
[0033] For each new hypothetical initiating event in the set of new hypothetical initiating events, a quantitative analysis is performed on the new hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact results of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. The quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program.
[0034] In some embodiments of the first aspect, the method further comprises:
[0035] In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determine the current operating condition classification and the initial operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event;
[0036] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the current operating condition classification is different from the initial operating condition classification, determining whether the calculation result of the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset second acceptance criterion corresponding to the current operating condition classification, and obtaining a fifth determination result;
[0037] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, if the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is applicable, conduct a qualitative analysis of the initial assumed initiating event to obtain the impact assessment conclusion of the initial assumed initiating event on the accident analysis. The qualitative analysis includes engineering judgment;
[0038] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable, a preset strategy is executed, and the preset strategy is used to improve the response capability of the nuclear power plant.
[0039] In some implementations of the first aspect, determining the current operating condition classification of the initial hypothetical initiating event includes:
[0040] Obtain the occurrence frequency of the initial hypothesized initiating event;
[0041] Determine the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event based on the frequency of occurrence.
[0042] In some embodiments of the first aspect, before determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion, the method further includes:
[0043] Obtaining fuel assembly information of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, the fuel assembly information including at least one of the fuel assembly type, fuel assembly structure and fuel assembly cladding material;
[0044] Determine whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria, including:
[0045] Determine whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria based on the fuel assembly information;
[0046] and / or, determine whether the initial PIE is appropriate for use with a pre-defined computer program, including:
[0047] Based on the fuel assembly information, determine whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program.
[0048] In some embodiments of the first aspect, after determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion to obtain a plurality of second determination results, the method further comprises:
[0049] determining a third acceptance criterion applicable to each first target hypothetical initiating event when at least one of the plurality of second determination results is not applicable;
[0050] According to the third acceptance criteria, quantitative analysis is conducted on each first target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. The quantitative analysis includes analysis using the target computer program;
[0051] Among them, the first target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the second determination result is not applicable.
[0052] In some embodiments of the first aspect, after determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program to obtain a plurality of third determination results, the method further comprises:
[0053] When at least one of the plurality of third determination results is not applicable, a modified computer program is obtained according to a preset computer program, and the modified computer program is applicable to the plurality of third determination results;
[0054] For each second target hypothetical initiating event, a modified computer program is used to conduct a quantitative analysis of the second target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using the target computer program;
[0055] Among them, the second target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the third determination result is not applicable.
[0056] In some implementations of the first aspect, the preset assumption condition includes a preset initial condition and a preset boundary condition, and the fourth determination result includes a first determination sub-result and a second determination sub-result;
[0057] After determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumed condition to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results, the method further includes:
[0058] When at least one of the plurality of first determination sub-results is not applicable, and / or at least one of the plurality of second determination sub-results is not applicable, for each third target hypothetical initiating event, a qualitative analysis is performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event, or a qualitative analysis and a quantitative analysis are performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event in sequence to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the qualitative analysis includes engineering judgment, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program;
[0059] Among them, the third target hypothesis initiating event is the initial hypothesis initiating event that the first determined sub-result is not applicable, and / or the second determined sub-result is not applicable.
[0060] Based on the same inventive concept, in a second aspect, the embodiment of the present application further provides an accident analysis and impact assessment device, comprising:
[0061] An acquisition module, used to obtain difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design;
[0062] A first determination module is used to determine whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the difference information, so as to obtain a first determination result;
[0063] The second determination module is used to determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis based on the first determination result and preset evaluation rules.
[0064] Based on the same inventive concept, in the third aspect,
[0065] According to the accident analysis impact assessment method and device provided in the embodiment of the present application, a first determination result is determined by utilizing the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design, and then the accident analysis impact assessment is performed using the first determination result and preset evaluation rules. Compared with the prior art of re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis on the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, this saves time, labor and is more economical. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0066] Figure 1 A schematic diagram showing the structure of a nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project provided by an embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0067] Figure 2 A schematic diagram showing a flow chart of the accident analysis and impact assessment method provided in an embodiment of the present application;
[0068] Figure 3 Another schematic diagram of the process of the accident analysis and impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application is shown;
[0069] Figure 4A structural schematic diagram of an accident analysis and impact assessment device provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0070] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the technical solution of the present application, the present application is further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0071] The features and exemplary embodiments of various aspects of the present application will be described in detail below. In order to make the purpose, technical solutions and advantages of the present application clearer, the present application will be further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only configured to explain the present application and are not configured to limit the present application. For those skilled in the art, the present application can be implemented without the need for some of these specific details. The following description of the embodiments is only to provide a better understanding of the present application by illustrating the examples of the present application.
[0072] It should be noted that, in this article, relational terms such as first and second, etc. are only used to distinguish one entity or operation from another entity or operation, and do not necessarily require or imply any such actual relationship or order between these entities or operations. Moreover, the terms "include", "comprise" or any other variants thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusion, so that a process, method, article or device including a series of elements includes not only those elements, but also other elements not explicitly listed, or also includes elements inherent to such process, method, article or device. In the absence of further restrictions, the elements defined by the statement "include..." do not exclude the presence of other identical elements in the process, method, article or device including the elements.
[0073] In order to better understand the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application, before introducing the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application, the nouns that may be involved in the embodiment of the present application are first introduced.
[0074] A nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project refers to a nuclear energy project that, in addition to nuclear power generation, also includes at least one application scenario such as regional heating, industrial heating, industrial refrigeration, seawater desalination, nuclear hydrogen production and isotope production.
[0075] Accident analysis refers to the deterministic safety analysis conducted on nuclear power plants.
[0076] The accident analysis impact assessment of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects refers to the need to evaluate the impact of the accident analysis results and conclusions of nuclear power plants that are only used for nuclear power generation. Since nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects introduce other application scenarios, they need to evaluate the impact of the accident analysis results and conclusions of nuclear power plants.
[0077] Standard design refers to a nuclear power plant that complies with a series of standards formulated by the state for nuclear power plant construction.
[0078] Figure 1 The following is a schematic diagram showing the structure of a nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project. Figure 1 As shown, Figure 1 The typical features of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project shown are: on the basis of the nuclear power plant 1 (standard design) used only for power generation, other forms of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities are added. Other forms of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities include seawater desalination facilities 2, and steam conversion devices 3 for providing industrial steam for the chemical industry park. Among them, the nuclear power plant 1 includes a core, a horizontal evaporator, a main steam main pipe, a steam turbine generator, a condenser, a main feed water pump and a main pump connected in sequence; the seawater desalination facility includes a membrane desalination facility and a desalination device connected in sequence; the steam conversion device 3 includes a feed water tank, a primary feed water pump, a first feed water heater, a deaerator, a secondary feed water pump, a second feed water heater, a steam generator and a superheater connected in sequence. The primary feed water pump is connected to the condenser, the desalination device is connected to the feed water tank, and the superheater is connected to the chemical industry park. The condensation membrane desalination facility can divide the input seawater into concentrated seawater and fresh water, and transmit the fresh water to the desalination device. The entire nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project can be used to provide industrial steam for the chemical industry park. Figure 1 The transmission path of steam in the medium horizontal evaporator can be main steam main pipe -> superheater -> steam generator -> first feedwater heater -> second feedwater heater -> primary feedwater pump -> feedwater tank -> condenser; the transmission path of seawater can be membrane desalination facility -> desalination device -> feedwater tank -> primary feedwater pump -> first feedwater heater -> deaerator -> secondary feedwater pump -> second feedwater heater -> steam generator -> superheater -> industrial steam -> chemical industry park.
[0079] for Figure 1 In the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project shown, the accident analysis of nuclear power plant 1 is usually completed. Due to the addition of seawater desalination facility 2 and steam conversion unit 3, the configuration of nuclear power plant 1 has changed, and the original accident analysis results and conclusions are no longer fully applicable. It is necessary to consider the changes in the configuration of nuclear power plant 1 to update the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
[0080] Figure 1 Only one situation in which the configuration of a nuclear power plant changes is given as an example and is used to limit this application. Any other situation that causes the configuration of a nuclear power plant to change and its impact on accident analysis can be evaluated using the method of the embodiment of this application. The configuration of a nuclear power plant includes structures, systems and equipment, operating limits and conditions, procedures and documents, computer systems, organizational structures and rules and regulations. Figure 1In the example given, the changes in the configuration of the nuclear power plant 1 may be multifaceted, the most obvious of which is the changes in structures, systems and equipment, because of the addition of systems and equipment related to the desalination facility 2 and the steam conversion device 3, as well as the structures that house these facilities and devices. The addition of structures, systems and equipment may also cause changes in operating limits and conditions, related procedures and documents, computer systems, organizational structures and rules and regulations. It should be noted that not all changes in the configuration of nuclear power plants are related to accident analysis, and the method proposed in the embodiment of the present application can systematically and structuredly identify the relationship between changes in the configuration of nuclear power plants and accident analysis, thereby ensuring the integrity and correctness of the accident analysis impact assessment.
[0081] Example 1
[0082] Figure 2 A flow chart of an accident analysis and impact assessment method provided in an embodiment of the present application is shown.
[0083] The accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application can be executed by an accident analysis impact assessment device and an electronic device, etc. The following takes the execution of the method by an electronic device as an example for explanation.
[0084] like Figure 1 As shown, the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application may include steps S210 to S230.
[0085] S210. Obtain the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design.
[0086] S220. Determine whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project based on the difference information to obtain a first determination result.
[0087] S230. Determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis based on the first determination result and preset evaluation rules.
[0088] According to the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application, a first determination result is determined by utilizing the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design, and then the accident analysis impact assessment is performed using the first determination result and preset evaluation rules. Compared with the prior art of re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis on the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, this method saves time, labor and is more economical.
[0089] The specific implementation of the above steps is introduced below.
[0090] In step S210, the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project may be a nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project that requires a nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project accident analysis.
[0091] The difference information may include at least one of structural difference information and operational difference information, and the operational difference information includes design parameters of the standard design, a first operational state of the standard design, and a second operational state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
[0092] Structural difference information may include systems and equipment added to the target nuclear energy complex project relative to the standard design.
[0093] The first operating state may be a standard designed operating state.
[0094] The second operating state may be the operating state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive project. The second operating state may include the normal operating state, special steady-state operating state, special transient operating state, startup and normal shutdown state, and other operating states of the added nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities themselves. Among them, the normal operating state may include the normal steady-state state and the normal transient state, and the other operating states may include the fault operating state and the accident operating state, etc.
[0095] As an example, we can first collect documents and materials related to the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and accident analysis, and then compare and analyze the differences between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design through the relevant documents and materials to obtain difference information. In other words, by comparing and analyzing the relevant documents and materials, we can preliminarily understand what differences the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has introduced compared to the standard design due to the addition of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities in the standard design.
[0096] The relevant documents and materials may include at least one of the following:
[0097] 1. Preliminary safety analysis report or final safety analysis report of standard design. This is the most important document for accident analysis and impact assessment of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects, because the accident analysis content for the standard is in these two reports, especially the input conditions related to accident analysis, which are concentrated in Chapter 15 accident analysis. These two reports are also the benchmark and starting point for carrying out accident analysis and impact assessment.
[0098] 2. The relevant design documents of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project may include thermal system diagrams, system flow charts, system manuals, technical specifications of systems or equipment, operating procedures, etc.
[0099] It should be noted that in the process of comparing and analyzing relevant documents and materials, two major aspects should be considered: one is the increase in systems and equipment, which is a static aspect; the other is the impact of the increase in systems and equipment on the standard design operation, which is a dynamic aspect. In terms of operation, one is that the design parameters and operating conditions of the standard design may change, and these changes may change the initial conditions and boundary conditions of the accident analysis; the other is that the added nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facilities themselves have normal operation (including steady state and transient), special steady state operation, special transient operation, startup and normal shutdown, and other operations (failures and accidents). These different operating states may lead to new hypothetical initiating events.
[0100] As another example, the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design may be pre-stored in an electronic device so that the difference information can be directly called later.
[0101] In step S220, after obtaining the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design, the electronic device can also determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event (PIE) based on the difference information to obtain a first determination result.
[0102] PIEs may include events that have been identified as having the potential to lead to anticipated operational occurrences or accident conditions and their subsequent failure effects.
[0103] The starting point of accident analysis is to determine the list of hypothetical initiating events and classify the working conditions. Therefore, in order to carry out accident analysis and impact assessment, we first analyze whether the newly added systems and equipment in the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project may lead to new hypothetical initiating events. The cause of the new hypothetical initiating event may be equipment failure or personnel misoperation. Since the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has added new systems and equipment, it is considered that it may lead to new hypothetical initiating events.
[0104] In some embodiments, determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event is generated in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the difference information may include:
[0105] Identify the difference information to obtain an initial assumed initiating event list, which includes multiple initial assumed initiating events;
[0106] For the list of initial assumed initiating events, multiple initial assumed initiating events are grouped to obtain multiple groups of initial assumed initiating event sets, each group of initial assumed initiating event sets including at least one initial assumed initiating event;
[0107] According to the multiple sets of initial assumed initiating events, a target assumed initiating event list is generated, wherein the target assumed initiating event list includes the multiple sets of target assumed initiating event sets;
[0108] Compare the first accident analysis results and conclusions of the standard hypothetical initiating event list of the standard design with the second accident analysis results and conclusions of the target hypothetical initiating event list to obtain a comparative result;
[0109] Based on the comparison results, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project will generate new hypothetical initiating events.
[0110] The comparison result may be used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encompassed by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, or may be used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not encompassed by the first accident analysis result and conclusion.
[0111] The standard hypothetical initiating event list may be a standard designed hypothetical initiating event list, which may be pre-stored in the electronic device for subsequent direct retrieval.
[0112] In some examples, the difference information is identified to obtain an initial list of hypothetical initiating events, including:
[0113] Using the Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (FMEA) method to identify the difference information, a first identification result is obtained;
[0114] Using a Master Logic Diagram (MLD) method to test the first recognition result, obtaining a first test result;
[0115] The engineering judgment method is used to identify the first test results and obtain an initial list of hypothesized initiating events.
[0116] In this embodiment, a first round of identification is performed by using a structured method such as a failure mode and effects analysis method to obtain a first identification result, and then the first identification result is tested using a main logic diagram method to obtain a first test result. Finally, the first test result is identified in combination with an engineering judgment method to obtain an initial hypothesis initiating event list, which can ensure the comprehensiveness and completeness of the initial hypothesis initiating event identification.
[0117] Failure mode and effects analysis can be used to identify and evaluate various failure modes that may occur in a system, product or process, as well as the potential impacts that these failures may cause. This method aims to identify potential problems in advance so that preventive measures or improvement measures can be taken to reduce risks or improve system reliability.
[0118] The master logic diagram method is a commonly used risk management tool to identify potential failure modes in a system, product or process and evaluate the impact these failures may have on the system.
[0119] Engineering judgment refers to the decision and evaluation made by engineers or technical experts on specific problems, challenges or situations based on their professional knowledge, experience and understanding. In other words, professionals make subjective judgments.
[0120] It should be noted that by analyzing the failure modes and effects of systems and equipment, i.e. FMEA, it is possible to determine whether a specific failure (the direct consequence of human error is also equipment failure) is a hypothetical initiating event. The impact analysis after equipment failure can directly consider core safety or use decoupling criteria. For example, Figure 1 Taking the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project shown as an example, when analyzing the impact of equipment failure on the reactor, we can directly consider whether the equipment failure in the steam conversion device 3 will affect the core safety, or we can use the decoupling criterion, that is, first analyze how the steam flow rate on the primary side of the steam conversion device changes. The steam flow rate on the primary side may increase, decrease, be interrupted, or be released due to pipeline rupture, and the impact of these changes on the core safety is different. For example, whether the following types of impacts have occurred (refer to NB / T20035-2011 Pressurized Water Reactor Nuclear Power Plant Condition Classification Table B.1): increase in secondary circuit heat removal, decrease in secondary circuit heat removal, decrease in reactor coolant system flow, abnormal reactivity and power distribution, increase in reactor coolant loading, decrease in reactor coolant loading, and release of radioactive substances from a subsystem or component. If at least one of the above-mentioned impacts has occurred, the discriminant difference information has reached the conditions for becoming an initial hypothetical initiating event.
[0121] In order to reduce the number of hypothetical initiating events that need to be quantitatively analyzed later, multiple initial hypothetical initiating events can be grouped. For example, for the list of initial hypothetical initiating events, the physical processes after the events can be combined to consider similar challenges to safety functions and barriers, and similar mitigation systems are required to achieve a safe state, and representative and enveloping initial hypothetical initiating events can be used to represent all initial hypothetical initiating events in the group.
[0122] Specifically, for nuclear power plants, there are three major safety functions and three major barriers. Among them, the three major safety functions are reactivity control, residual heat removal and radioactive material containment; the three major barriers are fuel cladding, primary circuit pressure boundary and containment. Challenges to safety functions and barriers mean adverse effects on the three major safety functions of reactivity control, residual heat removal and radioactive material containment, or threats to the integrity of the three major barriers. Excessive fuel cladding temperature, excessive primary circuit pressure, excessive containment temperature and pressure, etc. may threaten the integrity of the three major barriers.
[0123] Similar challenges refer to the fact that the adverse effects or barriers threatened by a group of specific faults are the same or similar. For example, reduced heat removal from the secondary circuit of a nuclear power plant will cause the temperature and pressure of the primary circuit to rise, affecting the integrity of the fuel cladding and the primary circuit pressure boundary, thus posing a challenge to the containment of radioactive materials. There may be many faults that lead to reduced heat removal from the secondary circuit of a nuclear power plant, and these faults can be classified into the same group, which can be represented by reduced heat removal from the secondary circuit of a nuclear power plant.
[0124] After an event occurs, a mitigation system is needed to mitigate the consequences of the event. For example, a reduction in heat removal from the secondary circuit of a nuclear power plant may trigger an emergency shutdown, or may cause the pressurizer safety valve to open to prevent overpressure in the primary circuit. The reactor protection system and pressurizer safety valve that achieve emergency shutdown are the so-called mitigation systems here. Initial hypothetical initiating events that are grouped into the same group are likely to require the same or similar mitigation systems to mitigate the consequences.
[0125] The reason why they are similar rather than identical is that different PIEs in the same group may pose different levels of challenges to safety functions and barriers, and the mitigation systems required may be different, but similar.
[0126] Exemplarily, multiple sets of initial hypothetical initiating event sets may be integrated into a target hypothetical initiating event list. Multiple target hypothetical initiating event sets are multiple target initial hypothetical initiating event sets.
[0127] In some examples, determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project based on the comparison result may include:
[0128] In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are covered by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, it is determined that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has not generated any new hypothetical initiating event;
[0129] Alternatively, when the comparison results are used to characterize that the second accident analysis results and conclusions are not encompassed by the first accident analysis results and conclusions, it is determined that a new hypothetical initiating event has occurred in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
[0130] In step S230, after the electronic device determines whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event based on the difference information to obtain a first determination result, it can also determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis based on the first determination result and preset evaluation rules.
[0131] It should be noted that the initial hypothetical initiating event list, acceptance criteria, computer program and analytical assumptions are the four elements of accident analysis. Any change in any element may affect the results and conclusions of the accident analysis. Therefore, the preset evaluation rules may include the preset first acceptance criteria, the preset computer program and the preset assumptions.
[0132] In some embodiments, the preset evaluation rules include a preset first acceptance criterion, a preset computer program, and a preset assumption condition;
[0133] Based on the first determination result and the preset evaluation rules, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis, which may include:
[0134] In the case where the first determination result includes that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project does not generate a new hypothetical initiating event, for each initial hypothetical initiating event in the target hypothetical initiating event list, determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion, so as to obtain a plurality of second determination results;
[0135] In the case that the plurality of second determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program, so as to obtain a plurality of third determination results;
[0136] In the case that the plurality of third determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumption condition, so as to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results;
[0137] When multiple fourth determination results are applicable, determining the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
[0138] In this embodiment, through the preset first acceptance criteria, the preset computer program and the preset assumptions, it is determined whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis. The accident analysis impact evaluation of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project can be completed with less manpower and smaller economic cost, and the integrity and correctness of the evaluation can be guaranteed.
[0139] The second determination result, the third determination result, the fourth determination result, and the fifth determination result described below all include applicable and inapplicable.
[0140] In some examples, before determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion, the accident analysis impact assessment method may further include:
[0141] Obtaining fuel assembly information of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, the fuel assembly information including at least one of the fuel assembly type, fuel assembly structure and fuel assembly cladding material;
[0142] Determine whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria, including:
[0143] Determine whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria based on the fuel assembly information;
[0144] and / or, determine whether the initial PIE is appropriate for use with a pre-defined computer program, including:
[0145] Based on the fuel assembly information, determine whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program.
[0146] Fuel assembly types may include novel fuel types and conventional fuel types.
[0147] The fuel assembly structure may include fuel assembly structures that have been changed and fuel assembly structures that have not been changed.
[0148] The fuel assembly cladding material may include new fuel assembly cladding material and traditional fuel assembly cladding material.
[0149] The preset first acceptance criterion may be an acceptance criterion corresponding to each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list. For example, the preset first acceptance criterion may include at least one of a deviation from nucleate boiling ratio (DNBR) limit, a cladding temperature limit, a cladding oxidation thickness, a cladding oxidation rate, and the like.
[0150] As an example, the fuel assembly information of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project can be stored in the electronic device for subsequent direct retrieval.
[0151] As another example, fuel assembly information of a target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project may be obtained from relevant design documents of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization facility.
[0152] Exemplarily, when a first preset condition is met, it is determined that the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion; when a second preset condition is met, it is determined that the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion; wherein, the first preset condition includes at least one of the fuel assembly type being a new fuel assembly type, the fuel assembly structure being a changed fuel assembly structure, and the fuel assembly cladding material being a new fuel assembly cladding material; and the second preset condition includes the fuel assembly type being a traditional fuel assembly type, the fuel assembly structure being an unchanged fuel assembly structure, and the fuel assembly cladding material being a traditional fuel assembly cladding material.
[0153] Specifically, in most cases, the first acceptance criterion of accident analysis will not change, for example Figure 1 The first acceptance criteria used in the standard design accident analysis for the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects shown are applicable to the accident analysis of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects. However, in some cases, for example, if the change in the configuration of the nuclear power plant is due to the use of new fuel assemblies, or the fuel assembly structure has changed, or the fuel assembly uses a new cladding material, it may cause the deviation from the first acceptance criteria such as the nucleate boiling ratio limit, cladding temperature limit, cladding oxidation thickness, cladding oxidation rate, etc. to change.
[0154] Exemplarily, when a first preset condition is met, it is determined that the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable to a preset computer program; when a second preset condition is met, it is determined that the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program.
[0155] Likewise, in the vast majority of cases, computer programs used for accident analysis rarely change, especially over short periods of time, e.g. Figure 1 The computer programs applicable to the standard design accident analysis of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects shown in the figure are applicable to the accident analysis of nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects. However, in some cases, for example, if a nuclear power plant uses a new type of fuel assembly, or the structure of the fuel assembly has changed, or the fuel assembly uses a new cladding material, the critical heat flux density relationship built into the computer program may no longer be applicable, that is, the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable to the preset computer program.
[0156] In some examples, after determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion to obtain a plurality of second determination results, the method further includes:
[0157] When at least one of the plurality of second determination results is not applicable, determining a third acceptance criterion applicable to all first target hypothetical initiating events;
[0158] According to the third acceptance criteria, quantitative analysis is conducted on each first target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. The quantitative analysis includes analysis using the target computer program;
[0159] Among them, the first target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the second determination result is not applicable.
[0160] The third acceptance criterion is the acceptance criterion applicable to all first target hypothetical initiating events.
[0161] The target computer program may be a computer program capable of quantitatively analyzing the first target hypothetical initiating event and obtaining the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. For example, the target computer program may include an accident analysis computer program.
[0162] Exemplarily, the electronic device may include a plurality of preset acceptance criteria, and for each acceptance criterion, it is determined whether it is applicable to all first target hypothetical initiating events, and if so, the acceptance criterion is determined as the third acceptance criterion.
[0163] That is to say, when at least one of the multiple second determination results is not applicable, it is necessary to redetermine the third acceptance criteria applicable to all first target hypothesis initiating events, and re-conduct quantitative analysis for all first target hypothesis initiating events applicable to the third acceptance criteria.
[0164] It should be noted that the quantitative analysis in the embodiments of the present application specifically refers to the use of an accident analysis computer program (certain simple accidents can also be calculated using corresponding formulas) to carry out computational simulation of the initial hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. This computational simulation process is well known to those skilled in the art and will not be repeated here.
[0165] In some examples, after determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program to obtain a plurality of third determination results, the method further includes:
[0166] When at least one of the plurality of third determination results is not applicable, a modified computer program is obtained according to a preset computer program, and the modified computer program is applicable to the plurality of third determination results;
[0167] For each second target hypothetical initiating event, a modified computer program is used to conduct a quantitative analysis of the second target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using the target computer program;
[0168] Among them, the second target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the third determination result is not applicable.
[0169] That is to say, when at least one of the multiple third determination results is not applicable, it is necessary to modify the corresponding module of the preset computer program and carry out verification and confirmation, and re-conduct quantitative analysis using the modified computer program.
[0170] Exemplarily, the new critical heat flux density relationship obtained from the experiment can be put into a computer program to verify and confirm the new critical heat flux density relationship, and the new critical heat flux density relationship obtained from the experiment can be continuously adjusted, and the above process is repeated until multiple third determination results are applicable to the new critical heat flux density relationship after iteration.
[0171] The quantitative analysis has been discussed above and will not be repeated here.
[0172] In some examples, the preset assumption condition includes a preset initial condition and a preset boundary condition, and the fourth determination result includes a first determination sub-result and a second determination sub-result;
[0173] After determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumed condition to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results, the method further includes:
[0174] When at least one of the plurality of first determination sub-results is not applicable, and / or at least one of the plurality of second determination sub-results is not applicable, for each third target hypothetical initiating event, a qualitative analysis is performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event, or a qualitative analysis and a quantitative analysis are performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event in sequence to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program;
[0175] Among them, the third target hypothesis initiating event is the initial hypothesis initiating event that the first determined sub-result is not applicable, and / or the second determined sub-result is not applicable.
[0176] The preset initial conditions and preset boundary conditions are usually expressed in the form of parameter value ranges and conservative directions, as well as the availability of normal operating systems or dedicated safety facilities. The conservative direction refers to whether the upper limit or lower limit of the value range is considered conservative during accident analysis. The target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project may affect the parameter value range or system availability of these assumed conditions. Based on the conservative direction, in some cases, direct qualitative analysis can be performed to determine whether the impact results of the accident analysis can be included in the impact results of the accident analysis of the standard design.
[0177] Exemplarily, when multiple first determination sub-results and multiple second determination sub-results are applicable, the third determination result is determined to be applicable; when at least one first determination sub-result and / or at least one second determination sub-result is not applicable, the third determination result is determined to be not applicable.
[0178] For example, the preset initial conditions and preset boundary conditions of a typical pressurized water reactor nuclear power plant are as follows. When conducting accident analysis and impact assessment for a target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, it should be determined item by item whether the following preset initial conditions and preset boundary conditions have changed:
[0179] Overall parameters, including reactor thermal power, reactor coolant flow, reactor inlet and outlet coolant temperatures, reactor pressure, steam generator pressure, main feed water flow, main feed water temperature, etc.;
[0180] Core power distribution, including axial power distribution, radial power distribution, decay heat power, etc.;
[0181] Neutron physical property parameters, including reactivity feedback coefficient, prompt neutron lifetime, delayed neutron fraction, etc.;
[0182] Control rod assembly insertion characteristics, including the speed and value of reactive introduction;
[0183] The performance of the dedicated safety facilities, including their capacity, commissioning conditions, etc.;
[0184] Emergency shutdown setting value and delay time;
[0185] Availability of normal operating systems, including performance parameters, commissioning conditions, etc.;
[0186] Geometric parameters, including flow area, volume, hydraulic diameter, etc.;
[0187] Thermophysical properties, such as the thermophysical properties of fuel assemblies.
[0188] The engineering judgment method has been discussed above and will not be repeated here.
[0189] In some embodiments, the accident analysis impact assessment method may further include:
[0190] In a case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not covered by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, determining a new set of assumed initiating events, wherein the new set of assumed initiating events includes at least one new assumed initiating event;
[0191] For each new hypothetical initiating event in the set of new hypothetical initiating events, a quantitative analysis is performed on the new hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact results of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. The quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program.
[0192] When the comparison results are used to characterize that the second accident analysis results and conclusions are not covered by the first accident analysis results and conclusions, it is determined that a new hypothetical initiating event has occurred. Then, based on the differences between the second accident analysis results and conclusions and the first accident analysis results and conclusions, a new set of hypothetical initiating events can be determined, and then a quantitative analysis can be carried out on each new hypothetical initiating event.
[0193] The quantitative analysis has been discussed above and will not be repeated here.
[0194] In other embodiments, the accident analysis impact assessment method may further include:
[0195] In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determine the current operating condition classification and the initial operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event;
[0196] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the current operating condition classification is different from the initial operating condition classification, determining whether the calculation result of the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset second acceptance criterion corresponding to the current operating condition classification, and obtaining a fifth determination result;
[0197] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, if the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is applicable, a qualitative analysis is conducted on the initial assumed initiating event to obtain an evaluation conclusion on the impact of the initial assumed initiating event on the accident analysis. The qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method;
[0198] For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable, a preset strategy is executed, and the preset strategy is used to improve the response capability of the nuclear power plant.
[0199] Domestic PWR nuclear power plants usually define four operating conditions, namely normal operation, expected operating events, rare accidents and extreme accidents, which correspond to different frequency ranges.
[0200] Exemplarily, the electronic device may pre-store initial operating condition classifications for subsequent direct retrieval.
[0201] That is to say, if the increase in the frequency of the initial assumed initiating event causes it to change from one operating condition classification to another, it is necessary to continue to analyze whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset second acceptance criteria corresponding to the current operating condition classification. Although the preset second acceptance criteria corresponding to the current operating condition classification are more stringent, if the calculation results of the initial assumed initiating event show that its consequences can not only meet the first acceptance criteria of the initial operating condition classification, but also meet the preset second acceptance criteria corresponding to the current operating condition classification, then the qualitative analysis can give a conclusion. If the qualitative analysis cannot make a judgment, it is necessary to carry out quantitative analysis, and finally make further judgments based on the results of the quantitative analysis.
[0202] Exemplarily, the preset strategy may include at least one of strengthening a safety system, increasing the amount of water in a water tank, and increasing the flow rate of a chiller.
[0203] It should be noted that an ideal situation is that the change in the configuration of the nuclear power plant neither adds new initial assumed initiating events nor changes the operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating events, so there is no change in the list of initial assumed initiating events.
[0204] In some examples, determining the current operating condition classification of the initial PIE may include:
[0205] Obtain the occurrence frequency of the initial hypothesized initiating event;
[0206] Determine the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event based on the frequency of occurrence.
[0207] For example, the occurrence frequency of the initial assumed initiating event may be stored in the electronic device for subsequent direct retrieval.
[0208] For example, the electronic device may store a mapping relationship between the occurrence frequency and the operating condition classification, and then determine the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event based on the mapping relationship and the occurrence frequency.
[0209] In order to better understand the accident analysis and impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application, a specific embodiment is described below.
[0210] like Figure 3 As shown, the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in the embodiment of the present application may include steps S1 to S20.
[0211] S1. Collect documents and information related to nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects (i.e. target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization projects) and accident analysis;
[0212] S2, determine whether it may lead to new PIE';
[0213] If the judgment result of step S2 is yes, jump to step S3;
[0214] If the judgment result of step S2 is no, jump to step S13;
[0215] S3, identification of hypothetical initiating events;
[0216] S4, hypothetical initiating event grouping;
[0217] S5. Determine whether it can be contained by the original PIE (i.e., the initial hypothetical initiating event);
[0218] If the judgment result of step S5 is yes, jump to step S6;
[0219] If the judgment result of step S5 is no, jump to step S12;
[0220] S6. Determine whether the increase in the frequency of PIE (initial assumed initiating event) changes the classification of the operating condition;
[0221] If the answer in step S6 is no, jump to step S7;
[0222] If the answer in step S6 is yes, jump to step S8;
[0223] S7. Confirm that there are no changes to the PIE list;
[0224] S8. Analyze the compliance of the acceptance criteria corresponding to the new operating condition classification (i.e., the current operating condition classification);
[0225] S9. Determine whether the qualitative analysis can provide a conclusion;
[0226] If the judgment result of step S9 is yes, jump to step S10;
[0227] If the judgment result of step S9 is no, jump to S11;
[0228] S10, qualitative analysis;
[0229] S11, quantitative analysis;
[0230] S12, determine that a new PIE is generated; and jump to step S11;
[0231] S13, judging whether the acceptance criteria (i.e., the first acceptance criteria) are applicable;
[0232] If the judgment result of step S13 is no, jump to step S14;
[0233] If the judgment result of step S13 is yes, jump to step S15;
[0234] S14, determine the applicable acceptance criteria (i.e., the third acceptance criteria); and jump to step S11;
[0235] S15, determining whether the computer program (i.e., the preset computer program) is applicable;
[0236] If the judgment result of step S15 is no, jump to step S16;
[0237] If the judgment result of step S15 is yes, jump to step S17;
[0238] S16, selecting an applicable computer program (i.e., the modified computer program), and jumping to step S11;
[0239] S17, determine whether the assumptions (i.e., the preset assumptions) are applicable;
[0240] If the judgment result of step S17 is no, jump to step S18;
[0241] If the judgment result of step S17 is yes, jump to step S19;
[0242] S18, determining whether the initial condition (i.e., the preset initial condition) has changed;
[0243] If the judgment result of step S18 is yes, jump to step S9;
[0244] If the judgment result of step S18 is no, jump to step S20;
[0245] S19. Determine that the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis;
[0246] S20, determining whether the boundary condition (i.e., the preset boundary condition) has changed;
[0247] If the judgment result of step S20 is yes, jump to step S9;
[0248] If the determination result of step S20 is NO, the process jumps to step S19.
[0249] Based on the above steps, the impact assessment conclusion of the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on accident analysis can be formed. The impact assessment conclusions formed include the following situations:
[0250] 1. It has no impact on the results and conclusions of the standard design accident analysis;
[0251] 2. The results and conclusions of the standard design accident analysis can be judged to be inclusive only through qualitative analysis;
[0252] 3. It is also necessary to conduct quantitative analysis on certain hypothetical initiating events in order to draw results and conclusions.
[0253] It is understandable that, no matter which situation, the cost of following the above accident analysis and impact assessment process is far less than re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis. At the same time, due to the systematic and structured approach, the integrity and correctness of the accident analysis and impact assessment provided by the embodiment of the present application are also guaranteed.
[0254] It should be noted that the quantitative analysis and qualitative analysis involved in the embodiments of the present application are well known to those skilled in the art and will not be described in detail here.
[0255] Based on the same inventive concept, the embodiment of the present application also provides an accident analysis and impact assessment device. The accident analysis and impact assessment device provided in the embodiment of the present application is described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0256] Example 2
[0257] like Figure 4 As shown, the accident analysis impact assessment device provided in the embodiment of the present application may include an acquisition module 410 , a first determination module 420 and a second determination module 430 .
[0258] Wherein, the acquisition module 410 can be used to obtain the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design;
[0259] The first determination module 420 may be used to determine whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the difference information, so as to obtain a first determination result;
[0260] The second determination module 430 can be used to determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis based on the first determination result and a preset evaluation rule.
[0261] According to the accident analysis impact assessment device provided in the embodiment of the present application, a first determination result is determined by utilizing the difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design, and then the accident analysis impact assessment is performed using the first determination result and preset evaluation rules. Compared with the prior art of re-conducting a comprehensive accident analysis on the nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, this saves time, labor and is more economical.
[0262] In some embodiments, the preset evaluation rules include a preset first acceptance criterion, a preset computer program, and a preset assumption condition;
[0263] The second determination module 430 may include:
[0264] The first determination submodule is used to determine whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list when no new assumed initiating event is generated in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, so as to obtain a plurality of second determination results;
[0265] A second determination submodule, connected to the second determination submodule, is used to determine whether the initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list is applicable to a preset computer program for each initial assumed initiating event when the plurality of second determination results are all applicable, so as to obtain a plurality of third determination results;
[0266] A third determination submodule is connected to the second determination submodule, and is used to determine whether the initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list is applicable to the preset assumption condition for each initial assumed initiating event when the plurality of third determination results are all applicable, so as to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results;
[0267] The fourth determination submodule is connected to the third determination submodule, and is used to determine that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis when multiple fourth determination results are applicable.
[0268] In some embodiments, the difference information includes at least one of structural difference information and operational difference information, and the operational difference information includes design parameters of the standard design, a first operational state of the standard design, and a second operational state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
[0269] The first determination module 420 may include:
[0270] An identification submodule is used to identify the difference information and obtain an initial assumed initiating event list, wherein the initial assumed initiating event list includes multiple initial assumed initiating events;
[0271] A grouping submodule, connected to the identification submodule, for grouping a plurality of initial assumed initiating events according to the initial assumed initiating event list to obtain a plurality of sets of initial assumed initiating events, each set of initial assumed initiating events including at least one initial assumed initiating event;
[0272] A generating submodule, connected to the grouping submodule, is used to generate a target assumed initiating event list, wherein the target assumed initiating event list includes a plurality of sets of initial assumed initiating event sets;
[0273] A comparison submodule, connected to the generation submodule, is used to compare the first accident analysis result and conclusion of the standard hypothetical initiating event list with the second accident analysis result and conclusion of the target hypothetical initiating event list to obtain a comparison result, which is used to characterize whether the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion;
[0274] The first determination submodule is connected to the comparison submodule and is used to determine whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the comparison result.
[0275] In some embodiments, the identification submodule may be specifically used to:
[0276] Using a failure mode and effects analysis method to identify the difference information, and obtaining a first identification result;
[0277] Using the main logic diagram method to test the first recognition result, to obtain a first test result;
[0278] The engineering judgment method is used to identify the first test results and obtain an initial list of hypothesized initiating events.
[0279] In some implementations, the first determination submodule may be specifically used to:
[0280] In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are covered by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, it is determined that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has not generated any new hypothetical initiating event;
[0281] Alternatively, when the comparison results are used to characterize that the second accident analysis results and conclusions are not encompassed by the first accident analysis results and conclusions, it is determined that a new hypothetical initiating event has occurred in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
[0282] In some embodiments, the device may further include:
[0283] A third determination module is used to determine a new set of assumed initiating events when the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, wherein the new set of assumed initiating events includes at least one new assumed initiating event;
[0284] The first analysis module is used to perform quantitative analysis on each new hypothetical initiating event in the set of new hypothetical initiating events to obtain the impact results of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis. The quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program.
[0285] In some embodiments, the device may further include:
[0286] a fourth determination module, for determining, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, a current operating condition classification and an initial operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event when the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion;
[0287] a fifth determination module, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the calculation result of the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset second acceptance criterion corresponding to the current operating condition classification when the current operating condition classification is different from the initial operating condition classification, and obtaining a fifth determination result;
[0288] The second analysis module is used for, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is applicable, to perform a qualitative analysis on the initial assumed initiating event to obtain an evaluation conclusion on the impact of the initial assumed initiating event on the accident analysis, wherein the qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method;
[0289] The execution module is used to execute a preset strategy for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable, and the preset strategy is used to improve the response capability of the nuclear power plant.
[0290] In some implementations, the fourth determination module may be specifically configured to:
[0291] Obtain the occurrence frequency of the initial hypothesized initiating event;
[0292] Determine the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event based on the frequency of occurrence.
[0293] In some embodiments, the acquisition module may also be used to acquire fuel assembly information of a target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, the fuel assembly information including at least one of a fuel assembly type, a fuel assembly structure, and a fuel assembly cladding material;
[0294] A first determination submodule may be used to determine whether an initial assumed initiating event is applicable to a preset first acceptance criterion based on fuel assembly information;
[0295] And / or, the second determination submodule can be used to determine whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to a preset computer program based on the fuel assembly information.
[0296] In some embodiments, the device may further include:
[0297] a sixth determination module, configured to determine a third acceptance criterion applicable to each first target hypothetical initiating event when at least one of the plurality of second determination results is not applicable;
[0298] A third analysis module is used to perform a quantitative analysis on each first target hypothetical initiating event according to a third acceptance criterion to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program;
[0299] Among them, the first target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the second determination result is not applicable.
[0300] In some embodiments, the device may further include:
[0301] an obtaining module, configured to obtain a modified computer program according to a preset computer program when at least one of the plurality of third determination results is not applicable, and the plurality of third determination results are all applicable to the modified computer program;
[0302] a fourth analysis module, for each second target hypothetical initiating event, using the modified computer program to perform a quantitative analysis on the second target hypothetical initiating event, and obtaining the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the quantitative analysis includes performing analysis using the target computer program;
[0303] Among them, the second target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the third determination result is not applicable.
[0304] In some embodiments, the preset assumption condition includes a preset initial condition and a preset boundary condition, and the fourth determination result includes a first determination sub-result and a second determination sub-result;
[0305] The device also includes:
[0306] a fifth analysis module, for performing a qualitative analysis on the third target hypothetical initiating event for each third target hypothetical initiating event, or performing a qualitative analysis and a quantitative analysis on the third target hypothetical initiating event in sequence, to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, when at least one of the plurality of first determination sub-results is not applicable and / or at least one of the plurality of second determination sub-results is not applicable, wherein the qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program;
[0307] Among them, the third target hypothesis initiating event is the initial hypothesis initiating event that the first determined sub-result is not applicable, and / or the second determined sub-result is not applicable.
[0308] It should be noted that the accident analysis impact assessment device provided in the embodiment of the present application can be used to execute the method in Example 1, and its implementation method and beneficial effects of the accident analysis impact assessment method provided in Example 1 of the present application can be specifically referred to the specific description of the accident analysis impact assessment method in the above Example 1, which will not be repeated here.
[0309] It is to be understood that the above embodiments are merely exemplary embodiments used to illustrate the principles of the present application, but the present application is not limited thereto. For those skilled in the art, various modifications and improvements can be made without departing from the spirit and substance of the present application, and these modifications and improvements are also considered to be within the scope of protection of the present application.
Claims
1. An accident analysis and impact assessment method, characterized in that: include: Obtain information on the differences between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design; Determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the difference information, so as to obtain a first determination result; According to the first determination result and preset evaluation rules, it is determined whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The preset evaluation rules include a preset first acceptance criterion, a preset computer program and a preset assumption condition; The determining, based on the first determination result and the preset evaluation rule, whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis comprises: when the first determination result includes that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has not generated the new hypothetical initiating event, for each initial hypothetical initiating event in the target hypothetical initiating event list, determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion, so as to obtain a plurality of second determination results; In the case that the plurality of second determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program, so as to obtain a plurality of third determination results; In the case that the plurality of third determination results are all applicable, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumption condition, so as to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results; When the plurality of fourth determination results are all applicable, determining that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis.
3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The difference information includes at least one of structural difference information and operation difference information, and the operation difference information includes design parameters of the standard design, a first operation state of the standard design, and a second operation state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, Determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the difference information includes: Identifying the difference information to obtain an initial assumed initiating event list, wherein the initial assumed initiating event list includes a plurality of initial assumed initiating events; For the initial assumed initiating event list, grouping the multiple initial assumed initiating events to obtain multiple groups of initial assumed initiating event sets, each group of initial assumed initiating event sets including at least one initial assumed initiating event; Generating a target assumption initiating event list according to the multiple groups of initial assumption initiating event sets, wherein the target assumption initiating event list includes the multiple groups of target assumption initiating event sets; Comparing the first accident analysis result and conclusion of the standard hypothetical initiating event list of the standard design with the second accident analysis result and conclusion of the target hypothetical initiating event list to obtain a comparison result; Based on the comparison result, determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event.
4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The identifying of the difference information to obtain an initial assumed initiating event list includes: Using a failure mode and effects analysis method to identify the difference information, and obtain a first identification result; Using a main logic diagram method to test the first recognition result to obtain a first test result; The first inspection results are identified using an engineering judgment method to obtain an initial list of assumed initiating events.
5. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that: Determining whether a new hypothetical initiating event occurs in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project according to the comparison result includes: In the case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, determining that no new hypothetical initiating event has occurred in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project; Alternatively, when the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not encompassed by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, it is determined that a new hypothetical initiating event has occurred in the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project.
6. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The method further comprises: In a case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are not encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, determining a new set of assumed initiating events, wherein the new set of assumed initiating events includes at least one new assumed initiating event; For each new hypothetical initiating event in the set of new hypothetical initiating events, a quantitative analysis is performed on the new hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact results of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program.
7. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The method further comprises: In a case where the comparison result is used to characterize that the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, determining the current operating condition classification and the initial operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event; For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the current operating condition classification is different from the initial operating condition classification, determining whether the calculation result of the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset second acceptance criterion corresponding to the current operating condition classification, to obtain a fifth determination result; For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is applicable, a qualitative analysis is performed on the initial assumed initiating event to obtain an impact evaluation conclusion of the initial assumed initiating event on the accident analysis, wherein the qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method; For each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, when the fifth determination result corresponding to the initial assumed initiating event is not applicable, a preset strategy is executed, and the preset strategy is used to improve the response capability of the nuclear power plant.
8. The method according to claim 7, characterized in that The determining of the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event comprises: Obtaining the occurrence frequency of the initial assumed initiating event; According to the occurrence frequency, the current operating condition classification of the initial assumed initiating event is determined.
9. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that: Before determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion, the method further includes: Acquiring fuel assembly information of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, wherein the fuel assembly information includes at least one of a fuel assembly type, a fuel assembly structure, and a fuel assembly cladding material; The determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion includes: Determining, based on the fuel assembly information, whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criterion; And / or, the determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program includes: Based on the fuel assembly information, it is determined whether an initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program.
10. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that After determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria to obtain a plurality of second determination results, the method further includes: In the case where at least one of the plurality of second determination results is not applicable, determining a third acceptance criterion applicable to each first target hypothetical initiating event; According to the third acceptance criteria, quantitative analysis is performed on each first target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program; The first target hypothetical initiating event is an initial hypothetical initiating event for which the second determination result is not applicable.
11. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that After determining whether the initial hypothetical initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program to obtain a plurality of third determination results, the method further includes: In the case where at least one of the plurality of third determination results is not applicable, obtaining a modified computer program according to the preset computer program, and the plurality of third determination results are all applicable to the modified computer program; For each second target hypothetical initiating event, the modified computer program is used to perform a quantitative analysis on the second target hypothetical initiating event to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the quantitative analysis includes performing analysis using the target computer program; Among them, the second target assumed initiating event is the initial assumed initiating event for which the third determination result is not applicable.
12. The method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The preset assumption condition includes a preset initial condition and a preset boundary condition, and the fourth determination result includes a first determination sub-result and a second determination sub-result; After determining whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumed condition to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results, the method further includes: When at least one of the plurality of first determination sub-results is not applicable, and / or at least one of the plurality of second determination sub-results is not applicable, for each third target hypothetical initiating event, a qualitative analysis is performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event, or a qualitative analysis and a quantitative analysis are performed on the third target hypothetical initiating event in sequence to obtain the impact result of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project on the accident analysis, wherein the qualitative analysis includes an engineering judgment method, and the quantitative analysis includes analysis using a target computer program; The third target hypothesis initiating event is the initial hypothesis initiating event that the first determined sub-result is not applicable, and / or the second determined sub-result is not applicable.
13. An accident analysis and impact assessment device, characterized in that: include: An acquisition module, used to obtain difference information between the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project and the standard design; A first determination module is used to determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event according to the difference information, so as to obtain a first determination result; The second determination module is used to determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has an impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis based on the first determination result and preset evaluation rules.
14. The device according to claim 13, characterized in that The preset evaluation rules include a preset first acceptance criterion, a preset computer program and a preset assumption condition; The second determining module includes: A first determination submodule is used for determining, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset first acceptance criteria, so as to obtain a plurality of second determination results, when the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project does not generate the new assumed initiating event; A second determination submodule, connected to the second determination submodule, is used to determine, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset computer program, so as to obtain a plurality of third determination results, when the plurality of second determination results are all applicable; A third determination submodule, connected to the second determination submodule, is used to determine, for each initial assumed initiating event in the target assumed initiating event list, whether the initial assumed initiating event is applicable to the preset assumption condition, so as to obtain a plurality of fourth determination results, when the plurality of third determination results are all applicable; The fourth determination submodule is connected to the third determination submodule, and is used to determine that the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project has no impact on the results and conclusions of the accident analysis when the multiple fourth determination results are all applicable.
15. The device according to claim 13, characterized in that The difference information includes at least one of structural difference information and operation difference information, and the operation difference information includes design parameters of the standard design, a first operation state of the standard design, and a second operation state of the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project, The first determining module includes: An identification submodule, configured to identify the difference information and obtain an initial assumed initiating event list, wherein the initial assumed initiating event list includes a plurality of initial assumed initiating events; A grouping submodule, connected to the identification submodule, for grouping the plurality of initial assumed initiating events according to the initial assumed initiating event list to obtain a plurality of sets of initial assumed initiating events, each set of initial assumed initiating events including at least one initial assumed initiating event; A generating submodule, connected to the grouping submodule, for generating a target assumed initiating event list, wherein the target assumed initiating event list includes the multiple groups of initial assumed initiating event sets; a comparison submodule, connected to the generation submodule, for comparing the first accident analysis result and conclusion of the standard hypothetical initiating event list with the second accident analysis result and conclusion of the target hypothetical initiating event list to obtain a comparison result, wherein the comparison result is used to characterize whether the second accident analysis result and conclusion are encapsulated by the first accident analysis result and conclusion; The first determination submodule is connected to the comparison submodule and is used to determine whether the target nuclear energy comprehensive utilization project generates a new hypothetical initiating event based on the comparison result.
