Computer-implemented method and passive radar detection system for detecting an aircraft in the vicinity of a wind turbine

DE502020009733D1Active Publication Date: 2024-12-05FRAUNHOFER GESELLSCHAFT ZUR FORDERUNG DER ANGEWANDTEN FORSCHUNG EV
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
DE502020009733
Authority / Receiving Office
DE · DE
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2019-03-12
Filing Date
2020-02-24
Publication Date
2024-12-05
Estimated Expiration
2040-02-24

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing radar systems used to detect flying objects near wind turbines face interference from rotor blade echoes, leading to difficulty in identifying actual targets, high computational effort, and limitations in multi-turbine environments, resulting in lost signal energy and inaccurate detections.

Method used

A computer-implemented method using a passive radar system with at least two input channels and complex-valued echo maps, where signal components from rotating wind turbine blades are distinguished and suppressed using a complex-valued coefficient set and interference echo maps, allowing for improved detection of flying objects by reducing quasi-stationary rotor blade echoes.

Benefits of technology

This method enhances the reliability and accuracy of detecting flying objects near wind turbines by suppressing interference from rotor blades, enabling the use of all available signal energy and reducing computational complexity, thus allowing for real-time detection on commercially available systems without the need for precise calibration or distributed sensor arrangements.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical field

[0001] Examples describe a computer-implemented method for detecting an aircraft in the vicinity of at least one operating wind turbine. Further examples include a corresponding computer program and a passive radar detection system for detecting an aircraft. background

[0002] Methods for using radar systems to monitor airspace in the vicinity of wind turbines, such as wind farms, are known. When radar is used to observe an area with wind turbines, it can be disrupted by signal echoes from the rotating turbine components (rotating wind turbine blades), particularly by so-called rotor blade flashes. Rotor blade flashes occur when the rotor blade is in a position relative to the radar sensor where its surface reflects a signal of maximum strength back to the sensor. Such interference can obscure targets, such as aircraft or drones, making their detection more difficult or even impossible.Additionally, the signal echoes from the rotor blades can be interpreted as false targets and flood processing blocks in the radar with information, leaving no processing time for the actual targets.

[0003] German patent application DE 10 2013 004 463 B4 discloses a passive radar system for handling rotating components. The document describes a device and a method for detecting flying objects in an area where wind turbines are operated. The device comprises at least one radar sensor for monitoring the area and an evaluation unit with which signals acquired by the radar sensor can be evaluated for the detection of flying objects. The evaluation unit is designed such that signal components from moving rotor blades are recognized during signal evaluation, and the evaluation of the signals for detecting flying objects is only carried out in time windows that do not contain a signal component from a moving rotor blade.

[0004] Passive radar uses the electromagnetic emissions of digital radio and television transmitters (OFDM) to detect moving objects without transmitting its own signals. It works by measuring the time-of-flight difference between the signal received directly in front of the known transmitter and the signal echo reflected from the object, thus creating a time-of-flight ellipsoid. By using multiple transmitters or multiple networked receivers, the object can be located by calculating the intersection points of at least three ellipsoids.

[0005] The passive radar system is designed to identify and process signal echoes from rotating components of wind turbines (wind turbine rotor blades). The corresponding method is based on skipping time periods with relevant signal echoes from wind turbine blades (e.g., rotor blade flashes) during processing.

[0006] Several disadvantages can arise with such methods. First, the computational effort required for robust identification can be high, thus necessitating expensive, high-performance computer systems. Second, identification may only be successful if only one wind turbine is located within an identification area (distance range). While this disadvantage could be minimized with a small number of wind turbines in a wind farm through a strategic distribution of sensors, this leads to limitations in sensor placement. With a large number of wind turbines, this condition is, for example, not fully achievable.

[0007] In particular, skipping time intervals can result in the loss of electromagnetic energy from aircraft echo signals, which is necessary, for example, for continuous detection. Due to an aircraft's movement during a given time interval, its echo energy can be distributed across multiple distance ranges. A coherent integration of this energy is not possible, for example, if these distance ranges are occupied by different wind turbines that require detection gaps at different times.

[0008] Depending on the locations of the individual sensors in a network, the detection gaps can occur at different times. Therefore, predicting a common time point is necessary to determine the intersection points of the time-of-flight ellipsoids. For example, in known detection methods, some process steps require tolerant parameters or wide parameter ranges, which can lead to poorer results in aircraft location and additional false detections. Finally, interferometric analysis intended to improve location, especially altitude estimation, may require calibration of the receiving channels and precise knowledge of the phase and amplitude response of the antenna patterns. Altitude estimation, for instance, is only possible after the location has been determined from the ellipsoid sections and thus the angles of incidence on the antennas are known.The values ​​required to determine the interferometer phase can then be read from the antenna diagram. This method, for example, is very computationally intensive and time-consuming.

[0009] One task is to be able to better detect flying objects in the vicinity of wind turbines using radar tracking. Summary

[0010] The problem is solved according to the subject matter of the independent patent claims. Examples of advantageous embodiments are described in conjunction with the dependent patent claims, the following description, and the figures.

[0011] One example deals with a computer-implemented method for detecting an aircraft in the vicinity of at least one operating wind turbine. In general, the method can be used to detect translationally moving objects in environments with rotationally moving objects (e.g., elements rotating at a relatively constant rate over time). The method is based on at least two complex-valued echo maps (e.g., range-Doppler maps) from a passive radar system, with at least one input or receive channel per echo map. In other words, a passive radar system with at least two input or receive channels, each comprising a receiving antenna or radar antenna, is used.

[0012] This allows an echo card corresponding to each input channel to be provided.

[0013] The method involves combining at least two complex-valued echo maps with a complex-valued set of coefficients to generate a modified echo map that corresponds to the set of coefficients. The modified echo map is called a beam echo map.

[0014] Furthermore, the method includes creating a noise echo map for the modified echo map (e.g., corresponding to the modified echo map). The created noise echo map can be used to combine the modified echo map and its corresponding noise echo map to obtain a compensated echo map. In the compensated echo map, quasi-stationary signal components of the modified echo map are reduced.

[0015] The signal components in the complex-valued echo maps, generated by the rotating parts (rotor blades) of the wind turbines, and those generated by the aircraft being detected, differ characteristically. The rotor blades move within a constant range, thereby generating recurring or quasi-stationary echoes at regular intervals with consistently recurring phase values. In other words, wind turbine rotor blades rotate at least relatively constantly, so that rotor blade flashes are continuously present in the signal components with a constant phase value. An aircraft, on the other hand, moves continuously through different detection areas and generates signal components with a continuously changing phase.By procedure, this difference can be used to distinguish the different signal components and to suppress the echo components of the rotor blades.

[0016] Due to the quasi-stationary nature of rotor blade lightning, it is possible to distinguish it from an echo signal from an aircraft. The interference echo map can include the signal components from the wind turbine blades, while signal components caused by the aircraft are suppressed in the interference echo map. By combining the modified echo map and the interference echo map, the signal components from the wind turbine blades can, in turn, be reduced or suppressed in the modified echo map. Ideally, this would mean that only signal components caused by one or more aircraft remain in the compensated echo map.

[0017] The procedure involves identifying potential aircraft in the compensated echo map. For example, a threshold value can be used, and the amplitude values ​​of cells in the compensated echo map are compared to this threshold. For instance, the presence of an aircraft can be assumed at positions corresponding to cells where the amplitude value is greater than the threshold. By suppressing the interference signal components caused by the wind turbine blades in the compensated echo map, as described above, improved, and therefore more reliable, identification of aircraft can be achieved. For example, only the aircraft's echo components might remain in the compensated echo map, or the number of positions falsely determined due to interference from the wind turbines could be significantly reduced.In contrast to methods that remove signal segments containing interference, this method allows for the use of more signal energy from the aircraft's echo to detect it, since no signal segment containing echo components from the aircraft is removed. It is readily apparent to those skilled in the art that, in addition to the application described, the method can advantageously be applied in other areas where translationally moving objects need to be detected in an environment with rotationally moving objects.

[0018] Further examples and advantageous embodiments are described below. For example, combining the at least two complex-valued echo maps includes generating a difference signal of the echo maps of the two input channels. It is possible to multiply at least one of the two echo maps by the complex-valued coefficient set and subtract it from the other echo map. For example, both complex-valued echo maps can be multiplied by a complex-valued coefficient set before generating the difference signal. For example, receiving antennas of the at least two input channels are arranged at different distances from the wind turbine, resulting in propagation time and phase differences in the corresponding echo maps. In contrast to signals from the aircraft, the quasi-stationary signals from the rotor blades lead to constant values ​​in the difference signal.

[0019] The complex-valued coefficient set can include a specific phase value. As previously described, the signal components from the rotor blades and the aircraft generally have different phase values. Therefore, by combining the complex-valued coefficient set, for example, by multiplying a value from the complex-valued echo map and the phase value, constructive or destructive interference results, depending on the phase value and the signal component in the echo map. The phase value can be adapted to the geometric distances between a receiving antenna of an input channel and a rotor blade, as well as to the wavelength of a radio signal used. For example, the phase value can lead to destructive interference with echo components from the rotor blades (interference signal components).

[0020] Combining the data can be achieved using a beamformer, as known from radar technology. The combination of the echo map and the complex-valued coefficient set is carried out by multiplying at least one echo map element by element by element by element by element. As already mentioned, the complex-valued coefficient set can be chosen, for example, based on a geometric arrangement of the wind turbine and radar detector, to suppress the signal components from the wind turbine (e.g., rotor blade echoes) as much as possible.

[0021] In particular, it is possible to use at least two different complex-valued coefficient sets or a plurality of complex-valued coefficient sets to generate at least two modified echo maps, each based on one of the coefficient sets. The phase values ​​of the complex-valued coefficient sets can be equidistantly distributed on the unit circle or symmetrically distributed on the unit circle. For example, a plurality of phase values ​​of the complex-valued coefficient set can be used to generate a plurality of modified echo maps associated with the coefficient set. Multiplying the echo map by the complex-valued coefficient set with different phase values ​​can result in the distribution of the wind turbine's signal components across the plurality of modified echo maps.This can improve the signal ratio between the signal component of the aircraft and the signal component of the wind turbine, thus preventing, for example, the echo signal of the aircraft from being masked by an interfering signal.

[0022] The coefficient set is adapted to a geometric arrangement of the wind turbine and the radar system. Based on the position of the radar system relative to the wind turbine, a single coefficient set or multiple coefficient sets can be calculated. Using multiple coefficient sets, several modified echo maps and corresponding interference echo maps can be generated based on at least two complex-valued echo maps, thus creating a corresponding number of compensated echo maps. For example, this allows for the consideration of the specific positioning of receiving antennas for at least two input channels to multiple wind turbines.

[0023] It is possible that the procedure involves adapting the complex-valued coefficient set based on the current detection situation. For example, when detecting the flying object, it may turn out that a coefficient set with a specific phase value is particularly suitable for suppressing interference signals. In this case, for example, a symmetrical distribution of phase values ​​in the unit circle can be deviated from, and phase values ​​within the range of the determined suitable phase value can be concentrated.

[0024] For example, adaptive adjustment can be performed when a modified echo map provides particularly good detections. In this case, new coefficient sets can be generated at closer intervals around the area of ​​the corresponding coefficient set. Coefficient sets from echo maps with poorer detection can, for example, be thinned out. Adaptive adjustment of the coefficient sets can be achieved, for instance, through a feedback, iterative process. In other words, it may not be a statically predetermined selection of coefficients that is used, but rather the coefficients are adjusted by coupling subsequent or preceding process steps. For example, such coupling can also occur with process steps other than those shown.

[0025] The process of creating interference echo maps involves the use of a low-pass filter. This takes advantage of the fact that the signal components from the wind turbines are quasi-stationary and recurring (low frequency), while the signal components from the aircraft are continuously changing (high frequency). The low-pass filter of the modified echo map allows the signal components from the wind turbines, i.e., the interference signals, to be retained in the interference echo map, while the signal from the aircraft (the desired signal) is filtered out.

[0026] For example, the low-pass filter is an adaptive low-pass filter. The low-pass filter can be an exponential filter. This makes it possible to account for slow changes in the signal component from the rotor blades, for example, when the rotational frequency of the rotor blades changes and / or the angle of the rotor blades changes.

[0027] The method for combining the modified echo map and its corresponding noise echo map can involve dividing the values ​​of the modified echo map by the values ​​of its corresponding noise echo map. The noise echo map contains low amplitude values ​​in cells without noise signals, so the division increases the values ​​of the corresponding cells of the modified echo map. This can increase the signal strength ratio between the desired signal and the noise signal in the compensated echo map. The division can be performed by subtracting logarithmic values, thus avoiding computationally intensive logarithms. Alternatively, a simple subtraction of the noise echo map from the beam echo map is possible. However, division can lead to better noise suppression.

[0028] The method for identifying potential aircraft can further involve summarizing detected elements with an amplitude value greater than a threshold from a plurality of compensated echo maps generated based on a plurality of modified echo maps. This can result in greater accuracy in aircraft detection. For example, the summarization can be presented in a cluster map or a histogram. At locations where a high percentage of the plurality of compensated echo maps show an amplitude value above the threshold (detection event), the probability of an aircraft being present is high. Conversely, if only a very small percentage of the plurality of compensated echo maps show a detection event, it can be assumed that it is a noise signal.This can advantageously reduce the number of false detections.

[0029] For example, the procedure includes determining the threshold value based on the current detection situation. This can be done using amplitude values ​​from areas of the echo maps where there is a high probability that no aircraft is present, or it can be determined using other monitoring systems that no aircraft is within the detection range of the radar system (i.e., in the vicinity of the wind turbines) at the time of determination. For example, the procedure can include calculating an initial threshold value theoretically, taking into account the size of the wind turbine and / or its distance and position from the sensor system. For example, the procedure includes continuously adjusting the threshold value to the current detection situation. This can be advantageous, for instance, when the rotor blade positions of the wind turbines change.

[0030] Further developments of the procedure can optionally include the removal of artifacts from at least one of the compensated echo maps. A constant false alarm rate algorithm, for example, can be used to remove the artifacts.

[0031] According to further training, this method can be used to track the flight path of an aircraft based on continuous detection of the aircraft. In other words, a tracking function can be provided by continuously repeating the procedure to determine the aircraft's position. Known tracking algorithms, such as those using a Kalman filter, can be employed for this purpose.

[0032] The described method can be used to monitor the airspace in the vicinity of wind turbines. For example, a control signal can be issued according to the method to control at least one characteristic of at least one wind turbine based on the detection of an aircraft. For example, the control signal contains instructions for controlling the brightness of position lights or signal lights of the wind turbine.

[0033] Claim 16 is defined in a computer program with program code.

[0034] Another aspect of the invention relates to a passive radar detection system for detecting an aircraft. The passive radar detection system comprises at least two coherent receive channels. The channels are coherently structured; for example, the oscillators assigned to each channel exhibit a synchronization that lasts significantly longer than the time constant of the low-pass filter used to create the interference echo map. Phase errors of less than 1° per minute, for instance, can occur.

[0035] The passive radar detection system further comprises a signal input for receiving radar signals from at least two receiving channels and a signal processing device configured to perform a method described above or below.

[0036] For example, the passive radar system or radar detection system is designed to operate with signals from OFDM-modulated illuminators. For instance, the radar system has at least two antennas and corresponding channels for reception. The radar system can be configured to enable range and Doppler measurements in amplitude and phase. The range resolution of the radar system can be on the order of the wind turbine blades or less than the rotor blade length of the wind turbines to be detected. The Doppler resolution of the radar system can be on the order of the Doppler dispersion of the aircraft to be detected during the observation period. The Doppler uniqueness range of the radar system can be greater than the highest expected Doppler frequency of the wind turbine blades, fDmax (see below for the definition of fDmax).

[0037] In passive radar, the Doppler uniqueness range is determined by the modulation of the illuminator used; in the case of an OFDM-modulated signal, for example, by the carrier spacing. If this uniqueness range is exceeded, the signal echoes of one carrier are correlated with the neighboring carrier during range compression and undergo a random phase shift that depends on the data content of the OFDM signal. As a result, constant phase differences can no longer be assumed. The described method is based on this constancy. Consequently, the radar system is designed such that the uniqueness range is not exceeded.

[0038] For example, the passive radar detection system includes a signal output for sending a control signal to a wind turbine. This control signal can include information about whether an aircraft is in the vicinity of the wind turbine. For instance, if an aircraft is detected in the vicinity of the wind turbine, the control signal can include commands to activate indicator lights on the wind turbine.

[0039] According to the passive radar detection system, the antennas for at least two receiving channels are positioned at different locations relative to at least one wind turbine. The distance between these different positions is based on a signal frequency used by the radar detection system. The distance between the two antennas can be within the range of a wavelength of the signal frequency. For example, a illuminator (e.g., a radio mast) used for the passive radar system can transmit signals in the range of 100 MHz to 1000 MHz, for example, 500 MHz. For instance, a signal frequency of 500 MHz is used, and the distance between the antennas is 60 cm, which corresponds to the wavelength of the signal.

[0040] For example, the area to be detected may contain multiple wind turbines. Since the described method does not require computationally intensive steps or signal processing, it is possible to operate the radar system in an area with many wind turbines, such as a wind farm. The echo signals from the majority of the wind turbines can then be suppressed or reduced.

[0041] Another example relates to a radar system with at least two receiving channels, each comprising a receiving antenna and a signal output for outputting a received radar signal, wherein the receiving antennas are arranged at different positions. Such a radar system can, for example, be combined with a device configured to perform a described method.

[0042] The proposed method eliminates computationally intensive steps, thus enabling the real-time identification of aircraft, for example, with minimal financial investment on a commercially available computer system. All available energy from the aircraft's signal echoes can be utilized for detection, resulting in improved detection capabilities. For instance, the method eliminates distributed gaps in signal and data processing. Error-inducing predictions are avoided. Stricter parameters (e.g., more precise parameter ranges) can reduce the number of false detections. Calibration of the receiving channels may be unnecessary. For example, precise knowledge of the antenna patterns is not required.

[0043] Examples deal with methods for suppressing the signal echo components of wind turbines when monitoring airspace with passive radar. Character description

[0044] Some examples of devices and / or methods are explained in more detail below with reference to the accompanying figures. These show: Fig. 1 a flowchart of an example of a method; Fig. 2 a schematic representation of a radar detection system; Fig. 3 a flowchart of an example of a detailed method for suppressing signal echo components from wind turbines; Fig. 4 an exemplary echo map showing the position of an aircraft without suppression of wind turbine echoes; and Fig. 5 an exemplary echo map showing the position of the aircraft after suppression of wind turbine echoes according to the method. Description

[0045] Several examples will now be described in more detail with reference to the accompanying figures, which illustrate some of these examples. The thickness of lines, layers, and / or areas may be exaggerated in the figures for clarity.

[0046] While further examples of various modifications and alternative forms are suitable, some specific examples are accordingly shown in the figures and are described in detail below. However, this detailed description does not limit further examples to the specific forms described. Further examples may encompass all modifications, correspondences, and alternatives that fall within the scope of revelation. Equal or similar reference signs throughout the description of the figures refer to identical or similar elements that, upon comparison, may be implemented identically or in a modified form while providing the same or a similar function.

[0047] It is understood that when an element is described as "connected" or "coupled" to another element, the elements may be connected or coupled directly or via one or more intermediate elements. When two elements A and B are combined using "or," this is to be understood as revealing all possible combinations, i.e., only A, only B, and A and B, unless explicitly or implicitly defined otherwise. An alternative formulation for the same combinations is "at least one of A and B" or "A and / or B." The same applies, mutatis mutandis, to combinations of more than two elements.

[0048] The terminology used here to describe certain examples is not intended to be limiting for other examples. Where a singular form, e.g., "a" and "the," "a," "a," is used, and the use of only a single element is neither explicitly nor implicitly defined as mandatory, further examples may also use plural elements to implement the same function. Similarly, where a function is subsequently described as being implemented using multiple elements, further examples may implement the same function using a single element or a single processing entity.It is further understood that the terms "include", "comprehensive", "exhibit" and / or "exhibit" when used specify the presence of the indicated features, integers, steps, operations, processes, elements, components and / or a group thereof, but do not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, operations, processes, elements, components and / or a group thereof.

[0049] Unless otherwise defined, all terms (including technical and scientific terms) are used herein in their usual sense within the field to which examples belong.

[0050] Fig. 1Figure 100 shows a flowchart of a method for detecting an aircraft in the vicinity of at least one operating wind turbine. At least two complex-valued echo maps from a passive radar system are used, the radar system comprising at least two input channels and using echo maps from different input channels. The method comprises combining the at least two complex-valued echo maps with a complex-valued coefficient set to generate a modified echo map associated with the coefficient set. A jamming echo map is then created for the modified echo map, and the modified echo map and its corresponding jamming echo map are combined to obtain a compensated echo map in which quasi-stationary signal components of the modified echo map are reduced. Finally, potential aircraft are identified in the compensated echo map.

[0051] Method 100 thus enables improved detection of aircraft within an environment containing wind turbines or windmills, whose rotor blades can cause interference in the radar detector's signal. This interference can be compensated for or filtered out of the radar signal according to the method, since the signal components generated by the rotor blades, unlike the echo response of the moving aircraft, are always recurring and can therefore be distinguished from the aircraft's echo response. Further details of Method 100 are available in conjunction with Fig. 3 described.

[0052] Fig. 2Figure 1 shows a schematic block diagram of a passive radar detection system 200 for detecting an aircraft. The passive radar detection system comprises at least two coherent receive channels or input channels 210, 220, and a signal input 230 for receiving radar signals 210', 220' from the at least two receive channels 210, 220. The passive radar detection system further comprises a signal processing device 240 configured to perform a method 100 as described above or below.

[0053] The radar detection system 200 shown can be used to execute a proposed method due to its two coherent receive channels 210 and 220. For example, a common reference signal or clock is used for the two receive channels 210 and 220, so that they operate synchronously, at least within a predetermined time range. Thus, a constant difference in signal components of the two receive channels caused by rotor blade reflections can be detected, and the corresponding interference signals can be compensated.

[0054] Further details and aspects of the Radar Detection System 200 are described in connection with the examples given above or below.

[0055] Another example (not shown) concerns a passive radar detection system for detecting an aircraft, comprising at least two coherent receiving channels 210, 220, each with a receiving antenna and a signal output for outputting a radar signal received by the respective receiving antenna. The receiving antennas can be referred to as radar antennas and are designed, for example, for a center frequency of 500 MHz. The receiving antennas are arranged at different positions with a predetermined distance from each other. For example, the predetermined distance is within the range of a wavelength of a radio signal used, which can be reflected by a wind turbine. Such signals can be in the frequency range of 500 MHz, and the predetermined distance can therefore be, for example, 60 cm.

[0056] The passive radar detection system according to the further example can be used, for instance, to detect an aircraft in conjunction with a previously mentioned signal processing device or another device designed to perform a described procedure.

[0057] Further details and aspects are described in connection with the examples given above or below. The examples are based on Fig. 2 The examples shown may have one or more optional, additional features that correspond to one or more aspects described in connection with the proposed concept or one or more examples above or below (for example, in connection with Fig. 1 or Figs. 3-5 ).

[0058] Fig. 3Figure 1 shows a flowchart of a detailed example of a method for detecting an aircraft. The method uses two complex-valued echo maps 300 and 302, which were generated using different receiving channels of a passive radar sensor (e.g., radar detection system 200). The method can be carried out, for example, with a passive radar sensor that has at least two channels.

[0059] In the first process step, Step 1, the echo maps 300 and 302 are multiplied by a complex-valued coefficient set C1. A beam shaper can be used in Step 1, for example. This allows for the creation of a modified echo map 310 or beam-echo map 310. For instance, after acquiring the complex-valued (amplitude and phase) measurement matrix (signal processing) for the propagation delay and Doppler shift of the signal echoes, a special processing block is inserted that coherently combines the matrices (e.g., echo maps 300 and 302) of the individual channels. This combination is performed, for example, with N different complex coefficient sets, resulting in N coherence spaces (e.g., N coherent beam-echo maps 310 to 310N).

[0060] As previously explained, the property is exploited that the signal echo of an aircraft, due to its changing position—and thus continuously changing phase at the sensor's receiving antennas—gradually traverses all coherence spaces. In contrast, the signal echo of a wind turbine blade, which occurs only briefly during co-phase (blade flashes), has a phase difference in the sensor's channels determined by the geometry of the scenario. This repeats continuously and is therefore always represented in the same coherence spaces. Co-phase occurs when the signal travel time from the transmitter to the receiver via any point on the wind turbine blade is the same—that is, when all signal echoes constructively overlap (e.g., blade flashes). This provides a feature that makes it possible to distinguish the signal echoes of aircraft from those of wind turbine blades.

[0061] An improvement in terms of detection probability compared to material and computational effort is possible by choosing the number of channels, the arrangement of the antennas, and the number and design of the coefficient sets, depending on the arrangement of the wind turbines and the illuminating transmitter used for the passive radar function.

[0062] For a more detailed explanation, a passive radar sensor is considered. This sensor has two receiving channels. Each receiving channel is capable of measuring the amplitude and phase of the signal echoes from the observation space. The antennas of the two channels are positioned at a distance from each other so that they observe the same observation space and receive the signal echoes occurring within the observation space with different signal travel times and thus different phases. The results of the signal measurements are displayed for each channel in a complex-valued distance-difference-Doppler matrix (echo map) according to their travel time difference to the illuminator and their Doppler shift (signal processing). An echo map shows the coherent integration of the signal echoes within an observation period. Echo maps are generated, for example, at equidistant times, and their time periods can overlap.

[0063] An aircraft moves continuously during an observation period, allowing it to occupy multiple distance cells and, through course correction or aspect angle changes in the bista arrangement, multiple Doppler cells of an echo map. However, it appears as a continuous, limited area. The phase difference in the corresponding echo maps of the two receiving antennas is primarily determined by the time difference of the signal echo. This difference could, for example, be used as the interferometer phase. The signal echo of a wind turbine blade can be considered the sum of all individual, point-like echoes along the blade. During one rotation, a rotor blade twice assumes a position where all individual echoes constructively overlap. This results in the so-called rotor blade flashes.In the first position, the rotor blade moves towards the bistatic arrangement of transmitter and receiver, thus generating a signal echo with a positive Doppler shift; in the second position, it moves away, generating a negative Doppler shift. The phase angles of the signal echoes from the rotor blade flashes are consistently identical for each position.

[0064] The signal echoes from the rotor blades are distributed in the Doppler direction from 0 Hz up to fDmax or -fDmax, respectively, due to the velocities contained in the point-like individual echoes. The following applies: f Dmax = 2 ωr λ cos δ cos β 2 Here, r is the length of a rotor blade, ω is the angular velocity of the rotor, and λ is the smallest wavelength of the illumination signal. 5 is the angle between the tangential rotor blade motion and the bisector of the bistatic angle, and β is the bistatic angle. Unlike an aircraft, a rotor blade experiences an additional difference beyond the phase difference caused by the time-of-flight differences of the signal echoes. This difference arises because the rotor blade flashes occur at different times for the two receiving antennas. The time at which the co-phase position is reached depends on the position of the receiving antenna in space. The Fourier transform used for Doppler resolution contains the following rule: s t − t 0 ∘ − • S ƒ e − j 2 πf t 0 . This is t 0 The time difference in the occurrence of the co-phase position. This means that the phase difference of a rotor blade flash can assume arbitrary values ​​for different Doppler frequencies f, which therefore do not allow the angle of incidence to be determined according to the interferometer principle.

[0065] The movement of a wind turbine rotor is a periodic process whose characteristic parameters can be considered constant compared to the observation periods used to generate the echo maps. Therefore, the signal echo of a wind turbine blade always appears in the same distance difference and Doppler cells in successive echo maps, with constant phase and amplitude differences between the receiving channels. As already explained, a fundamental aspect of this method is to utilize the differences in the phase difference characteristics of the signal echoes.

[0066] Fig. 3Figure 1 shows a processing block 304 used in step 1, which is known in classical radar technology, for example, as a beam shaper. Thus, the modified echo map 310 generated in step 1 can also be referred to as a beam-echo map 310. According to the procedure, the beam shaper is used to differentiate between repeating wind turbine echoes with constant phase and amplitude differences and the continuously changing phase difference of an aircraft. The phase and amplitude difference is measured for each cell of the echo map between the two receiving channels.

[0067] For example, echo maps 300 and 302 are multiplied element-wise by a beam-shaping vector C with N complex-valued coefficient sets C1 to CN. This results in N coherent beam-echo maps 310 to 310rr (coherence spaces). The coefficients are chosen to account for the expected phase and amplitude differences of the rotor blade echoes. One realization of C can be the uniform distribution on the unit circle in the complex plane. C N = A n e j 2 π n N The amplitude differences are taken into account by An. The term "ray" here does not describe a spatially assignable direction, but rather the phase and amplitude relationships in the outgoing echo maps. The signal echo of a wind turbine blade then appears in specific beam echo maps and remains there until the orientation of the rotor axis, the rotational speed, or the blade position of the corresponding wind turbine changes significantly. This generally takes considerably longer than the observation time of several successive echo maps. After this step, each rotor blade can be considered quasi-static within the beam echo maps with respect to distance difference and Doppler effect. Subsequently, for each cell, only the square of its amplitude is considered (see reference numeral 304 in [reference number]). Fig. 3 ).

[0068] In a second process step, Step 2, the described quasi-static echoes are suppressed per beam using a jamming echo map 312, 312 N, a type known from radar technology. A spatially moving aircraft, due to its motion, traverses the beam echo maps 310, 310 N and, within these, the individual distance difference and Doppler cells. Thus, it is neither permanently assigned to a specific beam echo map 310, 310 N by the beam shaping, nor is it suppressed within a beam echo map 310, 310rr by its jamming echo map 312, 312 N. The jamming echo map 312, 312 N is implemented, for example, by using an exponential filter per cell. to + 1 = to ( 1-a )+ x * α.Here, a is a cell of the disturbance echo map 312, 312 N in the nth time interval, x is a cell from the beam echo map 310, 310N, and α is the smoothing factor. Exponential filters have a low-pass characteristic that allows adaptation to slowly changing conditions. This takes into account the fact that the wind, and thus the orientation and speed of the wind turbines, can change. Echo map 310 and disturbance echo map 312 can be processed using a divider 314. A compensated echo map 316 can thus be generated using the divider 314, which can be present at the output of the divider 314.

[0069] Fig. 3Furthermore, an optional third process step, Step 3, is shown. This step uses a processing block 320, known as CFAR (Constant False Alarm Rate). It is applied to each beam (beam 1 to beam rr). It relates the value of a cell to its surroundings. The surroundings are divided into four areas, which are arranged to the left, right, above, and below the test cell in the suppressed beam echo map (e.g., the compensated echo map at the output of divider 314). A special feature of this application is that the surrounding sector with the highest average cell value is selected (CFAR-CAGO: Cell Average Greatest Of).This suppresses artifacts that arise, for example, when the observation period temporarily coincides with a situation where no wind turbine echo is present in a surrounding sector, but the interference echo map still reduces the amplitude in that sector.

[0070] Fig. 3Furthermore, a fourth procedural step, Step 4, is shown, in which cells whose amplitude exceeds a threshold value or threshold value 330 (e.g., Thri) are identified in each (e.g., interference-free) beam-echo map. To determine these threshold values, an area is selected in the respective beam-echo map (echo maps 1-N) where no echoes are expected. This is usually the case with large distance differences and high Doppler values. In this area, the threshold value is chosen such that a predetermined proportion of cells exceed it. The threshold value can therefore be set or selected empirically based on the detection situation. Alternatively, it is possible to determine the threshold value from a theoretical analysis of the echo signal statistics.

[0071] Fig. 3Furthermore, an optional fifth process step, Step 5, is shown. This step summarizes all cells identified using the threshold value 330, based on all beam-echo maps, into a cluster map 340 and determines contiguous areas. The parameters of each area are estimated. Parameters used include, for example, the location of the centroid, the maximum, the mean and maximum signal levels, and the extent in the distance difference and Doppler directions. To connect to the other existing process steps of the radar sensor, the location of the centroids is passed, for example, to a subsequent tracking algorithm 350 as measured values ​​for distance difference and Doppler. The covariances of these measured values ​​can be estimated from the signal level of the maximum and the extent.

[0072] Alternatively, the summarization of all cells identified in step 4 in cluster map 340 can be omitted entirely, or only contiguous areas within a ray echo map can be routed to the subsequent track formation algorithm 350. The merging of the rays (modified echo maps 1 to N) can be performed, for example, in a track merging algorithm (e.g., track merge).

[0073] The proposed method allows signal processing to be performed in equidistant, gapless time intervals—which can, for example, overlap—that are identical across all sensors in a network. This minimizes, for example, prediction errors in the calculation of the intersection points of the runtime ellipsoids. The parameters of the process steps can advantageously be chosen more strictly or precisely to reduce false detections. The method can, for example, suppress the signal echoes from wind turbines according to their characteristics, rather than skipping them, to avoid losing echo energy from a detectable aircraft. For instance, the method is not unnecessarily complex, allowing it to run in real time on an inexpensive computer architecture.

[0074] Further details and aspects are described in connection with the examples given above or below. The examples are based on Fig. 3 The examples shown may have one or more optional, additional features that correspond to one or more aspects described in connection with the proposed concept or one or more examples above or below (for example, in connection with Fig. 1-2 or Figs. 4-5 ).

[0075] Fig. 4 shows an example echo map 400 with position 410 of a flying object without suppression of wind turbine echoes 420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e (filled, circular points in Fig. 4The position 410 of the aircraft is known, for example, due to the use of a GPS signal. It can be seen that numerous interference signals or wind turbine echoes (420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e) are present in echo map 400. Due to the many interference signals, there is no detection signal at the aircraft's position 410. In other words, the interference signals from the wind turbines prevent the aircraft from being detected.

[0076] In Fig. 4 The Echo card 400 (for example, one of those in conjunction with Fig. 3The described echo maps (300, 302 of a receiving channel) are shown before the described procedure is applied. An aircraft, e.g., an ultralight aircraft, was equipped with a GPS logger that allows the expected signal echo position to be marked with an X on the echo map (position 410). The actual detections by the radar sensor are marked with solid dots (wind turbine echoes 420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e). The strong signal echoes from the wind turbine blades (wind turbine echoes 420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e) are visible – e.g., from the negative Doppler range. The existing signal echo from the aircraft is superimposed by a blade flash, leading to a false detection or to the fact that no echo can be detected at position 410. Many other false detections are also present.

[0077] In Fig. 5An example echo map 500 is shown, showing the position of the flying object at 410 after suppression of wind turbine echoes. For suppression of the wind turbine echoes (for example, wind turbine echoes 420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e, see below). Fig. 4 A described procedure was used.

[0078] Fig. 5 In other words, it shows a noise-reduced, resulting echo card 500 (e.g., the compensated echo card 500), for example, after applying the CFAR block (see block 320 from Fig. 3 ), for example, the result of step 3 from Fig. 3 For illustrative purposes, the maximum value per cell is selected from all beams. The signal echoes from the wind turbine blades are almost completely suppressed. For example, a large proportion of the wind turbine echoes 420a, 420b, 420c, 420d, 420e are filtered out. A detection by the radar sensor, a point 530 on the echo map where, for example, the signal component exceeds the threshold 330, or a result from step 5, is not shown. Fig. 3The area identified using the cluster map is now located at the expected position 410.

[0079] The described method can therefore suppress the interference signals from the wind rotor blades, so that they no longer obscure the actual echo signal of the aircraft being detected.

[0080] Further details and aspects are described in connection with the examples given above or below. The examples are based on Figs. 4 and 5 The examples shown may have one or more optional, additional features that correspond to one or more aspects described in connection with the proposed concept or one or more examples above or below (for example, in connection with Figs. 1-3 ).

[0081] The described method and passive radar detection system can be used, for example, to monitor air traffic in the vicinity of wind farms. Wind turbines are subject to regulations such as the General Administrative Regulation (AVV) on the marking of aviation obstacles. According to this regulation, structures relevant to air traffic safety must be marked with day and night markings. The AVV allows, for example, the night marking to be controlled as needed, for instance, to reduce the burden on the population from light emissions and thus promote the acceptance of wind energy. Radar systems are typically used to detect the need for these markings—the presence of an aircraft. Wind turbines are located within the detection range of these radar systems, and their rotating components (wind turbine blades) can complicate the detection of aircraft or lead to false detections.Thus, a proposed method for suppressing wind turbine echoes can increase detection reliability or lead to less unnecessary activation of nighttime marking.

[0082] The aspects and features described together with one or more of the previously detailed examples and figures can also be combined with one or more of the other examples to replace an identical feature of the other example or to additionally introduce the feature into the other example.

[0083] Examples may also include a computer program with program code for performing one or more of the above procedures, or refer to the execution of the computer program on a computer or processor. Steps, operations, or processes of various procedures described above may be performed by programmed computers or processors. Examples may also include program storage devices, such as digital data storage media, that are machine-, processor-, or computer-readable and encode machine-executable, processor-executable, or computer-executable programs of instructions. The instructions perform or cause some or all of the steps of the procedures described above. The program storage devices may, for example,Digital storage media, magnetic storage media such as magnetic disks and magnetic tapes, hard disk drives, or optically readable digital data storage media. Further examples may also include computers, processors, or control units programmed to perform the steps of the procedures described above, or (field) programmable logic arrays (PLAs) or (field) programmable gate arrays (PGAs) programmed to perform the steps of the procedures described above.

[0084] The descriptions and drawings only illustrate the principles of revelation. Furthermore, all examples presented here are expressly intended for illustrative purposes only, to assist the reader in understanding the principles of revelation and the concepts contributed by the inventor(s) to the advancement of technology. All statements made here regarding principles, aspects, and examples of revelation, as well as specific examples thereof, include their corresponding references.

[0085] A functional block designated as a "means for..." performing a specific function can refer to a circuit configured to perform that function. Thus, a "means for something" can be implemented as a "means configured for or suitable for something," e.g., a component or circuit configured for or suitable for the specific task.

[0086] The functions of various elements shown in the figures, including each functional block designated as "means," "means of providing a signal," "means of generating a signal," etc., can be implemented in the form of dedicated hardware, e.g., "a signal provider," "a signal processing unit," "a processor," "a controller," etc., as well as in hardware capable of executing software in conjunction with associated software. When provided by a processor, the functions can be provided by a single dedicated processor, by a single shared processor, or by a plurality of individual processors, some or all of which can be shared.However, the term "processor" or "controller" is by no means limited to hardware capable solely of executing software, but can include digital signal processor hardware (DSP hardware; DSP = Digital Signal Processor), network processors, application-specific integrated circuits (ASICs = Application Specific Integrated Circuits), field-programmable gate arrays (FPGAs = Field Programmable Gate Arrays), read-only memory (ROMs = Read Only Memory) for storing software, random-access memory (RAMs = Random Access Memory), and non-volatile storage devices. Other hardware, both conventional and / or custom-designed, may also be included.

[0087] A block diagram, for example, can represent a rough circuit diagram that implements the principles of the disclosure. Similarly, a flowchart, a process flowchart, a state transition diagram, pseudocode, and the like can represent various processes, operations, or steps that are, for example, substantially depicted in a computer-readable medium and thus executed by a computer or processor, regardless of whether such a computer or processor is explicitly shown. Methods disclosed in the description or in the claims can be implemented by a component that includes means for performing each of the respective steps of these methods.

[0088] It is understood that the disclosure of multiple steps, processes, operations, or functions in the description or claims should not be interpreted as being in a specific order unless explicitly or implicitly stated otherwise, for example, for technical reasons. Therefore, the disclosure of multiple steps or functions does not restrict them to a specific order unless these steps or functions are not interchangeable for technical reasons. Furthermore, in some examples, a single step, function, process, or operation may include and / or be broken down into multiple sub-steps, sub-functions, sub-processes, or sub-operations. Such sub-steps may be included and form part of the disclosure of that single step unless explicitly excluded.

Claims

1. A computer-implemented method (100) for detecting a flying object in an area of at least one operating wind turbine, based on at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) of a passive radar system (200) with at least one input channel (210, 220) per echo map (300, 302), the method (100) comprising: combining (110) the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) with a complex-valued coefficient set (C1) to generate a modified echo map (310) associated with the coefficient set (C1), wherein signals for generating the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) originate from antennas of the channels of the complex-valued echo maps (300, 302), which are arranged at a distance from each other such that they view the same observation space and receive the signal echoes occurring in the observation space with different signal propagation time, wherein the coefficient set (C1) is adapted to a geometric arrangement of the wind turbine and the radar system (200), wherein combining (110) the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) comprises element-wise multiplying at least one echo map (300, 302) with the complex-valued coefficient set (C1), and wherein the modified echo map is embodied as a beam echo map, creating (120) a spurious echo map (312) for the modified echo map (310), wherein creating the spurious echo maps comprises using a low-pass filter; combining (130) the modified echo map (310) and its corresponding spurious echo map (312) to obtain a compensated echo map (316) in which quasi-stationary signal components of the modified echo map (310) are reduced; and identifying (140) possible flying objects in the compensated echo map (316).

2. The computer-implemented method (100) of claim 1, wherein combining (110) the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) comprises: generating a difference signal based on the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302).

3. The computer-implemented method (100) of claim 1 or 2, wherein combining (110) the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) comprises: generating a plurality of modified echo maps associated with the coefficient set (C1).

4. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, wherein combining (110) the at least two complex-valued echo maps (300, 302) comprises: using a beamformer.

5. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: using at least two different complex-valued coefficient sets (C1, CN) to generate at least twice a modified echo map (310, 310N) respectively based on one of the coefficient sets (C1, CN).

6. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the coefficient set (C1) comprises complex-valued components arranged symmetrically in the unit circle.

7. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: adaptively adapting the complex-valued coefficient set (C1) based on a current detection situation.

8. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, wherein combining (130) the modified echo map (310) and its corresponding spurious echo map (312) comprises: dividing (314) the values of the modified echo map (310) by the values of its corresponding spurious echo map (312).

9. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims 3 to 8, wherein identifying (140) possible flight objects further comprises: combining determined elements having an amplitude value greater than a threshold value (330) from a plurality of compensated echo maps (316, 316N) generated based on the plurality of modified echo maps (310, 310N).

10. The computer-implemented method (100) of claim 9, comprising: determining the threshold value (330) based on a current detection situation.

11. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims 9 or 10, comprising: continuously adapting the threshold value (330) to a current detection situation.

12. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: removing artifacts from at least one of the compensated echo maps.

13. The computer-implemented method (100) of claim 12, comprising using a constant false alarm rate algorithm (320) to remove the artifacts.

14. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, wherein the echo maps (300, 302) have range Doppler signal components.

15. The computer-implemented method (100) of any one of the preceding claims, further comprising: outputting a control signal for controlling at least one property of the at least one wind turbine based on the detection of a flying object.

16. A computer program having program code which, when the code is executed on a programmable processor, causes a computer-implemented method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims to be carried out.

17. A passive radar detection system (200) for detecting a flying object, comprising at least two coherent reception channels (210, 220); a signal input (230) for receiving radar signals (210', 220') of the at least two reception channels (210, 220); and a signal processing device (240) configured to carry out a computer-implemented method (100) according to any one of the preceding claims.

18. The passive radar detection system (200) of claim 17, wherein respective antennas of the at least two reception channels (210, 220) are arranged at different positions with respect to the at least one wind turbine, wherein a distance provided between the different positions is based on a signal frequency used by the radar detection system.