METHOD AND DEVICE FOR CONTROLLING A WATER SUPPLY NETWORK

DE502019012391D1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-21SIEMENS AG
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
DE502019012391
Authority / Receiving Office
DE · DE
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2019-03-28
Filing Date
2019-04-18
Publication Date
2024-11-21
Estimated Expiration
2039-04-18

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current water supply network control methods prioritize security of supply over energy and cost efficiency, limiting the scope for savings due to conservatively selected minimum filling levels, which can lead to suboptimal operational decisions.

Method used

A method that determines a safety level exceeding the minimum fill level for water-storing nodes, incorporating virtual costs to optimize the control plan for pumps and valves, balancing energy consumption, costs, and security of supply through a forward-looking model analysis.

Benefits of technology

This approach enables energy and cost savings while maintaining or improving security of supply, enhancing the acceptance of innovative systems in the water industry by allowing early detection of potential safety level deviations and enabling counteractions.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[0001] The invention relates to a method for controlling a water supply network according to the preamble of claim 1.

[0002] The invention further relates to a device for controlling a water supply network according to the preamble of claim 5.

[0003] Such a method and such a device are known from EP 3 450 638 A1.

[0004] The known method and device are used to control a water supply network that includes node components and edge components. Water can be fed in, withdrawn, distributed, or stored at the nodes. The node components can therefore be feeders such as wells, springs, or external water suppliers, water consumers, and water containers such as tanks or basins. The water is transported between the node components via the edge components. The edge components can be passive components such as pipes, as well as active, controllable components such as pumps or valves. The active edge components are controlled, and thus the water flow, according to a control plan (schedule), in which a temporal sequence of the activations of the controllable edge components is defined. The control plan is determined on the basis of boundary conditions in such a way that, for a time sliced ​​into time slices (e.g.A predetermined water balance of the water supply network is maintained on average over time in each time slice within a planning period (e.g., days, weeks) divided into hours. The boundary conditions include, for example, upper and lower limits for water inputs into the water supply network in the individual time slices and expected water withdrawals from the water supply network in the time slices. For each water-storing node, a minimum fill level is specified as a boundary condition, which must not be undercut in order to ensure the water supply.

[0005] Subject to the boundary conditions, the control plan is optimized using an objective function (cost function) to minimize the energy consumption of the controllable components, e.g., pumps, of the water supply network and / or to minimize wear and tear on the components, e.g., valves, by minimizing their switching operations. To do this, in the objective function, for each controllable edge component, the number of times it is activated is multiplied by a cost rate for energy consumption and / or wear and tear of the respective edge component. The sum of all edge components is then calculated to obtain the total costs to be minimized. The term "cost" is not only to be understood in monetary terms, but also includes consumption, effort, wear and tear, etc., which ultimately translates into costs.

[0006] When supplying their customers with drinking water, water network operators must guarantee the security of this supply so that the water supply is assured for a certain period of time, even in extreme situations, such as a water supply failure or a sudden increase in consumption. The minimum fill levels of the tanks must be determined depending on how quickly they can react to such events (time to restore or increase water supply). At the same time, water operators naturally want to operate as energy- and cost-efficiently as possible, for example, by avoiding energy-intensive pumping during times of high energy prices or by making optimal use of tariff features such as atypical network usage. Security of supply and cost optimization can be competing objectives.

[0007] The invention is based on the specific problem of simultaneously taking into account security of supply and energy and cost efficiency in current operating decisions (switching of pumps, opening of valves).

[0008] Security of supply is generally a top priority. Traditionally, it is guaranteed by maintaining high minimum fill levels in drinking water reservoirs. These conservatively selected limits significantly restrict the scope for energy- and cost-efficient operation. Therefore, energy and costs are often not even taken into account in current operating decisions, for example, when pumps are switched on according to a fixed control set as soon as the reservoir level falls below a certain level and switched off as soon as a maximum level is reached. Or it is left to the control room personnel, with their expert knowledge, to decide how and when to switch pumps and open valves in order to maintain the required minimum fill levels.A more innovative approach is to use a forward-looking model analysis of the system over the following hours and days to determine suitable or even energy- and cost-optimal schedules for pumps and valves that meet the required minimum levels. However, as already mentioned, the scope for savings is limited with conservatively selected minimum levels. While forward-looking analysis allows for lower minimum levels if the model calculation demonstrates that, despite lower minimum levels, supply security is guaranteed in the following hours and days, lowering the minimum levels results in a certain reduction in supply security, which reduces the acceptance of such innovative systems.

[0009] According to the invention, this problem is solved by the method defined in claim 1 and the device defined in claim 5.

[0010] Advantageous further developments of the invention are specified in the subclaims.

[0011] According to the invention, a safety fill level exceeding the minimum fill level is defined for each of the water-storing nodes (containers, reservoirs, basins, etc.), and the objective function for each of these water-storing nodes is supplemented by a further summand in the form of a further cost rate dependent on the fill level, which is minimal at a fill level corresponding to the safety fill level and maximal at a fill level corresponding to the minimum fill level.

[0012] As in the innovative, model-based approaches mentioned above, a reduced minimum fill level is used which must not be undercut. In addition, a higher safety fill level is set, for example at the level of the traditionally conservatively selected minimum fill level. Using a forward-looking model analysis, the control plan (schedule) for the pumps and valves can be evaluated and optimized. The objective function is not only the energy consumption or the energy and switching costs as before, but also virtual costs are applied in the form of additional cost rates when the fill level falls below the safety fill level. The further the fill level is reduced and approaches the minimum fill level, the higher the virtual costs (additional cost rates).

[0013] The virtual costs or additional cost rates can be calculated according to a predefined function depending on the difference between the fill level and the minimum or safety level of the respective water-storing node. In the simplest case, the virtual costs increase linearly, starting from a value of zero at the safety level, as the fill level approaches the minimum level. However, this increase can also occur progressively.

[0014] The cost rates for energy consumption and / or wear and tear and the additional cost rates for fill levels can be assigned different weighting factors, i.e. the real costs and the virtual costs can be weighted differently in a configurable manner.

[0015] The advantage over the above-mentioned traditional approach with high minimum fill levels is that energy consumption and costs are actually taken into account, and savings are made during ongoing operation. Compared to the innovative evaluation and optimization approaches also mentioned above, the advantage is that, in addition to energy consumption and costs, security of supply is also taken into account. If, when optimizing the control plan for the pumps and valves, different operating modes arise that are equivalent from an energy and cost perspective, the operating mode that guarantees the greatest possible security of supply is recommended. If there are different operating modes that differ slightly in terms of energy and costs, but show significant differences in terms of security of supply, operating modes are recommended that cause slightly higher energy consumption or slightly higher costs, but with a lower energy consumption and cost.This will bring significant gains in terms of supply security. If there are different operating modes that differ significantly in terms of energy and costs, but only slightly in terms of supply security, then operating modes are proposed that make minor compromises in terms of supply security but enable significant savings in terms of energy and costs. The forward-looking approach of innovative systems also allows for early detection (early warning system) of when safety levels may be reached or undercut, thus allowing early countermeasures if desired. The invention thus enables energy and cost savings while simultaneously focusing on supply security, which will increase the acceptance of such systems in the water industry.

[0016] The invention will now be explained by way of example with reference to the figures of the drawing, in which: Fig. 1 shows an exemplary water supply network, Fig. 2 shows a flow diagram of an exemplary method for controlling a water supply network, and Fig. 3 shows examples of virtual costs when the fill level falls below the safety fill level.

[0017] Fig. 1 shows a water supply network 1 such as a municipal supply network for drinking water. The water supply network 1 comprises node components 2 and edge components 3. At the node points 2, water can be fed in, withdrawn, distributed or stored. The node components 2 can thus be feeders 4 such as wells, springs or external water suppliers, water consumers 5, water distribution points 6 and water containers 7 such as tanks or basins. The water is transported between the node components 2 via the edge components 3. The edge components 2 can be passive components such as pipes 8 and active, controllable components such as pumps 9, turbines 10 or valves 11. Several pumps 9 or turbines 10 can be connected in parallel in a pumping station 12 or turbine station 13. The pumps 9 or turbines 10 can be switched or controlled in stages or continuously.Likewise, the valves 11 can be switched (switching valves) or controlled (control valves). The controllable components 9, 10, 11 are powered by electrical energy suppliers 14, which typically comprise a connection or transfer point of a power grid.

[0018] The control of the controllable edge components, in this case, for example, the pumps 9, turbines 10, and valves 11, is carried out according to a control plan (schedule) 15, in which a temporal sequence of the activations of the controllable edge components 9, 10, 11 is defined. The control plan 15 preferably relates to a predetermined planning horizon 16, which can be divided into individual time slices 17. The planning horizon 16 can, for example, comprise one or more days, with a time slice 17 being, for example, one hour. The control plan 15 is determined in a processing device 18, e.g., in the form of a programmable microcomputer, of a control device 19 on the basis of boundary conditions such that a predetermined water balance of the water supply network is maintained on average over time in each time slice 17. The boundary conditions include, among others:upper and lower limits for water feeds into the water supply network in the individual time slices 17 and expected water withdrawals from the water supply network in the time slices 17. For each water storing node 7, a minimum fill level h min is specified as a boundary condition, which must not be undercut in order to ensure the water supply.

[0019] The control device 19 can be designed centrally or decentrally and has an interface 20 for controlling the controllable edge components 9, 10, 11.

[0020] Fig 2 shows an exemplary flow diagram of a method 21 for controlling the Fig. 1 shown water supply network 1. Individual steps of the method 21 can be performed in a different order than the one specified. The method 21 can, in particular, be executed, in whole or in part, on the control device 19. For this purpose, the control device 19 can comprise a programmable microcomputer or microcontroller, and the method 21 can be present at least partially in the form of a computer program product with program code means.

[0021] In a step 22, the planning horizon 16 and the time slices 17 can be determined.

[0022] In a step 23, feed limits of the water feeders 4 can be determined.

[0023] In parallel, in one step 24 withdrawals by water consumers 5 can be determined or predicted.

[0024] In a step 25, operating configurations, in particular the configuration of the edge components 3 of the water supply network 1, can be determined. Examples of this are the energy consumption of pumps 9 or flow rates in the pipes 8.

[0025] In a step 26, energy costs can be determined. These can be fixed or variable, and in the latter case, they can be determined individually for the time slices 17. The energy costs are relevant for the energy consumed, for example, by a pump 9 when it is activated or switched on.

[0026] In a step 27, states of node components 2 can be determined for each time slice 17. Examples of this are the maximum container volume or the maximum permissible fill level h max and the minimum fill level h min of containers 7.

[0027] In a step 28, initial states of the components of the water supply network 1 can be determined. Examples of this are the positions of valves 11 or fill levels in containers 7.

[0028] Based on the information collected in steps 22 to 28, the control plan 15 can be determined in a step 29. The concrete determination of the control plan 170 preferably takes place as an optimization within a search space specified by the boundary conditions described above. Detailed examples of mixed-integer linear optimization are described in the aforementioned EP 3 450 638 A1, to which explicit reference is made here. The determined control plan 15 can be transferred in part or in full to the control device 19 for controlling the water supply network 1. Additionally or alternatively, the control plan 15 can be output to the control center personnel, who can make decisions for the control system based on the plan 17 or intervene in the automatic control system.

[0029] The control plan 15 is optimized using an objective function in which, for each controllable edge component 9, 10, 11, the number of its activations is multiplied by a cost rate for energy consumption and / or wear of the respective edge component 9, 10, 11, and then the sum is calculated across all controllable edge components 9, 10, 11. In addition, for each of the water-storing nodes 7, a safety fill level h sec that exceeds the minimum fill level h min is defined, and the objective function for each water-storing node 9 is supplemented by a further summand in the form of a further cost rate that depends on the fill level. This further cost factor is selected or weighted such that it is minimal, e.g., zero, when the fill level corresponds to or exceeds the safety fill level h sec.The further cost factor is maximum when the fill level reaches the minimum fill level h min, which, as already mentioned, must not be undercut.

[0030] This ultimately results in the following simplified objective function: Z = w real ⋅ C real + w vir ⋅ C vir , where C real denotes the sum of the real costs for energy consumption and switching of the switchable edge components 9, 10, 11, and C vir denotes the sum of the virtual costs for filling levels of the water storing nodes 7 below the safety filling level h sec . The real costs C real and virtual costs C vir can be weighted differently using weighting factors w real and w vir, respectively.

[0031] Fig. 3 shows, by way of example, the dependence of the virtual costs C vir on the fill level h, whereby curve 30 represents a linear dependence and curve 31 illustrates a progressive increase in the virtual costs C vir as the fill level h approaches the minimum fill level h sec.

[0032] In the following, an embodiment of the method 21 for controlling the water supply network 1 is explained in more detail based on and with reference to the known method described in detail in EP 3 450 638 A1.

[0033] The list of parameters specified in EP 3 450 638 A1 can be extended by the following two parameters: ψ v , t min Safety stock of stored water volume (measured e.g. in m 3< ) in the node component v during the time slice t and in particular also at the end of the time slice t; the safety stock may in principle be undercut, but a corresponding deficit in water volume compared to the safety stock will be subject to (virtual) penalty costs; it should always apply ψ v , t min ≥ σ v , t min ; for all node components that are not tanks, the following always applies: ψ v , t min = 0 . γ v , t min Cost rate per m 3< Water deficit in the stored water volume ( w v , t end or w v , t s ) compared to safety stock ψ v , t min for the node component v during the time slice t ; this parameter corresponds to the virtual penalty cost rate that has to be paid in the model for falling below the desired water volume safety stock per cubic meter of water deficit.

[0034] The list of variables specified in EP 3 450 638 A1 can be extended by the following variables: x v , t + ≥ 0 Variable for determining a positive deviation of the node component v to the end of the time slice t stored water volume w v , t end compared to safety stock ψ v , t min (all measured e.g. in m 3< ), ( v ∈ V,t ∈ T ) . x v , t − ≥ 0 Variable for determining a negative deviation of the node component v to the end of the time slice t stored water volume w v , t end compared to safety stock ψ v , t min (all measured e.g. in m 3< ), ( v ∈ V,t ∈ T ). y v , t + ≥ 0 Variable for determining a positive deviation of the node component v at the time of the potential switching point during the time slice t stored water volume w v , t s compared to safety stock ψ v , t min (all measured e.g. in m 3< ), ( v ∈ V,t ∈ T ). y v , t − ≥ 0 Variable for determining a negative deviation of the node component v at the time of the potential switching point during the time slice t stored water volume w v , t s compared to safety stock ψ v , t min (all measured e.g. in m 3< ), ( v ∈ V, t ∈ T ) .

[0035] The following additional constraints (2a) and (2b) can also be specified: w v , t end = ψ v , t min + x v , t + − x v , t − v ∈ V , t ∈ T

[0036] The constraint (2a) defines the deviation of the node component v at the end of the time slice t stored water quantity w v , t end compared to the safety stock defined in this time slice ψ v , t min . If this safety stock is undershot, the variable x v , t + due to cost minimization always has the value 0, so that the positive value of the variable x v , t − is as low as possible (and thus corresponds to the actual inventory shortfall). w v , t s = ψ v , t min + y v , t + − y v , t − v ∈ V , t ∈ T

[0037] The constraint (2b) corresponds to the constraint (2a) with the difference that here the end time of the time slice is not t is considered, but the potential switching time of the edge component v within this time frame.

[0038] The objective function can be extended by the following summand (25a): ∑ ν ∈ V ∑ t ∈ T γ v , t min ⋅ x v , t − + y v , t −

[0039] Formula (25a) describes the virtual costs associated with shortfalls in the safety stock ψ v , t min are associated. For this purpose, all water volumes below the safety stock that occur within the planning horizon are added together and then multiplied by the associated cost rate.

Claims

1. Method (21) for controlling a water supply network (1) which comprises node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7) and edge components (3; 8, 9, 10, 11), wherein water is fed into, withdrawn from, or stored on the node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7) and the water is transported between the node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7) via the edge components (3; 8, 9, 10, 11), wherein a number of the edge components (9, 10, 11) can be controlled in terms of their flow behaviour for the water and are controlled in accordance with a control map (15) which contains a temporal sequence of controls for the controllable edge component (9, 10, 11), wherein the control map (15) is determined based on boundary conditions which include a minimum fill level (hmin) for each water-storing node component (7), which minimum fill level must not be undershot, and wherein the control map (15) is optimised based on a target function in which, for each controllable edge component (9, 10, 11), the number of controls is multiplied by a cost rate for an energy consumption and / or wear of the respective edge component (9, 10, 11) and the total across all controllable edge components (9, 10, 11) is then formed, characterised in that a safety fill level (hsec) which exceeds the minimum fill level (hmin) is defined in each case for each of the water-storing node components (7) and that the target function for each water-storing node component (7) is supplemented by a further summand in the form of a further cost rate dependant on the fill level in each case, which is minimal at a fill level which corresponds to the safety fill level (hsec) and is maximal at a fill level which corresponds to the minimum fill level (hmin) , wherein the control map (15) is determined in a processing facility (18) of a control apparatus (19) on the basis of the boundary conditions, wherein the control apparatus (19) comprises an interface (20) for controlling the controllable edge components (9, 10, 11), and wherein the control map (15) can be transferred in parts or completely to the control apparatus (19) for controlling the water supply network (1).

2. Method according to claim 1, characterised in that the further cost rate is calculated in accordance with a predefined function depending on the difference between the fill level and the minimum fill level (hmin) or safety fill level (hsec) of the respective water-storing node component (7) .

3. Method according to claim 1, characterised in that the function is a linear function.

4. Method according to one of the preceding claims, characterised in that the rates for the respective energy consumption and / or wear and the further rates for the respective fill level are provided with different weighting factors.

5. Apparatus (19) for controlling a water supply network (1) which comprises node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7) and edge components (3; 8, 9, 10, 11), wherein water is fed into, withdrawn from, or stored on the node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7), the water is transported between the node components (2; 4, 5, 6, 7) via the edge components (3; 8, 9, 10, 11), and a number of the edge components (9, 10, 11) can be controlled in terms of their flow behaviour for the water, wherein the apparatus (19) is designed to control the controllable edge components (9, 10, 11) in accordance with a control map (15) and wherein the apparatus (19) comprises a processing facility (18), which is configured to - generate the control map (15) in the form of a temporal sequence of controls for the controllable edge components (9, 10, 11) based on boundary conditions, which include a minimum fill level (hmin) for each water-storing node component (7) in each case, which minimum fill level must not be undershot, and - optimise the control plan (15) based on a target function in which, for each controllable edge component (9, 10, 11), the number of controls is multiplied by a cost rate for an energy consumption and / or wear of the respective edge component (9, 10, 11) and the total across all controllable edge components (9, 10, 11) is then formed, characterised in that the processing facility (18) is further configured to define a safety fill level (hsec) which exceeds the minimum fill level (hmin) for each of the water-storing node components (7) and that the target function for each water-storing node component (7) is supplemented by a further summand in the form of a further cost rate dependant on the fill level in each case, which is minimal at a fill level which corresponds to the safety fill level (hsec) and is maximal at a fill level which corresponds to the minimum fill level (hmin), wherein the control map (15) is determined in the processing facility (18) of a control apparatus (19) on the basis of the boundary conditions, wherein the control apparatus (19) comprises an interface (20) for controlling the controllable edge components (9, 10, 11), and wherein the control map (15) can be transferred in parts or completely to the control apparatus (19) for controlling the water supply network (1).