A closed-loop adjustment process for springback of a cover component

By performing full-surface compensation on the drawing and trimming processes of the cover parts, and using the first-order surface difference pass rate as the closed-loop judgment index, the problem of low surface difference pass rate in the stamping springback compensation of the cover parts was solved, achieving efficient surface difference control and reducing the number of rectification rounds.

CN123102869APending Publication Date: 2026-11-17ANHUI JIANGHUAI ASSET BODYWORK EQUIP
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202611568243.4
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2026-10-12
Publication Date
2026-11-17

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In the existing technology, the springback compensation method for stamping cover parts has the problems of low first-order surface defect pass rate, many rounds of debugging and rectification, and long cycle.

Method used

A closed-loop adjustment process for springback of the cover parts is adopted. By performing full-surface springback compensation in the drawing process and full-surface conformity compensation in the trimming process, and combining the first-order surface difference pass rate as the closed-loop judgment index, the mold is iteratively adjusted to meet the surface difference requirements.

Benefits of technology

This improved the first-order surface defect pass rate of the cover parts, reduced the number of rectification rounds and debugging cycles, and ensured the stability and accuracy of surface defect control.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure FT_1
    Figure FT_1
  • Figure FT_2
    Figure FT_2
  • Figure FT_3
    Figure FT_3
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

This invention provides a closed-loop adjustment process for the springback of automotive body panels, belonging to the field of automotive body panel stamping technology. The process includes: obtaining the free springback measurement results of the body panel under multiple stamping processes; based on the measurement results, performing full-surface springback compensation on the die for the drawing process and full-surface conformity compensation on the die for the trimming process following the drawing process; performing a trial stamping with the compensated die, placing the trial stamped part on a fixture to check the surface difference; calculating the initial surface difference pass rate, and when the pass rate is lower than a preset threshold, rectifying the dies for the relevant processes and repeating the above steps until the pass rate reaches the preset threshold. This application, through multi-process collaborative compensation combining pre-process full-surface compensation and post-process full-surface conformity compensation, can improve the initial surface difference pass rate of body panels and reduce the number of rectification rounds.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] This invention belongs to the field of automotive body panel stamping technology, specifically relating to a closed-loop adjustment process for body panel springback. Background Technology

[0002] Automotive body panels (such as hood inner panels and tailgate inner panels) are important components of the vehicle's exterior covering. They are typically formed from sheet metal through multiple stamping processes, including drawing, trimming, and shaping. The forming quality of body panels directly affects the overall appearance quality of the vehicle and the precision of subsequent welding and assembly. Among these factors, the deviation between the formed part's surface and the designed surface (i.e., surface difference) is a crucial indicator for measuring the forming quality of body panels.

[0003] During the stamping process, the sheet metal is subjected to complex stress states during drawing, bending, and other processes. After unloading, the elastic deformation partially recovers, causing springback deviation between the formed part and the die surface. Since cover parts are typically large, thin sheet metal parts with relatively low overall rigidity, this springback phenomenon is particularly pronounced. Springback causes the cover part's surface to deviate from the design surface, resulting in surface differences. When these differences exceed tolerances, they affect the part's appearance quality and subsequent welding and assembly. In severe cases, they can lead to rework or even scrapping, increasing manufacturing costs.

[0004] To control surface defects, springback compensation is required during the mold debugging stage. The basic idea of ​​springback compensation is to pre-calculate the mold surface in the opposite direction to the springback direction based on the springback distribution of the formed part, so that the formed part can approach the designed surface after springback. The accuracy of the compensation setting directly determines whether the surface defect of the formed part can meet the requirements.

[0005] Existing compensation methods typically only compensate for springback across the entire die surface during the drawing process, or only for localized compensation of defective areas, while subsequent processes (such as trimming and shaping) do not undergo conformity compensation. Since cover parts are formed through multiple processes, each process generates springback. Compensating only for preceding processes while neglecting conformity compensation for subsequent processes prevents the cumulative springback from being completely offset, resulting in a low initial surface defect pass rate for cover parts. In such cases, multiple rounds of process adjustments are often required to meet the surface defect requirements, leading to long debugging cycles and high costs. Summary of the Invention

[0006] This invention provides a closed-loop debugging process for the springback of a cover part, which aims to solve the problems of low first-order surface defect pass rate, numerous debugging and rectification rounds, and long cycle in the existing technology of cover part stamping springback compensation method.

[0007] To achieve the above objectives, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows: a closed-loop debugging process for springback of a cover part is provided, comprising: Step 1: obtaining the free springback measurement results of the cover part under multiple stamping processes, wherein the multiple stamping processes are the stamping processes that the cover part passes through sequentially during the forming process, and performing free springback measurement on the formed part of each stamping process, wherein the free springback measurement is performed in a state without external force constraint after the formed part is unloaded, and obtaining the springback amount distribution of the formed part relative to the design surface of each process, and using the springback amount distribution as the basis for springback compensation of the mold of each process; Step 2: based on the free springback measurement results, performing full-surface springback compensation on the mold of the drawing process in the multiple stamping processes, and performing full-surface conformal compensation on the mold of the trimming process located after the drawing process in the multiple stamping processes, wherein the compensation direction of the full-surface springback compensation and the full-surface conformal compensation is opposite to the springback direction of the formed part of the corresponding process. Step 3: The die surfaces of the drawing process and the trimming process are adapted to the state of the part after springback. Step 4: The cover part is test-stamped according to the compensated dies of each process. The test part is placed on the fixture, and the deviation between the surface of the test part and the surface of the fixture is measured under clamping condition. The surface difference is detected, and the fixture measurement result is used as the basis for calculating the first-order surface difference pass rate. Step 5: The first-order surface difference pass rate of the test part is calculated. When the first-order surface difference pass rate is lower than the preset threshold, the dies of the relevant processes are rectified. The free springback measurement results are obtained again according to the rectified dies, and the springback compensation scheme of each process is re-determined. The above measurement, compensation, test stamping and detection steps are repeated so that the compensation amount of each process gradually converges during the debugging process until the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold. When the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold, the surface difference of the cover part is judged to be qualified and the debugging ends.

[0008] In the above technical solution, by performing full-surface springback compensation on the drawing process and full-surface conformity compensation on the subsequent trimming process, the mold surfaces of the preceding and subsequent processes are adapted to the state of the part after springback, thereby controlling springback sequentially during the forming process. At the same time, the first-order surface difference pass rate is used as a quantitative indicator for closed-loop judgment. When the pass rate does not meet the standard, the relevant processes are rectified and iterated again, forming a closed loop between measurement, compensation, trial punching, inspection and rectification, thereby making the surface difference stably converge to the required range with fewer rectification rounds.

[0009] Compared with existing technologies, the technical contribution of this application lies in the following: Existing technologies typically only perform full-surface springback compensation on the die during the drawing process, or only perform local compensation on the defective areas. They do not perform full-surface conformity compensation on the die during subsequent processes such as trimming, nor do they use the first-order surface defect pass rate as a quantitative indicator for closed-loop judgment. Therefore, it is difficult to offset the cumulative springback generated by the forming of the cover part through multiple processes, resulting in a low first-order surface defect pass rate and a large number of rectification rounds. This application combines full-surface springback compensation in the drawing process with full-surface conformity compensation in the trimming process, so that the compensation of the preceding and subsequent processes are coordinated and cooperated with each other, making the die surface of each process adapt to the state of the part after springback, thereby controlling the cumulative springback from the entire forming process. At the same time, by using the first-order surface defect pass rate as a closed-loop judgment indicator, the surface defect detection results are directly converted into quantitative criteria for whether to continue rectification, making the rectification direction clear and the iteration process controllable, thereby improving the first-order surface defect pass rate of the cover part and reducing the number of rectification rounds.

[0010] In one possible implementation, the plurality of stamping processes include a drawing process, a trimming process, and a shaping process performed sequentially. The trimming process is located between the drawing process and the shaping process. The drawing process, the trimming process, and the shaping process are sequentially connected to complete the forming of the cover. The remaining processes in the plurality of stamping processes, except for the drawing process, the trimming process, and the shaping process, maintain the product surface and do not perform springback compensation.

[0011] In one possible implementation, the full-surface springback compensation is performed on the surface of the die for the drawing process, and the full-surface springback compensation covers all product surfaces of the die for the drawing process. The compensation amount of the full-surface springback compensation is determined based on the springback amount of the corresponding area in the free springback measurement results. The blanking surface of the die for the drawing process is not subject to springback compensation.

[0012] In one possible implementation, the mold for the trimming process includes a product profile corresponding to the surface of the cover product, a trimming cutting edge for cutting off waste, and a pressure surface; the full profile compensation applies to the entire area of ​​the product profile of the mold for the trimming process, excluding the trimming cutting edge, the pressure surface, and non-product areas; the compensation direction of the full profile compensation is opposite to the springback direction of the formed part in this process, and the maximum compensation amount is 4mm.

[0013] In one possible implementation, the shaping process only performs springback compensation on the flange shaping area of ​​the cover, which is the flange and shaping area with a large springback amount determined according to the free springback measurement results. The remaining surface areas of the shaping process do not undergo springback compensation.

[0014] In one possible implementation, the maximum compensation amount for springback compensation in the flanging and shaping area is 1mm. The compensation amount for springback compensation in the shaping process is determined based on the springback amount of the flanging and shaping area in the free springback state. The springback compensation in the shaping process is coordinated with the full-shape compensation in the trimming process.

[0015] In one possible implementation, the first-order surface difference pass rate is the ratio of the number of qualified test points with deviations within the tolerance range to the total number of test points when the test piece is held in the fixture; the rectification of the mold for the relevant process includes rectifying the mold for the drawing process, and after rectification, re-performing the free springback measurement, mold compensation, test punching and surface difference detection, and re-statistically calculating the first-order surface difference pass rate.

[0016] In one possible implementation, the free springback measurement results are obtained through stamping simulation analysis. The stamping simulation analysis generates springback cloud maps for each stamping process and determines the key areas and compensation amounts for mold springback compensation in each process based on the springback cloud maps. The stamping simulation analysis also verifies the springback compensation amount for each process by comparing the surface data under the free springback state and the fixture clamping state under the same stamping process.

[0017] In one possible implementation, the compensation directions of the full-surface springback compensation and the full-surface conformal compensation are opposite to the springback direction of the part formed in the corresponding process, so that the die surface of the drawing process and the die surface of the trimming process are adapted to the state of the part after springback.

[0018] In one possible implementation, when repeating the above measurement, compensation, trial punching and testing steps in step 4, the free springback measurement results are obtained again based on the rectified mold, and the springback compensation scheme for each process is re-determined accordingly, so that the compensation amount of each process gradually converges with the debugging process until the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold.

[0019] In one possible implementation, the surface difference detection includes placing the test stamp on a fixture, measuring the deviation between the surface of the test stamp and the surface of the fixture while it is clamped, and using the fixture measurement result as the basis for calculating the first-order surface difference pass rate.

[0020] In one possible implementation, in step 1, the free springback of the formed parts in each of the multiple stamping processes is measured, and the surface data under the free springback state and the fixture clamping state under the same stamping process are compared to verify the springback compensation amount of each process.

[0021] In one possible implementation, when repeating the above measurement, compensation, trial punching and testing steps in step 4, the free springback measurement results are obtained again based on the rectified mold, and the springback compensation scheme for each process is re-determined accordingly, so that the compensation amount of each process gradually converges during the debugging process.

[0022] In one possible implementation, the preset threshold is the lower limit of the first-order surface defect pass rate. When the statistical results show that the first-order surface defect pass rate of the test punch reaches the lower limit, the surface defect of the cover part is determined to be qualified and the debugging ends.

[0023] In one possible implementation, the closed-loop debugging process for the cover part springback also includes a data accumulation step: recording and storing the springback measurement results, springback compensation amount of each process and the corresponding first-order surface difference pass rate during each rectification to form springback compensation experience data; when conducting the next springback debugging of the cover part, the initial compensation scheme is determined by referring to the springback compensation experience data, so that the compensation amount setting of each process is continuously optimized as the debugging data is accumulated.

[0024] Compared with the prior art, the solution shown in this application has the following advantages: First, by performing full-surface springback compensation on the drawing process and full-surface conformity compensation on the trimming process, the mold surfaces of the preceding and following processes are adapted to the state of the springbacked part. This allows for sequential control of the springback of the cover part throughout the forming process, thereby improving the first-order surface defect pass rate of the cover part. Second, using the first-order surface defect pass rate as a closed-loop judgment index, the relevant processes are rectified and iterated again when the pass rate is not up to standard. This links springback compensation and surface defect detection, reducing the number of debugging and rectification rounds and shortening the debugging cycle. Third, the forming process only performs springback compensation on the flanging forming area, avoiding unnecessary surface processing and reducing the amount of mold processing. Fourth, by comparing and verifying the surface data under the free springback state and the fixture clamping state of each stamping process, the compensation amount setting of each process can be more accurate, further ensuring the stability of surface defect control. Fifth, by recording and storing springback compensation experience data, and combining it with surface difference offset, process capability index and manufacturing capability index to evaluate the stability of the springback-compensated surface, we can provide a reference for subsequent panel debugging and further improve debugging efficiency.

[0025] Furthermore, in the testing and debugging of the hood inner panel and tailgate inner panel, when using the combined approach of pre-process full-surface compensation and post-process full-surface conformity compensation of this application, the first-process surface defect pass rate of the hood inner panel (ST8 Hood Inner) can reach 93.6%, and the surface defect has met the requirements without surface correction. However, when using the comparative approach of only partially compensating for non-conforming areas and not compensating for conformity in subsequent processes, the first-process surface defect pass rate of the hood inner panel (P2221) is 81.7%, and two rounds of rectification are required for the drawing process. In the testing and debugging of the tailgate inner panel, when using the combined approach of pre-process full-surface compensation and post-process full-surface conformity compensation of this application, the surface defect of the cover part basically meets the requirements, and only local surface correction is required. However, when using the comparative approach of only compensating for pre-processes and not compensating for conformity in subsequent processes, two rounds of rectification are required for the drawing and trimming processes. The above test results show that, through the coordinated cooperation of full-surface springback compensation in the preceding process and full-surface conformity compensation in the subsequent process, and using the first-order surface defect pass rate as a closed-loop judgment index, this application can achieve a high first-order surface defect pass rate and fewer rectification rounds on different cover parts, thus achieving stable technical results. Attached Figure Description

[0026] Figure 1 This is a flowchart of the closed-loop debugging process for the springback of the cover component according to an embodiment of the present invention;

[0027] Figure 2 A schematic diagram of the springback compensation scheme for each stamping process;

[0028] Figure 3 This is a block diagram of the closed-loop iterative logic.

[0029] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the inner panel of the cap;

[0030] Figure 5 A schematic diagram of the reinforcing rib structure of the inner plate of the cover;

[0031] Figure 6 A schematic diagram of the inner panel of the cover (from another perspective);

[0032] Figure 7 A schematic diagram showing the surface difference inspection of a test stamp placed on a fixture;

[0033] Figure 8 This is a schematic diagram of the layout of the inspection points for the inspection tool;

[0034] Explanation of reference numerals in the accompanying drawings: The accompanying drawings in this application are all process flow diagrams, schematic block diagrams and simulation cloud diagrams. Each step in the drawings is indicated by a text box, and the amount of springback is indicated by a color bar in the simulation cloud diagram. No component reference numerals are provided in the accompanying drawings. Detailed Implementation

[0035] To make the technical problems to be solved, the technical solutions, and the beneficial effects of the present invention clearer, the present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are merely illustrative of the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention.

[0036] Please refer to the following: Figures 1 to 3 The closed-loop debugging process for springback of the cover part provided by the present invention is described below. The closed-loop debugging process for springback of the cover part includes the following steps: Step 1: Obtain the free springback measurement results of the cover part under multiple stamping processes; Step 2: Based on the free springback measurement results, perform full-surface springback compensation on the mold of the drawing process in the multiple stamping processes, and perform full-surface conformity compensation on the mold of the trimming process located after the drawing process in the multiple stamping processes; Step 3: Perform trial stamping on the cover part according to the compensated molds of each process, and place the trial stamped part on the inspection fixture for surface difference detection; Step 4: Calculate the first-order surface difference pass rate of the trial stamped part. When the first-order surface difference pass rate is lower than a preset threshold, rectify the mold of the relevant process, and repeat the above measurement, compensation, trial stamping and detection steps until the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold.

[0037] Understandably, in the above steps, steps 1 to 3 are the preparation and execution processes for springback compensation and surface defect detection, while step 4 is the convergence process for closed-loop judgment. By judging the initial surface defect pass rate in step 4, the non-compliant rectification results are fed back to steps 1 to 3, making springback measurement, mold compensation, trial stamping, and surface defect detection form an iterative closed-loop circuit. This closed-loop circuit uses the initial surface defect pass rate as a quantitative indicator, avoiding reliance on repeated trial stamping based on experience. This makes the springback compensation debugging process of the cover part controllable and quantifiable, thus enabling the surface defect to meet requirements with fewer rectification rounds.

[0038] In actual debugging, the first-order surface difference pass rate is calculated as follows: for each surface difference measurement point on the test punch placed on the fixture, it is determined whether each point is within the tolerance range. The ratio of the number of qualified measurement points to the total number of measurement points is used as the first-order surface difference pass rate. The higher this pass rate, the more sufficient the springback compensation and the better the surface difference control. The preset threshold is the lower limit for judging this pass rate, which can be set according to the surface difference requirements of the specific part. When the pass rate reaches this threshold, the surface difference of the cover part is judged to be qualified, and the debugging ends.

[0039] Specifically, in this embodiment, the cover is a hair cap inner plate. The hair cap inner plate is formed by stamping through a drawing process, a trimming process, and a shaping process.

[0040] First, the free springback of the inner cover plate under each stamping process was measured to obtain the springback distribution of each process. The free springback measurement results can be obtained through stamping forming simulation analysis. Specifically, the free springback of the formed parts in the drawing, trimming, and forming processes can be measured separately to obtain the corresponding springback amount for each process, providing a basis for springback compensation of the molds in each process. During the debugging of the inner cover plate, free springback measurement and part placement inspection were also performed on the formed parts in each stamping process. That is, the surface state of the formed part in the free springback state and the surface state of the formed part placed in the fixture and in the clamping state were measured separately, and the two data were compared to verify whether the springback compensation amount setting of each process was accurate.

[0041] Furthermore, in stamping simulation analysis, springback contour maps can visually reflect the magnitude and distribution of springback in various regions of the formed part. The springback contour map uses color or numerical values ​​to indicate the springback amount of each measuring point relative to the design surface, facilitating the rapid location of areas with large springback amounts and determining the key areas and compensation amounts for springback compensation in each process's die. The structure of the inner cover plate can be found in [reference needed]. Figures 4 to 6 For example, springback contour maps can be used to identify flanging and shaping areas with large springback amounts, thereby setting targeted compensation amounts for the corresponding areas in the shaping process.

[0042] Subsequently, based on the free springback measurement results, springback compensation schemes were developed for each process. (See also...) Figure 2 The drawing process performs full-surface compensation on the mold, specifically on the product surface of the mold; the blanking surface is not compensated. The trimming process performs full-surface compensation on the mold, with a maximum compensation of 4mm. In this embodiment, the maximum compensation for the trimming process is 2.8mm. The forming process only compensates the flanging forming area, with a maximum compensation of 1mm. In this embodiment, the maximum compensation for the forming area is 0.7mm. The remaining processes maintain the product surface and do not perform compensation.

[0043] Specifically, the compensation methods for each of the above stamping processes can be summarized as follows: the drawing process performs full-surface compensation (excluding the blank holder surface), the trimming process performs full-surface conformity compensation (maximum compensation amount is 4mm), the forming process only compensates the flanging and forming area (maximum compensation amount is 1mm), and the remaining processes keep the product surface uncompensated. By combining full-surface compensation in the preceding process with full-surface conformity compensation in the subsequent process, the die surface of each process is adapted to the state of the part after springback. Springback is controlled collaboratively throughout the forming process, thereby reducing the impact of cumulative springback on surface differences.

[0044] The inner plate of the cover is test-stamped according to the compensated molds for each process. The test stamps are placed on a fixture for surface difference detection, and the first-order surface difference pass rate of the test stamps is calculated. The calculation rule for the first-order surface difference pass rate is as follows: surface difference measurement points are collected under the fixture clamping state, and each measurement point is determined to be within the tolerance range. The ratio of the number of qualified measurement points to the total number of measurement points is used as the first-order surface difference pass rate. In this embodiment, the preset threshold is set to 90%. When the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold of 90%, the debugging is deemed qualified; when the first-order surface difference pass rate is lower than the preset threshold of 90%, the molds of the relevant processes are rectified. The rectification objects may include the molds of the drawing process. After rectification, springback measurement, mold compensation, test stamping, and surface difference detection are performed again until the first-order surface difference pass rate reaches the preset threshold. See also Figure 3 The above process uses the first-order surface defect pass rate as the judgment index, and connects springback measurement, mold compensation, trial punch inspection and process rectification into a closed loop.

[0045] Exemplary Iterative Scenario: To illustrate the complete iterative process of the closed-loop debugging process of this invention, an exemplary iterative scenario is given: A certain cover part is processed according to the process of this invention. After the first round of trial punching, the initial surface defect pass rate is 82%, which is lower than the preset threshold of 90%, and is therefore deemed substandard. The drawing die is modified, the free springback measurement results are updated, the springback compensation amount for each process is recalculated, and another trial punching and inspection are conducted. After the second round of inspection, the initial surface defect pass rate is 91.2%, reaching the preset threshold of 90%, and the surface defect of the cover part is deemed acceptable, thus the debugging ends. This example illustrates that this invention uses the initial surface defect pass rate as a closed-loop judgment indicator, which can automatically trigger die modification and re-iteration when the pass rate is substandard, until the surface defect converges to the acceptable range.

[0046] Example 1 (Hood Inner Plate, using the closed-loop debugging process of this invention): In this example, the ST8 Hood Inner plate is selected as the test object. The material thickness is 0.7mm, the inspection tolerance is ±0.05mm, and the preset first-order surface difference pass rate threshold is 90%. The closed-loop debugging process of this invention is executed according to the following steps: Step 1, obtain the free springback distribution of the formed parts in each process of drawing, trimming, and shaping through stamping forming simulation analysis, generate springback cloud map, and determine the springback amount in each area; Step 2, perform full-surface springback compensation on the drawing process die (no compensation on the blank holder surface), perform full-surface conformity compensation on the trimming process die, with an actual maximum compensation amount of 2.8mm, and only compensate the flanging shaping area in the shaping process, with an actual maximum compensation amount of 0.7mm. The remaining processes keep the product surface uncompensated; Step 3, complete the trial stamping using the compensated die, and place the trial stamped part on the inspection fixture (see...). Figure 7Step 4 involves measuring the deviation between the test stamp's surface and the fixture's surface while it is clamped, performing surface difference detection. In this embodiment, 219 measuring points were used for the mating surfaces (i.e., the initial surface difference), with 205 passing. The initial surface difference pass rate was 93.6%, exceeding the preset threshold of 90%. Therefore, the debugging was deemed successful, and the debugging process was completed without requiring mold modification. The results of the various tests are shown in Table 1.

[0047] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the thickness of the inner sheet material of the cap is 0.7mm, and the inspection tolerance is ±0.05mm. The dimensions of the test punch are inspected under the clamping state of the fixture, and the inspection data are shown in Table 1 below:

[0048] Table 1. Itemized data for the dimensional inspection of the inner panel of the hatch (ST8 Hood Inner, material thickness 0.7mm, tolerance ±0.05mm)

[0049] Testing items Number of measurement points Number of qualified pass rate mating surfaces (i.e., first-order surface difference) 219 205 93.6% General noodles 103 97 94.2% Cutting edge 73 64 87.67% total 395 366 92.7%

[0050] Comparative Implementation Method 1 (Inner Sheet of Hair Cover, Existing Partial Compensation Scheme): A hair cover inner sheet of the same grade as the embodiment, P2221-8402010P33LL, was selected as the comparative test object. The material is DC56, and the thickness is similar. The same stamping equipment, fixtures, measuring point layout rules, tolerance requirements (±0.05mm), and pass rate calculation rules as Embodiment 1 were used. The difference is that only the defective areas of the drawing process die were partially compensated; full-surface conformity compensation in the trimming process was not performed, and the first-order surface difference pass rate closed-loop iteration criterion was not used. In this comparative scheme, the surface measuring point pass rate was 81.7%, requiring two rounds of rectification in the drawing process to meet the surface difference requirements. The test data are shown in Table 2.

[0051] Furthermore, the dimensional inspection data of the comparative test object (P2221-8402010P33LL inner cover plate) under the clamping state of the fixture are shown in Table 2 below:

[0052] Table 2. Dimensional Inspection Data of Inner Panel Parts (P2221-8402010P33LL, Inspection Date: March 25, 2023)

[0053] Testing items Number of measurement points Number of qualified pass rate benchmark 11 11 100% hole 236 232 98.31% Surface 153 125 81.70% Cutting edge 108 102 94.44% Special features 6 3 50% Summary 497 459 92.35%

[0054] A comparison between Example 1 and Comparative Implementation Method 1 reveals that although the parts used in Example 1 and Comparative Implementation Method 1 are two different models of hood inner panels, both are large thin-plate inner covering parts for automobiles, with similar material thicknesses, comparable structural rigidity, and the same stamping equipment, fixtures, measuring point layout, tolerance requirements, and pass rate calculation rules. The only differences lie in whether full-surface conformity compensation is performed during the trimming process and whether the first-order surface defect pass rate closed-loop criterion is used. Therefore, both methods provide valuable reference for comparing process effects. Under the premise of keeping the above variables consistent, the first-order surface defect pass rate of Example 1 is significantly higher than that of Comparative Implementation Method 1, and no surface modification is required; while Comparative Implementation Method 1 requires two rounds of drawing processes to meet the requirements. This indicates that performing full-surface conformity compensation in the trimming process following the drawing process and using the first-order surface defect pass rate as a closed-loop criterion is key to improving the first-order surface defect pass rate of the covering parts and reducing the number of modification rounds.

[0055] It should be noted that, except for whether to perform full-pattern conformity compensation in subsequent trimming processes and whether to adopt the first-order surface defect pass rate closed-loop judgment index, the process conditions and testing methods in Embodiment 1 and Embodiment 1 are consistent. Under the premise of keeping other variables consistent, the first-order surface defect pass rate of Embodiment 1 is about 12 percentage points higher than that of Embodiment 1, and the requirement of two rounds of rectification is reduced to no rectification at all, significantly reducing the number of rectification rounds. The above comparative data objectively reflects the synergistic effect of full-pattern conformity compensation in the preceding and subsequent processes, as well as the improving effect of the first-order surface defect pass rate closed-loop judgment index on surface defect control.

[0056] In the second embodiment of this application, taking the tailgate inner panel as an example, the tailgate inner panel is stamped and formed sequentially through a drawing process, a trimming process, and a shaping process. The drawing process performs full-surface compensation on the mold, the trimming process performs full-surface conformity compensation on the mold, and subsequent processes such as shaping only compensate for local areas.

[0057] During the debugging process, the formed parts of each stamping process can be subjected to free springback measurement and part placement inspection, and the surface data in the free springback state and the fixture clamping state can be compared. For example, for the trimming process, the conformity data of the molds of each process before and after compensation can be compared to verify the conformity compensation effect of the trimming process; for the shaping process, the surface difference data in the free springback state and the fixture placement state can be compared to determine whether further adjustment of the compensation amount in the shaping area is needed. Through the above comparison, the springback compensation amount of each process can be checked and corrected, further improving the stability of surface difference control.

[0058] Specifically, during the debugging process of the tailgate inner panel, different compensation methods were implemented for each stamping process: the drawing process performed full-surface compensation; the trimming process was tested with both uncompensated and full-surface conformal compensation methods, where the compensated surface matched the state of the springback part; the forming process only compensated the areas with forming allowance; and the free springback process maintained the original surface without compensation. Through the above sequential compensation, the springback amount of each process of the tailgate inner panel was appropriately compensated and controlled.

[0059] Example 2 (Tailgate Inner Panel, using the closed-loop debugging process of this invention): This example uses the tailgate inner panel as the test object. The material is DC56D+Z 50 / 50-FB, and the material thickness, stamping equipment, fixtures, and testing conditions are consistent with Example 1. The preset threshold for the first-order surface difference pass rate is 90%. The closed-loop debugging process of this invention is executed according to steps 1 to 4: Step 1, obtain the free springback distribution of each process through stamping forming simulation analysis; Step 2, perform full-surface compensation on the drawing process die, perform full-surface conformity compensation on the trimming process die, and only compensate local areas in subsequent processes such as shaping; Step 3, use the compensated die for trial stamping, and place the trial stamped part on the fixture (see...). Figure 7 Step 4: Perform surface difference detection; Calculate the first-order surface difference pass rate. In this embodiment, the combined pass rates of multiple sets of measurement data are 91.97%, 93.07%, and 91.89%, respectively, all higher than the preset threshold of 90%, indicating that the debugging is qualified and the surface difference basically meets the requirements. Only minor adjustments to the local surface are needed. The detection data are shown in Table 3.

[0060] Furthermore, the dimensions of the tailgate inner panel test punch were inspected while it was held in the fixture. The inspection data are shown in Table 3 below (including multiple sets of measurement data):

[0061] Table 3. Dimensional Inspection Data of Tailgate Inner Panel Parts (Multiple Measurements)

[0062] Testing items Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 benchmark 81.82% — — hole 96.21% 95.89% 96.05% Surface 89.93% 91.57% 90.16% Cutting edge 83.33% 87.62% 82.86% Summary 91.97% 93.07% 91.89%

[0063] Comparative Implementation Method Two (Tailgate Inner Panel, Subsequent Non-Conformity Compensation Scheme): A tailgate inner panel of the same grade as in Example Two was selected as the comparative test object. The material was DC06, and the material thickness, stamping equipment, fixtures, and testing conditions were consistent with Example Two. The difference was that only the drawing process underwent full-surface compensation; subsequent processes such as trimming and shaping did not undergo conformity compensation, and the first-order surface defect pass rate closed-loop criterion was not used. Under this comparative scheme, two rounds of rectification were required for the drawing and trimming processes.

[0064] A comparison of Example 2 and Comparative Example 2 shows that when the tailgate inner panel adopts a scheme combining pre-process full-surface compensation and post-process full-surface conformity compensation, the surface difference basically meets the requirements, requiring only local surface adjustments. However, the scheme that only compensates for the pre-process and does not perform conformity compensation for the post-process requires two rounds of rectification for the drawing and trimming processes. This difference further confirms the effectiveness of performing full-surface conformity compensation for post-processes such as trimming in improving the surface difference pass rate and reducing the number of rectification rounds.

[0065] Similarly, except for whether to perform full-pattern conformity compensation for subsequent trimming and shaping processes, and whether to adopt the closed-loop criterion of first-order surface defect pass rate, the process conditions and testing methods in Embodiment 2 and Comparative Embodiment 2 are the same. Under the premise of keeping other variables consistent, after adopting the solution of this application, the tailgate inner panel only needs to be modified in a local shape, while the comparative solution requires two rounds of modification in the drawing and trimming processes, and the scope and number of modification rounds are significantly reduced. The above comparison results further show that the solution of this application can achieve consistent and stable technical effects on different types of covering parts.

[0066] Furthermore, in the dimensional inspection of surface defects in cover parts, in addition to statistically analyzing the pass rate of each measuring point, evaluation indicators such as surface defect offset, process capability index (Cpk), and manufacturing capability index (Ppk) can be combined to evaluate the stability of the profile after springback compensation. Among these, surface defect offset reflects the average deviation of the formed part profile from the design profile. The process capability index (Cpk) and manufacturing capability index (Ppk) are well-known process capability evaluation indicators in the stamping field, reflecting the ability of the profile to meet tolerance requirements under inherent process fluctuations and long-term manufacturing fluctuations, respectively. Through these indicators, the surface defect control effect of the springback compensation scheme can be more comprehensively evaluated, providing a reference for whether further rectification is necessary.

[0067] It should be noted that the specific values ​​such as the preset threshold and maximum compensation amount mentioned in this application can be adjusted according to the different materials, structures, material thicknesses, and surface difference requirements of the cover part, and do not constitute a limitation on the scope of protection of this application. The values ​​in the above embodiments are only examples used to illustrate the implementation effect of the process of this application. In actual production and debugging, operators can reasonably determine the compensation range and compensation amount of each process based on the specific structural characteristics and tolerance requirements of the cover part, combined with simulation analysis and the results of the first round of trial punching, and dynamically adjust the debugging process with the help of closed-loop judgment indicators.

[0068] Furthermore, during the implementation of the process described in this application, the springback measurement results of each rectification, the springback compensation amount of each process, and the corresponding first-order surface defect pass rate can be recorded and stored to form springback compensation experience data. When springback debugging is performed on a new cover part, the accumulated springback compensation experience data can be referenced, and the initial compensation scheme can be determined in combination with the material, structure, and material thickness of the new cover part. This reduces the blindness of the initial debugging, allows the compensation amount settings of each process to be continuously optimized with the accumulation of debugging data, and further shortens the debugging cycle.

[0069] As can be seen from the above embodiments and comparative embodiments, the solution of this application, which combines full-surface compensation in the preceding process with full-surface conformity compensation in the subsequent process, and uses the first-order surface defect pass rate as the closed-loop judgment index, has a higher first-order surface defect pass rate and fewer rectification rounds. The data in Tables 1 to 3 above are the test results obtained by dimensional inspection of the test punches under the fixture clamping state in Embodiment 1, Comparative Embodiment 1, and Embodiment 2, respectively, and do not extend to other items, batches, or working conditions not recorded.

[0070] The foregoing has shown and described the basic principles, main features, and advantages of the present invention. Those skilled in the art should understand that the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments. The embodiments and descriptions in the specification are merely illustrative of the principles of the invention. Various changes and modifications can be made to the invention without departing from its spirit and scope, and all such changes and modifications fall within the scope of protection claimed by the present invention. The scope of protection of the present invention is defined by the appended claims and their equivalents.

Claims

1. A process for closed loop tuning of a cover springback, characterized in that, Includes the following steps: Step 1: Obtain the free springback measurement results of the cover part under multiple stamping processes. Perform free springback measurement on the formed parts of each process to obtain the springback distribution relative to the design surface, which serves as the basis for mold springback compensation in each process. Step 2: Based on the free springback measurement results, perform full-surface springback compensation on the product surface of the die for the drawing process, and perform full-surface conformity compensation on the product surface of the die for the trimming process following the drawing process. The directions of both compensations are opposite to the springback direction of the formed part in the corresponding process, so that the die surfaces of the drawing process and the trimming process are adapted to the state of the part after springback in the corresponding process. Step 3: Perform trial punching on the cover part according to the compensated molds of each process, place the trial punch on the fixture, and measure the deviation between the surface of the trial punch and the surface of the fixture under the clamping state to perform surface difference detection; Step 4: Calculate the first-order surface defect pass rate of the trial stamping parts. When it is lower than the preset threshold, rectify the relevant process molds and repeat the above measurement, compensation, trial stamping and inspection steps until the first-order surface defect pass rate reaches the preset threshold.

2. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 1, wherein, The plurality of stamping processes include a drawing process, a trimming process, and a shaping process performed sequentially. The trimming process is located between the drawing process and the shaping process. The drawing process, the trimming process, and the shaping process are sequentially connected to complete the forming of the cover part. Among the plurality of stamping processes, except for the drawing process, the trimming process, and the shaping process, the remaining processes maintain the product surface and do not perform springback compensation.

3. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 1, wherein, The full-surface springback compensation is applied to the surface of the die in the drawing process. The full-surface springback compensation covers all product surfaces of the die in the drawing process. The compensation amount of the full-surface springback compensation is determined based on the springback amount of the corresponding area in the free springback measurement results. The blanking surface of the die in the drawing process is not subject to springback compensation.

4. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 1, wherein, The mold for the trimming process includes a product profile corresponding to the surface of the cover part, a trimming cutting edge for cutting off waste, and a pressure surface; the full profile compensation applies to the entire area of ​​the product profile of the mold for the trimming process, excluding the trimming cutting edge, the pressure surface, and non-product areas; the compensation direction of the full profile compensation is opposite to the springback direction of the formed part in this process, and the maximum compensation amount is 4mm.

5. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 2, wherein, The shaping process only performs springback compensation on the flange shaping area of ​​the cover, which is the flange and shaping area with a large springback amount determined according to the free springback measurement results. The other surface areas of the shaping process do not perform springback compensation.

6. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 5, wherein, The maximum compensation amount for springback compensation in the flanging and shaping area is 1mm. The compensation amount for springback compensation in the shaping process is determined based on the springback amount of the flanging and shaping area in the free springback state. The springback compensation in the shaping process is coordinated with the full-shape compensation in the trimming process.

7. The cover springback closed-loop tuning process of claim 1, wherein, The first-order surface difference pass rate is the ratio of the number of qualified test points whose deviations are within the tolerance range to the total number of test points when the test piece is held in the fixture; the rectification of the molds for the relevant processes includes rectifying the molds for the drawing process, and after rectification, re-performing the free springback measurement, mold compensation, test punching and surface difference detection, and re-calculating the first-order surface difference pass rate.

8. The closed-loop adjustment process for the springback of the cover as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The free springback measurement results are obtained through stamping forming simulation analysis. The stamping forming simulation analysis generates springback cloud maps for each stamping process and determines the key areas and compensation amounts for mold springback compensation in each process based on the springback cloud maps. The stamping forming simulation analysis also verifies the springback compensation amount for each process by comparing the surface data under the free springback state and the fixture clamping state under the same stamping process.