Delayed fracture evaluation method, manufacturing method and procedure for compression molded articles
By using CAE analysis and delayed fracture tests, the delayed fracture characteristics of the sheared end face of the post-trimmed high-strength steel plate were quantitatively evaluated. The shearing processing conditions were designed and optimized, which solved the problem of delayed fracture of the sheared end face in three-dimensional parts and improved the safety and reliability of automotive parts.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202480090690.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2024-04-11
- Filing Date
- 2024-12-05
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies cannot effectively evaluate the delayed fracture characteristics of the post-trimmed shear end face formed after shearing of high-strength steel plates, especially in three-dimensional parts, where the shear end face may suffer from quality deterioration and a high risk of delayed fracture due to unexpected stress.
By analyzing the stress and strain changes before and after shearing using computer-aided engineering (CAE) and combining them with delayed fracture tests, the delayed fracture characteristics of the sheared end face are quantitatively evaluated. Shearing devices and processing conditions to suppress delayed fracture are designed, including methods such as laser cutting, changing shearing conditions, and introducing plastic strain.
It enables accurate evaluation and prediction of delayed fracture of the sheared end face of the post-trimmed section, improves the delayed fracture resistance of automotive parts, reduces the risk of delayed fracture, and ensures the safety of high-strength steel plates in automotive parts.
Smart Images

Figure CN123076773A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention relates to a method for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of the sheared end face of a sheet metal for pressure forming. Furthermore, this invention relates to a method for manufacturing a pressure-formed article using this evaluation technique. This invention is suitable, for example, for manufacturing automotive parts by pressure forming a sheet metal formed from high-strength steel sheet and further shearing the pressure-formed sheet. Background Technology
[0002] Currently, automotive manufacturing demands lightweighting to improve fuel economy and collision safety. Furthermore, to simultaneously achieve lightweighting of the vehicle body and occupant protection in a collision, high-strength steel is used in the body. In recent years, in particular, high-strength steel with a tensile strength of 980 MPa or higher has been applied to vehicle bodies. One of the challenges of using high-strength steel in vehicle bodies is delayed fracture. Especially for steel with a tensile strength of 980 MPa or higher, delayed fracture occurring from the end face after shearing has become an important issue. It should be noted that the end face formed by shearing is also referred to as the sheared end face. Therefore, in this specification, the end face formed by shearing will also be referred to as the sheared end face.
[0003] Here, it is known that significant tensile stress remains at the sheared end face. Therefore, regarding the sheared end face, there is a possibility of delayed fracture occurring in the stamped product. As a method for evaluating delayed fracture at the sheared end face, for example, there is the method described in Patent Document 1.
[0004] Patent document 1 describes a method for evaluating the hydrogen embrittlement of steel by applying tensile stress while hydrogen charging a thin steel sheet.
[0005] Existing technical documents Patent documents Patent Document 1: Japanese Patent No. 5196926 Patent Document 2: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2014-70927 Patent Document 3: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2023-72460 Patent Document 4: WO2023 / 037961 Patent Document 5: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2023-173358 Summary of the Invention
[0006] The problem that the invention aims to solve Here, the sheared end face of the automotive part has two types: a front trimmed portion and a rear trimmed portion. The front trimmed portion is the part that is sheared before pressure forming. The rear trimmed portion is the part that is sheared after pressure forming. It should be noted that in this specification, the shearing process used to form the rear trimmed portion is also referred to as rear trimming.
[0007] The post-trimmed portion is generated, for example, during shearing for shaping the outline of a product. This shearing process for the post-trimmed portion occurs, for example, when excess flange portion is needed during press forming as a sheet holding portion for deep drawing. The post-trimmed portion is formed by shearing along the outline after press forming. Furthermore, the post-trimmed portion is also generated during processing such as punching after press forming.
[0008] The post-trimming process after pressure forming targets a part that has already acquired its shape through pressure forming. During this trimming, the part needs to be constrained by a constraint condition that holds it along its shape. Furthermore, during post-trimming, the constrained part needs to undergo a shearing process. That is, the shearing process for the post-trimming portion requires cutting along the three-dimensional shape of the part. Therefore, the quality of the sheared end face may deteriorate compared to the pre-trimmed portion. In addition, during post-trimming, unexpected stress may sometimes be applied to the sheared end face.
[0009] Based on the above insights, the inventors discovered that the risk of delayed fracture at the shear end face in a post-trimmed portion may be higher than that in a previous trimmed portion. For example, a typical three-dimensional post-trimmed portion could be a shoulder R portion 1C that includes a hat shape (see...). Figure 2 An example of a portion formed by shearing the entire longitudinal wall portion 1B (see [reference]). Figure 2 ).
[0010] However, the method in Patent Document 1 does not specifically address the evaluation of the sheared end face of such post-trimmed portions. That is, the method in Patent Document 1 cannot perform a delayed fracture evaluation that takes into account the aforementioned risks. These risks include, for example, the deterioration of the quality of the sheared end face during the shearing process used to form the three-dimensional post-trimmed portion.
[0011] This invention has been made with regard to the above-mentioned aspects. One object of this invention is, for example, to provide a method for quantitatively evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of a sheared end face formed by shearing in a three-dimensional post-trimmed portion. Another object of this invention is to provide a pressure-molded article with excellent delayed fracture resistance.
[0012] Methods for solving problems For practical press-molded articles, the evaluation of delayed fracture related to the post-trimmed portion as described above is very important. This is especially true for automotive parts, where the manufacturing process makes the evaluation of delayed fracture related to the post-trimmed portion crucial. Based on this, the inventors recognized the need to provide a method for quantitatively evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of the shear end face of a three-dimensional post-trimmed portion.
[0013] Furthermore, the inventors focused on the changes in stress distribution and strain around the sheared end face before and after shearing of parts manufactured by pressure forming. The present invention was completed with this in mind. Here, the stress distribution before shearing refers to the stress distribution around the sheared end face just before the shearing process. "Just before shearing" refers to the period from when the metal plate is held and constrained for shearing until the upper cutting tool contacts the material. The stress distribution after shearing refers to the stress distribution around the sheared end face after the part has been sheared and springed back.
[0014] To address this issue, one aspect of the present invention is a delayed fracture evaluation method, which evaluates the delayed fracture characteristics of a sheared end face of a press-formed metal sheet. The sheared end face used for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics is generated by shearing a metal sheet after press-forming it into a pre-defined target part shape. The stress or strain at or around the sheared end face under two conditions are determined: the state of the metal sheet before processing, where the press-formed metal sheet is constrained by the material constraints during the shearing process; and the state of the metal sheet after processing, where the shearing is completed and the constraints are released. The delayed fracture characteristics are evaluated based on the changes in stress or strain at or around the sheared end face under these two conditions.
[0015] Invention Effects According to the present invention, the changes in stress or strain around the sheared end face before and after shearing of the post-trimmed portion of a component manufactured by pressure molding are considered. Therefore, the present invention allows for the evaluation / prediction of the risk of delayed fracture at the post-trimmed portion. Consequently, the present invention provides pressure-molded articles with excellent delayed fracture resistance characteristics that incorporate these evaluation and prediction methods. Therefore, the present invention can improve delayed fracture characteristics when high-strength steel sheets are used in various automotive components such as panel parts and structural / frame parts. Attached Figure Description
[0016] [ Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the example of trimming after the example.
[0017] [ Figure 2 This is a perspective view showing an example of post-trimming the longitudinal wall portion of a cap-shaped pressurized component.
[0018] [ Figure 3 The following diagrams illustrate an example of the stress state during deformation in a shearing process. (a) is a diagram along the thickness of the plate, and (b) is a diagram along the width of the plate.
[0019] [ Figure 4 The following diagrams illustrate an example of the stress state after separation following a shearing process. (a) is a diagram along the thickness direction of the plate, and (b) is a diagram along the width direction of the plate.
[0020] [ Figure 5 This diagram illustrates the shearing process under conditions where external tensile stress is applied in the width direction of the plate.
[0021] [ Figure 6 This diagram illustrates the shearing process performed without external stress applied in the width direction of the plate.
[0022] [ Figure 7 This diagram illustrates the shearing process under conditions where external compressive stress is applied in the width direction of the plate.
[0023] [ Figure 8 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the situation where, after shearing, the sheared end face springs back and the stress in the area around the sheared end face is released, while the portion outside the sheared end face elastically deforms. Specifically, it is a schematic diagram showing the situation where the sheared end face undergoes additional deformation accompanying the elastic deformation around the sheared end face.
[0024] [ Figure 9 This is a diagram illustrating an example of the processing flow of an evaluation method based on an embodiment of the present invention.
[0025] [ Figure 10 This is a diagram illustrating an example of the processing flow for determining the threshold.
[0026] [ Figure 11 [A diagram illustrating an example of the processing flow of a program based on an embodiment of the present invention.]
[0027] [ Figure 12 This is a diagram showing the positions of each component A to I on the sheared end face of the post-trimming section.
[0028] [ Figure 13 This is a top view showing the location where delayed fracture occurred without intervention in the embodiment.
[0029] [ Figure 14 This is a top view showing a portion of the measures to suppress delayed fracture.
[0030] [ Figure 15 This is a diagram showing the amount of movement of the edge at the end of the flange after trimming and springback.
[0031] [ Figure 16 This diagram illustrates the post-trimming line (dotted line) for normal dimensions and the post-trimming line (solid line) in the corrected mold. Detailed Implementation
[0032] The embodiments of the present invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0033] (The concept of this invention) To clarify the principles of this invention, the generation mechanism of tensile shear residual stress is explained below. Tensile shear residual stress increases the risk of delayed fracture at the shear end face.
[0034] Here, Figure 1 The image shows an example of applying post-trimming to a metal sheet 1 (part 1) produced by pressure molding. Figure 1 In the attached drawing, reference numeral 1a represents the portion formed into a three-dimensional shape through pressure molding. Reference numeral TL indicates the cutting line in the post-trimming process. Furthermore, as a typical example of a post-trimmed portion, one could cite... Figure 2 This part is formed by trimming the entire longitudinal wall portion 1B. The longitudinal wall portion 1B includes the shoulder R portion 1C of the hat-shaped component. Figure 2 In the figure, reference numeral 1A shows the top plate portion in the shape of a cap. Reference numeral 1D shows the flange portion. Additionally, reference numeral 3 shows the scrap side of the metal sheet before trimming, which is the result of the shearing process. Furthermore, reference numeral 2 shows the product side (compression-molded product side) of the metal sheet before trimming, which is the result of the shearing process.
[0035] Figure 3 A schematic diagram illustrating the stress state during shearing. Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram illustrating the stress state of material after separation during a shearing process. Reference numeral 10 shows a die (lower die) with a lower cutter 10a. Reference numeral 11 shows a punch (upper die) with an upper cutter 11a.
[0036] like Figure 3 As shown, during the shearing process, the sheet metal clamped between the upper cutter 11a and the lower cutter 10a experiences extreme shear and tensile deformation with strains exceeding tens of percent in the region between the upper and lower cutters 10a and 11a. Furthermore, as... Figure 4 As shown, at the point when the material deformation reaches its limit, a crack occurs at the contact point with either or both of the upper cutter 11a and the lower cutter 10a, and the material is separated. Just before the material is separated, the sheared end face is subjected to extreme plastic deformation and tensile stress in the thickness direction. Furthermore, springback occurs after the material is separated. However, after separation, the portion of the material further inward than the undeformed end face is constrained. Therefore, the aforementioned tensile stress cannot be alleviated due to incomplete springback. As a result, a state of elastic tensile deformation stress in the thickness direction remains at the post-trimming portion. Figure 3 (a) Furthermore, the periphery of the shear end face becomes a state of plane strain with constrained deformation in the direction perpendicular to the thickness direction (the depth direction of the paper). Figure 3(b) Therefore, since tensile stress remains in the thickness direction of the plate, tensile stress also remains in the width direction of the plate.
[0037] As mentioned above, the residual stress in shear is caused by extreme deformation with strains exceeding tens of percent. Therefore, strain exists around the sheared end face before the shearing process begins. The minute strain that generates this elastic stress field has almost no effect. A minute strain is, for example, an elastic strain less than 0.6%.
[0038] At this time, as Figures 5-7 As shown in the schematic diagram, the aforementioned shear end face is generated based on three conditions, for example. These three conditions are: under external tensile stress in the direction of plate width (…). Figure 5 ), stress-free state ( Figure 6 ) and under compressive stress in the end face direction ( Figure 7 Each of the three conditions serves as a constraint. In any of these three conditions, the residual stress at the sheared end face is not significantly different. The stress field around the sheared end face before shearing may be generated during the actual post-trimming shearing process due to the deformation of the metal plate 1 caused by the plate holding 12 and the residual stress caused by forming.
[0039] On the other hand, such as Figure 8 As shown in the schematic diagram, after shearing, springback releases the stress in the region surrounding the sheared end face. Therefore, while the portion outside the sheared end face elastically deforms, the sheared end face undergoes additional deformation along with the elastic deformation around it. Consequently, situations exist where the sheared end face is subjected to tensile or compressive stress. It should be noted that... Figure 8 In the figure, reference numeral 2A indicates the range of residual shear stress. Additionally, reference numeral 2a indicates the shear end face.
[0040] At this time, as Figure 8 (a) In this case, when the stress in the region surrounding the shear end face decreases from tensile to zero, the shear end face 2a undergoes compressive elastic deformation. In this situation, due to the additional compressive stress, the risk of delayed fracture at the shear end face is reduced. On the other hand, as... Figure 8 As shown in (b), if the stress in the region surrounding the shear end face remains unchanged, the shear stress will not change. Additionally, as... Figure 8 As shown in (c), when the stress in the region surrounding the sheared end face increases from compression to zero, the sheared end face 2a undergoes tensile elastic deformation, thus inevitably bearing tensile stress. Therefore, the risk of delayed fracture at the sheared end face increases. Consider the elastic deformation that accompanies the stress release near the sheared end face 2a after shearing. This elastic deformation may occur during the actual post-trimming shearing process, when the metal plate leaves the plate holder 12 and springs back.
[0041] Therefore, for the shear end face 2a, in addition to the inherent tensile residual stress, a further tensile stress is applied, which can then be used as an indicator of the risk of delayed fracture to evaluate delayed fracture with good accuracy. The additional tensile stress is the tensile stress additionally imparted to the shear end face 2a by the elastic deformation of the region surrounding the shear end face 2a before and after shearing.
[0042] Furthermore, when the tensile stress additionally imparted to the shear end face 2a by the elastic deformation of the region surrounding the shear end face 2a before and after shearing reaches a certain value, the risk of delayed fracture can be considered to increase. By taking this into account, it is possible to achieve accurate prediction of delayed fracture at the post-trimming edge.
[0043] The elastic deformation of the region surrounding the sheared end face 2a before and after shearing can be determined using known forming analysis (CAE) on a computer. Specifically, the stress in the region surrounding the sheared end face 2a is calculated before shearing, when the metal plate is constrained by the plate holder 12 and the upper cutter 11a is about to contact the material. Additionally, the stress in the region surrounding the sheared end face 2a is calculated after shearing, when the metal plate leaves the plate holder 12 and springs back. Furthermore, the difference between the two stresses is taken to determine the additional tensile stress. Moreover, not only stress but also strain can be used. That is, the same evaluation can be achieved by considering the difference in strain in the region surrounding the sheared end face 2a before and after shearing, thereby taking into account the additional strain.
[0044] As a post-trimming process for components with actual three-dimensional shapes, examples can be made for, for instance, such as... Figure 2 The hat-shaped component shown is trimmed after cutting. In this case, at the point when the material is constrained by the plate holder 12, compressive deformation and compressive stress occur on the inner side of the shoulder R portion 1C, which is a bent portion, and on a part of the longitudinal wall portion 1B. Then, at the point when the metal plate leaves the plate holder 12 after shearing, it springs back, and the stress is released and reversed into tensile stress. Therefore, the stress change from compression to tension becomes greater. Furthermore, tensile stress is applied to the sheared end face 2a, which can be considered to increase the risk of delayed fracture.
[0045] Based on the principles and viewpoints of this invention, one of its objectives is to evaluate / predict the risk of delayed fracture of the post-trimmed portion of a metal sheet that has been formed into a three-dimensional shape by pressure molding with good accuracy.
[0046] Regarding the amount of additional stress required to delay fracture when applied to the shear end face 2a, the following steps can be taken, for example. First, evaluate how much stress needs to be applied to the trimmed shear end face in a normal plane to delay fracture, for example, as an indicator for limit determination. As a method to obtain this indicator, existing methods can be used, such as delayed fracture tests under stress application conditions like the four-point bending described in Patent Document 2 and the uniaxial tension described in Patent Document 3.
[0047] Furthermore, the inventors discovered that by suppressing the deformation caused by springback after trimming, the application of additional tensile stress can be suppressed. This additional tensile stress is the extra tensile stress on the shear end face 2a caused by the elastic deformation of the region surrounding the shear end face 2a. Specifically, it was found that using the following shearing device to minimize deformation after trimming is effective. This shearing device is designed with reference to the springback shape after trimming, specifically for the metal plate contact surfaces of the upper cutter 11a, the lower cutter 10a, and the plate holder 12.
[0048] By referring to such indicators, for example, the shearing conditions required to suppress delayed fracture can be designed.
[0049] (Evaluation method of this implementation) Next, processing examples based on embodiments of the present invention will be described.
[0050] The evaluation method for this embodiment is as follows: Figure 9 As shown, the process includes a threshold acquisition step S20, a pressure molding analysis step S21, a constraint analysis step S22, a springback analysis step S23, a change acquisition step S24, and an evaluation step S25. The processing of the pressure molding analysis step S21, the constraint analysis step S22, and the springback analysis step S23 is performed using computer-aided molding analysis (CAE).
[0051] <Step S20 for obtaining the threshold> Step S20, which involves obtaining the evaluation threshold value, is the step of obtaining the evaluation index value (judgment threshold). The evaluation index value is used to evaluate how much stress is applied to the shear end face 2a obtained by trimming the surface of the plane to cause delayed fracture. This index value can be obtained using existing methods, such as the four-point bending test described in Patent Document 2 and the uniaxial tension test described in Patent Document 3, under stress application conditions, through delayed fracture tests.
[0052] The threshold determination step S20 is as follows: Figure 10As shown, the test procedure includes a shearing step S20a, an external stress application step S20b, a step of setting the environment in a hydrogen intrusion environment S20c, and a threshold calculation step S20d. The shearing step S20a, the external stress application step S20b, and the step of setting the environment in a hydrogen intrusion environment S20c constitute the test procedure.
[0053] [Cutting step S20a] The shearing step S20a is a step of shearing a flat metal plate to form a test piece with a sheared end face having a cutting line extending on a plane.
[0054] [External stress application step S20b] The external stress application step S20b is a step of applying a pre-set external load stress to the shear end face of the test piece and constraining it under this load state. Regarding the method of stress application, for example, it can be performed by applying tensile stress or bending stress. In this case, from the viewpoint of simplicity, a method based on bending stress application using a fixture is particularly desirable.
[0055] [Step S20c, set up in a hydrogen intrusion environment] Step S20c, which involves placing a test specimen constrained under stress in a pre-defined hydrogen intrusion environment for a pre-defined time, and then evaluating the crack initiation status using the test specimen in this state. The hydrogen intrusion environment and the setting time are preferably set to conditions that allow for a hydrogen intrusion amount equivalent to the estimated hydrogen amount when the material being evaluated is intruded into an actual service environment.
[0056] For example, the test piece is placed in a hydrogen immersion environment by immersing it in a bath containing acidic solutions such as hydrochloric acid or NH4SCN aqueous solution. The concentration of the acid solution and the immersion time are set to conditions that allow the hydrogen immersion of the test piece to be pre-set as an allowable upper limit.
[0057] For each test piece produced in the shearing step S20a, the conditions for applying load stress are changed and the external stress application step S20b and the step S20c set in a hydrogen intrusion environment are repeated.
[0058] [Threshold calculation step S20d] In the evaluation value calculation step, based on the results of the above tests, the ultimate load stress is used as the index value (judgment threshold) for calculation. The ultimate load stress is the ultimate load stress at which delayed fracture of the shear end face of the metal plate will not occur.
[0059] Through the above processing, in step S20 of determining the threshold, the ultimate load stress (ultimate external load stress) that the sheared end face originally possesses without delayed fracture is calculated as an index value (judgment threshold). This index value is defined as the "reference ultimate load stress" for the sheared end face in the subsequent trimming. The "reference ultimate load stress" can vary according to the shearing conditions, such as the shearing angle and the setting of the die gap.
[0060] Regarding the threshold for judgment, a margin can be considered and set as the value obtained by reducing the reference ultimate load stress by a safety margin.
[0061] Furthermore, the criterion can be set to less than half of the yield strength of the material of metal plate 1. With this setting, the criterion can be easily set to a value obtained by reducing the safety margin from the reference ultimate load stress.
[0062] The ultimate external load strain that will not cause delayed fracture can be determined instead of stress, and the determined value can be used as the "reference ultimate load strain". Furthermore, this "reference ultimate load strain" can be used as a (judgment threshold). The same effect can be obtained in this case.
[0063] <Pressure Molding Analysis Step S21> In the pressure forming analysis step S21, the evaluation object (part 1) for pressure forming a metal sheet into the target part shape is analyzed using computer-aided forming analysis. The evaluation object for the target part shape is set as the part before the subsequent trimming.
[0064] The molding analysis is performed based on the actual material and molding conditions during pressure molding. Furthermore, the CAE-based molding analysis method can utilize any previously known molding analysis method.
[0065] <Constraint Analysis Step S22> In constraint analysis step S22, the evaluation object obtained in pressure forming analysis step S21 is analyzed under the constraint conditions of shearing processing. This results in the determination of the stress-strain distribution within the evaluation object. The determined stress-strain distribution is stored as the stress-strain distribution before shearing (before processing). The forming analysis can employ previously known analysis methods.
[0066] The aforementioned constraints are, for example, those applied when cutting with the lower cutter 10a and the upper cutter 11a, or when the evaluation object is constrained by the die 10 and the plate holder 12. Alternatively, conditions can be used to constrain the scrap side using the punch 11 and the second plate holder.
[0067] The constraints can be the same as those used in the actual post-trimming shearing process.
[0068] <Post-rebound analysis step S23> In the post-springback analysis step S23, following the analysis under constraint conditions in the constraint analysis step S22, an analysis of cutting using the lower tool 10a and the upper tool 11a is performed. Furthermore, an analysis is performed to exclude the area removed by the subsequent trimming. Then, a springback analysis is performed on the remaining area (the area that becomes the finished product). In the post-springback analysis step S23, after the springback analysis, a forming analysis of the stress-strain around the trimmed portion is performed and stored.
[0069] <Step S24 for obtaining the change> The stress-strain values around the post-trimmed portion before processing, obtained in constraint analysis step S22, are compared with the stress-strain values around the post-trimmed portion after processing, obtained in springback analysis step S23. Through this comparison, the change in stress or strain at each detection location is calculated. In this embodiment, the difference is calculated as the change. Furthermore, when the difference in stress or strain is positive (tensile side), the risk of delayed fracture is considered high. For locations with positive differences, the stress or strain of that difference is recorded as "delayed fracture driving stress" or "delayed fracture driving strain." The recorded values are used as indicators of the risk of delayed fracture.
[0070] <Evaluation Step S25> In evaluation step S25, if the "delayed fracture driving stress" or "delayed fracture driving strain" obtained in step S24 exceeds the "reference ultimate load stress" or "reference ultimate load strain", it is determined that the risk of delayed fracture is high.
[0071] However, in longitudinal sections of components, the end face characteristics often deteriorate compared to planar cuts. Therefore, when determining the risk of delayed fracture based on the reference limit, it is desirable to set a margin (safety margin) on the side with lower stress or strain.
[0072] Here, the pressure forming analysis step S21, constraint analysis step S22, and springback analysis step S23 are executed as a series of forming analyses using a computer. Then, the stress-strain distribution of the post-trimmed portion (shear end face 2a) and its surrounding area is stored. It should be noted that the area surrounding the post-trimmed portion is defined as a finite element within 3 mm from the cutting line (shear end face 2a) of the post-trimmed portion, which is expected to be close to the cutting line.
[0073] In the above description, the example of post-trimming is a shearing process used to trim the shape of a component after press forming. However, the applicable post-trimming parts are not limited to this. This invention can also be widely applied to post-trimming parts such as punching trimming parts after press forming, and outer diameter trimming parts with gently sloping contours.
[0074] (Manufacturing method of pressure-molded articles) <Manufacturing Method 1> The metal sheet is press-formed into a component of the target shape, and then post-trimming is performed to produce the finished product (press-formed product).
[0075] Before actual manufacturing, the sheared end face 2a of the post-trimmed portion formed by post-trimming is evaluated for delayed fracture using the evaluation method of this embodiment described above. Furthermore, the portions of the trimmed portion obtained after pressure molding and shearing are identified as having a risk of delayed fracture. For these identified portions, the above-mentioned article is manufactured using a manufacturing method that incorporates a suppression treatment (suppression method) to suppress delayed fracture.
[0076] Next, examples of suppression methods will be explained. The suppression methods shown below can be used in conjunction with these methods.
[0077] <First Suppression Method> The first suppression method involves, during post-trimming, performing cutting using a method with a lower risk of delayed fracture on the area and its surroundings that are assessed as having a risk of delayed fracture, instead of shearing. Examples of cutting methods with a lower risk of delayed fracture include laser cutting.
[0078] This enables the manufacture of compression-molded articles that reduce the risk of delayed fracture at the post-trimming edge. The resulting compression-molded articles can be used, for example, as automotive parts.
[0079] Furthermore, in the manufacturing method using this first suppression method, only a portion of the post-trimmed edge is laser-cut. Therefore, compared to forming the entire end face of the post-trimmed edge by laser cutting, the cutting length of laser cutting is shorter. Thus, the manufacturing method using the first suppression method allows for more efficient production of parts.
[0080] <Second Suppression Method> The second suppression method is, for example, to change the shearing conditions to shearing conditions that are more effective in suppressing delayed fracture, for the area and its surroundings that are assessed as having a risk of delayed fracture.
[0081] This is a method for modifying the shearing conditions after trimming in locations deemed to have a high risk of delayed fracture. For example, the shape after trimming and springback in the forming analysis, or the springback shape of the trimmed portion of the actual press-molded article, is determined. Then, based on this shape, the metal plate contact surfaces of the punch 11, the die 10, and the plate holder 12 during the shearing process are made as close as possible to the determined shape. In this case, the "delayed fracture driving stress" or "delayed fracture driving strain" is reduced. As a result, the risk of delayed fracture can be reduced. It should be noted that the punch 11 has an upper cutter 11a. The die 10 has a lower cutter 10a.
[0082] <Third Suppression Method> The third suppression method is a process of applying plastic strain to locations deemed to have a high risk of delayed fracture after post-trimming. The plastic strain application process is performed, for example, by applying plastic strain in such a way that the line length of the shear face 2a in the shear direction changes by more than 1% relative to a target line length. The shear face 2a to which the aforementioned plastic strain is applied is the shear face containing the region of the shear face 2a to which the plastic strain is applied.
[0083] Here, Patent Document 4 discloses a method and its principle for mitigating residual stress on the shear end face 2a and suppressing delayed fracture by applying a plastic forming-based pressure process to the shear end face 2a. The aforementioned plastic strain can be introduced using this known method.
[0084] Furthermore, even if the aforementioned residual shear stress is superimposed on by the springback stress after trimming, plastic deformation will be introduced after trimming. As a result, the stress around the shear end face 2a can be alleviated.
[0085] When performing such a process that introduces plastic strain, the trimming line TL of the post-trimmed edge changes compared to the normal dimensions of the part. At this point, plastic strain can be introduced into the post-trimmed edge line TL during the restrike after trimming, as long as the design ensures that the final part shape closely approximates the normal dimensions of the part.
[0086] Therefore, regarding the amount of additional stress required to induce delayed fracture on the post-trimmed sheared end face 2a, as mentioned above, an indicator can be set as the amount of stress required to induce delayed fracture on a normal plane after trimming and shearing. This indicator can be used as a reference to design the shearing device required to suppress delayed fracture.
[0087] Furthermore, when plastic strain is introduced after trimming, the stress on the shear end face 2a is reduced, thereby increasing the ultimate load stress at which delayed fracture occurs from the shear end face 2a. Therefore, for example, as in Patent Document 5, a delayed fracture test under the stress application conditions described in Patent Documents 2 and 3 can be performed on the shear end face 2a to which strain has been introduced. In this case, it can serve as an indicator of the ultimate load stress at which delayed fracture occurs when plastic strain is introduced into the trimmed portion.
[0088] Furthermore, in this example, for locations deemed to have a high risk of delayed fracture, the post-trimming line TL is selectively altered compared to the normal dimensions of the part. This introduces plastic strain into the post-trimming line TL during the final pressing process. It is desirable to alter the length of the post-trimming line TL by more than 1% relative to the normal dimensions of the part in regions containing locations with a high risk of delayed fracture, in order to introduce sufficient plastic strain, i.e., more than 0.2%.
[0089] (program) An example of the procedure used in the evaluation method described above is shown.
[0090] The stress or strain limit value for delayed fracture at the shear end face 2a of the flat metal plate being evaluated is determined in advance using conventional methods. Furthermore, a judgment threshold, which serves as a reference value in the program, is determined from this limit value. The determined judgment threshold is stored in advance in the storage unit. For example, the judgment threshold is set as a value obtained by subtracting a safety margin from the aforementioned determined limit value.
[0091] This program is used to evaluate the delayed fracture characteristics of the sheared end face 2a of a pressure-formed metal sheet. Specifically, this program can be used in a method for manufacturing pressure-formed articles. The method for manufacturing pressure-formed articles involves pressing a metal sheet made of a known material into a pre-defined target part shape, and then performing a shearing process to manufacture the pressure-formed article. This program is used to evaluate the delayed fracture characteristics of the sheared end face 2a formed by the aforementioned shearing process as a post-trimming step.
[0092] As described in the evaluation method above, the evaluation method in this embodiment is performed. That is, a molding analysis of pressure molding is performed. Then, a molding analysis of shearing and subsequent springback is performed. The difference between the position values obtained in the molding analysis is calculated. The calculated difference is compared with a threshold stored in the storage unit. The above molding analysis processing can be performed using CAE (Computer-Aided Engineering) based on conventionally known computers, taking into account the conditions of the metal sheet, the conditions of pressure molding, and the conditions of shearing. In addition, the processing of calculating the difference between the position values obtained in the molding analysis and the processing of comparing the calculated difference with a threshold stored in the storage unit can also be implemented by using computer processing.
[0093] Thus, the evaluation method of this embodiment can be implemented as a computer for executing a computer.
[0094] Next, an example of the program will be provided.
[0095] The procedure of this embodiment is as follows: Figure 11 As shown, the process includes steps S30 to S34, which are executed in this order.
[0096] Step S30 is a step of performing a forming analysis using a computer to press and form a metal sheet into a pre-defined target part shape.
[0097] In step S31, for the component with the target component shape analyzed in step S30, an analysis of the state under which the component is constrained by the constraints used for the aforementioned shearing process is performed using computer-aided forming analysis. Therefore, in step S31, the stress or strain distribution at or around the shearing end face 2a is calculated.
[0098] Step S32 involves determining the springback state of the metal sheet after shearing, using computer-aided forming analysis, for the component with the target part shape analyzed in Step S1. Furthermore, the stress or strain distribution at or around the sheared end face 2a is calculated.
[0099] Step 4, S33, refers to the distribution of stresses or strains obtained in steps 2, S31, and 3, S32. Step 4, S33, involves determining the difference in stress or strain at or around the shear end face 2a being evaluated. This step addresses two states: the constraints applied during the shearing process, and the state of the processed metal plate after the shearing process has been completed and the constraints on the metal plate have been released.
[0100] Step 5, S34, is a step to determine whether there is a delayed break based on the difference value obtained in step 4, S33. For example, the difference value at each location is compared with a threshold value stored in the storage unit to determine the location of the difference value above the threshold value.
[0101] With such a program, it is possible to automatically predict the presence or absence of the risk of delayed fracture in the post-trimming section, as well as the location of the risk of delayed fracture.
[0102] It should be noted that hazard assessment information can be displayed. For example, (difference / threshold) can be displayed as the degree of hazard.
[0103] (other) This document may also be structured as follows.
[0104] (1) Disclosure 1 is a delayed fracture evaluation method, which is a delayed fracture characteristic evaluation method for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of the shear end face of a metal sheet used for pressure forming, wherein, The shear facet described below is used as the shear facet for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics. This shear facet is generated by shearing a metal sheet after it has been press-formed into a pre-defined target part shape. Determine the stress or strain on the sheared end face or its surrounding area under the following two conditions: the state of the metal sheet before processing, where the material constraints during the shearing process constrain the press-formed metal sheet; and the state of the metal sheet after processing, where the shearing process has been completed and the constraints have been released. The aforementioned delayed fracture characteristics are evaluated based on the changes in stress or strain at or around the shear end face under the two determined conditions.
[0105] The above changes are calculated based on the difference between the stress or strain obtained under, for example, the two states mentioned above.
[0106] (2) The stress or strain in the above two states is calculated by using computer forming analysis.
[0107] (3) If the difference between the stress or strain exceeds the set judgment threshold, it is evaluated that there is a possibility of delayed fracture.
[0108] (4) The disclosure 4 determines the limit value of stress or strain that does not cause delayed fracture by applying tensile stress to the shear end face formed by shearing a flat metal plate, and sets the above-mentioned judgment threshold based on the determined limit value.
[0109] (5) The value obtained by subtracting the safety margin from the calculated limit value is used as the above-mentioned judgment threshold.
[0110] (6) The above-mentioned determination threshold is set to less than half of the yield strength of the material of the metal plate.
[0111] (7) Disclosure 7 is a method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which is a method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article by pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target component shape and then performing a shearing process on the component. Using the delayed fracture evaluation method described in this disclosure, the difference at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference exceeds a set judgment threshold, the constraint condition in the shearing process that makes the difference at the position where the difference exceeds the judgment threshold fall within the judgment threshold is determined. The above shearing process is performed based on the obtained constraints.
[0112] (8) Disclosure 8 is a method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which is a method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article by pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target component shape and then performing a shearing process on the component. Using the delayed fracture evaluation method described in this disclosure, the difference at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference exceeds a set judgment threshold, the position of the shear end face where the difference exceeds the judgment threshold is subjected to plastic strain treatment after the shearing process.
[0113] (9) The above-mentioned plastic strain is introduced by means of the following: plastic strain is introduced in such a way that the line length of the shear direction of the shear end face, which includes the shear end face whose difference exceeds the determination threshold, changes by more than 1% relative to the line length set as the target.
[0114] (10) Disclosed is a method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which involves pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target component shape, and then performing a shearing process on the component to manufacture the pressure-molded article, wherein... Using the delayed fracture evaluation method described in this disclosure, the difference at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference exceeds a set judgment threshold, the shearing process is replaced by laser cutting at the position of the shear end face where the difference exceeds the judgment threshold.
[0115] (11) Disclosure 11 is a program that evaluates the delayed fracture characteristics of the shear end face formed by the shearing process in a method for manufacturing a press-molded article by applying a shearing process to a component after press-molding a metal sheet into a pre-set target component shape, wherein the program is used to cause a computer to perform the following steps: Step 1 involves performing analysis of the metal sheet being press-formed into a pre-defined target part shape using computer-aided forming analysis. Step 2 involves analyzing the state of the component with the target part shape analyzed in Step 1 using computer-aided forming analysis to constrain the component under the aforementioned shearing conditions, and calculating the stress or strain distribution at or around the shearing end face; and Step 3: For the component with the target component shape analyzed in Step 1, the state after shearing and springback is analyzed by using computer forming analysis, and the distribution of stress or strain at the sheared end face or its periphery is calculated.
[0116] (12) The program of disclosure 11, wherein the program is used to cause a computer to further perform the following steps: Step 4: Based on the stress or strain distributions obtained in Steps 2 and 3, calculate the difference in stress or strain at the shear end face or its periphery between two states: the state constrained by the constraints used for the shearing process described above, and the state after shearing and springback following the shearing process described above; and Step 5: Determine whether there is delayed fracture based on the difference calculated in step 4.
[0117] [Example] Next, embodiments based on this implementation method will be described.
[0118] In this example, we will use a test material consisting of 1.4 mm thick steel with a strength of 1470 MPa as an example to illustrate the evaluation of the metal plate. The yield strength of this test material is approximately 1200 MPa.
[0119] It should be noted that the present invention is not limited to the material or thickness of such test material. The present invention can be applied to metal plates formed from metallic materials that exhibit delayed fracture at the shear end face 2a. Examples of such metallic materials include high-strength materials with a tensile strength of 980 MPa or higher. Furthermore, the present invention is particularly preferred for steel plates with a tensile strength of 980 MPa or higher.
[0120] Additionally, in this example, the test material is pressurized and molded into... Figure 2 The following is an example of a case where a pressure-molded product is made by cutting and processing the longitudinal wall portion 1B, which includes the shoulder portion 1C as a curved portion, after the hat shape shown.
[0121] (Regarding the actual manufacture of pressure-molded articles) First, the metal plate formed from the test material is pressurized and molded using a mold to produce... Figure 2The hat-shaped component shown. The hat-shaped component has a top plate portion 1A and a shoulder R portion 1C (ridge portion) that is connected to a curved portion as a longitudinal wall portion 1B.
[0122] Next, for the parts formed by pressure molding as described above, according to... Figure 2 The trimming line TL shown is subjected to shearing.
[0123] The shearing process is performed under constraints imposed by a mold 10 with a lower cutter 10a and a plate holder 12. Specifically, under these constraints, the shearing process is performed by moving a punch 11 with an upper cutter 11a relative to the lower cutter 10a. At this time, the gap between the upper cutter 11a and the lower cutter 10a during shearing is set to 10% of the plate thickness. The shapes of the cutting edges of the upper cutter 11a and the lower cutter 10a are designed to be the same as the shape of the trimming line TL, so that the cutters contact the various parts of the part being sheared as simultaneously as possible. That is, the contact surfaces of the mold and the plate holder 12 opposite to the workpiece are designed to follow the shape of the workpiece as closely as possible.
[0124] The product manufactured in this way is demolded from the shearing mold, thereby causing springback in the product.
[0125] Next, the sheared end face 2a of the post-trimming portion of the springbacked product, Figure 12 The nine locations shown, A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, and I, are designated as evaluation locations for delayed fracture.
[0126] The spring-rebound product is a cap-shaped compression molded article after trimming. This cap-shaped compression molded article after trimming is immersed in hydrochloric acid at pH 2 for 96 hours. Furthermore, for each evaluation location of delayed fracture (A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I), it is investigated whether delayed fracture occurred before and after immersion. Here, the criterion for delayed fracture is the presence of a visually perceptible crack with a length exceeding half the plate thickness.
[0127] Table 1 shows the evaluation locations for delayed fracture and whether delayed fracture has occurred. In Table 1, the evaluation locations for delayed fracture are recorded as the product locations.
[0128] [Table 1] (Calculation of reference stress) In this example, the reference stress (reference ultimate load stress) used as the criterion threshold is calculated based on a known method. The calculation method is shown below.
[0129] First, a test piece with a straight, extended sheared end face is produced from the flat test material (metal plate) before pressure molding. The shearing conditions are the same as those for subsequent trimming.
[0130] That is, the shearing process is performed by moving a punch with an upper cutter relative to the lower cutter while the test piece is constrained by a mold and plate with a lower cutter holding the molded part in a constrained state. Furthermore, the gap between the upper and lower cutters during shearing is set to 10% of the plate thickness. This is the same shearing condition as described above. It should be noted that the test material is flat, therefore the contact surface between the mold and plate and the product is also flat.
[0131] Next, the test piece was constrained by applying a load stress to its sheared end face using a four-point bending method as described in Patent Document 2, with the flat end face being sheared. An immersion test was then performed on the test piece. Multiple test pieces were used, with the load stress varying in 100 MPa increments. The occurrence of delayed fracture after immersion was investigated, and the ultimate load stress at which delayed fracture did not occur was determined. The determined ultimate load stress was confirmed to be 700 MPa. This confirmed load stress was defined as the index value (reference stress) for delayed fracture.
[0132] However, if the characteristics of the longitudinally cut sheared end face 2a are expected to deteriorate compared to the flat cut, the reference stress for delaying fracture can be set to a value with reduced margin (safety margin). For example, a margin of 200 MPa can be set, and the reference stress can be set to 500 MPa. This is because deviations in shearing conditions and forming states during actual mass production processes are taken into account.
[0133] Furthermore, the yield strength of the ultra-high-strength steel used in this study is approximately 1200 MPa. Therefore, if the residual stress is reduced to below 600 MPa (less than the aforementioned benchmark stress of 700 MPa), delayed fracture is suppressed. Thus, one criterion for stress reduction required to suppress delayed fracture is a value below half the yield strength. In this example, below half the yield strength is below 600 MPa.
[0134] (Evaluation of the post-repaired edges) Based on the material conditions of the test material, the aforementioned actual pressure molding and post-trimming shearing conditions, a molding analysis of the test material under pressure molding and post-trimming was performed using computer-aided molding analysis (CAE). Known methods can be employed for CAE-based molding analysis.
[0135] As an evaluation based on this CAE, among the seven integration points set for the shell element, the integration points at the surface (top plate side of the component), the central surface, and the interior are used as stress evaluation points. The evaluation points correspond to the evaluation locations for delayed fracture.
[0136] First, the test material was molded under the same pressure conditions as actual pressure molding. Figure 2 The molding analysis of the molded article shown. Next, regarding... Figure 2 The molded part shown is analyzed under the constraint of the plate holding force applied during shearing. That is, the load stress caused by the constraint of applying shearing to the part is analyzed. Furthermore, for each part position A to I, the stress in the state before the upper tool 11a contacts the part during shearing is calculated based on the integration points at the above three locations. The state before contacting the part refers to the state before processing under the constraint of the shearing constraint conditions.
[0137] Next, an analysis is performed on the shearing process of the scrap-side elements at the post-trimming division position, which are constrained by plate holding 12. Then, a springback analysis is performed on the remaining area (the area on the product side). Furthermore, after springback, for each position of part A to I, the calculation is performed again based on the integration points at the above three locations.
[0138] Then, the difference between the stress under the aforementioned constraints before shearing and the stress after springback is calculated based on each integration point at each location. The stress under the aforementioned constraints before shearing refers to the stress when the plate is held at point 12. This calculated difference is used as the delayed fracture driving stress of the post-trimmed shear end face 2a. At this point, it is confirmed that the same evaluation can be achieved by using the changes in strain such as the first principal strain and equivalent strain as indicators of driving force instead of this driving stress.
[0139] Table 2 shows the results.
[0140] [Table 2] Table 2 shows the values obtained from the integration points at three points: the surface (top plate side), the central surface, and the inside, for each of the component positions A to I. The values shown are the stress during plate holding, a comparison with the stress after trimming and springback, and the delayed fracture driving stress as the difference. The results of CAE-based determination of whether delayed fracture has occurred are also shown. However, for simplicity, the calculation results for each position are shown here based on the integration point with the highest delayed fracture driving stress among the three integration transfers.
[0141] Table 2 reveals the following: In components such as flange portion 1D at position A and top plate portion 1A at position I, the shape changes less before and after plate retention. Therefore, the driving stress at the integration point is relatively small in these locations. On the other hand, in shoulder portion R 1C at positions C and G, the delayed fracture driving force is very large due to the effect of bending. Furthermore, in the longitudinal wall portion 1B at position E, and the area around the R-stop points at positions B, D, F, and H, there is reverse bending deformation that flattens the curved shape. Therefore, these locations have a moderate level of driving stress.
[0142] Furthermore, a comparison is made with 700 MPa to determine whether delayed fracture has occurred. 700 MPa is the reference stress (judgment threshold) for delayed fracture as calculated above. This judgment is made when any integral point within the plate thickness exceeds the reference stress, indicating that delayed fracture has occurred. The judgment results are also shown in Table 2. However, if the characteristics of the longitudinally cut shear end face 2a are expected to deteriorate compared to the planar cut, a margin (safety margin) can be set for the reference stress for delayed fracture, such as setting the reference stress to, for example, 500 MPa.
[0143] A comparison of Tables 1 and 2 shows that the location of delayed fracture predicted by CAE (forming analysis) is consistent with the location of delayed fracture in the actual delayed fracture test. Therefore, it is demonstrated that the evaluation based on this invention can be used to evaluate the risk of delayed fracture, etc., of the shear end face 2a of the post-trimmed portion.
[0144] (1) Response to delayed fracture in the post-forming trimming section) Next, the test material is pressurized and molded into... Figure 13 After the shape shown, press Figure 13 The post-trimming line TL, indicated by a dashed line, is used for cutting. Furthermore, an evaluation test to assess delayed fracture is performed on the formed post-trimmed portion. The evaluation method is the one shown in the above embodiment. Through this evaluation test, in... Figure 13 The risk of delayed fracture was predicted at the location indicated by arrow 40, specifically at the R-section of the three-dimensional structure. Furthermore, an evaluation of delayed fracture was conducted based on an actual product, and it was found that delayed fracture occurred at the same location.
[0145] Therefore, as Figure 14 As shown, only the region 50 containing the location where the risk of delayed fracture was predicted (determined) was trimmed using laser cutting, which carries a low risk of delayed fracture. The actual product obtained by laser cutting was evaluated for delayed fracture, and the results confirmed that delayed fracture at the locations where the risk of delayed fracture was predicted (determined) was suppressed.
[0146] That is, it can be seen that by processing with a minimum laser trimming length, press-molded articles such as automotive parts with suppressed delayed fracture can be obtained. Thus, it can be seen that by using the method based on the present invention, automotive parts with effectively suppressed delayed fracture can be manufactured.
[0147] (2) Post-forming edge trimming to address delayed fracture In this example, a shearing device was designed using the springback shape after trimming as a reference, comprising the metal plate contact surface of the punch 11 with the upper cutter 11a, the metal plate contact surface of the die 10 with the lower cutter 10a, and the metal plate contact surface of the plate holder 12. This approach aimed to minimize deformation after trimming.
[0148] Figure 15 This diagram illustrates a comparison of the shapes of the trimming line TL before and after springback, and the definition of the shape mold during springback in the embodiment. The inventors focused on the edge of the flange portion of the metal plate with the largest springback distance. Furthermore, referring to the shape during springback, the mold after the measure was designed to reduce the flange movement amount ME of the metal plate edge portion. Specifically, without the measure, the flange movement amount ME of the edge portion is 13.6 mm. In contrast, as a measure, a mold including an upper cutter 11a, a lower cutter 10a, and a plate holder 12 was designed with flange movement amounts ME of 9 mm, 6 mm, 3 mm, 1 mm, and 0.2 mm, respectively.
[0149] Table 3 shows the presence or absence of delayed fracture driving force when the flange movement ME at the edge of the metal plate changes for the location where delayed fracture has already occurred, and the determination of the occurrence of delayed fracture on CAE when the reference stress is set to 700 MPa.
[0150] In this mold, the flange movement ME at the edge of the metal plate is equal to the maximum distance among the distances between the metal plate contact surfaces of the upper cutter 11a, the lower cutter 10a, and the plate holder 12, relative to the upper and lower surface shapes of each metal plate. Regarding the movement of 0.2 mm, the aim is to minimize the flange movement ME at the edge of the metal plate within the dimensional tolerance.
[0151] [Table 3] Then, molds corresponding to the movement amount ME of each flange are made, and test pieces including the post-trimmed portion are used for delayed fracture tests. Table 4 shows whether delayed fracture occurs at this time.
[0152] [Table 4] Table 4 shows the following: When the flange movement ME is 9.0 mm or less, the effect of suppressing delayed fracture is partially confirmed. On the other hand, when the flange movement ME is 3.0 mm or less, delayed fracture is completely suppressed, and the risk of delayed fracture of the shear end face 2a of the post-trimmed portion is reduced.
[0153] In addition, the execution of the above Figure 13 When manufacturing products using the same pressure-molded shape and post-trimming, the solution in example 2 was applied.
[0154] Specifically, the object is a metal sheet that has been sheared and is in a spring-back state after being held in place for 12 seconds. Furthermore, a delayed fracture measure is applied to the shearing device during the subsequent trimming process, ensuring that the surface shape of any of the subsequent metal sheet contact surfaces is consistent within ±3 mm relative to the upper and lower surfaces of the metal sheet. The subsequent metal sheet contact surfaces refer to the metal sheet contact surface of the punch 11 with the upper cutter 11a, the metal sheet contact surface of the die 10 with the lower cutter 10a, and the metal sheet contact surface of the sheet holder 12. In this case, it is possible to manufacture automotive parts with suppressed delayed fracture and excellent resistance to delayed fracture.
[0155] (3. Response to delayed fracture in the post-forming trimming) Furthermore, the inventors addressed the dangerous locations shown in Table 2, such as those that had already experienced delayed fracture. Figure 16 As shown in the diagram, post-trimming is performed using a shearing device that changes the post-trimming line TL to be at least 1% shorter than the normal part size. Therefore, precision pressing is performed using a die adjusted to induce plastic deformation while approaching the normal size during precision pressing after post-trimming, in order to impart at least 1% deformation. In this die, the shapes of the upper and lower dies in the forming process before post-trimming are also changed to match the post-trimming line TL. Furthermore, when precision pressing is performed after post-trimming to achieve the normal size, a allowance is provided in the die to ensure that the formed part is at the normal size.
[0156] Table 5 shows the results of the delayed fracture determination when the plastic strain is introduced during fine pressing after trimming at the location where delayed fracture occurred, and compared with the reference stress of 1400 MPa in the case of residual first principal stress and plastic strain.
[0157] Specifically, Table 5 shows the amount of plastic strain introduced into component locations B, C, F, G, and H, which are considered to be at risk of delayed fracture, during fine pressing after trimming. Furthermore, Table 5 shows the results of the delayed fracture determination compared to a reference stress of 1400 MPa in the presence of residual first principal stress and plastic strain. These results are obtained through CAE calculations. Due to the presence of plastic strain, the residual shear stress and the additional external tensile stress introduced by springback after trimming are mitigated. Therefore, the occurrence of delayed fracture can be determined by comparing the reference stress in the presence of residual first principal stress and plastic strain. In this CAE-based study, delayed fracture was determined not to have occurred.
[0158] [Table 5] Next, a mold corresponding to Table 6 is made, and a test piece containing the end face obtained by precision pressing the post-trimmed portion is used for a delayed fracture test. Table 4 shows whether delayed fracture occurs at this time.
[0159] [Table 6] As shown in Table 6, the locations where delayed fracture occurred without intervention were prevented from recurring after applying this treatment (3). As described above, an example was given of predicting the location of delayed fracture in the post-trimmed section based on stress changes during springback and selecting precise pressure to suppress delayed fracture.
[0160] It should be noted that when the trimming line TL is 0.5% shorter than the normal size of the part, the aforementioned delayed fracture suppression effect is not observed. This can be attributed to the fact that with a deformation of approximately 0.5%, only elastic deformation occurs at the shear end face 2a, thus failing to fully utilize the stress mitigation effect brought about by the required plastic deformation.
[0161] In addition, the execution of the above Figure 13 When manufacturing products using the same pressure-molded shape and post-trimming, the method of solution 3 in this example was attempted.
[0162] Specifically, the study investigated the application of the aforementioned modification of the rear trimming line TL relative to the normal size to the shear risk assessment area of the rear trimming section, and the implementation of delayed fracture measures based on plastic strain introduced by precision pressing. This study revealed that delayed fracture occurs near the R portion of the longitudinal wall portion 1B of the rear trimming section. On the other hand, with the implementation of measures, delayed fracture is suppressed, enabling the production of automotive parts with excellent resistance to delayed fracture. It should be noted that without such measures, delayed fracture occurs near the shoulder R portion 1C of the longitudinal wall portion 1B of the rear trimming section.
[0163] The entire contents of Japanese Patent Application No. 2024-064089 (filed on April 11, 2024), which claims priority to this application, are incorporated herein by reference and constitute a part of this disclosure. While a limited number of embodiments have been described with reference to them, the scope of the invention is not limited to these embodiments, and variations of the embodiments based on the above disclosure will be apparent to those skilled in the art.
[0164] Explanation of reference numerals in the attached figures 1 Metal plate 10 Molds 10a Lower Tool 11 Punch 11a Upper cutting tool 12 plates hold Flange movement at the edge of ME S20 Threshold Acquisition Steps S20a Cutting Steps S20b External Stress Application Steps S20c Steps for setting up a hydrogen intrusion environment S20d Threshold Calculation Steps S21 Compression Molding Analysis Steps S22 Constraint Analysis Steps S23 Post-rebound analysis steps Steps for obtaining the change in S24 S25 Evaluation Steps S30 Step 1 S31 Step 2 S32 Step 3 S33 Step 4 S34 Step 5 The trimming line (cutting line) after TL trimming.
Claims
1. A delayed fracture evaluation method, which is a delayed fracture characteristic evaluation method for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of the shear end face of a metal sheet used for pressure forming, wherein, The shear facet described below is used as the shear facet for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics. This shear facet is generated by shearing a metal sheet after it has been press-formed into a pre-defined target part shape. Determine the stress or strain on the sheared end face or its surrounding area under the following two conditions for evaluation: the state of the metal plate before processing, where the material constraints during the shearing process constrain the press-formed metal plate; and the state of the metal plate after processing, where the shearing process has completed and the constraints have been released. The delayed fracture characteristics are evaluated based on the changes in stress or strain at or around the shear end face under the two determined conditions.
2. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 1, wherein, The stress or strain in the two states is calculated using computer-aided forming analysis.
3. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 1 or claim 2, wherein, The delayed fracture characteristics are evaluated based on the difference between the stress or strain obtained in the two states.
4. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 3, wherein, If the difference between the stress or strain exceeds a set threshold, it is evaluated as a possibility of delayed fracture.
5. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 4, wherein, A delayed fracture test is conducted by applying tensile stress to the sheared end face formed by shearing a flat metal plate, and the limit value of stress or strain at which delayed fracture does not occur is determined, and the judgment threshold is set based on the determined limit value.
6. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 5, wherein, The threshold value is obtained by subtracting the safety margin from the calculated limit value.
7. The delayed fracture evaluation method as described in claim 4, wherein, The determination threshold is set to less than half of the yield strength of the material of the metal plate.
8. A method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which involves pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target shape, and then performing a shearing process on the component to manufacture the pressure-molded article, wherein... Using the delayed fracture evaluation method according to any one of claims 3 to 7, the difference value at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference value exceeds a set judgment threshold, the constraint condition in the shearing process where the difference value at the position where the difference value exceeds the judgment threshold becomes within the judgment threshold is determined. The shearing process is performed based on the obtained constraints.
9. A method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which involves pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target shape, and then performing a shearing process on the component to manufacture the pressure-molded article, wherein... Using the delayed fracture evaluation method according to any one of claims 3 to 7, the difference at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference exceeds a set judgment threshold, the position of the shear end face where the difference exceeds the judgment threshold is subjected to plastic strain treatment after the shearing process.
10. The method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article as described in claim 9, wherein, The process of importing the plastic strain is performed as follows: plastic strain is imported in such a way that the line length in the shear direction of the shear end face, which includes the region containing the shear end face whose difference exceeds the determination threshold, changes by more than 1% relative to the line length set as the target.
11. A method for manufacturing a pressure-molded article, which involves pressing a metal sheet into a component of a target part shape, and then performing a shearing process on the component to manufacture the pressure-molded article, wherein... Using the delayed fracture evaluation method according to any one of claims 3 to 7, the difference at the shear end face generated during the shearing process is determined. If the difference exceeds a set judgment threshold, the shearing process is replaced by laser cutting at the position of the shear end face where the difference exceeds the judgment threshold.
12. A procedure for evaluating the delayed fracture characteristics of a sheared end face formed by a shearing process in a method for manufacturing a press-molded article by pressing a metal sheet into a pre-defined target part shape and then performing a shearing process on it, wherein... The program is used to cause the computer to perform the following steps: Step 1 involves performing analysis of the metal sheet being press-formed into a pre-defined target part shape using computer-aided forming analysis. Step 2: For the component with the target component shape analyzed in Step 1, an analysis of the state of the component constrained by the constraints used for the shearing process is performed by using computer forming analysis, and the distribution of stress or strain at the shearing end face or its periphery is calculated. and Step 3: For the component with the target component shape analyzed in Step 1, an analysis of the state after shearing and springback is performed by using computer forming analysis, and the distribution of stress or strain at the sheared end face or its periphery is calculated.
13. The procedure of claim 12, wherein, The program is used to enable the computer to perform the following steps: Step 4: Based on the stress or strain distribution obtained in Steps 2 and 3, calculate the difference in stress or strain at the shear end face or its periphery between two states: the state constrained by the constraints used for the shearing process, and the state after shearing and springback. Step 5: Determine whether there is delayed fracture based on the difference calculated in step 4.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Jidoshano shotsukuboshi
JP1976096926A
Test piece and method for delayed fracture characteristic evaluation of ultra-high strength surface treated steel plate
JP2014070927A
Jig for assessing delayed fracture, method for assessing delayed fracture in sheared end surface, and test piece
JP2023072460A
Method for evaluating delayed fracture characteristics of sheared end surface and program
JP2023173358A
Mobile body control method and mobile body control system
JP2024064089A
