Coupling method for redundant servo devices of an actuator manipulation system, related
Through the communication between redundant servo devices and history adjustment, the correction coefficient is adjusted, and the median correction value is used to solve the problems of divergence and inconsistency of the servo system of multiple redundant actuators, and the reliability of the operating system is improved. and accuracy.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380032475.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-09-29
- Filing Date
- 2023-09-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
AI Technical Summary
In the multi-redundant actuator servo system, there are problems with divergence and inconsistency of values, which leads to difficulty in reallocation of the host system, and the average value is affected by the faulty system, resulting in inaccurate manipulator output.
Through communication between redundant servo devices, the median is used as the reference value to correct the magnitude value, and history is recorded in the data storage to dynamically adjust the correction coefficient to ensure the reliability and accuracy of the operating system.
It effectively prevents the divergence of magnitude, improves the correlation and accuracy of the operating system, enhances the reliability of redundant outputs, and reduces the burden and complexity of responsiveness.
Smart Images

Figure CN118974666A_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] The present invention relates to the field of servo systems for actuators. By "servo system" is meant any system designed to reach a set value as quickly as possible and to maintain the set value as much as possible regardless of the disturbances caused by the environment of the system. The present invention more particularly relates to the field of such servo systems when these servo systems are referred to as "redundant" or "multiple redundancy" for being adopted in, for example, land, water or air vehicles. The present invention will be described mainly in the context of flight control of an aircraft (whether the pilot is present in the aircraft or away from the aircraft, as may be the case for unmanned aircraft), but no limitation is imposed on the present invention accordingly. Such aircraft are generally presented in the form of a propulsion (preferably but not limited to vertical propulsion) device adapted or arranged to ensure the lifting and displacement of a load, which is composed of a pilot, one or more human or animal passengers and / or one or more solid or liquid cargoes, the transportation of which is ensured by the propulsion device.
[0002] The principle of servoing a quantity or a characteristic thereof generally consists of measuring the quantity produced by the system and comparing it with a set value. In order to make the produced quantity reach the target value determined by the set value as quickly as possible and then maintain this target value, the set value is corrected according to the difference between the value produced by the system and the set value. Some control systems through servo act on one or more characteristics of the servoed quantity such as position, speed or also acceleration. Therefore, such systems are sometimes called "control systems by negative feedback (rétroaction négative)" or "by negative feedback (contreréaction)" or also "in a closed loop". It is also possible to servo different quantities and / or characteristics of these quantities to ultimately produce the control of the actuator. The concepts of stability and accuracy are often opposed to the concept of rapidity. In order to improve the performance of the servo system, it is generally necessary to add a corrector to the servo loop. There are different types of correctors, whose action can be integral, differential and / or proportional to the difference measured between the servoed quantity and the set value. Therefore, it is called "PID (acronym for "proportional, integral, differential") corrector". Such a regulator is parameterized by means of gains or coefficients to weight the corrective action proportional to the difference, the integral of the difference and the differential, respectively. The action that can be called "proportional" contributes directly to the responsiveness and stability of the servo. The "integral" action allows to eliminate residual errors and brings accuracy to the system, and the "differential" action allows to limit the fluctuations around the set point of the servo quantity.
[0003] Furthermore, depending on the reliability sought, in particular for systems constructed to be employed in land, sea, air and / or space transport, such servo systems may be multiply redundant and require multiple means of arbitration of such multiply redundancy.
[0004] In engineering, the concept of "redundancy" consists in duplicating key functions or components of a system with the aim of increasing the reliability of said system. When the safety of potential passengers is at risk, as may be the case during the flight of an aircraft, certain parts of the aircraft's control system may be duplicated or triply duplicated, hence the term double or triply redundant systems. Thus, errors generated by an element, for example associated with a malfunction, or a performance drift of said element can then be offset or compensated by employing one or the other redundant element. Multiple redundant systems are also known by the names "majority logic / voting systems" or "voting logic systems" to employ multiple outputs of the same quantity to operate, for example, actuators.
[0005] There are several modes of adoption of multiple redundant actuator servo systems. Take, for example, an actuator manipulation system that employs three similar servo systems (called "pairs system" or "redundant system"), each of which generates (i.e. generates in parallel with each other) a quantity that must reflect the same setpoint value. The manipulation of the actuator is ultimately generated based on a single or multiple quantities generated by the redundant system. According to a first known mode of adoption, such manipulation of the actuator is generated based on the quantity generated by one of the three servo systems (sometimes called the "master"). Only when the master failure is confirmed (such a failure can be detected by the difference between the quantity delivered by the master and the average value of the quantity delivered by each of its peers being too large), the manipulation system or the operator of the manipulation system elects a new master from these redundant servo systems to replace the previous one. This solution may become suboptimal when the values of the servo quantities generated by each of the redundant servo systems diverge. When the three redundant servo systems represent quantities with very inconsistent values, the reallocation of the master system becomes difficult, because it is no longer possible to judge the potential failure or drift of the current master if no consensus is shown between the other redundant systems. Other techniques consist in calculating the mean of the quantities produced by each of the redundant servo systems and in producing the manipulation of the actuator based on said mean. This second embodiment is sometimes problematic, in particular when one of the systems delivers a quantity whose value is very far from that produced by its counterpart. In practice, the mean value obtained is adversely affected by the strong drift of the faulty system, which itself becomes far from the relevant value for finally producing the manipulation of the adapted actuator.
[0006] The present invention allows to solve the above mentioned drawbacks. Among the numerous advantages brought about by implementing the present invention, mention can be made of:
[0007] - Automatic correction of the output of a server device with respect to the output of a peer server device within a multiple redundant control system, preventing the risk of output divergence and increasing the correlation of outputs;
[0008] - Distributing arbitration and / or correction redundant outputs within the control system to make the outputs more reliable without creating complexity or overburdening the responsiveness of the actuator control outputs;
[0009] - precise and adaptive correction of redundant outputs with respect to the characteristics of the generated signals or data, improving the accuracy and relevance of the generated manipulations without burdening the responsiveness, cost and complexity of the system implementing the invention;
[0010] - Proposing a median to take into account the individual outputs of at least three redundant server devices and the delays caused by information sharing between said redundant server devices, brings about a compromise that is particularly relevant in the case of the output of outliers or divergent values.
[0011] To this end, the present invention provides a method implemented by a processing unit of one of multiple redundant servo devices in a manipulation system of an actuator, wherein each redundant servo device generates a value of the same quantity based on the same setting and the same measurement data, and the generated value is adopted by the system to manipulate the actuator, and the redundant servo devices communicate with each other so that each redundant servo device reads and accesses the latest value of the quantity generated by the redundant servo device.
[0012] In order to prevent any drift in the respective output of the magnitudes, the method iteratively comprises:
[0013] - a step based on setting and measuring the current value of the data generation quantity;
[0014] - a step of reading the last known value of a quantity produced by the redundant servo means of the maneuvering system and constructing a set of current values of said quantity;
[0015] - a step of determining a reference value of said quantity taken from said set;
[0016] - a step of calculating the difference between the current value of the produced quantity and said reference value;
[0017] - a step of correcting the current value and generating a corrected current value of the quantity, comprising subtracting from said current value a correction obtained by a calculation according to which said difference is multiplied by a correction factor of said current value.
[0018] In order to increase the relevance of the value of the quantity generated, when the handling system comprises at least three redundant servo means capable of generating such a value of the quantity, the step of determining the reference value advantageously consists in choosing the median of the values of the set of current values of the quantity.
[0019] As a variant, when said maneuvering system comprises only two redundant servo means capable of generating such a value of said quantity, the step of determining a reference value may consist in selecting one of the values from a set of current values of the quantity.
[0020] In order to limit the coupling produced by the redundant servo device, the value of the correction factor can be predetermined.
[0021] As a variant, such coupling may be dynamic. To this end, the method according to the invention may comprise a step of recording in a data memory of the servo means the current value or the corrected value of the quantity produced, so as to construct a history of the values of the determined quantity. Such a method then comprises, before the step of correction, a step of generating a correction coefficient value as a function of the variability of the values obtained from said history and of the iteration frequency of the step of reading the last known value of the quantity produced by the redundant servo means.
[0022] Furthermore, in order to prevent any drastic corrections and even to smooth the process of the generation of the correction magnitude, the calculation of the correction value is arranged so that said correction value does not exceed a predetermined limit value in absolute terms.
[0023] According to a preferred embodiment, according to which the redundant servo devices each comprise a PID corrector delivering three components of an output signal describing respectively proportional, integral and differential action, the quantity may include a component describing said integral action of said PID corrector.
[0024] In order to increase the reliability of the actuator control system, the actuator control system may include redundant sources arranged to jointly deliver a plurality of set values. The method according to the invention may advantageously include a step for generating a setting such that the setting takes the value:
[0025] - one of the values of said plurality of values when the control system comprises only two redundant sources;
[0026] - When the control system comprises at least three redundant sources, the median of the plurality of values.
[0027] In order to increase the reliability of the actuator manipulation system, the actuator manipulation system may include redundant sources arranged to jointly transmit a plurality of measurement data values. The method according to the invention may advantageously include a step for generating measurement data such that the measurement data takes the values:
[0028] - one of the values of said plurality of values when the control system comprises only two redundant sources;
[0029] - When the control system comprises at least three redundant sources, the median of the plurality of values.
[0030] According to a second object, the invention relates to a servo device of a plurality of redundant servo devices of a manipulation system of an actuator, each of said redundant servo devices generating the value of the same quantity based on the same settings and the same measurement data, and further said redundant servo devices communicating with one another so that each servo device has access to the most recent value of said quantity generated by a redundant servo device. Said servo devices are arranged to implement the method according to the invention.
[0031] According to a third object, the invention relates to an actuator manipulation system comprising a plurality of redundant servo means according to the preceding claims, said actuator manipulation being generated on the basis of a plurality of values of a quantity jointly generated by the redundant servo means.
[0032] According to an advantageous embodiment, the manipulation system may be arranged such that the manipulation may be generated based on:
[0033] - when said plurality of values comprises only two values, one of the values of said plurality of values of the quantity generated by a redundant servo device;
[0034] - if the plurality of values comprises at least three values, generating a median of the plurality of values of the quantity.
[0035] According to a fourth object, the invention relates to a vehicle with a load consisting of a driver, passengers and / or merchandise or cargo, comprising one or more actuators in the form of at least one thrust group for moving said vehicle, the manipulation of which is produced by a manipulation system according to the invention.
[0036] According to a preferred mode of application, such a vehicle may be an aircraft.
[0037] Furthermore, according to a fifth object, the present invention relates to a computer program product comprising one or more program instructions interpretable by a processing unit of one of a plurality of redundant servo devices of an actuator handling system according to the invention. To this end, said program instructions are loadable into a non-volatile memory of the servo device and are designed such that their execution by said processing unit causes the implementation of the method according to the invention.
[0038] According to a sixth object, the invention relates to a storage medium readable by such a processing unit, the storage medium comprising instructions of such a computer program product.
[0039] Other features and advantages will become more apparent upon reading the following description and examining the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0040] - Figure 1 A first known propulsion device is shown, which is arranged to provide a substantially vertical take-off and landing capability;
[0041] - Figure 2 Shown by Figure 1 and Figure 1A The arrangement of the thrust system of such a propulsion device is shown and known;
[0042] - Figure 3 shows the arrangement of a setting unit comprising a man-machine input interface for translating human commands of a pilot of the aircraft, such as those described in connection with the previous figures;
[0043] - Figure 4 An example of the functional architecture of a flight controller specifically designed for equipping an unmanned aerial vehicle is shown;
[0044] - Figure 5 An example of a functional architecture of an actuator control system according to the present invention, such as a thrust group of an aircraft, is shown, which includes multiple redundant flight controllers and may be similar to the flight controllers shown by the previous figures;
[0045] - Figure 6 shows that the correction is performed by, for example, Figure 5 A functional description of an example of a method of generating data for a servo device of an actuator manipulation system is described;
[0046] - Figure 7 Shown by and by following Figure 5 The control system produces a significant first contribution of the present invention in relation to pitch actuator control;
[0047] - Fig. 7A Shown by and by following Figure 5 The second contribution brought about by the implementation of the present invention in relation to such pitch actuator manipulation produced by the manipulation system;
[0048] - Figure 8 Shown by and by also following the Figure 5 The significant contribution brought about by the implementation of the present invention is related to the roll actuator control system produced by the control system.
[0049] The invention is preferably, but not limitingly, described by the example of application in the field of flight control of an aircraft or heavy aircraft arranged to provide a substantially vertical take-off and landing capability. As non-limiting examples, such a propulsion device may include an unmanned aerial vehicle, a quadcopter or an octocopter. Document EP 3495262 A1 describes an example of such a propulsion device. However, the invention is not limited to these single application examples, but may instead be employed in connection with any type of propulsion device with a load, a pilot or a passenger.
[0050] According to the invention, such a vertical take-off / landing aircraft is moved by means of a plurality of thrust groups. It differs from what is taken from document EP3495262 A1 in that the respective actuation maneuvers of said thrust groups are produced by a multiple redundant maneuvering system.
[0051] like Figure 1 As shown, according to the technical teaching taken from document EP 3495262 A1, such an aircraft 10 allowing the lifting of a load carried by the aircraft 10 comprises a quadcopter comprising a support member 14 for thrusters in the form of four arms describing an "X" above a substantially flat platform 11. Each arm supports a thrust system TSa, TSb, TSc, TSd, each comprising a thrust group 12a, 12b, 12c, 12d composed of thermal thrusters in the form of turbojets. In order to lift a load ( Figure 2 12a, 12b, 12c, 12d respectively transmit thrust vectors AL12a, AL12b, AL12c, AL12d substantially perpendicular to the platform 11. In order to land without damaging the nozzles or fluid injection outlets of the turbojets of the thrust groups 12a to 12d, the arms of the support members 14 of the thrust systems TSa, TSb, TSc and TSd cooperate at their respective distal end portions with protruding members or advantageously telescopic legs 17. The control system 30 in the form of an electronic processing unit transmits the thrust control to the thrust systems TSa, TSb, TSc, TSd, for example in the form of MIP (acronym for pulse position modulation or PPM in English) signals, according to known modulation techniques for transmitting over a "point-to-point" connection a number of bits in a single coded pulse in an alphabet of possible 2M transitions over time (or any other suitable format). According to the configuration and arrangement of the support means 14, the fluid outlets of the thrusters of the thrust systems are positioned above or below substantially the centre of gravity CG10 of the installation 10. In order to modify and stabilize the attitude of the platform 11, each thrust system TSa to TSd comprises correction means 19a, 19b, 19c, 19d of the thrust vectors AL12a, AL12b, AL12c, AL12d delivered respectively by the turbojets of the thrust groups 12a to 12d.
[0052] Figure 2 Shown according to Figure 1Arrangement of such a correction means of thrust vector 19a of a thrust group 12a of a thrust system TSa. Said correction means 19a of thrust vectoring comprises a pair of movably mounted deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5, more precisely mounted by respective pivot connections 19a-2 and 19a-6. Said deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 are arranged to deflect all or part of the thrust vector AL12a in the region of the fluid injection outlet 12a-o of the turbojet engines 12a-e of the thrust group 12a. The deflector assembly consisting of deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 thus allows to describe a "clamping" of said thrust vector AL12a. The deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 are advantageously each composed of only their actuators 19a-3 in a manner which is controlled in the thrust vector AL12a. Figure 1 1 and 2. The actuator 19a-3 is actuated by a pair of cam actuators or servomotors visible in the drawing. Thus, the actuator 19a-3 cooperates with the deflector guide 19a-1 via the connecting rod 19a-4. The cam actuation of the actuator 19a-3 causes a rotational movement r of the deflector guide 19a-1 about the axis 19a-2 located above the fluid injection area of the turbojet 12a, which reduces the torque required by the actuator 19a-3 to overcome and resist the suction or discharge generated by the thrust vector AL12a delivered by the turbojets 12a-e of the thrust group 12a when closing and opening the deflector guide 19a-1. When the cam actuators (such as actuator 19a-3) respectively associated with the deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 cause the thrust vector AL12a to be clamped by the deflector guides, said thrust vector AL12a is subdivided downstream of said deflector guide into two or three components AL12a, AL12a', AL12a"., depending on whether this or that deflector guide 19a-1 or 19a-5 passes through the airflow ejected at the fluid outlet 12a-o of the turbojet engine 12a-e. In the "open" configuration - according to which the deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 are Basically located outside the trajectory of the thrust vector AL12a - the force of the thrust vector AL12a is the largest. On the contrary, when one (or both) of the two deflector guides 19a-1, 19a-5 "clamps" the thrust vector, the thrust generated by the thrust vector AL12a downstream of the deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 is reduced until it is offset by the "full clamping" of the deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5 of the airflow at the outlet of the nozzle 12a-o of the turbojet engine. According to the arrangement of the deflector guides 19a-1 and 19a-5, in Figure 3In structure, these deflector guides are similar to two cup-shaped or semicircular surfaces that are essentially curvilinear and face each other, making it possible to generate a reverse thrust in the case of a "closed" configuration of the two guides 19a-1 and 19a-5, i.e. a thrust vector in a direction opposite to the direction of the thrust vector AL12a at the fluid injection outlet 12a-o. Such a reverse thrust (for example of the order of 10% to 30%) is possible due to the morphology of the guides. In practice, the guides can be arranged to guide the fluid flow induced at the outlet (distal part) of the guides, respectively, according to secondary thrust vectors AL12a' and AL12a" oriented in a direction essentially opposite to the direction of the primary thrust vector AL12a at the fluid injection outlet 12a-o of the turbojet engine 12a-e.
[0053] As a variant, the thrust systems TSa to TSd of the aircraft 10 may each comprise a propeller moved in rotation by an electric motor and / or a thermal motor to transmit the thrust generated by the propulsion system based on the Figure 1 and Figure 1A The thrust equivalent to the thrust described for the thrust system of the turbojet engine described in the related description. Whatever the embodiment of the thrust system of the propulsion device, the electronic control system 30 controls the respective powers of the thrust systems TSa to TSd based on the measurements delivered by an inertial navigation unit 40 advantageously located in the vicinity of the center of gravity CG10 of the aircraft 10 and the piloting settings delivered by a setting unit 20 communicating with the control system 30CL, by wire or by radio. Thus, the control system 30 converts the pilot's indications, via the setting unit 20, into actuator (thrusters, deflectors) manipulations for regulating the thrust delivered respectively by the thrust systems TSa to TSd, causing the trajectory of said aircraft required by said pilot relative to the attitude and position of the aircraft 10 estimated by the measurement unit 40.
[0054] Figure 1ASuch an aircraft 10 is described according to a reference system defined by three axes x, y, z, which are respectively indicated in the plane of the platform 11 for the x-axis and the y-axis and perpendicular to the platform 11 for the z-axis. The three axes x, y and z intersect at the center of gravity CG10 of the aircraft 10. The x-axis extends from the tail of the aircraft to the nose, and the y-axis extends from the starboard side to the port side. When the platform is horizontal, the z-axis describes the vertical direction from a distance towards the ground. Such an aircraft 10 can be moved in the air according to the rotations R, P, Y respectively around the x, y and z axes caused by the control system 30 that intentionally adjusts the corresponding thrusts transmitted by the thrust groups TSa to TSd. Therefore, the vertical lift of the aircraft 10 is caused by the joint and identical increase of the thrusts transmitted by the four thrust groups TSa to TSd, which is sufficient to generate a lift greater than the weight of the aircraft 10. On the contrary, the vertical displacement from the top to the bottom of the vehicle is obtained by a joint and identical reduction of the thrust delivered by the four thrust groups TSa to TSd, so as to generate a lift less than the weight of the vehicle 10 .
[0055] In order to cause a displacement towards the front (nose) or the rear (tail) of the aircraft 10, the control system 30 induces a thrust difference between the thrust group torques formed respectively by the thrust groups TSa and TSd on the one hand and by the thrust group torques formed respectively by the thrust groups TSb and TSc on the other hand. Thus, a rotation P about the y-axis is caused (also known by the name "pitch" or according to the English term "pitch"). The relative and combined lift of the torques {TSa, TSd} with respect to the torques {TSb, TSc} caused by the positive thrust difference induces a forward displacement of the aircraft. The opposite situation induces a rearward displacement of the aircraft 10.
[0056] In order to cause a displacement to port or to starboard, the maneuvering system 30 induces a thrust difference between the thrust group torques formed by the thrust groups TSa and TSc, respectively, on the one hand, and the thrust group torques formed by the thrust groups TSd and TSb, respectively, on the other hand. Thus, a rotation R about the x-axis (also known by the name "roll" or according to the English term "roll") is induced. The relative and combined increase of the torques {TSa, TSc} with respect to the torques {TSb, TSd} caused by the positive thrust difference induces a displacement to the port side of the aircraft 10. The opposite situation induces a displacement of the aircraft 10 to starboard.
[0057] The control system 30 can also cause a rotation Y of the aircraft about the z-axis (also known by the name "yaw" or according to the English term "yaw"). To this end, the control system 30 causes an asymmetric clamping of the deflector guides of each thrust group TSa to TSd, at least of the thrust group torques {TSa, TSb} or {TSc, TSd}. Figure 2In relation, such asymmetric clamping of the deflector guides 19a-1, 19a-5 of the thrust group TSa produces three components of the thrust generated by said thrust group, said thrust no longer being strictly parallel to the fluid jet of the turbojets 12a-e and therefore perpendicular to the direction of the platform, but becoming inclined relative to the platform under the combined action of one of the components AL12a which remains parallel to the direction of the fluid jet of the turbojets 12a-e and the main component of the components AL12a' or AL12a" which are substantially perpendicular to the turbojets 12a-e. Depending on whether the component AL12a' is greater than or less than the component AL12a", a clockwise or counterclockwise rotation Y around the y-axis is caused.
[0058] In order not to induce any lift or altitude loss in yaw, roll or pitch, the maneuvering system 30 causes an increase equal to the reduction in the combined thrust delivered by the torque of the thrust group or groups involved in such asymmetric clamping of the deflector guides, so that the total lift delivered by all thrust groups is constant.
[0059] In order to interpret the driver's instructions, such as Figure 3 As shown, the setting unit 20 may include a human-machine input interface including an input peripheral device e in the form of a pair of joysticks or a pair of levers 21 and 22, also referred to as joysticks according to English terminology. The invention is not limited to this sole choice of input peripheral devices, which may in addition or as a variant include a plurality of buttons, a touch surface or any other equivalent and adapted component.
[0060] As a basis Figure 3 and Figure 3A Example ( Figure 3A A top view of the handles 21 and 22 is depicted), the handle 21 allowing the detection of four displacements D21-1, D21-2, D21-3, D21-4 of the distal portion 21d of the lever 21 relative to its support 21b:
[0061] - Displacement D21-1 can translate into a pilot setting aimed at increasing the total thrust of the aircraft and causing an increase in altitude;
[0062] - opposite to displacement D21-1, displacement D21-2 can translate into a pilot setting that reduces the total thrust of the aircraft and causes a loss of altitude;
[0063] - Displacement D21-3 can be translated around according to Figure 1A The z-axis of the aircraft 10 is set by the pilot to rotate counterclockwise;
[0064] - In contrast to displacement D21-3, displacement D21-4 can be translated around according to Figure 1AThe z-axis is set by the pilot to rotate the aircraft 10 clockwise.
[0065] Still as a basis Figure 3A For example, the handle 22 allows detecting four displacements D22-1, D22-2, D22-3, D22-4 of the distal portion 22d of the lever 22 relative to its support 22b:
[0066] - Displacement D22-1 can translate the pilot setting intended to cause the aircraft to move forward;
[0067] - opposite to the displacement D22-1, the displacement D22-2 may translate a pilot setting intended to cause a rearward displacement of the aircraft;
[0068] - Displacement D22-3 can translate the pilot setting intended to cause the aircraft to move to port;
[0069] In contrast to displacement D22 - 3 , displacement D22 - 4 can translate a pilot setting intended to cause a displacement of the aircraft to starboard.
[0070] Furthermore, the setting unit 20 comprises electronic components 23, such as one or more microcontrollers or microprocessors, for translating such displacements of the distal portions 21 d and 22 d of the levers 21 and 22 into setting electrical signals Gsp, which are intended to be transmitted to the operating system 30 via radio or wired CL lines. Such electronic components 23 can be duplicated into several redundant components and jointly generate a plurality of setting signals Gsp.
[0071] Furthermore, the setting unit 20 may comprise other components, such as push rod buttons, for example for translating the order of activating the thrusters, indicating the loss of the pilot's ability to ensure the control of the aircraft, switching from manual control mode to assisted control mode, etc. The electronic components 23 of the setting unit 20 are arranged to also communicate the information transmitted by the components. Thus, the setting unit 20 may transmit, for example, a signal Gsp of the PPM type, or even a plurality of signals Gsp if the components 23 are redundant. Said signal carries an information vector, among which may be mentioned a position setting Xsp, a heading / yaw setting ψsp, a setting for starting or stopping one or more thrusters, a driving mode identification, etc.
[0072] As for Figure 4 , which describes a manipulation system 30 for an actuator TS, for example according to Figure 1The control system 30 is integrated or cooperates with one or more inertial navigation units 40 (accelerometers, gyroscopes, magnetometers), inertial navigation units (INU, the acronym for “Inertial Navigation Unit”), or even inertial measurement units (IMU, the acronym for “Inertial Measurement Unit”). Such measurement units 40 are designed in particular to estimate the position of the aircraft 10. Line speed Or angular velocity Line speed Location It can be estimated relative to a "NED (North-East-Down) frame" reference system defined by three orthogonal axes, the first axis pointing to the geographic north, the second axis pointing to the center of the earth and the third axis pointing to the east. and quaternions and any angular velocity It is usually estimated relative to a reference frame specific to the aircraft 10, such as Figure 1A The reference system is shown by the x, y, z axes. The linear velocity and the position may be corrected by a Kalman filter.
[0073] The control system 30 comprises one or more flight controllers FC whose function is to integrate the measurements delivered by the one or more measurement units 40 and the piloting settings delivered by the setting unit 20, so as to deliver to each thrust group TSa to TSd (or more generally to the actuator TS) a control Δ, for example in the form of a PPM signal or equivalent, which may mainly carry components related to pitch δp, roll δr, yaw δy, power / thrust δt.
[0074] Figure 4 More accurately depicts the Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the architecture of the flight controller FC of the unmanned aerial vehicle 10 shown. According to this example, the flight controller FC comprises a plurality of control devices, which form two main levels, Figure 4 The upper reference is STA and STB. The hierarchical STA is responsible for adjusting the position of the aircraft in the "NED frame" reference system. Figure 4 In the example shown, in general, the hierarchical STA is based on the measurements from the measurement unit 40 (in this case on the position of the aircraft). and line speed and on the other hand based on the estimation by the setting unit 20 (such as the previous Figure 3 and Figure 3A The position setting Xsp delivered by the setting unit (described in the related text) generates the setting acceleration Asp.
[0075] As for the hierarchical STB, it is responsible for regulating the aircraft in such Figure 1A The position in the reference system of the platform specific to the aircraft 10 (called “fuselage frame” according to English terminology) indicated by the x, y, z axes on the plane is used for the output of the hierarchical STA on the one hand (setting acceleration Asp) and the heading / yaw setting ψsp from the control unit and on the other hand based on the attitude setting ψsp obtained by the measurement unit 40 Quaternions and angular velocity The measurements transmitted are used to transmit the components of the actuator manipulation Δ related to pitch δp, roll δr, yaw δy. To this end, the interface 33 ensures a coordinate system transposition so that the set acceleration Asp and the heading / yaw setting ψsp are translated into the set quaternion qsp and the components of the manipulation Δ related to power / thrust δt.
[0076] Each hierarchical STA and STB may be "beaten" according to a different period or frequency. The modulation frequency implemented by the two main hierarchical STAs and STBs may be 50 Hz for a hierarchical STA and 250 to 1000 Hz for a hierarchical STB.
[0077] According to Figure 4 In the example shown, each of the hierarchical STA and STB comprises two control devices 31, 32 for the hierarchical STA and two control devices 34, 35 for the hierarchical STB, respectively.
[0078] The position control device 31 of the aircraft is based on the set position Xsp and the estimated position The set speed Vsp is then transmitted by the control device 32 and the line speed estimated by the measuring unit 40. The comparison is performed to generate the set acceleration Asp mentioned above.
[0079] For its part, the attitude control device 34 of the hierarchical STB performs the operation by comparing the set quaternion qsp with the quaternion delivered by the measurement unit 40. and posture Then, the set angular velocity Ωsp is compared with the angular velocity of the aircraft estimated by the measuring unit 40. The comparison is performed to ultimately generate the components of the steering vector Δ related to pitch δp, roll δr and yaw δy by the angular velocity control device 35 of the staged STB.
[0080] In an advantageous manner, the position control device 31 and the attitude control device 34 generate respective outputs proportional to the difference separating their inputs. Conversely, the linear velocity and angular velocity control devices 32 and 35 generate outputs based on components describing a corrective action, the corrective action being proportional to the difference between their inputs, the integral and the derivative of said difference, respectively, for example by means of a PID regulator. Each control device may advantageously comprise its own processing unit Ut (for example in the form of one or more microprocessors or microcontrollers cooperating with a data and / or program memory M), which samples, according to a given period, the measurements and / or settings delivered by the measuring unit 40 and / or the setting unit 20 or more generally by a source delivering setting or measurement data. Such a source, which may be referred to as a "setting source", may therefore comprise, for example, the previously described source with reference to Figure 3 The setting unit 20 is described in relation to the flight controller 30 (when the flight controller 30 is considered as a whole) or the only position controller 31 of such a flight controller FC. In addition, such a setting source can include a position control device 31 or an attitude control device 34, or even an interface 33 for a linear velocity control module 31 and an angular velocity control module 35.
[0081] As a variant, such a flight controller FC may comprise only a single processing unit Ut responsible for implementing the generation methods specific to the different electronic components (position controller 31, attitude controller 34, linear velocity controller 32 or angular velocity controller 35, or even interface 33). Regardless of whether the processing unit Ut of the flight controller is centralized or decentralized, i.e. all or part of the different electronic components of the flight controller comprise their own processing unit Ut ( Figure 4 Such a situation is shown for control modules 34 and 35), the behavior of the processing unit Ut can advantageously be determined by an appropriate computer program, the program instructions of which are loaded into one or more data and / or program memories M cooperating with the processing unit.
[0082] Figure 5 An embodiment of such a manipulation system 30 of an actuator TS according to the invention is shown, for which the measuring, communication and / or data processing elements are duplicated for reasons of reliability. Figure 4 The controller FC described in relation to the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are arranged in the manipulation system 30 to implement similar processing based on the measurement data from the measurement unit 40 and the setting data transmitted by the setting unit 20. Therefore, the three flight controllers FC-1 to FC-3 are responsible for each generating a manipulation Δ1, Δ2 or Δ3 of the actuator TS, such as the actuator TS that has been connected to the Figure 1The thrust groups TSa to TSd of the aircraft 10 are described in relation to each other. The maneuvers Δ1 , Δ2 or Δ3 thus jointly form the maneuvers of the maneuvering system 30
[0083] In contrast to known control systems that present multiple redundancy, i.e. comprise a plurality of flight controllers, each of which independently generates a maneuver Δ1, Δ2 or Δ3 based on measurement data GS and a common setting Gsp, the control system 30 according to the invention is arranged so that the maneuver Δ1, Δ2 or Δ3 is jointly generated by redundant flight controllers. To this end, the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are arranged to communicate with each other via a communication bus B so that each flight controller knows the values generated by its peer. More precisely, the control devices (such as those composed of) respectively constitute control devices and ensure the regulation of position, attitude, linear velocity and angular velocity. Figure 4 The devices 31, 32, 34 and 35 shown may possess the ability to know the data generated by their counterparts in the different flight controllers FC-1 to FC-3. According to an advantageous embodiment, such a communication bus B may comprise a data bus known as CAN (acronym for the English expression “Controller Area Network”), which is advantageously redundant, i.e. doubled, for example for reliability reasons. Such a technical choice is advantageous for sending large amounts of data via a single cable and distributing these data between the different electronic components of the control system 30.
[0084] Thus, the outputs or maneuvers Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 delivered by the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, respectively, can also be generated by these flight controllers no longer independently of one another but jointly, i.e. taking into account the outputs of the redundant flight controllers. The maneuvers Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 thus jointly form a multiple redundant maneuver and is sent to the actuator TS, more precisely, to the electronic controller of the actuator TS, which controller itself may be multiplexed and redundant. Figure 5 Such a controller is incorporated into the concept of an actuator. Such a controller and / or actuator TS implements a strategy of selection and / or arbitration between different manipulations Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 to perform its function. As an advantageous example, such a controller can be based on a multivariate manipulation transmitted by the manipulation system 30. A "simple" manipulation delta is generated such that the manipulation delta comprises:
[0085] - one of the maneuvers Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 generated separately and jointly by the redundant flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3, when only two of said flight controllers retain their ability to generate such maneuvers - a situation that may arise when one of said three flight controllers fails;
[0086] - the plurality of maneuvers Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 jointly generated by redundant flight controllers of the median.
[0087] As a variant, such a control system according to the invention can be arranged so that the control system can be based on a plurality of control Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 generated by the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, respectively and jointly. A "simple" manipulation Δ is directly generated in order to relieve the actuator TS of such arbitration tasks. In this case, such a manipulation system 30 may include an arbitration component (for simplicity, in Figure 5 (not shown above) for formulating such a manipulation Δ according to a technique similar to that previously disclosed for enabling arbitration of actuators.
[0088] According to Figure 5 In the example shown, the measurement unit 40 can also be enhanced in the form of three redundant measurement units 40-1, 40-2, 40-3, which transmit their measurements to three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3, respectively. These flight controllers can propagate the measurement data transmitted by the measurement unit dedicated to each flight controller to its peers via the communication bus B. Thus, according to the Figure 5 In the example shown, the measurement unit 40 - 1 transmits the position of the aircraft 10 to the flight controller FC- 1 Line speed and angular velocity The attitude of the aircraft 10 and quaternions In the same way, the measurement unit 40-2 transmits the measurement data Gs1 in the form of an estimate of the position of the aircraft 10 to the flight controller FC-2. Line speed and angular velocity The attitude of the aircraft 10 and quaternions Finally, the measurement unit 40-3 transmits the measurement data Gs2 in the form of an estimate of the position of the aircraft 10 to the flight controller FC-3. Line speed and angular velocity The attitude of the aircraft 10 and quaternions As a variant, the three measurement units 40-1, 40-2, 40-3 may be connected to the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3 via a communication bus B.
[0089] The setting unit 20 transmits the settings Gsp related to the position Xsp, heading and yaw ψsp to the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 via the communication bus B. When the setting unit presents multiple redundancies, such settings can also be multiple Figure 5 Also shown is a possible navigation assistance module 20 a which, as a supplement, can assist the pilot and deliver settings Gsp related to the position Xsp, heading and yaw ψsp, instead of the setting unit 20 or in addition to the setting unit 20 .
[0090] In an ideal situation, the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 will be exactly the same, will have the ability to sample the data or signals carried by the data bus B according to an infinite frequency, and will therefore immediately share the data generated by it with its peers. As for the measurement unit, it will pass the same and noise-free estimate. According to such an ideal situation, there is no difference or any possible deviation between the manipulations Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 passed to the actuator TS. However, this ideal situation is impractical. Therefore, there is a delay between the reading or sampling of the data generated by its peers and the generation of its own data implemented by each flight controller. In fact, the data sampling frequency available via the communication bus B cannot be infinite, the measurement data is noisy and may fluctuate according to the measurement units 40-1, 40-2 and 40-3 considered, and the electronic devices and clocks at the corresponding control devices of the redundant flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 cannot be perfectly cloned or synchronized. Therefore, the manipulations Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 are constantly deviated from each other, even divergent, and the accuracy and relevance are lost, impairing the driving of the aircraft. In order to cope with such real and / or technical limitations, the present invention provides for a method of distributing the magnitudes produced by the corrections at each flight controller FC-1, FC-2, FC-3 within the control system 30, or even at each control device 31, 32, 34, 35 of each of said flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3, taking into account the outputs of the peer flight controllers and / or control devices. Due to the implementation of such a method according to the invention, the manipulations Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3 become jointly produced by the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3, without divergence in the nominal function (i.e., in compliance with the design constraints), allowing the actuator TS to consider consistent and accurate manipulations Δ1, Δ2 and Δ3.
[0091] It is important to emphasize that when the control system 30 includes only two redundant flight controllers, or when the Figure 5 It is particularly advantageous for the redundant maneuvers to remain consistent with one another and without leadership when only two of the three flight controllers shown maintain their output capabilities. In fact, even if the actuator TS takes into account only one of the two maneuvers in its arbitration, the actuator does not experience a noticeable interruption in the maneuvers and therefore in the behavior when the flight controller that generated the maneuver previously adopted fails and the actuator TS must now select and adopt the second maneuver instead of the first one that has become unavailable. The situation would be very different if the outputs of the two redundant flight controllers were realized in parallel, that is, independently of one another, instead of being carried out jointly as in the present invention. In fact, without the contribution of the present invention, the maneuvers respectively transmitted by the two redundant flight controllers could gradually diverge from one another. When the maneuvers are switched, the behavior of the aircraft suffers a loss of continuity. Such a correction method specific to the present invention, which allows the joint generation of redundant maneuvers, can be implemented according to Figure 4 The servo means may be implemented by a processing unit of such a flight controller FC (i.e. in a centralized manner) or by one of the processing units of the different control devices 31, 32, 34 and 35 included in the flight controller FC (i.e. in a distributed manner). The expression "servo means" will hereinafter be used indiscriminately to denote such a flight controller itself or a control device included in the flight controller.
[0092] In order to adapt the functions of such a servo device, program instructions that can be interpreted by the processing unit of the servo device can be loaded into its non-volatile memory M. Therefore, such program instructions are designed to be executed by the processing unit Ut of such a servo device, resulting in the implementation of the method according to the invention for the output of the value involved in the correction. Such program instructions can constitute such a computer program product itself and can be carried or stored on any suitable storage medium.
[0093] Figure 6 Such a method 100 according to the invention is shown, which is intended to be implemented by a processing unit Ut of one of a plurality of redundant servo devices of an actuator manipulation system. Advantageously, such a method 100 is formulated to be implemented by each of said redundant servo devices. These redundant servo devices are arranged to respectively generate the value of the same quantity G based on the same setting Gsp and the same measurement data Gs. In order to jointly generate such a quantity, the servo devices are for example connected via Figure 5 The communication bus B shown communicates with each other so that each slave device knows (ie has read access via said communication bus B) the latest value of said quantity G generated by said redundant slave device.
[0094] Such a method 100 is implemented iteratively according to a given frequency SP. As described above, without giving any limitation to the present invention, for Figure 4 The controller FC is a control device for the stage STA, so that the frequency SP can be selected to be comprised between 50 and 100 Hz, or for a control device according to Figure 4 The controller FC controls the control means of the stage STB so that a frequency SP can be chosen to be comprised between 250 and 1000 Hz.
[0095] Such a method 100 comprises a first step 110 of generating a value G1 of the quantity G based on a setting Gsp and measurement data Gs.
[0096] Furthermore, it comprises a step 120 of reading the latest value of the quantity generated by the redundant servo device, for example via the communication bus B, and constructing a set of current values of the quantity G based on said value accessed by the read access and the value generated in step 110
[0097] According to According to Figure 5 In a first example of implementation of the control system 30 of the actuator TS, the servo device implementing the method 100 may include a flight controller FC-1, and the flight controllers FC-2 and FC-3 are peer servo devices of the controller FC-1. In this case, the quantity G mentioned is the actuator control The value G1 of the quantity G is alternately a manipulation Δ1 (when the servo device implementing the method 100 is the controller FC-1) or a manipulation Δ2 (when the servo device FC-2 implements the method 100, the flight controllers FC-1 and FC3 are peer servos of the servo device FC-2, and so on for the flight controller FC-3. According to this first example, the set As for setting Gsp, it includes the following steps: Figure 5 The unit 20 sets the position Xsp, heading and yaw ψsp of the unit. As for the measurement data Gs, it includes the components obtained according to the Figure 4 The measuring unit 40 delivers the position Line speed attitude and quaternions and angular velocity All estimates, including those based on Figure 5 The redundant measurement units 40-1, 40-2 and 40-3 of the illustrated example each deliver an estimate of .
[0098] According to a second example of implementing the method 100 according to the present invention, the method 100 is composed according to Figure 5The redundant servo device for implementing the method 100 may be the corresponding linear velocity controller 32 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, or even the corresponding angular velocity controller 35 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 (when the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are connected to the corresponding angular velocity controller 35 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3). Figure 4 In the case where the redundant servo device is a linear velocity controller 32, the quantity G is a set acceleration Asp, or even more precisely, a component of the set acceleration Asp reflecting the integral action when the velocity controller 32 comprises a PID regulator. As for setting Gsp, it comprises a set linear velocity Vsp, which itself is generated by the position controller of the flight controller FC-1, FC-2 or FC-3 in question. The set of values The set acceleration Asp is comprised of the set acceleration Asp generated by the equal speed control device 32 or by a single component of the set acceleration Asp reflecting the integral action of the PID regulator of the equal speed controller.
[0099] As a variant or in a complementary manner, the redundant servo means implementing the method 100 according to the invention may comprise the respective position control means 31 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3. The quantity G considered is then the set linear velocity Vsp. As for the set Gsp, which comprises components related to the position Xsp, the heading and the yaw ψsp coming from the setting unit 20, the measurement data Gs are the aircraft position estimated by the measurement units 40, 40-1, 40-2, 40-3.
[0100] In order to generate values for quantities of redundant slave devices in a coupled, ie jointly, manner, it is necessary to correct the values generated in step 110 to take into account the output of said redundant or peer slave devices. To this end, the method 100 according to the invention further comprises determining the values obtained from the set Step 130 of obtaining the reference value Gr of the quantity, i.e., forming the set from step 120 Select from the values in the drop-down list.
[0101] When the actuator manipulation system 30, the elements of which implement the method 100 in a distributed manner, comprises at least three redundant servo devices (such as controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3 or their position, attitude and / or linear or angular velocity controllers) capable of generating and communicating the value of the quantity G, the invention provides that the step 130 of determining the reference value Gr may comprise determining a set of current values forming the quantity G The median of the values in a data set (in this case, the set ) so that 50% of the data have values less than or equal to the median and 50% of the data have values greater than or equal to the median. In small data sets, it is sufficient to count the number of data and arrange them in ascending order according to their respective values. If the number of data is an odd number, the number must be increased by one unit and then divided by two to obtain a rank representing the median value. The rank is once the set The position of the values after sorting: the smallest value corresponds to the first rank, the second smallest to the second rank, etc. According to the example of a triple redundant system, the median will therefore be chosen as the value of the quantity of the second rank, or even as the middle value between the two values of the smallest and the largest. When the output of one of the servo devices deviates significantly with respect to the others, the choice of the median allows to avoid the biases caused by some previous techniques of preferential average or single selection.
[0102] On the contrary, when the control system 30 comprises only two redundant servo devices, or even when only two of the plurality of servo devices retain the ability to generate the value of the quantity G, the step 130 of determining the reference value Gr comprises determining from the set of current values of the quantity G One of the current values of said quantity produced by the first or second servo means maintaining the ability to produce values of the quantity G is selected. When the redundant servos are identified by such an index or by any other technique selecting an alternating or random selection, such selection may favor the servo means having the lowest index.
[0103] The method 100 then comprises a step 140 of calculating the difference Ge between the current value G1 of the quantity G generated in step 110 and said reference value Gr, and then a step 150 of generating a corrected current value G1' of the quantity G, which step 150 comprises an operation of subtracting a correction Gc. The value of the correction Gc comprises a calculation according to which said difference Ge is multiplied by a correction coefficient Kc of said current value G1 derived from step 110. In this way, the final output G1' of each redundant servo means is coupled to the final output G1' of the other redundant servo means. The latter in effect generate, in a joint manner, a corrected value G1' of the quantity G.
[0104] In order to implement the step 150 of generating the corrected current value G1′ of the quantity G, the value of the correction coefficient Kc that causes the coupling of the corresponding outputs of the redundant servo devices can be predetermined and recorded, for example, in the memory M of each servo device. The selection of said value of the correction coefficient Kc causes various significant technical effects on the behavior sought by the control system 30, as will be explained later in connection with Figure 7 , Fig. 7A and Figure 8As can be seen in relation to the quantity G considered, said value of the correction coefficient Kc can be chosen to be equal to 1, which means that from the current value Gl of the quantity G generated by one of the redundant servo devices is subtracted the entirety of the difference Ge between said current value Gl and a reference value Gr, which takes the value of said reference value Gr. As a variant, only a part of said difference Ge can be subtracted from said current value Gl to generate the correction value Gl'. Thus, said value of the correction coefficient Kc can be chosen in an empirical way, for example according to a criterion based on the variability of the quantity G with respect to the frequency SP, for sampling in step 120 the values generated by one or more peer servo devices, i.e. for constituting the set of current values of the quantity G generated by the set of redundant servo devices. For example, for a quantity G whose value varies strongly with respect to the frequency SP, a correction coefficient Kc of low value (e.g. of the order of 5%) is preferred, and conversely, in the opposite case, a coefficient close to or equal to 100%. In the case of a high delay between the current values generated by different redundant servo devices, a low correction coefficient Kc may also be selected for forming the set And in the opposite case, a value close to or equal to 100% can be chosen. Thus, when the quantity G in question is a component reflecting the integral action of the PID regulator of the linear velocity controller 32, a Kc value comprised, for example, between 80% and 100% can be preferred. As a variant or in a complementary manner, when the quantity G in question is a component reflecting the integral action of the PID regulator of, for example, the angular velocity controller 35, a Kc value comprised, for example, between 5% and 30% can be preferred. The invention is not limited to these single parameter examples. Thus, the memory M of the servo device can include a table of possible values for the correction coefficient Kc according to the quantity G in question, according to the performance of the communication means B for exchanging the respective outputs of the redundant servo devices, or also according to the respective iteration frequency SP of each redundant servo device.
[0105] The correction value Kc can be determined in advance during the design or calibration phase of the maneuvering system or during the simulation phase of such a system 30 in order to calibrate the technical effect of the coupling sought by implementing the method 100 as a function of the quantity or quantities G considered.
[0106] As a variant, the value of the correction coefficient Kc may be dynamic and may be adjusted in real time by each redundant servo device of the control system. In this case, the invention provides that such a servo device may constitute in a step 151 a history of a determined number of values Gl of the quantity generated at step 110 or of the value Gl' of the quantity corrected at step 150 in order to estimate its variability. Thus, before implementing step 150, in step 101, even according to a frequency of execution lower than the iteration frequency SP of steps 110, 120, 130, 140 and 150, it is possible to estimate and constitute a set of previous values of the quantity G according to the estimation of the variation of the values. The value of the correction coefficient Kc is dynamically adjusted with the iteration frequency SP of step 120. Such adjustment 101 can be determined by a pre-established calculation rule. According to a variant embodiment, such adjustment 101 can be implemented by a neural network, which is pre-trained with the help of data collected, for example, via a large number of flight simulations, or more generally for various quantities of servo.
[0107] As a variant or in addition to the weighting of the value of the correction Gc by the appropriate correction coefficient Kc chosen with respect to one or other of the quantities G involved, the invention provides for limiting the value of said correction Gc to an absolute value before it is subtracted from the value Gl produced at step 110. To this end, the step 150 of producing the value of the correction Gc can be arranged to limit the correction Gc in absolute value to a limit value L. Thus, when the value of the correction Gc calculated on the basis of the difference Ge between the current value Gl of the quantity G and the reference value Gr exceeds said limit value L in absolute value, the absolute value of said correction Gc takes on said limit value L. By way of non-limiting example, such a value L can be calculated as a percentage of the quantity of reference Gr strictly greater than 0 and less than 30%.
[0108] This step 150 of double parameterization by means of the value of the correction coefficient Kc on the one hand and of the limit value L on the other hand provides great flexibility for calibrating the desired behavior of the actuation system 30 of the actuator TS according to the invention.
[0109] like Figure 5 As shown, some of the input data of the servo device may be redundant, i.e. come from multiple sources. This may be the case when the measurement data are delivered to the servo device via multiple redundant sources, or when it is planned to intentionally inject values generated by a third party servo device, which is also redundant, at the input of the servo device via communication bus B. For example, with Figure 4 and Figure 5Relatedly, it can be planned to inject into the input of the linear speed servo device 32, on the one hand, the estimate of the aircraft linear speed transmitted by the measuring units 40-1, 40-2, 40-3 and, on the other hand, the set linear speed transmitted by the position control device 31 of the different flight controllers FC-1, FC-2, FC-3 respectively.
[0110] The same may also be true for the respective position controllers 31 , attitude controllers 34 or angular velocity controllers 35 of the redundant flight controllers FC- 1 , FC- 2 and FC- 3 .
[0111] Therefore, with Figure 6 Relatedly, when the setting Gsp comprises a plurality of values delivered by redundant sources that deliver said setting of the actuator control system, When the method 100 according to the present invention may include a step 102 for generating the set Gsp, so that the set Gsp takes the value:
[0112] -When the multiple values one of said plurality of values when only two values are included, i.e. when only two redundant sources deliver such a setting;
[0113] -When the multiple values When at least three values are included, that is, when at least three redundant sources deliver such a setting, the median of the plurality of values.
[0114] In the same way, when based on setting Gsp and including redundant sources respectively provided by the control system (for example according to Figure 5 The measurement units 40-1, 40-2, 40-3) transmit multiple values When the step 110 of generating the value G1 of the quantity G is implemented using the measured data Gs, the method 100 according to the present invention may advantageously include a step 103 for generating the measured data Gs, so that the measured data Gs takes the value:
[0115] -When the multiple values When only two values are included, that is, when only two redundant sources deliver measurement data, the multiple values One of the values in ;
[0116] -When the multiple values When at least three values are included, that is, when at least three redundant sources deliver such measurement data, the plurality of values of the median.
[0117] and Figure 4 and Figure 5 Relatedly, Figure 7 , Fig. 7A and Figure 8It is possible to illustrate the different contributions brought about by implementing the invention and the influence of the choice of the value of the correction coefficient Kc on the behavior of the control system according to the invention. Figure 7 and Figure 8 The two figures show two quantities G, in this case the magnitude of the control The pitch δp, roll δr related components, and more specifically, the components of these quantities reflect the Figure 4 The angular velocity controller 35 has an integral action of the PID regulator.
[0118] Figure 7 More accurately, the pitch delta p control related to the pitch delta p generated by the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 is described. Therefore, the corresponding output associated with the pitch δp of the flight controller is shown below:
[0119] - for controller FC-1 (component δp1), presented as a solid curve;
[0120] - for controller FC-2 (component δp2), presented as a dotted curve;
[0121] - For controller FC-3 (component δp3), presented as a dashed curve.
[0122] Said Figure 7 The respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 over time t are shown by three different graphs according to three different values of the correction coefficient Kc, respectively equal to 0, 5% and 1. The upper graph corresponds to the null value of the correction coefficient Kc (Kc=0), i.e. the situation in accordance with the prior art (no correction is applied to the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3). The middle graph corresponds to a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 5% (Kc=0.05), i.e. the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are partially coupled. Finally, the lower graph corresponds to a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 1 (Kc=1), i.e. the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are fully coupled.
[0123] It can be seen that when the value of the correction coefficient Kc is empty (by Figure 7The servo devices (in this case, the PID regulators of the angular velocity controllers 35 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3) are not coupled. The three curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 describing their respective outputs show increased dispersion and very significant fluctuations. On the contrary, the implementation of the present invention induces a significant technical effect of convergence and consistency of the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, such as the three curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 that are almost superimposable to the naked eye. Figure 7 As shown in the middle and lower graphs, as long as the correction factor Kc is greater than 0, excellent instantaneous coupling is exhibited. Very low values (according to Figure 7 The example shown in the middle graph of the example is five percent) leads to very good coupling, marked by the almost perfect superposition of the three curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 (as shown in the partial enlargement of said curves). The same is true for the complete coupling brought about by choosing a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 1. The curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 also perfectly superpose, which is equivalent to very strong coupling and complete correlation, as shown in the partial enlargement of said curves δp1, δp2 and δp3. If both the middle graph and the lower graph, which are associated with values of the correction coefficient Kc of 5% and 1 respectively, are considered more precisely, it can be seen that, beyond the alignment and coupling output of the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, the value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 5% maintains high responsiveness (the slopes of the curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 are very steep or vertical at the instant ti, for which the system responds to a setting that is likely to cause a significant transition in the values of the components δp1, δp2 and δp3). However, such responsiveness can be reduced by a higher value of the correction factor Kc (in Figure 7 The slopes of the curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 are not actually quite vertical at the instant ti. However, the superimposed curves δp1, δp2 and δp3 are smoother or more stable than those represented on the middle graph and not to mention those represented by the upper graph (without correction). Therefore, the choice of the value of the correction coefficient Kc allows to determine the compromise sought between responsiveness and stability. Fig. 7A This effect on responsiveness and stability is shown in a more accurate manner. Fig. 7A Three curves are superimposed which describe the values of the individual components associated with the pitch δp1 generated by the flight controller FC-1 respectively for three different values of the correction coefficient Kc:
[0124] - The value for Kc is null (K=0), which is presented as a solid curve;
[0125] - for a value of Kc equal to 5% (K=0.05), presented as a dotted curve;
[0126] - For a value of Kc equal to 1 (K=1), presented as a dashed curve.
[0127] exist Fig. 7A The corresponding tangents tg0, tg1 and tg2 of the three curves of the component δp1 (for Kc=0, Kc=0.05 and Kc=1, respectively) are shown above at the instant ti at which the system responds to a setting that is likely to cause a significant change in the value of the aforementioned δp1. The tangent tg0 (almost vertical and shown in solid line) shows a very high responsiveness of the control system when there is no coupling (Kc=0) in the case of the corresponding outputs of the redundant flight controllers FC-2 and FC-3. The tangent tg1 (shown in dots) still shows a very high responsiveness of the control system when the coupling is weak (Kc=0.05). In fact, the low value of the angle α1 determined by the tangents tg0 and tg1 indicates a slight reduction in responsiveness. The tangent tg2 (shown in dotted line) shows the responsiveness of the control system when the coupling is strong (Kc=1). The angle α2 determined by the tangents tg0 and tg2 is much larger than the angle α1, indicating a lower responsiveness.
[0128] However, the Fig. 7A shows the contribution of compensating for the possible reduction in responsiveness with stability. Therefore, the average amplitude of the change of the component δp1 is very large (this is due to Figure 7 As shown in segment A0 on the right), it is equivalent to instability, and once the present invention brings about coupling between the respective outputs of the redundant flight controllers, even if the coupling is minimal (value of the correction coefficient Kc = 0.05), such average amplitude represented by segment A1 becomes very low or even almost empty, as shown by segment A2 showing the average amplitude for strong coupling (Kc = 1).
[0129] When the invention is implemented for coupling the respective additional outputs of the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 (in this case reflecting the control related to the roll δr The component of the integral action of the PID regulator of the angular velocity controller 35) is related to the component of the integral action of the PID regulator of the angular velocity controller 35, by looking at Figure 8 It can be seen that significant and similar contributions are brought about by the present invention.
[0130] In fact, the Figure 8 The outputs related to the pitch control delta r generated by the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are described. These outputs are shown below:
[0131] - for controller FC-1 (component δr1), presented as a solid curve;
[0132] - for controller FC-2 (component δr2), presented as a dotted curve;
[0133] - For controller FC-3 (component δr3), represented by a dashed curve.
[0134] like Figure 7 In that way, Figure 8 By means of the Figure 8 The three different graphs in the upper, middle and lower parts show the corresponding outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 over time t according to three different values of the correction coefficient Kc, which are respectively equal to 0, 5% and 1. The upper graph corresponds to the null value of the correction coefficient Kc, that is, the situation in accordance with the prior art (no correction is applied to the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3). The middle graph corresponds to a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 5% (Kc=0.05), that is, the corresponding outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are partially coupled. Finally, the lower graph corresponds to a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 1 (Kc=1), that is, the respective outputs of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3 are fully coupled.
[0135] It can be seen that when the value of the correction coefficient Kc is empty (by Figure 8 The servo means (in this case the PID regulators of the angular velocity controllers 35 of the flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3) are not coupled. The three curves δr1, δr2 and δr3 describing their respective outputs show increased dispersion and very significant fluctuations. On the contrary, the implementation of the invention shows instant coupling as long as the correction coefficient Kc is greater than 0. Very low values (according to Figure 8 The example shown in the middle graph of 5% (5% for example) leads to an almost perfect superposition of the three curves δr1, δr2 and δr3. The same is true for the complete coupling brought about by choosing a value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 1. The curves δr1, δr2 and δr3 perfectly superimpose, which is equivalent to a very strong coupling and a high correlation. If both the middle graph and the lower graph, which are associated with values of 5% and 1 of the correction coefficient Kc respectively, are considered more precisely, it can be seen that, in addition to the consistent output of the three flight controllers FC-1, FC-2 and FC-3, the value of the correction coefficient Kc equal to 5% maintains a high responsiveness. In fact, the slopes of the curves δr1, δr2 and δr3 are very steep or vertical at the moment tj, for which the system responds to a setting that is likely to cause a significant transition in the values of the components δr1, δr2 and δr3. However, if one considers the higher values of the correction coefficient Kc (in the case of Figure 8In the case of the lower graph, the value is equal to 1) induced by the values of the components δr1, δr2 and δr3, then such a slope is less vertical. On the contrary, the superimposed curves are smoother or more stable than those represented in the middle graph. Therefore, the Figure 8 It has been demonstrated that the choice of the value of the correction coefficient Kc allows determining the compromise between responsiveness and stability sought by the system.
[0136] The invention has been described by means of different configurations of actuators, more precisely of control systems of thrust groups of aircraft. The invention is not limited to such a single example of an actuator control system. It more generally relates to any control system comprising one or more multiple redundant servo devices, applied to land, sea, air or space vehicles, home automation, industry, said actuators allowing to move these systems or to adjust the temperature, air pressure or even the brightness prevailing inside these systems.
Claims
1. A method (100) implemented by a processing unit of a plurality of redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) of a system (30) for manipulating an actuator (TS), each redundant servo device generating a value of a same quantity (G) based on a same setting (Gsp) and same measurement data (Gs), said value generated being used by said system (30) for manipulating the actuator (TS), said redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) also communicating with one another so that each redundant servo device has access to the most recent value of said quantity (G) generated by said redundant servo device, said method being characterized in that iteratively comprises (SP): - a step (110) of generating a current value (Gl) of the quantity (G) based on the setting (Gsp) and the measurement data (Gs); - reading the latest value of a quantity (G) produced by said redundant servo device and constructing a set of current values of said quantity (G) Step (120); - Make sure it is obtained from the collection a step (130) of determining a reference value (Gr) of said quantity (G); - a step (140) of calculating the difference (Ge) between the current value (Gl) of the quantity produced (G) and said reference value (Gr); - a step (150) of correcting the current value (Gl) and generating a corrected current value (Gl') of the quantity (G), comprising subtracting from said current value (Gl) a correction (Gc) obtained by a calculation according to which said difference (Ge) is multiplied by a correction coefficient (Kc) of said current value (Gl).
2. The method (100) according to the preceding claim, wherein: - the system comprises at least three redundant servo devices capable of generating the value of the quantity (G); - The step (130) of determining the reference value (Gr) comprises selecting the set of current values of the quantity (G) The median of the values.
3. The method (100) of claim 1, wherein: - the system comprises only two redundant servo devices capable of generating the value of the quantity (G); - The step (130) of determining the reference value (Gr) comprises selecting the set of current values of the quantity (G) One of the values of .
4. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the value of the correction coefficient (Kc) is predetermined.
5. The method (100) according to claim 1 , comprising a step (151) of recording a current value (G1) or a corrected value (G1′) of the quantity (G) in a data memory (M) of the first servo device for building a history of values of a determined quantity, and a step (101) of generating, before the correction step (150), a value of a correction coefficient (Kc) according to the variability of the values obtained from the history and the iteration frequency (SP) of the step (120) of reading the latest value of the quantity (G) generated by the redundant servo device.
6. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein calculating the value of the correction (Gc) is arranged such that the value of the correction (Gc) does not exceed a predetermined limit value (L) in absolute terms.
7. A method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein each redundant servo device comprises a PID corrector, said corrector PID delivering three components of an output signal describing respectively a proportional action, an integral action and a derivative action, and wherein the quantity (G) comprises a component describing said integral action of said PID corrector.
8. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, wherein the control system (30) comprises a plurality of setpoints arranged to be transmitted jointly. When the redundant source is a redundant source, the method comprises a step (102) for generating the setting (Gsp), so that the setting (Gsp) takes the value: - When the control system (30) includes only two redundant sources, the multiple values One of the values in ; - the control system includes at least three redundant sources, the multiple values of the median.
9. The method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims, when the operating system (30) comprises a plurality of values arranged to jointly transmit the measurement data When a redundant source is used, the method comprises a step (103) for generating the measurement data (Gs), so that the measurement data (Gs) takes the value: - When the control system includes only two redundant sources, the multiple values One of the values in ; - When the control system includes at least three redundant sources, the multiple values of the median.
10. A servo device of a manipulation system (30) for an actuator (TS), said system (30) comprising a plurality of redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3), each redundant servo device being based on the same setting (Gsp, ) and the same measurement data (Gs1, Gs2, Gs3) produce the value (Δ1, Δ2, Δ3) of the same quantity, the redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) communicating with each other (B) so that each servo device reads and accesses the latest value (Δ1, Δ2, Δ3) of the quantity produced by each redundant servo device, the servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) being arranged to implement the method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims.
11. A manipulation system (30) for an actuator (TS) comprising a plurality of redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) according to the preceding claim, wherein the manipulation is ( Δ) is generated based on multiple values (Δ1, Δ2, Δ3) of the quantity jointly generated by the redundant servo devices.
12. System (30) according to the preceding claim, wherein the manipulation (Δ) is generated based on: - when the multiple values of the quantity generated by the redundant servo means ( Δ1, Δ2, Δ3) include only two values, the multiple values ( One of the values Δ1, Δ2, Δ3); - when the multiple values of the quantity generated by the redundant servo means ( Δ1, Δ2, Δ3) include at least three values, the multiple values ( The median of Δ1, Δ2, and Δ3).
13. A vehicle (10) carrying a load consisting of a driver, passengers and / or merchandise or cargo, comprising one or more actuators in the form of at least one thrust group (TSa, TSb, TSc, TSd) for moving the vehicle (10), the manipulation of the vehicle (10) being Δ) is generated by an actuation system (30) according to the preceding claim.
14. Vehicle (10) according to the preceding claim, comprising an aircraft (10).
15. A computer program product comprising one or more program instructions that can be interpreted by a processing unit (Ut) of one of a plurality of redundant servo devices (FC-1, FC-2, FC-3) of a manipulation system (30) of an actuator (TS), said program instructions being loadable into a non-volatile memory (M) of the servo device and being designed such that execution of said instructions by said processing unit (Ut) results in the implementation of a method (100) according to any one of claims 1 to 9.
16. A computer-readable storage medium comprising instructions of the computer program product according to the preceding claim.
