A method for evaluating drilling effect of a horizontal well in a non-homogeneous coal rock
By obtaining the vertical formation thickness of the coal seam and the thickness of high-quality coal and rock, calculating the proportion, and establishing evaluation parameters and standard values, the problem of quantitative evaluation of the drilling effect of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock has been solved, and the level of precision in the development of coal and rock gas fields has been improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202611185919.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2026-08-06
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing technologies are insufficient to quantitatively evaluate the drilling effectiveness of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations, resulting in significant differences in drilling effectiveness during coal and rock gas field development, and a lack of effective evaluation standards and methods.
By combining well logging data to obtain the vertical stratum thickness of coal seams and the thickness of high-quality coal and rock in the study area, the proportion of coal and rock and high-quality coal and rock was calculated, evaluation parameters and standard values were established, and quantitative evaluation was carried out in combination with actual drilling data of horizontal wells.
It enables quantitative evaluation of the drilling effects of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations, provides clear evaluation standards, and improves the precision of coal and rock gas field development.
Smart Images

Figure CN123109648A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention belongs to the field of coal and rock gas field development technology, specifically relating to an evaluation method for the drilling effect of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock. Background Technology
[0002] In recent years, China has carried out large-scale exploration and development of deep coal and rock gas. Due to the poor physical properties of deep coal and rock gas, large-scale horizontal well fracturing is often used for development. China's deep coal and rock are highly heterogeneous and can be macroscopically divided into different types of coal and rock and interbedded rock. The microscopic components, industrial components and physical properties of different types of coal and rock vary greatly, resulting in large differences in gas content.
[0003] The drilling success rate of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations is influenced by both the coal and rock types within the coal seam and interbedded rock, as well as local structural changes. During drilling, various coal and rock types, interbedded rock, and even encounters with the roof and floor may occur. If the coal seam is stable and its heterogeneity is weak, the drilling success rate in the horizontal section is high, and the encounter rate of high-quality coal seams is also high. Conversely, if the coal seam is highly heterogeneous, has well-developed interbedded rock, and experiences rapid structural changes, it is likely to encounter interbedded rock or the roof and floor during horizontal drilling, typically resulting in a low coal and rock encounter rate, and a low encounter rate of high-quality coal and rock. In 2025, Zhou Lihong, Li Shuguang, Wang Yuan, and others published an article titled "Key Technologies and Practices for Efficient Development of Deep Coal Mine Gas—Taking the Daning-Jixian Block in the Ordos Basin as an Example" in the *Acta Petrolei Sinica*, which clearly identified the black gold target body (high-quality coal seam) as the main gas-producing section and confirmed that for every 1% increase in the drilling encounter rate of the black gold target body, the single-well EUR can be increased by 1%. In 2026, Li Cong, Ma Limin, Cong Peng, and others published an article titled "Analysis of the Main Controlling Factors for High Production of Horizontal Wells in Deep Coal Mine Gas—Taking the Jiaxian Area in the Northeast Margin of the Ordos Basin as an Example" in *Natural Gas Geoscience*, which pointed out that the higher the penetration ratio of 8-1# coal, the larger the initial production index and the single-well EUR, and the better the production effect. Both articles mentioned that good drilling encounter effect in the horizontal section is the main controlling factor for production, but a standard for quantitatively evaluating the drilling encounter effect of horizontal wells has not yet been established. Due to the influence of geological factors such as coal and rock type, interbedded rock, and geological structure, the drilling results of horizontal sections in coal and rock reservoirs vary greatly. Currently, there is no relevant literature or patent on how to determine the evaluation parameters and standard values for the drilling results of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock reservoirs. In practice, the drilling results are usually qualitatively judged based on parameters such as the horizontal section coal and rock encounter rate, the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate, and total hydrocarbons measured in gas. However, since total hydrocarbons measured in gas are not only affected by the coal and rock type itself but also by engineering construction parameters such as drilling fluid density, flow rate, and drilling time, the evaluation parameters and standard values are difficult to determine. Therefore, an effective method for quantitatively evaluating the drilling results of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock gas reservoirs has not yet been established. Summary of the Invention
[0004] The purpose of this invention is to provide a method for evaluating the drilling effectiveness of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations. This method combines well logging data to obtain parameters such as the vertical formation thickness, coal and rock thickness, and high-quality coal and rock thickness of the target coal seam in the study area. Then, it calculates the proportion of coal and rock and the proportion of high-quality coal and rock within the target coal seam, establishing evaluation parameters and standard values for the horizontal segment of the evaluation stratum in the study area. After the pre-evaluation horizontal well is completed, the coal and rock encounter rate and high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of this horizontal segment are obtained using well logging data. Based on a comparison of the actual drilling effect of the evaluation horizontal well with the evaluation parameters and standard values for the region, the drilling effectiveness conclusion is determined.
[0005] To achieve the above objectives, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is: to provide a method for evaluating the drilling effect of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock, specifically including the following steps: 1) Based on well logging data, obtain parameters such as vertical stratum thickness, coal and rock thickness, and high-quality coal and rock thickness of the target coal seam in the study area; Based on the core data of the study area, vertical or directional wells that typically penetrate the target layer were selected for research to clarify the vertical thickness of the target coal seam, the thickness of the coal and rock, and the thickness of high-quality coal and rock.
[0006] 2) Calculate the proportion of coal and rock and the proportion of high-quality coal and rock in the target coal seam of the study area, and establish evaluation parameters and standard values for the horizontal segments of the evaluation strata in the study area; Based on the stratigraphic characteristics of the target layer, the thickness of the coal seam, the thickness of the coal and rock, and the thickness of the high-quality coal and rock in a single well are obtained. Then, the proportion of the coal and rock thickness of the target layer and the proportion of the high-quality coal and rock thickness in the study area are determined, which are used as standard values for the lithology and gas-bearing parameters for evaluating the drilling effect of the horizontal section in the area. ; Where S c : Coal-rock ratio, %; h c H: Total thickness of coal and rock, m; ; Where S q : Percentage of high-quality coal seams, %; h q H: Total thickness of high-quality coal seam, m; H: Total thickness of coal seam strata, m.
[0007] The percentage of coal seam thickness and the percentage of high-quality coal seam thickness are percentages along the vertical direction of the coal seam. The higher the percentage of coal seam thickness and the percentage of high-quality coal seam thickness, the weaker the heterogeneity. The lower the percentage, the stronger the heterogeneity. Drilling into coal seams / high-quality coal seams is more difficult, and the drilling rate is lower.
[0008] 3) After the completion of the pre-evaluation horizontal well, the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of this horizontal section are obtained in combination with the logging data; Based on the logging data, the lengths of various types of coal and rock, as well as high-quality coal and rock in the horizontal section are statistically analyzed to determine the coal and rock drilling rate and the high-quality coal and rock drilling rate of the horizontal well. ; Among them W c Coal and rock encounter rate, %; L c L: Length of the horizontal section encountered during drilling, in meters; L: Length of the actual horizontal section drilled, in meters. ; Among them W q High-quality coal and rock drilling encounter rate, %; L q : Length of high-quality coal and rock encountered in the horizontal section, m; L: Length of the actual drilled horizontal section, m.
[0009] 4) Based on the comparison between the actual drilling results of the evaluated horizontal wells and the evaluation parameters and standard values of the local area, determine the conclusion of the drilling results; The drilling rate of coal and rock in horizontal wells is related to the vertical proportion of coal and rock in the target coal seam. The drilling rate of high-quality coal and rock is related to the vertical proportion of high-quality coal in the target coal seam. The gas content is related to the coal and rock type in the target coal seam. High-quality coal and rock have good gas content. Therefore, the drilling rate of coal and rock in the target coal seam and the drilling rate of high-quality coal and rock in the study area are selected as evaluation parameters and indicators.
[0010] The evaluation method given above emphasizes the vertical formation thickness of the coal seam; because if the well is a vertical well, the coal seam formation thickness is the same as the vertical formation thickness; if the well is an inclined well, the logging data includes both vertical depth and inclination depth, and the apparent formation thickness (inclination depth) of the coal seam is greater than the vertical thickness.
[0011] The coal and rock drilling rate refers to the bright, semi-bright, semi-dark, and dark coals in the macroscopic coal and rock formations. Mudstone, sandstone, limestone, etc., which are not considered as reservoirs, are not included in the coal seam drilling rate. The high-quality coal and rock drilling rate refers to the bright and semi-bright coals in the deep coalbed methane industry as high-quality coal seams, which are the targets for black gold.
[0012] The coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate mentioned are the average proportions of coal and rock around the pre-evaluation well. The values vary in different regions, but the coal seam deposition is relatively stable and the differences in a small area are not significant.
[0013] If both values of the horizontal well evaluation parameters are higher than the target layer evaluation index, the drilling effect is good; if one value of the horizontal well evaluation parameter is higher than the target layer evaluation index, the drilling effect is average; if none of the horizontal well evaluation parameters are higher than the evaluation index, the drilling effect is poor.
[0014] The beneficial effects of this invention are as follows: The evaluation method for the drilling effect of heterogeneous coal and rock horizontal wells established by the above process clarifies the evaluation parameters for the drilling effect of horizontal wells in strongly heterogeneous coal and rock formations, solves the current problem of difficulty in evaluating the drilling effect of coal and rock horizontal wells, and achieves the goal of quantitatively evaluating the drilling effect of heterogeneous coal and rock horizontal wells, which is of great significance for the refined development of coal and rock gas fields. Attached Figure Description
[0015] Figure 1 This invention provides longitudinal lithological diagrams of various coal seams. Figure 2 This is a diagram showing the drilling conditions in the horizontal section of the present invention; Figure 3 This is a flowchart of a method for evaluating the drilling performance of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations. Detailed Implementation
[0016] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and advantages of the present invention clearer, the present invention will be further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments.
[0017] Taking the Taiyuan Formation No. 8 coal seam in the X coal-gas field of a certain basin in China as an example, the Taiyuan Formation No. 8 coal seam was formed in a lagoon-tidal flat sedimentary environment, with widespread development, large-area stable distribution, and a large coal seam thickness, mainly ranging from 5.6 to 16.2 m, with an average of 9.4 m; Figure 1 As shown, the macroscopic coal and rock types include semi-bright coal, bright coal, semi-dull coal, and dull coal. Among them, bright coal and semi-bright coal have high organic matter content, well-developed cleavage and fractures, and high gas content, making them geologically desirable sweet spots and high-quality reservoirs. The coal seam contains mudstone and sandstone interbedded with gangue, with limestone dominating the roof and mudstone dominating the floor. Controlled by various sedimentary environments such as tidal flats, lagoons, and swamps, bright and dull coal alternate within the seam, exhibiting a fine-to-medium banded structure. Bright coal is mainly located in the upper part of the coal seam, while dull coal is located in the lower part, showing strong vertical heterogeneity. Influenced by paleogeography and later tectonic movements, the area has developed positive and negative structures. Due to the heterogeneity of the coal and rock and structural factors, horizontal wells will encounter various lithologies such as limestone, bright coal, semi-bright coal, semi-dull coal, dull coal, and mudstone. The following methods are used to evaluate the No. 8 coal seam of the Taiyuan Formation in the X coalfield, specifically as follows: Figure 3 As shown.
[0018] (1) Combine well logging data to obtain parameters such as vertical stratum thickness, coal and rock thickness, and high-quality coal and rock thickness of the target coal seam in the study area.
[0019] Based on the observation of coal and rock cores of the No. 8 coal seam in the Taiyuan Formation in the study area, taking the core well A as an example, the formation thickness of the target No. 8 coal seam, the thickness of each type of coal and rock, and the thickness of interbedded rock can be calculated (see Table 1).
[0020] Table 1. Vertical lithology of coal seam #8 in well A. Floor number Top depth (m) Bottom depth (m) Thickness (m) Lithology 1 2873.02 2873.68 0.66 Bright coal 2 2873.68 2874.22 0.54 Semi-bright coal 3 2874.22 2874.51 0.29 Semi-dull coal 4 2874.51 2875.13 0.62 Semi-bright coal 5 2875.13 2875.23 0.1 Bright coal 6 2875.23 2875.32 0.09 Semi-bright coal 7 2875.32 2875.45 0.13 Dull coal 8 2875.45 2875.62 0.17 Semi-dull coal 9 2875.62 2876.04 0.42 Semi-bright coal 10 2876.04 2876.17 0.13 Bright coal 11 2876.17 2876.36 0.19 Semi-bright coal 12 2876.36 2876.43 0.07 Semi-dull coal 13 2876.43 2877.8 1.37 Semi-bright coal 14 2877.8 2878.15 0.35 grayish-black mudstone 15 2878.15 2879.04 0.89 Bright coal 16 2879.04 2879.25 0.21 Semi-bright coal 17 2879.25 2879.37 0.12 Semi-dull coal 18 2879.37 2880.03 0.66 Semi-bright coal 19 2880.03 2880.12 0.09 Semi-dull coal 20 2880.12 2880.27 0.15 Dull coal 21 2880.27 2880.66 0.39 Semi-bright coal 22 2880.66 2881.25 0.59 Dull coal 23 2881.25 2881.35 0.1 Semi-dull coal 24 2881.35 2881.47 0.12 Semi-bright coal 25 2881.47 2882.53 1.06 Semi-dull coal 26 2882.53 2883.4 0.87 Bright coal 27 2883.4 2883.91 0.51 Light gray muddy siltstone 28 2883.91 2884.85 0.94 grayish-black mudstone 29 2884.85 2885.04 0.19 Semi-dull coal 30 2885.04 2886.01 0.97 Semi-bright coal 31 2886.01 2886.58 0.57 Semi-dull coal 32 2886.58 2886.95 0.37 Dull coal total 13.93 (2) Calculate the proportion of coal and rock and the proportion of high-quality coal and rock in the coal seam of the target coal seam in the study area, and establish the evaluation parameters and standard values of the horizontal segment of the evaluation stratum in the study area.
[0021] Based on the top and bottom of the target stratum #8 coal seam in well A, the vertical stratum thickness can be calculated to be 13.93m, the coal seam thickness to be 12.13m, and the thickness of high-quality coal seam (bright coal + semi-bright coal) to be 8.23m. Therefore, the coal seam proportion in the target stratum of well A is calculated to be 87.08%, and the proportion of high-quality coal seam (bright coal + semi-bright coal) to be 59.08%. For example... Figure 2 As shown, by calculating the average values of the corresponding parameters in the study area through multiple wells that have drilled through the target layer, the standard values of the parameters in the study area were determined (see Table 2). The standard value for the coal and rock drilling encounter rate in the area is 86.42%, and the high-quality coal and rock drilling encounter rate is 58.59%.
[0022] Table 2 Calculation table of standard values for evaluation parameters of typical wells in the study area
[0023] (3) After the completion of the pre-evaluation horizontal well, the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of this horizontal section are obtained in combination with the logging data. After the horizontal well P was completed, the various lithologies of the horizontal section of the well were identified according to the logging interpretation standards. The actual drilled horizontal section of the well was 1200m long, the coal and rock section was 1106m long (of which the bright coal and semi-bright coal section was 658m long), the limestone section was 69m long, and the mudstone section was 25m long. Thus, the coal and rock drilling rate of the horizontal section of the well was 92.17%, and the high-quality coal and rock drilling rate was 54.83% (see Table 3).
[0024] Table 3. Drilling conditions in the horizontal section of Well P Length of the actual horizontal section drilled (m) Length of coal and rock section (m) Coal and rock encounter rate (%) Length of high-quality coal and rock section (m) High-quality coal and rock drilling encounter rate (%) L <![CDATA[L c ]]> <![CDATA[W c ]]> <![CDATA[L q ]]> <![CDATA[W q ]]> 1200 1106 92.17 658 54.83 4) Based on the comparison between the actual drilling results of the evaluated horizontal wells and the evaluation parameters and standard values of the local area, determine the conclusion of the drilling results.
[0025] Based on the coal and rock types and high-quality coal and rock conditions encountered in the horizontal section of well P, and compared with the established standard value of coal seam No. 8 in this area, it can be seen that the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of well P are lower than the standard value. The overall geological drilling effect of the horizontal section of well P is generally considered to be average (see Table 4).
[0026] Table 4. Quantitative Evaluation Table of Drilling Results in the Horizontal Section of Well P .
[0027] A comprehensive evaluation of the completed horizontal wells in the No. 8 coal seam of the X coalfield was conducted. Of the 10 completed horizontal wells, 6 had good drilling results, 2 had average drilling results, and 2 had poor drilling results. This achieved the goal of quantitatively evaluating the geological drilling results of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal seams.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the drilling effectiveness of horizontal wells in heterogeneous coal and rock formations, characterized in that, Specifically, the steps include the following: (1) Combine well logging data to obtain parameters such as vertical stratum thickness, coal and rock thickness, and high-quality coal and rock thickness of the target coal seam in the study area; Based on the core data of the study area, vertical or directional wells that typically penetrate the target layer in the study area were selected as the research objects. (2) Calculate the proportion of coal and rock and the proportion of high-quality coal and rock in the coal seam of the target coal seam in the study area, and establish the evaluation parameters and standard values of the horizontal segment of the evaluation stratum in the study area; Based on the stratigraphic characteristics of the target layer, the thickness of the coal seam, the thickness of the coal and rock, and the thickness of the high-quality coal and rock in a single well are obtained. The proportion of the thickness of the coal and rock in the target layer and the proportion of the thickness of the high-quality coal and rock in the study area are determined and used as standard values for lithological and gas-bearing parameters for evaluating the drilling effect of the horizontal section in the area. (3) After the completion of the pre-evaluation horizontal well, the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of this horizontal section are obtained in combination with the logging data; The lengths of various types of coal and rock, as well as high-quality coal and rock, in the horizontal section are statistically analyzed to determine the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of the evaluation horizontal well. (4) Based on the comparison between the actual drilling results of the evaluated horizontal wells and the evaluation parameters and standard values of the local area, determine the conclusion of the drilling results; The drilling rate of coal and rock in the target strata and the drilling rate of high-quality coal and rock in the study area were selected as evaluation parameters and indicators.
2. The method for evaluating the drilling effect of a horizontal well in heterogeneous coal and rock as described in claim 1, characterized in that, In (2), the proportion of coal and rock thickness of the target seam and the proportion of high-quality coal and rock thickness in the study area are determined and used as standard values for lithology and gas content parameters for evaluating the drilling effect of the horizontal section in the area. ; Among them, S c : Coal-rock ratio, %; h c H: Total thickness of coal and rock, m; ; Among them, S q : Percentage of high-quality coal seams, %; h q H: Total thickness of high-quality coal seam, m; H: Total thickness of coal seam strata, m.
3. The method for evaluating the drilling effect of a horizontal well in heterogeneous coal and rock as described in claim 1, characterized in that, In (3), the coal and rock drilling rate and the high-quality coal and rock drilling rate of the evaluation level well are determined; ; Among them, W c Coal and rock encounter rate, %; L c L: Length of the horizontal section encountered during drilling, in meters; L: Length of the actual horizontal section drilled, in meters. ; Among them, W q High-quality coal and rock drilling encounter rate, %; L q : Length of high-quality coal and rock encountered in the horizontal section, m; L: Length of the actual drilled horizontal section, m.
4. The method for evaluating the drilling effect of a horizontal well in heterogeneous coal and rock as described in claim 1, characterized in that, The coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate are the average proportions of coal and rock around the pre-evaluation well.
5. The method for evaluating the drilling effect of a horizontal well in heterogeneous coal and rock as described in claim 1, characterized in that, If both the coal and rock encounter rate and the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of the horizontal well evaluation parameters are higher than the target layer evaluation index, the drilling effect is good; if either the coal and rock encounter rate or the high-quality coal and rock encounter rate of the horizontal well evaluation parameters is higher than the target layer evaluation index, the drilling effect is average; if none of the horizontal well evaluation parameters are higher than the evaluation index, the drilling effect is poor.
